Chapter Text
“What are you doing here?”
The words shot out of my mouth before I could stop them, brittle and sharp, like broken glass slicing through the silence. Ten heartbeats in, I was gazing at the man.
No, he wasn’t even a man. I could remember the way his mouth curled knowingly, a smile that was not human. His eyes—maroon, deep enough to drown in—locked onto mine. Unnervingly bright, like red garnets harvested from the very belly of the Devil himself. I felt them bore straight through my skull, past the surface, and into the raw, trembling core of my soul.
He saw everything. And even then, I stared back.
“Surely, that isn’t a way to greet a friend?” His voice sounded smooth, like a pool of honey waiting for me to dive in and drown. “You’ve been missing for quite some time now.”
The room swayed, or maybe it was just me. I gripped the back of a chair to steady myself. He was taller than I remembered, though maybe that was just my terror shrinking me down. Everything about him was the same: the immaculate hair, the impossibly perfect features, the same, enigmatic smile.
I opened my mouth to speak again, but no words came out. My throat closed against the storm of questions desperate to escape. How could he even be in my apartment? How long had it been since I’d last seen him—days, hours, weeks? Time felt slippery, like I was tumbling through it. I was Alice in Wonderland, except Alice wasn’t supposed to follow the Rabbit. She was supposed to escape him.
The Rabbit tilted his head, eyes narrowing slightly. Hannibal studied me, dissecting and unnerving, like I was a rare insect pinned to a board. Despite the piercing pressure of his red gaze, I continued to struggle beneath its weight.
My spine tingled as he leaned forward, the faintest flicker that resembled amusement playing at his lips. It wasn’t a smile, not really—it was a glint of knowing that sent a shiver crawling under my skin.
“You’re much more fractured than I remembered,” he said finally, his tone soft, almost gentle, like he was a doctor diagnosing a terminal condition.
The word struck me deep. Fractured . I was broken in ways only he could see.
He tilted his head again, and I caught the faint glint of his red eyes. No, not cherry red. Maroon. Dark as wine, but still sharp enough to cut me. For a moment, he almost looked amused again.
It occurred to me, absurdly, that he might as well be the Queen of Hearts. The way he looked at me—detached, but hungry—was enough to make my stomach churn. I thought about the Queen’s favorite line.
Off with her head.
And I couldn’t stop imagining him cutting mine off.
“Amelia, what—” Only then did the footsteps of someone rush to the door behind me. It was Mads.
There was an indescribable silence that followed as soon as Mads gazed at Hannibal.
The demon gazed back at him. For a moment, his face masked the hint of surprise, a curl in his perfectly curved lips telling on the brief, blunt betrayal.
I could not exactly guess how Hannibal was feeling. He just stood there for a long moment, as if time had frozen him solid. Meanwhile, behind me, Mads’ breathing grew heavier. I could almost hear the ba-dump of his heart. Repeatedly. Erratically.
The rustle of his clothes broke Hannibal from his reverie.
“Fascinating,” Hannibal whispered, his nostrils flaring very subtly. Maybe he was registering the man’s scent, or maybe mine, but Hannibal’s face did all the movements while the rest of his body remained motionless. “A duplicate.”
[INT. AMELIA’S “APARTMENT” — AFTERNOON]
Mads straightens at the calm, deep baritone of the doctor, like Hannibal had just insulted him.
MADS
(subtly grits his teeth, gaze darkening at the doctor)
That’s rich, coming from a man who is played by the so-called duplicate.
Hannibal caught on to the implication. A character played by an actor. The man and his duplicate. Who the man was depended on who you asked. Hannibal might count himself as the man. Mads could count himself as the man. But neither man would call himself the duplicate.
The doctor regarded us once more. There was no sneer as a response. That would be painfully human for him. Rather, he looked more amused, if not minimally annoyed. “An actor, you say?” He turned to me, almost accusingly. His garnet eyes reminded me once more of the Red Queen. Cold, hungry, and now, more demanding. Of an answer, perhaps. But I couldn’t give one. Not when I could barely answer to Mads, Hugh, and even Will.
“Well, isn’t this a curious case …” Hannibal whispered, his feet finally thawed by the conversation. He moved around, never venturing too close to me and the actor. Instinctively, I backed myself to the wall, my eyes following his movements.
Mads, too, stepped back to the door. If he truly knew Hannibal more than anyone, then he knew just how dangerous Hannibal was, in and out of his three-piece suit .
“We just want to understand what is happening,” Mads began softly, his eyes never leaving the doctor’s face. “Amelia is from this world. Your world. We just want to return her. She had ventured into ours.”
Hannibal looked over his shoulder, his red eyes darker in the shadows of my apartment. “And you believe her?”
The actor frowned, his browbones furrowing gently. “Is me being here not enough?”
Hannibal chuckled. A dark, soft, and unnerving sound that stung my feet once again. I did not dare to look down, to check if I was bleeding every time I felt that familiar sense of dread. Hannibal just gently leaned against the dinner table.
His chuckle hung in the air, soft and dark, coiling around my throat like ghoulish smoke.
“You ventured into their world, Miss Cartwright?” he asked, his tone light, almost teasing. One of his hands pressed on the surface of the table, splayed like a pianist bent on creating his masterpiece.
“And now you’ve brought them here…” Hannibal murmured, “Or perhaps… they brought you back here?”
His voice was soft, crooning, but every word felt deliberate, each syllable pressing into the cracks of my thoughts.
“Why do you sound like that?” The words stumbled out, my body backing against the wall even more. “You know me. You’ve always known me.” My voice cracked on the last word, like a thin veneer breaking.
Hannibal tilted his head slightly, his lips curling into something that wasn’t quite a smile. “Perhaps, I do. But let me ask you this: if you can’t even explain how you brought them here, how can you be so sure that you’re really in the world that’s meant to be yours ?”
My heart thudded in my chest. The room felt smaller, like the walls were inching closer. “I—I don’t…” Anger embraced my throat with its spiny limbs. “You know me. I am a worker at Shelby’s! You talked to me a lot. At the counter. Even just now you—” I could hear the blood rushing in my ears as I rambled on, “You bought cheese omelet and fries, and—”
“You should be hearing yourself, my dear,” Hannibal cut in, his voice soft and measured, but the edge of it was sharp enough to leave cuts through my defense. “Fast food is known to bring quick, mindless satisfaction to the body… something I am painfully aware of, not because I consume it, but I am surrounded by patients and people who do. Do you think I will indulge in such sacrilege to the body?”
Mads almost flinched at Hannibal’s accusation. My head circled back to the very first time I met Hugh and Mads. His words swam back to the surface of my mind:
You’re the first that cosplayed a minor character. Like a damned Shelby’s employee in a show full of gourmet food?
Yes, how would Hannibal even look at someone like me ? A replaceable employee. Every six months or so. But no… no, no, no… That couldn’t be. Hannibal attacked me. Hannibal ordered food at our restaurant.
You saw it, right? Hannibal was there. Maybe, I could check the cameras if I had the time…
He turned his gaze to Mads now, a flicker of amusement in his eyes. “She doesn’t know. But you… surely you have the answers. You must know everything about me, seeing as you claim to be me.”
Mads straightened, his jaw tightening ever so slightly. “I don’t claim to be you. I play you. There’s a difference.”
“Is there?” Hannibal asked, stepping closer. His movements were slow, unhurried, yet somehow predatory. His gaze flicked over Mads, appraising him like a butcher sizing up a cut of meat. “Do you understand me, mister? Truly? Or are you just wearing my skin like a costume?”
Mads didn’t flinch. His shoulders were tight, but his voice stayed firm. “You don’t scare me.”
Hannibal’s smile widened, his teeth gleaming faintly in the dim light. “How curious. You, who built your career on bringing me to life. Do you think of me as your mere creation? Or am I… greater than you imagined?”
“I think of you as a character,” Mads replied, his tone sharp, cutting through the tension like a sharp butterfly knife. “One I brought to life.”
Hannibal stilled for a moment. The amusement in his expression flickered—briefly, almost imperceptibly. Then it returned, softer this time, more insidious. “It seems that you and I have some similarities. The desire to create. Isn’t that right, Mister…?”
Mads’ silence was long. “Mikkelsen. Mads Mikkelsen.”
Hannibal turned his gaze back to me, his maroon eyes gleaming with a cold kind of curiosity. “And you, Miss Cartwright? You see this man as your savior, don’t you? The actor who plays Hannibal, who claims to know me better than I know myself.”
He stepped closer to me now, his presence pressing against me like a shadow stretching long across the floor. “Are you not scared that he’s just using me as a way to show you who he truly is?”
I froze, my body trembling against the wall.
Hannibal’s small smile celebrated the gaping opening at my defenses. He leaned in slightly, his voice dropping to a whisper meant only for me. “That makes me wonder, too, just how close are all three of us in spirit? Creators. He, my so-called creator. You, a creator of this chaos. And I…”
Hannibal’s face lingered in front of mine. “Perhaps, a creator of yours.”
“No.” The word broke from my throat, raw and desperate. “I am real. I know I am—”
“Shh.” His voice was a silken blade, his finger lifting slightly as though to quiet the world itself. “You’ve seen the cracks in the world yourself, haven’t you? The world you cling to, the world that seems to crackle under your feet. Is it not the hallmark of a fractured mind?”
I felt my knees weaken, my breath shallow. His words circled in my head, the soup of chaos threatening to spill over. Hannibal’s words drenched me in cold fire, burning away any semblance of safety in my mind.
“She is real,” Mads interrupted, his voice firm, cutting through the fog of doubt Hannibal was weaving around me. He stepped forward, his presence grounding, solid. “She is breathing. She is here. And so are both of us.”
Hannibal turned slowly to face him, his expression unreadable.
“You speak with such authority, Mr. Mikkelsen,” Hannibal said softly. He took a step closer to the actor, his eyes glinting like the edge of a knife. “But tell me, if I am real, if she is real, then why are you here? In this so-called world that you and the… gods of creation had birthed? Wouldn’t your existence in this world threaten what it means to be real?”
Mads didn’t flinch. “You feel real because I made you that way. That’s the power of stories.”
Hannibal tilted his head again, a slow, deliberate motion. “Oh, stories. Yes. They are powerful, aren’t they? But tell me this, creator… when you close the book, when you turn off the camera, what happens to the story? Does it die?”
“No,” Mads replied, his voice steady. “It lives in the minds of those who witness it.”
Hannibal smiled faintly, the amusement returning to his face. “Then perhaps I’m not your creation at all. Perhaps I am theirs.” He gestured faintly to the air, as though speaking to an unseen audience. “Theirs to consume. Theirs to shape. And you, Mr. Mikkelsen? Perhaps you are nothing more than a tool. A vessel. A duplicate.”
The two of them—man and monster—stood facing each other, their words circling like vultures. I wanted to scream at them, to tell them both to stop, but the words caught in my throat. I wasn’t even sure which one scared me more.
Mads gritted his teeth. “You’ve been brought to life by other men like me. At the end of the day, you are but an idea, at the mercy of those that create you. Of those who bring you to life.”
I glanced at Mads. He was silent, but there was an undeniable yet near-invisible streak of fear in his eyes, as if he was also convincing himself of the universal truth of his world.
Hannibal, ever the menace, just tilted his head. “And yet, here I stand, like you have said. Breathing. Thinking. Looking into your eyes, Mr. Mikkelsen. Tell me, my dearest actor ,” he mockingly addressed, “if I’m only a story you’ve brought to life, why does it feel now like I’m the one holding the pen?”
He turned to me, taking a lock of hair from my side and twisting it gently. “You may have all the answers to let the power flow, my dear.” Mads pulled me closer as Hannibal tugged at my hair. “The one to hold the pen…”
There was a different kind of indelible hunger in his eyes. One that never went away even with a brief blink.
“To walk between worlds… You may have fractured your mind, Miss Cartwright, but what you’ve achieved—impossible, divine—makes even a broken mind enviable. Imagine what someone with... clarity could do with such power.”
I frowned as the words from my mouth surprised me. “You won’t. Not when I will not let it.”
Slowly, I shifted, my back half-leaning against the wall and next to Mads. Looking at Hannibal, I was fighting the urge to lunge at him. I had Mads with me. Maybe we could survive.
Or maybe we couldn’t. That’s why my mind entertained the idea.
In the darkness that played with my vision, I asked, “Mr. Mikkelsen, he is still at large here, yes? According to the story?”
I had no idea how he exactly understood what I was going for, but Mads chuckled despite the tension. “This world still knows him as the Chesapeake Ripper.”
Letting the words sink in, Hannibal froze. I could see in his eyes that he didn’t like the insinuation, the game called Capture the Ripper.
“You dare ?” Hannibal hissed at the implication.
I took a deep breath, letting my locks slip away from his hand. “If this world will crumble under my own insanity… I might as well let the demon in it perish, too.”
At the sight of Hannibal’s unreadable expression, Mads held my wrist gently. I looked down where our skin met, the faint tattoo in his wrist radiating with encouraging warmth, “Are you sure? He could kill you. No… he would kill you if you tried to turn him in.”
“You know him well, Mr. Mikkelsen.” I muttered. “I trust that you will be my guide to this.”
Suddenly, I could feel the air shift. Heavier, more ominous. For a moment, I felt the fur of some animal brushing behind me. I didn’t dare check on it, if it was the Ravenstag, not when Hannibal’s gaze grew incredibly dangerous.
“You’re making a grave mistake, my dear,” Hannibal murmured, his gaze sharp and unrelenting. “You could have been something extraordinary. And yet, you choose this—a tragedy as old as time, told by a million far better than you could ever hope to be.”
The bear was poked. And before my eyes could register, Hannibal ripped through the air and lunged at me.
