Chapter Text
The dark gave way to a fire-lit passage delving beneath what had to be the hallways above. These were the lower level mines, the ones that had been the lowest before the dwarves had been too greedy and continued digging down even further. They all knew the tale, but no one told stories like Balin did.
Dwalin stumbled, just a little, but it was enough for Thorin to hold up his fist. “We cannot keep running blindly,” he said. “We’ll rest and search for a better path back up to the main halls.”
“Let me,” Aragorn said quietly, and Thorin gave him the nod. Not that Dwalin was paying too much attention to what they were doing or saying. They could’ve been talking about the state of their tunics and he wouldn’t have known the difference. All he knew was that his brother was gone.
It was the little things that came to mind. Things like the way Balin’s hair had gone white after the last time they’d fought for Moria. After Azanulbizar, his hair had suddenly been as white as snow, despite his age, and it hadn’t changed. Or how he’d always seemed so tall beside Dwalin, despite him being several inches shorter than his younger brother. It’d been his bearing, his wisdom always highly sought after. Dwalin remembered the way Balin had led him through Erebor as a young dwarf, hand in hand, and when Dwalin had said he’d be beside his brother to the end of his days, Balin had just smiled-
“Dwalin?”
It was Ori. His husband knelt in front of him, as if he’d been calling for a time. Only when Ori reached out to brush his hand across Dwalin’s cheek did he realize there were tears there. He bowed his head and let Ori cup his face. “Dwalin,” Ori murmured, and Dwalin clenched his hand into a fist until it ached.
“He shouldn’t have died.” It should’ve been Dwalin. He should’ve heard the arrow, should’ve done something.
“I know,” Ori said softly. “But it wasn’t your fault.”
“Mahal’s beard it wasn’t-“
“Balin would be so furious with you right now,” Ori said firmly. “Blaming his brother for something that couldn’t be stopped. Even the elves couldn’t hear anything! Legolas and Tauriel heard nothing. Those caverns are meant to stop sound, you know. So if they couldn’t hear anything, how were you supposed to?”
He just was, that was all. But Ori’s words weren’t so much removing his pain as they were wrapping a soft blanket around his grief. He couldn’t abolish it, but he could offer comfort, and Dwalin reached for his husband so suddenly that Ori nearly stumbled off his knees. He pressed his forehead to Ori’s and breathed. In, out. Once, twice. Two mittened hands slid up to cradle his head, not pressing, just resting, and he suddenly clutched at Ori, desperate to hold him. His husband went easily, cradling him as if he were bigger than Dwalin. He felt like a dwarfling now, the loss rocking him to his very core. Balin was gone. Balin was gone.
He pressed his face into the curve of Ori’s neck, soaking the skin with his tears. “Don’t you go,” he choked out. His fingers dug into his husband’s tunic. “Don’t you leave me.”
Ori whispered promises that fate could overturn if it felt so inclined to do so, and Dwalin just clutched all the harder. He’d lost one part of his heart, here, in Moria; he wouldn’t lose the other part. Balin had lived many years, but had still been too young, still shouldn’t have died. But Ori? Ori was his constancy, his breath, his everything, and he wanted, no, demanded more years with him. Fate could hang itself: he wasn’t allowing it to take his Ori.
Even as he clutched at Ori, even as Ori clung back and offered assurances, Dwalin felt fear settle in his heart, fear that he’d lose this, too.
It hurt, to watch them.
“Bilbo’s all right. He’s got Kili.”
“I wish that made me feel better.”
“He’s your brother, Fili.”
“Which is why I can make that statement better than anyone else.”
Thorin glanced over at his nephew. Fili could speak in any fashion he wanted: he was plainly worried about his brother. Separation never did either of them favors. Dernwyn could see it, that much was obvious, which was why she was gently prodding him to continue in his teasing vein. Anything to keep them all from the despair that was sinking in.
His heart was beating a staccato rhythm in his chest, pounding so harshly against his ribcage that he raised a hand to rub and soothe the ache. Balin was gone, dead right in front of him. His long time friend, his cousin, his confidant. Dwalin was lost to grief, and looking at his other cousin hurt in such a way that Thorin could not bear to do it. And Bilbo…
“We must find them,” Legolas said again. The elf had been frantic ever since they had left Bilbo and Kili to run. “We must just…simply take a path and follow it.”
