Actions

Work Header

A Promise in Reverse

Summary:

Sequel to A Fine Distinction. Ten years later, Hannibal gets the chance to repay Clarice for saving Will’s life.

Notes:

- Much thanks to DreamerInSilico for beta’ing!
- Thanks to enigmaticblue for being my informant!

- This fic is the conclusion of the series. When I wrote the first fic, I never intended to do a sequel, but then I got an idea. When I wrote the second fic, I didn’t exactly intend to do a sequel, but I also left the possibility open, in case I could figure out how to make a sequel believably work. And I thought about it a long time, trying to get it all to come together. The ideas for this story came in bits and pieces, and it was slow writing. And of course there were long stretches of time that I didn’t work on it at all. But this fic never would have been finished without all the people who left comments years after A Fine Distinction was posted, expressing appreciation for it, and interest in what would happen next. I hope everyone who’s still around the fandom finds this worth the wait.

-If you see a typo, please let me know. Really! I want to fix it!

Chapter 1: Prologue

Chapter Text

Once, Clarice went to the office of Dr. Hannibal Lecter.

It had been years since the last time she had seen him, time in which he and Will Graham had simply vanished. There had been no sightings and no leads, and the case remained open yet stagnant.

She went to the office solely because she was curious.

Crawford had given her a set of keys. She was certain he wasn’t supposed to have them. Before her time, the FBI had gotten access to Dr. Lecter’s office after the Tooth Fairy had broken in. Crawford had kept the keys in his own desk, where they’d been long forgotten by anyone else at the FBI. He had turned them over to Clarice during a conversation about his possible retirement, surprising her in both that he had them and that he thought they should be kept.

She was the obvious choice for obvious reasons. Clarice had taken them without comment, and had even considered simply disposing of them. But she couldn’t bring herself to do it.

Dr. Lecter rarely entered her thoughts these days, though it was inevitable that she now found herself thinking of him. In the end, she simply decided to use the keys for their intended purpose. She could open a door, and then close it again.

Clarice drove to Baltimore on a sunny day. She parked on the street and walked up the sidewalk to the gate, which she had to unlock. A set of steps brought her to stand at the building’s imposing door. She stared at it before she entered, like she imagined so many others before her had done. She put the key in the lock, entering the building as Dr. Lecter had done.

There was no electricity, of course, as utilities had been shut off long ago. The waiting room was lit by one dim window, muted light shining in between the blinds. The chairs were draped in plastic, as were the pictures that still hung on the walls. She felt like she was walking through a crime scene, one that had been long abandoned.

The office proper was much the same—everything swathed in plastic, a visible layer of dust on the floor. Clarice went to the windows first, pulling the curtains back as slowly as she could in order to stir up the least amount of dust. The high windows let in what seemed like a world of light, even with the semi-sheer blinds still closed. The office was massive, and she could easily envision how elegant it would have been when it was set up. It was still set up, in a way, as nothing had been moved, but merely covered.

Her footsteps echoed on the wooden floor.

There was a chaise that drew her attention, mainly because she couldn’t imagine Dr. Lecter actually doing therapy while his patient stared at the ceiling. Perhaps he’d only had it because it was a thing that amused him to possess, a thing others would expect to see in a psychiatrist’s office. It was an ornament that filled the empty space.

No, a session would have happened between the two leather chairs. Dr. Lecter would want the ability to study the person across from him, to analyze their every word and movement. Clarice circled the chairs, drawing back the covers of each one. She wondered which one Dr. Lecter would have favored. She sat down in one, testing the feel of it. This, she decided after a moment, would have been the patient’s chair. It faced the door, allowing the patient a sense of security, the ability to see the entrance to the room. The other chair would have been Dr. Lecter’s, then. Clarice moved to it, sitting down and staring at the chair across from her.

She wondered how many times Dr. Lecter had sat here and conversed with Will Graham. The echoes of conversations long past seemed as suspended in the air as the dust that caught the light.

After another moment, Clarice stood, carefully covering both chairs again. She walked the perimeter of the room. Bookcases and covered art, side tables and ornamental chairs stood shrouded, placed just as Dr. Lecter had left them. Towards the back of the room were two separate sitting areas, one in front of a fireplace, another in a corner with a table to work at. In the center of the space sat Dr. Lecter’s desk. Clarice ran her fingers over the plastic as she walked around it, but she didn’t uncover it.

She stood behind the chair and appraised the room. She was again struck by the feeling of something both preserved and forgotten. There was something haunting in walking rooms so little changed, rooms so defined by their owner.

Clarice left the desk and made her way over to the ladder that led to the second level. Her hands left prints in the dust as she ascended, and the bookcases that lined the walls above were also covered in plastic. Clarice slowly walked the length of the balcony, and then back to the center. Her position commanded an impressive view of the room. She personally would have found the ladder inconvenient for daily use of the library, but she imagined that Dr. Lecter would have liked the aesthetic of the balcony so much that it wouldn’t have bothered him.

The banister was covered in dust, and she resisted the childish urge to write her name in it. But common sense overruled her amusement, as she was technically trespassing in the building.

After making her way back to the main level, Clarice stood for a moment more, lingering in what she had come to see. Finally, she closed the curtains and crossed the room to leave. The waiting room door shut quietly as she pulled it to; the solid wood front door clanked as it closed.

Clarice locked the building and then the gate, and got into her car. She started it and began to drive, not back to Quantico, but to another address she’d never been to.

Dr. Lecter’s home sat on a road full of grand structures, all of them dignified and imposing. None more so than his house, which seemed to cast a pall over the area, despite not appearing outwardly much different from its neighbors.

Clarice parked across the street and simply looked. She understood that the interior of the house was much like the office, draped and closed up, but more or less just as he’d left it. She didn’t have a key, nor did she want one. Walking the halls of his office was one thing; being in his home would be quite another.

The house itself had become something of an urban legend. In the beginning, after Dr. Lecter’s arrests, it had attracted the curious and the crime junkies. But regular patrols down the street, plus neighbors ready to call the police on anyone loitering, had seen things more or less taper off. However, he was always a topic of interest to the public, and it wasn’t uncommon for people to still wander by.

The city had initially put up a chain link fence, which at least kept people to the sidewalk. Most of the time, anyway.

More recently, the house had drawn the attention of people young enough to not even remember when Dr. Lecter was first caught. Adventurous and impulsive, they were attracted to it partly for the shock value and partly because it was an abandoned mansion. After three of them died, the word ‘cursed’ began to appear in conjunction with mentions of the property.

Two young men had been spray painting the front door one night when someone called the police on them. They had bolted when they’d seen the police car’s lights, hopped the fence, and jumped into the car they’d been driving. Apparently afraid of pursuit, they had floored it and sped away, right through an intersection where a delivery truck struck their car and killed them both instantly.

Another man had died on the property only a few months later. He had been planning a break in, based on the tools found on his person. He had jumped the fence, landed on an unexpected patch of ice, cracked his head and broken his neck. A neighbor had seen his body the next morning.

Both were freak accidents with nothing to blame but stupidity and bad luck. But it had been years since anyone had seen Dr. Lecter, and the more outlandish corners of the Internet began to talk about the house being cursed or even haunted.

The idea was obviously ridiculous. Clarice didn’t believe in curses or ghosts, for one thing.

The other thing, of course, was that she still got Christmas cards from him.

The cards had started coming to her house, which perhaps should have worried her, but didn’t. Home addresses were easier to find than ever these days, and the change had actually coincided with a promotion she’d gotten. It had almost seemed a courtesy, that she no longer received mail from a serial killer care of the FBI.

But anyone who bothered to actually look at activity related to the house would know that he was still very much alive.

The chain link fence put up by the city had soon been replaced by a tall wrought iron one. The front door had been repainted. The yard had always been kept mowed, and tree trimmers were seen every few years. Taxes were paid annually. Dr. Lecter’s properties were maintained at the precise minimum to keep them from being seized due to fines or liens. So they stood, monuments to silent horrors, the buildings like tombstones over their streets.

Clarice imagined he kept them because his own memories there were pleasant ones. They were places that he had occupied at the height of his career and his killings, not to mention the beginning of his time with Will Graham. He would have disliked someone moving into spaces that were his and altering them, let alone making a spectacle of them. More practically, he had the financial means to keep them, no matter what his reasons.

The FBI had been able to monitor his bank account for a while. There were large payments to an attorney, who in turn was the one taking care of the property management on Dr. Lecter’s behalf, and who was on retainer if Dr. Lecter was ever apprehended again. Nothing else came in or out of the account. A significant amount had been transferred in from an offshore account years ago, seemingly for the sole purpose of conducting any business on U.S. soil Dr. Lecter needed to conduct. Offshore accounts being what they were, that was where the FBI’s attempts at tracing him had ended.

Over time, Clarice had become extremely realistic about the chances of finding Will Graham when he didn’t want to be found. Both Will and Dr. Lecter were capable of evading authorities, but something told her that Will was the one who ensured they never truly attracted attention. It had been years since she’d seriously looked for traces of either of them because she had come to the conclusion that it was a waste of resources that could be better spent elsewhere.

Clarice had been informally proactive after Crawford had given her the case, keeping an eye out for anomalies or for crimes overseas, but had seen nothing that made her suspect their involvement. She hadn’t made the mistake of pouring herself into the project like she had before; she was simply alert for anything odd. As her caseload had increased, she’d found herself with less time to devote to a case that had no movement, but it didn’t bother her the way it would have years earlier.

She had accepted the fact that nothing would happen unless it happened. She would know it when she saw it, and if it was strange enough, she would see it.

There was certainly nothing to see at the house, just as there hadn’t been at the office, but curiosity had driven her to come anyway.

After another moment, Clarice started her car and pulled away from the curb, beginning her drive back and leaving Dr. Lecter’s house behind her.

It probably would have amused him to know that she had been there, that he had occupied her thoughts so thoroughly, even if just for a short period of time. She briefly wished she could have discussed her visit with him, related her observations and seen what he would say in return. It was the first time in years she had actually wondered what it would be like to talk to him.

She and Dr. Lecter had a personal connection, but she had never been contemplative about it. After their last meeting, her understanding of herself and of him had faded to background noise in her life—always present, but not something that needed to be re-examined or dwelt on.

In truth, Clarice never expected to see him again.

Chapter 2: Chapter 1

Chapter Text

Clarice was a victim of her own success.

The fact that she was aware of it didn’t make it any easier to mitigate. She could hardly refuse cases, hardly stop working when results were expected. Her job had always been demanding and high pressure, and while she generally thrived on it, her own outstanding performance had become an almost impossible expectation to keep meeting.

It was currently nine in the evening, and she had just gotten home after a long day. Despite the late hour, Ardelia had offered to pick up Thai food for them both before she went home. Clarice had let her; there was nothing at her own house she felt like cooking or eating.

When the doorbell rang, Clarice let Ardelia in. She took the carryout bag from her, thanking her as she did so, and led Ardelia to the kitchen.

“It’s a mess, I know,” Clarice said as Ardelia followed her in.

“Hey, no judgment here,” Ardelia said, moving to wash her hands.

It was still a mess. There were dirty dishes in the sink, dry ingredients from the last time she had cooked strewn about the countertops, boxes of crackers and cereal that she simply hadn’t put back in the pantry, and a pile of miscellaneous non-kitchen items that had accumulated on the island. Through the doorway to the laundry room, piles of laundry, both clean and dirty, could be seen.

While Clarice in general liked her space tidy, the simple truth was that by the time she came home these days, she was too tired to deal with any of it.

Clarice cleared off space on the table by pushing the scattered papers and mail to one side. She untied the carryout bag and set the containers out, and then washed her own hands and got glasses of water for them both. Joining Ardelia at the table, Clarice opened her takeout and immediately started eating.

They ate in silence for a few minutes, before Ardelia said, “You’re running on fumes, Clarice.”

“This won’t last forever.”

“What makes you think that?”

“Dixon wants a high close rate because he wants the job for more than just the interim. There’s a good chance he’ll get it, and then the pressure will back off.”

“Or it won’t. Or they’ll hire someone else and the whole thing will start all over again,” Ardelia said, waving her fork. “The new boss will want to prove themselves.”

Crawford had retired six months ago. In the end, the work was all he’d had left, and he had continued with it long after he was eligible for retirement. When he’d finally been done, there had been a retirement party, where he’d announced he was moving to Italy to live out his golden years. Crawford had sold his house and moved almost immediately afterward. The swiftness with which it had been accomplished told Clarice that it was something he’d been planning for a good deal of time.

Within the space of a month, Crawford had removed himself entirely from their lives. It was something of an adjustment, as he had been a constant fixture of her career.

“Dixon isn’t even one of us,” Ardelia continued. “On paper, it’s a lateral move from the Justice Department, but in reality, it’s a job with a lot more prestige. Of course he wants it, even if he has no idea how our department actually works.”

“Only someone from inside the department would know how it actually works.”

“Exactly,” Ardelia said. She got straight to the point. “Have you applied for Crawford’s job?”

“No.”

“Are you going to? There’s still time.”

Clarice knew there was still time. The hiring process for high level government jobs moved slowly. Interim managers and directors until the final replacement was hired were common.

“I’m not sure I want it,” Clarice admitted.

“It’s the very best job someone in our line of work can get. Why wouldn’t you? I know you’re not afraid of the responsibility.”

Clarice sighed. “I’m a profiler. I’m good at being a profiler. It’s what I love. It’s where I—” She faltered, searching for the right words. “It’s where I shine, I suppose. I’d even say I’m excellent at it. I know Crawford’s job is a step up, but I don’t want it just because it’s a step up. My whole life, this is exactly where I dreamed of being. This is my dream job. Should I let go of it for more money, for a job I don’t know that I’d love?”

Ardelia pressed her lips together, pensive. “I don’t know,” she said. “I suppose I just can’t imagine not wanting it.”

“Crawford’s job is essentially managerial,” Clarice said slowly. “I’ve never aspired to have a job with that description. My passion is profiling. I can’t imagine managing profilers—I’d just be itching to do the work myself.”

“I think you’d be good at it. Managing, that is.” Ardelia paused, then said, “And you certainly couldn’t be worse than Dixon. You should seriously apply.”

Clarice took a drink of water. “You’re overlooking the obvious,” she said. “I’m forty. You don’t get that job unless you’re fifty.”

“You’re also the star of the department. You’d probably have a good chance at it.”

“If you think the next director is going to be so bad, why don’t you apply for it?”

“I did,” Ardelia said.

Clarice was surprised. “Then why do you want me to apply for it?”

“Because I think you’d be better at it than me,” Ardelia said easily, not at all bothered talking about professional strengths and weaknesses. “But I think I’d be better at it than Dixon.” She continued, saying, “Oh, I know I’m not going to get it. I’m thirty-nine, which is even worse than being forty. But it will be good practice, and the candidate pool is confidential, so Dixon won’t be able to be annoyed about me applying.”

Clarice worked on the last of her food.

“I don’t know,” she finally said. “Nothing is going to be exactly like it was. No matter who’s hired, we’re not going to have another Crawford. And Crawford had his faults, just like anyone. It was just that we were used to them. It’s going to be different going forward, and we can’t change that.”

“Different is fine,” Ardelia said. “But you can’t keep going like this. I can’t keep going like this. I don’t think either of us have gone home before eight in the last two weeks. And I know you worked all of last weekend, and the last before that. I know you worked through Thanksgiving. None of that is sustainable. And I would prefer to have a boss who realizes that. When was the last time you took an actual day off?”

“Before Crawford retired.”

“That’s what I thought.” Ardelia paused again, then said, “I’ll say it again, and then I’ll shut up: really think about applying, won’t you?”

“I have thought about it. But fine, yes—I’ll think about it again.”

When they were both done eating, Clarice stood up and took the containers to rinse at the sink. Then she left them on the counter to dry before they went into the recycling.

She came back to the table to see Ardelia gaping at a piece of her mail. Clarice saw that she held the recent Christmas card from Dr. Lecter. The envelope had been somewhere in the pile of mail that had accumulated over the last week or so.

Ardelia had seen them before, so Clarice wasn’t sure why it was so surprising.

“Is this what I think it is?” Ardelia asked, holding the card up. “You just have this sitting here?”

Clarice shrugged. “It’s not like there’s anyone to see it. Look at it if you want.”

There was a time when she would have tucked it away immediately, worried about someone stumbling across it, but those days were long past. She’d had a few brief relationships, but they had never become serious because she put her job above everything else. Clarice had come to the conclusion that she was a workaholic. Even the vacations she took were practical, so that she could clear her head and come back fresh for work. She had briefly fretted over her total dedication to her career, but had ultimately decided that there wasn’t anything wrong as long as it was what she wanted.

“There were also those,” Clarice said, gesturing to the floral arrangement on the counter, “delivered a day or two later.” Dr. Lecter had sent three other arrangements over the years, each after she had caught a particularly high profile killer. She had been doing so much work recently that she couldn’t immediately pinpoint which case he had found notable, though it could have been several of them. There hadn’t been a separate card with the arrangement.

Ardelia glanced at the flowers before she pulled out the Christmas card from the already opened envelope and looked inside, obviously staring at the signature, before she handed it back to Clarice.

Clarice simply tossed the card back with the pile of mail. “I’ll put it away when I sort through the rest of this.”

She was struck by the thought that if a self-described workaholic was overwhelmed by their division’s new grueling pace, something was going to have to give.

But she could deal with that in the morning. “I’m exhausted,” Clarice said, almost to herself. She suddenly felt like she could fall asleep standing there.

“Ditto,” Ardelia said. “Bright and early tomorrow morning is going to come soon enough.”

They said their goodbyes and Clarice let Ardelia out.

As much as she wanted to, Clarice didn’t go straight to bed. She made a quick sandwich for lunch the next day, took a shower so she didn’t have to in the morning, and found at least half of what she was going to wear tomorrow.

She was asleep nearly as soon as her head hit the pillow.

It seemed like it was only minutes later that her alarm went off, but a quick glance at the clock showed it was indeed morning. Another glance showed that she had slept through her first alarm entirely.

Clarice bolted upright, even as she mentally congratulated herself on her recent practice of setting two alarms. She had already started setting her alarm as late as possible, which led to a hurried morning routine. This morning, it was going to have to be lightning fast.

Clarice ate a yogurt and a bagel, and gulped down a cup of orange juice, wishing she’d had time to make coffee but figuring she would get some at the office. Then she did the bare necessities in the bathroom, skipping her minimal makeup routine entirely and doing nothing with her hair, before scrambling to get dressed. She finally located a clean shirt in the laundry room, and then dashed back to her closet to grab the slacks and blazer she’d laid out.

She was just about to leave through the garage when the doorbell rang.

Through the kitchen window, Clarice could see a UPS truck. She couldn’t remember what she’d ordered, but every few days, some package or other arrived. Nearly everything non-perishable she bought these days was online, much of it set to autoship.

While she was mentally debating whether to retrieve the package from the porch or simply collect it when she got home, the doorbell rang again. Clarice cursed to herself as she turned from the door that led to the garage and went back through the house. Of course the package needed a signature.

She felt more rushed than ever as she rounded the entryway corner. But at least the driver was still waiting, silhouette visible through the beveled windows.

Clarice flipped the lock and opened the door.

Chapter 3: Chapter 2

Chapter Text

Ardelia didn’t immediately notice that Clarice was late.

Ardelia was at her own desk, swamped with compiling notes for her cases into a status report for Dixon. The email had been sitting in her inbox first thing; everyone in the department had gotten one. It rankled Ardelia that instead of doing actual work and making progress, she was also now doing work for the sake of appearances. Dixon seemed to want a parade of people going through his office reporting the status quo.

It was something that took up valuable time and something else that Crawford hadn’t seen the necessity of. He’d expected his people to come to him when they had something big, and to be working at all other times to get something big. No one ever went to Crawford to say that they were still in the middle of things.

Dixon, however, wanted a presentation of case summaries from every agent by the end of the day. Ardelia worked most of the morning to get hers ready. Everyone else seemed to be doing the same; no one came by her desk, and the offices were quiet.

By eleven, she was done, and she went straight to Dixon’s office to get it over with. He simply sat and listened to her, then offered nothing but bland platitudes about making more progress on cases.

As she was leaving, he commented, “You’re on top of things, though. You even beat Clarice in here.”

“Oh?” Ardelia said.

“Mm-hm. She’s usually the first to report in.”

Ardelia said something in generic agreement, made her excuses about getting back to work, and left.

She went down the hallway, not to her desk, but to Clarice’s. Clarice had been exhausted last night, but surely she had made it in to work. Ardelia had spent the morning without leaving her own desk, but the fact that Clarice hadn’t even stopped by on the way to the kitchen to get coffee—which she seemed to live on these days—made Ardelia unexpectedly uneasy.

Clarice’s desk was empty, and there was no sign that she had been there this morning.

Ardelia sat down in Clarice’s chair and fired off a quick text to her. When she didn’t get a response, she called. Ardelia waited while the phone rang. Clarice had been dead on her feet the last few days, but maybe she was worse than Ardelia had imaged.

Clarice didn’t answer.

Ardelia walked back to her own desk for her purse, her mind already made up to leave for lunch and go check on Clarice. It wasn’t like her not to turn up to work, not to answer her phone.

Ardelia wasn’t immediately jumping to any worst case scenarios, as the most likely explanation was that Clarice was asleep, sick, or had even decided to take a day off in order to keep functioning. She supposed the most likely worst case scenario—if she was going to go there—was that there had been some sort of car accident.

But Ardelia couldn’t silence the sudden, nagging voice that said the last time Clarice hadn’t shown up and couldn’t be reached, it was because something had gone incredibly wrong.

They had discussed Hannibal Lecter several times over the years. Ardelia had accepted Clarice’s stance that it was better for her to deal with Lecter alone. But she had extracted the promise that Clarice needed to tell her if she thought something was leading to Lecter, needed to tell her if there was some far-flung theory she was going to check out. Clarice had agreed.

The topic of Lecter hadn’t seriously come up in years. Clarice barely had time recently to get her work done, let alone reopen a pet project. Whatever was going on today wasn’t about Lecter. And it was probably nothing.

But the paranoia in the back of Ardelia’s mind remained.

-----

Half an hour later, Ardelia pulled into the driveway of Clarice’s house, maneuvering around a UPS truck in the road. She had repeatedly called Clarice’s number on the way over, but had never gotten an answer.

Standing at the front door, Ardelia rang the bell. After another minute, she knocked loudly and yelled at the glass, “Clarice? It’s me!”

When nothing happened, Ardelia went around back. She knocked once at the back door, but was already making her way to where Clarice had told her a key was hidden. The shrubbery was in a bed outlined with bricks. Ardelia counted to the tenth brick from the wall, and raised it up. Underneath was a key tightly wrapped in tinfoil. She shook the dirt off and removed the key.

She had never used it. She doubted Clarice had ever used it.

Ardelia opened the back door. “Clarice?” she called again.

There was no answer. There was also no countdown tone from the security system, which should have been armed.

Ardelia headed towards the garage to check for Clarice’s car. The garage was empty, as she had more than halfway expected it to be. The idea of a car accident again jumped to the front of Ardelia’s mind. She hadn’t encountered any wrecks on the highway, but an accident from this morning could have been cleaned up hours ago, Clarice taken to a hospital—

Ardelia’s train of thought screeched to a halt when she noticed Clarice’s cell phone lying on the garage floor.

There was something smaller next to it, discarded on the concrete. She moved closer to make it out.

It was Clarice’s smartwatch.

Dread settled in Ardelia’s stomach even as her training kicked into gear. She drew her weapon automatically, and a moment later, she began a systematic search of the house.

Clarice wasn’t here—no one was likely here, not now—but Ardelia began a sweep room by room. There was nothing in the laundry room, nothing in the kitchen, nothing in the office. Nothing in the living room—but just around the corner, in the front entryway, she could see part of an overturned table.

Stepping through the living room, barely breathing, Ardelia rounded the corner.

The entryway was destroyed.

The small table was tipped over, on the floor several feet away from where it had been sitting. The contents of the table, a heavy metal lamp and a few decorative knick-knacks, were strewn across the floor. Shattered glass that used to be a bowl was in gleaming shards on the tile, and there was a package on the floor. The coat rack was knocked over, the coats in a haphazard pile around it.

On the wall above it all, the words I TOOK WHAT WAS OWED were scribbled in black permanent marker.

Ardelia was stunned, and for a moment she couldn’t move at all. Then she remembered that she was making sure the house was empty. She was more certain than ever that no one was here, but she quickly went through the bedrooms and bathrooms on the other end of the hallway.

Then she holstered her gun and returned to the entryway.

She couldn’t believe this was happening. It felt like something out of a nightmare.

None of the chaos in the entryway had been visible through the textured glass on and around the front door. The door wasn’t even locked, she noticed. She could have walked right in. It had never occurred to her to do so.

Ardelia opened the door. She realized almost immediately that she shouldn’t have. She wasn’t wearing gloves; she could have destroyed evidence. It had been automatic, opening a door she had opened hundreds of times before. But there was nothing to be done about it now besides not touch anything else.

From the doorway, the porch looked as it always had. Of course it did—she had walked right up to it minutes ago.

The UPS truck was still parked across the street.

Ardelia didn’t know quite how many minutes she had been inside, but it was strange that the truck was still there. UPS deliveries were notoriously quick; daily routes were predetermined and already mapped, and drivers had schedules to keep.

Walking out the door and down the driveway, she made her way to where the truck was parked. She looked up and down the road. There was no sign of the driver. No porch that they were on, nowhere else they could have been walking besides the three or four houses in the immediate area. Ardelia circled the truck once.

Stepping into the truck from the driver’s side, Ardelia peered into the back, her weapon held in front of her. There was nothing but packages. She stepped out again, looking around and finding no one at all.

The empty truck had been driven here by someone, and it was too much of a coincidence not to be tied to whatever had happened to Clarice.

-----

Ardelia didn’t go back to headquarters. Instead, she made a call and headquarters came to her. At least, more agents than were strictly required to process a scene came to her, and it felt like all of headquarters.

Everything seemed to happen at once, even though it took hours. Ardelia gave a detailed account of arriving at the house. Photographs of the entryway and garage were taken. Preliminary fingerprint dusting was done. Clarice’s phone and watch were bagged. Searches were started.

Ardelia moved through the house feeling lost as activity bustled around her, agents combing the house for anything out of the ordinary. As much as she tried to pretend that she could handle this like any other case, after the adrenaline of searching Clarice’s house had worn off, a steady combination of numbness and shock had been growing in her.

She kept waiting for someone to point out that she shouldn’t be here anymore, that she was too close to actually work this case. But no one did, and she couldn’t tear herself away.

Ardelia drifted out of the dining room and through the French doors to Clarice’s small office while the search was still going on in the main part of the house. She took advantage of the moment alone, gripping the back of Clarice’s desk chair and forcing herself to take a deep breath.

It was only a moment later that a sharp voice from the kitchen cut through the hum of background activity.

“Holy shit.”

At the sound of the other agent’s voice, Ardelia had one of those strange, prescient moments of startling clarity. In the space of one second, she knew exactly what had happened in the other room and what was going to happen because of it. She didn’t question the instinct that followed; she reached into Clarice’s bottom desk drawer, pulled out a small stationary box, and tucked it into her jacket.

No one noticed.

Everyone was moving toward the kitchen, curious what had been discovered.

Ardelia already knew, but went to look anyway.

The agent that had spoken held something up, his face grim. “Before Starling disappeared, she got a calling card from Hannibal fucking Lecter.”

-----

The rest of the day proceeded much in the same manner as the early afternoon had, in a peculiar kind of slow chaos.

First there was the recording from Clarice’s camera on the front porch. Dixon had raised hell and not only gotten a warrant, but had received footage from the security company within an hour of serving them. Ardelia had to give him credit for that.

The camera footage left her feeling sick, even though it was far from graphic. Just knowing that it was Clarice who had experienced it mere hours ago and was now God knows where with God knows what happening to her made Ardelia’s stomach turn.

The alarm system hadn’t gone off when Ardelia entered because it had never been set for the day. The front porch camera showed a man wearing a UPS uniform walk up to Clarice’s door with a package. The brim of his hat obscured his face from the camera in the porch corner. He rang the bell twice. When Clarice opened the door, he jammed a needle into her neck. Then he stepped forward, and they were both out of frame as they entered the house. Just before she disappeared from the shot, Clarice staggered backward.

It was presumed from the scene in the entryway that Clarice had tried to fight or get away but that she had never made it farther than the hall.

He had then apparently written his message on the wall and loaded Clarice into her own car, leaving the house without anyone seeing. No one had noticed the abandoned UPS truck sitting on the curb all morning. Clarice’s house was one house away from being at the end of a dead end street, and the few neighbors she had worked all day just as she did. No one had even been home when the FBI had initially started making door-to-door inquiries.

Dixon had also gotten a warrant for the GPS on Clarice’s car to be traced. It was found abandoned near a campground. There was preliminary evidence that suggested that Clarice had been placed in the trunk, though fiber analysis would take time. There was no blood in the trunk, no further sign of Clarice, and no other fingerprints in the car.

A search of the woods was being done, but faint tire tracks suggested that she had been transferred to another vehicle that had been left at the site, massively reducing the chances of finding her through tracing alone. Anyone camping in the park was being interviewed to see if they had noticed any cars left in that area, but even if they got a description of a vehicle, traffic cameras only did so much good when there were miles of unmonitored highway in either direction.

The actual UPS driver had eventually been located through police reports. He had been scheduled to make a pickup at a somewhat rural address. At the house, he had been struck over the head and knocked unconscious, at which point his uniform and truck had been stolen. The still unconscious driver had been later noticed by a postal worker on her route, and she had called the police. An ambulance had taken him to the hospital, where he was currently in a coma due to massive head trauma.

After another warrant, UPS had confirmed from GPS that the same truck that had been at Clarice’s had been at the location where the unconscious man had been found earlier. The address was an unoccupied house that was for sale after the elderly owner had died, though the FBI didn’t suspect any connection between the ambush of the driver and the deceased’s only family, a single woman who lived in another state, and a son who had married and moved abroad. The working theory was that the empty house had been chosen as a pickup location solely as a secluded place to accost the driver.

The FBI’s working theory, of course, was also that Hannibal Lecter was the perpetrator.

On the surface, Ardelia couldn’t fault the logic. Lecter sent correspondence to people he meant to kill, and Lecter frequently killed people he had history with. But Ardelia’s gut screamed that it was wrong.

The scene at the house was wrong. If Lecter had taken Clarice—if Lecter was going to kill Clarice—it would have been elaborate. It would have been important to him. What had happened at Clarice’s house was planned and perfectly executed, and setting aside her faith in Clarice’s reading of Lecter, Ardelia could almost see how Lecter could have done it.

But the details of the scene nagged at her. Lecter wouldn’t have used a marker to scratch a slapdash message on the wall. Nothing about it was stylish enough. There was also the fact that it was highly unlikely that Clarice wouldn’t have recognized Lecter if he’d been standing there when she’d opened her door.

As evidence was gathered throughout the afternoon, Ardelia hoped that the next discovery would point away from Lecter, would provide a clue for a different direction to look in. But nothing did. There were no fingerprints found at the scene that didn’t belong to either Clarice or Ardelia herself. Not any of Lecter’s, but also none that would point to another person being present.

She’d had to admit that the flowers had also come from Lecter, though further investigation showed that they had been purchased with a pre-paid card and ordered through a website. The name and address that had been entered for the sender were faked and were dead ends, and the IP address that had accessed the website had been routed through a proxy server.

With everything put together, it seemed entirely reasonable from the FBI’s perspective that Lecter had taken her.

No one but Ardelia knew of Clarice’s actual history with Lecter. Bits and pieces were known, as Clarice’s run ins with him were in official records, but Clarice had never publicized or spoken about her meetings with Lecter in detail, and even Crawford hadn’t known about the mail from him.

When it became clear that the focus was being narrowed to Lecter exclusively, Ardelia knew she had to head it off before it got any worse, since her suggestions of considering other suspects had been met with near silence.

She went to Dixon’s office. It was surprisingly empty.

Ardelia shut the door behind her.

Dixon looked up from the mess of papers on his desk. “Have a seat,” he said, sounding both agreeable but busy. “Have we got something new?”

“Not exactly,” Ardelia said, sitting down across from him. “But I think we’re wrong in focusing solely on Lecter.”

