Chapter 1: Serendipity
Chapter Text
The name had started out mostly as a joke between Will and Beverly. He had told her about the spot in the ocean where Great White Sharks seemed to gather periodically for a reason no one had been able to properly identify yet. She had joked that it would be a clever name for an actual Café, and that something along the lines of nominative determinism would make it so eventually the clientele would all be criminals.
Little had she known at the time, but she was really onto something.
When Will had opened the Café, nothing out of the ordinary had shown up for a few weeks.
The first killer had walked in on a slow morning, glowering at the world like it had personally offended him for the last time. Will could tell the man was one wrong word away from deciding to kill the first person that talked to him, but Will had a trick up his sleeve.
“What can I do for you this morning?” Will had asked, grinning brightly, “White Shark Café has something for everyone’s unique tastes, be they predator or prey.”
The man had frowned curiously at Will for that, clearly trying to figure out if he knew something. Will only smiled, though he wanted it to be clear he was a friend and not a threat.
“What would you recommend?” the man asked, glancing at Will's name tag, “Will?”
Will looked the man over, letting himself step into his head for a moment.
“A Short Blonde,” he said after a moment, flashing another smile, “Seems like your type. I think you’d also appreciate one of our gunshots, which is just a jelly donut. Do those sound good to you?”
The man looked at Will in wonder, barely concealed fear, and even more confusion.
“Sure,” he said hesitantly.
Will nodded and rang it up, telling the man his total.
“No need to worry, sir,” Will assured him, “White Shark is privately owned, and I have no intention of getting mixed up in any official business.”
Will set the coffee and the donut on the counter and forced eye contact with the man.
“Understand?” he prodded.
The man slowly smiled, nodding slightly.
“Yeah. I think I do,” he said, “Thank you, Will.”
Will nodded in return.
“Be careful out there,” He warned as the man walked to a table, “and don’t get me mixed up in anything either.”
The man grinned and nodded, agreement enough for both of them.
---
The second time a killer had shown up, Will had almost not noticed. He had been tired, and wasn’t feeling sociable.
The woman was acting a bit jumpy, and stared at Will as if he might lunge at her at any moment.
Will greeted her with what had become his habitual tagline for the café.
“White Shark Café has something for everyone’s unique tastes, be they predator or prey.”
The woman startled at the words, and her eyes widened with horror as she stared at him.
That was when Will let himself read her, and he nodded softly.
“You look like you need a ‘He Had It Coming’, and one of our ‘Warm Hugs’,” he said, pointing to the items on the menu, “A warm hug is just a chocolate croissant. Do those sound alright?”
The woman nodded, her eyes glistening with tears that were both relieved and afraid.
“How do you-” she began.
“I can see you more clearly than most,” Will said gently, “and I know how to mind my own business. I wouldn’t have even brought it up, but you needed someone to understand. Be careful out there.”
The woman nodded, thanking him tearfully as she walked out.
After that, it was as if there was some sort of community of killers, and they regularly talked with each other, because they started showing up almost every day. After only a few weeks, Will had a regular clientele of killers. He didn’t know any of their names, knowing better than to ask. A few of them had given him aliases, or he had overheard them when they spoke to another customer, so he at least had a name to call them by.
Will just kept his head down, being polite to them all and being sure to show understanding whenever he could see that one of them had recently killed or was about to.
Despite the nature of his customers, Will found it to be a surprisingly comfortable community atmosphere. No one in the café was truly who they said they were, but they all understood that they were among like minds. They were in no danger.
Will had only had to break up one fight, and then it was an unspoken rule among the customers that no one was allowed to cause a disruption in White Shark.
Will ended up hiring a girl whose father had been a client. Her father had been caught and killed, and she was left alone. Will knew Abigail shared some of her father’s tendencies, but he figured that would make her the perfect employee for the café. He made sure she understood the exact nature of their customer pool, and what would be expected of her. She had readily agreed, happy to find a community like it after being rejected by more polite society.
Will had initially worried about bringing a young girl into a den of monsters such as he had built, but the general consensus came soon enough, and every regular treated Abigail like family. They were polite, friendly, and offered(subtly as well as not-so subtly) to take care of anyone who gave her trouble.
Will was actually really enjoying running the café like this. The customers considered it a safe haven, and they were willing to protect it with their lives.
Will was happy, and everything was going smoothly.
Until the Chesapeake Ripper walked through his door.
Chapter Text
Will felt an involuntary chill run down his spine when the man walked in for the first time.
Burgundy eyes scanned over the entirety of the café before the tall man strode up to the counter. He was wearing a window pane suit that should have been ridiculous. Will found that it actually managed to soften his appearance, probably helping him to appear less threatening to people who didn’t know what he was.
Will saw Jeff come in right after, and worried a bit that they would be standing near each other in line.
“White Shark Café has something for everyone’s unique tastes, be they predator or prey,” Will said to the Chesapeake Ripper, smiling politely, but not overly friendly. He didn’t want to annoy the man. “What can I get for you this morning?”
The man studied him carefully for a moment, as if stripping him bare and learning his soul. It made Will want to squirm, but he just held eye contact, showing the man he was not afraid.
“I have heard that you are quite adept at guessing what your customers would enjoy,” the man said, his voice smooth and accented, “why don’t you give it a try on me?”
It was a test. Will could tell. He was trying to find out what Will could really see.
Will huffed a soft laugh and turned the menu so it was visible to both of them.
“I think an artist's blood and a cannibal crown would be to your taste,” Will said, smiling coyly and raising his eyebrows expectantly.
The Ripper looked at Will with thinly veiled fascination. He didn’t seem concerned that Will had been able to see him. He turned and read the descriptions of the items Will had pointed out, nodding in consideration.
“They sound acceptable. I must warn you that my tastes are very refined,” the man said, seeming amused.
Will shrugged.
“I figured. Abigail will make that for you if you’ll just stand over here so I can get the next order.”
Will nodded at Abigail and handed her the ticket. He had made a note for her to be extra polite with the man, because Will didn’t want to have her earn a place on his list of future meals.
The man did as Will bid him to, letting Jeff walk up to the counter next. Will saw Jeff cast some dubious glances at the Ripper, but he didn’t say anything.
“Your usual, Jeff?” Will asked, already writing the order down. Jeff always had the same thing.
“Sure thing, Will,” Jeff said happily, “You been reading the news lately?”
Will shrugged, huffing a soft laugh. Jeff really liked for his kills to get into the news, and he always asked Will about it if he thought the article was particularly good.
“Not much,” Will replied, “You know I’m busy baking and running the café all the time. If it wasn’t on the tv, I didn’t see it.”
Jeff nodded, though he did look a little disappointed.
“Fair enough. Has Abs applied to any colleges yet?” Jeff continued.
Will smiled, glancing over to where Abigail was talking pleasantly with the Chesapeake Ripper. The man seemed to be satisfied with her service, which was a relief for Will.
“Not yet. She wants to be sure she has enough saved up for tuition. She’s thinking of going into psychology.”
Jeff grinned, accepting his coffee and pastry.
“Well, I’ll leave a big tip as long as you promise she’ll get it,” Jeff said, “She’ll be a great student when she goes. I’ll just be sad I won’t see her anymore.”
Will nodded.
“I think we’ll all be sad to see her go, but she already promised me she’ll visit after she leaves. Have a good day, Jeff, and be careful out there.”
Jeff saluted smartly and turned to take a seat at a table with a few other regulars.
“Are you certain you are old enough to be employed here?”
Jeff and Will both froze upon hearing the Ripper ask Abigail that. Will stared at Jeff, knowing he was going to react poorly.
“Hey, new guy,” Jeff said, walking right up to the Ripper with a scowl, “Abs is nineteen, and Will doesn’t serve alcohol. She’s saving up to go to college, and you’d better not give her any grief.”
The Ripper turned, annoyance flickering over his features as he studied Jeff.
“I did not mean any harm by the comment. I was simply concerned for her mental health, as it can be hard on young people to work,” the man said smoothly and calmly, “are you very well acquainted with her?”
The insinuation wasn’t lost on Jeff, and Will could see a few other heads turning their way. He would have a riot soon if he didn’t settle this. They were all willing to get kicked out if it meant they could defend Abigail.
“No harm meant, and no harm done,” Will cut in, motioning for Jeff to hold his tongue, “my apologies, sir. The regulars are very friendly with both Abigail and I. They can get a bit defensive if they feel one of us has been snubbed or anything. Please don’t mind Jeff.”
Will made hard eye contact with the Ripper, then. He wanted his full meaning to get through. The man had better not kill Jeff for this, because Jeff just didn’t know who he was messing with. He didn’t know the shark he was taunting had bigger teeth.
“Very well,” the Ripper said, then turned to Jeff, “I apologize. I hope you do not hold this against me. As you have said, I am new to this café, and it seems there is a unique atmosphere I have not been privy to as of yet.”
Jeff narrowed his eyes at the man, but glanced to Will for confirmation. Will nodded solemnly.
“Fine,” Jeff said, “just don’t give Will or Abs any trouble. Plenty of us are willing to help them out if they ever need anything.”
The Ripper nodded. Jeff cast one more glance to Will, as if giving him a chance to rescind his request for peace. Will only smiled politely, and Jeff headed to his seat. The Ripper watched Will for a moment, in which Will just continued with his usual activities, arranging the pastries in the display and taking inventory to make sure they weren’t low on anything. Abigail headed into the back to check on the pastries that were still in the oven, and eventually the Ripper walked away and found himself a window seat in the café.
Will felt his entire body relax once he was no longer trapped in the man’s gaze. He saw that the rest of the customers weren’t welcoming him in the way they normally did with a new guy. They kept their distance, maybe sensing he was a different caliber, or maybe trying to be unfriendly to make him not come back.
Will wasn’t sure he wanted the Ripper to come back, but he sure as hell didn’t want the Ripper to hold anything against anyone associated with the Cafe. A dispute like that could draw attention, putting the customers at risk of being caught, and, by extent, putting Will out of business when it was no longer safe.
Abigail came back out with a tray of fresh croissants, and she smiled at Will.
“Hey, you good? What’s with the new guy?” she asked.
Will shrugged.
“Just don’t get on his bad side. I don’t know if he’ll be a regular, especially after all that, but no matter where you see him, don’t be rude. He’s got a thing about rudeness. I hope to god he doesn’t hurt Jeff,” Will said, aggressively taking a bite out of one of the croissants.
Abigail laughed lightly, though Will could tell she was also worried.
“Do you even know why you call him Jeff?” she asked teasingly.
Will raised an eyebrow.
“Because that’s what he said for me to call him?” he said, prodding Abs to just get on with whatever she was about to say.
“Well, duh, there’s that,” she said, “but he’s a total creepypasta fan.”
Will frowned.
“Is there a creepypasta about a guy named Jeff?” he asked.
Will knew vaguely what creepypastas were, but he had never felt the inclination to read any, or listen to the narrations Abigail enjoyed.
Abigail laughed.
“Just about the most popular one,” she said, “Jeff the killer. He’s a huge thing in the community. Everyone knows about Jeff.”
Will chuckled.
“Ah, so Jeff figured out I know he’s a killer, and named himself accordingly. Clever of him,” Will said.
Abigail nodded.
“He’s got at least that,” she said, “even though he might not be the sharpest knife in the block. He’s at least got that.”
Will huffed a laugh and handed Abigail the tip Jeff had insisted on getting to her.
“He wanted this to go towards your college fund, so make sure to thank him and then actually get into a college, Abs,” Will said.
Abigail grinned and slipped the money into her pocket. She started setting the croissants into the display where the others had been getting low, and she shot Jeff a wide grin when he glanced over.
Will would protect Abigail with his life, but he was glad he had so many dangerous people behind him if that ever became necessary.
Notes:
I might not know a thing about coffee, but I know my horror. Watch out for a ton more references just as obvious as Jeff here XD I'm not pulling any punches.
Chapter 3: Titles
Summary:
Iliad conversations, because they are a hannigram staple XD
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
“Hello, Will.”
Will recognized that voice, and he made sure to smile politely as he looked up to meet the burgundy eyes of the Chesapeake Ripper once more.
“Good afternoon, sir,” Will replied pleasantly, “what can I do for you today?”
The man had come in at a time when very few customers were around. Most of the regulars had jobs, or at least lives, and came by for a while in the mornings or evenings, but the middle of the day was typically slow for the café. Abigail was taking her lunch break, and had walked down the block to a sandwich shop.
The Ripper looked Will over once before speaking again.
“You are a peculiar man, Will,” he said, not making it sound like an insult, but certainly not meaning it as a compliment either, “I can’t but wonder how you have managed to gain such an influence over so many of your customers.”
Will huffed a soft laugh and shrugged.
“Everyone wants to be understood and accepted,” Will said, taking a sip of his own coffee, though it was cold, “and I offer understanding and acceptance. My customers are safe when they are here. I might know dangerous things about them, but they all know I don’t intend to cause them any trouble. They return the favor, by not causing trouble for my shop, and by dealing with anyone who would. That’s why they almost chased you out the other day. They thought you were likely to make trouble for me.”
The Ripper nodded thoughtfully.
“I suppose you are aware that the man you defended that morning is not named Jeff,” the man said.
Will shrugged again, leaning on the counter since it didn’t seem the man was about to order anything just yet.
“I don’t know the real names of any of the regulars,” Will said, “it’s better for all of us that way. You might want to give me an alias as well if you plan to come in more, since I can’t very well announce to them all exactly who you are.”
The man tipped his head curiously, the hint of a smile pulling at the corner of his mouth.
“And who am I, exactly?” he asked.
Will raised an eyebrow.
“You’re the Chesapeake Ripper,” he said.
The Ripper huffed his own laugh, looking at Will with open fascination now. He didn’t feel the need to hide it.
“I can only wonder how you find such things out about your customers,” he said.
Will nodded.
“It’s just something I’ve always been able to do. I don’t know why exactly all my customers happened to end up being this particular brand of odd, but I suppose I don’t care that much. I guess they all just want to be seen, and I can do that for them.”
The Ripper hummed in consideration.
“What name would you give me for this alias?” he asked, his voice smooth and curious.
Will looked the man over, taking in every detail and processing it to come up with something appropriate.
“Order something and I’ll answer,” Will said at last, standing up fully and stretching a bit.
The Ripper smiled and made his order. Will prepared his drink and wrote the name on the cup like all the other coffee shops did. He had never done it with his usual type of customer, because he didn’t know their names and he was never busy enough to make it necessary for them to be away from the counter while it was being prepared. He just thought this was an interesting game, and he had the feeling the Ripper would appreciate the gesture.
“Here you go, sir,” Will said as he handed the drink to the Ripper.
The man lifted the cup and read what Will had written, smiling before he nodded to Will and headed out of the café once more.
Will could tell he was impressed with the decision Will had made, and it gave him an inexplicable thrill to have pleased such a man. The Chesapeake Ripper was pleased with the name Will had bestowed upon him.
Achilles.
---
“What motivated you to choose such a name for me?” Achilles asked, standing at the counter, to the side so others could order as he spoke with Will, “Are you implying I may have some grand weakness?”
Will scoffed, quickly making a drink and handing it off to Carrie. She thanked him, though she cast curious glances at Achilles the entire time. Carrie had taken her name from the Stephen King work, being a horror fan.
Will wondered if all his regulars would be horror fans, or if it was just a popular thing among killers and not expected.
“Nothing so banal as that,” Will said, “it has more to do with the duality of your fate. You could live an easy life forever without drawing any attention, but you enjoy the novelty of being so singular in your craft that you will be remembered for many years to come. If you fall, it will be because of this decision to be known.”
Achilles hummed thoughtfully at that, watching with open amusement as Will refilled some of the machines and took the next order. Will wasn’t sure why the man was so interested in him, but he didn’t mind the conversation as much as he had expected to.
“Achilles was capable of turning back and living an unremarkable life, until the moment he resolved to kill Hector,” he said, “do you believe I am still redeemable?”
Will raised an eyebrow.
“Whoever said you need redeeming?” he shot back, “but yes, you could still easily fade into the background and be safe, yet forgotten. I would venture to say the true weakness of Achilles was Patrocles.”
Achilles tipped his head curiously.
“And who might you be, should you be carried through the metaphor?” he asked.
Will frowned, considering that as he took care of the next customer.
“I suppose, for most of my regulars at least, I would be Odysseus,” he decided, “I offer advice and support, though I’m considered somewhat ‘other’ by the majority of them.”
Achilles huffed a soft laugh at that, seeming amused by Will’s answer.
“Odysseus was a man of great wisdom and influence, though markedly not the most skilled warrior when compared to one such as Achilles. He was highly favored by Athena as well as the men he fought alongside. For perhaps anyone else, I would consider them vain for even comparing themselves to such a man.”
Will looked at Achilles, reading his face carefully.
Achilles didn’t seem to be upset, but all of his emotions seemed more subdued than most of the regulars.
“But not me?” Will asked.
Achilles turned and surveyed the building full of domesticated serial killers, eyes shining with some warm fondness.
“No. Not you,” Achilles said sincerely, “I believe you have a unique ability, and that it allows you to influence others effectively to create the atmosphere you want.”
Will hummed, placing a pastry down in front of Achilles despite him not having asked for anything.
“And what might that unique ability be?” he asked, propping his chin in his hand to look up at Achilles. Achilles smiled at his pastry and leaned forward a bit, meeting Will’s eyes.
“That, perhaps, is where you may be less like Odysseus,” he said, “Patrocles is the man described by his empathy. He essentially became Achilles on the battlefield, fighting because he could not stand by as so many suffered.”
Will nodded in consideration.
“You might want to be more careful, Achilles,” he warned, “or I might just start finding you interesting, and then I’ll end up figuring out your real name.”
Will turned and started on another customer who had walked up. Achilles smiled and took a bite of his pastry.
“You already know two names for me that reflect who I am better than any legally given name does,” he said, “how much do I owe you for this?”
Will waved him off about the pastry, grinning and finishing up with the customer.
“No charge other than pleasant conversation,” Will said, “I don’t get many who just come in to talk with me.”
Achilles took another bite of his pastry, his eyes glittering pleasantly.
“How unfortunate for them,” he said.
Will smiled to himself as Achilles went to find a seat.
Notes:
Me: *trying to think of pastry names and ending up just saying "pastry" anyway* Sorry <3
Chapter Text
“Will, I don’t want to shock you,” Abigail said, “but Mr. Achilles has the hots for you.”
Will spluttered, trying not to choke on his coffee.
It was after hours, and they were just cleaning up and preparing pastries for the next day, so Will didn’t have to worry about any customers overhearing, but that didn’t stop him from looking around to be sure they were alone.
“What the hell , Abs?” Will demanded, scowling at her as she measured out some butter.
“It’s just the truth,” she said with a shrug, “you think he comes here for the coffee? He only orders half the time. He compared you to Patrocles after you named him Achilles. The Ancient gays ? For someone so smart most of the time, you can be really dumb sometimes.”
Will knew he was red and he tried to hide it behind his cup as he took another drink of his coffee.
“I could fire you, you know,” Will said half-heartedly.
Abigail laughed, dumping some flour into the mixing bowl.
“Only if you want to have a hoard of serial killers after you,” she said, “they like me more than you.”
Will laughed at the tease, shaking his head.
“Sorry to break it to you, but they were all coming here long before I hired you. They wouldn’t touch me,” he shot back.
Abigail shrugged.
“But they sure wouldn’t be happy with you,” she pointed out, “so I guess you could take that chance and see.”
Will huffed a laugh and shook his head.
He wouldn’t fire her. They both knew that. He also didn’t really want to test the loyalty of his customers. As much as they valued his services, they were a group not notorious for forgiveness.
“Also, if you don’t like the idea of Mr. Achilles, I’d stop flirting with him if I were you,” Abigail said with a grin.
“I’m not !” Will said, scoffing at her.
Abigail shook her head.
“You give him free food and bat your eyelashes at him,” she said, leaning on the counter as if to mimic him, “ No charge other than pleasant conversation, big strong ancient gay man. ”
“That is not what I sound like, and I do not bat my eyelashes,” Will objected, swatting her with a hand towel, “and it’s not wrong to have friends. You should try it sometime.”
Abigail stuck her tongue out at him as she tasted the dough she was mixing, checking to see if it had been made correctly.
“I have friends,” she said casually, “and most of them aren’t even serial killers. Can you say the same?”
Will humphed at her, but didn’t otherwise answer. They both knew he didn’t have friends outside the café other than Beverly. His one normal friend, and she was a computer tech for a big security company. They didn’t talk much, and Beverly didn’t know the reality of what the café had turned in to.
“What makes you think Achilles would be interested in me, anyway?” Will asked, curious despite himself.
Abigail smirked.
“Ever heard of mirroring?” she asked.
Will’s expression must have communicated just how silly of a question that was, because Abigail just shrugged and continued talking.
“When someone likes someone else, they tend to mirror their movements, either consciously or not. You lean on the counter, Achilles leans forward to match you. You smile, he smiles. He tries not to get caught doing it, so he’ll turn away sometimes and look somewhere else, but he always turns back quick. He can’t help but stare at you too. He has eyes for nothing else in the world but you, Will. God , you can be so dense.”
Will was actually considering this now. He hadn’t noticed the mirroring, but thinking back he realized they did often end up with the same position or posture. He almost always felt Achilles’ eyes on him too.
Damnit. Did Achilles actually like him?
“Not to mention, he doesn’t exactly make friends with the other regulars,” Abigail continued, rolling out dough as she spoke, “he rarely even sits down in the café anymore. He just stands by the counter to talk to you. When he does sit, he sits alone and just stares at you the entire time. That’s textbook infatuation right there.”
“Alright, I get it,” Will said, stopping her from going any further and making him have a crisis, “I’ll try to be a little more aware from now on. God. You’re like a child sometimes.”
Abigail pouted.
“I’m an adult ,” she complained.
Will huffed a laugh.
“Still a teenager, though,” he reminded her.
“For one month!” she objected, putting her hands on her hips and getting flour all over her clothes, “you’re worse than Norman!”
Will grinned.
“Who’s Norman ?” he asked sweetly.
“Ugh. You’re more of a child than I ever was,” Abigail said, throwing a handful of flour at him and getting it all over his clothes as well, “I want to start dating him, but I just need to convince him he wants that too.”
Will laughed.
“Well, he’d better watch out. You’ve got a thing for psychology.”
Abigail stuck her tongue out at him.
---
“Good morning, Will.”
Will smiled, though he felt a pang of panic at hearing the voice again after Abigail literally spelling it all out for him.
“‘Morning, Achilles. What can I get for you today?” he said.
The other regulars had taken to leaving Achilles alone after Will had started referring to him by the name. It was like a rite of passage, where having an alias meant you were allowed to visit the café in peace. Will hadn’t noticed that before this man.
Achilles hummed pleasantly, his eyes drawing over Will’s face fondly.
“I would like to have what you first gave me, if you can recall what it was,” he said.
A clear challenge, and one Will was well equipped for. He had a fabulously good memory.
“One Artist’s Blood, and one Cannibal Crown coming up,” he said with a wink, turning to get them for the man.
Oh god. Had he just flirted with Achilles? He hadn’t thought about it first. He had just acted how they usually acted with each other. Were they usually flirting with each other? Was that what this was?
Will turned back around, knowing his face was a complete blushing mess, and put the cup and the pastry down on the counter for Achilles. The man smiled warmly, as he always did, and Will felt a flutter in his chest.
“Thank you, Will,” Achilles said, taking some cash from his pocket and holding it out.
When Will took the money, Achilles grabbed his hand. He didn’t pull sharply, yanking Will towards him, as Will expected. Instead, he just held on, waiting for Will to look up at him.
Will finally looked up, meeting his eyes, and the man tipped his head curiously.
“Is there something wrong, Will?” Achilles asked, his thumb tracing over Will’s knuckles absently, he actually looked concerned.
Will swallowed and shook his head.
“No, sir ,” Will said, tensing a bit and feeling his face heat up even more, “Be careful out there.”
Achilles blinked, then looked down at where their hands were joined. He traced his thumb over Will’s knuckles again, more slowly and deliberately, then lifted it and pressed a kiss where his thumb had gone.
“Will Graham,” Achilles whispered, “I hope you do not fear me, but know this: you will be mine .”
And with that, he was gone. Will was left, holding the cash in his hand, his face blank and flushed. Achilles was gone so fast Will didn’t have time to process what had happened.
Notes:
I'm going to be updating a bit more sporadically for a while. I'm hoping to get a new job, and then I'm moving, so I'm going to be pretty busy. I'll update as often as I'm able, and I'm posting the first chapter of a few fics I've been working on.
<3
Chapter Text
When Abigail walked into the kitchen and saw Will with his back against the counter, a bottle of whiskey in his hand, she knew something was up. She came over and sat opposite him, watching him expectantly until he finally spoke.
“You know, you were right,” Will said, taking another swig from the bottle, “Achilles has it out for me. I just don’t know if it’s in the way we thought.”
Abigail raised her eyebrows and reached for the bottle, but Will pulled it away.
