Chapter Text
There were, of course, questions from the Company as to why my group of Wraiths had decreased in number from nine to eight, but it did not seem right to me to allow Angmar’s treachery to become known to them, both as his punishment would be a blow to his pride and because it would lessen the dwarves’ trust for the Nazgûl. I told them instead that he had left on business of his own, and would be back as soon as he was able.
The next morning it was time for Thorin and me to make our way down the tunnel to speak with Smaug. I waited patiently for him by the entrance whilst he decided how much of his heavy garb to strip off, for I had spoken of the wet heat that filled the halls below, and if he was to face the killer of his people it would not do to do so sweating and half-faint. Finally he settled on leaving his cloak and his steel scale-mail, though he kept on the fine chain of mithril, nestled between his tunic and his underclothes. It still seemed like too much to me, but then dwarves tended to be more resistant to high temperatures than one would at first expect.
“So,” he said, as we passed into the darkness of the tunnel like stepping into a beast’s throat. “In this I must bow to your experience. How do you wish to proceed?”
“The protection of the Ring’s magic first of all,” I replied, “and then you can talk to Smaug without fearing his fire. As to what you say to him; that is not for me to decide. You have many rightful grievances, and it is not as though hobbits as a whole are good at putting aside a grudge. I cannot ask you to put them aside when likely I could not, if he had slaughtered my own people. I merely fear the consequences of deciding to fight a dragon.”
Thorin made a thoughtful noise. He gazed forth into the damp dark, a passage more easily illuminated to me as I slipped into the ghost-world than to even his keen eyes. If not for the steaming wet that drenched the air, it would be too much like Mirkwood’s night for comfort.
We paced further on and down. I turned my attention to the power that even now was slowly surging around us, more familiar since I perceived it for the third time. It was not easy to draw it up and harness myself to its strength, but nor did it have the throat-clenching peril of before.
You learn fast, as always ‘little master’, the Ring said, halfway between praise and mocking. Yet with the earth’s blood like boiling mud beneath my skin, it could find no real bitterness or irritation within it. It was too much in its element. The mountain must feel so much like home, like whatever puissant forge Mairon had shaped it upon and within.
Thorin was watching me, I noticed, as I became aware of my physical surroundings once more. I could not read his expression, yet there was something... hungry... about it. “You have done something,” he said. “There is... you glow.”
I looked down at myself. He was right. In the shadow-world I was invisible, yet from the outlines of my form warm light seemed to blossom out, diffuse in the blanketing heat and dark. It wreathed me like thick fog. How had I not seen this before? How had Smaug not seen it?
“Is this the mark of the magic you would put upon me?” Thorin asked. His hand hovered outstretched; he did not seem to be aware of it. The light drew him in like a moth.
“It is,” I replied. Something about the moment, the secretive campfire glow in the gloom, softened our voices down to whispers. “It is the power of the mountain. Thorin... it is beautiful.”
“If it is of Erebor, I cannot doubt but that it is.”
I reached out for him. Our fingers met, and the earth-blood within me jumped, shifting with great strength behind it like the liquid rock it remembered. The link that led to Durin’s ring was but inches away. I had only to nudge it to direct the power through it, towards Thorin. It went easily, hungrily. I saw him stiffen, saw light come about him, felt it lap away at him like the now too-familiar touch of gold lust. In sudden panic I pulled it away and around, forcing it to pass about him like a river parting around a great rock. The flow began to settle, and my breath came more freely.
“You were right,” Thorin said, looking down at where our hands were joined, where languid gobbets of fire splashed down upon the stone and returned to their source. His voice was hushed and awed. “It is truly beautiful.”
----
Smaug was waiting for us in the hoard-hall. His great head rose as we entered, and his nostrils flared, his tongue flickering out like a snake’s.
“You have not come alone this time, Hidden One,” he said, tempering his usual mellow rumble with an audible sneer. “Earth’s child pollutes this lair of mine. I smell his sweat and his greed. Watch his hands for me, lest he snatch up some treasure and I must perforce bite them off.” He bared his fangs at our now barely-visible forms.
