Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

 

Actions

Work Header

he served a dark and a hungry god

Summary:

After seven years in prison on false charges, Will Graham has returned to Baltimore. He moves in with a charismatic butcher/baker/pie shop owner, restarts his former business, learns about the tragedy that has befallen his family, and sets his sights on exacting revenge and justice on the man responsible for it all. Meanwhile, Margot Verger tries to escape the thumb of her cruel brother with the help of Alana Bloom, and Abigail Hobbs becomes close to a pair of potentially dangerous men, one of whom might be leading Will down a dark path.
Or: A retelling of the tale of Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, except with Hannibal characters.

Notes:

here's a new project I've been wanting to start ever since the recent Sweeney Todd revival hit Broadway this year: a Hannibal/Sweeney Todd AU. combining one of my favorite musicals with my current favorite show seemed almost too easy, although it took a bit of thinking to decide which characters to assign which roles in the narrative. events from both canons will likely end up being mixed up and rearranged to suit the story, but I had fun creating it.
will the tale of Sweeney Todd still work if he's a fishmonger instead of a barber? let's find out.

Chapter 1: No Place Like Baltimore

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Seven years abroad in prison had done a number on Will Graham, but he was determined to return to his former home city in the hopes that if he had changed, the people and places around him had not. He knew this was a fool’s errand, as one could never expect the world outside to stay the same as time passed in a monotonous daily routine within, but he thought at least that returning to the familiar ports and harbors of Baltimore would do him some good.

He was traveling back home on a ship called the Bountiful, and although he had not expected to speak to anyone else on board for the duration of the journey, he had ended up finding a companion when he reunited with a Dr. Alana Bloom, who was coincidentally heading to the same destination as him. She had first met him while interviewing prisoners of the Australian penal colonies as part of her studies in psychology, and he believed she had been instrumental in getting him released not long afterwards.

He had told her much of his story along the way. She listened with a sympathetic ear and told him that if he ever found himself struggling with the aftereffects of his experiences when he returned home, he could always talk to her.

The facts were this: He had once been a common citizen of Baltimore, Maryland, working in the boatyards fixing others’ vessels and catching fish to sell and to eat. He was known for being hardworking and good at what he did, but solitary and reluctant to interact with anyone outside of business-related transactions. He lived alone except for a number of stray dogs he had taken in when they came sniffing around his door for scraps of food.

One day, the police, led by Inspector Jack Crawford, came to his door asking if he knew anything about a murder that had been committed near the harbor where he did most of his work. He had gone to see the body, and although he did not know who the man was, he was able to provide them some valuable suggestions about the methods and motive that led them directly to the killer. After that, Crawford began asking after him whenever there was a particularly difficult crime scene in the area, and he developed something of a working relationship with the man. He never officially worked for the police, but he was in many ways their most valuable asset when solving crimes.

His strength was his ability to step into anyone’s head, even a murderer’s. Will’s father used to say that he knew what everybody was thinking and felt everybody’s pain. It was part of why he disliked interacting with other people. The vast breadth of emotions and thoughts and history he found himself reading whenever he looked into someone else’s eyes got quickly overwhelming. It did make it easy for him to adopt the mindset of another person, to step back and imagine what someone might have been thinking when they created something he saw before him. This was helpful both for appreciating artwork and understanding murders.

He always insisted he was perfectly alright no matter how many crime scenes he took in this way, but Jack encouraged him to at least get out more and talk to more living people to counterbalance the deluge of negative thoughts with more positive ones. As he worked he got to know the community better; he became friends with Jack and a few more people on the police force, although they didn’t go out of their way to see each other often and he still knew that most of the officers looked at him with more wariness than admiration outside of the job. He met a woman, a widow named Molly Foster, who had a young son named Walter, and for whatever reason Will could fathom, they were soon married. For a time he was happy, he thought.

Until the year came that two cases converged. Will met the heir to the Verger meatpacking fortune, a pompous and unpleasant man named Mason, following the death of a worker at one of their slaughterhouses that was eventually ruled an accident. Will still didn’t quite trust that Mason Verger had nothing to do with it, and his sister Margot had sensed this and met up with Will in secret that night, confessing that she believed her brother planned to kill her.

It was risky, to be indulging in such plots against a wealthy and respected member of the community when his own position as a respected ally of the law was on the line, but he tried to help Margot as best he could. She was in favor of arranging an “accident” for him, but not before she found a way to conceive a child of her own, as that would be the only way she could retain the family fortune as per her father’s will.

At the same time, a man was stalking the city and the surrounding areas, murdering young women who all fit a similar physical description. Will, determined to solve the case and accomplish Margot’s goals at the same time, looked into Mason Verger as a suspect.

He did find the real killer, tracking down a Garrett Jacob Hobbs and confronting him in the act of attempting to cut his own daughter’s throat. She looked very much like the other victims and his motive, twisted as it was, was clear. It was the first time Will had ever killed another human being, and in the moment he felt righteous.

It didn’t last long, though. Mason Verger had evidently figured out that Will was either suspicious of him or attempting to frame him, and mounted a case against him. Clearly, Hobbs was not the killer – Graham was, and he had murdered an innocent man who had narrowly saved his daughter from having her throat slit. No one else had seen him do it, and the girl, Abigail, was still recovering and could not speak, so there was no one to counter Mason’s accusations. Thus, Will was shipped off to prison, and remained there until it was determined that he was of sound mind to return to society.

“Thank you again for helping me get out,” he said to Alana as they prepared to disembark.

“You’re welcome,” she said, “but I think it may have been that they only just received the news that you were innocent.”

Will took a deep breath as they stepped off the ship, allowing the sea air to flood his senses. Alana sighed contentedly behind him.

“It’s good to be home,” she murmured. “I expect you’re relieved to finally be back, too.”

“Not quite yet,” he said. “I fear I’ve developed too much cynicism about the world to be able to appreciate this place as I once could.” He glanced back at Alana. “But it’s been kinder to you, I hope.”

“I’ll have to see how it goes for me, now that I’m not just a woman of science but a doctor of psychology,” she said as they began making their way into the city. “I hope to improve the treatment of patients in asylums, and prevent more people from being involuntarily committed to them. What do you plan to do?”

“I suppose I’ll get back to my old job of working on fishing boats. First, I want to go to my old home and see if my wife still lives there. I wouldn’t blame her if she left.” He scanned the buildings around them for a recognizable sign or two. “And then perhaps I’ll get something to eat.”

“I’ll walk with you as long as you want,” said Alana.

They were stopped momentarily by two women at the side of the road, offering a tin for monetary donations.

“Alms, please? To help the city’s vagrants?”

“Of course,” said Alana, digging in her change purse.

“I’m sorry,” said Will. “I’ve only just returned from – I’ve only just arrived in the city, and I don’t have any money.”

“That’s alright,” said the woman who had spoken first, as the coins dropped into the tin held by her companion. “Every bit helps. We usually collect more in a day than the people who have to beg in the streets for a living do in a week, I’m sorry to say.” She stared straight ahead as she spoke, and while one arm held gently onto the arm of the woman beside her, the other leaned on a cane.

Her companion had not spoken. She was dressed all in black, and her face was shrouded by a veil, but Will could tell she was looking right at him. He glanced uncomfortably away, knowing at least the other woman couldn’t see him.

She did seem to have noticed her companion’s silence, turning to her. “Something wrong?” she asked softly.

The veiled woman shook her head. “Sorry. I thought he looked familiar…”

“We should go,” said Will. “I promise I’ll have more for you next time we see each other. Or…”

“Or you see us, I know,” said the blind woman. “Thank you, sir. Have a nice time in the city.”

Will continued down the street in the direction of his old house, unable to shake the awareness that he was being watched.

 

Will and Alana parted ways before they reached the house he used to live in. She gave him the address where she was staying and wished him luck in all his endeavors. He thanked her again and wished her the same, then made his way to the house by the lake where he’d spent many a day enjoying the company of his dogs, the natural tranquility of the woods, and later, the affection of his wife and stepson.

He found it empty, abandoned, the windows boarded up.

He stood silently staring at it for a minute before turning around and heading back to town.

 

There were a number of buildings nearby with empty space to rent out, but the closest one – which had been empty when Will left, and where Molly would likely have gone first if she had needed somewhere else to stay – was currently unoccupied. The lower floor now housed a shop offering meats, wines, and “freshly baked pies”, however, and Will’s stomach led him in. He’d barely eaten a thing all day, and the food that had been available on the ship hadn’t done much to stimulate the appetite. And prison, of course, was the last place you would expect to find freshly baked pies.

The man behind the counter was busy rolling out dough, but looked up at the sound of the softly tinkling bell above the door. He smiled as he caught sight of Will.

“I wasn’t expecting any customers today,” he said, stepping back from his work to wipe his hands on a towel. “What can I get for you?”

His accent was difficult to place – European, an immigrant, Will thought, or the son of one. His shop was well-kept, clean, with the available food prominently displayed and looking especially tempting to a hungry passerby. Yet the place was strangely devoid of other customers in the middle of the day.

Will put aside his misgivings and stepped in to peruse the available menu items. He lingered on a particularly savory-looking meat pie, and pointed to it. “I’d like to try one of those pies, if you don’t mind.”

“Excellent choice.” The proprietor lifted it out from behind the glass, set it on the counter, and paused. “Would you like a sample first? Most people prefer to taste before they buy.”

“That would be nice,” said Will, wondering if he offered this to all his customers and if so, how many of them actually paid for their food. He watched the man take a knife and cut a slice with expert precision before wrapping it in paper and handing it to Will.

Will took a bite gratefully, and tried not to wince as it went down.

He looked up. The man was watching with what looked like interest.

Will forced himself to take another bite.

“Terrible, isn’t it?” the man asked pleasantly.

Will almost choked.

“Here,” the man said, taking a bottle off one of the shelves behind him, “have a drink, it’ll help it go down easier. My wines and ales tend to sell better than my food, although still not well enough that I can buy better-quality meat. I assure you that when I have access to better ingredients, I am quite a good cook.”

“I’ll believe you,” said Will, after pouring himself a glass. “Although honestly, it doesn’t matter that much to me right now. I’ll eat anything that hasn’t been below the deck of a ship for several days.”

“You’ve just come into town, I imagine?”

Will nodded. “I’m looking for a place to stay.”

“Perhaps I could be of some assistance in that department. What is your name?”

“Will Graham.” He paused, but there was no sign of recognition in the man’s face. “You?”

“Hannibal Lecter. I came here a number of years ago. Before that I lived all over Europe. I’d trained as a surgeon, but I found the profession rather…emotionally taxing to deal with.”

“I can understand that,” said Will.

“So I transferred my passion for anatomy into the culinary arts. Unfortunately, it has been much harder making ends meet here as an independent business owner than it was at home, but I do keep trying.”

Will glanced upwards. “Have you ever considered renting out the room above you?”

Hannibal sighed. “I’ve tried. The people around here seem to be scared away by its history.”

“Do they say it’s haunted? I could live with that.”

“I can show it to you, if you would like.”

Will could see the stairs leading to the upper floor. They traveled up a short distance and faded into darkness, with nothing to be seen above the few visible steps on the ground floor but a black void.

“I’ll see it.”

Hannibal took a candle from a drawer and lit it. Will followed him up the stairs.

 

“When I first moved in,” Hannibal said, “there was a woman and her son living here. They were glad to have my company, and my protection. At that time another series of murders had just started up, this time targeting families. Even though her husband was no longer with them, she still feared for the safety of her son, and I vowed to defend them if need be. But one night…”

“What?” Will asked. He’d been pacing the room, which was largely empty except for a bed that hadn’t been slept in for years, a small chest of drawers and a desk, and a large trunk in the corner (unlocked and empty).

Hannibal continued mournfully. “I had been invited to a gathering at the Verger estate. I shouldn’t have gone – like many, I find Mason Verger to be a detestable man, and would never willingly spend more than an hour in his company. But I thought he might be interested in a deal between our respective businesses, and so I went. My tenant assured me she would be fine on her own. I left them here, and when I returned…”

“Yes?”

“The Dragon had been here. That was what they called him, after he’d been caught. I knew right away from the way the windows were broken. I followed the trail of blood up the stairs, and when I found her…” He turned away. “I could scarcely bear to look.”

“No,” said Will, softly at first. “No!”

“Did you know her?” Hannibal asked with mild curiosity.

Will closed his eyes, swallowed hard, looked Hannibal right in the eye for the first time. “What was her name?”

“Molly Graham. The boy was Walter.”

“That was my wife. And my stepson.”

“Oh, Will.” Hannibal’s voice softened, and he took a step towards him. “I’m so sorry.”

Will sat down slowly on the old bed. He stared at his hands. They shook slightly.

A few steps and Hannibal was sitting beside him. “It wasn’t your fault, Will. I know what happened. You’d been sent away through no fault of your own. Your name has been cleared now, if that is any assurance at all.”

“Jack Crawford would have called me in if I’d been here,” Will said. “I could have found him before – I could have prevented this. I would have prevented it.” He ran his hands roughly over his face, wiping away any tears that might have started to form. “What about Walter? Did her son survive?”

“Yes, he did. He went to live with someone else – her parents, I believe. He’d be grown up now, I think.”

“God,” Will whispered. He stared into the distance, thinking.

He turned back to Hannibal. “When you went to the Verger estate…was Margot Verger there? Mason’s sister?”

“Yes, she was there. She didn’t seem very happy to be, in my opinion. I didn’t get a chance to talk to her. She still lives there today, and unfortunately for all of us, so does he.”

Will rose slowly and walked to the desk. He opened the drawer and found an array of fishhooks, tied with feathers and fur and grasses. Flies. He was going to teach Walter to fish before he was sent away.

He selected one, turned to the window and held it up to the light. “She kept these. Probably has a lot more of my old fishing equipment stored away somewhere here…”

Hannibal approached behind him. “You were planning to return to your old trades, were you not? Repairing boats, fishing on the bay…”

Will nodded. He examined the point of the hook.

“If you are a good fisherman – which I have heard you are – perhaps you could help supply my store. Fresh fish would likely be more appetizing to most patrons than meat they don’t know the source of. And I would rather not buy from the Verger company.”

“I wouldn’t either,” said Will. Hannibal was watching just over his shoulder. Almost without thinking, he sank the fishhook into the pad of his thumb. A bead of blood welled up and the sting of pain brought him back to himself with a jolt.

Hannibal sharply inhaled. Will turned around to face him.

“I’ll get you a bandage,” he whispered.

“Is there a hunting knife in that drawer?” Will asked.

“Yes. A good one, too. I’ve kept it sharp, in the event I or someone else might need it. It seemed the kind of thing well worth keeping around.”

“Good,” said Will. “Thank you.”

“I’ve read about you, you know,” Hannibal said. He gently took the fishhook from Will’s hand, his thumb still bleeding. Will let him. “They wrote about you extensively in the papers following your acquittal. It seems you had quite the mind when it came to solving murders. I trust you still do.”

“I don’t think I’ve lost a bit of it,” Will said. Hannibal’s hand was still in his and he was touching his own thumb to the puncture in Will’s.

“I think you and I will be very good friends, Will. I look forward to having you stay here.”

“I’ll be moving in, then. What’s the rent?”

“For you? Not a dime. You will be back on your feet before you know it. Now, come. We must stop you from bleeding all over the floor of your new quarters.”

As he followed Hannibal downstairs, Will thought he saw the man put his thumb to his lips, as if licking a bit of flavoring off his fingertips while cooking. They descended into the darkness of the stairwell before he could be sure of what he saw.

Notes:

I don't have a regular update schedule set for this and the chapter number is subject to change, but stay tuned regardless. I have lots of ideas in store that I'm excited to write about.
if you liked this story/chapter, consider leaving a comment! everyone loves comments on here