Actions

Work Header

If There Were Water

Chapter Text

Bilbo wakes at Bywater on Saturday and throws off his quilts. With sunlight—actual sunlight, not  just the wan aspirations that have fought their way through the clouds these past weeks—streaming in through the wide window at the foot of the bed, his room is warm and still. Squinting against the light, he throws open the windows and waits for the inevitable cool breeze. It doesn’t come. April has started the turn into summer. The birds are loud in the hedgerows of the garden, and though the smell of rain lingers, the grey-green fields are dry, not glistening with dew. The brightness of it all, the clarity, makes Bilbo’s head hurt. His mouth is dry; his limbs are heavy.

            He was up until the early hours of the morning writing, the words coming more quickly to his mind than they have in a long time. This house, it seems, is doing exactly what he had wanted after all. Stretching, catching his balance with a hand along the walls, Bilbo pads across the hall to the upstairs study. He needs to reassure himself that he actually wrote all those pages last night. And they are there, stacked neatly beside the typewriter—if he wasn’t so firm in his own rules, he would pick one up and read it. But that isn’t how he works. The beauty of a typewriter, rather than a computer, is that he can’t just scroll up to read his previous day’s work, doesn’t always have that temptation lying around. He simply gathers the pages and slips them into a folder, shuts it in a desk drawer each morning. It’s progress, he tells himself; No use undermining it by looking backwards. He’s having a hard enough time getting through this story as it is. Still, he can’t help but notice that the stack in his hands is thicker than it usually is, even for a good night. Thicker than he remembers it being, last night when he went to bed. Or was it this morning? Did he go to bed at all, even? Sneaking a glance at the bottom page, Bilbo notes the chapter heading: six.

            “Could have sworn I stopped at four,” Bilbo says to himself, his voice quiet in the empty room. “Hmm.” The words on the page aren’t familiar; he doesn’t remember writing this. But that’s ridiculous. Of course he did, it’s his own typewriter that the pages have come from, with the distinctive smudge on the capital F that he keeps meaning to fix, putting it off only because he doesn’t actually start that many sentences with the letter F and it seems like more of a bother to fix it than to leave it alone. He’s just tired, that’s all. And overly warm. It had been cold enough for a sweater and two pairs of socks last night, and now he’s stripping his shirt off and opening the study windows.

            The ground level is cooler than upstairs, the walls half-built into the hill retaining the coolness of the underground. Bilbo puts the kettle on for tea and opens the door to the sunroom built off the back of the house. He’s been meaning to start a vegetable garden there, get the plants far enough along that they’ll survive the move outside. The air in the glassed-in room is stifling. Bilbo has to catch himself with a hand against the doorframe, taken aback at the heat, the cloying smell of what must be rotting wood. Pressing a hand over his mouth, Bilbo shuts the door and leans back against it. When did the seasons change so fast? When did the morning sun grow so bright? The kettle whistles and Bilbo pulls it off the stove. The kitchen clock tells him it’s two in the afternoon.

            He sits in the nook and drinks his tea. Fiddles with the golden ring, still on the middle finger of his left hand. It’s not as though it’s the first time he’s slept in well past when he meant to. Not the first time he’s been up writing all night. And besides, isn’t that part of living out here, not being accountable to anyone’s schedule but his own? A shower, Bilbo decides; a shower, and then a proper breakfast, and then he’ll see to the sunroom. A good airing out, a bottle of vinegar and some baking soda, lemon polish for the floors. Water must have gotten in, sitting stagnant in a pool somewhere, probably spawning algae—hence the smell. All he needs to do is air it out, clean it up a bit. Whatever wood has actually rotted can be replaced. It may take him a while, but he’ll sort out this house. A hundred years of history, all his now. The only thing, really, that he can call his own, and surely that’s deserving of his attention. As soon as he can get his mind to catch up, that is.

            The upstairs bath looks out over the sunken garden, crumbling stone walls covered in ivy, a hawthorn tree laden with blossoms, its branches grown wild. Wild cherry, too, and Bilbo keeps meaning to see about gathering its fruit. He found a guide to the regional flora on one of the bookshelves in the back parlour and has been paging through it a little each day, comparing its sketches to the landscape visible from his windows. One of these days he’ll actually go out and walk the hills, too. It’s seemed more important to focus on the house first, on its sloping walls and dark hallways, on figuring out how it works. He’s searched the bookshelves for something on the house’s history and come up short; even the realtor didn’t have much to say about it. Gimson, Thorin had said, and Bilbo reminds himself, lathering up his hair, to look into that name.

            He’s standing in front of the mirror, a towel wrapped around his waist, debating whether or not he needs a haircut, when the noise comes. The same knocking sound that has been in his dreams, these past few nights, a tapping against the walls. At first Bilbo thought that a bird had gotten into the attic, or the chimney flue. When his searches turned up nothing, he chalked it up to being over-tired, and having an active imagination. The noise returned, a light tap-tap against the windows, the walls, as he tossed and turned in bed just last night. Or was it the night before? And this time the noise is slightly different: a grating, scraping sound follows the knocking. Tense, one hand on his towel, Bilbo pokes his head out of the bath. The hallway is empty. Nothing moving. He draws back into the bath and the noise grows louder, until a single, solid thump. Leaning out the window Bilbo can see a dark head and broad shoulders, wrestling with scaffolding against the back of the house. Thorin—of course it’s Thorin, he said he would come tomorrow, and now it’s tomorrow, so he’s here. Bilbo laughs at himself when he catches his reflection in the mirror, and goes out into the bedroom to dress.

            The roofline is higher at the back of the house, but the ground levels out: it’s a trade-off Thorin has to make, in order to secure the scaffolding. He’s borrowed the materials from Durin & Sons, an indefinite loan from the foreman, who gave him a very strange look when Thorin stopped by this morning to say that he’d be continuing the job, and would need a supply catalogue to order materials. “You sure about that?” he asked. “How’d it go yesterday?” “Fine,” Thorin said, and didn’t tell the boss that he’s been paid already, in cash, and won’t be filing a contract with the kid at the front desk. The boss will certainly find out, and probably sooner rather than later, but Thorin figures he can deal with that when it comes up, when he’ll have a little more money in his pocket. A little more weight to throw around in the bargain.

            He’s standing on the lawn and craning his neck to look upwards. The peak of the roof rises over a broad window, a hint of the back chimney just visible beyond. Thorin’s already been up on the roof today, checking on the chimney brace to make sure it lasted the night’s storm. Fíli and Kíli were still sleeping when he left in the morning. No school today, and no practice either, and he feels guilty for leaving them on their own all day but Bilbo had asked him to come back. Despite that, there was no answer when Thorin knocked on the door, not even bothering with the broken doorbell, and so he figured he may as well get to work; Bilbo would be out soon enough, no doubt. That was six hours ago. He heard the water running, briefly, a moment ago, but now all is silent, apart from the first crickets of the season, hidden somewhere in the high grass.

            The barn was always filled with music during the workday, a rotating cycle of genres over the ridiculously heavy speakers they’d rigged up on either side of the main doors, someone always humming along. Thorin, often, hummed along. He works in silence now, noticing the buzz of the crickets, the call of gulls resounding across the heath—they’re not far from the sea, twelve or fifteen  kilometers at most, and the birds range far. The sun is warm on the back of his neck, a rare clear-weather day, perfect for scrabbling around on a roof of slick slate. He’s two steps up the scaffolding when Bilbo comes up behind him and says, “Hello?” and Thorin nearly falls off in shock, wrenching his arm as he catches himself. Same arm, twice in two days.

            “Where did you come from?” he asks, rubbing his shoulder. There’s a bottle of aspirin in the truck, saved for emergencies, and he’d rather not waste two tablets on himself, but the temptation is definitely there.

            “I’ve been calling and calling your name,” Bilbo says. “Sorry I wasn’t out here to greet you properly. Long night, you know.”

            Thorin turns and looks around, as if something in the landscape will give him a clue. The crickets carry on, undisturbed. Bilbo is tilting his head sideways and eyeing Thorin as if there’s something wrong with him. Thorin flushes and turns back to the house to hide it. “It’s fine,” he says. “Just been continuing on from yesterday.”

            “That’s wonderful, thank you.” Bilbo comes around to stand beneath the scaffolding. “I’m glad you could come back. The weather’s certainly good for working.”

            “It won’t hold,” Thorin says, automatically, because it never does. Spring might be drier up here than down in the islands, but the wide blue skies above them will see clouds soon enough. He climbs up to the next level. Looks down at Bilbo below, at the dark shadows under his eyes, cast by the overhead sun. “D’you want to come up?” he asks, the words out of his mouth before he even has time to think them over.

            “I’m not exactly good with heights,” Bilbo says, but puts a hand on the lower rail. “Are you sure?”

            Thorin nods, even though he isn’t sure. Sure that the scaffolding can hold both of them, yes; sure of what he’s doing, not even a little bit. But then there they are, both atop the roof of Bywater, looking out over the landscape. Bilbo sways on the spot, caught up by the sudden shift in perspective, a feeling of vertigo washing over him. He reaches out, on instinct, and catches hold of Thorin’s arm. Grips his sleeve just above the elbow and steadies himself. The highlands are empty before them, rolling hills and swathes of dusty heather all the way out to the rocky cliffs that jut out against the sea. On the other side of the house, not visible, is the city. Thorin shoots a glance down to Bilbo’s hand, pale, fine fingers against the worn-out denim of his shirt.

            “I used to live by the coast,” Bilbo says. “But it wasn’t anything like this. The east is much . . . I want to say much more cultivated, but that’s not quite right. More civilised? Less wild, at any rate.”

            “I lived by the coast before, too,” Thorin says. “West, near the islands.” He doesn’t know why he’s telling Bilbo this. It’s been so long since he’s talked to anyone but the boys, had anyone to talk to about his own life, and Bilbo is still holding onto his arm. Why is Bilbo still holding onto his arm? “I think I know what you mean.”

            “As though you could just drop out of the world. Although, I’ve been here a month now and have never even been out to the cliffs, so I suppose my life wants a little more adventuring before I disappear.” Bilbo smiles up at Thorin. Notes the strong line of his jaw, his nose, a face of hard angles. Thorin looks tired, and Bilbo finds himself feeling guilty for all but demanding that the man come back and work a second day in a row. Who knows what other obligations he has in his life? “I’m keeping you,” Bilbo says, when his voice catches up with his thoughts.

            “What?” Thorin asks, and his eyebrows draw together, and all right, Bilbo’s voice hasn’t actually caught up. That came out wrong.

            “From your work,” Bilbo clarifies quickly.

            “Oh.”

            “And I didn’t intend to press-gang you into coming back today. Really, you can set your own hours, it’s not as if I’m going anywhere. I could even leave you a key, I suppose, if that’s easier for you.”

            “No, it’s—” Thorin starts to say, and then has to stop, because he doesn’t even know what words he wants to come next. Because he, in a way, wants to be kept here. Just here, looking out over the wild, entirely at peace. Except, who would look after the boys? “I need the money,” he says, and might as well just jump off the fucking roof. Being far too blunt has always been one of his faults. What happened to losing his honesty? Why does it have to come back at the worst possible moments? “I mean, it’s not a problem.”

            “I’m glad,” Bilbo says. “And I’ll pay you for your time, I promise.”

            “No, I really didn’t mean to say that,” Thorin says. He tugs away from Bilbo and stuffs his hands in his pockets. “You paid me far too much, yesterday. I can’t accept it. And the food, too, that was—”

            “Thorin, there was no way I could eat all of that by myself. I grew up in a large extended family and I have yet to figure out how to cook for less than twelve. Honestly, you’re doing me a favour by taking it off my hands. Left on my own, it would only be a matter of days before I got far too fat to even climb the stairs, let alone up here.” Bilbo runs a hand over his stomach as he speaks; not fat, but not hollow, either, beneath the softness of his shirt.

            “You don’t understand. It’s— I don’t need charity,” Thorin says, and if he’s jumping to conclusions, it’s only because he’s been here before. Had this same conversation, nearly word-for-word. Last time, it ended with his fist in another man’s face, and he’s not proud of that at all.

            “I know that,” Bilbo says. Thorin frowns; that’s not how the conversation is supposed to go. “I’m not trying to offend you,” Bilbo continues, “and I’m sorry if I have already. I just thought that you looked like you’d enjoy a good meal. If this is your way of telling me that my cooking leaves a lot to be desired, though, have it out and let’s be done with it. Well?”

            Thorin wants to look back at Bilbo. Can hear the laughter barely suppressed in his voice. “Your cooking’s fine,” he says, a bit more gruffly than he means to. “And . . . and appreciated.” He almost wants to tell Bilbo about the boys. It’s not that they’re some secret he needs to keep; he’s not ashamed of what he does, what his family has become. No, his family is all he has left. And perhaps that’s exactly why he’s so hesitant to share it, even just in conversation—he’s terrified, honestly, that any day now someone will show up and take the boys away. All it would take is a stray word to the wrong ears, or one too many remarks from any of the boys’ schoolmates. He’s terrified and he hates it, hates living in fear, hates even more that he can’t provide for them the way he ought to. Wonders every day, sometimes twice a day, whether the boys hate it, too. Or worse, hate him.

            “Good. That’s settled, then,” Bilbo says, and startles Thorin out of his thoughts, the motion of him stretching his arms over his head a blur in the corner of Thorin’s eye. “I’m afraid I was horribly lazy this morning and only just finished breakfast, but if you’d like tea—”

            “I should get to work,” Thorin says, and stops himself from commenting on how pale Bilbo looks, how deeply he must have been sleeping to not hear Thorin knock. He really can’t talk. At this point, tiredness is imprinted on his bones, ingrained so deeply he can never shake it off. If he should be concerned about anyone’s exhaustion, it’s his own. “You all right to get back down from here?” he asks, and hopes that Bilbo takes the hint for what it is: a dismissal. He’s getting too distracted.

            “I’ll manage. If you need anything, let me know. I’ll be cleaning out the sunroom today, so try not to drop any slates through the glass roof.”

            “I wouldn’t,” Thorin protests, and then turns to see that Bilbo is smiling. A joke, then. His sense of humour is really, severely out of practice.

            “No fear,” Bilbo says, and gives him a wave before easing himself back down over the edge of the roof.

            All things considered, Thorin should probably just wear his hard hat all the time, given how often he feels the need to knock his head against things after he opens his mouth. He works well into the afternoon, shoring up the chimney. The weather won’t hold, no matter how brightly the sun shines; there’s going to be a storm tonight, winds rising off the sea. They’re protected, down in the glen, in the city, enough that Thorin’s more concerned with flooding than high winds. If Bywater weren’t built halfway into the hills as it is, hadn’t been standing for a hundred years and more, he’d worry about it lasting the summer. But this house has lived through more than he can imagine. It doesn’t need some artisanal furniture maker with delusions of grandeur to come along and reclaim it from the wild as if it were a national heritage site or the like. It’s just a house, another home that’s not his own.

            There’s no sign of Bilbo when Thorin gets back down to the ground. The sunroom just around the corner is empty. He can tell from the outside that the wood is rotting, and makes a note to offer to rebuild it, even though it’s an atrocity. It doesn’t belong out here, on a house like this. There’s hardly ever any sun, anyway. Somebody’s foolish hope, that addition. Thorin tries the backdoor to the kitchen and, finding it unlocked, toes off his boots and steps inside. “Bilbo?” he calls. No answer comes, and he steps out into the hallway. Fingers the aged wallpaper, blinking against the dimness. “Bilbo?”

            Bywater creaks and sighs, settling around Thorin as he makes his way to the bottom of the staircase. He’s reluctant to go up to the second floor unasked. Already feels like enough of an intruder. The house has a presence of its own, and it’s not just the narrowness of the halls or the lowness of the ceilings that makes Thorin feel pressed in; Bilbo is nowhere in sight, and yet Thorin can’t shake the feeling that someone is following him. There’s a tension across the back of his neck, spreading into his shoulders. He turns on the spot, traces a line around the corners of the hall, sees nothing. Nothing but shadows across dark and faded wallpaper, across long wide floorboards. Bilbo must be upstairs, probably writing whatever it is he writes. There was a time when Thorin wasn’t a stranger to being in that creative frame of mind, so focused you block out everything around you. Dwalin had to physically lift him off his stool once when the table-saw overheated and started filling the barn with smoke—Thorin only had eyes for the dovetail joints in front of him, the chisel in his hands.

            Back in the kitchen, thinking to leave Bilbo a note, Thorin finds another thick envelope with his name on it. On the back flap, in a fine hand, Bilbo’s written:

 

In case you need to head out, there’s food in the refrigerator—help yourself. And take tomorrow off. It is a day of rest, after all! Everyone needs that.

     Thorin opens the refrigerator doors more out of curiosity than hunger, not intending to take whatever it is Bilbo’s left. Where is the man, anyway? In a neat stack of matching glass containers are sausages, mashed potatoes, and yet more tomatoes. Bilbo’s refrigerator is well-stocked and orderly, the crisper drawers full, three kinds of juice and a pitcher of water on the top shelf. The kitchen’s been updated, of course, since the house was built, but at least whoever did it had good taste. The appliances are understated, white enamel and stainless steel, clean lines against the dark floors. Thorin lingers, waiting to see if Bilbo will emerge from wherever he’s gone. He’s halfway down the hall, envelope tucked in his back pocket, when he turns around and goes back to take the food. “Bilbo?” he calls once more, wondering if he should be concerned. But really, Bilbo’s probably just fallen asleep somewhere, and in a way it’s easier for Thorin to leave, hands full of things he’s done nothing to deserve, when he doesn’t have to face the man.

            It isn’t until he’s driving back into the city that Thorin realises he never did leave a note. Embarrassed now, as well as still unaccountably on-edge, he has to pace the apartment parking lot for a full ten minutes before he can settle his face into a neutral enough expression to go inside.

 

Thorin doesn’t return to Bywater on Sunday. Bilbo insisted he take the day off, and though Thorin is reluctant to let a day go by without working, he does have to admit that he’s hardly seen the boys all week, and it’s not fair to them to leave them on their own for so long. Not that they seem to care that he’s around, doing their homework at the kitchen table in silence. He’d offered to take them out somewhere, to a park or up into the hills for a walk, but Fíli just shrugged it off, and Kíli, who does nearly everything his brother does these days, did the same, though he looked for a second like he would say yes. Thorin thinks that if he could just win Kíli over, Fíli would follow, and every day wouldn’t be a battle. Or at least, things would change; the battles would be ones he stood a chance of winning. They are getting better, but slowly, so slowly, every inch won a hard-fought siege.

            But then, he’s had seven years to get used to Fíli shadowing him and hanging onto his every word, and only four months to try to break through this new stubborn, grieving refusal. All the things Thorin has read—because he has done the reading, knows what all the child psychologists would tell him—say that it will take time. “Take time,” as if it’s something that can be neatly dealt out, in even increments, the same for everyone. Thorin knows that’s ridiculous. It took time for him to come to terms with his grandfather’s death, with his parents’. He’s still taking time to process the fact that he doesn’t have a younger brother anymore and Frerin died twelve years ago. Grief doesn’t take time so much as consume it, and all you can do is try to keep your footing, hope to come out the other side eventually, somehow still standing. So Thorin doesn’t press the boys, even though the pamphlets say he should. He has enough trouble sorting through his own emotions about Dís’s death, and anything he could say to try to comfort the boys would bleed into mutual sorrow, and that’s not helping anything, feeding the cycle like that.

            Although really, given how much loss his family has seen in his lifetime alone, it doesn’t seem to matter if you feed the cycle or not. It continues either way.

            Thorin spends a miserable day napping on the couch, pacing the front room, and trying not to loom over Fíli and Kíli at the kitchen table. He knows he should talk to them, knows he’s probably doing them more harm than good with every passing minute of silence. But how do you bridge that gap when the thing that most held you together has become the thing no one can stand to think about? They do have lunch together, at least; Bilbo’s leftovers, and Fíli is burning with questions, obvious enough that Thorin starts to wonder if the boy thinks he’s robbed a grocer. The bruise on Fíli’s face is beginning to turn yellow. Left unchecked, Kíli would have consumed the entire pan of blueberry crumble. From the outside, they seem to be coping. A little thinner, a little quieter than Thorin would like, when they’re not acting out, running wild in all three of the apartment’s rooms or getting sent to the headmasters’ offices at their respective schools, but largely coping. Lifting the container of dessert over Kíli’s head and stowing it in a high cabinet, Thorin could almost fool himself into thinking that they’ll be all right, just carrying on like this.

            But the only reason he’s even home to see them instead of still caught up in endless job-hunting is because a stranger with an old house—an old, broken, intriguing, unsettling kind of house—has decided to show Thorin kindness. It’s not that he’s unused to kindness. He has plenty of friends. Good friends, loyal to the point of fanaticism, and even if they’re some three hundred kilometers away he knows they would do anything he asked, should he ask it. And there’s the fundamental problem, there’s what’s really wrong with things: Thorin Oakenshield doesn’t like to ask for help. Can’t bring himself to do it, even if it’s for the ones he loves. Because he does love the boys, really desperately, so much that it makes him ache day in and day out, and he would do anything for them, but somehow that “anything” doesn’t include answering simple yes or no questions.

            Are you all right? No.

            Do you need help? Yes.

            He can’t do it. It’s like some kind of mathematical limit: he can approach it forever, but never actually reach it. Can lose his honesty piece by piece, lie so often it becomes routine, but there’s always something standing in the way of outright asking. Something that has forced him to become adept at dodging the point of people’s questions, whether it’s the foreman at Durin & Sons or one of the boys’ teachers. He’s become skilled at talking in vague words and clipped phrases.

            Don’t think that he doesn’t know the name of it, either, that driving force: it’s pride, plain and simple. The same pride that made Fíli punch out one of his rugby mates, the same pride that keeps Kíli from going to remedial reading classes even though his teacher is constantly sending notes about it. Thorin sits with him on the couch instead and they flip slowly through the pages, Kíli tracing words with his finger and muttering to himself, Thorin guiding him through rough patches in pronunciation. Books are the one thing their apartment has in anything like abundance, carried over from their old house in cardboard boxes and suitcases, stacked high at the foot of the boys’ bed or along the work table and atop the filing cabinet that passes for Thorin’s wardrobe; dog-eared paperbacks, serial comics, a set of encyclopedias in matching gilded bindings that must’ve been a gift from someone on their father’s side of the family, textbooks and dictionaries and atlases. Every interest the boys have ever had is chronicled in the stacks. Fíli reads in context, has to know everything going on around any book that becomes a favourite of his. Kíli is slower—much slower—but more eclectic, spending months at a time on the same novel before going off in a completely new direction. As a result, Thorin’s read along through a surprising catalogue of stories, these past four months.

            It’s a book that brings them out now, a history text Fíli is meant to have for lessons on Monday. “I forgot,” he tells Thorin, and the hesitation in his voice hurts to hear. “We’ll go out and buy a copy, Fíli,” Thorin says. “Now, before the shops close. Kíli, get your coat. Leave that for later,” he says, gesturing to whatever it is Kíli’s trying to build out of sheets of paper stiffened in a mix of glue and water. The boys’ crafts are best left alone, Thorin has found. Anytime he tries to help, they become elaborate, intricate affairs, and though the boys used to delight in having their uncle build the tiniest toothpick towns, Thorin has seen the aftermath of too many wrecked projects, stomped on by classmates or thrown into the toilet. Kids are cruel, and the more you stick out the crueler they are, and Thorin lets the boys muddle through their own science projects now.

            On a rainy Sunday afternoon the streets are practically empty; the long walk to the used bookstore down by the bridge is quiet, but the silence is a far more pleasant one that what had been smothering them in the apartment. There’s a bigger shop in the center of town, but they’re headed to the one where Dís used to take the boys. Thorin lets Fíli lead the way, keeps Kíli’s hand in his as they walk, wondering where yesterday’s sun went, and if he’ll be working in this wet weather tomorrow. The park is empty; the bus stop is empty; two or three people mill about outside one of the local pubs. A family of ducks swims back and forth beneath the bridge, playing in the gentle current. The used bookstore is called Rivendell; the name has nothing to do with the river it sits atop, but with the glen, the low-lying land of the whole city. The hills curve up around the city, and the cliffs rise on either side of the river mouth. But this was a floodplain once, down here in the flats. The sea rose up in a storm, burst over the dyke wall and drowned the land. Just east of the train tracks you can still see the dead lines of drowned trees, bog grass flat and brown. When Dís first moved up here and Thorin came along to help—“the manual labour,” she’d called him, joking—they walked out into the marshes one evening, a sliver of a moon out over the sea, the last of the day’s light dimming to dusty red behind their backs. “What the hell are you doing, coming all the way out here?” Thorin had asked. “Starting over,” Dís had said; “Getting out.” Out of what, exactly, didn’t need to be said. Thorin already knew.

            Thorin’s only been inside Rivendell a handful of times. It’s an older building, warm woods and pale grey stone, plants absolutely everywhere, two floors of books with a winding staircase in between and a tiny basement café. With the wages Bilbo’s paid him these last two days, Thorin could even afford to buy the boys a scone each, if they behave. He turns them loose on the main floor, gives a nod to the girl behind the counter, and goes off to their local history section to see if they have anything on Bywater house and whoever it was who built it, all those long years ago. There’s something about the house beyond its age and its architectural style that he can’t let alone. Something he can’t define, wants to attribute to too little sleep and too much whisky but can’t quite write off. There are plenty of books about the region, the important battles fought here back in the 11th century, the kingdom of Moray, the castle. Books, too, about city planning and the history of the local distilleries, about the cathedral on the opposite riverbank. There’s a slim volume, dating back to the forties, about regional architecture, but it doesn’t tell Thorin anything new. Thatched cottages and stone houses, fishing huts, all fairly typical. Nothing about the Arts & Crafts movement and how it might have spread all the way up here to the highlands, nothing about the aesthetes. Thorin glances up at the girl at the counter, wonders if she might know anything. She’s awfully young to be working, though Thorin suspects it’s a family business, and she doesn’t do much besides smile and ring up the till, fingers quick on the ancient mechanical cash-register.        

            “Something I can help you find?”

            The question startles Thorin so much that he turns on his heel and backs into a bookshelf. Standing just before him in the aisle is a man, tall and lean, long hair in a sleek dark ponytail. He’s wearing a dress shirt and slim, neatly pressed trousers and Thorin feels shabby just looking at him. “No, thanks,” he says, but the man doesn’t go away.

            “You came in with Fíli and Kíli,” he says instead.

            Thorin straightens up and all but glares at the man. He can’t decide what question to ask first. Settles on saying, “What’s it to you?” Not the most eloquent.

            “Forgive me,” the man says, and inclines his head. “I knew their mother, that’s all. It’s been some time since I’ve seen Dís, and you’re clearly family. I thought I might introduce myself. My name is Elrond, I’m the owner.”

            “Thorin Oakenshield. Dís . . . was my sister.”

            Elrond pauses a moment, and then nods. “I see,” he says. “I’m very sorry, Thorin.” His eyes are a dark blue-grey but warm, warmer than most others when they’ve said the same words. “She used to come by with the boys after school, in search of new books several times a month. How are they holding up?”

            “They’re all right,” Thorin says, because what else is he supposed to say? “I mean, they’re . . . yeah. They’ll be all right,” he amends.

            “And you?”     

            “What?”

            “How are you holding up?” Elrond asks. His hands are clasped behind his back, but he’s leaning forward ever so slightly, pushing at the edge of Thorin’s personal space.

            “I’m fine.”

            It hits Thorin then, standing there in the local history section with the bookshop’s owner staring him down, that this is the first time anyone has asked him that. He swallows tightly and tries to hold Elrond’s gaze. Reminds himself that Dís would have given him an earful if she ever found out he was rude to one of her friends—and she always found out. He’s saved from the embarrassment of whatever would have come out of his mouth next by the girl at the counter.

            “Daddy,” she calls, “can you come here a minute, please?” Elrond gives Thorin one last, slow nod before turning to go to his daughter. Thorin drags a hand over his face, presses his fist to his mouth. Wonders where the boys are, and whether they’ve broken anything yet. He picks his way through the shelves to the staircase, keeping Elrond and his daughter in his line of vision. The man’s still staring at him. Thorin climbs up to the second floor, spies Fíli and Kíli half-hidden behind an array of spider plants, seated on cushions on the floor and reading.

            “Did you find your book?” Thorin asks, crouching next to them.

            Fíli waves a textbook at him, not looking up from his reading. Kíli shifts over until he’s pressed up against Thorin’s side, pointing at a page in his picture book. “Look, look! There’s a new book, Uncle, and look, they’re going into the cave but that’s where the dragon is!”

            “I see that, Kíli,” Thorin says. “Are you two ready to go, then?”

            “Can we get it?” Kíli asks, holding the book up.

            “Kíli, we have a lot of books,” Fíli says, before Thorin can answer. “Come on, let’s just go.” He takes his brother’s hand and they stand up, brushing past Thorin to head downstairs.

            “Wait,” Thorin says, trying to catch up. “Wait, Kíli. We can get it.”

            “It’s all right?” the boy asks. Thorin nods. “Really?”

            “Really. Fíli, give me your book, I’ll go pay and you can take your brother down to the café. Go on,” he adds, when the boys hesitate. “I’ll be down in a minute.”

            “Thanks, Uncle!” Kíli says, and grabs Thorin’s arm, hanging off him. Then he drops to the ground and barrels down the staircase. Fíli stares at Thorin as if he doesn’t quite believe him, but then thumps off down the stairs after his brother. An elderly lady browsing magazines frowns at them. Thorin frowns right back at her, and she looks away. At the counter, the girl rings up the books and smiles at him, even though he’s reasonably certain he’s still frowning.

            “Tea and scones are our compliments,” she says as she hands him the bag and his change. “Please enjoy them.”

            “What?” Thorin asks. Wonders if the ability to startle him runs in this Rivendell family, along with their looks, tall and sleek, even this girl who can’t be more than fourteen.

            “The least we can do,” Elrond says, appearing out of nowhere to stand beside his daughter. “Arwen’s brothers run the café. I’ve already spoken to them, so go ahead and order whatever you’d like. And I hope you’ll bring the boys back again. They do enjoy it.”

            “Yeah, well,” Thorin says, prickling at the implication that he doesn’t know what his own nephews enjoy. But Elrond has that same patient half-smile, his hand on Arwen’s shoulder, and there is sincerity, not judgement, in his voice. “Thanks. For, uh, everything.”

            “Not at all,” Elrond says. “We’ll see you again soon.”

            “Right,” Thorin says, “sure,” and ducks down into the basement, leaving father and daughter still smiling. The boys are seated at a small table along the rough stone walls, a plate of scones rapidly disappearing before them. Thorin gives a nod to the two young men behind the bakery counter and goes to join Fíli and Kíli. And walks straight into a chair, smacking his shins against its metal frame. Bilbo Baggins is seated at the far end, the lamp over his table casting a golden haze over his hair, the soft turn of his nose, the tortoise-shell frame of his glasses. He looks up—of course—at the noise, the metal chair scraping along the stone floor, knocked aside by Thorin’s carelessness. Behind the pie case Elrond’s sons are laughing, quietly and behind polite hands but laughing nonetheless. Thorin can feel his face heating up and turns resolutely away, sits down with the boys and hunches his shoulders over.

            It’s no good. Bilbo comes over to their table anyway. “Well, hello,” he says. He’s wearing a bulky sweater, a shade of mustard yellow incongruously bright for such a rainy day. “Fancy meeting you here.”

            “Bilbo,” Thorin greets, and wonders when his voice dropped a register. The boys are staring at him.

            “Nice to see you out and about, Thorin. I was starting to wonder if you worked all the time, considering that you’re at my house before I’m up and don’t leave until after I’ve fallen asleep. I’m sorry about that, by the way, from yesterday. I don’t know what came over me. All of a sudden I couldn’t keep my eyes open. I hope you found everything all right.”

            “I— Yeah, it wasn’t any trouble,” Thorin says. Bilbo standing there just over Fíli’s shoulder has him on edge; that must be why he offers, “Join us.”

            “Are you sure? I don’t want to intrude.”

            Thorin pushes out the empty chair—beside him—by way of answer. At least this way they’ll be on eye level. “These are my nephews,” he says, as it becomes clear that Bilbo is waiting for introductions. “Fíli, on the right, and Kíli.”

            “Hello, boys. You can call me Bilbo. Your uncle’s helping me repair my house. Or at least,” he says, sending a smile over at Thorin, “I hope I haven’t driven him away. Will you be coming back, tomorrow?” Thorin nods. “Oh, wonderful. I meant to work on the sunroom yesterday but that didn’t happen, and then my editor wrote and wanted me to send him another chapter so I had to come into town to the postal office. While I was here, I thought I’d pick up some new reading material. I thought spring was meant to be drier up here?”

            “I . . . wouldn’t know,” Thorin says, a bit stunned by the speed of Bilbo’s speech.

            “They really have excellent tea here, don’t you think, boys?” Bilbo asks. “The owner’s sons, or so I’m told. I’d quite like to take home their entire case of pastries, but we must leave some for everyone else, right?”

            Fíli’s giving Bilbo a wary look, pale eyebrows drawn in. He keeps glancing over to Thorin, whether seeking confirmation or questioning, Thorin can’t quite tell. But Kíli seems taken to Bilbo right away, and gets up on his knees in the chair to see the man better. With crumb-sticky fingers, he reaches for his tea, tries to drink and talk at the same time and spills. “I got a new book today, too,” he says. “Wanna see?”

            “Certainly, Kíli.”

            “Uncle, show him my book!”

            Bilbo turns to Thorin, expectant. Thorin grimaces and pulls Kíli’s book out of the bag. When the boy reaches for it, he holds it back over his head. “Clean your hands first. And your shirt.” Kíli sticks out his tongue and steals Thorin’s napkin. It doesn’t make much of a difference.

            “I was just the same, at your age,” Bilbo says, leaning across the table. Thorin doesn’t see how it could be true. Bilbo’s hair might be in a state of perpetual disarray, but his clothes are neat, if never quite the right size, and his manners definitely outstrip Kíli’s by a far margin.

            “I doubt that,” Thorin says, and if he’s feeling like an idiot once again for opening his mouth, it’s worth it to see Bilbo laugh, tossing his head back, shoulders shaking.

            “Well, all right, I was a bit better,” he says. “But only because my mother wouldn’t stand for anything less.”

            The boys go still. Thorin lowers the book, sets it on the table.

            “Of course,” Bilbo says, taking stock of the fallen faces and quickly coming to more or less the right conclusion, “when I was your age, I wasn’t reading nearly such difficult books.” He takes the book from Thorin’s hand with the briefest brush of fingers and starts flipping through it. “Your reading skills must be quite good.” Kíli perks up a little, and his brother relaxes back into his chair. Bilbo spares Thorin a glance from the corner of his eye. The man is sitting ramrod straight, never mind that that position makes his knees knock against the underside of the table.

            If the boys have lost their mother, and likely recently, too, that certainly explains why Thorin would be out with them. Might explain, also, why Thorin was so quick to take payment in cash. If he’s the one looking after these boys, that is, and trying to bring them up in this expensive city. Bilbo wonders if the boys go to private schooling or public, and where they’re living, and whether their father’s in the picture, and with a pang in his gut realises that Thorin’s bafflement to being strong-armed into lunch the other day probably had more to do with hunger than any rudeness of character. Making a quick resolution to keep feeding them all, as much as possible, and an equally quick resolution to be as subtle about it as possible, Bilbo nudges his shoulder against Thorin’s. It’s all right, he wants to say; You’re doing a great job. Because now that he knows what to look for it is so painfully obvious that the way Thorin is, how he carries himself, how he speaks, how he dislikes both asking and answering questions, comes from the position he’s in and the worries he holds. And though Bilbo prides himself on being perceptive, if he can see this much in just a few days, Thorin must be practically overrun. Bilbo has had his own share of worry, but his came from looking after parents, not children, and even though it’s similar in many ways he also knows he can’t ever relate. You can’t ever know, not really, what’s going on in anyone else’s life. Bilbo knows this, and yet, pressed against Thorin in a basement café, two young boys looking at them expectantly from across the table, he’s determined to try.