“You are one to talk of pollution, wyrm,” Thorin replied with no less of a growl. “Your sulphurous stink could not be scrubbed from this place if we had decades.”
“It has been sufficient to cover the odour of your kind,” the dragon replied, “for which I am grateful. So you are one of those stone-kin who has come to take back your homeland, and indeed the Prince of them, for whom else would come to parlay with me?”
“Yes wyrm, I am he,” Thorin replied, voice heavy with hate. “I am Thorin, son of Thrain, son of Thror, rightful King Under The Mountain.”
The dragon laughed, making the coins jump around his massive barrel of a chest where it lay half-buried in them. “Proud words for the Prince of a proud people,” he said. “But your friend, he who holds Mairon’s Ring, has put me in a good mood and so I will speak with you rather than eat you up as I should.”
“You might find me a difficult morsel to swallow.” Thorin’s hand went up to grip the hilt of Orcrist at his shoulder.
Smaug grinned, baring teeth each as long as that elf-forged sword. “A spirited morsel, ‘tis true. Well enough of your threats, and I shall put aside mine. Our weapons are words this morning, and I would hear how sharp are yours.”
“Sharp enough to get a good bargain from you, dragon.”
“We shall see,” Smaug told him, shifting upon his bed of gold. “The halls are yours, I care little for them. It is of the treasures of the earth that we must speak. This tithe, this tribute, your little friend has promised me for the favour of sparing you the flame.”
Thorin bristled at that. “You did not spare Dale, nor did you spare those of my people who stood before you all those years ago. Do you expect I would forget your evils against them?”
“I expect and ask for no forgiveness for that,” the dragon said. “I came for what was mine, and cared only for it. Understand that the lives of short-lived creatures matter little to my kind – what of it if some were burned and some crushed before me? More would be born soon enough. But I did not go forth with death as my purpose. You cannot change the past, and you cannot change what must happen if you want any scrap of your home returned to you.”
Thorin was tense and ready as though to spring to an attack. I could see the memory of the dead fresh within him, the memory of fire, of choking heat and scorched flesh. I knew I could not even hope to imagine the horrors of that day. But to my surprise he did not cry out in anger and hate, but mastered himself and his emotions before he spoke again. “As much as it pains me, I know you speak true. For my kingdom, for our home returned, I suppose even my pride can bow to this. Not that I think you any less evil, any less a murderer. But in the years past I have come to understand the place of hard bargains and distasteful compromise.”
“Would you rather then wait and hope to strike me down as I sleep?” the dragon asked, but the question seemed more rhetorical than anything, and he did not wait for an answer. “No, I see you are not so foolish. Perhaps I have misjudged you. I did not truly think you would abide by any measure of this treaty that was put to you.”
“Nor did I, until I came down here,” Thorin said, glancing over at me. His eyes were warm and fond in that quick moment, and happiness flushed through me. I could only be glad that things were working out as well as this. It was more than I had expected. It seemed I kept on being pleasantly surprised by the way things turned out. “I set foot in the halls of my forefathers and all the memories of my childhood came back to me. I remembered anew everything Erebor has ever meant to me, what it has meant to my people. And I saw this hoard and remembered the worry and fear in my heart every time I saw my grandfather down here, glorying in it and consumed by his gold-lust. I do not desire to be caught in that self-same trap, for I know I have come too close, too often, on this journey. So hear all this, wyrm, and know that I deal with you truthfully.”
“Princely words, Thorin son of Thrain,” Smaug said, his tail twisting with his pleasure. “Princely and practical. We both are the creatures that we are, and I did not think our natures would allow peace between us. Yet if you may see past the sorrow of the past and your gold-lust, surely I can see past my love of my hoard enough to allow this... unlikely endeavour.”
It was enough of an agreement that with a few more diplomatic words they fell to talking through more technical matters, of these many pounds and ounces of gold, this weight of silver, these measures of diamonds and emeralds and sapphires, and so on and so forth in great detail. Although I tried to pay attention, I soon found my attention wandering. There was too much else of interest in the great hoard-hall; the lapping waves of coin, the beautifully wrought armour and weapons, the gems that glinted loose or from other finely crafted goods. Let the dragon and the dwarf discuss their trade, I would admire what was not mine.
