Chapter Text
The cafeteria hummed with the usual midday din—trays clattering, conversations tumbling over each other, the underlying chaos of teenage routine. Abigail and Chandra had claimed their usual table under the drafty side window, half-shielded from the noise.
Chandra was picking at her tiffin of lemon rice and chickpeas. Abigail had a sandwich and carrot sticks packed in immaculate rows—clearly one of Hannibal’s more subtle meals.
“He even cut them on the bias,” Chandra muttered. “It’s like eating art. Kind of makes me want to rebel and eat it with my fingers.”
Abigail smirked. “Do it. I won’t narc.”
“I’d hope not,” Chandra said. “I’ve seen you fake an entire moral breakdown to avoid gym class. You could get away with murder.”
Abigail smiled but didn’t answer.
Then—click.
The cafeteria speakers popped once, and everyone flinched just a little before the voice came through.
“Attention students and faculty. This is Principal Alders. Due to ongoing public safety concerns and updated police guidance, all students will be released early today. Buses will arrive within the hour. Please wait in your assigned areas and check your email for further updates.”
The buzz in the room stilled for a moment—then swelled into a low roar of confused, nervous voices.
“Shit,” Chandra said softly.
“Popcorn Killer,” Abigail muttered. “Too close.”
Across the cafeteria, someone stood and said too loudly, “It’s probably fake! Just to freak us out!”
Someone else snapped, “Then why is school closing?”
“I don’t like this,” Chandra whispered, gripping her lunchbox. “He’s not even targeting anyone specific, right? Random people? It could be anyone.”
Abigail’s face hardened a little. Her voice dropped. “It won’t be you.”
Chandra looked at her. “You don’t know that.”
“I do,” Abigail said. “Because if he tries, he won’t make it to the second attempt.”
Their eyes locked.
Something passed between them—fear, yes, but also something steadier. Heavier.
A choice.
Chandra exhaled and looked around at the cafeteria as if seeing it differently now. “You think it’s today?”
“I think people panic before the storm,” Abigail said. “And sometimes... they're right to.”
The school front lawn buzzed like a disturbed hive—students gathered in loose clusters, some pacing, some sitting, some pretending not to be scared. Teachers stood around in high-visibility vests with clipboards, trying to maintain order with forced smiles and frayed patience.
Abigail stood with her backpack slung over one shoulder, arms crossed, eyes scanning the lot.
Chandra hovered beside her, chewing the inside of her cheek. “My parents are on their way. My dad called and yelled at a teacher from traffic. My mom’s probably prepping a lecture about how you’re a bad influence.”
Abigail smirked. “I mean, she’s not wrong.”
Chandra elbowed her gently. “She doesn’t know anything.”
Abigail’s gaze drifted to the curb just as a sleek, deep gray car pulled up—Will behind the wheel, eyes hidden behind dark glasses, jaw tense. Hannibal sat in the passenger seat, gloved hands folded neatly in his lap, his posture perfect and unreadable.
They didn’t get out.
They didn’t need to.
Abigail straightened. “That’s me.”
Chandra turned to look—and blinked. “Okay. Why do they look like they just got back from burying someone in the woods?”
Abigail gave her a small smile. “Because they probably did.”
Chandra opened her mouth, then paused. “I can never tell when you’re kidding.”
“You shouldn’t try.”
From the opposite side of the crowd came the unmistakable sound of a car horn—sharp, aggressive, insistent. A red SUV pulled into the lot like it owned the place, almost clipping a traffic cone. Chandra’s parents spilled out, both shouting over each other before they even reached the sidewalk.
“—you said you’d wait at the side entrance—!”
“—I told you it’s the front! Why would she be in the back if they’re evacuating?!”
“Chandra!” her mom barked. “We’re leaving. Now.”
Chandra sighed, looked at Abigail, and started to walk—then hesitated.
Abigail walked toward her.
They met halfway between the two cars.
Neither spoke for a second. Around them, teachers barked names, students crammed into buses, the world swelled with noise.
But the space between them was still.
“You okay?” Abigail asked.
Chandra nodded. “You?”
“I will be.”
They didn’t hug. Didn’t need to.
But as they stepped back toward their respective rides, they both paused—turned—and locked eyes.
Abigail standing at the edge of something old and sharpened.
Chandra pulled by something safe but suffocating.
For just a second, it was like the crowd melted away.
And then—
Abigail got into the car beside Hannibal, silent and composed.
Chandra disappeared into her parents’ SUV, windows tinted, voices already rising inside.
Two cars.
Two directions.
But eyes still searching.
The house was too quiet.
Abigail stood in the library doorway, arms folded, back straight like a soldier awaiting orders. Hannibal was across the room, placing a book back on the shelf with careful deliberation. Will leaned against the desk, his eyes heavy but sharp.
“You’re not to leave the house,” Hannibal said without looking at her.
Abigail’s mouth tightened. “I wasn’t planning to sneak out.”
“This isn’t punishment,” Will added. “It’s containment.”
“Like I’m a pathogen?” she shot back.
“Like you’re a target,” Will corrected. “One we’d rather not see gutted in a park.”
Abigail’s jaw clenched. She hated the logic mostly because she couldn’t argue with it.
Hannibal turned at last, folding his hands. “This killer is impulsive, erratic—but skilled. He escalated without warning. That implies confidence.”
“Or desperation,” Will muttered. “He’s getting sloppy.”
“Sloppy doesn’t mean harmless.”
Abigail looked between them. “So what now?”
“We go hunting,” Hannibal said simply.
Abigail blinked. “Tonight?”
Will nodded once. “We have leads. Partial patterns. He’s circling somewhere near the university district.”
“And I stay here like some Victorian daughter locked in the attic?”
“No,” Will said. “Like someone we don’t want to lose.”
Abigail looked at him for a long moment, then dropped her eyes. “Fine.”
Later that night – Hours pass
The grandfather clock ticked too loudly. The fire burned low. The house creaked like it knew something was missing.
Abigail sat curled on the living room couch, a knife resting beside her on the armrest, phone silent in her lap.
No messages from Chandra.
No updates from Will or Hannibal.
Just the slow crawl of time.
Then—
The front door opened.
Footsteps. Two sets. Heavy. Agitated.
Abigail stood before they even entered the room.
Will was the first to speak, stripping off his coat. “Nothing.”
Hannibal followed, gloves half-off, face tight and unsmiling. “Three false alarms. One mutilated deer. And a very uncooperative homeless man who nearly stabbed Will.”
“He missed,” Will said dully, rubbing his temple.
Abigail raised an eyebrow. “Did you stab back?”
Will gave her a faint glare.
Hannibal peeled off his scarf, hung it with deliberate slowness. “We’re circling something—but it eludes us. For now.”
Will dropped into a chair. “He’s not following a full pattern. He’s playing with chaos.”
Abigail watched them, her voice quiet. “Do you think he knows you’re looking?”
Will stared into the fireplace. “If he doesn’t yet, he will soon.”
Hannibal sat across from him, fingers steepled. “And then, he’ll come to us.”
Abigail folded her arms, gaze sharp. “What if he comes when I’m alone?”
“You won’t be,” Hannibal said simply.
“You’re the bait now,” Will added. “And we’re the trap.”
The next morning.
Breakfast sat untouched.
The kitchen was filled not with the smell of coffee or herbs, but tension.
Abigail leaned against the counter, arms crossed, eyes clear. Hannibal stood by the sink, slicing grapefruit with mechanical precision. Will hovered in the doorway, mug in hand, jaw tight.
“I’m serious,” Abigail said. “He’s targeting public spaces. The theater on Main is the perfect lure. It’s chaotic, it’s dark, and people won’t pay attention. Chandra and I go in, act normal. You two wait outside, watch for anything. When he shows—because he will—you take him out. Clean. Done.”
Will set his mug down with a thud. “No.”
Hannibal didn’t look up from his cutting board. “Absolutely not.”
Abigail pushed off the counter. “Why not? I’m not helpless, and Chandra’s safer with me than walking around blind. We’d be prepared. It’s a controlled environment.”
Will glared at her. “It’s a trap using you as the bait. That's not controlled—it's reckless.”
“You’ve both killed for me before,” she said. “Let me help kill for myself.”
Hannibal wiped the knife clean with a towel and finally turned to face her.
“You are not bait, Abigail. You’re our daughter.”
“That’s exactly why I should have a say,” she shot back. “You trained me for this. Self-defense, situational awareness, reading intent. This isn’t some fantasy—I know the risks.”
Will ran a hand through his hair. “It’s not just the risks. It’s Chandra. You’d be endangering her.”
“She wants to fight back,” Abigail said. “She’s not weak. And she deserves to live in a world where monsters don’t always win.”
Hannibal’s voice dropped an octave. “And if something goes wrong? If he doesn’t take the bait? If he goes after her instead?”
“Then you make sure he doesn’t leave the parking lot,” Abigail said, locking eyes with Will. “I trust you.”
Will stared at her. That unblinking, wolf-holding-back-the-snow-storm stare.
“This isn’t about trust,” he said finally. “It’s about not turning you into us.”
Abigail’s voice softened. “Maybe I already am.”
Silence.
Hannibal exhaled slowly, the knife still in his hand.
Will stepped back, hand clenched at his side. “We’re not deciding this now.”
“You’re right,” Abigail said. “We’re deciding it soon. Because he’s not going to stop. And you two can’t catch him without a little chaos.”
She turned and walked out of the kitchen.
Hannibal looked at Will.
Will muttered, “She’s not wrong.”
Hannibal gave a faint, grim smile. “She never is when it matters.”
