Actions

Work Header

A Promise in Reverse

Chapter 9: Chapter 8

Chapter Text

Clarice slept for several hours, waking in the early afternoon.

She still felt a deep weariness, but it wasn’t something that could be cured by sleeping more now. She was fully awake, and for the time being, her body had no more interest in sleep. Overall, she felt better than the last time she’d woken up, and worlds better than she had last night, when her body was failing her and she’d barely been able to get her bearings mentally.

But Clarice remembered her rescue with perfect clarity; it was starkly imprinted on her mind amongst a sea of disorientation. That was definitely something she wanted to discuss today.

Carefully getting to her feet, she was pleased when her balance didn’t falter. She made her way to the bathroom while only lightly leaning on the wall.

After she was done, she returned to the bedroom, sat on the bed and drank the Gatorade that remained on the nightstand.

Then she stood, ready to find Dr. Lecter. She opened the door.

The living room of the cabin was done in much the same style as the bedroom was. The walls and floor were wood, and the furniture was elegant but cozy, upholstered in lighter shades of leather to offset the dark surroundings. The cabin was small, with the open kitchen visible in one corner, and a fireplace on the shared wall of the bedroom.

Arranged on either side of the fireplace were two armchairs and a sofa. Dr. Lecter was seated in the chair nearest the fire, and he looked up with interest as she slowly approached. Will, who had been lying on the sofa, got up without comment and took the other chair.

“Thank you,” Clarice murmured. She arranged herself on the sofa, half-sitting, half-lying against the cushions of the arm, with her legs stretched out in front of her. She wasn’t going to pretend that she was at her best when she clearly wasn’t; this time there would be no words traded across a table, words that felt balanced on a knife’s edge.

This time, they were past all that.

Her feet were pointed toward the fire, which gave her the best view of Dr. Lecter, who regarded her patiently as she got settled. He had the glass fireplace doors open to better appreciate the warmth it generated.

“How is your ankle?” he asked.

“It’s fine, thank you,” she said, pulling an afghan from the back of the sofa and draping it over herself. Despite the fire going, there was still a slight chill in the air, and she’d been cold for days. “If the only injuries I got out of being abducted by a serial killer are dehydration and a sprained ankle, I’ll count myself as extremely lucky.”

“Would it interest you to know he wasn’t a serial killer?”

“Yes, actually.”

“Then we may begin our discussion there.” Then he asked, “When is the last time you drank something?”

“Just now.”

He nodded, but stood. “Nevertheless,” he said, retrieving another bottle of Gatorade for her, before sitting back down, “you need to hydrate throughout the day as much as possible. It was extremely fortunate we found you when we did.”

Clarice obligingly opened the bottle and took a sip. As she loosely screwed the cap back on, the thoughts from earlier returned to her.

She looked at Dr. Lecter and tapped the Gatorade bottle with her fingernail. “This isn’t something you would drink. You had it for me, and you had it before you found me. Which meant you knew the state I’d likely be in.”

He seemed pleased at the amount of information she had gleaned from a bottle.

She had already known that them finding her hadn’t been by chance, but she honestly had no idea about anything beyond that. She voiced her best and only real theory. Glancing in Will’s direction, she asked, “Did you guess his methods because he was a killer you were tracking?”

“Not exactly,” Will said.

When he added nothing more, Dr. Lecter asked, “What do you remember of your abduction?”

“Nothing of the abduction itself,” Clarice admitted. “I remember getting up that morning. I think I remember going to the door. There must have been a struggle, but I don’t know what happened. I came to in the trunk of a car. I guessed that I had been drugged. I know a loss of memory isn’t uncommon, but it’s—it’s frustrating not to remember something so significant.”

Will tilted his head. “Your abduction was carefully planned. He went to your house disguised as a delivery driver. The second you opened your door, he injected you with the drugs. You tried to hit him with the lamp in your entryway but fell, knocking over the table and coat rack. Once you were unconscious, he put you in your own car and left the scene. He later changed cars and abandoned yours.”

