Actions

Work Header

to rule the fate of many

Chapter 16: Breaking

Summary:

Even as they have come together, the company begins to fracture, one by one.

Notes:

Hiiiiii. I'm back. With angst!

Oh, sorry, did I forget to give you a side of angst with that plate of angst? Here you go. My apologies. (Am not sorry.)

Also, in advance, yes: dwarves are thick-headed. And certain people continue to have problems with Talking.

Chapter Text

Everything felt so strange. The mountains were perfectly fine, looming tall over them with sunlight running over them on a daily basis. The air was clean, birds flew overhead, and frankly, their hearts were light. Well, should have been light. They had saved the Shire, after all, had rescued all the hobbits and cut off the orcs’ plans to take Bilbo after a ransom demand.

Except their hearts weren’t light, and nothing was all right. The cloud of anger over Fili and Dernwyn was almost palpable. Poor Éomund looked as if he didn’t want to be anywhere close to them when it blew, and even Legolas was acting off, more standoffish than Bilbo had ever seen him before. Yet he remained by Kili’s side, as if helpless to be anywhere else.

Thorin, too, remained by Bilbo’s side. Well, behind Bilbo on the horse, at any rate. But it felt wrong, as if he wanted to be there but didn’t want to be there all at the same time. Bilbo felt about the same: he wanted to perhaps ride with someone else for a short time, but wanted to stay by Thorin’s side all in the same instance.

How many times was Thorin going to ask him to return to Erebor? He knew how to wield his blade, he knew how to defend himself, and yes, perhaps he was a little slower because he couldn’t sleep, but how were nightmares his fault, exactly? He was getting sleep now, and he hadn’t had a nightmare since the Shire. So Thorin could take his utterly ridiculous idea somewhere else. Bilbo wasn’t having it.

He couldn’t keep Thorin safe if he was in Erebor. And with every nightmare he’d had on the way to the Shire, it made him all the more determined to stay by his husband’s side. The thought of Thorin, cold and dead and bleeding out in front of him, was more than Bilbo could take. No, he wasn’t leaving Thorin.

Not that Thorin was going to accept that, not after the last battle. Orcs were one matter, for they were monsters and foul creatures that held nothing but destruction if you let them. Those Bilbo could fight against. But dwarves? And men? Even as twisted and wicked as they might have been, Bilbo held most dwarves and men in high esteem. They had kin, they had friends and family. Taking a life…he hadn’t been able to do it. It had left him ill and remembering too clearly when he’d accidentally knocked Gollum off and into the flames. So he’d injured instead, helping where he could, and leaving the final blow to the others who were better acquainted with battle.

He hadn’t taken the life of a dwarf or a man yet, and he didn’t intend to start now.

Thorin obviously knew this: Bilbo’s blade had been too clean. And it was obviously rankling his husband, if his attempt to send Bilbo away – again – was any indication.

The mountains beside them were still beautiful, though. Bilbo sighed and tried to find the peace he’d felt back in Bag-End with Thorin. Just his husband, sprawled out next to him on his bed, long hair hanging about in such a way that Bilbo had been tempted to run his fingers through it. He felt so removed from it now, as if Thorin were a hundred miles away instead of right behind him on the horse.

He would feel so much better when the thieves were gone. They could take Moria back, perhaps; Kili and Dwalin had both made mention of seizing the opportunity of cleaning out the mountain as they had done to Erebor. Well, if that was the case, they were going to need a burglar, but frankly, Bilbo would’ve been content to let the thieves have Moria if he could have peace. He just wanted peace.

Gandalf began to speak, pulling Bilbo from his tumultuous thoughts. “We are about a day from Moria now,” he said. “We have the option of going over the mountain and back to Erebor to ready troops, or we can take the lower gate into Moria. The decision must be made now.”

Bilbo frowned. If anything, Gandalf looked…almost apprehensive. They were merely thieves, and though the woman was a mysterious unknown, she couldn’t be that powerful yet to warrant Gandalf being as wary as he was. Before Bilbo could ask, however, Thorin spoke. “The lower gate into Moria is our best option. We cannot afford to lose any more time. If we are to strike, we must move now.” He paused. “Others could, perhaps, go back to Erebor for troops.”

Bilbo had to admit, the attempt had been a good one. Still, no one was biting. “Looks as if we’ll all be going, then,” Bilbo said, and tried to give Thorin a smile. Thorin, for his part, attempted to offer one in return, but it faltered and fell into grim silence.

Once Moria was done, perhaps they could discuss just why Thorin was so insistent about Bilbo being sent away to stay behind. This was far more than simply protective measures.

