Chapter Text
“Someone once told me time is a flat circle.
Everything we've ever done or will do we're gonna
do over and over and over again—forever."
True Detective, Season 1, Episode 5
II. Nothing New Under the Sun
Will could hear the faint hum of a catchy jazz tune before he caught onto anything else in the dream. It filled the room like a thick smoke, wafting in and out around him and filling his head with a sluggish kind of noise. It had no identifiable point of origin. There was no speaker or record player in sight. As he looked for the music’s origin point, he became aware of sitting in a room of some kind. He was boxed in on all sides with velvet curtains colored something like crimson, the crimson red sinking more into garnet in the shadowy dips and valleys. The patterned floor beneath him was a headache-inducing and stark black and white chevron.
Two black velvet armchairs sat adjacent to him, and he sat in one just like it. Behind and on either end of each chair was a grey, minimalist-style Y-lamp. Next to one lamp and behind one of the lounge chairs, the one furthest from him, stood a statue of the Venus De Medici, her white stone figure standing perpetually posed, demurely hiding her nakedness with her hands, as she stood out like a reverse silhouette with the curtains behind her. From his position, she appeared to be glancing away from him, at nothing in particular, except vaguely at the sea of red.
Where the hell was his mind getting all of this?
There were recurring figures that appeared in his dreams, in his visions, but never any places that stood out to him so starkly. He didn’t have a mind palace like Hannibal did, hadn’t yet taken the time to construct one, and if he did have a mind palace, he would have made it to look more like his own home, or a nice stream where he liked to fish, and less like the Limbo you sat in before you could be taken to the First Circle with Virgil as your guide. Which of God’s servants was sent to the pit after designing this place?
If not to Hell, it undoubtedly had the atmosphere of a place that was a prelude to something. A not-quite place. An unplace. Like the obscured background of a photograph, like an elevator to the 13th floor.
Will was in half a mind to stand and walk through the curtains, just to see if anything lay beyond them, beyond that void of rippling velvet. It might just be the case that his mind had constructed nothing past those curtains, and that would be the wake-up trigger for this dream. Truly, he was hoping that would be the case. He would stand and walk past those curtains and wake up, and this place, being so vivid in his memory now, would disappear like salt stirred into water. Mixed into his wider consciousness, it would be undetectable.
When he attempted to stand up, placing both hands on the arms of the chairs for leverage, he found his muscles taut, out of his control. He was compelled to sit by a great invisible weight. Gravity had shifted, had become too much, his muscles ached so he let go.
For a moment, he was reminded of Italy.
A rustling of the show-curtains beside him. The only sound besides the slow-paced jazz. A figure walking forth slowly, confidently, in a way that told him she belonged here and he didn't.
This was no unfamiliar girl.
She’d appeared in his dreams many times. Usually, she had fishing gear on and an unblemished neck and two ears. Now, she wore what he'd last seen her in. She lacked one ear, which he could easily see with her hair up in a ponytail, and she was bearing two distinct knife scars on her throat, one nearly overlapping the other.
What was most different about her, most alarming, even, was her eyes.
This dream-Abigail lacked any semblance of color in her eyes. A white film covered them. They weren’t fully white marble, though. There was an idea of color, a shadow outlining the circular shape of the iris, but nothing more than that. It created the appearance of two sickly offwhite pearls staring back at him. Or rather, through him. He could not see into them to communicate. He could not see into them to understand them. He’d never been good at such a thing in the first place but now even the possibility was gone.
Will was not fond of eye-contact, and never had been, so it was an exceedingly rare occasion that he would have the active desire to look someone in the eyes.
This was different, as he now found himself with the urge to peel back the egg white film that obscured their worlds, so that they could see face to face. With that urge, he distracted himself momentarily with the mildly amusing revelation that he understood the so-called monomania of the narrator of the Tell-Tale Heart.
A pale-blue eye, with a film over it. Whenever it fell upon me, my blood ran cold.
Will could never previously understand the obsession with eyes before, the fixation that some had with them. He would have liked, conceptually, the idea of a curtain between his eyes and the eyes of others. Then, true eye-contact would be impossible. This, however, gave him some kind of an internal-chill. Maybe it was the glassy dead look in the eyes of something animated and moving that broke the instinctual view of reality one had internally built.
His view of the world had been forcibly altered before, so it could happen again, if need be. But really, it needn’t happen.
No, it didn’t have to happen, because none of this existed in reality. None of this would stay. It would slip away, maybe as soon as he woke. What he was currently experiencing was nothing more than a dream his mind had conjured to fuck with him. After all, his mind’s favorite pastime was fucking with him.
He was conscious of dreaming, and that hasn’t woken him. He couldn’t stand up and walk through the curtains in an attempt to wake. He doubted pinching himself would work, but he was desperate enough to try.
It didn’t work.
Wakeupwakeupwakeup.