His brows rose. “How so? We’ve got a signed card from Lecter, and Clarice herself told you the flowers were from Lecter. She disappears days after that you don’t think it’s connected to him?”

Ardelia was conciliatory. “I’m not saying we shouldn’t be looking at Lecter, but I think at this point it’s too early to rule out someone else. We should be exploring who else might have targeted her.”

Dixon brought his hands flat against the desk, smoothing the papers as if he was smoothing his thoughts, but he didn’t speak.

Ardelia continued on. “There’s also the crime scene. It doesn’t look like Lecter and it doesn’t feel like Lecter.”

“In what way?”

She resolved to stick to nothing but the facts. Arguing that Lecter wouldn’t kill Clarice was only going to bring her own judgment into question. Ardelia herself had questioned Clarice’s judgment long ago, and it had taken nearly a year for her to completely reverse her opinion and admit that as far as Lecter was concerned, Clarice had been right. But no one had that kind of time right now.

“Lecter’s crime scenes were always carefully crafted, but they were brutal,” Ardelia started. “If he had taken Clarice, we wouldn’t have a scene at her house unless it was her body. Lecter doesn’t announce that he’s taken people. He leaves their mutilated corpses to be found. Everything he does is elaborately planned.”

Dixon’s expression shifted in incredulity. “You don’t think hijacking a UPS truck so he could walk up to her house like he belonged there didn’t take planning? That leaving in her car so he wasn’t seen carrying an unconscious woman back to said truck wasn’t calculated? That having a second vehicle at a predetermined location didn’t take forethought?”

“Everything was done like clockwork,” Ardelia agreed. “But successfully taking someone is not unique to Lecter. And Lecter never would have left a message written on the wall in marker.”

“Lecter left a message in the Miriam Lass case,” Dixon said, crossing his arms. “That was also notable because Lecter deviated from his patterns with her, including kidnapping and holding her a considerable length of time. He’s deviated before.”

Ardelia struggled to recall the details of the exact case. Most of her insight about Lecter had come from discussing him with Clarice. She had studied Lecter’s case, of course, as nearly everyone had at some point. But Miriam Lass had been two decades ago, and Lecter had a high body count to keep straight.

“That note was planned, planted,” Ardelia countered, even though she couldn’t remember the exact details of the note. “It wasn’t done on the spur of the moment, and it wasn’t sloppy. This was sloppy.” She leaned forward. “Lecter thinks himself elegant, and this doesn’t have that style.”

For long moment, Dixon didn’t speak.

Finally, he said, “I appreciate your thoughts on this. But I don’t think there’s a strong enough case to be made. Everything points to Lecter, and we can’t waste manpower just because he wrote on the wall. Hell, it could have been Graham doing the actual abduction, if he’s still helping Lecter.”

“But there’s the abduction itself,” Ardelia said. “Lecter or Graham wouldn’t have been able to get the drop on her because she would have recognized them both. They couldn’t have fooled her with something like that. It had to be someone she didn’t know.”

Dixon opened his mouth to speak, but then seemed to reconsider. He looked thoughtful.

He tilted his head and opened his laptop, turning it sideways on his desk so they could both see the screen. Then he pulled up the security footage. The entire clip was ten seconds long, and the relevant part wasn’t even three. Dixon repeated it several times as they both watched.

He shook his head at her, resigned. “No. He literally injects her the second she opens the door. And the windows were beveled, so she had to open the door to see him.” He played it again. “She didn’t have time to react, even if she had recognized him in that split second. He was ready.”

Technically, he was right, Ardelia realized as she watched again and again. Of course, it wasn’t Lecter, but there was nothing in the video that would prove that.

The man had a small package in his left hand. He held it slightly in front of him as he rang the bell with his right. He obviously already had the syringe in his right hand, though it couldn’t be seen yet. Clarice opened the door, his arm came up, and the needle went into her neck. The whole thing barely took two seconds.

“The writing on the wall still doesn’t make sense,” Ardelia said again. “This isn’t Lecter.”

Dixon sighed. “Ardelia—” he started.

Ardelia could see the possibility of finding Clarice slipping away from her.

“I can work on it myself,” she said. “Even if you don’t want to waste other resources. I know there has to be something here, something that’s going to give us another lead.”

“We have a solid lead. We have evidence. We have motive.”

Ardelia shook her head. “Lecter never had a reason to kill Clarice,” she said, beginning an argument she had promised herself not to pursue. “Neither did Graham.” She had to make him see. “They had met several times, but she was never one of Lecter’s targets.”

“And you know this how?”

“Clarice told me. They have a history, but it wasn’t contentious. He’s sent her cards before,” Ardelia continued. “So the fact that she has a card now doesn’t mean anything. There’s no reason to think that he followed the card this time.”

“That doesn’t point away from Lecter being involved. Lecter has killed or tried to kill nearly everyone he had a passing connection with. Clarice obviously isn’t the exception to that.”

“But she is,” Ardelia started. “Crawford knows—”

“Crawford is gone,” Dixon snapped, his voice rising. “Crawford’s lapses in judgment are legendary. Like hell am I going to consult with Crawford! He nearly destroyed this entire department multiple times trying to catch Lecter.”

“And you’re going to destroy Clarice!”

Dixon stood up, his face red with anger.

Ardelia did the same. She knew it was over, and she knew she’d lost her temper.

“You,” he said shortly, “are on leave.”

“Sir, I apologi—”

“I’m not seeing Lecter in this because I want to,” he cut her off. “The evidence is there, and everyone in the department sees it but you.” He sighed, and his tone softened somewhat as he said, “I don’t want to see you back in this building for week. You’re too close to be working this case anyway, and we both know that.”

She had known, but it was still maddening to hear. She was too close; she couldn’t be responsible for making a call when it came down to what could be life or death decisions. But she also couldn’t imagine not being able to do anything but wait.

“Go home,” Dixon said, in what she assumed he thought was a reassuring manner. “Get some rest and leave it to us. We’ll find Clarice.”

Not trusting herself to speak, Ardelia simply nodded and left the room.

-----

They wouldn’t find her. Not when they were all looking in the wrong direction.

Ardelia had immediately gone home and opened her laptop. Even if she couldn’t be on the case, she could still see what was being done. Maybe she would be able to see some new piece of evidence differently, figure something out or find a new lead.

However, when she tried to connect to the FBI servers, Ardelia found that her login credentials had been suspended. She honestly hadn’t figured Dixon would think that far ahead. After a minute of sheer frustration, Ardelia shut the laptop, somehow managing not to slam it the way she wanted to.

Her eyes drifted towards her purse. Inside was the stationary box she had taken from Clarice’s desk.

It contained every piece of mail Clarice had ever received from Hannibal Lecter.

The moment that the card on Clarice’s kitchen table had been discovered, Ardelia had known that one card was going to be bad enough, but a box of them would be too much to ignore. So she had taken them, tampering with the crime scene and committing a felony.

She felt bad that she didn’t feel bad.

But her actions hadn’t mattered at all, since the case was currently playing out worse than she could have imagined, even without the other cards being discovered. She had brought them up to Dixon as a last ditch effort, but she wasn’t going to admit to having taken anything from the crime scene—Clarice’s house was a crime scene—unless she knew it was going to make things better, not worse.

The FBI already thought Lecter had done it; the cards would be a literal pile of evidence.

Ardelia stood and walked across the room to her purse. Maybe she could find something that Lecter had written at some point, something that was the opposite of whatever you wrote to people you intended to kill. It was a long shot, but she had been completely shut out of the investigation, and she couldn’t stand doing nothing to help Clarice.

Ardelia sat down at her kitchen table with the stationary box.

She knew more or less what was inside, though it still felt like an invasion of privacy to go through it. But if she could find anything that would make Dixon see that Hannibal Lecter wasn’t part of this, it didn’t matter. Clarice could be mad at her later, when she came back alive.

Ardelia took the lid off the box. She pulled out the stack of paper within and loosely spread it across the table.

Some of it she had seen and some of it she hadn’t. Clarice had opened the box several times when the topic of Lecter had come up, but it wasn’t as if she had shown Ardelia every time she received something in the mail, nor had Ardelia expected her to.

As it was, there were almost two dozen envelopes. Ardelia slowly began opening them. The majority by far were Christmas cards. Most contained nothing but Hannibal Lecter’s signature, though one notable exception also contained Will Graham’s signature. A few cards had a handwritten line inside in Lecter’s fine calligraphy wishing Clarice well, but it was the sort of platitudes that anyone might put on a Christmas card. Ardelia noticed that the year each card had been received was written in Clarice’s precise handwriting on the inside of the envelope.

There were then three small cards that had obviously come with floral arrangements. Being sent through a delivery service, they were not signed by Lecter, but had generic messages of congratulations on them. Clarice had obviously guessed what they were for and who they were from, because she had marked the date on them as well, and because they wouldn’t have been in the box otherwise. Inside the box was also the note that Clarice had received upon her graduation from the Academy, and the card and necklace that had arrived after her encounter in Minnesota. Ardelia had seen both before, but she read them again. The necklace itself was in a small thin box that she set to the side.

The next envelope looked like it was another Christmas card, but instead contained a plain card with a seemingly random note written inside.

Clarice,

Some recent bad luck in Baltimore has captured my attention. One hardly expects to find one’s name in the news regarding accidental deaths a continent away, and the referenced events amused me greatly. I’m flattered to be ascribed such omnipotence, though I can hardly claim to have as far-reaching an arm as that of God. I am once again put in mind of church collapses, a topic we never discussed, but which I have always found highly entertaining.

All the best,

Hannibal Lecter

Ardelia couldn’t make heads or tails of it, though she assumed Clarice had been able to. It confirmed that Lecter and Graham weren’t in North America, but that was practically a given at this point.

The only remaining envelope from the pile was the largest, though it was still a standard greeting card size. When Ardelia opened it, her breath caught. Tucked inside on fine paper was a drawing of Clarice. As she moved it, Ardelia realized another drawing lay beneath it, a layer of semi-translucent paper between them. Both were of Clarice, but they were as different as night and day. In the first, she was seated at a table, the details of which faded around the edges, as all the focus of the picture was on Clarice. Her lips were pressed together, and her expression seemed particularly poised, like she was considering what to say next. Everything about her was perfectly rendered, and the level of detail was extraordinary—Ardelia could see the stress in her shoulders, the tightness around her eyes. It took Ardelia another beat to realize that Lecter had drawn this from memory, and that this exact instant had probably actually happened.

The drawing underneath showed Clarice at the same table, and wearing the same clothing. This time, she was leaning forward slightly, and while she didn’t look precisely relaxed, there was nothing present of the tension from the previous picture. There was a difference, Ardelia decided, between relaxed and at ease, and Clarice looked at ease here. Her expression was almost neutral, but for the slight upward turn of her open mouth, and she was obviously speaking. Even on paper, her eyes were sharp and bright, and Ardelia herself had seen that exact cast to them when Clarice was talking about profiling. She was again astounded at the detail and at how much of Clarice was captured on the page. Ardelia could only assume that this was another moment that had in fact occurred.

She laid the two drawings carefully on the table, and turned her attention to the card they had been in. It was not a Christmas card, and there was a handwritten message that took up the entirety of one side.

Clarice,

It is seven years to the day since last we spoke, and I find myself reminiscing over our conversations. Perhaps seven is not a traditional number of importance while marking the passage of years, but the number has had significance in cultures across the globe since ancient times. I myself find it has curious consequence. I first made your acquaintance seven years after meeting Will, and through your fortuitous interference, I have now spent twice that span of time with him by my side. Perhaps fate will be tempted once more, and this is the year we will again converse. I wonder at what such a conversation could bring, and what new understanding it could expose.

I trust you will forgive the liberty of the enclosed sketches. Drawing is as much an exercise in memory as an exercise in dexterity; as your words echoed in my mind, my pencil committed them to paper. I find the results to be an inadvertent study of contrasts. Understanding is a remarkable thing; it both informs who we are and how we relate to others. With such a marked change produced from one conversation to the next, you can hardly fault me for desiring another. I endeavor always to move forward, because the past, while pleasurable, can bring no new experiences. While the future is an uncertain thing, one never knows what may yet be.

Yours sincerely,

Hannibal Lecter

Ardelia laid the card down, feeling uncomfortably voyeuristic. Even though the message was quite formal, it seemed intensely personal. It was an odd contradiction but she didn’t know how else to describe it. The drawings themselves were Clarice through Lecter’s eyes, snapshots of a memory. Even though Ardelia had heard all about the night at the cabin, Clarice had never shown her this piece of mail. But she found she could hardly blame her; none of this was something she was meant to see.

She knew that Lecter and Clarice had not ended up crossing paths three years ago, no matter what stock Lecter put in coincidence and fate. But the fact that he had put so much thought into the possibility of seeing Clarice again left Ardelia off balance.

She put the card on the table with the others. Finally, she took the necklace out of its box, staring at the pendant for a moment before she twisted it absently between her fingers. Everything inside the stationary box had been opened.

Ardelia surveyed the array of papers spread before her, and was unsettled in a way she hadn’t expected.

Clarice had nearly fifteen years of correspondence from a serial killer.

Ardelia had known, of course, but seeing it all at once was staggering. The cards, the flowers, the jewelry—Christ, the drawings—it looked like obsession.

The obsession of a psychopath.

For one terrible moment Ardelia wondered if everyone else was right, if she was blind to what was actually happening.

But then her conviction returned in full force, answering the question. She trusted Clarice. She trusted Clarice not to be wrong, and especially not to be wrong about this.

She trusted her own, original sense that said that if Lecter were going to kill Clarice, it would have to be perfect, a masterpiece in his eyes. If anything, the amount of thought and personal interest demonstrated in the years of cards supported that gut instinct. If he had done it, Lecter would have arranged everything to the finest detail. He would have put just as much thought into the presentation as he would into the process of taking her. For him they would be one and the same.

But whatever proof Ardelia had hoped to find certainly wasn’t here.

Lecter’s long-term interest in Clarice would be taken as all the more motive for her disappearance. The things he wrote weren’t threatening, but neither were they reassuring. There were too many interpretations possible and nothing was directly stated at face value.

Ardelia closed her hand around the necklace, staring blankly at the cards before her. None of them helped her, and none of them would help Clarice. She didn’t know how to reconcile that with the desperate hope she’d had that something here would change everything.

She didn’t realize she was close to tears until her gaze went unfocused and everything started to blur together.

“Goddammit!” she yelled, frustration making her voice crack.

Ardelia resisted the urge to sweep the table clear, to pound her hands against it and scream. Instead, she brought her fists to her forehead and leaned on her elbows, squeezing her eyes shut.

The contents of the stationary box were damning. There was nothing that she could take to Dixon, nothing that wouldn’t add fuel to the already raging fire.

After another minute and several excruciatingly long breaths, Ardelia opened her eyes.

Her left hand was still clenched around Clarice’s necklace. Ardelia let go in defeat, dropping the necklace to the polished wood of the table. The pendant clinked as it fell; the chain followed with a sinuous rattle.

The shape of a bird was left imprinted into her palm. She stared at it, and a terrible, treacherous thought slid into her head.

There was one person who would believe that Hannibal Lecter hadn’t taken Clarice, and that was Hannibal Lecter.

Chapter 4: Chapter 3

Chapter Text

Clarice drifted in a state of disorientation, not quite gaining consciousness.

She was unsure of where she was or why she felt the way she did. Darkness seemed to surround her whether she had her eyes opened or closed.

She just needed to wake up. Just wake up.

It felt harder to breathe than it should have been. She couldn’t seem to get up and she felt dizzy.

Clarice didn’t know how many minutes it took her to realize that she wasn’t having some sort of nightmare or sleep paralysis, that she was actually awake. When she did, she wished she hadn’t.

The back of her mind had been putting the pieces together despite her confusion, and everything snapped into place in one terrifying instant.

She couldn’t get enough air because her mouth was taped. She couldn’t move her limbs because they were zip tied. And she was surrounded by darkness because she was in the trunk of a moving car.

The horror of it was overwhelming. Clarice struggled against the zip ties in vain, her mind stuck in a loop of panic.

Then she remembered everything she knew about abductions and she forced herself to think straight. It took a lot of forcing, but she managed it.

Clarice took deep breaths through her nose and relaxed all the muscles in her body, her arms and legs going slack as she tried to calm down. Then she experimentally moved and clenched different muscles, noting that she didn’t feel pain beyond some soreness, which meant she wasn’t seriously injured.

Though she was fully awake, her thoughts were still disordered as she desperately tried to reconstruct how she had gotten here. She remembered getting ready for work, but it felt hazy and faraway. Someone had come to the door, she thought, but after that, her memory was blank. She didn’t know what had happened, and she didn’t know where she was besides in a terrible situation. It felt unreal, like she was in a nightmare. It was a nightmare.

She did another full minute of slow breaths, and then again tried to focus on what she could do.

Her head was throbbing, but as she rolled it from side to side, it didn’t feel tender in any particular area like it would have if she’d been knocked unconscious. Her best guess was that she had been drugged, but that didn’t tell her anything else.

Clarice’s arms were tied behind her back, and she curled into something like a fetal position and then pushed herself up on her knees. She pressed her back to the top of the trunk, groping with her hands for an emergency release, even though she hadn’t seen the telltale glow-in-the-dark pull of one. It seemed unlikely that her abductor would have overlooked a trunk release, but many criminals were caught because they did something simple but stupid.

However, after several minutes of unsuccessful searching, Clarice had to conclude that either the release had been removed or the car was old enough not to have been manufactured with one. She changed her strategy, lying down on her side again and pulling at the carpet along the trunk’s wall in the hopes of either exposing the taillights or finding the cable that ran from the driver’s side to release the trunk.

But no matter how she tried, she couldn’t get the angle right or the leverage right with her hands behind her back.

The detail that both her hands and feet had been tied, with her hands behind her, was beginning to worry her more than the fact that she was in a trunk. A fair number of people were abducted and thrown into trunks by criminals who operated at an impulsive or opportunistic level, such as carjackers or other robbers. But the forethought and precaution that someone had used in securing her implied a level of planning that didn’t bode well.

Clarice pushed that thought to the back of her mind. She needed to be as calm and clear headed as possible to have the best chances of extricating herself from this.

She paid attention to the motion of the car. She hadn’t noticed any stopping and starting, so they were likely on a highway. She had no idea how long she had been unconscious, no idea how far away she was from Quantico. No idea where she was—and she couldn’t stop her mind from repeatedly returning to that unpleasant thought with every minute, every mile that passed.

A frustratingly indeterminate amount of time later, the car slowed and turned to the left. From there, the car drove on straight roads with very sporadic stops and occasional turns. She thought they might be on county roads, someplace with little traffic and stop signs only every mile or so.

When the car’s tires hit a gravel road, Clarice knew she was right. She also knew that whenever the trunk opened, she was going to be in the middle of nowhere, with no place to run and likely no one else nearby to lend assistance.

The car traveled on gravel roads for miles. Eventually, it slowed, and Clarice realized it was stopping—actually stopping—and not just halting at an intersection.

Her heart started pounding uncontrollably.

The engine cut and the driver’s side door opened and closed. Clarice shut her eyes and pretended to be unconscious, hoping that she could manage to look dead to the world while she was spiraling inside.

While normally the best strategy was to do anything to avoid being taken to a secondary location, she was already at the secondary location, and she had no ability to fight. Any struggle would be meaningless with both her hands and feet tied. Her best course of action was to play possum and wait for any advantage she could.

Clarice forced herself to go totally limp, her mind repeating what she needed to do like a mantra. Don’t react, don’t clench any muscles. Don’t react, don’t clench any muscles.

There was the sound of a key in the trunk, and then there was a flood of light as it opened.

She had been expecting the light and didn’t react.

Whoever was there was silent, and she assumed they were looking her over. They prodded her twice, and then turned her head to the side to presumably look at her face.

She didn’t move in the slightest.

Her chin was released and then there were hands on her and she was being lifted. Her abductor threw her over their shoulder in a fireman’s carry and started walking with her.

Not moving was the hardest thing Clarice had ever, ever done.

Once out of the trunk, she tried to catalog everything going on around her. It seemed likely that her abductor was a man and that he was working alone. He hadn’t spoken to anyone, and she only heard one set of footsteps as she was carried.

She took a calculated risk and cracked one eye open. She mostly saw the back of his shirt, but as his gait caused her head to sway, she could see glimpses of what was ahead of her. A field and some trees, but nothing that gave her anything to work with.

After several more strides, his pace slowed, and she heard the sounds of scraping metal. Clarice risked another quick look.

There was a cellar next to a concrete foundation. She could only assume he was about to take her down into it.

Every instinct in her wanted to struggle, but she knew there was nothing she could do. The only advantage she had right now was the element of surprise, and she had to use it at the best possible time. She would only get one chance.

He descended into the cellar with her, and she could tell from his movements when they were at the bottom. He slung her down from his shoulder, and she expected to be deposited on a concrete floor. Instead she was dropped without ceremony on her side on what had to be some sort of canvas cot. She again forced herself not to react to whatever was about to happen.

She felt his hands on her feet, and then a sort of pressure, before the zip tie simply snapped.

Clarice’s heart jumped wildly, adrenaline flooding her system.

He was cutting the ties. This was it—this was her chance. He touched her hands next, and she felt the slide of a knife next to her skin, before the zip tie there was also cut away.

Clarice could still feel him standing over her.

She was free—she had to act any second now, she knew that, but her life depended on getting it right.

When she heard the snap of the pocket knife being closed, Clarice knew this was it. She opened her eyes and swung her leg sideways, aiming a kick at his groin, which connected enough to send him doubling over. Another kick knocked him off balance, and he went sprawling on the concrete.

A flashlight spun as it fell from his grasp, but the light from the open cellar door was more than enough for her to see by. Clarice jumped to her feet and darted toward it. She staggered, nearly losing her footing, and some part of her mind belatedly realized she was still feeling the effects of the drugs.

Her hands grasped at the ladder-like stairs, and she hauled herself up. But she had only gotten a few steps before he grabbed her around the middle and wrenched her back down. Clarice fought with everything she had as he pulled her off the ladder, but he simply swung her in the other direction and let go of her with a hard shove.

The momentum of the movement sent her flying and stumbling, her foot twisting beneath her as she went down.

She got back up as fast as she could, but it was too late.

He was already halfway up the steps, and even as she lunged after him and followed, she couldn’t reach the top fast enough.

The metal doors slammed in her face.

And she was left, alone.

Chapter 5: Chapter 4

Chapter Text

It perhaps said something about Ardelia’s state of mind that once the idea occurred to her, she didn’t try to talk herself out of it.

She was desperate, she knew that—but the longer she considered it, the more absurdly brilliant it seemed. Lecter had given the necklace to Clarice as a token of thanks after she had stopped Will Graham from being killed in Minnesota. Clarice had told her all about that night and the conversations that had passed between them, including the suddenly not insignificant fact that Lecter had offered to do for her what she had done for Graham.

Ardelia grabbed the card that had come with the necklace again, scanning it to confirm what she already knew.

Her heart sped up as she re-read the last line, and if anything at all in her had been wavering, it was decided in that moment. If Lecter was still looking for the opportunity to repay Clarice for saving Graham’s life, Ardelia was going to give it to him.

After all, she thought darkly, he wasn’t going to get another chance.

-----

Two hours later, Ardelia was back from her trip to buy a prepaid burner phone. Paranoia had made her drive out of town, too afraid she would see someone she knew. Of course, she hadn’t, but the drive had done her good anyway, as it had given her time to consider what she intended to do and how she intended to do it.

The best way to attempt contact with Lecter was through Tattle Crime. Ardelia vaguely remembered that the FBI had used the site to get Lecter’s attention before, but more than that, Clarice had said they’d briefly discussed the site while in Minnesota, so Lecter had at least still been a reader at that time. She had to hope he still was.

Several times, Ardelia questioned what she realistically expected to happen, even if she did manage to contact Lecter. Lecter and Graham were undoubtedly out of the country. The logical part of her mind said there was no way Lecter could be of any use, even if he wanted to be.

But the frantic part of her mind clung to the idea that she could speak to them and something would change. The more she thought about it, the more she realized that the one she wanted wasn’t Lecter, but Graham. Graham was the one who looked at a case file and divined the impossible, the one who saw everything. If Lecter’s interest in Clarice led to him involving himself, Graham would become aware of the case as well. Ardelia didn’t have access to the file anymore, but she had been swimming in it all day, and had been the first to witness the scene at Clarice’s house. She could tell them everything; Graham could tell her what obscure detail she had missed, and then she could do something about it.

If she could contact them at all.

Once she configured the phone to maximum privacy settings, connected to a proxy server, and set up an anonymous email account, she opened the browser and went to the Tattle Crime website. After scrolling through the menu, she entered the forum and opened a tab to post a new topic.

Then Ardelia sat staring at the empty text box for a literal five minutes, mentally rejecting any words she thought of before she even typed them.

She had to get Lecter’s attention, but she couldn’t write anything that would be understood by any other reader. The words had to be vague yet exact, and nothing that anyone could trace to herself, Clarice, or Lecter. Making any sort of reference to Lecter was the last thing she wanted to do, as that would only attract attention on the site.

Ardelia read the card again. She knew she had to work the word ‘favor’ in somehow, but everything she thought of sounded wrong. It didn’t sound like something Clarice would write, and no matter what Ardelia started to type, she found herself trying to explain something using words that meant nothing.

Frustrated, Ardelia deleted the sentences she had just worked out; they had looked like a goddamn riddle.

She tried to imagine what Clarice would write, if Clarice were contacting Lecter. Clarice understood Lecter. Clarice wouldn’t have explained anything; she would have trusted that Lecter would catch her meaning, and she would have written something Lecter couldn’t mistake.

Again, Ardelia read the card that had come with the necklace. It was well composed but short, only five sentences in total. It also didn’t spell anything out, she noticed. The true substance of the note was dependent upon context from prior conversations. Perhaps the best way to get Lecter’s attention was to make her message dependent upon the words of the card and nothing more.

And the necklace, she thought with a burst of inspiration. The pendant was generic, meaningless to anyone else, and Lecter alone would know what it was.

Finally, Ardelia settled on a subject line of two sentences, mirroring Lecter’s own language but written in the passive voice: A service was done. A favor is requested. For the body of the post, she simply took a photo of the necklace, and then wrote, Please, followed by the number of the burner phone.

The words were simple yet indirect, which satisfied her. They were also misleading, as she was effectively masquerading as Clarice. Lecter would assume that Clarice had written the message, because of the necklace if nothing else. But Ardelia didn’t know how else to get his attention. Truthfully, the last thing she wanted was his attention, but if there was a chance that it could keep Clarice from dying, she would deal with it.

She still stared at the screen for another two minutes, not actually debating on whether or not to go through with it, but knowing that once she submitted the post, it was done. Her thumb hovered over the screen as she read her words over and over, as if proofreading was going to change something.

Gathering her resolve, Ardelia tapped the screen, and the post went live.

-----

Ardelia carried the phone with her for the rest of the evening. The maddening tension of waiting for a call—even one that was unlikely to come—had her taking the phone to the bathroom with her every time she needed to go, afraid that it would ring in the seconds she was out of earshot. It didn’t, of course.

Nor did it ring when she heated a frozen dinner for herself, or when she uncharacteristically took a bath instead of a shower because she was afraid she wouldn’t hear the phone over the sound of the water.

Throughout the evening, she had also checked her new email account what felt like hundreds of times, constantly refreshing it to see if there were any replies to her post. There weren’t.

Not having anything else to do and not feeling like doing anything, Ardelia stayed in the tub for nearly two hours, simply adding more hot water as the bath began to cool. She felt numb; the events of the day had left her overwhelmed and anxious. She thought about Clarice, who, wherever she was, was certainly not taking an unenjoyable bath.

When Ardelia finally got out, she went straight to bed, even though she did nothing but lie in the dark for what seemed like hours. She did eventually sleep, however, because she was awakened by the sound of a phone ringing.

It took a bleary second for her to confirm that it was the burner phone ringing and not her own, and then she was instantly awake.

In the split second before she answered, several thoughts flashed through her mind in one chaotic jumble as her heart sped up. The post had been a desperate gambit, and while she had written it knowing full well that she was opening a line of communication, receiving that contact was another thing entirely. There was also the possibility that the person on the other end was someone who had simply seen the number and called it for kicks. She feared disappointment even as she worried about success.

“Hello?” Ardelia said, answering.

“May I speak to Clarice Starling, please?”

Ardelia’s breath caught. There were only two people besides Clarice who could infer her full name from what Ardelia had written, and only one of them had that accent. Lecter, she was actually talking to Lecter.

“She’s missing,” Ardelia blurted, realizing that as much as she had imagined what might happen in this conversation, she wasn’t at all prepared for it to actually occur.

There was a pause on the other end. “Then to whom do I have the pleasure of speaking?”

Once, long ago, Ardelia had asked Clarice what piece of advice she would give to anyone dealing with Lecter, besides the obvious of being polite. It had been hypothetical, a conversation of maybes and nevers. Clarice had thought for a moment, then said, “Don’t try to manipulate him; you can’t. Don’t lie to him; he’ll know it.”

With those words ringing in her mind, Ardelia found herself blurting, “Her friend, Ardelia.” She quickly continued with, “I’m the one that wrote the message on Tattle Crime. I apologize if it was misleading, but Clarice isn’t in a position to ask for herself. So I’m asking on her behalf.”

There was another pause. “Asking for a favor that was not yours to receive? One might comment on the presumption of such an act.”

Lecter didn’t sound entirely pleased, not with her or that it hadn’t been Clarice who had answered the phone.

“If the favor was to save her life, she is still the recipient,” Ardelia said with a calm that she didn’t feel, hoping that the fact that he had called at all meant he was inclined to be obliging to whatever he assumed Clarice might ask. “Clarice was abducted from her house this morning, and the FBI isn’t going to be able to find her.”

“Distressing news, to be sure, but I find it hard to believe the department grinds to a halt at the loss of one agent.”

“No, it doesn’t,” Ardelia said. “They’re doing everything they can, but it will all be for nothing because they’re wrong about their suspect.” She paused, gathering herself before continuing. “The FBI thinks you took her.”

The darkness of the room around her seemed almost tangible in the silence that followed.

“Do they indeed?” Lecter said, a note of amusement creeping into his voice. “And why is that?”

“The card from you was in her mail, and you have a history with her. The planning behind the abduction was impressive. It’s a reasonable assumption, and there wasn’t enough found to contradict it.”

“Yet you think otherwise?”

“I know that there’s a difference between what Clarice has spoken about publicly and what actually happened. I’m the only one she told about that night in Minnesota, the only one she ever showed the necklace to.” After a moment, Ardelia said, “Clarice needs help, and I can’t help her.”

Lecter was silent a long moment, but then he spoke. “So you thought of me. A strange impulse for an FBI agent.”

Ardelia was thrown; she hadn’t identified herself as such. “How—how did you know I’m an FBI agent?”

“I recognize your name. It’s in my interest to keep apprised of the agency’s doings.”

He knew who she was. Wasn’t that a lovely thought.

“You are going rather impressively off the rails for an agent,” he continued. “Or has contacting wanted killers become standard protocol when the FBI is adrift?”

Ardelia swallowed. “I don’t care if this costs me my career. You’re the only other one who knows that you didn’t take her.”

“Are you certain I didn’t?” Lecter asked mildly. “I’ve done worse to better friends.”

The easy way he said it was unsettling. But it was a question she had already asked herself that day, and answered long before she had written the message. But she only said, “If you had taken her, you wouldn’t have called and asked to speak with her.”

Again, Lecter didn’t immediately reply. “And what do you imagine I could do?”

“You can see things I can’t,” Ardelia said. “I know there has to be something that we’ve missed, some clue that will tell me how to find her. I was the first on the scene. I can tell you everything that’s known so far.”

“And you yourself have nothing but the purest of intentions, of course.”

“What do you mean?”

He actually chuckled, and Ardelia knew he was laughing at her. “Your eloquence leaves no doubt that this conversation is a means to an end. I only wonder if it will be the end you intended.” Before she could ask what that meant, he said, “Perhaps we will speak again. Goodbye, Ardelia.”

Lecter ended the call.

Well, that wasn’t ominous at all.

After another moment, Ardelia brought the phone away from her ear, double checking to make sure he had actually hung up. She pressed the button to lock the screen and then let the phone fall to the bed.