They made camp alongside the mountain, the branches of the trees shading them from any unwanted eyes. Bofur had a fire going, under Gandalf’s watchful eye, and soon the talk turned almost merry. It reminded Bilbo of the journey to Erebor so much, and he couldn’t help but smile. Even Fili and Dernwyn were not as icy with one another, the good spirits of the others thawing them to where they could almost speak to each other without snapping.

Kili remained near the fire, separated from Legolas, and it made Bilbo frown. The elf was off to the side, tending to the horses, eyes distant. He looked as if he had been gravely injured and was desperately trying to cope, but Bilbo found no wound on him, could not find a place he was cradling or treating more gingerly. Kili watched him until it was clear Legolas was settling in with the horses, then reluctantly turned back to speak with Ori and Nori. As if sensing Kili was no longer watching, Legolas turned and watched him, and there was such a pain in his eyes that Bilbo could not understand.

What had happened while they’d been parted?

Only one way to find out. Bilbo made his way over to where Fili sat, removed from Dernwyn by Bofur and Balin both. “Feeling better?” he asked, nodding towards Fili’s leg.

“I can walk on it, and I can certainly ride on it,” Fili told him. “It’s not that bad.”

“Good. Is, ah, is anyone else injured? Like Legolas?”

Fili frowned but shook his head, instantly crushing Bilbo’s hopes that it was, indeed, something so simple as that. “No, he’s fine, as far as I know.”

“Nothing that happened while you were trailing the thieves?”

“No. We followed them for days and days, but nothing really happened until you all showed up. Which, by the way, I’m very grateful for.”

“A Baggins is never late,” Bilbo said, and Fili’s lips dared to turn up into a grin.

“Neither are wizards, from what I understand. You always arrive precisely when you mean to.”

Yes, Gandalf had a penchant for doing that. The wizard still looked pensive, but he was speaking with Aragorn and Thorin, and none of them looked particularly happy. Planning on what exactly to do when they reached Moria, no doubt. Bilbo shook himself and turned back to his nephew. “Something like that. You’re sure nothing happened.”

“Nothing. Honestly, it was boring, for the most part. Legolas and Kili kept smiling at each other, which gets old very quickly, let me tell you, and Nori kept trying to pickpocket me for practice.”

So whatever had happened between Legolas and Kili had also happened at the Fords of Isen. Bilbo was starting to believe that their meeting had been cursed, for no one seemed terribly happy at the moment, and hadn’t been since Isengard. Fili was still glancing sideways at Dernwyn, his thrum of anxiousness and frustration almost physically felt. Dernwyn looked to be in much the same way. Kili stole glances of worry at his husband when Legolas wasn’t looking, and Legolas in turn would gaze almost painfully at Kili.

Then there was Thorin.

There was only one way to start fixing what was going on, and Bilbo decided right then and there to not wait until after Moria to talk to Thorin. He could just as easily catch him now as he could then, and at least he’d have answers. He excused himself from Fili when Aragorn, Thorin, and Gandalf broke away, and Bilbo quickly pulled himself up in front of his husband. Thorin’s eyes were dark and clouded, and all Bilbo wished to do was run fingers through his hair and make things right.

Instead, he gave a small smile and watched some of the clouds recede from Thorin’s gaze. “Did Gandalf have anything except for riddles to tell you?” he asked.

Thorin’s lips turned up, and Bilbo managed to keep his grin of victory to himself. “For once, yes. He seems highly concerned about Moria and our entering it, but has agreed that we should march on it. We’ll bed early tonight and hopefully reach the gates before night falls.”

A thought came to mind, and Bilbo nearly cursed himself. Moria held bad enough memories for the dwarves, but Thorin had lost not only his grandfather and king, but his brother, Frerin. No wonder he was so touchy lately. “This isn’t where you fought, is it?” he asked quietly. “This gate we’re going to?”

Thorin blinked. “No, it isn’t. This is…elsewhere from what you think.” His gaze dropped, and Bilbo reached up to catch his hand. There was such a thing as being annoyed at overprotectiveness, and then there was such a thing as allowing certain things for a fear.

“This time in Moria will be better,” he assured. Thorin met his gaze, and Bilbo smiled. “I promise. We’re all capable fighters, we can all handle ourselves. Even little Esse: you should’ve seen her in the Shire, waving a shovel around.” She’d been something fearsome to behold, wading in with a cry and bopping every orc she’d seen about the head.

