Actions

Work Header

Perfect Red

Chapter 5: V. Le Loup et Le Chien

Notes:

FINALLY added another chapter, guys! Thank you SO MUCH for your patience. I've been receiving saves and kudos here and there in the last two months and THANK YOU for your unending support! I managed to pull this out of my cobwebbed brain hehe. Enjoy!

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

I should be happy to prove Hugh wrong.

After all, he was the one who had been skeptical from the start. Calling the police on me. Brushing off my story. Treating me like some deluded fan. And now, here I am. Standing next to him, watching his surprised face as he stares at his doppelgänger.

I should be happy, right? I should be exalting, screaming at the top of my lungs that I told them so. I should be thanking whatever God decided to give me this impossible moment.

But I wasn’t. I couldn’t be. Not when I looked into the eyes of Hugh’s doppelgänger.

Will Graham’s eyes.

Identical to Hugh’s, but not. Blue, yes. Wide with confusion, yes. But darker somehow—like something in them was broken. His shoulders were hunched forward, his movements tight yet deliberate—like a predator sizing up a threat.

My stomach churned. In hindsight, maybe this was fucking crazy. Maybe I was fucking crazy. They thought I was. The heat radiating from their bodies was enough to tell me this was real. They were real. And yet...

I glanced quickly at Mads. His lips parted as if he wanted to speak but couldn’t. His gaze flickered between Hugh and Will, brows furrowed in confusion. Right—it wasn't exactly normal for actors to meet their own characters. Even in my world—though Hugh and Mads clearly separated mine from theirs—I knew that much.

Yet here was Will Graham.

And here he was, raising his gun in defense.

It was slow, deliberate. The metallic click of the safety disengaging filled the silence. Immediately, Hugh and Mads raised their hands, their eyes wide with something I couldn’t name—fear, maybe. Or disbelief.

“Who are you?” Will Graham’s voice was low, his words measured and sharp. That was another difference. Hugh’s accent was British. Will’s had a faint, deliberate, Southern twang. The distinction didn’t comfort me. If anything, it made the moment worse.

“We’re starting to question that, too.” Hugh’s chuckle was uneasy, brittle around the edges. His hands remained raised, his shoulders tight. Will’s gun didn’t waver, and Hugh’s attempt at humor died in the air.

“I am Hugh Dancy,” Hugh began carefully, his eyes steadying despite the way Will glared at him like he was an anomaly. “This is my friend, Mads Mikkelsen. We’re actors.”

“Actors,” Will repeated the word like it tasted strange in his mouth. His eyes slid to Mads. “Your friend looks an awful lot like Hannibal.”

Before I could respond, Will shifted his aim, leveling the gun squarely at Mads’ chest. The older man’s eyebrow quirked slightly at the gesture.

“We’re not here for trouble,” Mads said smoothly, his voice calm in a way that felt wrong.

Will muttered, his gaze unflinching. “You look like trouble.”

Mads smiled—just slightly, but enough to make my skin crawl, “I would know. Hannibal is trouble.”

Will’s jaw tightened, his teeth grinding as the tension in his body became palpable. For a split second, I thought I could empathize with him—he might be experiencing the same invisible plight I was. The only difference was...

I pulled two people into this reality.

“How do you know him?”

Will’s voice cut through the silence like a knife. The gun didn’t waver, his eyes locked on Mads.

I glared at Mads. Sure, let’s just imply to the man with a gun that they were from another world. That would go over well.

A part of me whispered that he might believe us. But I wasn’t betting on it. The gun looked too real.

Before the two idiots could say anything worse, I blurted out, “They’re not from here.”

Will’s eyes flicked toward me, narrowing slightly, though his aim remained fixed on Mads. “What do you mean?”

The two men—Hugh and Mads—both turned their gazes to me, and suddenly, the ball was in my court.

I took a deep breath. The air tasted strange, tinged with the faint scent of blood and something chemical. It tickled my nose and throat, making me want to cough, but I swallowed it down.

“You wouldn’t believe me,” I said, forcing my voice to steady, “but do you promise to listen?”

For a moment, something in Will’s posture shifted. His shoulders uncoiled slightly, his legs relaxing by degrees. His aim, however, stayed locked on Mads.

“If it’s ridiculous—”

“Then you can hold us in a cell,” Hugh interrupted smoothly, his voice calm but edged with a faint, desperate tremor. He didn’t say anything else, but his hopeful tone lingered in the air, hanging like smoke.

Will studied him for a long moment before narrowing his eyes and, finally, clicking the gun’s safety back on.

He turned his gaze to me. “What is this, then?”

The weight of his attention made my stomach clench. But at the same time, something in me straightened, solidified even. The ground beneath my feet felt more stable, and the sickly green tint of the sky faded as I focused on Will Graham. The world felt more real.

But I wasn’t going to hope—not yet. Still, I offered the best explanation I could muster.

“They’re actors from a TV series,” I said, my voice trembling slightly but growing steadier as I spoke.

“That’s what they’re saying. I…” I hesitated, swallowing hard. “I pulled them here. To our world, Mr. Graham.”

Will stared at me, unblinking. “And you know my name because?” His hand shifted slightly on the gun, as if contemplating whether to turn it toward me.

“Through them,” I replied, my voice quieter now. I gestured vaguely at the two men. How could I even explain to him? That they were actors playing him and Hannibal? That he was a character in their world? He wouldn’t believe me. He wouldn’t believe us .

The thought of my own doubt made the air cold again. My spine tingled as Will processed my words.

Through them. I could almost hear him repeating the phrase in his head, over and over. Through them. The confusion in his eyes sharpened, hardening into something darker. Horror, maybe.

“Actors playing who?” he finally asked, his voice laced with disbelief. And doubt. And something like dread.

