Actions

Work Header

Cumin & Cannibalism

Summary:

Abigail Hobbs has two overprotective, slightly murderous dads. She takes violin lessons from a fellow psychopath and goes "hunting". She's in love. Only problem is her girlfriend is a vegetarian.

Notes:

This is an AU where Abigail is already adopted by Hannibal/Will. It doesn't have a episode divergent point. Not sure if I will add Alana or others like Jack Crawford yet. Maybe. idk.

Chapter 1: Breakfast

Chapter Text

The smell of eggs and cracked pepper drifted lazily through the air, warm and familiar. Abigail sat at the kitchen table, still in her hoodie and pajama pants, her history textbook splayed open in front of her. Will Graham, hair mussed and sleeves rolled up, was tending to a cast-iron skillet with more focus than most people devoted to national security.

“You put nutmeg in eggs?” Abigail asked, squinting suspiciously at the spice jar.

Will shrugged. “A dash. Hannibal says it rounds out the flavor.”

“It smells like French toast and poor judgment.”

From across the kitchen, Hannibal Lecter’s voice floated in like silk lined with steel. “That is precisely how your father and I began our relationship, Abigail. French toast and poor judgment.”

Will snorted without looking up from the pan. “She means you, in case that wasn’t clear.”

“I assumed as much,” Hannibal said, walking in with a copy of The New Yorker folded under one arm and a faint, amused smile on his face. “But poor judgment is often just foresight misinterpreted by the dull.”

“I’ll quote you on that next time the FBI asks why I let you near sharp objects,” Will replied, plating the eggs and handing Abigail her portion. “Eat. Brain development needs protein.”

Abigail poked at her food. “You two always talk like you're trying to out-weird each other.”

“It’s not a competition,” Will said.

“But if it were,” Hannibal added, settling into a chair with a perfectly brewed cup of coffee, “I’d be winning.”

Abigail smirked, then flipped a page in her textbook. “We’re reading about the French Revolution. Guillotines and class warfare. It’s fun.”

Will raised an eyebrow. “Define ‘fun.’”

“I mean, at least it’s honest. People got mad and did something about it. Bloody, yeah, but... real.”

“Revolution tends to be,” Hannibal murmured, almost to himself. “There’s a strange comfort in the clarity of consequences.”

Will gave him a look over the coffee pot. “Do I want to know what that means?”

“I doubt it,” Abigail said, stealing a bite of Will’s toast when he wasn’t looking.

Will sighed. “You're both exhausting.”

“And yet you made us breakfast,” Hannibal said.

“Because I love both of you,” Will said, quietly.

Abigail smiled. Hannibal's gaze softened just for a moment before he turned back to his coffee.

“How are your violin lessons progressing with Tobias, Abigail?”

Abigail looked up from her textbook, chewing on the end of her pen. “He’s intense,” she said after a beat. “He corrects me before I even make the mistake. Kind of like you, actually.”

Will snorted quietly.

Hannibal’s smile was thin and unreadable. “He has a good ear. And a low tolerance for mediocrity.”

“Yeah,” she said, nodding. “He also talks a lot about... precision. Like, every note has to mean something or it’s a waste. Is he always like that?”

“Always,” Hannibal replied. He reached for his cup, pausing a fraction too long before sipping. “It’s both his greatest virtue and a considerable liability.”

Will dried his hands on a towel. “So you are still wary of him.”

“I am careful,” Hannibal corrected, not looking at Will. “There’s a difference.”

“He’s not gonna murder me with a cello string, is he?” Abigail asked, half-joking, half not.

Will glanced at her, frowning. “If he does, he’ll have to answer to Hannibal.”

“And if that fails,” Hannibal added, placing his cup down delicately, “Will’s wrath is much less... surgical than mine. But considerably more enduring.”

Abigail raised an eyebrow. “Is this your version of a threat or parental bonding?”

Will leaned against the counter. “Yes.”

Hannibal chuckled softly, folding his hands. “Tobias may be unsavory, but he’s a capable musician. And I find that teaching tends to tame the more... volatile aspects of temperament. At least temporarily.”

“Speaking from experience?” Will asked dryly.

Hannibal met his gaze. “Always.”

Abigail looked between them, sensing that familiar current—affection, challenge, something sharp underneath. “You two should do a podcast,” she said. “Call it Murder Dads: Notes on Parenting and Casual Threats.”

Will grinned despite himself. Hannibal merely looked amused.

“A charming idea,” Hannibal said. “Though I’d insist on a more refined title.”

“Of course you would,” Will said, finally taking his own seat. “You’d probably open each episode with a harpsichord solo.”

“Preferably Bach.”

“God help our listeners.”

 

The morning sun barely filtered through the clouds as Abigail shrugged on her backpack. She stood by the front door, brushing lint off her hoodie while Will handed her a small thermos.

“Tea,” he said. “Not coffee. I know what you tried yesterday.”

Abigail smirked. “It was decaf.”

“It was espresso,” Will corrected, watching her with that over-perceptive look of his. “You vibrated through dinner.”

“I had to stay awake through group presentations. One of the girls did hers on crystals and moon energy.”

“...Okay, fair.” He opened the door for her. “Still, no more coffee unless it’s from me or Hannibal. And not from Hannibal if it smells like flowers and nightmares.”

“Got it. I’ll avoid anything garnished with edible gold.”

They stepped outside to the car, the gravel crunching beneath their feet. Hannibal watched from the upstairs window, a ghost of a presence. Will could feel it more than see it.

“Don’t forget Tobias at four,” Will said as he pulled onto the road.

“I won’t. He sent me a text reminder this morning. It had punctuation. Lots of it.”

Will raised an eyebrow. “Aggressive commas?”

“And two periods where none were needed. It felt hostile.”


Later That Day: Tobias Budge’s Studio

The studio sat behind a modest brownstone, a detached structure surrounded by bare winter trees and creeping ivy. It looked like it once might have been a gardener’s shed—if the gardener was a perfectionist who tuned pianos with surgical equipment.

Will parked and turned to Abigail. “If he makes you uncomfortable—”

“He doesn’t,” she said. “He’s weird, but I know the difference between weird and... wrong.”

Will studied her. “You’re sure?”

Abigail nodded. “Yeah. He’s all... control. But not in a creepy way. More like... ‘don’t touch the Stradivarius or I’ll disembowel you’ energy.”

Will sighed. “That’s exactly the kind of energy I worry about.”

“Don’t,” she said, opening the door. “I’m fine. Go home. Pet the dogs. Read one of those books you start and never finish.”

She hopped out before he could respond, slinging her violin case over one shoulder. Will watched her walk up to the door, where Tobias opened it precisely on time.

“Mr. Graham,” Tobias said, nodding politely. His posture was rigid, but not unfriendly. “She’s improving. Her vibrato has depth now. It’s... unexpected.”

Will stepped out of the car but didn’t cross the drive. “She’s full of surprises.”

Tobias smiled faintly, like a man tolerating bad violin technique. “She listens. That’s rare in students her age.”

Will returned the smile, tight-lipped. “She listens to you. That’s rarer.”

Tobias tilted his head, perhaps a fraction too far. “I’m not in the habit of harming what I find beautiful.”

The air changed. The phrase hovered like a blade balanced on a string.

Will’s eyes narrowed. “Let’s keep it that way.”

Tobias nodded again, the civility returning like a mask slipping back into place. “Of course.”

He turned and disappeared inside with Abigail, the door clicking shut behind them with a well-oiled finality.

Will stood there a moment longer, watching the building like it might exhale something unnatural. Then he got back in the car and drove away, the tension in his chest refusing to uncoil.

 

Tobias’s studio smelled faintly of resin, lemon oil, and control. The walls were lined with instruments like a museum of carefully curated voices—silent, judgmental, expensive.

Abigail stood poised, violin tucked beneath her chin, bow arcing through the air with exacting motion. Tobias stood beside her, close but not quite invading, eyes on the strings like they were surgical incisions.

“Again,” he said, gesturing to the same passage she’d just played.

She sighed but obeyed.

“Too emotional,” he interrupted before she even reached the second bar. “Let the structure do the work. Your hand isn’t conducting grief. It’s guiding a blade.”

Abigail frowned. “I’m not trying to be emotional.”

“And yet you are. Sloppy vibrato is sentimentality masquerading as technique.”

She lowered her violin, biting back the urge to say something snarky. He wasn’t wrong—just exhausting.

“I’ll work on it,” she muttered.

Tobias studied her for a moment, then nodded once. “You’re improving. But you have to decide if you want to be heard or remembered.”

She blinked. “Can’t I be both?”

Tobias almost smiled. “Only if you stop apologizing with every note.”


Later That Evening: The Lecter-Graham House

The house was quiet when Abigail let herself in, the evening cool brushing against her as the door closed behind her. She could smell the cooking before she even saw it—saffron, garlic, butter melting with something delicate and expensive.

Hannibal was at the stove, wearing an apron too elegant to be called one. Classical music played softly from a speaker in the corner—something string-heavy and European, as usual.

“You’re early,” he said without turning around.

“You’re alone,” Abigail replied, dropping her bag near the stairs.

“Will is at the shelter. One of the strays has an abscessed tooth.”

“That sounds like a terrible way to spend a Tuesday.”

“I thought the same,” Hannibal said, sliding something golden and fragrant onto a platter. “So I chose risotto.”

Abigail leaned against the counter. “I played Bach today. Tobias said I was too emotional.”

Hannibal’s eyes flicked to her, then back to the pan. “Emotion is not inherently a flaw in music.”

“He said my vibrato was sentimental.”

“Ah. Then he’s projecting again.” Hannibal ladled a perfect portion onto a plate and slid it across the counter to her. “You express yourself honestly. That threatens him.”

She stared at the food. “It smells like... art. Expensive art.”

“Good. Sit. Eat.”

Abigail took her seat and dug in. Hannibal poured wine—just a finger’s worth—into a small glass and passed it to her without ceremony.

“Don’t tell Will.”

“Of course not,” he said, taking his own seat. “Will doesn’t believe in indulgence unless it’s bleeding or barking.”

Abigail laughed softly. “You think Tobias is dangerous?”

“I know he is,” Hannibal said. “But danger is not always a reason to say no. Sometimes, it’s a reason to listen more carefully.”

She chewed thoughtfully. “So... should I keep learning from him?”

“That’s not my decision,” Hannibal said, eyes on her now, unblinking and gentle in a way that wasn’t quite human. “But if you do, know that you are never without protection. Even when Will is away.”

Abigail met his gaze. Something flickered between them—trust, or something darker wearing trust’s skin.

“Okay,” she said. “I’ll keep learning. But I’m not trying to be remembered.”

“No?”

She shook her head. “I’m trying to be understood.”

A pause. Hannibal smiled.

“Then you’re already ahead of most adults.”

 

 


Chapter 2: Chandra

Notes:

I love Chandra as an OC! I loved the episode where Hannibal makes an Indian dish on Banana Leaf. I think Hannibal is very knowledgeable and respects other cultures. I wanted more diversity in Hannibal a bit so I'm writing this!

Chapter Text

The next morning broke colder than the last, a brittle wind tugging at Abigail’s coat as she stepped off the bus and walked toward the front steps of the school. Students moved like lazy fish upstream—hoods up, earbuds in, mostly ignoring each other.

Abigail liked mornings. They were quiet. Contained. No one expected you to smile yet.

She made her way to her locker, dialed the combo without looking, and retrieved the worn folder with her violin sheet music. She was halfway to homeroom when she saw her.

The new girl.

Dark braid down her back, headphones slung around her neck, fingers painted in chipped silver polish. She was sitting in the back corner of the hallway, cross-legged, sketching something in a beat-up notebook with heavy, practiced lines.

Abigail slowed her pace. Then stopped.

The girl looked up at her like she felt the stare.

Big eyes. Warm brown, flecked with gold. Eyes that saw things and didn’t flinch.

“Hey,” the girl said. “Do you need something?”

Abigail blinked. “No—I mean. Sorry. I haven’t seen you before.”

“I just transferred. I’m Chandra.” She gave a small wave with the hand not holding a pencil. “From Atlanta. My mom’s a cardiologist, so... new hospital, new city, new life.”

Abigail nodded. “That’s a lot.”

“Yeah. I’m exhausted and it’s only Wednesday.” Chandra gave a crooked smile. “What’s your excuse?”

Abigail laughed before she could stop herself. “Let’s just say I have two dads and one of them believes breakfast is a ‘moral obligation.’”

Chandra grinned. “I like that. Is he strict?”

“He’s... intense. He owns knives he doesn’t cook with.”

“Yikes. I’ll be sure to stay on your good side.”

“I don’t think you have a bad side,” Abigail said before she could think better of it.

Chandra blinked.

Abigail looked down at her shoes, flustered. “That sounded weird. I just meant—”

“No,” Chandra interrupted, smiling again—softer this time. “It didn’t sound weird. It sounded nice.”

The bell rang.

Abigail flinched a little. “You going to music theory?”

Chandra stood and slung her sketchbook into her bag. “Yep. Mr. Foster’s already suspicious of me. I told him I could sight-read tabla rhythm notation and he looked like I’d offered to summon demons.”

Abigail fell into step beside her as they headed down the hall.

“I play violin. Classical. Kind of obsessed with Bach.”

“Nice,” Chandra said. “I like chaos. I listen to prog rock and sometimes I just play scales over it and pretend it’s a symphony.”

“That sounds... perfect, actually.”

They walked quietly for a few seconds. Close, but not touching. Like maybe the hallway had gotten warmer all of a sudden.

Abigail stole a glance sideways. Chandra was still smiling.

 

Abigail sat across from Chandra at a side table near the windows, where it was quieter and the sun made patterns across their trays. Chandra had pulled a small metal tiffin box from her bag and was opening the compartments with practiced ease.

“Smells amazing,” Abigail said, leaning forward.

“It’s bhindi masala,” Chandra said, smiling. “Okra. With roti. And... this is mango pickle. My mom made it. She doesn’t trust the local stores.”

Abigail grinned. “She’s probably right.”

“Want a bite?”

“Yeah,” Abigail said, not hesitating.

Chandra tore a piece of the soft, slightly browned flatbread and offered it up like it was nothing. Abigail took it, dipped it where Chandra pointed, and popped it in her mouth.

Spicy. Warm. Tangy with something sharp at the end. It hit all at once and left a trail of flavor that lingered.

“Holy shit,” Abigail said. “That’s incredible.”

“I’ll tell my mom. She’ll pretend to be annoyed, then make you a week’s worth of it.”

Abigail laughed. “Please do.”

But then the laughter stopped.

Three boys walked past their table—lacrosse kids. Big sneakers, loud mouths. One of them slowed just enough to sniff the air dramatically.

“Jesus. Who microwaved curry in here?”

The other snorted. “Smells like feet and potpourri.”

Abigail froze. Chandra’s face didn’t change, but her hand stilled over the tiffin.

The third boy, too pleased with himself, leaned just slightly in their direction. “You bring that in from home or did the cafeteria lose a bet?”

Abigail stood.

Not fast. Not loud. But deliberate.

She looked directly at the one who had spoken last. The one with too much gel in his hair and a laugh he’d never learned to earn.

“Keep walking,” she said. Calm. Cold.

The boys hesitated. Maybe they remembered her name. Maybe they’d heard the rumors.

Or maybe it was just the look in her eyes.

“Jesus, relax,” one muttered, shoving his friend’s shoulder. “It was a joke.”

They moved on.

Abigail sat back down slowly.

Chandra hadn’t moved.

“Sorry,” Abigail said.

“Don’t be,” Chandra said quietly. “That happens. Sometimes it’s worse.”

“It shouldn’t happen at all.”

Chandra looked up then, eyes serious. “You looked like you were going to stab him.”

Abigail gave a crooked smile. “That’s my resting face.”

Chandra laughed, the tension breaking like a dropped bow. “Remind me never to piss you off.”

“You’d have to try really hard.”

“I won’t,” Chandra said. “Promise.”

“I’m vegetarian, by the way,” Chandra said. “In case you ever bring snacks or offer me... bacon, or something horrifying.”

Abigail blinked. “Oh. Okay.”

“No big deal,” Chandra added, glancing up. “My parents are too, but they’re chill. My aunt eats chicken sometimes and nobody exiles her.”

Abigail laughed softly. “Got it. So like, ethical vegetarianism or just... cultural?”

“Both, kind of. I don’t like the idea of eating something that used to look back at you.”

That made Abigail pause.

Chandra raised an eyebrow. “You okay?”

“Yeah, just—” Abigail twisted the cap on her water bottle. “That’s an intense way to put it.”

“Well,” Chandra said, playful again, “you said one of your dads owns knives he doesn’t cook with, so I figured we could handle a little intensity.”

“Right,” Abigail said, lips quirking. “Okay, full disclosure... Hannibal—Dr. Lecter—he cooks. Like really cooks. Gourmet, old-world, Michelin-level drama in the kitchen. But he... uh... doesn’t always say what the meat is.”

Abigail kept going, slower now. “It’s not like weird animals or anything. Just... he gets really into sourcing ingredients. Specialty butchers, rare cuts, imported spices. Stuff I can’t pronounce.”

Chandra tilted her head. “Okay... so like organ meats? Foie gras? Stuff that still had a name five minutes ago?”

“Sometimes,” Abigail said, too carefully. “I don’t always ask. Will says I shouldn’t ask. Which probably tells you everything.”

Chandra laughed once, surprised. “Okay, that’s creepy. But also... kind of charming?”

Abigail raised an eyebrow. “Charming?”

“Well, in a terrifying, ‘my boyfriend’s family has secret wine cellars’ kind of way.”

Abigail laughed this time—really laughed. “Yeah, it’s a lot like that.”

“So when I come over—if I come over—I’ll bring my own food.”

“Probably wise,” Abigail said. “Hannibal will try to convert you with a mushroom tart so perfect it makes you question your worldview.”

“Challenge accepted,” Chandra said, smiling again. “But fair warning—I come from a long line of aunties who weaponize spice levels. Tell him to bring his A-game.”

“I will,” Abigail said. And she meant it.

She wasn’t going to lie to Chandra. Not really. But there were some truths with sharp edges. You didn't hand those to someone you liked without a warning.

And she liked Chandra.

A lot.

 

The final bell rang with the kind of exhausted relief that only a Thursday could carry. Students spilled out of the doors like air escaping a balloon—loud, fast, mostly chaotic.