Except his soft words and jest didn’t alleviate any of Thorin’s tension: if anything, it only made it worse. “I would be more assured of that if I knew you were safe,” he said, and Bilbo tightened his grip in warning. I will not leave you, Thorin Oakenshield. “My luck in Moria is poor enough; knowing you were safe-“

“I’m not going back,” Bilbo snapped, suddenly very angry. His nightmare rose to the forefront of his mind, and it was all he could see, for a moment: Thorin dead before him, Fili and Kili lifeless beside him. It only added heat to his frustration. “I’m staying, and that’s final.”

Thorin narrowed his gaze. “We have saved the Shire; Moria is simply a scouting, and nothing more. You would be more help to Erebor-“

“Moria is not ‘simply a scouting’ and you know it!” Bilbo swallowed hard and realized that most everyone was watching them now. Tact was the better option here. Tact was very much the better option here. He tried again. “We’ve ventured into more dangerous situations before just fine, and I’ve been a great help to you before.”

“You have always been more helpful than you know,” Thorin said, and the compliment would’ve been better if he hadn’t looked so furious. “But you would continue to be helpful in Erebor as well.”

“I’m going with you,” Bilbo said, dropping any sort of sideways tactic because Thorin wasn’t listening. Thorin was simply being Thorin and getting so angry over nonsense and Bilbo was through with it. “I’m not leaving you!”

“I’m asking you one simple thing, that is all!” Thorin yelled. “You are not foolish, you know there is danger, and I am asking you as your husband and as your king to take your kin and return to the mountain!”

“If you think I’m going to be so easily dissuaded, you’ve got another thing-“

“I made a vow,” Thorin shouted, just shy of a roar, and Bilbo stopped. “I made a vow to follow you, to always be by your side so I could keep you safe, and I will not break that now.”

“You were content enough to leave me behind just a moment ago-“

“Because it is the only way I can be assured that you will be safe! If you come any further with me, I cannot!”

And that was what it all boiled down to: Thorin needing to know that Bilbo was safe. It made part of him relieved, there was no doubt about that. But it also set a part of him on fire, warming his cheeks in humiliation and rage that he was being ordered like a child to go home because he couldn’t take care of himself. “Do you truly think I can’t handle myself?” Bilbo seethed. “You know that I can.”

“The air gap-“

Oh for Eru’s sake, of course it was about the damned air gap nonsense from two years ago. “That was a one time issue that demanded an immediate response! I walked away with minimal wounds-“

“You shouldn’t have been wounded-“

“Minimal wounds that could’ve been much worse but weren’t. What would’ve happened to Hildili if I hadn’t gone down after her? Would you have ever gotten her out? I was small enough, I fit in the little tunnel, I found her and kept her safe until you all arrived.”

With every word, Bilbo watched as Thorin’s face grew redder and redder. His fists were clenched so tight that they were nearly white, and he looked angrier than he had in many years. Bilbo pursed his lips. “You’re not leaving me behind,” he insisted, refusing to cave. “I am going with you, I am not turning back. I can handle myself, you just saw that I held my own in the last battle-“

“You didn’t kill a single one of them,” Thorin growled. “You injured but did not take a life.”

The very thought turned Bilbo’s stomach, and Thorin knew that, he knew the nightmares that still came, of Gollum being pushed over the edge by Bilbo’s own two hands, and yet he was actually using that as his excuse, now? It was like salt being poured into a wound and ground deeply, and Bilbo forced his hurt to fuel his anger. “There were others enough to do the killing, you know how I feel-“

“That’s exactly my point!” Thorin shouted. “Even if it meant your life, you would refuse to strike the final blow.”

“I could just-“

“My job is to protect you from all harm, and right now, that is achieved by sending you back to Erebor.”

“I will not-“

“You would defy what you promised to me ten years ago?” Thorin yelled, and Bilbo stopped. Thorin grabbed his wedding braid and pointed to the bead, the bead that Bilbo had labored over in the forge. “You told me I was your protector, your defender, that you trusted me to look out for you. Yet now you deny me and tell me it means nothing?”

It would have hurt worse if Thorin had simply struck him. Around them, the camp had gone silent. Thorin seemed frozen now, eyes wide in shock at his own words. The dwarf looked like a statue, unable to move, his unspoken remorse in his eyes. Bilbo felt his hand reach for his own wedding bead, his comfort, his one solid truth he could cling to time and time again. He stopped his hand before it reached the bead and clenched his hand into an empty fist instead. His hand was lowered to his side in a single swipe, the action sharp and precise.

No. There was no comfort to be had in his marriage, not now. Not if Thorin truly believed he thought so little of his vows. How had their argument turned into this?