She could still feel her heart racing, still taste the panic of trying to say the exact right thing, and she wasn’t sure she’d succeeded. She might have even failed. Ardelia was somewhat shocked her plan had worked, that he had called. Part of her thought he’d been intrigued, but the other part was stuck on the slightly vindictive tone of his every word.

She had no idea how Clarice had actually been in the same house with that man and remained calm.

-----

Ardelia understandably did not go back to sleep.

First, she deleted the post on Tattle Crime. Lecter had her number—which wasn’t worrisome at all, of course—and wouldn’t need the site to call it again.

Second, she got up and made breakfast, despite the fact that it was barely after three in the morning. Then she started cleaning her kitchen—unable to sit and do nothing, and very much needing to do something to take her mind off the fact that she was waiting for she didn’t know what.

Lecter practically said they would speak again, and she wasn’t entirely sure that was a good thing.

Ardelia could only hope he was enticed enough by the idea of repaying a favor to Clarice that he would help in some way. He had to be interested, she told herself. It was about Clarice; he had to be interested.

In that, she wasn’t disappointed. Just over an hour later, the burner phone rang again. Ardelia quickly stopped what she was doing and answered it.

“Hello?”

“Hello, Ardelia. I’ve decided I should like to see where the abduction took place,” Lecter said without preamble. “A remote tour of the scene, if you will.”

“But it’s a crime scene,” Ardelia said.

“Precisely. A viewing unfiltered by another’s observations is necessary if anything useful is to be learned.”

“I mean they’ll be there again this morning, processing things and combing for any trace evidence.”

“Then you should hurry,” Lecter said, “so that we can be done before dawn comes and the FBI descends.”

Ardelia rapidly calculated—she still had Clarice’s spare key, its place in her pocket forgotten during the whirlwind of the day until she had come home that night.

She would be fired if she was caught. But Clarice was going to die if she couldn’t do something. And Ardelia was convinced that if Lecter could only point her in the right direction, she could find Clarice. If he needed to see Clarice’s house to do that, then so be it.

“I can be across town in twenty minutes,” she said, deciding. As if there had been any other decision.

“Then we shall call you in half an hour.”

The line went dead.

Ardelia literally ran to her bedroom, throwing on a pair of jeans and a sweater, then pulling on her shoes in the hallway. She put on a coat and grabbed her keys, Clarice’s key, the phone, and her wallet.

One minute later, she was pulling out of her driveway.

Ardelia made good time. There was no traffic to speak of this early, and soon she was in Clarice’s neighborhood.

Parking at Clarice’s house was out of the question, dead end street or not. If anything was likely to get neighbors’ attention, it would be the noises of a car in the driveway. Instead, Ardelia circled nearby streets. Two blocks away, she found several houses that had extra cars parked in the road. She parked neatly between two of them, hoping that if anyone heard or noticed the extra car, they would suppose it belonged to the house next door.

The night was pitch black, and even if anyone was awake, they were still settled firmly indoors. Ardelia quickly walked the distance to Clarice’s house, arriving exactly twenty-six minutes after she had left her own house. The front door had a temporary FBI lock box on it, but the back door was simply locked from the inside.

Both, of course, had yellow crime scene tape across them. Ardelia pulled on a pair of latex gloves she’d had in the car, used the key to open the back door, and ducked under the tape.

She hesitated before turning the lights on, but the lights would be more than necessary. After a short debate with herself, she turned every light in the house on. At least if someone noticed, they wouldn’t see lights going on and off as she moved between rooms, and might simply assume the lights had been left on.

Clarice’s house was no less messy than it had been when Ardelia had eaten dinner there a day and a half ago. Ardelia had the mad impulse to straighten things up. She didn’t, as it would be the absolute least helpful thing she could do, but she knew that Clarice would hate anyone seeing the current chaos of her personal space, let alone Lecter, who had an uncommon interest.

The phone rang.

It was a request ringing for a video call. Ardelia braced herself even as she answered it, her pulse suddenly racing.

She didn’t know what she had expected to see, but a black screen wasn’t it.

“Hello, Ardelia,” a new voice said, the diction crisp and intense. “This is Will Graham. Flip your camera, please.”

“Right,” she said, her nerves making her fumble as she hit the screen to change the input from the front camera to the back one.

Of course he had obscured his own camera. And of course he wasn’t interested in seeing her. Though that didn’t mean she liked the fact that two serial killers knew exactly who she was.

“How do you want to do this?” she asked him, forcing herself to get a grip. She had expected Graham to become involved if Lecter was, but she hadn’t expected to talk to him so abruptly.

“Show me the scene first. You can tell me what you know afterward.”

“All right.”

Ardelia went to the front entryway.

Graham gave her directions. At his prompting, she alternately panned the area with the camera and stepped forward or back, showing him everything from every angle. He bit out commands in a brisk manner; the last time he had said please had been the first time he’d spoken to her. But there was also something detached about his orders, like he was so focused on what he was looking at that she wasn’t even an afterthought.

Ardelia learned very quickly never to zoom in, but to always get physically closer to whatever he wanted to look at. And to always, always go slower. Ardelia had thought she was moving slowly, but if there was so much as a blur of motion in the video, Graham would simply say, “Slower.”

The entryway was just as it had been yesterday when she’d found it—coat rack and table tipped over, decorative items fallen to the floor. Then there was the box that was a random package from the stolen UPS truck, and the message in marker, of course, stark on the wall. Yellow crime scene markers indicated each item, but so far, nothing had been removed.

After a thorough survey, Graham started asking questions.

“When were you here yesterday, and why?”

“It was nearly noon and Clarice hadn’t even called in. It wasn’t like her. I used the spare key and came in the back door, around the corner, there,” she said, turning around in her position to point the way through the living room. “I checked the garage for her car, but it was empty. I thought she had left, until I saw her phone and her watch discarded together on the floor. That’s when I came inside and found this.” She turned toward the entryway again.

“Tell me what the FBI knows so far.”

Ardelia did, giving him the details of what the warrants had discovered: the hijacking of the UPS truck, the location of Clarice’s abandoned vehicle, and the security footage of Clarice answering the front door in the morning. She tried to keep her voice level and even, as if she were just repeating the basic facts of any other abduction. She wasn’t sure she succeeded.

Ardelia told him how the Christmas card had been discovered, and how the investigation had focused on Lecter from there. She did not mention that she had taken the stationary box full of cards, or read its entire contents. Lecter hadn’t spoken once, but she knew he was on the call, watching from behind the blackness of the screen. She had told him that Clarice had shared things with her, but the idea of admitting that she had read years of private correspondence made a cold feeling settle in the pit of her stomach.

“Obviously there were no fingerprints found,” Graham commented, “or there wouldn’t be a question of Hannibal.”

“No prints,” Ardelia said. “Though he wasn’t wearing gloves in the video. A cloth glove might interfere with his dexterity and his grip on the syringe, and latex ones would look out of place. I suppose he had some in his pocket.”

“It wouldn’t be hard,” Graham said in placid agreement. “Have the syringe in his hand, ring the bell with his knuckle. Kick the door closed afterward and put his gloves on at his leisure. I doubt he even fought with her. He knows the dosage. He knows she’s not going anywhere. He knows he already has exactly what he wants.”

A shiver went down Ardelia’s spine. If she had been troubled by reciting the events of the camera feed, it was nothing to how she felt about Graham’s dispassionate reconstruction of the crime. It was more than the simple facts; it was the why of the facts. He was seeing things as the man who’d taken Clarice had seen them.

It was exactly what she’d wanted, but it was chilling to hear. The tone and timbre of his voice changed, slipping into something distant, darker.

“You don’t think there was a struggle?” Ardelia asked, gathering herself.

“This was a struggle of one person, not two,” Graham said, his voice still flat. “She seizes the lamp to hit him, but she’s already faltering. She misses and knocks over the table in the process. She grabs the coat rack to drag herself up, but it goes down under her weight.” Graham continued, “He watches. He likes seeing her helpless. He didn’t come here for brutality and violence. He came with efficiency and purpose.”

Ardelia didn’t know what to say to that. Perhaps she could have found words, if this hadn’t been about Clarice. Hearing Graham’s narration was worse than watching the video.

Graham saved her the trouble of a reply, saying, “Show me the writing again.”

Ardelia did, moving to face it and framing it with the camera.

“I would guess he wrote that directly over where she finally fell,” Graham said.

The words were above and just to one side of the fallen coat rack. Ardelia stared at them, as if they weren’t already burned into her memory. “I knew these were wrong,” she said absently. “Hannibal Lecter wouldn’t have written this. It’s too impulsive.”

“Hannibal is as impulsive as anyone,” Graham said.

Ardelia was surprised, but she didn’t argue with him. Graham’s knowledge of Lecter was hardly a theory at this point.

She started again. “Regardless, all of Hannibal Lecter’s crime scenes say something. There may be writing here, but the rest of this doesn’t say anything. It’s just aftermath.”

“Everything says something, even when it’s not designed to. All of this says that he only cares about achieving his goal. And this…” He fell silent for a moment. “…was written once it was done. It was… an afterthought to his success.” Graham was silent again, then said, “A message from Hannibal would have been different. He also would have righted the furniture, and left everything just as it was.”

He would have, Ardelia realized. It seemed obvious once it was pointed out to her. Clarice undoubtedly would have noticed it, in addition to noticing what Ardelia had. Ardelia had known that the scene wasn’t staged elaborately enough to be Lecter, but only now did she see that the chaos left behind would have been cleaned up entirely, unless it had fit with whatever message Lecter would compose.

“Do they think I did it, too?” Graham asked.

“Your name has come up. But only because of your connection to Lecter.”

There was a noise that might have been a chuckle. Then Graham said, “Show me the rest of the house.”

Ardelia had known this was probably coming, but she still recoiled at the idea. “There’s nothing in the rest of the house.”

“Nothing that you saw.”

She hated the matter-of-factness of his tone, as well as the truth of the words. This was exactly what she’d wanted—for Will Graham to tell her what she couldn’t see—but she hated that she had to show him—show them—everything in Clarice’s house.

Ardelia didn’t reply, but simply did as he asked, going down the hallway off the living room. Graham directed her as before, though there were fewer instructions. There really was nothing to see in the guest bathroom and bedroom, certainly nothing that required consideration as things in the entryway had.

Then she followed the hall to the master bed and bath. There were shoes and clothes strewn about, and random items littering the floor near the bed. Cords to charge devices, a triangular pillow to prop up a tablet, house shoes and a robe. There were three glasses of water on the nightstand, all partly full to varying degrees. The bed was unmade, the sheets still rumpled from when Clarice had crawled out of it yesterday. The bathroom counter was messy, littered with everyday items used and not put back to place—toothpaste, hand lotion, a powder compact, Chapstick, a hair brush, and more.

All of it Ardelia saw through the camera screen, as she let it linger on each personal detail. She felt sick.

It felt like a betrayal. Like she was offering up Clarice’s privacy to Lecter in some terrible exchange.

Yet Ardelia knew that Graham seeing everything was the best chance Clarice had. For a while, Graham said nothing besides simple directions. Then he asked, “What does the FBI think about the bedroom?”

“We don’t think he came this far into the house. But so much is out of place that I suppose he could have moved something or taken something without it being obvious.”

“Is it typical that this much is out of place?”

“Generally, no. Clarice isn’t a neat freak, but she keeps things more or less in order because she’s efficient. But work has been non-stop lately. She’s barely had time to sleep.”

“Because of Jack’s retirement,” he said mildly.

Ardelia wasn’t sure why she was surprised that he knew. “Yes.”

He then directed her to go into the living room. There wasn’t as much mess here, only a few blazers thrown over the back of the couch and some dishes from a meal eaten in the recliner. Another pair of shoes, a winter coat, and two piled up afghans. A few books left out from who knows how long ago—Ardelia couldn’t imagine the last time Clarice had been able to read for leisure.

The office was in much the same state as the living room, with the expected papers and bills left unfiled on the desk, and books and folders that had been untouched on the bookshelf opposite.

The kitchen, however, was another room of commotion and disarray. Everything that had been here when she’d eaten dinner with Clarice was still here—the dirty dishes, food from the pantry on the countertops, the stack of things on the kitchen table, and piles of clothes visible from the laundry room.

Ardelia began to slowly show Graham the kitchen, panning to let him see the layout of it. Then she waited for him to instruct her which side of the room to start on in detail.

He surprised her, by instead saying, “Why didn’t you mention the flowers earlier?”

Ardelia turned toward the vase of white lilies that sat on Clarice’s countertop, a yellow evidence marker next to it. She walked closer, keeping them in frame.

She frowned to herself. “Because you sent those.”

There was a beat of silence, followed by the indistinct murmur of Lecter’s accent, the first confirmation that he was indeed on the call.

Then Graham spoke, his tone decisive yet intrigued. “Those weren’t from us.”

-----

Ardelia had shown Graham the rest of the kitchen as well as the laundry room and garage, but there was nothing else he found out of the ordinary. To her, the rest of the call had been overshadowed by the revelation about the flowers. Graham had asked her about any messages with the arrangement, but Ardelia could only say that the FBI had found no card, and that Clarice had offhandedly told her it was from Lecter.

Everything had changed and yet nothing had changed. The FBI had already investigated the floral delivery, and hadn’t been able to identify the sender. Ardelia had the ridiculous thought that the FBI should know the arrangement wasn’t from Lecter, even if just to point out that there was indeed another party involved, but she could hardly tell them her source of information.

Ardelia left Clarice’s house when it was still fully dark. She walked back to her car and drove home as the beginnings of morning traffic were starting.

Once at her house, she numbly plugged in the burner phone to charge.

She didn’t know what to do, what she could do, or even what Graham and Lecter could possibly do. Graham had found something she hadn’t seen, but it was still a dead end.

At the end of the call, she’d asked, “What happens now?”

“That remains to be seen,” Graham had said, maddeningly cryptic. Then he’d hung up.

Surely he would find something, think of something that could lead her to Clarice. Some detail would occur to him and the whole thing would fall into place.

Ardelia waited, and waited, and waited. No matter what else she was doing as hour after hour dragged by, her whole being was waiting for the phone to ring.

After a day, she called their number again in desperation. An alert tone and a robotic message told her that the number was no longer in service.

She never heard from them again.

Chapter 6: Chapter 5

Chapter Text

Clarice threw herself against the cellar doors after they closed in her face.

It achieved nothing. She didn’t have the strength to move them. She had to stand on the steps to reach them, and there was simply no way to apply enough force with her hands braced over her head, even as she ascended higher to really put her back into it. That didn’t stop her from furiously rattling the doors for several minutes after her captor left.

When she had momentarily tired herself out, Clarice slumped to the concrete floor and mentally and physically regrouped. She realized she still had the tape on her mouth, and she carefully pulled it off. The flashlight he had dropped was still on, laying on the floor a few feet away from her. Clarice stared at it for a minute before she shifted to reach for it.

That was when she became aware of the pain in her right ankle. She knew abstractly that it had twisted when he’d thrown her, but only now after her adrenaline rush was gone, did she register the pain of it.

Clarice winced and grabbed the flashlight. It was a cheap plastic one that was only as long as her hand was wide, the kind of thing that would be in a bin at Walmart for a dollar. But it was more than enough to illuminate the space.

First, Clarice examined her ankle, and after moving experimentally, determined that it was sprained but probably not broken. It hurt to turn it and put weight on it, but it felt nearly exactly the same as when she had twisted her other ankle several years ago. Either way, right now her ankle was the least of her problems.

She turned her attention to the rest of her surroundings.

It was a cellar, obviously. Concrete all around, maybe seven by ten feet. The steps leading out of it were like a cross between a ladder and stairs. They more closely resembled a ladder because of the steep angle, but all the rungs were made of boards wider than would have been used in a ladder’s construction. The cellar floor was filthy and looked like it hadn’t been swept in years; there were already streaks of dirt on her clothing from it. On one long wall was the cot he’d dropped her on, a thing that was stained, sagging, and looked like it had been purchased at an Army surplus store fifty years ago. On the wall opposite there was a busted plastic cooler. Behind her and underneath the ladder were two broken lawn chairs.

Clarice clicked off the flashlight, and gave her eyes a minute to adjust. When she opened them, she could see a small amount of gray light coming in through the ventilation pipe, and she could make out the outline of the cellar doors where a hint of light crept in around the cracks. Neither was enough to see by, but it would be a gauge of the passing of day and night.

She turned the flashlight back on.

Clarice gingerly got to her feet, dusted her clothing off as best she could, and sat down on the cot again. She stared blankly at the opposite wall.

She wondered what time it was and looked at her wrist without thinking. Of course her watch was missing—it had GPS on it, after all, and some part of her had known that it wouldn’t be there just as her phone wasn’t in her pocket. But she looked at her watch a hundred times a day and doing so had been automatic. She took several deep breaths and closed her eyes, before opening them to look at the wall again.

The blinding terror that she’d felt earlier had dissipated, leaving in its place a looming dread. The man had left her here, and she was not currently in immediate danger of being hurt or killed. She was alone, and while nothing about that was good in the bigger picture, it meant that she had time to think without the life-or-death calculus she’d been consumed by since he had opened the trunk.

She again tried to calculate where she might be. The brief glimpses of light that she’d seen when she’d cracked her eyes open as he carried her had seemed consistent with midday. If he had been driving the entire time since he’d abducted her that morning, he couldn’t have made it more than four hours away from Quantico. Though that was still a disturbingly large radius when mapped out. Of course, she could also be much closer; she had no way of knowing what had happened when she’d been unconscious. And as much as she wanted to figure it out, where she had been taken was irrelevant if she couldn’t get out of the cellar.

Clarice tried to take control of the situation as much as she could. She was going to try the doors again, but she hadn’t heard the car start, which made it likely that he was still nearby. Though whether he was near the cellar or doing something else, she had no way of knowing. Until she thought it was safe to attempt opening the doors, she did the only thing she could, which was take what she knew and try to extrapolate a profile.

She did it every day. She had never done it from this perspective before, but it wasn’t the first time she had done a profile backwards.

Clarice could only assume that he had gone to considerable effort to abduct her. While she still didn’t remember the abduction itself, he had successfully pulled off abducting an FBI agent, which said something about his skills. She had already noted that he had tied her up in the trunk in a way that was almost impossible to get out of, and that he’d made sure the trunk couldn’t be opened from the inside. He hadn’t made any real mistakes that she could see besides believing that she’d been unconscious when he’d carried her down to the cellar. And if she hadn’t had all her training and experience, she doubted that she would have managed to pull that off.

She also assumed that she was a chosen target, not a random one. She would never be a target for monetary ransom, but he could have hoped to use her as leverage against the FBI somehow. It remained a possibility, since he had confined her but had yet to harm her. However, her gut said that this was something else, and she had made a career out of following her gut instincts. And so far, her circumstances had too much in common with cases where abduction victims ended up dead. She had to operate on the assumption that he intended to kill her.

If she was a chosen target that he intended to kill, she needed to figure out why. Killers who had ‘types’ that they went after might stalk a victim for weeks, might even abduct them from outside their home, but they also tended to opportunistic and impulsive about when to pounce, and this seemed too well planned to be impulsive. And as far as she could remember, there were no open cases in this part of the country with abductions in any demographic that she fit, beyond the general category of ‘woman.’ Two open cases that she could bring to mind involved the disappearances of college aged women, one case particularly around the time of spring break, and then an additional third case that involved hitchhiking young men going missing. And were no known killers who were targeting law enforcement in general.

She could be wrong, but it seemed likely that her captor had wanted her specifically. She could be a target simply because of who she was and what she did—it was a risk of such a public FBI job. Or she could have done him some perceived slight, as some killers were egotistical about what they did. Dr. Lecter had made a spectacle more than once because incorrect things were speculated or reported about him.

Clarice cut that thought off abruptly. This wasn’t one of Dr. Lecter’s crime scenes—she wasn’t anyone’s crime scene. She was alive and she intended to keep it that way.

If she was working under the assumption that her captor knew exactly who she was and wanted her for some particular reason, then she needed to figure out what he wanted. Which was admittedly hard to do when she had nothing to work with.

Clarice began going through a mental file of all her current cases, reviewing what she knew about the victims and what she had surmised about the killers. It took a considerable amount of time, but she had near encyclopedic knowledge about everything that was currently assigned to her, and when she closed her eyes she could almost see the case files.

Unfortunately, there was nothing that jumped out at her as definitive or even promising. She knew he could still be related to something there, as many of the cases were just beginning to take shape, but as it was, she had nothing to go on.

She had thought of everything she could, and she still had nothing to go on. But processing this like any other crime scene was how she was keeping herself from going crazy.

She still hadn’t heard the car start, even after all this time.

Clarice stood up. Her ankle pained her more now, but it hardly mattered. She made her way to the ladder, and took two steps up. Then she turned the flashlight off and put it in her pocket. She let her eyes completely adjust until she could clearly discern faint light from of the doors. She wanted to be able to see if a shadow passed over either of them. She also wanted her voice to carry.

“Hello?” she called in a neutral, professional tone. “Hello?”

There was no response, but she hadn’t expected one. She continued nonetheless. “My name is Clarice Starling. I’d like to speak to you. However you’re planning for this to end, it’s not going to lead to a good outcome for you. I can help you with that. You can change your mind at any time, and I’ll speak to the FBI on your behalf.”

He didn’t reply, but she would have been surprised if he had done so immediately. She paused, waiting a solid minute before speaking again.

“Or maybe there’s something you want?” she continued. “I can help you with that too. We can talk about this.”

There was no indication that he had even heard her. But her gut instincts told her that he was still nearby. Clarice kept talking in intervals, using all the skills she had built over the years. She talked about herself only enough to perhaps humanize her, but she never directly alluded to his obvious plans to kill her. She tried to identify with him, and gave him chances to share his point of view, all the while offering any assistance she could. She pretended that they were sitting across from each other in an interview room, and that this was only a casual information gathering chat, not a hostile situation.

He never responded.

After a time, Clarice stopped. She had made a good start, but she knew she had to let her words settle in his mind before she tried again. Clarice turned the flashlight back on and made her way to the cot. Her ankle was hurting more now, and she stretched her leg out as she pondered her next move.

Around half an hour later, she heard the car come to life and drive away.

Her heart jumped in anticipation at the idea of being truly alone. If she could manage to get the doors open, she could get away.

She heard nothing else from above, but she stayed where she was on the cot and counted out sixty seconds ten times in her head. When she heard nothing, she set the flashlight upright on the floor and climbed the ladder again. She pressed on the doors, ratting them ineffectually. She again tried throwing all of her weight, such as it was, at the middle of the doors where they opened, but she still didn’t have the leverage.

At the thought of leverage, Clarice climbed down the ladder and surveyed the cellar again. She examined the broken lawn chairs with interest. The woven plastic fibers were brittle and shredding, and she thought she might be able to separate them from the frame. She dragged one of them over to the cot, re-positioned the flashlight, and began to work.

It took her probably an hour, but eventually she picked enough of the plastic loose to free the metal frame. The frame itself, she managed to partially disassemble, which gave her one long L-shaped piece that she intended to try on the door. It even had an end that was flat, from where it had been shaped to screw into another part of the frame.

Clarice balanced on the ladder and applied her makeshift pry bar along the edges of the doors. She tried not to be discouraged, and even tried the least likely places for pressure to work after she had applied leverage at the obvious places. She bashed and pried at the hinges, but they were solid and immovable. She worked for long after she knew she’d failed, but if she simply sat and gave up, that was giving up.

She wondered if he had slid something like a broom handle through the doors after he’d locked them. It’s what she would have done, if she were designing an escape-proof room. A bar was a simple, yet incredibly effective way of blocking an exit.

Eventually, she had to accept that she wasn’t going to be able to get the doors open. She threw her piece of metal to the floor. Then she screamed for help as loud as she could.

Clarice knew the chances of someone being nearby, let alone nearby when she happened to yell, were close to zero. But she had to try. She knew that screaming her head off was going to do nothing but make her lose her voice and dry her mouth out. But she determined that she would make an attempt at regular intervals. However, she couldn’t climb up the ladder every time to do it.

Getting down, Clarice dragged the cot close to the ladder so that she could sit at one end of it and have the ventilation pipe directly overhead. She moved the remains of the lawn chair back under the steps so he wouldn’t immediately see it when he came back. The longest piece of frame, she leaned against the wall next to the cot. If nothing else, it could be a makeshift weapon. It was aluminum and lightweight, but it would take him by surprise if nothing else. A surprise blow to the head, even without much weight behind it, could be very effective. A smaller L-shaped piece of the lawn chair frame, she balanced on the second step from the top. He would see it if he looked, as it stuck out at an angle, but if he simply started down without looking, it might trip him and give her the advantage she needed.

The afternoon passed slowly.

She examined the cellar again with the flashlight, looking for anything she had missed. She also looked for any hidden cameras that might be monitoring her. But she found nothing. Cameras were of course small enough to be nearly invisible, but there were no electrical outlets, no smoke alarms, no picture frames to hide them in here. And everything was covered with a layer of grime. It truly looked like nothing in the cellar had been touched in years.

Clarice never heard the car return, and she shouted for help whenever she could. Twice, she heard a car pass on the distant gravel road, but they never slowed or stopped. Her thirst and her hunger began to make themselves known, but she tried to ignore them. She designated the broken cooler as her toilet, which was disgusting on many levels, but at least it was better than going in a corner.

Her ankle remained sore, a persistent pain from the multiple times she balanced on the ladder, but it only swelled minimally and hadn’t gotten worse. She had initially tried to stay off of it, but had quickly given up on that. If she hurt her ankle further getting out of here, that was a price she was willing to pay. Occasionally she had to get up and move just to stay warm. The temperature outside had been cool since this morning, but as the day wore on and her adrenaline wore off, she was plagued by a persistent chill.

She only realized that night had fallen when she turned off the flashlight to check, and no longer saw the faint daylight through the ventilation pipe.

It was still early in the evening, but the stress of the day, plus the fact that she’d been sleep deprived for at least a week, had finally caught up to her. She disliked the idea of going to sleep, of being unaware and vulnerable, but she also knew that it was going to be impossible to remain awake the entire time she was here, however long that might be.

Clarice was a light sleeper while napping, and she told herself that she would hear the noises of the metal doors opening if he came back before she woke, and she would definitely hear him if he tripped and fell. However, despite her exhaustion and her usual ability to find sleep easily, sleep was elusive. The metal supports of the cot dug in uncomfortably, but more distracting than that was the cold.

It wasn’t life threatening—the forecast for the entire region had been milder than usual, and temperatures were not going to be nearly cold enough for frostbite or hypothermia. But it was more than cold enough to be profoundly uncomfortable for someone who was dressed to go into an office. She had on wool socks and practical leather ankle boots, but her polyester slacks, while perfectly serviceable for walking briskly around a crime scene, seemed painfully thin. Her blazer gave her another layer on top, but it was far from enough to make her comfortable.

She had the dry thought that she could thank climate change for the fact that she wasn’t freezing to death in December.

Clarice slept in fits and starts throughout the night, curled in a fetal position with her hands tucked into her armpits for warmth. Sometimes it seemed like she had only just gotten to sleep before the cold or the discomfort woke her.

When she finally woke up for good, it was light outside, but she’d slept so badly that she had no other gauge for how early it might be. It could have been eight in the morning or it could have been noon. She also had no way of knowing if her captor had returned or if he was still gone. She was confident she would have heard the cellar door opening while she was asleep, but she was less certain that she would have heard the car.

Clarice briefly debated, but decided that she had to operate on the assumption that he both was there and that he wasn’t. She tried talking to him again, all the same essentials that she’d said yesterday but with different words. When that produced nothing, she screamed for help, fully aware that such a thing might bring him down into the cellar to silence her.

But there was nothing.

The day passed slowly, agonizingly slowly.

She kept up her routine of calling for help, but she had to wet her mouth before each time, and it was increasingly hard to do so. She was thirsty, and she was hungry, but her thirst was a thing that was impossible to ignore. It was also going to start affecting her physically soon, in more ways that just her mouth being dry.

Sometime into what had to be the afternoon, she heard the car again. It was the sound of a rumbling engine that left the road as the car pulled onto the property. The engine cut, and a single door opened and closed.

Clarice waited, her heart in her throat. She gripped the end of the lawn chair bar.

Minutes passed, but he didn’t open the door.

There was a slight possibility it wasn’t him, but she had to assume that it was. Therefore, it would be better to try talking again than to try yelling for help. She stood on the ladder and again worked her way through all that she had said that morning. There was no reply.

But since she knew he was there, she kept talking, trying different tactics than she had before. She tried to get him to identify and empathize with her. She mentioned her situation directly, but still with the assumption that it could be worked out between them. Knowing that some killers liked to hear it, she even tried begging. It was humiliating, and no part of what she said was put on, which made it all the more awful on a personal level. Everything she said was true—she wanted to live and she didn’t want to die here.

She had felt a creeping sense of desperation and uncertainty at the continued utter silence from above, and finally, her voice worn out, she stopped talking and sat down on the cot.

It had to be over a day since he’d thrown her down here, and that had been the sole interaction she’d had with him.

He hadn’t returned to torture her physically, assault her sexually, or terrorize her psychologically. Which was an abduction best-case scenario in nearly all ways, while being deeply worrying in one other, incredibly specific way. If he wasn’t coming in the cellar, that meant she had not even the smallest chance to trick him or overpower him and escape.

If he never opened the doors, the doors would never open.

It was a stark, bleak realization. Any hope she had of getting out had been entirely pinned on the assumption that he would return for some reason of his own.

Yesterday, she had been frightened but proactive—realistic about how bad this was, but hopeful that she would be able to maneuver something to her advantage. Now that hope had disappeared.

It was clear he was going to leave her here to die.

She could be wrong—there could be something she wasn’t seeing, or even some larger part of his plan that hadn’t gone as anticipated. But she knew she was imprisoned here and he was visiting the scene of his crime, which killers often did for personal enjoyment, even after their deeds were done.

He didn’t even seem to want to be part of it, to do anything to hasten her death. She guessed he simply wanted to know that it was happening. His intention had been to leave her here in the dark—dropping the flashlight had been an accident, but not enough of one that he felt the need to rectify it. He wanted her to know that there was no way out no matter what she tried. Perhaps he wanted her to know that he was there right now, to know that there was a person on the other side of the doors who could easily open them, but wouldn’t.

To know that she was going to die.

The blunt reality of it was overwhelming. She thought she’d been prepared for the idea; she’d known it was a possibility all along, but it wasn’t until this moment that she realized how much she truly thought she would get out of this somehow.

She needed to deal with the fact that that wasn’t going to happen.

Clarice shut her eyes.

Only a minute later, she opened them.

Actually, she decided with a grim practicality, she didn’t have to deal with it. She was going to die here whether she tried to make peace with it or whether she refused to think about it.

The end result would be the same.

Chapter 7: Chapter 6

Chapter Text

By the time darkness fell again, Clarice was beginning to feel the real toll of dehydration on her body.

She felt sluggish, both physically and mentally. She didn’t have the energy for much besides lying on the cot.

But she had already exhausted the possibilities of the cellar, and she had decided that she wasn’t going to give her captor the satisfaction of continuing to plead with him. She hadn’t heard the engine of the car again, and she wasn’t going to yell for help until he was gone.

Curled up on the cot, she started to get drowsy. She didn’t want to go to sleep, didn’t want to fall into a slumber she might not wake from, but she also couldn’t muster the strength to walk around the cellar.

She was uncomfortable, and she was cold, and she was so tired.

When Clarice next opened her eyes, she realized she had been asleep, but she had no idea how long. She had left the little flashlight on the floor, upturned to point at the ceiling. She squinted at the place where the vent was. It looked like it was still dark outside but it was hard to tell with the flashlight on, and she couldn’t be bothered to move to turn it off.

She wondered if he was still there, if it had been ten minutes or two hours since she had shut her eyes.

Maybe he was gone. Maybe he was there. She yelled for help anyway.

Nothing happened. But then, she hadn’t expected it to.

She drifted back into a pitiful slumber. In a way, it felt like she didn’t sleep at all, like she was floating in a miserable state of insomnia, only able to get near the cusp of sleep before she was pulled back to reality. Except she wasn’t quite sure she was making it all the way back to reality either.

But she must have truly slept at some point, because she thought she saw daylight around the vent. Unless she was dreaming now.

