Actions

Work Header

Perfect Red

Chapter 4: IV. Folie à Trois

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

I’ve been thinking. Maybe, this was for the best.

Maybe God does exist and He has some plans for me. Maybe, I was experiencing this cosmic prank because there was something that I needed to do. Perhaps, the universe has a plan for good, old Amelia Cartwright.

Maybe, this was a way to end my term as a replaceable fast food slave.

The hum of the car’s engine buzzed beneath my feet. The forests that we passed by blurred into dark green.

As the trees melted into one neverending, oddly-formed hedge, I frowned. I’d never seen trees planted in such perfect lines before, especially along a roadside. Desperate for logic, I searched for any signs that we were passing through a tree farm. I couldn’t. There were no picket fences that protected the trees, nor a sign of a farmer in the shadows. Just… rows and rows of trees, where the ones farther from us darkened into tunnels of light that led to nowhere.

I blinked. Goddamn, Amelia, those were trees . Nothing more.

Mads seemed to note my interest in the trees. He had been silent throughout the drive, occasionally talking to Hugh about their projects other than Hannibal . I wanted to protest, to sound offended at how easily they dismissed Hannibal Lecter—my demise and my undoing—to be a TV character, but I stopped myself.

After all, I wasn’t prepared to live in a world where I was considered fictional.

As Hugh took a turn, Mads spoke softly, his eyes gently probing mine, like a father coaxing a frightened child. “You’ve been quiet for a while, Amelia. What’s on your mind?”

I wanted to say something irrational, but instead, I remained quiet, drifting back into my earlier thoughts.

Maybe I was supposed to be a herald. Maybe I needed to tell everyone we live in a goddamn matrix.

A flicker of hope kindled in my chest. Yes, maybe I was meant to do something. This was something . It was only a matter of when and how I’d tell everyone. Maybe.

At the thought of it, though, I felt the buzz of a thousand needles attacking my soles again, the sting of exposed flesh melting in lye. My heart rate quickened, afraid to confront my body, but I pushed against the urge. Through it all, I could hear Hannibal’s voice in my head.

One, two, three. Breathe in, Miss Cartwright.

His voice had always been soothing during those overwhelming crew shifts. Even now, I could recall how his maroon eyes gleamed warmly, sparkling with an eagerness to help. In retrospect, it was disturbing how effortlessly the damned psychiatrist knew exactly what to say—how to earn my trust, only to crush it. Hannibal was a wolf coaxing a trapped lamb to relax as it struggled, fully aware it would run straight into his waiting jaws.

I stiffened at the memory, at the comparison brewing in my head.

Or maybe not, I conceded. Maybe what was happening to me was just some goddamn joke. That seemed more plausible. After all, what kind of God would let His creation endure this insanity, let her suffer the prick of a thousand needles piercing her every pore?

I could only think of one. And I could see his resemblance in Mads’ face.

“Do you think any of my answers would be enough?” I asked Mads, my tone inevitably sharpening again at the uncanny resemblance of the actor to the damned doctor.

I regretted the question the second it left my lips. My brain kept screaming that he wasn’t Hannibal, that this was just a cruel trick of familiarity, but it didn’t stop the instinctive fear curling in my gut. He was an actor. An actor , I reminded myself. He wasn’t paid to do this, to play along with what might be an exhausting charade in his eyes and Hugh’s.

Yet, the way his brows furrowed, the way his eyes flickered with curiosity—it was too similar. Too Hannibal . 

“I’m sorry.” I looked away, my fists whitening as they gripped my work pants tightly.

My lips let out the burden that weighed my body down. “It’s hard to be kind around you, knowing that face wanted to kill me.”

There was another silence in the car. Hugh eyed me through the rearview mirror, his earth-blue eyes focused on mine. It was his turn to speak.

“Can you tell us exactly how Hannibal will kill you?”

The question took me aback. How would Hannibal kill me? In all honesty, I do not know. Not knowing left room for doubt to creep in. Should I even know? To them, I was a character existing within the universe their cast and crew had created and maintained.

My mind spun for a complete minute. How could I possibly know how Hannibal planned to kill me? If I claimed to know, wouldn’t that make me a liar? After all, how could I predict my own future when I was trapped within the very world they considered fictional?