I could not wander far from Thorin, not if I wanted to keep up the link that let the earth’s blood continue its languid loop of power between us. Still, with even the small amount of practise I had had, it had become easier. I could concentrate on other things. I scanned the vaulted ceiling far overhead, half-hidden in the fogged shadows of the ghost-world, a little breathless at the thought of the weight of stone above. My gaze dropped down, past heavy, blocked pillars to the sea of shining gold. Everything was lit with Smaug’s warm-glowing fires and the unearthly vision afforded by the Ring.
Well, almost everything. There was another light, I noticed. A soft, pale, wavering light like liquid silver that wafted out from the valley between two heaps of coin shored up by interlinked shields. It was not very far away. Keeping as tight a leash as I dared upon the mountain-fire beneath my skin, I tip-toed cautiously toward it.
There was a gem, I saw, half-hidden beneath the golden scree. I brushed the cool metal aside to get a better look. The jewel was about the size of my hand and the light was coming from within it, a sparkling heart that moved and shifted with a glow somewhere between white and blue and then many other colours in turn. I stared down upon it, captivated. It came to me quickly what this must be. Thorin had spoken of it before. The prize of Erebor, the Heart of the Mountain. The King-stone. The Arkenstone.
This... was not good. I dared not reveal my find to either of the parties currently locked in discussion behind me. Smaug regarded all of this hoard as his; this would not be excluded from that term of our deal. Thorin would see it as his birthright, and be no less adamant. Unless I wanted to destroy everything I had been working towards, I had better hide it again quickly. There would be plenty of time later to decide what to do about it.
I shovelled handfuls of coins back over the top of the stone, taking care to note its position. Once I was sure I would be able to find it again, I stood and casually wandered back over to the others. It seemed that they might be drawing to a close at any rate. Thorin was nodding vigorously, and Smaug was smiling without teeth.
“So have you two come to some sort of arrangement then?” I asked them, doing my best to sound casual.
“I believe it is so,” the dragon replied. “Perhaps I have not insisted on as much as I ought, but for the entertainment and novelty of all this I am willing to be lenient. May you think it some kind of were-gild, if you like, for those soldiers of yours I slew.”
Once more anger returned to Thorin’s eyes. “It is not the custom of my people to accept gold for lives,” he said sharply. “Not that you are giving me gold in any case, merely not forcing me to pay more.”
“And you may take the steel,” Smaug said, taking no offence. Perhaps he had enjoyed their bargaining. There was much of the character of dragons that was still a mystery to me. “Iron is good and fine, but it has no fire in it until Aulë’s folk put it there.”
“And much good the armour and arms of this vault will do us against you,” Thorin said with a bitter smile. “Yet we may still need it. I do not trust the Master of the Lakemen, and the elves of Mirkwood may come looking for revenge.”
Smaug laughed. “Why fear anything whilst I am here? None have come against me and lived; that will not change because I have showed some small mercy to a pack of dwarves who pose me no threat.”
“Still there is something in the air that makes me uneasy.”
I spoke up. “I trust your instincts,” I said, which was true, although I also wished to take the side of my intended. Of course, I realised with a little thrill, that moment was closer than ever, that moment he would come into his kingdom and restore his honour and thus as he had promised we would be able to court one another openly in the manner of his people. “Even if it seems unnecessary, it is surely always a good idea to prepare for the worst.”
The dragon smiled. “As you wish, little ghost.”
We left after that, since the treaty and its terms had been decided. The soft noises of Smaug settling back atop his bed of gold wafted up the still air behind us as we ascended the stair. Thorin was silent. I did not try to make conversation – he was clearly in no mood for it. It was not as though I didn’t understand the reasons for it. The memories of his dead, of the great wrongs that had been done to him and his kin, of stolen gold and halls that stunk of fire-drake... And now a forced and unpleasant peace, the only path left open. It would take some time for him to stomach it, and as its architect, I was not the person to help with that. I only hoped he could come to forgive me for my role in all this.
