Chapter Text
“Do you ever wish it had turned out differently?”
Merry turned to look at Pippin directly, noting his brooding stare across the barrels full of who-knows-what floating in the flooded valley. Pippin’s hands were not holding a pipe, so Merry assumed the question was serious, not one of the hazy, rhetorical ones his cousin tended to ask after a long smoke.
“You mean, if we had managed to find Frodo in time, and gone along with him to Mordor?”
Pippin nodded at the question. He tore his gaze from the wreckage and looked at Merry; Pippin’s brows were furrowed together in worry.
“Yeah... I guess the others will help him, but... you know how Frodo gets. He’s gloomy. And all the others... they tease Frodo, but secretly they’re as bad as him. They overthink things.”
Despite the seriousness in Pippin’s face, Merry had to snort with laughter at that. Of course Pippin’s biggest concern was that Frodo and the others would be sad, not their physical safety. (Although-- if what Merry feared about the Ring’s powers was right, perhaps he wasn’t too far off.) Still, Pippin could not be dissuaded by Merry’s mirth, and he continued morosely.
“And Bilbo and the others will be so mad at us, too.”
And there went Merry’s good spirits. Thorin’s ranting temper was legendary, and Fili and Kili could be quite vicious in their jokes. But it was Bilbo’s anger that everyone actually feared: a tirade, even if it went on for quite some time, would eventually be over, tricks could be painful or humiliating, but they were just unpleasant events. But a disappointed, chiding stare right into the depths of your heart? That stayed forever.
Still...
In the dark tower looming over them, a wizard of the highest order was seething powerlessly. Creatures so apathetic to the cares of the world they had passed into legend had changed the fate of the many, and made sure they would never be forgotten. And two little Hobbits who didn’t even have Dwarf relatives to rely on had caused all this.
“No. No, it is good like this.”
Some things were worth the wrath of Bilbo.
--*--*--
“Do you ever wish it had turned out differently?”
Next to Thorin, his husband was looking dispiritedly towards the horizon, where the masses of Orcs gathering to attack Erebor could just barely be seen. Gone were Bilbo’s impossibly steady hands and forever golden-brown curls that had been the cause of much envy amongst the other Hobbits his age; there was finally white blossoming at his temples and Thorin not certain that he even saw the distant Orcs.
The Dwarf didn’t know if Bilbo was talking about the soon-to-be demise of the Ring, or that all their children were off into parts unknown and dangerous, their family powerless to support them. And he didn’t know which question he was answering when he lifted Bilbo’s slightly shaking hand to his lips, kissed the palm and spoke.
“No. No, it is good like this.”
Perhaps both.
--*--*--
“Do you ever wish it had turned out differently?”
Boromir started at the question, and stumbled to a stop. He turned back to look at the young woman holding the sword he had just smuggled her. (Boromir honestly didn’t agree with Eowyn’s weary-of-life desire to fight and tumble into a violent death. But a violent death was likely coming for them all within the next few hours, and he was too practical not to let her attempt to delay it in any way she knew how.) Eowyn’s eyes were serious, full of a half-hidden despair, as she elaborated.
“Do you wish you had made some different choice, so that you did not end up here?”
There could only be one choice that she spoke of, even if she didn’t know she spoke of it. If Boromir had only had the strength of will to resist the Ring... Frodo would not have had to go into Mordor with only Sam as back-up; the Orcs could have been defeated and Merry and Pippin wouldn’t have had to suffer at their hands; Gandalf would not have awoken King Theoden only to have him lead his people, Legolas, Gimli, Aragorn, and Boromir into almost certain death.
And Boromir would not have gotten the promise of a king to return to his people.
A small smile lurking at the edge of his lips, Boromir turned to this shield-maiden-to-be, standing there so fierce and proud and with a wish for the impossible the likes of which he’d seen before only in his younger brother.
“No. No, it is good like this.”
He would make those words his oath, and do anything in his power to keep from being an oathbreaker a second time.
--*--*--
“Do you ever wish things had turned out differently?”
Kili cocked his head when he heard the strangely melancholy tone that had entered Fili’s voice. The further along the Anduin they travelled, the more Fili became convinced that their brother had run off into Mordor with only Sam to help him, on some stupid foolhardy whim. And Elrond’s request for the brothers to travel to some specific place in the Eastfold where they would supposedly meet the Fellowship did nothing to appease him.
Personally, Kili was absolutely sure Frodo had run off into Mordor with only Sam to help him, but, unlike his older brother, he trusted completely there was some reason in his madness. (People always underestimate the youngest in the family; Kili had spent decades in this position and could sympathize.)
“You mean if we had joined this fellowship of theirs instead of, or alongside Gimli? Could have been both Companions and Fellowshippers so that Gandalf doesn’t get too lonely...”
At the response, Fili rolled his eyes and sighed loudly, though without any real ire. It had been a long shot anyway: Kili rarely answered something seriously if a less somber (more interesting, as he would put it) answer was available. Still, the alternative was too tantalizing to resist...
“Might as well just make it a family trip completely and take along the old company too.”
“What was it Bilbo wants to call his book again? There and Back Again, right? And now this: There And Back Again, And Then Somewhere Else. Not quite as catchy, is it...”
“Perhaps not, but can you imagine us trying to sneak across Mordor with those old bastards?”
“Especially Oin-- do you think he can hear anything at all anymore or is he just pretending he can out of vanity? EXCUSE ME WHAT ARE WE DOING WITH THIS RING AGAIN? The Eye would be drawn to us immediately!”
“Ah, but you have to admit, Oin would be nowhere near as Eye-catching as Bilbo and Thorin’s combined rage at everyone’s inability to be stealthy. We’d leave a wide trail of plants wilting at the sheer anger that would come off of them like steam...”
“True, true...”
The Dwarves chuckled at their own foolishness. But finally Kili sobered up and he grinned fiercely at his brother as he answered the original question.
“No. No, it is good like this.”
Unfortunately, at some point even the littlest brothers have to be allowed to grow up.
--*--*--
“Do you ever wish it had turned out differently?”
Sam took in Frodo, his eyes still glassy from spider poison, his body shaking and covered in bruises from the Orcs’ treatment, and his eyes, shadowed and half-dead from the weight of the Ring. He answered truthfully.
“No. No, it is good like this.”
Because it was.