My eyes flicked nervously around the car, my toes curling involuntarily as the pressure mounted in my lungs.

“I don’t know,” I finally admitted, feeling a stab of defeat. “I don’t know how he’d do it.”

I looked back at Hugh through the rearview mirror, meeting his gaze. “But I do know that he will. He’s been... let’s just say, stalking me for weeks.”

I continued, not letting them interrupt, “At first, it seemed harmless, you know? Just another face in the breakfast rush—he always ordered the same thing: medium cheese omelet, small fries.”

I paused for a moment, only to assess their reactions. “But… he never ate it. He just took the takeout bag and went.”

My eyes slid over to Mads, and staring at him felt empowering this time. He looked like Hannibal, sure, but at that moment, it felt like I was staring down Hannibal. Telling him—his mirror image, anyway—to go fuck himself.

“And you know what? I realized he was tossing it in the trash. Every. Single. Time. I saw the takeout bags in the back alley. That’s when I knew.”

Silence again. But this one felt heavier, even more suffocating than the dread of the Ravenstag.

Mads was the first to react. His fingers tapped against his thigh, a restless rhythm like he was missing a cigarette between them. His eyes darted to Hugh, clearly trying to piece things together. “Hannibal as a stalker… can’t say that it’s not possible.”

He smiled a little, like he was in the middle of an interview thinking if Hannibal would even act that way. I could almost forget the sentiment I had for Hannibal when I looked at him. Still, he asked Hugh a question to confirm his understanding of the doctor, “Did we have a kill like that in Season 1?”

Hugh made another turn, the road looking more familiar. Home was close now. Too close.

“I don’t think Hannibal ever targeted a fast food worker,” Hugh said, eyes still on the road. His voice was thoughtful, but he wouldn’t meet my gaze. His shoulders tensed and relaxed, as though he was trying to let the puzzle pieces fall into place. Words died in his throat, but his lips delivered them anyway.

“Hannibal isn’t… that kind of killer, is he? He’s too... selective. A fast-food worker? No offense, but that’s not his style.”

Ouch.

I really wanted to punch him. What was that supposed to mean? That I was too low in the food chain to even be worthy of a serial killer’s attention? My blood boiled. But then—on the flipside—why the hell would I want to be worthy of Hannibal’s dangerous attention? Why would I need that kind of validation?

My fists tightened in my lap, knuckles turning white. No. I didn’t want that. I wasn’t just some victim in his twisted game.

“My worth isn’t defined by that doctor,” I said, my voice firm with newfound resolve. “Because if it is… then I’m nothing more than someone he’s going to kill.”

Silence followed. Mads shifted beside me, sensing the anger simmering just beneath the surface. His eyes flicked toward me briefly, and he gave a small, almost imperceptible nod. It was like he understood where I was coming from.

Fictional or not, I was here . I was breathing. I was sitting in a car with him. I was defending myself like any sane person would.

“We’re not saying you’re worthless without Hannibal, Amelia,” Mads began, his voice deep and deliberate. The tone was careful but familiar enough that it made me stiffen. I forced myself to push past it, letting him finish.

“What we’re saying is, in our canon , Hannibal often has a reason for his kills. His victims fascinate him in some way.” He paused, his gaze drifting back to the road as if weighing his next words carefully.

“And from what you’re telling us… well, Hannibal hasn’t targeted anyone like you yet. The canon hasn’t demanded him to.”

I frowned, the implication hitting me harder than I expected. Hannibal, according to them, operated by rules. Rules of their TV show canon. To them, he was also a fictional character bound by rules.

In a way, it comforted me. Hannibal and I were not so different in the eyes of these actors.

Still, a thought occurred to me. Knowing my interactions with the doctor, my brain allowed an idea to wriggle restlessly. A dreadful one.

My voice dropped to a whisper, the weight of it sinking into the silence. “Has it crossed your mind that he might start operating by his own rules?”

Mads met my gaze, and for a moment, I saw the understanding flicker behind his eyes. If anyone knew Hannibal’s patterns, it would be him. But as my question hung in the air, his own brown eyes darkened, mirroring the uncertainty I felt.