He couldn’t meet Thorin’s gaze. He marched himself over instead to his pack, sitting beside Thorin’s. He moved it swiftly to the other side of camp, next to Esmeralda’s. Where it had once been done for Esmeralda’s sake and agreed upon by both Thorin and Bilbo, now it was a means of escaping having to sleep beside his husband. No one moved as he pulled his roll out and flattened it to the ground in stilted movements. Only then did he lay himself down, his blanket tucked up near to his ears. He aimed his gaze at the tree line and refused to acknowledge the tears burning in his eyes.

If he had but glanced back, he would have seen his husband standing and staring, stunned, at the huddled mass that was Bilbo.

The fire eventually had to be stoked, and Ori tentatively stepped forward to do so. Others began to move around, still quiet, still hesitant to speak or do the wrong thing. Not after what they had witnessed. Bilbo kept his gaze straight ahead, determined to not listen for the heavy footfalls of his husband.

He also was determined to not wipe the tears away as they trailed down his face.

The night went on for far too long, and when he finally did find sleep, it was filled with horrible images of Bilbo pushing Gollum off the edge into the fires, only to realize it was Thorin he had sent down into the flames. Waking only made him wish for the warmth of his husband’s embrace. He supposed, perhaps, he would go to Thorin tomorrow. Just one night, this night, without him.

But the next day was spent in silence and in misery. They rode through and into the mountains, Bilbo riding with Fili and Dwalin riding with Thorin. The air was hot and wet, and it all would have been worth it if he’d been beside Thorin. If perhaps he could speak his own apologies, hear apologies from Thorin. If perhaps he hadn’t felt so alone and condemned, if he hadn’t felt so afraid of actually speaking to Thorin, lest it start another fight.

Neither spoke. And the day went on.



“I can’t stand it anymore.”

Legolas nodded. Kili pursed his lips. “Fili and Dernwyn are barely speaking to each other, but at least they are speaking to each other. Bilbo and Thorin aren’t speaking at all! They won’t even look at each other!”

He received another nod, but no other response. Frowning, Kili looked at his husband. “Are you all right?” he asked. Legolas nodded but again said nothing.

Kili was completely done with his kin and friends and everyone. Mahal, he wanted to be home. They should be celebrating right now, not out here in the woods leading to the mountain, bitter and silent. They had rescued the Shire, they were going to clean out the thieves and maybe even take back their old ancestral home. They should have been rejoicing, not…not fighting or talking stiltedly with one another, afraid to say the wrong thing.

There was something so wrong with Bilbo and Thorin being at odds with one another. Thorin hadn’t meant to say what he had, and everyone knew it, but the look of pure betrayal that had spanned Bilbo’s face had left it obvious it was too late to take it back. The aborted reach for his bead had put a terrible look on Thorin’s face, too, and when Bilbo had moved his sleep roll away from Thorin’s, the hurt on both of their faces had about done Kili in.

Fili and Dernwyn being angry with each other was, at least, almost familiar. They’d snapped and glared at each other when they’d first met, too. He could pretend to take comfort in that.

But now Legolas was slowly pulling away from him, and without his comfort, Kili felt lost and adrift. What was wrong with everyone?

He cleared his throat and leaned back into Legolas a little more. His husband didn’t seem to notice, or if he did, he at least didn’t shy away. That was an improvement, he supposed. “Have you ever been to Moria?”

“No,” Legolas said softly. “I have only heard tales of its fall and woe.”

Well, at least he was speaking to Kili. Another improvement. Emboldened, Kili glanced back at him and smiled. “I’m not worried,” he said. “We took them at the river, and we can take them here in Moria.” He found Legolas’s hand on the reins and grasped it with his own. “You and me,” he said. “We could take them on. That is, if Gimli left any to us.”

Legolas offered a smile that almost looked fragile. There was something wrong, something deeply wrong, and Kili didn’t have the first idea of how to fix it. “You’d, um, tell me, right?” Kili asked, his voice almost a whisper. “If there was something wrong?”

“I would,” Legolas said, but he still looked so lost. Whatever it was, Legolas could obviously not put it to words. So Kili kept his hand in his and leaned back against Legolas, to offer what comfort he could. I’m here, Legolas. And I’m not leaving you.

Legolas took a deep breath, then another, then finally settled back, tension running through his body. When Legolas moved the horse’s reins, Kili’s hand slid off, without any mutual grasp to keep him there. He moved his hands to his lap, hating the mountains, hating Moria, with every single step. Not a single one of them was happy, and he wondered if it was leaving Legolas troubled. If he could feel the distance and anger and hurt that whispered through the group. Perhaps Legolas could feel it and couldn’t escape it.

