Chapter Text
"There are more things in Heaven and Earth,
Horatio, than are dreamt of in your philosophy.”
Hamlet, Act I, Scene V
William Shakespeare
I. One More Cup of Coffee (Hot/Cold)
“Coffee’s not bad."
He took another tentative sip of the coffee out of the mug. It was still steaming, and it was warm against his face. A nice juxtaposition to the relative chill outside. This place was warm, not just in temperature but in atmosphere, in the gaudy wood paneling he thought existed in memories of his childhood only, in the mouth-watering smell of fried eggs, bacon, and coffee, in the hum of an oldies tune on an honest to God jukebox.
“I told ya it wouldn’t disappoint. The coffee up at the Great Northern won’t disappoint either. I’ve had a lot of coffee in my life, but there’s just something right about it here.”
Will was skeptical that it was the town itself that determined how good the coffee was.
The affable man who sat in the booth in front of him speaking with great animation about coffee was called Cooper. Federal Bureau of Investigation, he had said it without the acronym, Special Agent Dale Cooper.
In the strictly aesthetic sense, Will noticed, Special Agent Dale Cooper stuck out like a sore thumb in the midst of this plaid-flannel and steel-toed-boots type of environment. Will figured he himself fit into the surrounding scene more easily, if it were purely up to aesthetics. However, it wasn’t, and the man sitting in front of him, in both attitude and mannerisms, was decidedly warm like his surroundings. Will had trouble describing it to himself any other way. Twin Peaks was–or it felt–warm, Dale Cooper was warm, Will was cold, and the coffee was, thankfully, hot.
“Is that the hotel up the road?”
“It is. If you’re looking for somewhere to stay, it does come highly recommended by me.”
Another sip of coffee for Cooper. He looked at that orange mug reverently, a look many might reserve for something of the high-art variety.
Cooper spoke again, “Say, what brings you to Twin Peaks?”
“I’d be more interested to know what brings you here.”
Not the most clever way to deflect, but he had high hopes that it would work. To continue to pry would be exceedingly impolite, and Dale Cooper seemed far from impolite.
“I see, you’d rather not share,” he raises his hands in a placating gesture, making it evident that there was a silent acknowledgement of Will’s deflection, and then continues, “A murder and an attempted murder bring me here to this fine town.”
And when Cooper said “fine town” he meant it earnestly. Not in the kind of way Will would probably say it. This guy was far from a cynic: a rare breed among FBI agents whose job it was to repeatedly witness the depths of human depravity and pretend to come out unscathed. This was all the while they were covered head to toe in the grime it left behind. With this kind of job one found that there was always some dirt stuck under one’s fingernails, some untouchable filth in the crevices of the mind, always lingering like an ancient scar, always lingering.
"A small town murder case not being handled by local authorities. So that means that there was a crossing of state lines, the local authorities asked for help–which seems unlikely–or you’ve connected this case with other murders.”
Cooper didn't beat around the proverbial bush.
“One of the victims crossed the state line after she escaped her attacker.”
“So you’ve got a direct witness to the crime? Should make your job easy.”
“Unfortunately, my friend, it does not. Ronette Pulaski is in a coma.”
“Who was the girl who was murdered?”
“Her name was Laura Palmer. Local homecoming queen. She was found on the shore of a local lake, wrapped in plastic. She was only seventeen years old.”
A genuinely doleful note in that last sentence in particular; a striking contrast to the priorly cheerful lilt of Cooper’s voice. A morose pause before and after it. In such a space, Will found, were kept the unspoken dreams of what could have been. There is always such a space in a statement like: she was only seventeen years old.
So what had gone so wrong for dead Laura Palmer?
His thoughts began to drift out. He could already picture the scene in his head. In fact, it was less that he was actively picturing it and more that his brain was impressing it upon him against his will, as it often did with many things. Laura. Who was Laura? Why did he—statistically, probably a he, though he supposed nothing could be ruled out, especially with the little information he’d just been given—kill her?
Homecoming Queen. Laura. Wrapped in Plastic
He hadn’t even seen a photograph of the poor girl, and yet he was already trying to understand the significance of things. For instance, the plastic. The plastic meant something, as things like that always did. It could either be simply for ease of transport, or it could be that the killer wanted it to be known what had happened was deliberate.
Instinctually, he felt it was the latter, or at the very least, he was indifferent to it being seen as a murder. He might not be ashamed, then. Had he been ashamed he would have hidden her in a place where she wouldn’t so easily wash up, somewhere she wouldn't so soon come back to haunt the townsfolk.
Because Will did not know this Laura, in fact, he barely knew of her, but that's what happened with such a case in a small town. It haunted. It haunted in the new curfews the town would enforce on its youth, in the young girl’s room left alone never again to be touched, in the name acknowledged at graduation and at reunions after that, the name, but no living, breathing, person. The chill, the gut-dropping feeling of a lack, a void, a nothing where there should be something.
It would be even worse if the case went cold.
Like Catherine Earnshaw’s spirit, haunting the moorland of Wuthering Heights, begging for a respite from her eternal wandering, he could imagine a girl pleading from outside the window of one of these outdated houses in the dead of winter. He imagined her shivering and blue, her hands pressed against the panes, repeating desperately, “Let me in! Let me in!” but getting no answer.
Who was Laura? He had to feel like he knew her, in some sense, to have any idea who killed her.
This isn’t your case. You’re not doing this anymore. Back away now. Stop it.
“It’s not like it is in the city, this kind of case,” Cooper said, anchoring him back to reality before he could float away too far down the stream of making up shit about something he knew little to nothing about.
To learn or not to learn? God, once he knew it, he wouldn’t be able to take it back. He wouldn’t be able to take it back. It wasn’t completely a cliche that to know less was sometimes better, because as irresponsible as it was, ignorance was an irrefutably zen thing. That was until the post-effects of it started to bang at your head like a gong, making your ears ring and bringing on a splitting headache in consequence.
As a response Will offered, “What you mean to say is that in a place like this she will be missed.”
“That’s an understatement, really. Everyone is affected by it in some way or another, and in a place like this you just don’t see this kind of violent crime. Life still means something here.”
“I…I, uh, I get that, actually.”
“Are you from a small town, Will?”
“I’m not, but, it’s just that I’ve seen a lot of this kind of violence in my time, and how it affects people.”
“You work in law enforcement?”
“Yeah. I was a cop at one time, and more recently, I taught at the Academy. Did some profiling for the BSU for a while.”
He wanted to be honest while saying as little as possible.
“You didn’t tell me you were a man of the Bureau, Will! I suppose we have a lot more in common than I thought.”
Cooper finished off the last of his coffee, sat the mug down, and gave Will a smile of approval. Will understood the sentiment, but could only bring himself to nod once in response. His lack of enthusiasm didn’t curtail Cooper’s, who hailed down a pretty, light blue-uniformed waitress.
“More coffee?”
“You know me well, Norma! And two pieces of that fabulous cherry pie you have here,” he looked at Will, “You want a piece of cherry pie? It’s really something, trust me.”
“I’m fine, thanks.”
Cooper paused a moment before he spoke again, his mouth still creased upward in a content smile. That’s what this man appeared to have droves of that Will found baffling: contentment.
“What’re the odds, huh?” He mused, with a sense of wonderment and enviable clarity.
Clarity. If Cooper swam in clear, serene waters, Will knew that he himself swam in opaque waters. And if Cooper was content, Will was deeply uneasy. Not about his current situation, which wasn’t by any means bad, but about his life as a whole and how it persistently greeted him like a total stranger these days. It had ever since–no, no need to think about that.
“They’re definitely not very high, I suppose.”
“Call it kismet, then.”
“Kismet, sure.”
“Will, you’re gonna have to forgive me for not catching on earlier.”
“Well, uh, I guess I don’t exactly look the part. I’m not doing it anymore, anyway. Working with the FBI, that is.”
The waitress, Norma, placed two pieces of cherry pie in front of Cooper, and then refilled his cup of coffee. Without asking, Norma filled up Will’s only half-empty cup as well.
The coffee was good, certainly. It was quite good, in fact. He just wasn’t as psyched about it, or really anything, as Cooper seemed to be. He wasn’t apathetic about it, either. It was only that, at the moment, he was taking it slow. The aspirin he’d taken earlier was causing some heartburn, and the acidic nature of coffee only had the chance to add to that like fuel to flame. If anything, he knew he should probably drink water, but he needed caffeine. That had become clear when he’d grown bleary-eyed from driving, and nearly had a head-on encounter with a Douglas Fir.
“Thank you so much Norma. And Will, I’m sorry to hear that,” Cooper lamented, before he took a bite of his pie, savoring it, “Man, this is good. You’re absolutely positive you don’t want any pie?”
“Positive. Sorry to disappoint.”
He looked a little incredulous, but shook it off, and then continued, “What made you leave this line of work? If you don’t mind me asking.”
Actually, Will did mind him asking. He wasn’t even sure why he’d sat down at this booth with Cooper to begin with, other than the fact that it might pass some time until he could find somewhere to stay, and it had seemed polite, though in his life he couldn’t remember ever really caring about being polite.
The social expectation was that he would give up some kind of information. Though however kind this man was, the idea of sharing the mess that was his life with someone so seemingly put together, this man who donned a well ironed suit, slicked back his hair, talked like he was in an old movie, and who was positively effervescent in attitude in a way diametrically opposed to himself, it made him uneasy.
“I guess you could say that it got to me,” is what he offered. Simple, and enough, he hoped.
It more than got to him, though.
Saying the work had “gotten to him” in relation to what he had been through felt like the definition of an understatement and bordered on an outright lie.
The crime scenes had been bad enough for his state of mind, but that wasn’t what had done him in the end. He certainly wouldn't have been able to keep working in the field indefinitely, but he imagined he might have been able to continue for some time if things had gone another route.
After all, it was no crime scene that had pushed him to his limits (and past them). It turned out to be a someone rather than a something that “got to him.” That someone pulled him apart into little tiny pieces. Shattered the proverbial teacup, brought it back together, and shattered it again. He had become molecules, gone back to the stardust from which he had come, to the primeval state. Being nothing, being dust, felt familiar. He’d seen so many people turn to dust, why shouldn’t he? Wasn’t it ultimately what he was?
Some part of him had wanted to remain dust, so that he had no decision to make, no thinking to do. He would simply go with the Wind. The temptation to stay in that state was strong. He floated in space and then nearly dissolved, but was snatched up and refigured in the heat of a forge by the Demiurge, the Ruler of this World—of His World, at least. The Ruler of His World, whom he liked to think had no sway over him anymore. To arts unknown he bends his wits, and alters nature. One could not explain the entity that is Hannibal Lecter. They had to live it or die it to know.
There was no way to elaborate on such an experience past a certain point. It was ineffable.
As soon as Will Graham—name to him then unknown—strode into the Double R Diner, Dale Cooper knew he wasn’t from Twin Peaks.
In superficial ways Will Graham appeared more like a local than he did, looking much more small town America in a tucked flannel and dark blue jeans than Cooper. His hair, curly, coffee bean colored, wasn’t particularly styled to be professional, and he had a short beard. His frame was somewhat wiry but lean enough that he could still imagine the man as a lumberjack working at the mill, or imagine seeing him fishing as he drove by the Black Lake. In appearance alone, this man could easily be a resident of sleepy old Twin Peaks.
But had he been a local, he would have waved at someone, asked Norma or Shelly what the special was, or looked, in general, much less like he was happy to allow himself to fold up and disappear among other people. Other people, who chatted loudly over their meals, called to a friend who just walked in, or spoke of the recent tragedy of one of their own, found wrapped in plastic, washed up on the shore of the lake they grew up swimming in during the summer, the memory forever tainted now.
Cooper had learned in his brief time here that people from Twin Peaks didn’t lack presence or want to lack it. Everyone had a kind of wholeness and an individuality about them that there was a room for in this town that there didn’t seem to be everywhere else. It was one of the paradoxes of the place. So small, and yet so much room. So familiar and so unnerving. So warm apple-pie smelling double-decker American home and so dark, frigid, plastic-wrapped place you were terrified of. So comfortably inconsistent. He loved it.
Another thing Cooper noticed when Graham had arrived: Graham didn’t look present in the room. He was occupied inwardly, eyes glazed over. Looking inward. There was a veil between whatever was going on in his mind and this place. He kept his eyes locked with the floor, as if making eye contact was some deadly thing to be avoided. Yes, definitely not a local. That made Cooper all the more interested to find out who this was, because being an outsider in a place like this could get lonely. Every other outsider who showed their face was here for work only, like Albert, who had done nothing here except be hostile to the point of getting him a whack in the face by Sheriff Truman.
Maybe it was part of the recurring serendipity of Twin Peaks that, occupied in his own mind, Graham appeared to nearly trip over a chair that someone had forgotten to push all of the way back in at their departure. He caught himself with the chair itself before he could fall over it. Still, he had managed to hit his shin pretty hard on it.
Here, Cooper had an excuse to say something that wasn’t terribly awkward or abrupt. Not that he wouldn’t have greeted the stranger anyway, this was Twin Peaks, after all, but this just made it easier, and he found he held genuine concern. Who wouldn’t, after all?
“You alright there, friend?”
“I’m fine,” Graham had grumbled. This was despite the other man speaking with the kind of attitude Cooper imagined was befitting a sleepwalker woken early. The veil had been pulled away. A heavy wool blanket pulled swiftly off in the chill of winter. Goosebumps rising.
Not, not fine at all. Severely discontented. Needs coffee and good conversation to warm him up, maybe.
...
In the present moment, Cooper knew almost precisely what Will Graham meant when he said that working for the FBI had gotten to him. Things had gotten personal, in some sense. He could read that easily, in the unnatural silence after Graham’s words and his sudden captivation at his coffee, as he began to sip it down at a much faster rate, to have something to fill his mouth, so that no more could be said, so that nothing could even slip out by mere accident. He had just retreated so far back into his shell.
Cooper understood letting this work get to you, letting things in that shouldn’t be too close. He understood how the consequences of such actions could be devastating, how the shrapnel could hit so many people besides just oneself; how all you could do was watch and do nothing besides suffer in the aftermath.
It was his turn to say, “I understand where you’re coming from, Will. There have been things that have happened in the past that have made me consider retiring from the Bureau as well.”
“Really?”
Now, that properly caught his attention.
“Let’s just say I failed to protect someone that it was my duty to protect, and not a day goes by that I don’t think about it.”
Will didn’t press for any more information. After all, Cooper had backed off when they’d reached a sensitive subject for him, so he would reciprocate. After a few moments of uncharacteristic silence and lack of movement from Cooper, he began again to work on his piece of pie. Or, rather, his second piece. Will knew then that it was okay for him to continue on, preferably to a different subject.
“Tell me more about this girl who was murdered—Laura Palmer.”
Once you know you can’t not know. Once you know you can’t give it back. It will stay.
“Well, Will, by most accounts she was your typical high school girl. She was homecoming queen, tutored, delivered meals on wheels for people who can’t leave their houses, grew up relatively well-off with parents who care for her. That’s the general consensus amongst the townsfolk.”
“You said most accounts?”
“Well, by all accounts, really. Though, apparently, Laura had secrets.”
“What teenage girl doesn’t? Hell, what sort of a person doesn't?”
And despite Will saying what he did in that moment, he knew when Cooper mentioned Laura having secrets, he meant those kinds of secrets that could entirely alter your view of a person, of a case like this—he’d shared those kinds of secrets before. The kinds that were life-altering. The kind that blinded you, and as the scales fell from your eyes, you no longer saw through a glass darkly, but saw things as they truly were. Face-to-face, for better or for worse.
In a moment, thinking of being face-to-face, Will added, “But I’m guessing these weren’t your typical secrets."
“Will, you’re exactly right.”
“Do you have any idea of who could have killed her yet?”
“You see, that’s the thing with this case,” Cooper had finished his pie. He stacked his plates and wiped his mouth with a napkin, and went on, “On the surface, you would expect it to turn out to be straightforward, a boyfriend, or something of that nature, but I’m starting to think this may be the least-straightforward case I’ve encountered in my time at the Federal Bureau of Investigation. That is to say, we have very little in the way of suspects currently.”
“The killer went after two girls. Is it possible he's killed before? I mean, do you think this is a crime of passion, or do you think he planned it?”
“According to my gut instinct and everything I’ve examined?”
“Yeah.”
“I fear it could be both, from the method in which she was killed combined with other information that I’m not at liberty to share.”
“Not at liberty—I forgot, for a moment, you know. That I’m not working in this case and all. Did it for so long. I know you can’t tell me specifics, can't alert whatever public there is to alert, but what do you mean by other information?”
“By other information, I mean that there were connections made between Laura Palmer’s murder and that of another young woman found last year in Tacoma, a girl named Teresa Banks.”
“So it wasn’t just about the crossing of state lines?”
An eyebrow raised, as if to ask the silent question of whether or not the information had been purposefully withheld.
“It was until we found the connection.”
“And that connection probably wouldn’t have been found if the Pulaski girl never crossed state lines. You wanna talk about kismet? Now, that’s kismet, if there really is such a thing.”
“You're an insightful one, Will. You said you used to profile for the Behavioral Science Unit?”
“Used to, yeah.”
“Are you gonna be in town long?”
“I don't know.”
And he truthfully didn't. He hadn't come here for any particular reason. The idea was that he would drive around, see different parts of the country, without the baggage of doing it in the attempt to find someone, or look at the gory display of yet another killer. Even so, here he was, hearing about a murder. Murder stuck to him like dog hair on a black shirt. Or he stuck to it. It was one of the two.
“If you are, and I can get permission, maybe you could look over what we have so far. It’s always good to have many sets of eyes to look these things over.”
“I’m not sure if I should,” he shrugged, now feeling hesitant about the suggestion. The idea of looking into this case had seemed appealing a moment ago because it felt, in his mind, a far-off idea. He had sincerely felt invested in hearing of Laura Palmer’s case, but that was hearing of it, nothing more required. He could surely hear of something without becoming involved. He was distancing himself from these things. Besides, he’d concluded he would likely get to read about the solving of the case, because surely it would be solved. Really, it probably wouldn’t go cold.
Now that Cooper had essentially offered to get him permission to look over the case, there was an odd skittish sensation in him. He was not only out of practice and jittery at the idea of working a case again, even if recreationally, he was also deliberately avoiding immersing himself in these so-called evil minds (as Crawford might have put it). Last time he jumped into one, he'd ended up in the deep end, spluttering and trying desperately to keep his head above water. He survived, if only because he was pulled out of the water just in time. As he looked up at his savior, it was that coal-black creature that stared down at him like the warped counterpart of John the Baptiser. It had not been a light sprinkling of blood on the head but a full immersion.
He thought of the girl at the window again.
Then he thought of the percentage of homicides that didn’t get solved, something he’d done on and off since he stopped working for the FBI, every time he was unwillingly exposed to a bloody headline. He felt that archaic sense of obligation creeping up into him, that same sense that Jack Crawford held over his head so he would continue doing his bidding, the idea that if he could do something, he probably should. Was it a real obligation he felt, or was it something he had convinced himself he felt? That was the type of thing Hannibal would have asked him. He currently had no veritable answer to that question, and felt he never would.
“No trouble, Will. No trouble at all. I understand if you don’t want to. How about—how about you take some time to think it over?”
“I think that would be a good idea.”