She was so cold, even in her dreams.

Once, Clarice tried to force herself up, to walk around the room and get her blood flowing, but her limbs wouldn’t cooperate. Everything was too heavy, too hard to move. With a defeated sigh, she slumped back on the cot and closed her eyes, waiting until she slept again.

During a somewhat more lucid moment, Clarice distantly realized that she was probably less sleeping and more slipping in and out of consciousness. At some point, she knew she would simply slip under and not come back. It would take her body longer than that to die, but at least she wouldn’t be aware of it.

She wondered if he would just leave her here, forever entombed like so many other lost women. The first case she’d ever worked had been a kidnapped girl in a hole in the ground, and now that’s how she was going to die.

Clarice stopped that train of thought right there—she didn’t have to think about it and she wasn’t going to.

Time continued to pass in a hazy blur that she was sometimes present for, and sometimes not. Even when she was awake, there was nothing she could do besides look at the ceiling until unconsciousness claimed her again.

She was pulled out of something like slumber when she heard a metallic noise of some sort. But it felt indistinct and faraway, like she was listening to it underwater.

A moment later, Clarice thought she heard another noise. She forced her eyes open with effort and saw a shadow moving in the room.

Everything seemed both heightened and dulled as someone said her name.

Then the shadows rearranged themselves into the form of Dr. Lecter, his face cast in a sepulchral light.

Clarice had known her ability to distinguish reality was failing, but whatever hold she’d had on herself must have washed away. She was hallucinating. She’d thought of Catherine Martin once, and now she was seeing the man who was forever entwined with memories of that case.

He said her name again and then something else as he came closer.

Clarice looked in that general direction, but her gaze fell to the floor instead, to the brightness of the upturned flashlight. She felt like she was hovering on the edge of a dream, removed from what was happening, because nothing was really happening.

Only when she felt the unexpected contact of physical touch did she surface from her haze. Dr. Lecter was next to her, his hands cradling her head as his fingers clinically probed over her skull.

Clarice focused on him with some effort, stunned. He was solid and real. But his being here made even less sense than a hallucination did.

She also couldn’t make sense of the thought that immediately followed, though she felt the truth of it in her bones: if he was here, she was going to live.

Dr. Lecter smiled, satisfied, when her eyes met his.

“Are you injured?” he asked. Even though she was foggy, Clarice got the impression he had repeated the question more than once.

She finally found the answer. “No.”

“You seem to be having some cognitive difficulties.”

“I’m severely dehydrated.”

He looked unsurprised. “But nothing else?”

“No.”

His hands left her head. “Can you walk?”

She slowly blinked at him, still processing. “I’d love to say yes.”

Dr. Lecter nodded to himself. Then he shifted his weight, said, “Pardon me,” and slid his arms underneath her.

He picked her up with no effort and turned on his heel.

Just like that, she was leaving the cellar.

Clarice rested her head against his shoulder because it was convenient, but her hands fell limply in her lap. She didn’t hold on to him.

Dr. Lecter shifted her somewhat as he began up the steps. He gripped one side of the ladder with his left hand, pressing her legs into the crook of his arm. But he never faltered, even while balancing her weight at an awkward angle.

“I put a thing on the steps,” Clarice said, belatedly remembering her trap.

But he only said, “So I saw.”

Of course he had, she realized. He wouldn’t have made it down otherwise.

A literal breath of fresh air hit her once she was aboveground. The night was cold, but she scarcely cared now. Clarice was far from completely with it, and everything still felt distorted as she tried to make sense of what was going on.

Dr. Lecter began to walk.

Clarice slowly became aware of a sound—a peculiar noise she’d never heard before, a dull, wet thwunk thwunk thwunk. After another moment of confusion, she located the source of the sound just ahead of them.

It was Will Graham, repeatedly swinging a hatchet into a body at his feet.

He was a silhouette in the moonlight, the darkness masking the gruesomeness of the scene. But nothing could obscure the sound of flesh being methodically destroyed.

Dr. Lecter neither made her look nor shielded her from the view. He simply walked, passing Will and leaving the sick sounds of Will’s work behind them, the noise fading into the distance with each step.

The dead man had to be the man who’d brought her here. She could guess that much, but she knew nothing else.

She let her head fall back, completely becoming dead weight as she stared up at the sky.

She could see the stars straight above. And she could see Dr. Lecter.

“How are you here?” she mumbled. “Why are you here?”

“I keep my promises, Clarice.”

“You didn’t promise me anything.”

“Perhaps not,” he agreed. “But I also pay my debts. What is debt, if not a promise in reverse?”

“This is insane,” she said, shaking her head. “You’re insane.”

Dr. Lecter only chuckled. “So I’ve been told.”

Encounters with Dr. Lecter were always surreal, but she was on the edge of being delirious. It was madness that he was here, madness that he was the only thing suspending her between life and death.

Madness that she felt safe.

At the edge of the property, Dr. Lecter turned to walk down the dirt road. After what seemed like an age but probably wasn’t, they came to a car parked to one side. Dr. Lecter opened the back passenger door and set her in the seat.

He produced a small flashlight from somewhere, and crouched beside the car door as he tested her pupils. He checked her pulse next, taking her hand and pressing two fingers to her wrist. Clarice hazily stared past him as he silently counted her heartbeats.

Then, and it was so strange she wasn’t entirely sure she didn’t imagine it, he brought the inside of her wrist close to his nose and inhaled. A beat later, he nodded to himself.

“You’ve avoided kidney failure,” he said. “You should recover easily enough with plenty of fluids.” He placed her hand back in her lap.

Dr. Lecter stood and moved out of view. Clarice heard the trunk open.

A moment later, he was back. There was a bottle of Gatorade in his hands, as well as a paper-wrapped straw. He opened the bottle and put the straw in it, and Clarice reached for it with both hands. She might not be able to walk, but she was determined to drink by herself. Dr. Lecter let go after a pause to make sure it wasn’t going to slip from her grasp.

She balanced the bottle on her leg for a moment, testing her own grip before she bent down to suck at the straw. Clarice imagined it would be the most refreshing thing she’d ever tasted. While wetting her mouth was a relief, the liquid landed with an odd feeling in the pit of her stomach. But when nothing immediately came back up, she forced herself to slowly drink as much as she could stand, before bringing the somewhat emptier bottle to rest between her knees.

“Thank you,” she said.

The words seemed profoundly inadequate. However, Dr. Lecter only said, “You are most welcome.”

Clarice dropped her hands to her lap, and Dr. Lecter took the bottle, leaning slightly over her to place it into a cup holder on the back of the center console.

Then he was crouching beside the car again, regarding her with an even gaze. Clarice looked at him tiredly, her head falling back against the seat as she met his eyes. She found herself staring at him, unable to look away.

He, of course, simply stared back.

Clarice said exactly what she was thinking.

“I’ve never been so happy to see someone in my entire life.”

Dr. Lecter smiled. “I suspect you would say the same to anyone at the moment.”

“But you’re the only one who could be here.” She said it and it became true. She didn’t know how or why, but it had to be him. Maybe it was always going to come to this, maybe this was always going to happen, because his reality included a favor returned and the universe had obliged him. Clarice wasn’t sure she was making sense. She had the ironic thought that she wasn’t lucid enough for philosophical musings, even though they seemed to be coming to her quite easily.

Dr. Lecter was still watching her, his hands clasped loosely in front of him.

Whatever else was spinning through her mind, there was one thing she knew with absolute certainty.

Clarice reached out, putting her hand over the top of his.

“You saved my life,” she said quietly. “Thank you.”

One of his hands slid to cover hers. “It was my pleasure,” he said. There was a genuine smile on his lips, and his eyes were dark but sincere as they held her gaze.

The moment seemed frozen, suspended between them in the silence of the darkness. The dome light of the car cast shadows over his face; the light itself made the car seem like an island in a sea of night.

Time restarted when Dr. Lecter let go of her hand. He asked, “How do you feel?”

“Awful. Like I’ve been drained.” She realized after she said it that that’s exactly what she was—drained of hydration.

Clarice felt the weary exhaustion that had never really left her rising to the surface again. Dr. Lecter’s appearance had been shocking enough that her mind had been forced to attention, but she questioned her ability to remain coherent for much longer.

“I feel like I want to lie down,” she said.

“Then you should do so.” He stood. “But drink a little more first.”

Clarice half-slid, half-pushed herself over to the middle seat, and then leaned down to drink from the bottle in the cup holder. After she had made herself drink more, she folded in on herself, curling up across the backseat on her side. She winced as her twisted ankle made itself known at the movement.

Her feet were nearest the open door, which meant that she could see the field beyond. She closed her eyes, drifting in the odd space of fatigue that enveloped her. She could hear Dr. Lecter rummaging in the trunk. Clarice didn’t wonder or care what he was doing; she only registered the background noise.

She idly opened her eyes when it finally stopped, wondering if Dr. Lecter was going to say something. But he wasn’t near her at all. Instead, he was walking to meet Will, who had come through the field instead of down the road.

Both of them stopped a short distance from the car. They spoke quietly with each other, each occasionally nodding, but they were far away enough that she couldn’t hear anything besides the sounds of their voices. A minute later, Dr. Lecter and Will turned their heads in her direction, and Clarice knew they were talking about what to do with her.

She also knew they weren’t going to do anything with her in any way that she needed to be worried about, so she couldn’t find it in herself to care.

After a few more moments, the conversation was over, and they started walking towards the car. She saw that Will still had the hatchet in his hand. Dr. Lecter and Will both disappeared from view as they rounded the trunk. She heard the sound of a garbage bag being opened, and then a thud as Will presumably deposited the hatchet into the trunk.

Curiosity took precedence over her need to rest, and she pushed herself up to look over the seat, following them with her gaze. The trunk was still open, and there was only a narrow line of sight between the back of the car and the top of the trunk.

Given what little she could see through the gap, she couldn’t immediately tell who was who. Then she noticed the bloody clothes, faintly discernible by the trunk’s own interior light, and knew those belonged to Will. A second later, Dr. Lecter snapped open another garbage bag, and Will began stripping out of his clothing.

Clarice slid back down the seat. She could hear the rustling sounds of material, followed by the noise of plastic as ruined garments were chucked away, piece by piece.

She knew how she’d gotten here, yet at the same time, she had no idea how she’d gotten here, to this place where men came and went like shadows in the night, leaving chaos behind them even as they cleaned up with mundane efficiency. It didn’t even feel like part of the real world, despite the fact that she was in it.

She felt like she was in a dream again.

Clarice was almost asleep as soon as she closed her eyes, being both mentally and physically exhausted. Sleep was welcome in a way it hadn’t been earlier; there was no reason now that she needed to worry about drifting off.

But she was roused back into something like wakefulness a few minutes later when Dr. Lecter lifted her feet and sat in the seat they had been occupying. Clarice made a noise of discomfort when he jostled her ankle as he placed her lower legs to rest across his lap.

“You said you weren’t injured,” he commented.

“I forgot about it,” she said, not bothering to open her eyes. “It’s just sprained. I think.”

All she wanted was to go back to sleep. But she was also morbidly curious why he wasn’t in the front seat and was instead taking up her legroom. “Should I be flattered you’re sitting with me instead of with Will?” she asked dully.

Dr. Lecter chuckled. “It would be careless of me to assume that your gratitude would override your sense of duty. Better to be close at hand.”

It took Clarice longer than it should have to tease out his meaning. When she did, she almost laughed. “You have a higher opinion of my faculties right now than I do,” she mumbled.

“Then you should be flattered,” he said, amusement in his voice.

She couldn’t summon the energy to stay awake, much less to do something that would get the car noticed or pulled over. She was too tired to care.

It was funny, she thought vaguely, how a person could feel bad enough that normal concerns simply ceased to matter, and normal reactions ceased to exist. The out-of-it feeling she had now reminded her of being ill with a fever, only about three times worse.

She didn’t care that she couldn’t get them caught. She didn’t care that she was sitting with Dr. Lecter. She didn’t care that she didn’t know where they were going.

She could care again later, when she could think clearly and keep her eyes open.

The trunk of the car closed with a thud. Then Will was in the driver’s seat, starting the car and putting it into gear.

A moment later, they were in motion, and everything fell away.

Chapter 8: Chapter 7

Chapter Text

Clarice woke up slowly at first. She was so tired and all she wanted was to stay in bed.

But as she came out of that state between dreaming and waking, she had a moment of panic. She didn’t know where she was and she couldn’t remember what had happened.

She flailed and her foot hit something solid. Clarice immediately opened her eyes and jerked upright.

Will was stretched out on the covers next to her, reclining against propped up pillows and idly holding a tablet in his hands. He was dressed for the cold; his shoes were still on, even as his feet rested on top of the quilt.

She had the mad thought that Dr. Lecter must hate that.

Will’s attention had turned from the tablet when her foot had connected with his shin, and he regarded her with a steady gaze.

Clarice only looked at him for a second before she exhaled and slumped back in bed, her head falling to the pillow as she pulled the warmth of the covers over herself once more. Now she remembered what had happened, more or less. She also felt dizzy from moving so quickly.

“Why are you sitting here?” she asked, for lack of anything better to say.

“To make sure you stay put,” Will said. “It seemed in poor taste to tie you up, considering the circumstances.”

Considering that she had been confined and left to die, he meant. She stared blankly at the ceiling. “I wasn’t tied up,” she said. “I just couldn’t get out.”

“Even so.” Will laid the tablet aside and sat up. Clarice was struck by their relative positions. Last time they had met, he had been the one in bed barely able to move; now it was her.

He looked down at her for a moment, his gaze even. “You’re not our prisoner,” he said softly.

It was something she had already known. There was no doubt that Dr. Lecter had saved her life, and that his being there to do so had been his purpose, not a coincidence. Wherever she was now, she wasn’t a captive, but a guest.

“All the same,” Will continued, “you should be aware that we’re somewhere remote, and the nearest road you might encounter traffic on is miles from here. Hannibal has the car keys, as well as the only device connected to cellular.”

Clarice gave him a wan smile. “You don’t call that being prisoner?”

“I call it a situation free from moral dilemma,” Will said, a vague note of humor in his voice. “There’s nothing you can do about me and Hannibal being here, so you should content yourself with doing nothing. Don’t waste energy on what you can’t change.”

Clarice took his point, and she took it because she had no energy. She wasn’t their prisoner; she was her body’s prisoner. She was exhausted to the point of illness, and she wasn’t going anywhere.

“I should be in a hospital,” she said.

“You’re not going to die because we didn’t take you to a hospital.”

“And if I had been?”

“Then things would have been both simpler and more complicated,” he said wryly.

Clarice could imagine how it could have been simpler. If she had been unconscious the whole time, they could have left her at the doors of an ER and have been gone before anyone realized who they were. And of course it would have been more complicated if she’d needed emergency attention but was still capable of telling someone to call the FBI on them.

“You’re dehydrated,” Will said, cutting off her thoughts, “but not in danger beyond that. You need to drink and keep drinking.”

His eyes flicked to a spot beside the bed, and Clarice turned her neck and saw both a water bottle and a Gatorade bottle sitting on the bedside table. She slowly pushed herself into a sitting position, pleased when her head didn’t spin this time, and reached for the Gatorade.

Drinking proved more challenging than it should have been, as she was unable to get the plastic cap off. She made several attempts before Will wordlessly took the bottle from her and opened it. Clarice thanked him as he handed the bottle back to her, but she was appalled at how weak her grip was, how weak she was.

She slowly starting drinking.

Will watched her, quietly, unobtrusively.

It was a side of him she’d never seen—sympathetic and attentive, with nothing calculating behind his eyes. She wondered if this was what he’d been like before he’d met Dr. Lecter. Yet there was a contradiction there, because apparently this was what Will was still like, under the right circumstances.

Will himself looked much the same, despite the years. There was gray around his temples and streaking his short beard, but he had one of those faces that simply didn’t seem to age. He could have been fifty or a decade in either direction quite easily. He looked, somewhat annoyingly, like the stereotype of a distinguished professor.

Clarice’s attention next turned to her surroundings. She was in what appeared to be a cabin. The walls were a rich natural wood, and even though the room wasn’t large, there were beams of round timber exposed on the plaster ceiling. A fireplace with a crackling fire was on one wall, and she could see trees and a hint of snow outside the window in the morning light.

She reflected on how long she had slept, a bit amazed yet also not surprised that she hadn’t woken up during the car ride to wherever she was now. Sleep had been easy once she knew that falling asleep didn’t mean she might not wake up, and she’d been exhausted.

Though Clarice stamped down the urge to ask where she was, afraid of what she might learn. It was obviously someone’s house, but right now she absolutely couldn’t hear if it had been empty or if Dr. Lecter had made it empty.

Instead, she asked, “Where is Dr. Lecter?”

“Splitting wood.”

Of course he was.

Clarice listened, and thought she could hear the faint thunk of wood being cut somewhere outside.

Thinking of an axe made her remember what she had seen Will doing last night. He looked remarkably composed for a man who had murdered someone with a hatchet so many hours ago. Of course, she was remarkably composed for someone two feet away from a hatchet murderer.

Despite Dr. Lecter being the one who wanted to return a favor, Clarice couldn’t help but wonder if it was Will’s abilities that actually led to them locating her, given what she had briefly seen of Will’s hands on involvement.

Clarice finished half the bottle before she set it back on the nightstand.

“Have you ever been starved and dehydrated?” she asked.

“I’ve been shot and stabbed, beaten and drowned,” Will said distantly. “But I’ve never been left to waste away, no. Speaking of starvation, you’ll also need to get something in your stomach. Maybe not today, but by tomorrow.”

For the first time since waking up, Clarice felt the beginnings of real anxiety. “I can’t eat anything,” she said, shaking her head. Yet she’d be starving; she wouldn’t have a choice about eating whatever Dr. Lecter put in front of her. She wouldn’t be able to not eat.

Will read the fear on her face. “There are no special ingredients here.”

Clarice looked at him doubtfully. “You didn’t… take anything from him?”

“Hannibal was occupied with you, and taking things has never been my priority,” Will said.

“Dr. Lecter must be disappointed.”

Will chuckled. “He’ll get over it.”

At least she wouldn’t have to worry about eating. It was true she wasn’t hungry yet, which surprised her on an instinctual level, even though she knew medically how the beginnings of starvation worked.

In the meantime, she would drink. She already felt so much more with it mentally than she had mere hours ago, though she still felt terrible. She also felt disgusting, and was well enough to care that she felt disgusting.

She said it aloud. “I feel disgusting. Is there a bathtub here, or only a shower?” She thought she could manage to sit in a tub, while she knew she couldn’t remain upright long enough to take a shower.

“There’s a tub,” Will said, raising a brow in question.

“I want to take a bath.”

He looked at her appraisingly. “Can you do it without cracking your head open?”

It was a valid question.

Clarice moved to swing her legs over the side of the bed and braced her hand against the wall. Then she slowly stood. She felt a brief sensation of dizziness, but when her legs didn’t threaten to fall out from underneath her, she considered it a success. Her sprained ankle pained her but she didn’t care.

“Yes,” she said.

Will shrugged. She couldn’t tell whether he was satisfied or whether he simply wasn’t going to tell her she couldn’t. “Sit down. I’ll start one.”

He got up as she sank to the bed. He walked the short distance to what was presumably the bathroom door. Clarice heard the bathtub tap come on, followed by the sound of cabinet doors opening and closing.

A few moments later, Will reappeared. He nodded his head toward the bathroom door. “Go. Feel better.”

Clarice gathered herself and gained her footing again, bracing her hand against the wall as she walked. She felt weak, but it was less than ten feet away. She could make it ten feet. All she had to do was get to the bathroom, and then she could feel human again.

Luckily, she could lean on the wall the whole way, the bathroom door being in the corner of the room. She pointedly didn’t look at Will, who had remained standing as she progressed, like he didn’t entirely believe that she wasn’t going to collapse, but wasn’t going to call her on it.

Once Clarice shut the bathroom door behind her, she slid to the floor, not trusting her ability to both strip and keep her balance. She had no intention of standing at all in the bathroom, not with slippery surfaces and hard tile to hit.

The bathtub was filling behind her, and she could see a fresh towel, washcloth, and new bar of soap sitting on the edge of the tub. There was another damp looking towel hanging over the shower curtain rail above. The room smelled faintly of bleach.

Well, there was no question about the tub being clean, she thought grimly. Either Dr. Lecter or Will had already used it, and then thoroughly cleaned up after themselves. She guessed Will, since he’d been the one with blood all over him last night.

Clarice leaned her head back against the wall, for a moment doing nothing but listening to the sound of the tub filling. Then she straightened, and started to pull her shirt over her head. She got about halfway and stopped.

She realized she didn’t have anything clean to put on afterwards. The idea of crawling back into her days-old dirty clothes after taking a bath was both impractical and undesirable. For a moment, her thoughts simply ground to a halt. There was nothing else; she would have to wear these again.

But then, she was in a house, so surely there was something else. Clarice still didn’t know where she was, and the idea of wearing anything that was here also settled unpleasantly on her. Yet she desperately wanted to have something clean. She debated for a for almost a minute and then opened the door.

Will was sitting on the bed again, the tablet in his hand. He looked up at the sound of the door.

Clarice didn’t bother standing. “I don’t have anything clean to wear,” she said from the floor.

Will grimaced, looking almost bothered that he hadn’t thought of that already. He stood and went to rummage in the dresser on the other wall. After a moment, he pulled something out and closed the drawers. Then he crossed the room to hand it to her.

Clarice took it—pajamas of some sort—and swallowed as her hand closed around the fabric. She couldn’t put the question off any longer.

Still staring at what she held, she asked, “Whose clothes are these?”

“Mine. Or they were, once upon a time.”

Clarice looked up at him in shock. He’d taken them out of the dresser. “Whose house is this?” she blurted.

“It’s Hannibal’s, in a roundabout way.” There was amusement in his eyes, and she had the feeling he knew exactly what she’d been thinking, that the house was only empty courtesy of Dr. Lecter. “But we haven’t been here in a decade.”

“I see,” Clarice said. While that answered the immediate question, it led to even more, and she was still too tired to consider them. “Thank you,” she said, gesturing with the hand that held the pajamas. Then she shut the door.

She scooted toward the tub, which was nearly full enough, and checked the temperature of the water. It was pleasantly hot, and she only adjusted the faucet slightly. She stripped, folding her clothes on the floor and then sitting on the toilet. It was a relief when she peed a little, because it meant her body already had enough water to do so.

Clarice turned off the faucet and crawled into the tub sideways, one arm and leg over the side followed by the other arm and leg. It felt awkward, but she was set on not doing anything that would lead to her hurting herself.

She sat in the tub and leaned her head against the tile wall, closing her eyes. After a few minutes of letting the heat wash over her, she picked up the soap and the washcloth, and began to wash herself. It didn’t take long, and as nice as the hot water was, all she could think about was getting back to bed to lie down. She would feel like a long soak some other day, feel like washing her hair some other day.

When she was done, she pulled the plug on the drain and carefully got out of the tub. Clarice sat down square on the bathmat, hating how tired she was after doing something so simple. Though it was absolutely worth it to be clean. Still sitting, she reached for the towel Will had left out for her and began to dry off. Once done, she put on the pajamas, which were a soft and heavy flannel. She expected them to smell musty since they’d been sitting for years, but they only smelled of cedar. Will had also included a pair of warm socks, and she put those on as well.

There was a leather toiletry bag sitting next to the sink and a suitcase to one side of the counter. Dr. Lecter might own the house, but there must not have been enough left here to get by on, despite whatever was in the dresser. She wondered if this was like all of his properties, a home abandoned.

Tired but curious, Clarice crawled over to the bathroom counter and opened the cabinet underneath. There were some towels, toilet paper, a first aid kit, and new bars of soap. A drawer revealed a comb, scissors, a few safety razors, travel size shampoos, and new toothbrushes with a few travel sized toothpastes. It was the absolute basics. There was nothing in any of the other drawers.

Clarice picked up one of the toothpastes. The expiration date was years in the past, but she didn’t care. She opened a toothbrush, and knelt at the sink as she brushed. Brushing her teeth felt more amazing than the bath. When she was finished, she laid the toothbrush in the plastic packaging it had come in and put both it and the toothpaste she’d used in one of the empty drawers.

Then she collected her folded clothes, and dragged herself up the bathroom doorframe. When she opened the door, the bedroom was empty, and she could see a glimpse of the living room beyond through the half-closed door. She made the effort to walk the few steps to the bed, holding onto the wall for balance. She slid her dirty clothes under the edge of the bed, out of sight and out of mind.

Then she sank down on the bed, exhausted. She still felt obviously unwell. She was physically weak and mentally drained, but at least she didn’t have the fog of confusion that had been with her last night.

Clarice leaned over to the nightstand for the bottle of water. She knew she needed to keep drinking. The Gatorade would taste terrible after the toothpaste, but she would work on drinking it later. It had sugar and electrolytes that the water didn’t.

She put the water down when she was done, and her eyes fell on the Gatorade again. Electrolytes or not, it was a cheap and artificially flavored drink—not at all the sort of thing coinciding with Dr. Lecter’s palate. Yet he’d had it when he’d found her, which meant that he had somehow known that she would need it.

Clarice pulled herself halfway up and flipped the covers back, only to see that the ivory sheets were full of dirty smudges right where she’d been lying. She had felt disgusting because she hadn’t showered for days, but some part of her had forgotten that her clothes weren’t just the normal sort of dirty, but were actually filthy from the cellar. It was something totally beyond her control, but she still disliked seeing the mess she had inadvertently made.

She also didn’t want to sleep there now. But it was king sized bed, so she simply moved to the side that Will had been sitting on. She pulled the covers all the way back, but didn’t immediately get beneath them, instead settling against the pillows propped up against the headboard. Will hadn’t returned and had left her alone, evidently satisfied that she wasn’t going to do something like try to go out the window.

She wasn’t going to do anything for obvious reasons. She had barely made it to the bathroom, and it wasn’t worth contemplating how far she’d make it before collapsing if she tried to leave the cabin. What Will had said was true—there was nothing she could do about him and Dr. Lecter being here.

She was here, and they were here, and that was that.

Clarice closed her eyes, just meaning to rest for a moment before she got into the bed properly. But she was drifting somewhere near half-asleep when she heard a door close from the other room, which was enough to bring her back to herself. It was followed by the sound of Dr. Lecter’s voice as he said something to Will.

She heard Will reply, and after another minute, Dr. Lecter looked into the bedroom.

Upon seeing her awake, he stepped farther in. “Good morning. How are you feeling?”

“Tired, but better. Kind of.”

He nodded, and his eyes ran over her. He made no comment about what she was wearing, though obviously he noticed it. Instead he said, “May I examine your injury?”

“Sure, why not,” Clarice said, not particularly caring.

Dr. Lecter crossed the room and sat down on the end of the bed. He lightly touched her right ankle, rotating her foot with minimal pressure and feeling along the lines of the bones.

Clarice watched him, looking at him for the first time in the light of day, as well as the first time when she was in a state of mind to really examine him. The years had made a larger difference on him than they had on Will, but Dr. Lecter had to be pushing seventy by now. His hair was fully silver, and it gave his looks a striking contrast that they hadn’t had before. Despite the extra lines around his eyes and mouth, something undeniably sharp remained about his features.

“It is indeed sprained, though with hardly any swelling,” Dr. Lecter said. “But it should be wrapped for support.”

“All right,” she said easily.

Dr. Lecter got up and went into the bathroom, returning with a bandage roll. He sat back down on the end of the bed. Sliding one hand under her foot, he removed the sock and began to wind the bandage around her leg in an easy, practiced manner.

As Clarice watched him wrap her ankle, taking meticulous care over what was a very minor injury, she was suddenly struck by something Will had said years ago about Dr. Lecter and those in distress.

“You like seeing me like this,” she said.

“I like helping you,” he countered, his attention still on the task at hand.

Clarice studied him a moment more. “You like being able to give help that only you can give. You like being a solution in times of crisis, a lifeline to the drowning.”

Dr. Lecter glanced up at that. “And whom amongst us does not enjoy making use of our talents?” he asked, the smallest of smiles on his lips.

Will spoke from the doorway, where he lingered. “Now and then, you pushed them in first, and then threw the lifeline.”

Dr. Lecter smiled outright. “And you, Clarice? Did I push you in first?”

It took her a moment more than it normally would have to work out his question. Then she realized that Will meant Dr. Lecter created some of the situations he offered assistance in.

“No,” she said with certainty. “You’re the one who placed value on saving my life, the one who decided it needed to be done. If you had engineered the opportunity to do so, you wouldn’t consider it truly discharging a debt.”

He said nothing, but looked pleased at her accurate assessment.

There was a time she never would have accepted his assistance, but that was before she’d been nearly dying. Yet he had never metaphorically dangled assistance in front of her, waiting for her to accept it—he had simply done it.

“Do you know,” Clarice mused, “if you took all the times we’ve spoken and put them together, I don’t think they would equal twenty-four hours combined?”

“Then it is all the more astonishing that we understand each other so well.”

She gave a half-hearted smile. “Yes, you and I and Will have nothing but understanding between us.”

Dr. Lecter finished wrapping her ankle, fixing the end of the bandage into place with clips. He put the sock over the bandage, and then satisfied, patted her shin once. Then he clasped his hands and said, “You refer to Will by his given name, and to me by surname and honorific. Why is that?”

She was thrown by the change in topic, but her reply came easily.

“Because you, Doctor Lecter, are the type of person one always gives the appropriate amount of respect.”

His lips curled upward at that, acknowledging her point. Amusement still lingering on his face, he raised a brow and asked, “And Will is not?”

Clarice studied him a moment, and was herself amused at the line of questioning. “You think there’s some particular reason I refer to you as ‘Dr. Lecter’ and to him as ‘Will’.”

He inclined his head, not so much in affirmation, but in consideration. “Everything we do, we do for a reason.”

“And yet the simplest explanation is often the correct one.” Clarice paused before imparting her answer. “I call him Will because he asked me to call him Will.”

“Sometimes,” came Will’s dry voice, “a cigar is just a cigar.”

Far from being dissatisfied at the ordinary explanation, Dr. Lecter looked as interested as ever.

Directing his attention to Will, he asked, “And why did you ask her to use your first name?”

“Because my days of being Mr. Graham to students were left behind long ago.”

Dr. Lecter held Will’s gaze. “And?” he pressed.

For a moment, they simply stared at each other, the silence of two people who knew each other too well. Dr. Lecter’s expression was one of expectation, like he knew exactly the sort of thing Will was likely to say. Will looked simultaneously exasperated that his words had had the opposite of their intended effect, and smug about whatever thing he had clearly done.

Will finally spoke. “And to foster a sense of camaraderie.”

Dr. Lecter looked delighted. “So you see, Clarice, nothing is ever simple when it comes to Will.”

“That sounds exhausting,” Clarice said plainly.

“Not at all,” Dr. Lecter said, his eyes landing on Will again. “It keeps things interesting.”

“Well, it was simple on my end,” she said.

“Then it would be just as simple for you to call me Hannibal,” he said, looking back at her. “Since we are so well acquainted.”

Clarice was surprised, and she was sure it showed on her face. She raised a brow. “And is your request as ‘simple’ as Will’s was?”

“Even more so. Or less so, if you prefer.” The corner of his mouth quirked up, but his expression was unusually sincere as he held her gaze. “I think we’re well past formality, Clarice, don’t you?”

She supposed they were.

In spite of the peculiar line of the conversation, or perhaps because of it, Clarice was struck by the impression that his request was genuine. While nearly everything with Dr. Lecter could be a manipulation at some level, she sensed that wasn’t his motivation.

“I suppose your friends call you Hannibal,” Clarice commented.

“My enemies too,” he said. Then he tilted his head slightly, studying her. “Are we friends?”

Clarice was honest. “I can’t be friends with you, but I think you’re friends with me.”

His eyes crinkled. “As good a summation as any.”

“Then there you have it,” she said, before adding, “Hannibal.”

He smiled at that, a true smile.

In her mind, he would always be ‘Dr. Lecter’ to her; it seemed almost impossible to think of him otherwise, the same way one always referred to one’s teachers by surname, no matter how many years had passed. But it cost her nothing to call him Hannibal.

“Then,” he continued, “as a friend, you must know I look forward to speaking to you before we leave.” Dr. Lecter ran a critical eye over her. “Whenever you are equal to the task.”

