Actions

Work Header

Please Send Weekly Reports on Hobbitling Survival

Chapter 14: Owe

Notes:

Hey guys, if you haven’t already, run don’t walk to Linelen’s Please Allow Young Hobbits Into Your Heart! (http://archiveofourown.org/works/702586) It is set in the Please!Hobbitlings AU and deals with Dwalin and Primula, and it is fantastic and glorious and heartbreaking and just aaaaafjslkdf! so check it out.

On a less-excited-more-nervous note, several people have asked me about Boromir’s fate. This chap deals with that and I sincerely hope it does him justice.

Chapter Text

Boromir awakens with a start; he sits up immediately, clutching his head. The first feeling is a mixture of panic and confusion. A split second later, the world slides into some sort of focus and understanding, and a wave of shame hits him. He groans.

His face is sticky with dried blood and mud, and there are dead leaves in his hair. But the main feeling of dirtiness nonetheless comes from inside. Boromir’s thoughts are dark.

(Paradoxically, it was, in fact, his very madness that allowed Frodo to escape from him. The Ringbearer is a fine warrior, but he does not have to fight every day for his life and the lives of his family and people. It is only Boromir’s hazy, Ring-clouded mind that allowed Frodo escape without complication. Yet without the madness Frodo would have had no reason to run in the first place; there is no comfort to be found in this puzzle.)

Presently, there is a rustle and Boromir looks up. He finds Aragorn leaning against a tree and breathing hard. There is blood on his cloak: the consistency and color identifies it as some type of Orc. Aragorn does not have the signs of battle-readiness upon him, so Boromir assumes the enemy must be gone. Yet... the battle is over, but Aragorn’s sword is neither cleaned nor in its sheath. The battle is done; is it now time for the execution?

(There is a sort of grim humor, and justice, in this thought.)

As though sensing the direction of his musings, Aragorn reacts. His eyes do not leave Boromir’s as the Man slowly and deliberately slides his sword back into its scabbard. Boromir remembers that just a few scant days ago, he had told Aragorn, passionately and without hesitation, that there still existed honor within the race of Man. His own honor could never be cleared with death; but perhaps he can do so with life. He will at least try.

Boromir stands up.

--*--*--

He feels the judging looks from the Elf and the Dwarf, of course-- no, from Legolas and Gimli. He wouldn’t feel quite as ashamed if they were still just Elf and Dwarf to him. Well, that is not true, he would still feel as ashamed, but the feeling wouldn’t be compounded in the way it is now. Their stares are hot on his back. He will not meet their eyes, but he can well picture their wise, saddened looks at their disgraced, disgraceful companion.

The four of them are chasing poor Merry and Pippin, running faster than Boromir has ever run before. His water flask is empty and he cannot breathe properly through his nose-- Frodo’s kick got him good. Boromir’s lungs are bursting and his head throbs. The valleys and hills before him blur together.

Just as he thinks he can no longer go on, Gimli calls a halt. The rest is welcome; Gimli grumbles about how the rock formations above ground make running uncomfortable. But Boromir knows it is him who is trailing behind, and it is for his benefit that they are now pausing. The shame, which never really goes away, intensifies. He does not want to be the reason that Merry and Pippin suffer for a second longer than necessary (if only he had been awake to at least try to help Aragorn protect them!) and the relief for the break is mixed with a strand of bitterness.

Suddenly, a flask is thrust under his broken nose. Boromir blinks at the water for a second, his mind still clouded from the light concussion that was Frodo’s other parting gift. Then his eyes slowly follow the arm up to meet the gaze of Legolas. There is no disgust, or pity, to be found in those old eyes; there is only companionship.

For the first time since the madness took him, Boromir begins to really believe that there is perhaps some hope left for him.

--*--*--

The feeling vanishes when they see Gandalf-- Gandalf the White now. He is even more distant than he had been before his Fall; Legolas, the most otherworldly person Boromir knows, seems as solid and simple-hearted as Sam when standing next to this new wizard. With each second though, Gandalf becomes a tiny bit more there (as Merry had once explained the concept to Boromir during a rather monotone watch). Boromir is terrified what he will find in those ancient eyes when Gandalf the White’s color turns just a slightly darker shade.

But all those thoughts are driven out of his head by the course of action Gandalf decides upon. It was evening when they had met the wizard and thus they are now sitting around a small campfire (made from only dead wood, a small distance from the Forest). Boromir has listened silently to Gandalf’s story of his Fall --he does not think he can bear the wizard noticing his guilt and so for now he keeps quiet-- but it is difficult to contain himself at these plans.

Why must they ride to Edoras?!

Surely now, if Gandalf is certain Merry and Pippin are safe and Frodo and Sam are beyond their reach, now is the time to tarry no longer but hurry back to Gondor? His father would-- well, Boromir would get him to see reason. Lord Denethor would not turn away fighters as strong as these, not when Mordor is breathing ever heavier down their neck. And together, they could keep the Eye away from seeking Frodo.

But no, for some reason it is to Rohan they must ride, to the Horse Lords who honor no peace treaties and keep only to their own lands. It is hard to swallow down the petulant It isn’t fair, they never helped us and now I have to help them?! that threatens to escape; Boromir knows it is childish to think thus but he cannot completely squash the thought. And it is impossible to hide his disappointment that Aragorn agrees with Gandalf’s plans immediately; there is not even a hint at protesting for a different choice. Once more, the Man who should be his king is off to help others-- always somebody but never Gondor.

The disappointment he feels at Aragorn’s choice both does and doesn’t surprise Boromir. He isn’t sure when anger at the idea of a King shifted into anger at the absence of the King, but it is not an abrupt development. Perhaps his view changed when Aragorn forgave him his treachery, perhaps it was when Gandalf fell and Aragorn did what was needed, and perhaps it was the first time his feet unconsciously snapped to attention at a careless, hurried order. Boromir is a man of action: if his body acknowledges something, then he knows his mind, kicking and screaming, will nevertheless be dragged along. And secretly, Boromir also knows that Aragorn will be a good king: he is just and it is tempered with mercy, he is strong and it is tempered with wisdom.

But ever his would-be king runs away from his people, and it frustrates Boromir. He turns away from the others when Gandalf announces their course; if he stays there he will start raging and screaming and he does not wish to say something he would regret (nor to draw Gandalf’s attention to him). He mutters something about going off to search for more firewood.

Legolas and Gimli follow him.

“You owe him your allegiance,” reminds Legolas.

As if Boromir didn’t know that already!

“That is not the problem,” grinds out Boromir, because after what they had all been through the two of them deserve an honest answer and a proper explanation. “I would give him my allegiance in a heartbeat-- I already have-- but he would throw it away, as he throws away all our people’s love and devotion. I-- we do not enjoy being discarded so lightly.”

“But that is not it at all!” Legolas says, agitated and saddened for his friends. (The Elf’s emotions are never easy to interpret, but Boromir knows he feels each more deeply than most mortals ever do. Sometimes he secretly wishes Legolas could care less, just forget about all Middle-Earth’s petty squabbles and run off to the West with the rest of his kin; Legolas reminds him of Faramir.) “Aragorn would not-- he does not mean to--”

“Kings think differently than normal folk,” breaks in Gimli. Boromir is reminded of how much younger he is than his friends; Gimli’s voice is as slow and deliberate as stone. “They have to. I have known two kings in my time, and even when they are playing with their children or reposing with their loved ones, their minds are constantly whirring around deep, broad matters. But sometimes,” his solemn face morphs into a crooked grin, “they can still be a little dumb. Go talk to our young king and tell him your thoughts plainly. He is not particularly good at this type of thing.”

--*--*--

Boromir does what his friends suggest; they have not steered him wrong yet (and he is still constantly grateful for how little they have judged him for his mistakes). Still, it is more than a bit nerve-wracking, and as he goes to find Aragorn he wonders how best to approach the topic. Boromir is a man of intense actions and introspective silences-- it is hard for him to express thoughts and feelings out loud.

He walks, thinking of his frustration:

Why will you not come home to us? Do Elves and far-off places entice you so much? Are we too plain and normal to be worthy of your time? We have our own wonders and our own goodness, and every door and window would be flung open to greet you if only you stopped running.

He thinks of his secret fears:

Is it that we’re not good enough, not good enough for our wise and powerful, destined king to come home? I failed-- I do not deny it-- but do not take your anger over me out on your people. If you wish me gone from your sight I will leave at once, but your people need you and it is cruel of you to make them wait. I know what I have done, but what have they? In what terrible ways have they sinned that makes you so unwilling to come home?

And he thinks of his anger:

How dare you run away from your throne at every chance! What fear drives you, my King-- and what allegiance do I owe a king who ran away from his people before, and is now doing it once again?! A coward, I call you! A coward who does not deserve the throne of Gondor no matter how willingly we may offer it to you.

It is in the midst of his raging anger that he stumbles upon Aragorn.

The Ranger is sitting on a fallen log, slowly and methodically wiping down his sword. He has not yet noticed Boromir-- or, more likely, has pretended not to notice him coming a mile away out of courtesy. There is a heavy weariness in his stooped posture and his brows are creased together slightly with a worry that never quite leaves his face. One last swipe and Aragorn finally looks up. His eyes are full of resignation: he is prepared for Boromir to come and rage his fill. And then he will quietly tell Boromir not to worry (because Boromir is not good with words, especially when he is angry, and Aragorn will certainly misunderstand the reason for the ranting) and that he is not looking for a throne but only to help all people. And then they will be back to where they started.

Suddenly, taking in the sight of this tired face and hunched shoulders, Boromir’s anger vanishes.

He strides over to Aragorn, unsheathing his sword. The Man twitches in surprise (and Boromir feels a little twinge of pleasure at surprising his oh-so-wise king) as Boromir nears him, but he does not move. Boromir knows exactly what he needs to do and say, to finally, properly get through to Aragorn. He goes down on one knee before his king, offering his sword hilt-first, his head bowed. There is a sharp intake of breath from Aragorn.

“I offer to you my life and allegiance,” Boromir says. “And, as heir to the Stewardship, on behalf of our people I offer to you the throne of Gondor-- if you will have us.”

There is silence, and all Boromir can hear is his own wildly beating heart. Then Aragorn takes the sword from him-- and props it on the log he is sitting on, a little awkwardly; he is clearly unused to such an offering. Boromir still cannot bear to look up, and the sudden warmth of hands cupping his face startles him. But Aragorn is merely steadying Boromir as he gives him a soft kiss on the brow. The king murmurs: “I accept your oath.”

Aragorn releases him, vaguely motioning for his subject to stand. But Boromir is not yet done; his eyes are still firmly focused on Aragorn’s boots and he is still kneeling. Being deferential does not come easily to the warrior, but this is important and this is necessary and this is right. And if he wants Aragorn to be a king, then Boromir must at least attempt to act the part of the steward.

“Will you not come home to us, my King?” he says softly. And once he starts, it is difficult to stop. “Your people need you-- why must they suffer and die while their king protects all others but them? You are no coward or fool, so the problem must lie with us, yet-- I know I have sinned, but do not take your anger towards one out on-- there are warriors brave and true at the White City and they would be gladdened of your help! What have we-- they-- the people done that makes you so unwilling to defend them from the Enemy? Why are our-- why are their lives worth so much less to you than others’?”

Then he clams up abruptly, because his own issues and shames are slowly crawling into the plea, and this formal audience with the king (as formal as Boromir can make it whilst Aragorn sits on a log instead of a throne) is not about Boromir. It is about kingship and Gondor and the people. His own feelings are not part of the topic; his role is to be an emissary between People and King. He hopes he is at least partly succeeding.

There is a bone-weary sigh from Aragorn.

“Boromir,” he says. “No, Boromir, look at me; this stuffy formality is silly.” A short pause, and Boromir’s eyes dart up to Aragorn’s face. At the sight of the raw honesty he finds there, they stay, transfixed. “Boromir, I cannot go to Gondor-- no, don’t hide your feelings and hurt under that stoic warrior mask-- just listen for once. I cannot go to the White City now. I will not return to your-- to my-- to our people-- like an unwanted beggar at the door. Don’t try to protest-- it is true. Do you not remember your own feelings towards me at the start of the Council-- Boromir, honestly, I am not criticizing, just stating the truth. It is how it is. And thus, I will not turn to our people with empty hands. I will ride instead with Gandalf, and renew the peace and friendship with the Rohirrim, and come to Gondor with pride and help in our darkest hour. Then, perhaps, Gondor can begin to put the same amazing trust in me that you do now, and that trust will seem to all well-founded.”

With that he stands, pulling Boromir up next to him. He clasps Boromir’s arm-- a bond of friendship and brotherhood that runs far deeper than this newer vow of fealty. Boromir’s heart lifts suddenly and the hope flickering in his chest blossoms just a bit more. For if his king reaffirms the bonds Boromir was sure he had ripped completely with (in) his madness, surely this means there is a real chance of redemption left for him?

Aragorn speaks again, and his voice is strong and light. “And then the trumpets will ring out-- the Lords of Gondor have returned.”

“‘The Lords of Gondor have returned,’” echoes Boromir softly. “Yes, the King and his court will have returned.”

He smiles and his king smiles back.

--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--*--

BONUS: Just So You Know I Think Boromir Is Secretly Just As Traumatized By His Dad’s Weird Issues As Faramir Is

“By the way,” says Aragorn, going for light-hearted but coming out as concerned. “Perhaps it is not too late to talk about these deep-rooted feelings of shame and lack of self-worth that you sometimes show. I do not think it very healthy, and as your newly affirmed king, I feel it my duty to help you overcome them...”

King or not, vow of allegiance or not, at the threat of more talking about feelings, Boromir picks up his sword and runs. A faint cry of Who’s the coward now? drifts after him.