He acquiesced. He had to see this through, didn’t he? He had to go with this phantasmagoria presented to him. He probably even had to interact with it.
Interact with it, move it forward, and maybe get it over with.
He wondered if he should speak. Or even if he could speak at all. His unconscious mind had already revoked his ability to stand up, why not his speech, too?
“Abigail?”
So speaking was not one of his limitations.
Relief at not being stifled washed over him. His voice had been loud, crisp, clear in this place where there had been no sound but his voice. The jazz music had faded out some time ago, maybe when he was thinking about her pale eyes. He couldn’t pinpoint when it ended. In its place, without the interruption of his voice, was a precarious silence waiting to be filled.
".dneirf ym tem ev'uoy ees I”
Wrong. It struck him. All wrong. Just like the eyes. It was bizarre, the way she spoke. Her voice sounded like it was being spun in reverse, like a record during the Satanic Panic. He knew that no version of her that his mind created could be wholly her. It would only ever be a kind of a simulacrum built of his knowledge of her. This was just so profoundly disquieting. But he couldn't get angry at this being presented to him; he supposed it was the case he probably deserved to be tormented like this. He supposed he deserved the discomfort. It was his penance, his subconscious’s version of self-flagellation.
"Your friend?"
Partially, he expected his voice to begin to emulate hers. It didn't. He continued to exist in this reality, and she in hers.
".remlaP aruaL"
“I haven't met Laura Palmer, Abigail,” he reasoned to dream-entity Abigail, “I've only heard of her.”
She simply shook her head, and repeated, ".dneirf ym tem ev'uoy ees I”
She gestured to his left. The curtain rustled again, and into the liminal room walked a blonde girl with bangs and a formal black dress. Laura, or who he assumed must be his mentally created version of Laura, said nothing. She took her time walking over and sitting in the chair furthest from him, while Abigail backed away and sat in the chair closest to him, as if pulled by a magnetic force to sit.
“You're Laura Palmer?”
Dream Abigail and Laura shared a look. They shared an idea. He knew it well. They knew something that he didn't.
If this was in his mind, how could they share knowledge of something he had none of? How was that fair? He knew if it was happening in his mind, he must know what it was they shared, his mind was just being stubborn and hiding it from him.
“I dna dneirf yM,” Laura spoke, sharing the same kind of off-kilter speech as Abigail, “.nommoc ni hcum os evah eW.”
“What do you have in common?”
Another shared look by the two girls, but no response given. Of course. He’d have to figure that one out himself, if there was really anything to it. It was just coherent enough not to sound like complete nonsense, but so vague that it might just be that. It was the kind of thing that went on in his mind much of the time.
The jazz faded back in after an indeterminate amount of silence wherein no one spoke. The air seemed too thick to speak for some time, as if something would be interrupted if anyone were to do so. He felt the pressure of air in his ears. He was sure he even felt them pop at some point. His jaw ached. There was an air bubble in his stomach, then in his esophagus, waiting to come up. But it never came, and the feeling of air fullness stayed.
This felt preliminary to something, like waiting for something. The waiting room to limbo it once again seemed. It was like being on hold and waiting desperately for someone to pick up the line.
Hello, operator? Hello, operator? Hello, operator? Are you there? Anybody there? Static. He thought of some of the crime scenes he’d seen in his time, some of the crimes he’d studied. Sometimes a killer would cut telephone lines to the house of their victim. Back when that was a thing to worry about it was an appalling thought. Being boxed into an enclosed space with death, communication with the outside, civilized world taken away with a sharp object. Static.
Static buzzing in his head, the audio equivalent of TV snow. A break to the monotony came when he began to feel something warm running down his face. Movement. Movement of what? Water, he thought it must be. Here in limbo, they had leaky pipes. Could the condemned expect any better?
It wasn’t water. He began to smell copper, and some of the liquid dripped into his eyes and stung, and there was a red haze in one of them as if a filter had been put over his vision. His stomach tightened, and to his mind came the image of being unable to move and a vindictive Hannibal standing in front of him with a saw, waxing poetic to Jack Crawford about the merits of getting, quite literally, inside Will’s head.
He could feel, again, that transcendent kind of terror he’d felt then. He’d waded in a warm spring of it, and became, nearly, the frog being boiled slowly as the heat was turned up on the burner. It struck him then that he needed to move, to get up off this chair and out of this place. There was some dread in him that he would be held down again as he tried to move.
But, as soon as a drop of blood fell down onto his pants, he was up and moving in a flight response, because what, really, was there to fight? Himself? He’d done that enough already.
The un-eyes of Laura and Abigail followed him as he sprinted across the room and headlong into the heavy red show curtains.
He did not wake.
As the curtains split he knew he was out of the room but not out of this place. Simply, he was in an extension of it, a hallway. To his left stood the gracefully armless Venus De Milo. He walked forward, through the curtains again. The room he entered was shaped the same as the previous one had been, except this time it was lacking both the furniture and the statue. When Will stopped moving to process the nothing in front of him, he felt the blood continue to drip down his face. Some was on the floor, now, polluting the chevron with a cherry red of fresh blood.
His abdomen stung. It more than stung, really. He went to run his hand over his scar. There was something familiar about this. The tearing of flesh, the burning radiating and spreading out like an acid all over his gut and further. The leaking of blood pooling down to the ground and meeting the smaller pool from his forehead. Oh, what the hell was this?
The sound of liquid gushing and his own heartbeat in his ears was all he could hear until the curtains rustled again. Maybe it was “Abigail” again, or this Laura he’d finally met.
Will looked up from the stained floor to see his eviscerator. Well, his original eviscerator. He wasn’t sure who to blame now, to blame his mind, memory, or this creature that took the form of Hannibal Lecter in front of him. He didn’t know the rules, the laws of this place, and his mind didn’t want to accept it as a place in and of itself, to conceptualize it that way, because that would be nonsense. This place wasn’t its own entity. It had no existence on its own, when he, the observer, the dreamer, wasn’t here. He had created it and was putting himself through it. It was nothing like his mind had ever put him through, but now it was and,
This isn’t a place.
This Hannibal in front of him was much like the version that existed in reality, and therefore much like the version of him that appeared in both dreams and nightmares, not including the Wendigo. He donned a three-piece suit, stylish and blue, and somewhat eccentric as was usual with him. All the markings of a man who’d fallen through time and landed in the modern world. He was Mephistopheles, sent to convert Doctor Faust. He was Satan making a deal with the Lord. A kind of a living superstition, uprooting his own earth and bringing it with him where he went, his true nature uncomprehended by nearly all people, people who tried to ward it off. Not all people because there was one other who did understand.
But just like Abigail, those dark eyes he was used to were altogether gone, replaced by that filmy eggwhite look she’d had. His generally beautiful, even if somewhat gaunt, countenance became a good deal more cadaverous without the darks of his eyes. The shadows of this dreamscape (Will couldn’t figure where the light source was) helped very little. Again, he wanted to peel back those whites and see what was behind him. Hannibal would find that amusing, very probably, given that their first ever conversation had been over the fact that he didn’t enjoy eye contact.
Not fond of eye contact?
Eyes are distracting.
This version of Hannibal stepped forward.
“?yaw ym gnioG”
“I can’t…” he began, “You’re not…I don’t understand. Where are you going?”
His head and his midsection were still bleeding, running down his body and pooling onto the floor in greater amounts than Will understood possible.
An impish smile. That smile of mischief that Will knew well.
“.wonk uoY”
“Actually, I don’t know.”
Will backed up so that he could almost feel the velvet curtains behind him. This Hannibal had moved forward, extending a hand to lead him.
Hannibal asked again, “?yaw ym gnioG”
“Maybe if you’d tell me where you’re going.”
That wasn’t the truth. He knew it. The dream Hannibal knew it, as Will continued to back up so that his back was against the curtains.
“.lliW, taht rebmemeR .nus eht rednu wen gnihtoN”
And so, Will fled this particular room and sprinted. He knew there probably wasn’t a point in running. After all, he was leaving the worst possible bread crumb trail, one of his own uncontained blood betraying whichever way he ran. Besides, this was a dream, and whatever wanted to find him in a dream would. A dream was supposed to be one’s unconscious mind processing experiences, wasn’t it?
He ran into something. A person.
“Will? What’re you doing here?”
It was Abigail, but the one with blue eyes, the one that he knew or had known. There was a genuine upset in the brief moment he could glimpse her face.
“Abigail? Didn’t I just see you?”
...
Will became aware of the smell of pine trees and cleaning supplies and the fried smell of breakfast (that delicious blend of coffee, bacon grease, and fried eggs that shouldn’t go together as well as it did) wafting from other rooms or from downstairs, he couldn’t tell which. He was horizontal, lying in the relatively comfortable bed provided by Twin Peaks’ Great Northern Hotel. He felt a chill. He’d sweated through his shirt ,and the cool temperature of the room didn’t help. He couldn’t yet bring himself to move, despite the chill and the dampness of his shirt feeding into that chill. That was because he didn’t quite feel embodied. This hotel room, his waking awareness, felt less real than what he’d just experienced, and he could remember it all, down to the detail. He could recall the jazz tune especially and felt it floating in and out of his memory. He could remember the blank eyes and the hair on the back of his neck standing on end.
Later that day at the Twin Peaks Sheriff's Station, he saw, for the first time, the face of Laura Palmer smiling in her picture as homecoming queen, his stomach dropped, and he felt frozen, hollow, like a bell. He felt faint, his throat dry, his hands tingling.
Because this wasn’t the first time he’d seen her.
“.nommoc ni hcum os evah eW.”