Clarice absorbed the information, but felt a prickle of unease that had nothing to do with Will’s nearly omniscient reconstruction. While it was eerie hearing a recitation of things that had happened to her that were a blank in her own memory, she was also struck by the precise way he’d described her entryway.

Her brows raised. “I thought you needed to be at the location to reconstruct a crime scene.” It was how she had first met him, after all.

“We have not been to your home,” Dr. Lecter said, answering her unasked question. “But we have seen it.”

“Was news of me being taken released? Were pictures leaked?”

Dr. Lecter shook his head. “No. Though I fear we have come to the part of our tale you’re going to dislike.” At the same time, there was something arch in his expression that indicated he was very much going to like telling her about it.

“Already?” Clarice almost laughed. “I can’t imagine what I could like less than being abducted.”

The corners of his mouth turned up. “I’ve spoken to Ardelia.”

Clarice’s blood ran cold. For a moment, she couldn’t even process all the things his words could mean. She only felt horror. “What?” she finally managed to get out.

He smirked, then continued. “She had quite unexpected things to say. Would it surprise you to know that the main suspect in your abduction was me?”

“Yes.” Clarice felt like she’d more than lost the thread of the conversation. Also, she was still stuck on the fact that Dr. Lecter knew who Ardelia was. “Why did they think that?”

Will spoke. “Because of circumstantial evidence at the scene. And a lack of evidence in any other direction.”

“What circumstantial evi—” The question died on her lips, as she flashed back to the conversation she and Ardelia had had in her kitchen, as well as one of the things they talked about—the thing that, at the time, had seemed the least consequential. “The Christmas card,” she said, staring blankly at the fire. “And the flowers.” Both had been sitting on her kitchen counter, and both would have been found by the FBI. “Because they came from you, everyone would have assumed it was connected to me going missing.”

“Not a completely flawed first assumption,” Will commented, “but flawed nonetheless. Also, the flowers weren’t from Hannibal.”

That surprised her. Clarice looked at Dr. Lecter, who nodded in confirmation.

“Really, Clarice,” he said, amusement still evident on his face, “I would hardly send you white lilies.”

“Of course not,” she said dully. “What was I thinking?”

In truth, she hadn’t been thinking about the flowers, certainly not about what kind they were. She had gotten a card followed by flowers, and she had assumed they were from him.

“The killer sent the flowers,” Clarice said. It was obvious now.

Dr. Lecter nodded, then added, “White lilies are common in funeral arrangements.”

It had been a message, and she hadn’t realized it. Would she have if she hadn’t thought the flowers were from Dr. Lecter? She didn’t know. Work had been all consuming, and every single thing in her life had become harried and hectic.

Even if she had thought something was strange about the delivery, she couldn’t imagine suspecting that it would be a precursor to what had actually happened.

“So the FBI thought it was you. How does Ardelia come into this?”

“She had a differing opinion,” Dr. Lecter said, “but no audience willing to listen to it. She seemed quite desperate.”

It took everything Clarice had to keep her tone light when she said, “And you enjoy desperation.”

His eyes glittered darkly. “Just so.”

Clarice hadn’t anticipated this conversation being tense, but until she knew how Ardelia was involved with them she couldn’t shake her uneasiness. Yet if she came right out and demanded to know exactly what happened with Ardelia, she suspected Dr. Lecter was only going to be more entertained than he already was. The conversation itself was half the point.

She resigned herself to a circuitous route instead of a direct one, and used the opportunity to take another drink.

“An unusual message on the Tattle Crime forums caught my eye,” Dr. Lecter said. “It asked for a favor, and had nothing but a phone number and a picture of the necklace I sent you, which I could hardly fail to recognize.”

“You thought I wrote it.”

“Naturally. I assumed you had contacted me perhaps hoping you could leverage my favor into helping you save someone else. I was prepared for a diverting conversation and an interesting exchange. Imagine my surprise.”

A small part of Clarice was astonished that he had seen what looked like a message from her and had immediately responded to it. She knew taking promises seriously was part of his pathology, but she was still somewhat surprised by the fact that he placed her in such importance after all this time.

