Chapter Text
Chandra had gone pale—one hand still hovering near her mouth, eyes wide and glassy.
“Did I… actually…?”
Abigail, for the first time since the conversation began, looked almost guilty.
Then she shook her head.
“No. Your dishes were vegetarian. Always.”
Chandra blinked. “You’re not just saying that?”
“I’m not.” Abigail’s voice was firm now, grounded. “Hannibal doesn’t break people’s preferences. It’s about control, not chaos. He thinks it’s rude to ignore someone’s dietary boundaries.”
Chandra blinked again, as if unsure she heard that right. “Wait. So manners are what keep me off the menu?”
“In his mind? Absolutely.”
Chandra sat back against the bed frame. “I can’t believe this is real.”
Abigail smiled, but it was gentle. “He even makes vegetarian dishes for Freddie Lounds when she comes over.”
“Freddie Lounds,” Chandra repeated. “The woman who probably has a vault of blackmail material and a Google alert for her own name?”
“That’s the one.”
“And he cooks for her?”
“She’s dramatic, but she’s never pretended to be anything else. Hannibal respects people who are honest about their intentions—even if he wants to strangle them half the time.”
Chandra rubbed her face. “This is insane. It’s like finding out your friend’s family are vampires, but with better knives and a wine pairing.”
“You’re not far off.”
She looked at Abigail again. “But really—he kept it clean for me?”
Abigail nodded. “Always. We’re monsters, not assholes.”
That pulled a shocked laugh from Chandra. A broken little sound—but real.
“Jesus Christ,” she whispered, eyes falling shut. “Okay. Okay. I needed that.”
Abigail let the moment settle before saying, “You can leave, you know. No one will stop you. Not even me.”
Chandra opened her eyes.
“I know.”
Abigail leaned forward, voice softer now. “But if you stay—really stay—you don’t have to become anything. You just have to know who we are.”
Chandra nodded slowly. “And… you’ll keep telling me the truth?”
“Always.”
Another long silence passed.
Then Chandra asked, voice quiet: “Does Hannibal know you’re telling me all this?”
Abigail looked toward the door.
“No,” she said. “But I have a feeling he’s listening.”
Chandra sat cross-legged on the bed now, her back against the headboard. She was still pale, still visibly rattled—but she hadn’t run. Her voice had steadied.
“So,” she said, picking at the corner of the book cover still lying between them, “if Hannibal’s the refined killer and Will is the storm… what are you?”
Abigail looked down at her hands. “I’m the question.”
Chandra tilted her head. “That’s poetic and unsettling. Clarify.”
“I’m what happens when you survive monsters and then decide you’d rather be one than be prey again.”
There was no drama in her tone. No pride. Just truth.
Chandra studied her. “Is that what you really want?”
Abigail’s brow furrowed. “Want isn’t the right word. It’s what I am. I just get to decide how I live with it.”
Chandra looked at her for a long time. “Do you enjoy killing?”
“I don’t need to do it. I’m not addicted. But when it happens—when it’s right, when it’s clean—I feel… whole. Like I’m not someone’s daughter or someone’s victim. I’m just me.”
Silence again.
Then Chandra asked, quietly, “Am I safe with you?”
Abigail looked up slowly. Her voice didn’t waver.
“You are the safest thing in my life.”
Chandra swallowed, throat tight. “You said I’ve eaten at your table. Been around these people. Sat at the edge of the abyss. And now I can’t unsee it. I can’t unknow it.”
“You don’t have to,” Abigail said. “You don’t have to carry it with you.”
“But I already am,” Chandra replied. “I’m still here. I’m still… trying. And I don’t know what that says about me.”
Abigail’s gaze softened. “It says you’re brave.”
Chandra laughed once, bitterly. “Or stupid.”
“You don’t strike me as stupid.”
Chandra looked down, then whispered, “I don’t know what scares me more—that I’m not like you… or that I might be.”
Abigail reached out slowly, resting her hand over Chandra’s.
“Then let’s figure that out. Together.”
They sat in the silence, the weight of impossible choices between them, and something unspeakable—but very real—growing in the dark space where honesty lives.
Chandra still held Abigail’s hand, but her expression had shifted—thinking now, not panicking. Her brows furrowed as something turned over in her mind.