Thorin eyed his elf-son. Thankfully, Nori seemed to have the same thoughts that Thorin did. Or perhaps, the same thoughts they all had. “I get them,” the dwarf said, jerking his pointed hair towards Fili and Dernwyn. “And I get Bilbo and Thorin’s tiff. What I still don’t get is what’s going on with you and Kili. And I don’t like not knowing things.”
Even as Thorin glared at the dwarf – their argument had not been a tiff – Legolas shook his head. “It is no different than theirs,” he insisted. “I just need to find Kili. Much as Thorin must find Bilbo.”
“I’d believe you except for the fact that you and Kili still look miserable,” Fili said. “I know my brother better than that. There’s something not right between you two. What’s going on?”
“You can tell us,” Dernwyn said quietly. “Please. If not for your sake, then for his.”
Her soft spoken words were almost magical: one moment, Legolas paced before them, fretful and anxious, and the next, he stood still, shoulders slumping. He wore a look of such heartache that Thorin felt urged to reach for him. The comfort would not be welcomed or wanted, though. Not until Legolas had spoken.
He was not the Durin Legolas wanted to hold, either.
“It truly is no different,” Legolas said, his voice nothing more than a whisper. “Mortality. The length of a given life.” He tightened his grip on his bow. “And how we will be the ones left behind.”
The silence that followed was a stunned one, followed swiftly by heartache. For once, the eternity of an elf seemed a terrible punishment. Thorin knew he would lose Bilbo, one day, and if they were both allowed to see their old age, he would be the one to bury his hobbit. Fili would lose Dernwyn far too young, before he even reached his two hundredth birthday, yet all of them would have a comfort of seeing their beloved on the other side, in the halls of their forefathers. But Legolas?
Legolas, unless slain, would live forever. He would bury Kili and continue on without him. There was no hall for Legolas.
“That’s what this is about?” Dernwyn said, eyes wide. “That’s why you’ve shied away from him?” She glanced around at them all, and her eyes were accusing when they landed on Fili and Thorin. “That’s what this has all been about? Because one day we’ll die?”
It sounded almost foolish, now, with her incredulity coloring her tone. “I wasn’t aware it was such a topic of disregard,” Thorin said, eyes narrowed. “Do you not understand you’ll leave us behind?”
“Leave you…” She threw her hands into the air and muttered a curse beneath her breath. “We know that. Do you think I don’t know that? I watched my mother bury my father, and my uncle bury my mother. I settled Thengel into his grave. I know what it means to be left behind.”
She spun to Fili, her glare falling. “That doesn’t mean I would rather live my life alone then to never stand beside you again,” she said. “You could die here, in Moria, and leave me a widow and your children fatherless, and I could be the one left behind. Life is short and precious. I would rather spend the few years I have with the man I love. And I know Kili and Bilbo feel the same.”
She let her words hang in the air before she spoke, a quiet, resigned tone. “Death is a part of life. It is a cruel part, and one never deserves to say goodbye to a loved one. It’s never fair, because you always want just one more day, but it’ll never be enough. I will never have enough time with you,” and she took Fili’s hands in hers. “But I would rather have even a few short days with you than none at all.”
It was a truth that Thorin felt in his own blood. If he were told that he would only have a mere day left with Bilbo, he would be with his husband during every waking moment that he could, if just to have that one day. And he could envision, even now, how he would spend it: not thinking of the end of the day, but only of how to pull another smile forward, how to win that scowl that usually hid amusement.
For some reason, despite the fear still curling in his gut and the gravity of their situation, her words were calming. Not enough to abolish his anxiety, but enough to curtail it so he could focus.
Legolas still looked anxious, and no words from Dernwyn would keep his fear at bay. Still, he seemed to be trying to breathe more deeply, to calm himself. Fili, too, looked to be trying to accept his wife’s words as best he could. If only Thorin had known how desperately his sister-son and his elf-son had felt, that they had shared the same fears, he would have spoken sooner. Perhaps he would have found a peace himself.