“Unlike the FBI,” Will said, “Ardelia was familiar with all the details of what happened in Minnesota. She was at the end of her rope, and we were her last resort. She hoped that we would notice some overlooked element of your disappearance, something we could give her as a lead.”

“Which you obviously did,” Clarice said.

Will regarded her evenly. “Yes and no. We found a lead, but we didn’t give it to her.”

“What did you tell her?”

“Nothing,” he said without concern. “We never called her back.”

Dr. Lecter caught her gaze. “I would not pass up the chance to see you myself, Clarice. And I’m not in the habit of giving my whereabouts to the FBI.”

She wanted to protest that they could have at least let Ardelia know they had figured out where Clarice was, but she knew it would fall on deaf ears. Neither of them had any obligation to Ardelia; neither of them cared that Ardelia probably thought Clarice was dead by now. If anything, Dr. Lecter was probably relishing the uncertainty he’d left Ardelia in.

They had used Ardelia and discarded her without a care. After only the briefest consideration, Clarice decided that she was fine with that actually, as long as it kept Ardelia alive. It was the best outcome possible. She just needed to ensure that it remained that way.

“It had to be dangerous to talk to her at all,” Clarice said, “given the fact that you were the FBI’s main suspect.”

“And what is life without a little danger?” Dr. Lecter countered. “After the initial phone call where you were claimed to be missing, I was intrigued, yet couldn’t dismiss the possibility of a ruse.”

Will spoke, picking up where Dr. Lecter left off. “We both felt that you were unlikely to use yourself as bait in this particular way, trading on Hannibal’s esteem for you. But we also couldn’t reject it entirely. So I requested a walkthrough via camera of the site of the abduction.” He brought his hands together. “I saw three possibilities. One, someone at the FBI came by the information about your history with Hannibal and tried to bend it to their own use, and they would cry off with excuses about your house being inaccessible. Two, you were in on it, and would know that I would want to see the scene, in which case I was curious what story you would try to tell. Three, you really were abducted, and your house would tell its own story. If your friend had gone so rogue as to contact the lead suspect in an investigation about said investigation, she would be unlikely to back down at breaking and entering a crime scene, even if that meant being charged.”

Clarice digested all of that. She couldn’t find fault with Will’s insights. He was also correct that it had never occurred to her to use her connection with Dr. Lecter to try to draw him out. Even now as she considered it, it felt shameful somehow to pretend to be in danger as a lure for the FBI to catch him. And the practical side of her noted that had she done so, he would have considered it a truly egregious betrayal, in a way that he wouldn’t if she arrested him under other circumstances.

She belatedly realized that when Dr. Lecter had said earlier that he’d seen her home, he hadn’t merely seen pictures, but had probably seen every inch of it. Clarice was never particular about housekeeping, but some small part of her disliked the fact that he had seen it now when it was nothing but evidence of her falling apart life.

Then she got over it. If he hadn’t seen it, she would be dead.

“Obviously my house told you something,” she said.

“It did.” Will nodded. “My impression on viewing the scene was that you really had been taken. A story that had been created would want to lead me to a particular conclusion, which would in turn lead me to our arrest. But I saw no narrative at your house, only forms that had yet to solidify into shape. The struggle in the entryway looked genuine. And there were details that seemed too incongruous to be planted. Take the flowers, for instance,” he said, waving a hand. “If you had constructed the scene, why send yourself extra flowers and say they were from us when the card was already there and would have provided enough cause to say the FBI was looking in our direction? It would be one detail too many, an unstable variable to the equation. The simplest answer is that they were real, and everyone thought they were from us, including you. Then there was the message on the wall.”

“What message?”

“In your entryway, he wrote ‘I took what was owed’ in marker. While not definitive, the word ‘owed’ suggests a history or a prior relationship. It would be harder to construct a fictitious story around a known killer, since if their patterns were truly predictable, they would have been caught. It seemed likely the message was real, though it was still a piece I couldn’t fit into the whole. It wasn’t until long after the call that I saw his complete design.”

Throughout Will’s recitation, Dr. Lecter had been watching her intently. She caught his gaze when Will didn’t immediately continue, and she wasn’t surprised when he spoke next.

“The most likely scenario,” Dr. Lecter said, “seemed to be that you had encountered this person and done them a perceived wrong. I imagine there might be many such individuals over the course of your career, but there are fewer who would be in a position to accomplish what this one did. I’ve followed your career quite closely.”

Clarice smiled in spite of herself. “Yes, I’m aware.”

“I considered your notable cases, but most were easily dismissed. But there was one with curious parallels. You and I even discussed him.” His gaze was dark and sharp and completely focused on her as he continued. “Darryl Bayles. He took young women and buried them alive. He sent their families a note that began with the words ‘I took what I wanted’ announcing their abduction, and after they were dead, he sent a bouquet of lilies with coordinates to the coffin.”

Clarice shook her head in disbelief, a sense of dread building in her as he recited the facts of the case. “Darryl Bayles is in prison.”

“He was in prison,” Will said. “Two months ago, he was killed in a fight with another inmate.”

“But then—” she stammered. The conclusion she thought they were leading up to was abruptly swept out from under her. She frowned. “A copycat?”

“Or an accomplice,” Will said. “What do you remember about the case?”

“Most of it.” It had been a dozen years ago, but it was one of the higher profile cases she’d been involved in.

“When you caught Darryl and sent him to prison, he was twenty-three. He had a younger brother, Wade, who was seventeen at the time.”

Clarice nodded. “Wade wasn’t charged. He was a minor, and there wasn’t any evidence that he was complicit in his brother’s crimes. And Darryl confessed to all of it.”

“There might not have been evidence, but there were questions.”

“Even though Darryl Bayles was dead,” Dr. Lecter said, “we looked deeper into the original case. It seemed likely there was a motive for abducting you with such similar calling cards so shortly after his death.”

“The brothers were very close,” Will said. “As children, they were often locked in the cellar together by their abusive mother.”

At the mention of a cellar, Clarice felt a chill wash over her. In the same instant, she saw the case of her own abduction laid out entirely, from beginning to end with crystal clarity. She knew exactly what Will was going to say, and she saw the moment that he saw her put it all together.

“Wade Bayles blamed me for the death of his brother because I was the one who put him in prison,” she said. “And he decided to kill me for it.”

Will nodded. “Prosecutors in the original case looked at Wade, but ultimately dismissed him. In retrospect, Wade was likely involved in his brother’s crimes, even if he didn’t participate directly. At the very least, Darryl shared everything with him and found a willing and interested audience, perhaps one that would have joined him had he not been caught. When Darryl was arrested, Wade didn’t turn in the older brother that he idolized, and the older brother protected the younger as he had been doing his entire life.”

“Given the slight differences of the message and the lilies,” Dr. Lecter said, “Wade did not set out to duplicate his brother’s crimes, but he took inspiration from them and wanted to pay homage as he crafted his first tableau.”

“Lucky for me,” Clarice said. Her tone was dry, but the sentiment was serious. A cellar was preferable to a coffin.

She felt Dr. Lecter watching her again. When she looked up, he asked,

“Did you interact with him when you awakened?”

“No,” Clarice said. Then she exhaled. She didn’t particularly want to talk about this part, but she knew he would, so she went with a bare bones narration of facts. “Like I said, I woke up in the trunk of a car. I was tied up and my mouth was taped, so there was nothing I could do. I pretended to be unconscious when he carried me into the cellar. He cut the ties on my hands and feet when he put me down, and that’s when I saw my chance. I kicked him and bolted for the ladder, but I was still moving too slowly. We struggled and he threw me off. He went up the ladder and locked the cellar doors. I tried to talk to him through them several times. It was the usual sort of negotiation tactics we’re trained in,” she said, glancing at Will, “to establish rapport, to feel out information. He never replied once.”

“He cut your bonds because he wanted you to experience exactly what he did in the cellar,” Will said, his voice and his eyes distant. “To know that you were trapped and there was nothing you could do about it.”

“Yes,” she said, suddenly feeling exhausted.

“But he didn’t care if you knew why you were there or not. Your ignorance might have even been part of the appeal. All he wanted you to know is that you were going to die there.”

“Yes,” she said again.

Will’s gaze slipped back into focus. “Your abduction was planned with an orchestration the original murders lacked. Wade wasn’t young and rash, but methodical and efficient. And he wanted different things from the experience. I would guess he began making plans within a week of Darryl’s death.”

“It is fortunate Wade Bayles differed from his brother,” Dr. Lecter said, echoing her earlier thoughts. “Because of the initial similarities of the crimes, it seemed like you might already be beyond any reach.”

He meant that if she’d been buried in a coffin, she would have been dead.

Dr. Lecter’s eyes flicked in Will’s direction. It was only the briefest of glances but there was both fondness and pride in his look. “But Will thought otherwise.”

“I wondered if it was Will who actually cracked the case,” Clarice said, “but that seemed rude to say.”

Dr. Lecter gave her a true smile, and then looked toward Will, the smile still on his face. “It’s never rude to compliment my husband.”

Will shook his head, as if in exasperation, but there was the ghost of a smile on his lips.

Somehow they had actually gotten married, despite the fact that they had to be living under assumed names.

Clarice didn’t know what to say. So she said the only thing she could. “Congratulations.”

“Thank you,” Dr. Lecter said, nodding to her.

She noticed neither of them wore rings.

Will saw her looking. “Rings are symbolic. I left symbolism behind long ago.”

Clarice knew he had been married once before, and she wondered if that was what he was referring to. But his first marriage certainly wasn’t any of her business. Also, she didn’t particularly care.

Instead, she looked at Dr. Lecter. “And yet you place a high level of importance on symbolism and ritual.”

“That is true,” he acknowledged. “But traditions may be set aside. The rarest things are worth having in and of themselves.”

“Like the fact that I can’t testify against him,” Will said, sardonic.

One corner of Dr. Lecter’s mouth turned up. “Hardly my first consideration, Will,” he said, catching Will’s gaze again.

Will arched a brow, his smirk an answer to Dr. Lecter’s. “Useful though.”

“Let us hope it is never put to use.”

“It won’t be,” Will said, certainty in his tone. Like it was that easy to declare that they’d never be caught, never be arrested again. Perhaps it was, Clarice thought cynically. They seemed to be doing phenomenally well so far. As if reading her thoughts, Will turned back to her and said, “Hannibal has the Devil’s luck. You do, too.”

Clarice almost protested that she clearly didn’t, but hadn’t she thought just moments ago about how lucky she’d been? Instead, she asked, “Then why can’t I catch you? Either of you?”

“Perhaps it’s more accurate to say that you have the Devil’s luck in conjunction with Hannibal.”

“I suppose I can’t really refute that, given my current circumstances. Everything about us meeting like this is extraordinary.” She had been in the wrong place at the right time, the time the universe had crossed their paths again.

“I’m happy to agree,” Dr. Lecter said.

“After our last meeting, you left the country. I’m surprised you were back here at all.”

“We had an errand to complete.”

“And what was that?”

“Come now, Clarice,” he said. “I would hardly admit such things to an FBI agent.” His eyes were bright and sparked with amusement. “Friends though we are.”

He had obviously committed a crime, and given his history, it was most likely murder. Clarice pressed her lips together in frustration. He wasn’t going to tell her, and there was nothing she could do about it. She didn’t like backing down, but she wasn’t going to pointlessly keep asking. He wasn’t a suspect who would break and confess because she pressed him and repeated the question.

“I’m going to find out later,” she said.

“Of course you will. I never imagined otherwise.”

Clarice gave him a hard stare, which he returned without blinking. She knew there was no point in pursuing the matter, though she closed the door on that topic with resignation. “Fine,” she said, annoyance coloring her voice.

Dr. Lecter showed no signs of displeasure. If anything, he was enjoying her reaction.

Clarice paused to take a drink, and then returned to the previous thread of the conversation. “You hadn’t finished telling me about Wade Bayles.” She looked at Will. “How did you know he hadn’t put me in a coffin?”

“Darryl buried the girls remarkably close to their homes, in order to devastate the families further with how near they were the whole time. But your car was found almost sixty miles north of Quantico. It’s possible Wade changed direction after abandoning your car, but continuing on seemed more likely. Especially as that highway would be on the route to his childhood home in Pennsylvania.”

Clarice’s breath caught. Wade had put her in a cellar as he had been put in a cellar, but she hadn’t imagined it was actually the cellar.

“The house itself burned down several years ago,” Will said. “Wade’s mother, the sole resident, was killed. Wade was never a suspect—he was on a three month long construction job as site manager in Tennessee at the time, and investigations ruled that the cause of the fire was a cigarette. Wade inherited the property, but never rebuilt it, despite having the skills to do so himself. The lot has sat abandoned since. The cellar, of course, is still intact.” Will held her gaze, his eyes intense but his voice detached as he continued. “I saw his design of reverence and revenge. He took inspiration from his brother and sought to honor him. He wanted to punish you for Darryl’s death, in the very place that he and Darryl forged their childhood bond. You would die where he and his brother were metaphorically born. That was his design.”

Silence fell after his pronouncement, the only sounds in the room being those that came from the fire.

Clarice herself was struck speechless. She had watched Will pull answers out of the air before, drawing conclusions that only he could see. She had heard him recite facts in that dead flat voice as he reconstructed something. The way his mind accurately leapt from one conclusion to another with only the barest evidence and impressions remained astounding. But having him narrate her own account left her unmoored.

She’d thought that Will had most likely been the one responsible for actually finding her, but only now was she struck with the full force of what part he’d played in saving her life. Dr. Lecter was the one who had an interest in her, and his interest had all but guaranteed Will’s involvement. She certainly wasn’t discounting Dr. Lecter’s own insights, particularly regarding his knowledge of her past cases, but she knew that if it weren’t for Will Graham she wouldn’t be sitting here.

She was aware that she was still staring at him.

Clarice blinked, coming back to herself. Then she said, “I thanked him, but I never thanked you. Thank you. For everything.”

Will inclined his head. “You’re welcome.”

There was another moment of silence, before Dr. Lecter broke it.

“The rest,” he said, “I’m sure you can surmise. You were still well within the timeframe for surviving dehydration, and while we of course didn’t know for certain what we would find at the Bayles property, we prepared accordingly.”

“I also suspected Wade might be visiting the site,” Will said. “The temptation to experience what he had done would be too much to resist. The area was rural and deserted; he wouldn’t need to worry about being seen.”

“And he was there,” Clarice said.

“Yes.” Something dark and satisfied flickered over Will’s face. “His endeavors were undone in a single moment. He did not foresee us.”

“Who would,” Clarice said, almost to herself.

“You would, perhaps,” Dr. Lecter said. “But few others.”

There was undoubtedly some commentary to make about being saved from a would-be murderer by serial killers, but at the moment, Clarice had no idea what it was. She couldn’t help but feel incredibly grateful to both Dr. Lecter and Will, and part of her resented the fact that she now had such warm feelings towards them. The semi-professional arm’s length she had held them at for years had utterly evaporated in the last twenty-four hours.

But she couldn’t make herself feel differently, and trying to do so seemed disingenuous.

Clarice had a good understanding of herself, and she could hold two contradictory sentiments in her head at the same time. They were killers who had done unspeakable things. She had a deeply personal connection to them. Both were true, and neither canceled out the other.

“Wade Bayles set out to settle a debt,” Dr. Lecter said, “and ended up being the means to settle one in turn.”

“I wasn’t interested in debt,” Will said.

“What were you interested in?” Clarice asked. It was Will’s life she had saved in Minnesota, yet he hadn’t brought it up once. She doubted he viewed it as Dr. Lecter did, as something to be repaid, but she also suspected that his empathy would have played a role in helping her.

“Hannibal has an interest in you. My interest often follows his, even if it doesn’t correspond completely. I was intrigued, because of you and the mystery surrounding your disappearance. I act because I want to, not because of obligation.”

Still looking at Will, Clarice indicated Dr. Lecter with a nod of her head. “Are you saying he does things out of obligation?”

“Hannibal takes whimsy and masquerades it as obligation.”

Dr. Lecter glanced in Will’s direction, obviously diverted by the turn of the conversation. “Obligations are much more fun if they’re enjoyable to fulfill.”

“You make your own obligations.”

“I also make my own fun.”

Will’s lips quirked upward at that.

“So you see, Clarice,” Dr. Lecter said, “Will and I both follow our natures. Fortunately they lead us to many shared places.”

“You got to return a favor, and Will got to solve a case and hunt a killer.” Then Clarice’s own words registered in her mind. “Wade Bayles wasn’t technically a murderer,” she realized. She had heard them say it before, but only now did she connect that fact to Will killing him. “But you must have killed him. I saw you hacking up the body. You killed someone who wasn’t actually a killer.”

Will gave a minuscule shrug. “He was in the process of killing you.”

“I’m honored that merited an exception to your pattern.” Clarice’s tone was dry, but the profiler in her was suddenly desperately curious. “Or did it? Was he the first person you’ve killed who wasn’t a murderer?”

Will’s smile was cool and didn’t reach his eyes. “I couldn’t say.”

She wondered if he really had expanded his pool of acceptable victims, or if Wade Bayles had simply been close enough that Will didn’t see a material difference.

“I’m not asking you to confess to a murder,” she said. “I’m asking if your priorities have changed.”

“You mistake the distinction as black and white, as if there is no action besides a finger pulling the trigger. Participation is participation.”

“That’s a broad brush if you count intentions and attempts as equivalent to successes.”

Will raised a brow. “I’d say Wade Bayles made quite the attempt, wouldn’t you?”

Clarice couldn’t disagree with that. If she had been there another day or so, Wade Bayles would have been a murderer.

“How do you feel,” Dr. Lecter cut in, “knowing that he’s dead?”

“Relieved.”

“And?” he prompted. “Nothing else?”

Clarice really considered it. She could feel what the answer was; it was there hiding in the darkest corner of her mind. “Part of me is glad,” she admitted.

“Why should you not be glad?”

“Because he should have been brought to justice. But at the same time, I’m glad that he’s gone and can’t ever hurt me, glad I never have to look into his eyes.”

He continued to study her with a quiet intensity. “What did you think while you were in the cellar?”

“Mainly about trying to get out.”

“And how did you feel when you knew you wouldn’t be able to, knowing that you might die there?”

“No,” Clarice said, so abrupt she shocked herself. Dr. Lecter had always been drawn to pursuing painful topics, but this time he had scratched at something too new, too raw. She could feel her jaw clench, but she kept her expression as neutral as possible as she searched for the correct words. In the end she simply said, “No. I’m not discussing with you what it feels like to be a victim.”

Dr. Lecter stared back at her in the silence that followed, his face a mask of peculiar blankness, as if he too were weighing responses.

Then he blinked and the moment passed. “As you like.” Something darkly amused passed over his features as he added, “Though your refusal leaves me to draw my own conclusions.”

“I can live with that.”

Will chuckled. Dr. Lecter’s attention briefly shifted to him, breaking any remaining tension. Though when Dr. Lecter glanced back at her, he still seemed like he was enjoying himself at her expense.

She didn’t care. Dr. Lecter could think whatever he wanted about her mental state.

“Do you still dream about the lambs, Clarice?”

It was an unrelated question on the surface, except for the fact that the lambs had also been a tender subject. He had chosen it to make a point about not discussing the cellar with him. Still, the answer was easy.

“I haven’t dreamed about the lambs in years. Not even after cases that went wrong.”

“And will you dream of them now? After you couldn’t save yourself?”

“Probably not,” Clarice said. She stared at him boldly as the fire crackled between them. “I was saved, after all.”

Something behind his eyes shifted as he held her gaze, and his expression slowly turned to one of unquestionable satisfaction. “You were indeed.”