Actions

Work Header

he served a dark and a hungry god

Summary:

After seven years in prison on false charges, Will Graham has returned to Baltimore. He moves in with a charismatic butcher/baker/pie shop owner, restarts his former business, learns about the tragedy that has befallen his family, and sets his sights on exacting revenge and justice on the man responsible for it all. Meanwhile, Margot Verger tries to escape the thumb of her cruel brother with the help of Alana Bloom, and Abigail Hobbs becomes close to a pair of potentially dangerous men, one of whom might be leading Will down a dark path.
Or: A retelling of the tale of Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street, except with Hannibal characters.

Notes:

here's a new project I've been wanting to start ever since the recent Sweeney Todd revival hit Broadway this year: a Hannibal/Sweeney Todd AU. combining one of my favorite musicals with my current favorite show seemed almost too easy, although it took a bit of thinking to decide which characters to assign which roles in the narrative. events from both canons will likely end up being mixed up and rearranged to suit the story, but I had fun creating it.
will the tale of Sweeney Todd still work if he's a fishmonger instead of a barber? let's find out.

Chapter 1: No Place Like Baltimore

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Seven years abroad in prison had done a number on Will Graham, but he was determined to return to his former home city in the hopes that if he had changed, the people and places around him had not. He knew this was a fool’s errand, as one could never expect the world outside to stay the same as time passed in a monotonous daily routine within, but he thought at least that returning to the familiar ports and harbors of Baltimore would do him some good.

He was traveling back home on a ship called the Bountiful, and although he had not expected to speak to anyone else on board for the duration of the journey, he had ended up finding a companion when he reunited with a Dr. Alana Bloom, who was coincidentally heading to the same destination as him. She had first met him while interviewing prisoners of the Australian penal colonies as part of her studies in psychology, and he believed she had been instrumental in getting him released not long afterwards.

He had told her much of his story along the way. She listened with a sympathetic ear and told him that if he ever found himself struggling with the aftereffects of his experiences when he returned home, he could always talk to her.

The facts were this: He had once been a common citizen of Baltimore, Maryland, working in the boatyards fixing others’ vessels and catching fish to sell and to eat. He was known for being hardworking and good at what he did, but solitary and reluctant to interact with anyone outside of business-related transactions. He lived alone except for a number of stray dogs he had taken in when they came sniffing around his door for scraps of food.

One day, the police, led by Inspector Jack Crawford, came to his door asking if he knew anything about a murder that had been committed near the harbor where he did most of his work. He had gone to see the body, and although he did not know who the man was, he was able to provide them some valuable suggestions about the methods and motive that led them directly to the killer. After that, Crawford began asking after him whenever there was a particularly difficult crime scene in the area, and he developed something of a working relationship with the man. He never officially worked for the police, but he was in many ways their most valuable asset when solving crimes.

His strength was his ability to step into anyone’s head, even a murderer’s. Will’s father used to say that he knew what everybody was thinking and felt everybody’s pain. It was part of why he disliked interacting with other people. The vast breadth of emotions and thoughts and history he found himself reading whenever he looked into someone else’s eyes got quickly overwhelming. It did make it easy for him to adopt the mindset of another person, to step back and imagine what someone might have been thinking when they created something he saw before him. This was helpful both for appreciating artwork and understanding murders.

He always insisted he was perfectly alright no matter how many crime scenes he took in this way, but Jack encouraged him to at least get out more and talk to more living people to counterbalance the deluge of negative thoughts with more positive ones. As he worked he got to know the community better; he became friends with Jack and a few more people on the police force, although they didn’t go out of their way to see each other often and he still knew that most of the officers looked at him with more wariness than admiration outside of the job. He met a woman, a widow named Molly Foster, who had a young son named Walter, and for whatever reason Will could fathom, they were soon married. For a time he was happy, he thought.

Until the year came that two cases converged. Will met the heir to the Verger meatpacking fortune, a pompous and unpleasant man named Mason, following the death of a worker at one of their slaughterhouses that was eventually ruled an accident. Will still didn’t quite trust that Mason Verger had nothing to do with it, and his sister Margot had sensed this and met up with Will in secret that night, confessing that she believed her brother planned to kill her.

It was risky, to be indulging in such plots against a wealthy and respected member of the community when his own position as a respected ally of the law was on the line, but he tried to help Margot as best he could. She was in favor of arranging an “accident” for him, but not before she found a way to conceive a child of her own, as that would be the only way she could retain the family fortune as per her father’s will.

At the same time, a man was stalking the city and the surrounding areas, murdering young women who all fit a similar physical description. Will, determined to solve the case and accomplish Margot’s goals at the same time, looked into Mason Verger as a suspect.

He did find the real killer, tracking down a Garrett Jacob Hobbs and confronting him in the act of attempting to cut his own daughter’s throat. She looked very much like the other victims and his motive, twisted as it was, was clear. It was the first time Will had ever killed another human being, and in the moment he felt righteous.

It didn’t last long, though. Mason Verger had evidently figured out that Will was either suspicious of him or attempting to frame him, and mounted a case against him. Clearly, Hobbs was not the killer – Graham was, and he had murdered an innocent man who had narrowly saved his daughter from having her throat slit. No one else had seen him do it, and the girl, Abigail, was still recovering and could not speak, so there was no one to counter Mason’s accusations. Thus, Will was shipped off to prison, and remained there until it was determined that he was of sound mind to return to society.

“Thank you again for helping me get out,” he said to Alana as they prepared to disembark.

“You’re welcome,” she said, “but I think it may have been that they only just received the news that you were innocent.”

Will took a deep breath as they stepped off the ship, allowing the sea air to flood his senses. Alana sighed contentedly behind him.

“It’s good to be home,” she murmured. “I expect you’re relieved to finally be back, too.”

“Not quite yet,” he said. “I fear I’ve developed too much cynicism about the world to be able to appreciate this place as I once could.” He glanced back at Alana. “But it’s been kinder to you, I hope.”

“I’ll have to see how it goes for me, now that I’m not just a woman of science but a doctor of psychology,” she said as they began making their way into the city. “I hope to improve the treatment of patients in asylums, and prevent more people from being involuntarily committed to them. What do you plan to do?”

“I suppose I’ll get back to my old job of working on fishing boats. First, I want to go to my old home and see if my wife still lives there. I wouldn’t blame her if she left.” He scanned the buildings around them for a recognizable sign or two. “And then perhaps I’ll get something to eat.”

“I’ll walk with you as long as you want,” said Alana.

They were stopped momentarily by two women at the side of the road, offering a tin for monetary donations.

“Alms, please? To help the city’s vagrants?”

“Of course,” said Alana, digging in her change purse.

“I’m sorry,” said Will. “I’ve only just returned from – I’ve only just arrived in the city, and I don’t have any money.”

“That’s alright,” said the woman who had spoken first, as the coins dropped into the tin held by her companion. “Every bit helps. We usually collect more in a day than the people who have to beg in the streets for a living do in a week, I’m sorry to say.” She stared straight ahead as she spoke, and while one arm held gently onto the arm of the woman beside her, the other leaned on a cane.

Her companion had not spoken. She was dressed all in black, and her face was shrouded by a veil, but Will could tell she was looking right at him. He glanced uncomfortably away, knowing at least the other woman couldn’t see him.

She did seem to have noticed her companion’s silence, turning to her. “Something wrong?” she asked softly.

The veiled woman shook her head. “Sorry. I thought he looked familiar…”

“We should go,” said Will. “I promise I’ll have more for you next time we see each other. Or…”

“Or you see us, I know,” said the blind woman. “Thank you, sir. Have a nice time in the city.”

Will continued down the street in the direction of his old house, unable to shake the awareness that he was being watched.

 

Will and Alana parted ways before they reached the house he used to live in. She gave him the address where she was staying and wished him luck in all his endeavors. He thanked her again and wished her the same, then made his way to the house by the lake where he’d spent many a day enjoying the company of his dogs, the natural tranquility of the woods, and later, the affection of his wife and stepson.

He found it empty, abandoned, the windows boarded up.

He stood silently staring at it for a minute before turning around and heading back to town.

 

There were a number of buildings nearby with empty space to rent out, but the closest one – which had been empty when Will left, and where Molly would likely have gone first if she had needed somewhere else to stay – was currently unoccupied. The lower floor now housed a shop offering meats, wines, and “freshly baked pies”, however, and Will’s stomach led him in. He’d barely eaten a thing all day, and the food that had been available on the ship hadn’t done much to stimulate the appetite. And prison, of course, was the last place you would expect to find freshly baked pies.

The man behind the counter was busy rolling out dough, but looked up at the sound of the softly tinkling bell above the door. He smiled as he caught sight of Will.

“I wasn’t expecting any customers today,” he said, stepping back from his work to wipe his hands on a towel. “What can I get for you?”

His accent was difficult to place – European, an immigrant, Will thought, or the son of one. His shop was well-kept, clean, with the available food prominently displayed and looking especially tempting to a hungry passerby. Yet the place was strangely devoid of other customers in the middle of the day.

Will put aside his misgivings and stepped in to peruse the available menu items. He lingered on a particularly savory-looking meat pie, and pointed to it. “I’d like to try one of those pies, if you don’t mind.”

“Excellent choice.” The proprietor lifted it out from behind the glass, set it on the counter, and paused. “Would you like a sample first? Most people prefer to taste before they buy.”

“That would be nice,” said Will, wondering if he offered this to all his customers and if so, how many of them actually paid for their food. He watched the man take a knife and cut a slice with expert precision before wrapping it in paper and handing it to Will.

Will took a bite gratefully, and tried not to wince as it went down.

He looked up. The man was watching with what looked like interest.

Will forced himself to take another bite.

“Terrible, isn’t it?” the man asked pleasantly.

Will almost choked.

“Here,” the man said, taking a bottle off one of the shelves behind him, “have a drink, it’ll help it go down easier. My wines and ales tend to sell better than my food, although still not well enough that I can buy better-quality meat. I assure you that when I have access to better ingredients, I am quite a good cook.”

“I’ll believe you,” said Will, after pouring himself a glass. “Although honestly, it doesn’t matter that much to me right now. I’ll eat anything that hasn’t been below the deck of a ship for several days.”

“You’ve just come into town, I imagine?”

Will nodded. “I’m looking for a place to stay.”

“Perhaps I could be of some assistance in that department. What is your name?”

“Will Graham.” He paused, but there was no sign of recognition in the man’s face. “You?”

“Hannibal Lecter. I came here a number of years ago. Before that I lived all over Europe. I’d trained as a surgeon, but I found the profession rather…emotionally taxing to deal with.”

“I can understand that,” said Will.

“So I transferred my passion for anatomy into the culinary arts. Unfortunately, it has been much harder making ends meet here as an independent business owner than it was at home, but I do keep trying.”

Will glanced upwards. “Have you ever considered renting out the room above you?”

Hannibal sighed. “I’ve tried. The people around here seem to be scared away by its history.”

“Do they say it’s haunted? I could live with that.”

“I can show it to you, if you would like.”

Will could see the stairs leading to the upper floor. They traveled up a short distance and faded into darkness, with nothing to be seen above the few visible steps on the ground floor but a black void.

“I’ll see it.”

Hannibal took a candle from a drawer and lit it. Will followed him up the stairs.

 

“When I first moved in,” Hannibal said, “there was a woman and her son living here. They were glad to have my company, and my protection. At that time another series of murders had just started up, this time targeting families. Even though her husband was no longer with them, she still feared for the safety of her son, and I vowed to defend them if need be. But one night…”

“What?” Will asked. He’d been pacing the room, which was largely empty except for a bed that hadn’t been slept in for years, a small chest of drawers and a desk, and a large trunk in the corner (unlocked and empty).

Hannibal continued mournfully. “I had been invited to a gathering at the Verger estate. I shouldn’t have gone – like many, I find Mason Verger to be a detestable man, and would never willingly spend more than an hour in his company. But I thought he might be interested in a deal between our respective businesses, and so I went. My tenant assured me she would be fine on her own. I left them here, and when I returned…”

“Yes?”

“The Dragon had been here. That was what they called him, after he’d been caught. I knew right away from the way the windows were broken. I followed the trail of blood up the stairs, and when I found her…” He turned away. “I could scarcely bear to look.”

“No,” said Will, softly at first. “No!”

“Did you know her?” Hannibal asked with mild curiosity.

Will closed his eyes, swallowed hard, looked Hannibal right in the eye for the first time. “What was her name?”

“Molly Graham. The boy was Walter.”

“That was my wife. And my stepson.”

“Oh, Will.” Hannibal’s voice softened, and he took a step towards him. “I’m so sorry.”

Will sat down slowly on the old bed. He stared at his hands. They shook slightly.

A few steps and Hannibal was sitting beside him. “It wasn’t your fault, Will. I know what happened. You’d been sent away through no fault of your own. Your name has been cleared now, if that is any assurance at all.”

“Jack Crawford would have called me in if I’d been here,” Will said. “I could have found him before – I could have prevented this. I would have prevented it.” He ran his hands roughly over his face, wiping away any tears that might have started to form. “What about Walter? Did her son survive?”

“Yes, he did. He went to live with someone else – her parents, I believe. He’d be grown up now, I think.”

“God,” Will whispered. He stared into the distance, thinking.

He turned back to Hannibal. “When you went to the Verger estate…was Margot Verger there? Mason’s sister?”

“Yes, she was there. She didn’t seem very happy to be, in my opinion. I didn’t get a chance to talk to her. She still lives there today, and unfortunately for all of us, so does he.”

Will rose slowly and walked to the desk. He opened the drawer and found an array of fishhooks, tied with feathers and fur and grasses. Flies. He was going to teach Walter to fish before he was sent away.

He selected one, turned to the window and held it up to the light. “She kept these. Probably has a lot more of my old fishing equipment stored away somewhere here…”

Hannibal approached behind him. “You were planning to return to your old trades, were you not? Repairing boats, fishing on the bay…”

Will nodded. He examined the point of the hook.

“If you are a good fisherman – which I have heard you are – perhaps you could help supply my store. Fresh fish would likely be more appetizing to most patrons than meat they don’t know the source of. And I would rather not buy from the Verger company.”

“I wouldn’t either,” said Will. Hannibal was watching just over his shoulder. Almost without thinking, he sank the fishhook into the pad of his thumb. A bead of blood welled up and the sting of pain brought him back to himself with a jolt.

Hannibal sharply inhaled. Will turned around to face him.

“I’ll get you a bandage,” he whispered.

“Is there a hunting knife in that drawer?” Will asked.

“Yes. A good one, too. I’ve kept it sharp, in the event I or someone else might need it. It seemed the kind of thing well worth keeping around.”

“Good,” said Will. “Thank you.”

“I’ve read about you, you know,” Hannibal said. He gently took the fishhook from Will’s hand, his thumb still bleeding. Will let him. “They wrote about you extensively in the papers following your acquittal. It seems you had quite the mind when it came to solving murders. I trust you still do.”

“I don’t think I’ve lost a bit of it,” Will said. Hannibal’s hand was still in his and he was touching his own thumb to the puncture in Will’s.

“I think you and I will be very good friends, Will. I look forward to having you stay here.”

“I’ll be moving in, then. What’s the rent?”

“For you? Not a dime. You will be back on your feet before you know it. Now, come. We must stop you from bleeding all over the floor of your new quarters.”

As he followed Hannibal downstairs, Will thought he saw the man put his thumb to his lips, as if licking a bit of flavoring off his fingertips while cooking. They descended into the darkness of the stairwell before he could be sure of what he saw.

Notes:

I don't have a regular update schedule set for this and the chapter number is subject to change, but stay tuned regardless. I have lots of ideas in store that I'm excited to write about.
if you liked this story/chapter, consider leaving a comment! everyone loves comments on here

Chapter 2: If I Cannot Fly, Let Me Sing

Notes:

I'm back with another installment in my newest work proving that if it doesn't involve cannibalism, I won't write about it. in this week's chapter: Will and Hannibal collect ingredients for future use, Will reunites with Abigail, and Margot and Alana meet cute.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Margot Verger had a few different ways of exercising her freedom while living on the family estate with only her brother for company. One was riding her horses – really, they belonged to the whole family, but she spent enough time in the stables and around the spacious grounds with them that the animals were considered hers above all else, and her brother rarely bothered her when she was with them. Another was going into town to the market.

After their father’s death, many of the Vergers’ household staff had quit, and it was awfully hard finding people who were willing to work directly for Mason, especially as more reports began to surface about various incidents on their farms that betrayed his lack of concern for fair wages, workplace safety, or both. Truthfully, his father before him wasn’t much better in those departments, but at least he was a good enough businessman to maintain an honorable reputation despite it all. He had always been concerned about his son’s lack of care for how his actions reflected on the family, but not enough to disinherit him. Margot often wondered if her father’s will was an attempt to spur her into marrying as soon as possible. She never gave him the satisfaction while he was alive.

The lack of servants around the house these days meant that Margot did most of the errands herself, which she didn’t mind, as it gave her plenty of reason not to be in the house during the day. Today she was traveling down to the marketplace with a shopping list and her allowance. (“Our family funds aren’t unlimited, Margot,” her brother would remind her whenever she bought something for herself.)

She said hello to Molly and Reba, two women she often saw walking through the streets arm in arm on their way to their respective workplaces. Molly was a seamstress who occasionally sold clothing she’d made at the dress shop, and Reba had a position helping to develop film at the still-new photography studio.

Margot was happy they were both doing well for themselves these days. She had met Molly when she and her son first moved in to the boardinghouse that had started out as one of the Verger family’s charitable projects before falling into disrepair when they decided to focus their fundings on other endeavors. Many of its inhabitants still had to resort to begging in the streets for enough money to get by. Margot had helped Molly get out of that position because she felt guilty over being partly responsible for putting her in it in the first place. Mason hadn’t objected – he did think it was good of her to use their wealth for charitable purposes, even if he rarely gave it himself. She kept donating when Molly moved in with Reba and they collected alms for those in worse states than themselves.

Mason would draw the line at giving money to beggars who lived on the streets. “There’s no point in helping people at that level until they help themselves,” he would say.

Molly and Reba were bonded together partly because they had both survived encounters with the man they called the Great Red Dragon. Most people assumed that Molly wore a veil because she was still in mourning for her husband, and while he had indeed been taken from her several years ago, it also served to hide the scars that had been left on her face from the attack she had suffered in the night a year after he was gone.

Reba, meanwhile, had met the man himself at work. He photographed families who came in for portraits, and then went to the houses of the ones he liked and killed them. Before she knew this, she knew him as a shy, kind man who took her to the zoo and let her pet a chained-up tiger. There had even been talks of him moving up north with her so they could be legally married, but that had come swiftly to an end after he was found out and tried to burn down his house with her inside. He went after Molly and her little boy not long after, and she killed him.

Margot knew all this from talking to them, and she felt she had become good friends with them both, but she still hadn’t told Molly how she knew her husband. By now her son was grown up and had moved out to be on his own, and although Molly still wore her widow’s veil, it seemed she considered the part of her life she spent with Will over and done with. Margot had a strong suspicion that she had entered into a similar partnership with Reba, and longed to ask her about it, to lean in and whisper that she felt the same way about other women, but that was far too much of a risk to take.

Now Margot stood in front of a stall filled with cages, each containing a twittering songbird.

“How do you get them to sing?” she asked. “I had a lark once, but he wouldn’t make a sound when he was in the cage.” She had finally let that bird go free, realizing he would never sing while captive, although Mason had thought they should return the bird to the man who sold it to them and possible sue him for selling a defective lark.

“They’re all blind,” the salesman said, with a shrug of his shoulders. “They don’t know anymore whether it’s night or day, so they sing all day long just to be sure. Pretty creatures, aren’t they?”

“Yes,” said Margot. She didn’t ask how they had all been blinded. She had been chided enough for her soft heart when it came to animals, ever since she had first gasped when their father stuck a knife into a pig’s back to check the depth of its fat. She couldn’t even bear to listen when they were being slaughtered. A pig’s scream sounded terribly human.

She felt sorry for the birds, too, blind and in cages, confused about the time. They would never even attempt to escape if their doors were open – they wouldn’t know they were, at first, and if they couldn’t see they’d never survive on their own. Her lark had been tethered to a post in his cage by a tiny chain, which she had removed as soon as she brought him home. He’d wanted to be free. Like her.

She thought of Reba, and how she never wanted to be pitied for her blindness, how she navigated the city perfectly well with just her cane and her memory of the way the streets were laid out, but these birds couldn’t do that out in the open air. They were safe in their cages, but completely reliant on the care of whichever person happened to be responsible for them, and Margot could keep them safe if she were that person. She could easily buy all of them but her brother would never allow it—

“Would you like to buy one?”

“Oh, no, just looking. I’m only supposed to buy what we need. Money is a bit tight for us right now, you know.” The salesman’s easy smile fell somewhat.

“I could buy one for you, if you like,” said a voice behind her.

Margot turned around to see a dark-haired woman in a blue dress, a basket over her arm. She’d evidently been watching their exchange and, Margot could tell as their eyes met, had similar thoughts about the birds.

She was rather beautiful.

“You don’t have to do that,” said Margot, smiling, “but I appreciate the offer.”

“I think you’d take good care of them,” the woman said, coming closer. “It would be nice to know that just one had a good life, wouldn’t it?”

“You’re new in town, aren’t you?” Margot asked. “I haven’t seen you here before.”

“I am. I just got here yesterday. I’m Alana Bloom.”

