Chapter Text
The name had started out mostly as a joke between Will and Beverly. He had told her about the spot in the ocean where Great White Sharks seemed to gather periodically for a reason no one had been able to properly identify yet. She had joked that it would be a clever name for an actual Café, and that something along the lines of nominative determinism would make it so eventually the clientele would all be criminals.
Little had she known at the time, but she was really onto something.
When Will had opened the Café, nothing out of the ordinary had shown up for a few weeks.
The first killer had walked in on a slow morning, glowering at the world like it had personally offended him for the last time. Will could tell the man was one wrong word away from deciding to kill the first person that talked to him, but Will had a trick up his sleeve.
“What can I do for you this morning?” Will had asked, grinning brightly, “White Shark Café has something for everyone’s unique tastes, be they predator or prey.”
The man had frowned curiously at Will for that, clearly trying to figure out if he knew something. Will only smiled, though he wanted it to be clear he was a friend and not a threat.
“What would you recommend?” the man asked, glancing at Will's name tag, “Will?”
Will looked the man over, letting himself step into his head for a moment.
“A Short Blonde,” he said after a moment, flashing another smile, “Seems like your type. I think you’d also appreciate one of our gunshots, which is just a jelly donut. Do those sound good to you?”
The man looked at Will in wonder, barely concealed fear, and even more confusion.
“Sure,” he said hesitantly.
Will nodded and rang it up, telling the man his total.
“No need to worry, sir,” Will assured him, “White Shark is privately owned, and I have no intention of getting mixed up in any official business.”
Will set the coffee and the donut on the counter and forced eye contact with the man.
“Understand?” he prodded.
The man slowly smiled, nodding slightly.
“Yeah. I think I do,” he said, “Thank you, Will.”
Will nodded in return.
“Be careful out there,” He warned as the man walked to a table, “and don’t get me mixed up in anything either.”
The man grinned and nodded, agreement enough for both of them.
---
The second time a killer had shown up, Will had almost not noticed. He had been tired, and wasn’t feeling sociable.
The woman was acting a bit jumpy, and stared at Will as if he might lunge at her at any moment.
Will greeted her with what had become his habitual tagline for the café.
“White Shark Café has something for everyone’s unique tastes, be they predator or prey.”
The woman startled at the words, and her eyes widened with horror as she stared at him.
That was when Will let himself read her, and he nodded softly.
“You look like you need a ‘He Had It Coming’, and one of our ‘Warm Hugs’,” he said, pointing to the items on the menu, “A warm hug is just a chocolate croissant. Do those sound alright?”
The woman nodded, her eyes glistening with tears that were both relieved and afraid.
“How do you-” she began.
“I can see you more clearly than most,” Will said gently, “and I know how to mind my own business. I wouldn’t have even brought it up, but you needed someone to understand. Be careful out there.”
The woman nodded, thanking him tearfully as she walked out.
After that, it was as if there was some sort of community of killers, and they regularly talked with each other, because they started showing up almost every day. After only a few weeks, Will had a regular clientele of killers. He didn’t know any of their names, knowing better than to ask. A few of them had given him aliases, or he had overheard them when they spoke to another customer, so he at least had a name to call them by.
Will just kept his head down, being polite to them all and being sure to show understanding whenever he could see that one of them had recently killed or was about to.
Despite the nature of his customers, Will found it to be a surprisingly comfortable community atmosphere. No one in the café was truly who they said they were, but they all understood that they were among like minds. They were in no danger.
Will had only had to break up one fight, and then it was an unspoken rule among the customers that no one was allowed to cause a disruption in White Shark.
Will ended up hiring a girl whose father had been a client. Her father had been caught and killed, and she was left alone. Will knew Abigail shared some of her father’s tendencies, but he figured that would make her the perfect employee for the café. He made sure she understood the exact nature of their customer pool, and what would be expected of her. She had readily agreed, happy to find a community like it after being rejected by more polite society.
Will had initially worried about bringing a young girl into a den of monsters such as he had built, but the general consensus came soon enough, and every regular treated Abigail like family. They were polite, friendly, and offered(subtly as well as not-so subtly) to take care of anyone who gave her trouble.
Will was actually really enjoying running the café like this. The customers considered it a safe haven, and they were willing to protect it with their lives.
Will was happy, and everything was going smoothly.
Until the Chesapeake Ripper walked through his door.