She almost smiled. “Is having a conversation a task?”

“That depends on your perspective.”

Clarice had once wished for the opportunity to talk with him again, so she would be lying to herself if she treated his conversation as something to be gotten through or endured, as she once had. Of course, she had a much better understanding now than she did during their earlier meetings, both of him and of herself.

“I don’t perceive it as such,” she said. “Though it’s true that right now I can barely keep my eyes open. So I’m not equal to much.”

Dr. Lecter nodded, looking unsurprised. “That’s to be expected. Your body has been under a tremendous amount of stress and deprivation.” He stood. “Rest. We’ll talk after you wake.”

“How long are you staying here?” she asked, curious.

“Will and I will depart tonight after dark. We have the rest of the day.”

With that, he and Will left the room, Dr. Lecter shutting the door behind him.

Clarice rearranged the pillows, crawled under the covers, and was asleep almost as soon as she closed her eyes.

Chapter 9: Chapter 8

Chapter Text

Clarice slept for several hours, waking in the early afternoon.

She still felt a deep weariness, but it wasn’t something that could be cured by sleeping more now. She was fully awake, and for the time being, her body had no more interest in sleep. Overall, she felt better than the last time she’d woken up, and worlds better than she had last night, when her body was failing her and she’d barely been able to get her bearings mentally.

But Clarice remembered her rescue with perfect clarity; it was starkly imprinted on her mind amongst a sea of disorientation. That was definitely something she wanted to discuss today.

Carefully getting to her feet, she was pleased when her balance didn’t falter. She made her way to the bathroom while only lightly leaning on the wall.

After she was done, she returned to the bedroom, sat on the bed and drank the Gatorade that remained on the nightstand.

Then she stood, ready to find Dr. Lecter. She opened the door.

The living room of the cabin was done in much the same style as the bedroom was. The walls and floor were wood, and the furniture was elegant but cozy, upholstered in lighter shades of leather to offset the dark surroundings. The cabin was small, with the open kitchen visible in one corner, and a fireplace on the shared wall of the bedroom.

Arranged on either side of the fireplace were two armchairs and a sofa. Dr. Lecter was seated in the chair nearest the fire, and he looked up with interest as she slowly approached. Will, who had been lying on the sofa, got up without comment and took the other chair.

“Thank you,” Clarice murmured. She arranged herself on the sofa, half-sitting, half-lying against the cushions of the arm, with her legs stretched out in front of her. She wasn’t going to pretend that she was at her best when she clearly wasn’t; this time there would be no words traded across a table, words that felt balanced on a knife’s edge.

This time, they were past all that.

Her feet were pointed toward the fire, which gave her the best view of Dr. Lecter, who regarded her patiently as she got settled. He had the glass fireplace doors open to better appreciate the warmth it generated.

“How is your ankle?” he asked.

“It’s fine, thank you,” she said, pulling an afghan from the back of the sofa and draping it over herself. Despite the fire going, there was still a slight chill in the air, and she’d been cold for days. “If the only injuries I got out of being abducted by a serial killer are dehydration and a sprained ankle, I’ll count myself as extremely lucky.”

“Would it interest you to know he wasn’t a serial killer?”

“Yes, actually.”

“Then we may begin our discussion there.” Then he asked, “When is the last time you drank something?”

“Just now.”

He nodded, but stood. “Nevertheless,” he said, retrieving another bottle of Gatorade for her, before sitting back down, “you need to hydrate throughout the day as much as possible. It was extremely fortunate we found you when we did.”

Clarice obligingly opened the bottle and took a sip. As she loosely screwed the cap back on, the thoughts from earlier returned to her.

She looked at Dr. Lecter and tapped the Gatorade bottle with her fingernail. “This isn’t something you would drink. You had it for me, and you had it before you found me. Which meant you knew the state I’d likely be in.”

He seemed pleased at the amount of information she had gleaned from a bottle.

She had already known that them finding her hadn’t been by chance, but she honestly had no idea about anything beyond that. She voiced her best and only real theory. Glancing in Will’s direction, she asked, “Did you guess his methods because he was a killer you were tracking?”

“Not exactly,” Will said.

When he added nothing more, Dr. Lecter asked, “What do you remember of your abduction?”

“Nothing of the abduction itself,” Clarice admitted. “I remember getting up that morning. I think I remember going to the door. There must have been a struggle, but I don’t know what happened. I came to in the trunk of a car. I guessed that I had been drugged. I know a loss of memory isn’t uncommon, but it’s—it’s frustrating not to remember something so significant.”

Will tilted his head. “Your abduction was carefully planned. He went to your house disguised as a delivery driver. The second you opened your door, he injected you with the drugs. You tried to hit him with the lamp in your entryway but fell, knocking over the table and coat rack. Once you were unconscious, he put you in your own car and left the scene. He later changed cars and abandoned yours.”

Clarice absorbed the information, but felt a prickle of unease that had nothing to do with Will’s nearly omniscient reconstruction. While it was eerie hearing a recitation of things that had happened to her that were a blank in her own memory, she was also struck by the precise way he’d described her entryway.

Her brows raised. “I thought you needed to be at the location to reconstruct a crime scene.” It was how she had first met him, after all.

“We have not been to your home,” Dr. Lecter said, answering her unasked question. “But we have seen it.”

“Was news of me being taken released? Were pictures leaked?”

Dr. Lecter shook his head. “No. Though I fear we have come to the part of our tale you’re going to dislike.” At the same time, there was something arch in his expression that indicated he was very much going to like telling her about it.

“Already?” Clarice almost laughed. “I can’t imagine what I could like less than being abducted.”

The corners of his mouth turned up. “I’ve spoken to Ardelia.”

Clarice’s blood ran cold. For a moment, she couldn’t even process all the things his words could mean. She only felt horror. “What?” she finally managed to get out.

He smirked, then continued. “She had quite unexpected things to say. Would it surprise you to know that the main suspect in your abduction was me?”

“Yes.” Clarice felt like she’d more than lost the thread of the conversation. Also, she was still stuck on the fact that Dr. Lecter knew who Ardelia was. “Why did they think that?”

Will spoke. “Because of circumstantial evidence at the scene. And a lack of evidence in any other direction.”

“What circumstantial evi—” The question died on her lips, as she flashed back to the conversation she and Ardelia had had in her kitchen, as well as one of the things they talked about—the thing that, at the time, had seemed the least consequential. “The Christmas card,” she said, staring blankly at the fire. “And the flowers.” Both had been sitting on her kitchen counter, and both would have been found by the FBI. “Because they came from you, everyone would have assumed it was connected to me going missing.”

“Not a completely flawed first assumption,” Will commented, “but flawed nonetheless. Also, the flowers weren’t from Hannibal.”

That surprised her. Clarice looked at Dr. Lecter, who nodded in confirmation.

“Really, Clarice,” he said, amusement still evident on his face, “I would hardly send you white lilies.”

“Of course not,” she said dully. “What was I thinking?”

In truth, she hadn’t been thinking about the flowers, certainly not about what kind they were. She had gotten a card followed by flowers, and she had assumed they were from him.

“The killer sent the flowers,” Clarice said. It was obvious now.

Dr. Lecter nodded, then added, “White lilies are common in funeral arrangements.”

It had been a message, and she hadn’t realized it. Would she have if she hadn’t thought the flowers were from Dr. Lecter? She didn’t know. Work had been all consuming, and every single thing in her life had become harried and hectic.

Even if she had thought something was strange about the delivery, she couldn’t imagine suspecting that it would be a precursor to what had actually happened.

“So the FBI thought it was you. How does Ardelia come into this?”

“She had a differing opinion,” Dr. Lecter said, “but no audience willing to listen to it. She seemed quite desperate.”

It took everything Clarice had to keep her tone light when she said, “And you enjoy desperation.”

His eyes glittered darkly. “Just so.”

Clarice hadn’t anticipated this conversation being tense, but until she knew how Ardelia was involved with them she couldn’t shake her uneasiness. Yet if she came right out and demanded to know exactly what happened with Ardelia, she suspected Dr. Lecter was only going to be more entertained than he already was. The conversation itself was half the point.

She resigned herself to a circuitous route instead of a direct one, and used the opportunity to take another drink.

“An unusual message on the Tattle Crime forums caught my eye,” Dr. Lecter said. “It asked for a favor, and had nothing but a phone number and a picture of the necklace I sent you, which I could hardly fail to recognize.”

“You thought I wrote it.”

“Naturally. I assumed you had contacted me perhaps hoping you could leverage my favor into helping you save someone else. I was prepared for a diverting conversation and an interesting exchange. Imagine my surprise.”

A small part of Clarice was astonished that he had seen what looked like a message from her and had immediately responded to it. She knew taking promises seriously was part of his pathology, but she was still somewhat surprised by the fact that he placed her in such importance after all this time.

“Unlike the FBI,” Will said, “Ardelia was familiar with all the details of what happened in Minnesota. She was at the end of her rope, and we were her last resort. She hoped that we would notice some overlooked element of your disappearance, something we could give her as a lead.”

“Which you obviously did,” Clarice said.

Will regarded her evenly. “Yes and no. We found a lead, but we didn’t give it to her.”

“What did you tell her?”

“Nothing,” he said without concern. “We never called her back.”

Dr. Lecter caught her gaze. “I would not pass up the chance to see you myself, Clarice. And I’m not in the habit of giving my whereabouts to the FBI.”

She wanted to protest that they could have at least let Ardelia know they had figured out where Clarice was, but she knew it would fall on deaf ears. Neither of them had any obligation to Ardelia; neither of them cared that Ardelia probably thought Clarice was dead by now. If anything, Dr. Lecter was probably relishing the uncertainty he’d left Ardelia in.

They had used Ardelia and discarded her without a care. After only the briefest consideration, Clarice decided that she was fine with that actually, as long as it kept Ardelia alive. It was the best outcome possible. She just needed to ensure that it remained that way.

“It had to be dangerous to talk to her at all,” Clarice said, “given the fact that you were the FBI’s main suspect.”

“And what is life without a little danger?” Dr. Lecter countered. “After the initial phone call where you were claimed to be missing, I was intrigued, yet couldn’t dismiss the possibility of a ruse.”

Will spoke, picking up where Dr. Lecter left off. “We both felt that you were unlikely to use yourself as bait in this particular way, trading on Hannibal’s esteem for you. But we also couldn’t reject it entirely. So I requested a walkthrough via camera of the site of the abduction.” He brought his hands together. “I saw three possibilities. One, someone at the FBI came by the information about your history with Hannibal and tried to bend it to their own use, and they would cry off with excuses about your house being inaccessible. Two, you were in on it, and would know that I would want to see the scene, in which case I was curious what story you would try to tell. Three, you really were abducted, and your house would tell its own story. If your friend had gone so rogue as to contact the lead suspect in an investigation about said investigation, she would be unlikely to back down at breaking and entering a crime scene, even if that meant being charged.”

Clarice digested all of that. She couldn’t find fault with Will’s insights. He was also correct that it had never occurred to her to use her connection with Dr. Lecter to try to draw him out. Even now as she considered it, it felt shameful somehow to pretend to be in danger as a lure for the FBI to catch him. And the practical side of her noted that had she done so, he would have considered it a truly egregious betrayal, in a way that he wouldn’t if she arrested him under other circumstances.

She belatedly realized that when Dr. Lecter had said earlier that he’d seen her home, he hadn’t merely seen pictures, but had probably seen every inch of it. Clarice was never particular about housekeeping, but some small part of her disliked the fact that he had seen it now when it was nothing but evidence of her falling apart life.

Then she got over it. If he hadn’t seen it, she would be dead.

“Obviously my house told you something,” she said.

“It did.” Will nodded. “My impression on viewing the scene was that you really had been taken. A story that had been created would want to lead me to a particular conclusion, which would in turn lead me to our arrest. But I saw no narrative at your house, only forms that had yet to solidify into shape. The struggle in the entryway looked genuine. And there were details that seemed too incongruous to be planted. Take the flowers, for instance,” he said, waving a hand. “If you had constructed the scene, why send yourself extra flowers and say they were from us when the card was already there and would have provided enough cause to say the FBI was looking in our direction? It would be one detail too many, an unstable variable to the equation. The simplest answer is that they were real, and everyone thought they were from us, including you. Then there was the message on the wall.”

“What message?”

“In your entryway, he wrote ‘I took what was owed’ in marker. While not definitive, the word ‘owed’ suggests a history or a prior relationship. It would be harder to construct a fictitious story around a known killer, since if their patterns were truly predictable, they would have been caught. It seemed likely the message was real, though it was still a piece I couldn’t fit into the whole. It wasn’t until long after the call that I saw his complete design.”

Throughout Will’s recitation, Dr. Lecter had been watching her intently. She caught his gaze when Will didn’t immediately continue, and she wasn’t surprised when he spoke next.

“The most likely scenario,” Dr. Lecter said, “seemed to be that you had encountered this person and done them a perceived wrong. I imagine there might be many such individuals over the course of your career, but there are fewer who would be in a position to accomplish what this one did. I’ve followed your career quite closely.”

Clarice smiled in spite of herself. “Yes, I’m aware.”

“I considered your notable cases, but most were easily dismissed. But there was one with curious parallels. You and I even discussed him.” His gaze was dark and sharp and completely focused on her as he continued. “Darryl Bayles. He took young women and buried them alive. He sent their families a note that began with the words ‘I took what I wanted’ announcing their abduction, and after they were dead, he sent a bouquet of lilies with coordinates to the coffin.”

Clarice shook her head in disbelief, a sense of dread building in her as he recited the facts of the case. “Darryl Bayles is in prison.”

“He was in prison,” Will said. “Two months ago, he was killed in a fight with another inmate.”

“But then—” she stammered. The conclusion she thought they were leading up to was abruptly swept out from under her. She frowned. “A copycat?”

“Or an accomplice,” Will said. “What do you remember about the case?”

“Most of it.” It had been a dozen years ago, but it was one of the higher profile cases she’d been involved in.

“When you caught Darryl and sent him to prison, he was twenty-three. He had a younger brother, Wade, who was seventeen at the time.”

Clarice nodded. “Wade wasn’t charged. He was a minor, and there wasn’t any evidence that he was complicit in his brother’s crimes. And Darryl confessed to all of it.”

“There might not have been evidence, but there were questions.”

“Even though Darryl Bayles was dead,” Dr. Lecter said, “we looked deeper into the original case. It seemed likely there was a motive for abducting you with such similar calling cards so shortly after his death.”

“The brothers were very close,” Will said. “As children, they were often locked in the cellar together by their abusive mother.”

At the mention of a cellar, Clarice felt a chill wash over her. In the same instant, she saw the case of her own abduction laid out entirely, from beginning to end with crystal clarity. She knew exactly what Will was going to say, and she saw the moment that he saw her put it all together.

“Wade Bayles blamed me for the death of his brother because I was the one who put him in prison,” she said. “And he decided to kill me for it.”

Will nodded. “Prosecutors in the original case looked at Wade, but ultimately dismissed him. In retrospect, Wade was likely involved in his brother’s crimes, even if he didn’t participate directly. At the very least, Darryl shared everything with him and found a willing and interested audience, perhaps one that would have joined him had he not been caught. When Darryl was arrested, Wade didn’t turn in the older brother that he idolized, and the older brother protected the younger as he had been doing his entire life.”

“Given the slight differences of the message and the lilies,” Dr. Lecter said, “Wade did not set out to duplicate his brother’s crimes, but he took inspiration from them and wanted to pay homage as he crafted his first tableau.”

“Lucky for me,” Clarice said. Her tone was dry, but the sentiment was serious. A cellar was preferable to a coffin.

She felt Dr. Lecter watching her again. When she looked up, he asked,

“Did you interact with him when you awakened?”

“No,” Clarice said. Then she exhaled. She didn’t particularly want to talk about this part, but she knew he would, so she went with a bare bones narration of facts. “Like I said, I woke up in the trunk of a car. I was tied up and my mouth was taped, so there was nothing I could do. I pretended to be unconscious when he carried me into the cellar. He cut the ties on my hands and feet when he put me down, and that’s when I saw my chance. I kicked him and bolted for the ladder, but I was still moving too slowly. We struggled and he threw me off. He went up the ladder and locked the cellar doors. I tried to talk to him through them several times. It was the usual sort of negotiation tactics we’re trained in,” she said, glancing at Will, “to establish rapport, to feel out information. He never replied once.”

“He cut your bonds because he wanted you to experience exactly what he did in the cellar,” Will said, his voice and his eyes distant. “To know that you were trapped and there was nothing you could do about it.”

“Yes,” she said, suddenly feeling exhausted.

“But he didn’t care if you knew why you were there or not. Your ignorance might have even been part of the appeal. All he wanted you to know is that you were going to die there.”

“Yes,” she said again.

Will’s gaze slipped back into focus. “Your abduction was planned with an orchestration the original murders lacked. Wade wasn’t young and rash, but methodical and efficient. And he wanted different things from the experience. I would guess he began making plans within a week of Darryl’s death.”

“It is fortunate Wade Bayles differed from his brother,” Dr. Lecter said, echoing her earlier thoughts. “Because of the initial similarities of the crimes, it seemed like you might already be beyond any reach.”

He meant that if she’d been buried in a coffin, she would have been dead.

Dr. Lecter’s eyes flicked in Will’s direction. It was only the briefest of glances but there was both fondness and pride in his look. “But Will thought otherwise.”

“I wondered if it was Will who actually cracked the case,” Clarice said, “but that seemed rude to say.”

Dr. Lecter gave her a true smile, and then looked toward Will, the smile still on his face. “It’s never rude to compliment my husband.”

Will shook his head, as if in exasperation, but there was the ghost of a smile on his lips.

Somehow they had actually gotten married, despite the fact that they had to be living under assumed names.

Clarice didn’t know what to say. So she said the only thing she could. “Congratulations.”

“Thank you,” Dr. Lecter said, nodding to her.

She noticed neither of them wore rings.

Will saw her looking. “Rings are symbolic. I left symbolism behind long ago.”

Clarice knew he had been married once before, and she wondered if that was what he was referring to. But his first marriage certainly wasn’t any of her business. Also, she didn’t particularly care.

Instead, she looked at Dr. Lecter. “And yet you place a high level of importance on symbolism and ritual.”

“That is true,” he acknowledged. “But traditions may be set aside. The rarest things are worth having in and of themselves.”

“Like the fact that I can’t testify against him,” Will said, sardonic.

One corner of Dr. Lecter’s mouth turned up. “Hardly my first consideration, Will,” he said, catching Will’s gaze again.

Will arched a brow, his smirk an answer to Dr. Lecter’s. “Useful though.”

“Let us hope it is never put to use.”

“It won’t be,” Will said, certainty in his tone. Like it was that easy to declare that they’d never be caught, never be arrested again. Perhaps it was, Clarice thought cynically. They seemed to be doing phenomenally well so far. As if reading her thoughts, Will turned back to her and said, “Hannibal has the Devil’s luck. You do, too.”

Clarice almost protested that she clearly didn’t, but hadn’t she thought just moments ago about how lucky she’d been? Instead, she asked, “Then why can’t I catch you? Either of you?”

“Perhaps it’s more accurate to say that you have the Devil’s luck in conjunction with Hannibal.”

“I suppose I can’t really refute that, given my current circumstances. Everything about us meeting like this is extraordinary.” She had been in the wrong place at the right time, the time the universe had crossed their paths again.

“I’m happy to agree,” Dr. Lecter said.

“After our last meeting, you left the country. I’m surprised you were back here at all.”

“We had an errand to complete.”

“And what was that?”

“Come now, Clarice,” he said. “I would hardly admit such things to an FBI agent.” His eyes were bright and sparked with amusement. “Friends though we are.”

He had obviously committed a crime, and given his history, it was most likely murder. Clarice pressed her lips together in frustration. He wasn’t going to tell her, and there was nothing she could do about it. She didn’t like backing down, but she wasn’t going to pointlessly keep asking. He wasn’t a suspect who would break and confess because she pressed him and repeated the question.

“I’m going to find out later,” she said.

“Of course you will. I never imagined otherwise.”

Clarice gave him a hard stare, which he returned without blinking. She knew there was no point in pursuing the matter, though she closed the door on that topic with resignation. “Fine,” she said, annoyance coloring her voice.

Dr. Lecter showed no signs of displeasure. If anything, he was enjoying her reaction.

Clarice paused to take a drink, and then returned to the previous thread of the conversation. “You hadn’t finished telling me about Wade Bayles.” She looked at Will. “How did you know he hadn’t put me in a coffin?”

“Darryl buried the girls remarkably close to their homes, in order to devastate the families further with how near they were the whole time. But your car was found almost sixty miles north of Quantico. It’s possible Wade changed direction after abandoning your car, but continuing on seemed more likely. Especially as that highway would be on the route to his childhood home in Pennsylvania.”

Clarice’s breath caught. Wade had put her in a cellar as he had been put in a cellar, but she hadn’t imagined it was actually the cellar.

“The house itself burned down several years ago,” Will said. “Wade’s mother, the sole resident, was killed. Wade was never a suspect—he was on a three month long construction job as site manager in Tennessee at the time, and investigations ruled that the cause of the fire was a cigarette. Wade inherited the property, but never rebuilt it, despite having the skills to do so himself. The lot has sat abandoned since. The cellar, of course, is still intact.” Will held her gaze, his eyes intense but his voice detached as he continued. “I saw his design of reverence and revenge. He took inspiration from his brother and sought to honor him. He wanted to punish you for Darryl’s death, in the very place that he and Darryl forged their childhood bond. You would die where he and his brother were metaphorically born. That was his design.”

Silence fell after his pronouncement, the only sounds in the room being those that came from the fire.

Clarice herself was struck speechless. She had watched Will pull answers out of the air before, drawing conclusions that only he could see. She had heard him recite facts in that dead flat voice as he reconstructed something. The way his mind accurately leapt from one conclusion to another with only the barest evidence and impressions remained astounding. But having him narrate her own account left her unmoored.

She’d thought that Will had most likely been the one responsible for actually finding her, but only now was she struck with the full force of what part he’d played in saving her life. Dr. Lecter was the one who had an interest in her, and his interest had all but guaranteed Will’s involvement. She certainly wasn’t discounting Dr. Lecter’s own insights, particularly regarding his knowledge of her past cases, but she knew that if it weren’t for Will Graham she wouldn’t be sitting here.

She was aware that she was still staring at him.

Clarice blinked, coming back to herself. Then she said, “I thanked him, but I never thanked you. Thank you. For everything.”

Will inclined his head. “You’re welcome.”

There was another moment of silence, before Dr. Lecter broke it.

“The rest,” he said, “I’m sure you can surmise. You were still well within the timeframe for surviving dehydration, and while we of course didn’t know for certain what we would find at the Bayles property, we prepared accordingly.”

“I also suspected Wade might be visiting the site,” Will said. “The temptation to experience what he had done would be too much to resist. The area was rural and deserted; he wouldn’t need to worry about being seen.”

“And he was there,” Clarice said.

“Yes.” Something dark and satisfied flickered over Will’s face. “His endeavors were undone in a single moment. He did not foresee us.”

“Who would,” Clarice said, almost to herself.

“You would, perhaps,” Dr. Lecter said. “But few others.”

There was undoubtedly some commentary to make about being saved from a would-be murderer by serial killers, but at the moment, Clarice had no idea what it was. She couldn’t help but feel incredibly grateful to both Dr. Lecter and Will, and part of her resented the fact that she now had such warm feelings towards them. The semi-professional arm’s length she had held them at for years had utterly evaporated in the last twenty-four hours.

But she couldn’t make herself feel differently, and trying to do so seemed disingenuous.

Clarice had a good understanding of herself, and she could hold two contradictory sentiments in her head at the same time. They were killers who had done unspeakable things. She had a deeply personal connection to them. Both were true, and neither canceled out the other.

“Wade Bayles set out to settle a debt,” Dr. Lecter said, “and ended up being the means to settle one in turn.”

“I wasn’t interested in debt,” Will said.

“What were you interested in?” Clarice asked. It was Will’s life she had saved in Minnesota, yet he hadn’t brought it up once. She doubted he viewed it as Dr. Lecter did, as something to be repaid, but she also suspected that his empathy would have played a role in helping her.

“Hannibal has an interest in you. My interest often follows his, even if it doesn’t correspond completely. I was intrigued, because of you and the mystery surrounding your disappearance. I act because I want to, not because of obligation.”

Still looking at Will, Clarice indicated Dr. Lecter with a nod of her head. “Are you saying he does things out of obligation?”

“Hannibal takes whimsy and masquerades it as obligation.”

Dr. Lecter glanced in Will’s direction, obviously diverted by the turn of the conversation. “Obligations are much more fun if they’re enjoyable to fulfill.”

“You make your own obligations.”

“I also make my own fun.”

Will’s lips quirked upward at that.

“So you see, Clarice,” Dr. Lecter said, “Will and I both follow our natures. Fortunately they lead us to many shared places.”

“You got to return a favor, and Will got to solve a case and hunt a killer.” Then Clarice’s own words registered in her mind. “Wade Bayles wasn’t technically a murderer,” she realized. She had heard them say it before, but only now did she connect that fact to Will killing him. “But you must have killed him. I saw you hacking up the body. You killed someone who wasn’t actually a killer.”

Will gave a minuscule shrug. “He was in the process of killing you.”

“I’m honored that merited an exception to your pattern.” Clarice’s tone was dry, but the profiler in her was suddenly desperately curious. “Or did it? Was he the first person you’ve killed who wasn’t a murderer?”

Will’s smile was cool and didn’t reach his eyes. “I couldn’t say.”

She wondered if he really had expanded his pool of acceptable victims, or if Wade Bayles had simply been close enough that Will didn’t see a material difference.

“I’m not asking you to confess to a murder,” she said. “I’m asking if your priorities have changed.”

“You mistake the distinction as black and white, as if there is no action besides a finger pulling the trigger. Participation is participation.”

“That’s a broad brush if you count intentions and attempts as equivalent to successes.”

Will raised a brow. “I’d say Wade Bayles made quite the attempt, wouldn’t you?”

Clarice couldn’t disagree with that. If she had been there another day or so, Wade Bayles would have been a murderer.

“How do you feel,” Dr. Lecter cut in, “knowing that he’s dead?”

“Relieved.”

“And?” he prompted. “Nothing else?”

Clarice really considered it. She could feel what the answer was; it was there hiding in the darkest corner of her mind. “Part of me is glad,” she admitted.

“Why should you not be glad?”

“Because he should have been brought to justice. But at the same time, I’m glad that he’s gone and can’t ever hurt me, glad I never have to look into his eyes.”

He continued to study her with a quiet intensity. “What did you think while you were in the cellar?”

“Mainly about trying to get out.”

“And how did you feel when you knew you wouldn’t be able to, knowing that you might die there?”

“No,” Clarice said, so abrupt she shocked herself. Dr. Lecter had always been drawn to pursuing painful topics, but this time he had scratched at something too new, too raw. She could feel her jaw clench, but she kept her expression as neutral as possible as she searched for the correct words. In the end she simply said, “No. I’m not discussing with you what it feels like to be a victim.”

Dr. Lecter stared back at her in the silence that followed, his face a mask of peculiar blankness, as if he too were weighing responses.

Then he blinked and the moment passed. “As you like.” Something darkly amused passed over his features as he added, “Though your refusal leaves me to draw my own conclusions.”

“I can live with that.”

Will chuckled. Dr. Lecter’s attention briefly shifted to him, breaking any remaining tension. Though when Dr. Lecter glanced back at her, he still seemed like he was enjoying himself at her expense.

She didn’t care. Dr. Lecter could think whatever he wanted about her mental state.

“Do you still dream about the lambs, Clarice?”

It was an unrelated question on the surface, except for the fact that the lambs had also been a tender subject. He had chosen it to make a point about not discussing the cellar with him. Still, the answer was easy.

“I haven’t dreamed about the lambs in years. Not even after cases that went wrong.”

“And will you dream of them now? After you couldn’t save yourself?”

“Probably not,” Clarice said. She stared at him boldly as the fire crackled between them. “I was saved, after all.”

Something behind his eyes shifted as he held her gaze, and his expression slowly turned to one of unquestionable satisfaction. “You were indeed.”

Chapter 10: Chapter 9

Chapter Text

Clarice went back to bed after their conversation, finding that while she had initially been equal to the task, it had in fact worn her out. She slept for several hours, and when she woke, both the room and the sky outside were dark.

She hadn’t dreamed at all.

She didn’t immediately get up, but instead stared at what she could see of the ceiling. There was the faintest gray light coming from the outline of the window, and a somewhat brighter strip of light coming from under the bedroom door.

Finally, though she would rather stay in bed, the urge to pee became too great and she dragged herself to the bathroom.

When Clarice came out, Will was sitting on the edge of the bed. The bedroom door was closed and the lamp on the nightstand was on.

“Hannibal is asleep,” he said without preamble.

She approached the bed. “Are you sleeping in shifts?”

“Something like that.”

He gestured for her to sit next to him, and she did so.

Will had something in his hand. “This was in Wade Bayles’ pocket. He wanted a memento so he could always revisit his work.”

Will held it up to the light, and Clarice saw that it was a voice recorder. Less than half the size of a cell phone, it was the sort of thing students might use to record lectures.

Clarice felt her stomach drop as she realized that the recorder, though it had been outside the cellar, likely contained everything from her screams for help to her pleas for mercy to her desperate maneuvers to establish a connection.

She stared at the recorder, not meeting his eyes. “Did you listen to it?”

“Long enough to determine it was what I suspected.”

“Did he listen to it?” There was no question of who she meant.

“Hannibal doesn’t know about it.”

Clarice’s head snapped up, and she gaped at him in shock.

Will took her hand, placing the recorder in it and closing her fingers around it. “These words belong to you, not him.”

His expression was solemn but open, and she was struck by the dizzying prospect of being on the receiving end of Will Graham’s empathy.

It had never occurred to her that he would keep the secrets of anyone other than Dr. Lecter, let alone that he would keep secrets from Dr. Lecter.

Clarice clutched the device in her hand, and everything that she had pushed down came rushing back to her. It was all here in this tangible object, every single horrible minute of it. She blinked rapidly, suddenly feeling shaky.

Will made the barest movement—it was something that was almost closer to the precursor of a movement than it was a movement itself. It was an offer if she wanted it; it was nothing if she ignored it.

Her first instinct was to ignore it, but a split second later she changed her mind and swayed towards him. He moved in turn, shifting to envelop her in a hug.

Clarice wrapped her arms around him and tried to focus on taking slow breaths and not crying. She didn’t entirely succeed, as she felt a single tear slide down her cheek.

Somewhat unsurprisingly, Will was good at giving comfort when he chose to be. Holding him should have been awkward, but he made it feel like nothing out of the ordinary. There was steady solace in his touch, an ease that undoubtedly had everything to do with his ability to read her completely.

But she didn’t care.

She was here and she was alive.

After a long moment of the embrace, Clarice dropped her shoulders slightly. Will took the hint and released her, and she let go of him and pulled back.

Clarice still looked down. “I hate that I can’t remember what happened that morning,” she said softly. “Surely there was something I could have done.”

“The way the camera footage was described to me, you had no time to react. But you’ll be able to see it for yourself soon enough.”

There was something she hadn’t considered. She didn’t know whether watching the footage would make her feel better or worse. “I’m an FBI agent—I should have—have known something was wrong.”

Will was silent for a moment. Then he said, “Let’s try a thought experiment.”

Clarice glanced up, meeting his gaze. “All right,” she said dubiously.

“We’re strangers standing in line at the grocery store. You’re standing behind me and haven’t even spoken to me. What reasonable expectation would you have that I’m going to turn around and stab you without a word?”

She sighed, realizing what he was getting at. “None.”

“Yet it’s happened twice. Once in Nevada in 1975, and once in Mississippi in 1982. Nearly identical incidents, but completely unrelated. I used to use the cases as examples of random acts of violence that couldn’t have been predicted by the victim or the bystanders.”

“This wasn’t random.”

“No,” he agreed. “But no one can be prepared for every thing that could possibly happen at every moment. Not you, not me—no one.”

Clarice knew he was right, but that didn’t make it any easier.

She looked again at the voice recorder still clutched in her hand. She didn’t want to talk about it anymore.

Will saw as much and changed the subject entirely.