-----
The others were waiting for us at the entrance of the tunnel, the Company and the Ringwraiths behind them standing tall and still as statues. Visible once more and shorn of the mountain’s power, I looked up rather wearily into twelve expectant faces and eight hidden ones. But it was not for me to bear the news of the conclave in the trove-hall. I looked across to Thorin, sour-faced and grim.
“It is done,” he said. “I have spoken with the beast and bought back our home with the treasures of its mines.”
A sigh arose, and with it expressions of disappointment and bitterness.
“Enough,” Thorin said, with a quick cutting motion of his hand that forestalled any objections. “It was our only chance of regaining Erebor. This is not something any of us wanted, but Bilbo was right. I have seen Smaug, seen him without the heat of battle to alter his size in my mind, and it was foolishness to think any strength of our arms could have felled him. We are no army. And it is not as bad as it could have been. We have our home, save that one hall. We have a means to make our wealth.”
“How much did the wyrm demand?” Glóin asked.
“Of refined gold, one ounce in every twelve, of silver one in twenty, of cut gems weight matters more to him than size or quality or colour, but he desires half of all we mine. Iron and other lesser metals are ours, though Erebor is not known for those.”
“It is a hard toll to bear, but I suppose it is acceptable,” Balin said. “To regain Erebor.”
“Such were my thoughts,” Thorin replied.
“I still think we could kill him,” Kili muttered, half under his breath.
“We could not,” Thorin said sharply.
“But what of the Arkenstone?” Fili asked. “Is there no hope of getting that back? I remember the stories you and Mother told of it when we were young. Such a marvel...”
But Thorin was shaking his head, to my own rising wave of guilt. “It was lost in a sea of coin when I pulled my grandfather away from that hoard, and it would take much searching to find it again. Not that the dragon would permit it.”
Should I mention now that I had found it? But what good would it do? It was part of Smaug’s treasure now, and he would never give it up. No, I decided. It would be pointless, and only cause further pain. Better to keep my silence.
“So what must be done now?” I asked the Company. “Will you draw up a contract like the one you had me sign? Thought I suppose that is null and void now... Still I can’t imagine Smaug signing his name easily.”
Bofur laughed. “Now there’s a sight I’d like to see.”
“Next we move into the halls of Erebor,” Thorin said. “And best we enter past the dragon, so Kili can see why I have decided upon this course of action. Then there are repairs to be made to the outer gate, and a raven to be sent east to Ered Luin to my sister Dís, if one can be found that knows the way.”
“Aye,” Dwalin said, “I have not seen Erebor since I was a child. I want to waste no time before I see it again.”
So it was that we sent the rope down to Bombur and Bifur and the camp below and brought up the supplies load by load, and then finally brought up the two dwarves themselves, though Bombur took much persuading that it would indeed bear his weight. Our Laketown steeds had to be left where they were until we could bring them round by the main gate and let them enter that way. Then we lit torches and the whole great cavalcade of us started off down the tunnel, closing the hidden door behind us.
----
There was no longer any need for secrecy, so the torches stayed lit and I did not dip into the shadow-world when we came to the stair into the treasure-hall. The Wraiths were set as a guard around me, their hands upon the hilts of their deadly swords. The Company were nervous too, but also amazed. I could see it the moment their eyes fell upon the hoard, the lust that both dwarf and dragon shared and that I now recognised well from all I had seen of it. Thorin must have noticed it too, for he rushed us on and down, between the heaps of gold and armour. He wanted them to see why they must give all this up.
Smaug huffed out black smoke when he saw us, fixing his great golden eyes on each dwarf in turn. “I had not thought to see you back so soon,” he said. “But on, on with the lot of you, through to your home. Go and think not of stealing from me on your way, for I know this hall and all it contains, know it in my blood, and so I shall know if you take so much as a coin.”
Fili’s eyes were wide and round, and he was not the only one. But Balin and Dwalin both looked upon the dragon with expressions of great hate and disgust. I had no doubt their thoughts had turned to the blood Smaug had shed a century past.
