Chapter Text
Monday finds them back at Bywater again, Thorin fixing Bilbo’s back door, in and out of the kitchen as he works. Bilbo’s writing in the front study; Thorin can hear the clatter of typewriter keys, short bursts followed by long silences. The day is overcast and cool, a light breeze blowing off the sea. Thorin’s grateful, odd as it may seem, that the sun isn’t shining. After putting the boys to bed last night, he couldn’t sleep, stayed up far too late jumping at every odd noise from the back alley or the hallway, pacing a new indent in the floor. Drank far too much whisky in a pathetic attempt to at least get some peace from his thoughts, if not outright sleep, and now it’s morning and he’s horribly hungover, exhausted, and also out of whisky. So there’s that.
At some point—Thorin couldn’t even say how long he’s been working, except that the latch is fixed and the hinges are tightened and he shored up the sagging back steps—Bilbo comes back into the kitchen, hair standing on end, barefoot. “I’m half-starved,” he says. “And if I write any longer, my fingers may stop working.”
Thorin grunts in reply, incapable of speaking actual words yet, both because he’s starting to wonder if he should just throw up and be done with it, and because he has a mouthful of nails. When he finishes tacking in the screen, and spits out the last nail, he says, “Door’s done. Still waiting on the slates for the roof, otherwise I’d do that, too. I could clear out your fireplace . . .”
“No, no, have a seat,” Bilbo says, and waves him into the nook. “I’ll be right over.”
“Or I could go check the attic. Make sure it’s holding up.”
“No need. I was up there yesterday. Last night? Sometime, anyway.” Bilbo is slicing lemons, neat and methodical on a wooden cutting board. The gold ring glints on his left hand, yellow against yellow. “We have to talk about restoration plans, anyway. Might as well do it over lunch, right?”
“It’s past lunch.”
“Does that matter?”
“Not much,” Thorin says, and eases himself onto a bench. He’s spent the large part of three days in this house now and yet feels like he doesn’t know anything about it beyond the kitchen and the dark front hall and the roof. He could draw the roofline from memory, pick out the quarry the stone walls came from if he were to drive past it, but that’s just the exterior. Inside is where the mystery is. Bilbo doesn’t seem to have a lot of possessions. The kitchen is outfitted well but there are plenty of open shelves; a glance into the drawing room beyond shows clean, bare floors, not even a rug; the front parlour on the other side of the hall is all shadows but Thorin suspects it, too, is far from crowded. The attic is the only place that looks full.
Turning his head at the briefest snatch of a voice, Thorin sees only Bilbo, who has clearly not said anything. Bilbo pours lemonade into tall glasses and brings them to the table, along with a plate of sandwiches. Does food just materialise around him, then? Wouldn’t that be a gift to have, Thorin thinks, and slides over on the bench to make room for his host.
“I hope you’ll forgive me for bringing this up again,” Bilbo says. “But I felt I needed to apologise, for yesterday. I didn’t mean to bring up bad memories.”
“You didn’t.”
“Thorin, I saw the looks on all your faces. I went and ruined what I’m sure was a lovely outing. I hope you’ll bring the boys by sometime, let me make it up to them.”
Nodding without really thinking about it, Thorin takes a drink of lemonade and wishes his head would stop aching.
“They’re in school all day, yes?” Bilbo asks.
“Yeah. And then Fíli’s got rugby practice after, and Kíli waits with him.”
“It’s very good of you to look after them. No, don’t shrug, it is. It’s . . . very difficult, looking after people. Kids in particular, I’d imagine. I don’t know the first thing.”
“You were good with them yesterday,” Thorin says. “Better than I am, really.”
“Oh, come on, surely you’re selling yourself short.”
“We don’t— It hasn’t been— They’re good kids, but I don’t know how to talk to them.” Later, when he has a clear head to think things through, Thorin will blame this on being hungover and sleep-deprived, on the comfort of Bilbo’s kitchen, lemonade and cucumber sandwiches—really, who the hell makes cucumber sandwiches? His mental filter’s turned off. And Bilbo is just sitting there, listening, waiting. So Thorin tells him practically everything. Tells him about Dís, healthy one day and ill the next and never getting any better; about the boys, changed from easygoing to temperamental, his own difficulty talking to them as kids when they’re the only family he has left and he’s desperate for someone to mourn alongside of so he doesn’t have to do it alone; about Oakenshield’s and all that he’s left behind there. Frerin comes up somehow too, and their father, and the whole story just keeps spilling out, and Bilbo just sits, listens, refills Thorin’s glass and slides him another sandwich. Thorin eats and drinks automatically, his throat thick, the cucumbers like cardboard on his tongue. At some point he’s wiping his face on his sleeve and Bilbo’s hand is on his arm, just where the hem of his t-shirt sleeve meets skin. That’s the other thing about Bilbo that Thorin can’t get over: he’s generous not only with his food but with his touch. Thorin hasn’t been around someone so tactile since he left his barn, and doesn’t know what to do with it.
Through this all Bilbo is quiet. What can you say, in the face of such tragedy? This is the sort of thing he writes as the plots of his novels, not something people should have to live through in real life. And sure, he has his own share of grief that he could contribute. Thorin might feel better if they were a bit more obviously on equal footing. But whenever Bilbo starts to open his mouth, to tell Thorin how he watched his own father take ill and fade away, his mother following after, all he can hear is his mother’s voice telling him, “There’s no use having a contest to see who’s the most unhappy. Who has the right to judge? And who would want to win?” Bilbo thinks afterwards that Thorin has probably won already, and that thought in itself is so unhappy he presses his lips together and turns away from the window, straightening up the kitchen with more than usual fervour. If his pans are a little more scoured that afternoon, his floors more vigorously swept, at least he keeps himself from sorrow long enough to see Thorin off from the front steps, to watch the Land Cruiser bounce down over the hills and towards the glen.
They have their first brief argument not even two minutes before, Thorin refusing payment and food, saying, gruffly, “Job’s not done yet, you can pay me later,” but Bilbo can recognise the look of someone who is hungry, and hates that he can’t speak up about it for fear of driving Thorin away. The least he can do—and does—is slip the money into one of the pockets of Thorin’s coveralls when the man’s not looking. He’ll feed Thorin more next time, and leave containers of food in the truck if need be. Risking another argument’s not the problem; he doesn’t know yet where the line is, and when he might be about to cross it, and push Thorin away entirely. He may have come up here to find some solitude, to clear his head and write his book, but then he bought this old rambling house and then his book started to write itself, or so it seems, and he may as well scrap all his other plans regarding highland isolation and take a leaf from E.M. Forster instead: “Only connect.” The simplest, most basic, most human thing, and yet so terribly hard. Bilbo’s seen both sides of the divide now, grown up in a family with countless cousins constantly underfoot and then seen them all move away while he stayed behind in a dying town, with dying parents. He is, he thinks, well placed to make those connections. But then, he’s also never met anyone quite like Thorin.
Thorin, predictably, feels like a complete idiot afterwards, as he shoves off from the table and clambers back up to the roof, his shoulder twinging in pain still but he needs to put some distance between himself and Bilbo. When he leaves Bywater that afternoon to go pick up the boys at school, he tells himself he can’t come back. Has gone too far, said far too much, and now that he’s a complete disgrace his only option is to disappear. And yet, even hours later, the whole drive back to the city through the hills, the whole long night on the couch listening to the cars passing by, there is also relief. To have finally said it all to someone, and to have it be accepted, no questions asked, and for Bilbo to say what he did after it all—relief. Thorin feels practically weightless with it, until a new fear enters his mind: How long can this last? How long can he possibly keep this up?
Not long at all, apparently. Thorin takes the day off on Tuesday, because the relief has fled and he feels like he won’t be able to look Bilbo in the eye, and wonders if it’s possible to still be hungover, two days later. The thin carpeting surges underfoot as he moves about the apartment; the crows feeding from the dumpster in the alley are ear-splitting. The morning goes as it always does, breakfast surly and slow, the boys dragging their feet out the door. He walks them to their schools, but doubts that it makes a difference. Fíli broke one of their two chairs this morning. Threw it clear across the room, sending Kíli running to slam the bedroom door and hide while his brother and his uncle yell at each other. Now, standing on the sidewalk in front of Fíli’s school, Thorin knows he should say something but the words just won’t come. Fíli stomps up the school’s steps without even a look back. Thorin sighs and brings a hand up to massage his temples, tells Kíli, “I’ll meet you after practice,” sends him off across the road. He’s half tempted to go down to the local pub, responsible adult behaviour be damned, but finds himself walking along the river instead.
He knows, has known for years now, that he needs to figure out how to get his temper under control. Especially now, when he doesn’t have Dwalin around to knock some sense into him, metaphorically or literally. When Thorin gets upset, it’s loud and it’s clear and it’s dramatic; he throws things and shouts and has to go out of the flat so Fíli and Kíli don’t see. They must know, though. If they didn’t know before, they certainly know now, after four months of living on top of each other, and fuck if Fíli isn’t following in the same way. But really, Thorin suspects Dís told them about her oldest brother’s temper ages ago. They’ve always learned young, in this family, how to recognise a fight, when to keep your head down and when to stand your ground.
A colony of herring gulls screeches past, streaking down the river towards the sea. The air smells of fish and rain and bog mud, typical spring. Rare days of sun, weeks of clouds, and near-constant threats of rain. Thorin wonders if the boys wouldn’t be happier if he’d just packed them up and moved them back south with him from the start, if the new scenery wouldn’t shake them loose from this slump they’ve fallen into. Slump, hah; That’s about the least adequate word you’ve come up with yet, Oakenshield, he thinks. Down on the pier, fog is rolling in off the water and fishermen are returning to their moorings, out across the low-tide flats. The problem is that he has no place here, nowhere to call home, no proper job, nothing worth going back to except the boys, and he’s doing a bang-up job of that. The problem is that everyone always said he was a leader, but most days he’d prefer not to have anyone following.
So it goes, most of the day. The city’s easy enough to wander in, narrow cobblestone streets, footbridges crisscrossing the river. By the time four-thirty rolls around hunger is gnawing at Thorin’s stomach. He shoves his hands into the pockets of threadbare jeans and makes his way back to the rugby pitch—really just a corner of the city park where they’ve uprooted most of the trees. Kíli’s dark head is easy enough to pick out on the top row of the bleachers. Hanging back a minute, Thorin watches the kids race across the pitch, not playing rugby so much as running about in a mob. One of the kids in that mob is the one who’s been giving his boys a hard time. It’s not as if staring hard enough is going to tell Thorin which kid that is, but he stares all the same, boys aged seven through twelve in blue and white kits, mud-coated. Soon enough practice disbands and Fíli’s climbing into the stands to fetch his brother, barefoot with his cleats hanging around his neck and a towel over one shoulder. Thorin buys them fish and chips on the way home and they eat as they walk, straight out of the paper, Kíli getting grease stains on his uniform shorts that Thorin will have to figure out how to clean later. The dinner is as close to a gesture of apology as he can make. Words certainly don’t seem to work. Evening is calmer than morning; Thorin repairs the broken chair while the boys do their schoolwork, shower, go to sleep beside each other. The only thing keeping their little fractured family together right now is the fact that the boys have basically grown up plastered to each other’s sides, and no amount of shouting or broken furniture is going to change that.
The rain starts up again around three o’clock and Thorin’s awake to see it. Stands at the one window in the front room and looks out over the alley, watches the puddles form. Sleep is a lost cause; Fíli and Kíli, fortunately, sleep like the dead for at least eight hours, and that is one small thing he never has to worry about. But if he stays in the flat any longer, he’s going to go insane. So he locks the door behind him and goes out, umbrella in hand, into the rain. He’s actually irrationally angry about the umbrella, that he could remember to be practical but can’t handle his own emotions. If he’s going to be capable of dealing with one problem in his day, it could at least be one of the important ones. Oh, sister, what were you thinking, leaving things like this? he wants to know. Leaving your boys with me, and me with them, and none of us with anyone to connect us, to go between. Of course, it’s not as though Dís had another choice, with the rest of their family dead. This is why she left him in charge: he will do whatever it takes to keep them together, to keep them safe and always together. In the care of another, separated, they wouldn’t stand a chance. And if he’s being honest he knows, too, that he couldn’t bear to know that they were with anyone else. Dís certainly wasn’t going to leave them to her husband’s family; they never got along. Kíli actually bit his father’s brother once, Thorin remembers, and that thought lifts his mood enough for him to look up beyond his feet on the stone street and notice someone standing under a street lamp beside the river.
Of all the people it could possibly be, it’s Bilbo. Who has, apparently, been standing under that street lamp for the past fifteen minutes because he’s absolutely soaked. Funny, as out of the pair of them Bilbo’s the one who always seems to have his shit together. The “always” comes easily to Thorin’s mind, for all that he only met the man five days ago, and he tries not to think too hard about that. Thorin calls Bilbo’s name four times before the man answers, turning around and looking completely dazed. “What are you doing out here?” Thorin asks, tilting the umbrella up to cover both of them. “Bilbo?” They’re the only two foolish enough to come out a night like this—the rest of the street is empty. “Bilbo?” Thorin asks again. Rain is dripping down the back of his neck.
Bilbo blinks and presses his lips together, lifts his chin a bit. “Sorry,” he says. “Right, sorry. Hello, Thorin. We do keep meeting in the oddest places, don’t we? I’m just . . . Would you believe I’m on my way home?” Bilbo pushes wet hair off his forehead.
“Really,” Thorin says, raising an eyebrow.
“Really.”
“Kíli can come up with better excuses and he’s five.”
“Well, we can’t all have Kíli’s gifts.”
“Thank God.”
Bilbo laughs a little. He really is losing it. Has to be, to be out here in the pre-dawn hours, in the rain. He’d been writing, in the upstairs study, looking out over the dark expanse of back lawn to watch the moonlight reflecting over the rough sea. The story that he set out to write isn’t the one he is actually writing. He has no clue, in fact, where that story is coming from. Every night he writes, and every morning wakes to more words than he remembers. This morning, when Thorin didn’t show up, Bilbo used his time to break his own rule about re-reading yesterday’s work. Not that it did him any good; he can’t remember a word of it now. And the attic flooded again, the water dripping down into one of the spare bedrooms. By the size of the stain on the ceiling, it must have been leaking for a while. It doesn’t make any sense. Thorin repaired the roof just days ago. Or was it longer? Standing here under the same umbrella, Bilbo feels as if they’ve known each other for ages. Perhaps Thorin can tell him, then, that the only reason he keeps dreaming about a flood is the rain and the leaking roof, and not some larger, looming disaster. That the quickening of his heart is a side-effect of over-excitement about the move up north, or of too many late-night pots of tea. Perhaps Thorin, who knows about Bywater, or at least about houses like Bywater—if any of those exist—can tell him why the lights in the front hall never seem to work, or why the phonelines only work on outgoing calls. Faulty wiring? Water damage, again?
“Are you all right?” Thorin asks, after about a minute of staring at Bilbo and waiting for him to speak. “Do you, uh, need a lift back to your house?”
“I drove into the city,” Bilbo says, and blinks twice, three times, trying to clear the image of stained walls out of his eyes and focus on Thorin instead, holding a patterned umbrella and wearing a dark t-shirt, wet across the back and shoulders, his long hair tied back messily. Is it comforting that the both of us are out here, together, inadequately dressed? he wonders. Or is it just a little bit pathetic? “At least, I think I drove. Do you know, I can’t remember where I left my car.” There’s no sign of his Triumph on the main road, or down the nearest side street. Why can’t I remember? What’s wrong with me? This is why you should have stayed a morning person, Bilbo Baggins, he tells himself.
Thorin studies him, the compactness of him: shoulders tight, back straight. He is struck, almost immediately, by how small Bilbo is, there under his umbrella. A teenager on a bicycle goes splashing past, humming off-key as he disappears into the night. There’s no reason for the two of them to continue standing there, getting wet. But then, there’s no reason for either of them to be out at this hour in the first place. So really, they’re at a pointless standstill.
“I should start walking, I suppose,” Bilbo says. “Long way home.” And he turns to go. Might as well salvage what’s left of his dignity. Next he’ll forget how to iron his shirts, or how to make his mother’s pork roast, and then where will he be?
“Wait,” Thorin blurts out, taking a step. Bilbo stops, but doesn’t turn around. “You live at least nine kilometers from here. What are you . . .”
“I would have thought that was obvious, Thorin,” Bilbo says, cocking his head to one side. Idly, he plays with the ring on his finger, turning the band against wet skin.
“You’re soaking wet.”
“Obvious,” Bilbo repeats. “Again.” He turns back around, finally. “That’s unlike you, really.”
Bilbo’s stepped far enough away from the streetlamp that Thorin can’t read the expression on his face. Thorin shifts his footing, re-centers the umbrella. “Come over,” he chances, even though it is a phenomenally bad idea for many reasons. The boys are sleeping, for one, and the walls are paper-thin. Not to mention that the two of them left on uncertain terms yesterday, and then Thorin just ignored his promise to return this morning, and yes, he did find the envelope of cash tucked into a back pocket of his coveralls and the mix of gratitude and shame that came with it was definitely not welcome. And yet here he is, saying, “Come over.”
“Over? Over to you?”
“Yeah. Er, I mean, to the flat”—Thorin, Bilbo has noticed, never calls it his flat, just the flat—“It’s just around the corner.”
“I don’t think that’s a good idea right now. Considering . . .” Bilbo trails off, preferring to leave it unsaid rather than bring up how awkward Thorin obviously is feeling around him now. It’s a measure of grace he’s offering, really, by walking away from this. And a chance to sort through his own mind before bringing in another person’s thoughts. His head is determined to become a labyrinth these days, it seems, and isn’t that new. “Considering. Hmm. Goodnight, Thorin.”
“It’s late. Bilbo, it’s nearly four in the morning.”
“Is it? Good morning, then, in that case.”
Thorin’s stepped forward and put a hand on Bilbo’s shoulder before he even realises it, and when he does, he questions what he’s even trying to do. There’s a reason he’s never invited Bilbo over, namely, that the flat is awful, utter crap. Peeling paint and mould he can’t keep out of the bathroom no matter how hard he tries, a broken pull-out couch and two wooden chairs, one of them now with a leg glued back on: it is not the sort of place you invite people to, particularly not people like Bilbo, who, though he may not always look it, comes from money. Thorin knows all of this, and is ashamed of it even as he hates being ashamed, but here he is, inviting. Why is he doing this? Why doesn’t anyone stop him? Where is his sister when he needs her?
Bilbo looks from the hand on his shoulder up to Thorin’s face, and then off into the distance, down the street. “All right,” he says, mildly. “Lead on.” This is as good a time as any, he supposes, for reconciliation. So Thorin leads them through the center of town and out into the housing estate, the buildings changing from old stone to new as they go, tall and narrow on dirty streets.
“It’s just here,” Thorin says, shaking rainwater off the umbrella. He shows Bilbo inside the building’s main door, and then up the stairs, down the hall. Bilbo toes off his wet shoes and leaves them outside before stepping into the flat. It’s dark inside, just the light over the stove casting a dim glow over the room. “The boys are asleep,” Thorin says, unlacing his boots. “I’d rather not wake them, so . . .”
“Of course. They’ve school tomorrow, don’t they?”
“Yeah.” Thorin opens a drawer and tosses a kitchen towel at Bilbo. “It’s clean,” he says, and Bilbo smiles.
“I wasn’t worried.”
“Can I, uh, offer you a dry shirt?”
“No, no, I’m all right. Thank you, Thorin.” Bilbo rubs at his wet hair until it stands on end, taking the time to look surreptitiously around the flat, taking in the sparse furnishings, the single bedroom door, the sagging couch that must be where Thorin sleeps, a tiny gas range and tinier sink, peeling linoleum on the kitchen floor. The entire flat could fit comfortably into Bywater’s front parlour. Suddenly Bilbo feels ridiculous for having such a large house with just one person in it.
“You don’t mind if I do?” Thorin asks.
“What? Oh, no, go ahead.” Wrapping the towel around his shoulders, Bilbo tries to figure out where to sit and do the least amount of damage. Wet pants on wood never ends well, though the chairs at the table are hardly fine furnishings. In a space so small, it’s impossible to be subtle about watching Thorin strip off his wet t-shirt, showing lean, tanned muscle, a line of hair down his chest. He’s a good deal thinner than Bilbo expected, for someone who gives off such an imposing impression, who has such a broad back. Thorin bends to get a dry shirt out of the middle drawer of a filing cabinet along the wall, tugs it on over still-damp hair and then fights to get his arms through. Bilbo’s trying to school his face into a more appropriate expression when Thorin turns and tosses a sweatshirt at him.
“At least put that on,” he says. “You’re drenched. What the hell were you doing, walking about in the rain like that?”
“Just . . . walking,” Bilbo says, and turns the sweatshirt over in his hands. It’s pale grey with navy lettering across the back, the International School of Furniture, and a strange crest with stags holding an urn of some sort. “I didn’t know you studied furniture making.”
“I gave that to you to wear, not talk about.”
“Sorry, I didn’t mean to pry.”
“No, I— We can talk about it, just put the damn thing on first. Getting cold just looking at you.” Thorin reminds himself not to slam the drawer shut, not to stomp into the kitchen, to set the kettle down quietly on the burner. He turns to get two mugs out of a cabinet just as Bilbo’s pulling off his own wet sweater and gets a waft of damp-wool smell, sees a pale stomach and thin wrists emerge briefly from under a t-shirt before Bilbo is swamped in Thorin’s old school sweatshirt.
“Cozy,” Bilbo says, and smiles up at Thorin. “So, furniture making?”
“Yeah. That’s my real work. Not roof repairs.”
“Well, I’m glad you made an exception just this once. Do you have any of your pieces here?”
“No. I, uh, kind of had to leave things behind in a hurry when . . . when I came up here.” Thorin swings the kettle off the burner and pours water into the mugs, adds a splash of milk to his and holds the bottle up to Bilbo, who nods and says, “Please.” Turning a listening ear to the hall, Thorin settles in against the counter opposite Bilbo and tries to figure out what words he actually wants to say. “I was a bit of a smart arse after secondary. Didn’t see the point in uni. So I worked a year at the marina, filling in the crew on fishing trawlers. Whatever got me out of the house. Saved up enough for the course, mostly because it was on the other side of the country.”
There are so many things Bilbo wants to ask about the Oakenshield family. Thorin’s mother, for one thing, and what happened to her, and how she felt about her son moving away. His own mother cried a little when he left for uni, never mind that it was only twenty kilometers away, practically just across the river, and him home every weekend and sometimes weeknights for supper. Of course, she’d later claimed they were tears of joy, for him finally getting out of the house. “And then you moved back home?” he asks, figuring that geography, at least, is a safe topic of conversation.
“Thought I was going to stay over there,” Thorin says. “A couple of lads from the program, they wanted to start up a furniture company, wanted me to join them. We'd already been working together. But land was cheaper on the other coast, and I knew the area, so we ended up moving back. Bought an old farm, set up shop in the barn, knocked down a couple of wrecked outbuildings and started building from the reclaimed lumber.”
Bilbo takes a sip of tea and smiles, recognising that he’s broken through Thorin’s conversational barrier once more, except this time there’s not quite so much grief involved. They end up talking about Oakenshield’s and Thorin’s school friends, about dovetail joints and the different chisel blades, all the tools Thorin’s hands have been missing, until the sun is just starting to lighten the skies. Utterly exhausted, in still-damp jeans, Bilbo kind of wants to just put his head down on the table right there in the flat. Maybe, he thinks, he won’t dream about floods again if he sleeps here. But Thorin is standing and stretching, pouring the long-forgotten dregs of his tea down the sink, and saying, “I should’ve driven you back hours ago.”
“I’m glad you didn’t,” Bilbo says. “Though I have to confess I’m about to fall asleep right here on your table.”
“Don’t do that,” Thorin says, too quickly. “I mean, uh, the table’s not worth it. Really, it’s junk. I could make a better one in my sleep.” Bilbo laughs at that and Thorin can’t help but smile, pleased that he’s managed—they’ve managed, together, somehow—to find a way of being in the same room together again. A soft rain falls as they drive out to Bywater, Bilbo’s head resting lightly on the window, and Thorin has never been given to metaphors but thinks that this one is fitting: for better or worse, Bilbo has become the rain to him, a steady presence, a steady present, that washes away the past.