“When Hannibal and I leave this place,” he said, “he’ll likely leave you with the key to it. Don’t let your sense of duty override your sense. There’s value in having access to a location that’s completely untraceable to you.”

Clarice could admit it wasn’t entirely bad advice given the risks in her line of work, even though her gut reaction to the idea was negative. But she put all of that on a mental back burner. If Dr. Lecter offered her use of the cabin, she would deal with it then.

Instead, she asked, “How long has he had this house? When were you here?”

“Hannibal has had it for longer than I’ve known him. But we came here together after the Red Dragon,” he said. “To hide and heal unhindered, to recover our losses and forge something new. We’ve been here a few other times as well.”

“Why bring me here at all?”

“Because Hannibal wanted privacy. And because after this we’re never coming back.”

She supposed she had expected as much.

Clarice cleared her throat, then said, “I’m starting to be hungry. Is there anything to eat here?”

Will gave her a crooked smile. “There’s Lipton’s instant chicken noodle soup.”

She had a flashback of childhood sick days spent eating that exact thing. “That sounds great, actually,” she said. And it was far from something she could imagine Dr. Lecter eating. “Did you pick that up with the Gatorade?”

“I stopped at a gas station grocery store. Hannibal was appalled,” he said dryly. Then he stood up. “I’ll fix the soup. Come in when you’re ready.”

Will left the door cracked, and after a moment more, Clarice decided there wasn’t a reason not to go into the other room. She quickly stashed the voice recorder in the pile of her folded up dirty clothes under the bed.

She found Will in the kitchen and Dr. Lecter asleep on the sofa. Clarice briefly paused to look at him. His arms were crossed over his stomach, and his chest rose with regular deep breaths. His face was completely relaxed, and it struck her as strange to see him void of any expression, strange to see him not in complete control of the situation.

She didn’t get very close; something told her he had a violent startle reflex.

Clarice sat down at the table, which was small but in a farmhouse style, with benches on either side instead of chairs. There was a package of Gatorade bottles on the kitchen counter, as well as a plastic bag with a small case of shrink wrapped water bottles. Clarice got to her feet again to get one of the waters.

She noticed another plastic shopping bag to the side of them. Inside were three boxes of Lipton’s and two packages of fruit cups. Will’s gas station grocery purchases. Food for her, that he’d been hopeful of her needing if they found her alive. She briefly wondered how they expected her to get back to civilization since they were leaving tonight, but she also assumed they would get to that.

Will was heating water on the stove. Clarice went back to the table. She leaned her elbow on it and rested her head against her hand. The bench she sat on was nearest to the wall, though the wall wasn’t close enough to lean back on. She sat facing the kitchen, with the living room to her side.

The soup was done quickly, and Will set the bowl in front of her. Since Dr. Lecter was not awake to critique her table manners, she blew on the spoonfuls just like she had as a child. Will washed the saucepan in the sink.

The noises from the kitchen, slight though they were, roused Dr. Lecter. He greeted her, excused himself to the restroom, and returned just as she was about halfway done with the bowl.

After he tended to the fire, Dr. Lecter sat at the table on the bench across from her. Will had retreated to lean against the kitchen cabinets, opening a bottle of water for himself.

Clarice didn’t miss the slight way Dr. Lecter’s lip curled as he looked at her out-of-a-package meal.

“I wish I could have cooked for you properly,” he said.

“Could you have cooked for me properly?” Clarice asked, her tone leaving no doubt as to what she meant by ‘properly.’

Dr. Lecter looked briefly contemplative, as if he had to give it serious thought. He drummed his fingers once on the table, and then said, “I suppose we’ll never know.”

Clarice ate more of the soup.

After a few moments, she said, “I finished a profile of you, after the last time we met.”

His eyes sparked with interest, as she had known they would. “And what did you conclude?”

Clarice collected her thoughts. It had been years since she’d written her profile, but she knew the shape of it inside and out, and now she had even more support for it. She finished off another few spoonfuls of soup, with the last of the noodles, and then said, “Everyone gets hung up on the cannibalism. It’s showy in a way, and people have a visceral reaction to it. But at its core, cannibalism is an act of dominance.”

“I don’t disagree.”

“I would argue that cannibalism isn’t the defining characteristic of your pathology. I think your defining characteristic is that you go to extraordinary lengths to give people what you think they deserve. You said before that you kill those you deem deserving, but that’s not particularly notable. Many killers believe their victims deserve it for some reason or other. Where you differ is how far you go to achieve that end—or any end that you want.” She waved a hand between them. “Like this one, like me sitting here right now. It’s what you think I deserve, and look at the effort you’ve put in to give it to me.”

One corner of his mouth turned up. “Your experiences have informed your approach to a profile.”

She wondered if he remembered that he had more or less given her that advice. Based on his expression, she assumed he did.

Clarice nodded. “They complete the picture in a way that focusing solely on your murders doesn’t. My experiences with you are unique. At first, I thought they were so unique that I couldn’t fit them into everything else I knew. Then I realized that while they were the inverse of the usual picture, that didn’t make them untrue. It just made them a reflection, and reflections can reveal.”

Dr. Lecter was still watching her, intently interested in her analysis of him. “And what revelations did you find?”

“I stopped treating the fact that you hadn’t killed me like an anomaly, and instead asked what it said about your motivations. You made considerable efforts to arrange time for conversations with me, both in Belvedere and Minnesota. You made a genuine offer to save my life, which I took seriously, though I never imagined it actually playing out. I may have saved Will’s life, but it was the action of an instant. Whereas you’ve gone to considerable effort—a decade later—to repay what was, in essence, a fortuitous accident.

“In general,” she continued, “you find people’s actions more important than their intentions. I’m sure most of the people you killed didn’t set out to anger you, but their actions marked them nevertheless. Likewise, you went to extraordinary efforts both to abduct your victims and to stage elaborate crime scenes. While all of your victims can be assumed to have crossed you in some way, there were over a dozen from your time in Baltimore as the Chesapeake Ripper where the original connection to you couldn’t be found. You may have waited years in some cases to kill them. You have tremendous patience and it doesn’t wane with time. That’s why the lengths you go to is what I think defines your pathology.”

His eyes hadn’t left hers while she’d spoken, and his expression had only brightened into a look of genuine delight as she had continued. Doubtless it pleased his egotistical streak to hear his mind dissected, whether it was correctly or incorrectly done.

Though the small egotistical part of Clarice wanted it to be correct. She folded her hands. “And that’s my profile of you.”

Dr. Lecter smiled and said, “It seems you have gained understanding.”

“Does that mean I’m right?” she asked with a smile of her own.

“I can find nothing to refute, which must be a success in its own right.”

It was an indirect answer, but she could read between the lines. Even if Dr. Lecter didn’t view himself exactly the way she’d just presented him, the fact that he wasn’t offended was confirmation enough that she wasn’t entirely off base.

Still, Clarice glanced at Will. “And what do you think?” she asked bluntly.

Will raised his water bottle to her in a faux toast. “You say extraordinary. I say never underestimate how far Hannibal will go to fulfill his sense of the dramatic.”

Dr. Lecter didn’t turn to look at Will, but his eyes crinkled at the corners. “Why spend time on things we do not enjoy? Anything worth doing should be done with devotion and dedication.” He caught her gaze again. “Wouldn’t you agree?”

Clarice could hardly agree that murder was something time should be devoted to. But this time, his total commitment to his chosen task had done nothing but serve her well. “I agree that your dedication has benefited me, and I’m grateful for it.”

The smile remained on his face at her answer. “Shall I tell you a secret?” he asked her, tilting his head. “Would you like to know how I kept track of those I meant to kill?”

Clarice was thrown by the question, but she nodded all the same.

“I took their business card and put it in my Rolodex. When I killed them, I removed the card.”

It was such a simple, yet elegant solution. A kill list hidden in plain sight as a collection of business contacts. Clarice couldn’t remember a Rolodex being mentioned in the manifests of evidence the FBI had seized, but a Rolodex was hardly a notable object, compared to what had been found in his basement and freezer. Perhaps it was in FBI storage, or perhaps it was still sitting in his home or office collecting dust.

But ultimately, it ceased to matter. There was nothing to be gained from dragging out a list of people who never knew they were once marked for death.

“You were very careful,” Clarice said. “You got away with it for years.”

His eyes glittered and he gave her a rare sharp grin. “I still get away with it.”

“I suppose that’s true. But people know who you are now, and they didn’t then.”

“That is also true. Nothing lasts forever, but I would not have it do so.” Then, swinging the topic in another direction entirely, he asked, “Have you killed anyone since we spoke last?”

Clarice was unsurprised at the question. “No. Have you?”

“Of course.”

She had known what his answer would be, but she hadn’t been able to resist asking. It was a strange sort of banter that she had finally mastered the rhythm of, that she was confident enough to engage in.

“No,” Clarice repeated thoughtfully, “the only two people I’ve killed in the line of duty remain Jame Gumb and Charlie Benton.”

“Perhaps someday you will have more,” Dr. Lecter said, as if it were something to aspire to.

“Perhaps,” Clarice said, noncommittal. “And perhaps not. My deadly force encounters were somewhat unique, for reasons we’ve discussed before.”

Dr. Lecter glanced sideways at Will, who was watching the exchange, but who didn’t comment.

“If circumstance forces your hand,” Dr. Lecter asked, “would it be different than Will doing it?”

“I won’t ever know unless that happens. But you’re correct that the end result would be the same. It’s a result I try to avoid.”

“You prefer to apprehend suspects alive, both because of your morals and because you want them to answer for their crimes.”

“Yes.”

“Just as you want to apprehend me because of my crimes.”

“Yes.”

“And how would you feel if you did so?”

It was strange that she had never actually considered it. She had always thought of his theoretical arrest as the goal, the end to his murders, the conclusion of a long and hard investigation. She had assumed she herself would play a large part in the investigation, but she had never thought of herself beyond that point. He needed to be caught and it was her job to catch him—that was where her considerations ended.

“I would feel satisfied,” she said slowly, “that I was successful at my duty. I would feel good that I had saved future lives.”

Dr. Lecter seemed as if he had anticipated such an answer. Then he asked, “Would you feel conflicted about arresting me? After the service I’ve done you?”

Clarice’s first reaction was to say no, but his words made her re-examine her thoughts. And she found a very small part of her that wouldn’t be able to fully relish catching him. It wasn’t large enough to be called conflict or regret, though it existed all the same.

But now that she was aware of it, it no longer had the potential to surprise her.

“I do feel a sense of obligation to you,” she said, “but my duties and my responsibilities are to others. My gratitude won’t prevent me from doing my job.”

A smile played about the corner of his mouth. “You would not be nearly as interesting if it did.” Then in a teasing tone he asked, “Do you never do anything solely for yourself, Clarice?”

“If I did, it wouldn’t be letting you go,” she responded in kind. “I trust you won’t hold that against me.”

“Do you?”

Clarice was thrown. “Do I what?”

“Do you trust me?” he asked.

She had simply said it as a turn of phrase, but now he was actually asking and expecting an answer.

“In what way?” she said.

“It’s a yes or no question.”

“Nothing with you is a simple yes or no question.” With this question in particular, there were too many possibilities to take into account.

He merely stared at her in response, a look of easy interest on his face, as he waited for her to properly reply.

Clarice reflected on an answer. Regarding herself at least, she found one. For the last day, she’d been dependent on him, and was unconcerned with being so. That was a definition of trust, even if it wasn’t entirely complete.

“Most would consider it stupid to trust you,” Clarice said, arching a brow as she held his gaze. “I would hardly admit to my own stupidity.”

His face barely changed at her unspoken answer, but there was no mistaking the pleasure in his eyes. “Would you not? It sounds intriguing.”

She should have known he wouldn’t be satisfied with a yes or no, not even an oblique one. He would want to hear her reasoning.

“I trust that I understand you,” Clarice said.

“That is trust in yourself. Quite a different thing.”

“I trust that our conversations have been genuine,” she countered, “allowing me to draw accurate conclusions.” She paused, then added, “Like the one that I drew when I saw you in the cellar.”

“And what was that?”

“I knew you would help me.”

Dr. Lecter’s lips turned up in a slow smile, and there was satisfaction on his face. “Why call that stupidity?” he asked. “You were correct.”

“Because you’re dangerous,” she said, telling him what he already knew. “Because of the obvious risk in trusting you.”

“A risk you calculated without error.”

“Yes. Because I trust that I know where I stand with you, Hannibal.” As Clarice spoke, she realized this was the opening she’d been waiting for. “And I need you to promise me something.”

If Dr. Lecter’s full attention hadn’t already been on her, it was now. He leaned forward slightly, his hands clasped on the table.

“I want to know that you’re not going to hurt Ardelia.”

He paused, tilting his head as if in contemplation and surprise. “What reason would I have to do so?”

“None that I can see. But I wasn’t privy to your conversation. She could have offended you.” Clarice regarded him steadily, her own expression open. “Will you promise that you’re finished with her?”

She’d briefly thought about trying to word it differently, to specify and stipulate. But such an effort would be an insult to them both. He would either do it or not because she asked—not because she found the perfect words to seal him in an unimpeachable bargain. And while she knew from what Will had said about them leaving that it would be unlikely for Dr. Lecter to come anywhere near Ardelia, she would rather have it from him that he wouldn’t, than to assume that sheer logistics were enough to keep Ardelia safe.

Dr. Lecter studied her closely, and nothing in his stare seemed to change. The blackness of his eyes was unreadable now, but she didn’t look away.

After another moment, the intensity of his expression shifted, and he gave a single nod. “I will promise,” he said solemnly, “because you asked me.”

“Thank you,” Clarice said.

Then he said, “Perhaps you will promise me something in return.”

Clarice was skeptical, but she kept an open mind. “I might. But not until I know what it is.”

“If I am ever apprehended, promise that you will come and visit me, and continue our conversation.”

She was astounded by the request, and she was certain it showed. “Do you anticipate being caught?”

“Not at all. But if I am, I would like the assurance of good company,” he said, in much the same congenial tone she imagined he would have used to invite her to a party he was hosting.

Clarice thought about all sides of the question, from the optics and access, to the personal. Despite all that she had come to terms with about her strange connection to Dr. Lecter, she was still surprised that her gut reaction wasn’t refusal. Refusal should be the answer, but perhaps it couldn’t be her answer, not now, not anymore.

“I would visit you,” she said. “You have my promise.”

He nodded his head to her in acknowledgment.

Then he folded his hands and said, “And yet, I feel that our conversation will end here, and that this will be the last time we speak.” There was a beat of silence, and then he said, “Will and I will be leaving shortly. There are some practical matters we should discuss.” With that, he stood, and went to retrieve something from the living room.

Will moved towards the table and took her empty bowl, going to wash it in the sink.

Dr. Lecter sat back down across from her, a piece of paper in his hand. He passed it to her, and she quickly skimmed it, seeing several phone numbers and an address.

“The first number is for this phone,” he said, briefly pulling a cell phone out of his pocket. “It has been activated, but never used. I shall mail it to you at this address, and then you may call whomever you please. This is the address of the house.”

Clarice looked at the paper again. So she was in upstate Maine right now.

“And the other two numbers?” she asked.

“Of course you will tell the FBI whatever you wish about the last few days. But if you choose to be circumspect, you might make use of these. The second number is the presumable burner phone Ardelia used to contact us. The third number is for a local service that provides rides county-wide for a minimal fee. They still accept cash because they cater primarily to seniors who need to get to stores or medical appointments, but anyone may use their services.”

Clarice glanced at the second number. It was definitely a burner phone, because that was not Ardelia’s number. Clarice had no idea what she was going to say to the FBI about the more personal aspects of Dr. Lecter’s involvement in this—she hadn’t gotten that far yet. But she could appreciate that being found at Dr. Lecter’s secret cabin might not be ideal. Obviously she wouldn’t leave out his involvement, but she wasn’t sure she was prepared to get into why he brought her here specifically.

Clarice nodded, both to him and herself.

“You may bring the FBI here or not, as you choose,” he said. “But since you know of this place, Will and I will certainly never return here again.” He slid a key without a ring to the middle of the table. “I trust you’ll lock up when you leave.”

Clarice eyed the key, remembering what Will had said earlier. “And then what?” she asked. “You haven’t been here in years, but someone has been taking care of the house. It would be in terrible shape if it had truly been left to sit.”

“A property management company is paid to maintain this as a vacation home—a different one than that which oversees my properties in Maryland,” he added. She had already assumed that, since if this property were owned under his legal name, all it would take to locate it would be a simple public records search. “They do maintenance and utility checks, and will continue to do so. When I lived in Baltimore, I came here several times a year to manage such things myself. During that period, I kept supplies fully stocked, in case I was ever discovered and needed to disappear.”

“And you’ve kept the house until now for obvious reasons. Even if you weren’t planning to come back, it would be a useful last resort.”

“It is still a useful last resort, even if not for myself.” His gaze flicked to the key on the table, before his eyes met hers again. One corner of his mouth turned up, and he leaned forward slightly and whispered to her conspiratorially. “You could use it. I won’t even make you ask.”

Clarice didn’t move. “And what do you get out of it if I don’t ask?”

She had realized that regardless of whether his assistance had been helpful or detrimental to a person, he wanted them to ask for it, if only for the gratification of knowing that whatever occurred, they brought it on themselves.

Will came to stand by the end of the table. “He gets to see a single chink in the armor of your morality,” he said dryly. He looked down at Dr. Lecter. “A negligible success after nearly fourteen years.”

Dr. Lecter grinned, glancing between them. “But a remarkable one after a mere twenty-four hours of conversation.”

“Why not sell this place?” Clarice countered. “Why not sell all of your U.S. properties? You have both the house and the office in Baltimore.”

“Because I have no reason to do so,” Dr. Lecter said simply.

Clarice could wrap her mind around many concepts that she had no personal experience with; her successful career at the FBI attested to that. But the part of her that had grown up poor still couldn’t fathom what it was like to be so wealthy that you could abandon multi-million dollar properties without a second thought.

“There was another house, once,” he continued. “The site where we confronted the Red Dragon. Eight years ago the cliff collapsed entirely, casting everything into the sea below. Not a trace of the house or my time there remains.”

“And you find something fitting in that.”

“Eventually, everything we leave behind turns to dust. Some things simply take longer than others.”

“I visited your office,” Clarice blurted, “several years ago.”

She had surprised him, she could tell. While related to the subject of properties, her statement was something of a non-sequitur, and probably the last thing he’d expected her to say.

“Did you indeed?” he asked. “What were you hoping to find?”

“Nothing,” she said. “I went because I was curious. Crawford gave me a set of keys and I decided to use them.”

“And what did you find?”

“I found a place that was far from turning to dust. Besides the plastic coverings, everything was left just as it was. Like you had just stepped out.” Clarice paused, and then continued. “It was a space that felt wholly yours. I could see you there, see you both there.”

Despite all the times she had spoken with Dr. Lecter, she had never been in a space that was his until she’d gone to the office. It had given her more context in a way, a view she hadn’t been in a position to see.

“You saw a glimpse of things that once were,” Dr. Lecter said.

Clarice nodded. “It was like walking into the past. But in a way it felt incredibly present, like time had stopped there.”

“And yet time never stops. Sometimes it merely slows enough for us to see it like a mirage behind us.”

“Is that what you would see, if you went there again? A mirage?”

“Perhaps. The past is a vivid thing, but one cannot live life to its fullest by attempting to remain there. I can never return to such places, but that is the way life moves.”

Will spoke. “The list of places we can never return continues to grow.”

“So it does,” Dr. Lecter said, amusement in his voice. He looked back at her, one corner of his mouth turning up. “But I am gratified to hear of your visit.”

“You like that I was curious enough to go.”

“Of course. I would not have predicted it.”

Clarice almost smiled. “Well, I would hate to be completely predictable.”

“Indeed not,” he said. “Where would be the fun in that?”

In the beat of silence that followed, her eyes again fell to the key on the table. After a moment of hesitation, she slid her hand to cover it. “I’ll take the key,” she said, “but I make no promises about what I’ll do with it.”

“You leave me in suspense, Clarice,” he chided.

“I leave myself in suspense. Because even I don’t know what I’ll decide. You’ve given me a moral quandary.”

“His favorite kind,” Will commented.

“Is it immoral,” Dr. Lecter asked, “to accept assistance when no other alternative is available?”

“I’ve accepted your help here and now, and I feel no conflict about that. But it would be another thing entirely for an FBI agent to plan to use assets that belong to a serial killer on the FBI’s wanted list. I think you can appreciate the difference.”

His eyes were dark with interest. “And yet you do not say no outright.”

“I don’t,” she admitted. “Because I also now know what it’s like to be targeted. Will has already pointed out to me the value in keeping the key, and on a purely strategic level, I don’t disagree with him. But I still have to give the decision the full deliberation it deserves.”

“I would never object to being in your thoughts.”

“Then that will have to be satisfaction enough for you,” Clarice said with a half-smile.

“Then so it must be.” Dr. Lecter smiled in turn. “It was satisfying to meet you again.”

“Likewise,” Clarice said, surprising herself. “And not just because you saved my life.”

She had wondered what it would be like to speak to him again, and now she knew.

“Our conversation has evolved,” he observed.

“Each time it changes as our understanding changes.” Or perhaps, as her understanding changed. She was far from the nervous trainee trying to prove herself that she’d been so many years ago. Though she was struck by the stray thought that he hadn’t changed much at all. Dr. Lecter had been secure in who he was and how he moved in the world long before she had ever known him.

But she understood him, a thing that she had only realized at the very end of their last meeting. This was the first time that they had met without some large or small part of her being wary.

“As it should,” Dr. Lecter said. “Understanding shapes how we move through the world.” He paused, and then said, “We have discussed the past and the present, even the potential future. Does anything remain to be said?”

“I imagine you could always find something to discuss.”

His eyes twinkled at that. “I imagine I could. But our time here grows short, and the most pertinent and intriguing topics have been brought forward. Unless you think otherwise.”

Clarice considered it. “I don’t suppose that I do.”

“Then we shall leave it here, and Will and I shall prepare to leave.”

With that, he stood.

Clarice stood as well. Dr. Lecter disappeared into the bedroom, and Will collected a small leather bag that had been sitting to one side of the cabinets that she hadn’t noticed before. She raised an eyebrow in question.

To her surprise, Will brought the bag over to her.

“You’re welcome to anything inside,” he said, “though there’s not much left.”

The bag was rectangular, and when she lifted the open zip flap, she saw that the bag was basically a fancy lunchbox with a shoulder strap option. There were six sticks of jerky from a premium Argentinian beef importer, a glass jar half full of deluxe dry roasted nuts, two oranges, an apple, and five pieces of one ounce dark chocolate that contained 85% cocoa.

Clarice was surprised that she hadn’t once wondered what Will and Dr. Lecter were or were not eating, after Will had assured her that there wasn’t any human flesh on offer. She supposed her excuse had to be that she’d had other things on her mind. But of course they must have eaten something—they’d been with her for the better part of a day, since they’d found her last night. And she had no idea how long they had been traveling before that.

She briefly pondered the contents of the bag. Both the jerky and the nuts sounded unappetizing and entirely too heavy. But she took the fruit, along with three pieces of chocolate, and set them on the counter with her other food. On second thought, she took the nuts as well.

When she turned back around, Will had his wallet out. Clarice watched dumbly as he counted out four hundred dollars: three one hundred dollar bills and five twenties. He held it out to her.

“What’s that for?” she asked.

“Options. If you need to pay for a ride, a bus ticket, a motel room, then you can.”

Clarice hated taking his money, but she knew it was irrational not to do so. She still didn’t know exactly what she was going to decide, but it was either bring the FBI here, or be away from here before she contacted the FBI. And the latter option wasn’t going to be free.

She thanked him and took it, setting it on the counter as well.

“If you use the local transport to get to town,” Will said, “you can give them whatever name you want. They have no reason to ask for ID.”

Clarice smiled in spite of herself. “You’ve done this before.”

“A few times. Long ago.”

Dr. Lecter came out of the bedroom, pulling the suitcase behind him and carrying two coats.

Will picked up the bag with their food, and moved to join him in the living room. He took one of the coats and put it on. Clarice trailed after him as Dr. Lecter donned his own coat.

And then she was standing there facing them. It was moments from their departure, and she had been here before. Though not quite like this.

“You know,” Clarice said, “this is the first proper leave taking we’ve had. I was somewhat indisposed the other times.” Once, she’d been drugged, the next time, she’d been tied up.

Dr. Lecter’s lips twitched, and she knew he realized to what she referred.

“Fitting perhaps,” he said, “since this is our last farewell. It shall be the truest one.”

“Were the others less true?”

“They were not so at the time, but they do not reflect our current understanding.”

She supposed it was hard for something to feel true when she hadn’t entirely had a choice in participating. Some things remained the same this time, of course—they were walking out and she couldn’t stop them. But other things had irrevocably shifted.

A true parting was this—standing together and saying goodbye because she wanted to say it.

“Thank you again,” she said. She had already said it, but given everything, she felt it was worth repeating. “Both of you.”

Will nodded in acknowledgment.

Dr. Lecter said, “You’re very welcome.”

Clarice met his gaze. “Goodbye, Hannibal.”

“Goodbye, Clarice.”

She said the most honest thing she could. “I will never forget you.”

A genuine smile graced his lips. “Nor I you.”

His eyes were warm but intense as he held her gaze. Then he inclined his head to her, and turned and moved towards the door. Will moved with him, and only a moment later, the two of them walked out into the night.

The door shut with finality.

Clarice locked it behind them.

Chapter 11: Chapter 10

Chapter Text

After Dr. Lecter and Will left, Clarice went to bed.

She slept nearly the entire night, save for the two times she woke to go to the bathroom. It was sometime mid-morning when she got up, and she felt the benefits of a full night’s rest, though she still didn’t feel completely like herself. After coming out of the bedroom, she sat at the kitchen table and drank a bottle of water and ate fruit for breakfast.

Then she moved toward the living room window. She pulled back the curtain and stood and looked at the dense trees of the woods. They were tall and close, and only the most minimal area of forest had been cleared to build the cabin. The ground was still covered in a faint frosting of snow. Not having anything else to do, she drifted into the bedroom and looked out the window there. The view from that window was exactly the same. There was nothing but forest.

Dr. Lecter and Will had come here after they disappeared from the house on the cliff all those years ago, and the fact that they hadn’t been found during the manhunt afterward told her everything she needed to know about exactly how remote a place this was.

Clarice closed the curtain and returned to the living room. There was a neat stack of split logs on one side of the stone fireplace, as well as a bundle of a few smaller sticks. The log that Dr. Lecter had put in the fireplace last night had been large enough to burn almost all night, and while the flames themselves had died out, what remained of the log was still glowing orange. Clarice opened the glass fireplace doors and threw some of the sticks in, followed by three of the smallest pieces of split wood. She arranged them with the poker, and watched as they slowly caught fire. When a good blaze was going, she added a medium sized log and then shut the doors.

She stared blankly at the fire as it burned, losing herself to it for several minutes before she leaned back and sighed. She was suddenly so tired of doing nothing. And yet she had nothing to do.

Clarice, quite literally, had cabin fever.

While her current circumstances were far from dire, she was once again completely alone, and she’d had enough of being alone in the last few days. She had been suitably distracted by Dr. Lecter yesterday, but she once again had nothing but her own thoughts to occupy herself. She had never had a problem with her own company, but right now it felt familiar in an unwanted way.

It was likely that she was going to be here at least another day, maybe two. And she was no longer ill enough that she would be sleeping the time away. Normally when she was feeling a bit under the weather, she would happily watch something while curled up on the sofa or read something light. But of course there was no television here, and no other devices for entertainment. There were two shelves of books in the living room, but a quick perusal of both the fiction and nonfiction titles ruled them out as options. Clarice was feeling better, but Dr. Lecter’s idea of leisure reading material was a far cry from hers. Some of it was something she would have read with interest at work, but all of it was more dense than she currently had the processing power for.

Dismissing the contents of the bookshelf, Clarice instead began slowly exploring the cabin. It was something to do, and she couldn’t deny that she was curious.

She was in no hurry and she took her time. Time was something she had a lot of right now.

Clarice started with the piece of furniture that the books were on. It was the only furniture in the living room besides the sofa, chairs, and the small table that sat between them. It was a piece for both display and storage, with two shelves behind glass for books above, and a cabinet and drawers below. In the cabinet she found a Bose CD player and nearly three dozen CDs. They were all classical or opera, and not particularly to Clarice’s taste, but she pulled out the player anyway and plugged it in. She selected one of the orchestra recordings and put it on, simply for background noise.

The drawers were mostly empty except for some general items like matches, scissors, and pens and pencils. There were two 5”x7” memo pads and a blank sketchbook. Clarice snatched the pads and an ink pen and set them on the table for later, her mood brightening. Writing would definitely occupy her time as well as her mind.

The outside wall of the living room had several doors on it, one of which was a closet and two of which were very large cupboards. All perfectly blended into the woodwork for concealed storage. The closet was nearest the front door and contained two coats, two pairs of boots, an unopened bag of ice melt, and a show shovel. The first cupboard had a two electric space heaters, two propane heaters, a compact propane stove, and two empty five gallon gas containers. There were flashlights and lanterns, a battery operated radio, and new packages of batteries that had expired three years ago. The other cupboard was completely full of tools, everything from screwdrivers and wrenches to outdoor items like axes and saws.

It was everything one would need in a place like this, save for the fuel. Dr. Lecter might have paid for the cabin itself to be maintained, but he had stopped keeping anything perishable in it stocked long ago.

The kitchen was much the same. There was no food in the cabinets, not even old canned goods. The mental image of Dr. Lecter stocking regular canned goods almost made her smile. But if he had come here to lie low, he would’ve had to have shelf-stable supplies that didn’t depend on refrigeration, and he would need enough to last for months if he didn’t want to leave and possibly be seen. As Clarice considered it, she could easily imagine him preparing foods and canning them himself, in addition to stocking dry goods. He knew how to plan meals and could calculate exactly how long how much food would last.

There was a refrigerator, though it wasn’t hooked up. And there was a microwave, which surprised her for some reason, though she supposed he perhaps regarded it as a necessary evil for a kitchen like this. She knew he couldn’t have liked the electric stove and oven, as all chefs preferred the precision of gas cooking. But gas lines might not run this far, if the cabin was truly skirting an area off the grid.

The cabinets held the expected dishes, though fewer of them than she had perhaps imagined. There were exactly three each of saucepans, frying pans, mixing bowls, and baking dishes. One large cutting board. A drawer of silverware and knives, and another of various cooking utensils. With the knives, at least, there was the expected variety and quantity, she thought dryly. Four place settings of plates, bowls, and glasses. Another cabinet held assorted small appliances, including a food processor, plus a metal coffee pot for stove-top brewing. Overall, it was less than she had in her own kitchen, and to someone like Hannibal Lecter, it practically would’ve been roughing it.

Most cabinets were empty, and she assumed all the open space would have been used for food storage. One wall of the kitchen had sliding pocket doors on it, and behind them she found a stackable washer and dryer, an electric hot water heater, basic cleaning supplies, a small laundry basket, and detergent and an iron. Clarice couldn’t even remember the last time she had used her own iron—she couldn’t imagine wanting to iron something in a cabin in the middle of nowhere. She slid the door shut.

But thinking about the utilities earlier had made her curious, and Clarice went to the living room closet and pulled out a coat and a pair of the boots. The boots were hopelessly large, but it wouldn’t matter for simply taking a quick look outside. Key or no key, Clarice wasn’t even going to chance a freak occurrence like the front door jamming behind her, so she left the fire poker across the threshold, keeping the door just slightly ajar.

The front of the cabin had a covered porch that ran the length of it, and plenty of room to stack firewood for the winter. The porch ran halfway around the next side of the house, where it ended in a concrete pad that a generator sat on. It obviously wasn’t running now, but existed as a backup power source. Clarice could also see a well house further out, but she had no idea whether it was currently in use, and she wasn’t so curious that she wanted to tramp around what could only very generously be called a yard looking for a water meter. Whenever the cabin had been built, it had probably been completely off grid, and had been designed to be self-sufficient. Sometime later the fixtures in the bathroom and kitchen had obviously been updated, and the cabin was at the very least on the power grid now. In dire circumstances, the fireplace was a guaranteed source of heat.