Abigail didn’t rush. She rarely did. She found Chandra already outside, leaning against the bike rack, sketchbook under one arm, hoodie sleeves pushed up to her elbows. The breeze tugged at the ends of her braid.

“You survived,” Chandra said, handing Abigail a mint from her pocket. “Barely.”

Abigail took it, smiling. “Chemistry nearly killed me. We had to do a group worksheet and I was assigned to the guy who thinks ions are ‘a vibe.’”

“Sounds like my cousin.”

They stood quietly for a moment as people filtered past them, their voices fading toward parking lots and buses.

“Thanks for hanging out today,” Abigail said.

“Of course,” Chandra said. “You’re like... strangely easy to be around.”

“That’s the nicest way anyone’s ever called me weird.”

“No, I mean—” Chandra paused. “You don’t feel like work. Being around people usually feels like work.”

Abigail nodded, understanding instantly. “You don’t feel like work either.”

They glanced at each other then. Brief, warm. Unspoken things in the silence.

A car pulled up at the curb—a battered old station wagon with mismatched hubcaps and a soft growl in its engine. The back windows were down, and ears flopped out over the edges.

Will leaned over from the driver’s side. “Abigail!”

The two dogs barked as if announcing royalty. One of them tried to climb halfway out the window.

“Jesus,” Abigail muttered, hoisting her bag. “They get louder every time.”

“More excited to see you,” Will called. “Or maybe I’m just boring.”

“You’re definitely boring,” Abigail replied over her shoulder, then turned back to Chandra.

“That your other dad?”

“Yeah,” Abigail said. “That’s Will. He’s... soft inside, but you have to know how to look.”

Chandra smiled. “Like a lava cake?”

“Exactly,” Abigail said. “But with trauma.”

They both laughed.

“I’ll text you later?” Chandra asked.

“Yeah. Do.”

Abigail hesitated. Then: “I’m glad you transferred here.”

Chandra blinked. “Me too.”

Abigail gave a small wave and jogged to the car, pulling open the back door and letting the dogs climb into her lap immediately. Will passed her a napkin from the glove box without looking.

“You smell like mango pickle,” he said.

“You say that like it’s a crime.”

Will smiled, pulling away from the curb. “Not at all. Just an observation.”

She leaned her head against the window as the school disappeared behind them. Her fingers smelled faintly of cumin and paper. She didn’t say anything else for a while.

But she was still smiling.

 

 


Chapter 3: Tiffins and Thermos

Notes:

I like how Chandra talks about the subtle racism of Indian food that it is "smelly" like ffs. I love their developing relationship!

Chapter Text

Dinner at the Lecter-Graham house was always... precise.

The table was set before anyone sat down. Napkins folded like origami. Cutlery aligned with surgical accuracy. Hannibal served the plates himself, never in a rush, and never in silence. There was always a string quartet playing low from the speakers. Some obscure European composer that only Will pretended to recognize.

Tonight, the risotto was earthy with truffle, the asparagus charred just so. It smelled amazing.

Abigail barely noticed.

Her phone buzzed softly in her lap. Again.

Under the table, her thumbs moved fast.

Chandra: your dogs looked like they wanted to adopt ME

Abigail: you should come over and let them, i’ll trade you for the okra

Another buzz. Then another.

Will was halfway through his first bite when he looked up, quirking an eyebrow across the table. He didn’t say anything. Hannibal did.

“Abigail.”

She glanced up, eyes wide like she'd just been caught shoplifting.

“Yes?”

Hannibal didn’t raise his voice. He never needed to.

“You know the rule.”

Abigail shifted uncomfortably in her chair. “I was just—”

“You are just at the table. With your family,” he said, gently. “A meal is not only nourishment. It is attention. Presence. And presence is a courtesy.”

She sighed, sliding the phone out of her lap and onto the buffet behind her. “Okay. Sorry.”

Hannibal inclined his head, satisfied. “Apology accepted.”

Will gave her a small look from across the table—half teasing, half understanding. She returned it with a whisper of a smile.

“Chandra?” he asked quietly, stabbing a piece of asparagus.

“Yeah.”

“She’s good for you,” Will said.

Hannibal refilled her glass with sparkling water. “Curiosity is a healthy impulse. But it should never eclipse the moment you're living in.”

“Okay,” Abigail muttered. “I get it. Phones are evil. Eat the mushrooms. Engage with your elegant surroundings.”

Will chuckled. “I think that’s the modern translation of the rule, yeah.”

Abigail took a bite. It was incredible. She hated how good it was.

“I’m not obsessed,” she said after a beat. “She just... makes the day feel less heavy.”

Hannibal paused at that.

Then, softly: “We all need something that does.”

They ate the rest of the meal in relative peace. The conversation wandered—from Will’s dogs to Hannibal’s contempt for microwave ovens—and eventually, the music and the food worked their usual magic.

But Abigail’s mind kept wandering.

To silver-painted fingers. To soft laughter. To a girl who looked back at her like she wasn’t broken.

Her phone buzzed again once the plates were cleared.

She didn’t check it right away.

But the smile that tugged at her mouth gave everything away.

 

The next morning, Abigail had just barely slumped into her homeroom desk when the door creaked open and the teacher cleared her throat.

“We have a new addition to our homeroom,” she said. “Well—familiar to some of you already.”

Chandra stepped into the room, backpack slung over one shoulder, braid slightly messier than usual. She offered a polite smile, but her eyes scanned the room—and stopped when they met Abigail’s.

Abigail didn’t wave, didn’t smile. But she tilted her head just a little. That was enough.

Chandra made her way over and sat down in the open desk beside her.

“Stalking me?” Abigail murmured.

“They reassigned me,” Chandra whispered back. “Apparently my last homeroom teacher complained I was too quiet.”

“God forbid.”

“Right? Next I’ll be arrested for thoughtful nodding.”

Abigail let out a small laugh—sharp and surprised. “Well, welcome to the island of misfit introverts.”


Lunchtime

They ended up back at their usual spot outside—sunny but shaded, a little cracked bench under the old oak tree where nobody really paid attention to them. A perfect hideaway.

Abigail pulled a thermos and a small tin from her bag. Chandra unwrapped her tiffin box and laid out soft, folded rotis like playing cards.

“I have lentil stew,” Abigail said, cracking open her thermos. “Technically it has a French name, but Will just calls it ‘stuff Hannibal made with too many herbs.’”

“Let me guess,” Chandra said. “He foraged them at dawn in a misty forest while reflecting on Nietzsche?”

“Pretty much.”

Chandra offered a corner of her roti. “Try mine. It’s aloo sabzi today. Potato, turmeric, mustard seed. My mom woke up early to make it.”

Abigail took a bite and closed her eyes dramatically. “Okay. You win. Hannibal’s going to be deeply insulted.”

“Good. Maybe it’ll humble him.”

Abigail grinned. “Nothing humbles Hannibal. He once made pheasant pâté during a power outage. With a candle.”

Chandra laughed so hard she almost dropped her tiffin. “Wait—what? How?!”

“He says candlelight ‘focuses the senses.’ Will says he’s unbearable. I just eat the pâté and try not to think about where it came from.”

They laughed for a minute longer, then fell into easy silence, eating and trading bites. Chandra nudged Abigail with her elbow.

“Hey. Thanks for letting me sit here.”

Abigail looked up. “Why wouldn’t I?”

Chandra shrugged. “People get weird. Especially when you bring food that smells like ‘a whole spice cabinet threw a party.’”

“Well, I like your food. And your weird.”

“You mean you’re into my weird,” Chandra teased.

Abigail flushed—just a little—and took another bite instead of answering.

Chandra didn’t push it. She just smiled and handed over the last wedge of roti.

 

The afternoon sun filtered through the trees in lazy gold, the kind of warm that made the pavement hum and the grass smell like memory.

Abigail and Chandra sat on the swings in the small park behind the school, bags dropped carelessly nearby, half-melted iced drinks between their sneakers.

“So you’re telling me Will literally cried the first time he held a newborn puppy?”

“Sobbed,” Abigail confirmed, pushing herself gently back and forth. “Like, full-on, voice-cracking tears. Hannibal had to step outside because he didn’t know what to do with the emotion.”

Chandra wheezed with laughter. “He’s such a feral raccoon of a man. That’s adorable.”

“Don’t tell him I told you. He tries to keep up the tortured genius image.”

Chandra twisted slightly in her swing to face her. “Secret’s safe with me, obviously. Just like I’m never telling you how many times I’ve watched ‘Pride and Prejudice’ just for the hand flex scene.”

“Oh no,” Abigail said, mock-dramatic. “You’re one of those.”

They both broke into giggles, a warm silence stretching between them like a thread.

Then a shadow fell over them.

“Miss Hobbs.”

Abigail froze. The swing slowed.

She looked up to see Tobias Budge standing just off the path, dressed in a dark coat that felt entirely too formal for the park. His posture was relaxed, but his hands were buried in his pockets, and his eyes were too sharp for the afternoon sun.

“Tobias,” Abigail said, keeping her voice even. “Hey.”

Chandra looked between them, instinctively picking up on something that didn’t quite belong.

“I wasn’t expecting to see you outside of your studio,” Abigail added.

“I was passing through,” Tobias said. “I recognized you from across the lawn. Thought I’d say hello.”

His gaze flicked to Chandra, measuring. “Friend of yours?”

Chandra straightened slightly on her swing. “Chandra. I go to school with Abigail.”

Tobias gave a small, precise nod. “Pleasure.”

Something about the way he said it made it sound more like evaluation than greeting.

Abigail stepped off her swing, placing herself just slightly in front of Chandra. “We’re just hanging out. I’ve been practicing the D minor prelude, by the way. I’ll be ready for Saturday.”

“I’m sure you will,” Tobias said, a faint smile touching his lips. “You have a good ear. Don’t let it get cluttered with noise.”

He looked at Chandra again. “Nice to meet you.”

Then he walked off, just like that—no farewell, no backward glance.

They watched him go, the air somehow colder now.

Chandra let out a breath. “Okay. That was a villain cameo if I’ve ever seen one.”

Abigail didn’t laugh.

“Is he your teacher?”

“Yeah. Violin.”

Chandra looked at her. “Are you okay?”

Abigail nodded, slow and practiced. “I’m used to him.”

“But you don’t like him.”

Another pause.

“No,” Abigail admitted. “But I understand him. And that’s... complicated.”

Chandra didn’t push. She just picked up her drink and stood beside her. “Want to walk for a bit?”

“Yeah,” Abigail said, quietly. “Thanks.”

They walked without speaking for a while, just the steady rhythm of sneakers on gravel and the quiet rustle of breeze through thinning leaves.

The late-afternoon sun bled into orange and gold, casting long shadows across the path. A flock of birds cut across the sky, sudden and sharp.

Abigail glanced up and slowed. “I should head home.”

Chandra looked at her, concerned. “You okay?”

“Yeah. Just—Tobias kind of messes with my head sometimes. It’s not a big deal.”

Chandra nodded, her brow furrowed. “You sure?”

“I promise,” Abigail said, forcing a smile that wasn’t entirely false. “I just need... quiet.”

Chandra pulled her into a quick, tight hug. “Text me when you get home?”

“Yeah,” Abigail murmured, hugging back. “I will.”


Lecter-Graham Residence – Evening

The house was warm, dimly lit, and quiet in that careful, curated way Hannibal preferred. Somewhere in the kitchen, something aromatic simmered low and slow—thyme, citrus, and the faint undertone of veal stock.

Abigail came in without a word, took her boots off with practiced motion, and headed straight upstairs. She didn’t slam her door—but she closed it.

Her room was still, half lit by the fading light filtering through the curtains. She sat on her bed, pulling her knees to her chest, and just... breathed.

There was a knock.

Three soft, measured taps.

Abigail didn’t respond. But the door opened anyway.

Hannibal entered with the silence of a man who never had to ask permission, carrying a small tray with a steaming mug and a folded cloth napkin.

“I made chamomile,” he said. “With a touch of vanilla and orange peel.”

Abigail stared at him for a moment, then reached for the cup.

“Thanks.”

He set the tray on her desk and moved to stand near the window, not crowding her. Just... present.

“I passed Tobias earlier,” he said quietly. “He mentioned seeing you.”

Abigail stared into her tea. “He saw us in the park.”

“‘Us’ meaning you and Chandra.”

“Yes.”

Hannibal’s gaze stayed on the window. “He’s observant.”

“He makes her nervous,” Abigail said.

Hannibal finally looked at her. “He makes most people nervous. Rightly so.”

“You trust him enough to let him teach me.”

“I don’t trust Tobias,” Hannibal said, choosing his words carefully. “I respect the edges of his control. That’s not the same thing.”

Abigail nodded, watching the steam rise from her mug.

“She asked if I was okay.”

“Are you?”

“I think so.”

A long pause.

“She makes things feel... lighter,” Abigail said softly. “Not easier. But lighter.”

Hannibal’s voice was gentle. “That’s rare.”

Abigail looked up at him. “You don’t think she’ll run away screaming?”

“I think,” Hannibal said, folding his hands behind his back, “that if she does... it won’t be because of you.”

That sat between them for a while, heavy but not cruel.

Abigail took a sip. The tea was warm and calming, like velvet and dusk.

“Thanks,” she said again.

Hannibal gave her a faint, almost human smile. “Sleep well, Abigail.”

 

 

Chapter 4: Macabre Thoughts

Chapter Text

The house was quiet. Mostly.

Abigail lay in bed, curled under a too-heavy quilt, the dim blue light of her phone casting shadows on her face. Her room was dark, but her mind wasn’t still.

She’d almost drifted off when the buzz sounded—soft, a pulse against her palm.

Chandra: u still up?

Abigail blinked. The clock said 11:54 p.m.

Abigail: yeah. couldn’t sleep.

A pause. Then another buzz.

Chandra: just wanted to check in. you seemed off after the park. that guy was… weird. you okay?

Abigail stared at the screen for a while. Her thumbs hovered over the keyboard. She wanted to say yes.

She wanted to say no.

Instead:

Abigail: yeah. just needed time. thanks for texting.

The reply came faster this time.

Chandra: anytime. i like talking to you, even when you’re moody and cryptic. it’s your whole vibe and i respect it.

Abigail smiled faintly, her chest tightening with something good.

Then she heard it.

A muffled thump downstairs. Then the unmistakable scrape of heavy weight over tile.

Her body stiffened.

She sat up slowly, clicking her phone screen off. Listened.

Low voices. Will, muttering something sharp and frustrated.

Hannibal, calm and composed as ever.

Another thud. Something dense. Wet.

Then a metallic clang. The door to the basement freezer. The familiar creak of old hinges.

Abigail’s hand tightened around her phone.

She’d known, of course. She always knew. But hearing it—feeling it beneath her floorboards—was different.

A breath. Then another buzz.

Chandra: you sure you’re okay? i mean really?

Abigail stared at the message.

Outside her room, the house was quiet again.

The kind of quiet that knew how to clean itself up.

She typed slowly.

Abigail: i am right now. you texting me made it better.

She hesitated.

Abigail: i like talking to you too.

She hit send and lay back down, eyes on the ceiling. The silence pressed in, thick and familiar.

But the warmth in her chest didn’t fade.

Two worlds. One heartbeat.

 

The smell hit her the second she came downstairs—savory and rich, smoky with just a whisper of something sweet.

Abigail rounded the corner into the kitchen barefoot, hoodie sleeves covering her hands. Hannibal stood at the stove, movements precise as ever, slicing sausage into golden rounds, steam rising from a pan of eggs and roasted peppers. A plate of neatly wrapped burritos sat nearby, folded like art.

Will leaned against the counter, coffee in hand, hair still sleep-rumpled and eyes very awake.

“Mornin’,” Abigail muttered, sliding into her usual chair.

“Good morning, Abigail,” Hannibal said, sliding a burrito onto her plate with a faint smile. “You’re just in time. I let the tortillas rest so the texture wouldn't offend you.”

“I feel so seen.”

Will raised an eyebrow. “They’re ‘breakfast sausage burritos,’ according to Hannibal. That’s all I know. I’m not asking what’s in the sausage.”

Abigail unwrapped hers and took a cautious bite. She chewed, then nodded slowly. “Okay, morally questionable but delicious. As usual.”

Hannibal looked pleased.

She took another bite, then spoke casually—too casually.

“So... how was the hunting last night?”

The air in the kitchen changed.

Will looked up from his coffee. Hannibal did not.

“Productive,” Hannibal said. “Clean. Intentional.”

Will exhaled through his nose. “Not the word I would’ve chosen.”

Abigail licked a spot of sauce from her thumb. “Can I come next time?”

Will froze.

Hannibal, however, looked delighted. Not in a wide-smile way—just a slight shift in his posture, an almost imperceptible lift at the corners of his mouth.

“You’re curious,” he said.

“I want to see,” Abigail replied. “What it’s really like.”

Will set his coffee down with a soft thud. “Abigail.”

She met his eyes. Steady. “You told me not to look away from what I am. I’m not saying I want to kill anyone. I just— I don’t want to be the kid you protect from the truth anymore.”

“She already knows the truth,” Hannibal said, carefully folding the empty pan into the sink. “She simply wants context.”

Will ran a hand down his face. “You don’t just observe a hunt, Abigail. You participate, whether you mean to or not.”

“I’m not afraid,” she said softly.

“That’s what I’m afraid of,” Will murmured.

Hannibal crossed to her side and placed a linen napkin beside her plate like they were discussing poetry, not predators.

“I think,” he said, “that when the time is right, you should see it. One must never fear the act that shaped them.”

Abigail glanced at Will. “I won’t go without your okay.”

He stared at her, jaw tight.

“I’ll think about it,” he said finally.

She nodded, satisfied for now.

 

Abigail moved quietly through the upstairs hallway, her backpack half-zipped and earbuds tangled in one hand. She had a habit of not rushing before school—Will always said panic was contagious, and Hannibal refused to dignify lateness with acknowledgment.

She’d just stepped into her room when she heard it.

Voices. Low and clipped. Below.

She paused.

The stairs creaked softly as she leaned closer to the landing, just enough to hear.


Downstairs

Will’s voice came first, tight and hushed but edged with fire. “She’s not ready.”

“She disagrees,” Hannibal replied, calm as always. “And so do I.”

“She’s sixteen, Hannibal. She’s a child.”

“She’s not. Not anymore. Not since Minnesota. Not since Nick Boyle.”

A pause.

Will exhaled, slow and painful. “That’s not the same. That was survival.”

“And now it’s education.”

Will snapped, voice rising a notch. “Don’t twist it into something noble.”

“I’m not twisting anything,” Hannibal said, quiet steel beneath the silk. “You helped teach her how to shoot. How to watch body language. How to disappear. I trained her in knife control, situational reaction, threat assessment. We’ve already prepared her for the world we live in.”

There was a long silence.

Then Will’s voice, lower, cracking around the edges. “I just wanted her to feel safe. That’s all I ever wanted.”

“She feels safe because she understands the darkness around her,” Hannibal said. “Because she’s not blind to it. You gave her instincts. I gave her precision. And now she wants truth. We should not deny her that.”

More silence. Then Will spoke again, reluctant but heavy with finality.

“If she’s going... I pick the target.”

Hannibal didn’t respond right away. When he did, it was almost warm.

“Of course.”


Upstairs

Abigail stood frozen just inside her doorway.

Backpack hanging from one shoulder, forgotten. Her heart was beating too fast—but not from fear.

It wasn’t that they were arguing about her.

It was that they were arguing like she was already one of them.

Not a child. Not a bystander.

A participant.

She sat on her bed slowly, the morning light spilling across the floor. Part of her should have been scared.

But mostly, she felt something else.

Seen.

 

First period was English, and Abigail didn’t hear a word of it.

Something about The Crucible, probably. Or metaphor. Or mob mentality. She stared through the open window while Mrs. Tisdale’s voice droned on in the background, reading from the textbook like she was trying to hypnotize the class into submission.

Outside, the sky was overcast, the trees bare and stark. The kind of light that made everything feel sharper.

You helped teach her how to shoot.

You gave her instincts. I gave her precision.

Abigail’s fingers gripped her pen, unmoving. Her notes for the day were two words long:

False confession.

Fitting.

“Okay,” the teacher called out suddenly. “Partner discussion—three minutes. Pick someone next to you.”

A chair scraped across the floor beside her. Chandra dropped into the seat, grinning.

“You looked like you were solving crimes with your mind,” she said, nudging Abigail’s notebook with the eraser of her pencil. “Very FBI. Very ‘intense girl in a Netflix series.’”

Abigail blinked, snapping back. “Huh?”

“You’ve been staring out the window like it owes you money. What’s going on up there?”

“Nothing.”

Chandra gave her a skeptical look. “Mmhmm. Sure.”

“I’m just tired.”

“Oh, is this where you tell me you stayed up rewatching Hereditary and brooding over your mortality?”

Abigail couldn’t help the laugh that escaped her—short and startled.

“No,” she said. “Just... weird dreams.”

“Classic excuse. Next you’ll tell me you wrote a cryptic poem about it.”

“I did write a poem,” Abigail said, mock-defensive. “But it wasn’t cryptic. It was broody and extremely on-the-nose.”

“God, you’re so mysterious,” Chandra said, grinning. “No wonder you’re the school goth even though you don’t dress like one.”

“I’m not the school goth.”

“Abigail, please. You carry a thermos like a haunted Victorian child.”

Abigail smiled again, and something loosened in her chest. Just a little.

Chandra leaned in, lowering her voice. “Seriously though. You okay?”

Abigail met her eyes. Something in them—steadiness, light, safety—made her want to tell the truth.

Or at least part of it.

“Just a heavy morning,” she said. “Stuff at home.”

Chandra nodded, accepting it. “You want me to bring you extra okra tomorrow?”

“I want you to bring me a gallon of mango pickle and a getaway plan.”

“Done,” Chandra whispered. “But only if you promise to text me a warning next time you zone out like that. I was starting to think you were about to levitate.”

“Next time,” Abigail said, smiling again. “Promise.”

 

The bell hadn’t even rung when the front office called for her.

“Abigail Hobbs, early dismissal,” came the crackling announcement over the intercom.

Heads turned. Chandra shot her a look from across the room.

Abigail quietly gathered her things. Slid her phone into her pocket.

She met Chandra at the door with a shrug and a half-smile. “Apparently I’m leaving early.”

Chandra tilted her head, brow furrowing. “Everything okay?”

“Yeah,” Abigail said quickly. “It’s just... family stuff.”

Chandra didn’t press, but her eyes lingered. “You’ll text me?”

“I will.”

And then, after a breath: “Thanks.”

Chandra touched her fingers to Abigail’s wrist, just briefly. “Don’t disappear on me.”

“I won’t,” Abigail murmured.

But something in her chest whispered that she might.


Outside

The car was already parked along the curb—Will in the driver’s seat, sunglasses on, jaw set. Hannibal sat in the passenger seat, perfectly still, gloved hands resting lightly in his lap.

Abigail opened the door and slid into the back without a word.

They pulled away from the school in silence, the hum of tires on asphalt louder than it should have been.

It was Will who spoke first, once they turned onto the quieter stretch of road that led out of town.

“No talking in the car during the approach,” he said, eyes fixed on the road. “No names. No small talk. No mistakes.”

Abigail nodded once. “Okay.”

Hannibal glanced back at her in the mirror. “And no improvising. This is not theatre. It’s ritual.”

Will continued. “The target’s a man in his sixties. Alone. No family, no close connections. He has a history of cruelty. The kind people don’t bother prosecuting. Animals. Children. We’ve watched him for weeks.”

“He’s easy,” Hannibal said calmly. “Clean entry. Clean exit.”

Abigail’s fingers curled around the hem of her jacket. “I understand.”

“You’ll stay behind us until the moment’s right,” Will said. “We’ll give you direction. If you freeze, we handle it. No shame in that.”

“But,” Hannibal added, “if you don’t freeze—if you move—you must finish what you start. There is no halfway.”

Abigail looked out the window. Trees blurred by.

“I won’t freeze.”

Silence stretched.

Will’s voice was quieter now. “This doesn’t make you like us, Abigail. You already are.”

She swallowed. Hard.

“I know.”

The sun had dipped just enough that the shadows lengthened across the dash. In her backpack, her phone buzzed once.

A text from Chandra, probably.

Abigail didn’t check it.

She was already somewhere else.

 

 


Chapter 5: Warmth

Notes:

a cute little murder scene! Happy Murder Family vibes!

Chapter Text

The woods were quiet.

Late afternoon light bled through the trees in copper streaks, catching on the leaves and the low mist that clung to the ground like breath.

Abigail stood a few paces behind Will and Hannibal, her boots sinking slightly into the soft earth, heart beating steady—not fast, not panicked. Just present.

The man moved through the clearing below, oblivious.

Old denim jacket. Limp. A quiet routine. He carried a heavy flashlight and a habit of hurting things no one missed.

Will raised two fingers in a silent signal. Abigail stepped forward, slowly.

They circled in perfect formation—like wolves who had done this dance a hundred times. Hannibal moved without sound, a ghost in wool. Will’s eyes flicked once to Abigail, giving her the final word without speaking it.

And she made the decision.

The knife in her hand wasn’t cold anymore. It was part of her now—balanced, familiar, earned.

She struck clean.

No flinching. No falter.

Just breath. Pressure. Silence.

And then it was over.

The man crumpled like something already discarded.

Will knelt to check the pulse, his face unreadable. Hannibal simply stood nearby, watching her with something dangerously close to pride.

Abigail wiped the blade against the dead man’s jacket sleeve.

Then she smiled.

A small, strange, genuine smile.

 

They wrapped the body in tarp, quiet and quick. By the time the sun dipped behind the trees, they were already headed back to the car—Abigail between them, lighter than she had felt in weeks.

No guilt. No fear.

Just clarity.

“I want the liver,” she said as she buckled her seatbelt, voice calm and matter-of-fact. “And part of the thigh, if it’s clean.”

Will blinked. Hannibal turned to her, delighted.

“Of course,” he said. “Any particular preparation?”

Abigail considered. “Pan-seared. Just butter and rosemary. Nothing fancy. I want to taste it.”

Will started the car, eyes forward, jaw tight—but he didn’t argue.

Not this time.


Home

By the time they returned, the house felt unusually warm. The dogs barked once and fell silent. The kitchen light hummed quietly as Hannibal carried the cooler to the back prep space.

Will took Abigail’s coat without speaking.

“You okay?” he asked after a moment.

Abigail looked up at him.

She nodded.

“I feel...” She paused, trying to find the right shape of it. “...right. Like my skin fits again.”

Will didn’t smile, but he didn’t look away either.

“You did what had to be done,” he said.

“No,” Abigail replied. “I did what I chose to do.”

And Will, despite everything, nodded.

Because she was right.

 

The fire crackled softly in the sitting room, its orange light dancing over dark wood and wineglasses. Outside, the wind whispered against the windows like a lullaby made of breath and leaf.

Will sat curled into the corner of the couch, wine in hand, his gaze distant but not cold. Hannibal reclined opposite him, legs crossed neatly, a glass of Barolo glinting in the firelight. His presence, as always, was deliberate. Calming. Like a man who never had to raise his voice to control a room.

They weren’t talking loudly. But Abigail knew how to listen.

She crouched at the top of the stairs, just beyond the archway. Barefoot. Quiet.

Will swirled his glass slowly, eyes flicking toward the fire. “She didn’t hesitate.”

“No,” Hannibal said, his voice low and pleased. “She was precise. Present. Purposeful.”

“She didn’t just survive it. She chose it.”

“She embraced what she already knew,” Hannibal replied. “The world will not forgive her for it. But we will.”

Will hesitated. “I keep thinking I should feel guilty.”

“You don’t,” Hannibal said gently.

Will exhaled through his nose. “No. I don’t. I’m proud of her. That’s what scares me.”

“Why?”

“Because it means I’ve let go of the version of her I used to protect. The child.”

“She was never just a child,” Hannibal murmured. “She’s something new now. Because of us.”

Abigail took a breath. It caught in her throat—not because she was sad.

Because it was true.

Then—

“She’s eavesdropping,” Hannibal said suddenly, his eyes lifting to the archway with that small, secret smile.

Will didn’t even flinch. “Of course she is.”

“Come in, Abigail,” Hannibal called, voice soft but unmistakable. “You’ve already heard the best part.”

She stepped down slowly, sheepish but not ashamed. The fire made everything look warmer than it was.

“You weren’t exactly being quiet,” she said, folding her arms loosely as she approached.

“Intentional,” Hannibal replied.

Will looked up at her, his expression tired but honest. “It’s true. I’m proud of you.”

She blinked, surprised by the way it landed—solid and real.

“Thanks,” she said. “I’m... proud of me too.”

Hannibal gestured to the space between them on the couch. “Sit with us.”

She did, curling between them like it was always meant to be this way. Her head rested lightly on Will’s shoulder, her legs curled beneath her.

No one spoke for a long while.

The fire burned low, the wine stayed half-full, and in the hush of it all, Abigail felt something rare settle in her chest.

Not peace.

But place.

She belonged here. With them.

In the warmth they made together.

 

 

Chapter 6: The Popcorn Killer

Notes:

Thought i would add some suspense!

Chapter Text

Morning sunlight crept lazily across the kitchen tile, catching the steam rising from a pan on the stove. Hannibal stood, sleeves rolled, effortlessly assembling omelets—egg whites whipped to silk, a sprinkle of herbs, a whisper of something earthy no one dared identify.

Abigail sat at the table, curled in one of the chairs, sipping coffee she wasn’t technically allowed to have. She wore one of Will’s flannels like a robe, sleeves too long, eyes still sleepy.

Will sat across from her, the paper open in front of him, glasses perched low on his nose. His expression tightened as he read.

“Well, this is horrifying,” he muttered.

Hannibal didn’t look up. “You’ll need to be more specific. It’s the news.”

Will cleared his throat and read aloud:

“Police are investigating the discovery of a second body found in a movie theater in Baltimore—both victims murdered and found with their mouths filled with popcorn kernels. Detectives have not released details, but sources confirm that no popcorn was found on the premises. Authorities are considering a pattern.”

A silence followed.

Hannibal finally turned from the stove, placing a plate down gently in front of Abigail. “Popcorn,” he said mildly. “How quaint.”

Will looked up. “They’re calling him ‘The Popcorn Killer.’”

Abigail made a face. “That sounds like a Netflix documentary narrated by a YouTuber.”

Will folded the paper. “It sounds like someone wants attention.”

Abigail picked up her fork. “Or someone’s mocking the way people digest violence. Theatrics as protest.”

Will raised an eyebrow.

“Or they’re just a psychopath with a snack fetish,” she added dryly.

Hannibal sat across from them, plate untouched for now. “Popcorn in the mouth suggests symbolism. Suffocation by indulgence. Or perhaps they simply wanted a motif.”

Will narrowed his eyes. “You know I’m going to ask if it’s someone you know.”

“If it were,” Hannibal said with an elegant shrug, “they’d be using truffle salt.”

Abigail snorted into her coffee.

Will looked back down at the paper, jaw tight. “I’m going to call Jack later. They’re going to want a profile.”

“Of course,” Hannibal said smoothly. “Do try not to take it home with you.”

Will didn’t answer.

Abigail quietly watched them both over the rim of her mug—two wolves in breakfast clothes, reading signs in blood and kernels.

 

The halls buzzed louder than usual.

Students gathered in clusters—some with phones out, others just whispering, laughing too loudly or not at all. Even the teachers looked more alert, glancing at passing faces like something was off.

Abigail didn’t need to guess.

She caught snippets as she moved through the crowd:

“—a movie theater again. In Baltimore. That’s like, two hours away, right?”

“Did you see the photos? Someone leaked crime scene stuff on Reddit—”

“They’re calling him the Popcorn Killer. That’s so gross. And kind of dumb.”

“Not dumb if you’re the one choking on kernels—”

Abigail turned the corner and spotted Chandra at her locker, pale and hunched a little tighter than usual.

“Hey,” Abigail said, slipping in beside her. “You okay?”

Chandra startled slightly, then nodded, not very convincingly. “Yeah. Just... everyone’s being weird. And loud. And dramatic.”

“They’re teenagers. It’s what they do best.”

Chandra shut her locker with a soft click. “It’s just creepy, y’know? The popcorn thing. It’s not even violent in the usual way. It’s—ritual. That’s what freaks me out.”

Abigail was quiet for a beat. She looked down the hall, her voice low.

“People want killers to be monsters. Easier that way. But this one’s doing it with a theme. That makes it harder to ignore.”

Chandra gave her a sidelong look. “How are you always so calm when everyone else is losing their minds?”

Abigail smiled faintly. “I’ve seen worse.”

Chandra shivered. “God, don’t say it like that.”

“I’m just saying,” Abigail said, soft but certain, “you don’t need to be scared. Not while I’m around.”

Chandra turned to face her, trying to read her expression. “Yeah?”

“I won’t let anything happen to you.”

Abigail meant it.

And Chandra, after a pause, nodded slowly. “Okay. I believe you.”

Their eyes held for a beat too long.

Then the bell rang, and students began peeling off toward class in waves. Chandra reached over and nudged Abigail’s arm.

“Walk with me?”

Abigail did.

 

The house was quiet when Abigail returned, the kind of quiet that meant something was already happening.

She dropped her bag by the stairs and followed the faint murmur of voices and the rustle of papers to the study.

Will sat at the desk, sleeves rolled up, face lit by the cold blue of his laptop screen. A series of images were open—crime scene stills: rows of theater seats, a slumped figure, the grotesque puff of popcorn scattered like snow. On one screen, a close-up of a mouth forced open and stuffed with dry kernels. Another showed an empty concession counter—untouched.

Hannibal stood behind him, wineglass in hand, eyes focused, hands still.

Neither of them looked up as she entered.

“You’re home early,” Will muttered, clicking to the next image.

“Finished my scales before Tobias could guilt me into arpeggios.” She stepped into the room, gaze scanning the photos. “So... that’s him?”

Will nodded. “Victim number three. This one wasn’t killed right away. Died from asphyxiation. Popcorn in the throat.”

Abigail moved closer, careful not to interrupt. “That’s new, right? The others were already dead.”

“Yes,” Hannibal said. “Which implies escalation. Or experimentation.”

Will leaned forward, squinting at the timestamp in the corner of the image. “He’s getting bolder. Less careful. No attempt to stage the scene theatrically this time. Just... left there.”

“Like a message,” Abigail murmured.

“Or an impulse,” Hannibal said.

Will rubbed his temple. “It’s always messaging with these guys. Everything’s either a confession or a performance.”

Hannibal circled to the front of the desk, speaking slowly. “The kernel motif implies something both domestic and absurd. Something banal used as a weapon. But popcorn is also nostalgic. It’s tied to childhood. Safety. Entertainment. The desecration of it is intentional.”

“So it’s personal?” Abigail asked. “Someone with trauma around theaters or movies?”

“Perhaps,” Hannibal said. “But perhaps it’s simply symbolic. Popcorn expands when heat is applied. The killer might feel the same way under pressure.”

Will stared at the screen, voice lower now. “He’s not killing to hide. He’s killing to be seen. But he’s not theatrical. He’s precise. This isn’t chaos—it’s ritualized spite.”

Abigail moved closer, eyes narrowing. “He’s not killing for pleasure, then.”

“No,” Hannibal said. “He’s killing for punishment.”

Will finally looked up at her. “You’re good at this.”

Abigail didn’t smile. She didn’t have to.

“I listen,” she said. “To you both.”

A pause.

Will sat back in his chair, eyes still on the screen.

“Well,” he muttered, “let’s hope the Popcorn Killer’s not planning a sequel.”

 

The living room was warm and dimly lit, fire crackling softly in the hearth. Hannibal and Will sat across from each other—wine glasses untouched for now—discussing murder with the same tone most people reserved for recipes or chess.

Abigail sat curled into the corner of the couch, legs tucked under her, phone in hand, only half listening.

Will was talking about blood spray patterns.

Hannibal was disagreeing, politely but firmly, about arterial angles and “emotional blunt force.”

Abigail was texting.

Chandra: my parents are freaking out. they’re talking about not letting me go anywhere alone. my mom literally called the school board today lol

Abigail: they’re not wrong. it’s getting worse.