The thought of Bilbo lost in this place, thieves seeking him out as a ransom, kept his heart pounding to the point of making him ill. He moved his attention to Legolas, who looked to be more agitated than Fili. After one last glance at Dwalin, still seated on a rock slab with Ori in front of him, he caught Legolas by the shoulder and watched the elf stare at him, almost desperately. Thorin swallowed. “Do not fear tomorrow,” he said quietly. “Fear today. And know that your fear is shared by all here. We will find them. But I will need your help, before the end.”
There was no other option. They had to find Bilbo and Kili. The loss of his youngest sister-son would be devastating, and Thorin feared losing Legolas and Fili both if Kili fell. And if Bilbo fell…
It didn’t warrant thinking of, but Thorin’s heart pounded all the more painfully for it.
Aragorn came to him then, moving back down the rocks. “There is a drumming in the deep,” he said. “It sounds like a call to war.”
“We have to find the others,” Legolas began, but Aragorn caught him by his other shoulder. Thorin had a sudden memory of Thengel taking both Thorin and Aragorn by the shoulders, seeing the kings they would be before even they had. He felt a pang of loss and wished that Thengel was here, now, beside them. He had no doubt the king would have known what to do.
Aragorn stood tall, however, and spoke with a soft but insistent urgency. “We will find them, of this I swear to you. If we are to discover what lies within Moria, however, if we are to end the fear and death that follows these thieves, we have to stay together. I have no doubt that if we follow the drums, we may very well find Kili and Bilbo. They could be well on their way to seeking the drums: if there is one thing I know about Bilbo, it is that he would be clever enough to search for answers.”
“And Kili wouldn’t abandon Bilbo,” Bofur said firmly. “You know it. So if we find one, we find both.”
Words meant not just for Legolas, but for Thorin as well, and he gave Aragorn a grateful nod. Aragorn returned the gesture with a slow nod of his own. Bilbo would follow the drums, hoping they would do the same. If there was any chance of finding them, it was there.
Even now, Thorin could feel the steady thrum of a heavy drum beat, deep within his boots from the very stones they stood upon. It was steady and angry, a certain call to arms. It was for them, that much was certain. Following the drums was a danger all its own, for they would be met with the thieves.
Thorin had no trouble with that. Especially if it reunited him with his beloved, one whom he owed more words to than the paltry ones he had given outside of Moria. Yet they were all he had been able to give as the fear had almost swallowed him whole. He had never felt this way before: he had stood in battle and been the solid rock for his dwarves, had nearly met his own fate again and again without any qualms. The thought of Bilbo in battle, the thought of losing him…
He wasn’t strong enough to bear it. Losing Bilbo would end him, and it was as simple as that.
“That’s a war beat,” Dwalin rasped. When Thorin looked to his cousin, his face was wet and his eyes were red, but he stood tall and strong beside Ori. “Nothing good will follow it.”
“What’s that make us, then?” Gimli muttered, and Nori snorted a quick laugh. Even Dwalin managed a small grin, and Bofur gave Gimli a friendly nudge as thanks. Gandalf merely rolled his eyes.
“Uncle,” Fili said, and Thorin caught his gaze. His eyes were dark but sure, and he hefted his sword in his hands. “Let’s find Bilbo and Kili.”
“Aragorn, lead us,” Gandalf said, and Aragorn turned to move back up the path he’d found. Legolas kept his grip tight on his bow, and if his eyes were harder and more intently focused on the path, no one made mention of it. Thorin would almost prefer if he was angry. Anger was a key tool to use, where fear could only limit. Better for Legolas to be silent and furious than afraid.
They moved on through the darkness, following the steady, angry beat of the drums.
The pace had been brutal, made worse by the fear of not knowing where to place his feet as surely as the men did. They were obviously well familiar with the various paths through the mines, whereas Kili and Bilbo were not. It had felt too much like going through Mordor had, the orcs kicking him and urging him along all while his ankle had throbbed and ached and burned.