Clarice went back inside and sat in the chair by said fire, taking a break and warming up. She ran an appraising eye over the room as she did, considering it in a new light. There was shockingly little décor or personalization. Perhaps that was the point. It didn’t look like Hannibal Lecter lived here; anyone could have lived here. The room was very nice, and it fit into a general category she would define as ‘upscale vacation cabin,’ but she couldn’t say that it felt anything like walking into his office had. Still, this was a space that he had occupied, and he must have enjoyed its aesthetics to some extent. She could see a blurry picture of the two of them here, existing between these close walls as they retreated from the world together.

After resting, she went to the bedroom, the only room she hadn’t investigated. One nightstand contained an old-fashioned windup alarm clock and nothing else; the other was empty. The dresser wasn’t even halfway full, and had the expected folded clothing. Inside the closet she found her own shoes and blazer, but there was nothing else hanging besides a few practical canvas tote bags. On the shelves above the hanging space, however, there were multiple quilts and blankets, and what looked like three separate down comforters. Every shelf was nearly full, which she supposed made sense. Bundling up was the last line of defense against the cold if things went catastrophically wrong.

Silence from the living room made her realize the CD had ended, and she closed the closet doors and drifted back to that part of the house. She selected another CD at random to put on while she fixed a package of soup for herself. Clarice ate slowly, and afterward settled in on the sofa with a memo pad and a large book from the bookshelf. With her knees drawn up, she used the book as a surface to brace the pad against, and she began to write.

Much as she had done after their last two encounters, she committed the entirety of their meeting to paper. She started with the words she and Dr. Lecter had traded after he’d pulled her out of the cellar, and continued from there, recounting every piece of their conversations as accurately as she could.

What she did not write about was the time she spent in the cellar alone. She was perfectly fine with not having a meticulous record of that. There was much of it she would never forget, but as for the details, she was content to let the passage of time take what it would.

Writing the account took all afternoon. She took breaks to rest her hand, to drink something, to stoke the fire, to snack, and once, to take a small nap. At sunset, she set the windup clock to 4:30. The time wasn’t exact, but it was a good estimate for sunset this time of year, and it gave her at least a vague idea of what time it actually was.

After dark, she decided it was time to take that long bath that she hadn’t taken yesterday.

She filled the tub, got a fresh towel, and folded the towel she’d used yesterday to pad the back of the tub. Clarice slipped into the hot water and stretched out, adjusting the towel beneath her neck as she leaned back. She fully intended to have a luxurious soak while she pondered what her next steps were.

She had to determine was what to do about Dr. Lecter’s cabin.

The absolutely correct thing to do was let the FBI know about the cabin, to have the property records investigated and to add the existence of this place to the files on Hannibal Lecter. At the same time, she doubted that anything about this address connected to any other identity he had maintained. He wouldn’t have brought her here if it could lead her straight to wherever he was living now. He had to know she would check, and an investigation would likely lead nowhere, as all past ones had.

But the likelihood of the cabin as a useful piece of evidence wasn’t the real question, of course. The real question was whether she was going to keep the key, and what she intended to do with it.

Clarice didn’t want to keep it. She didn’t want to use something that belonged to him. She didn’t want to feel like she had given in, like he had finally corrupted her somehow.

She also didn’t want to be nearly killed again.

And she would do anything in her power to keep that from happening.

Clarice didn’t know what it said about her that she would feel less guilty about shooting an assailant outright than she would in planning to keep this place a secret. It might have sounded cold, but she didn’t have a moral dilemma over any true kill or be killed situation. She had never felt good about the two lives she had taken, but neither had she felt bad about them. It had been something she’d had to do.

She didn’t have to keep the key.

Having access to place like this wouldn’t have stopped her from being taken this time—a bolthole was only helpful if you knew you were being threatened. On the other hand, she was too pragmatic to dismiss the potential of the cabin outright. As a bolthole, she couldn’t have asked for a better one; no one would ever, ever find her here. Given the high-profile attention she’d had in her career, she wasn’t sure refusing to use something that could potentially save her life was the moral hill she wanted to die on.

She didn’t want to die, and it wouldn’t hurt anyone but her to keep the cabin secret.

Clarice suspected that in the back of her mind, she had known what her decision would probably be, but she’d still had to take the time to weigh all the options and consider things fully. And now she had.

She would keep the key and she would feel guilty about it. But she could live with herself. And she could live with Dr. Lecter likely knowing that he had gotten her to budge in some small way on an issue of morality. She didn’t care. After all, she thought wryly, she was hardly going to vacation here. She would never come here again.

But she was secure in the knowledge that she could.

Decision made, Clarice turned on the tap to add more hot water to the bath, so she could soak for a while longer.

When she got the phone, she would call Ardelia and find out exactly what was going on. She assumed Ardelia was at work like normal, though for all Clarice knew, Ardelia’s unauthorized trespass at the crime scene of her house had been discovered and she had been brought up on disciplinary charges of some sort. It seemed extremely unlikely that the FBI had discovered Ardelia had contacted Dr. Lecter, but Clarice could easily imagine how other things might not be going well.

After she talked to Ardelia, she could better figure out what to do next.

When she was finally tired of sitting in the bath, Clarice washed her hair using one of the travel size shampoos, which felt just as divine as taking a short bath yesterday had. Then she got out and dried off, put the pajamas back on, and re-wrapped her ankle. She had been up and about today, though she had hardly done anything strenuous and she had tried to keep most of her weight off it. As long as she took plenty of time to rest it once she was gone from here, it would be fine.

But taking a bath again brought to mind the problem of her own clothing, which was still filthy. Clarice went into the bedroom and pulled her clothes out from under the bed. Something in her viscerally shuddered at the idea of putting them on. Those were the clothes she’d thought she was going to die in, and she never wanted to wear them again.

But she absolutely was not going to leave this house wearing Will Graham’s pajamas. There was probably something else she could manage to wear in the dresser—there had been pants and several long sleeve shirts—but she knew the most practical thing was to wear her own clothing. She decided she would wash it and then simply get rid of it when all was said and done.

Clarice didn’t trust a washer or dryer that had been sitting for ten years, whether maintenance checks had been done on the house or not. It was too likely that a gasket or hose had cracked in the washer and she would flood the place. But she could use the detergent to hand wash things in the bathtub. She retrieved the detergent from the closet, and began refilling the tub. Then she threw all of her clothing in and left it to soak. Everything she’d been wearing was a dark color, so she wouldn’t be able to tell if it came completely clean, but at least she wouldn’t be leaving dirt everywhere she sat.

That done, she went to the kitchen to fix another bowl of soup. When she was finished eating, Clarice went to sit in front of the fire again. She added another log to it.

Then she looked at the thing she had set on the table before she’d washed her clothes. The voice recorder.

If the FBI had found Bayles themselves, the recorder would be evidence. She supposed it technically still was evidence, evidence of a crime that was already solved, evidence against a perpetrator who would never be prosecuted. In that light, it was remarkable that she felt no guilt over the fact that she was going to destroy it.

She didn’t want to listen to it. She didn’t want anyone else to listen to it. She wanted it not to exist.

Clarice was rational enough to realize that destroying the recorder wouldn’t erase anything that had happened, but keeping the worst moments of her life forever preserved was something that she was simply not going to do. As Will had said, the words were hers, and she got to decide what happened to them.

She got out several different tools from the cupboard. The recorder itself had standard AA batteries, which she removed. After inspecting the rest of the plastic casing, she saw that the recorder was cheap enough that it was not meant to be disassembled. There were no visible screws, but that was easily solved. Clarice hit the case with a hammer hard enough to crack it apart, and then pried it open with a screwdriver. There was no removable memory card, so the files were somewhere on the circuit board inside. She didn’t know enough about electronics to definitively say which part the memory was on, but it was easy enough to destroy it all. With two pairs of pliers, she snapped the circuit board in half, then repeated the process again and again until it was nothing but shards.

That probably would have done it, but she was aiming for completely eradicated data. She briefly thought about throwing the shards in the fire, before rejecting the idea as potentially dangerous. Instead, her eyes fell to the hammer again.

After considering it, Clarice stood and went to the kitchen. She took the plastic bag that the water bottles had been sitting in, as well as an empty metallic paper package that the Lipton’s had been in. She put the remnants of the circuit board in the paper package, folded it over, and wrapped that in the plastic bag. Then she opened the front door, laid the bag on the boards of the porch, and crouched in the doorframe.

Clarice struck the bag as hard as she could with the hammer. Encouraged when she felt a crunch, she repeated the action, hitting the bag again and again. She continued the blows long after she was sure nothing could be left.

The destruction was cathartic and entirely satisfying.

When she was done, she cautiously unwrapped the plastic bag, and was unsurprised to find a few tiny pieces of pulverized material loose in the folds, and a small pile of it spilling out of the Lipton’s bag. It had broken in several places under the force, as she had suspected it might. But there was nothing left that resembled a circuit board anymore. Clarice carefully rolled the bag back up, and threw it in the other plastic shopping bag that she had been using for trash. She deposited the broken casing of the voice recorder in the trash with a flourish, and it was done.

Gratified, Clarice relaxed into the sofa, covering up with the afghan. She hadn’t done anything demanding today, but just being awake nearly the entire day had tired her out enough that she was content to simply sit and rest. When enough time had passed, she rinsed her clothes in the tub and then hung them to dry from the shower curtain rail.

The clock said it was barely after eight, but she had no reason not to go to bed, so she did.

Clarice fell asleep easily, and when she woke in the morning she felt better. Not entirely back to normal, but better. She had slept almost twelve hours.

Also her appetite had fully returned and she was properly hungry. She had Lipton’s for breakfast, despite not really wanting soup first thing in the morning. Then she built up the fire again. It slightly amused her and annoyed her that this was beginning to feel like a routine. She looked out the window; the snow on the ground was mostly gone, only existing here and there in patches. She checked her clothes; they were still damp but would be dry by the afternoon.

Clarice felt boredom creeping in again. For lack of any other occupation, she opened the memo pad she’d written yesterday. She read through the pages, reviewing the words and occasionally adding something in the margins. Then she opened the blank memo pad and began writing even more, putting down her own impressions and thoughts about the conversations she’d recorded. She expanded beyond observations and wrote what she had felt about the encounter, about the complicated place Dr. Lecter held in her life. It was more personal than anything she’d written before, but account this was solely for her.

It kept her busy for hours.

Just after one o’clock, Clarice heard the unmistakable rumble of a delivery trunk engine.

She jumped to her feet in anticipation. They had to be here to deliver the phone. Looking out the window, she saw a UPS truck pulling into the yard. She quickly put on a coat to open the door. The driver called hello to her and came up to the porch. She was unsurprised that she had to sign for the package, as that was the only way to guarantee that she actually received it. Clarice barely glanced at the name on the label as she signed the digital screen with an illegible scrawl that could have been anything.

Then she was shutting the door and the driver was returning to the truck.

Only as the truck was driving away did Clarice realize that she had just opened the door to accept a package without without feeling any particular way about it. She had wanted the phone and she knew they were bringing the phone. She hadn’t second guessed herself, and she hadn’t panicked over doing something so similar to what she’d been doing when she’d been abducted.

Clarice knew that didn’t mean she had nothing to work through, but it was a positive sign nonetheless.

The package in her hand was addressed to Ashley Smith, both names so common they were unremarkable. It was a small box, and inside she found a phone and a charger.

Clarice turned the phone on. It already had a significant charge.

She looked at the paper Dr. Lecter had given her, and typed in the number of Ardelia’s burner phone to send a text. She simply wrote: I’m alive. Call this number when you’re alone.

Less than thirty seconds later, the phone rang.

“Ardelia?” Clarice answered.

“Clarice! Oh my god, it’s really you.” Clarice heard Ardelia’s voice crack. “Are you okay? Where are you? What happened?”

“I’m fine; I’m safe. I’ll tell you the whole story in person, but the short version is that someone kidnapped me looking for revenge and threw me in a cellar. I was there for days and nearly died of dehydration. I would have died if it weren’t for Hannibal Lecter and Will Graham. And if it weren’t for you. If you hadn’t contacted them, I would be dead. They’re the ones who found me.”

“You actually saw them,” Ardelia repeated. “They were here?”

“Apparently they were in the country when they called you.”

“I just thought—I thought maybe they could tell me what I had missed, what I needed to find you.”

“I suppose they might have, if they weren’t at hand.” Clarice also would have assumed they were abroad, though she never would have assumed that Dr. Lecter wouldn’t take as active an approach as possible with something personally important to him. “But since he was here, he was hardly going to pass up the opportunity to do it himself.”

“They knew how to find you and they never told me they could,” Ardelia said blankly.

“I know. And I’m sorry. I’m sorry you must have thought I was dead. I can’t imagine going through that.”

Ardelia let out a surprising bark of laughter. “Jesus, Clarice, don’t apologize to me. You’re the victim here. You’re the one who’s been through something. Lecter is a psychopathic bastard; I can’t exactly be shocked that he was a bastard to me. As long as he wasn’t a bastard to you, I’ll call it a win.”

Clarice laughed herself. “He was a perfect gentleman. He saved my life and it was insane. I’m alone, they’ve left, and the man who took me is dead. Also, I’m in Maine.”

“Maine?”

“Like I said, it’s a long story. One I’d rather not have on the phone. Can you tell me what’s been going on there?”

“Eh, not really,” Ardelia said. “I’ve been put on leave.”

Clarice’s stomach dropped. “Because of what you did?”

“Oh, no, they have no idea about that. No, I yelled at Dixon when he wouldn’t consider anyone besides Hannibal Lecter as a suspect. And that was on the evening of the day you were taken, so I’ve been out of the loop since then. Did Graham tell you everything about the case that I told him?”

“He told me a good amount.”

“Then you probably know as much as I do. I was sent home and locked out of the system that same day. I assume the FBI is still looking for Lecter and still doing nothing in any other direction.”

“All right,” Clarice said slowly, turning over options in her head. “I need to officially contact the FBI, and I need to get home.”

“I’ll come get you.”

“Are you sure? It will probably be an eleven or twelve hour drive.”

“Yes, I’m sure.” Clarice could practically hear Ardelia rolling her eyes. “Anyway, how else would you do it? I’m guessing you’re kind of stranded.”

“I have cash. I could get a bus ticket.”

“Yeah, you’re really gonna have to tell me the whole story,” Ardelia muttered.

“Or I could contact the FBI, tell them I’m alive, and make them buy a bus ticket home. I can’t get on a plane; I don’t have any ID.”

“A bus is going to take even longer with the stops and the bus changes. Do you want to take the bus?”

“Not especially,” Clarice admitted. “But I could.”

“I’ll come get you. Where are you?”

“I’ll be at a motel. I’m just not there now.” If Ardelia was coming to get her, then they would be telling the FBI about it. Clarice wanted a location Dr. Lecter could have conceivably left her at, and a nondescript motel was a believable option. “I don’t want to put you in a position to directly lie to the FBI on my behalf. Hannibal Lecter left me in Maine and you’re picking me up at a motel—both of those things will be true.”

She heard Ardelia exhale. “All right. However you want to do this, I trust you.”

“Let me look up a few things and then I’ll call you back and we can figure out exactly what to do. Half an hour or less,” Clarice promised.

“I’ll hold you to that—I’ve got your number now. Talk to you soon.”

“Bye for now.”

“Bye.”

Clarice hung up. She felt good, both in having spoken to Ardelia and in having something proactive to do after feeling like she had been killing time and waiting.

The phone was a prepaid budget model, but it had a browser, and she was able to search for the phone number that Dr. Lecter had given her.

She found the website of the local ride service, and saw that it was as Will had described. Clarice had already mostly decided to use it, but she wanted to fully review her options. She had ruled out the idea of a bus, though there was a Greyhound station within the area covered by the ride service. Clarice also found a taxi company that ran anywhere in the state of Maine. The bus station was the perfect place to take the local transport to from here. It would be an unremarkable destination, and it would be an unremarkable location from which to order a taxi to a motel.

Clarice was thinking about the most prudent ways to proceed, even though she knew how the FBI worked. She was the victim, and she was hardly going to be under investigation. She only needed to have a plausible explanation about what had happened. The FBI wasn’t going to be cross checking phone records or GPS to make sure she was where she said, when she said. Still, the one thing she wanted to at least do was obfuscate her current location, and that meant taking exactly two rides somewhere else.

With those thoughts in mind, Clarice called the number for the transport service. She was pleased when she was able to get a spot at nine next morning with no problems.

Then she looked up motels in the area. She wanted to find a place somewhere a bit remote, somewhere Dr. Lecter might easily have been without being noticed. After browsing through the results on the map, she located a suitable motel. It was in a different town than the bus station, still inside city limits but situated next to a highway on the outskirts. It was a budget motel that would be a destination for no one besides those traveling along the interstate.

That sorted, she called Ardelia back.

“All right,” Clarice said, after Ardelia answered, “I can get to a motel around noon tomorrow using local transports.”

“I can drive part of the way today, then do the rest in the morning.”

“Sounds good.” She gave Ardelia the motel’s address, with the understanding that she would let her know if something changed tomorrow. Then she said, “I don’t really want to call the FBI from here, even with a burner phone, but I suppose I need to officially contact them.”

“Why?” Ardelia asked, surprising her.

“To let them know I’m alive?” Clarice said.

“I’m the FBI. And you’ve contacted me.”

Clarice abruptly laughed. “I’m overthinking this, aren’t I?” She had been considering the best time and way to actually contact the FBI, because she’d been thinking about what to tell the FBI and what to tell Ardelia as two separate things. But it was true that in any other bad situation where she needed help, she would only call Ardelia and would then let Ardelia handle the law enforcement logistics.

Ardelia chuckled. “I get the idea that overthinking things happens when you’ve just dealt with Hannibal Lecter.”

“You don’t mind running interference?”

“I would love to be the one to tell Dixon that you’re alive and in Maine for some reason. Since he wouldn’t listen to me in the first place. Look, I don’t know what you’re going to tell him and the rest when you get back, but you don’t have to deal with any of that until then. Like I said, you’re the victim. You’re alive, you’ve been through an ordeal, and you need me to come get you. All of that is true and that’s all he needs to know. Keep it simple, stupid. Dixon is stupid, and he needs it simple.”

Ardelia had never been Dixon’s biggest fan, but she was openly vitriolic now. Clarice supposed she couldn’t blame her. And she suspected she might end up feeling the same way, whenever she got the full story of what had happened the day she was abducted.

“Okay,” Clarice in agreement. “Then I will officially call you on your actual phone so you can say you’ve been contacted.”

They both hung up, and then Clarice called Ardelia’s number. About five minutes was spent further discussing plans, and Ardelia agreed that she would text Clarice when she actually left and when she stopped for the night, but other than that, they wouldn’t be in contact again until tomorrow, and that Ardelia would continue to use the burner phone instead of her own for texting or calling Clarice.

When the conversation was done, and they had said their goodbyes, Clarice was once again left to her own devices. But at least now she had a device. Clarice was not usually one for mindless scrolling on the internet, but it sounded pretty good right now.

Since she knew she was leaving first thing tomorrow, Clarice was also less concerned about rationing her food. She was hungry again, and had a late lunch of yet more soup (she was thoroughly sick of Lipton’s and was never eating it again after this). She decided she could easily eat the remaining food throughout the day, and have the last Lipton’s right before she went to bed.

Clarice then settled in on the sofa with the phone in hand. She didn’t look up anything serious or heavy, but instead played word games, looked at articles rounding up the best new books, and searched various sites for professional yet comfortable shoes, which were always hard to find.

When her own clothes were finally dry in the early evening, Clarice determined that she actually was going to have to iron them. They didn’t just look slightly rumpled, they looked awful enough that it would draw attention. But she literally had nothing else to do, so she spread out the two towels she’d already used on the bathroom floor as a makeshift ironing surface, and then ironed her shirt, her slacks, and her blazer as best she could. She had the stray and somewhat amusing thought that Dr. Lecter really should have an ironing board here if he was going to have an iron.

Afterward, she returned to killing time with the phone. It was a slow evening, but she found something almost peaceful about it, now that she knew she wasn’t stuck here, now that she was leaving in the morning. When she was tired, she plugged the phone in to charge overnight. Clarice hadn’t yet received a text from Ardelia saying Ardelia was stopping for the night, but Clarice had already warned her that she herself would likely be going to sleep early and wouldn’t see it until the next day.

The last thing Clarice did before going to bed was make sure she had the address of the cabin memorized, before throwing the piece of paper into the fire.

Clarice woke the next morning before the alarm went off and began making preparations to leave. She ate the last two fruit cups for breakfast, but it was far from enough. She felt ravenously hungry now, but she tried her best to ignore it. In a very short amount of time, she would be able to get something else at the bus station.

She cleaned up in the kitchen, washing the dishes and utensils she’d used and putting them away. She made sure all of her trash was in the plastic bag, then tied it off, and put it inside one of the cloth bags from the closet. The last Gatorade bottle and water bottle she also took with her. She put the toothbrush and toothpaste she’d used in the bag. She made sure the memo pads she’d written in were packed, as was the phone charger.

The fire had died overnight, but she poured several cups of water over the ashes as a precaution. There were still a few small logs that Dr. Lecter had split sitting next to the fireplace. She left them there.

Clarice got dressed in her own clothes. She put the pajamas and the used towels in the basket in the laundry closet. It was laundry that would never be done, but it seemed better to put it there than to leave it elsewhere. She also stripped the dirty sheets from the bed and put them in the laundry basket. The blanket and quilt she spread over the bed, leaving it with the appearance of being made.

Then she walked through the cabin, putting anything else she had used to place. Clarice had been raised to both clean up after herself and to be a good guest, but she also wanted to leave the cabin with as little trace of her time here as possible. Not for forensic reasons, but because at some point in the near future she assumed the property management company would be there to winterize things again, and she wanted the house to look as close to the same as it always did.

With everything arranged and done, Clarice sat in the living room. The bag was at her feet and the money and the cabin key were in her pocket. The ride service was supposed to be here in half an hour. She killed time on the phone as she waited, looking at things she didn’t need and wouldn’t buy.

When she heard the sound of a vehicle, she stood and saw a small transit van pulling up.

Minutes later, she had paid the driver and settled onto one of the seats by herself, just another anonymous passenger. The van turned around in the yard before starting down the long dirt driveway.

Clarice sat by the window, but she never once looked back.

Chapter 12: Chapter 11

Chapter Text

The bus station was mildly busy but it was a space of anonymity. Everyone was wrapped up in their own concerns, and no one paid attention to her.

Clarice threw away her trash and then headed to the waiting area.

The station had a row of vending machines, and Clarice immediately got two packages of peanut butter crackers and a bottle of tea. She sat down on a bench by herself and ate, then drank half the tea and waited for her brain to catch up with her stomach. She placed a call to the taxi company, and got a taxi pick-up arranged in thirty to forty-five minutes.

Then she stood and perused the vending machines again to get something to take with her. The machines were mostly full of junk food, though there were a few healthier options. She was hungry but she still wanted something fairly plain. She purchased some more crackers, a bag of peanuts, a fiber bar, a protein bar, a few other granola bars, plus another tea and a bottle of juice. Given the obvious overpricing, she ended up spending almost thirty dollars on what amounted to not that much food, but it wasn’t her money and she didn’t care. It would be snacks for the motel and snacks for the drive back. Once Ardelia arrived, she would be able to get some hot food as well.

The taxi ride was uneventful, as was the motel. Clarice paid for a room that she wasn’t even sure they would sleep in. Because she was paying with cash, she had to put up nearly all of the rest of the money she had as a security deposit. Again, she didn’t care. She wasn’t even planning on officially checking out, instead she would just leave the key in the room when they departed. Let the motel keep Will and Dr. Lecter’s money—she didn’t want it back.

Clarice had made good time; it was just before noon. Ardelia wouldn’t be here for another two or three hours, based on what she had texted that morning.

Clarice pulled back the spread on one of the beds and settled in to wait. She ate some more; she watched an old movie on TV; she occasionally looked at something on the phone.

When she finally got a text saying Ardelia was here, Clarice opened the door to the motel room. She saw Ardelia circling the parking lot, and she waved to her.

Ardelia engulfed her in a hug as soon as she got out of the car. “I’m so glad you’re all right.”

“Me too.” Clarice squeezed her back. “And it’s really good to see you.” Ardelia was a piece of her real life, and Clarice didn’t feel like she’d been in her real life for days now.

“You have to tell me everything,” Ardelia said, pulling back. “And I need a definite break before we start driving again.”

They went inside, still talking, briefly going over logistics before sitting at the small table as Clarice began to relate what had happened. She told Ardelia about the abduction from her point of view, though she minimized how awful it had been. She related everything Will had said about Wade Bayles, from how Will had found him to Bayles’ history with his brother’s crimes. And of course she talked about Dr. Lecter. Clarice didn’t touch on every single conversation they’d had, but neither did she keep anything a secret. Instead, she spoke generally about how pleased he had been to see her, how insane his being there to save her had seemed, and how they had discussed aspects of both his life and hers. She admitted that she had enjoyed speaking to him, and that she had found herself strangely comfortable with all of it. She told Ardelia about the cabin, and then swore her to secrecy about everything.

Ardelia was clearly flabbergasted, much as she had been the last time Clarice had related what an evening with Dr. Lecter had been like. Despite everything Ardelia had already known about Clarice’s encounters with him, and despite her placing her hopes on Dr. Lecter being able to do something for Clarice, Ardelia clearly hadn’t expected any of it to go like that.

In return, Ardelia told Clarice exactly how the day she’d been abducted had unfolded, hour by hour. Clarice found that she couldn’t blame the FBI for thinking that Dr. Lecter had taken her. It made perfect logical sense from what was publicly known, and the card could certainly be considered circumstantial evidence. However, she found herself growing angry as Ardelia related the conversation with Dixon where he had refused to consider the additional information she presented. Ardelia described how she had contacted Dr. Lecter that night, as well as confessing how uncomfortable she found talking to both of them.

“And you’re sure you’re not mad about the house?” Ardelia asked at the end.

“Ardelia, I don’t care. Would I have wanted to show Hannibal Lecter the inside of my house? Not particularly. But it saved my life, so I’m hardly going to complain.”

“There’s also something else. I took all of the cards and letters he’d sent you. At first I didn’t want them to be found by the FBI, then I wanted to see if there was anything in them that would help the case and show he wasn’t coming after you. There wasn’t, of course. But I read them all, and saw the drawings. I know they were private.”

“I don’t care,” Clarice said. When Ardelia looked skeptical, she continued, “Really, I don’t. It doesn’t matter anymore.” Then another thought occurred to her. “Does he know you read them?”

“No!” Ardelia said fiercely. “No, I definitely did not mention that.”

Clarice let out a half laugh. “Well, either way, I made him promise he wasn’t going to hurt you, so don’t worry about anything. He keeps his promises.”

“If you say so.” When neither one of them immediately said anything else, Ardelia sighed and slapped her hands on her thighs. “I say we should be getting out of here. What do you think?”

“I think it’s up to you, because I’m not sure I’m going to be any use at driving. I feel mostly fine, but I probably shouldn’t be flying down the interstate at seventy miles an hour, either. Also, it’s my right ankle that’s messed up.”

“I’ll drive—it’s not a problem. We can go as far as we want tonight and then stop somewhere. You ready to leave?”

Clarice picked up the tote bag. “Completely. As long as we can get something real to eat.”

Something real to eat turned out to be easier said than done. Nothing that was fast food, even nicer fast food, seemed like something she should eat after having almost starved and then having been on a very minimal diet. Chinese food or a pizza sounded incredible, but she thought they might also come right back up. In the end, they stopped at a mom-and-pop place where Ardelia ordered a grilled chicken dinner and Clarice had hot mashed potatoes and rolls, a surprisingly good salad, and a small piece of Ardelia’s chicken.

After that, they were on the road. The plan was to drive until nine or so and then stop for the night. They wouldn’t even be halfway, but Ardelia had already been driving since morning, and tomorrow they could be leisurely about it, even if it took them most of the day.

She and Ardelia talked for a while, both about things they had already said as well as topics completely unrelated to the last few days. When the chatter mutually tapered off, Clarice’s thoughts once again turned to the FBI and to Dr. Lecter.

Clarice had always been discreet with how much she shared about Dr. Lecter. In the beginning, it had been a matter of prudence; it seemed like an extraordinarily bad idea to go around talking about him. She had just started her career, and while it was hardly a secret that she had spoken to him, claiming that she had anything unique to say about Hannibal Lecter as a brand new agent seemed like career suicide. Or possibly actual suicide—she had figuratively escaped him and she wasn’t going to do anything to refocus his attention on her.

And she had never expected to see him again, so her silence would hardly matter. Of course, that hadn’t been how things played out.

She had seen him again, and after that encounter, she had even more that she didn’t share. The meeting itself and her profile of Will, and the case of the missing girls that tied it all together was perfectly accounted for in her reports. Dr. Lecter’s personal interest in her, she had left out entirely. There was the fact that it ventured into the unbelievable, but she also hadn’t wanted to become notable, as so many others had, for being associated with him. His specter overshadowed everyone; it was almost impossible for it not to. Clarice had no particular desire for fame, and the best way to keep Hannibal Lecter from interfering with her ability to do her job wasn’t to point out how unique his treatment of her had had been. And it certainly wasn’t to declare that she understood him better than anyone at the FBI.

She’d simply had no way of knowing that her decisions would circle back round in such an unpredictable way. There wasn’t a single person at the FBI besides Ardelia who knew her true history with Dr. Lecter, but she never could have imagined that the result of not publicizing her interactions with him would be everyone thinking that he’d come to kill her. It was like some sort of horrible perfect storm.

Clarice wondered if she should have done something differently. She couldn’t say that what had just happened was a necessarily a consequence of keeping silent, but it was certainly an unexpected outcome. She wondered if she could have prevented it somehow.

But she couldn’t imagine how that would have gone, couldn’t imagine putting the personal details into an FBI report, let alone anything more public. And the practical side of her noted that if her connection to him were more widely known, or even leaked, there was no guarantee that she wouldn’t have attracted a different sort of attention, from parties more interested in Dr. Lecter than her. It wasn’t as if copycats and those vying for Dr. Lecter’s notice didn’t exist.

The conclusion that Clarice ultimately came to was that she had made the best possible decision with the information she’d had at the time, and it was still probably the best choice she could have made. As with most things, there were no perfect options and there were no perfect outcomes.

In the end, she had still gotten a better outcome than many.

-----

She and Ardelia traveled unhurriedly the next day, leaving the motel after nine but not getting back to Quantico until six that evening, on account of how many rest stops they’d made. They disposed of the burner phones by putting them in a takeout container and throwing them away at a rest stop with other trash. At another stop, they similarly discarded the removed SIM cards. Clarice had also still been taking hydrating very seriously, and she was determined to drink at least the recommended number of daily ounces, even if doing so while completing a seven hour drive was inconvenient.

When they finally pulled into her driveway after dark, her house looked perfectly normal. She wasn’t surprised that the crime scene was cleared and she was free to go in—it shouldn’t have taken more than a two days to clear a scene that hadn’t been part of a murder, let alone a scene where there had been such little evidence.

“We’ll have to go in the back,” Ardelia said. “I only have the back door key.”

Clarice got out of the car, nodding. She absently wondered where her own keys were.

“Do you want me to stay tonight?” Ardelia asked.

“Yes,” Clarice said without hesitation.

Ardelia got her bag from the car, and together they walked around the house. Ardelia unlocked the back door, and then stepped inside and flipped on the lights. Clarice followed her in.

It felt surreal, almost like she was a stranger arriving at her own house. And yet it felt just like her house, exactly as she’d stepped away from it. She remembered that her house was a disaster, especially the kitchen, which she could see from the back door.

But she knew what the kitchen looked like. What she wanted to see was the entryway.

She drifted in that direction.

All the evidence markers had been removed, but her possessions were still knocked over and strewn about the floor. There was broken glass on the tile. And there was the message on the wall.

This was where it had happened. Clarice just stood there, staring at it all. She could feel Ardelia watching her carefully.

After what seemed like a full minute, Ardelia said, “Clarice, are you okay?”

“I feel like I should be having a panic attack or a flashback, but there’s just nothing,” Clarice said slowly. “I still don’t remember a thing.” Then she added, “But that doesn’t mean I don’t hate it. I hate that someone came into my house and did this,” she said, gesturing at the space. After another moment of measured silence, Clarice carefully crossed the entryway. She experimentally opened the front door, but didn’t have a particular reaction to that, either.