Chandra: yeah but i’m not scared of “some popcorn weirdo” i’m scared of how my mom starts googling homeschool options

Abigail: ok THAT is terrifying

Across the room, Hannibal gestured with one hand.

“A hammer suggests disorganization,” he said, “but with that kind of pattern, it was likely selected intentionally. A symbolic object, perhaps.”

Will shook his head. “No. He wanted a blunt connection. Something personal. You don’t pick a hammer unless you want to feel the weight of it.”

Abigail barely blinked.

Chandra: you’re so chill about all this. you’re like my emotional support chaos witch

Abigail: i’m just good at pretending nothing rattles me

Chandra: yeah but it’s not pretend is it

She stared at that for a second.

Then:

Abigail: no. not really.

“Abigail,” Hannibal said suddenly, glancing over his glass. “What would you use?”

She looked up. “Huh?”

Will gave her a faint smile. “Hypothetically. If you had to kill someone up close—quickly. What would you use?”

She didn’t even hesitate.

“A belt,” she said. “Wrapped around the throat. Fast. Quiet. Nothing left behind if you take it with you.”

Will blinked.

Hannibal’s lips curled, pleased. “Elegant. Efficient. And personal.”

Abigail went back to her phone as if it were nothing.

Abigail: so anyway... wanna hang out this weekend?

Chandra: yes pls. i need a break from my family’s true crime meltdown

Abigail: my house is worse tbh

Chandra: somehow i believe that

Abigail smiled faintly, the soft glow of her screen reflected in her eyes while her guardians argued about strangulation techniques ten feet away.

 

 

Chapter 7: Popcorn Panic

Chapter Text

The phone rang just past 3 a.m.

Abigail woke in the half-dark, hearing the low murmur of Will’s voice down the hall, the quiet rustle of clothes, the dog’s soft whine as Will moved through the house like a man already halfway gone.

She didn’t ask what happened.

She already knew.


Morning

Sunlight hadn’t quite touched the windows yet when Abigail stepped into the kitchen. The air smelled like citrus and iron—fresh orange peel and the tang of Hannibal’s sharpening stone.

He stood at the counter, dicing mushrooms into symmetrical slivers, a thermos already packed and sealed beside a neatly folded cloth napkin.

“Will left hours ago,” Hannibal said, not looking up. “Baltimore. Another one. The same… signature.”

Abigail nodded. “Popcorn?”

“In the mouth. Car trunk this time. Posed. Theater staff member. Young.”

Abigail exhaled slowly. “He’s escalating.”

“Indeed.”

Hannibal turned then, folding a small steel object into a linen napkin—quick and deliberate. A pocketknife. Slim. Polished.

He tucked it gently into the front zipper of her lunchbox.

“For safety,” he said.

Abigail arched an eyebrow. “So I cut the popcorn killer’s throat if he tries to offer me a movie ticket?”

Hannibal smiled faintly. “No. You run. Then cut.”

She zipped the lunchbox shut without another word. They understood each other.


Outside School – Morning

The parking lot was a swarm of backpacks, tired faces, and the low buzz of fear dressed up like gossip. News vans were parked half a block down. Everyone knew.

Abigail crossed the pavement with a casual stride, her thermos clinking softly in her bag.

Chandra was waiting at the front steps, hoodie pulled up, eyes a little wider than usual.

“Hey,” she said. “You heard?”

“Yeah.”

“They found the body in a car. Near a mall we’ve been to. My mom texted me four times and I hadn’t even brushed my teeth yet.”

“Your mom’s not wrong.”

Chandra looked at her. “Do you think they’re gonna cancel school?”

“They never do,” Abigail said, stepping up beside her. “People just pretend fear isn’t contagious.”

Chandra gave a nervous half-laugh. “I’m not scared, exactly. Just… weirded out. Like something’s watching.”

Abigail stared past the crowd. “It probably is.”

Chandra looked at her sideways. “You always say the creepiest possible thing in the calmest voice.”

“Gifted and talented.”

They both cracked a smile—just a little.

Then Abigail gently bumped her shoulder. “Come on. We’ll survive first period. Maybe.”

And the two of them walked into the building together, side by side.

Abigail didn’t look back.

She had a knife in her lunchbox.

And something colder in her chest.

 

Third period.

The classroom buzzed with whispers, louder than usual, each desk like its own little rumor factory. Students leaned across aisles, phones hidden behind textbooks, eyes not even pretending to look at the board.

“…they found popcorn in his lungs, like he was alive when—”

“No, it’s fake. My cousin says the media makes up half this crap—”

“My dad thinks it’s political. Like a distraction.”

“Three people’s mouths full of popcorn isn’t political, Kyle.”

At her desk by the window, Abigail sat perfectly still, pencil tapping idly against the corner of her notebook. She wasn’t trying to listen—but there was no escaping it. The words filled the room like smoke.

Across the row, Chandra glanced at her, mouthing, “You okay?”

Abigail gave the smallest nod.

She was fine. Everyone else was unraveling.

“Alright,” Mr. Lockridge said at the front of the room, clapping his hands once. “Enough. I know you’ve all read the news. Believe it or not, the killer’s not waiting in the hallway for you to finish algebra.”

A few nervous laughs rippled through the class. Someone in the back coughed popcorn-style. Someone else hissed, “Dude, not funny.”

Mr. Lockridge sighed, rubbing his eyes. “We are focusing on quadratic equations today. That means pencils out, phones away, and your morbid curiosity can wait until after school.”

Reluctantly, most of the class quieted. Papers shuffled. The whiteboard came back into focus.

But the tension didn’t leave.

It clung to the air like static, and Abigail could still feel it crawling just under her skin.

 

It was late afternoon when the school finally emptied out, the sky streaked with thin gold and lavender light. Abigail and Chandra cut away from the busier streets, toward the park—needing air, needing away.

The tension of the day clung to them like dust.

“I feel like everyone’s vibrating at the same frequency today,” Chandra said, wrapping her arms around herself as they walked the path. “Like they’re waiting for something awful to happen, but no one wants to say it out loud.”

Abigail kept her eyes on the path ahead. “Sometimes saying it makes it real.”

Chandra glanced at her. “That a personal rule?”

“Something like that.”

The trees thinned slightly, leading them to a clearing ringed by brush. They paused near a bench, Chandra exhaling as she looked up through the bare branches.

“This is nice,” she said.

Abigail smiled faintly. “Yeah. Quiet.”

Then—footsteps.

Too fast. Too hard.

Three men stepped out of the trees on the opposite side of the clearing. Hooded. One carried a bat, the other something heavier, glinting.

Abigail’s hand went straight to her backpack—zipping it open, fingers brushing metal.

“Keep walking,” she said low, not looking at Chandra.

“What—?”

“Now.”

The men fanned out. One grinned. “You girls got the wrong park.”

Abigail stepped in front of Chandra. “We’re leaving.”

“You’re staying.”

Then it happened fast.

One lunged. Abigail yanked the knife from her bag—Hannibal’s knife—and slashed upward. A scream. The man staggered back, hand to his cheek.

Another came at her from behind. A blow landed hard against her shoulder—pain bloomed sharp and bright. She dropped to one knee, arm numb.

“Abigail!” Chandra shrieked.

The third grabbed Chandra by the arm, yanking her back toward the brush.

And then—

CRACK.

A body hit the ground hard.

The man holding Chandra crumpled suddenly, breathless.

Behind him stood Tobias Budge.

Elegant. Silent.

Holding a carbon fiber violin case like a bludgeon.

Another attacker turned—too late. Tobias’s foot swept beneath his knee. He went down with a grunt.

Abigail pushed herself up, knife still in hand, shoulder throbbing. The final man turned to flee.

Tobias didn’t follow.

He looked at her instead.

“Are you injured?” he asked, voice calm.

Abigail was breathing hard, face pale. “Just bruised.”

Chandra stared at him, frozen.

Tobias looked to her next. “You?”

She shook her head.

The men groaned on the ground behind them.

Tobias crouched beside one, placing two fingers to his throat.

“Alive,” he said, disappointed. “Unfortunately.”

“Why are you here?” Abigail asked, still panting.

“I walk this park on Thursdays,” Tobias said. “For air. And symmetry.”

He stood, brushing his coat sleeves. “Consider this… an intervention.”

Abigail looked at him for a long moment, knife still in her hand.

Then, finally:

“Thanks.”

Tobias gave the barest nod. “You’re welcome.”

 

The three attackers lay groaning in the dirt, their bravado long gone. One clutched his knee, another held his bleeding cheek, and the third had barely moved since Tobias dropped him.

Abigail stood over them, knuckles white around Hannibal’s pocketknife. Her shoulder ached, but the pain felt far away now—muffled by fury.

Chandra sat on the bench, hands shaking, trying not to cry.

Tobias stood nearby, leaning against a tree like he hadn’t just cracked a man’s ribs with a violin case.

“Your friend needs grounding,” he said, nodding toward Chandra. “She’s hyperventilating.”

Abigail shot him a look. “You’re not the nurturing type.”

“I didn’t say I would do it.”

Fair.

Abigail walked to the bench, slowly crouching in front of Chandra. “Hey. Look at me.”

Chandra blinked at her, dazed. “Abigail, what—who the hell was that guy—?”

“We’re okay,” Abigail said softly. “We’re okay now.”

Chandra stared at her, eyes wide. “That was a knife. You had a knife. You didn’t even flinch—”

“I need you to breathe,” Abigail interrupted gently, pressing Chandra’s hand between hers. “In through your nose. Out through your mouth. Come on.”

Chandra did. Shaky, ragged—but she did.

Abigail stood, pulled out her phone, and dialed.

The line rang once.

Then: “Abigail?”

Hannibal’s voice—calm, alert.

“We were attacked,” she said, voice low and steady. “In the park off 8th. I defended us. Tobias showed up. He helped.”

Silence on the other end for a beat.

“Are you injured?”

“Not badly. Bruised. One of them’s bleeding.”

“And Chandra?”

“She’s scared. But not hurt.”

“I’m coming,” Hannibal said. “Stay where you are. Tobias will remain until I arrive.”

“I figured,” she said, glancing over at him. “He seems invested.”

Another pause.

“Do not put the knife away,” Hannibal said, voice quiet steel. “Not yet.”

Click.

Abigail slid the phone into her jacket pocket.

Tobias met her eyes across the path.

“Your father sounds... unconcerned.”

“He’s very concerned,” Abigail said. “He just expresses it with food and murder.”

Tobias smirked slightly. “How civilized.”

Chandra looked up, still pale. “What’s happening right now? Why are you both acting like this is normal?”

Abigail exhaled, sitting beside her. “Because it is. For me.”

The words hung there, heavier than anything else.

And above them, the branches swayed in the wind.

Waiting.

 

By the time Hannibal’s car pulled up to the curb, the shadows had lengthened across the park and the attackers had limped away into the trees—broken, humiliated, but breathing. Tobias remained until the very moment Hannibal arrived, then tipped his head in a courteous nod and vanished without waiting for thanks.

Hannibal stepped out of the car in his usual tailored calm, coat buttoned, gloves on. But his eyes—when they met Abigail’s—were fire behind glass.

He looked her over quickly, efficiently. “Show me.”

Abigail pulled back her jacket just enough to reveal the deep bruising blooming across her shoulder. Hannibal’s jaw flexed. He said nothing.

Then he turned to Chandra, who stood stiffly by the bench, shaken but alert.

“Chandra,” he said smoothly, his voice gentle but firm. “Would you like me to take you home?”

She hesitated. “I—I don’t want to leave her—”

“You’re not,” Hannibal said, offering a small, careful smile. “You’re trusting that I will take care of her now.”

Abigail nodded toward Chandra. “It’s okay. Really. I’ll text you.”

Chandra looked between them—her best friend and the man she’d only heard about in fragments. She wasn’t sure if she felt safer or more unnerved by his presence.

But eventually, she nodded. “Okay.”


In the Car

The drive was quiet.

Chandra sat up front, silent and wide-eyed, hands folded tightly in her lap. Hannibal drove without haste, eyes fixed on the road like it had personally offended him.

Abigail sat in the back, watching the passing lights flicker through the window.

No music. No small talk.

Just the soft hum of tires and the weight of everything unspoken.

When they reached Chandra’s house, Hannibal pulled up to the curb and put the car in park.

He turned to her slowly. “Would you like me to speak with your parents? Reassure them that you’re safe?”

Chandra blinked. “No—thank you. They’d... have a lot of questions I don’t know how to answer.”

“A wise choice,” Hannibal said, smiling faintly. “You handled yourself well, Chandra. Not everyone does under pressure.”

She opened the door slowly, hesitating.

Then looked back at Abigail.

“You’ll text me?”

“Yeah,” Abigail said. “Soon.”

Chandra nodded once and stepped out into the dark. Hannibal waited until she was inside—until the porch light clicked on and her silhouette disappeared behind the front door—before pulling away.


Back in the Car – Alone

Hannibal spoke without turning his head.

“Tobias intervened.”

“Yes.”

“Uncharacteristically noble of him.”

“He saved us.”

“He endangered you by approaching you earlier this week.”

Abigail didn’t argue. She just looked out the window.

“I defended us,” she said quietly. “But I couldn’t finish it. I froze, just for a second.”

“And you survived,” Hannibal said. “Which means it was enough.”

They didn’t speak again until the house appeared ahead of them—quiet, safe, glowing like nothing in the world had gone wrong.

Chapter 8: The Edge

Chapter Text

The kitchen was dimly lit, the kind of quiet Hannibal cultivated like a symphony. Abigail sat at the counter in one of Will’s old sweaters, bruised shoulder wrapped in a compress, fingers curled around a warm mug of thick hot chocolate. Real chocolate—melted dark, spiced faintly with cinnamon and a hint of clove. No packets. No shortcuts.

Hannibal had even made fresh whipped cream.

“I added a touch of anise,” he said, placing the spoon gently on her saucer. “It helps with pain.”

“I thought that was psychosomatic.”

He gave a faint smile. “Psychosomatic doesn’t mean ineffective.”

Abigail took a sip. Sweet. Sharp. Perfect.

In the living room, the opening credits of a French noir film flickered across the screen—black-and-white, slow-paced, stylish and fatal. Exactly the kind of thing Hannibal considered “comfort viewing.”

For a while, there was peace.

Then the front door opened with more force than usual.

Will.

Boots thudding against hardwood. Breath audible before he even reached the kitchen.

Abigail turned slightly. Hannibal didn’t.

“What happened?” Will’s voice cut through the quiet like a blade.

Hannibal simply said, “She was attacked.”

Will froze. “Where?”

“The park near school,” Abigail said, calm but not cold. “Three guys. They were trying to drag Chandra into the trees. I stopped them.”

Will stepped forward, hands trembling with restraint. “You stopped them?”

“I had the knife you gave me,” she said, gesturing to her bag. “Hannibal’s, technically.”

Hannibal added, “She defended herself. Then Tobias intervened.”

Will’s jaw clenched. “Tobias.”

Abigail nodded. “He saved us. He left once Hannibal arrived.”

Will’s eyes went dark.

“You’re telling me three men tried to take you,” he said slowly, “and they’re still breathing?”

“Yes,” Abigail said. “They’re broken. Not dead.”

Will turned to Hannibal.

Hannibal simply said, “I didn’t want to leave her alone. But now we’re both here.”

A pause.

No more discussion.

No debate.

Will’s voice dropped to a growl. “Where?”

“About a mile south of the east entrance. They ran into the woods.”

Will turned, already reaching for his coat.

Hannibal moved without rush, already pulling on gloves. “They won’t expect to be punished. Which makes this... efficient.”

“You’re not doing this just because of me,” Abigail said quietly. “Are you?”

Will looked back at her, eyes softer now. “No. But for you? Absolutely.”

Hannibal met her gaze. “Finish your chocolate.”

They left together—shadows moving out into the cold, unspoken promises wrapped in silence.

The front door shut behind them.

Abigail stayed on the stool, sipping her hot chocolate, the movie flickering softly behind her.

She didn’t smile.

But she didn’t stop them, either.

 

The movie played on in grainy black-and-white. A man smoked in shadows, a woman wept behind a curtain. The score whispered strings and silence.

Abigail sat curled into the corner of the couch, blanket pulled around her knees, the empty mug still warm in her hands. The fire crackled in the hearth like it didn’t know anything was wrong.

But she knew what time it was.

Will and Hannibal would be in the woods by now.

Moving with purpose.

Doing what needed to be done.

She didn’t check the clock. She didn’t need to.

Her phone buzzed softly against her thigh.

She hesitated—then picked it up.

Chandra:
hey. u home?

Abigail stared at the screen a moment before replying.

Abigail:
yeah. just got back a little while ago.

Chandra:
okay. just checking.
i can’t stop thinking about it.

Abigail:
me neither.

There was a pause. Three blinking dots. Then:

Chandra:
you weren’t scared.

Abigail exhaled, thumb hovering over the screen.

Then she typed:

Abigail:
i was.
but fear doesn’t stop me anymore.

Another pause. Longer this time.

Chandra:
tobias… that guy…
who is he?

Abigail looked at the fire, eyes unfocused. Smoke curled up like secrets.

She could lie.

She could deflect.

But instead:

Abigail:
someone who understands the parts of me i don’t show most people.

The typing bubbles appeared. Then vanished.

Then reappeared.

Chandra:
does that include me?

Abigail’s breath caught for just a second.

Then:

Abigail:
i’m still figuring that out.
but i want it to.

Another long pause.

Chandra:
okay.

Just that. Simple. But it hit harder than anything else that day.

The movie kept playing.

Someone screamed offscreen.

Abigail leaned back into the couch cushions, phone resting on her stomach, the firelight dancing across her face.

Outside, the night held its breath.

Inside, Abigail waited.

And hoped the blood wouldn’t reach the carpet.

 

The fire in the hearth had dwindled to glowing embers.

The house was still, wrapped in silence, save for the soft hum of the movie credits rolling on repeat.

Abigail lay on the couch, half-awake, half-watching. Her mug was empty. Her blanket had slipped halfway off her legs.

She heard the front door open before she saw them.

She didn’t sit up right away.

Boots on wood. The click of the door shutting. The shuffle of coats being peeled off, damp fabric landing on the entryway tile.

And then—

Footsteps.

Will entered the room first, his hair wind-blown, his face streaked with drying blood. None of it his.

His eyes were quiet. Focused. Clear in a way they rarely were.

Hannibal followed, perfectly composed as always, though his white cuffs were stained crimson and his gloves were tucked into his coat pocket—wet with something that would never come out.

They looked like two men returning from an evening walk.

Or from war.

Abigail sat up slowly, blanket sliding off.

“You’re back,” she said softly.

Hannibal gave a faint nod, moving to the bar to pour himself a small glass of port.

Will remained standing, breathing steadily, eyes on the flickering screen. The light made the blood on his cheek look black.

“They’re gone,” Will said simply. “All three.”

Abigail didn’t ask how.

She didn’t need to.

Hannibal returned, glass in hand, and sat down across from her. He removed his watch carefully, setting it on the table beside him.

“Will was,” he said with quiet reverence, “exceptional.”

Will shot him a look, but said nothing.

“I expected us to share the work,” Hannibal continued, swirling the port. “But he... finished.”

Abigail looked at Will, not with fear.

But with understanding.

“You didn’t have to,” she said softly.

Will finally met her eyes.

“Yes, I did.”

Hannibal sipped his drink, content.

No more words were needed.

The fire popped quietly. The movie looped into its opening frame again.

And in that moment, blood drying on the floor of the entryway and darkness wrapped around them like a second skin, Abigail felt something sharp settle in her chest:

Security.

Not softness. Not peace.

But protection.

The kind carved in flesh and silence.

 

The lunch courtyard buzzed with the same nervous energy it had all week. Popcorn Killer whispers still floated through every conversation, even as school life tried to normalize around the fear.

Abigail and Chandra sat under their usual tree, two trays between them, their backpacks like fortresses at their sides. Chandra had brought homemade potato curry again. Abigail offered part of her sandwich, carefully made by Will—roasted vegetables, pickled onions, crust trimmed neatly. The unspoken domestic weirdness of her life.

Chandra took a bite, then looked down at the grass. Her voice was quiet, careful.

“I didn’t tell my parents what really happened.”

Abigail glanced up. “You didn’t?”

“They think some guys scared us and ran off. I said you yelled, that they didn’t touch us. I didn’t say anything about the knife. Or... Tobias.”

Abigail nodded slowly. “That’s probably smart.”

Chandra fiddled with her spoon, still not meeting her eyes. “But I’ve been thinking about it.”

Abigail waited.

Finally, Chandra looked up. “How did you know what to do? That fast. That calm. You had a knife in your bag. Not pepper spray. Not a key between your fingers. A knife.”

Abigail’s fingers twitched on her sandwich wrapper.

“I’ve had to learn,” she said. “Things happened to me. Before I came to live with Will and Hannibal. Bad things. And after that, I wasn’t allowed to be unprepared.”

Chandra blinked. “So they taught you?”

Abigail gave a slow nod. “Yeah. Self-defense, awareness, reading people. Hannibal made me practice on moving targets—he calls it discipline. Will made sure I knew when not to act.”

Chandra leaned in slightly. “But in the park, you didn’t hesitate. You moved like someone who’d already made peace with hurting someone.”

“I did,” Abigail said quietly.

Chandra didn’t speak for a long moment.

Then: “Does that scare you?”

Abigail thought about it. Really thought.

“No,” she said. “It scares me that I like being ready. That it feels better than being afraid.”

Chandra studied her, uncertain.

“I’m not dangerous to you,” Abigail said quickly. “I would never hurt you.”

“I know,” Chandra said. Then, softer: “I believe you.”

They sat quietly for a bit, the noise of the school falling away. The trees above them swayed gently. A breeze passed, cool and sharp.

Then Chandra reached over, took Abigail’s hand in hers, and squeezed.

“You’re still weird,” she said. “But I guess you’re my kind of weird.”

Abigail smiled.

 

 

Chapter 9: Dinner & Danger

Notes:

Finally a cute scene and a budding relationship!

Chapter Text

The end-of-day sun was slanting low across the schoolyard, painting the pavement in long gold streaks. Most students had already cleared out, voices trailing into the distance like smoke.

Abigail and Chandra sat on the low concrete ledge outside the science wing, picking at the remnants of vending machine trail mix. The silence between them was easy now. Less about what wasn’t being said—and more about what had been.

Chandra tossed a peanut into her mouth and glanced at Abigail.

“So,” she began. “About what you said earlier…”

Abigail raised an eyebrow. “Which part?”

“The part where you admitted you know how to maim people.”

Abigail smirked. “That narrows it down.”

Chandra laughed under her breath. Then, hesitating just slightly: “Will you teach me?”

Abigail blinked. “What?”

“Self-defense,” Chandra clarified. “Like, real stuff. Not the PE-class elbow-jab nonsense. What you know. The way you moved in the park... it wasn’t luck.”

Abigail’s pulse kicked up, not with fear—excitement.

“You want me to teach you?” she asked, sitting up straighter.

Chandra shrugged, but her eyes were serious. “I don’t want to be scared anymore. And you make it look like... survival doesn’t have to mean flinching.”

Abigail grinned, teeth flashing. “We can practice at my house. The backyard’s secluded. Will won’t care, and Hannibal will just make weirdly philosophical comments about balance and footwork.”

Chandra laughed. “He probably has a monologue prepared already.”

“Oh, definitely. He’ll bring us tea halfway through and say something like, 'Stability in the body is a metaphor for control over one’s moral compass.’”

“And then offer us finger sandwiches with a suspicious filling.”

Abigail stood and offered her hand. “C’mon. You’re officially my student now. First lesson: don’t fall for charm.”

Chandra took her hand and pulled herself up. “Even yours?”

Abigail smirked. “Especially mine.”

 

The Lecter-Graham home stood at the edge of the woods, half-swallowed by trees and late afternoon light. Chandra paused at the base of the stone steps, bag slung over one shoulder, eyes tracing the details—wrought-iron railings, weathered shutters, windows like watchful eyes.

“Okay,” she whispered. “This is definitely not what I expected.”

Abigail grinned beside her. “Yeah, it looks like a magazine and a murder scene had a baby.”

“You have lamps in the entryway. Matching ones. There’s no dust. I think that’s what’s freaking me out.”

“You haven’t even met Hannibal yet,” Abigail said. “That’s the part that freaks people out.”

Chandra swallowed and followed her inside.


Inside

The foyer was warm and dim, lit with soft amber light and the scent of roasted garlic and something floral. Chandra looked around slowly—polished wood floors, heavy bookshelves, oil paintings that stared too long. The air felt intentional.

Will emerged from the hallway first, sleeves rolled up, damp curls clinging to his forehead. He paused when he saw them.

“You must be Chandra,” he said, voice tired but kind. “Welcome.”

“Hi,” Chandra said, holding out her hand. “You must be the lava cake of trauma.”

Will blinked.

Abigail groaned. “Chandra.”

Will looked between them. Then, unexpectedly, he smiled. “I’ve been called worse.”

Then: “You’re staying for dinner?”

Before Chandra could answer, Hannibal stepped in from the kitchen, still in his apron, wiping his hands on a linen towel. He looked every bit the part of the perfect host—calm, elegant, eyes bright with practiced interest.

“Ah,” he said smoothly. “The infamous Chandra. You’ve been quite the topic at our dinner table.”

Chandra flushed. “Hopefully in a good way?”

Hannibal stepped forward and extended a hand. “Always. I’m Hannibal Lecter.”

“Nice to meet you,” Chandra said, shaking it. “Your house smells... amazing and intimidating.”

“Thank you,” Hannibal said, pleased. “Would you like to stay for dinner?”

Chandra glanced at Abigail—who gave a subtle, reassuring nod.

“I’d love to,” Chandra said. “Just... heads-up. I’m vegetarian.”

Hannibal didn’t even blink.

“Not a problem. I prepared lentil and walnut pâté, mushroom tartlets, and grilled squash with rosemary. A meatless evening... in your honor.”

Abigail gave him a look. “You just happened to make a fully vegetarian meal?”

“I suspected she might be,” Hannibal said, glancing at Will. “And it never hurts to be prepared.”

Will muttered, “You’re never unprepared.”

Chandra laughed nervously. “I think I might be a little scared of him.”

Abigail smirked. “Good instinct.”

 

The tour started politely.

“This is the library,” Abigail said, gesturing at a high-ceilinged room filled with books that looked older than their school. “Hannibal alphabetized them by subject, not author. He says it ‘stimulates thematic curiosity.’”

Chandra wandered in a slow circle, staring up at the rows. “It’s like a haunted castle in here. If I hear a cello solo out of nowhere, I’m running.”

“You’ll hear one eventually,” Abigail said. “That’s not a joke.”

They passed through the parlor, where the fireplace was still faintly warm, and the sitting room, where Hannibal had arranged dried lavender on the mantle with surgical precision.

By the time they stepped into the backyard, the tension had peeled back like a layer of skin. The sky was dusky, bruised purple and orange, the trees rustling softly at the edge of the woods.

Chandra looked around. “Okay. This is more your energy.”

Abigail smiled. “Yeah. Out here I don’t have to be so still.”

She led Chandra to a patch of grass near the tree line—cleared, flat, with a few pavers outlining a ring. The training spot. Will called it the circle.

“So,” Chandra said, dropping her bag, “what’s lesson one?”

“Balance,” Abigail said, stepping back and sliding into a stance—feet shoulder-width apart, knees slightly bent. “Everything starts with where you put your weight.”

Chandra mirrored her, awkwardly.

“Feet out a little more,” Abigail said, nudging her left foot with the side of her own. “You want to be able to move in any direction without falling.”

“Like this?”

“Better. Now, when someone comes at you—don’t think about stopping them. Think about redirecting. Use their movement.”

Chandra raised her eyebrows. “You do sound like a kung fu movie.”

Abigail grinned. “Just wait until we get to disarming techniques.”

She stepped closer. “Okay, I’m going to push you. Try to stay grounded.”

“You’re what now—?”

Abigail gave her a sudden, sharp nudge at the shoulder. Chandra wobbled, yelped, and stumbled back.

“You weren’t grounded,” Abigail said, suppressing a smirk.

“You’re smug.”

“I’m right.”

They reset. Abigail pushed again—this time slower. Chandra held her footing.

“There you go,” Abigail said. “See? Strong base. Good reaction time.”

Chandra beamed. “I feel like a boulder.”

“A very graceful boulder.”

For the next twenty minutes, they moved in the fading light. Abigail demonstrated basic grabs, blocks, and a wrist escape that made Chandra gasp when it actually worked.

They were laughing by the end. Breathless, flushed, alive.

Abigail stepped back, eyes soft. “You did good.”

Chandra looked at her—really looked at her. “You’re kind of incredible, you know that?”

Abigail blinked, caught off guard.

“I mean it,” Chandra said. “Not just the knife stuff. The you stuff.”

Abigail looked away, suddenly shy. “We should head in.”

“Yeah,” Chandra said, still watching her. “But this... we’re doing this again.”

Abigail nodded. “Definitely.”

 

Abigail’s room was lit by a small, amber lamp in the corner. The curtains were half-drawn, the window cracked slightly to let in the cool evening air. It smelled faintly of clean linen and cedarwood—Hannibal insisted on natural incense, of course.

Chandra sat cross-legged on the rug, flipping through a worn sketchbook she’d brought from her bag. Abigail lounged on the bed, upside down, head hanging off the side, hair brushing the floor, staring at the ceiling.

“Your room’s... so clean,” Chandra said, still flipping pages. “I imagined more chaos.”

“Will tried to let it be messy,” Abigail said. “Hannibal didn’t.”

Chandra smirked. “Of course he didn’t. He probably labels the spice jars in Latin.”

“He does,” Abigail said. “And he keeps a special drawer for tea leaves. With dividers.”

They laughed softly.

A comfortable silence settled between them.

Chandra set the sketchbook aside and lay back on the rug, looking up at Abigail from below. “You know... this is the first time I’ve felt calm all week.”

Abigail tilted her head to meet her gaze, upside down. “Really?”

Chandra nodded. “I keep thinking about the park. About you. And how... you didn’t even flinch.”

“I’ve had practice.”

“I know,” Chandra said softly. “But still. It felt like you were protecting me. Like, really protecting me. No one’s ever done that before.”

Abigail slowly rolled upright, sliding off the bed to sit on the rug beside her.

They sat close. Too close.

Abigail’s voice was quieter now. “I wanted to. I want to.”

Chandra looked at her, face open. Unafraid.

“I feel safe with you,” she whispered.

And then, slowly, like the moment had always been waiting—

Abigail leaned in.

Chandra met her halfway.

Their lips touched gently—warm, uncertain, a little clumsy. It wasn’t practiced or perfect. It was real.

When they pulled apart, just a breath between them, neither of them moved right away.

Chandra’s cheeks were flushed. Abigail looked stunned—but soft.

Chandra smiled, shy but sure. “So... yeah. That happened.”

Abigail laughed once, breathless. “Yeah.”

Then: “Do it again?”

Chandra leaned in and kissed her again—longer this time. Steadier.

From downstairs, faintly, came the sound of classical music playing and a kitchen drawer sliding open. The smell of rosemary and something baking floated up through the vents.

But up here, in this moment—

There was nothing but them.

 

A soft chime rang through the upstairs hallway—Hannibal’s voice, calm and measured, drifting up from the intercom speaker embedded in the wall:

“Dinner is served.”

Chandra blinked. “You have an intercom?”

Abigail stood, brushing invisible dust from her sleeves. “It’s Hannibal. Of course we have an intercom.”

They made their way downstairs, the scent of rosemary and lemon deepening with every step. Warm lights glowed across the long dining table, which was already set: ironed linen napkins, wine glasses (sparkling water for the girls), individual side plates for each dish.

Will was already seated at one end, nursing a short glass of whiskey. Hannibal stood at the head of the table, carving a tart into perfect triangles with a silver knife.

Chandra hesitated in the doorway just for a moment—then straightened her shoulders and followed Abigail in.

“You two took your time,” Will said with a raised eyebrow, though his voice was neutral.

Abigail shrugged. “We were practicing self-defense.”

Will looked at her for a beat longer than necessary. Then turned back to his drink.

Hannibal smiled as he set the serving plate down. “I’m sure that’s exactly what it was.”

Chandra’s ears burned, but she sat down gracefully at her place, napkin in her lap. “It smells amazing.”

Hannibal nodded. “Tonight: a vegetarian spread. Wild mushroom tart, spiced red lentils with curry leaves, roasted root vegetables, and a sorrel-and-rice salad with mustard seed dressing. Dessert is rosewater semolina cake.”

Chandra blinked. “You cooked Indian food?”

“I improvised,” Hannibal said with a small smile. “In deference to your heritage—and your appetite.”

Will muttered, “He researched all afternoon. We had a whole turmeric conversation.”

Chandra laughed, tension slipping a little. “That’s really thoughtful.”

“I find cultural specificity... grounding,” Hannibal said, slicing tart portions onto plates. “Your culture’s reverence for spice is admirable. Spice as history. Spice as memory. Not unlike French cuisine, but far more honest.”

Chandra looked between him and Will. “Do you guys cook together?”

Will shook his head. “I try. He doesn’t like when I measure by ‘feel.’”

Hannibal offered Will a flat, dry look. “He once attempted to sear eggplant without salting it first.”

Chandra made a fake gasp. “Scandalous.”

Abigail grinned behind her fork. “This is them flirting.”

Will took a sip of whiskey. “She’s not wrong.”

They all laughed—genuinely, this time. The air eased a little.

Chandra glanced toward Hannibal. “My mom makes something called saag paneer that I’ve never seen in any restaurant. She grows the fenugreek in our backyard. Says if you don’t get the leaves young enough, it all tastes like bitterness.”

Hannibal gave a slow, impressed nod. “Your mother sounds meticulous.”

“She’s terrifying. But yeah.”

“I would be honored if you shared one of her recipes sometime,” Hannibal said.

Will smirked. “You’re asking for her family secrets now?”

“I believe in connection through tradition,” Hannibal replied.

“Careful,” Chandra said, smiling. “She’ll try to invite you over for chai and three hours of passive-aggressive questions.”

“I welcome the challenge.”

Abigail gave Chandra’s knee a quiet nudge under the table. Their eyes met. Chandra’s face softened.

She wasn’t sure if this was weird or perfect or both.

But she felt seen.

 

The rosewater semolina cake was delicate, warm, and just slightly sticky—the kind of dessert that lingered on the tongue like memory. Chandra took one bite and let out a tiny, involuntary hum of satisfaction.

“Oh my god, this is good.”

Hannibal inclined his head. “I’m glad. It’s a variation on sooji halwa—with a French-style finish.”

“Of course it is,” Abigail said, grinning. “Everything here is a variation on something French.”

Will added dryly, “Except for me.”

“You’re Appalachian,” Abigail shot back. “You’re your own cuisine.”

Chandra snorted, nearly choking on her cake. “Is that like... whiskey and moral dread?”

Will raised his glass slightly. “You’ve been paying attention.”

Hannibal sipped his espresso. “We each bring something to the table.”

Chandra, still smiling, leaned forward slightly. “Do you guys have any family traditions? Like weird ones?”

Abigail shrugged. “Hannibal celebrates everything like a monk at a tasting menu. Will pretends holidays don’t exist unless there’s pie.”

Will gestured with his fork. “I like traditions when they don’t come with tinsel and judgment.”

“And you?” Hannibal asked, looking to Chandra. “What traditions do you hold close?”

Chandra smiled, more thoughtfully now. “We do rangoli on Diwali—colored powder designs on the porch. My mom’s always exact about the patterns, but mine’s messier. I like it that way.”

Abigail tilted her head. “I bet it’s pretty.”

“It’s meditative,” Chandra said. “And then we light a ridiculous number of diyas. Tiny clay lamps everywhere. It’s beautiful and borderline unsafe.”

Will smirked. “Sounds like our Christmas Eve.”

Hannibal added, “We set fires more intentionally, but the sentiment is the same.”

Abigail nodded. “Next time you come over, we should make our own. Rangoli, I mean.”

“You want to do art with me?” Chandra said, eyebrows raised.

“I’ll let you pick the colors.”

“I feel honored.”

Then, as the conversation lulled and the plates cleared, Chandra asked, “Do you guys ever have other guests over?”

Will looked to Hannibal. Hannibal, of course, looked to Abigail.

She leaned back in her chair, casual but clearly enjoying the moment.

“We have one sometimes,” she said. “Freddie Lounds.”

Will groaned softly. “Of course she comes up during dessert.”

Hannibal’s mouth twitched. “Freddie is... difficult to digest.”

“Who’s Freddie?” Chandra asked.

“A journalist,” Abigail said. “Well, blogger. Tabloid legend. Chaos gremlin.”

“She writes about true crime,” Will muttered. “And smells like expensive leather and lawsuits.”

“She’s also my friend,” Abigail said, poking Will with her fork. “Kind of.”

Chandra tilted her head. “That... actually makes sense.”

Hannibal said mildly, “Freddie is an acquired taste. Much like revenge or durian.”

“She helped me,” Abigail added, more quietly now. “When I didn’t have anyone else. So I put up with her... Freddie-ness.”

Will sighed. “She’s dangerous.”

Abigail smiled. “So am I.”

Chandra looked between them, then settled her eyes on Abigail.

“Yeah,” she said softly. “You are.”

 

Back upstairs, the tension that hummed quietly under the dinner table melted away.

Abigail kicked off her boots near the bed. Chandra dropped onto the rug, pulling her hair up into a loose bun, the remains of laughter still on her face.

“That was… the fanciest dinner I’ve ever had,” she said. “I don’t know whether I’m full or just emotionally fed.”

Abigail flopped onto the bed beside her, stomach full, heart fluttering. “You survived Hannibal’s full host mode. That’s basically a rite of passage.”

Chandra grinned. “Will’s whole vibe is like, ‘I live with a terrifying genius, and I’d really rather be in the woods.’”

Abigail let out a snort. “Exactly.”

They lapsed into silence for a moment, the kind that settles easy between people who trust each other. Abigail picked at the edge of her sleeve, then glanced down at Chandra.

“I’m really glad you stayed.”

Chandra looked up, eyes soft. “Me too.”

Laughter and light hummed through the closed door as they shifted into softer conversation—music, stories, secrets—but downstairs…


Downstairs – Kitchen

The warmth of the evening lingered in the air as Hannibal and Will cleaned in near silence, the clink of dishes and running water the only sound between them for several minutes.

Will dried a wine glass with a linen towel, his movements methodical.

“She likes Chandra,” he said finally.

Hannibal nodded, stacking plates with deliberate care. “She does.”

“You think it’s safe?”

Hannibal’s mouth curved, subtle. “Nothing is safe, Will. But it may be worthwhile.”

Will set the glass down. “She’s curious. I can see it in her eyes.”

“She’s intelligent,” Hannibal replied. “Curiosity is inevitable.”

“That’s not always a good thing around us.”

Hannibal glanced toward the stairs. “Abigail is cautious when it matters. She’ll reveal what she chooses, in her own time.”

“And if Chandra asks the wrong question?” Will asked, drying another glass. “What then?”

Hannibal turned the faucet off and looked at him fully now. Calm. Composed. Sharp.

“Then we trust Abigail to answer it the right way. Or not at all.”

Will exhaled. “You’re not even worried, are you?”

“I find her instincts... promising.”

Will shook his head, but there was no fight in it. “You find everything promising until it bites back.”

“Then we’ll bite harder,” Hannibal said, and handed him the next plate.

The dogs barked softly in the next room, a single, distant warning.

But upstairs, laughter echoed again, soft and bright.

 

Chapter 10: Nowhere Safe

Notes:

Popcorn Killer is getting close!

Chapter Text

The cafeteria hummed with the usual midday din—trays clattering, conversations tumbling over each other, the underlying chaos of teenage routine. Abigail and Chandra had claimed their usual table under the drafty side window, half-shielded from the noise.

Chandra was picking at her tiffin of lemon rice and chickpeas. Abigail had a sandwich and carrot sticks packed in immaculate rows—clearly one of Hannibal’s more subtle meals.

“He even cut them on the bias,” Chandra muttered. “It’s like eating art. Kind of makes me want to rebel and eat it with my fingers.”

Abigail smirked. “Do it. I won’t narc.”

“I’d hope not,” Chandra said. “I’ve seen you fake an entire moral breakdown to avoid gym class. You could get away with murder.”

Abigail smiled but didn’t answer.

Then—click.

The cafeteria speakers popped once, and everyone flinched just a little before the voice came through.

“Attention students and faculty. This is Principal Alders. Due to ongoing public safety concerns and updated police guidance, all students will be released early today. Buses will arrive within the hour. Please wait in your assigned areas and check your email for further updates.”

The buzz in the room stilled for a moment—then swelled into a low roar of confused, nervous voices.

“Shit,” Chandra said softly.

“Popcorn Killer,” Abigail muttered. “Too close.”

Across the cafeteria, someone stood and said too loudly, “It’s probably fake! Just to freak us out!”

Someone else snapped, “Then why is school closing?”

“I don’t like this,” Chandra whispered, gripping her lunchbox. “He’s not even targeting anyone specific, right? Random people? It could be anyone.”

Abigail’s face hardened a little. Her voice dropped. “It won’t be you.”

Chandra looked at her. “You don’t know that.”

“I do,” Abigail said. “Because if he tries, he won’t make it to the second attempt.”

Their eyes locked.

Something passed between them—fear, yes, but also something steadier. Heavier.

A choice.

Chandra exhaled and looked around at the cafeteria as if seeing it differently now. “You think it’s today?”

“I think people panic before the storm,” Abigail said. “And sometimes... they're right to.”

 

The school front lawn buzzed like a disturbed hive—students gathered in loose clusters, some pacing, some sitting, some pretending not to be scared. Teachers stood around in high-visibility vests with clipboards, trying to maintain order with forced smiles and frayed patience.

Abigail stood with her backpack slung over one shoulder, arms crossed, eyes scanning the lot.

Chandra hovered beside her, chewing the inside of her cheek. “My parents are on their way. My dad called and yelled at a teacher from traffic. My mom’s probably prepping a lecture about how you’re a bad influence.”

Abigail smirked. “I mean, she’s not wrong.”

Chandra elbowed her gently. “She doesn’t know anything.”

Abigail’s gaze drifted to the curb just as a sleek, deep gray car pulled up—Will behind the wheel, eyes hidden behind dark glasses, jaw tense. Hannibal sat in the passenger seat, gloved hands folded neatly in his lap, his posture perfect and unreadable.

They didn’t get out.

They didn’t need to.

Abigail straightened. “That’s me.”

Chandra turned to look—and blinked. “Okay. Why do they look like they just got back from burying someone in the woods?”

Abigail gave her a small smile. “Because they probably did.”

Chandra opened her mouth, then paused. “I can never tell when you’re kidding.”

“You shouldn’t try.”

From the opposite side of the crowd came the unmistakable sound of a car horn—sharp, aggressive, insistent. A red SUV pulled into the lot like it owned the place, almost clipping a traffic cone. Chandra’s parents spilled out, both shouting over each other before they even reached the sidewalk.

“—you said you’d wait at the side entrance—!”

“—I told you it’s the front! Why would she be in the back if they’re evacuating?!”

“Chandra!” her mom barked. “We’re leaving. Now.”

Chandra sighed, looked at Abigail, and started to walk—then hesitated.

Abigail walked toward her.

They met halfway between the two cars.

Neither spoke for a second. Around them, teachers barked names, students crammed into buses, the world swelled with noise.

But the space between them was still.

“You okay?” Abigail asked.

Chandra nodded. “You?”

“I will be.”

They didn’t hug. Didn’t need to.

But as they stepped back toward their respective rides, they both paused—turned—and locked eyes.

Abigail standing at the edge of something old and sharpened.

Chandra pulled by something safe but suffocating.

For just a second, it was like the crowd melted away.

And then—

Abigail got into the car beside Hannibal, silent and composed.

Chandra disappeared into her parents’ SUV, windows tinted, voices already rising inside.

Two cars.

Two directions.

But eyes still searching.

 

The house was too quiet.

Abigail stood in the library doorway, arms folded, back straight like a soldier awaiting orders. Hannibal was across the room, placing a book back on the shelf with careful deliberation. Will leaned against the desk, his eyes heavy but sharp.

“You’re not to leave the house,” Hannibal said without looking at her.

Abigail’s mouth tightened. “I wasn’t planning to sneak out.”

“This isn’t punishment,” Will added. “It’s containment.”

“Like I’m a pathogen?” she shot back.

“Like you’re a target,” Will corrected. “One we’d rather not see gutted in a park.”

Abigail’s jaw clenched. She hated the logic mostly because she couldn’t argue with it.

Hannibal turned at last, folding his hands. “This killer is impulsive, erratic—but skilled. He escalated without warning. That implies confidence.”

“Or desperation,” Will muttered. “He’s getting sloppy.”

“Sloppy doesn’t mean harmless.”

Abigail looked between them. “So what now?”

“We go hunting,” Hannibal said simply.

Abigail blinked. “Tonight?”

Will nodded once. “We have leads. Partial patterns. He’s circling somewhere near the university district.”

“And I stay here like some Victorian daughter locked in the attic?”

“No,” Will said. “Like someone we don’t want to lose.”

Abigail looked at him for a long moment, then dropped her eyes. “Fine.”


Later that night – Hours pass

The grandfather clock ticked too loudly. The fire burned low. The house creaked like it knew something was missing.

Abigail sat curled on the living room couch, a knife resting beside her on the armrest, phone silent in her lap.

No messages from Chandra.

No updates from Will or Hannibal.

Just the slow crawl of time.

Then—

The front door opened.

Footsteps. Two sets. Heavy. Agitated.

Abigail stood before they even entered the room.

Will was the first to speak, stripping off his coat. “Nothing.”

Hannibal followed, gloves half-off, face tight and unsmiling. “Three false alarms. One mutilated deer. And a very uncooperative homeless man who nearly stabbed Will.”

“He missed,” Will said dully, rubbing his temple.

Abigail raised an eyebrow. “Did you stab back?”

Will gave her a faint glare.

Hannibal peeled off his scarf, hung it with deliberate slowness. “We’re circling something—but it eludes us. For now.”

Will dropped into a chair. “He’s not following a full pattern. He’s playing with chaos.”

Abigail watched them, her voice quiet. “Do you think he knows you’re looking?”

Will stared into the fireplace. “If he doesn’t yet, he will soon.”

Hannibal sat across from him, fingers steepled. “And then, he’ll come to us.”

Abigail folded her arms, gaze sharp. “What if he comes when I’m alone?”

“You won’t be,” Hannibal said simply.

“You’re the bait now,” Will added. “And we’re the trap.”

 

The next morning.
Breakfast sat untouched.

The kitchen was filled not with the smell of coffee or herbs, but tension.

Abigail leaned against the counter, arms crossed, eyes clear. Hannibal stood by the sink, slicing grapefruit with mechanical precision. Will hovered in the doorway, mug in hand, jaw tight.

“I’m serious,” Abigail said. “He’s targeting public spaces. The theater on Main is the perfect lure. It’s chaotic, it’s dark, and people won’t pay attention. Chandra and I go in, act normal. You two wait outside, watch for anything. When he shows—because he will—you take him out. Clean. Done.”

Will set his mug down with a thud. “No.”

Hannibal didn’t look up from his cutting board. “Absolutely not.”

Abigail pushed off the counter. “Why not? I’m not helpless, and Chandra’s safer with me than walking around blind. We’d be prepared. It’s a controlled environment.”

Will glared at her. “It’s a trap using you as the bait. That's not controlled—it's reckless.”

“You’ve both killed for me before,” she said. “Let me help kill for myself.”

Hannibal wiped the knife clean with a towel and finally turned to face her.

“You are not bait, Abigail. You’re our daughter.”

“That’s exactly why I should have a say,” she shot back. “You trained me for this. Self-defense, situational awareness, reading intent. This isn’t some fantasy—I know the risks.”

Will ran a hand through his hair. “It’s not just the risks. It’s Chandra. You’d be endangering her.”

“She wants to fight back,” Abigail said. “She’s not weak. And she deserves to live in a world where monsters don’t always win.”

Hannibal’s voice dropped an octave. “And if something goes wrong? If he doesn’t take the bait? If he goes after her instead?”

“Then you make sure he doesn’t leave the parking lot,” Abigail said, locking eyes with Will. “I trust you.”

Will stared at her. That unblinking, wolf-holding-back-the-snow-storm stare.

“This isn’t about trust,” he said finally. “It’s about not turning you into us.”

Abigail’s voice softened. “Maybe I already am.”

Silence.

Hannibal exhaled slowly, the knife still in his hand.

Will stepped back, hand clenched at his side. “We’re not deciding this now.”

“You’re right,” Abigail said. “We’re deciding it soon. Because he’s not going to stop. And you two can’t catch him without a little chaos.”

She turned and walked out of the kitchen.

Hannibal looked at Will.

Will muttered, “She’s not wrong.”

Hannibal gave a faint, grim smile. “She never is when it matters.”

 

 

 

Chapter 11: Daugther of Death

Notes:

Finally the Truth! Wasn't sure how to make Chandra react....

Chapter Text

The email came in just past dawn.

Abigail sat up in bed, phone glowing pale blue in her hands, blinking at the subject line:

[Important: Campus Closure – Emergency Notice]

She opened it with a strange calm.

Dear Students and Families,

We regret to inform you that due to an active and ongoing investigation into the deaths of three students, school will be closed until further notice. Crisis counselors will be available via remote services. Please do not share unconfirmed information online.

We urge everyone to remain home and vigilant.

Our thoughts are with the victims’ families.

—Principal Alders

Abigail didn’t react at first. She just stared.

Then she opened her texts.

Abigail
Did you get the email?

It took only seconds for Chandra to respond.

Chandra
Yeah
I can’t stop shaking

Abigail’s fingers hesitated over the keys. Then:

Abigail
I’m so sorry
Do you know who they were?

Chandra
Two juniors and a senior
I didn’t know them well
But they were in the same building
One of them was in my chem class

Abigail swallowed.

Abigail
Do your parents know yet?

Chandra
My mom came in crying
She thinks I should leave town for a while
Go stay with family in New Jersey

Abigail
…are you going to?

Chandra
Not yet
Not without saying goodbye
And not if you’re still in danger

There was a long pause before Abigail replied.

Abigail
I don’t want you to leave
But if you do
I’ll understand

Another pause.

Then:

Chandra
I’d rather face it with you
Than hide without you

Abigail stared at the screen for a long time before a small, shaky smile crept in.

Abigail
Then we stick together

Chandra
Always

Abigail:
Can you come over?

Chandra:
God, yes. Give me 10 minutes to beg for my life.

She set her phone down and walked into the kitchen, where her parents were watching the news with identical scowls.

“Abigail just texted. She wants me to come over.”

Her mother’s head snapped around. “Absolutely not.”

Her father added, “You are not going anywhere while there’s a lunatic butchering teenagers.”

Chandra crossed her arms. “I’ll be safer with her. Her guardians are literally FBI-adjacent.”

Her mother narrowed her eyes. “That man with the beard who looks like he eats sadness for breakfast? He’s FBI-adjacent?”

“He’s emotionally unstable but married to a man who owns fourteen kinds of knives and never smiles unless he’s plating a salad,” Chandra shot back. “So yes. I’ll be fine.”

Her father groaned and gestured wildly. “Why can’t you have normal friends?! You’re sixteen. There are nice girls who play chess and don’t live in houses that smell like taxidermy!”

Chandra pointed toward the screen. “Three kids just died. I’m not sitting at home like prey. I’m going to her house, and you’re going to drive me, or I’ll walk. In broad daylight. In leggings.”

Her parents exchanged a silent, horrified look.

Fifteen minutes later, the red SUV pulled up to the Lecter-Graham house.

As Chandra stepped out, her mother hissed under her breath, “I swear, every time we visit this neighborhood, I feel like we’re walking into a Netflix docuseries.”

Her father grumbled, “Weird white people and their murder mansions.”

“Don’t wait up,” Chandra said over her shoulder.

Her mom called out, “If they offer you anything in a ramekin, you don’t eat it!”

Chandra gave a quick wave and walked to the front door, heart pounding—not from fear.

From certainty.

Abigail opened it before she could knock.

“You made it.”

“I told you I would.”

They stood there for a moment, just looking at each other.

Then Abigail stepped aside, and Chandra slipped inside.

 

The entryway was calm. Classical music drifted faintly from somewhere deeper in the house—Debussy, maybe. The air smelled like bergamot and polished wood.

But further in, raised voices cracked through the civilized veneer.

Abigail gave Chandra a small, almost apologetic look. “They’re... debating.”

Chandra blinked. “Debating what?”

Abigail hesitated. “You’ll see.”

They stepped into the kitchen.

Will and Hannibal stood on either side of the butcher block counter, clearly mid-argument. Between them was an array of tools laid out with surgical precision: boning knives, bone saw, a paring blade, something that looked like it belonged in a dental nightmare.

Will’s tone was clipped. “You go for the arteries too early, you’re leaving a mess and cutting off useful time. Bleed-out means chaos.”

Hannibal’s voice was calm, but firm. “Aesthetic restraint doesn’t require hesitation. Precision is not sloppiness. A clean tendon cut renders resistance... theoretical.”

Will pointed at the longer blade. “You don’t even use that one for tendon work. That’s overkill.”

Hannibal raised an eyebrow. “Overkill is a myth perpetuated by people who don’t appreciate finality.”

They both stopped as the girls entered.

Chandra froze in the doorway.

Her eyes swept over the array of knives. The glint of metal. The tension still in the air.

“I—what—are you... butchering something?” she asked, voice wavering.

Abigail muttered, “Kind of.”

Chandra looked from Will—who still had bloodstains under his fingernails—to Hannibal, who hadn’t moved a single hair out of place.

“This is the kitchen,” she hissed. “Is this where you cook or interrogate demons?”

Will coughed once. “Both.”

Chandra turned to Abigail, wide-eyed. “You live here?”

“Yes,” Abigail said, deadpan. “And no one’s ever made me eat anything that suspicious.”

“Yet,” Will said under his breath.

Hannibal cleared his throat. “Chandra. Please. I apologize for the visual—Will and I were... discussing technical matters.”

Chandra stared at the tools again. “Technical murder matters?”

No one answered.

She took a slow step back, then stopped. “You know what? No. No, this is fine. This is... this is a murder mansion. I accept that now. This is like, that moment in the horror movie where I should leave.”

 

Upstairs, the quiet felt louder.

Chandra paced the length of Abigail’s room, arms crossed, her breath shallow and fast.

“I’m trying to be chill,” she said, pacing faster. “I’m really trying, but I just walked into a gourmet Dexter dinner prep, and Will was talking about arteries like he was discussing soup stock—”

“Chandra—”

“And Hannibal smiled at me like he wanted to wear my skin, but in a polite, European way—”

“Chandra.”

She stopped pacing. Looked at Abigail. “What is going on?”

Abigail didn’t flinch. She didn’t dodge.

Instead, she walked to her bookshelf, reached behind a row of mystery paperbacks, and pulled out a thick, tabloid-published hardcover with a blood-red spine and a truly awful font.

Chandra read the title aloud:

“Daughter of Death: The Abigail Hobbs Story” – by Freddie Lounds

The silence that followed was sharp enough to cut skin.

“What... is this?”

“It’s a book,” Abigail said, sitting on the bed. “Freddie wrote it. Most of it’s trash. But the facts? They're real enough.”

Chandra opened it with slow fingers. The first page was a grainy photo of a younger Abigail—wide-eyed, pale, wrapped in a wool blanket outside a cabin. A caption read: “Survivor or Seed?”

Chandra looked up, her voice cracking. “This is you.”

Abigail nodded.

“My father was a serial killer,” she said. “He killed young girls. I was supposed to be next. He almost made me like him. He wanted to. Will and Hannibal saved me. Sort of.”

Chandra stared at the photo again. “Sort of?”

“They also made me,” Abigail said. “In different ways. After everything went public, I was a media ghost. Then Hannibal faked my death. Hid me. Trained me. Will helped.”

Chandra slowly sat down on the floor, the book in her lap. “Trained you. In what? Knife skills? Hiding bodies?”

Abigail was quiet.

Chandra flipped to another page—one filled with scribbled notes in Abigail’s handwriting. "‘Psychological inheritance’… ‘learned predator instinct’… What does this even mean?”

“It means,” Abigail said softly, “that I don’t always know where he ends and I begin. But I try. Every day. And I protect the people I care about.”

Chandra looked up, her eyes shining now. “That’s why you were so calm in the park. Why your aim was perfect. Why you didn’t flinch.”

Abigail nodded. “It wasn’t bravery. It was muscle memory.”

Chandra swallowed. “Are they killers?”

Abigail didn't answer right away.

Then, slowly, carefully: “Yes.”

“You know those murders Freddie talks about—the ones no one ever solved?” she asked softly.

Chandra didn’t answer. She just looked at her.

“The ones where organs were removed with surgical precision. The ones that looked like rituals. The ones that stopped for a while, then came back even cleaner.”

Chandra finally whispered, “The Chesapeake Ripper.”

Abigail nodded once. “Hannibal.”

Chandra blinked, her lips parting, her breath catching in her throat.

Abigail continued. “The Ripper is Hannibal Lecter. The man who made you rosewater cake and knows twenty ways to gut someone without leaving a trace.”

Chandra stared at her. “And he’s just... walking around?”

“He doesn’t walk. He glides.” Abigail’s voice was dry now. “But yes. He hides in plain sight. Operas. Dinner parties. Charity boards. He feeds the world while carving through it.”

Chandra’s voice dropped to almost nothing. “Why isn’t he in prison?”

Abigail looked her straight in the eye. “Because the only person smart enough to catch him was Will Graham.”

“Will... the quiet one. The woodsman therapist?”

Abigail leaned in a little. “Will Graham was the FBI’s best profiler. He got inside killers’ heads, saw what they saw. But it cost him. It broke something.”

Chandra shook her head. “Wait—he caught Hannibal?”

“No,” Abigail said. “He loved him.”

The room went still.

Chandra’s voice cracked. “But you said—Will’s the darker one?”

Abigail nodded, her tone almost reverent. “Hannibal’s refined. Ritualistic. Predictable, even. He has rules. But Will? He’s instinct. Chaos. He doesn’t need precision to be lethal. He disappears into the minds of killers and comes back carrying pieces of them.”

Chandra’s voice trembled. “And you live with them.”

“I chose them.”

Silence.

Abigail leaned forward now, eyes steady. “I’m not telling you this to scare you. I’m telling you because I trust you. Because I want you to understand. I was raised in darkness. And I survived it. With them.”

A long silence.

Then Chandra asked, still whispering: “Would they kill me if I left?”

Abigail shook her head. “Not unless you became a threat. And you’re not.”

Another beat. Then Chandra, voice hoarse: “I don’t want to be afraid of you.”

“I don’t want you to be.”

Abigail sat on the edge of the bed, motionless. A silence stretched between them—not hostile, but taut. Honest.

Chandra finally spoke. “So when you said Hannibal made dinner…”

Abigail looked up slowly. “Yes.”

Chandra’s lips pressed into a line. “And when you said he feeds the world while carving through it…”

“Still yes.”

She turned around, slowly, eyes wide, scared, but needing the words spoken aloud. “He fed people… to people?”

“Yes.”

A beat.

“And you…?”

Abigail didn’t look away.

Chandra’s voice trembled. “Have you eaten—?”

“Yes.”

Chandra sat down hard on the floor, back against the wall, like her knees had given out.

Abigail’s voice remained steady, but her hands twisted in her lap. “It wasn’t… dramatic. The first time. Not some ritual. Not firelight and forks. It was a stew. One spoonful.”

“Who?” Chandra asked, hoarse.

“I don’t know. I didn’t ask. Hannibal never forced it. But he… offered.”

Chandra stared at her, throat tightening. “And you just… said yes?”

“I was hungry. I was lost. I needed something to feel real. He made it beautiful. Safe.”

“Safe?” Chandra laughed—a sharp, broken sound. “That’s your word for cannibalism?”

Abigail looked down. “It’s survival. It’s about control. About owning the thing that tried to destroy you. About being the wolf, not the rabbit.”

Chandra buried her face in her hands. “You said you protected me.”

“I am protecting you.”

Chandra lifted her head. Her eyes were wet but furious. “You protected me with a knife in your boot and a smile while serving me soup. You didn’t warn me.”

“I didn’t want to lose you,” Abigail said quietly.

Silence.

The truth filled the room like smoke.

Eventually, Chandra asked, softer now: “Do you enjoy it?”

Abigail blinked. “What?”

“The meat. The killing. Do you like it?”

Abigail’s voice was barely a whisper. “Sometimes. Not always. But… it makes me feel alive.”

Chandra pulled her knees up to her chest, voice cracking. “I don’t know if I can look at you the same anymore.”

Abigail’s response was immediate, pained: “Then don’t.”

“What?”

“Don’t look at me like you did before. Like I’m a girl with a soft heart and a pretty secret. Look at all of me. The real me.”

Chandra didn’t answer.

Abigail moved closer, still keeping distance. “You asked to know. Now you do. I won’t lie to you again.”

A long silence stretched between them.

Then Chandra whispered, “You’re terrifying.”

Abigail nodded. “I know.”

Chandra sat on the edge of Abigail’s bed, her arms wrapped around her knees. Her breathing had slowed, but her eyes hadn’t lost that searching edge—part fear, part morbid curiosity.

Abigail sat opposite her on the floor, cross-legged, fingers idly picking at the hem of her shirt. She wasn’t smiling. She wasn’t trying to charm or comfort. She was just... there.

Present. Honest.

Chandra finally spoke, voice small but clear.

“How does it work?”

Abigail tilted her head slightly. “What do you mean?”

Chandra looked down at her fingers. “The whole... cannibalism thing. The actual logistics. I mean, is it like, you just find someone and start... carving?”

Abigail didn’t flinch. “No. It’s planned. Carefully. Hannibal doesn’t do anything without a sense of artistry.”

Chandra gave a short, sharp laugh. “Of course he doesn’t.”

“He picks people who deserve it,” Abigail added, then caught herself. “I mean... people he decides deserve it.”

“So... not innocent?”

“Rarely.” Abigail paused. “But that’s subjective.”

Chandra nodded, trying to keep her voice even. “And then what? You kill them and cook them like they’re... meat?”

Abigail met her eyes. “Because they are.”

The words sat heavy in the air.

Abigail leaned back, resting her palms on the rug. “Hannibal breaks it down like any butcher would. Muscle groups, fat content, organ integrity. He’ll freeze what needs aging, marinate what doesn’t. He’s... meticulous. It’s not about gore. It’s about transformation.”

Chandra swallowed. “That’s why the food’s always so... perfect.”

“Yes.”

“And Will helps?”

Abigail hesitated. “Not with the cooking. Will’s more... instinct. He’s the predator who smells blood before it hits the air. He chooses who. Hannibal chooses how.”

Chandra shivered. “And you?”

“I’ve assisted,” Abigail said plainly. “But mostly, I observe. I learn. I’ve tasted. I’ve hunted once.”

Chandra blinked. “You said once.”

“For now.”

The room felt small. Not unsafe—but thick with consequence.

Chandra hugged her knees tighter. “How do you live with it?”

Abigail thought for a moment, then said, “Because it was already inside me before I ever tasted anything. Hannibal just taught me not to be afraid of it. And Will... Will showed me what it means to carry darkness and still love someone.”

Silence.

 

Chapter 12: Lion's Mouth

Notes:

Maybe a darker blooming Chandra???????

Chapter Text

Chandra had gone pale—one hand still hovering near her mouth, eyes wide and glassy.

“Did I… actually…?”

Abigail, for the first time since the conversation began, looked almost guilty.

Then she shook her head.

“No. Your dishes were vegetarian. Always.”

Chandra blinked. “You’re not just saying that?”

“I’m not.” Abigail’s voice was firm now, grounded. “Hannibal doesn’t break people’s preferences. It’s about control, not chaos. He thinks it’s rude to ignore someone’s dietary boundaries.”

Chandra blinked again, as if unsure she heard that right. “Wait. So manners are what keep me off the menu?”

“In his mind? Absolutely.”

Chandra sat back against the bed frame. “I can’t believe this is real.”

Abigail smiled, but it was gentle. “He even makes vegetarian dishes for Freddie Lounds when she comes over.”

“Freddie Lounds,” Chandra repeated. “The woman who probably has a vault of blackmail material and a Google alert for her own name?”

“That’s the one.”

“And he cooks for her?”

“She’s dramatic, but she’s never pretended to be anything else. Hannibal respects people who are honest about their intentions—even if he wants to strangle them half the time.”

Chandra rubbed her face. “This is insane. It’s like finding out your friend’s family are vampires, but with better knives and a wine pairing.”

“You’re not far off.”

She looked at Abigail again. “But really—he kept it clean for me?”

Abigail nodded. “Always. We’re monsters, not assholes.”

That pulled a shocked laugh from Chandra. A broken little sound—but real.

“Jesus Christ,” she whispered, eyes falling shut. “Okay. Okay. I needed that.”

Abigail let the moment settle before saying, “You can leave, you know. No one will stop you. Not even me.”

Chandra opened her eyes.

“I know.”

Abigail leaned forward, voice softer now. “But if you stay—really stay—you don’t have to become anything. You just have to know who we are.”

Chandra nodded slowly. “And… you’ll keep telling me the truth?”

“Always.”

Another long silence passed.

Then Chandra asked, voice quiet: “Does Hannibal know you’re telling me all this?”

Abigail looked toward the door.

“No,” she said. “But I have a feeling he’s listening.”

 

Chandra sat cross-legged on the bed now, her back against the headboard. She was still pale, still visibly rattled—but she hadn’t run. Her voice had steadied.

“So,” she said, picking at the corner of the book cover still lying between them, “if Hannibal’s the refined killer and Will is the storm… what are you?”

Abigail looked down at her hands. “I’m the question.”

Chandra tilted her head. “That’s poetic and unsettling. Clarify.”

“I’m what happens when you survive monsters and then decide you’d rather be one than be prey again.”

There was no drama in her tone. No pride. Just truth.

Chandra studied her. “Is that what you really want?”

Abigail’s brow furrowed. “Want isn’t the right word. It’s what I am. I just get to decide how I live with it.”

Chandra looked at her for a long time. “Do you enjoy killing?”

“I don’t need to do it. I’m not addicted. But when it happens—when it’s right, when it’s clean—I feel… whole. Like I’m not someone’s daughter or someone’s victim. I’m just me.”

Silence again.

Then Chandra asked, quietly, “Am I safe with you?”

Abigail looked up slowly. Her voice didn’t waver.

“You are the safest thing in my life.”

Chandra swallowed, throat tight. “You said I’ve eaten at your table. Been around these people. Sat at the edge of the abyss. And now I can’t unsee it. I can’t unknow it.”

“You don’t have to,” Abigail said. “You don’t have to carry it with you.”

“But I already am,” Chandra replied. “I’m still here. I’m still… trying. And I don’t know what that says about me.”

Abigail’s gaze softened. “It says you’re brave.”

Chandra laughed once, bitterly. “Or stupid.”

“You don’t strike me as stupid.”

Chandra looked down, then whispered, “I don’t know what scares me more—that I’m not like you… or that I might be.”

Abigail reached out slowly, resting her hand over Chandra’s.

“Then let’s figure that out. Together.”

They sat in the silence, the weight of impossible choices between them, and something unspeakable—but very real—growing in the dark space where honesty lives.

Chandra still held Abigail’s hand, but her expression had shifted—thinking now, not panicking. Her brows furrowed as something turned over in her mind.

“So… this Popcorn Killer,” she said slowly. “Is he, like… one of Hannibal’s friends?”

Abigail actually laughed. A short, derisive sound. “No.”

Chandra blinked. “But you said Hannibal respects certain killers.”

“He does,” Abigail said. “But this guy? He’s not one of them. He’s messy. Crude. He kills without elegance, without meaning. It’s not a performance—it's just violence. And worse than that?”

“What?”

“He doesn’t deserve what he takes. He’s not choosing his victims with any clarity. It’s random. Indulgent. Cowardly.”

Chandra nodded slowly, absorbing it. “So Hannibal hates him.”

“Despises him. Will too. They won’t say it out loud, but I’ve seen it in how frustrated they get when they can’t catch him. It’s personal.”

“And you think you can do better than them?”

Abigail smiled. “I know I can.”

Chandra gave a skeptical look. “Okay. So what’s the plan?”

Abigail shifted, her voice lowering as if the walls might be listening. “We make ourselves bait.”

Chandra froze. “We?”

“You and me,” Abigail said. “At the Main Street theater. It’s a prime target—dim, crowded, chaotic, and poorly patrolled. We go, act normal, blend in. Will and Hannibal are stationed nearby with eyes on every exit.”

“You think he’ll show?”

“I know he will. He escalated to students. He’s getting bolder. A public place is next.”

Chandra’s breath caught. “What if we’re wrong?”

“Then nothing happens. We leave. We try again.”

“And if we’re right?”

“Then he dies.”

Chandra stared at her.

Abigail’s gaze was steady. “You don’t have to come. I’ll do it alone if I have to.”

Chandra didn’t speak for a long moment. Then: “You really want me there.”

“I trust you.”

Chandra’s voice was quiet. “I think that’s the scariest thing you’ve said all night.”

Abigail gave a small, sad smile. “I know.”

Chandra leaned back, exhaling slowly. “Okay. I’ll think about it.”

“No pressure.”

Chandra paused. “Do I get to wear something dramatic?”

Abigail blinked, then grinned. “Obviously.”

 

The stairs creaked as Abigail and Chandra descended. Not loudly—just enough to remind them of where they were, of who waited below.

The scent of something herbal lingered in the air—tea, likely—but beneath it, there was something metallic. Barely there. Like blood rinsed down a drain but never fully gone.

Chandra followed just behind Abigail, her hands clenched into fists at her sides. Every logical voice in her mind screamed leave, but her feet kept moving.

The living room opened up at the foot of the stairs, fire crackling low in the hearth.

Will and Hannibal were seated on opposite ends of the leather couch, both in dark clothes, both still, both watching.

Not the television.

Not each other.

The girls.

Will’s gaze was sharp, but not hostile. His fingers tapped against the armrest absently, a hunter’s stillness wrapped around a storm.

Hannibal looked more like a painting than a man—perfect posture, teacup in hand, expression unreadable.

“Evening,” Hannibal said, voice smooth as silk.

Chandra swallowed. “Hi.”

Will tilted his head. “You’re still here.”

Abigail gave Chandra a small glance, then looked at the men. “She knows. Everything.”

Will didn’t move.

Hannibal set his teacup down with a soft clink. “And you chose to remain.”

“I did,” Chandra said, her voice wavering but clear.

There was a moment of silence. Something assessing passed between the two men.

Hannibal finally offered the faintest smile. “That requires a certain kind of courage.”

Will didn’t smile. “Or recklessness.”

Chandra forced herself to stand straighter. “Maybe both.”

Abigail stepped forward. “We want to talk to you about the plan. The theater.”

Will leaned back, exhaling through his nose. “You’re serious about that.”

Chandra looked down. “I wasn’t. Not at first. But I understand now. He’s not going to stop. And I’d rather walk toward danger with people who’ve mastered it than run from it forever.”

Will raised an eyebrow at her, but said nothing.

Hannibal’s gaze lingered on Chandra—thoughtful, sharp. “You would willingly stand in the lion’s mouth.”

Chandra met his eyes. “As long as the lion’s on my side.”

Abigail grinned. “She’s good, right?”

Will sighed, rubbing the bridge of his nose. “She’s terrifying. You’ve made another one.”

Hannibal didn’t look away from Chandra. “No. She made herself.”

 

 

Chapter 13: Baiting

Chapter Text

“We’ll handle the rest,” Will said, standing from the couch with the slow precision of a man walking toward a kill rather than away from it. “The plan’s happening tomorrow night. That gives us today to lay the groundwork.”

Hannibal gave a slight nod, already reaching for a notebook from the nearby end table. “We’ll need floor plans, blind spots, exit routes, and vantage points. Nothing improvisational.”

Will glanced at the girls. “You two go upstairs. Sleep, if you can. No more talk of killers or lures. Tomorrow is when you become bait. Tonight, you're just kids.”

Abigail raised an eyebrow. “That’s a bit rich, coming from you.”

“Go,” Will said with a faint smirk.

Abigail didn’t argue. She grabbed Chandra’s hand and tugged her toward the stairs.


Upstairs, Abigail’s room felt smaller now—cozier, somehow. The night was cool, and the soft hum of the heater barely covered the rustling of trees outside.

Abigail pulled open a drawer beneath her bookshelf and knelt beside it. “Want to see something mildly concerning?”

Chandra gave a weak laugh. “Is it more body parts?”

Abigail smirked. “Less squishy.”

She opened the drawer and pulled out a small, velvet-lined wooden box. Inside was an array of knives—some ordinary, some ornate. Folding blades. Throwing knives. A slender stiletto with an engraved bone handle. One was shaped like a leaf. Another gleamed obsidian black.

Chandra’s eyes widened. “Jesus. Is this a murder Etsy shop?”

Abigail grinned. “This one’s mine,” she said, pointing to a short, worn blade with a carved wooden grip. “Got it when I was fifteen. Hannibal said it was too sentimental. Will said it was ‘solid in the hand.’ I listened to Will.”

Chandra reached out and gently touched the bone-handled one. “This looks ceremonial.”

“It probably is. Hannibal gave it to me for Christmas once. Said it was ‘historically symbolic of feminine defense.’ Translation: pretty and deadly.”

Chandra sat down beside her, staring at the glittering collection. “You sleep with these in the room?”

Abigail shrugged. “It’s not the knives I’m afraid of.”

Chandra leaned back on her elbows. “So tomorrow we walk into a theater, and you hope this… Popcorn Freak shows up. And if he does…”

“We finish it.”

Chandra was quiet for a moment. “Do you think you’ll be able to sleep tonight?”

Abigail looked at her. “Will you?”

Chandra hesitated, then slid a little closer. “Maybe. If I stay here.”

Abigail softened. “Then stay.”

They lay side by side on the bed, the knife box closed but still nearby. The moonlight filtered through the curtains in soft silver.

“Did you ever think your life would turn out like this?” Chandra asked.

Abigail chuckled. “Not exactly. But I stopped trying to measure it by normal a long time ago.”

A pause.

Then Chandra said, “You scare me, sometimes.”

Abigail turned her head to look at her. “I scare me, sometimes.”

Another pause.

“But I trust you.”

“I trust you too,” Abigail whispered.

Outside, the wind picked up. But inside, there was stillness. And just enough warmth to sleep.

 

Evening fell like a knife sliding into silk.

The dining table had been cleared of its usual silver and bone-white plates. Instead, it was covered with printed schematics of the Main Street theater: exits, security blind spots, lighting plans, even janitorial access corridors.

Will pointed at a red-marked corner of the map. “We’ll position here. Second-floor maintenance door, north wing. It overlooks the main atrium. Clear line of sight to both entrance and concession.”

Hannibal nodded. “I’ll be at the east corridor. Less foot traffic, more shadows. We’ll triangulate. If he appears, we’ll see him.”

Chandra sat across from Abigail, her hands in her lap, expression focused and tightly wound.

Abigail tapped the map near the center of the theater. “We sit here. Middle-left seats. Casual, but visible. Enough light. Easy access to the exits if it goes sideways.”

Will looked at them both. “You don’t break formation. If anything feels wrong, you text the word rosewood. We pull you out immediately. No debate.”

Hannibal’s voice followed, smooth and unhurried. “This man is reckless. Desperate. If he senses a trap, he’ll flee or escalate. You must play the part—frightened, distracted, just enough to look vulnerable.”

Abigail smirked. “I can look vulnerable with a knife in my boot.”

Chandra gave her a sidelong glance. “You always have a knife in your boot.”

Before Will could speak again, the doorbell rang.

Everyone looked up.

Will frowned. “Did you invite someone?”

“No,” Abigail said.

But Hannibal simply rose, serene as ever. “I did.”

Moments later, the front door opened—and in stepped Tobias Budge.

Dark jacket. Black gloves tucked into one hand. His expression unreadable, his presence strangely theatrical.

Abigail stood up sharply. “What is he doing here?”

Tobias looked at her and offered a shallow, almost respectful nod. “Relax. I didn’t invite myself.”

Hannibal closed the door behind him with a soft click. “I thought it prudent to involve someone who understands subtlety and performance. He also has a personal interest in your safety.”

Tobias looked to Abigail again. “You’re my student. And while I’m not sentimental, I am territorial.”

Abigail narrowed her eyes. “You planning to use me as an excuse to kill someone?”

“I don’t need excuses,” Tobias replied evenly. “But I’d rather not let a theater become your grave.”

Will gave Hannibal a cold glance. “You didn’t think to mention this before?”

“I wanted it to be… a surprise,” Hannibal said mildly.

Chandra whispered to Abigail, “Is this the scary violin guy?”

“Yes,” Abigail muttered. “Unfortunately, he’s also really good with a garrote.”

Tobias smiled faintly. “And with acoustics.”

Will looked at the girls, then at Tobias. “Fine. But he doesn’t go off-script. And if he puts either of them at risk—”

“I don’t,” Tobias interrupted. “I clean risks. I don’t create them.”

Abigail let out a long breath. “Well. Looks like the hunter’s gallery is full tonight.”

Hannibal returned to the table, folding his hands calmly. “Then we proceed.

The Popcorn Killer won’t know what he’s walking into.”

Chandra leaned close to Abigail. “You know, I thought theater night meant popcorn and a weird trailer for a horror movie.”

Abigail whispered back, “It still might.”

 

 

Chapter 14: Tattle-Crime Time

Chapter Text

The Main Street Theater glowed softly under flickering marquee lights. Rain had started just after sunset, turning the sidewalk slick and dark, city lights reflected in puddles like broken glass.

Inside, the lobby buzzed with low, nervous chatter. The movie tonight—a slasher film—played to a nearly full house. Life imitating art. Or perhaps circling it.

Abigail and Chandra moved through the crowd with calculated ease. No hesitations, no glances over shoulders. Just two teenage girls buying overpriced snacks, whispering about movie trailers, and pretending not to notice the extra weight in their jackets or the glances exchanged at every corner.

Their seats were mid-row, just left of center. Not too exposed. Not too hidden. Perfect.

They sat, passing popcorn between them. Abigail’s expression was bored. Chandra leaned into the role—nervous, giggly, tucking her legs beneath her like someone trying to shrink.

But their eyes swept the room constantly.

Abigail shifted slightly and whispered under her breath, “You still good?”

Chandra nodded once, her voice low. “Yeah. Just wish we had actual popcorn.”

“This is close enough.”

The previews began.

Behind them, in places no one else would think to look, Will, Hannibal, and Tobias moved like ghosts. Hidden in service corridors, shadowed upper walkways, and maintenance alcoves. Each with a view of the theater. Each with a weapon.

Twenty minutes in, the killer entered.

He came through the left side door. Alone. Hoodie pulled up. He bought no snacks. Made no sound.

He didn’t look at the screen.

He looked at them.

Abigail didn’t move, but every muscle in her back went stiff. Chandra kept her eyes forward, but her breath slowed.

He sat three rows back.

Too close.

Too quiet.

Abigail tapped her boot heel once. Then again. A silent signal through the floor.

Three rows back. Left aisle. Target in position.

From the catwalk, Will’s hand hovered near the rifle slung under his coat.

Hannibal, tucked in the corner balcony, reached into his coat for the stiletto blade he preferred—quiet, elegant, final.

Tobias, concealed behind the projection room wall, adjusted a narrow garrote wire between gloved fingers. Focused. Listening.

Onscreen, a woman screamed as a fictional killer closed in with a hatchet.

In real life, the Popcorn Killer leaned forward slightly, just as Abigail slowly shifted her hand toward the knife hidden beneath her thigh.

Then—

The killer stood.

And began walking down the aisle, toward them.

Chandra’s breath caught.

 

The Popcorn Killer stepped into the aisle with a loose, unsettling gait. Not theatrical, not confident—just wrong. Like someone imitating human movement.

Abigail shifted, ready to draw.

But he moved faster.

In one blur of motion, he lunged—reaching not for Abigail, but Chandra, grabbing her by the arm and wrenching her halfway from her seat.

Abigail shouted, lunging to intercept, but the killer struck with a surprising strength—backhanding her across the face with enough force to split her lip and slam her against the seats.

“Chandra!” she gasped.

Chandra screamed, kicking and twisting, but he had her. A flash of something—metal—in his hand. A blade.

Audience members turned in confusion. Screams began to rise, scattered and confused. Someone fumbled with a phone. Others froze in disbelief.

The killer whispered something to Chandra—something rasping and awful—before jerking her toward the exit.

And that’s when the trap sprang.

From above, like shadows loosed from the ceiling, they came:

Will dropped from the upper catwalk, silent as death, landing just behind the killer with a predator’s stillness. The rifle wasn’t in his hands anymore. Just a knife. Long, brutal, familiar.

Hannibal moved through the emergency exit corridor like he’d always belonged in the dark. His blade glinted once before vanishing into his palm.

Tobias slipped behind them from the aisle, unseen, unannounced—garrote glinting in the flickering projection light.

The Popcorn Killer turned—too slow.

Will struck first, driving the knife into the man’s thigh, slicing across the hamstring with cruel precision. The killer screamed, staggering sideways—but kept his grip on Chandra.

Hannibal followed. No wasted movement. The stiletto plunged into the killer’s side, angled carefully between ribs. He twisted it once before pulling back.

Still the man wouldn’t fall.

Then Tobias moved.

He struck from behind, looping the garrote around the killer’s neck and jerking back with surgical force. Blood sprayed—not from the neck, but the killer’s mouth, teeth clenching, trying to stay upright.

The killer slashed blindly with his free hand, the knife catching Chandra’s arm.

Abigail—dazed, bleeding—snapped.

She launched herself at him, driving her boot into the side of his knee with a brutal crunch.

The Popcorn Killer collapsed, finally screaming.

Will disarmed him.

Hannibal caught Chandra as she stumbled free, pulling her gently but firmly aside, checking her wound.

Tobias released the garrote only once the man stopped thrashing.

For a moment, all was still.

Just blood. Shaking breath. The scent of sweat and fear and the faint, horrifying aroma of copper.

Abigail staggered to Chandra. “Are you okay?”

Chandra, wide-eyed, pale, nodded slowly. “I—I think so.”

She looked at Will—his face splashed with blood, his eyes wild, knife still dripping.

She looked at Hannibal—calm, immaculate, expression unreadable, already assessing the room.

She looked at Tobias—clean and quiet, almost bored.

Then back at Abigail, whose hands trembled even as she stood tall, defiant, jaw bruised.

“You…” Chandra whispered, awe and horror interwoven, “You weren’t exaggerating. They’re monsters.”

Abigail nodded. “But they’re mine.”

 

The drive home was mostly silent, save for Chandra’s sharp intakes of breath and the low muttering from Will in the front seat about “next time, body armor.” Hannibal drove with one hand, the other resting with poised calm on the wheel, his shirt stained dark at the cuff.

Once home, the girls were led immediately into the kitchen, where Hannibal pulled out the med kit as naturally as if he were plating hors d'oeuvres.

Abigail sat on the counter, lip swollen, cheek purpling. Chandra sat beside her, her arm bandaged in gauze, still trembling slightly, her knuckles white where she clutched a warm towel.

Will cleaned Abigail’s lip with gentle precision, jaw clenched. “You’re lucky your teeth are still in.”

Abigail winced. “He hit harder than I expected.”

“You’re lucky we were faster than he expected,” Hannibal said, dabbing a bit of antiseptic along Chandra’s arm. “It could have ended very differently.”

Chandra looked between them, still stunned. “You three were like… demons. Controlled ones.”

Will didn’t look up. “That’s generous.”

A knock at the door interrupted the moment.

Hannibal glanced at the clock. “I told her not before midnight.”

Will sighed. “Of course you did.”

He went to the door and opened it—revealing Freddie Lounds, already pulling off her gloves, her hair artfully disheveled for maximum flair.

“Well,” she said brightly, brushing past him, “you really do know how to throw a screening party.”

“Freddie,” Hannibal said with clipped politeness.

Freddie beamed. “I heard about the incident before the credits even rolled. Anonymous tip. Guess who was watching from the alley with a zoom lens and a battery pack?”

Will groaned. “Freddie—”

“Relax, I’m not printing anything yet. I just wanted to get the tone right.” She looked toward the kitchen and froze. “Well, look at you two.”

Chandra blinked. “Is she—”

“Don’t ask,” Abigail muttered.

Freddie sauntered in, eyeing the gauze, the blood stains, the scattered med supplies. “This feels very... exclusive. Were the girls the bait?”

Abigail didn’t answer.

Freddie turned to Hannibal. “You’re going to cook, right? You always cook after trauma.”

“I’m not a catering service,” he said mildly, though he was already walking to the pantry.

“I brought wine,” Freddie said, producing a bottle from her oversized coat like a magician pulling a rabbit.

Chandra whispered to Abigail, “Is she always like this?”

“Worse,” Abigail replied. “But she’s useful. Like a cockroach that knows secrets.”

Freddie called over her shoulder. “Heard that, sweetheart.”

Will reentered the kitchen, folding his arms. “What’s the real reason you’re here, Freddie?”

She raised an eyebrow. “The Popcorn Killer is dead. In a theater. Ripped apart by what will eventually be reported as a 'freak incident' involving an unstable man and a tragic accident. I want to know what actually happened.”

Hannibal looked up from the spice rack. “You already do.”

Freddie smiled slowly. “Yeah. I just wanted to hear you say it.”

No one answered her.

So she made herself comfortable.

 

Freddie Lounds perched on a barstool, legs crossed, notebook open in her lap though she hadn’t written anything down yet. Her eyes were on the girls.

“So,” she said, lips curling, “you two almost got murdered and then got rescued by three men who could’ve passed for a hit squad. And you’re… fine?”

Chandra glanced at Abigail, unsure how to answer.

Abigail sipped a glass of water and replied evenly, “We were prepared. The killer wasn’t.”

Freddie snorted. “Sure, Joan of Arc. But your lip’s split and your friend’s still shaking.”

“I’m not—” Chandra started, then stopped. “Okay, maybe a little.”

Freddie turned to her with a faux-sympathetic pout. “First time’s always rough.”

Chandra raised an eyebrow. “First time what?”

Freddie’s smile sharpened. “First time realizing the world is full of predators and some of them wear cashmere and pour French wine.”

Abigail muttered, “You should write that on a pillow.”

“I will. Limited edition. I’ll give you royalties.”

Hannibal, from the stove, chimed in with a dry tone. “Miss Lounds, you’ve always had a gift for distilling horror into something flippant.”

Freddie beamed. “I take that as a compliment.”

“It wasn’t,” Hannibal said, turning to slice a bundle of basil with elegant precision.

Freddie leaned her chin on her hand. “Tell me, Dr. Lecter, are you cooking something vegetarian because of me or because you still don’t want me writing about your protein preferences?”

Chandra blinked. Abigail gave a small, warning shake of her head.

Hannibal responded without looking up. “I cook vegetarian when the company demands restraint.”

Freddie gave a mock-gasp. “Why, Dr. Lecter, are you calling me civilized?”

“I’m calling you observed.”

Freddie laughed, delighted. “God, I missed this.”

Abigail groaned. “You two flirting is going to kill me faster than the guy in the theater.”

Chandra leaned over and whispered, “Are they flirting or threatening each other?”

“Yes,” Abigail whispered back.

Freddie turned toward them again, eyes narrowing playfully. “And you, violin girl—how are you finding the company of our little murder family?”

Chandra hesitated, then gave a crooked, tired smile. “It’s… unconventional. But I’ve had worse dinners.”

Hannibal glanced at her then, something flickering in his eyes—not judgment, not approval. Just… consideration.

Freddie noticed. “You like her.”

Hannibal replied without missing a beat. “I find clarity attractive.”

Freddie grinned at Chandra. “He means you haven’t lied to him yet. Keep it up. It’s the only reason I’m still breathing.”

Chandra’s smile faded just slightly. “I’m not sure if that’s comforting or terrifying.”

“Why not both?” Abigail said, tossing an olive at Freddie.

Freddie caught it in her mouth with theatrical flair and raised her glass.

“To secrets, then,” she said, voice laced with danger and delight.

Hannibal returned the toast, softly: “And those who know how to keep them.”

 

The halls of the school buzzed like a beehive poked with a stick.

Clusters of students stood around lockers, phones out, faces lit up with a mix of shock and delight. Some were reading aloud. Others were whispering in rapid-fire disbelief.

“Did you see the new Tattle-Crime post?”

“She named the theater but said the incident was ‘resolved off the record by unnamed vigilantes.’ That’s basically code for serial killers.”

“Do you think it was the FBI? Or like… secret assassins?”

“No way the cops pulled that off. Whoever it was didn’t leave a trace. It’s straight out of a horror movie.”

Abigail walked through it all with practiced detachment, her lip still healing, her backpack slung over one shoulder. Chandra walked beside her, wearing a hoodie with the sleeves rolled up to show the clean gauze patch where the knife had grazed her arm.

They both kept their heads down until they reached the stairwell landing. Then—

Abigail burst out laughing.

Chandra followed half a second later, snorting. “She called you ‘an icy-eyed lamb made of razors.’”

“She also described Hannibal’s voice as ‘velvet soaked in blood.’ I think she has a crush.”

“She called Will ‘the ghost in the crawlspace of God’s house.’”

Abigail wheezed. “What does that even mean?”

They leaned against the railing, laughing harder the more they remembered.

“She made me sound like… a femme fatale in a YA thriller,” Chandra said through giggles. “‘The mystery girl with the sharp smile and a secret in her shoes.’”

“That’s so you.”

“I think she described Tobias as ‘death’s orchestra conductor.’”

Abigail nodded. “Accurate.”

A group of freshmen walked by, glancing at them with wide, reverent eyes. One even whispered, “I think that’s them.”

Abigail raised her eyebrows. “Are we… urban legends now?”

Chandra smirked. “Only if we get matching rings and speak in cryptic riddles.”

Abigail straightened. “Deal. But only if mine has a hidden blade.”

They laughed again, but this time it faded slower—softer, more comfortable.

Chandra looked over, voice quieter now. “Are we okay?”

Abigail met her gaze. “We faced a killer. You didn’t run. You didn’t break.”

“And you didn’t let him take me.”

“I never would.”

Chandra smiled. “Then yeah. We’re more than okay.”

The bell rang above them, distant and unimportant.

 

 

Series this work belongs to: