Chapter Text
The Dark Roads of Erebor were a frightful and unpredictable place, most of the paths twisting and turning and stretching for countless miles of complete blackness in all directions around the mighty mountain. Few dwarves dared to venture into such dank and perilous depths, none wishing to fall through hidden segments of bad rock or crash into a rotten plank full of rusty nails. Thankfully, the entrances and exits to the Dark Roads were difficult to locate, especially since the tunnels had fallen into chronic neglect and disrepair during Smaug's occupation of the Lonely Mountain. Only Nori and his minions frequented the dangerous passages now, occasionally escorting miners or masons to mend the most decrepit portions of the tunnels, namely those around the treasury, upper markets, and central city. However, a few of Erebor's smallest inhabitants had become semi-regular patrons of the Dark Roads as well.
"All of them are stupid," Frodo mumbled to himself. "And liars, too. Stupid liars."
The faunt wiped at his snotty nose and itchy eyes for the tenth time in as many minutes, stubbornly refusing to cry or whimper over the volatile confrontation that he'd just had with his uncles in the throne room. Frodo felt emotionally drained and rung out, hands shaking from the anxiety that was still thrumming through his exhausted body. It was rare for the faunt to fight with his guardians and Frodo could count on one hand the number of times he'd ever raised his voice to them. Hobbits weren't an antagonistic race; shouting and arguing and upheaval tended to take a lot out of them and Frodo was not an exception to this rule.
"I thought I'd find you here."
Frodo didn't bother to move, small form huddled into a nigh-invisible opening along the low-hanging wall. Various blankets and boxes and mining tools were scattered around the circular charter shaft that Nori himself had installed four years ago, its location offering a convenient rest point for the spymaster and his industrious minions. Packages of watered down ale and rations were hidden along the upper walls, gifts of necessity that Nori personally restocked every two weeks for his minions and any miners that might be wandering through the tunnels. And from the loud sound of crunching near his feet, Nori figured that Frodo must have found them and decided to have a midnight snack.
This was a very good thing, of course. Hungry hobbits were terrible business. And despite Dwalin's opinion on his masochistic tendencies, Nori didn't particularly enjoy being bit or gnawed on by a pint-sized butterball if he could avoid it.
"Did my uncles send you?"
"I had hoped that you'd know me better than that, mim kalilâl," lamented Nori with a dramatic pout. "Since when have I ever listened to Thorin on matters such as this? I'm wholly loyal to His Royal Gruffness, but you've gotta admit that your uncle's a lil' thick in the head at times."
"And Uncle Bilbo?"
"For you, my dearest Frodo, I can live without raspberry sticky buns," sighed the dwarf, his movements hard to track in the dark. "For a few weeks. If it's any longer, then I'll have to exact revenge upon your person. I've killed for those delicious buns before, I'll have you know."
"I don't wanna talk right now."
"Aye, your little friends down the tunnel told me as much. Quite fierce, those two are."
Frodo didn't even bother to respond after that, stubbornly lying on the hard floor while also keeping his face hidden in the middle of his crossed arms. A few blankets could be seen in the darkness, positioned beneath Frodo's chest, stomach, and legs to hold off some of the damp chill that haunted every part of the mountain. The fauntling obviously knew where Nori stashed all of his goodies, although the thief didn't really mind this development, either. Taking in traumatized and delinquent strays had become one of his more commendable habits in recent years.
"Master Nori?"
Ah, and there was one of them now.
"You can inform our King and Consort that their sproutling is safe and sound and in the company of a trusted adult," Nori instructed. "Well, mostly trusted, at least. I assume that they're throwing quite the fit at this point."
Fróya nodded. "According to Jóya, there was much cup throwing and chair smashing. He hid behind the purple tapestry, I think."
"Clever boy."
"Should I inform Master Dwalin as well?"
The faunt watched in the very dim light as Nori pressed a small...something into Fróya's hand, instructing her to give it to Dwalin after she returned home for the night. Frodo knew that the captain and spymaster had been caring for several of Nori's youngest minions, most of whom were orphans or down-on-their-luck tweens. His uncle frequently baked cupcakes and pies and casseroles for the pick-pocketing brood, a whole plethora of snacks and finger-bites conveniently laying around the royal apartments and offices whenever no one was there. Bilbo always smiled when the tiny gifts disappeared during an absence, happily puttering around and interrogating Dwalin about which child liked what food, drink, candy, whatever the least or the most.
"And tell your brother to leave my knives alone," warned Nori. "Evil lil' rascal's been snatching 'em for weeks now."
"I can't promise anything."
With that, Fróya disappeared into the black, her footsteps as silent as the ghosts and specters that Bofur loved to tell stories about. Frodo didn't know much about Fróya and Jóya, but they seemed nice enough and he'd caught Nori and Dwalin smiling a lot more often since their arrival seventeen months ago. And considering Dwalin's tendency to frown and scowl at anything and everything, that was a very, very good sign.
Or maybe the wrestling was a major influence, too. Adults were strange about things like that, Frodo had learned.
"I swear, I have to do everything around this city," Nori mumbled. He flicked at a small, concealed torch that was hidden in the ceiling. "Honestly, the whole lot of them would be dead a hundred times over if I wasn't around to save their self-righteous asses. Shameful..."
Frodo just laid there and listened to the spymaster gripe and groan to himself. It took his mind off of less...pleasant things in his life.
"Okay, now listen and listen well, beansprout. I've got a story for you," said Nori as he flopped down beside Frodo on the ground. "Even by dwarven standards, your uncle's a bit of a judgmental prick, and I'm saying that in the nicest way possible. There's a reason why I held more respect for your aunt in Ered Luin. So, it's not surprising that dear, cranky Thorin acted like a hobbit-hating dope for the first half of the quest. I've never been much for authority or dwarven superiority, as you well know, and I've ran into an interesting array of shirelings throughout my travels. Best food in the west, hands down, no competition."
Nori paused for a moment, eyes drifting off into fond memories. Frodo wondered if he'd ever been smacked with a broom. That dwarf had a bad case of sticky fingers and lady hobbits were viciously protective of their pies.
"But I digress...now, it took a long while for Thorin to warm up to our devious butterball of a burglar, but he was quite taken by Bilbo's fierce genius and invisible powers by the time we reached Laketown. Or maybe it was just how cleverly Bilbo was able to outsmart the elves in their own home. That's a very attractive trait. I think Thorin was all but salivating and swooning when Bilbo busted us out of there."
"I already know all of this, Uncle Nori."
"None of that sass, beansprout, I'm just giving some backstory for effect. Bofur's not the only one who can tell a good tale around here," sniffed the thief. "So, we've already established that your hairier uncle's a stubborn galoot, which resulted in him suffering from a wee case of gold sickness. I'm assuming that no one has properly informed you of the side-effects that come with such an unfortunate illness, have they?"
Frodo shook his head, face still buried in his arms. Maybe if he didn't look up, Nori would go away.
"And that's where everything went wrong," Nori mumbled to himself. The spymaster scooted over and wrapped an arm around Frodo's shoulders. "Okay, I'm gonna give you the bluntest, most straightforward explanation I can, mizimith. And it's not going to be pleasant, but I want you to listen and not jump to conclusions until I'm done, alright?"
The faunt nodded again.
"You know the rest of the story, so I'm just going to fill in the gaps," Nori said. "And that starts about two minutes after Smaug barreled out of Erebor and proceeded to burn Laketown to the ground. Or the lake. Whichever one works, take your pick. We dwarves have a wee bit of an issue with gold and gemstones and other shiny things, as you've probably seen with your Uncle Glóin and the other bankers. Most of the time, we can control ourselves by pushing the thoughts to the back of our minds. I might pick my fair share of pockets, but only as much as I need to survive and support my family. Although I will admit that your aunt's jewelry box was quite tempting..."
Frodo glared at him.
"Now, now, there's no need for that. And as I said, most of the time, pushing away the pull isn't a big problem." Nori's face darkened after that, his hold on Frodo tightening as he approached the grimmer parts of the story. "But with a treasury like Erebor's at our feet? Well, it changed things."
The dwarf took a deep breath and closed his eyes, fingers tightening around Frodo's shoulders. If something conjured up that kind of expression on the spymaster's face, then Frodo knew it was a very unpleasant subject. Or a nightmare...
"Gold sickness creeps up on you like a phantom, or a small voice slowly becoming louder and louder in your ears. It pulls you toward the gold like a magnet and everything else seems not to matter; even eating and drinking and sleeping becomes a chore when there's so much gold and jewels to count and catalogue. I knew what would happen to my fingers if I tried to take anything, so I stuck to the outer halls during most of the frenzy, but it was always there, right on the edges of my mind. Whispering to me, calling to me."
"Why didn't you just leave?" Frodo asked. "Wouldn't leaving the mountain cure it?"
"Maybe, maybe not, all dwarves react differently to it. Fíli and Kíli were naturally more resistant to the pull, but I think that was due to their young ages and what they'd just witnessed in Laketown. I had to make a conscious effort to resist it. The craving was always there. And as you know, your uncle's grandfather had suffered from the madness more than any other dwarf in recent times and—"
"Except for Uncle Thorin."
Nori paused at that and eventually said, "Aye, except for your uncle. I suspect that the gold sickness had already started taking root as soon as he saw the mountain for the first time. His eyes were different after that. His behavior, too. The madness often makes a dwarf cold and callous; all they wish to do is find their gold and count it until the end of time. No pile is ever large enough; no jewel is ever grand enough. It's a vicious cycle and the line of Durin has been stuck in it for many centuries. Your uncle was just the latest casualty. Not that that excuses any of his actions, either."
"Uncle Bilbo seems to think so," grunted the faunt. "He married the dwarf who tried to kill him."
"I'll admit, I was shocked that your uncle forgave Thorin after what he'd done," admitted Nori with a sigh. "In the eyes of Thorin and the madness, stealing the Arkenstone was an act of high treason, and in dwarven society, that means death."
"You don't kill the people you love over a stupid rock."
"Aye, you're right, beansprout. Not that either of them were willing to admit or act on their feelings at the time, but killing your companion over a shiny rock isn't something that most dwarven mothers would be proud of. And Bilbo was the only one of us with a lick of sense at the time, so he made the best decision he could with limited time and four armies knocking at our gates. Erebor would've been lost if your uncle hadn't taken such a dangerous risk. I think Thorin realized this, but the madness and pull towards Erebor's birthright overrode everything else in his mind."
"Why didn't you stop him?" Frodo demanded. "You said that you and Fíli and Kíli weren't completely bonkers with the madness, so why didn't any of you even attempt to stop Uncle Thorin from killing your burglar?"
Nori sighed and scrubbed at his face with a filthy hand. "I can't speak for your cousins, but I was a coward, plain and simple. The only reason I'm not rotting in a prison cell is because of Ori volunteering me to the quest itself. It was your aunt who convinced Thorin to let me accompany them, and that was only because of my...unique abilities. Not exactly the best way to gain someone's trust, eh? Anytime something went missing in the camp or on ponyback, I was blamed for it. At least until they found whatever it was they'd lost. And if they didn't manage to find it, then, well, I was still blamed for it."
"Did they think you took the Arkenstone? When they couldn't find it?"
"Aye, they did, and it wasn't a friendly encounter." Nori took the faunt's hand and ran it over a long, jagged scar on his right forearm. "Our burglar wasn't even a suspect at that time, which is something that I'll never regret. Your uncle may be tough and fierce for a hobbit, but he's still much smaller and delicate compared to us dwarves. Thorin would not have been so kind without Gandalf there to stop him. I'm glad it was me who he targeted inside the mountain and not our Bilbo. I can take punches and kicks and knife fights with the best of them, but a malnourished hobbit?"
The thief reached over and grabbed an oatmeal bar from Frodo, stuffing over half of the sweet treat into his mouth. Just like everything else that the Company and their family and friends ate, this snack had been made by Bilbo, specially designed with herbal preservatives to remain edible for several weeks before staling in the tunnels or while out on patrol. Yet another thing that the Company's burglar had done to make their lives easier.
"No, it's good that it was me who took the initial blame. And the scar's not too bad, either. Very dastardly."
Despite his anger and continued resentment towards the Company for their actions—or complete lack thereof—Frodo found himself cuddling closer to Nori. The faunt tried to wave it away as basic instinct to avoid the tunnel's damp chill, but Frodo also knew that he was desperately craving physical and emotional contact with an adult who hadn't wronged Bilbo or himself.
"Uncle Dwalin should've protected you. Or punched Uncle Thorin in the head for being an asshole."
"No foul language, beansprout. I'll not have Bilbo boxing me in the ears again." Nori didn't hesitate to cuddle the faunt. "And Dwalin wasn't exactly my biggest patron back then. Actually, if he could've thrown me off the battlements, he probably would've without a second thought. It's taken decades for us to even hold a civil conversation. Or to get past all those times I broke out of his supposedly impenetrable jail cells. He did confront Thorin though, when Dáin and his men were stuck fighting our battles for us. And like your cousins, Dwalin didn't hesitate to put himself between Thorin and Bilbo when our King went truly barmy on the battlements."
"I still don't understand why he did what he did," Frodo murmured. "Or why Uncle Bilbo would take him back, either."
"That's something that you'll have to ask your uncles," was Nori's reply. "However, I can assure you that it was a long, unpleasant process. Bilbo may have forgiven Thorin on his supposed deathbed, but our burglar was still quite leery of him before leaving for the Shire. That's the reason why everyone was surprised to see Bilbo return. And with you in tow!"
"But that still doesn't—"
"And I can't answer that for you," said Nori as he took another bite of the oatmeal bar. "I have little memory of the days immediately after the battle, and no one but Bilbo or Thorin knows what was said in that tent. I do know that Dwalin apologized after my concussion finally started to recede and it didn't feel like two dozen miners were throwing a party inside my head. Oddest day of my life."
Frodo giggled at this. "Did he look constipated when he did it?"
"Oh, it was the most painfully and gassily constipated expression I'd ever seen." Nori laughed and tried to wipe away the snot from Frodo's nose with a handkerchief. It had Bilbo's initials on it. "Pulling teeth would've been less painful for him."
It was quiet for a few moments before Frodo asked, "I don't understand how he could love gold and jewels more than Uncle Bilbo. Or Fíli and Kíli..."
"Look at me. I said look at me, Frodo Baggins."
When the faunt didn't turn, Nori grabbed his chin and made Frodo face him. They were having this conversation whether the faunt liked it or not; and rest assured, Frodo really didn't like it.
"Your uncle has made a lot of very stupid decisions in his life and I've seen many of them in Ered Luin and in Erebor. We won't even cover some of his poorer decisions on the quest itself. He's one of the most emotionally constipated dwarves I've ever met in my life, and this is coming from me of all people. However, if there's one good thing I can say about Thorin Oakenshield, it's that he loves his boys. All three of them."
Frodo sniffled and tried to turn away.
"Did you hear me? Thorin loves you. And Bilbo. And Fíli and Kíli. Although I'm certain that he sometimes wishes he could kill them."
Another round of sniffles were stubbornly held in.
"Your uncle doesn't enter the treasury because he loves all of you too much. He's scared of the gold sickness. Terrified of it. Because Thorin knows—and I was eavesdropping, so I know this for a fact—that if he succumbs to the madness again, Bilbo will pack up and return to the Shire. And he'd take you with him." Nori forced Frodo to look him in the eyes. "Your uncle loves you too much to risk that. And if you think any differently, then you're not the clever boy I know you are, fuzzfoot."
Frodo tried to shove him away, but Nori wouldn't allow it.
"A hobbit sits upon the throne of Erebor instead of the Arkenstone. Here, in the Lonely Mountain, home of Durin's Folk. If that doesn't scream devoted and everlasting love, then our King Under the Mountain's not a true dwarf."
Two fingers suddenly pulled at the pointed tips of Frodo's ears.
"He'd be an elf."
Those words were enough to unleash another round of tears, but this time, Frodo didn't even attempt to struggle against Nori's arms or the prickly beard against his cheeks. He let the spymaster hold him, reveling in Nori's assurances that Thorin would still love him. That Erebor's gold and jewels weren't more important than the faunt that he'd adopted and raised as his own nephew and child. Nothing scared Frodo more than losing another parent, and Nori seemed to know this.
"I'm not sure of a lot of things in this world, beansprout, but your uncle's love for you? That's nonnegotiable."
"But what if it's not enough?"
"Then Bilbo will bash him over the head until his marbles line up." Nori pulled out another handkerchief. "Here, blow..."
Frodo did as he was told and thoroughly ruined yet another handkerchief. Not that that would be considered a tragedy to any dwarf worth his salt in hairiness. Destroying Bilbo's handkerchiefs was a favorite pastime of the Company, namely Bofur and the princes. Gimli was a common culprit as well.
After ten or more minutes of crying and muttering, Nori finally asked, "You ready to talk to them yet?"
The dwarf didn't pressure Frodo into an immediate answer, which the faunt was very grateful for and he returned the favor by giving Nori an even tighter hug. He just stared into the darkness for a little while, nose sniffling and eyes sticking as the tears slowly dried up and Frodo's thoughts cleared for the first time in hours. Frodo remembered the terrible pictures and words in the books, the horrified faces of his uncles, and the awful tapestry that had triggered everything. With a shiver that was half from the cold and half from the overall situation, Frodo snuggled under the spymaster's beard and decided to make himself at home for now.
"Can we just lay here for a little while?"
Nori reached down and carded his fingers through Frodo's curls before slowly rolling onto his back. In this position, Frodo was safely situated atop the dwarf's stomach and well away from the tunnel floor. The last thing any of them needed was for Frodo to catch a cold. They'd already filled up their yearly quota on that particular illness, thank you very much.
"Aye, we can do that."
