Chapter Text
The Great Library of Erebor was probably one of the least utilized chambers in the entire mountain. Dwarves weren't necessarily stupid or non-academic per se, but they were not naturally inclined towards scholarly occupations, either. There were notable exceptions, of course; such as Balin, Dhola, Ori, Donel's mother, and the twenty-plus dwarves that made up the library's dedicated staff. However, when taking into consideration the great scheme of things, only a handful of Ereborian dwarves were interested in books, scrolls, maps, and fairytales. Blueprints and schematics were a far more common sight in the library than epic poems, medical texts, and classic literature, most of which was sectioned off into various languages. The shelves with Sindarin and Quenya texts were among the dustiest in the whole mountain, something that Erebor's Consort frequently complained about.
"I can't find Ori anywhere."
Frodo sighed in defeat. "I can't, either. He must've left for supper with Clona again."
"We can't really ask anyone else..."
The two friends trudged over to an oaken table and flopped down, Frodo's eyes roaming over the nearby aisles while Donel sifted through a pile of papers that was scattered in front of them. Despite being familiar with the archives, neither of them had paid much attention to the rest of the library, which was usually considered to be Aunt Dhola's and Ori's domain. Like Uncle Bilbo and Glóin, the faunt tended to prefer the older histories of Middle-Earth, most of which were located in the archives and sealed rooms just beneath the library's main floor. And even with the new cataloguing system, finding an exact book or scroll was still very difficult without Ori's assistance, since he seemed to know the entire athenaeum like the back of his wooly hand.
"I finally found it!"
A massive tome was slammed down on the table right in front of their noses, Dwina bustling off for a few moments before returning with four more small books, all of which appeared to be freshly bound and relatively new compared to the rest of the library's usual selection. She positioned them throughout the table and opened each to a bookmarked page, small fingers pointing to the blocky titles at the top of the selected chapters. And in typical Dwina fashion, she crossed her arms and smiled smugly at them.
"They were five aisles down in the recent history section," said the dwarfling. "Honestly, it's not that difficult to decipher Ori's catalogue system. Now, all of these texts give a thorough account of the Quest's last weeks, so we should be able to find something on the incident."
"But this one's written in Sindarin?"
"I know, that's why I selected it." Dwina pushed that small tome towards Frodo and said, "My aunt says that historians and storytellers are biased sometimes, so I thought it'd be best to read several different perspectives. This one's in Khuzdul, these three are in Westron, and that's in Sindarin."
"What about this one?"
"I think that's in Ulgathig, but I've no idea how to read it," she admitted. "A Lotani scholar wrote it while visiting last summer. Almost every other page has a picture on it, so I thought it might be worth a quick lookover."
"You're brilliant, Dwina. I hope you know that."
The young girl preened, her smile even smugger as she started to look through the Khuzdul text and point out any parts that were relevant to their research. It only took five minutes for them to discover that the old weaver hadn't been lying at all. In fact, he'd glossed over several parts and made them seem much more benevolent than they truly were, much to Frodo's horror. The Westron texts and Ulgathig pictures were definitely the most damning, all of them describing and showing his actions and gold madness in all of its cruelty.
"I'm surprised these even made it into the library," said Dwina, her fingers tracing the pictures with a sad reverence. "They make the King look like...well, a treasure hungry dragon. I never knew this had happened."
Donel shushed her and snapped, "You can't say things like that! Someone might hear you."
"Let them. I like Bilbo and what was done to him was deplorable," countered Dwina with that terribly defiant air of hers. If Farina had been with them, Frodo was sure that they would've been scowling and huffing together. "All over a stupid rock. My aunt's always blamed it for bringing Smaug upon us, anyways."
"Umm, Frodo?"
In their bickering, neither of them had noticed their friend's stony silence. Frodo was staring at a picture of Thorin and Bilbo atop the battlements, a small contingency of men and elves standing beneath it. In Bard's hand rested the Arkenstone, the cause of so many problems in Erebor and the Dale Lands. At the bottom of the page was yet another picture, but this one showed Thorin's face twisted into a murderous snarl, his teeth flashing as he shook and dangled Bilbo above the hard rocks beneath Erebor's walls. Both of them cautiously watched Frodo's face, which had remained eerily still for several long moments.
"I don't like that look."
"Frodo?"
"Do something, Dwina!"
"Here, give me the book, Frodo. There's no need for you to—"
A clatter echoed through the cavernous chamber as Frodo shoved out of his chair and took off towards the door, footsteps as silent as his voice as Donel and Dwina tried to keep up with him. The evening librarian called out and asked them what was wrong, but neither dwarfling paid him any mind. Frodo was moving fast and they could barely keep him in their sights as he breezed through the corridors like an angry ghost. Not for the first time, the dwarflings wondered if there was any truth to the tall-tales and rumors that were told in the Dale Lands about halflings and their gift of invisibility.
"Frodo! Stop! You're not thinking straight!"
"Where's he going?"
"Are you joking?! Where do you think he's going! Hurry up!"
"Seriously?"
"Yes! Now hurry up and grab him!"
"But his uncle's in Open Court right now! He'll kill him if he—"
"Don't say that, you fool!"
It only took another sharp turn for Donel and Dwina to put the pieces together about where Frodo was going, the faunt's white-knuckled hand clenched onto the small tome that had shifted his entire worldview in less than a minute. It was as if a dense fog of anger had descended upon Frodo's mind, urging him to the face the parent who lied to him. Entire sections of the Quest—vitally important parts pertaining to his uncles!—had been kept from him; purposely omitted so that Frodo wouldn't ask questions that they might not like or want to answer. Well, he wasn't having of that!
"Frodo! For Mahâl's sake, slow down! If you don't, I swear that I'll rip your hair out!"
"Ugh, why is this city so damned big!"
"You're complaining about that now?! Worry about your breathing later and run faster, you dolt!"
That horrible, awful, gut-churning picture just kept flashing through Frodo's mind. Until this morning, he wouldn't have been able to fathom Uncle Thorin deliberately hurting his beloved husband in such a terrible way. The Dwarf-King doted upon Bilbo like he was the most precious being in the universe. Frodo had tried to explain away the strange tapestry on their return to Erebor, adamantly telling himself that it was all a big misunderstanding and the storybooks in the library would clear everything up and they could all go back to the way things were yesterday—life was so much simpler when he'd gotten out of bed this morning. And then Frodo had seen the horrific pictures and words of his dwarven uncle trying to murder his hobbit uncle.
"Stop! Frodo Baggins! I order you to stop right this instant!"
And then the faunt was entering the throne room, his feet moving easily along the treacherous walkways that led to the massive stalactite in the center of it. Bilbo hated the cavernous chamber and its complete lack of railings, often telling Thorin that all it would take was a slight tumble of Frodo's growing limbs and they'd lose their nephew to a tomb of rock and stone. It worried the older hobbit to no end, especially since Frodo was entering the major growth spurt years and had already begun to trip over his own feet from time to time. However, Frodo's steps were firm and precise right now; he was here for answers and the faunt wasn't leaving until his uncles told him the truth about what had happened atop the battlements twelve years ago.
"Thorin, I really think we should—oh, Frodo, what are you doing here? Is something wrong?"
His uncles were both standing before the throne and looking over guild reports, Dwalin and Dori and Glóin bickering in the background about a territory dispute that had recently exploded between the Carpenter and Silversmith Guilds. Apparently, several noses and fingers had been broken and Dori was damned tired of throwing the involved parties through the nearest door or wall. Dís was nowhere to be found, which was quite odd. The chamber was mostly empty at this point—Open Court always ended before supper—only the usual contingency of guards standing near the doors and behind the throne. Because of this, Frodo felt no need to keep his voice down or thoughts to himself.
"You lied to me!"
The King was the first to respond and asked, "What are you talking about, mizimith?"
"Both of you, all of you," hissed Frodo as he threw the book at his uncle, "Lied to me about what happened! You tried to kill Uncle Bilbo!"
If it was possible for a person to pale to the color of white marble, then all of the dwarves in the throne room would've looked like statues after those words came out of the faunt's mouth. Bilbo was the only one who didn't look ashamed or physically ill, and he didn't waste any time in approaching his distressed nephew, hazel eyes wide and dark with concern. But Frodo wasn't having any of it this time. No, he'd had enough of being coddled by the adults in his life.
"Why didn't you tell me?" demanded the faunt. "Did you think I was too stupid to understand?"
"No, Frodo, we never thought that," said Bilbo, hands wringing in the air. "The whole truths behind our journey aren't the epic fairytales that everyone thinks or makes them out to be, my darling. A storyteller's tale isn't the same as the actual event."
"But you're not a storyteller," said Frodo, accusation heavy in his voice. "You're my uncle. And you lied to me."
"Don't take that—"
Thorin was promptly silenced with a wave of Bilbo's hand. The very last thing they needed was for Frodo to go any more on the defensive; he was already eyeing Thorin and the other adults with wary glares, something that Bilbo had never wanted to see. It was like Brandy Hall all over again, except Frodo was older and much more articulate now, so sullen silence and frightened hiding was obviously not his first reaction this time around. Bilbo wasn't sure if that was a good sign or not. Was it better for Frodo to let it all out or bottle it up like before? He honestly didn't know.
By the Green Lady, Primula would've been so much better at this.
"A lot of very unpleasant things took place during those last days, Frodo," reasoned the older hobbit. "We've already spoken about the treasure and why my share had to go to the men of Dale, correct? Gold can have a strange effect on some people."
"You never told me that Uncle Thorin tried to murder you." Frodo's glare was cold enough to melt glacial ice. "And is that why he won't go into the treasury? Because he might let the gold take over his mind and try to kill you again?"
A deep intake of breath could be heard around the room, Donel and Dwina stepping back to hide behind the throne. They could hear Dori and Glóin wince to their left, eyes fixed on the infuriated faunt. Dwalin didn't seem to know what to do about the situation, fingers twitching in confusion while his face flickered between Frodo and his uncles every few seconds. And for the first time, all three of the children noticed the presence of Lord Dáin and his son, who had both arrived earlier in the week to discuss several military and trade agreements.
"Frodo, I think it'd be best if we discussed this in a more—"
"What? So you can just lie to me again? That's all everyone's been doing around here for years!" Frodo's face was flushed at this point, eyes watery from anger and frustration and a whole collage of unpleasant feelings. "None of them tried to help you! They just stood by and let you be dangled off the battlements like a ragdoll! Why didn't any of you think to tell me that?"
"We wanted to protect you."
"How can you protect me from something that everybody else already knows?" Frodo demanded. "It's in the books, it's on the tapestries, all of the men and women in Dale know about it, too. And apparently so does every dwarf in the mountain except us. Is that why Brunna and her lot think Uncle's going to leave you? Just throw us out onto the desolate dirt and rock when our strangeness wears off?"
Now that stirred up a combustion of shouts and cries from the adults, Dwalin speaking in defense of his cousin while Dáin and Helm appeared to be quite constipated by the whole situation. Bilbo looked genuinely flabbergasted and very upset that their youngest nephew had been harboring such terrible thoughts without any of them knowing; it was exactly what he had been trying to avoid whenever the female dwarf was visiting Erebor's halls. But Frodo had seen all of it: the blatant flirtations, the whispers behind his uncle's back, the ridiculous duel of honor, and the awful truth behind the many snickers and jabs that had been made towards his uncles' marriage. The cruel comments about a stone being worth more than a halfling made a lot more sense now.
"Frodo," said Thorin in a choked voice, "I would never do such a thing to you or—"
"Don't make a promise you can't keep!"
Frodo could feel tears welling in his eyes, but he was too angry to care about them at this point. Everything was so confusing and he couldn't believe that they'd lied to him. Once the novelty wore off, the dwarves would find something better to occupy their time with and then they'd disappear like everybody else, happy to be rid of the pathetic little orphan. Without Uncle Bilbo, he'd be all alone again.
"You're not any better than Mama and Papa! All of you are a bunch of liars! All of you!"
"Frodo, please, you need to calm down and allow your uncle and myself to explain exactly what happened," said Bilbo, gently reaching out to touch Frodo's cheek. "You are right, we shouldn't have kept this from you, but Thorin's actions weren't what you—"
And then Frodo saw it. In the older hobbit's hair were his marriage beads, carefully clipped on the end of Bilbo's short braids and then tucked behind his leaf-like ears, nearly hidden to the untrained or non-dwarven eye. Frodo had always thought them to be beautiful and perfect and a physical expression of the love that existed between his uncles. But now...
"Why are you wearing it?" Frodo demanded. "It glows like the Arkenstone. It is the Arkenstone! Why are you wearing it?!"
The fauntling backed away, barely paying any attention to the nervous breaths that everyone took in around him. He didn't notice how Bilbo and Thorin and the others nearly surged forward, their eyes wide with terror when the faunt's feet came a little too close for comfort to the platform's edge. Even Dwina tried to venture forward—always the most loyal of friends, Dwina was—but her path was blocked by a distraught Bilbo, all semblance of calm gone from the hobbit's face. Everything was spiraling out of control and the adults couldn't figure out how to stop it.
"It was a gift, Frodo. Just as much for marriage as for forgiveness," Bilbo assured, desperately trying to soothe his crying nephew. "What your uncle did was wrong, and he's been repenting for it ever since, but you have to understand that he would never do such—"
"But he already did it! He loved a thrice-damned rock more than you!"
That particular statement seemed to spur Thorin into action, his regal form stepping forward to confront the irrational and upset faunt, who was yet again wandering far too close to the platform's edge. However, the King's sudden movement had the opposite effect and caused Frodo to flinch backwards, his eyes darting between Thorin, the abyss, and the empty slot above Erebor's throne. The significance of those glances was not lost on anyone in the room.
"Please, mizimith," whispered Thorin in the gentlest tone possible, "Please, don't be scared of me. You have nothing to—"
And then a loud clang came from one of the adjoining walkways, nearly a dozen bickering councilmen making their entrance in such a way that it startled Frodo to the point of almost toppling over the gallery's edge. Thorin instantly made a grab for the teetering child, but Frodo somehow managed to regain his balance and move out of the Dwarf-King's path, blue eyes wide with anxiety and fright. Those horrible pictures flashed through Frodo's mind and he felt an awful coldness constrict around his heart. What if his uncle became enraged again? Would he choose to rid himself of an annoying, bratty faunt who wasn't even his own blood-kin? It was just like Brandy Hall all over again and Frodo just couldn't seem to find a parent who'd—
"Frodo!"
Startled like a deer in the lamplight, Frodo bolted away from his uncle's grabby hands and ran for the only walkway that wasn't being blocked by guards, friends, or relatives. He didn't even notice Donel and Dwina running straight after him, their small bodies ducking underneath the guards' hands as well. It only took a few seconds for Dwalin and Thorin to take off in pursuit.
After that, everything was silent for several long moments.
"It wasn't supposed to happen this way," lamented Bilbo. "I should've explained it all to him sooner. With his parents' deaths and everything else, I should've known that he'd react terribly to our omissions and the whole truth."
"Things will be alright, Bilbo," assured Dáin as he handed the hobbit a handkerchief. "Frodo's a bright lad. He's just very confused right now."
Helm walked up and whispered to his father, "I'm going to help them. Are you alright, Bilbo?"
"Aye, I'll be fine. It's Frodo I'm worried about."
None of them noticed the shadowy figure that slinked out from behind a nearby pillar, disappearing into the granite walls like a ghostly specter. The footsteps were silent and precise, aiming for the eastern halls. Everyone else had directly followed the distressed faunt, but this figure knew that a more subtle method needed to be employed as soon as possible.
Damage control seemed to be the order of the day.