“Margot Verger,” she said, and almost immediately wished she hadn’t given her last name, because she could tell from the flicker of recognition in Alana’s eyes that she already knew what that meant.

“Ah,” said the salesman, “you know her brother?”

“I’ve heard of him,” Alana said.

“Well, she’s nothing like him, I’ll tell you that. Miss Verger is a kindhearted young lady, and I just know she’d give any of these birds a good home…” He looked pointedly at his wares, clearly hoping one of them would hurry up and buy something or leave.

“Alright then, I’ll give one to her,” said Alana. “Which would you like?”

“Oh, whichever one looks the loneliest…” Margot felt herself blush.

Soon she was carefully carrying a birdcage, its occupant chirping softly, with Alana walking beside her.

“Thank you very much, Miss Bloom,” she said.

“It’s Dr. Bloom, now,” said Alana. “I’ve just returned from studying psychology abroad.”

“Are you going to work at the asylum?” Near the Verger estate was a hospital that treated the mentally ill, which loomed large in her memory of the few times she’d seen it as an ominous-looking place even if it was supposed to help people. People like her mother, who had been sent there after Margot had been born and never came out. Her father hadn’t liked to talk about it.

“I plan to teach at a women’s college,” said Alana, “but I would like to visit that place sometime soon. Mental hospitals in general are in desperate need of reform, and I hope that they’re treating their patients well. If they aren’t…I can only hope they’ll listen to me as someone with expertise in the subject.”

“I hope they do, too.” And that they’ll be willing at all to listen to a woman. “And I hope to see you again soon, Dr. Bloom.”

“The same to you, Miss Verger. Enjoy your new bird. And…good luck with that brother of yours.”

Margot tried to laugh lightly. “He’s alright. I’ve dealt with him long enough to know how to handle all his foolishness.”

Alana smiled at her as they parted ways, but she seemed a little sad when she did.

 

Will had enjoyed the first full night’s sleep he’d gotten to have in many years the preceding night, albeit not one untroubled by dreams. He could only remember vague bits of imagery when he woke up, but they included water rushing in through the windows and filling the room as he slept, and shadowy deer-like creatures stalking in from the corners. He thought there might be some truth to the rumors that the upstairs was haunted.

Hannibal had been very kind to him ever since he arrived, at least. He had prepared breakfast for both of them that morning, a dish of eggs and sausage that was much better than the meat pie he’d been offered the previous day. He was glad for some proof that his host was indeed a good cook.

After they’d eaten, Hannibal invited Will to come with him to the marketplace to pick up some fresh ingredients. Will accepted, if only because he’d slept in past the ideal time for fishing and the thought of being alone in this house for several hours did not appeal to him in the present state.

Few people seemed to recognize him in town, but he was aware of how Hannibal had known his name. He considered using a false one when the time came to officially set up shop in Hannibal’s residence.

He might not have noticed the young woman hawking newspapers if she hadn’t called out to him first, startling him out of his thoughts. She was the first person aside from Hannibal to address him by name all day.

“Mr. Graham! I see you’re back.”

He turned to see who’d spoken and lit on a familiar face – dark hair, blue eyes, wearing a dress with a high collar and an extra ribbon around her throat…

“Abigail. It’s good to see you alive and well.”

“We were the first in the city to print the news you’d been acquitted,” she said, tucking the stack of papers she held under one arm. “They agreed you’d killed my father, but they had officially determined he had killed the other girls, so it was justified. And of course by that point, I’d been able to tell my side of the story.” Her fingers brushed against her neck.

Will nodded, unsure of what to say. “How are you doing now?”

“I’ve come to terms with it.”

“Ah…”

“And now that I’m working with the paper, I’ve been able to clear my own name in writing. I was never on trial, but there were all sorts of rumors going around that I’d had something to do with my father’s murders.”

“I’m sorry about that.”

She shrugged slightly. “As I said, it’s all over now. You’ll probably want to lay low for a while, though, now that your name is in headlines again.”

By now Hannibal had noticed Will had gotten sidetracked, and come back to see who he was talking to. “Ah, Miss Abigail Hobbs. I hope you’re doing well?”

“I am.” She glanced sidelong at Hannibal, and something passed between their gazes. “Thank you for your help after…everything, Dr. Lecter.”

“I may no longer be a doctor, but I try to provide whatever services one may be in need of when in difficult situations such as yours, Miss Hobbs.” He eyed the papers she was holding. “Have you taken over this journalistic enterprise from Miss Lounds?”

“No, she hasn’t,” said another woman, sidling up to Abigail with a bundle of papers of her own. “I’m still in charge and I plan to be for a long time. Good to see you back, Mr. Graham.”

Will recognized her immediately from her fiery red hair. She had been a frequent sight outside the courthouse following his accusations, scribbling notes and asking every person going in or out about the details of the case and their thoughts. “Fredericka Lounds. You weren’t much help during my trial, from what I recall.”

“I just reported the facts, Mr. Graham. And what people said. No judgment on my part, just the conclusions readers were invited to draw for themselves.” She smiled at Abigail. “Miss Hobbs has taken an interest in my line of work in the years since we’ve seen each other. She’s now my apprentice of sorts, aren’t you, Abigail?”

Abigail nodded. She’d grown quieter when her employer appeared. “I might like to be a reporter someday. Like Nellie Bly.”

“Not one like Miss Lounds, I hope,” said Hannibal.

“Don’t disparage me too much, Dr. Lecter,” Miss Lounds shot back, the smile not leaving her face. “I still buy advertisements for your business.”

“Which you run next to articles postulating that various butcher shops in the area are using the meat of stray cats. The suggestions this is meant to plant in readers’ minds are clear.”

Will glanced at Abigail, their eyes meeting after watching their companions’ exchange like a tennis match. “Perhaps we should be going soon. It was nice seeing you again, Abigail.”

“Nice to see you too, Mr. Graham.” They were soon off to advertise their papers somewhere farther down.

“She’s going to be trouble,” Will said as soon as they were out of earshot. “Lounds, I mean. And who knows what she’s been filling Abigail’s head with in the meantime? Her paper might be trash, but it’s widely read enough that she did nearly as much to turn the public’s opinion against me as Mason Verger did.”

“I can imagine,” Hannibal agreed. “Her articles on your acquittal and impending release were not without bias. But we’ll worry about such things later. Don’t overwhelm yourself right now when you still have much to recover from.” He touched a hand gently to Will’s side, reaching subtly around his back. “Shall we go home? I think you might prefer to occupy yourself with finding a new fishing boat to purchase and refurbish.”

Will sighed. “You’re probably right.” He did miss the harbor, and especially the bay.

 

There was one more stop before they left, made for them by a man who smiled at them in an unpleasant manner.

“Will Graham, is it?”

“Yes,” he said without looking. “I’ve been allowed to return.”

“Mr. Verger sends his apologies.”

“We accept them, Mr. Cordell.” Hannibal offered a thin-lipped smile in return.

“What are you up to these days, Mr. Graham?”

“The same as before,” said Will, not betraying any emotion in his responses. “Fishing. Fixing boats. I may be selling fish above Dr. – the former Dr. Lecter’s shop.”

“You won’t be working with the police anymore, I take it?”

“No,” said Will, “those days are over.”

“Inspector Crawford sends his regards, too. He regrets working you so hard, and that you couldn’t be around when the Dragon stalked the city.”

“Thank you, Mr. Cordell,” said Hannibal, a hand on Will’s shoulder. “We’ll be going now.”

“Mr. Verger is fond of seafood,” said Cordell, before they could turn away. “He has been lamenting the lack of decent fishmongers near the estate recently. Perhaps we will see one another soon. I’m sure once he knows about your new business he’ll send me over to purchase something for dinner within a week.”

“Thank you, Mr. Cordell,” said Will, and they left him behind.

“That,” said Hannibal, “was Mason Verger’s manservant and personal cook. He is one of the Verger estate’s few remaining in-house servants. He was the one who invited me to the ball the night that…the Dragon visited us.”

“I could imagine,” said Will. “Let’s hope he does visit us soon. I’ll start preparing as soon as we get back.”

“As you should. It will be good for you, getting back into your old routine, I think.”

Will nodded, thinking of the array of fishhooks that awaited him back home, and the knives ready for slitting the stomach of a fish and neatly gutting it.

He really needed to get back on the water as soon as possible, to clear his head of these bloody thoughts. He might invite Hannibal to come fishing with him, if only to keep himself grounded.

Notes:

a 19th-century Mason Verger would be even worse than in any version of canon I think. my interpretation is that the family has maintained a reputation as progressive since they never owned slaves and their father fought for the Union in the Civil War, but they're absolutely hiding some shit especially as the Industrial Revolution commences.
I can't promise that this will be a heavily-researched historical fic, since the musical has always taken place in more of an impressionistic version of the time period imo, but I'd like to scatter a few details to make it feel a little more real.
as always, if you liked this story/chapter, consider leaving a comment! everyone loves comments on here

Chapter 3: Freely Flows the Blood of Those Who Moralize

Notes:

this time around: Mason continues to be the absolute worst, Margot resolves to do something about it, and Will and Hannibal get a couple of visitors.
warnings in this chapter for discussions of sibling incest and implied past sexual abuse. it won't go much farther than that but I felt I should give a heads-up and update the tags while I'm at it. Mason Verger is a creep and so is Judge Turpin.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

A week passed and the next began.

Margot had been finding herself unusually content ever since she met Alana. She was making time to go and visit her at almost every opportunity, and Mason hardly even said anything when she announced she was leaving for a social excursion in the middle of the day. In fact, he had been bothering her far less often than usual lately, and hadn’t mentioned the necessity of her finding a marriage prospect once in the last few weeks.

Alana was very pleasant company. She told Margot all about what she’d been studying and what interested her about the workings of the human mind, and how much and how little we really knew about it. She talked about the psychologists she admired and the ones she didn’t, and her own ideas for how to best use the ever-increasing understanding of the brain to help people. She did not think much of Freud.

Margot listened, and told Alana a bit about her own family and their situation. She still held back on the more personal details. As much as she liked Alana, she did not really want Dr. Bloom to try psychoanalyzing her on one of her visits. She told her about the family business of meatpacking, and growing up around animals destined to be slaughtered, and her brother learning the workings of the meat trade from their father when he was young while her tutors trained her in etiquette and penmanship. She talked about her love of horses, and how free she’d always felt when riding, and the old blind mare she’d bonded with as a child and tried to lead to safety in the middle of the night when she learned what would happen to horses who couldn’t work anymore.

“When my father caught up to me I fell on my knees and cried and begged him to save that horse,” she said with a rueful smile. “At that point he still had enough of a heart that he let me keep her, provided I took full responsibility for caring for her the rest of her life. I was relieved, but the very next week he took me out to the stockyards and made me watch them slit the throat of a different horse just so I would see how it was done. Every time I fed my horse or led her around the grounds after that I thought about how that one might have had more time left if I’d let her go.”

Alana didn’t smile at that story. She laid a hand over top of Margot’s, took it in hers and gently caressed the back of it with her thumb.

Margot told Alana that her mother had since passed on, which might have been true, but she did not tell her about her mother being sent to an asylum after she was born. Or that she had a different mother than Mason. Their father’s first wife had died of illness a long time ago. She also didn’t mention how often her brother looked at her in ways that didn’t feel like the way a man should be looking at his sister, how he used to remind her frequently that they were only half-siblings, how as children he kept a stash of candy in his room and would sometimes invite her in and promise her she could have some if she’d just do one small thing for him.

She liked having a friend. She hadn’t had many friends in her life. Friends didn’t need to tell each other everything about their lives.

She borrowed some of Alana’s books, including one about London mental institutions and the conditions therein. It was rather disturbing to read about, and she quickly hid it under her pillow when Mason knocked on her bedroom door to tell her dinner was ready.

At the dinner table, Mason announced that he had recently discovered something very interesting about their family tree.

“Oh?” said Margot. He rarely seemed to notice or care much about what she thought was her obvious lack of interest. “What is it?”

“Our father,” he said, with a grandiose pause for effect, “was never actually married to your mother.”

Margot sat up, realizing that this did actually concern her. “Really?”

“We knew she was a serving girl who he’d become…involved with when she started working here, that much was true. But he’d promised to marry her after she’d gotten herself with child, and to save face he proclaimed that they’d already done it in secret. He waited just a little too long, though, before doing anything about it, and then you were born, and she fell into that awful melancholy, and they sent her away. He might have been hoping she’d be out soon enough and then he could make her an honest woman, but she never recovered, and…” Mason shrugged. “Legally, you’re illegitimate.”

“And that means…” Margot was already running through the facts in her head. She already didn’t stand to inherit anything on her own in their father’s will, so this wouldn’t change anything for her in that regard. But the contract had stated that in Mason Verger’s absence, the family fortune would go to a legitimate male heir, biologically descended from the Verger family. That was why she had been trying to think of a way that she could have a child, before she enacted her plan to get Mason out of the picture.

She was still her father’s daughter, no question about that. And she was Mason’s blood sister even if he would remind her that they weren’t full siblings. It might be alright, if…

“I went over everything very meticulously with the family lawyers,” said Mason. “There are all sorts of wording issues and loopholes you have to be mindful of when dealing with documents like these, you know. What we determined is that legally, you are the biological child of our father Molson Verger. But, since you were also born out of wedlock, you cannot be granted the privileges of a legitimate heir. Now that doesn’t change much for you, of course, and it might have been the reason he didn’t mention you in the will…” He paused as if he’d just thought about that. “Hmm.”

“I always thought it was because I was a woman,” said Margot. She was going to contact the executor of their father’s will first thing next morning and demand to see these papers.

“Well, there’s no way to know his exact reasoning now, of course. Anyway, this also means that any child you bear will not be considered a legitimate heir to the Verger family fortune.” He smiled at her in that faux-apologetic way he had when giving her bad news. “Sorry.”

Margot realized she’d stood up at some point while he was explaining all this. She slowly sank back down into her chair.

Trapped. Trapped forever, for the rest of my life in this house, dependent entirely on what he deigns to lend me, not even the one possible way out I used to have as an option anymore…

She had told Alana about this predicament of hers. She’d said how she thought Mason would likely die childless just to spite her if she didn’t have any children of her own to inherit. He’d have no incentive of his own to reproduce, hedonist that he was.

Then another thought began to form in her head. Perhaps, if there was no point anymore in her trying to find a way to keep her inheritance, this would be the push she needed to finally leave. Pay no more mind to the family fortune, simply walk away from it all. Break away from the Verger name, start a life of her own.

“There is one way, though,” Mason said.

Margot eyed him warily. “What?”

“With what the documents say, there’s nothing stopping me from simply marrying you.”

Margot let this hang in the air for a moment as she regarded him with nothing but pure disgust.

“You’d marry your own sister? Not even you would seriously consider that. We don’t even marry our second cousins anymore.” She tried to quell the rising wave of panic inside her, coming from the knowledge that there was no reason to think he wouldn’t.

“Ah, but legally, we aren’t siblings,” he said, a smug smile on his face she badly wanted to wipe off as forcefully as possible.

“That doesn’t matter. It’s not about the law, it’s about – oh, you’ve read about those royal families that kept marrying their siblings and what happened to their children. The diseases, the birth defects, the…” She was actually looking at him pleadingly, she realized, begging him not to go through with this, even if she didn’t outright say so.

Margot did not like to be in the position of begging her brother for anything.

Mason waved a hand dismissively. “Oh, that sort of thing only happens when it’s been going on for generations. We’d only need to do it once.”

He saw her look of horror and he was relishing it, she knew.

“Come on, Margot,” he said, softer now, entreating. “Think of it as a political match. You and I both know you won’t be marrying any men for love. Once you have your Verger baby, I’ll leave you alone and we can both have what we want. Everybody wins.”

He didn’t give her any more time to respond before sweeping out of the room, leaving her to clear the table.

Margot blinked hard, rubbed her eyes, put her head in her hands, then looked back up with her face having turned to stone.

This settled it. She was going to have to kill him.

 

“Where is Verger? Or his assistant? He said they’d be here within the week, and it’s already been—”

“Will, please be patient,” said Hannibal, busy arranging flowers in a vase on the countertop. He had suggested that they brighten the shop up with some new décor the day before, and when Will had agreed and asked if he wanted to buy any flowers, Hannibal said he had a better idea. They had spent the rest of the afternoon on a walk through nature, gathering whatever they could find that might look nice in the front room. Will suspected this was Hannibal’s way of making up for their attempt at a joint fishing excursion the previous week, which had been largely unsuccessful and terribly dull – or at least that was how Hannibal clearly found it even while insisting he did not.

Will would admit that any extended period of time spent in nature, away from the choking smog and crowded spaces of “civilization” where it was impossible to ignore the thoughts and emotions of every individual human he bumped into, was beneficial to his state of mind. Hannibal’s presence didn’t even dampen the experience, as he seemed to always understand the exact level of human interaction Will needed that day and spoke to him as much or as little as necessary. He was a better conversation partner than most anyone else Will had ever met, and surprisingly willing to get his hands dirty for such a neat and proper-looking man, whether it was by digging up a cluster of daisies or gutting a fish. Will supposed it would do to remind himself that the man was a butcher by trade.

Still, there was work to be done. Will could waste no time when there were still people in trouble, in situations they needed to get out of.

“I know,” he said now, “but I would prefer it if at least one of them would come here as soon as possible. The longer this takes, the more I begin to feel…”

Hannibal came up behind him, laid a hand on his shoulder. “Doubt? Remorse? Or simple frustration?”

Will closed his eyes and sighed. “Whatever it is, I don’t think it’s good for me.”

“I understand. But you mustn’t rush yourself. Expecting immediate results will only increase your anxiety the longer they take to arrive. All good things to those who wait, Mr. Graham.”

Will turned to face him, looking into the warm dark eyes of a man whose expressions were almost always unreadable, but had a gentle quality all the same. “You do know what I’m planning to do when one of them gets here, do you?” he asked softly.

Hannibal nodded, a simple bow of the head that betrayed no obvious emotion. “I would never begrudge you any action you chose to take with such a motive. I know all too well the value revenge can hold for one personally wronged, no matter how…bloody it may be.”

“So you understand how hard it is for me to wait,” said Will, with the hint of a smile that Hannibal returned.

“I do, but I must also remind you that it is often better to spend time planning one’s actions before carrying them out, to go into one’s vengeance with a clear head and sound mind. Acting on impulse can lead to regret.”

“I’ve had a long enough time in prison to plan my revenge,” said Will. “And besides…I’ve often felt that thinking too long about doing something lessens the chance of ever actually doing it.”

“Also true. You must strike the right balance. Your killing of the man Hobbs was impulsive, was it not?”

Will glanced away from Hannibal’s eyeline. “Don’t remind me. I’ve spent the last seven years regretting that mistake.”

“Was it a mistake? Would you do it again, if you had the chance?”

“What, kill him? I would probably want to have more evidence against him gathered before I did it. But when a man is in the process of slitting his daughter’s throat, you don’t think very much before shooting him.”

“How did you feel, as you pulled the trigger?” Hannibal’s voice was almost a whisper. He was intensely focused on Will’s face. “And as you watched him die?”

“Righteous,” said Will.

Hannibal smiled. “As you should.”

 

Neither Mason Verger or his manservant Cordell entered the shop that day, but they had another notable pair of customers at around noon.

“Afternoon, Dr. Lecter,” Freddie Lounds greeted him as she entered with Abigail in tow. “Is Mr. Graham here?”

“He’s upstairs,” said Hannibal, dusting flour off the counter. “Would you like to go and see him, or shall I call him down? We’ve been putting the finishing touches on his area of the store, and I must say it has turned out rather nicely.”

“I’ll go talk to him in private, thank you,” said Freddie. “Abigail, you stay downstairs. Maybe get an interview with Dr. Lecter, ask him about what it’s been like living and working with the infamous Will Graham.”

“Alright,” said Abigail, watching Freddie head for the stairs. Hannibal watched her too, and watched Abigail. She had a curious gaze, he thought. Wide blue eyes, very expressive.

“Would you like something to eat, Miss Hobbs?” he asked. “We still offer free samples to first-time customers. I wouldn’t recommend the meat pies just yet, though.”

“If you can’t afford good meat, maybe you shouldn’t be offering free samples so often,” she said.

He smiled. “Perhaps that is good advice. If we charge for samples before people taste them, we may save up enough to buy real beef and pork instead of having to chase down stray cats.”

Abigail smiled back, still not entirely at ease but approaching the counter with less caution. “Sorry about that. It wasn’t entirely about you, though. You’ve probably noticed there aren’t nearly as many cats as there used to be hanging around Mrs. Mooney’s pie shop down the road, for instance.”

“Of course. She’s using them all up. Now please, feel free to take a sample of whatever you’d like. Is Miss Lounds paying you enough?”

 

“You have fixed this place up nicely,” said Freddie, lifting the lid of the icebox upstairs and peering in to see the fresh fish.

Will stood in the center of the room, arms crossed. “What did you want to talk about?”

“First, I wanted to make amends for any harm I might have caused to your reputation in the paper,” she said. “I may have inadvertently negatively influenced public perception of you with some of my articles, and I am sorry.”

“You’re forgiven,” said Will.

“Good. I mean, you’re out now, aren’t you? We can put all this behind us.” She smiled ingratiatingly. “And now that you are, we can talk about your story. You’ve been officially exonerated, they know you didn’t do any of it – well, you did kill that man, but he’d killed plenty more innocent victims and you saved his daughter’s life in the process, so you’re a hero, aren’t you?”

“I don’t think you need to interview me for your newspaper,” said Will. “The public seems to know the general facts of my case by now.”

“Yes, but they don’t know your side of the story, straight from your mouth. If I have turned anyone against you in the past, I can help to turn their opinions around now. We both know there’s doubtlessly plenty of people out there who still don’t believe you’re not guilty…”

“Their opinions don’t matter to me very much,” said Will, “seeing as the law has finally ruled in my favor.”

“You’re underestimating how much of an effect public opinion can have on a person,” said Freddie. “Believe me, Mr. Graham, I’ve seen plenty of instances…”

“I’m still saying no to your offer.”

“What if Abigail were the one to interview you? I’m sure the two of you would have lots to say to each other. She’d be grateful for the opportunity to expand her journalistic skills, and I think she would be very interested to hear your perspective on the whole situation, seeing as it directly involves her. She did play a part in getting you freed, you know, even if you did kill her father.” She was advancing on him now, walking slowly towards him, not losing her easy smile.

Will found himself backing slowly away. He was up against the desk where he kept his fishing lures in the drawer, along with his hunting and fishing knives.

“You’re not obligated to speak to us, of course. But if you choose not to…” She paused, as if contemplating something she was pleased to have thought of.

“What, then?” asked Will. His fingers curled under the desk drawer.

“You might not like what we write without your input. It’ll be very widely read, I must remind you. By lots of people in this town, including some with a certain degree of influence.”

“Are you really threatening me with your cheap sensationalist newspaper?”

“I’m just telling you the facts. And providing some incentive for you to entrust me – and Abigail – with the exclusive rights to your story. You have a certain obligation to her, too, you know.” She leaned in. “And she knows things about you. More than you’d think.”

“Do you know what I keep in this desk?” Will asked.

“What?”

She barely had time to think before a knife that Will had sharpened that very morning, one that had last been used to slit the stomach of a fish, whipped across her throat.

Freddie Lounds’ eyes grew huge. She stumbled back.

Will’s expression mirrored hers. He dropped the knife and jumped to catch her before she fell. They sank to their knees together, the life leaving Freddie’s eyes as the blood left the gash in her throat. Will, his face close up to hers, could think only of exactly this happening to Abigail if he hadn’t fired the gun in time.

 

Downstairs, Hannibal and Abigail glanced up from their lunch at the sound of heavy footsteps upstairs.

“What’s going on?” she asked.

“I’ll go and check,” he said. “You finish your meal.”

She did not go back to eating, but turned around in her chair to watch him disappear into the dark of the stairwell.

 

Will was on his knees, Freddie Lounds’ body lying prone and stiff on the floor in front of him, her throat slashed wide open like the belly of a fresh-caught fish.

“Oh, Will,” said Hannibal softly, gently as always. “What have you done?”

Will turned slowly to look at him. There was blood lightly splattered across his shirtfront. His voice was strained when he spoke. “What does it look like?”

Notes:

I really do love Freddie, she's one of my favorite characters in the show, and I take no pleasure in killing her off. that said, while I admire how she's survived in canon and would never want her to die there, if anyone's going to kill her it would be Will. I think Hannibal has a strange sort of respect for her and keeps her alive for his own interest in what she'll do next. Will, though...he's more prone to impulse.
as always, if you liked this story/chapter, consider leaving a comment! everyone loves comments on here

Chapter 4: What a Sweet Child It Is

Notes:

this week's chapter is a bit shorter than the others. I keep finding myself splitting up my original plans for chapters and I'm now bumping the total count up to 8. consider this an interlude of sorts since it doesn't map directly onto any scenes from the musical. this fic is turning out to be a slower burn than originally expected.
this week: Margot hits a low point, Will and Hannibal have portentous conversations, and Abigail kind of sort of joins the family.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

As a peace offering, Margot had volunteered to prepare and serve dinner the following night, after so rudely rejecting her brother’s generous proposal. She spent the morning buying ingredients, promising something truly special to make up for their earlier disagreement.

She stopped at Eldon Stammets’ counter to inquire about which types of mushrooms were edible and which were poisonous. He was happy to expound on this subject at great length, and provided her with a helpful visual guide to the types of fungi that could be commonly found on the east coast. Some of the toxic ones, she noted, looked very similar to some of the species that were safe to eat. She pointed this out and he only nodded gravely, and wished her luck on her foraging.

She offered him some extra cash to show her what he kept under the table. She made her selection alongside a purchase of some expensive imported truffles, and went home to spend the rest of the day riding.

Cordell watched her like a hawk going in and out of the kitchen, but said nothing.

Dinner was a quiet affair, although Mason did compliment her cooking midway through. “See, Margot, I knew you’d make a good wife someday.” She forced herself to smile, but it felt more like a grimace and probably looked more like one too.

She talked up the final course, describing the rarity and high value of the truffles and how they were considered a great delicacy in France and Italy, and she thought she may have truly pulled it off when he stopped with the fork halfway to his mouth and said, “Just one minute.”

“What?” she said.

“I’ve never had these before. How do I know I won’t have some kind of reaction?” His tone was calm, even pleasant, but she knew that was when he could be at his most dangerous.

“They’re perfectly safe. Mr. Stammets said—”

“Eldon Stammets sold you these, did he?” Mason set the fork down. “You know, in the past kings and wealthy nobles would have servants hired for the sole purpose of tasting their food before they ate it, to make sure it wasn’t poisoned. It was a dangerous job, of course, but plenty of people volunteered for it because they knew the importance of preventing a potential assassination. Plus they got free food out of it.”

“I’ve already tasted it myself,” said Margot, perhaps too quickly.

“That’s good of you, but I’d never ask you to be my taster. I wouldn’t put you at risk like that.” He stood up. “In some cases, the taster was an animal.”

Margot had set up her new pet bird’s cage in the dining room. It was a good wide-open space for even a blind bird to fly in, she thought, and she left the door of the cage open when no one was eating in the room, but the bird had never dared try flying. Not that she’d seen.

“Mason, no,” she said, trying to keep her own voice calm. “How do you know birds can eat truffles? If he gets sick, or dies, even, that won’t mean anything as to whether we can eat it. Like how dogs can’t eat chocolate.”

“I’m sure birds eat mushrooms all the time,” he said. “They eat worms out of the dirt, don’t they?”

Margot was at a loss for what to do or say, short of knocking the mushroom out of his hand. “Don’t feed my bird anything without my permission.”

“Would you rather I feed it to one of your horses?” he asked, softly and dangerously.

“No,” said Margot, softly and angrily.

She watched the bird, unseeing but trusting anything offered as food, peck at the bit of mushroom.

When nothing happened, Mason said they might as well wait to eat the mushrooms anyway, and had the table cleared.

The next morning, Margot found her bird unmoving at the bottom of his cage. She took him out, stroked his tiny soft-feathered body, and allowed herself to cry. She buried him behind the stables, marking the spot with a stone, not knowing how else to commemorate the short, confused, unnatural life of an innocent little creature that never did anything but sing.

She tried the door to the kitchen and found it locked. Cordell informed her that, for security reasons, only he and Mason now held the key.

 

All things considered, Hannibal had handled the situation rather well, Will thought.

He himself had been practically catatonic after killing Miss Lounds, but Hannibal had been almost completely unfazed on seeing it. If anything, he seemed to see the incident as an inconvenience for him, but one that could be dealt with. He had swiftly sent Abigail away on her own, saying that he, Will, and her employer were having a discussion that could take a while but that she need not worry about. Then he had set about cleaning up the blood and, with Will’s help, heaving the body into the ice chest and covering it with ice and, yes, fish.

Will felt as if he were in a dream.

“Shouldn’t we bury her?” he asked after the chest was securely closed.

“Not yet,” said Hannibal. “You may want to consider putting a lock on this chest, though.”

Will’s dreams were troubled again that night, which didn’t surprise him. He found himself locked in a chest of ice, dying fish weakly twitching all around him, and woke up soaked in sweat despite how cold he’d been in the dream.

After looking around and assuring himself he was now awake and in the real world, he got another shock when he saw a figure standing in the doorway. But it was only Hannibal.

“I heard you upstairs, making noises as if you were thrashing about in the midst of a nightmare,” he said. “I wanted to see that you were alright.”

“I am,” said Will.

“I’ll be right here if you need anything,” said Hannibal. Will fell asleep easily after that, but when he awoke in the morning, realized he did not remember Hannibal ever returning downstairs. He did not know if he really felt safer knowing Hannibal was watching over him or not, or if he even should feel safe with that man in the room.

At breakfast, Will thought Hannibal might not bring up anything that had happened the previous day, but instead he asked Will how he felt about it right away.

“Nervous, mostly. Scared that I’ll get caught for it and sent right back to prison. This time for an actually justified reason.” He took a sip of the coffee Hannibal had prepared. Will had gotten used to drinking black coffee during his time working with the police, but Hannibal preferred to make his with all sorts of spices and sugars added to give it more flavor. It took some adjusting to, but Will did admit it tasted better that way.

“Understandable. I can only assure you that if you let me handle it, there will be nothing for you to worry about. But how did you feel while doing it? And directly after?”

“You mean, how did it compare to killing Hobbs?” He did have to think. It was like trying to remember a dream – in fact, he felt like it was easier to remember his dream of the previous night than the reality of the previous day. “It was – impulsive. I lashed out, out of…panic?” No, panic was what he had felt when he saw Hobbs cutting his daughter’s throat. He had not had any time to think or act rationally in that situation. “Out of fear. She was threatening me. Not with a weapon, but with – slandering me.” It sounded especially foolish when he put it like that. “I knew she could ruin things for me, when I’d finally come back home, started putting my life back together. Before I even had the chance to do what I needed to do.” He met Hannibal’s eyes. “But that doesn’t justify killing her, does it.”

“Perhaps not in the eyes of the law,” Hannibal said, “but it can be justified if your own moral code allows for it. I believe you did what seemed reasonable from your position. Especially now that you have been hardened by many years spent incarcerated, and returned already planning to kill again for the purposes of serving your own idea of justice. After you had already killed a man, for entirely justified reasons, but still you felt righteous, as you said.”

“That was a very different situation,” said Will. “And if I am going to kill Verger, that will also be different. These are people who pose an immediate threat to others. Taking them out could save lives. With Lounds I was just trying to save my own reputation.”

“You saw a strong potential threat to yourself and eliminated it in the quickest and most effective way available. And you likely saved many more reputations by doing so, which could lead to saving more lives. Didn’t you think that she was at least partly to blame for putting you in prison?”

“Are you trying to convince me that this murder was in fact justified?”

“I am trying to help you balance your thoughts on the matter. Playing the devil’s advocate, as it were.”

“I still feel guilty.” Do you? a voice whispered in his head, and he tried to push away thoughts of the benefits Freddie Lounds’ death could have. One less thing to worry about, now.

“Dwelling on guilt can be unhealthy. It’s usually best to accept whatever responsibility you bear and then move on to more productive modes of thought.”

Will ate the last bite of his breakfast sausage. “That’s true. I should get out on the water as early as possible. There are other people’s boats that need fixing, and the earlier I get to work on that, the sooner they can return to their livelihoods and keep feeding their families.”

“Good. Focus on the positive effects of your actions, not whatever negative emotions you associate with the actions themselves.”

“Mm-hmm.” Will barely heard him, but must have absorbed something, because he barely thought about Freddie Lounds’ body in the ice chest for the rest of the day. Not even when he opened the chest to place what he’d caught that day on top of the ice.

He slept well that night. Once he woke up in the middle of the night to see a shadowy figure in the doorway again, but reminded himself it was just Hannibal keeping an eye on him, and returned to sleep. He remembered no dreams – except, upon waking, briefly thought he recalled seeing the shadowy figure with deerlike antlers sprouting from its head.

The mind played strange tricks on itself at night.

 

It was Hannibal who was there to receive Abigail Hobbs the next day when she made her second visit to the shop.

He was alone at the counter, rolling out dough for the next batch of meat pies, when the soft ring of a bell above the front door announced a customer. He greeted her as one despite knowing what she was most likely really there for.

“Ah, Miss Hobbs. Come for a pie? Or perhaps another luncheon?”

“Sorry, but I’m not looking to buy anything today. Have you seen Miss Lounds recently?”

“She hasn’t come by here since she left the last time you were here.” Hannibal was good at speaking casually so as not to betray any further knowledge.

“Well, I haven’t seen her since either. She didn’t come home that day.”

“Hmm. That is strange.” Hannibal stepped back from the counter, thinking. “Did she say anything about leaving before? Is it like her, do you think, to make off without telling you for long stretches of time?”

“She’s left me alone before, but usually she tells me where she’s going first. I was going to ask you if she said anything about leaving town.”

“Now that I think about it,” said Hannibal, pretending to think about it, “she may have mentioned that she was considering moving the newspaper headquarters to a different part of town. Will and I tried to convince her there was not very much here that was newsworthy these days, and we may have succeeded.”

Abigail nodded slowly. “Where is Will, anyway?”

“Out fishing. He usually works on boats in the harbor on alternating days.” Abigail was walking around the shop, taking in the small seating areas and the meats and wines on display, then stopped at the foot of the stairs leading to the upper level.

“What’s up here?”

“Will’s part of the business, and his living arrangements. He sells fish, and he may be planning to expand his trade to fishing supplies. He makes his own lures. I used to rent the room out for a bit of extra money, but now that we are becoming a dual-income household, I do not need to charge him as a tenant.”

“Too bad it’s already occupied, then. I was thinking I might need a place to stay if Freddie – Miss Lounds is gone any longer.”

“We do have a spare room on this floor,” Hannibal said, nodding in its direction, “that we could make up as a bedroom if you need it. We would be happy to offer any help we can to those who need it. You wouldn’t need to pay.”

“I could help out here, though,” Abigail offered, “whatever you’d like. I’ll sweep the floors, arrange the tables, serve the customers…I could even learn to cook some more.”

“You don’t plan to keep working at the newspaper, now that there might be an opening in the staff?”

Abigail glanced out the window. “I’d still like to be a journalist, but…I don’t really think I’ll get very far in that field if I stay at the National Tattler. At least not in the field of serious journalism.”

“You’re glad to get out from being under her custody, I take it. No longer indebted to her for work and housing.”

“Maybe so.”

“If you’d like to learn more about cooking,” he said with a small smile, “you can start by helping me knead the dough for these pies.” She’d now wandered back over to the counter where he prepared the food, and was watching with interest as he rolled out another lump of dough. “What’s your experience with it?”

“Not much. I can feed myself well enough, but the most I did at home was when I helped my father prepare the meat after…” She trailed off. “Um – we’d go hunting together, before…you know.”

Hannibal nodded sympathetically. “Your memories of working with meat, and more broadly of spending time with your father, may now be tainted by your experiences and what you know now of his true nature. Fortunately, I believe you can still alleviate the pain associated with those memories by supplementing them with new experiences. Shall we try?”

Abigail stepped behind the counter. “I think so.”

 

Will returned with a bucket of fish to see Hannibal making pies with Abigail Hobbs.

“Hello, Will,” Hannibal said cheerfully as he stepped through the door. “Abigail will be staying with us for the time being, in the spare room down here. I’m showing her how to bake so she can help with our business. Freddie Lounds has been missing since the day we last saw her, did you know that?”

“No,” said Will.

Abigail acknowledged him only slightly, concentrating on her pie crust. “Hello, Mr. Graham.”

“You may call us by our first names, if we are to be housemates and potential business partners,” said Hannibal. “Perhaps Will could teach you to fish.”

“Some people find fishing boring,” said Will.

“I wouldn’t mind,” said Abigail, finally looking at him. “It might be good for me to spend more time with you. Dr. Lecter told me about supplementing my painful memories with more pleasant experiences. This could be just similar enough to hunting with my father to work for that.”

“Right,” said Will. Strange, he thought, that Hannibal had seemingly adopted Abigail while he was out, but he supposed that if he was responsible for killing both her father and the woman who had been her guardian after her parents’ deaths, he had a sort of responsibility to her now. “I’m more of a fisherman than a hunter, but the two methods of gathering meat have their similarities alongside their differences. One you stalk, the other you lure.”

“I saw some of the lures you made upstairs,” said Abigail. “They’re very nice.”

“Thank you.”

Will headed upstairs to put the fish in the icebox right over top of the frozen body of Abigail’s “missing” employer. As he passed Hannibal, he shot him a look that he could only hope properly communicated – we’ll talk later.

Notes:

I have a few...issues with how Margot and her storyline are written in the show and one of them is that we know she tried to kill her brother but we never get to see or hear about the details of how. fortunately we have an infinite variety of possibilities to explore in fic. poison seemed an appropriate choice for the setting.
as always, if you liked this story/chapter, consider leaving a comment! everyone loves comments on here

Chapter 5: Ladies in Their Sensitivities

Notes:

here's a longer chapter since the last one was a little shorter, and there is stuff happening in this one.
this week: two relationships finally become official, Will fails to carry out a murder, and Hannibal convinces him it's okay to kill your customers once in a while.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

“Marry you? Your own brother?”

Margot was glad that Alana, at least, was having the appropriate reaction to learning this news.

“There’s some legal loopholes that allow him to do it, but it won’t do any good to explain to him that we’re still biologically related,” she said. They were sitting on Alana’s bed, surrounded by her notes and books on psychology and medicine, as well as Alana’s own touches of plush pillows and flowered curtains that made her home that much more comfortable. Margot usually felt safer here than she ever did at home, but now she was wondering if there was anywhere she would ever be safe.

“I know the amount of control he has over you,” said Alana. “He sounds like the type of person who won’t let anything or anyone go if he feels it’s his right to have them. Is there anywhere you can go…?” She trailed off at the end, as if she knew it was a futile question; if there was anywhere Margot could go, she wouldn’t be in such despair.

“Short of fleeing the country, no. I’d have to leave so much behind, too. I’ve lived my whole life on that estate, and our father did a good job ensuring we wouldn’t easily adjust to anything different. There’s the whole farm, and my horses…”

“Oh, Margot.” Alana put her arms around her, and Margot, who did not often cry in front of other people, felt the tears welling up again.

“I’ll help you,” Alana whispered in her ear. “You can stay here for now. Hide in my room if you have to. If he comes by, I’ll say I haven’t seen you. Then, we can work on getting you away from him.”

“Are you planning to have him arrested? I’ll warn you, that would be hard to do.”

“I’ve heard. He had a friend of mine sent away almost solely through his own influences.”

Margot pulled back to look her in the face. “Do you mean…you know Will Graham?”

Alana nodded. “I met him on the ship back from Australia. He was being released. I know what you might be thinking, but – I helped get him finally acquitted of the false charges against him. I think I can be more careful than he was, now that I have the knowledge I do.”

“He helped me,” said Margot, “back then. Or at least he tried, and I appreciated it. Perhaps he can help me again.”

“I’ll talk to him,” said Alana. “But I do worry that he is nursing a personal grudge against your brother that could cloud his judgment.”

“Well, I’m nursing an even more personal grudge against him, and I don’t feel that my judgment is at all clouded.”

“True, but Will…he’s spent a long time in an environment that does one’s state of mind no favors. Many men have come out of prison more disposed towards violence and murder than they ever were when they went in.”

“I know, we talked about your study. You said people would do well to remember there are means of influence other than violence, like your colleague Chiyoh said. But she also said that violence is the only thing some men understand.” Margot sighed and laid down on her back. “I think my brother is one of those men.”

“I’m not saying anything against violence,” said Alana, and laid down beside her. Margot glanced over at her with slight surprise, but remained in her position. “I think we’ll have to see what method of solution will work best for this situation. We just can’t be too reckless and lose sight of a practical goal in the pursuit of catharsis.”

Margot smiled. “You’re very intelligent. Combine that with your kind heart and you’ll be the person the field of psychological medicine has always needed.”

Alana’s returned smile was shy, hesitant. “I don’t know if I’ll be as good as that. But I can try.”

Margot turned onto her side. “I think the only way I’d be able to get out of this marriage is if I were already married. Of course, my brother knows I’d never do that on my own or I’d have found a husband years ago. And it’s awful what happened to Will’s wife, but since he is – no longer married, perhaps he and I could…”

“If I were a man, I’d marry you as soon as possible,” said Alana.

Margot felt her heart skip a beat, as they said. “I would gladly marry you, too. If only…” She stopped, not sure if she should say it.

“If only women could marry each other? I’ve often wished that. We don’t have to be married to go away together, though. When did he say he wanted to have the marriage performed?”

Her heartbeat quickening by the second, Margot whispered, “Monday.”

“We can leave Sunday, then. Or Saturday, or tomorrow, or even tonight.”

“Alana…”

“Yes?”

“Kiss me.”

She did.

 

Hannibal was at the front counter of the shop the next day when Mason Verger entered alone.

“Mr. Verger,” he said, greeting him as soon as the bell rang. Verger, he gathered, was the kind of man who expected prompt and immediate service. “I haven’t seen you around lately. Is everything going well?”

“Oh, just fine, Dr. Lecter – do they still call you Dr. Lecter? I hear you’re no longer practicing.” He aimed a probing eye from atop the small pair of spectacles he wore. Hannibal wondered idly if the glasses were purely decorative, like the reading glasses Will only wore when he wished to put further barriers between himself and the gaze of his current company.

“Most do,” said Hannibal. “Even those who did not know me in my former profession. I don’t blame them – it’s hard to adjust, sometimes, to a new form of address, and in this case especially people fear being accidentally rude by not respecting my doctorate. And to be fair, giving up the practice didn’t mean giving up the degrees I’d earned.”

“I suppose,” said Verger. He glanced around the shop. “Interesting setup you have here. Meats, pastries, and wine, all in the same place?”

“My customers find it convenient. It helps that I already had the freedom to be somewhat eclectic with my choice of wares, since I came here with a good accumulation of resources.”

“I hear business isn’t as good as it once was, though,” Verger remarked, never losing his supercilious smile. “Meat’s lower-quality these days. Doesn’t taste very good at all, people say, which is a shame, because I hear you’re quite a good chef when you have better ingredients.”

“Yes, it is, but we work through it.” Hannibal smiled back.

“I will say, the Verger company has been offering affordable and high-quality meat for generations now, and I would always welcome a new client – oh, hello there, Miss Hobbs.” Abigail had stepped out of the back kitchen and stopped short when she saw Mason Verger.

“How are you doing?” he asked, his tone taking on a veneer of sympathy. Hannibal imagined it was similar to how he spoke to the orphans who visited Muskrat Farms for their sponsored tours and riding lessons.

“Just fine,” said Abigail, giving him a hard stare.

“You’re working here now?”

“Yes, I am,” she said. “Are you here to buy anything, or just dropping by?”

“Oh, I am here to purchase, but not on this floor. Is your business partner in, by any chance?” Verger glanced upwards.

“He is,” said Hannibal. “Are you looking to buy fresh fish, or fishing gear?”

“Fish for me today. I felt like seafood for dinner tonight, and normally I would have sent my sister out to buy it, but…we had an unfortunate incident the other night, and I’m afraid I can no longer entrust her with the privilege of shopping for dinner ingredients right now. We really do need to hire more staff once business is better. Times are hard for all of us, Dr. Lecter…”

“I’m aware,” said Hannibal.

Abigail watched Verger head upstairs. When he was out of sight, she muttered, “God, I hated him.”

“Saw enough of him during Will’s trial, I imagine,” said Hannibal.

Abigail nodded. “I didn’t see him much in person, but I read about what he said in the papers, and…I couldn’t stand how he kept talking about me when he’d never even met me, acting like he cared about me and as if he was advocating entirely on my behalf, when it was clear all he really cared about was whatever grudge he held against Mr. Graham. And you can probably imagine how frustrating it was to be the only other person who knew what happened and not even be able to speak.” She sighed heavily, leaning against the counter and looking up.

“Well, you won’t have to worry about him for much longer,” Hannibal said. “Our friend Will, if all goes right, will soon take care of that for us.”

Abigail looked back at him, surprised. “He’s…going to kill him?”

“He might. He seemed very set on it when he returned. I wouldn’t be concerned, though. I assure you this will be the most expedient way of preventing that man from causing any more harm than he already has.”

Abigail didn’t need to ask what else he’d done – she had been reporting on it alongside Freddie Lounds and her staff for the last seven years. The only real loss that would result from Mason Verger’s death would be the reliable fountain of scandals and corruption that the Tattler always managed to know about no matter how carefully the Vergers covered it up.

And it wasn’t as if Miss Lounds needed to worry about her career at the moment, either, but Abigail didn’t need to know that just yet.

“Mr. Graham said that killing someone, even if you have to do it, is—”

“The ugliest thing in the world?”

“Yes, that’s what he said. Were you listening in?”

“One cannot help but overhear things when living in close quarters. But yes, he has confessed that he doesn’t enjoy the act of killing. However, I believe he sees it as a necessary evil, in certain circumstances.”

“Freddie said he could develop a taste for it.”

“She said a lot of things, didn’t she?”

Abigail kept looking up. “I just don’t know how to feel about a man being killed right over our heads. Even if it’s a necessary evil.”

“It’s certainly a preferable situation to having innocent girls killed by a member of your household while you were unawares, no?”

Abigail looked at him sidelong. “I’m going to step outside for a bit, if that’s alright.”

“Do what you need to do.”

 

“You’ve fixed this place up nicely, Graham.”

“What do you want?” asked Will, who was in the middle of cleaning off a fishing knife.

Mason Verger held up both hands. “I know you’re probably not thrilled to see me after our last confrontation all those years ago, but I think we can try making amends at this stage. What kind of fish would you recommend for a family dinner?”

Will turned slowly to face him, keeping the knife wrapped in the handkerchief he held. “What’s the occasion?”

“Celebrating an engagement.”

Will walked casually over to the glass-fronted case displaying fresh catches. He did not look at the sealed ice chest. “Whose?”

“Mine.”

“Oh.” Will set down the handkerchief that held his knife, newly cleaned and sharpened just that morning. “Who’s the, ah…lucky woman?”

“You haven’t gotten much better at hiding when you have a clear disdain for the subject of your address, Graham…” Verger leaned against the glass, just inches away from Will. He slipped a hand into his front pocket. Will knew very well that he likely concealed a knife there, too.

“Forgive me,” Will said. “I haven’t had much chance to improve my conversational skills while in prison.”

“And we can agree that I’ve apologized. I know now I had the wrong man, of course, but I’m sure you understand that I just wanted to do right by those poor girls. As a man of the law, you’d been in situations before where you had to work with what you believed to be the case even if it didn’t turn out to be true, hadn’t you?”

“You were talking about your upcoming engagement.”

“Yes, right. You see, I recently discovered something interesting about my family history – well, I needn’t get into all the details here, but suffice it to say, I learned that Margot and I are not actually siblings. Which means that, in the eyes of the law, we can solve the problems of my bearing an heir and her need to secure a marriage in one simple move. It’s a shame we didn’t find this out earlier, could have saved a lot of trouble for us…” He bent down to study the dead, staring eyes of the fish behind glass.

Will’s hand clenched around his concealed blade. He took a step towards Verger, prepared to make a sudden move at any second, knowing the other man might be equally prepared to do the same thing.

He might be trying to lure you into a false sense of security…and he knows exactly where to stick you whether you’re a human or a pig…but you know, too.

“Tell me, Graham,” Verger said without looking up, “what kind of fish do you think Margot would like best?”

 

Alana passed the Hobbs girl in the street on her way to Dr. Lecter’s shop. The young woman seemed to be taking a walk, not going anywhere in particular but lost in thought. She nearly walked right into Alana.

“Sorry, miss,” Abigail said hastily.

“It’s alright. Were you just coming from the pie shop?” She pointed towards it.

Abigail nodded. “I’m working there now. I was taking a short break.”

“Oh, that’s nice…” Alana needed to think straight. “Will Graham lives on the top floor, doesn’t he?”

“Yes, he has his own part of the business up there. He sells fish.”

“Perfect. Thank you.” She hurried past Abigail and pushed open the door, the tinkle of a bell announcing her arrival.

“Are you Dr. Lecter?” she asked the man at the counter.

“That I am. What have you come for?”

“I’m Alana Bloom. I’m a friend of Will Graham’s. I apologize for not buying anything, but I just need to talk to him for a minute.”

“You’re Dr. Bloom?” Dr. Lecter’s eyes shone with interest. “I’ve heard about you. Will is right upstairs.” He gestured towards the stairwell, set back in the wall and heading up seemingly into pure darkness.

Alana started towards it, then stopped. “He’s not with any customers at the moment, is he?”

“No, he should be quite alone. If anyone else comes in while you’re having your conversation, I can hold them off down here for however long you need until you’re finished.”

“Thank you, sir.” Alana wasted no time in getting up the stairs.

 

There was no door at the top of the stairs, which was a design flaw Will should have drawn more attention to when he first moved in. Unfortunately, it wasn’t something he thought of very often, and at the moment he was more focused on getting the immediate task done while he had the perfect opportunity to do it.

“Will!” Alana exclaimed as she reached the landing.

Mason Verger straightened up at the sound of her voice. Will swiftly drew his knife behind his back and re-wrapped it.

“Alana,” he said. “Could you wait just a minute?”

“Miss Bloom,” said Verger. Alana had frozen in shock at the sight of him. “I know you. My sister’s always going over to your house. I’ll bet that’s where she was last night.” He turned around to face Will, smirking. “And I heard you helped get Mr. Graham here off in Australia. What was it you wanted to talk to him about?”

“Later,” she said, taking a step down.

“No, no, don’t mind me. We were just making small talk, catching up on our lives. Did you know I’m engaged to be married, Miss Bloom?”

“It’s Dr. Bloom,” said Will.

“Yes,” said Alana, “I heard.”

“Did my sister tell you? What else did she say? Because when I first proposed, she showed a certain…reluctance. That’s why I’m hoping to reconcile with her by buying her dinner tonight. I know she has a taste for the flesh of creatures from the deep.” His smile grew wider and, if possible, more sinister.

“Alana,” said Will, trying to keep his voice steady, “why don’t you leave, and we can meet up later and talk?”

“No need,” said Verger. “I’ll actually be leaving now. I’ve decided not to buy anything – in fact, I’m terribly sorry, Mr. Graham, but I don’t think I’ll be able to patronize this establishment anymore. I need to get home straightaway and have a serious talk with Margot. By the way, Miss Bloom, don’t expect to see her around much after this. I think she’s going to visit her mother very soon.” He stormed off down the stairs, shoving past Alana on the way.

Once he was gone, Alana came back up, her face pale and drawn. “I’m so sorry, Will. I came here to tell you – it seems you already know, but – Margot was going to come here, and we thought you might be able to help her hide before we…left…”

“I’m sorry, too,” said Will. “I almost had him. I should have been faster.”

“With what?”

“Nothing. I think you should go.”

Alana hesitated. “Margot’s mother is dead, isn’t she?”

“Yes, I think. But before that…she was in an insane asylum.”

“Oh, god, that’s right. She told me.” Alana clutched the railing. “I’ll go now. I really am sorry.” With that she turned and fled downstairs.

Will stared after her for a few minutes, then unwrapped the fish knife and put it away in the drawer it belonged.

 

“I had him. I was so close, it would have been the perfect time. He might not even have suspected anything. And then Alana burst in – not her fault, she couldn’t have known, but – now he knows we know, and he’s probably going to send Margot off to some asylum, exactly the kind of place Alana’s been saying we need to reform, and she’ll be even worse off and it’ll all be my fault, when you think about it—” Will collapsed on his bed and buried his face in his hands.

Hannibal, who had been watching calmly from the desk chair as Will paced frantically around the room, spoke up. “I understand your frustration, Will, but all hope is not lost.”

“It might as well be!” Will stood up again. “He’s never coming back here, and when am I ever going to get another good opportunity to get to him?” He laughed, mirthlessly but with a degree of honest reaction to absurdity. “I can’t believe I ever thought I’d be able to do anything about a man with that kind of wealth and influence. What was the point of coming back here? What’s the point of anything, really?”

Hannibal was now standing up, coming over to him. “Questioning the ‘point’ of anything can lead to dangerous places. Let’s look at what you have done.”

“Like what?”

“You found a place to live at no cost to yourself and started a business, doing something you enjoy and are good at, and which is doing fairly well for the short time it has existed. You met two people who have helped you – one who lives near you and was instrumental in your release, and who considers you a friend and would be willing to offer you whatever you need. And one who gave you a residence and space to work out of, who lives with you and who, if I am not mistaken, you enjoy the company of. Correct?”

“Correct,” said Will.

“You also reunited with a young woman whose life you saved – living proof of your ability to make a positive difference in the world – and who now also lives and works with you.”

“Yes,” said Will, becoming heated again, “and despite that, she doesn’t seem to like or trust me very much, considering I also orphaned her when I killed her father, and she associates me with a significant traumatic change in her life. And she also only works here because I killed her previous employer. I came here planning to kill one person, one terrible person who’s responsible for so much misfortune and suffering in others’ lives, and I ended up only killing someone else who has done nothing but write some mildly inflammatory news articles. And my wife is dead, Margot is going to be locked away in an awful place by her devil of a brother who’s also planning to legally marry her with all that entails…”

“Will,” said Hannibal, and suddenly was wrapping his arms around Will in an embrace, and pulling him close, resting his head on Will’s shoulder.

“Breathe,” Hannibal whispered.

Will, even while being held tight, managed to draw in a deep breath. He let it out slowly and shakily.

Hannibal held him for a moment longer. Will had the sense he should be embracing him back, but before he lifted his own arms to attempt it, Hannibal was stepping back and looking him in the eyes again.

“Do you feel better?” he asked.

“Yes,” said Will.

“Good. Now, think. How did you feel when you killed Mr. Hobbs?”

“This again?”

“Yes. Think. Remember that feeling. In the moment. Not the shock or the horror or the guilt you felt afterward, but how you felt in the action of it.”

“I felt…” Will swallowed hard. “Good.”

“And when you killed Miss Lounds?”

“I felt…similarly. But – that might have been the same action, but a different situation. The guilt set in quicker then.”

“But in addition to the guilt, did you not feel anything else?”

Will thought. “I felt…relief. That it was over. That I didn’t have to worry about her and what she might say or do anymore, concerning me.”

Hannibal nodded. “Exactly. When you talked to Mr. Hobbs, or Miss Lounds, before you killed them, did you get the sense that they were bad people? Even before you knew what they did, or could do?”

“Hobbs I only spoke to once, but I didn’t like it. He seemed shady. I could tell he was hiding something. Not just the murders, but – nervousness that he might be caught, and a touch of guilt over what he’d done. Conflict within himself, trying to rationalize it. Protectiveness over his daughter – worry for her, and worry about himself, whether how he felt about her was appropriate. Deep down he knew he wasn’t a good man, and I knew it too.”

“Good. Your empathy sees a lot. And Lounds, what was she like?”

“I didn’t like her either, the first time I talked to her, but for different reasons. She was upfront about everything. She had few morals and was mostly self-serving. She said she just wanted to tell my side of the story, but I could sense the calculation underneath, that she was hoping to get something interesting out of me and didn’t care if it made me look good or not. I knew she could very easily be a threat to me, and I was right.”

“What about Mason Verger?”

Will smiled bitterly. “You don’t need a lot of empathy to tell what he really is. Or maybe you just need to be someone he isn’t paying off.”

“So some people are easy for you to read, and some require a bit more probing. But you can always tell a person’s true nature, when you interact with them and allow yourself to connect with their emotions, their way of speaking, the inner thoughts they reveal in their face and body language. In other words, you can tell if someone deserves to die.”

“I wouldn’t go that far.”

“But you have already, twice. Three times if you count your plans for Mr. Verger. Tell me, Will, did it get easier or harder after you’d already done it once?”

“I thought it would be harder, but…” Will looked at the chest where Freddie Lounds’ body lay. “It was easier. And that was frightening, to me.”

“You could do it again, then. If someone walked into this shop, and came upstairs and was alone with you, and you looked into their eyes and saw the soul of a cruel, selfish, unrepentant person who could cause great harm to others, who has done so already…”

Will knew what he was implying. “When I was working with the police, we arrested one man who had been killing people and making their bodies into – angels, of sorts. He said that sometimes when he looked at someone he would see their head wreathed in flames, and it would always turn out that person had committed some violent crime. So he began killing people he saw like that, to rid the world of dangerous sinners. When we were alone I asked him what he saw when he looked at me.” Will looked down. “He wouldn’t tell me. He killed himself later. The autopsy showed he had a tumor in his brain.”

“You saw yourself in him. Except you don’t have a tumor in your brain.”

“Not that I know of.”

“You can see the truth of a person just from how your mind naturally operates.”

“So you’re saying I could be a better vigilante than him? I’m not sure I should. If you go by my mind’s logic, you could start finding reasons that everybody deserves to die.”

“Everybody will die, someday.”

“You’ve always been hard for me to read, Hannibal.” Will was looking directly into his eyes, something he didn’t do often when talking to anyone. Hannibal’s eyes were deep brown pools, with an almost maroon tint he noticed now. Mesmerizing eyes, the kind that were almost impossible to look away from once you got this close.

“I would think that makes me more interesting to you.”

“I think it does.” He was aware of Hannibal’s hand coming up behind him, their heads bowing towards one another, foreheads nearly touching.

“You’ll be alright, Will,” Hannibal whispered, his breath on Will’s face. The smell of him in the air, not unpleasant, smelling like the downstairs area of his shop. Meats and pastries and wine all mixing together.

A thought flickered into Will’s mind – one that had come to him before, but which he had dismissed as irrational, not to be seriously entertained. Now seemed the time to grab it and hold on to it like a circling fish and yes, it seemed much more reasonable now.

“Hannibal?”

“Yes?” He’s thinking it, too.

“Kiss me.”

He did.

Notes:

Hannibal and Will's conversations always end up going on for much longer than originally intended. these two will not stop talking in the most florid philosophical manner.
as much as I'm all for the murder husbands doing their murder thing, I don't really think Will would be going around killing people as indiscriminately as Hannibal does - at the very least he'd need a more substantial motive for his murders than Hannibal usually requires. so his version of "Epiphany" is less of a full swing into "let's just kill everyone, who cares!" madness but he will absolutely find reasons to do it.
I think one of the biggest diversions from Sweeney Todd here (aside from the nature of the character relationships) is that Will isn't hiding his true identity from anyone, which I didn't really feel was necessary, but it will affect some greater changes down the line.
also: in this AU I imagine Chiyoh is studying alongside Alana after whatever her version of finally leaving Castle Lecter was. she's interested in what makes people like Hannibal, or those he's punished for their crimes against his family, or herself after all that's happened. another example of a potentially interesting side story hiding in the background of the main one?
and as always, if you liked this story/chapter, consider leaving a comment! everyone loves comments on here

Chapter 6: We'll Serve Anyone (and To Anyone)

Notes:

sorry for the late update but I am back again, and the full chapter count has been increased once again. this is a somewhat lighter chapter (for a given value of lighter, in this story and this fandom). it's got some sweet Hannigram interactions in it! you guys like Hannigram, right?
updates may become somewhat more sporadic from here as I try and figure out the right pacing for each chapter, but I will get it finished.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

“Have you decided what to do about her yet?” Will asked, gesturing in the direction of the ice chest that still sat almost forebodingly against the wall of his workspace.

“I have an idea,” said Hannibal, “but I’m not sure how you will respond.”

“At this point, I’m willing to entertain anything you say.”

Will had been thinking over the previous day’s conversation all night, which he had spent in the same room as Hannibal for the first time. The same bed, in fact. If Abigail knew or suspected anything in the morning, she gave no indication.

“With the price of meat being what it is today,” said Hannibal, as casually as anything, “it seems a terrible shame to waste any fresh animal flesh one might come into possession of. And it would also be better to use ingredients one has procured oneself, knowing exactly where they came from and the state the animal lived and died in, rather than buying from sources with dubious reputations of quality.”

“Oh,” said Will.

“Would you consider it?”

“It’s worth a try.”

“Good. I’d hate for you to have to keep this hidden too long. I doubt anyone would discover it, but I could tell the weight of it on your conscience was causing you much stress.” He then stepped up to Will, slipped an arm around his waist to pull him closer, and kissed him on the forehead.

Will blinked in surprise, but didn’t pull away. “Thank you.”

“Go on fishing today, Will. I’ll take care of this.” Hannibal made to let him go, but Will stopped him to lean in and murmur one more thing.

“You’ve done this before, haven’t you?”

Hannibal did not answer. He often did that, Will noticed, avoiding a direct answer to a question but letting you draw your own conclusions anyway. “Tonight, you shall finally see what I can do with a good supply of meat.”

“I look forward to it.” And, Will realized, he did. He had thought when Hannibal first suggested it that it would be an unpleasant but efficient way to dispose of the body, that he would only eat it himself if absolutely necessary, but now he found himself experiencing a frisson of excitement at the prospect of trying something that the general population almost certainly had never tasted before. There were plenty of stories about sailors getting caught in shipwrecks and having to eat their dead crewmates to survive, and how they agonized over the morality of the act, but they never mentioned how it tasted. Presumably that was the furthest thing from their minds when starving and mourning their friends at the same time, but you’d think more people would be interested to know.

Whatever quandaries one might have about the morality of cannibalism, Will thought, it was well past the time to set them aside once the deed of murder had already been committed. There was no going back on that now. And since he was not starving on a deserted island, despairing of ever being rescued and surrounded by drowned corpses, he was in the ideal circumstance to actually enjoy the meal.

 

Abigail asked to come with Will when he went fishing that day, which he readily agreed to.

“Are you taking Hannibal up on his idea to replace your memories with something more positive?” he asked.

“Not everything has to be related to my past,” she said. “What if I just want to spend some more time with you doing something you like?”

“Good point,” said Will.

As they set up the boat, though, Abigail brought the same subject around again.

“Do you ever hunt?” she asked.

“No,” said Will, “unless you would classify this as hunting. I’m not opposed to it, when it’s done for sustenance and not just sport – I think I’m uncomfortable with guns.”

“You didn’t seem uncomfortable with them seven years ago.”

“That was a rare incident for me. I hated having to do it.”

“Right.” He’d told her it was the ugliest thing in the world.

“Now,” Will said as they dropped their baited hooks in the water, “we wait.”

“This gives you plenty of time to think.” Abigail shifted in her seat on the boat. She was wearing pants today, and a more practical choice of footwear for being out on the water. It was rare to see women on the bay, but when they did go fishing few would bat an eye at them dressing the same way the men did. “And to talk, if you like.”

“It certainly does.” Will leaned back and admired the calm of the bay, away from the harbor and the bigger vessels that would be out today.

“Hunting’s a bit different,” said Abigail. “You always have to be on guard. Not that you don’t have to be vigilant here, of course, but when you have a shotgun you have to be prepared to use it.”

“Did you like hunting?” Will asked.

“I did. My father and I spent a lot of time together in the woods, and…I think I learned a lot of valuable lessons then. When I was younger I was worried about the deer, if it was right for us to kill them when we had so many advantages. He assured me that we would honor every part of the animals we shot.” She trailed her hand in the water. “He said it was important to use as much of them as we could, because otherwise…it would just be murder.”

“Good advice,” Will said, then quickly added, “when it comes to animals.”

“I agreed. Even when I knew what he’d been doing, it didn’t quite sink in that he was applying all the same rules to people until I was alone in the house and I found a pillow – it was stuffed with human hair.” She said all this in a rush, then looked up. “I was there with Freddie, visiting, after the trial was over. It had been almost a year and the house just sat abandoned. No one wanted to buy it or go near it.”

“They thought it was haunted.”

“Or it just carried so many bad associations that it was impossible not to think about them in the vicinity. Anyway, it was a good thing I found that, especially for you, because it was the first piece of evidence that led to the verdict being reconsidered. Freddie couldn’t believe they hadn’t thoroughly searched the house. She was proud of being the first one to break the news.”

“I suppose I should thank you, then,” said Will. “And…Freddie, too.”

“Mm. She wasn’t always the best to work under, but she helped me out a lot in the beginning.” She met his eyes. “I’m enjoying my time here, too, though. I think it was time for me to move on.”

“Maybe so.”

A breeze picked up and sent the boat listing suddenly to the side. Abigail, startled, instinctively grabbed the side of it.

“Don’t worry,” said Will. “We can withstand much stronger winds than this. On the ship coming back from Australia, we got caught in a storm, and I can’t tell you how many of the other passengers thought we were all going to die.”

Abigail finally smiled, a small one, but a smile nonetheless. “What did you think?”

“I was huddled belowdecks with Dr. Bloom, so we couldn’t see much of what was going on, but I did think it sounded rather frightening. I thought if I did die at sea, it would be an awfully good bit of irony, but I wouldn’t mind going out on the ocean.” Which was true.

 

Dinner that night was a quiet affair; Will and Abigail ate the fish they’d caught earlier that day, while Hannibal claimed he had eaten earlier and wasn’t hungry at the usual time. Abigail cleared the table and went to bed early, saying she was tired from the long and busy day she’d had. Will bid her good night.

“I thought she might want to retire just after dinner,” Hannibal said once she’d closed her bedroom door. “All the better for us, to have our dessert of sorts in private.”

“Did you put something in her food or drink to make her tired?” Will asked.

“No, there was no need for that. I simply gave her lots to do today after she came back from her trip with you, and she took to her tasks eagerly, but had clearly worn herself out by suppertime. It’s good to see her wanting to learn so much, I think.”

“She’s surviving,” said Will. “I’m not sure yet that she’s thriving.”

“In time, she will be. We can be of great help to her. Now, would you like to taste what I’ve prepared for us tonight?”

Will sat down again, nerves abuzz with anticipation. His stomach fluttered, but not in the way it did when he was awaiting something unpleasant. The way it had all throughout his trial and most of the days he was in prison.

Hannibal’s shop was once a popular business, and he had no trouble selling meat. Will knew he could be a good cook with the right ingredients, so he must have been using better ones back then – but what was the difference? Was it fresher, or simply more expensive? Did the Verger company use to produce better meat? Did he only use specially imported stock?

Abigail knew as well as anyone that crime hadn’t slowed down while Will was away from the city. Freddie’s newspapers were full of articles about mysterious murders that were never solved but attributed to unidentified perpetrators with fanciful nicknames. The Shrike. The Tooth Fairy, or the Red Dragon before he was caught. And the Chesapeake Ripper. If the body of someone from out of the city, a traveler passing through for some reason or another, usually on business, was found mutilated in an almost artistic manner and missing one or a few key organs, it was generally assumed to be the work of the Ripper. Baltimore’s answer to London’s infamous Jack, except with a different demographic of victims. And so far, far more prolific.

What could he be doing with the organs he takes? one article had questioned. Are they mere trophies, gloating symbols of his power over life and death? Does he steal vital pieces of his victims’ bodies because he feels they don’t deserve them? Or could he be eating them?

“Oh, Hannibal,” Will murmured.

Hannibal emerged from the kitchen carrying two plates. “An extra dish for your dining pleasure tonight. Lomo saltado, a recipe from Peru. I’ve seasoned it with ginger, freshly sliced today.” He set one plate down in front of Will and sat down with his own across from him, the two just inches apart on the small round table. “Traditionally it’s made with beef, but this substitution should taste just as good as any other type of meat.”

“What kind is it?” Will asked. “Pork?”

“You might say it was from a pig.”

Freddie Lounds would never write a word about the Chesapeake Ripper again. Will took up a fork. “It’s been so long since I’ve had good meat.”

“You deserve it. Please, eat first.” Hannibal was watching him intently, a sly smile just underneath the calm set of his mouth.

Will ate.

He closed his eyes to savor it. There were notes of pork, yes, but at the same time it was like nothing he’d ever tasted before. He chewed and swallowed slowly, taking the time to understand that he was eating something special, something prepared especially for him, something few people would ever have the opportunity to try. Something shared intimately between him and just one other.

“How do you like it?” Hannibal asked.

Will opened his eyes to see the other man gazing into his with those dark eyes, endless and impenetrable like black pools in the low light, but at the same time warm and inviting and with a spark of life dancing in the middle. Or a spark of madness.

What’s the difference? Will thought somewhere in the depths of his subconscious mind.

“It’s delicious,” he said.

“Good,” said Hannibal, and smiled more broadly, genuinely happy for Will that he was sharing this experience and enjoying it. “Good.”

 

“You were the Chesapeake Ripper,” Will said after they’d finished eating. It was a statement, not a question.

“Some called me that, yes. Of course they didn’t know it was me, at least not until they died.”

“Why did you stop?”

“A variety of reasons. A few times I came dangerously close to being discovered. There were periods when supplies were harder to come by. I have had to carefully space out my harvests, and it has been more difficult in recent years to acquire the right kind of meat. A feast must present itself, and whenever feasible, I prefer to eat the rude.”

“And you think I would be a good business partner, now that you’re considering starting your enterprise back up again.”

“Yes, I think you have the right combination of attributes to be an ideal match for my method of gathering meat. But I promise you, Will, I wouldn’t have offered to let you move in and work with me if I didn’t sincerely like you as a person. Your ability to connect to the minds of others is a unique gift, a part of who you are, and you should surround yourself with people who see it and you as more than a means to an end for them.”

“Well, thank you,” said Will. He knew what Hannibal meant, about his “gift” being seen as a means to an end; he’d had enough of that during his time working with the police, and while he did think Jack Crawford cared about him as a person, he was also willing to let Will push himself to the brink just so he could feel like he was doing something useful with his abilities. Channeling the thoughts that often tormented him into something productive, something that could save lives.

Jack had come to see him just before he was sent away, to apologize for not letting Will have at least a break, which could have saved him from the position he was in. Will forgave him.

That part of his life was well over now. He could still channel his abilities into something useful in a different way.

“I do hope your business picks back up soon,” said Will. “You’ll probably have to keep offering free samples for a while, but now that your customers will be able to taste something good, word should get around quickly and then we’ll have people coming from all over.”

“Free-range rude,” Hannibal agreed. “If I get a customer with the right profile, I’ll send them right up to you. I trust your judgment.”

“Then you can’t expect me to kill someone just because they spoke to you discourteously or spilled wine on the floor,” Will reminded him. “I have different standards for who deserves to be made into a pie.”

“I’ll handle the merely rude ones, then.”

“But you’d rather I do it because I have a more discreet place to store the bodies, though, don’t you?”

“True. I haven’t used the large oven in the basement for a long while, but I feel I may find use for it again soon. Perhaps we could install a trap door that would deliver ingredients straight to the downstairs level…” He stared contemplatively at the floor.

Will stood up, looked up at the ceiling, considered the layout of the building. “I think I might be able to get a chute running straight down from my workspace to the basement, just to make the delivery even easier.” He was starting to get a bit excited, now, thinking of all the things he would want to do to make their business plan as efficient as possible. “You’d do well partnering with someone mechanically-minded who won’t question why you need such things in your shop.”

“And who won’t make the connection between recent improvements and the disappearance of a violinist whose poor skills were bringing down the whole symphony orchestra, now that we can afford to go.” Hannibal stood up too, smiling at Will with one corner of his mouth.

Will rolled his eyes to the ceiling and back again. “I’ll go to the symphony orchestra concerts with you, but I still won’t eat any violinists.”

“Not even if they’re terribly rude, in addition to playing terribly?”

“No,” said Will, “because their meat is far too stringy.”

Hannibal took a moment to get the meaning, then grinned more broadly than Will had ever seen him. “Perhaps you’d prefer flutist, then. Or piccolo player, for a lighter taste.”

Will grinned back. “That would come out piping hot.”

“I know, but you simply have to blow on it first.”

Will couldn’t help laughing, less because their jokes were so funny and more because of the sheer morbidity of the situation, and because he hadn’t laughed in a very long time. “We’re more likely to get a lot of seamen – sailors, I mean, coming up with questions about their boats. I wouldn’t take advantage of a common fisherman, but I’d be willing to take out, say, a pompous naval officer who doesn’t know a thing about his own ship because he usually delegates those tasks to the lower-ranking…” He looked sideways at Hannibal. “If the taste of the captain isn’t too salty for you.”

“Not at all, although you must accept that those who sail all over will taste of wherever they’ve been. A good thing my palate is varied, and in time yours shall be too.” Hannibal took his hand, wrapped an arm around his waist. “Oh, dear Will, the flavors we will have access to.”

“As long as they include that of a certain meatpacking business owner at some point,” Will said, more seriously. “Wouldn’t it be gratifying for him to have the chance to serve the lower classes after being served by them all his life?”

“Of course. Now watch, follow my lead…”

Before Will knew it they were moving, both of them, turning in circles while still embracing. “What’s this?” Will asked, smiling again.

“A waltz. It would be better with musical accompaniment, but I cannot play the harpsichord and dance at the same time.” One-two, one-two, Will thought as their feet fell into a steadier rhythm.

“I can hum something, then,” he said. Had he and Molly ever waltzed? He tried to remember what music had been playing the last time they danced together. “I might have to make up my own tune, though.”

“I don’t mind as long as we don’t wake up Abigail,” Hannibal whispered fondly. “Soon I’ll dust off my instrument and play you something lovely. I feel creative inspiration about to strike once more.”

Will may not have remembered what was playing when he and Molly last danced, but he remembered it ended with a kiss. It felt right to be kissing Hannibal, he thought, and it hardly mattered at all to him that both were men.

“I am so glad you are able to love and be joyous again,” Hannibal whispered against his lips, “after what you have endured.”

“It’s the human spirit,” Will whispered back. “We have infinite capacity for anguish and cruelty, and for joy and love.” Both existing in the same person, he thought, Hannibal’s fingertips meeting at the small of his back.

 

Elsewhere, in the Baltimore State Lunatic Asylum, Margot Verger stared out the small, barred window of her hospital room.

“Married on Sunday,” she murmured. “I hope you’re waiting for me, Alana.”

Elsewhere, Alana Bloom stared out her bedroom window at the moon. She had been drafting a hundred different letters in her head, and thought she may have come up with her final plan. “Wait for me, Margot,” she whispered. “I’ll come to save you even if I have to steal you away.”

Notes:

I had to work in at least some of the puns from A Little Priest. you know Hannibal would love that part even if he prefers his own cannibalism references to be more subtle. we'll check in on Margot more fully next time, as she and Alana prepare their heist plan to bust her out.
as always, if you liked this story/chapter, consider leaving a comment! everyone loves comments on here

Chapter 7: God, That's Good!

Notes:

back again! this time: Will and Hannibal's business is booming, but Margot is still trapped in the asylum. also, the murder family adopts an eel. we'll see how long it takes for the last two chapters to go up from here.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Margot had been deliberately hostile towards almost everyone she met at the asylum, which convinced them that she was indeed a dangerous patient, but she had allowed herself to be escorted to her room and brought her daily meals, so Dr. Chilton had decided she did not need to be permanently restrained. She only lashed out when someone tried to touch her, or if they came near her with a needle. Perhaps, she thought, the doctors simply didn’t consider it worth the risk, or at least the inevitable struggle, to try and strap her into a straitjacket or inject her with any kind of sedative.

She spent most of her days sitting on her bed looking out the window at what she could see of the sky through the bars. She was aware that her time being left alone for most of the day would soon be running out, and the doctors would want to try and start treating her at some point. She thought she would act amenable to psychoanalysis, if it only involved speaking to a counselor, but if she didn’t like how they were speaking to her she would refuse to say a word. Right now, they seemed to think she just needed to rest for a few days. Her room was devoid of anything that could possibly be considered stimulating to the mind. Once they thought her head had cleared, they would likely pull her out to talk about, as Chilton termed it, the overly aggressive impulses she was feeling towards her brother.

A knock at her door. “Dinner, Miss Verger.”

She turned to look without getting up. “Bring it in.”

Margot’s assigned orderly, who brought her food, escorted her down the hallway on the rare occasions she left her room, and delivered a pill or two that she never took, was a young man named Matthew Brown. According to him, he was the only one who had volunteered to go down to her room on the first day, after everyone had seen her come in kicking and baring her teeth.

She still did not fully trust anyone who worked here, but she didn’t hate Matthew. He was the only person she had met so far in this place who she would willingly talk to, and he seemed to enjoy being able to converse with her.

He stood in the doorway while she ate. He was supposed to monitor her the whole time. No pills on the tray tonight – if he’d noticed she wasn’t taking them, he didn’t say anything, and probably wouldn’t rat her out.

“When do you think they’re going to start officially treating me?” she asked. Matthew was also good for picking up information around the hospital. 

He shrugged. “Don’t know for sure yet, but Chilton has been talking about letting you out more during the day. If you can prove you won’t attack the other patients, he might let you spend time in the common room.”

Margot nodded. “And what usually goes on in there?”

“Not much. Most of them just mill around, wandering the room, but there’s a lot of open space and a much better view than you have here. The more lucid ones talk to each other. There are organized activities you can sign up for – art classes and a sewing circle.”

Matthew had a lisp she’d noticed when he first started talking to her, and which he seemed to be conscious of as well, his voice getting softer whenever he pronounced the letter S. As they talked more and she hadn’t commented, his speaking grew a little more confident.

Reba had said the Dragon, when she knew him as a man, spoke the same way. He avoided saying words with sibilant sounds in them because he was insecure about the way he sounded. He had been born with a cleft lip that had been repaired when he was a young man, with only a small scar left to show for it, but growing up with the obvious marks of difference in his face and voice had left him with deeper scars in his mind. That was why, Reba thought, the fixation on teeth.

Margot did not talk about any of this with Matthew Brown. She wondered if going to a place like this would have helped the Dragon or hurt him more. She wondered if the patients who were not lucid had started out that way when they came here. She pictured the sad, doleful faces of the women who wandered around the common room, not speaking to anyone.

“I’d like a little more freedom,” she said.

“I’m trying to put in some good words for you so you’ll be more likely to get it. Telling the doctors how well you’ve been doing, and all that. They’re glad you’ve calmed down since you got here.”

“Oh,” said Margot, “I’m calm.”

“Also—” Matthew glanced behind him as if to make sure no one was listening, then leaned in and spoke in a whisper. “Chilton has been in contact with your brother. I think he’s recommended you be treated for hysteria, but Dr. Chilton is hesitating to make any decisions before you’ve been evaluated more directly. Just to let you know.”

“Hysteria,” said Margot, keeping her voice calm. “Isn’t that an old-fashioned diagnosis?”

“There’s a lot here that’s old-fashioned. I wouldn’t put it past him.”

Margot put a hand on her stomach. Alana had told her, of course, about how it used to be accepted that when a woman was experiencing depression or neuroses that there seemed to be no obvious cause for, the problem lay in her womb. In extreme cases, the obvious course of action would be to perform an operation to remove it, although that would mean the patient would no longer be able to bear children.

“I think I’m done eating now,” she said. Matthew nodded and took the cart away, although her tray was not empty.

The first time he had brought her pills, Matthew had explained that they were supposed to help her if she was having trouble sleeping. Margot had said she wasn’t, which was true. She would be having trouble if she did sleep. She was well aware of the high possibility that if she fell asleep for longer than even one hour, she would awake in an operating room.

 

Will thought of Margot often, but Hannibal was doing a good job keeping his mind on other topics. Abigail helped in her own way.

They had held a grand re-opening of the shop, since Hannibal believed many of his former loyal customers genuinely thought it had closed down, and served fresh fish upstairs and delicious meat pies downstairs all day. With the advertising the three of them had put together, the turnout was good and reception was very positive. Hannibal offered free samples for the skeptical, and watched every taste with close interest and fond amusement. By the end of the day they’d pulled in a good profit, and Hannibal was already talking about how they could remodel the building with what they would soon make.

Will had seen fewer customers than Hannibal, who had Abigail downstairs helping him serve them all, but he didn’t mind dealing with them one-on-one, especially when they had genuine questions about the best cuts of trout or how he made his fishing lures. At one point, a man appeared at the top of the stairs with Hannibal just behind him.

“Will,” Hannibal said, “this gentleman is from out of town. He said he would like to have a look at what you have on ice.”

His eyes met Will’s behind the man’s back and Will knew what he was supposed to do.

Fortunately, a few minutes of conversation made that action easier. Will had spoken to plenty of unpleasant individuals in his life and career, and he knew a wealthy boor when he saw one.

“Your friend downstairs has an impressive wine collection,” the man said, examining the flies laid out on Will’s work desk. “You’d think he’d serve some more elevated cuisine to go along with it, instead of catering to the common rabble. It’s terribly crowded down there.”

“We’re thinking of expanding to a full restaurant,” Will said, “and adding some outdoor seating when the weather gets warmer.”

“That might be nice. Class up the place a bit. What are these, dead insects?”

“Flies, but not that kind. They’re meant to look something like insects. They’re fishing lures.”

“Right, he said you catch your own fish. I don’t know if I’d bite if I were one, though, these look like they were swept out of a dirty carpet.” He laughed to show he was just kidding Will, then crossed to the ice chest in the corner. “Now, what’s in here? I’d like it as fresh as possible.”

“I assure you it will be extremely fresh,” said Will, watching him open the chest, which was now unlocked. He slipped his knife out of the drawer and strode up behind the man.

“What is this? There’s nothing in here. Or is it under the—”

The ice was dappled with bright red droplets of blood, before the rude customer pitched forward into the chest. Will calmly wiped the knife off with a cloth he kept for that purpose, then set it aside and maneuvered the body so it lay in a more comfortably-fitting position within the ice chest. He locked it again before heading downstairs to let Hannibal know the business had been done.

So far it was working, and they had plenty of meat for another batch already.

 

Abigail still went fishing with Will, and was getting rather good at it. She was pleased whenever she caught something, and Will was always proud of her when she reeled it in. She still couldn’t quite stomach the actual killing of the fish, so Will did it himself without making her watch. He did so as quickly as possible, as he always did, but he still understood why Abigail would be uncomfortable with that part of the process.

One day, after their first successful day back in business had come and gone, Abigail felt an especially strong tug on her line.

She started reeling immediately, both of them knowing this was sure to be a big catch, but when she pulled up the fish she looked more startled than anything. It twitched and jerked and leaped out of the water, its body going on for much longer than usual.  

“What is that?” Abigail asked, sounding both fascinated and mildly disgusted.

“It’s an eel,” said Will, excited now. He had seen a few eels in the bay, and had always thrown them back if he caught one, but he had never seen one this large before. It looked like a different species entirely than those native to the area. “Let’s get a closer look.”

Together, they finished reeling it in, the eel fighting valiantly the whole way. Abigail grabbed an extra bucket and filled it with water, and Will dropped the eel in, the hook still stuck in its throat.

“Alright,” said Will, putting the fishing pole aside, “now we have to get him unhooked. Hold him still while I go in…”

Abigail peered into the bucket, the eel only just fitting inside. “I don’t know if I want to touch him. He looks ready to bite.”

“He won’t while his mouth’s open. Hold onto his body.”

Abigail rolled up her sleeves and grabbed onto the eel just behind its head. Its mouth gaped open, showing multiple rows of teeth. Will reached in carefully and found the fishhook lodged inside, the eel’s eyes darting from side to side. It looked curiously at Will.

“Got it,” he said, and withdrew his hand before the eel’s jaws could snap shut. Abigail dropped it back into the bucket, and it dove to the bottom, its long sinuous body twisting around and over itself.

Now they could look at it safely. It was indeed huge, silvery-gray and spotted with black rings along its body. Its teeth were decidedly carnivorous.

“I’ve never seen anything like that before,” said Abigail.

“Me neither,” said Will. “Whatever he is, he’s not from around here. There are a few different ways an exotic species could get into the bay. Maybe he was tossed off of a vessel that was fishing in international waters, or maybe someone bought an illegal specimen and released it into the nearest body of water before it was discovered by the authorities…”

The eel was looking up at them now, its strangely curious eyes now calmer and with a sort of innocence about them.

“What are we going to do with him?” asked Abigail.

“I don’t think we should throw him back,” said Will. “If he’s not native to this area, he’s probably going to prey on the local fish population, and if they’re not used to a predator like this being around, that could be devastating for them and us. But I don’t think we can eat him either. And besides…” The eel was still looking up with those innocent, curious eyes, waiting for its own fate to be decided.

Abigail glanced at Will and smiled. “You want to take him home?”

Will smiled back. She knew about his old habit of collecting stray dogs. “There’s a tank upstairs that used to be for holding live bait. I think it would just about fit him.”

 

The eel seemed comfortable in the tank once it was filled with water and decorated with kelp and river rocks. Hannibal stood admiring the creature as it swam back and forth, rippling like an elaborate trailing ribbon.

“She’s beautiful,” he said. “Congratulations on your catch, Abigail.”

“Thanks,” she said. “How do you know it’s a female?”

“Well,” said Hannibal, “how do you know it’s a male?”

“Good point,” she said.

“We will have to feed him something,” said Will. “I don’t want to use up too much of the fish I catch, though, and catching fish specifically for him would defeat the purpose of taking him out of the ecosystem.” He was frowning at the thought. “I should have thought of that, but…”

“I understand,” said Hannibal. “You couldn’t bear to kill such a magnificent specimen. No worries, though.” He went towards the ice chest, unlocked it, and brought out a small piece of the meat stored within. “This should tide you over, no?”

He dropped it into the tank. The eel eagerly snapped it up.

“You won’t run out of that?” Abigail asked.

“It will only be a small amount each day. A comparatively small percentage of our stock, and we can always get more.” He looked meaningfully at Will.

After Abigail had gone downstairs, Will asked Hannibal if it was really a good idea to give a large carnivorous fish a taste for human flesh.

“As long as she stays in the tank, we’ll have nothing to fear,” he replied. “Which I think is a safe bet to make. She won’t survive long outside it, would she?”

“I suppose you’re right,” said Will, although the eel’s eye looked a little less innocent now and a little more cunning as it glided past them. He made a note to remind Abigail to wear thick gloves if she wanted to add anything to the tank.

 

Over the next several weeks, the business continued to improve and expand.

They soon introduced outdoor seating arrangements, and Hannibal adorned the dining area with the most visually pleasing and fragrant flowers and other plants he could find, buying more whenever he went into town. Since they were also saving money on food supplies due to buying less meat, they frequently had enough left over from their profits to spend on the decorations and atmosphere of the establishment.

Abigail waited tables outside, putting on a pleasantly cheery demeanor when interacting with the customers; she got good at remembering multiple orders at once before ducking back inside to call them out to Hannibal and Will, who remained at the ready in case anyone requested seafood. He did his fishing early in the morning, and remained in his area of the shop during the day, able to watch the restaurant patrons from the upstairs window and see if any of them were giving Abigail trouble. Hannibal would step in to help her in the evenings, and proved to be a gracious and charming host. As word spread to the upper crust of Baltimore society that he was back in business, a few of his old friends showed up and took the time to catch up while he served them.

“This meat is delicious, Dr. Lecter,” Will overheard one lady sigh as he stepped out to dispose of some fish guts. “What is your secret?”

“Ah,” Hannibal said, “one never reveals one’s family recipes to those outside of the household.”

“Something to do with herbs?” her companion asked. “This is wonderfully spiced with coriander.”

“Perhaps partially,” he demurred, “but really, it may just come down to having a good eye for prime meat.”

Will was also always ready to receive the customers Hannibal sent up to him specially, which were becoming easier to recognize without Hannibal having to let him know. On occasion Will would come downstairs himself for a time, and make the selection on his own.

They hired carpenters to help install the sliding chute down to the basement, where Hannibal was using the huge furnace oven to cook larger cuts of meat and incinerate what was left. Will no longer had to keep the ice chest locked in the corner of his workspace; Hannibal would be alerted whenever a new body was sent downstairs so he could take care of it instantly.

Will still thought about Margot, locked away in an asylum by the one man he most wanted to come upstairs right now. Alana sometimes came by, but didn’t usually stay long. She was working on various plans to get Margot out of the asylum, it seemed.

Hannibal bought a few caged songbirds, to add their musical accompaniment to the garden. Alana recognized where they’d come from.

“I bought one of those for Margot when I first met her,” she said. “I felt sorry for them, and I thought at least one should go to a good home.”

“We felt the same,” said Hannibal. “I think they are happier here, in the fresh air, than in that crowded and smoky market. They dare not leave their cages when they can’t see to fly, but I should hope the open doors will give them the feeling of more freedom.”

“Hmm,” said Alana, contemplatively examining the open cages and their occupants staying put.

“I wanted to evoke the atmosphere of a restaurant I visited in Paris as a young man, that kept its caged ortolans outside while the customers ate. But don’t worry,” he added with a wink, “we won’t eat these.”

“Ortolans?” Wil asked.

“A songbird eaten as a delicacy, traditionally roasted and consumed whole in one bite,” Hannibal explained. “Also traditionally drowned in Armagnac, to add to the flavor. It’s a wholly singular experience, eating one. I should like to procure some just so you could have it as well.”

“I don’t know if I agree with the practice of drowning a bird in wine,” Alana said, “no matter how good it ends up tasting.”

“It’s becoming controversial, yes,” said Hannibal, “but I don’t think drowning in Armagnac is such a bad way to go, myself.”

 

Many a visitor to Will’s shop stopped in front of the fish tank to admire the eel. The tank was now well-stocked with rocks and water plants, and Will and Abigail had built a small cave out of stones for the eel to hide in. People were always delighted to see its head poke out, and then amazed to view the full length of the creature as it kept going.

Will had done some reading and decided their eel best matched to a species called Muraena kidako, commonly known as the “brutal moray” for its aggressive hunting habits. They were native to the Pacific, so it was anyone’s guess how one had ended up in the Chesapeake Bay.

“What do you think we should name her?” Hannibal asked. He always referred to the fish as a female, although Will was hesitant about determining its sex. It was hard to tell the difference in the pictures he’d looked at, and he felt an odd sense of obligation to show respect to the animal by referring to it correctly.

“I don’t know,” said Will. “I don’t think it needs one. Not like a dog, where you’d have to call it.”

“The species name made me think of the name Murasaki,” said Hannibal, “which was the name of my aunt. My uncle Robertas met her while traveling to Japan just after the country opened its borders to the rest of the world. She in turn was named for the author of The Tale of Genji, often said to be the world’s first novel.”

“I’m all for honoring women writers,” said Abigail, “but I’m not sure either she or your aunt would really want an eel named after her.”

“I’ve named dogs after family members before,” said Will. “Only as long as there wasn’t any potential for confusion – so, only if they were dead.”

“I would have plenty of relatives to choose from, in that case,” said Hannibal. “We could call her Simonetta, for my mother. Or Michelina, for my sister, though we always called her Mischa.”

Will and Abigail were both looking curiously at Hannibal, who spoke casually as he always did of people he had lost, not giving any further details.

“My mother died when I was very young,” Will offered. “I never got to know much about her, except that her name was Elizabeth.”

“Mine was Louise,” said Abigail. The three stood watching the eel swim, gracefully undulating in the water and oblivious to the humans’ remarks.

Hannibal broke the silence. “I think she deserves nothing less than four syllables in her name, don’t you?”

“Elizabeth it is, then?” Will asked.

“Eel-izabeth,” said Abigail, and they all smiled.

Later, though, Abigail would take to calling the eel Lizzie. “Freddie wrote a lot about the Lizzie Borden trial,” she explained. “Her full first name really was Lizzie, not Elizabeth. And her middle name was Andrew, after her father. I wouldn’t blame her for resenting him.” Abigail often had a dry sense of humor about the murder cases she and Freddie Lounds had covered.

“So named for her brutality, then,” said Hannibal.

“Well,” said Abigail. “Miss Borden was acquitted.”

 

Sometimes, two women would hover on the outskirts of the garden; sometimes, only one of them would be there. Will recognized them as the veiled woman and her blind companion who he had met briefly upon returning to the city. Hannibal seemed bothered by their presence, but never said anything about them to Will. If they stayed too long, he would ask Abigail to tell them politely to leave if they weren’t going to buy anything.

 

The chimney of the pie shop billowed smoke at night. Molly and Reba always hurried past it.

“God, it smells awful,” Reba whispered. “Like – like burning flesh.” She knew what that smelled like, all too well, since the Dragon had left her in a burning house with another man’s body the night before he went after Molly.

“I know,” Molly whispered back. She only knew it didn’t smell like any kind of meat she’d ever smelled cooking before, but there was no proof. Not yet. The smoke seemed terribly sinister after so many years without anything issuing from that house.

Notes:

fun facts: Muraena kidako is not a real species of eel. the "Muraena" part comes from the genus name for most moray eels and the species name is that of an existing eel which is sometimes called the "brutal moray", but on the full species name Mason is either misinformed (unsurprising) or they just made something up for the show (and possibly the book, I don't remember if that species name was stated there)
I really think this situation (selling human meat to the unwitting populace with Will and Abigail, all living together in domestic semi-bliss while he and Will kill people with impunity) would be Hannibal's dream life. a shame it's an impossible ideal.
as always, if you liked this story/chapter, consider leaving a comment! everyone loves comments on here

Chapter 8: Not While I'm Around

Notes:

I haven't died or dropped off the face of the earth since the last chapter, just haven't had as much time to write. I do now, though. the story is hurtling towards its conclusion and the finale should be full of violence and death if it goes right.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

"Have you ever visited the seaside, Will?"

They were lying in bed together, Hannibal with one hand on Will's chest, feeling his heartbeat, he imagined.

"You mean the beach? A few times, as a child. My father and I moved around for most of my childhood, never staying in one place for long. We stayed in a few seaside towns, though. It was usually too cold to swim in the ocean." He paused. Will did not often consciously remember his childhood. Usually bits of the past came to him unexpectedly, triggered by a particular sight or sound or smell that reminded him of something from the past.

"I used to visit my mother's relatives on the Mediterranean coast in the summer," said Hannibal. "It was beautiful. I still remember the first time I saw the sea. I couldn't have been more than four years old. That endless expanse of water, more than I'd ever seen in one place in my life, constantly moving and crashing as if it were alive...overwhelming, to a child. It takes tremendous courage to go in."

Will smiled. "I remember. I would stand at the edge and let the waves come up to my bare feet, but the ones farther out looked much too big and powerful to venture out into. Like they'd swallow you whole."

"Did you eventually conquer your fear?"

"When I was older..." He thought and yes, he did go all the way out, encouraged by his father who thought he should know how to swim in deep and even rough waters if he was to go out on the boat with him. "Once you got past the breakers, it was surprisingly calm. Peaceful. Even when I couldn't reach the bottom, I remember being out in the middle of the sea, water all around me, watching the waves crash on the shore. They seemed so far away. And I felt..." He closed his eyes to call the image up more clearly, hearing the waves crash in the distance, smelling the sea air. His father watching fondly, proudly, ready to put out an arm if Will started struggling but letting him float on his own for the moment. "Safe."

"I never made it out that far," Hannibal said, sounding somehow faraway. "I was still quite young when I became an orphan. I haven't had much occasion to go back to the seaside since."

"There's plenty of beaches around here," said Will. "And you've been out with me on the bay."

"Maybe someday we will go. Just to spend some time there for ourselves."

"And Abigail, too."

"Yes, and Abigail." Hannibal turned towards him. "Would you ever want to live there? By the sea? Not in the city on the bay as we do now, but truly by the sea, even on the beach if we can."

"That'd be nice," said Will, not really thinking but picturing a little house on the shore where he and Hannibal and Abigail could live peacefully, away from the noise and smoke and crowds of the city. They would be an unconventional little family, for certain, but if they lived away from most everyone else no one would question them much. He could still fix boats and sell fish in town, and Hannibal could sell meats - hopefully having moved on from the need to source them as they did now - and Abigail would find work in town too, and perhaps someday she'd move away but still come back to visit, and they'd spend evenings on the porch looking out at the ocean. They could have a dog or two. It would be just like the life he had always wanted to have for him and Molly and Walter before--

He stopped himself. There were still things he needed to do, before he could have that.

Hannibal, though, was also fantasizing. "It would be nice, wouldn't it? There would be a nice market for our wares, and we would have almost total privacy in our home. We could have friends over on weekends, and if we had a big enough house we could rent a room to overnight guests. And every once in a while, if one of them were rude..."

Will sighed as imperceptibly as he could. "Maybe someday."

Not yet.

 

Alana had finalized her plan and arrived at Lecter's shop first thing in the morning. It should be simple, but she was also aware that things often did not go as one would like, and would need backup from trusted friends.

Will greeted her at the door.

"I'm sorry if I've woken you," she said.

"You haven't," he said, although he still looked about half-dressed. "We were just about to start the day. What do you need? Or - want?"

She smiled thinly. "I have a plan to rescue Margot from the asylum her brother's got her locked up in."

"Oh." Will immediately grew serious. "Come in. Tell me all about it."

"Her brother knows me, but I've written to the hospital and he hasn't been in to see her since he had her committed," Alana explained at the table. "I'm writing under a false name, of course, but I know the director of that place enough to be sure he'll be easier to fool than Verger or his snake of a manservant." She grimaced at the thought of Mr. Cordell's smug face. "So he believes that Mr. Verger has sent a family doctor to check up on his sister, and that Dr. Alan Bloom will be the one speaking with him in the coming days about a plan for her treatment."

"I apologize for critiquing your plan now," said Will, "but you may want to come up with a false name that's farther from your own."

"Verger doesn't even know my name," said Alana. "That's how little he actually cares about the people his sister spends time with - he only knows that I'm a bad influence on her. If I showed up to the hospital disguised as a man, which isn't hard to do if you have a brother you can borrow clothes from with no questions asked, and a hat to put your hair under, Dr. Chilton would be none the wiser."

"And then you'll convince him that you need to take her out of the hospital?"

"Just for a short time. We may need to distract him first. But once we're out, we'll come here and...could you shelter us for the night?"

"Of course."

"After that, we'll be off." It sounded solid when she rehearsed it in her head, but saying it aloud forced her to think about each step again in a new light, and she had to stop herself from dwelling on all the possibilities of things going wrong. "Dr. Lecter and Abigail, they'll be willing to help us too, won't they?"

"I'm sure they will." As if on cue, Hannibal appeared at the top of the stairs, fully dressed and looking much more put together than Will, as he always did.

"Ah, Dr. Bloom. What brings you here so early?"

"I'm planning to spirit Margot out of the asylum this week," she said. "Will you help us hide here when we get out?"

"Certainly. You need not fear any secrets escaping this house." He glanced at Will, who averted his eyes, even though Hannibal usually seemed to be the one person he was able to make unbroken eye contact with. She had to tell herself to stop overanalyzing every move that others made. They were all nervous.

"You should arm yourself," said Will. "Even if your plan works out without suspicion, I just think - I'd want to be prepared. I know anyone hired by Mason Verger is likely not to hesitate to use violence."

"We want you to be safe," Hannibal agreed. "How are you planning to disguise yourself, by the way? I might suggest going under the cover of a wigmaker. I would not be surprised if Chilton's asylum still allowed people to collect human hair from their patients, and it might be one of the few ways a lady could enter on her own without arousing suspicion."

Will looked askance at him. "Really?"

"Thank you, but I'm already disguising myself as a doctor," said Alana. "A male doctor, that is. The doctor part won't be a disguise."

"Good, then," said Hannibal. "It is an interesting fact regardless."

"While I'm there, I might as well make an inspection, offer a review on how the place is treating its patients...not that he'll be likely to take whatever I offer into account after I make off with one of his patients, but hopefully my ideas will be worth considering." She took a shaking breath. "Oh, god. I might never work in the psychiatric field again if anyone discovers what I've done."

"It will be worth it," Hannibal said. "You are doing the right thing for someone you love."

She looked up at him and found that he meant it. "Thank you."

Will gave her a pistol that could be easily hidden in the folds of her brother's jacket. She prayed she wouldn't have to use it.

 

As soon as Alana left, Will went upstairs, took to his desk, and drafted a letter.

Dear Mr. Verger,

Your sister Margot, through some means devised by herself, has managed to escape the lunatic asylum you confined her in and come to my home and workplace. I agreed to shelter her for the night, but she may be planning to leave by next morning.

However, I have spoken to her and she seems repentant. I believe she would be willing to return home and be more amenable to your conditions for living there, as she says anything would be preferable to the asylum. She awaits your arrival presently.

- Will Graham

Hannibal read it over his shoulder.

"I presume I am correct in assuming Margot is not the one you intend to lure into a trap," he said.

"Correct," said Will. "This is the only way I can think of to get Mason here. Hopefully they'll be gone by the time he does come, and then we'll finally be done with all of this." He sighed deeply, leaning back and closing his eyes.

"All of what?"

"Oh - you know. The hiding, the waiting, the worrying. Once we've done away with him, we can...relax."

"I support your goals in wanting Mason Verger dead," said Hannibal, "but I feel I must remind you, Will, that revenge rarely results in the personal healing one might hope for. Don't expect anything more than a brief moment of catharsis after you kill him."

"I'm aware that killing him won't bring back my wife. What I want is for him not to be able to abuse anyone ever again."

"Good." Hannibal did not turn to leave, and Will sat looking at him expectantly.

"You're wondering if I'll lose my taste for it after him," said Will. "Killing, I mean."

"Do you think you will?"

Will considered. "I don't know if I'll have the same...passion for it."

"That would be a shame. In my opinion, Will, you've never seemed more alive than when sharpening your knife on the less honorable throats that pass through these doors."

"Would you still want to be with me if I wasn't killing with you?" Will asked softly.

Hannibal did not answer. Instead he said, "Would you still feel fulfilled if you weren't?"

Will had no answer to this either. He turned back to his work, certain Hannibal could tell he wasn't actually writing anything.

 

Hannibal was expecting the next few days to go smoothly and uneventfully. The calm before the storm, in a way; perhaps he was just hoping what could be their last days of living as they currently did would be peaceful and idyllic. He fed bits of meat from the freezer to the eel in its tank, cleaned the oven in the basement to ensure no traces of human remains were left inside, and started composing a new musical piece on the harpsichord. He was feeling unusually restless as he waited for Will to return home.

Home, indeed. He had lived in so many different places throughout his life that it was hard to think of any one of them as "home," even his childhood ancestral manor, and he had never thought to consider the pie shop any differently. Now, though, he thought of saying something to Will that he might have thought foolishly romantic in his younger years: Home is wherever you are.

It was true that having a family changed a man, he thought, as he ascended the stairs to find Abigail standing in his and Will's shared bedroom holding a small leather coin purse.

He stopped in the doorway as she looked up and locked eyes with him.

"Recognize this?" she asked.

"I believe Miss Lounds may have left it behind," he said evenly.

"Why would she?"

"She seemed in a hurry to leave."

"There's nothing in it." Abigail held the purse open, turning it towards him to show it was empty.

"Then she won't be missing it. It would be awful for her to realize she left money behind so long ago."

"It wasn't that long ago," said Abigail. "It must not have been, because I still remember what we did that day. I was holding onto this at first, collecting the payment when we sold a newspaper. It wasn't empty when we came here." She didn't break her gaze, still staring him down with the same wide blue eyes that had looked so innocent and pitiable as a young orphaned girl selling papers on the street.

Hannibal made a decision.

"Abigail," he said, "I'm terribly sorry to keep secrets from you. Especially after you have already been the victim of your father hiding things from you in your own home."

"Did you kill her?" Abigail asked the question calmly, but he could tell she was controlling her voice.

Hannibal did not lie. "I did not."

"Do you know who did?"

"You seem certain that she's dead, when there can be any number of other explanations--"

"I know she wouldn't just run off and disappear out of nowhere. I probably knew that all along, but I'm used to going along with things other people decide for me. I'm used to not questioning things in order to keep myself safe." She clutched the purse tighter. "What happened to Miss Lounds?"

Hannibal took a step into the room. Abigail took a step back.

"What do you think happened?"

"I think either you killed her or you're covering up her death for some reason. I know how people act when they're hiding something like that. My father--" She stopped.

Hannibal sensed the change in subject right away. "You suspected him, too? Or did you only realize after the fact, looking back? You did write a fair amount about how it felt to learn such things were going on behind your back."

Abigail finally looked away, down at the floor, and sat down slowly on the bed. In a small voice she said, "You didn't really think I never knew, did you?"

Hannibal moved closer, and she didn't shy away. "It's alright, Abigail. I apologize for keeping things from you, and you don't have to keep anything from me. I won't look badly on you, whatever you say."

She looked up, and he found himself searching for tears brimming in her eyes but found none he could see. "After everything came out, people thought I helped him. They accused me of befriending the girls, luring them to him, participating in their deaths even if I didn't kill them myself. I said I didn't, I wrote so much about how I didn't, but...they were right."

Hannibal only nodded. "I understand. You were frightened, and you wanted to keep yourself safe, so you did what he wanted to stay in his good favor. To keep his attentions away from you."

"Yes. I don't think anyone would sympathize with me if they knew the truth. I felt terrible lying so much, but I had to keep protecting myself. I was terrified for so long that Freddie might find out, because she'd helped me tell my story, or the version of it that didn't make me look guilty, and she could just as easily ruin me if she..."

"Miss Lounds' poison pen has irrevocably tainted many a public reputation," he agreed. "Will knows this, too."

Abigail's suspicion briefly returned to her eyes. "But now..."

"There will always be people like her, and people who will not be so understanding or forgiving of the truth. But we'll protect you, Abigail. Will and I."

"Does he know?" she asked softly.

"He will understand when I tell him, I'm sure of it." He sat down next to her then, and put a hand on her shoulder. "You have nothing to fear from us."

"My father told me I had nothing to fear from him," she said, "and I believed him for a while. Until the end. I played along to protect myself and it still didn't work."

"But Will saved you."

"He did." She looked down at the coin purse she still held. "Sometimes I think I shouldn't be alive today. Because if I wasn't, then maybe..."

"Don't think like that, Abigail," Hannibal said, sharply enough that her eyes snapped back to him suddenly. "The world is full of demons, but you aren't one of them. You were a victim, too. And now, I can promise you, nothing will harm you while you're with me. You're a survivor."

Abigail said nothing. She put the coin purse aside and allowed him to embrace her.

 

In the Baltimore State Lunatic Asylum, Margot Verger still waited.

She had spoken to Dr. Chilton a few more times, and he determined that she was well enough to be allowed into the common area, where she could partake in various activities (nothing too stimulating to the mind or body, of course) and talk to the other patients, or at least the ones who were lucid enough to talk. She was learning some interesting things about them.

She had made a few friends of sorts, chief among them being a young woman named Miriam Lass. She had been found the year before at the bottom of a well on an abandoned area of former farmland, and had insisted she had been held captive for the last two years by the Chesapeake Ripper. When asked who her captor was or if she could even describe what he looked like, she could recall nothing, not even his voice. She had essentially been remanded to the asylum until she could recover enough memories to provide any useful information at all, but so far any therapies had been unsuccessful. She was deeply resentful of the doctors for forcing her to stay when she had already proved again and again that she could not remember, and delaying her freedom ever longer after she thought she'd been rescued.

She was missing her left arm up to the elbow. The Ripper had amputated it and left it as a message for Inspector Jack Crawford last year. He had been a friend of hers.

"I used to want to join the police force myself, but if I couldn't I would content myself with doing some amateur detective work," she said. "Jack let me help him out on some of his cases. He said I was good at it even if it was unofficial. Said I saw things the men couldn't, sometimes."

"My friend Will used to consult unofficially with them, too," said Margot. "He didn't get targeted by the Ripper, but he got framed for murder by my brother. He only just got out of prison."

Miriam's eyes lit up. "Will Graham? I've heard of him. Jack didn't seem to want to talk about him that much, but it sounded like he had some impressive deduction skills, like he was the real-life Sherlock Holmes. I figured he was probably exaggerating a bit, and he just felt guilty about what happened to him. I'm glad he's out now, though, because I know he was also investigating the Ripper, and he might know something useful. If he could visit here, and I could talk to him, I might be able to remember."

Miriam did badly want to remember what had happened to her, which was why it was so frustrating for her every time another attempt failed. Not only would she finally get out of the asylum if her memories were recovered, she could be the one to solve the case. The worst part about being confined there, for her, was not being able to proceed with her investigation. If she had access to her notes and the facts she'd gathered on the Ripper case to occupy herself with, she might be chafing less at her situation. She had apparently suggested this multiple times as something that would be beneficial to her therapy, but so far no one had taken her up on it. It would be too distressing to her already fragile psyche, they thought, if she exposed herself again to the gruesome details of the murders.

"What do you talk about in therapy?" Miriam asked, once they'd both acknowledged that they were unlikely to get Will Graham to come by anytime soon.

"I wouldn't talk at all at first," said Margot, "but to seem more cooperative lately I've been discussing my life up to now. I tried to bore them with stories about boarding school and taking care of the horses, but they kept asking about my relationship with my brother. So I told them the truth, about what he used to do to me and how he treats me now. Apparently a lot of women here have been abused by male relatives and were repressing the memories of it until they brought it out of them under hypnosis or something, but if you're like me and you already remember, they think you're either making it up or it's the other way around and you're remembering something that didn't happen."

"Seems like no one's memory is reliable unless it's what Dr. Chilton miraculously made you come up with," said Miriam.

"Exactly. He told me last time that maybe Mason should come by and we'll have a session together, so he can hear my brother's side of the story. I can imagine who will somehow end up sounding more believable in that session."

"Miss Verger?"

She turned around in her chair to see Matthew waving her over from the entrance to the common room. "What is it?"

"You have a visitor."

She sighed and stood up. "Speak of the devil. Unless it's a guest doctor looking to run some experimental treatments on me. I'll see you tomorrow, Miriam."

She followed Matthew back to her room, wondering, in the dull, idle way her mind seemed to be stuck in even when she hadn't taken any pills, if she could get away with assaulting Mason if he showed up. She would probably have whatever privileges she'd "earned" by now taken away again and possibly be locked in solitary confinement for a while if she got violent, but at this point, she would prefer that to Mason trying to take her back home with him. It unnerved her that she would prefer that to anything at all, but that was what living with her brother had done to her. On the other hand, she really would like to try and write to Alana, which she would almost certainly not be able to do if she lost any privileges. She had started writing at least a dozen letters to her during the times she had access to pens and paper, but gave up on trying to write something that wouldn't be deemed suspicious by the staff.

She tried not to think about what they might do to her here if she stayed for too long. Mason wanted to keep her here for as long as possible, and she imagined he expected there would come a point when she would be begging to go home. Would that be when they started electrocuting her? Of course, she wouldn't have much of an opinion on anything if they tried some experimental brain surgery--

She shook her head to dispel these thoughts, which made Matthew glance back at her but determine that there was no cause for concern.

In her room, Matthew handed her off to Dr. Chilton himself, who escorted her inside before she could ask who was there to see her.

"Your brother's sent a psychiatrist hired by the family to evaluate you," he said. "He wants to speak with you in private to determine whether or not you're ready to go home."

"Wonderful," said Margot tonelessly. Like most people who talked to him, she had disliked Frederick Chilton on sight, but she had also figured out through multiple sessions with him that he was not anywhere as intelligent as he considered himself to be, and was therefore both easy to deal with and potentially dangerous in a different way than a man who knew what he was doing. One had to be strategic when talking to him, especially in conversations that could affect one's own life. Margot knew how to navigate those kinds of conversations well.

Anyway, if Mason really had sent a psychiatrist, she would have to figure out for herself what his angle was quickly, because saying the exact right thing would be crucial if she wanted to--

Her eyes widened immediately in recognition when she turned to see her guest.

"This is Dr. Alan Bloom," said Chilton. "Do you know him?"

"Yes," said Margot, suppressing her smile, "I do."

Notes:

there's going to be a lot happening in the last chapter at this rate, but I hope I'll be able to pull it off well. I worry about the pacing of this a little since I've often had to recalculate what will go in each chapter. I don't want to make it exactly like the musical but I want to follow the same plot beats because I thought it would work well with these characters. so far I think it has.
as always, if you liked this story/chapter, consider leaving a comment! everyone loves comments on here

Chapter 9: City on Fire

Notes:

it's done! I have successfully completed my second multichapter fic before the new year. consider this a belated Christmas/Boxing Day/winter solstice gift. this is an extra-long chapter to wrap everything up and it's where I try to actually earn my "graphic depictions of violence" and "major character death" tags, so get ready.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Molly Foster still smelled smoke.

She couldn't pretend she didn't know what the source of the black steam issuing from the chimney of Dr. Lecter's little butcher shop these days was, just as she couldn't pretend she didn't know the identity of his new tenant. She hadn't crossed paths with either of them since Will had first arrived back in town, but she knew. She only had to figure out what, if anything, she could do about it.

Some days she longed to go in and reveal herself, to reunite with her husband - they were still legally married, weren't they? - and warn him away from that man he was living with, who she hadn't trusted ever since he had left her and her son alone in his house when the Dragon was still stalking the city. She couldn't tell if he had arranged it on purpose or not, but he was the reason she had been attacked that night, why she had to throw herself in the path of a murderous madman to protect her son, why she had been left with scars disfiguring half her face from his blade.

But she had killed him. She had saved Walter's life and she had killed the man, getting in a good shot with the hunting rifle Will had left her but never used himself, then taking his knife once he had been felled and stabbing him back, over and over, until he no longer moved and lay in a spreading pool of blood behind the house. Lecter had returned to find her calmly cleaning herself up, washing the blood away from her face and hands in a trance like Lady Macbeth.

"He came for us," she told him, the wound in her cheek making it hard for her to talk. "He came, but he's dead now. Go see for yourself."

She and Walter left the very next morning. She went to the hospital to have her face stitched up and Walter went to stay with her parents, who she thought had never approved of her remarrying after her first husband's death and now felt vindicated that she had made the wrong choice. Even with their disagreements, though, she felt it best to prioritize her son's safety, and let him go up to New York to grow up in a better environment than she could currently provide. Once alone, she put on a widow's veil so people wouldn't stare at her face and went to work providing for herself. She would not rely on any strange men anymore.

Thank goodness for Reba McClane. The woman who had known the Dragon and even loved him, as a man and not a beast, reached out to Molly and ended up taking her in. "Just to get back on your feet," she said, with compassion and not pity, because she too hated to be pitied and knew how others felt. She invited Molly to live with her as a companion, not a tenant or an assistant or a pet, and Molly did her best to earn her keep while she was there. And she ended up staying even after she could have been said to have gotten back on her feet, because they liked each other and the arrangement was good for both of them. Molly saw easily what Francis Dolarhyde - the man, not the Dragon - saw in Reba, as a woman who relied on herself but was happy to have someone to share her life with. Someone who was easy to talk to because you knew she wasn't staring at you.

Molly never wore her veil at home, because the only other person at home was Reba. One day they were talking, and Molly brought up what had happened to her and why she hid her face in public now, and Reba asked if she could touch it.

"I don't care what people look like, of course," she said with a small smile, "but touch is how I navigate the world, how I understand the physical being of things. If I become close enough with someone, I'd like to know their face the same way."

Molly let her. She closed her eyes and let Reba hold her face, tracing her features with the soft touch of her thumb. She could feel the jagged ridges cut into her skin, down her cheek from under her eye, twisting the corner of her mouth, and she ran her fingers over these with careful, gentle tenderness.

"It doesn't hurt anymore," Molly whispered.

They kissed each other for the first time later that night, and it seemed perfectly natural to both of them. They'd been living together long enough, and they each filled the traditional duties of a spouse to each other, although they shared the responsibilities of both the bread-winning and the housekeeping. If Walter had been there - something Molly thought about often - Reba would have been a second mother to him. Molly had thought of herself becoming both mother and father to her son after he had lost both the men he could have called his father. Now she and Reba were both husband and wife to one another. Or perhaps they were something other than husband and wife, something new. Two women who shared a household, managed it together, held their own jobs, and loved each other. As simple as that.

They had made a good life together over the years. Walter was mostly grown up now, and he had come back to visit a few times. She had introduced Reba to him as her friend, someone she lived with, and she thought he understood when he shook her hand and said it was very nice to meet her. "Thank you so much for keeping my mother company," he'd said.

It would be almost perfect, really, if it wasn't for her actual husband returning and that awful smell in the air returning with him. She felt she had to go and talk to him just once, but the people he lived with had made it clear they didn't want her around, for whatever reason. Whether they thought she was a mad vagrant or some kind of solicitor or otherwise someone intruding on their own perfectly happy life, she didn't know, but she did not like Dr. Lecter any more than she had when she had last lived with him, and she still cared enough about Will and that poor orphan girl Abigail to want them away from him.

She could only hope they didn't know what she knew.

 

Alana had managed to get herself, Margot, and Dr. Chilton out of Margot's room, but she was having more trouble convincing the doctor to let her and Margot leave the hospital.

"I'm sorry, Dr. Bloom, but I don't think Miss Verger is anywhere close to ready to leave yet," Chilton said with his usual thoroughly self-assured air. "I have been monitoring her closely since she was admitted, and although her violent outbursts have decreased, her delusions and paranoia about people close to her remain persistent."

"I think," said Alana patiently, keeping her voice low and even, "that it would be best for her to go home for just a short visit, to see her brother and prove to her that he means her no harm. She is ready to accept that by now, aren't you, Margot?"

Margot nodded. "Yes. I do want to go home. I think talking to my brother again would help me, um, reorient myself with regards to my position in the family."

"That isn't what you told me yesterday," Chilton said. "As I'm sure Dr. Bloom is aware, patients often feign recovery so they will be allowed more privileges or a stronger chance of release. It is unfortunate to be fooled into thinking a patient is making progress only for him or her to relapse just days after checking out, but when you have worked in the psychiatric field for as long as I have, you will learn to tell the true signs of healing from the false."

"I understand," said Alana, "but--"

"You also learn to tell true doctors from frauds," said Chilton, suddenly more serious, his voice going soft and insinuating. "Have you really been hired by the Verger family, Dr. Bloom? And if you have, how can I be sure Mason isn't trying to pull one over on me and get a potentially dangerous patient released back into the world for his own ends? I'm very protective of my charges, as Miss Verger knows well..."

"You have no idea what's actually going on," said Alana. She reached into the pocket of her coat and pulled out a small gun.

Margot could only stare in shock. So much for Alana's carefully crafted plan, then.

"Let us leave," said Alana, now using her real voice. "I promise I won't hurt anyone. I don't want to have to use this. I care about Margot, too, and I want to protect her. And as a doctor, I can tell you that the best thing for all of us would be for you to allow me and her to leave the hospital, peacefully."

"Who sent you?" Chilton was angry now, but he was also frightened, Margot could tell.

"No one but myself. Please let us go and there won't be any need for a fight." Alana was advancing on him, slowly, the gun pointed at his chest. Chilton backed away down the hall. He stumbled when they reached the threshold of the common room.

"Oh, no. Please, let's not do this in front of my patients..." Everyone inside was now staring at the scene - Dr. Chilton with a gun on him, wielded by a woman in menswear. Miriam was there, and she met Margot's eye.

"Miss Lass." Chilton tried to smile at her. "How are you doing? I heard you are making some progress towards recovering your memories."

"I am," she said warily.

"Could you get Mr. Brown, please? And quickly. Really, there's no need for violence, anyone, I just want to resolve this--Miss Lass?"

Miriam had stood up, and was fixing Chilton with a calculated glare. Suddenly she pointed at him and shouted, "It's him! He's the Ripper! I remember now and seeing you made it all fall into place, it was Dr. Chilton, he kidnapped me and then brought me here so no one would believe me!" Her voice rose and grew more hysterical as Chilton frantically looked back and forth from her to the gun Alana held trained on him, seeing that not even she or Margot seemed to understand what was happening.

"Really, Miriam?" Margot asked quietly.

She looked at Margot, nodded once, then strode forward and grabbed the gun from Alana's hand.

"No!" Alana cried, but it went off before she could stop it, and Chilton went down.

Miriam stood, breathing heavily, her remaining hand locked around Alana's fingers on the trigger. "I'm sorry," she said. "But I've wanted to do that for years."

Chilton had not been shot in the chest; Miriam had knocked Alana's aim upward and hit him in the face just under his eye. He lay on the floor clutching his wound, blood flowing from between his fingers and gazing in abject horror.

"He'll live," said Miriam. "You two - go. Run. We need to take advantage of the time we have with him in this state." She released her hold on Alana's hand. "I won't need the gun."

Matthew Brown had finally showed up behind them in the hallway. He seemed surprised, but more amused than horrified. "What happened here?"

"Taking care of a few problems at once," said Margot. "He might need urgent medical attention."

"While you get that," Miriam said to Matthew, "could I have your keys?"

He held out his keyring. "Who else are you setting free?"

"Whoever doesn't want to be here."

"Isn't that everyone?" He handed them over, and Margot and Alana ran.

 

As they burst through the doors of the asylum, Margot began to laugh.

"What is it?" Alana asked, seeming genuinely concerned.

"Oh - I'm just glad we made it out," she said.

"I don't know how I feel about leaving all those other patients to fend for themselves..."

"They'll be alright," said Margot. "Anyone who was there wrongly, like me, can escape now. If they do need help, there are people there who I know will take care of them. Or, once we get out of this, you could."

"That would be a long way off," said Alana. "If anyone ever finds out I threatened the head of this institution with a loaded weapon, and was partly responsible for him getting shot, I'll never have a chance at doing anything like that."

"You didn't shoot him, though," Margot said reassuringly. "Miriam did. And there is at least one staff member who knows what happened. And soon we won't have to worry about Mason paying anyone off to speak against us."

Alana did not seem that reassured, but they had to keep moving. As they headed for Dr. Lecter's shop, Margot thought about the other patients she'd spoken to; Miriam, of course. Georgia, who had believed she was dead for a time and had killed her best friend when she could no longer see her face. Eva, who had lost her own children and wanted to make a family so badly that she kidnapped other people's. Katherine, who had been a nurse and tried to give her patients a peaceful death. They had found a man in the park with bees nesting in his head and Margot could almost see how that might be a nice way to go.

"I could have killed him," said Alana. "I don't know if I would have been able to do it. But I was ready to. I always thought I would never understand how someone could kill a human being. I thought I'd never be in that position myself."

"If you want to help people like some of the ones I've met," said Margot, "I think you have to be able to understand even if you've never killed anyone."

"Will could do that," Alana murmured.

"It isn't that hard to understand," said Margot. "Experiencing it over and over, I think, is what puts you in that kind of place."

They walked on in silence.

 

Hannibal had decided to show Abigail how to work the oven in the basement.

“It’s a powerful flame,” he said as they stood back from the gas jet, watching it flare up with startling ferocity, “but it cooks pies to perfection. You need only hold the meat inside for a few minutes at most, and can turn it on for longer to incinerate any unneeded parts left over.”

“My father said that when hunting you should use as much of the animal you kill as possible in order to properly honor it,” said Abigail.

“Wise words,” said Hannibal, “if only when applied to animals.”

“He said if you don’t honor what you kill, it’s just murder.”

“Taking only the very best parts of what you kill can be a way of honoring them,” said Hannibal. “Working with organ meats allows one to elevate what would ordinarily be considered just one part of the whole to real significance in its own right, outside the context of the body.”

“Hmm,” said Abigail.

From above, there came a knock at the door, following by the soft tinkling of the bell that signaled the entrance of a customer.

“Excuse me, I must attend to our next arrival.” Hannibal started upstairs. “Stay down here. I’ll be right back.”

Abigail watched him go, then looked around the basement, eyeing the vast open space that it branched off into when away from the light of the oven’s fire. They really only used a small part of their property’s underground space. Abigail had always been slightly too unsettled by the darkness of the empty area. Will thought it connected with the city’s sewer system, and suggested half-jokingly that it was how Hannibal got around at night.

He hadn’t confirmed anything yet, but Abigail thought there might be some truth to that idea. If he really was the Chesapeake Ripper – a fact he had all but openly confessed to by now – Hannibal had gotten up to quite a lot under cover of darkness, and using some kind of network of underground tunnels would make a lot of his work much easier. She only wondered how he would have managed to dig a basement that connected to the sewers without being found out by the municipal authorities, but perhaps public maintenance on that sort of thing was worse off than she thought.

Abigail had decided that she could live with a man who killed people, and yes, even ate parts of them, as long as she wasn’t a potential target. Living in this house guaranteed her safety while also keeping her isolated from the rest of the world, which was full of people who could themselves wind up in the pies they sold and were therefore not worth getting attached to. She felt a strong kinship with the birds they kept in the outdoor seating area.

It was strange to think that she had lived so much of her life as an accomplice to murder, and yet had never killed anyone herself, or even directly witnessed a murder. Her father’s work was done privately, after she had lured the targets within range; her newest guardians somehow kept the bodies just out of her sight in the same house where she now lived. It was a bit patronizing, really; she was still being treated like a child who needed to be shielded from the difficult and unpleasant aspects of the adults’ lives.

She could change that, though. She wondered if that’s what Hannibal was bringing her down here for – she certainly hoped it wasn’t for another possible reason. If she made it clear that she did understand what they were doing and she would like to participate, she might be allowed to have a little more agency in her life. If she was going to resign herself to life as an accomplice to murder, she might as well lean into it and become more than a silent observer who didn’t even see the truly gory details.

She wandered to the meat grinder and gave it an experimental turn. She remembered how she felt when she first realized her father was feeding his family human flesh – shock and revulsion, mostly, and guilt that she hadn’t been disgusted by the taste. She never said anything about it. It was something only she and her father knew but never discussed with each other. After he was dead, she’d thought she would never taste that meat again, but here she was now helping to prepare it and sell it to hundreds of unwitting civilians. Her family’s dynamic on a much larger scale.

She was well past the initial horror of realization by now. This was simply how she lived.

 

“Ah, Mr. Cordell. What brings you here?”

“There’s a strange smell coming from your chimney,” said Cordell, standing in the doorway. “I thought I’d come in and see what it might be. And to make sure that nothing is burning that shouldn’t be.”

“I assure you that the only thing being burned here is meat, as we cook it in the downstairs bakehouse,” said Hannibal smoothly.

“It didn’t smell like any meat I was familiar with.”

“Then it might also be refuse. Will and Abigail sometimes burn scraps of discarded food and trash in the oven, although I’ve told them it isn’t good for the air around us to release the fumes of just anything into the atmosphere.”

“Very well, then.” Cordell was looking around the shop with mild interest. “It’s a very nice place you have here, Dr. Lecter.”

“Thank you. Business has been doing extremely well lately. Would you like to stay for a drink? Or do you have your own business to attend to elsewhere?” Hannibal gestured towards the rack of wine bottles behind the counter.

“No, but I’ll probably be off shortly…” Cordell wandered over to the harpsichord and plucked out a few notes on the keys. “Lovely instrument.”

“It is indeed. I’ve been working on composing a few pieces of my own for it. Do you play any yourself?”

Cordell chuckled lightly. “No, I never took much to music. My employers learned the piano as children, but they didn’t keep up with it much as adults. Mr. Verger usually hires a professional to provide the music at his parties – you remember when I invited you to the manor, don’t you?”

“Yes, I do. The atmosphere was beautiful, although I did regret how much I’d enjoyed myself when I returned home.” Before Cordell could say anything, he sat down at the music bench. “I’ve always preferred the sound of the harpsichord to the piano, myself, although of course all instruments have their own merits. The immediacy of the notes provides an interesting contrast to the more lasting sound of the piano. Listen.” He played a quick scale to demonstrate. “Do you have any favored composers? I am a great admirer of Bach.”

“I’m afraid I’m more familiar with simple parlor songs than the great classical artists.” Cordell chuckled again, a little more nervously this time. “Is Will Graham here? I might want to speak to him about what kinds of trash he’s been burning.”

“He’s right upstairs. I’ll be down here if you don’t mind a little musical accompaniment to your conversation.”

“Not at all,” said Cordell, smiling thinly, and went upstairs.

Hannibal began to play. He did not know if Bach’s Goldberg Variations would sound very good on the harpsichord, but he knew the piece well enough that he could try and find out right now.

 

Will was sitting at his desk sealing his letter to Mason Verger in an envelope when one of the man’s employees arrived.

“Hello, Mr. Graham,” said Cordell. “Do you know anything about what might be making some odd-smelling smoke issue from your chimney?”

Will turned around in the chair, not deigning to get up. “No, but Hannibal might.”

“He said you might. Or should I question your young ward, what was her name – Abigail?”

“Did it smell like fish?”

“No.”

Will continued to regard him coolly for another minute, allowing the man to grow uncomfortable.

“Well,” he said, “I’ll be going soon.” He glanced around the room. “You know, I really am sorry about what happened to your wife all those years ago. I am glad, though, to see that you’ve been able to make a home of the space where such a tragic event occurred.”

Will stood up then. “I’ve done the best I can to move on.” He crossed, idly, to the table where he kept his fishing lures and knives.

“I should hope,” said Cordell, raising his voice, “that your moving on includes letting go of the grudge you still hold against Mr. Verger. Blame Dr. Lecter all you like for not being home to defend her, but we had nothing to do with it.”

“We?” Will asked over his shoulder.

That supercilious, thin-lipped smile appeared on his face. “I invited him personally a few days before. Mason sometimes sends me out to do that for guests he especially wants to appear. I suppose you can’t blame a man for being persuasive. I would have extended an invitation to his tenant, too, since I could imagine why she’d be apprehensive about staying home alone at that time, but then she’d have to bring her little boy along and our parties are really no place for children.”

“So you did have something to do with it,” said Will.

“What do you mean?”

Will didn’t answer. He was barely thinking as he jammed the knife into the side of Cordell’s neck. Downstairs, Hannibal’s harpsichord playing grew louder and faster, each note a decisive punctuation to the air as Cordell choked on his own gushing blood and fell heavily to the floor.

He was still barely thinking as he dragged the still-bleeding body to the trapdoor and pushed it down the chute leading to the basement, but he might have reflected later that he would not have sent it down then if he’d known Abigail was there.

 

Abigail jumped about a mile when the man’s body came tumbling down from the ceiling. Instinctively she ran over to see and just as instinctively stepped back when she did. His eyes, frozen in a now-permanent expression of shock, stared blankly upward as blood gushed from a wound in the side of his neck, until with one final spurt and convulsion he was still.

Heart hammering, she could only think so that’s how they’re sending them down without me seeing a thing, isn’t it?

 

Hannibal stopped playing and looked up as Will strode down the stairs.

“Hannibal,” he said.

“Yes?”

Will held out an envelope. “Deliver this to Mason Verger as soon as you can. If Margot and Alana get here first, have them hide in the bedroom until he gets here.”

“Cordell is dead, then.”

“He should be by now.” Hannibal took the envelope, and Will turned around and went right back up.

Hannibal contemplated the letter in his hand for a moment before going to the basement stairs. “Abigail,” he called down.

She appeared at the bottom, eyes wide as if she’d just seen something horrifying or revelatory or both. “Yes?”

“I’ll be going out for a little while. Something came up. Feel free to practice with the tools downstairs if you wish to catch up on the food preparation for this week.”

“Alright,” she said, and watched him go.

 

Molly waited until she’d seen Dr. Lecter leave before going up to the shop and slipping quietly in the door. She left enough time after his departure to ensure he wouldn’t see her, but not too much, she hoped, to risk him returning too soon.

Immediately she was hit with the familiar smell of fresh-baked bread and rich meats combined with the old wooden floors and dusty glass of aged wine bottles. The main difference from how she remembered it was that the shop looked much more like a place that customers frequented. It was better maintained and the food in the display cases looked to be replenished daily.

Will lived upstairs just as she used to. She drifted through, feeling rather like a ghost in her black dress and widow’s veil, and began ascending the staircase. Hearing the slow creak of floorboards brought back highly specific memories. She knew which stairs would creak as soon as she started up them again for the first time in seven years.

Her heart ached when she reached the top and saw the upstairs room. If she hadn’t known before, she would have been able to tell instantly who was living here. A table full of fishing lures, his own display case of fresh fish – was he selling his catches? Good for him, to find a way to make a living here without having to resort to whatever his housemate was doing. He’d even adorned the walls with a couple of paintings, classic scenes that fit the area’s general aesthetic, like a boat being tossed on a stormy seascape and a gathering of hunting dogs in the forest. No live dogs here, but there was a large fish tank set up, with the long rippling body of an eel visible inside, swimming peacefully back and forth.

Entering, she drifted further, reaching out to run her hand along the polished wood of a writing desk he’d set up, moving to the worktable to pick up a fishhook. The trappings of her old home with Will in this space where she had lived before without him were strange to her, two periods of her life that had once been separate now combined.

She was temporarily distracted from why she’d originally come here. A voice from behind brought her straight out of it.

“What are you doing here?”

She spun around and there he was, at the top of the stairs, not looking happy to see her. His right hand dangled from his side and he was holding – was there blood on his hands?

He was holding a knife, the kind he used to use to gut fish, and she certainly hoped it was only fish blood and guts staining his fingers, but something in his expression unsettled her. Of course he didn’t recognize her, she reminded herself, she was hiding her face behind a veil, but would he recognize her without it? He didn’t know what she looked like now. He might not even know what had happened, but Dr. Lecter must have told him. Unless—

“Will,” she said. “I want to tell you…” How could she start?

He began to look more worried. “You need to leave. It’s not safe to be here right now. Later, maybe tomorrow, you can come back for whatever you need, but now, you can’t be in here.” He started walking towards her, and she took a step back.

“But—” He was growing desperate and so was she. “Don’t you know who I am?”

“No,” he said. “I’m sorry. Please, just go. I can explain afterwards.”

“After what?” She wanted to throw back her veil, but at the moment she hesitated, afraid to see the look on his face when she revealed herself and what had become of her. And from how he was acting, they might not have time to deal with the fallout.

Will was about to say something else, but just then a bell sounded from downstairs; the same bell she had carefully avoided setting off when she entered the building.

Will’s head snapped to the direction of the stairs, then back to her. “He’s here. Go. Run. Hide!”

“Who? Where?” Molly kept backing away, her mind growing frantic in the confusion. Will made as if to push her and she stumbled, and then the floor gave way beneath her and she was falling down some kind of sliding chute, hands grasping at thin air and too shocked to even scream.

“Mr. Graham?” called Mason Verger. “Are you there?”

“Just a moment,” Will called back, and set about cleaning the blood off his hands and knife.

 

“Mr. Verger,” said Will, greeting him downstairs. “I’m glad you came here so soon.”

“Yes, yes,” said Mason. “Is my sister here? Where is she?”

“She’s right upstairs.”

“And she really wants to go home?”

“She does. I told her you were coming to pick her up.”

Mason squinted suspiciously. “And you’re sure she hasn’t fled again since you did?”

“I’m sure. I was just talking to her right before you came in. If she changes her mind again, there won’t be much time left for it to make a difference.”

“Good. Take me to her.”

“Right away. Follow me.”

Up the stairs they went again, the wooden steps creaking ominously beneath their feet, all the way to Will's killing floor. Will supposed you could spend your whole life raising hogs for the slaughter and still not recognize when you were being led there yourself.

Mason was briefly distracted from his goal of finding Margot by the eel tank.

"Lovely specimen you have there, Graham. Is that a brutal moray?"

"We're fairly certain it is," said Will.

"Funny. I purchased a juvenile one of those myself a few years back, but I set it loose in the bay when I grew tired of keeping it fed. Watching them tear apart a fish is really only exciting the first number of times, after that it just gets repetitive and tedious trying to keep them interested. You'd think an eel wouldn't care that much about variety in its diet...did you catch this one yourself?"

"I had help," said Will.

"Where is Margot, anyway? You said she'd be up here. Did she try to flee after all? Is she hiding somewhere? Or are you covering for her somehow? You do know, Mr. Graham, that I have employees I can send out to all corners to find out where she really is. And they'll help me deal with you and your friend Dr. Lecter while we're at it, too."

"Not as many as you used to have, though, isn't that right?" asked Will. "I've only seen you with one since I returned, and he isn't with you now."

"He was also supposed to be here," said Mason, "but..." He paused, looking around as if listening for something. "Did Mr. Cordell come by recently?"

"Not that I know of," said Will. "Mr. Verger, could you please look at me while I'm talking to you?"

"Oh," said Mason, turning around with a smirk, "now Mr. Graham wants to look me in the eye. This must be a terribly important conversation, then. What could possibly warrant you actually making eye contact for once?"

"I want you," said Will calmly, "to look into the face of the man whose family you stole from him all those years ago. Remember Molly Graham? Or was she going by Molly Foster by then?"

Mason stared at him, then burst out laughing. "The man who did that is already dead! Are you just looking for someone to blame? If you want to take your grief out on someone, take it out on Dr. Lecter! He's the one who left her and her kid alone that night. He didn't have to come to my house. That could have happened any night, how were any of us supposed to know?"

"It was the night of the full moon. Why did you have to have one of your parties then? Why did you have to invite him, of all people?" Will grabbed the knife from his pocket then, and grabbed Mason by the collar. "You knew what you were doing. You already sent me away and you wanted to make sure I would have no one waiting for me when I came back." He pressed the blade against Mason's throat. The man's expression barely changed; he still looked more amused than anything. "But I did have someone waiting. I had Hannibal, and he's going to help me make sure nobody ever finds out what happened to you."

"Where is my sister, Graham?" Mason asked.

"Right here," said Margot.

Will looked behind him without releasing Mason Verger from his grasp. Margot was indeed at the top of the stairs, with Alana - her hair down, but still dressed in her brother's clothes - just behind her. Margot herself was wearing a plain, simple white dress that looked like a nightgown combined with a hospital gown, and her hair also fell loosely down her back. Her eyes were heavily shadowed as if she hadn't slept for a week, even though she was dressed as if she'd just gotten out of bed. Alana looked similarly hardened, but not quite as tired. She held the pistol Will had given her in one hand.

"There you are," said Mason. "Can you believe this? Mr. Graham thinks he's going to kill me. But he told me you'd be waiting for me here, repentant and ready to go home. Are you?"

"Do it, Will," she said.

Will looked back at Mason, staring him down. He did not believe Will was a killer - had never believed that, not even when framing him for murder, but he knew the public would. He might have been more willing to believe Margot would kill him, but she wasn't the one holding a blade to his throat.

Will decided to let him be surprised in the last moment of his life. He yanked the knife sideways, swiftly and suddenly, opening a long horizontal gash across Mason Verger's neck and watching the blood spurt out and downwards, falling like a red curtain to close out the last act.

Margot entered the room, Alana hanging back in trepidation. Her brother, looking wildly around, staggered forward as Will released him. He clutched for his sister.

"Margot," he gasped through rapidly evacuating gouts of blood. "Help me--"

He grabbed onto her then, grasping her shoulder, wrapping himself around her waist, and she gave a cry of disgust and pulled away. He held on to her dress and Alana rushed to help her, and soon together they had hold of Mason as he thrashed against them, losing more blood by the second but refusing to go down without a fight. Will felt almost paralyzed watching the grotesque scene, but he felt he should not interfere.

Mason screamed, Margot hauled him up, and she dragged him to the fish tank. They crashed into it, knocking the lid askew and nearly spilling all the water, but the eel, smelling blood, came to the surface and Margot could force her brother's head underwater, yanking it back to further expose and open his neck wound enough for the eel to eagerly dive in. Soon all that was left of the life inside Mason was a stream of red-tinged bubbles issuing from his mouth and open throat.

Alana helped her hold his head under until he'd stopped moving. When the two women withdrew their hands from the tank, they were clean of blood, although it splattered the fronts of their clothes and soaked the ends of their sleeves.

Margot turned towards Will, her haunted eyes now calm. "Thank you."

"For what?" he managed to say in a strained whisper.

"For letting us kill him."

They sent his body down the chute together, all three of them watching it disappear into the depths of the house.

 

Will headed down to the basement as soon as he could to find the woman who had come in earlier - it seemed so long ago, now - and had fallen down the chute. When he descended, he found Hannibal, who had returned sometime during the commotion upstairs, and had the woman from behind. It seemed he was trying to strangle her.

"Hannibal!" Will cried out. "Stop! Let her go. She's not supposed to be here - I mean, she came here and fell down into the passageway. I only wanted her to hide while I took care of Verger. That's done now."

Hannibal looked right at Will with a frightening intensity he had not seen before, but he released his hold on the woman in black. She stopped struggling and stumbled forward, away from him. When she looked up, Will saw in the dim light that her veil had been flung back and her face was now fully visible. Even scarred, he recognized her.

"Molly?"

She gasped, recovering her breath; she might have laughed, one side of her mouth, the scarred side, twitching into a half-smile. "I tried to tell you."

"I thought you were dead." He looked now at Hannibal, who still fixed him with a strangely detached gaze. "You told me she was dead."

"Did I, Will?" asked Hannibal, coming out of his trance now but still staring unnervingly. "Or did I tell you some of the details and you assumed the rest?"

"Why wouldn't you tell me the truth?" Will's mind was racing to process everything he had just learned. "Why..."

"She was doing well enough on her own by the time you returned - weren't you?" Hannibal addressed Molly, who did not answer. She was backing away from him towards Will. "I saw no point in you running back to be with her, Will. She had made a life of her own that did not include you. Mine did, though."

"Why did you leave her alone here on the night of the full moon?" Will asked. "Her and Walter. You must have known what would happen."

"They survived. She fought bravely and came out stronger for it. I always meant to commend you, Molly, but you were in no state to take in anything I said at the time, and then you never returned to see me after the doctors had stitched you up."

"I'm glad I didn't," said Molly. "I should never have moved in with you or trusted you at all. Will, I wanted to warn you..."

"It's alright, Molly," he told her. "I see now. I see him for what he is. Go, leave this house and save yourself. I have one last thing to accomplish tonight."

Molly took her chance, flying up the stairs without looking back. When the basement door had slammed behind her, Will and Hannibal faced each other once more.

"Where's Abigail?" Will asked.

"I don't know," Hannibal said, "and I'm telling the truth, I promise. She was down here when I left, but I haven't seen her since I returned. I think she may have disappeared into the expanses of the basement area." He gestured to the darkness behind Will, which stretched out into a seemingly endless void. "I hope she took along a lantern. This space goes on for miles. I explored it a bit myself when I bought this property, but I never found where it ends. Perhaps it connects to the sewers underneath the city. I do not know who built it, or how it happened."

"I hope she escapes," said Will. "I hope she gets away from you."

"Come now, Will, why are you turning on me now? Was this your plan all along, after your revenge had concluded? You seemed perfectly happy to go along with my ways of doing business before."

"You lied to me," said Will, and held up a hand before Hannibal could respond. "A sin of omission is still a lie. You knew I misunderstood the situation and never corrected me, because my lack of knowledge suited your interests. You didn't want me to go back to her and leave you." Will felt a quaver in his voice coming on and tried to suppress it. "Why? If I knew she was alive and had made a good life for herself without me, I wouldn't have tried to force my way back into it. I would even have understood if she didn't want anything more to do with me. I wouldn't have left you for her. You didn't trust me, though. Or maybe - maybe you didn't want her to tell me what you'd done, how you'd betrayed her. You didn't want me to know too much about who you really were. Were you ever going to tell me?"

"Someday I might have," said Hannibal. "I think you would have found out on your own eventually, though."

"And then what would you have done?"

"I don't know. I don't often know what the consequences will be when I set an action in motion. I find it more interesting to wait and see what will happen."

"Everyone and everything around you is just there for your own amusement, isn't that so? You and Mason Verger aren't so different after all."

"Will," he said, and Will could tell, surprisingly, that this had finally struck a nerve. "You have forgiven me so much since we have known each other. Much more than the average person would. Is this where you draw the line?"

Will sighed and hung his head. He waited until tears no longer threatened to overflow his eyes, and walked toward Hannibal. "Come here. Open the oven door. I want to burn his body." He gestured with a jerk of his head toward Mason Verger, lying prone and lifeless on the floor where the chute had deposited him.

"To cook him all at once?"

"Being eaten is too good for him. I just want him gone from this earth."

"Understandable." Hannibal opened the huge baking oven and turned on the flame. Before he could collect the body, Will pulled him into a close embrace, wrapping his arms around the other man's shoulders and burying his head under Hannibal's.

"Oh, Will..."

"I do love you, you know," Will whispered.

"I know you did. You do."

Will allowed himself to remain warmly and comfortably within Hannibal's embrace for just a moment longer, before pulling himself and Hannibal sharply to the side and letting both of them tumble into the open flame.

 

Abigail, far off in the dark depths of the basement, heard a sound. She turned around and ran back to the source of it, her lantern bobbing frantically in front of her, illuminating nothing more than long empty passageways, and arrived back under the house just in time to see the oven door slam shut from within and the flames leap higher to cover what could be seen inside from the small window in the door.

She stood there until the flames died down, and looked inside. There was nothing.

She went upstairs.

Four women stood in the store's main area, and it was a strange sight. Alana Bloom was there, wearing men's clothes and holding a gun. Margot Verger was there too, wearing a white nightgown stained with blood. The veiled woman in black who she had been told to keep away from the store during dining hours was there, only her veil was off, revealing a face covered in scars and wearing a determined but exhausted expression. She held lightly to the arm of the blind woman Abigail had seen her with sometimes when she hung around outside, who was now gripping her cane as if it were a sword she was prepared to defend them all with.

"You must be Abigail," said the woman in black.

"What's going to happen?" Abigail asked.

"We're going to go home," said Margot.

"Where is that?" Abigail asked.

"Right now, I'm not sure," said Margot. "But I think my house may finally be safe to call it home."

"You can come with us if you want," said Alana. "Or you can go out on your own. We will keep our doors open to you no matter what you choose."

"So will we," said the woman in black. "I think you should have options you know are safe, if you can trust us."

The blind woman nodded. "You don't know us, but I know what it's like to be taken in by someone who you were only safe with because they'd chosen to bring you into their circle against the rest of the world. My name is Reba McClane, and this is Molly Foster."

Abigail looked around at the four women, mostly strangers to her, but all of whom had been through things she could understand. "I'm Abigail Hobbs. And wherever we go, we should probably get out of here as soon as we can."

 

Will Graham and Hannibal Lecter’s names would fade into legend as the years went on. No traces of their remains would ever be found in their shop, not even any ashes in the oven, which was thoroughly cleaned out by the investigators. Some said their ghosts had escaped with the smoke perpetually issuing from the chimney. Some said they still haunted the now-abandoned building that no one yet dared to buy or move into. Some said they had actually hurled themselves off one of Will’s fishing boats into the sea. Some said they had never died at all, and were even now living among the general populace, somehow disguising themselves perfectly while still residing in the same city; perhaps you might have passed one or both of them on the street, given a nod to a man who decided based on your courtesy not to have you for dinner that week.

Some said they were living by the sea, running an inn that only occasionally did in its guests. Some said they were living on the sea as nomadic sailors. Some said they lived in the sea. They said a lot of things.

Abigail didn’t know what she believed anymore, but she was glad that she did not have to think about them very often. Once in a while she would be reminded, and would spend an hour or so wistfully reminiscing about the brief, strange period of her life spent with two men she might have called her fathers in a different world. By now, she thought, she’d had enough of fathers.

She was also glad to know people who understood what it was to have killed and to have been an accomplice, if not a willing one; to have done things in the name of keeping oneself safe that most people who had never had to do anything similar would be scandalized about. She had spent so much of her life not being safe, only feeling able to delay the inevitable a little bit longer, that it was almost stranger not having to worry about the precarious position of her life every day. Not even in the back of her mind.

For the first time in a long time, Abigail was able to see some kind of future for herself, rising out of the ashes of her past. Someday, perhaps, she might tell her story in all its truth and horror, but that day did not have to be soon. She had time and room enough in her life now for the madness of her earlier years to be only a small part of her story.

And after all, who would believe a tale so sensational?

Notes:

"to seek revenge may lead to hell/but everyone does it, though seldom as well"
I felt it fitting to end with Abigail, because I love her, and because so many productions leave Toby (her counterpart in the show) as the one to tell the story by the end.
consider commenting if you liked it. thanks for reading <3