“Nope. Not gonna happen,” he said, “you’re not even almost there. You’ve still got a year to go before that’s legal. This is mine.”
Abigail pouted, but she let it go.
“Okay, so are you saying he might be thinking of taking you out in the not dinner-and-kissing way?” she asked.
Will shrugged.
“Hey, maybe they're the same thing for him,” he said, then stopped, “No. Forget I said that. They aren’t. Not for him. He’s not that kind of killer.”
Abigail watched him for another moment.
“So, you can figure out what kind of killer this guy is just by talking a few times, but you can’t figure out if he’s flirting or threatening?” she asked.
Will huffed.
“I don’t think he’s used to being in a situation where he can be himself with someone,” he said, “so he’s not acting the same around me as he would with someone he’s planning on dating or killing. I have no reference point or contrast.”
Abigail hummed at that, tipping her head back so it tapped the wall.
“Well, you’re in a real jam, aren’t you?” she asked, “at least you have all our regs behind you if he tries anything.”
Will shook his head.
“That won’t do any good,” he said, “if he kills me, not only will there be no evidence it was him, he would easily take out anyone who went after him. Jeff, Carrie, Jason, Freddy. None of them would stand a chance against him. Even if they all went at him together, I don’t know who would come out the other side. If he decides to kill me, there’s no stopping him.”
Abigail looked down at her hands, fidgeting nervously. Will could tell she was worried for him, and that she was afraid. He hadn’t meant to frighten her, but he wanted her to be aware of the situation.
“So let’s just hope he’s going for the dinner and kissing way,” Will said, earning a laugh from Abigail.
“Will, please be safe,” Abigail said quietly, hugging her knees to her chest, “I don’t have a home to come back to anymore. Once I go to college, I don’t have parents to visit on the weekends or for holidays. I don’t have a place to come when I have a hard day. You’re that for me now. You and the café, and all those stupid killers that hang out here. This is my family, and my home. I couldn’t stand to lose all of this too.”
Will put down the whiskey and moved over to hug Abigail. She had never confessed all that to him before, though he had figured it out. Abigail had lost everything when her father had been caught. He had killed her mom right in front of her, and had almost killed her too. She didn’t have a family aside from this.
“I know, Abs,” he said, pulling her close and setting his chin on top of her hair, “I know. I’ll do my best. I just want you to be safe and happy. If anything happens to me, you get the shop, and I bet all the regs will make sure nothing threatens it. I want you to be sure that you’re going to be okay. Even if I’m not around someday, because we both know I’ll die sooner or later, I’m going to make sure you are taken care of.”
Will hadn’t told her before that he had made sure to make her his sole beneficiary if he died. He hadn’t expected it to come up, but he felt like he had to give her some reassurance in this moment. Let her know she wouldn’t be left with nothing. Not again. She would have somewhere to start this time, and people to help her.
He wasn’t her father, but he was going to do better than he had. Her father had left her with nothing but a tainted name and a tabloid journalist after her scent. Will wanted to give her something.
“Don’t leave me, Will,” she sobbed into his shoulder, “I won’t ever forgive you if you leave. Everyone always leaves.”
Will shushed her gently, stroking her hair to soothe her. He wanted to cry right along with her, because it all felt that way at times. His own parents had left him at a young age, and he hadn’t been able to make anything of himself until he started this café. She and him were the same. They were alone without each other, and adrift at sea without the café.
“Abigail, I can’t promise to be around forever, you know that,” Will said, fighting back the urge to promise the impossible, “but I’ll be strong for you, and I’ll fight for you, as long as you do the same for me. Be strong, and fight. Don’t ever let the world tell you what you should be, because you’re the only one who gets to decide that.”
Abigail continued to sob and sniff into his shoulder, and Will just held her.
It was cathartic to experience this with her, even though Will didn’t cry himself. Feeling her work through the pain and fear as he helped was as good as going through it all in his own heart.
Will did all the baking after Abigail went home that night.
---
“Hello, Will.”
Will looked up with a smile, meeting the dark brown eyes of someone who looked too young to be one of his usual kind of customers, but he saw the same hunger in the boy’s eyes.
“White shark has something for everyone’s unique tastes, be they predator or prey,” Will chirped back, “what can I do for you today?”
The boy tipped his head, reminding Will of a curious dog the way he did.
“What do you think?” the boy asked.
Will almost rolled his eyes, realizing this kid had come because he wanted Will to read him. Will looked him over before pointing to the menu.
“Two birds with one stone and a bear claw,” he said, “unless you’re more fresh than you look, in which case I would suggest a short blonde.”
The boy grinned, apparently giddy about being understood. Will almost wanted to step farther away from him, having grown used to the others being casually friendly.
“I don’t think I’m all that fresh,” the boy said with a smile, “so the first one sounds good to me. I don’t suppose you’re hiring, are you?”
Will paused in his work for a moment.
He did need more help, and he would need even more once Abigail left for college. He had actually been thinking about hiring someone, though he had been hesitant due to what the job was like. He couldn’t exactly advertise that he needed someone who could bake, make coffee, and sympathize with serial killers since that was the majority of their business.
But this kid was one of them . That might work out.
Will turned and set the order down on the counter.
“I just might be, but why do you ask?” Will said, smiling politely.
The kid handed over a card to pay unlike the usual cash the regs used to keep their anonymity.
“A friend of mine told me to ask, but they said to keep their name out of it, which I hear is sorta a theme in the café,” he said with a shrug, taking a sip of the coffee.
Will nodded, not sure who would have thought he needed fresh help, but knowing it could rightly be any of the regs.
“Alright. What do you know about coffee?” Will asked.
“I’m a connoisseur,” the boy shot back just as quickly, grinning widely, “and this is excellent, by the way.”
Will nodded, waving him down. The enthusiasm was a bit over the top for him.
“How about baking?” he shot back.
The boy shrugged.
“Give me a recipe and I’ll get it close the first time, if not perfect,” he replied casually.
Will nodded.
“And what exactly do you know about how this café is run? What did your friend tell you?”
This part was important, because Will refused to hire someone who was unaware who they would be dealing with on a daily basis.
The boy smiled and leaned in close, lowering his voice.
“Most of the customers are killers, and you keep that pretty lowkey so they keep coming back,” he said, “you don’t ask questions, and they don’t string you up over the café awning. Is that what you wanted to hear?”
Will rolled his eyes.
“Bit dramatic, but essentially yes. You can start tomorrow if that works, and I’ll run you through the motions at noon. That’s when we’re pretty slow, but still get customers. Perfect time for training. You in?”
The boy grinned even wider and stuck his hand out for a shake.
“That sounds good, sir. My name’s Billy, and I can’t wait to get started.”
Will shook his hand with a smile, hoping this was a sign that things were going to go well for a while at least. He didn’t want all this drama in his life. He just wanted to run a little café, and see Abigail go to college, and live his boring but peaceful life.
Life had other plans.
Notes:
Anybody recognize where Billy's from??? Probably. I'm not being overly subtle XD
(next chapter might make it more obvious, though)I'm trying to update whenever I can. Getting around to writing is a bit of a struggle at the moment, though.
<3
Chapter 6: Offerings
Chapter Text
Billy Loomis was right when he told Will he could get most recipes the first time. He wasn’t as good as Abigail, but everything he made was technically correct. He worked well, was cheery with the customers, and had a very dark sense of humor that amused them all.
He was also a huge horror movie buff, meaning he got right along with Carrie and the likes.
The regulars didn’t rally around Billy the same way they had with Abigail. Maybe it was because he was a killer. Maybe it was because he was a boy. Will didn’t really know, but he figured it didn’t matter. What mattered was that they didn’t hate the kid or feel the need to kill him.
“Sir,” Billy said, poking his head back into the kitchen where Will was working, “this guy says he wants to talk to you.”
Will cursed under his breath. He didn’t want to have to deal with any problems at the moment, but he knew Billy was hardly the person to let handle any sort of confrontation. The boy had a hot temper and sharp tongue that could come off as incredibly rude if you managed to irk him at all.
“Tell him I’ll only be half a tic, and then I’ll be out,” Will called back.
Billy nodded and went back to the counter.
Will finished what he was doing and headed up to the front of the store, trying to brush some of the flour off his clothes despite the futility of the effort. He looked nothing like a manager, much less a store owner, when he was such a mess, but whoever it was was going to get what they got anyway.
“Hello, Will,” Achilles said, smiling genially.
Will inwardly cursed even more aggressively than he just had, finding himself wanting to fidget and squirm like a child at the shoe store.
“Good morning, Achilles,” Will said politely, “What can I do for you?”
Will glanced at Billy, wondering if he had done something to upset the man, which would be bad news for multiple reasons.
“Are we no longer on speaking terms, or have I interrupted you in something?” Achilles asked, tipping his head curiously.
Will sighed.
“I just got done, so you’re in luck there, but I must ask if this is something important you want to talk about. I figured Billy could have made your coffee, and I thought you might want to get familiar with him too, since he’s new here,” Will said.
Most of that was just rubbish, because Will knew Achilles wasn’t interested in getting to know some kid who worked with Will. He clearly had come to talk to Will, and had been disappointed when he had been met by Billy’s bored expression instead. Will just wanted to get the man to say something that might shine a light on what he was really thinking.
“Nothing of too much importance, if I am keeping you from something,” Achilles replied carefully, looking Will up and down slowly, “but I did come with an offering.”
Achilles lifted up a small container of food, and Will felt his shoulders tense. He knew this man was not the regular kind of killer. He had guessed the first day that the man was a cannibal, but he hadn’t expected him to bring him any food.
It was a test .
The Chesapeake Ripper was testing Will, to see if he would accept an actual offering of flesh. There was clearly only one right answer in the man’s eyes, but the moral and ethical parts of Will’s mind argued about the reality of the situation and the implications of accepting such a gift.
“What is it?” Will asked, stepping forward with interest.
The man set the container on the counter and pulled the lid off, releasing an aroma of cooked meat and eggs into the air. Will confessed to himself that it was making his mouth water, and he hadn’t eaten anything substantial in days. He mostly lived off coffee and the pastries he made for the cafe. Real food sounded like heaven to him.
“A simple protein scramble,” Achilles answered, inching the container closer to Will as if to entice him further, “A good meal for the beginning of a day, and relatively portable, making it the ideal choice for me as an offering today.”
Will took another step toward the counter despite himself. He didn’t want to accept the food, seeing sausage in the mix that he was sure contained more than beef or pork. The increasingly prominent voice at the back of his skull insisted it was just meat, and he hadn’t killed the person, so he needn’t feel guilty about eating it. It would be consumed whether he accepted it or not. The only thing he could determine was if he would be well fed that day.
“What makes you feel as if you need to offer something?” Will asked, taking the container from Achilles and studying the contents.
It looked even better than it smelled, and Will was willing to bet it tasted even better than that. He wanted to eat it so badly, but he also wanted to feel disgusted by that.
“I was concerned I may have done something to upset you, reflecting back on our last conversation,” Achilles admitted, watching as Will studied the food, “and regardless, you often offer food to me, and I thought it was time I return the favor.”
Will hummed taking a deep breath and filling his lungs with the aromas coming off the food.
Oh this was sinful of him, he knew. He shouldn’t want anything this bad.
“Alright,” Will said at last, pulling a plastic fork from the cup on the counter, “but just this once. I don’t want the rest of the regs to think I play favorites.”
Will flashed a smile, hoping he wasn’t making the man feel uncomfortable or concerned.
Achilles smiled.
“Very well. Perhaps next time I wish to treat you I will simply ask you to dinner at my home,” he said.
Will felt his face heat up, and he took a bite of food to avoid being expected to have a response to that. It was obscenely delicious, and he wanted to hate Achilles for letting him know that. Human flesh should absolutely not be allowed to taste good if it was morally wrong to eat.
Billy flicked his gaze between the two of them, raising an eyebrow curiously. Will was not ready for this kind of attention, especially from some kid he didn’t even know.
“You can ask all you want,” Will replied, smiling as innocently as he could, “but convincing me to accept the invitation might be another battle altogether. Did you want a coffee this morning, or just came to see my face?”
Achilles blinked, apparently stunned at Will’s sudden change in attitude toward him.
Two could play at this game.
“Would you be averse to it if I had?” Achilles asked, tipping his head curiously, “If I came to your shop today for no reason other than to set eyes on you.”
Will huffed a laugh and took another bite of the food.
“Just this once,” Will said again, “I’ll let it slide. Buy something next time, and I’ll make sure to smile at you as you leave.”
Achilles smiled and gave a curt nod.
“Very well. It’s very prudent of you to set forward expectations at this point,” he said conspiratorially, “I look forward to our next meeting.”
With that, he turned to leave, but Will called after him.
“Don’t you want your dish back?” he asked.
Achilles shook his head lightly.
“Return it to me next time you see me,” he said simply, “I don’t expect to miss it before then.”
And he was gone again, leaving Will to wonder if he had made a mistake by poking at him. Will had mostly been hoping to keep on the man’s good side, without letting himself become boring to him. Will knew he could be dangerous to the man if he became boring, so it was better to keep his interest as long as he could, but he didn’t want to have Achilles become fixated on him.
He wasn’t sure any part of his plan was working.
“So, you and him a thing ?” Billy asked, tossing his hair from his face and smirking at Will.
Will sighed and shook his head.
“I’m not like our regulars, Billy,” he said, “and I don’t really want to get mixed up with any of it. I’m just trying not to get myself killed. You should try to stay on his good side too.”
Billy hummed in consideration.
“He a big player on the field?” he asked.
Will studied Billy for a moment, trying to decide what to say to that.
“Don’t get yourself killed,” is what he landed on, “it would bring too much attention to the café.”
Billy huffed a laugh and nodded, turning back to the register as Misery walked in. She tucked a lock of hair behind her ear as she looked up at Billy, and smiled. Will walked back to the kitchen, not really in the mood to watch her flirt with the boy.
Chapter 7: Plans
Chapter Text
“How are things going with that Norman kid?” Will asked, mixing some frosting for the cinnamon rolls that were in the oven.
Abigail pouted a bit.
“He’s twenty one, Will, so he’s not a kid and neither am I. And we’re going out on Saturday,” she said, “What about you and Achilles?”
Will smirked, knowing she was just deflecting. She was clever, especially when it came to psychology, but Will was better.
“If any alcohol becomes involved, I will not only find out, but there will be consequences,” he warned, “Just because he can legally drink and purchase it, doesn’t mean you’re allowed to join in. You still have a bit more than a year to go yet.”
Abigail huffed, but didn’t argue. She knew better than to question how he would find out, or his decisions regarding it. She could have argued that he wasn’t really her dad, but she knew that it would hurt him deeply, and she didn’t really mind following his rules as much as she made show of it.
“Alright,” she pouted, “but you didn’t answer my question. Any developments with Achilles?”
Will sighed, knowing there was no escaping her. She was stubborn and smart, and not easily dissuaded.
“He invited me over for dinner, sort of,” he admitted, “but I told him he needs to start buying things when he comes in.”
Abigail nodded in consideration.
“So, a date then?” she asked.
Will shrugged.
“From what I know about the man, the offer was as ambiguous as anything else he has said to me,” he replied.
“Ah,” Abigail said, “I guess so. What are you going to do about that?”
Will ran a hand over his face with a sigh.
“Well, I’ve given him reason to believe I don’t have anything wrong with his preferred diet,” he said, still feeling a bit guilty for having enjoyed the food.
Abigail tipped her head curiously, furrowing her brow.
“How did you do that?” she asked.
Will shrugged, but couldn’t bring himself to meet her eyes.
“He brought me breakfast,” he said softly.
Abigail gasped lightly, covering her mouth with her hand. Her eyes were wide and shocked, and she clearly hadn’t expected to hear that Will had accepted food that he knew would have been made out of human flesh.
Will hadn’t expected it to happen either. He had never once thought he would be in a position where he thought that was the best thing to do.
“And you ate it?” she asked.
Will nodded.
“I told you, I don’t want to give him any reason to be angry with me or something like that. I thought it was for the best. It’s not like I killed somebody.”
Abigail frowned, but nodded.
“That’s true. God knows I’ve done things like that before, to keep the peace in one way or another,” she said.
Will sighed.
He knew she had been in a bad situation with her father before he had died, and that he had been feeding his victims to his family. Will wasn’t sure if Abigail was aware of the full extent to which her father had been manipulating her, but he could tell she probably knew more than she was letting on. It was one of the things that made her perfect for the café.
“I hoped you would understand, even though I wish you didn’t,” he said.
Abigail shrugged.
“We don’t get to choose what happens to us in life,” she said, “just how we deal with it. So, how are you going to deal with this? He’s not going to wait for you forever.”
Will nodded.
“But he’s not going to give up, either,” he agreed, “I guess I’ll just have to accept his invitation and see what I can do. Maybe I can convince him to not kill me, or cause problems for the café.”
Abigail sighed and shook her head.
“Will, this is getting really dangerous,” she said, “If he lets you know his real identity, know where he lives, and personal things about him, then you will have to be even more careful about how you treat him. You won’t be allowed to betray him. You know all of this, right?”
Will groaned and ran a hand over his face. He knew all of it. He knew what accepting the invitation would mean for Achilles. He also knew it was his only option.
“I know,” Will agreed, “You have no idea how many things I know about this situation. I’ve been analyzing everything, and working over all eventualities to find the best solutions. I’ve been planning and re-planning everything. I want you to know that I’ll do whatever I can. I’m going to be as careful as possible.”
Abigail nodded, visibly steeling herself for whatever the future might bring. Will wished she didn’t have to go through hard things anymore. She would never have a regular life, but he wished she could.
“Well, I guess that makes my dating problems a bit inconsequential,” she said, huffing a laugh to lighten the mood.
Will shook his head.
“No matter what happens with Achilles, I’ll still track down this Norman kid if he does anything to you,” he vowed, “even if I’m a ghost. Don’t think I’ll forget about him just because I’m trying to not get murdered.”
Abigail laughed, shrugging as if to say “well, I tried”.
Will pulled the cinnamon rolls from the oven and moved them to a cooling rack. He made sure to keep his back turned as Abigail “snuck” a taste of the frosting.
---
“Good morning, Will,” Achilles all but purred as he stood at the counter.
Will managed a smile, though he was tired as all hell. He had been stressed about what he was going to do, and stress always led to nightmares for him. He hadn’t slept well.
“Morning, Achilles,” he said dully, “what can I do for you today?”
Achilles pursed his lips and studied Will for a moment, concern flickering over his features for a moment before vanishing like so much birthday candle smoke. He could obviously tell how tired Will was.
“I would like what has become my usual, unless you think something else is more suited to my taste today,” he said, sounding as if he had rehearsed it, but was unsure if he should follow the script now that he was faced with a clearly fatigued Will.
Will looked up at him, trying not to yawn. After a moment, he shrugged and pulled a pastry from the case and handed it to him. Achilles seemed surprised by that, and looked dubiously at the pastry before accepting it. Will watched him drowsily until Achilles took a tentative bite.
Achilles chewed slowly, considering the food.
“It’s delicious,” Achilles stated after he swallowed, “but I must ask, are you unwell?”
Will huffed a wry laugh and shook his head.
“Just sleep deprived,” he answered, “I didn’t sleep last night.”
The expression on Achilles’ face seemed to come to terms with the fact that he was concerned, allowing his brow to crease as he frowned.
“And yet you are here so early in the morning,” Achilles said, almost reprimanding him.
Will scoffed.
“It’s only seven,” he said, “I get here at four every morning to make sure everything is ready for opening. Here’s the total for the food and the drink, since I’m assuming you still want your usual coffee.”
Will slid the paper across the counter for Achilles to read as he motioned for Billy to start on the coffee. Achilles didn’t seem satisfied, but he offered exact change for the order.
“You should take better care of yourself, Will,” Achilles said, “whatever would we all do if something happened to you?”
Will rolled his eyes.
“Well, you would just find somewhere else to get your coffee and entertainment. I know this place isn’t even up to your usual standards. As for everyone else, there would be a bit of confusion for a while, but Abigail would be able to keep the place running long enough for a new order to get established. I have measures in place for the likelihood that something is going to happen to me someday. I don’t exactly run the safest business here.”
Will hadn’t meant to tell Achilles all of that, especially now. He had hoped to keep the threat of serial killer pandemonium dangling over his head for a bit longer, to discourage him from being the thing that happened to Will. Will hated when this kind of thing happened, because being sleep deprived always meant he spoke before really thinking about what he was saying. He was more honest when he was tired than when he was drunk.
Achilles sighed lightly, shaking his head.
“I had hoped to invite you to dinner, but I would not want you to feel I am taking advantage of your slightly vulnerable state of mind,” he said, “I can see you are not entirely capable of making an informed decision at the moment. I suppose that is everything today.”
Achilles picked up his coffee from the counter where Billy had set it as they talked, and started turning to leave, but Will caught his sleeve.
Achilles turned back, tipping his head curiously. Will stared at his own hand, knowing he had not told it to do that.
“Uh, you almost forgot the dish,” Will said eventually, tearing his hand away from Achilles’ sleeve and pulling the dish out from under the counter.
Will had washed it carefully and made sure to keep it by the register for when Achilles would come in. Now, he handed it back to the man, trying to shake away the fatigue clouding his mind. He had planned what he would do this morning when he saw Achilles. He had thought everything out, accounting for every possibility.
Apparently, his own exhaustion had not been something he could account for.
“Thank you,” Achilles said, looking at the dish with something akin to affection, “Perhaps I will have more luck tomorrow.”
Will smiled brightly, remembering his promise to smile at Achilles if he bought something.
“Dinner tomorrow sounds great,” he said, then paused, questioning who had been in charge of his tongue just then.
Achilles smiled and nodded.
“Very well. Thank you, Will. I will see you tomorrow.”
Chapter Text
Abigail noticed the stunned, slightly horrified expression on Will’s face the moment she walked through the door of the café. She raised her eyebrows and spread her hands in a gesture that asked “what the hell happened?”
Will sighed, rubbing at his eyes and some vain attempt to make them no longer want to shut. He had been drinking coffee like it was going out of style all morning, trying to stay awake, but he must have hit his limit somewhere along the way.
“Billy,” Will called, “man the front for a bit. Abs just got here.”
Billy came out, pulling his apron off and tossing it under the counter unceremoniously.
“Sure thing,” he said.
Will and Abigail made their way into the kitchen, where Will explained the predicament he was in.
When Will finished explaining how the morning had gone before she showed up, Abigail considered the situation silently.
“I guess it’s better to get it over with,” she said at length, “you were going to do this eventually, so the plan is still viable. It’s just a bit quicker than we thought. How are you feeling?”
She asked the last part as almost an afterthought, as if just remembering he may have been affected by it all already.
Will dropped his head in exhaustion. He honestly didn’t know how to answer that question. He was too tired to function properly, much less execute an elaborate plan to simultaneously satisfy a serial killer and protect the café.
Will actually felt his body slump into sleep, and he jolted awake before his muscles had the chance to fully relax and drop him onto the floor.
“My god, Will,” Abigail said, “go home and get some sleep. You’re no good to anyone half dead like that.”
Will smiled wryly.
“But I’d be some good if I was all dead?” he asked.
Abigail rolled her eyes.
“I’d prefer you not even close to dead,” she said, “but I could sell the shop and pay for college if you died, so I won’t say it would be all bad.”
Will sighed, putting a hand over his heart in a wounded gesture.
“I knew it,” he said, “you’re only nice to me for the money.”
Abigail shook her head, tying an apron around her waist.
“Go home. At least we can consider today a trial run in case you end up actually getting killed. We can make sure the place won’t burn to the ground without you.”
Will sighed again, but this time is was real. He was basically asleep on his feet, and he knew she was right about him not being any good in this state.
“Just promise you’ll call if there’s a problem,” he said, casting his most pitiful worried parent look at her.
“God, okay ,” Abigail said, throwing her hands up in the air, “you’re worse than my mom.”
Will grinned, heading out to the door of the café.
“I should hope so,” he called back.
---
“Good afternoon, Will,” Achilles said smoothly, though there was a slight hesitation in his words, as if he were worried how Will would react to him today.
“Hello, Achilles,” Will said with a smile, “What would you like today?”
Achilles seemed to relax a touch at Will’s friendly demeanor.
“I believe you gave me a Panzarotti on my last visit, correct?” he asked, seeming curious to see how Will would act after their previous interaction.
Will smirked.
“We like to call that one the “I’m better than you”, but we sometimes just call it the vanity,” he said, “I guess I thought it would be funny. Do you want another one?”
Achilles seemed slightly hurt by that revelation, though he was hiding it admirably. Will almost wanted to laugh aloud at the thought.
“Perhaps not,” Achilles said, clearly trying to play it off as merely wanting to try something new, “what would you recommend for me today?”
Will looked the man up and down, deciding that if Achilles did kill him at dinner that night, there were worse ways to go.
“Try the Chest Cavity on for size,” Will said, handing over a pastry heart, and writing a ticket for Abigail to make the coffee Achilles usually ordered, “It’s a mite sweeter than what you probably like, but maybe it’ll help with that sour look you’re giving me.”
Achilles blinked in surprise, his expression going blank for a moment. He had clearly not realized he had been making any “look” at all, especially regarding the pastry incident last time. He accepted the heart and took a bite as Will watched.
“You are correct that it is somewhat more sugary than what I prefer,” Achilles agreed, “though I still find it enjoyable.”
Will smiled and nodded.
“We don’t make anything that tastes terrible, here,” he said, “so anything is a safe bet for the most part, assuming you don’t have any food allergies. You would have warned me already if you did.”
Achilles nodded, and stepped to the side as another customer walked in.
It was Christine. She hadn’t been in for a while, but she had been one of the first regulars. She had been dubbed Christine after the Stephen King novel about a car.
Will could see why she had been given that name. She dressed in a sort of retro way, though she was certainly capable of pulling it off. She looked almost like a character from Grease. One who could easily beat you up. Will had figured out that she lured men to their deaths by convincing them she was one of those special girls who knew about cars.
And Will was glad she was back.
“Hey, Christine,” Will said pleasantly, “your usual today? I haven’t seen you around much.”
Christine popped her gum loudly, though she smiled at him and nodded.
“I’m surprised you remember my usual,” she said, her voice smooth and honey-like, “I was out of state for a while. Road trip.”
Will nodded, writing her ticket as well and handing it off to Billy. He knew what she meant by “road trip”, and he didn’t want to hear anything about it. He never wanted to know the details about what the regulars did. It was safer that way.
“Well it’s good to have you back. This is Achilles. He’s a new reg, but he’s not the most friendly. Maybe try to keep on his good side.”
Will said it with good humor, but made sure to let her know he was serious by the look in his eye. He didn’t want a repeat of the incident with Jeff.
Christine looked Achilles over, snapping her gum again.
“You must drive that Bentley,” she said.
Will raised his eyebrows, having not known that about Achilles yet. Achilles smiled, but there was no warmth in it. Not like when he smiled at Will.
“Indeed,” he said, “what an astute observation.”
Christine wasn’t buying the flattery, continuing to size Achilles up idly. Her green eyes scanned up and down his form as if he was a car, and she could just lift the hood to see what made him run.
“You’re just about the only guy here who would dare drive a car that makes you a target like that,” she explained bluntly, “you look like someone who would drive a Bentley.”
Achilles didn’t reply, simply watching her as she watched him, the air between them growing slowly colder.
“Here you go, Achilles,” Will said, thrusting the finally finished coffee out for him, “have a good day.”
Achilles took the cup, and a spark lit up his eyes as he smiled mischievously.
“Thank you, Will,” he said smoothly, “can I still expect your company tonight?”
Will gaped at the man, realizing Achilles was using him. Achilles was flaunting in front of Christine. He was showing off. “Look at this. I have a more intimate relationship with Will. Will, who never gets close to the regulars. He’s having dinner with me.”
After an awkward pause, in which Christine’s eyes hardened, Will swallowed.
“Yeah. I’ll be here,” he said weakly, knowing there was no way out of this.
Achilles smiled brightly, the warmth back.
“Wonderful. I’ll come to retrieve you. Until then, Will.”
Achilles nodded politely and strode out of the café, not bothering to glance back to see Christine’s reaction.
Christine was glaring at Will, though. He was sure she might just decide to kill him, despite the general truce among the customers.
“Are you mixed up in something you can’t handle?” she asked sternly.
Will smiled wryly. At least she seemed to be more concerned for him than angry at him.
“I think I can handle it just fine ,” he answered, “but I’ll let you know if I can’t.”
Christine nodded, looking unconvinced.
“I can take care of that guy in a cinch if you ever need it,” she said, “so just say the word, and I’ll do it.”
Will shook his head.
“Get in line,” he said, “I’m pretty sure Jeff is already sharpening his knives in preparation.”
And Christine laughed, and everything was better. She wasn’t upset, and Will didn’t feel like he was about to be killed. Abigail walked out from the back, and Christine’s eyes lit up.
“Hey, Abs,” she called, smiling brightly, being as charming as she could.
Abigail smiled and waved, grabbing a tray and returning to the back. Will rolled his eyes and shook his head.
“She’s going after a guy right now,” he told Christine, drawing her gaze and making her frown slightly, “so it’s no use.”
Christine shrugged.
“He won’t last,” she decided, “and there’s always a use in starting early.”
Will frowned.
“She’s young,” he warned.
Christine winked.
“So am I.”
Notes:
I am currently on a bit of a Stephen King kick, so be expecting more references like that. XD
Chapter 9: Precautions
Chapter Text
Achilles had insisted on driving Will to dinner, casting more suspicion and worry into Will’s mind. No one would be able to see and later identify his car in the area. If Achilles was going to kill him, that would make it much easier for him.
But Will tried not to think about that. He wanted to have faith that Achilles truly meant him no harm. If he played his cards right, he could get out of this alive.
The moment the man’s Bentley pulled up outside what could only be the house where he lived, Will sent the address and the license plate number to Abigail in case something were to happen to him.
Achilles eyed Will as he did it, but made no comment, only smiling some secret smile.
“I don’t expect that to stop you,” Will explained as he put his phone back into his pocket, “but if you do kill me, I’ll at least have caused you an inconvenience. I also don’t expect that you’ll get caught because I did that. I think you’re too smart for that. But you’ll have more than just the police after you if I don’t make it back to work tomorrow.”
Achilles’ smile never faltered, never wavered. If Will had to explain that smile, he would almost say that Achilles was thrilled . Thrilled that Will was still concerned about being killed, or thrilled that Will was being so petulant about it, Will wouldn’t have been able to say. He just knew there was some twisted glee in Achilles’ expression, and Will still didn’t know how much danger he was in.
The house where Achilles lived was grand, if not grandiose , and Will felt a dark sense of admiration for it. The interior was impeccably well kept, and the décor was just to this side of gothic horror. The man would be considered eccentric by most of his guests. Will thought he might be the first guest to know that the design was less out of morbid fascination, and more a dark, internal humor. It was as if all of it was an elaborate joke, which only Achilles was privy to.
And now Will.
“Please, allow me to take your coat,” Achilles said in the foyer, all chivalry and consideration.
Will shucked off his windbreaker, that he had only been wearing because of the slight drizzle outside. He wouldn’t deny that he also considered that it would be more evidence left behind if he were killed. He thought idly of the old movie, Rope, in which the final clue for identifying that the murder had occurred was the hat of the victim being left in the coat closet by the door.
Will had no delusions about Achilles being that foolish if he chose to kill Will. He was much smarter than the boys of that story.
But, much like the old movie, Achilles would be sure to throw a dinner party after Will’s death, though the guests would not simply be unknowingly eating over his soulless corpse.
Something about comparing Achilles to the movie lightened Will’s mood a bit, as if he could now be killed and just laugh about it. He smiled secretly to himself, and it seemed to catch Achilles’ eye.
“I hope you will enjoy yourself tonight,” Achilles said pleasantly, shutting the coat closet and leading the way through the house to the kitchen, “I have been told it is something of a show to watch me cook, so please, take a seat.”
Achilles gestured to a few bar stools at the island, and turned to begin his preparations.
Will again felt that this could be a ploy to make the eventual murder go more smoothly. A way to ensure Will did not leave Achilles’ sight, at the same time as having him already be in the kitchen. It would certainly be more convenient.
Will took a seat, knowing the events of the evening were mostly in the hands of Achilles, and all he could do was be ready for whatever may come.
Achilles had taken his jacket and vest off, and rolled his crisp, white sleeves up to begin cooking. It was a bit strange for Will to see him that way, as he had only ever seen him impeccably dressed in three-piece suits to this point.
Achilles’ forearms were tan and strong, which again surprised Will. He tried to picture the man wearing clothes with shorter sleeves while out in the sun, in order to have gotten a tan, but he couldn’t conjure the image.
“Tell me about yourself, Will,” Achilles said pleasantly, moving with a peculiar, practiced grace around the kitchen as he worked.
Will tipped his head and frowned.
“What?” he asked.
Achilles looked up at him frankly and pleased.
“Conversation,” he said, as if it were obvious, “you are not required to speak with me, of course, but I imagine it will be more enjoyable for both of us if we are not trapped in silence for the entire evening. You may ask me questions as well, if you like. Conversation goes both ways.”
Will considered that. It was somewhat reassuring that Achilles had asked to get to know him, as Will could tell he wasn’t the type of killer that would enjoy killing the person more the more he knew about them. He wouldn’t bother asking if he planned to kill Will.
But, of course, it was still on the table.
“Alright. Well, you know my real name, care to even the playing field a bit?” he asked, unsure if he would get an honest answer or not. It didn’t hurt to ask. Unless it did.
Achilles smiled, the corners of his eyes crinkling with amusement.
“That is a dangerous bit of information, Mr. Graham,” he said smoothly, “for the both of us. You must know I do not intend to be caught in this life. If I tell you, it would bind you to me. Do you truly wish for that?”
Will considered it. It did seem a bit intimate, now, to learn the man’s name. If he spoke his true name, he wondered if it would feel right, or if it would feel like a curse.
“Maybe not. Fine,” Will conceded, “where are you from?”
Achilles nodded, accepting the change of course. He seemed pleased that Will felt the same way, and Will would have even guessed he was glad Will was being cautious.
“Lithuania, though only in my very early years. I travelled around Europe for many years as I learned, before I found myself in the states and settled.”
Will nodded, the pieces fitting well into the puzzle the man had made of himself. Will thought he probably could have guessed most of that himself, if not all of it. He had a way of guessing things.
“I’m originally from Louisiana,” he told Achilles, offering information about himself in return for what he was given, “but I’ve moved around quite a bit too. Settled here with the café for good after meeting Abigail. She needed a bit of stability after her father died, and I just happened to have a café.”
Achilles nodded again, looking as if he had his own puzzle of Will that he was piecing together in his mind. Will wondered if they might not be doing reflections of what the other was, dancing and circling around each other for the time. He didn’t know quite what would happen when the dance ended.
“I had originally thought you might be her father,” Achilles confessed, “there is some resemblance, and you certainly treat each other as family. I quickly realized, though, that your bond was of a different nature.”
Will smiled sadly, humming in agreement.
“Yeah. Her dad was the Minnesota Shrike,” he said.
Achilles halted his movements for a moment, glancing up at Will in surprise.
“Garrett Jacob Hobbes?” he asked.
Will nodded.
“The same. He killed all those girls because Abs was growing up. She was going to leave him. He got caught, and Abigail was left with nothing to show for everything she had gone through. We ran into each other at the café one day, funnily enough, and I knew she was desperate for someone she could hold onto. Maybe it wasn’t the best thing for her mental health, necessarily, but I couldn’t do anything but try to be her someone.”
Achilles was listening intently, as if this story was a valuable insight into Will’s life, and it was. This was something Will felt as if his entire reality had been built around for the past few years. It was the cornerstone of who he was. Nothing would be the same if they had not met.
“When Abigail basically begged for me to hire her, I had just decided I was going to need some help, and I couldn’t have asked for anyone better suited for it. I think we kind of needed each other,” Will finished, feeling like he had started rambling, but smiling regardless. He had always had a hard time keeping from talking about Abigail. He was just so proud of her, and she was doing so well for herself now.
Achilles continued cooking, his motions a tad slower and more deliberate as he seemed to consider what he had learned.
“And the regulars of the café have grown fond of her as well,” he noted after a time.
Will huffed a laugh.
“Yeah. We’ve never told any of them about her dad, but I bet a few of them recognize her from the news, and they feel a kinship with her regardless. She’s more likely to understand them than a random person off the street, even if she’s not like them. In a way, they see her as unblemished innocence, and they want to protect that.”
Will paused, after saying that, studying Achilles for a moment. The man showed no clear reaction to the words, but Will knew he was probably remembering his first visit to the café.
“The regs wouldn’t go after you if you ended up killing one of them ,” he said slowly, “but they’d not stop until you were dead if you ever hurt her.”
Chapter 10: Desire
Chapter Text
Achilles met Will’s eyes, and must have seen the sincerity there, because he nodded solemnly.
“I have no intention to cause her any harm,” Achilles assured him, “If I am quite honest, she reminds me of my own sister.”
Will didn’t allow himself to react to the news that Achilles had a sister. He just watched the man for another moment before he spoke.
“She’s dead, isn’t she?” he asked carefully.
The look on Achilles’ face was one of long held mourning. He didn’t frown, but the crinkle and light were gone from his eyes.
“Yes. She died when we were both still quite young.”
Will didn’t ask for the man to elaborate. He didn’t need to know anything more, and he had no intention of making Achilles upset. It was clear he had loved his sister, and had not been the one to kill her. He genuinely mourned her, and if she had been killed at the hand of any agent, he had avenged her.
“So,” Will said, changing the subject and lightening the atmosphere, “what first brought you to the café?”
It was something he had wondered before. He didn’t exactly know how any of the regulars first heard of it, especially including the unique type of people that worked there. They all just showed up. None of them would ever admit to talking about it outside the walls of their oasis, but someone had to be blabbing if word was getting around.
“A patient of mine,” Achilles revealed, “they are not a regular, and I doubt they are aware of the slip, but they frequently recalled your cafe, and the way you had seemingly peered into their soul when they visited. I was intrigued, especially considering their unique personality and the way they described your insight.”
Will hummed thoughtfully.
That was fair enough.
“You’re a psychiatrist,” he mused, “I should have guessed. I probably could have. It fits.”
Achilles smiled, seeming pleased.
“Care to elaborate?” He asked slyly.
Will huffed a laugh.
“No.”
He wasn’t about to inflate the mans ego any more than necessary for Will to survive. Achilles didn’t need to hear that he was smart and insightful. He already knew. He just wanted to hear Will compliment him.
“But I will tell you this,” Will offered placatingly, “I don’t think most of the regs would be glad to hear it. Most of them have had unpleasant experiences with psychiatrists.”
Will had never been told as much, but it was a fairly safe thing to guess. He knew they wouldn’t have argued if they heard him.
Achilles nodded.
“I understand that is not uncommon for a demographic such as you have collected,” he agreed, “how did that begin?”
Will huffed another laugh, feeling the muscles in his shoulders slowly relax as he grew more comfortable, but never letting his guard down.
“That there’s a story for the ages,” Will said with a grin, “and it all started with a conversation about nominative determinism.”
At that, Achilles tipped his head curiously, silently bidding Will to keep going.
“The White Shark Café,” he continued, “is an area in the middle of the ocean where great white sharks gather yearly. My friend suggested an actual café by that name would mysteriously attract predators as well. I guess I didn’t expect her to be right.”
Will told Achilles about the first and second visitors that he had known were killers, and how the rest had shown up and slowly accumulated. He talked about Hobbs, and how he had worried the café would be dragged into the investigation after his death.
And then, he met Achilles’ eyes, and nearly jumped out of his skin from what he saw.
Achilles was listening intently, his expression soft and pleasant. He looked as if he were enjoying himself immensely. But that wasn’t what gave Will pause. There was some secret, caged hunger in those burgundy eyes. Something more frightening than all the polite indifference and quiet judgment. This was more dangerous than being seen as inconsequential or unimportant by the Chesapeake Ripper.
Will had once said he didn’t want Achilles to fixate on him, and now he knew it was too late. Achilles had locked on, and was prepared to raze everything in his path to get what he wanted.
And he wanted Will.
Will must have stuttered to a stop as he spoke, because Achilles tipped his head again and looked at him with curious concern.
“Is everything alright, Will?” He asked kindly.
Will shook himself back to reality, trying to smile and cover up the sudden strike of fear.
“Yeah,” he said weakly, “I guess I just drifted for a moment. What was I saying?”
Achilles smiled indulgently, as if allowing Will this one lapse.
“I believe the tale was over,” he said, picking up the plates of overly beautiful food that he had carefully created as Will had talked, “and now is a perfect time for me to show you to the dining room as well, if you would just follow me.”
Will did, thinking over the implications of what he had seen.
Will still could not tell if Achilles had a desire to kill him. The hunger he had seen could easily have been the kind sated by the death and devouring of the subject, and it was equally as likely as it being the kind to motivate a new outlook on life. Will simply had no way to tell as of yet.
This night was going to be a terror on his nerves.
Will was seated, and Achilles placed a plate of food in front of him.
“That’s just so damn unfair,” Will mumbled as he looked at it.
Achilles paused in his movements and tipped his head at Will. Will didn’t notice for a moment, but then he laughed nervously and shrugged for his host.
“I mean, it’s just that cannibalism is so taboo. It’s basically drilled into people from a young age that it’s an act of evil. I just think it’s not fair that your cooking is so… pleasing.”
Will felt a pang of worry once he finished, not sure how Achilles would respond to something like that. He hadn’t planned to say anything like that, but it was the best explanation he could come up with, at least and not outright insult the serial killer providing him with food.
After a terrible moment of silence, Achilles smiled and hummed pleasantly.
“I’m so pleased you think so, Will,” he said, and Will wasn’t sure what part of the statement he was so glad about, “one must toss aside many societal standards in order to truly enjoy oneself, in my opinion. We cannot possibly please everyone, so the only thing left is to please ourselves.”
Achilles took his own seat, taking up his silverware and looking at Will with casually pleased expectation.
Will glanced down at the food once more, mentally apologizing to whomever it was he was about to eat, and lifted his own set. He carefully cut a piece of meat and lifted it to his lips, feeling Achilles’ eyes on him the entire time. Once the food touched his tongue, Will had to suppress a sound of pleasant surprise at the taste.
As beautiful as the display was, it was infinitely more delicious.
And Will stood by his earlier statement. It was damn unfair.
“It’s delicious,” Will managed, trying to keep his tone even to avoid letting Achilles know what he was thinking.
Achilles’ eyes sparkled and he finally looked down at his own plate to cut a bite for himself. Will almost audibly sighed in relief to no longer be pinned in place by his intense gaze.
“Thank you, Will,” Achilles said, “I have always had the opinion that we should not allow ourselves to become complacent when it comes to the quality of what we make up our lives with. We must eat to survive, and so we should enjoy eating to the fullest.”
Will nodded, considering that as he tried not to stare at the man across the table from him. He wasn’t privy to all the nuances of high class table etiquette, but Achilles had set them across from each other rather than sitting at the head with Will at his side. Will felt like that was significant, but he had no idea why. He didn’t know what it meant.
“You keep saying my name,” Will accused, knowing he was being rude, but also aware that he was all the time being tested, “That’s a manipulation tactic. It makes a person like and trust you more, without them understanding why. Are you trying to manipulate me?”
Chapter 11: Hunger
Chapter Text
After one beat of silence, Achilles laughed. It was a subdued sound, as if he were too polite to laugh from his belly, but Will thought it was probably the most genuine laugh he would ever hear from the man.
“My apologies,-” Achilles said, clearly having to extract Will’s name from that sentence with purpose, “I had no intention of causing you discomfort in that way. Would you prefer I call you by the name I gave you in the café?”
Will didn’t know what he had been expecting, but the sparkle in Achilles’ eyes told him he was doing well on the test, whatever that meant for his future.
Did Will want Achilles to start calling him Patrocles , though? That hadn’t been his intention when he asked about the verbal habit, but it seemed he had backed himself into a corner. Achilles intended to continue structuring his sentences the same way, so Will just needed to decide if he wanted the man to call him by his real name or the alias.
There was no right answer, and that was likely by design.
“It almost seems fair, doesn’t it?” Will asked, masking his internal debate and consequential nerves, “I can’t very well call you by your real name, as I don’t know it, Achilles.”
Throwing the trick back at him to illustrate his point made Achilles smile wider. It was almost as if Will couldn’t do anything to make Achilles actually upset with him. Will was starting to wonder if he should test the boundaries a bit and see if he could make Achilles angry.
The larger part of himself screamed that he was not the only one in danger if he made this man angry. He could be putting all the regulars and Abigail in his line of fire. And that was just the people he knew immediately about. He might also go after innocent civilians and people in the FBI or local police. No one would be safe from the Chesapeake Ripper if Will managed to actually make him angry.
But the temptation was there all the same.
“Very well,” Achilles said, looking back down to his food and smiling all the while, “Then Patrocles it is. Then tell me, Patrocles, why might I want you to like and trust me? Surely you have an idea, as you were prepared to make that accusation.”
Will wanted to roll his eyes at the man. He sounded so pretentious.
“The most logical reason I can think of is that you are trying to lull me into a false sense of security. Calming the lamb before the slaughter,” he said smartly.
Achilles tipped his head curiously.
“And what does the less logical voice in your head tell you of my motivations?” he asked.
Will’s thoughts flashed back to that look of odd, intense hunger that he had seen, and what he felt it meant. He didn’t feel that he should reveal this knowledge, at least not yet. It was his last card to play, and he wanted to hold onto it until the time came.
“You are desperate for understanding. While you could accept that understanding from someone who dislikes or even hates you, you would prefer to be understood and still held in some kind of high regard. You see that I can understand you, and maybe I’m the only person you’ve ever met who can do that, so you are desperate for me to see you in a positive light, even though I know the worst about you,” Will said calmly, but firmly, “did I get that about right, Achilles?”
A fire lit in Achilles’ eyes, and they almost seemed to flash red for a moment. That hunger was back in full force, a desire so strong Will almost felt as if it were his own for a moment as it overshadowed almost everything else.
And then it was gone. Achilles was back under control, his emotions kept in careful check.
“Very near perfection, dear Patrocles,” Achilles said conversationally, “and I cannot help but wonder what you think I stand to gain by changing our relationship from the somewhat comfortable one we had when I was nothing more than a patron of your café.”
Will considered that for a moment.
“Perhaps you are worried you will lose my interest if you do not do something to capture my attention in a more permanent way,” he mused, “or maybe you’re just so possessive that you can’t stand the thought of any of the other regulars getting close to me. You needed to stake your claim so they wouldn’t try it. So which is it, Achilles? Are you insecure, or possessive?”
And if Will was taunting the Chesapeake Ripper, he almost didn’t regret it. He had planned to be careful, but the man’s self-assured attitude was contagious, and he was getting to the point where he almost didn’t care about the consequences of his actions. Achilles had been warned of what would happen if he hurt Abigail or Will, so he either would or wouldn’t follow that advice.
Achilles smiled, almost benignly, giving Will the impression that he was a tiger slowly stalking his prey and nearing the ambush. It was a dangerous expression, but Will refused to back down.
“There is an alternate answer that you have not stated,” Achilles said smoothly, “I believe you are quite aware of it, yet you did not offer it as an option. Is that not overtly manipulative of you, Patrocles?”
Will felt his face grow warm, but he held Achilles’ gaze.
The other option. The other option was actually a mixture of both the others, in a way. This final option was that Achilles actually felt some form of attraction and even affection for Will, and thus was simply courting him, in the way he knew how.
The reason Will had not offered it as an option was because, of all potential options, he considered it to be the most dangerous.
With the others, Will had hope that the feeling would wane or Achilles would grow bored of the game. With this, Will could clearly see that the most likely, if not only, escape from the man would be death. Will would end up hurting the man, and because he was someone entirely unused to being capable of being hurt, the only way to alleviate that pain would be to eradicate the cause. Will would have to die.
And now, Achilles was trying very hard to make it seem like this was the reality of where they stood with each other.
Achilles was becoming vulnerable, but could turn the moment he thought Will betrayed him. Will didn’t know if he could stand much more of this.
“Are you saying the other, unspoken option is the answer you would want to give me?” Will asked, taking a drink of wine and trying to hide the slight tremor in his hand.
Achilles examined Will carefully, probably seeing the shaking despite Will’s best efforts. He seemed to be considering whether or not he could allow this to be the truth. It made Will even more nervous, seeing that Achilles had his own reservations, because it added weight to whatever the man might say next. It meant this wasn’t a game at all.
“How would it make you feel, if that is what I am saying?” Achilles asked eventually, apparently refusing to be the first to outright say what it was they both knew.
That meant it was on Will’s shoulders to finally bring an end to the macabre dance they had been doing all night, perhaps since the moment they had met.
Recognizing the obligation didn’t make it any easier for Will.
“Just the thing a psychiatrist would say,” he said dryly, drinking more wine in the hopes to gain some liquid courage, “it makes me damn nervous, honestly. I don’t know how to handle it.”
Achilles watched Will drain his glass with something akin to fascination before he rose and filled it again. The action put Achilles right over Will’s shoulder, and the man all but draped himself over the back of the chair so his presence loomed over Will.
Will could smell the man’s expensive cologne, and the wine and meat on his breath. Despite everything Will knew and believed, his heart beat faster and he felt his entire body growing warmer in such close proximity to the man.
Had Will flirted with the man? Yes. He had come to the decision that he had, and it had been intentional. But had he actually meant it to go anywhere? That was where things got a little more blurry.
There had been times, he would admit to himself, when he had actually allowed himself to consider encouraging some kind of warm attraction to grow between them. Achilles was handsome, that much was easy to admit, and Will had imagined what it might be like to run his fingers through his spun-gold hair, or kiss his elegantly Romanesque lips.
But Will feared the kind of love Achilles offered. It would burn, and bite. A killer like the Chesapeake Ripper would have love like a wild fire. Love like the hunger Will had glimpsed earlier. Will couldn’t convince himself that he would be held and loved by Achilles. He was sure he would be consumed and devoured.
Achilles pulled away and returned to his seat after what felt like an eternity, leaving Will feeling mildly sunburned, as if he had just come inside from a hot day of working outside.
“Perhaps if you voice your specific concerns, we can address them properly,” Achilles said calmly, “rather than leave it all to guesswork.”
Will took a deep breath, steadying his nerves as well as he could under the circumstances. He placed his fingers along the stem of his wine glass, not picking it up to take another drink just yet. He only watched the way the light refracted through the glass and liquid, casting stars of wavering light onto the table and his hand.
“Alright,” Will relinquished at last, “first things first. I think we should settle exactly what this is you’re doing. If we leave it all just implied and assumed, things could get messy.”
Achilles nodded, his eyes sparkling just like the wine.
“I would prefer to avoid messes,” he agreed readily, “so please, enlighten me to what you believe I am doing, so I may clear up any confusion.”
Will almost rolled his eyes. Of course Achilles was putting it back onto Will to actually say it out loud. A psychiatrist thing.
“Fine,” he said, a bit more roughly than he had intended, “I think, at least I’m mostly convinced, that you are trying to… court me… in a way you are not used to. For most people, you don’t see them as permanent, but for me you think I could be. You’ve strayed into unfamiliar territory, and you find that exciting. You’re doing your best to not scare me away, but keeping me just scared enough that I won’t lash out at you. You’re afraid of losing the game you’ve decided this is, because you realized you can get hurt.”
Will hadn’t exactly meant to say all of that, having set out just to say the bit about courting, and now he felt as if he’d slipped and shown his hand to the other man. He watched, nervously, as Achilles considered what he had said.
“Your perception has yet to do anything other than amaze me,” the man said, sounding honest, “and I confess I have not put such articulation to my motivations. Despite my negligence to do so, I would say your observations are nearly, if not perfectly accurate.”
Against what Will expected, he felt relieved to hear that he had been right. He hadn’t been worrying over nothing. He felt relieved, validated, and justified. Even though the confirmation that he was being courted by a prolific serial killer should have only frightened him more.
A memory surfaced. One Will couldn’t believe he had forgotten while he worried over his situation.
“So, when you said I’ll be yours…” he said slowly, almost not believing he was saying it.
Achilles nodded, almost reverently.
“Mind, body, and soul, I fully intend to possess you,” he said.
That did nothing to assuage Will’s feelings that this wouldn’t be the kind of relationship he wanted.
“So you are the possessive type,” Will pointed out, trying to keep himself from having a nervous breakdown, “That doesn’t sound like a healthy way to go about this, Doctor.”
Maybe that had been pushing it too far. Will saw the hunger reignite in Achilles’ eyes, and it looked like he wanted to eat Will alive, which was still probably on the table. Will felt his face warm with a blush as he realized he had sounded flirtatious. He had intended to merely remind the man that he’s a psychiatrist, hopefully making him rethink the entire situation. He had utterly failed to sound stern.
“I mean, think about all of this,” Will said, trying to reclaim his original point, “If you had a patient describe their feelings for someone the way you do for me, you’d either tell them to quit it, or you’d pity the subject of their affections. Tell me I’m wrong.”
Achilles’ expression turned pensive, losing the nearly flippant amusement he had always worn since their first meeting.
Will felt as if he had hit a nerve, or at least struck a chord within the man. Perhaps he did have a patient who had spoken that way about another person, and he was now comparing himself to them. If the slowly shifting expression on his face was anything to go by, he found the patient distasteful. Will thought he might just be getting through to the man.
Chapter 12: Amends
Chapter Text
Achilles led Will to a sitting room after dinner was finished, pouring more wine for both of them. Will hoped he wasn’t planning to get Will drunk for any reason. Will had a high alcohol tolerance, but he didn’t feel safe refusing wine offered by the Chesapeake Ripper.
Achilles was quiet for a long time, standing near the active fireplace, and Will started to feel as if Achilles might not have any intention of bringing him back. Will didn’t have his car, so he was basically a prisoner if Achilles decided he didn’t want him to leave.
“Did I upset you?” Will asked nervously when the silence became too much.
Achilles jumped slightly, apparently startled out of his thoughts. He looked over at Will, and his expression grew fond, despite the slight look of fright that lingered in his features.
“No, of course not, Patrocles,” he said immediately, almost unthinkingly, “You have simply given me much to think about. I confess I am somewhat absorbed in my own thoughts at the moment.”
Will nodded, relaxing a bit now that he knew Achilles wasn’t angry.
“Well, feel free to share,” Will said, almost sounding mocking, though that hadn’t been his intention, “It’s killing me not knowing what’s going on.”
Achilles smiled, and that was a relief as well. If he was smiling in this way, a harmless smile with no malicious intent behind it, Will felt assured that he had not made a very big mistake. At least not yet.
“If you must know, Patrocles, I have been wondering how I can rectify this blunder of mine. This night has taken a turn I did not expect or prepare for.”
Will smiled, but hid it behind his glass as he took a sip of wine. He had made the Chesapeake Ripper second guess himself. That was a rare privilege, he was sure.
“Tell me what you’re thinking, and I’ll tell you where you can improve,” he offered.
Achilles frowned in confusion, studying Will like he might be trying to play a trick.
“Why would you help me?” he said suspiciously.
Will shrugged. He had nothing to gain by lying here. Achilles was not someone who could be easily messed with, and Will was aware that he was already getting away with more than almost anyone else would have been able to.
“Believe it or not, Achilles,” he said, “I do actually like you. If you started going about this properly, I might even fall for you. I want to see you succeed, probably against my better judgement, so I’ll help where I can.”
A spark of hope flashed in Achilles’ gaze, and Will hoped he hadn’t just made a mistake. He knew this could all go very wrong, but the way Achilles looked at him just then made him feel like it was worth the risk. God, he was such a temptation to Will. It was not good.
“Very well, Patrocles, tell me what I can do to improve,” Achilles said, somehow making it sound like a request and not an order.
Will shifted in his seat to get more comfortable on the couch. He took another drink of his wine and thought about what to say first.
“You should start by getting over being scary,” Will said bluntly, earning another slight jump from Achilles, “You’re not going to get anywhere with me by being threatening, and I think I’d like it if you at least try to be friendly with the regulars. You don’t have to like them, sure, but I want them to at least stop hating you. They’re like a family to me, in some ways, so you should try to get along.”
Achilles walked over and sat on the other end of the couch, his expression contemplative. Will knew the man had no real desire to socialize with anyone at the café other than him, but the fact that he was considering it gave Will hope that something could potentially work for them. He had started the night almost sure he would end up dead, but now he thought he might actually come out better than he had gone in.
“Very well,” Achilles said after a moment, sounding mildly unhappy, “I will do my best. I assume that is not the only advice you would offer me, though.”
Will smiled and nodded, trying to show Achilles he wasn’t doing this all just to be difficult. His next suggestion was bound to put more strain on this delicate situation.
“You should also start treating me like I’m a regular person,” Will said, holding a hand up to stop Achilles when he saw the man wanted to argue, “I don’t mean you can’t try to ask me out and things like that, but try some more normal things. Maybe I’m frightened that you have been trying to move too fast, or that you’ve been so serious about it. I want you to treat this like we’re both just regular people who might just get to the point where a relationship would work. Casual.”
Achilles frowned, and it was clear he was actually unhappy about this bit of advice. Will hoped he hadn’t made a mistake in how he had said it, but he knew he had to hold his ground on this. He couldn’t back down, or Achilles might decide he wasn’t serious about it. Will had to be serious about it now, or he never would be.
“I cannot promise I will be able to do that,” Achilles said at length, a tone of regret in his voice, “but I will try.”
Will nodded reassuringly. He had to tread carefully, to be sure Achilles didn’t snap and decide to just lock Will up in the basement. That would probably be easier for him than what Will was asking him to do, as unlikely as that sounded.
“That’s all I ask,” he said with a smile, “and as long as I see that you are trying, I’ll give you a chance. I’ll let you know about anything else as it comes up.” Then, without letting himself think better of it, “I really hope we can work this out.”
Will felt his face heat up slightly at the confession, but Achilles’ face lit up with renewed hope, and Will knew he was going to fall into the trap that this man seemed to be. The Chesapeake Ripper was far too tempting for Will, even though he knew every reason to stay away.
“I believe I have imposed on you for too long,” Achilles said with a note of finality, “Please allow me to drive you back to your shop.”
Will nodded and Achilles stood up from the couch. Achilles took Will’s wine glass, and Will stood to join him.
They walked into the kitchen and Achilles set both the wine glasses by the sink before he led Will back to the foyer. Achilles helped Will into his windbreaker, and they made their way out to the Bentley.
The drive back was largely uneventful, both of them silent and the only sounds being the classical music from the radio, and rain pouring over the exterior of the car.
Will glanced at his companion a few times, and saw a smattering of raindrops clinging to Achilles’ copper hair. They glistened in the reflected street lights, reminding Will of fairy handkerchiefs in early morning grass. He wanted to run his fingers through that hair and collect the tiny droplets on his fingers.
Will knew this was an extremely dangerous game he was playing, especially since he was dangerously close to letting himself actually fall for Achilles. Fall for the Chesapeake Ripper.
Achilles insisted on opening the car door for Will when they were parked at the café. Will thanked him, but could tell there was something Achilles wanted to say still, as they stood between their respective cars. They were each getting slightly soaked from the rain, but neither of them moved to leave yet, sensing the unfinished quality in the atmosphere.
“Just spit it out,” Will said eventually, surprised he had managed to not sound irritated, “I can tell there’s something you want to say, so say it.”
Achilles pressed his lips together, and he actually looked a bit nervous. He wasn’t meeting Will’s eyes, and Will thought he might actually be blushing, but it could be on account of the rain. There was another moment of silence between them before Achilles finally plucked up the courage to say what was on his mind.
“May I kiss you?” he asked.
Will blinked in surprise. Of all things, he supposed that wasn’t the last thing he had expected to hear the man say, but it still caught him off guard.
And Will knew he should say no. He had just laid down rules for their continued interactions, and kissing had not been included at all. He hadn’t said anything about this kind of thing, and hadn’t even set boundaries for them. He supposed he should be glad Achilles was asking instead of just going for it.
And Achilles’ hair was starting to flop into his face, making him look so harmless and charming.
Will sighed, raking his own hair away from his face and thinking about what he should do about this. He knew whatever he did, he could be taking a risk. He just had to decide what kind of risk he was willing or wanted to make.
Achilles was watching Will intensely as Will considered it. His dark eyes were a source of warmth among the cold rain making his clothes stick to his skin.
Will reached out and took the lapels of Achilles’ suit between his fingers. He smiled softly and pulled Achilles into a soft kiss.
It was just a quick, chaste, press of their lips, and it was exactly what Will had wanted. It was nice, and soft, and warm. Will allowed himself to enjoy it while it lasted, telling himself he would not let this happen again until he was sure Achilles was improving on his approach to their potential.
Achilles leaned forward, attempting to deepen the kiss, but Will used his strategically placed hands to push him away.
“Stop,” Will said, and Achilles froze in spot, “just that. It’s a gesture of good faith. I believe you can do this, so do it.”
Will managed to pull away and get into his car, Achilles standing in stunned silence as Will drove away.
That was probably a huge mistake. Will knew it, and he worried over it the entire drive home. He just hadn’t been able to help it. He had been trying to be reasonable the entire time. For months, he had forced himself to act with reason as much as possible. He had just wanted to let himself be delusionally selfish for a moment. Just a second.
Chapter 13: Consequences
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
“You survived,” Abigail noted, clocking in and getting her apron.
She didn’t sound surprised, but Will could tell she was relieved. He was sorry he had made her worry, but he was glad to know she cared.
“Yeah,” he agreed, “and I actually think we may not have to worry too much about Achilles now.”
Abigail raised her eyebrows in a silent bid for an explanation.
Will nodded, smiling a bit to himself as he remembered the way Achilles had looked in the light rain just before they had kissed.
“Well, I talked to him and basically explained what I want him to do, and what has to change,” Will said, “and I think he actually listened. He’s going to try to be better because I asked him to.”
It was a novel idea that Will could have that kind of sway over someone like the Chesapeake Ripper. He had never expected to find himself in a position like this, but he thought it was just a little bit wonderful.
“Oh really,” Abigail mused, looking at Will with subtle amusement and curiosity, “You just talked?”
Will felt his face heat with a blush, and he huffed indignantly at Abigail.
“I didn’t actually say that’s all we did,” he pointed out, though he knew it wasn’t exactly helping, “and yes, to answer the next question I know is coming, we kissed. Happy?”
Abigail laughed and shook her head.
“I’m just ribbing you, Will,” she said, “but I am a bit surprised he would agree to be better. At least I’d be surprised if it doesn’t come with conditions. I would expect someone like him would want something in return.”
Will sighed and nodded. He was proud of Abigail, of course, but sometimes it was frustrating that she also had a thing for psychology.
“I didn’t offer anything expressly,” he said, almost feeling like it was a lie, “but I told him I would let him ask me out more, and that we can try to make it work.”
Abigail nodded, as if she had expected it to be something like that. She started rolling out some dough on the counter, and her expression grew pensive.
“I hope you know what you’re doing,” she said with finality.
Will nodded.
Me too, he thought.
“How have things been with Norma?” he asked, earning a dramatic eye roll from Abigail,
She sighed heavily and shook her head.
“That ship has sailed,” she declared, “he’s got some serious mommy issues, and that’s some baggage I refuse to carry for him. I guess I’m back on the market.”
Will huffed a laugh. He was glad she didn’t seem heartbroken over it. She looked like she was well and truly glad to have dodged that particular bullet.
“Anyone you might go for next?” he asked, half-hoping the answer would be no.
Abigail shrugged, folding butter into the layers of the dough and starting to roll it out again.
“Christine is pretty cute,” she said, shooting him a wry smirk.
Abigail knew Will didn’t think it would work between her and Christine, even if he would never say it outright. He wanted her to learn her own lessons, and tried not to offer advice when she didn’t want it.
“And she would jump at the opportunity,” Will agreed, still not shooting it down despite the bait, “she’s been trying to catch your eye for months.”
Abigail nodded. She had been aware.
“Alright, tell me honestly, why shouldn’t I go out with her?” she asked.
Will raised his own eyebrows and looked up at her. He hadn’t expected her to ask. He had thought she would have to learn this lesson the hard way.
“Well, to start with, she travels too much for your taste,” Will offered, “you like to stay around where you know people, and she likes to be a stranger among strangers, except when she comes home to talk about her adventures. Hot to mention, you are planning to go to college, which means staying in one place for an extended period of time, and you wouldn’t have time for her. At least not as much as she would want. I believe she would be good to you, but you wouldn’t be good for each other. On the things that really matter to either of you, the other wouldn't be willing or able to make a compromise. It would just end up being painful for both of you, and we both know our regulars don’t deal well with pain.”
Abigail was silent for a bit as she rolled and folded the dough again. Will worried he had said too much. Gone too hard on the sell.
Then Abigail started to laugh. It wasn’t much, and not loud, but enough to reassure Will that he hadn’t messed up.
“You’ve really thought it all out, haven’t you?” Abigail asked, smiling and shaking her head.
Will smiled and shrugged.
“I do a lot of thinking, and I want to make sure I do what I can for you, so of course I thought it all out. I started thinking about it the first time she looked your way.”
Abigail grinned.
“What I love the most about you,” she said, “is that you didn’t even mention that she kills people. Of all your reasons, that wasn’t one of them.”
Will huffed a laugh.
“I think that would be really hypocritical of me, all things considered, and it’s not like I could stop you if you really fell for someone. I’ve never had a problem with people like our regulars, as long as they leave me and you out of it. It’s your decision if you want to get involved anyway.”
Will had turned away to tinker with a mixer that had broken, and Abigail surprised him by hugging him from behind. He huffed and smiled.
“What’s up?” he asked.
Abigail pulled away, leaving flour all over his clothes.
“I know I give you a lot of flack, Will, but I seriously can’t tell you how much I appreciate you. You’re infinitely better than my dad ever was. I’m not really grateful for everything that happened to me, but I’m glad I met you.”
Will felt ready to burst, because Abigail so seldom expressed her positive emotions so honestly. Not to mention he felt the same way. Will had never really thought much about being a father, he certainly didn’t want to curse his progeny with the same ability he had, but he had always distantly thought he would be a good father. And now, being able to be at least some sort of father figure for Abigail, he actually enjoyed it. He supposed he had managed to skip over all the really hard bits, having met Abigail when she was already a mostly independent adult, but that also meant he had missed out on teaching her to fish, or change a flat tire. He regretted having missed those things, but he knew he may have not been quite as good at teaching her to forgive and forget trespasses of others. He was very good at being himself, but he was sure he would not have been as good at teaching her to be herself.
“I’m really glad we met too,” Will said, trying to hide the emotion in his voice, though Abigail probably heard it anyway.
“Aww, Will,” Abs crooned, though there was no malice in her teasing, “we’re having a moment.”
Will laughed and shook his head.
“Not anymore. You ruined it. Now get back to work. We have to open in an hour.”
Abigail feigned a pout, but she soon got back to smiling and putting trays into the oven.
---
“Thank you very much,” Achilles said, handing Will his cash.
There was something else with the money, and Will looked to see what it was.
The moment Will saw it, he cursed loudly and dropped it onto the counter.
“What the hell?” he asked, “you can’t give that to me. You shouldn’t even have that out in here. What if one of the other regs saw it?”
Achilles smiled and picked the business card back up from the counter. He offered it to Will again, appearing as innocent as possible.
“I trust you, Will,” he said, “and I believe it is only fair that you know my true name. At the very least, I could now use your name without being unfair to you. It would be remiss of me to attempt anything near courting if you do not even know my name.”
Will huffed and snatched the card from Achilles’ outstretched hand. He finally actually read what was printed there, feeling as if he was standing on a rug that was about to be pulled out from under him.
Doctor Hannibal Lecter.
Absurdly, the name seemed to fit. There was a ridiculous, high brow regality to the name, paired with an underlying sense of danger, that matched the man Will had come to know far too well.
Will sighed and slipped the card into the front pocket of his shirt. Achilles, or Hannibal Lecter, seemed incredibly pleased, and politely took his food and coffee to sit at his regular seat.
Will continued working, finding it hard to avoid looking at him, but his gaze was constantly drawn back to Hannibal Lecter. There was something different about him. If the Chesapeake Ripper had walked into White Shark like that, on that first day, Will was sure it would have gone differently. He might not have been able to tell he was that killer.
Eventually, Will was starting to come to terms with this new side of the man he was being shown. That was, until Misery came in and ordered.
Achilles smiled at her as she turned around with her coffee, and gestured for her to join him. She hesitated, clearly and rightfully wary of anyone trying to make friends in this place, but she was smart enough to know he wasn’t the type of man one should refuse. It would be rude.
Will was awestruck, and just stared at them until Abigail came out from the back room.
“Hey, Will, what do you want me to do with-” Abs began, but stopped in her tracks when she saw what Will was staring at, “is that Misery, talking to Achilles?”
Will nodded slowly, amazed as he saw Misery smile at something Achilles said. Her entire face lit up, and she started talking animatedly, the most energy Will had ever seen in her. He couldn’t hear what they were talking about over the rest of the conversations between him and their table, and he didn’t really have any clue what topics they might have in common.
“What the hell happened?” Abigail asked, bewildered, “Why the sudden change of attitude?”
Will realized what had probably been the catalyst, and he felt his face grow warm. He cleared his throat and tore his gaze down to his hands on the counter.
“Uh, I mean, I did ask him to try to be friendly with the other regs,” he said, feeling more nervous than he thought was necessary, “maybe he’s trying to do what I asked.”
Will could feel the wide, almost mocking grin Abigail wore before she spoke.
“Oh really,” she mused, “I guess he’s really serious about you. You must be a good kisser.”
Will’s blush deepened, and he cleared his throat again.
“Don’t you have something you should be doing?” he asked, “you’re on the clock, after all.”
Abigail pouted.
“I know the guy who runs this place, and he’s a pushover,” she said, “so I can spare a minute.”
Will sighed and rolled his eyes.
“He also told me his real name,” he told her quietly, careful not to be overheard, “I guess I can’t predict him as well as I can with most people.”
Abigail grinned again.
“I’ve heard you should always look for someone who can surprise you,” she said, smirking a bit, “how’s all this make you feel?”
Will swallowed hard and wet his lips. He looked back up at where Achilles and Misery were still talking.
Achilles smiled politely, making Misery feel comfortable with him, and Will saw the way the other regulars were reacting to the change. They were all interested and curious, but above all they were pleased. Achilles wasn’t acting as if he was above them anymore. They were all on even ground.
Will felt his chest fill with warm fondness, and he smiled.
“I feel like I might actually get something I want this time around,” he said.
Notes:
My internet basically gave up on me for a bit there, but I'm back now. Sorry for the wait.
Chapter 14: Actions
Chapter Text
“Doctor Hannibal Lecter,” Will said, feeling the name roll over his tongue.
It was technically after hours for the café, but he had left the door unlocked. He was hoping Achilles would show up. He wouldn’t have done so if he didn’t really and truly think the man would come. And he wanted to see him again. He was half convinced he needed to.
Even though he was planning out things like leaving the door unlocked for Achilles to use, Will couldn’t be sure what he would do when and if he came. He just wanted to see him again, when they could be away from the eyes of all the others.
Will heard the bell ring as the door of the café was opened.
“We’re closed,” he called, sure it would not dissuade the person he was waiting for.
The bell didn’t ring again, so Will just waited. He rolled out some dough, in an attempt to both look as if he were not expecting anyone and to have something to keep him from being too rash. He had something to do with his hands.
Will didn’t hear Achilles’ footsteps as he walked to the door of the back room, but he felt the change of atmosphere as soon as those dark eyes had landed on him again.
“Can I help you?” Will asked, glancing up at the man in the doorway. Those burgundy eyes looked almost red, like hot coals.
“You were expecting me,” Achilles said, though not in an accusing tone.
Will raised an eyebrow and looked up again from the food he was preparing.
“Was I?” he asked, “how do you figure that?”
Achilles walked into the back room, looking around with a warm smile. Will wondered what he was thinking.
“You do not make a habit of leaving the café unlocked while you are working after hours. I always thought it due to your unique clientele, as leaving it unlocked may seem like an open invitation,” he said, his dark eyes sparkling pleasantly, “and I have thought you felt the same way. That leaves me to believe you intended to be seen as an invitation for someone. Perhaps I am hopeful it was me.”
Will smiled and wiped his hands on his apron.
“I can’t decide if that was psychology or sherlockian deduction, Achilles,” he said, scrubbing his hands clean of flour and dough, “but it’s impressive regardless. How does it make you feel, to believe I extended that invitation to you?”
Achilles stood next to the counter, looking over the pastry Will had been making. Will pulled off his apron and set it aside.
“I would count myself incredibly fortunate if that is the case,” Achilles said warmly, “Though I do wonder why you do not use my true name, now that you have it.”
Will nodded gently, smiling and walking up to Achilles, so they were standing nearly toe-to-toe. He saw and heard when Achilles’ breath hitched slightly and it gave him no small amount of satisfaction to have that effect on the Chesapeake Ripper. There was a certain thrill to this whole situation, and he imagined it was similar to that which people got from swimming with sharks. The knowledge that the creature could choose to kill you at any moment, and was actively deciding to spare you. When he felt his heart begin to beat faster, he couldn’t tell if it was from fear or excitement, but that had its own strange appeal.
“How about some deduction of my own?” Will offered, and didn’t wait for a response, “you have some particular tastes, and you gave me your name with the express desire to hear me use it. Not only that, but you came back when I would be alone, so I could do so safely. Now that I can say your name, you are anxious to hear it.”
Will watched curiously as Achilles swallowed, observing the movements of his throat.
“Did I get it right, Doctor Lecter?”
At those words, Achilles’ mouth fell slightly open and his eyes widened. Will seized the opportunity and grabbed the lapels of Achilles’ suit. He pulled him into a kiss, taking advantage of Achilles’ parted lips.
Once Achilles recovered from his initial shock, his hands found their place on Will’s hips to pull them closer together. And when Achilles moved to deepen the kiss further, this time, Will allowed it.
They pulled apart for air after a moment, and Will smiled.
“I bet you didn’t think doing what I asked would work so quick,” he said, and Achilles nodded, still slightly stunned, “but I have to confess, neither did I. After you made friends with Misery, all because I asked you to, I couldn’t stop thinking about this.”
Will pulled him into another kiss, and Achilles shifted his hands so one was at the small of Will’s back and the other cupped the back of his neck. Achilles gently carded his fingers through the hair at Will’s nape, and Will loved it. The Chesapeake Ripper was being gentle with him, and he couldn’t get enough of it.
“You aren’t gonna kill me if I reject you someday, are you?” Will asked the next time they parted.
Achilles tipped his head, holding Will’s gaze as his fingers played with Will’s hair a bit.
“I confess I cannot say for sure how I may react,” Achilles admitted, “but I find a certain amount of thrill in the knowledge that you can inspire that kind of uncertainty in me. Are you afraid of me?”
He sounded genuinely curious and Will was glad he hadn’t offered a lie to make him feel better.
“Yes,” Will answered honestly, “I’m afraid of what will happen if you kill me. I’m afraid that you might decide not to kill me, but to hurt me instead. I know what and who you might go after if you do, and that frightens me much more than the thought of my own death.”
Achilles considered that for a moment, his fingers still twirling themselves in Will’s hair in a manner that was incredibly distracting. Will didn’t know what to expect from the man, after he had admitted all that, but he was interested to find out.
“I suppose there are too many potential variables to truly predict what either of us might do in the future,” he said at last, “and I will not make a promise I cannot keep, but I will tell you I have no intention to harm you, physically or otherwise. You may not be able to take much solace in that, I understand, but it is what I can offer at this point.”
Will smiled and nodded.
“I’m getting tired of being afraid,” he confessed, “which makes it awful tempting to just take your word for it and pretend everything is fine.”
Achilles hummed in agreement, letting Will know he was being understood and that Achilles wasn’t upset with him for anything he had said.
“I do not often wish to allay the fears of others,” Achilles said, “but I am finding I would very much like to do so for you.”
Will huffed a soft laugh.
“I guess there’s a certain security in my knowing your real name,” he said, staring at the loud pattern of Achilles’ tie, “since I can write a note saying you’re the Chesapeake Ripper in case I ever go missing.”
Achilles’ eyes shone with amusement at that, and he nodded. They were still entirely in each other’s space, and Will knew they probably would have looked ridiculous to an outside observer, but he also knew they were entirely alone, so he didn’t care.
“Then you needn’t be afraid of me, Will,” Achilles said with a smile, “I will protect my own interests, and I have no desire to be caught. I enjoy the life I have found here.”
Will considered that, one hand moving to trace the delicate silk flowers of the tie.
The Chesapeake Ripper was being so gentle with him. It was intoxicating, thinking he held this power over someone who would otherwise be so dangerous. It was probably unhealthy for him to like it as much as he did.
“A life where you masquerade as an upstanding citizen while moonlighting as the most prolific serial killer in the state?” Will mused aloud, “I can see why you would want to protect that, I suppose, but you should remember the conversation we had about fate in the Iliad.”
Achilles pulled gently on one of Will’s curls, then watched as he let go and it sprang back into shape.
“Are you asking me to stop?” he wondered, “is this the next condition of our agreement?”
Will tipped his head to look at Achilles more fully. He wasn’t sure what that tone in his voice meant, but he was very curious.
“If that is what I am asking, what would you do?” he asked, “would you stop, just because I asked you to?”
Achilles took one of Will’s hands and pressed a kiss to his palm.
“I would move mountains for you, Will Graham, but would you ever truly ask that of me?”
Will felt his chest fill with warmth again as Achilles pressed his face into Will’s hand and met his gaze again. Will knew the only honest answer he could give, and he didn’t know how to expect Achilles to respond.
“Call me crazy, but no. I never would, Hannibal.”
Both of Hannibal’s hands flew up to cup Will’s face and pull him into a bruising kiss. Will’s own hands curled around the back of Hannibal’s head, weaving into his fine copper hair.
Chapter 15: Revelation
Chapter Text
“Hey, Will!”
Will froze in place, terrified out of his mind at the voice he heard from the door of the café. Much more afraid than when he had seen the Chesapeake Ripper walk through his door.
“You don’t have to make that face,” Beverly said, walking up to the counter, “You’re gonna make me feel unwelcome.”
Will laughed uncomfortably.
“Bev. I just didn’t know you were coming,” he said, praying the regs wouldn’t try anything, “you startled me. How are you?”
Beverly grinned.
“I’m doing fine. Everything’s boring at work, of course, but I finally got away so I can come say hi to you and Abs. Where is she?”
Will hesitated.
Abigail was currently on a date with Christine. She had promised not to get into anything serious with the girl, but she said she wanted to see for herself and let her down softly. Will supported her in the endeavor, and was glad she was taking his advice at least that much.
“She’s on a date, actually,” Will told Bev, not sure what would be safe to tell her. Beverly was insatiably curious, and he didn’t want her to be put in danger.
Beverly raised an eyebrow.
“Oh? Who’s the lucky person? Last I heard, she had just broken up with that Norman Bates kid. She’s already on someone else?” She asked.
Will shrugged and smiled to keep her from thinking anything was wrong.
“One of our regulars, her name’s Christine, has been trying to ask her out for a while. Abs decided to go out with her once, then let her down soft. She doesn’t really think it’ll work.”
Beverly nodded in consideration, then looked at the menu for the café.
“You’ve changed all the names, Will,” she said, “these are all weird.”
Will shrugged.
“Most of the people who come in regularly are horror fans, funnily enough,” he told her, skirting around the truth, “and they think it’s funny. I had to appeal to my audience.”
Beverly huffed a laugh.
“Alright then,” she said, “give me something. I’ll take whatever you give me.”
Will nodded and turned to make her a cup of coffee and grab a croissant. He handed them to Beverly, who was looking at him suspiciously.
“What about you?” she asked, “you been dating anyone recently? There’s something different about you today, and I’d bet it’s because you met someone.”
Will blushed and bit his lip.
This would be hell to explain to Beverly. He didn’t even really know how to describe what was going on between him and Hannibal. They hadn’t exactly been going out like normal people do.
“I guess you could say that,” he said carefully, “I mean, I met someone, yeah. It’s complicated.”
Beverly raised her eyebrows at him and took a sip of her coffee.
“Sounds like a story. Want to take a break and sit down for a bit? I haven’t seen you in forever.”
Will swallowed nervously.
“When Abs gets back I can, but I can’t leave just the new kid in charge. She should be back soon, and then we could go get sandwiches or something. I’d like a little change of scenery.”
He mostly just wanted to get Beverly out of the café. It wasn’t safe for someone like her, and every moment she was in there was more dangerous than the last. Usually, when someone who wasn’t like the regulars came in, Will offered them a specific order that had turned into a code for the regulars. With Bev, he knew he couldn’t do that, and he couldn’t guarantee how the regulars would react to her. She was too curious.
“Speaking of scenery,” Beverly said with a grin, turning to gesture to the shop, “the décor in this place is really nice. I didn’t think you had an eye for that kind of thing, but I stand corrected.”
Will smiled and shrugged.
He had designed the whole place to have a beachside feel, before his regular clientele had changed the atmosphere. Glass blown buoy lanterns and cobalt blue walls, white trimmings and driftwood tables. He had been satisfied with it, and then the killers had filled in. He saw no reason to change any of it, and none of the regulars had complained, even though it didn’t quite fit with what the café had become.
“Abigail can be thanked for the way it all matches,” he said, a half truth he didn’t feel at all bad for, “she has more of an eye for it than I do. I just had a vague idea of what I wanted. She helped me put it together.”
In truth, most of it had been the way it was long before Abigail had shown up. She had just made a few suggestions, mostly having to do with the color of the coffee cups. Will liked to give her more credit than she necessarily deserved, and he didn’t see any harm in it.
“That makes sense,” Beverly said with a nod, “She has good taste. She could go into interior design if she wanted. But I know you said she’s set on psychology.”
Will nodded.
“Hey, why don’t you go find a place for us to eat, then send me the name so I can find it. I’ll be there the moment Abs gets back, okay? Then we can talk at our leisure.”
Beverly sighed dramatically, but nodded. She took her drink and croissant and headed to the door.
On Beverly’s way out, the door was held open for her by one elegantly dressed man on his way in. She thanked him, and Achilles made his way to the counter with a pleasant smile.
“Good morning, Will,” Achilles said, and Will could tell he was thinking of the strange woman he had passed in the door.
“Good morning, Achilles,” Will replied, glancing toward the door so he wouldn’t miss Abigail when she got back, “what would you like today?”
Achilles noticed his slightly distracted state, tipping his head curiously.
“What’s on your mind?” Achilles asked, “you appear to be elsewhere.”
Will shook his head, trying not to think about how much he needed to get to Beverly and hopefully keep her away from the café for the future. Tried not to think about how much he needed Abigail to get back so he could get to Beverly and try to explain his new paramour.
“I got a visit from an old friend,” he answered, “and I have some things I need to explain to her, but I’m not sure how I’m going to do it.”
As Will spoke, he prepared a coffee and a mulberry tart for Achilles and set them on the counter for the man. He knew his words were a bit clipped, and he wasn’t looking up at Achilles at all, but he was internally freaking out and couldn’t bring himself to really care.
“Is there anything I can do to help you?” Achilles asked, not moving to take either the cup or the plate.
Will sighed and rubbed his face hard with his hands.
“She’s asking about you. Well, in a way. She was asking about if I’d met anyone, and I said yes, but now she wants all the details. I don’t know what to tell her, but I have to go get lunch with her as soon as Abigail gets back from her date. Add onto that the fact that my best friend was just in this café, surrounded by my regulars, and I’m pretty much not happy with everything at the moment. I don’t know what I’m going to do.”
Achilles reached out and took Will’s hand, immediately rubbing soothing circles into it. Will froze at the sudden contact, but he felt his shoulders slowly relax and he finally looked up to see Achilles’ face.
Achilles’ warm burgundy eyes were looking at him with gentle concern.
“I saw Abigail in the parking lot,” he said, “she will be in any moment. Would you like me to come with you to lunch? I may be able to help you with your friend. If my presence would not upset you.”
Will’s eyes widened, because he hadn’t even thought about that. He could have Achilles come with him, and they could both tell Beverly something to satisfy her curiosity and keep her from getting too involved.
But, then he would be introducing another way for Achilles to manipulate him. If he introduced Achilles to Beverly, Achilles could use her against Will. Or, if Will ever hurt him, Achilles could kill Beverly to punish him.
Perhaps Achilles could see the debate in his features, because he smiled wanly and lifted Will’s hand to press a kiss to it.
“I have already told you I have no intention to harm you. Do you doubt that?” he asked quietly.
Will took a deep breath, trying to slow his heartbeat, which had sped up the moment Achilles’ hand had touched his own.
“We’ll have to tell her your real name. I guess that gives me more insurance,” he said, smiling bitterly, “and you have quite a way with people. I think you’d make a good impression, if I ask you to.”
Achilles smiled warmly, and the door to the café opened as Abigail walked back in.
Chapter 16: Convincing
Chapter Text
“No way. Will, I didn’t think you’d have the guts, but you have to be kidding me. This is a joke, right? You asked this guy to pretend to be your boyfriend as a joke on me, right?”
Will felt his face growing warm with embarrassment and frustration as Beverly talked. He hadn’t expected her to react that way, and he didn’t know what to do about it.
Hannibal put an arm around Will, affectionate and subtly protective.
“He did not,” Hannibal said smoothly, “Why would you think that?”
Beverly looked at Hannibal as if he were from another planet. And he might as well have been, where she was concerned.
“Well, you just don’t seem like his type. Or more, I guess, he doesn’t seem like your type. You look like the kind of person who goes to operas, and Will hasn’t even set foot in anywhere more fancy than an olive garden since he graduated college.”
Will wanted to object, tell Beverly she was wrong, or that he would happily go to an opera with Hannibal, but he couldn’t make himself do it. It would feel too much like begging for an invite from the man, and Hannibal was already pretty much doing this as a favor for him.
“As it happens,” Hannibal said, not sounding at all perturbed by Beverly, “I do enjoy going to the opera. But that has no standing in my attraction towards Will.”
Hannibal’s fingers were drawing lazy circles on Will’s ribs, as soothing as it was distracting. Will didn’t know what to do or say to Bev, but he thought he really should try to get control of the conversation.
“We didn’t meet all that long ago, Bev,” Will said, as if that explained everything, wincing at himself for it, “so I’m sure there are still things to be worked out. I think it’d be nice if you didn’t point out all the reasons we shouldn’t work together. Also, Hannibal doesn’t like it when people are rude.”
Beverly raised an eyebrow, and the hand at Will’s side pulled him a bit tighter to Hannibal in a reassuring and possessive way.
“He doesn’t like rude people and he still likes you? I guess I really don’t have any right to say anything about it. There’s something going on that I don’t understand.”
The way Bev said it wasn’t brash or impolite, and actually sounded like she would mostly drop it. It made Will relax a bit, and he felt Hannibal smile slightly.
“I find that fear makes Will rude,” Hannibal said, “but as defense mechanisms go, I have seen far worse. His other charms more than compensate for any deficiency due to his rudeness.”
Beverly laughed, and Will felt relief flood him that she wasn’t arguing about their compatibility any more.
“His other charms,” Beverly said, amused, “I never thought I’d see the day someone said something like that about Will. How did you guys meet in the first place?”
Hannibal smiled, but allowed Will to answer.
“He came into the shop,” he said, “how else do you think? It’s not like I have a rich social life.”
Beverly nodded.
“Fair enough. How did you get together, though? What made you like each other? I want details, boy. This is the most exciting thing to happen to me since all the servers at work crashed at the same time a few months ago.”
Will huffed a laugh.
“Well, I do this thing for people when they come into the shop for the first time. I guess what they would like off the menu, just by looking at them. I’m pretty good at it, usually.”
Hannibal nodded and picked it up from there, almost as if they had rehearsed it. It made Will smile.
“Will is excellent at reading people, and I have not seen him guess wrong once in my time going to his café. It’s an incredibly charming ritual, and I was taken at once by his cleverness and beauty.”
Will huffed and shook his head.
“I was annoyed that he kept hanging around and ogling me,” he said, “but eventually I gave in and went out with him. He’s not as bad as he seems at first.”
Beverly laughed, and Hannibal pressed his nose into Will’s hair. It was strange, but oddly intoxicating to have Hannibal completely in his personal space. He usually kept everyone at an arm's length, physically and metaphorically, but Hannibal was incredibly warm and solid and soothing to be pressed against.
“Well, I’m glad,” Beverly said, grinning widely, “I never thought I’d see the day you finally let someone into your little cold heart, Will. You look happy. Both of you.”
Will smiled.
“We still have a few things to work out, obviously, but I think we are happy. I mean, it’s still pretty new, but I think it’s nice.”
Hannibal pressed a kiss behind Will’s ear, making Will flush red.
“Even though he does stuff like that in public. Hannibal, please, come on.”
Hannibal huffed a laugh.
“I do apologize, Will,” Hannibal said softly, “I am just so infatuated with you it is difficult to contain at times.”
Will scowled, but his face was warm, and he knew he was probably an incredible shade of red. The expression on Beverly’s face only confirmed that. She looked like she was witnessing the best thing since color television.
“We get it,” Will said, “you’re incredibly winsome. Now back down a little or I’ll suffocate.”
Beverly laughed again, and Will felt secure in her safety. He saw no reason Hannibal would harm her, and even thought Hannibal might genuinely like her. His anxiety about the whole thing was slowly dissipating, and he was actually enjoying himself.
“What kind of food do you like?” Beverly asked Hannibal, having gotten her own food before they had arrived, “you didn’t seem very interested in getting anything here.”
Will chuffed.
“Hannibal probably won’t eat anything from here,” he said, “he’s extremely picky about what he eats. He cooks like a professional chef. I’m surprised he puts up with my baking, he’s that good.”
Hannibal huffed in a mock pout.
“You make me sound like a spoilt child,” he chided, “and regardless, your baking is exceptional. No one could find fault in it.”
Will laughed and shook his head.
“I compliment your cooking and all you hear is the part where I said you’re picky,” he said, “so maybe you are a spoiled child. You sure act like one sometimes.”
Hannibal continued to pout, and Beverly just grinned. Will could tell she thought they were incredibly entertaining. He continued to hope he hadn’t made a mistake in this. He had gotten tired of being afraid, but now he had to worry about Beverly’s safety and he couldn’t be careless with that responsibility.
“Regardless of what Hannibal wants, I’m getting a sandwich,” Will declared and opened a menu.
Hannibal peered over his shoulder, reading the menu Will was holding instead of picking up the one he had been given. Will could imagine sitting on a couch, curled up into Hannibal’s side with a book. Hannibal would read over Will’s shoulder just like he did with the menu, not unhappy with the speed at which Will turned the pages, because he had already read the book, so it didn’t matter if he missed parts of it or had to wait for Will to finish.
The sudden image of it all struck Will like a knife to the heart, making him ache with longing. He wanted that. He really did. And the more time he spent with Hannibal, the more attainable it all felt.
“What would you like?” Hannibal asked him, his voice in Will’s ear pulling him back to the moment.
Will shrugged, his shoulder brushing the underside of Hannibal’s chin.
“Probably a philly cheesesteak,” he said, considering the items on the menu, “but I’m not really that hungry now that I think about it.”
Hannibal sighed lightly.
“You haven’t eaten yet today, Will,” he said, his tone stern like a parent with a misbehaving teen, “regardless of how you feel, you need food.”
Will huffed and glanced up at Beverly. Beverly was eating her own chicken salad sandwich with her eyes trained on them as if they were the newest episode of her favorite sci-fi show. Will felt his face grow warm and he quickly looked back down at the menu.
“If you have such strong opinions on my diet, maybe you should order for me,” he said, then took a moment to consider that he might regret that decision.
Hannibal hummed and plucked the menu from Will’s hands before Will had the chance to stop him.
“If I were to have my way,” Hannibal said smoothly, “you would never eat anything I had not prepared for you. However, I believe something suitable can be found here.”
Will was insatiably curious, even though he was now worried what Hannibal might do. He didn’t ask another question, and when Hannibal managed to order discreetly, without Will hearing what he was saying, Will wasn’t entirely surprised.
Beverly was watching this all go down with the expression of someone about to see a cute proposal, and Will worried that wasn’t too far off.
Eventually, the server came with a sandwich for Will, and Will inspected it suspiciously. Hannibal watched curiously, though he didn’t seem overly concerned about whether or not Will would like it. Will wondered how much Hannibal could have learned about Will’s preferences just in the time they had been getting to know each other. He supposed it could be quite a lot, considering how much he had known about Hannibal the first time he had laid eyes on the man.
Chapter 17: Relapse
Chapter Text
Will didn’t know what kind of sandwich it was, but it was really good.
Hannibal, predictably, had chosen something quite a bit more fancy than what Will would have chosen, but it tasted fantastic regardless.
“So, Hannibal,” Beverly said, sounding like she was about to start a long list of questions, interrogating Hannibal about his worthiness to be with Will, “what do you like about Will? What first made you interested? You have to admit you make an odd pair.”
Hannibal hummed in thought, his fingers counting Will’s ribs in a way Will was sure he meant to be exactly as distracting as it was. The longer it went on, the more Will thought of Hannibal’s hands, and the more of a problem that became.
“My interest was piqued when I first met him,” Hannibal said, “and he guessed immediately what items from his menu I would prefer. I had never before met anyone who could see me that clearly, even after years of interacting. After conversing with him further, I found his intelligence ran far deeper than simple parlor tricks, and I find intelligence attractive. I cannot claim his appearance has no bearing on my feelings, though. Will is by far the most beautiful man I have ever met.”
Will nearly choked on his sandwich, having to turn away from the table to hide the deep red color of his face and catch his breath.
He had known Hannibal wasn’t going to hold back, but this was just ridiculous.
Beverly laughed at Will, and Hannibal just pulled him closer. That large, musicians hand pressed against Will’s ribcage firmly to hold him in place, and Will had never felt so protected.
“I guess you haven’t said that to Will’s face before,” Beverly guessed, smirking at Will who was still red.
“Not in so many words, no,” Will confirmed, taking a long drink of water to try to calm his rapidly beating heart.
Hannibal hummed thoughtfully, his hand straying from Will’s side up to the nape of his neck where the fingers began carding through Will’s hair. Every slight movement or change in position was more distracting to Will than the last, and he wondered if Hannibal had any idea he was doing that. If all of this was intentional, or he was really acting as idly as he would appear.
“I should endeavor to remedy that,” Hannibal said thoughtfully, “but if you wish for me to further explain myself, outlining every aspect of Will I find attractive, I’m afraid we would be here for quite some time yet. As we each have our own lives to return to outside of this shop, I must summarize.”
Will huffed softly, shaking his head at the man, and Beverly just grinned wider.
“That’s alright, Doctor Lecter,” she said, “I don’t need the whole laundry list. I think I’m getting a pretty good idea.”
Will rolled his eyes, and Hannibal chuckled softly. The sound rumbled against Will where his shoulder was touching Hannibal’s chest, and the sensation soaked into Will’s flesh like heat from a fire. He wanted more of it.
“But Will,” Beverly said, drawing his attention away from the sandwich and his thoughts about domesticity, “what is it you like about Hannibal? He’s clearly lost on you, but you haven’t said nearly a thing about why you like him.”
Will swallowed hard, feeling a fluttering in his stomach at the thought of not only confessing to what he felt about the man to Beverly, but in front of Hannibal himself. Will hadn’t told anyone what he thought of this all. Not really. Even Abigail only knew bits and pieces.
Will could feel the way Hannibal’s gaze sharpened on him, and the intense curiosity he had to hear what Will would say in response. Will knew he should not disappoint the man, though he could not pander to his ego either. Will had to be perfectly honest, but still careful about what he said.
Will had never felt so much that he had been put between a rock and a hard place.
“At first,” Will began, wanting to be honest and open, “I wasn’t all that interested. I knew Hannibal was different from most of my regulars, but that he could cause trouble if I wasn’t careful. I just wanted to keep the peace, so I did what I had to do. I was polite and diffused any tension I could. After a while, I started to enjoy our conversations together. And, of course, I found out he’s a fantastic cook. Most people don’t match me conversationally as well as he does. I freaked out a couple times when I realized he was trying to ask me out, but I guess I got over that after a bit.”
The fingers in Will’s hair were now tracing lines and patterns in the skin behind his ear, and it felt so warm and intimate Will was sure he could just have melted right there. How the Chesapeake Ripper managed to be so gentle with him, Will may never understand, but he was eternally grateful for it.
“Now, I’ve sort of come to terms with the fact that I really, really want this kind of thing,” Will confessed, and it felt more like a confession than anything he had ever said before in his life.
Beverly was looking at Will with a sickly sweet expression, and it made Will flush again. That wasn’t helped by the way Hannibal tilted his head and kissed Will deeply, almost gratefully. As if he had doubted himself before hearing of Will’s feelings. Will wondered if this entire situation hadn’t been just as much torture on Hannibal as it had been for him. Sure, Hannibal hadn’t had to worry about his friends and family being killed if he miss-stepped, but Will knew the man felt things acutely and would certainly have been frustrated by his constantly rebuffed advances.
The kiss didn’t turn aggressive, though Will could taste the underlying hunger. He wondered what might have happened if they had not been in a public setting. Regardless, he was grateful. This kiss was gentle, and loving, even as it was possessive. It was what Will wanted.
They pulled apart, and Will stared into Hannibal’s eyes in stunned bewilderment. He wasn’t sure why he was so startled every time Hannibal showed him such care, but he was smart enough to realize it was at least partially to do with the fact that his first impression of the man had been a realization that he was a prolific serial killer that would come after anyone who posed a threat to him.
“Get a room, you two,” Beverly said, laughing like a kid on Christmas, “I’m going to get diabetes from how sweet you two are. God.”
Will tore his eyes down from Hannibal’s, blushing and anxious. He suddenly wasn’t sure what he was doing. He was playing a dangerous game with a serial killer, and putting his heart out on the line. He wasn’t just humoring Hannibal anymore. He was letting himself get wrapped up in it all.
“Sorry,” Will said quickly, feeling every muscle in his body tense as his mind started buzzing with worry again.
Beverly tipped her head and frowned in concern.
“Don’t be sorry,” she said, “I told you I’m enjoying this. I think I’ve been keeping you both for too long. You both have jobs to get back to, and so do I. But I do intend to see you more often, Will. Hannibal too, now that you’re a package deal.”
Will smiled wanly, unsure what to do now.
---
“Is something wrong?” Hannibal asked, rubbing circles into the back of Will’s hand as they walked.
Will pulled his hand away, anxiety spiking through his chest and making him feel as if he was being watched.
“Yeah, I guess so,” Will admitted, knowing there was no point in lying to the man, “I told you I’m tired of being afraid of you, and that’s true, but that isn’t making me any less afraid. I keep letting my guard down, and it feels nice, but then I remember why I was afraid in the first place. It’s even more exhausting this way, but I don’t know if there’s anything I can do to stop it.”
Hannibal put his hands into his pockets as they walked, and Will wondered how he would react to what he had said. He could imagine a cold, burning anger under his skin that would end up consuming them. Something befitting a killer of this caliber.
“I would like to help, if I can,” Hannibal said at length, and the soft, gentle tone struck Will more deeply than any harsh word could have, “if there is anything within my power that would help, all you need do is ask. I will not do anything without you expressly requesting it.”
Will felt his chest ache, and he didn’t know what to say. No matter how many opportunities Hannibal had to be cruel, the man didn’t lift a finger against Will or his loved ones. Will didn’t know if that was difficult for him, but the effort was appreciated regardless. The Chesapeake Ripper could threaten in order to get his way, but he had chosen to take this course because Will had asked it of him.
“I’ll let you know if I think of anything,” Will said, wringing his own hands together as they stopped in front of the door of the café, “thank you for not being angry.”
Hannibal cupped Will’s face in his hands and tipped his head up so he met Hannibal’s eyes again. The emotion in Hannibal’s features gave Will pause again. He looked sad, and mildly hurt, but hopeful.
“Dear Will,” he said softly, “did you expect anger from me?”
Will felt his face flush a bit at his touch, and he looked down at Hannibal’s tie rather than hold his gaze.
“I didn’t know what to expect, but I was afraid you’d be angry,” he confessed, and Hannibal stroked his thumb across Will’s cheek fondly.
“I find fear beautiful in most cases, Will,” he confided, “but in you I find confidence to be the most alluring. I would that you need not fear anything. I do not wish you to fear me.”
Will smiled sadly and nodded.
“I know. I’m sorry I’m still afraid.”
Hannibal pressed a kiss to Will’s forehead, gentle and thoughtful and warm. Will nearly melted into it, wanting to just let go of everything for once in his life.
But then, Abigail’s face surfaced in his mind, and he pulled Hannibal’s hands away from his face.
“See you tomorrow,” he said softly, and left Hannibal there at the door.
Chapter 18: Yield
Chapter Text
“White Shark Café has something for everyone’s unique tastes, be they predator or prey. What can I get for you this morning?”
The man tipped his head at Will, the way he had seen hawks do as they watched a potential prey item. It made him feel uncomfortable, like he was being sized up. He could see the man was a killer. If not from actual experience, then he fully intended to be soon enough and had the mentality of one already.
And this man was not the kind Will normally got, either. He wasn’t unique in the way Hannibal had been, though. Hannibal was different by nature of his crimes, because they were not merely killing, but art and music and all things poetic. This man was different because he was just looking for someone he could latch onto and kill for. He was looking for purpose in the people around him rather than in himself.
That made him dangerous in a different way than the regulars, and Will hoped he would keep all the drama of his self-discovery far away from the café.
“What do you think?” the man asked, sounding frankly curious.
Will studied him for another moment before he pointed at the menu.
“My guess would be a Blood Spatter and an Accomplice,” he said, pointing out the items for his approval. The man leaned against the counter to view the items, putting him much closer to Will than Will would have preferred, and he hummed in consideration.
“That sounds perfect , Will,” he said with a smile as Will pulled away from him while trying not to look like he was unsettled by the man, “do you mind if I ask how you do that?”
Will turned to get Abigail started on the coffee and to grab the turnover for the man. He was relieved to have an excuse to put some distance between them, and he wasn’t sure why he was reacting that way to him. Will had never had a problem with any of the regulars. Even with Hannibal at the beginning, he hadn’t really had a problem being friendly or acting comfortable with him.
“I do mind, actually,” Will said lightly, knowing he shouldn’t make this one angry any more than the others, “Trade secret I’m afraid. Can’t have all my competitors trying to do the same thing and put me out of business, am I right?”
Will placed the plate on the counter for the man, smiling politely to keep it friendly. He really didn’t need this kind of thing in his shop today.
As Will pulled his hand back after setting the plate down, the man’s hand shot out and gripped him hard by the wrist. Will startled and didn’t have a chance to react before the man had pulled hard, jerking him forward so their faces were mere inches apart.
Will froze, seeing Hannibal in the corner of his eye, standing in the doorway. He knew this would not go well.
The man stared at Will for a moment, so close Will couldn’t meet his eyes and had to stare down at the floor to keep from looking at the man. Will felt his face heat up, but not with embarrassment. With anger.
“I’ll be seeing you around, Will,” the man said softly, placing cash into Will’s hand and releasing him just as Abigail came up with his drink.
Will pulled away sharply, almost stumbling back to give himself some space. The man just smiled politely at Abigail and took the cup and the plate before he found a table. The other regulars were staring at him suspiciously, but Will knew they wouldn’t have to worry about him for long. They wouldn’t get a chance to get to him before Hannibal had already dealt with it all.
Hannibal, himself, had come up to the counter and was watching Will with wide, imploring eyes.
Oh.
Hannibal didn’t think Will would allow him to deal with the man. Hannibal wanted permission to punish him.
Will met Hannibal’s eyes, and he knew Hannibal wouldn’t do a thing if Will asked him not to. Just like that first day with Jeff. Hannibal’s anger would be stayed by Will if he simply wished it.
Will remembered the conversation they’d had in the kitchen. He remembered Hannibal asking if Will would ever ask him to stop, and how Will had honestly said no.
Will flicked his eyes to the stranger, then back to Hannibal, and he nodded slightly.
Hannibal’s eyes flashed with something Will didn’t have a chance to process before Hannibal had made his way over to the man where he sat, and began chatting him up.
Abigail stepped over to Will, shielding him from the room with concern pouring out of her entire being.
“Are you alright, Will?” she asked, “did he hurt you? Did he threaten you? You look really spooked.”
Will took a deep breath, calming his nerves, and shook his head.
“No, I’m fine,” he told her, despite the fact that he had just set his serial killer on someone in revenge. His cannibalistic serial killer. “He’s just a little aggressive in trying to make new friends, I guess.”
Will rubbed absently at his wrist, where he could still feel the prints of the man’s fingers like iron on his flesh. He wanted to scrub it off.
“Well, next time he comes in, I’m going to make the worst coffee he has ever tasted, and if he can handle that then I’ll add a laxative or something the next time.”
Will laughed at the idea, and didn’t bother telling Abigail she wouldn’t have to worry about that. The man wasn’t likely to be coming back any time soon.
“Thanks, Abs,” Will said, trying to shake the whole thing off and keep going, “let’s get back to work.”
---
“You left the door unlocked again.”
Will smiled and shrugged.
“Thought something interesting might wander in,” he said lightly.
Hannibal walked up to him and once again cupped Will’s face in his hands so he could tilt his head and meet Will’s eyes. He was glowing with concern, and Will nearly lost his breath at the sight. Hannibal was genuinely worried about Will, and Will knew he didn’t know how to make it better.
Hannibal was beautiful.
“What if it had not been me who wandered in?” Hannibal asked, his tone soft but deadly serious.
Will chewed his lip. He had known that man from the morning could have come before or instead of Hannibal, and he had known that was a huge risk. But he had wanted Hannibal to come so much he hadn’t cared.
“I trust you to protect me,” he said, and was shocked to realize he believed it. He didn’t feel any more fear of Hannibal, and he didn’t know when that had happened.
Hannibal sighed softly and pressed a kiss to Will’s forehead.
“Are you hurt?” he whispered.
Will sheepishly rolled up his sleeve, revealing a few dark bruises on his wrist from where the man had grabbed him. He had been able to hide them from Abigail all day, since he had told her he wasn’t hurt, but he didn’t feel like he needed to hide it from Hannibal. Hannibal was going to take care of it.
Hannibal’s eyes flashed again, and Will had the chance to understand what it meant. It was all that possession and obsession Will had seen in Hannibal’s eyes before, with some of the hunger and desire as well, but the thing that burned hottest was his anger. Hannibal was livid.
“I guess this guy didn’t get the memo,” Will tried to joke, “no one gets away with upsetting me or Abs in the café.”
Hannibal closed his eyes and pressed both of Will’s hands to his lips reverently. Will felt awkward, having been trying to make light of the situation while Hannibal was clearly having such a hard time with it.
“Will you join me for dinner again?” Hannibal asked, and the way he said it was like a prayer. Supplication.
Will couldn’t think of a single reason to say no, and he didn’t want to. He could think of nothing he wanted more in that moment than to get out of there and go somewhere with Hannibal. Somewhere no one would find him or look for him. Where he didn’t have to worry for just the night.
“Yes please,” Will said, and he saw the real, immediate joy that lit up Hannibal’s face.
Will had made up his mind, and he was done making them both wait for him to stop being afraid. He was ready to stop being afraid, now.
Hannibal didn’t react immediately when Will pulled him into a kiss, but when he was apparently convinced Will wasn’t about to change his mind about it he reciprocated in full.
Will could feel that underlying, burning hunger, and it didn’t frighten him. He had been wanting something gentle all his life, but he was starting to think he was ready for something a bit more. Something consuming.
They made it through dinner, though Will could tell it was a test of Hannibal’s endurance. It was amusing, and he appreciated that Hannibal was willing to do that. Hannibal was being so careful not to mess up. Now that Will was giving him a chance. Hannibal was determined to keep Will, so he was being careful.
But Will could feel something building up in his chest. Something hungry and intense, and he was sure he hadn’t meant for that to happen. He looked at Hannibal, and he wanted to lay claim to him. He wanted to pillage the man’s mouth and mark the column of his throat with his teeth. Will wanted to plunge his hands as deep into Hannibal’s mind as he felt Hannibal had been into his.
He wanted he wanted he wanted.
Will had never wanted anything so dearly. No. So desperately . This wasn’t a dear, soft, longing. This was a hunger more deep than Will had ever known. He wanted to dig into Hannibal’s flesh and cling to him so they would never be apart. He craved the way those burgundy eyes burned with hunger and anger and everything that made the other man burn. He wanted to see them both burn, if that was how to quench this ache that had taken residence in his chest.
When Hannibal led Will up to the bedroom, he didn’t even spare a thought for that stranger he had thrown to the wolves. He didn’t think about where he might be, that he could have eaten part of the man that night, that the man could be still alive and just under his feet.
Hannibal laved his tongue over the marks on Will’s wrist, claiming them as his own instead of allowing that man to have any mark on Will. He nuzzled into Will’s hair, peppering him with kisses and whispering in a language Will didn’t understand.
And Will had never known himself as well as he did that night.
Chapter 19: Repair
Chapter Text
Abigail left the newspaper on the counter, not mentioning the article she had turned it to. It was clear she didn’t want to be the one to bring it up, but she was nervous about what she had seen.
Matthew Brown. That was the stranger Will had set Hannibal on.
And they were all lucky Hannibal wasn’t around when Will saw the display he had made of the body. He would certainly have attacked the Chesapeake Ripper, but he didn’t know if he would have dragged the man to the back room to kill him or do something a bit less appropriate considering the circumstances.
Matthew had been covered in bruises. It was clear Hannibal hadn’t been pleased by the man leaving a mark on Will’s skin, so he had taken the time to leave rings of bruises all up and down his arms and legs, nearly giving Matthew stripes. His eyes had been removed, leaving gaping bloody holes in his face, and they were cradled in his palms. His hands were outstretched, as if offering his eyes to someone, and his throat had been cut from ear to ear.
Will knew he might be biased, but he thought it was just about the most beautiful crime scene he had ever seen.
But the fact that it was so public could really be a problem. The regulars might think they were in danger, or they might think it was going to draw attention to the café. Will didn’t know how to expect them all to react
What was done was done, and Will would just have to deal with whatever came of it.
He just hoped it wouldn’t bring too much trouble.
“Are you upset?” Will asked Abigail, when they finally had a moment without the risk of being overheard.
Abigail sighed softly. She was facing the counter, and Will couldn’t see her face, but he was worried she was disappointed.
“I trust you, Will,” she said, “I always have. I don’t think you’re going to get us in trouble or put us in danger. I’m just worried he might be changing you more than you know.”
Will was silent for a moment.
He knew she was probably justified in that. He had been acting a bit differently since meeting Hannibal, and even more so after he had actually given in to the man. He had been acting differently, but Will didn’t feel like he had really been changed. Hannibal hadn’t convinced him to act this way against his nature, he had just allowed Will to act on his natural impulses. If anything, Will felt more himself now than he ever had before.
“Are you worried I’ll become someone like your dad?” Will asked gently, not wanting to upset her any more than she already was.
Abigail turned to him, her lips pressed into a thin line.
Will knew Abigail had loved her father, but that she also hadn’t forgiven him for doing what he had done. He had killed her repeatedly by proxy, and had been caught. She had feared him for the first, and hated him for the second. He had been loving right up until the point when he wasn’t, when he almost killed her. He hadn’t wanted her to outlive him, and every day she lived after he had been killed she was defying him.
Abigail sometimes wondered if she was doing the right thing or not. Will knew she had a hard time.
“I’m not afraid you’ll get caught, if that’s what you mean,” she said, a bit tense, but Will didn’t blame her for that.
“Are you afraid I’ll hurt you?” Will asked, honestly wanting to know what she was worried about.
Abigail huffed lightly and shook her head.
“I’m afraid you’ll lose yourself. I’m afraid you’ll stop caring about what you always have. I’m afraid you’ll stop caring about me, or about the shop, or about your own life. I don’t know what to expect, and that’s why I’m worried.”
Will frowned.
“Abs, you know I’ll never stop caring about those things,” Will said, hoping he sounded sincere so she would know he was serious, “I won’t let him change me that much. If you ever think I’m getting there, you have permission to slap sense into me.”
Abigail smiled gently, clearly still nervous. Will knew there wasn’t much he could say to make her feel better. He would just have to prove his point by not letting himself stop caring about her. But he didn’t think that would be a problem.
Soon enough, there were customers in the shop again, and they had to go back to their regular routine.
Will noticed a few regulars didn’t show up that day, and he was sad to think they might not return. While he hadn’t set out to create a safe place for people like Hannibal, they had become his friends. He didn’t want them to think it wasn’t safe.
“You saw the news?” Jeff asked, seeming more curious than nervous, which was a relief to Will.
Will nodded, but didn’t offer further comment. He didn’t know what to say about the entire thing.
“Was it Achilles?”
Will looked up at Jeff, and he saw the man already knew the answer to his question. The real question he was asking was if Will had sanctioned this course of action. Jeff wanted to know if Will still had the reins, or if Achilles was a problem they were going to have to deal with, one way or another.
“Yes,” Will told him, handing Jeff his usual order of coffee.
Jeff nodded and sat down at a table. The shop was oddly quiet that morning, as if everyone was waiting for the worst to happen. That being the case, Will was sure everyone had overheard his short exchange with Jeff, and he hoped they would keep to themselves about it. He didn’t want anyone else to get hurt, but he wasn’t overly fond of the anticipatory hush in the shop either.
When Hannibal walked in, Will wasn’t sure what to expect.
A ripple of whispers ran around the shop as Hannibal approached the counter. The man ignored them in a way only men used to being the center of attention could. Will was sure only Hannibal could have borne it with such grace.
Hannibal stepped up to make his order, and Will grabbed his tie, pulling him into a kiss over the counter. The rest of the shop became even more deadly quiet than it had been, and Will released the man with a grin.
Hannibal was stunned, his pupils blown wide as he stared at Will. Will just continued to smile as he fixed Hannibal’s tie, smoothing the fabric down so no one would know how his wardrobe had been abused.
“Morning, Achilles,” Will said pleasantly, “what can I get for you today?”
Hannibal’s mind seemed to catch up with itself, and he returned Will’s smile easily.
“I’ll have whatever you’d like to give me,” he replied.
Will felt the tension in the shop dissipate immediately. He had been hoping for a result like that, but he hadn’t dared to expect it. The regulars trusted Will, and he had known that, but he hadn’t known if they trusted him that much. He hoped this would be more or less the end of this entire conflict, but again he didn’t dare expect it to be.
Will got Hannibal his order, and the shop began to come alive with the regular soft conversation. Abigail glanced nervously at Hannibal, but didn’t say anything to either of them. Will hoped she wasn’t upset with him, and he would talk with her about it later to be sure, but for the moment he was content in the knowledge that she was safe.
---
“Abigail is not pleased with my actions,” Hannibal said from his seat in the kitchen as he watched Will finish up the baking for the night.
Will sighed softly and shook his head.
“I don’t think she’s pleased with either of us at the moment,” he agreed, “but she’s just nervous. I can’t blame her, considering how things turned out with her dad.”
Hannibal nodded. Will found his presence comforting, and was glad he’s invited the man to join him that evening.
“I hope you will not consider this rude,” Hannibal said, and Will scoffed at the idea, to which Hannibal only smiled, “but why are you here?”
Will frowned and looked to Hannibal for explanation.
“You are clearly educated, and have a natural ability to identify killers with merely a glance,” he elaborated, “yet you are here, running a coffee shop that, while charming and successful, is far from sensational. I find it hard to believe this is what you envisioned for yourself when you reached adulthood.”
Will huffed a soft laugh. He didn’t know why, but he was glad Hannibal was asking that. He supposed it could be that this line of questioning showed Hannibal was truly interested in him, and perhaps that he had more long term plans for them than Will had previously guessed. Regardless, he would try to give the most honest answers he could, despite the discomfort he felt with the subject.
“You’re right in thinking so,” Will said, “when I was young, I thought I’d be a boat mechanic like my dad. Didn’t realize there were other options. About High School, I got into law enforcement.”
Will glanced up at Hannibal, and didn’t see any surprise or judgment in his face. Only sincere interest.
“A criminal profiler is what I’d thought I’d be,” Will continued, “nothing glamorous or scary. Just looking at crimes and thinking like someone else. I’m pretty good at both of those.”
Will could remember all the classes and lectures he had attended. All the papers he’d read and work he’d done. All the smiles and compliments the professors and what he’d thought of as “more adults” had thrown his way. He’d had a bright future and would become the best of them. That’s what they had all said.
“Few weeks before graduation, I got real sick. Encephalitis.”
Will saw the look of devastation descend on Hannibal’s face, as if he had just gotten the diagnosis. Will had no doubt the man understood the implications behind the words. What Will had likely gone through before finally being diagnosed and properly treated. In some ways, he was glad Hannibal was saddened by this information, because it meant he really understood.
“I’d always been a mite strange,” Will continued, determined to get it all out in the open now, “which is probably why it took so long for people to notice. I kept thinking I would get better. But I didn’t.”
“Oh, Will,” Hannibal whispered, almost more to himself than to Will. His distress was evident, and Will felt comforted.
Will didn’t have many people who sympathized with him over this. He didn’t tell anyone about this if they would pity him, but it was something he hated having to carry alone. Hannibal didn’t pity him, but his understanding of Will as a person was growing.
Will smiled sadly and took a breath before he finished the story.
“I missed graduation, got hospitalized, and couldn’t afford college anymore. All the money I’d saved up went to hospital bills, so I had to go job hunting right away. I bounced around a bit before I landed on my feet. I saved up enough to get this place, and didn’t feel like college was something I was really interested in anymore. The encephalitis might have done some permanent damage, but I don’t know. All I know is I don’t think I’d pass the psych portion of the testing to get a job as a profiler if I ever went that way again. I’m fine where I am for the time being. I have a shop, Abigail, and now you.”
Will felt himself blush after he said that last bit, not sure how Hannibal would react to it. He was glad he’d managed to get through his story, but now it was up to Hannibal choose what that meant for them.
Will washed flour off his hands, and when he turned around he was caught in Hannibal’s arms. He hadn’t even heard the man move, but he wasn’t about to complain.
When Hannibal kissed him, Will all but melted. He felt safe and cherished, and there was still a hunger in him that Hannibal had somehow awoken. Will just wanted Hannibal like this.
Chapter 20: Acquaintance
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
“I don’t know how to feel about this,” Will said, knowing Hannibal was likely growing tired of his doubtful comments.
Hannibal smiled indulgently and straightened Will’s tie for him. Will wasn’t used to wearing a suit, but Hannibal had invited him to an opera, and there was a dress code for that kind of thing.
“You needn’t be sure how to feel yet,” Hannibal replied calmly, “you are free to change your mind as often as you like over the course of the evening. But I do hope you will enjoy it.”
Will sighed and resisted the urge to run a hand through his hair. He’d actually styled it today, and didn’t want to ruin it.
“I hope I don’t make a complete fool of myself,” he said, “I’m not used to your lifestyle, Hannibal. What if everyone can tell?”
Hannibal’s eyes softened impossibly more, and he pressed a kiss to Will’s forehead.
“Everyone in that building had a first experience,” he said softly, “and if they judge you for being introduced into this sphere, they are not worth the air they breathe.”
Will smiled a bit, feeling marginally better. He was still nervous, but he wanted to make Hannibal happy. They had always met on Will’s turf to this point, save for the times they went to Hannibal’s home. Every public meeting had been in the café, and Will knew that wasn’t fair. Hannibal had been introduced into Will’s life, had met everyone Will knew, and it was only fair if Will did the same for Hannibal’s life.
“You’ll have to tell me about your first experience,” Will said, feeling strangely exposed despite the layers of fabric shielding himself from the outside world, “maybe tonight. I already told you all the sticky details of my past. Reciprocation.”
Hannibal grinned.
“Absolutely,” he said, “I would like nothing more than to be known by you entirely.”
Will believed it.
There was socializing before the performance, much to Will’s continued dismay. He wanted to make Hannibal happy, but he didn’t have to like being around so many people.
“Hannibal, dear, I haven’t seen you in ages.”
Hannibal smiled charmingly at the woman, his hand flexing on Will’s waist minutely.
“I have been quite preoccupied, Luisa,” Hannibal replied, his tone apologetic while simultaneously self-satisfied, “may I introduce you to my partner? This is Will Graham.”
The woman looked at Will, and he was surprised to find she wasn’t judging him. She was pleased and curious, but not intrusively so. She smiled warmly, appraising him with a gentle amusement he was entirely unused to when in the presence of anyone wearing something that cost his entire earnings for a day.
“Charmed,” She said, “I was beginning to think we’d never have the pleasure of seeing Hannibal again, but if he’s been busy pursuing you I don’t hold it against him a bit.”
Will felt his face flush and he smiled shyly.
“I didn’t intend to steal him, I assure you,” Will told her, “In fact, I was against his attentions at the beginning.”
That earned him a laugh, and Will felt instantly more at ease. He had worried he wouldn’t know how to act, but it seemed like it wasn’t so hard. He could do this.
“Is that true, Hannibal?” Luisa asked, shaking her head slightly in disbelief, “I can’t imagine anyone turning you down.”
Hannibal sighed softly, smiling fondly at Will.
“It’s the truth,” he admitted, “in fact, that was likely a sugared version. Will made his objections very clear to me, but I am not easily dissuaded.”
Will smirked to himself.
“No, you are not,” he agreed.
Luisa was beaming at them, charmed by the easy intimacy they had between them. Will felt far more comfortable than he had expected to be, and he was glad he had Hannibal there. He was a grounding and guiding presence among the throng of strangers.
“You simply must meet Charles,” Luisa said, casting her eyes around the room in search of this man, “He would be so delighted.”
Hannibal seemed pleased with that, so Will decided it would be fine to follow this woman for the time being.
Charles turned out to be just as pleasant as Luisa, and Will was actually pleased to meet him.
“Son, you must have some brilliant brain in that head of yours,” Charles said, absolutely shining with pleasure, “Hannibal has always gravitated to the more intelligent ones, but I’ve never seen him bring anyone to the opera.”
Will smiled, knowing his blush had stained his face by now but not caring. He hadn’t realized people would be so accepting of him. He had expected a crowd of snobs, people who looked down their noses at people like him. This was so much better.
He thought being Hannibal’s companion might have something to do with it.
“I don’t know if I’d say that,” Will replied, shaking his head, “but I have a knack for psychology, so we have something in common to talk about.”
Charles and Luisa laughed lightly, and Hannibal hummed.
“Far more than that,” he said, “Will profiled me with nothing more than a glance. I nearly thought he had studied me before we met.”
Will huffed a laugh.
“That’s amazing,” Luisa said, “I’ve heard nearly everyone claim he’s an enigma. No one can understand him past what he shows us.”
Will raised his eyebrows and turned to Hannibal, who appeared a bit sheepish.
“You can see why I was so interested in you from the start,” he said, “you were the first to see beneath the mask.”
Will knew it was more than that, because Hannibal had decided Will was the only person who could truly see him and understand. Hannibal had considered Will to be the only person who might accept him as he was.
And Hannibal believed Will deserved it. He wasn’t merely a sheep.
Charles and Luisa excused themselves to speak with a few of their friends, but Hannibal was never in want of company. People flocked to him, making Will’s head swim. Everyone seemed eager for Hannibal’s approval and companionship.
As they spoke with each person, Will began to understand Hannibal much better. Not only had Will seen through his façade and called him out on his true identity, he hadn’t clamored for his attention. He had been uninterested from the beginning, posing a unique challenge for the man. Hannibal had been accustomed to this kind of interaction with others, so had been intrigued by Will’s response to his attention.
Will began to appreciate Hannibal more. It had to be exhausting to play this kind of part for everyone, and have no one see it was false.
Hannibal looked at Will, and his gaze grew curious. Will thought maybe he saw the renewed understanding in his face. They eventually made their way to their seats, and Will knew Hannibal was going to say something about it.
“You seem to be enjoying yourself,” Hannibal noted, a pleased sparkle in his eye.
Will nodded.
“Peeking behind the curtain,” he said with a smile, “finding out how you operate when you’re not poking at uninterested café workers.”
Hannibal huffed softly, feigning annoyance. Will could see the amusement in his eyes regardless.
“Café owner,” Hannibal replied, “I didn’t much poke at Abigail. I have no interest in poking at that new hire, either.”
Will laughed softly.
“Aw, Billy isn’t that bad. He’s one of you guys, you know. That’s part of why I hired him.”
Hannibal grimaced.
“He is a boy with very little taste. No finesse.”
Will pulled Hannibal into a kiss.
“He makes coffee well.”
And with that, the opera was starting. Hannibal didn’t reply, and Will allowed himself to watch the performance. He could feel Hannibal’s enjoyment, like a light radiating from him as the music swelled. With him there, Will found he was better able to enjoy it himself. He had never had the opportunity to enjoy opera, but he had never been a fan of theaters in general. There were always too many people, and nowhere to direct his empathy. But with Hannibal, Will could really feel what it was supposed to be like.
Will could do this more often, as long as he had Hannibal there with him.
To Will’s irritation, there was more socializing during the intermission. He wasn’t too worried about it, but he knew he would be socially exhausted by the time the day was up.
“I might have to give the café to Abs if I keep leaving her to do evening prep by herself,” Will told Hannibal when there was a break in conversation.
Hannibal laughed softly.
“She wouldn’t take it,” Hannibal replied, “she is set on college.”
Will agreed with that, and then he felt Hannibal tense beside him. Looking around, Will saw a portly man making a beeline for them, followed closely by a taller man with an intense gaze. Will gathered the shorter man was the object of Hannibal’s discomfort, but Will thought the taller one looked like more of a threat.
“Doctor Lecter!” the short man said excitedly, and Will realized he must be a patient. That explained Hannibal’s reaction. “We just keep running into each other. It’s like fate.”
Will almost laughed, but thought Hannibal wouldn’t appreciate it.
“Yes,” Hannibal said blandly, “quite a series of coincidences.”
The taller man seemed to decide he had waited long enough for his companion to introduce him, stepping forward and extending a hand to Hannibal.
“I’m Tobias Budge,” he said, flicking his eyes between Hannibal and Will curiously.
Hannibal nodded.
“Mister Budge. I have heard so much about you,” Hannibal said, continuing to sound uninterested, “Franklyn. This is Will Graham.”
Hannibal set his hand on the small of Will’s back in a possessive gesture, which seemed to be lost on Franklyn. Tobias, though, tipped his head minutely at the show.
“Pleasure to meet you,” Franklyn said excitedly, taking Will’s offered hand with a vigor Will thought entirely too much, “I’m one of Doctor Lecter’s patients. I don’t suppose he’s mentioned me.”
Will smiled wanly, pulling his hand from the man’s sweaty grip to offer it to Budge.
“The pleasure’s mine, I’m sure,” he said coolly, “and no, he hasn’t. Hannibal prefers to keep his profession separate from his personal life.”
Budge released his hand within a polite amount of time, much to Will’s relief, and Hannibal’s hand pressed more firmly for just a moment. Will knew he was grateful for that last bit, because it was clear this patient was a bit too infatuated with him.
But Budge was a problem. Will could see it in his eyes. He was a killer, too. Will could see the calluses on the pads of his fingers, and it all fell into place. He made strings from the guts of his victims.
Franklyn seemed a bit deflated, having hoped Hannibal would have talked about him.
And it was time for them to return to their seats, to Hannibal’s evident relief. He excused them and they enjoyed the last half of the opera together. But Will’s mind was turning. He was distracted from the opera because of the new acquaintances he’d made just then.
Notes:
Happy Valentine's day! If you're reading this on the day I've posted it, odds are you're single, but have some cute date night vibes from the boys. <3
Chapter 21: Evening
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
After the opera, there was yet more socializing. Will was starting to feel the drain, and he hoped no one would be too difficult. Hannibal promised they could leave early, likely because he could see the way Will was struggling to keep a smile on his face.
“I just can’t believe you would neglect your social life for so long,” Their most recent acquaintance drawled. Will hadn’t bothered to remember his name. “I almost thought you had died.”
Hannibal’s smile was tight-lipped, and Will could tell he wasn’t terribly fond of the man.
“If perfection is stagnation, then heaven is a swamp,” he said easily, “I was not neglecting my social life in the slightest. In fact, I have made quite a few new acquaintances in the short time I was absent.”
“Yes,” the man said, almost a sneer as he looked Will up an down doubtfully, “that’s clear. I dread to think what kind of people they may be when not vying for your good graces.”
Will prickled at that, stung by the idea this man thought he was some gold digging lowlife. He could see the truth the man was trying to hide behind his snobbery. He was jealous, because Hannibal didn’t like him, and he couldn’t understand why he would choose to be around someone he deemed lesser.
It was almost funny, since Hannibal wasn’t at all the man any of these people thought him to be. They were all vying for the attention of a serial killer.
“Hannibal has little to worry about in that respect,” Will said offhandedly, almost waving away the words like offensive smoke, “he is a very good judge of character, and is not fooled by the faces men wear.”
The strange man gaped slightly, stunned into silence by Will’s words. Will could see Hannibal suppressing a smile beside him, and he offered his own benign grin to the man as he continued.
“Hannibal respects only those who are true to themselves, and after that he can grow to like a few.”
The man turned slightly red and quickly excused himself. Will felt entirely satisfied with himself, but more tired than before. Hannibal huffed a soft laugh and pulled Will tighter against his side.
“You are startlingly beautiful when you do that,” he murmured into Will’s ear, and it was Will’s turn to flush, though with pleasure.
“I’ll just bet,” he replied, “even around your fancy friends, you can’t help but be antagonistic.”
Hannibal hummed.
“I was not the one making veiled accusations,” he replied calmly.
Will scoffed.
“You would have if I hadn’t,” he shot back, “if only because he was being rude to me.”
Hannibal said nothing, which was enough of a confirmation. They were discussing their escape plan when an unwanted pair turned back up.
Franklyn was glowing, apparently recovered from Will’s earlier comment, and Tobias seemed perfectly satisfied to be drug around with him.
Like a pilot fish, Will thought.
“What did you think of the show, Doctor Lecter?” Franklyn asked brightly, apparently having forgotten Will’s presence for the moment.
Hannibal’s tight-lipped smile was back, and Will thought he might be seriously considering a recipe to incorporate Franklyn into.
“The performance was wonderful, as always,” Hannibal replied politely, “And I enjoyed it entirely.”
Franklyn nodded energetically, nearly bouncing on his toes like a child. Will saw a flash of disdain in Budge’s eyes, and thought Hannibal might not have the chance to kill Franklyn. Budge would find some use for him, despite the man not being lean enough to yield tough gut.
“The orchestra did well,” Will said, watching Budge for a reaction, “Don’t you think, mister Budge?”
Tobias was apparently surprised enough by Will addressing him that his mask slipped a bit. Will saw the raw shock and hunger there for the moment. The hunger was nothing like Hannibal’s. Tobias didn’t love. He was what most serial killers were called.
A monster.
“Indeed,” he said, sliding back into his persona of collected indifference, “Are you familiar with the opera, mister Graham?”
The way he said Will’s name felt like a taunt. As if the mere fact that he knew Will’s name was a threat. Will knew better, though.
“It’s my first time,” he admitted without shame, “I tend to avoid crowded places. But I enjoyed it, if only for my company’s enjoyment.”
At the mention of Hannibal, Tobias turned his eyes back to the object of Franklyn’s obsession assessingly. Will wondered if he could see the beast wearing the human skin, or could only sense its presence.
“Well,” Franklyn piped up, unable to stand not being included, “for a first time, La Traviata is a wonderful choice.”
Budge seemed to disagree, but said nothing. Instead, Hannibal stepped in to take the role he had been given by the society he lived in.
“I would have preferred Faust for Will, myself,” he said magnanimously, “but I was anxious to show Will this aspect of my life.”
Franklyn seemed slightly deflated by Hannibal’s reminder that he had not been invited to share these things with him, but Budge just seemed more curious.
Will suddenly felt the weight of all his exhaustion fall onto his shoulders. He nudged Hannibal gently, and the message got through.
“I’m terribly sorry, but we must be on our way,” Hannibal said, pulling Will close to his side and smiling apologetically to the pair of men they had been talking to, “It was pleasant to meet you, Mr. Budge. Franklyn.”
Will had to hide a smirk behind his hand as the two men nodded and Hannibal led him to the exit.
Once in the car, Will had the chance to mull over what had happened. After a few minutes, he burst into laughter.
Hannibal looked over at him, bewildered.
“Franklyn,” Will said, tears coming to his eyes from laughter, “he’s your patient.”
Hannibal didn’t seem to see why that was funny.
“On our first date, I mentioned a hypothetical patient who described their feelings the same way you were doing. I didn’t think I’d gotten so close to the truth. You were thinking of Franklyn when you got all quiet that night, weren’t you? You thought I was equating your behavior to his.”
Hannibal pressed his lips together and didn’t reply. Will couldn’t help but laugh harder.
“How long did you seethe over the idea of being compared to him?” Will asked, and Hannibal continued to refuse to answer, “I can imagine you, sitting in your study, staring into the fire, devastated because I accused you of acting like that man. I bet you nursed an entire bottle of wine that night, maybe you even considered killing him to prove you’re better. Unless you thought about killing me.”
“No,” Hannibal said, finally deigning to speak, “I had already decided I would not kill you.”
Will smiled, shaking his head at the man.
“You’re not objecting to any of the other things I just said,” he said, “just the thinking about killing me.”
Hannibal didn’t reply, apparently deciding to continue being quiet as they pulled up to the house.
“I also called you insecure that night. I didn’t realize how accurate it all was until now. I should thank Franklyn personally for this. God. I haven’t laughed this hard in years,” Will said, barely managing to get out of the car without falling over.
Hannibal didn’t seem amused at all, but that just made it all more funny to Will. The man was always so serious about things, and he had felt insecure about being compared to Franklyn. The Chesapeake Ripper was insecure.
“Are you going to pout all night?” Will asked, grabbing Hannibal’s arm as they reached the door, feeling a bit bad for going on for so long about the whole thing. He still thought it was funny, but didn’t necessarily want to really upset Hannibal. “You know I don’t think you’re like him, right?”
Hannibal pressed his lips together, considering as he opened the door and they stepped into the house. Will worried that he actually had managed to offend Hannibal. It had all been in fun, but he was dealing with a serial killer, after all.
“Come on,” Will pressed, honestly concerned now, “Do you really think I’d be able to stand being around someone like Franklyn? Not to mention actively choose to be around them?”
Hannibal turned to Will, the interior of the house still dark because he hadn’t turned the lights on yet. His eyes seemed to spark with something intense when they met Will’s, and Will felt pinned in place by his gaze.
It was like being cornered by a tiger.
“Tell me, Will,” Hannibal said lowly, his voice rumbling and dangerous, “are you merely here in order to pretend at being unafraid, or do you find yourself drawn to that which you should fear, yet don’t? Is this you facing your fears, or embracing your nature?”
As Hannibal spoke, he prowled towards Will, encroaching on his space with that same dangerous intensity in his gaze. Will backed up until he was against the door they had just entered through, but not out of fear. He just wanted to keep Hannibal’s face in view for as long as possible, watching the shadows shift dynamically across his features and accentuating the danger he presented.
Will felt adrenaline rush through him, but he didn’t feel afraid. He wasn’t afraid of Hannibal anymore, wondered if he ever really had been. Maybe his fear had all been an act to begin with. Maybe he had been fooling himself because it was the reaction that made sense at the beginning. What Will did feel was hunger. He ached with it.
“You don’t scare me, Hannibal,” Will said, placing a hand in the middle of Hannibal’s chest, as if to push him away, “I think you’re frightened of me, though. The same way a predator fears the man holding its leash.”
Will saw the way Hannibal’s pupils blew wide, even in the dark. The man pushed forward against Will’s hand, and Will let him. Up to the point where they were sharing breath, and the tips of their noses barely brushed. Then, Will held him back.
“Care to weigh in, Doctor?” he whispered, smirking as he blinked slowly.
Hannibal’s breath hitched slightly.
“You are by far the most dangerous person I have ever met,” Hannibal replied, then pushed forward again and captured Will’s lips in a kiss.
Notes:
Wrapping up date night with a nice little conversation about glorious becoming. Very like our boys.
<3
Chapter 22: Planning
Chapter Text
“You know, Tobias Budge is one of you guys, right?” Will asked, and Hannibal stopped halfway through tying his tie to look at him questioningly, “like the regulars.”
Understanding dawned on Hannibal’s face and he finished tying his tie into an intricate knot Will didn’t know how to do.
“You think mister Budge is a killer,” he said.
Will bristled slightly at the wording, though he knew Hannibal probably didn’t mean anything by it.
“I know he is,” he said, a bit sharper than he had intended, “he kills people and turns their guts into strings for instruments.”
Hannibal stopped again, walking over to where Will sat on the bed. Will had dressed already, before Hannibal had even woken up. The café had gotten him into a routine of excessively early rising, and even someone like Hannibal didn’t get up quite that early.
“How does that make you feel?”
Will laughed as Hannibal set his hands on Will’s shoulders, right at the base of his neck. It could have been threatening, but Will was comforted by it.
“Back to psychiatry, doctor?” he asked, and Hannibal’s grip tightened slightly on his neck, not a warning. It was just a response. “I feel worried he’s going to do something.”
Hannibal hummed, leaning down and kissing Will gently.
“What makes you think he would do something?” Hannibal asked, and Will stood up to stand with him.
“Because of the way he looked at you,” Will answered softly.
Hannibal brought his hands up to cradle Will’s jaw and pulled him into another soft kiss. Will allowed it, knowing Hannibal was trying to placate his fear. He didn’t know why Hannibal would be so intent on keeping him from worrying about this, especially if it could be a problem, but he would accept the affection offered.
“What way did he look at me, Will?” Hannibal asked.
Will sighed and shook his head.
“Like he knows what you are, and he wants to do something about it.”
Hannibal moved his arms around Will’s waist, pulling him close and nuzzling at his hair. It felt like Hannibal was trying to keep Will from freaking out, and it was starting to prickle at him. He didn’t like being treated like he was one wrong move from hysterical.
“What do you think he might do about it?” Hannibal asked.
Will pushed him back and glared at Hannibal, forcing him to pay attention. He had accepted enough affection for the moment, and wanted his point to get across.
“He’s going to kill someone, which isn’t necessarily a problem,” Will told him, “but he knows you and me, and knows our connection, so I don’t think it’s too far fetched to say he’s going to draw attention towards the café. You know how bad that would be for me.”
Hannibal sighed and nodded somberly. He was finally taking this seriously.
“What would you have me do?” Hannibal asked, meeting Will’s eyes with an intensity that would have frightened Will only weeks before.
Will chewed his lower lip, unsure what to say.
Did he want to set Hannibal onto another killer, just to protect himself?
But he would also be protecting Abigail, and all the regulars who were like his family. Will had never had a family before opening the café, had never really known what that would be like. He had never wanted a family, because it had felt too distant and out of reach. Now, he had one, strange and dangerous as it may be. He wanted to protect them.
It didn’t feel right to just sent Hannibal off to do all the work, though. He had already killed one man simply because Will had given him the go ahead. If Will did this again, would Hannibal begin to feel that was all Will wanted from him?
Hannibal lifted a hand and gently rolled his thumb over Will’s lip, pulling it from between his teeth. The touch was so unexpected and intimate Will froze instantly. He didn’t know how to respond.
Hannibal smiled fondly and kissed Will softly.
“You will damage your delicate lip if you bite it like that,” Hannibal whispered, his nose brushing Will’s, “I would ask you allow me that privilege.”
Will huffed a laugh, closing his eyes and pressing his forehead to Hannibal’s.
“Pretentious,” he said, “you’re trying to avoid the subject, but we really do need to talk about Tobias.”
Hannibal kissed Will again.
“I will ensure he is not a problem to you,” Hannibal promised.
Will almost began to chew on his lip again, but resisted.
“You don’t have to,” he said, “you’re not some dog I set on a trail. You’re not a pet serial killer I can just set loose on people I don’t like. That just isn’t healthy.”
Hannibal smiled softly.
“For you or for me?” he asked.
Will shook his head.
“It doesn’t matter,” he said, “I just can’t abide that.”
Hannibal nodded gently. Will felt as if Hannibal understood him, which was good. He hoped Hannibal agreed, but couldn’t be sure if he did.
“I’ll ask again, Will,” Hannibal said, “what would you have me do?”
“I don’t know,” Will confessed, “I don’t know if I want you to do anything. I don’t know if I should do something myself.”
Hannibal kissed Will again.
“Whatever you decide, I will be there for you.”
Will smiled and kissed Hannibal back.
---
“You aren’t gonna believe this, Will,” Abigail said, her eyes sparkling with excitement.
Will raised his eyebrows and waited for her to tell him something he wouldn’t believe.
“I was accepted to Johns Hopkins!” She squealed, bouncing a bit in her excitement.
Will blinked once before he shook his head.
“What?” he asked, “I didn’t even know you applied there. Their acceptance rate is really low, and they’re expensive. You can handle that?”
Abigail continued beaming, and Will was having a hard time understanding what was going on.
“I’ve been saving up for forever,” she reminded him, “I can do it. They have basically the best psychology program in Maryland. I didn’t think I’d be accepted, because they do have freakishly low acceptance rates, but I guess I’ve got something going for me I didn’t know about.”
Will grinned as well, excited for her. He felt a pang of sadness at the thought of her leaving, but pushed it aside to focus on being happy. She really had been working towards this for a long time, and had gone through hell with her father to get here. Will was glad she was finally going to get what she wanted.
“Well, that’s fantastic,” Will said, “thank god for good luck, right? But honestly, you’ve earned this. Hard work is really what it’s about. Let’s throw a party. All the regulars. We can have a separate one for your non-killer friends, too, if you want.”
Abigail whacked Will’s shoulder and stuck her tongue out at him. Will just continued to grin at her. He was completely serious. He knew the regulars would want a chance to celebrate her success and say goodbye before she left for college. He didn’t think it’d be a good idea to invite civilians to that gathering, so he was willing to throw two separate parties. Abigail deserved it.
“If you’re joking about that, you’re going to regret it,” Abigail warned, “because I’m absolutely taking you up on it. If you won’t, I bet I could convince Achilles to fund a party for me.”
Abigail offered her most innocent smile, and Will dropped his jaw theatrically.
“This is coercion, or entrapment, or something,” he said, shaking his head and pouting, “you’re using my partner against me. The worst part is, I bet you’re right. He’s exactly that kind of person.”
Abigail grinned widely, and Will sighed.
“Lucky for both of us, I wasn’t joking. Two parties. One safe, and one a little exciting.”
Abigail laughed and hugged Will.
“I’m going to miss you so much,” she said.
Will laughed and hugged her back.
“You won’t even be that far away,” he said, “you could visit every day if you felt like it. Don’t act like you’re crossing an ocean. You’ll make me cry if you do.”
Abigail huffed softly.
“If you don’t cry when I leave, I’ll break your kneecaps,” she said, “You know I don’t make idle threats.”
Will laughed again and shook his head.
“I believe you, and don’t worry. I’ll cry plenty. Just don’t tell Hannibal.”
Abigail released him and grinned.
“We’ll see.”
Chapter 23: Preparing
Chapter Text
As the regulars had been coming in, Will had let them each know about the party. He didn’t have any way to contact them outside of the café, but that was alright. They were reliable, if nothing else. A few had asked where Abigail would be going, but Will couldn’t tell them. It just wasn’t safe for them to know. They had all been understanding, and some hadn’t even asked because they knew how Will would respond.
It was strange how understanding and accepting a group of serial killers was. Probably more so than regular people.
Will had just gotten done serving Carrie her coffee when none other than Tobias Budge walked in.
Will had done a little research since meeting the man, and had found a few disappearances Will thought could be attributed to him, but he didn’t seem to be the flashy kind of killer.
At least he hadn’t been.
Just last week, there had been a display made of a member of the Baltimore Orchestra.
It really rubbed Will the wrong way. He had seen the meaning behind it, and he didn’t like it at all.
Tobias wanted to get the attention of the Chesapeake Ripper. He wanted to get his attention, and show him how well he played. Tobias Budge was trying to draw Hannibal away from Will.
Will didn’t take kindly to that.
“Good morning, Will,” Tobias said, smiling as if they were good friends.
Will did not smile.
“Good morning. What can I get you?”
Tobias considered it, in the way they always did before asking Will to guess. It was a pattern, and one he was not thrilled to see today. Not from him.
“What would you guess?” Tobias asked.
The way he said it further irritated Will. It was like Tobias was already laughing at him. Expecting him to fall short, or to jump through the hoops for his pleasure. Tobias thought he was better than Will, perhaps because he knew Will was not a killer. He thought he was better for Hannibal.
“Either make an order or leave my shop, please,” Will said, deciding it wasn’t worth engaging the man, “I’m not a circus act, sir.”
Budge smiled, not seeming perturbed.
“I’m sure you’re not,” he said, “I don’t think men like Lecter enjoy the circus.”
Will wanted to bite the man’s throat out. Anyone could have heard him say Hannibal’s name, and that was dangerous in the café. The people here weren’t safe people, no matter how they acted towards Will and Abigail.
“You don’t know anything about him, Tobias Budge,” Will said, smiling wickedly at the man across the counter, “now either order or leave. I have things to do other than humor your bizarre assumptions about my partner.”
There was a spark of anger in Budge’s eyes at that, which satisfied Will immensely.
“You might be more careful what you say, Will,” Budge said lowly, “wouldn’t want miss Hobbs to lose another father.”
And he left.
Will felt irritated, but only mildly threatened. He knew he was in no real danger from Tobias. He might not even have to worry about it at all. He had said the man’s name aloud in the shop, and there were several regulars at the nearby tables. They had heard him make those veiled threats, and would more than likely take care of him for Will.
But Tobias should not be underestimated. Will knew that. He knew too much, and would probably make sure the FBI showed up at Will’s door the moment anything happened to him.
Will would have to find a different way to take care of him.
“Was that guy bothering you?” Carrie asked, pulling on a strand of hair nervously. She always had her head down, looking at everyone through her eyelashes. It wasn’t flirtatious, but just anxiety around direct eye contact.
Will considered it for a moment.
“Yeah,” he said, “but don’t worry about him. I can handle it. But if anything happens to me, you know where to look. Thanks for asking.”
Carrie glanced as Misery, who was sitting at the same table. They exchanged a glance, and Misery bit her lip.
“You sure, Will?” Misery asked, “He sounded like he meant to do something to Abigail.”
Will smiled reassuringly.
“No, he means to do something to me, which would affect Abs. But I can take care of him so he doesn’t hurt anyone else. Don’t do anything unless something happens to me.”
Misery didn’t seem convinced, but Will could see that Carrie would do as he asked at least. He thought it likely she would be able to convince Misery to do the same. Tobias would be his problem to deal with. He didn’t have to worry about them doing anything unwise.
Billy walked out from the kitchen and raised an eyebrow at Will.
“You okay?” he asked, and Will shrugged.
“Fine,” he answered, “know anyone who’d be interested in a job here? When Abs leaves I’ll need a few more hands.”
Billy considered it, smiling blandly.
“I might,” he said, “and I’ll definitely scout for you, but I was hoping I could get the afternoon off today. I’ve got a thing with my girlfriend.”
Will nodded and waved him away.
“Yeah, go ahead. I can handle things here. And Abigail should come in at some point as well.”
Billy’s smile turned more genuine, and he thanked Will.
Will wondered if Billy’s girlfriend knew what he was. From the very little Billy had said about her, Sidney sounded intelligent. She might know, even if Billy hadn’t told her, but Will knew she might not. Not everyone was like him.
Will didn’t bother himself with things like that. He didn’t much care what Billy did in his free time, and wasn’t about to get involved with something. He had enough on his plate already. Especially with this new debacle with Tobias Budge.
---
The Chordophone shop was small. The kind of place you could usually trust to be good at what they did, because it was so specialized. A bell rang over the door as Will entered, and he heard a violin abruptly stop playing.
Tobias Budge appeared, and frowned slightly upon seeing Will.
He was expecting Hannibal , Will thought, and he was glad to be a disappointment.
“Mister Graham,” Tobias said politely, “can I help you with something?”
Will smiled and turned to look at a cello that was standing on display.
“If you could help me in any way, I don’t really think you would, would you?” Will asked, glancing at the man to see how he responded.
It seemed to have caught Tobias of guard, because he tensed, motionless, then relaxed into his professional persona once more.
“If it has to do with string instruments, I’m sure I would,” he answered.
Will huffed a laugh and shook his head.
“I guess it sort of does,” he said, “because here’s the thing. If you ever step foot in my café again, or if you somehow lead the police to it out of spite, I will make sure you are caught. I can do it. You’d be wise not to doubt that. I just want you away from me, and away from my family.”
Tobias tipped his head. It was like seeing a shark scent the water, smelling for blood. Will didn’t like him at all.
“Your family,” Budge mused, apparently finding that interesting, “by that, do you mean Miss Abigail Hobbs?”
Will laughed.
“I mean my employees, my regulars, and my significant other. If you cause problems for any of them, the police will come knocking. This isn’t a threat, but a warning. I don’t take kindly to anyone who tries to mess with the life I’ve built.”
Will looked the man up and down.
“Do you understand me, Tobias?”
A flash of anger, and Will knew he wasn’t getting out of this. Tobias was angry, and he wouldn’t follow orders. He intended to fight.
“I understand you don’t intend to make things easy for either of us,” Tobias said, turning and picking something up from a shelf, “I had hope this wouldn’t be necessary, because I do expect Lecter will be unhappy to lose his favorite toy.”
Tobias turned, swinging a wire with a weight on the end. Will managed to dodge, and now he was angry too. He fell into a crouch and then kicked Tobias’ feet out from under him. Tobias hit the floor hard, and Will heard a whoosh of air as his breath was knocked out of him.
That was even better than he could have hoped for.
Will stood and kicked Tobias in the shoulder, sending the man onto his back as he continued to try to catch his breath. Will stepped on the wrist of the hand holding the wire, slowly increasing pressure until the bizarre weapon was released.
Tobias was gasping for breath, and Will knew he didn’t have long before the man would be back up and swinging. He had to think quickly.
Will picked up the string and held it by the weights on each end. It was an interesting sort of weapon. Not entirely practical, but the aesthetics would have appealed to someone like Budge. That made sense, at least.
“Are you going to keep making trouble for me, or can I leave you with this warning?” Will asked, staring down at the man.
Tobias grabbed Will’s leg and yanked, pulling Will down onto the floor as well. Will managed to twist and aim, landing his knee in Tobias’ side and keeping himself from losing his breath as the other man had. Tobias grunted when Will’s knee made contact, but he was rolling so he could stand up.
Tobias had let go of Will’s leg as he rolled, so Will brought himself to a kneeling position and watched as Tobias reached for the same shelf again.
How many of the damn things did he have there?
Will brought his hand up in time to block a swing aimed at his head, and the wire wrapped around his arm. Tobias pulled hard, and Will braced himself and pulled back. The wire cut through his sleeve and blood began to darken the fabric.
This was not going as well as he had hoped.
Will stopped pulling abruptly, letting himself be dragged forward, toward Tobias. The move startled Tobias, who was unprepared when Will swung his own recently acquired wire with the weights on the ends.
Will wasn’t as practiced as Tobias in the handling of the weapon, so his aim was off, but the wire curled around Tobias’ head and left angry slashes in across his face. That distracted him long enough for Will to slam his hand against the wall hard enough for him to release the wire that had wrapped around Will’s arm, and Will brought a knee up into his stomach.
Will unwrapped the wire from his arm and held it, unsure if he would need a weapon again. Tobias was more trouble than he was worth.
Tobias scrambled to get up, but Will kicked him down again.
“You only get to stand up once I’m gone,” Will said, “if you try to get up while I’m still here, I’ll kill you. Do you understand?”
Tobias looked up at Will, his face bloody and filled with humiliated rage. He had been beaten at his own game, and he was not happy.
“I understand,” he said.
Will smiled and nodded.
“Are you going to honor my request, or are you going to continue to be a problem for me?” he asked, “because I don’t want to kill you, and I don’t really want to send police here now my blood’s on the floor, but I will do either when I see it necessary.”
Tobias breathed heavily for a moment, staring at Will with enough hatred to poison a well. Will wasn’t at all bothered by it. He wasn’t bothered, but he did know Tobias had no intention of leaving him alone. He just hoped the man would opt to be arrested rather than killed. Will hadn’t ever killed anyone before.
“I’ll honor your request,” Tobias said, dropping his eyes as if humbled.
Will turned to leave. Maybe Tobias was taking the path he had hoped.
There was movement from behind him as Tobias stood to lunge again.
Chapter 24: Fury
Chapter Text
Will pivoted, but he wasn’t quite fast enough, and Tobias hit him full force in his shoulder. It sent Will slamming into the door of the shop, and he felt a pain in his chest as a rib cracked. That was inconvenient.
Will grunted, then finished his turn in order to elbow Tobias in the neck. It sent Tobias reeling, his hands flying up to his throat as he coughed and sputtered. He stumbled toward a door, and Will knew that would lead to the basement. The room where he took apart his victims and made their intestines into instrument strings.
It would be a bad idea to let him get down there.
So Will lunged after him, pulling the wire he was still holding taut between his hands. His rib and injured arm screamed at him, but Will blocked it all out as he got the wire up and over Tobias’ head. It landed into place around his throat, and Will pulled hard.
Blood spurted out in arterial gouts, and there was a wheezing sound as Budge tried to breathe. The wire had cut the carotid arteries as well as the man’s windpipe, and Will let go of Tobias Budge, letting him drop to the ground to die.
Will grimaced.
“You knew I wasn’t like you,” he told the man who probably couldn’t hear him anymore, “and you were right. But now I am, and you’re the fuel for this change.”
Will got to work cleaning up.
---
The expression on Hannibal’s face when he saw Will on his front step, one hand pressed to his painful ribcage and the other poorly bandaged and bloody, was almost funny. Will would have laughed if the very act of breathing wasn’t painful to him.
“Will,” Hannibal breathed with surprise and concern, “come in and tell me what happened. Did Tobias Budge do this?”
Will stepped in, wincing each time a movement or breath caused his rib to cry out at him.
“In a way, I did this to myself,” he answered as Hannibal led him to the kitchen and brought out a medical kit, “I went to his shop. I talked to him.”
Hannibal said nothing, carefully unwrapping Will’s arm and surveying the corkscrew cuts that curled around it.
“His weapon of choice is a piano wire garrote,” Will confided, explaining the odd pattern, “Figures. He didn’t take too kindly to being asked to leave us alone.”
Hannibal pressed his lips to Will’s palm reverently, letting out a soft sigh through his nose.
“You could have been killed,” Hannibal said, his words so soft Will almost didn’t hear him.
Will huffed, the grimaced at the pain in his rib.
“Don’t have much faith in me, do you Achilles?” he asked, then considered the similarities between what had happened and what Homer had said about those characters they used the names of, “the point is that I’m alive, and he’s not.”
Hannibal looked up at Will, part in surprise and part in wonder.
“You killed him?” he asked.
Will nodded.
“I gave him a choice. He had three options. One, he could leave me alone and I’d leave him alone. Two, he could bother me again, and I’d send the police after him. He chose the third, which was a fight to the death.”
Will swallowed, realizing his throat felt dry.
“He lost.”
Hannibal was silent again as he cleaned and rebandaged Will’s arm. He looked upset, and Will was worried he’d done something wrong.
“God, please talk to me,” Will said, his voice cracking a bit. He was tired, and he couldn’t stand this emotional turmoil Hannibal was making in him.
Hannibal looked up and met Will’s eyes at last. Will could see he was also struggling with conflicting emotions.
“I am the cause of your pain,” Hannibal said softly, “I am the reason you have now killed.”
Will reached out to take Hannibal’s face in his hands, but quickly lowered them again with a grimace of pain as the movement agitated his injuries.
“Don’t think that way,” Will told Hannibal sternly as the man took Will’s hands to offer comfort, “I would have killed anyone who threatened my family and I in that way. In a way, it’s only fair it had something to do with you. I asked you to kill Matthew Brown, after all.”
Hannibal pressed a kiss to the back of each of Will’s hands.
“I would have killed him for you,” he said.
Will smiled and shook his head.
“I know,” he said, “but after a while of me letting you fight on my behalf all the time, we would have started to resent each other. Plus, he didn’t deserve to be killed by you. I think he would have liked that.”
Hannibal laughed softly, reassuring Will that he was not unreachable in his sadness.
“I did not begin to love you because I thought you would become a killer,” Hannibal said, as if Will had thought this. And maybe he had. “I only cared that you had the ability to understand me.”
Will pulled Hannibal closer and kissed him softly.
“Achilles, this isn’t about what you want from me. It’s what I want from this,” Will gestured between them, “I wouldn’t be happy with the imbalance forever. I was already afraid of you for so long, because you were something I wasn’t. Now, we’re on equal footing. This is what I wanted. This is why I did what I did.”
Hannibal was watching Will speak with something akin to wonder in his eyes. Will smiled at him, admiring the noble structure of his face and the way his eyes seemed to spark crimson in the shifting light. It was amazing to Will the he had caught the eye of someone like Hannibal in the first place, and now they were matched better than before.
There was an entirely different energy between them, at least to Will. He didn’t feel like a man with a tiger on a leash. Now, they were two predators together, equals and partners.
“Can you feel it?” he asked, and Hannibal finally smiled.
“You are spectacular, Will Graham,” he said, leaning forward and pressing their foreheads together, “in all my fantastic dreams I could not have conjured you up.”
Will pulled Hannibal in for another kiss, his entire body lit up with pleasure at Hannibal’s words and this new power he felt within him.
“Take off your shirt,” Hannibal said when they parted.
Will laughed.
“Why doctor, how forward of you.”
Hannibal smiled and shook his head.
“I need to examine those ribs that are bothering you,” he said, making Will laugh again, then wince at the pain in said ribs.
“Yeah, okay. Fair enough,” he said, and reached to pull off his shirt. It hurt, and he grimaced.
“Here,” Hannibal said gently, rising from his knees to help.
Together, they managed to get the shirt off without hurting Will too much, and Hannibal inspected the dark bruises left by the altercation with Tobias. Will didn’t look, not sure he wanted to see the marks of the man.
He thought about what he would feel if they had been left by someone else. If Hannibal had marked him with violence.
If Hannibal had harmed Will, leaving marks on his body, Will imagined he would adore the marks. He would look at them in the mirror, admiring how the colors stood out against his pale skin.
That was probably a mental illness of some sort. It definitely wasn’t healthy.
“What are you thinking of?” Hannibal asked, looking up at Will from where he had resumed his kneeling position, his hands ghosting over the skin of Will’s torso.
Will flushed, feeling as if Hannibal had caught him in something particularly bad.
“I wish he hadn’t left any marks on me,” Will admitted, hoping that would be enough.
Hannibal hummed, nodding.
“If he were not dead, I would kill him over these injuries alone,” he said, “as it is, I can only satisfy myself with the idea that you enacted your own, righteous justice.”
Will smiled. Hannibal was romantic in his own, eccentric way. Will liked it. He didn’t think he’d be able to stand the romantic stuff normal people liked. It had never had all that much appeal to him, though he had convinced himself that was what he wanted. Because he had wanted to be normal.
“Maybe next time,” Will said.
Hannibal pressed a kiss to Will’s ribs, soft enough it didn’t cause him pain though it was directly over the darkening bruise.
“You must avoid strenuous activity, take anti-inflammatory medication, and ice the area periodically,” Hannibal decided, then stood to face Will.
Will huffed a laugh.
“You’re not going to wrap it or anything?” he asked.
Hannibal clicked his tongue.
“That is an outdated practice, as it promotes illness such as pneumonia because of restricted breathing,” he confided.
Will smiled.
“Thank you for the checkup, doc,” he said, “I guess I should get home and sleep. I have an early morning tomorrow. I have to get everything ready for the party.”
Hannibal pulled Will closer, pressing his nose into Will’s neck and breathing in deeply.
“Stay,” he said, his voice rumbling against Will’s skin in a way that was pleasant.
“Where else would I go?”
Chapter 25: Endings
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
“Oh my God, Will. What happened?” Abigail asked when she saw him, taking in the careful way he was standing and the bandage along his forearm.
Will smiled wryly, knowing he wouldn’t be able to lie to her. Not that he wanted to.
“I just had to take care of some business,” he told her, “it was a bit more difficult than I had accounted for. But it’s done, and I’m fine. We’re all safe.”
Abigail frowned. She looked older when she was worried, and it made Will sad to ever be the cause. She should have been enjoying her life.
At least she was going to college. She was going to become something. And it would take her farther away from Will and the trouble he attracted.
“Was it that guy?” she asked, “the one threatening you?”
Will sighed. He shouldn’t have expected the regulars to keep it from Abigail, but he had hoped she wouldn’t have to find out. It had been foolish, and probably more than a bit patronizing.
“Yeah, but he wasn’t really threatening me,” Will said, “he was threatening you. I just didn’t stand for it.”
Abigail hugged him gently, careful not to hurt him.
“Will,” she said softly, “you’re a really good man. I hope you know that.”
Will hummed an agreement, though he honestly held some doubts about that.
He had enjoyed killing Tobias.
“Make sure the regulars know it’s taken care of during the party,” he told her, “otherwise they might get it into their collective mind to do something to avenge me.”
Abigail laughed.
“They absolutely would,” she agreed, “I think this is about the strangest cafe in the world, you know. Something in the universe aligned to make it possible, and I’m not sure I’ll ever know if that’s really a good thing.”
Will grinned.
It was clear Abigail didn’t know just how much danger Will had been in. If she knew there had been a not inconsiderable chance he would die, she would not be so calm now.
But that was fine. Will didn’t want her to worry, and he knew she was likely to anyways.
“It’s all subjective,” he told her, and Abs rolled her eyes.
---
“Where did you study?” Will asked suddenly, and Hannibal lifted his eyes from his book, raising his eyebrows in question.
Will didn’t offer any further explanation. He thought it would be better if he didn’t.
“I began my studies in Paris, on a work scholarship, but I came across the ocean and finished my education at Johns Hopkins,” he said.
Will huffed a laugh. It all made sense, now. He was surprised he hadn’t thought of this before.
“You got her in,” he said.
Hannibal didn’t answer, but Will nodded. He didn’t need Hannibal to confirm it, but he thought he would after Will made himself more clear.
“You’re the kind of guy who has connections. You’re popular and social. You pulled some strings when you found out she had applied, and you got her in.”
Hannibal closed the book he had been reading and leaned towards Will.
“Would that upset you?” he asked.
Will laughed.
“I’m thrilled,” he said, “she deserves the best, and you’re helping her to get it. And it clearly wasn’t just to impress me or anything, since you don’t seem to have had any plans to tell me about it. God, could you be any more perfect?”
Hannibal moved and caught Will in a kiss.
“It was not all nobly for Abigail’s sake,” he confessed, “I did it so you might be pleased.”
Will huffed a laugh and pulled Hannibal into another kiss.
“Well, I am pleased,” he said, “I don’t really care what the reason was, because I only care about her being happy. The only thing I’m worried about is her being able to pay for it.”
Hannibal smiled, almost sheepishly.
“I am entirely capable of helping her in this area as well,” he said.
Will shook his head, but not in disagreement or denial. He was just trying to clear his thoughts.
“You already did something, didn’t you?” he asked.
Hannibal kissed Will, placating.
“I may have,” he said, “but only so she would not have to worry about finances. I would not have been pleased if she were accepted and had to turn it down for lack of funds. And I wouldn’t want her education to suffer because she had to work through her school years.”
Will closed his eyes, smiling to himself. He was so happy.
“God, I love you,” he said.
Hannibal stared at Will in wonder, apparently stunned to speechlessness. Will just huffed a laugh and pulled him into a kiss.
“How rare it is to see you at a loss for words, Doctor Lecter,” he said.
Hannibal lifted his hands to cradle Will’s jaw, pressing their foreheads together gently.
“You have never said that to me before,” he whispered.
Will hummed.
“You’re right,” he said, “I hadn’t. I’ve been waiting to find out you couldn’t be gentle after I showed I could be sharp. I expected this to change, so I wouldn’t be able to keep it. I didn’t trust you to stay soft.”
Hannibal kissed Will like it might be his last chance to do it, stealing Will’s breath and entirely capturing his mind.
All things considered, Will thought it was strange how fixated he was on Hannibal after such a short amount of time. His mind was always occupied with Hannibal, now, despite the rest of his life still being there. And Abigail was getting ready to go to college, but Will still couldn’t stop thinking about Hannibal.
“You trust me now?” Hannibal asked.
Will curled his hands into the fabric of Hannibal’s suit.
“I know now that even when you aren’t soft, even when I can feel your sharp edges and teeth, I still want you. I want every facet of you as a person, and I hope you want every part of me.”
Hannibal buried his face in the side of Will’s neck, breathing in deeply.
“Will Graham, you have no idea how desperately I do.”
---
“When Abigail is gone, how do you expect to keep people coming?”
Will rolled his eyes, but he smiled.
“Come on Jeff,” he said, “you were coming here long before I hired her.”
Jeff shrugged.
“Might be, but now we know how good it can be to have a pleasant worker here,” he poked, “you expect us to keep coming just for your grumpy face?”
Will huffed a laugh.
“Maybe you’ll start liking Billy,” he shot back.
Jeff laughed. He had a loud, full laugh that could have been annoying, but ended up being plain pleasant when in a comfortable atmosphere like this.
“Don’t count on it,” Jeff said, “but don’t worry. I’m sure you’ll be fine. You’ve been less grumpy since Achilles started coming around.”
Will hummed, glancing around to set eyes on Abigail. The looming separation was making him feel anxious and he was constantly checking on her. He hoped he wouldn’t have too hard of a time after she actually left, but he didn’t know.
“Sometimes you just need a specific person to come into your life,” he said distractedly, “and they change you for the better or worse. Sometimes both.”
Jeff was looking at Will with a strange expression when Will turned back to him. As if Will had said something odd. Reflecting, Will supposed he had.
“Don’t forget that we’re all here for you, Will,” Jeff said, “no matter what. You don’t only have Achilles to rely on. I know he’s all you feel you need, but don’t forget the rest of us.”
Will felt a pang of regret for making Jeff feel like Will didn’t care about him as much. He really did appreciate all the regulars. They were just different from Hannibal.
“Abigail says she’ll come ‘round to visit plenty,” he said with a smile, “so you guys are sticking around if only to catch her every so often.”
Jeff laughed again and headed off to give Abigail his own congratulations.
Will felt pretty good about how the party was going. No one had died, and he didn’t think anyone was going to. Everyone was in too good of a mood.
Abigail was the bright point of the evening, of course. She was flushed and beautiful and happy, smiling as she spoke to each of the regulars in turn and thanked them each for their support.
In a way, her manner reminded Will of Hannibal. She was giving everyone the right amount of attention, pleasant and intelligent just as Hannibal had been at the opera.
He knew she would do well. He knew she would learn fast and work hard. He just knew it. And he was glad to have been in her life even just this much. If he never saw her again, he could be happy to have helped her get this far. She was better for having had this chance, and having met these people.
Not to mention, getting all that help from Hannibal.
Will would have bet money Hannibal would gladly pay every expense for Abigail for the rest of her life, just for Will. Without Will even having to ask.
Will’s chest swelled with affection for the man, and for Abigail.
He had never thought he’d really have a family, but in some strange way he did now. He had a family. A strange, somewhat broken family. One made out of coincidences and unlikely occurrences. One that would be a force to be reckoned with if anyone got the idea to.
Will couldn’t be happier.
Notes:
Gonna wrap up a few things next chapter. I can't promise the ending will leave no loose ends, but I just don't want to keep stretching it out to the detriment of the story.
I hope you still enjoy it. <3
Chapter 26: Promises
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
When Abigail left, Will cried. He tried not to, and he did manage to keep it together until she had actually left, but he was only human.
Hannibal held Will, huffing the occasional soft laugh into Will’s hair as Will sobbed.
At least Will had someone with him.
And at least Abigail had left before Tobias Budge’s body had been found. The paper didn’t portray the scene in the light Will would have liked.
Tobias had been found in his own basement, where he had killed and processed his victims. He had been dismembered, and his intestines had been put through the first few steps of the process to turn them into gut string.
Will had done some research for that. He knew it probably wasn’t up to the standard of Hannibal’s own kills, and it could have been better if Hannibal had been there, but he had wanted to do the first one himself. He had wanted it to really mean something.
Hannibal had been pleased with him. When he read the article, Hannibal immediately went in search of Will and wasted no time in making his feelings known. Will had been relieved and more than pleased with his reaction. He had worried Hannibal would be upset over something.
He should have known better.
Things were going smoothly again. Just as Will had found a rhythm to his life before Hannibal had shown up and upended it all, now they settled again. He saw Hannibal every day, kept up the cafe and maintained his relationships with the regulars. He met more killers, and some of the regulars got caught. He scheduled time to see Beverly in order to keep her away from the group of killers he called friends.
He hired another girl. Her name was Esther. She didn’t talk much, but she was very smart. Will could see she was entirely willing to manipulate those around her if she thought it would suit her needs. In that way, she fit right in. He thought she had probably killed before, but he wasn’t bothered.
That had stopped bothering him entirely.
Every time anyone new showed up at the cafe, Hannibal made an appearance to make it very clear what the status quo was. Will hadn’t laughed aloud at him yet, but it was a near thing every time. It was like watching a peacock strut around, the way he staked his claim.
Will thought Jeff found the humor in it as well, but it would have been even worse if Jeff laughed at Hannibal.
When Jeff got caught, Will was upset. He told Abigail, and they both commiserated over their unfortunate friend.
But there was nothing to be done. Sometimes the regulars got caught, and there was nothing Will could do about it. Jeff had been there for a long time, but Will had always know it was sheer luck that kept him on the streets. He hadn’t been the sharpest knife in the block.
Christine left on another of her road trips, and Will didn’t know when or if she would be back. Misery got a job as a librarian in the city, so she started working just a few blocks over from the cafe and was there every day.
Other than that, most of the regulars were the same.
Will was happy with his life. Hannibal didn’t let him neglect his sleep schedule, insisting he call in if he ever didn’t get enough sleep. Billy and Esther could handle a day on their own, usually. Will still wanted to hire a few more hands in case something ever happened. Even though hiring killers was a huge risk.
Because they do often get caught.
But he wasn’t afraid of anything. If nothing else, Will knew Hannibal would protect him if something happened. Hannibal would make sure Will and Abigail were alright. The regulars could fend for themselves, just as they always did. Hannibal would take care of Will and his family.
If the FBI someday broke down the door of the cafe and arrested everyone within, Will fully believed Hannibal would find a way to get them both out of it.
Maybe that was foolish. Maybe Will saw Hannibal as more of a god than a man. Maybe that was the most dangerous part of it all.
It didn’t matter to Will. He was happy, and felt truly safe for the first time he could remember.
“What are you thinking of, Mangusteli?” Hannibal asked.
Will hummed, lifting his head off of Hannibal’s shoulder to look at his partner.
“Not much,” he said, “I’m just happy.”
Hannibal smiled warmly and pressed a kiss to Will’s forehead.
“Would you marry me, if I asked?” Hannibal wondered aloud.
Will pulled away, studying Hannibal’s face for any sign of insincerity or jest. He found none.
“Are you asking?” he prodded.
Hannibal only retained his enigmatic smile.
“I want an answer first,” he said.
Will huffed.
“You would probably plan out some huge, elaborate wedding, inviting a bunch of people I don’t know. I would have to smile and pretend to like them all, while in uncomfortable clothes and lights that are too bright. After, you would be one of those insufferable people who gushes about me to everyone you know, just calling me your husband and never using my name. So people always wonder if I actually exist or you’re just crazy. When I’m actually out with you, you would show me off like an accessory, basically gloating for anyone who sees us.”
Hannibal listened, his expression mild. He didn’t seem upset by Will’s words, or accusations. Just interested to know what Will would say next.
“But you’d come home to me at the end of the day, and make me an absurdly fancy dinner, and kiss me breathless every night. You would never let anyone hurt me, or let me be upset over something for long. You would do anything you can to make me happy. If Abigail ever needed anything, you wouldn’t hesitate to do it, just to please me.”
Now, a spark of amusement and pride flashed in Hannibal’s eyes. Will kissed him softly.
“So yes, I would marry you if you asked. Even if you ended up annoying me with all your pretentious habits and plans. Even if I never felt like I could live up to the expectations you have. I would marry you.”
Hannibal grinned.
“If you asked,” Will said with finality, pulling away.
Will stood up from the couch and stretched, letting out a sigh.
“But, since you’re not,” he said, “I guess-”
Will didn’t have the chance to finish, as Hannibal’s hands fell onto his hips and pulled him back down onto the couch. He let out a rush of air as he landed on the couch, and Hannibal was there, covering him with his body. Kissing him breathless just as he had said.
“I am,” Hannibal said, his voice low and slightly rough, “I am asking. Will Graham, will you marry me?”
Will grinned and lifted his hands, sinking them into Hannibal’s soft coppery hair.
“Till death do us part,” he said.
Notes:
There we are, folks! The end of our fun little journey. Sorry most of this chapter was just exposition. I offer you the last part of the chapter as recompense.
I hope you enjoyed it! Thank you for reading! <3 <3 <3