“With you now in the picture,” he said, his voice softer now, “I hope he doesn’t.”

We finally reached the place. The neighborhood where I was residing looked brighter than before, as if my memories of it were nothing but scenes from a color-graded thriller picture.

Well, according to both actors, it was a color-graded, green-tinted thriller picture.

My eyes scanned the surroundings, seeing the rows of houses and establishments the way I remembered them. There was the old coffee shop that served exotic beans from Asia. There was the pet store where I would run to in case I had to feed my cat some treats. There was the barbecue place that never ran out of smoke, even when I would stroll past it every night.

They were all familiar… and yet, why did it feel like I’d never seen it my entire life?

I began to narrow my eyes, focusing on the details of each establishment. My shoulders felt stiff as I made sense of it all. As we slowed down closer to my home, everything felt wrong.

The pet store didn’t have the calico cat that usually greeted me. And the barbecue place—where were the two black ladies who ran it? Instead, there was an old white man by the door, fanning smoke into the street. Then my eyes locked onto what should have been my apartment complex—a seven-story building. But instead, I was staring at a three-story, brutalist nightmare. A derelict slab of concrete looming over the neighborhood.

As Mads, Hugh, and I got out of the car, we all stared beyond the wrought-iron gates of the building. Past the gleaming grass and the sprawling virility of the weeds, the sun was mocking me with its rays shining on the giant wooden signage:

Under renovation. For inquiries, please reach out to the Baltimore Psychiatric Institute.

“An asylum?” Hugh asked, immediately turning his head to me. I couldn’t stare back at him. I couldn’t look at his perplexed, annoyed look. I fixed my gaze on the signage, the sun shining brighter, taunting me with its rays cast deliberately at the signage.

“No… No, this isn’t… this isn’t my home.”

My own voice seemed far away. Panic rose, sucking my stomach from cavity to my throat. The world spun around me. The wind picked up, but it felt like the hot, humid breath of a monster drawing me closer to its maw. My eyes left the signage to gaze at the darkness of the building.

There it was again, the damned stag.

Standing tall just a foot shy away from the doorframe of the asylum, the stag’s red eyes glowed, its silken black body gleaming ever so subtly. Its form stayed almost frozen, if not for the faint wisps of shadows that snaked all around its strong legs.

“It’s here,” I whispered, my eyes never leaving the stag. If only my eyes could capture what I was seeing…

“What is?” Mads asked as he stood next to me. His voice once again made my blood cold. Gone was the comfort it provided in the car. With the stag’s menacing yet inviting presence in the darkness of the asylum, the older actor’s voice sounded like Hannibal’s once again.

“What do you see, Miss Cartwright?” I could not tell if I was hearing Mads or Hannibal. The voice blended in my head, prompting me to tear my body away from Mads’ personal space. I looked back at him again. This time, my eyes trembled with each shift of his clothing. Three-piece suit to a tracksuit. Cap to no cap. Red eyes to brown eyes.

I could not speak. I could not move. Mads and Hugh were shifting in front of me, yet they were unaware. Oh, how they were so unaware.

“Mads, I think we need to call the police.” Hugh finally decided, shooting more ice into my veins.

The police? Why?

“I am not doing anything wrong,” I continued from my thoughts, my voice sounding like it was about to unleash a scream. I took another step back.

“Miss Cartwright, Amelia, this is all we can humor.” Hugh dismissed me flatly, his blue eyes stern and unforgiving. He had already decided this was a con. “Please, just let us handle this—”

“YOU ARE WRONG!” I snapped, caging myself against the closed gates. “I am not doing anything wrong!”

“Amelia—”

But I couldn’t hear them as the words poured out of my mouth, desperate to be used as my stake in the truth. “I am Amelia Cartwright. I am twenty-three. I live at 20B Floor 4 of Carnation Residences.” Tears blinded me again as I stammered and raved about the details of my life. “This is fucking Carnation Residences, not some fucking asylum!”

I shrieked, which now earned the curious glances of the passersby.

But I didn’t care anymore. At that point, I was ready to defend myself, maybe even assert my existence in ways God didn’t sanction. “I am me…” I crumpled to the warm pavement. “I am me… I am real… I…”

I stared at the stag again. It still stood there as if its unmoving elegance mocked my state of disarray.

“You… you!” I yelled at the stag. I could swear I was tearing up blood as red washed my vision. The stag barely moved, only tilting its head to taunt me further.

“I am real. I am real…” I gripped at the gates’ metal railing. Everything felt like it was bleeding. My eyes, my mouth, my feet, my hands. The air didn’t help as it stung my entire body. And it didn’t just sting—it gnawed at my skin, tiny pinpricks of pain like I was torn apart through the layers of skin and sinew.

No other ways to find comfort, it seemed. I was alone in my battle.

Utterly and completely alone.

I gripped the railing, wishing I could bend it and throw it to the damned stag. If I were truly experiencing hallucinations, at least I should be able to bend some rules of reality, right? But no, the metal didn’t bend to my will. It stayed unyielding, leaving nothing but rust in my palms as soon as I let it go.

I steadied myself, not bothering to look at the two men as I took a step inside the property.

“Amelia, wait!”

But my mind was fixed on one thing. Ignoring—or perhaps not even seeing—the blood smearing the pavement with each step, I leveled my gaze at the cursed stag.

“They can’t see you…” I whispered softly to the creature, unmoving in the asylum’s darkness. “So I should just get rid of you, yes?”

There was no answer, of course. The stag’s eyes followed me, glowing with an intelligence I could feel beneath my skin. Its antlers stretched higher with every breath I took, casting shadows that twisted like dark tendrils across the yellow walls.

The two actors followed behind me, each step they took erasing the blood seeping from my feet.

“We’d like to report an escaped patient.” Hugh talked to his phone, his tone urgent and barely concealing the perplexion and panic. I barely focused on what he was saying. Whatever it was, I didn’t care anymore.

I had to kill the damned stag.

“You can’t be seen,” A laugh escaped my lips as I slowly sauntered to the stag, my legs wobbling in and out of my gait. “Yet I see you.”

Mads was right behind me, his tone full of warning, “Amelia.” He now sounded more cautious, looking more tense like he was ready to pounce at me and hold me down. “Enough of this, please. You are ill.”

You are ill.

I heard it somewhere, I was sure of it, but I couldn’t remember exactly. Even Hugh—as if I wasn’t enough for today’s madness—tensed at the words. As if he knew exactly who uttered those words.

“Mads, you’re quoting him.”

Mads froze for a moment, eyes flicking from me to Hugh and back. He recognized Hugh’s concern. His eyes flashed at the Englishman and then at me.

He sounded completely like Hannibal—the concern that belied the mockery, the subtle, arrogant tone that conveyed his disdain for humanity’s lack of discernment.

Mads’ browbones knitted, his lips parting slightly like he hadn’t realized what he’d said. Then, with a forced chuckle, he tried to shrug it off. “Well, it’s not hard to quote a doctor who’s dealt with patients like her, is it?”

But something in his voice was off. Forced. Like he wasn’t even sure where the words were coming from. I could sense his need to sound sure that the quote was a mere slip of the mind. Nothing more than an actor referring to a character he had studied for some time.

Despite their tense exchange, I pushed through, walking to the stag as the stoop seemed to stretch longer, prolonging my desperate chance to pounce at the apparition. It felt like hours, like I was chasing something that shouldn’t be chased. My mind had a singular idea, though, and it couldn’t be held back. Not by the impossible, not by the bickering of the two men as they argued behind.

I just wanted to kill the fucking stag.

I was ten steps away. Five. Three. I lunged forward—

But the stag was gone. Just like that. Vanished. No black hide, no red eyes. Nothing but the mocking shadows of the asylum buzzing in my ears. Frustration surged up my lungs again. My fingers curled in my palms, wishing at that moment the stag would reappear so I could beat the shit out of it. But there was no stag in sight.

Despite the light coming from the front door, I couldn’t make out anything in the darkness. Other than the empty rooms, the prison-like quarters, and the abandoned nurse ward, there was nothing else. Just the cold, damp air that gripped my ankles, shooting ice into my veins.

I stepped forward. One, two, three, four, five… until I was ten steps away from the mouth of the asylum.

One blink, it was an abandoned facility. Another, it was my home.

“This is not happening,” I whispered, more to myself and the looming dread that suffocated each cell in my body. “This should be my… home.”

I blinked again. When I did, the facility shifted into my room again. The hallway transformed into my apartment’s hallway, lined with pictures of my family and my cat. The nurse’s area became the couch, with a bunch of my clothes hanging over the backrest. Beyond the immediate space, the darkness became the rest of my apartment—the kitchen, the bedroom, and the path leading to the darkened balcony.

Warmth briefly embraced me, the thought of home quickly comforting me. But my eyes had other ideas. When I blinked, it was all gone again, replaced by the abandoned facility once more.

Tears began to fall again, this time faster, more urgent, like my body was processing everything all at once, the tears working as my sole relief.

“The police are on their way,” Hugh whispered to Mads, immediately shattering my need to be alone, my desire to let it all out.

“They will be dealing with this…” He continued, urging the older actor until Mads stopped Hugh from walking out the door.

“No, Hugh, we promised her. She needs us.” Mads murmured, low and firm. His grip tightened around Hugh’s arm, which prompted the younger actor to narrow his eyes.

“Mads, whatever she’s doing… we’re not gonna be a part of it. She’s a fan. A deluded one at that.” Hugh looked at me with a stern conclusion, “Don’t feed her anymore, Mads.”

Hugh’s words stabbed through my heart, the pain now spreading from chest to toes. A cloud of resignation rained all over me, soaking me with its rain of despair. There was no point. I could never convince them. Hell, I couldn’t even convince myself, despite all my assertions. Maybe, I was not real. Worse, maybe, I was insane .

I was insane. A laughter escaped my lips.

I was shaking from core to skin, I thought I was laughing but I wasn’t. I sat there on the floor with my quivering shoulders. The two men looked down at me, unsure if I was crying or laughing underneath the veil of my hair.

Suddenly, the world turned and undulated again. Despite the turmoil I was processing, I could feel the ground shifting. Not in an earthquake sense, no, but rather, that certain party trick—where the magician would pull the fabric away from the dining table and leave no mess. The same was happening to me, to the world around me.

“Wait,” I said, my voice shaking with realization. “Don’t move.”

They exchanged glances as the world started to feel less warm. Colder, more sinister, more unforgiving.

I gazed at the world outside the asylum. It was tinted green like it was enclosed in an emerald cage. Hugh seemed to notice it, stepping outside just a few inches away from the door.

“What the hell is happening?”

Then we saw the man. He, too, had the same perplexed expression as Hugh. He wore a brown flannel shirt. His dark, curly hair was in wild disarray like he didn’t bother taking care of it when he woke up. The man had his thick glasses on, but the resemblance was uncanny.

He stepped forward, assessing Hugh, his pronounced jawline gritting with tension. His blue eyes were identical to Hugh’s, but the way they flickered between confusion and something darker made my stomach lurch up. The world was holding its breath, stretching and warping like the fabric of a nightmare. I glanced at Hugh, who seemed to know exactly who the man was.

In turn, the man gazed at the actor, then at me, and then finally at Mads.

“What the fuck?” Hugh and the man asked in unison, their voices blending like two identical timbres.

Mads finally spoke, his voice dropping to an octave, “Will Graham.” He spoke like it should explain the reason we were seeing two Hughs.

The older actor gazed at me, a profound look of awe and a sense of realization gracing his features. Then he focused his eyes on the second Hugh—the one he called Will Graham . He spoke softly, careful with his words as he finally conceded. He looked at Hugh with a somber expression, the words heavy as they left his lips.

“She’s telling the truth, Hugh.”

 

Notes:

Now is the start of trying to push out one chapter a week. This is short, ladies and gentlemen, and everyone in between. Any thoughts or questions? Please let me know! I am currently juggling between this and finishing an artwork since I will attend a con where Mads and Hugh are guests. I hope to finish this before I attend the con, so I can ask them to read this. :)

Wish me luck!