“So… this Popcorn Killer,” she said slowly. “Is he, like… one of Hannibal’s friends?”
Abigail actually laughed. A short, derisive sound. “No.”
Chandra blinked. “But you said Hannibal respects certain killers.”
“He does,” Abigail said. “But this guy? He’s not one of them. He’s messy. Crude. He kills without elegance, without meaning. It’s not a performance—it's just violence. And worse than that?”
“What?”
“He doesn’t deserve what he takes. He’s not choosing his victims with any clarity. It’s random. Indulgent. Cowardly.”
Chandra nodded slowly, absorbing it. “So Hannibal hates him.”
“Despises him. Will too. They won’t say it out loud, but I’ve seen it in how frustrated they get when they can’t catch him. It’s personal.”
“And you think you can do better than them?”
Abigail smiled. “I know I can.”
Chandra gave a skeptical look. “Okay. So what’s the plan?”
Abigail shifted, her voice lowering as if the walls might be listening. “We make ourselves bait.”
Chandra froze. “We?”
“You and me,” Abigail said. “At the Main Street theater. It’s a prime target—dim, crowded, chaotic, and poorly patrolled. We go, act normal, blend in. Will and Hannibal are stationed nearby with eyes on every exit.”
“You think he’ll show?”
“I know he will. He escalated to students. He’s getting bolder. A public place is next.”
Chandra’s breath caught. “What if we’re wrong?”
“Then nothing happens. We leave. We try again.”
“And if we’re right?”
“Then he dies.”
Chandra stared at her.
Abigail’s gaze was steady. “You don’t have to come. I’ll do it alone if I have to.”
Chandra didn’t speak for a long moment. Then: “You really want me there.”
“I trust you.”
Chandra’s voice was quiet. “I think that’s the scariest thing you’ve said all night.”
Abigail gave a small, sad smile. “I know.”
Chandra leaned back, exhaling slowly. “Okay. I’ll think about it.”
“No pressure.”
Chandra paused. “Do I get to wear something dramatic?”
Abigail blinked, then grinned. “Obviously.”
The stairs creaked as Abigail and Chandra descended. Not loudly—just enough to remind them of where they were, of who waited below.
The scent of something herbal lingered in the air—tea, likely—but beneath it, there was something metallic. Barely there. Like blood rinsed down a drain but never fully gone.
Chandra followed just behind Abigail, her hands clenched into fists at her sides. Every logical voice in her mind screamed leave, but her feet kept moving.
The living room opened up at the foot of the stairs, fire crackling low in the hearth.
Will and Hannibal were seated on opposite ends of the leather couch, both in dark clothes, both still, both watching.
Not the television.
Not each other.
The girls.
Will’s gaze was sharp, but not hostile. His fingers tapped against the armrest absently, a hunter’s stillness wrapped around a storm.
Hannibal looked more like a painting than a man—perfect posture, teacup in hand, expression unreadable.
“Evening,” Hannibal said, voice smooth as silk.
Chandra swallowed. “Hi.”
Will tilted his head. “You’re still here.”
Abigail gave Chandra a small glance, then looked at the men. “She knows. Everything.”
Will didn’t move.
Hannibal set his teacup down with a soft clink. “And you chose to remain.”
“I did,” Chandra said, her voice wavering but clear.
There was a moment of silence. Something assessing passed between the two men.
Hannibal finally offered the faintest smile. “That requires a certain kind of courage.”
Will didn’t smile. “Or recklessness.”
Chandra forced herself to stand straighter. “Maybe both.”
Abigail stepped forward. “We want to talk to you about the plan. The theater.”
Will leaned back, exhaling through his nose. “You’re serious about that.”
Chandra looked down. “I wasn’t. Not at first. But I understand now. He’s not going to stop. And I’d rather walk toward danger with people who’ve mastered it than run from it forever.”
Will raised an eyebrow at her, but said nothing.
Hannibal’s gaze lingered on Chandra—thoughtful, sharp. “You would willingly stand in the lion’s mouth.”
Chandra met his eyes. “As long as the lion’s on my side.”
Abigail grinned. “She’s good, right?”
Will sighed, rubbing the bridge of his nose. “She’s terrifying. You’ve made another one.”
Hannibal didn’t look away from Chandra. “No. She made herself.”