He pressed himself more firmly against Legolas, a solid and sure weight. “I love you,” he murmured.

There was a pause, and finally, finally, Legolas bent down to press a long kiss to the top of his head. “And I, you,” he breathed.

That, Kili hadn’t doubted, just as he knew that Fili loved Dernwyn and Thorin loved Bilbo. That didn’t mean they couldn’t hurt one another with words, or that they couldn’t dislike one another for a time. It was just frustrating to see it and to be unable to say a thing.

At least he had Legolas.

“The mines are close,” Gandalf called back through the group, arresting Kili’s attention. “I would advise we let the horses go here, to return home. They cannot embark on this next part of our journey with us.”

“Will they find their way home?” Esmeralda asked from in front of them, and Kili smiled, finally glad to have someone willing to have a normal conversation.

“They will, actually; they know their way to Erebor. We could fall asleep on our horses and be home before anyone knew it, thanks to them.”

Gandalf coughed. “As someone who’s slept on a horse as it rode onward, I can safely assure you that it is not the way in which one wishes to travel.” Aragorn ducked his face to hide a grin, and Kili took a breath, then another. Smiles and jokes all around: things were looking better every minute.

“’Course not,” Gimli said, as if eager to join the conversation that would lend sound. Anything was better than the wretched silence that had befallen them. “Miss all the orcs that way! No, awake’s better for findin’ orcs.”

“In Rohan, we learn from a very young age to come alert and wield our blade at the slightest sound,” Dernwyn said as she rested her hand on the hilt of her sword, and she very pointedly didn’t look to Fili. Fili refused to look at her as well. Kili felt his heart sink again as that miserable silence threatened to loom once more. He hated this so much, and yet there was nothing he could do about it. It seemed every topic would be off limits.

Aragorn, however, was peering at Dernwyn closely. “Is your blade new?” he asked. “For I have never seen it before. How did you come by it?”

Dernwyn frowned. “It’s the blade I have always had. It was my father’s blade, and his father’s before him.” She glanced down at the hilt, as now many others were also doing, then back up at Aragorn. “Why?” she asked. “Is there something the matter with it?”

“No,” Aragorn assured her. “There is nothing wrong with the blade. Its hilt simply reminds me of another sword I once saw. I had wondered if it was the same one, but yours is a family heirloom. It has obviously defended you well so far; I hope it will continue to protect you and your loved ones.”

It was clear that Aragorn was a king, not just in deed but in word as well. He handled words the same way Bilbo did: clearly and with intent to neither dissuade nor dismay. He was good at it, and Kili was grateful when Dernwyn settled back with a small nod, and Fili even did the same from his horse.

“How far into the mountains?” Éomund asked, finally daring to speak. Kili would’ve laughed at the reluctant look on his face if the oppressive force of the silence hadn’t been returning.

“Not far,” Gandalf said, and he stopped and swung off his horse. Everyone else dismounted and pulled their packs from their steeds. Ori stood by Nori and Dwalin, looking anxiously at the others. Less anxious, Kili amended in his own head, more frustrated. He looked as if he wanted to say something, then glanced at Thorin and Fili and obviously thought the better of it. Kili didn’t blame him.

It was Dernwyn and Tauriel who seemed to have the most trouble letting their horses go, but eventually all the horses were nudged back down the path. All of them followed after one another, and Kili watched until the first horse turned to the east. They would get home safely enough, of that he was sure of. And it was better than them trudging up the sharp incline that the company now faced. It didn’t look particularly inviting, and with his stomach still tender from the last battle – though thankfully not sliced open, he would take tender over sliced – it didn’t look appealing.

He began to climb up after the others, envying Tauriel’s gentle grace that let her quickly move to the top. Kili glanced around for his husband and found him surprisingly right beside Kili. He stumbled a little on the rocks, and Legolas quickly caught his elbow to pull him to standing. Kili shot him a grateful smile, wishing he could so easily speak the way Bilbo and Aragorn could. I wish I knew what to say to you, to remove that frown from your face. I wish you’d smile again. I wish I knew what the matter was. I wish…

Bilbo had a saying about wishes, something his mother had told him. Kili didn’t quite remember it, but he knew it had something to do with how useless they were. He could attest to that.

As soon as they were on solid ground, Legolas was moving forward, leaving him behind with Fili. That wasn’t much of a comfort either, and Kili wished he felt more at ease to so readily follow after Legolas. It didn’t feel right to do that now, though, and for Mahal’s beard, he didn’t even know why.

He silently sighed and kept trudging along into the mountains.