Still, no-one spoke and no violence broke out. It was not the time to be thinking about gathering up the promised iron and steel either. Between two tall pillars ahead were great gates of stone with gilded handles, the way forward into the rest of Erebor. It did not seem to me that the massive doors would be easily opened, yet even after all this time dwarvish workmanship and ingenuity still had their power. As Thorin pulled they slid inwards like the opening of a mouth, and the dim light that fell from Smaug’s skin passed through them, illuminating the high corridor beyond. There must have once been lamps down here, but with the passing of many years unattended they had dried up and died. All was quiet, and still, and dark.
Yet as we went through and stood upon a flat, cold stone floor, enough subtle radiance filtered through from somewhere that dwarvish eyes – and those made keen through magic – could still see that before us was the railing of a balcony that looked out upon a great space that rose up and fell down for hundreds of feet. The yawning gap was crossed with strong bridges, and many shadowed windows looked out upon it from houses burrowed into rock. Stairs wound here and there, and all was carved from beautiful green marble and greenschist pierced with the dregs of rich seams.
“It’s... amazing,” I said.
“It is home.” Thorin replied, and in the flickering light of his torch he looked strong, and handsome, and proud, and I wanted him more than ever.
----
Of course there was much to do after that. Thorin’s people had left Erebor in a hurry, and had not had time to pack. The great majority of the houses we went into were strewn with furniture and belongings half-rotted away with time. Even the royal apartments, where we made our camp, were clearly but the shadow of the glory of their finer days. Still, Erebor was warm with mountain-blood heat, rising up from far below, and we were comfortable. We brought the ponies in by the main gate and stabled them on the entrance level, and our supplies with them. The Wraiths, un-tempted by gold, brought armour and weapons out from the hoard. We set rooms to rights, we began to shore up the broken ruins of the gate with new-quarried stone, and we gave proper burial to the bones of those who had fallen beneath the claws of Smaug, though not without guilt.
Besides all this, Balin also led an expedition to the old south-western watch-post on a rise called Ravenshill, where had lived in days of old the messenger birds that winged letters between the dwarven strongholds of Middle-earth. He took with him Dori, Ori and Gloin, and I joined them with Khamûl and Adûnaphel. It was about five hours walk from the gate, in the cold of autumn that could not seem to bite at me. I had too much fire in my blood now for that.
The watch-post, when we came upon it, was blackened and charred, the stone half-melted by dragon-fire. It lay high up on a bluff however, with good views to west, east and south, and far and about there was nothing to see but the Desolation and the ruins of Dale. There were birds though, a small flock of crows circling far overhead, the song of thrushes brought on the breeze, the occasional blackbird hopping from one rock to another.
“If any of the Ravens of Erebor yet remain, we must wait for them to come to us,” Balin said.
It was perhaps the span of a few hours, but we were prepared to wait for longer than that. The creature that came fluttering out of the clear sky to perch on an outcrop of broken stone was a bedraggled and piebald sort of thing, speckled with white and grey through its black feathers, and quite bald in several places. The Raven – for indeed it was one of that line of birds blessed with speech and understanding – cocked its head at us and peered with rheumy eyes.
“Strange to see dwarves on this mountain with the dragon yet living,” he croaked. “I am Róac son of Carc, and it has been a hundred years and three and fifty since my egg was hatched. I am patriarch of the few of my kind that have not yet left for the other kingdoms, and I know of you, Balin son of Fundin, King’s Steward.”
“You are old and wise indeed, friend Raven,” Balin said. “Thorin son of Thrain son of Thror has returned to the mountain, and made peace with Smaug.”
“Peace with the wyrm?” the Raven cawed. “I do not think it wise, but you know your business I suppose. It matters little to the birds. We are too small for him to take heed of us.”
Dori spoke this time. “We had hoped, good Raven, that you would renew the ties between our people. Now that we are here, we hope to spread the good news to our kin back in the Blue Mountains... and to the other kingdoms, of course.”
Róac bobbed his head at this, but I saw that his gaze had turned to me and the two Wraiths at my back. “Who is this who comes cloaked in power? Who comes with the dead as his guards?”
“Just a friend,” I replied. “An ally of the dwarves, and – although I suppose it is not exactly something to be proud of – broker of the peace.”