“You,” Hugh murmured. He spoke the word softly, carefully, like he was confessing a crime.

Will’s eyes narrowed, his expression darkening further. “That’s impossible.” His voice was lower now, more dangerous. “This must be one of Hannibal’s pranks.”

“I’m afraid not,” Mads said, finally breaking the ten-second silence that felt like ten years. Even Hugh flinched slightly at the sound of his voice.

Mads’ tone shifted, taking on that gravelly, upbeat cadence that felt both comforting and alien, knowing he looked like the man who would never sound as childlike as he. “We found Amelia passed out near our comic con booth. You know, those conventions where people gather to meet celebrities?”

“I’ve heard of it,” Will muttered. His gaze flicked back to me, colder now. “But never in Baltimore.”

Will added sharply, “That doesn’t answer my question,” his hand urged to lift his gun again. “How?”

“It is the answer,” Hugh managed to say, stepping in with a calmness that I knew was fraying at the edges. His eyes darted toward the asylum behind us—the building where everything had begun.

“We found her. She led us here. And this asylum…” He gestured toward the looming structure, its shadow stretching over us like a living thing.

“Is my apartment,” I whispered.

The building groaned in response, shifting again before my eyes. It wasn’t just my apartment—it wasn’t just the asylum either. It was both. It flickered like a mirage, the warm lights of the Carnation Residences bleeding into the overgrown, decaying lawn of the asylum.

The Ravenstag was gone from the building, but its absence didn’t soothe me. The lobby door stood ajar, empty and dark, daring us to step inside. None of us moved. We all waited for something—or someone—to pull us in.

“What do you see?” I finally asked, my voice trembling. Maybe I should start asking them that. I needed their eyes to anchor me, to tell me when I was wrong—or when I was right.

Mads’ voice broke through the silence, smooth and steady. “Building. Carnation Residences.”

Hearing him say it made me want to collapse with relief. It was real. It was still my building. For now, anyway. That was enough for me.

Will, however, turned toward the building, his body angled slightly as if he couldn’t fully lower his guard around Hugh and Mads. His gaze lingered on the building, and his frown deepened. “This shouldn’t be here,” he said finally. His voice was calm and unflinching, like a blade slicing through frost. “I know this place. It’s an asylum.”

The words hit me like a block of ice dropped straight onto my skull. “ What? ”

I felt their eyes on me—Mads and Hugh’s. Heavy, questioning, accusatory. But I couldn’t meet their gaze.

“That doesn’t—” I stammered, trying to grasp at anything to anchor myself. That doesn’t make sense. That’s what I wanted to say. But Will’s frown deepened, his thick eyebrows pulling together into a pair of disappointed arches.

“This was still an asylum back in 2011,” Will said, his voice disturbingly matter-of-fact. “I would know. I visited a few criminals here.”

I opened my mouth to refute him, but no words came out. I hesitated, my thoughts crumbling into shards. This was so tiresome. Exhausting. To prove over and over again that I wasn’t lying. It was bad enough to prove it to two men outside my world. But now, to think this man—who was supposedly from mine—was saying I was wrong?

It was too much.

Will’s detail replayed in my head like an echo I couldn’t escape. 2011. That was years ahead of the year I knew. I still wore the brand-new Nike Air Max 95—the shoes I’d saved for months to buy. My first indulgence, one I didn’t need but cherished anyway.

But when I glanced down, they weren’t there.

My feet were bare. Raw. Bleeding. All over again.

The sight of my own blood made my head spin. My soles stung, and suddenly, the pain was back—the sharp prickle of a million barbs tearing at my skin, marching their way up my knees.

“That can’t be it,” I murmured, flexing my toes to ground myself, to force the pain to keep me present. “I’ve been a resident here for years—”

My feet moved before my mind could catch up, as if drawn forward by some invisible thread.

“Amelia, wait!”

I didn’t know who said it. Mads? Hugh? Will? Their voices melted into the background as the lobby door yawned wider, pulling me into its shadowy maw. My head felt heavier with every step but my feet grew lighter across the dark path leading to nowhere.

The wooden floors groaned under my weight, their creaks swallowed by the soft, wet sound of my own blood smearing across the planks. The faint smell of blood clung to the air, metallic and cloying, mixing with the faint smell of cherries and chemicals.

I climbed three flights of stairs, my hand brushing the splintered railing. I didn’t dare take the elevator; I was sure it would hurtle straight to hell if I stepped inside.

When I reached my floor, the air changed. It was heavier, tinged with something sharp and electric. My throat felt tight, my breath shallow.

The wallpaper in the hallway—yellow and white stripes, faintly peeling at the edges—glowed under the dim incandescent lights. It was warm and familiar, yet my arm hairs rose like needles.

I stared down at my feet again. The bleeding had stopped. My soles were clean, unmarked.

The door to my apartment was unlocked. I didn’t remember unlocking it.

My hand trembled as I reached for the knob. The door swung open before I could touch it, as if drawn by some invisible hand.

No. Not invisible. It was perfectly timed.

Blood shot up my throat, curdling in my chest. I stepped back instinctively, but my feet wouldn’t obey me.

He was there.

Standing in the center of my apartment, perfectly poised, his dark eyes gleaming with quiet amusement.

“At last, Miss Cartwright,” Hannibal Lecter said, his voice as smooth as silk, as sharp as a scalpel. He smiled, tilting his head slightly as if I were an old friend returning home.

“I’ve been waiting.”



Notes:

So yes, this is super slow burn but ngl, this chapter was SO HARD to write because I've always imagined the tension between Hannibal and Amelia, NOT Will and Amelia. I hope this is worth the wait. Any questions or concerns, please comment!