Except this time, he at least had Kili, and the thought reassured him even while it shamed him. He didn’t want anyone to suffer this fate, but especially not his warm-hearted, cheerful nephew. Kili was like a stone beside him, saying nothing, glowering at the men in front of them, taking their jeers and kicks in due silence. Only when they’d shoved at Bilbo and sent him spilling to the floor had he spoken up and told them off, then had raised Bilbo to his feet and kept him close. The lack of bound hands had helped in that regard, and when Kili had kept his arm wrapped around Bilbo to help him walk, the men had mostly left them alone. They hadn’t slowed the pace at all, however, and they’d marched on and on.
Then they’d stopped marching, and Bilbo had never wished to keep walking so much in his life.
The ragged remains of what had once been a throne room were lit by the red flames of fires below them. The smell was so sharp and acrid that his nose burned, and he rubbed at it with his hand, hoping to stop the sting. Everything was dark, hidden in shadows, save for that which was revealed by flickers of flames. Bodies hung from the ceiling by chains, bones and skin that left him feeling ill. Orcs and men and dwarves stood around, watching them with a harsh glare.
And at the end of the room, on a stone throne, sat a woman.
Even before they were forced to walk closer, Bilbo could see her beauty. For she was beautiful: long blonde hair that was done up on her head in an intricate fashion, a slender, though short, neck that almost seemed to beg for jewels to adorn it. Her green eyes were bright and vivid and watched them all the more closely as they approached. And when she smiled, it was a fearsome thing, terrible and brilliant all at the same time.
She stood, and she was so much shorter than Bilbo had expected, given the magnitude of her presence, that he stumbled in his next steps. Only when they’d been marched straight in front of the throne did she speak. “Am I in the presence of Bilbo Baggins?” she asked, and her voice was a little deeper than he’d expected. Yet it still sounded like a song, something that could have been beautiful, if not for the cruel lilt to it. “I held your kin here, some time ago.”
She glanced at Kili briefly, then moved her gaze back to Bilbo. He’d registered the surprise in her eyes, however: she hadn’t been expecting Kili. Good. They could be the surprise for once. “Have you brought others to my home?” she asked him. “For you were meant to come to me in quite a different fashion.”
“I didn’t get your invitation,” Bilbo said, forcing himself to not bite his tongue. “My apologies if I wasn’t supposed to bring a guest.”
She gave a laugh as if delighted. “My, what a mouth on you,” she said, still grinning. “Such a way with your words. Yes, you’re the Bilbo Baggins I’ve been looking for.” She glanced at Kili, tilting her head to the side. “You have to be of the Line of Durin,” she said at last. Kili stiffened, clenching his fists. “The anger in your eyes, the features of your face, they all mark you as a Durin. Though what you’re doing in my domain, that is a question indeed.”
“I’m afraid we’re a little in the dark,” Bilbo said. “I don’t have your name to address you by properly, Miss…?”
“Caila,” she said. “My name is Caila, and I am the true Ruler of Dwarves.”
Silence followed that statement. Bilbo tried to find the right words, tried to figure out just what she was saying, but Kili found his voice first. “You can’t be the Ruler of the Dwarves,” he said. “No one is. Not even if you married the King of Erebor, which will never happen.”
“I don’t need to marry the King,” she said. “I just need to dispose of him. Dwarves don’t need to be a man to rule on their own.”
Bilbo frowned, focusing on anything else except for the words dispose of him. A dwarf? He’d never seen a dwarf as tall as she was, let alone one with only a brush of sideburns. Her hair was not thick and bushy, but looked slender and sleek to the touch. Only her broad jaw and wider stance gave her statement any credulity.
It was Kili, of course, who said what Bilbo had been thinking. “You’re not a dwarf,” he said. “There’s absolutely no way you could be-“
Swords were drawn and pointed their way, almost immediately, and Bilbo drew Kili back towards him. Caila’s green eyes burned like a dangerous fire. “I am a dwarf,” she declared. “I may only be half in blood, but I am fully dwarf. My father’s blood does not matter at all.”
“Your father?” Bilbo hazarded asking. The longer she spoke, the longer Bilbo and Kili could live, and the longer Bilbo had to figure out just what they were going to do. The dense circle of thieves around them now was going to keep them well contained and captive. Never mind the fact that he had no clue just where they could go.