“I am old enough to know many things, and I like not the smell of you,” the Raven replied. “But I remember the oaths I took as a hatchling. You will have my wings, and those of my family. I will take your message, and all those you wish to spread after that.”
Balin bowed deeply, and the rest of us took our cue from him and did the same. The Raven croaked in approval and took wing. I doubted he would fly all the way to Ered Luin himself, but I was sure that our message would be in safe hands – so to speak – all the same.
As we later came to find out however, Róac was not the only bird who bore a message afar that afternoon. A little thrush had been listening also, and the words it took south were to prove great trouble for us. It flew to Laketown, and a man named Bard the Bowman, of the line of Dale’s Kings.
----
The Ravens’ flight to Ered Luin was long indeed – we had ourselves been on that road for many months, such that I had quite lost the count of days. Still, half a year on foot perhaps, and though swifter by air it still held its dangers. Plus however long the great dwarvish exodus would take to reach us, of how many? Perhaps a thousand or more. They must needs come spread out; else like an army on the march they would eat the country bare as they passed. So it was that the news of the fate of Erebor reached other places first, and the trouble from Laketown returned to us soonest of all.
The supplies were beginning to run low by that point, and some talk had been made of re-opening the trade links that had previously kept Erebor fed. Some strange and unfamiliar plants would grow in mountain depths watered by hot springs and far from the light of the sun, but they had been left to grow wild, or to wither from lack of tending. Also there were great jars of honey unspoiled in the storerooms, and packets of cram wrapped in waxed leather, which was hard yet edible, but all else that had been in there had soured and rotted and turned most horrible. When the door to the first chamber was opened such a stink came out of it as to turn all our stomachs and make us slam it closed. It would have to be cleared, but no-one wanted that job.
Bofur and Bombur, who had experience of working mines, had begun to explore the seams and deep delvings of the mountain, and had brought back some little samples of uncut gems and electrum ore. There had been some maps of the seams here, but most of it had been in the heads of the miners, and much needed to be investigated before it would be entirely safe to re-open them.
As to myself and Thorin… well. It had been but a few days, and those busy and long. I had not yet had a chance to broach with him the subject of courtship – though from the looks he sent me I knew he wanted to speak of it just as much as I.
Such was the situation when Oin, who had been sitting the morning guard at the re-made gate, blew the warning horn to summon us there. Standing on the broken path beside the river was a small company of men, led by a tall and serious archer with a great bow slung over one shoulder. He was dark of hair and beard, and grim-faced. He looked up at us gathered at the top of the newly mortared wall with a curious expression.
“So it is true then,” he called out. “You are still alive. Does the dragon live or is it dead?”
“Smaug yet lives,” I called out in reply. “But we have made peace between us. Who are you?”
“I am Bard, called the Bowman,” the man replied. “The Master sent me to see the fate of he who laid claim to the title King-Under-The-Mountain.”
“And is that all?” Thorin shouted down.
“It is not only the treasure of Erebor the dragon keeps beneath the mountain,” Bard replied. “He sortied forth to sack the ruins of Dale before he began his slumber. The Master would have me lay claim to that which he took.”
“What the dragon has taken he keeps,” Thorin said. “We have had none of it back, and he will be no more generous with you.”
The assembled men were murmuring amongst themselves. Bard did not take part in it, but I could tell he was uneasy. Perhaps he did not believe Thorin’s words. It would not be so surprising. The gambit of a treaty had been unlikely enough, and for it to have succeeded even more so.
“I will take your words back to the Master,” Bard said, bowing low. He motioned to his men and they turned and left. That would not be the last we would see of them, I was sure. I could see how the Master might be tempted into war, thinking us few in number, and the treasure vast. He would learn better when the flames descended upon him, but that would benefit no-one. Perhaps it might be wise to have Smaug leave the mountain and pay a visit to the town, so he might explain the situation to them in person. It would not do to actually cause any harm to the town, for we needed them to trade with, but a dragon is persuasive.
Yes, it was a problem that would have to be dealt with, but not right now. There was a little time. We watched the men of Laketown wind their way back down towards the ruins of Dale and disappear from sight, and then we got back to the work of making Erebor fit for habitation.
----
