Chapter Text
Long had Balin desired to look upon the halls of his ancestry, the great kingdom of Khazad-dûm. But it had always been a fantasy hidden in the scrolls and the histories of his people. He had imagined, perhaps, a dwarf coming to them with a message of victory, that the orcs had abandoned the mines, and that it had been reclaimed. Walking into the great halls and finding them needing but a few willing hands to put it all back together. He had envisioned the mines, the great and vast hallways, and the very gates themselves being bright and glorious.
A lot of that had changed, when Thorin had first taken up his oaken shield to save them from absolute ruin. And still more of it was changed now, as they walked up to a dark, vast wall hidden almost as a crevice in the mountains. A wide pool spanned in front of a small beach of black and grey pebbles, and only a few trees grew alongside the mountain.
This was not the Moria Balin had expected to find. He wasn’t entirely certain there was a Moria here. And if there was, he wasn’t entirely certain where it was.
But Gandalf seemed less apprehensive than he had been since they had agreed to go to Moria, and was even now moving to examine the thick rock wall. A hidden door, perhaps, and Balin smiled. Yes, one of the many hidden doors of Moria, and of course the wizard would know where they were. He felt like a young dwarf again, pouring over documents, reading everything he could about their once great and mighty kingdom.
He turned to his once young pupil, now fully grown and capable scribe, and frowned. Ori looked so disgruntled that Balin was almost afraid to ask what the matter was. He’d seen Dwalin wear less ferocious scowls. “What’s the matter?” he asked.
Ori crossed his arms in front of him. “All of them,” he said, and he motioned with his head towards the others that were following after Gandalf. “Well, most of them. But still! Look at them!”
Balin pursed his lips. It was hard to do as much, to watch them as they floundered. Fili and Dernwyn still weren’t entirely speaking to each other, but they offered a few words here and there. Mostly to keep themselves safe, he had thought at first, and now he realized it was just the opposite. Neither wanted to be the one to lash out at the other, and thus were keeping their words to themselves. He only wished it would bring them peace instead of the anxious standstill they now found themselves in.
Kili and Legolas were a disturbing matter all their own, for though they had not spoken of issues between them, it was painfully obvious that something was wrong. The usually soft and gentle elf was morose and trying hard to hide it. Kili was watching him anxiously and trying to hide that, and Balin remembered dryly that neither had ever been good at keeping secrets or being subtle. Now was certainly not any different.
But the most heartbreaking was, perhaps, his cousin and king, who looked to be torn between angry and deeply grieved, and his husband, Balin’s good friend, who wore the same face and held himself in the same tight and unhappy way. It’d been hard to listen to Thorin rant and sink himself further and further last night, but Balin didn’t think he would’ve been able to do a thing about it, anyway, had he been able to jump in. And before they’d known it, Thorin had said things he hadn’t meant to and left the both of them aching.
He could only hope that they’d all resolve themselves of whatever nonsense had seemed to leak into their minds and hearts, and swiftly. Because if they didn’t, Balin had no doubts that Ori’s anxiousness was going to bleed out into angry vocabulary.
Still, best to try and curb that where he could. He knew the tongues of the brothers Ri, and while Ori had a swift mind and a caring heart, his words might not get held back in time. “Best to leave them as they are, lad,” he said gently. “Only so much you and I can do. They need to sort this out on their own. You and Dwalin muddled through the nervous beginnings of a relationship on your own just fine.”
“But this isn’t the beginning!” Ori protested. “This is, this is years and years! How can it matter so little now?”
“It’s a new beginning of a sort,” Balin told him. He glanced over and found the others gathered behind Gandalf by a tall section of unblemished stone. That would be the door, he was certain of it. “Dernwyn and Fili have never had little ones to worry over before; that makes the situation unique. Thorin and Bilbo have never truly seen battle together, so that adds a new tension.” He had absolutely nothing for Kili and Legolas, however, and found himself stumped. Ori huffed in silent agreement, also unable to find the words.
“Come on, lad,” Balin finally said. “We’ve a hidden door to find.” There had been several, into Moria, at one time. Or so the histories had said. He wondered which one this was.
Even as they approached, he heard Gandalf telling Esmeralda, “They’re often hidden so well that not even their masters can find them!” The wizard turned to the darkened sky, where clouds hung in front of the moon. “A bit of light would help,” he murmured, and gave a gentle wave of his hand.
Slowly the clouds parted, as if blown away like smoke rings, and the moon shone down upon them. Balin found everyone else staring with wide eyes at the spectacle. Even Aragorn seemed startled.
“Show-off,” Dwalin muttered, and Balin grinned at his brother’s attempt to not sound impressed. Even as he turned to lend his own words, his eyes caught sight of the rock wall, and all sense of speaking fled him.
It was as if someone had lit gold aflame and let it cascade down the mountainside. The lines of a carved archway began to emerge, revealing not just a doorway, but a noble work of art. Stars sparkled in the rock, and ancient words came from the stone. It was a dazzling, brilliant sight to behold, and Thorin murmured words of reverence and awe. And he was right to: these were the Doors of Durin, the West Gate of Moria. They couldn’t be anything less.
It was more than Balin had ever thought he would see in his lifetime. He smiled and felt as if he were a student once more, reveling in the magnificence of Khazad-dûm. He was so caught up in the moment that he failed to notice that Gandalf had turned to him. He blinked in surprise. That was the look his mentor had often given him when he knew Balin didn’t have the answer. It was the look Balin had given Ori a few times, and Kili and Fili both many times.
He wasn’t entirely appreciative of it being directed at him by Gandalf. And even before the wizard spoke, Balin knew exactly what he’d ask.
“In your studies, Balin, have you ever-“
“I don’t know how to open the door,” Balin said firmly. “I’ve studied Moria a great deal, but I haven’t the slightest idea how to open it.”
Gandalf looked as put out as Balin had ever seen him. “What do the words say, above the door?” Éomund asked.
“‘Speak, friend, and enter,’” the wizard finally said. “In the Elven tongue. But I do not know the password.”
“Neither do I,” Balin said. He glanced around at the others. “Ori, do you?”
Ori shook his head shortly, glancing at the others. “Fili, Kili?” Balin tried. “Aragorn?”
“I have no knowledge here to lend,” Aragorn said. “Perhaps Thorin would be able to help. Or Bilbo: I had heard rumors of a hobbit who escaped from goblin caves and dragon’s lairs with only his words.”
It was a good attempt to shuffle the two together, Balin had to applaud him there. Thorin looked at Bilbo, as if hoping to see any sort of motion or words from his husband. Bilbo kept his gaze to the door and seemed to be forcing himself from glancing back at Thorin. Thorin finally cleared his throat, and Bilbo bit his lip. When Thorin went to speak, however, he stopped before he even began. He clenched his fists and turned away, frustration evident on his face.
Bilbo finally shook his head at the door. “No, I…I don’t think I can figure it out,” he said, voice rough after a full day of barely saying anything. He turned and walked away, refusing to look in Thorin’s direction.
And apparently, that was all the youngest Ri brother needed to hear before he’d had enough.
“That’s it,” Ori snapped, and everyone froze in place. He looked furious, glaring at them all. “What is wrong with you all? Of all the times we need to stand together, it’s now, more than ever before. And you’re all fighting with each other!”
He turned to Fili and Dernwyn first. “Dernwyn, you shouldn’t have come, and you know it. But Fili, she came because of you. Not for adventure or excitement, she can get enough of that with Holdred and Hildili. She came because she was worried for you, which, ironically enough, is the exact reason Fili’s telling you to go home, Dernwyn.”
Dernwyn and Fili had barely turned to each other, guilt and sorrow on their faces, when Ori whipped over to Bilbo and Thorin. “You two…Bilbo, he’s trying to protect you because he’s terrified he’ll lose you. I watched him when you were missing or when you’d fallen down the air gap, and he’s nearly lost you more times than he can count. Trust me, him letting you go back to Erebor and out of his sight is a sign of how scared he is.” He swung his glare to Thorin. “And why do you think he’s fighting with you so hard to stay? Because he’s just as equally scared that something will happen to you! You were the only reason he made it to Mordor, and you know it, you know you mean that much to him. He trusts you and loves you. Leaving you means being unable to help you or protect you; you can’t ask him to do the same thing you refuse to do. You’re both stronger together, and how have you not learned that yet?”
He shook his head and didn’t even bother waiting for Thorin and Bilbo’s response, instead glancing at Kili and Legolas. “And I don’t even know what’s wrong with you two, but it’s just wrong. Whatever it is, talk. I’m sick of watching you all flounder when you’re essentially fighting for the exact same thing. You want to keep each other safe. That means you have to trust each other to protect themselves and each other. Stop letting the fear of what happened or what could happen muck it all up!”
He was panting heavily by the time he was done, and he gave a sharp nod, crossing his arms. “Well done, my lad,” Gandalf murmured approvingly. Dwalin looked the proudest Balin had ever seen him look before. Balin held back from rolling his eyes and found himself watching the three couples Ori had just…well, scolded, for lack of a better phrase.
Dernwyn and Fili slowly stepped towards each other, hands meeting to twine around the other’s. The fear-fuelled anger was gone, and in its place was the worry that had started it all. Kili was much like his brother, stepping towards Legolas with a hopeful look on his face. Legolas tried to offer him a smile, but it fell away almost immediately. His gaze dropped to his feet, leaving Kili looking bereft and unsure once more. Balin pursed his lips but said nothing, and finally turned his gaze to his friend and king.
Bilbo was still hunched over, shoulders up to his ears, arms wrapped around himself, back to Thorin. Thorin carefully moved across the rocks to his husband, unaware that all eyes had turned to them. “Bilbo,” Thorin said softly, regretfully. Bilbo did not move, and Balin peered at the hobbit with a frown. It was only when he caught the sheen in Bilbo’s eyes that Balin understood his silence.
Thorin stepped in closer, his hand hovering as if aching to touch Bilbo. “Beloved,” Thorin murmured, pleading, and Bilbo shook his head.
“Don’t do that. Don’t…don’t do that when you don’t even trust in what I vowed-“
“I do trust in what was promised,” but Thorin had hardly begun when Bilbo whirled around, anger on his face but tears in his eyes.
“Then what don’t you trust in? Me? My ability to keep myself and you safe?”
“I trust in everything except the world around us,” Thorin snapped, but Balin frowned as he watched his cousin. There was something raw there, something he had never seen before, and he didn’t understand its reason, nor what had caused it. “You don’t understand what-“
“Of course I don’t, you won’t tell me!” Bilbo said. “You just keep trying to send me away, and what other conclusions am I to draw from that?”
“I cannot lose you!” Thorin shouted suddenly and desperately, eyes wide and wet. “I cannot!”
Bilbo’s face had gone slack in surprise at the naked pain on his husband’s face. “Thorin…”
Thorin crossed the two steps between them and cradled Bilbo’s face between his hands. “You don’t…you don’t understand,” Thorin choked out, and Balin swallowed hard. This was Thorin more vulnerable than Balin had ever seen him before, as if he’d been shredded and skinned and left open and bare to the world. Never before had Balin seen him so undone. “I have nearly lost you so many times, , by orcs, by simple twists of fate, by…by my own hand. It feels as if the earth will not be content until you are taken from me, and I cannot…” He let out a shuddering breath. “You are my everything. I could not…I could not breathe if you weren’t here.”
Everyone was silent. Fili had Dernwyn’s arm wrapped within his own, holding tight to her as if he thought she would be blown away by the breeze. Even Legolas was no longer turned away from Kili, but instead immediately behind him, looking as if he ached to touch but didn’t dare to do so. Aragorn had his hands clenched and his head hung low, eyes fixed on the simple wedding band upon his finger. Balin could only imagine the elf queen he knew waited for the king in Gondor.
He didn’t look to Dwalin and Ori. He couldn’t bring himself to see what emotions of love and fear were on his brother’s face.
Bilbo slowly reached up to touch Thorin’s wedding braid. When he spoke, it was in a low and soft tone that made Balin’s heart ache. “The nightmares I’ve been having…they’re of you, Fili, and Kili. I had them, ten years ago, on the way to Mordor. The three of you brought low by Sauron’s forces. Now, though, they’re…they’re painfully vivid. And they’re getting more detailed, as if they’re no longer a dream but a reality waiting to happen. I can’t…” He pursed his lips to try and stall his emotions. “Don’t send me away,” he all but pleaded. “You say you can’t bear to lose me, but I’ve been losing you nightly for days, weeks now. And I know that I can’t live with it.”
It was Thorin’s turn to comfort, remorse and too much understanding flooding his face. It would’ve been comical if it hadn’t been so heart wrenching. Both of them had been fighting for the same thing, to keep the other safe by whatever means necessary.
“I’m not going back,” Bilbo said as firmly as he could, but his voice wavered. “So don’t bother.”
Thorin took a breath. “I know,” he said quietly. It was not accepted, not approved of, but the agreement was silently stated: Thorin would not try to send him away again.
Bilbo let out a soft, shuddered breath. “All right then,” he said after a moment. Then he was stepping up and pulling Thorin into his arms. Thorin shut his eyes, visibly relieved, and clutched at Bilbo. There was something settling about seeing them together once more, as upset as they’d been for the past few days, then completely apart since yesterday. They were better together, Balin thought. And it was good to see.
Bilbo finally raised his head and rested his forehead against Thorin’s. They seemed to speak to one another silently, communicating without words. Only when Thorin began to smile, tears in his own eyes, did Balin let himself completely relax. Apologies accepted, forgiveness given, it seemed.
“What is that?”
Startled from their silent conversation, Bilbo and Thorin turned with everyone else to Tauriel. Her eyes were on the lake, concerned. “What’s what?” Fili asked.
Bofur was moving forward now, too, holding a hand up when Esmeralda made to follow him. Nori walked slowly along the banks, and he hoisted his blade when Tauriel drew her arrow. “There’s something in the water,” he said lowly.
Then it was upon them.
The first tentacle caught Bilbo and Thorin, sending them flying. Thorin somehow managed to catch Bilbo with his arm to protect him as they landed. More tentacles were rising from the depths, striking out at their company. Aragorn caught one with his blade when it tried to take Gimli, and Dwalin made quick work of one that had merely twisted in Ori’s direction. Balin hurried to Thorin and Bilbo, helping them to their feet. “We need that door opened,” Balin said urgently. If it wasn’t opened, they’d be dead within minutes.
Bilbo took off running. Thorin hefted Orcrist and made himself a wall between his husband and the beast. Hobbit and King settled, Balin hurried back to the water to aid where he could, helping Nori to his feet after having been caught by a stray tentacle. “Can’t you do somethin’?” Bofur yelled at Gandalf, who was fighting off two tentacles at once with his own blade.
“Unless I can see it, no,” Gandalf said shortly. “And the less magic I use, the better for us all!”
Balin desperately cast a glance back at the door, but it was still not open, and Bilbo was gazing at it with fear. “Does no one know the answer?” Tauriel demanded. She fired two arrows into a tentacle and sent it falling back into the water. “Or are we doomed to riddle with it all night long?”
“We don’t have all night!” Dwalin growled.
“That’s it!” Bilbo shouted, and when Balin looked back, he was pointing at the door. “It’s a riddle! The Elvish word for ‘friend’ is-”
“Mellon!”
The shout came from not only Bilbo, but from Gandalf, Tauriel, and Legolas. The low rumbling of the doors was a welcome distraction from the beast in the water, and slowly they began to open. Balin took off for the doors, intent on pushing Thorin and Bilbo inside to safety.
Which, of course, was when the beast from the lake finally appeared.
Esmeralda shrieked at the sight of it, and Balin was hard pressed not to join her. It was a foul thing, a large skull as black as night, tentacles attached everywhere. Its eyes were coal black and gleaming, and it quickly caught Kili by the waist when he notched another arrow. Fili’s blade stopped his brother from going more than a few stumbled steps, and Dernwyn caught Kili by the arm to pull him away. “Go, go!” Gandalf shouted. Legolas and Tauriel continued to fire arrow after arrow to cover their retreat into Moria.
Out of the corner of his eye, Balin watched as Bilbo raced back for Esmeralda. He pushed her onward, hurrying with her. “Go, come on!” he yelled. Thorin caught Esmeralda with one arm, the other still holding tight to Orcrist, and all but tossed her behind him through the doors. He turned and grasped Bilbo to do the same.
Almost grasped, that was. Fingers brushed before a tentacle caught hold of Bilbo around the ankle and yanked, hard. Whatever the beast was, it was determined to take one of them with it. Bilbo cried out as it pulled him away from Thorin at a rapid speed straight towards the water. Thorin took off running, shouting, and Legolas darted back to fire one last arrow, straight at the beast’s eye.
It landed with perfect accuracy, and the beast let out a howl the likes of which Balin had never heard before. But it let go of Bilbo, and the hobbit tried to get his feet beneath him. Dwalin raced to join Thorin, helping Bilbo to his feet. He stumbled, limping on as best he could, pain tight across his paling face. From behind Balin, Tauriel and Kili were stepping back out into the fray to fire arrows covering the retreat. The beast snarled, tentacles whipping about furiously, but it didn’t reach for Thorin, Dwalin, or Bilbo, whom the dwarves were all but carrying at this point.
“Get inside!” Dernwyn shouted at the others when Thorin and Dwalin were safe, and slowly the elves and Kili began to back up. The beast continued to stare straight at them with its one good eye, ever watching, and it was enough to send a chill down Balin’s spine. But the threat of arrows were keeping it at bay, and finally it disappeared back under the water. Kili, Legolas, and Tauriel held their bows for a surprise attack, but none came.
A gasp from Bilbo called everyone’s attention to the hobbit. Dwalin helped Thorin settle him on the ground. “Is he all right?” Bofur called from where he stood, mattock in hand near the doors.
Gandalf quickly hurried over, whispering something to his staff to make it glow. It was a dim light, but enough to give meaning to shapes in the room. Bilbo panted harshly, squeezing his eyes shut. “Let me see, my friend,” Gandalf murmured.
“Ankle,” Bilbo gasped out, and Thorin shut his eyes tight. “My bad…my bad ankle.”
Balin closed his own eyes. Though he hadn’t gone with them for the entire duration of the journey to Mordor, he’d been there in the end, enough to see what had become of Bilbo during his own venture. The ankle had been the most damaged, so much so that even Lord Elrond himself had been worried about its continued use. For the past ten years, it had healed, only causing slight pain in the cold. Bilbo certainly had never complained, not once, and that was a worry all its own.
For if he was calling attention to it now, it had to be bad indeed.
It was a solemn gaze that Gandalf wore after examining the ankle. The ankle was red and almost jagged looking from the marks left behind by the tentacle. Bilbo had his lip between his teeth, but Balin could still hear the small keening sounds he was making as Gandalf carefully moved the limb back and forth. Thorin was nothing but tension settled beside his husband.
“We need to go,” Fili said, reluctant to voice the truth. At his words, Bilbo began pushing himself up, with Thorin and Dwalin both reaching to push him back down.
“Need to go,” Bilbo managed.
“Bilbo-“
“I can walk,” and Balin raised his eyebrow at the bald-faced lie. But Bilbo was getting to his feet, pausing when he finally put weight on it, and he looked as if he’d pass out for a long moment. Then he swallowed hard and continued to rise. He took his husband’s arm when it was offered, however, if just to steady himself. “I can walk,” Bilbo said again. He gritted his teeth and put his foot down on the ground.
The first two steps went well, and then he was crumbling, chest heaving, arms reaching for Thorin. Thorin managed to catch him before he hit the ground, and between him and Dwalin, they were able to lower Bilbo until he was seated. “We need to go,” Bilbo insisted, but he looked as thrilled with the idea as they did, and that was to say, not at all.
“Did you fight here, Uncle?” Kili asked quietly, suddenly. Thorin glanced at him, completely bewildered. “When you fought Azog in Moria. Did you fight here, in this place?”
“No,” Dwalin said, sounding equally as confused as Thorin looked. Balin frowned, wondering where the question had come from, until he glanced around the room. The dim light of Gandalf’s staff allowed what had once been hidden by darkness, and the sight was enough to turn anyone’s stomach.
Orcs. Worse than that, dead orcs. There were orc corpses everywhere, some of them already showing bones, some with creatures still eating their flesh. There was a small army here in this entrance to the mines, and it was one that no dwarf had slain. A rodent appeared through what appeared to be a stab wound in one of the orcs, flesh in its teeth. It glared at them with bright red eyes and dove back into the corpse it was obviously intent on eating.
“Sweet Eru,” Esmeralda whispered, moving to Tauriel’s side. Tauriel wrapped an arm around her even as Bofur came to offer her comfort. Éomund had the look of one who would be ill on his face, and he caught the hilt of his blade as if it were a comfort. Everyone looked an equal measure of disgusted and alarmed, and Balin moved to Thorin. These orcs had not been slaughtered by the hands of the dwarves from yesteryear. No, these were recent kills.
There were certainly thieves here, and they were willing to kill to defend what they saw as their territory. Given the state of their small company, there was no way they could keep themselves safe and take on an army of thieves all at the same time. No wonder the orcs who’d ambushed them on the way to Rivendell had been willing to strike out at them.
“This place is cursed, laddie,” he said sharply. “We need to leave.”
“We can hold the one-eyed monster,” Legolas said, face grim. “But Balin is right. If we do not leave now, I fear-“
The walls began to shake and suddenly the beast was there, tentacles reaching inside through the doors, pulling at anything it could just to get to them. Legolas began firing his arrows once more but shoved Kili away when the dwarf went to join him. “Behind me!” Legolas told him. “Go!”
The doors started to fall under the creature’s might. Dwalin caught Ori’s tunic and all but dragged his husband away from the entrance. Dernwyn and Fili were running as fast as they could away from the doors, even as large stones came down. “Move!” Thorin bellowed, and the ceiling suddenly began to fall. Balin threw himself away from the damage and covered his head as best he could. For a moment, there was nothing but the rumbling and harsh cracking as rocks landed around them.
The room went silent. Balin could no longer see anything, but he could still breathe. That was a luxury, at least. He coughed and sat up, hearing stones shifting in the black. “Is everyone well?” he called.
A sudden light began to glow: Gandalf’s staff, lending light once more. Now, now it was bright enough to illuminate the entire room, but Balin focused his attentions on his companions. Kili and Legolas were well, and Dwalin was the furthest from the door with Ori, Nori immediately moving towards them. Dernwyn and Fili were there, and Bofur was beside Tauriel and Esmeralda. Aragorn was lifting Éomund to his feet, and the lad looked a bit winded but otherwise all right. Gimli shook himself and sent dust and little stones flying from his beard. None of them looked harmed.
Thorin was all Balin could see, at first, his travel cloak covering him as he slowly pushed himself from the ground. But there, in his arms, was Bilbo, who was blinking blearily in the dust. The hobbit coughed and waved at the foul air. “No one’s hurt?” Balin asked again.
“We’re all right,” Dernwyn called, glancing at everyone. “I think we’re all here and well.”
It was more than he’d expected, to be honest. “Good,” Balin said. “Good.” Except it was anything but. One glance back at the doors showed that their entry and hopeful exit was now completely covered by stones. There was no getting out that way. Which meant they had to move forward.
Now they had to weave their way through Moria, a place Balin had never once been in. Add to that the decaying corpses of a fair number of orcs, and Balin wanted to be anywhere except where he was. His younger brother seemed to share the same opinion, and for a quick moment, Balin wished his brother was somewhere else. Anywhere else. If he could but send Dwalin and Ori from this place with his thoughts, he would.
A grunting noise caught Balin’s attention. Bilbo was trying to stand, again. “Bilbo, rest for a bit,” Thorin said, trying to glare at his husband but failing for his worry. “Please.”
“We don’t have time,” Bilbo said, shaking his head. “And I can walk.”
“Course you can,” Dwalin drawled. “You did great the first time.” Still, Balin’s brother was poised, ready to catch the hobbit if he faltered.
“I must agree with your husband,” Gandalf said, and that pulled a glare from Bilbo at last. “You need to rest your ankle, if you’re to walk on it. I believe you could walk on it, but you need time for the swelling to ease.”
“I refuse to be the reason we’re…we’re slowed down,” Bilbo said. He grimaced as he stood on his own two feet, his one ankle wobbling as it attempted to bear the weight of both. “And Balin’s right, we need to get out of this place. I don’t like it, not one bit.”
Thorin managed to not roll his eyes, which Balin thought was quite the accomplishment. Within a short moment he had his arms under and behind his husband, and even as Bilbo flailed, Thorin hefted him up without any hesitation. “Thorin!”
“Now you need not fear about slowing us down,” Thorin said. “And I need not fear about you.”
It was those last words that finally caused Bilbo to relent. He crossed his arms about him, however, and looked highly put out about being carried. Thorin’s grip was gentle, one arm beneath his husband’s knees, the other wrapped behind his back. It was for the best, and Balin could see Gandalf giving Thorin an approving nod. Thorin gave a short one in return, then went back to ignoring Bilbo’s grumblings. An injury, especially one that grieved an old injury, was taxing on the body. Bilbo would tire easily, and he was light enough that Thorin would be able to carry him without any cautiousness.
Of course, Balin was fairly certain his cousin would have carried the hobbit had he been injured himself. Thorin was bound and determined to keep Bilbo safe, and it was a testament of how sorry both had been about the earlier fight that Bilbo had given in so easily. His mutterings, even now, were more about how stubborn Thorin was and how no one was willing to lend him aid in standing against his husband.
“Onward into the dark of Moria,” Gandalf murmured, and he moved to the front of the group as they cautiously crept up the stairs. His light was bright, bright enough to shine against the walls and illuminate their path with ease. If they had any luck, it wouldn’t attract attention.
As far as their luck went, however, Balin didn't exactly feel encouraged.