She closed the door. “Right now I think I’m just angry.”

“That’s valid,” Ardelia said. “Look, tomorrow I will clean all this up. Hell, I’ll even repaint. But right now, what do you say we eat something? Anything you’ve got, I’ll fix it.”

Clarice sighed, turning her back on the entryway. “I’ve got a bag of frozen ravioli, I think.”

Ardelia laughed. “If you want to have me boil a pot of water instead of actually cooking for you, sure, I can do that.”

“I’m not even sure what there is to cook,” Clarice said honestly. “I was barely cooking before, and anything fresh left in the fridge has probably gone bad by now.”

They went to the kitchen, where Ardelia stood and fixed the pasta, and Clarice took a seat at the table. She saw her purse sitting on the counter, just where she usually set it right before walking out the door. She bet that’s where her keys were.

“What about my phone?” she said absently.

“It’s still in evidence. But we can get it tomorrow.”

Dixon, unsurprisingly, wanted to see her tomorrow, and expected to unless he heard otherwise. Ardelia had briefly spoken to him that morning and had relayed the message to her. Clarice didn’t have a real opinion on the timing of the interview—she might as well get it over with tomorrow.

Clarice felt oddly overwhelmed by the physical chaos of her house. All the things she’d never had time to do, all the items she’d never put away, were all still here waiting for her, and she was still too tired to deal with any of it. Tired in a different way, but tired nevertheless.

The flowers from Wade Bayles were gone, thankfully. Though so was the Christmas card from Dr. Lecter.

Well, it’s not like she needed it; she had plenty of others.

When the ravioli was done, Ardelia brought two bowls over, and they sat at the table eating in companionable silence.

Ardelia’s phone vibrated. She ignored it, and ignored it when it vibrated again. The third time, she rolled her eyes and pulled it out of her pocket. “I’ve been off of mandatory leave for one day,” she grumbled, “and Dixon is already bothering me with something, even though he knows I’m officially busy with you.”

She unlocked the screen and irritably flipped to her messages. Then her eyes widened and she said, “Oh, shit.”

“What?”

Ardelia told her, and that was how Clarice learned what errand Dr. Lecter had been in the country to complete.

Bedelia du Maurier had been found dead in her home.

-----

The FBI offices were predictably a bit chaotic the next day.

Ardelia had to check on the status of her own cases since she’d been out, so Clarice found herself going to Dixon’s office alone. She was fine with that; it would be easier to talk around what had happened to her if there was no one else present. Clarice was absolutely not going to tell the FBI that Dr. Lecter had set out to save her life on purpose. She only needed to give a vague, bare bones account of what had happened, without any of the motivations behind the actions. She fully intended to lean on the reality that she’d nearly died, and had in fact been delirious for over a day.

Ardelia had been as good as her word, and had only told Dixon a minimal amount, with one additional detail they agreed she would tell Dixon yesterday: that Clarice had said it was not Hannibal Lecter who had abducted her.

Clarice figured it was a good thing to get out of the way, and questions about Dr. Lecter would have been the first thing out of most agents’ mouths upon seeing her. It was entirely reasonable that they would have discussed it.

Dixon ushered her into his office, gesturing for her to close the door as he sat back down at his desk.

“Good to have you back, Clarice.”

“Good to be back,” she returned, taking a seat.

“We had all our best people on it, I can tell you. Nobody was going to rest until we got you home.”

“I know how dedicated everyone is.” They were completely dedicated, and she had no doubt that everyone had put their all into it, just as she would have if one of them were in trouble. It was just that those efforts and resources had been pointed in the wrong direction.

Dixon brought his hands together. “Well, let’s get down to the brass tacks. We had Hannibal Lecter as our suspect, but Ardelia reported that you said it wasn’t him.”

“That’s right,” she said.

“He just killed Bedelia du Maurier,” Dixon pointed out.

“Yes, I heard.”

“And you’re sure he had nothing to do with this?”

“Lecter didn’t take me,” Clarice said, “but he did have something to do with the time I was gone.”

Dixon’s eyebrows rose.

Clarice began, neutrally describing what she remembered of that morning, what had happened when she’d woken up in the trunk and been taken to the cellar, and how she’d been held there without food or water. “I didn’t recognize the man who took me, and he never spoke to me once.” she said. “I tried to get out of course, but I couldn’t. I was there for days—I’m not sure how long, I was slipping in and out of consciousness near the end. And that’s when I saw Lecter.”

“So Lecter was working with this other man.”

“No. He and Graham killed the other man. I was barely with it, but I remember seeing that much when they pulled me out of the cellar.”

Dixon frowned in disbelief. “They what, just got you out?” he said. “What reason on earth would Lecter have to do that?”

“You’d have to ask him.” Then, sensing she needed to give a little more, she said, “You know I’ve had run ins with them before. Talking to Lecter was how I solved the Buffalo Bill case. I always assumed he found me amusing in some way. Or maybe he didn’t think it would be fun to kill someone who was already half dead. He’s unpredictable.”

He wasn’t, but she couldn’t imagine anyone arguing the point.

“It didn’t really make sense why they were there at the time,” Clarice said. “But given what I now know about Dr. du Maurier, my guess is that they were calling on old acquaintances and somehow realized I’d been abducted.”

Dixon snorted. “How could they possibly realize that? And why would they care?”

“I don’t know how Graham realizes anything,” Clarice said truthfully. “But he hunts other killers. It’s his entire pathology.” She had published as much in her profile of him years ago. “He likes it—it satisfies him. And his skills shouldn’t be underestimated.”

“Will Graham is not some sort of murder savant,” Dixon said, beginning to get irritated. “He’s a psychopath.”

“Maybe, but you’ve never dealt with him. You’ve never seen him pull impossible facts out of thin air. I have. There are a few other people still around who have. Zeller is still here. Ask him what seeing Graham work was like.”

From the expression on Dixon’s face, he was clearly not going do that.

Clarice continued. “Graham likes killing murderers. And Lecter likes proving that he’s smarter than everyone else. Finding me and killing who had me could have seemed like a fun challenge. If he pulled one over on the FBI in the process, all the better for his ego. I know Lecter enjoyed seeing me helpless. I know he enjoyed me knowing there was nothing I could do to him. He likes having power over other people.”

“And they left you at this place where Ardelia picked you up?”

“Yes,” she lied.

“Why didn’t you call in the sighting of them immediately?”

“I nearly died; I couldn’t even walk. Even after drinking something, it was over a day before I could drag myself to the motel office to make a call.” She had stayed in enough budget hotels to know that most had removed their in-room phones years ago, and only maintained one line for guests without cell phones to make calls on. “I called Ardelia as soon as I could.”

“When she said she’d heard from you, I could hardly believe her. But she was adamant that you were alive and that she was going to get you in Maine, of all places.”

“I don’t remember getting there,” Clarice said. Then she shrugged. “Maybe Lecter and Graham were on their way to leave the country. They could have been heading to the Canadian border, or they might have had a boat. We should probably check docking registrations.” She actually did suspect that they traveled by boat, as it was much easier for registrations to slip through the cracks than it was not to be flagged while buying international plane tickets.

“I’ll get someone one it. Though Lecter’s probably flown the coop by now.” Dixon clicked his pen several times with obvious annoyance, before dropping the pen to the desk. “So. Big picture, we don’t know who took you or why, and the case is still open.”

“Technically, I suppose. But the man is dead. In fact, you’ve probably already found him, or local law enforcement has. I can tell you what to look for. It will be a rural area, with nothing left of the house but the foundation. There will be a cellar and there will be a mutilated body.”

“I’ll get someone on that too.” He sighed, then said, “I really wanted to get this one done. I thought you’d have something more for me.”

Something in Clarice bristled at his callousness. He had said when she’d come in that it was good to see her, but he hadn’t expressed any real sympathy, let alone taken two minutes to ask how she was doing. Clarice was hardly one for wanting her hand held, but a modicum of concern that one of his agents almost died would have been nice. Instead, all he was worried about was getting the case closed.

“Well, I wasn’t exactly investigating it,” she said tightly. “I was the victim.”

“No one said you weren’t,” Dixon replied, seeming confused at where she was coming from. “You and Bedelia du Maurier are both victims. Just not of the same man like we thought.”

“Speaking of Dr. du Maurier, has anyone contacted Dr. Alana Bloom?”

“What for?” His brow furrowed.

Clarice was incensed, and part of her couldn’t believe he was actually asking. “Because Lecter has made multiple threats against her. He sends recipes to her in the mail. Dr. Bloom should have been notified as soon as Dr. du Maurier was found.” Then she added, “Actually, they both should have been notified when you thought he had abducted me, and should’ve been told that the FBI suspected he was in the country and active again.”

“It didn’t end up being him,” he said, dismissive.

“You didn’t know that at the time,” Clarice said, her anger building. “Though you could have, if you had just listened to Ardelia.”

“She didn’t have any evidence. She didn’t have anything but an opinion, and I don’t pay people for their opinions.”

“Well, you should be.”

Dixon fixed her with a hard stare. “Excuse me?”

“All we do here is give opinions. Profilers interpret the evidence and we put together informed opinions that, if we do our jobs right, lead to the arrest of killers. But you aren’t interested in any of that.” Her temper was flaring but she had no desire to rein it in. Clarice knew if she continued speaking, there would be no turning back, but she didn’t care. “You just want high close rates to magically appear,” she continued, her tone quiet but cutting. “But you won’t do anything to further them. In this case, you shut down valid lines of inquiry. Lecter was a perfectly reasonable suspect, but he never should have been the only one. What’s more, you refused to listen to a reliable, proven agent who had more information than you did. You bungled this entire—”

“You are seriously out of line,” Dixon cut her off, raising his voice. His expression was thunderous, his jaw clenched. “You may have just been through a lot, but you will not—”

“That’s the first time you’ve even acknowledged that I’ve been through something,” Clarice interrupted. Then deciding she was done here, she stood. “I’ll see myself out.”

She didn’t expect him to follow her, and he didn’t.

Clarice was absolutely furious. She was enraged at how ineptly he had handled things, how he couldn’t even see his mistakes.

Maybe the FBI could have found the connection to Bayles if they had been trying to figure out who else might be targeting her. And maybe they couldn’t have. Maybe only Will Graham would have been able to make those connections. Clarice knew better than anyone that sometimes there was simply nothing you could do to keep from losing people, no matter how hard you tried. But she also knew that if you didn’t do everything you could, victim after victim would slip through the cracks.

There was no doubt in her mind that Dixon was going to get people killed.

In what seemed like a different lifetime, Clarice had told Ardelia that she couldn’t imagine not wanting to be a profiler, couldn’t imagine herself in a managerial role. But now she saw the true impact of a department head not caring about the work. The department needed someone capable of making informed decisions, and agents needed support from above to truly excel at their jobs.

She found Ardelia at her desk. Ardelia saw her coming, and her eyes widened fractionally at whatever she saw on Clarice’s face.

Clarice walked over, and in a voice low enough for only Ardelia to hear, she said, “I’m going to get his damn job.”

Ardelia didn’t ask what happened, but only said, “Damn right you are.”

-----

The rest of the afternoon was occupied by the bureaucracy of her disappearance.

She sat down with the agent who had officially been lead on her case, and told him the same things she’d told Dixon. Unlike Dixon, he didn’t question her at all, and seemed to want to close out the case as quickly as possible. He could also barely look her in the eye, and she realized that he seemed ashamed.

Clarice took a wild guess. “You were the one who found the card in my kitchen.”

He glanced up, startled, but he met her eyes. “Yeah, I was. I’m the one who got it wrong.”

“You made a perfectly logical supposition based on the evidence. Doing that wasn’t wrong.”

“You sure about that? It was because of me that this whole investigation got derailed and you nearly died.”

“It wasn’t because of you,” she said. “From what I understand, everyone was told the direction to take the investigation in.”

“Yeah,” he agreed. “We were. But that doesn’t keep me from feeling like a failure.”

“We all fail at some point. And I’m alive,” she added frankly. “Save the guilt for the dead ones.”

He laughed, abrupt. “Fair enough. Let’s get this thing finished.”

When they were done, Clarice retrieved her phone and her watch, which she had been told were cleared from evidence. She also went to check on her car, which had been towed to the FBI for forensics after its discovery. Upon seeing that she was limping a bit, the security officer at the desk said that he would have someone drive the car over to her house later, and all she needed to worry about doing was signing the release forms.

Forms were also required by HR, as Clarice would be on medical leave following a traumatic event. She had to be evaluated for emotional stability to return to duty. Because of what she had been through, she knew the evaluation wasn’t simply a formality, and that multiple sessions with a therapist would be required. But that suited her fine, and she filed a request for five weeks leave. It wasn’t like she didn’t have the time banked.

Later that afternoon, she found out that Dr. Bloom had indeed been contacted after the discovery of Dr. du Maurier, though an oversight had led to neither of them being contacted after Clarice’s abduction. Dr. Bloom was still alive and well, which was good to know, but which didn’t entirely surprise Clarice. She had only met the woman once in passing, but she knew that Dr. Bloom and her wife paid millions every year for private security, and had done so ever since Dr. Lecter’s escape.

Before she and Ardelia left for the day, she heard an update on her own case. Local police in Pennsylvania had been called a few days ago when a hunter driving down a dirt road had noticed carrion birds and pulled over. He’d found a mangled body next to an old cellar, and a car hidden and parked in an overgrown area. The property and the car were owned by Wade Bayles, and he was assumed to be the dead man, though dental records hadn’t been confirmed yet.

Clarice said that the name sounded familiar—and that she had definitely arrested a Darryl Bayles some years ago, it was one of her most notable cases. She waited for someone else to connect Wade and Darryl as brothers, as well as discover Darryl’s death in prison, and then she agreed that revenge seemed a likely motive against her.

And her case was closed.

-----

That evening, Clarice sat down to watch the footage of her abduction.

She knew she didn’t have to, and that maybe she even shouldn’t. Ardelia was of the opinion that she shouldn’t, but she’d opened her laptop and pulled up the footage for Clarice nonetheless. Whether she should or not, Clarice desperately wanted to see what had happened. She wanted to know that there was nothing she could have done.

In that, she was vindicated.

The footage showed her opening the door and him immediately injecting her. The angle of the camera didn’t account for anything that happened after that, anything that happened inside. Part of her wished she could see that too, just because she knew she would likely never remember it. But she had seen the most important part, the part that she had questioned herself over. And now she had her answer: she couldn’t have stopped it.

Somehow, that was both better and worse.

Clarice watched the clip on a loop until she realized she was crying, and then she shut the laptop. But she couldn’t stop crying.

She found herself telling Ardelia how scared she’d been during her brief interaction with Bayles, about the horrifying feeling of being left alone in the cellar, and how devastation had taken over by the end when she’d thought she was going to die. She cried, Ardelia cried, and while Clarice didn’t entirely feel better by the end of it, she felt like she had done something necessary.

Clarice had known in some part of her mind that she had been so distracted by Dr. Lecter and Will immediately after her rescue that she had more or less closed the door on everything that had happened before that. But that didn’t mean it wasn’t still there, and she knew she hadn’t really started to work through it.

But she was starting now.

Chapter 13: Chapter 12

Notes:

This is it! The end! Of the fic, of the series, of the years that this story has been haunting the corners of my mind. :) I hope you enjoyed, and thank you all for being here!

Chapter Text

Clarice did not go to the crime scene at Dr. du Maurier’s home.

She was officially on leave, for one thing. She did feel frustration at not being able to go, but there was nothing she could do about it. The site was also in New York state, where Dr. du Maurier had moved many years ago when she’d completely retired from public life, and Clarice was in no way up for another road trip right now. And it was clear that this was Dr. Lecter’s doing, so there was nothing to solve, only things to catalog.

So she made do with accessing the FBI report from Ardelia’s laptop a day after the scene had been processed.

Bedelia du Maurier had been discovered by the woman who cleaned her house. Her leg had been removed and cooked, and nearly the entirety of it was on two separate platters with elaborate arrangements in her refrigerator. Bedelia herself was in the deep freeze.

Everything inside had been removed but her. The top of the freezer had been left open, but a large clear piece of thick plastic had been fastened over it so that she remained frozen yet on display. Inside, she lay with her eyes closed and her face in a neutral expression. A necklace encircled her throat, and a similar chain lay across her brow. Her hands were clasped around an antique Italian stiletto buried in her heart, blood starkly staining the white bodice of her dress around the wound. The flowing skirt of the dress filled the empty space around her, the full folds arranged to lie beneath her and to pool at her hips. Both her skin and the dress had been sprayed with water and left to freeze, the process repeated multiple times. The result produced not the patchy crystals that usually accompanied a body in a freezer, but instead a smooth layer of sheer ice that enveloped her completely.

She was an icy queen, crowned by Dr. Lecter.

It was one of his least gory crime scenes, but still just as sobering.

Due to the nature of freezing a body, exactly how many days she had been dead couldn’t be determined. There were none of the usual signs of rigor mortis or decomposition. But the only way Clarice could make a timeline make sense in her head was to assume that Dr. Lecter had killed her before he’d been contacted by Ardelia. Then instead of leaving the country as he’d presumably intended, he and Will had delayed their departure.

It seemed even more insane now that she knew what they’d been here to do. They had to have known the clock was ticking on the discovery of Bedelia’s body. On the other hand, given that the FBI was already hunting for them because the FBI thought Dr. Lecter had abducted Clarice herself, perhaps the additional risk hadn’t mattered. At any rate, it explained why Dr. Lecter had seen Ardelia’s Tattle Crime post so quickly—he had probably been checking the site to see if any sightings of himself had been reported.

The autopsy confirmed that Bedelia’s leg had been removed while she was alive, and that she had been alive for at least a day after its removal. Undoubtedly so she could be at the table and have a final dinner with Dr. Lecter. A considerable amount of opiates were found in her system, but the stiletto to the heart was the cause of death. While the scene had been arranged to make it look as if the dagger in her heart was her own doing, the autopsy unsurprisingly said that the angle was wrong. The stiletto had been expertly wielded in a single strike; the tableau of her stabbing herself was just for show.

Clarice wondered whether it was Dr. Lecter or Will who had actually stabbed her, and then immediately wished she hadn’t.

It wasn’t that Clarice didn’t fully know what they were capable of—she did. But it was extremely unsettling to realize that the only reason they had been at hand to save her own life was because they’d been killing Bedelia du Maurier. It seemed likely to Clarice that Bedelia was Dr. Lecter’s target, as having vendettas against former associates was thoroughly in line with how he operated. But she suddenly couldn’t be sure. Will might have given an indifferent approval to the idea and tagged along, but it also occurred to Clarice that he might have been completely on board. Bedelia du Maurier had claimed that both Hannibal Lecter and Will Graham had been present on the long ago night that Dr. Lecter had taken her other leg.

Clarice thought about the conversation when she’d asked if Will had ever killed someone who wasn’t a murderer. Then she wondered if Bedelia had ever killed anyone. A quick search of the FBI archives turned up documentation of immunity, as well as a report about an extremely questionable death that had occurred in her office, that she herself admitted wasn’t entirely self-defense. Though the fact remained that Dr. Lecter had been peripherally involved somehow and nothing about the circumstances was concrete.

But perhaps it was enough to give Will an excuse, either to go along with Dr. Lecter, or because he’d wanted to kill her himself for his own reasons. Clarice knew that there was some history between them, and that Dr. du Maurier had done a series of not-entirely-well-received lectures about her time in Italy with Dr. Lecter. But the finer details of what had happened were only known to the parties involved.

Clarice still believed that her profile of Will was correct and that killing murderers and only murderers fulfilled something in him. But she could also see how his definition of murder might have stretched and expanded over the years. Will was adaptable, after all. Wade Bayles, attempted murderer; Bedelia du Maurier, murderer by technicality. Adjacent enough that Will could justify it to himself.

It was a piece of information to mentally file away, though it did nothing for Clarice now. She still felt oddly shaken by the whole situation, and for more reasons than the fact that someone was dead.

Hannibal Lecter had raised Clarice out of a hole in the ground; he had put Bedelia du Maurier in one.

She knew it wasn’t as if their lives had been traded somehow. Her abduction had absolutely nothing to do with the other woman’s death, except for the fact of astronomically coincidental timing. It was the timing that bothered her more than anything, because that was something that no one could control or manipulate. It had happened when it happened because that’s the way it happened.

Like it was fate.

Clarice wasn’t sure which idea disturbed her more—that a thing like fate actually existed, or that her fate was somehow tied up with his.

-----

Ardelia had stayed at Clarice’s house for three nights, and had then gone back to her own by mutual agreement.

After only a day of being back at work, the same day she had brought Clarice in, Ardelia had taken a week of vacation, saying that she needed to help Clarice, and that Dixon had gotten along fine without her when he’d put her on mandatory leave so there shouldn’t be a problem.

Ardelia came to Clarice’s every day and spent a significant portion of her time there. Both because she didn’t want Clarice to be entirely by herself, and because Ardelia had decided she was going to clean Clarice’s entire house. Clarice protested that she didn’t have to do that, and Ardelia countered that yes she did, because it needed to be done and Clarice was supposed to be staying off her ankle.

So Clarice retreated with her laptop to the guest bedroom, the only undisturbed room in the house, and left Ardelia to it. Ardelia left her to it as well, as Clarice was furiously working on her application for Crawford’s job. She channeled all of her anger over what had happened to her into productivity—laying out her notable experience and excellent close rate, her ideas for the direction of the department, the unique assets and skills she would bring to the job, and her plans for developing talent in new agents.

When it was done she submitted it, immediately feeling a sense of both accomplishment and finality. She had told Ardelia that she was applying for the job, but she hadn’t told her the other resolution she’d made: if Dixon got the job permanently, she was going to resign. Staying at the FBI under him would be untenable.

The medical leave she was on had only reinforced how impossible her career had been becoming prior to this. Clarice was dedicated to doing a demanding job and doing everything within her power to do it well. But there were human limits, and she had been at a breaking point before, though she hadn’t quite realized it at the time. The FBI was her dream job, and it would break her heart to leave, but she also wasn’t going back to a job that would break her.

Clarice had resolved that if someone besides herself or Dixon got the job, she would see how it went for six months, and then she would decide about leaving. But if Dixon got it, there was no question of staying. Clarice had an excellent resume behind her, and she had in demand skills. She could get a private detective license and become a police consultant. There were thousands of cases that never reached the FBI, and people in need of assistance who would welcome someone with her experience.

She would of course tell Ardelia she was planning to quit if it came to that, but she also hoped it would never happen. Now that she had considered what getting the job would mean in a new light, she absolutely wanted it. Clarice had always thought of her calling in life as saving lives, but she could see the bigger picture now. She no longer needed to personally save the lives herself, and if she got the director position, she would have a bigger impact than she ever could have as a profiler.

While Clarice had spent days drafting documents and reports full of data, Ardelia had spent those same days dusting, vacuuming, wiping down surfaces, doing laundry, and putting things to place. She had thrown out over half of the food in Clarice’s fridge, re-ordered groceries, and deep cleaned the entire kitchen. The house was almost spotless, a thing that hadn’t happened in so long Clarice had forgotten what it looked like. Ardelia had even dug out a gallon of paint in Clarice’s garage from when Clarice bought the house, and had painted over the writing on the wall.

Now they stood in front of said wall, looking at the streaks from the roller which had unfortunately not dried the same as the surrounding color.

“The wall must have faded,” Clarice said. “We should have thought of that.”

“It was worth a try. Maybe you could hang a picture there?”

“Maybe,” Clarice said. But she wasn’t sure she wanted anything right there. Seeing a picture that she had only hung to cover the spot where the message had been seemed like a good way to think of it every time she saw it.

“I could repaint the whole thing,” Ardelia offered. “There’s half a gallon here.”

Clarice laughed. “No, you’ve done more than enough.” But then an idea occurred her. She stared at the space of the entryway in general, considering it. “I think I want to change the color of the room.”

“Really?”

“Yes,” she said with a decisive nod. “Not right now, but a later. What else am I going to do with my month off? And I think it would be good for me.”

Clarice had had one session with a therapist so far, a very professional woman named Dr. Vo who had a calming and open demeanor. They hadn’t delved very deeply into Clarice’s recent experiences, but instead had discussed general strategies for dealing with trauma. Clarice knew that no matter which therapy model was being used, a large part of healing from anything was allowing yourself to feel things, acknowledging the feelings for what they were, and then incorporating that into your life going forward.

They had also discussed physical activity as being helpful if things felt like too much. Clarice didn’t particularly feel like anything was too much, but the idea of repainting her entryway and making the space new appealed to her.

“I’m definitely doing it,” she said aloud. “And I want to do it myself. But if you want to help, you can take this stuff to Goodwill,” she said, gesturing to the small table, and the lamp and trinkets that sat on top of it. None of it was anything special, and all of it had only been bought to fill the space.

“You sure?” Ardelia asked.

“I want it gone. I want to start over.”

Ardelia nodded. “Can do. I’ll drop it off tonight.”

“There’s no rush.”

“Eh, I might as well. No reason not to.”

“Thanks.” A beat later, Clarice added, “For everything, Ardelia. You’ve been a lifesaver—in more ways than one.”

“I know,” Ardelia said confidently, taking the praise. “I mean, Hannibal Lecter might have done the dirty work, but could he have found you without me? I think not,” she said, nudging Clarice with her elbow. “And I know he couldn’t have cleaned your house like this.”

Clarice smiled. “No,” she agreed, “he couldn’t have.”

She knew he absolutely could have. She had seen his particular attention to cleanliness after Will had been injured by Benton. Also, a person did not remain an uncaught serial killer for years without knowing their way around how to clean up. But that was hardly what Ardelia had meant, and Clarice was incredibly grateful to her.

Ardelia’s own week of vacation time was over, and she had spent nearly all of it helping Clarice put her life back together.

Ardelia had gotten almost everything in Clarice’s house back where it should be, but Clarice spent the next day doing a few things that Ardelia couldn’t, like finishing the filing in the office and putting loose papers away. Ardelia had returned the box of cards from Dr. Lecter, and Clarice had put those back in her desk. The necklace, however, she left sitting in a tray on her dresser. She would still never wear it, but its existence had been pivotal to saving her life, and it was no longer something she wanted hidden away.

Clarice had also done some digging on the cabin, but as she had expected, it yielded nothing. With private browsing and a proxy server enabled, she had looked up property records. The cabin was owned by Forest Cabin Trust, a name so nondescript and unoriginal it barely warranted notice. Most trusts were named after the people who created them, though they didn’t have to be. Most trusts were also formed to enable the easy distribution of assets, but she knew that concealment would have been Dr. Lecter’s primary concern.

The property had been owned by the trust for twenty-six years, and she could only assume the trust had been formed for the purchase of the cabin. Trusts were not registered with the state the way other legal entities were, and only the involved parties would have the legal documents naming the trustees. Even the attorneys who had drafted the documents would have purged the files by now; legal records didn’t have to be kept anywhere near this long. The only ones who knew Dr. Lecter owned the property were probably himself and Will. And now her.

Clarice tossed the key in her kitchen junk drawer, unlabeled.

Two days before Christmas, she received a small package in the mail. She immediately clocked it as being from Dr. Lecter, as it had several international postmarks on it. She hadn’t entirely expected something so soon after seeing him, and the only other time he had mailed an actual package was when he’d sent her the necklace.

Inside, she found a card, and a small paper-wrapped object that felt like a book. Clarice read the card first.

Clarice,

This has been one of my favorite volumes, but I have long ago committed its contents to memory. I thought perhaps you would find better use for it. Going forward, I shall endeavor to leave you with no doubts about any arrangements that come from my direction. If nothing else, remember that I will never send you white lilies.

Regards,

Hannibal Lecter

Bemused, Clarice unwrapped the book. She found an antique pocket-sized edition on the language of flowers, barely four inches tall and bound in dark blue leather.

Much like his other gift, it was simple and thoughtful, but had more meaning behind it than anyone else would know. It was also probably just as expensive—the book was almost two hundred years old but in excellent condition. Clarice flipped through it with idle interest, reading a page here and there, before tucking the card away with the others and putting the book on her bookshelf.

Christmas passed, and so did New Year’s.

The first week in January, Clarice had an interview for the job, and the next week, she had a second one. She thought that both of them went incredibly well, and she felt like a new chapter was about to begin.

During her leave, she had also had time to thoroughly decompress from the stress that had been the last few months of her life at the FBI. She cooked real meals and read books that she’d been meaning to get around to. She made projects of simple things like cleaning out her bathroom cabinets, or putting together that shelf in the garage that she’d bought for the office, and she felt good when she finished them.

Clarice also tackled the entryway. Because of how the floor plan separated things, the entryway was not part of the living room itself, but was instead a space half-enclosed by its own walls. Part of it could be seen from the living room, but there was a clear delineation between the rooms, which made it a perfect place to change a paint color. She chose a brighter, lighter neutral, one that would accentuate the area compared to the living room’s slightly darker tones. Days were spent carefully taping off her baseboards and windows, and applying the layers of new paint to her walls. There was satisfaction in the work, and she was incredibly pleased when it was done.

A day later, she went shopping for some piece of furniture to put in her refreshed space. Clarice found a small antique sideboard at a used furniture store, and while it was unlike anything else she owned, she found that she liked it incredibly well. It was a unique accent piece for a room that only existed as a pass through area.

Only after it was delivered did she realize it looked like something that could have been sitting in Dr. Lecter’s office. She had hardly bought it with him in mind, and if the similarity in style had occurred to her at the time, she probably wouldn’t have purchased it. But there was nothing she was going to do about it now. Clarice still liked it and she wasn’t going to try to return it. Dr. Lecter was not the only one allowed to enjoy antique furniture.

In her next session with Dr. Vo, she related the completion of her project, as well as discussed her hopes for the FBI job. They had already had sessions where they talked about her abduction and the aftermath. Because Clarice needed a doctor’s positive evaluation to return to work, and because she knew they were covered by doctor-patient confidentiality, she told Dr. Vo more than she’d told the FBI. Not all of it—not even half of it—but in the interest of not lying to her therapist, she knew she had to explain some of her history with Hannibal Lecter. Dr. Vo had listened as she’d listened to everything else, and at the end she’d only asked if Clarice felt she had any issues to address regarding Hannibal Lecter, to which Clarice had honestly been able to reply that she did not.

She’d already discussed him with a doctor, after all.

At her final session, Dr. Vo said she saw no indication that Clarice wasn’t fit for return to duty, and filled out the paperwork saying as much. She made the comment to Clarice that Clarice seemed very secure in who she was, and the fact that she was emotionally aware would only continue to help her.

A week later, Clarice received a call offering her the job of Director of Behavioral Science. She accepted graciously, even though her heart was pounding at the thrill of the job really being hers, and a start date was set. The next day, she went to headquarters, not to return to work, but to be present for the official announcement. She said a few lines about her hopes for the department, and how much she looked forward to working with everyone in her new role. Her coworkers seemed genuinely happy for her; a few even looked excited. Clarice supposed she and Ardelia hadn’t been the only ones who were chafing under the interim management. Ardelia was both ecstatic and smug over Clarice getting the job, and had grinned and said “I told you so” when Clarice had shared the news.

Three days after her promotion was announced in a press release, the largest floral arrangement she had ever received was delivered to her house.

There was a small card tucked into it, and Clarice opened the envelope. The message inside the card was printed, and the text had obviously been entered on the floral service’s website. Therefore, it was neither addressed to her nor signed, though she suspected she knew what she was going to find. It said:

I must offer my congratulations on your promotion. It is most well deserved. By an abstract reckoning it has been a mere twenty-four hours since I first spoke to a trainee close to graduation, but what a difference the true years make. The department will no doubt flourish under your dedicated and steady hand, and I am confident you will outperform your predecessors entirely. You, of course, would never throw a trainee in my direction, but would handle such matters yourself. I anticipate following your advancement with interest, and you have my best wishes for the future.

Clarice smiled to herself as she finished reading.

Then she retrieved the antique book from her shelf. Even though the message didn’t leave any question as to who the flowers were from, she began looking up their meanings anyway.

Dr. Hannibal Lecter might remain at large in the world, but it was partly because of him that she had become who she was. She sat at the head of Behavioral Science thanks to the experiences that had shaped her life, including her experiences with him.

Somehow, it seemed entirely fitting.

 

—the end

Series this work belongs to: