Actions

Work Header

White Shark Café

Chapter 2: Greetings

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Will felt an involuntary chill run down his spine when the man walked in for the first time.

Burgundy eyes scanned over the entirety of the café before the tall man strode up to the counter. He was wearing a window pane suit that should have been ridiculous. Will found that it actually managed to soften his appearance, probably helping him to appear less threatening to people who didn’t know what he was.

Will saw Jeff come in right after, and worried a bit that they would be standing near each other in line.

“White Shark Café has something for everyone’s unique tastes, be they predator or prey,” Will said to the Chesapeake Ripper, smiling politely, but not overly friendly. He didn’t want to annoy the man. “What can I get for you this morning?”

The man studied him carefully for a moment, as if stripping him bare and learning his soul. It made Will want to squirm, but he just held eye contact, showing the man he was not afraid.

“I have heard that you are quite adept at guessing what your customers would enjoy,” the man said, his voice smooth and accented, “why don’t you give it a try on me?”

It was a test. Will could tell. He was trying to find out what Will could really see.

Will huffed a soft laugh and turned the menu so it was visible to both of them.

“I think an artist's blood and a cannibal crown would be to your taste,” Will said, smiling coyly and raising his eyebrows expectantly.

The Ripper looked at Will with thinly veiled fascination. He didn’t seem concerned that Will had been able to see him. He turned and read the descriptions of the items Will had pointed out, nodding in consideration. 

“They sound acceptable. I must warn you that my tastes are very refined,” the man said, seeming amused.

Will shrugged.

“I figured. Abigail will make that for you if you’ll just stand over here so I can get the next order.”

Will nodded at Abigail and handed her the ticket. He had made a note for her to be extra polite with the man, because Will didn’t want to have her earn a place on his list of future meals.

The man did as Will bid him to, letting Jeff walk up to the counter next. Will saw Jeff cast some dubious glances at the Ripper, but he didn’t say anything.

“Your usual, Jeff?” Will asked, already writing the order down. Jeff always had the same thing.

“Sure thing, Will,” Jeff said happily, “You been reading the news lately?”

Will shrugged, huffing a soft laugh. Jeff really liked for his kills to get into the news, and he always asked Will about it if he thought the article was particularly good.

“Not much,” Will replied, “You know I’m busy baking and running the café all the time. If it wasn’t on the tv, I didn’t see it.”

Jeff nodded, though he did look a little disappointed.

“Fair enough. Has Abs applied to any colleges yet?” Jeff continued.

Will smiled, glancing over to where Abigail was talking pleasantly with the Chesapeake Ripper. The man seemed to be satisfied with her service, which was a relief for Will.

“Not yet. She wants to be sure she has enough saved up for tuition. She’s thinking of going into psychology.”

Jeff grinned, accepting his coffee and pastry.

“Well, I’ll leave a big tip as long as you promise she’ll get it,” Jeff said, “She’ll be a great student when she goes. I’ll just be sad I won’t see her anymore.”

Will nodded.

“I think we’ll all be sad to see her go, but she already promised me she’ll visit after she leaves. Have a good day, Jeff, and be careful out there.”

Jeff saluted smartly and turned to take a seat at a table with a few other regulars.

“Are you certain you are old enough to be employed here?”

Jeff and Will both froze upon hearing the Ripper ask Abigail that. Will stared at Jeff, knowing he was going to react poorly.

“Hey, new guy,” Jeff said, walking right up to the Ripper with a scowl, “Abs is nineteen, and Will doesn’t serve alcohol. She’s saving up to go to college, and you’d better not give her any grief.”

The Ripper turned, annoyance flickering over his features as he studied Jeff.

“I did not mean any harm by the comment. I was simply concerned for her mental health, as it can be hard on young people to work,” the man said smoothly and calmly, “are you very well acquainted with her?”

The insinuation wasn’t lost on Jeff, and Will could see a few other heads turning their way. He would have a riot soon if he didn’t settle this. They were all willing to get kicked out if it meant they could defend Abigail.

“No harm meant, and no harm done,” Will cut in, motioning for Jeff to hold his tongue, “my apologies, sir. The regulars are very friendly with both Abigail and I. They can get a bit defensive if they feel one of us has been snubbed or anything. Please don’t mind Jeff.”

Will made hard eye contact with the Ripper, then. He wanted his full meaning to get through. The man had better not kill Jeff for this, because Jeff just didn’t know who he was messing with. He didn’t know the shark he was taunting had bigger teeth.

“Very well,” the Ripper said, then turned to Jeff, “I apologize. I hope you do not hold this against me. As you have said, I am new to this café, and it seems there is a unique atmosphere I have not been privy to as of yet.”

Jeff narrowed his eyes at the man, but glanced to Will for confirmation. Will nodded solemnly.

“Fine,” Jeff said, “just don’t give Will or Abs any trouble. Plenty of us are willing to help them out if they ever need anything.”

The Ripper nodded. Jeff cast one more glance to Will, as if giving him a chance to rescind his request for peace. Will only smiled politely, and Jeff headed to his seat. The Ripper watched Will for a moment, in which Will just continued with his usual activities, arranging the pastries in the display and taking inventory to make sure they weren’t low on anything. Abigail headed into the back to check on the pastries that were still in the oven, and eventually the Ripper walked away and found himself a window seat in the café.

Will felt his entire body relax once he was no longer trapped in the man’s gaze. He saw that the rest of the customers weren’t welcoming him in the way they normally did with a new guy. They kept their distance, maybe sensing he was a different caliber, or maybe trying to be unfriendly to make him not come back.

Will wasn’t sure he wanted the Ripper to come back, but he sure as hell didn’t want the Ripper to hold anything against anyone associated with the Cafe. A dispute like that could draw attention, putting the customers at risk of being caught, and, by extent, putting Will out of business when it was no longer safe.

Abigail came back out with a tray of fresh croissants, and she smiled at Will.

“Hey, you good? What’s with the new guy?” she asked.

Will shrugged.

“Just don’t get on his bad side. I don’t know if he’ll be a regular, especially after all that, but no matter where you see him, don’t be rude. He’s got a thing about rudeness. I hope to god he doesn’t hurt Jeff,” Will said, aggressively taking a bite out of one of the croissants.

Abigail laughed lightly, though Will could tell she was also worried.

“Do you even know why you call him Jeff?” she asked teasingly.

Will raised an eyebrow.

“Because that’s what he said for me to call him?” he said, prodding Abs to just get on with whatever she was about to say.

“Well, duh, there’s that,” she said, “but he’s a total creepypasta fan.”

Will frowned.

“Is there a creepypasta about a guy named Jeff?” he asked. 

Will knew vaguely what creepypastas were, but he had never felt the inclination to read any, or listen to the narrations Abigail enjoyed. 

Abigail laughed.

“Just about the most popular one,” she said, “Jeff the killer. He’s a huge thing in the community. Everyone knows about Jeff.”

Will chuckled.

“Ah, so Jeff figured out I know he’s a killer, and named himself accordingly. Clever of him,” Will said.

Abigail nodded.

“He’s got at least that,” she said, “even though he might not be the sharpest knife in the block. He’s at least got that.”

Will huffed a laugh and handed Abigail the tip Jeff had insisted on getting to her.

“He wanted this to go towards your college fund, so make sure to thank him and then actually get into a college, Abs,” Will said.

Abigail grinned and slipped the money into her pocket. She started setting the croissants into the display where the others had been getting low, and she shot Jeff a wide grin when he glanced over. 

Will would protect Abigail with his life, but he was glad he had so many dangerous people behind him if that ever became necessary.

Notes:

I might not know a thing about coffee, but I know my horror. Watch out for a ton more references just as obvious as Jeff here XD I'm not pulling any punches.