Chapter Text
The blindfold was taken off him and Frodo blinked in the sudden light. It was already dark outside the cave they were in --or something like a cave, at least; the rock formation was so different here he wasn’t even sure if the room was completely man-made or just tweaked-- but the moonlight shone bright. A quick check beside him found a similarly blinking Sam, who shot Frodo a small, reassuring smile: his friend was unhurt. Where Gollum was off to Frodo could not tell, but he hoped the poor creature was safe.
The Hobbit took in the room with a wary interest, eyes searching for an escape, but for now there were too many Men to make any real plan. And besides, perhaps Sam and he would get out of this with only diplomacy this time-- the Men guiding them had been efficient but not unkind. His eyes focused finally on the person who seemed to be the leader of these warriors. It was strange: there was the something the slightest bit familiar about this young Man... an annoying itch of recognition like a word on the tip of his tongue... He could not place it.
As if sensing Frodo’s thoughts, the stranger-but-not-a-stranger walked over to crouch next to the two Hobbits. A puzzled frown was on his face; he spoke briskly, but it was tinged with curiosity.
“You are not a Dwarf. You have their height and braids, their weapons, their clothing. But your sword and your cloak is of Elven make, and you have no beard. What are you?”
It had been so long since someone questioned him thus, Frodo had almost forgotten what it felt like. You are not a real Dwarf, you are not a real Hobbit, others used to ask him, back in the Shire, back in Erebor. What are you? But that had been long ago, and eventually Frodo had made a place for himself with both Peoples. It was strange to hear the same question again, so far from home.
A little spark of Prince Frodo of Erebor, one which he thought had been drowned by the Ring, returned to his heart. He opened his mouth to go on his usual rant (Biologically, perhaps I am a Hobbit, and my heart is molded from the same clay as theirs, but my spirit was carved by Mahal just the same as any Dwarf’s!) but Sam, always the more practical, nudged him in the ribs. Hard. Frodo closed his mouth, swallowed down his words, and said, a bit sulkily:
“I’m a Hobbit.”
“A Hobbit?” The man’s frown deepened. “Ah-- a Halfling? What would a Halfling be doing in such a place? Have the Halflings finally decided to take sides-- spies for Mordor perhaps?”
“Never!” Sam broke in, his voice heated. “He is Prince Frodo Baggins of Erebor. Have you never heard of Thorin Baggins Oakenshield, King Under The Mountain? This is his nephew and you should show some respect.”
Frodo glanced at Sam, a wry smile on his face. Sam just shrugged slightly and lifted his chin defiantly. It had been a long time since Sam had been forced to defend him thus, from sly whispers and cruel laughter, but he had not forgotten how.
The human warrior’s gaze turned appraising as he turned his attention to the other Hobbit for the first time. “And you are..?”
“His best friend.”
For the first time the Man’s expression changed from one of businesslike neutrality; a brief smile flashed across his face and his posture relaxed a little.
“All right,” he said. “Let us say I believe you-- we have not had dealings with Dwarves for many years, but the name Oakenshield is known to me. That still does not explain what a prince and his friend are doing, wandering the Enemy’s land.”
Frodo chewed on his lower lip, wondering how much to say. Perhaps Sam had gotten a bit carried away, telling this Man their names. He seemed-- there was still that frustrating sense of almost-familiarity, but who knew what that really meant... Ah well, only one way to find out.
“We have told you our names,” Frodo said softly. “Will you not return the favor, before we talk more?”
The Man gave him a long, appraising look. Then he said: “That is fair. I am Captain Faramir, son of Denethor.”
“Denethor?!” Sam and Frodo exclaimed together. They exchanged wild, amazed glances.
“Then... perhaps you are related to Boromir?” said Frodo hesitantly.
“He is my brother.”
And the feeling of familiar stranger resolved itself abruptly. Frodo could see the family resemblance well: the same strong nose and willful glance. The determination in that expression was of a different sort than in Boromir’s, but it was equally strong. And there was also a glimmer of quiet wisdom in Faramir’s eyes that Frodo did not remember in his brother. For a second he allowed the face before him to merge and intertwine with his memory of Boromir. The man he now pictured was as strong as he was wise, with no shadow upon him. It was a good image; perhaps it was how Boromir would have been, had the memories he had recounted in the middle of the night not been true, had he had enough time with the Fellowship and their cheerfulness, had there been no Ring. Until he saw Boromir again, he would remember him thus, without a trace of the madness he last glimpsed.
“We are companions of Boromir!” Sam said, ripping Frodo out of his broodings. “We travelled from Rivendell with him and six others.”
Faramir’s eyes widened, then narrowed.
“If you are truly companions of Boromir,” and his voice held a challenging lilt to them, just barely covering a deep excitement underneath, “then you could tell me something about him-- an object that he carries with him and holds most precious, perhaps?”
“That’s easy,” Sam shrugged. “It’s that little silver brooch of his.”
There was a sharp intake of breath from Faramir. His crouching form wavered and he tipped over to sit on the floor next to the Hobbits. Faramir’s eyes were wide.
“You thought Sam would speak of the Horn of Gondor, didn’t you?” Frodo smiled. “But no, it is that little brooch that you gave him; that is what he values most.” His smile widened into a sad, weary grin. “And now I know that you are who you claim to be as well-- you brothers are similar in your nature.”
At this comment, the young Man flushed to the roots of his hair. But his excitement soon overtook his embarrassment. He cleared his throat.
“Aye?” he said, going for nonchalant. But his eyes shone like a little boy’s when opening presents, and he spoke quickly and eagerly. “Ah, well, any friend of Boromir is my friend also! I will aid you in any way I can, you and that skulking creature we saw near you-- is he a Hobbit as well? But no matter-- tell me more instead of your travels!”
Frodo looked at the enthusiasm on Faramir’s face, and he thought of how young the warrior appeared right now, and of the little things Boromir had said and the little things he had left out. And he thought of how much Boromir worried about his brother. Next to him, Sam was attempting not to chew his lip anxiously.
“Your brother is-- fine,” Frodo started hesitantly. But gradually his voice gathered in strength. “No, Boromir is better than fine. He has become a true friend and a loyal companion to us all, and he is someone I would not hesitate to call friend.”
“And his soups are quite tasty, too,” chimed in Sam.
But Faramir’s excitement had slipped from his face and he regarded the Hobbits with a shrewd, serious eye. Sam and Frodo’s words were genuine, but they could not completely cover the darkness that shadowed the descriptions true and loyal. And Faramir, with the patient cunning that was so unlike Boromir’s boldness (and brashness), saw through it immediately.
“Still, there is something you will not say.”
Frodo hesitated, then he replied slowly: “If you are truly a brother to Boromir, you know why he travelled to Rivendell.”
There was a moment's pause, as Faramir considered those words. Then his eyes widened suddenly and he let out a shaky sigh; he buried his head in his hands. A barely audible whisper of Isildur’s bane escaped him. Silence stretched between Hobbits and Man as each considered what they knew of Boromir and, more importantly, what they knew of the power of the Ring.
“Tell me,” said Faramir, looking up from his hands finally. His expression was blank and his voice smooth. “Did he fall into madness? Was he why you left your companions?”
“No!” said Frodo at once. “Well-- he-- no. I left willingly. He did not drive me out, and in the end, he broke free of Its curse. No, it was my decision alone to leave.”
Another shaky sigh escaped Faramir, but this time it was relief that stirred it.
“Then there is hope for us yet,” he murmured.
He would have said more, but one of his warriors had hurried over. The Man spoke quietly into his captain’s ear. The words were too quiet for Frodo to make out well, but from Faramir’s expression the message was clear: their guide to Mordor had been found. The time for talking and reminiscing was over; it was time for decisions and action. Frodo held his breath.
“Come,” said Faramir; he stood. “I said I would aid you, and I will honor that.” His smile was soft and sad. “No matter what our father wishes... In the end, Boromir made his choice. And I sincerely hope it was the right one, for I will keep to it." He reached out a hand to the Hobbits and pulled them to their feet, one after the other. Abruptly, the Man's widened into a grin, one with a hint of a mischevious edge. "Long has my brother watched over me, and ever has he helped me when I failed. And now I finally have the chance to return the favor! We shall see what he thinks of that.”
There was a note of satisfaction and a triumph in his voice amidst the solemn wonder; Frodo, also a younger brother, thoroughly approved.