“Elf,” she spat, and it began to make sense. Her rounded ears matched her face, but her hair went with her slender fingers. She was a perfect mix of dwarf and elf, and it was so obvious now, looking at her, that he wasn’t certain how he’d missed it the first time. “And I was cast away from every dwarven settlement for it years ago. I am, however, fully dwarf. His blood matters not.”
“It doesn’t matter whether you’re a bird in the sky or Durin the Deathless reborn,” Kili insisted. “The throne of Erebor is occupied. You can’t have it.”
“I could have any throne I wanted, let alone Erebor’s,” she said, and the dangerous gleam was back in her eyes. Bilbo pulled Kili closer still until they were nearly against a wall of thieves behind them. “But that matters not. No, I seek a different prize. What better way to prove my heritage, my true heritage, then to take the greatest treasure from the greatest dwarf kingdom in all of Middle-Earth?”
Kili began to speak again, but Bilbo tightened his grip so suddenly on his arm that Kili could only let out a helpless gasp of pain. The Arkenstone. She had to want the Arkenstone. Why did it always come back to that terrible stone? “I don’t know what you intend to do with the Arkenstone, but how, exactly, will that make you the ruler of all the dwarves? And what do I have to do with anything?” he asked, apologetically rubbing Kili’s arm.
She smiled, a toothy thing that offered no comfort. “I don’t want the Heart of the Mountain. I hold six things that will not only prove my heritage, but gain me the title I deserve.” And she held out something small and sparkling in her hands, something Bilbo didn’t quite understand for a moment.
But beside him, Kili froze, staring at it intently, and Bilbo felt his gut lurch. “What is it?” he whispered.
It was Caila who answered. “A ring, little hobbit. Much like the one you carried to Mordor, except this ring belonged to a great and powerful dwarf. Six of them I have in my possession, now, and all of them will loan me exceptional power to rule over the dwarves.”
“Seven,” Kili said without thinking, and he winced. Her gaze narrowed, even while Bilbo all but begged someone, anyone, to find them. He had a feeling the conversation was wrapping up swiftly.
“Seven rings went to the dwarves,” she agreed. “Yes, these are the seven rings of power you think they are. Well studied, little Durin. They were crafted by Sauron, then controlled by him. However, now that the One Ring is gone, they hold their own power, and when placed together, can lend their wearer great dominion.” She gazed at the ring in her hand much the same way that Bilbo imagined Gollum had stared after his precious, and it made him ill. “But the problem is that I only have six, as you so readily pointed out. The seventh is within Erebor, and the only being who could give it to me is your king.”
A ring of power was in Erebor? Bilbo knew he was staring at the small ring in her hand, his breathing coming unevenly. Had Thorin known? No, his husband would have told him there was a dangerous ring within the mountain, given Bilbo’s laborious trek to Mordor. But if there was anywhere that a ring could be in the mountain, it had to be in the Treasury. It had to be.
The Treasury. The thieves had been trying to get into the Treasury. Bilbo hadn’t been their prize, the ring had been their prize. That’s why they’d tried to get in two years ago. And when that hadn’t worked, they’d decided upon another tactic in order to retrieve what they wanted, what she wanted.
“Me,” he murmured, and Caila’s eyes slid up to meet his. “That’s why you wanted me. You ransomed the Shire to get me, then planned on ransoming me for the ring.”
Her eyes lit up with approval. “When they said you were clever, they weren’t lying,” she said. There was a madness in her voice and eyes, one Bilbo wanted to be very far away from. “Yes, you’re absolutely right. Except I didn’t really need you for the ransom.”
Bilbo’s heart faltered. “What?”
“I didn’t need you. I simply needed them to believe it was you, that I had you. You see, everyone knows that your king, your Thorin Oakenshield, he would drop it all for you. He would give up anything he had if just to have you back.”
Something tightened in his gut, and Bilbo rapidly shook his head. “He wouldn’t,” he swore. “Not everything, and certainly not a ring of power.”
“Ah, then you and I will have to agree to disagree.” She tilted her head just slightly, closing her hand around the ring at last. “Because I very much think he would.”
And he knew she was right. Before, he would have questioned it; there was only so much anyone would do for their loved ones before the good of others came into light. But after having watched Thorin all but crumble outside of Moria’s gates, falling apart and desperately cradling Bilbo…
You’re my everything. I cannot…I cannot lose you.
Thorin would give her the ring. Thorin would give her his very life if it meant returning Bilbo unharmed.
Her eyes lit up in triumph. “You know he would. I can see it in your eyes. And that, Bilbo Baggins, is why I took you for my very own. Because you would do anything for your kin, and Thorin? The great and mighty Thorin Oakenshield would give it all up for one little hobbit.”
She rolled the ring around in her hand, eyes watching it sparkle from the fires, and Bilbo thought he’d be ill. The Shire had never been the point. That was why there’d been so few orcs. She’d pulled Bilbo out of Erebor in order to take him captive, then had planned to ransom him back in order to take the ring. And the worst part of it all was that it was going to work.
“I wonder,” she mused out loud, watching Bilbo now, “I wonder where your king is. I had presumed him to be in Erebor, yet if you are here, with one of his heirs…perhaps he is nearer than I had anticipated?”
A chorus of shouts came from somewhere distant, catching everyone’s attention. “Go and aid them with her,” Caila ordered, and several of the thieves left. It wouldn’t be enough to escape from, but it gave Bilbo some small measure of hope. There were fewer thieves on the left: if they could just get through…
“She’s been a difficult pet to keep,” Caila said. She almost sounded bored, as if discussing the weather. “But I think, in the end, she’ll be worth it. Well worth the long journey from the caverns near Minas Morgul.”
“The what?” Kili asked, but Bilbo could barely hear him. The City of the Dead. His mind flashed back to Mordor, scaling the mountain, hands bloody, trying desperately to get up the stairs. Mablang’s knife at his throat, plunging into the darkness, running through the webs, getting hopelessly lost, then finding her.
“The City of the Dead, near Mordor,” Caila told him. She stared at Bilbo long and hard. “I have to presume you’re familiar with my pet, then. There were rumors that you fled from her once. I hadn’t thought anyone could have, but meeting you now…yes, you could have done it.”
Bilbo shut his eyes and tried not to fall back into his memories. The hot air around them didn’t help. She couldn’t be here. She just couldn’t. There was absolutely no possible way that they could have taken her from the caverns and brought her all the way across Middle-Earth without anyone noticing.
Kili gripped his shoulders tightly. “Who is she talking about?” he hissed, but Bilbo shook his head. The heat everywhere around him, the pain in his ankle, it was too much to even consider thinking about her.
Kili gave a frustrated huff and turned instead to the woman before them. “What do you mean, you only needed them to believe it was him?” he demanded. “Uncle wouldn’t give up anything unless he had Bilbo.”
Caila settled back into her throne, casually lounging as if she had not a care in the world. However, her eyes were fixed solely on them, and that, Bilbo was quickly discovering, was not a good thing. She was far too clever, far too quick, and far too calculated. They were used to dealing with the impulsive and foolish responses of the orcs, the enraged and maddened attacks of men. She was calm and collected, and she had a plan. So far, she had been two steps ahead of them, and all for her final goal.
He wondered if, once upon a time, Sauron had been like this, collected and careful in his every plan until he’d dominated Mordor completely and managed to spread his darkness throughout Middle-Earth. He shuddered.
“I had planned on showing him Bilbo,” she agreed. “But now I have you instead, a good faith token, and I need not even bring Bilbo forward.” She moved her attention to Bilbo. “Which is good, as you’ve already been promised to another. I never would have given you to your king. Once I have my ring, nothing else will matter.”
“Promised…?” Bilbo began, then watched as a dark shape emerged from the shadows. His heart stopped in his chest, and true fear began to blossom inside him. No. Oh sweet Eru no.
“In exchange for my fine army of dwarves, and his allegiance, you were the price. I thought it quite an affordable one,” Caila said, and her eyes all but gleamed in the darkness. “He is my greatest general, and for that, I would give him anything.”
Lips turned up into a sneer, followed by his cruel voice. “I believe it’s been a very long time since we last saw each other, your majesty. I have to say, however, that I’m very pleased to see you.”
And when Kili shoved Bilbo behind him, Bilbo too numb to move, Dekir’s smile broadened all the more.
