Actions

Work Header

to rule the fate of many

Chapter 18: Darkness descends

Summary:

The venture into Moria is a deep, dark, and dangerous one. And one of them will pay the ultimate price for it.

Major Character Death this chapter.

Notes:

WARNING: CHARACTER DEATH.

This is that chapter. This is where it hits. Y'all have been warned.

*hands out blankets and tissues*

And then there's other stuff that happens, too. Nice, long, angsty chapter.

Not sorry. ...Well, sort of.

Chapter Text

Each step was made in silence without any true effort on his part. Legolas thought it a kindness, given that his mind was everywhere else.

Esmeralda was a worry, for she had had her innocence slowly stripped from her on this journey. Yet she seemed to be standing as bravely as one could, given the circumstances. With Tauriel and Bofur both beside her, she was well protected from the horrors around her. Her and her babe, and that was not a thought Legolas even wanted to entertain, now that they were in the long, dark passageways of Moria.

Fili, Dernwyn, Éomund, and Aragorn were all walking together, and Dernwyn had not left Fili’s side since the resolution of their argument outside of Moria. They were speaking in quiet, hushed tones that Legolas could hear despite the lack of sound in the caverns around him. The spaces nearly seemed to swallow any noise, which he could understand as being a boon when one worked with stone. The echoes of mining had to be dreadful, after a time. Carving the caverns to dampen sound made a great deal of sense.

He forced himself to focus on those ahead of him, the reason his thoughts continued to stray.

Behind Gandalf, Thorin continued onward, Bilbo in his arms. He had gone from a careful grasp to a firm one, all but cradling Bilbo now. For Bilbo had gone from being alert to half aware of what was going on, leaning into Thorin and holding on as best he could. The injury was costing him a great deal, the pain leaving him blinking blearily and lost. Legolas winced in sympathy when he saw the ankle again. It seemed a macabre memory of the events ten years ago, when Bilbo had been forced to walk with a cane for quite some time. He could only hope his friend would not have to endure it again.

And, right behind them, walking alone, was Kili.

“Speak to me.”

Legolas was not surprised to find Tauriel at his side. The others were moving forward, and no one was near enough to hear them, even if the cavern had not all but taken Tauriel’s question with it. “What’s wrong?” Tauriel asked again. “You keep from him when I know you would rather be at his side. You have kept yourself from speaking to him, as if you could not care, but you instantly pushed him behind you when the beast attacked. Do you not trust him to care for himself?”

It was so hard to describe, to put into words the feelings he had. “Legolas,” she murmured, and he sighed.

“I would have him preserve what little of life he has left. I will not see him fall.”

She frowned. “He has much life left-“

“And now you think as they do,” Legolas said, trying not to glare at her. “Not as an elf.”

The stare he received was too knowing, and he clenched his fists beside him. “Of all the times to confront mortality,” she finally said, shaking her head, “you have picked the worst time to do it.” She moved ahead to rejoin Esmeralda, offering him no words of peace. There were none to offer, after all. Kili was mortal and Legolas…was not. He could feel the choice before him, however, had known the path made to him when he’d wed his dwarf. Yet it had not been until Esmeralda’s words that he had truly let himself think of it.

“We have short lives. A little longer, perhaps, than men, not as long as dwarves, and we’ll never see eternity pass as the elves do. But it’s what you do with the years you’re given that counts, doesn’t it?”

He knew it had changed everything, that night. Fili had been forced to face the truth, that he would outlive his wife, and had become too protective of her. Thorin had done the same, and both of their attempts had been met with nearly disastrous results. Yet here Legolas stood, doing the same.

He would outlive Kili. He would outlive them all. He would be forced to bury his light, his hope, and then go on forever with only a memory to keep him company. He could not, would not, love again. When Kili went, so too did his heart. It had left him so stunned, so frightened, watching Kili fall and thinking him dead, that he had pulled away from Kili and the sure knowledge of a future heartbreak. For he had only felt the distant possibility of sorrow since marrying Kili. Never before had he been forced to confront it, or acknowledge Kili’s mortality so rapidly, so violently. Yet when he had been forced from Kili’s side, and had been forced to watch his husband fall…

He wondered if it would be better to leave him, now, to think of him as only a memory, but a living memory, then to go on past him with the sure truth that he was dead and gone. It was a choice only he could make, and to explain it to Kili felt like a betrayal. Even if Kili understood, Legolas would feel shame at the indecision he warred with.

Yet how was this any better? He was living as a shade, so far from Kili’s light, and every day his distance dimmed that light.

He watched Tauriel with Esmeralda and Bofur, unafraid to speak and be with them. Even confronted with Legolas’s hesitation over mortality, she still remained by their sides. Mind made up, at least for the moment, Legolas took three large strides forward that put him beside Kili. Kili had barely turned towards him when he slid his hand into the dwarf’s. After a stunned moment, Kili squeezed his hand tightly, and the relief on his face made Legolas’s chest too tight.

He had to speak with his husband. He would tell him then how he felt.

“If my memory and history’s right, we are near to the main Great Halls,” Balin said, his voice muffled by the room. “If there was ever going to be a place to call a den, it’d be there.”

Dwalin nodded. “Surprise attack’s a good way to go. They’ll never see it comin’.”

The sharp whistle of an arrow came too late to stop it. For a long moment, no one moved, too stunned.

Then, Balin began to fall.

Dwalin shouted and dove for his brother, catching him before he could reach the ground. “There,” Bilbo said from Thorin’s arms, pointing off to the side, and Legolas did not pause to ask where or what Bilbo had seen or how alert his friend was. He simply grabbed Kili and ran.

They darted through the darkness, Gandalf’s light all there was to lead them across the stone floor. Above them, arrows flew through the dark, and Legolas pulled an arrow of his own when he was certain he knew where one archer was. The responding cry was all he needed to know, and then they were running again.

A door, half on its hinges, stood out, somehow illuminated by a stray beam of light coming from above. Nori and Aragorn grabbed the door and swept it open, and everyone rushed in. A few stray spears and weapons helped barricade the door, and when they were done, Legolas turned back at last.

Balin was gasping for air, pained gasps that rattled in his lungs. The arrow stuck out through the front of his chest, the point red and dark. Dwalin laid his brother upon the ground, carefully arranging Balin’s white beard with nothing else to do. “You’ll be all right,” Dwalin said gruffly, and Legolas knew then that Dwalin could not bear to face the truth.

There was nothing to be done.

“Down, put me down,” Bilbo was insisting. “Thorin, go,” and Thorin settled his husband down against a large stone before hurrying over to Balin and Dwalin. There was a grief on his face, not just for himself but for Dwalin as well. It was a terrible sight to behold, and everything Legolas feared. Mortality. And for Balin, it was nearly at its end.

“Don’t look that way,” Balin gasped out, shaking his head at both Dwalin and Thorin. “Don’t. You’ll…be all right.”

“Balin,” Thorin murmured helplessly. He caught Balin’s hand in his own, clinging, as if his grip alone could keep Balin there. But the blood continued to pour, and Balin’s gaze was beginning to drift away. Legolas could only hope it was his father’s halls he saw, now.

Balin took in a short, ragged breath. “Get them out,” he whispered. He murmured something in Khuzdul to Dwalin that made the warrior choke on a sudden sob and the other dwarves bow their heads in grief.

Then his eyes sank shut, and Balin, son of Fundin, was gone.

Legolas closed his eyes. His blessing for the dead, though small and in Sindarin, was all he had to give to the dwarf he had called a friend. Aragorn mouthed the words with him, and Tauriel’s eyes were suspiciously bright across the room, where she had Esmeralda in her arms. The young hobbit’s face was turned away, shoulders hitching with silent sobs. Bilbo had his head buried in his hands, and Legolas caught the shine of tears upon his face.

Dwalin knelt there on the stone for a long time. When he finally moved, it was slow, careful movements, as if he were so much older than he was. He gently pressed his forehead to Balin’s, much as he had many times before, and now would never do again after this day.

How did the others deal with mortality? How, when it came to them every day, so swiftly and so suddenly? How, when it was promised to them no matter what they did with their lives?

Thorin rose to leave him be, for a time. His blue eyes were brimming with tears, but he fought to keep his countenance. “They will come,” he said roughly.

Already Legolas could hear a force moving towards the door. “The door will not hold for long,” Aragorn said. He nudged Éomund forward towards Dernwyn and Fili. “It is hardly a barricade.”

The room itself was small, an easy place to keep them trapped. It looked to have been a storage room, once. Shelves were cut into the stone, and broken pieces of wood were strewn about the floor. Pieces of the ceiling were now on the ground, large stones such as the one Bilbo was leaning against. One of the stones from above had left a gaping hole to the outside, allowing the moonlight to stream through. It was much too high to reach, but it allowed them visibility, at the least.

“Let them come,” Dwalin said hoarsely. When he lifted his head, his cheeks were tearstained, but his eyes were red with fury. “Let them come and stand against the last son of Fundin.”

“Let them stand against us all,” Gimli challenged, hefting his axe high. “I’ll wager they’ll not last long.”

Bilbo wiped his face and stood carefully, and before anyone could stop him, he put weight on his injured ankle. It held, and with more determination he strode over towards one of the walls. “There’s light, here,” he said. With each step he took he seemed to gain new strength, until he was walking almost normally across the room. He dug his fingers into a hole even Legolas could not see, and suddenly there was a red light streaming across Bilbo’s face. “If we can open this, we can get out.”

“There’s a door, made for walkin’ through,” Dwalin growled. Legolas pinched his lips but it was Thorin who spoke.

“We need to leave, Dwalin. In one piece.” He glanced down at Balin’s still form. “Help us with the stone wall.”

Dwalin kept his gaze on the door. “Dwalin-“

“I’ll not leave him,” he snapped at Thorin. “I won’t.”

“Here, what about this?”

All eyes turned to Bilbo. He’d moved from the hole to a broken shelf in the wall. The shelf above it had been cracked, leaving a large gap in the lower part of the wall. “There’s enough large stones to roll in front of it,” he said softly. “We could at least keep him safe until we can come back.”

It was obvious how much it pained Dwalin to do it. But at last, he gave a sharp nod. “Fili, Kili,” Thorin ordered, and as one they moved to the stone Thorin had pointed to.

It hurt to watch Dwalin lift his brother’s body with such reverence. Legolas felt a pain in his breast, wondering if perhaps he would one day lift Kili in much the same manner. He could not look as Dwalin carried his brother to the shelf in the wall and gently placed him there. The stone was rolled in front of the wall, and if Legolas had not known, he would have said nothing had been changed. The room looked completely untouched. Yes, Balin would be safe here.

“Time to leave,” Nori pointed out, and everyone quickly moved to the wall. Legolas caught sight of Bilbo resting a hand upon Dwalin’s arm in sympathy and comfort before the elf turned to the reddish light pouring in. The stones were easy to pick away, and between the many hands lending themselves to the task, the hole was soon large enough to climb out of. The drop to a stone floor was simple enough, but Legolas still jumped out first to ensure the ground would hold. When it did, he reached his arms up to assist the others in coming down.

Once Tauriel had jumped out, along with Gandalf, Legolas caught a glimpse of the cavern around them. This one seemed to be ablaze everywhere, an eternal fire that would not go out. It was all red: red rock, red light pouring in everywhere, exposing the multiple stone pathways and columns that rose high above them. The cavern smelled of death and something horrible. Something so wrong and terrible Legolas wondered if perhaps Sauron himself had not walked these passageways once. He could only hope that whatever it was, it was no longer there.

It was just as Éomund was being lowered that the sounds of the door splintering caught Legolas’s ears. “Swiftly,” Gandalf said, having heard the same thing. “Everyone, swiftly!”

Bilbo was helped down as carefully as they could. “I’m all right,” he tried to assure them, and he took several steps to prove it. They were slightly uneven, but they were still steps. For now, it would have to do.

“Go,” Thorin said, when Dwalin would not move from the room. “Dwalin, go.”

Dwalin shuddered, his eyes holding on something in the room. Legolas knew what it was he continued to gaze at. To not only lose a loved one, but to be forced to leave them behind? It was an unbearable thought.

Ori moved back towards the hole. “Dwalin,” he called softly. Dwalin finally moved to glance below, and Ori gave him a gentle smile. “I’m not leaving without you,” he said. “So you’d best come down or haul me back up with you.”

The doors continued to give. Dwalin jumped down and clear of Legolas and the others, then took Ori’s hand as if his husband was the last lifeline left to him. Thorin followed behind to join an anxiously waiting Bilbo. “Move,” Aragorn said, and they were off. They hurried down the first main path available to them before taking a long set of stairs down, down and further into the mines. The glistening mithril veins told a devastating story, despite their gleam. There had been a people here, once. And then they had been cut down. There was no one left to mine the mithril. No one but the dead and a den of rogues.

They followed another path beside the large, empty void below them, then finally came to a long stone pathway that spanned across the dark pit. “Where does that go?” Tauriel asked.

Balin would have had an answer, would have known exactly where it led. Gandalf answered in his stead. “Deeper into the mines. Where we, too, must go.”

It was all the answer Tauriel needed. She flew across the pathway, Esmeralda and Bofur by her side. Nori went with Aragorn and Éomund, and Fili would not go until Dernwyn had crossed. Shouts from behind them were angry but distant, so distant that even Legolas’s eyes could barely make out their forms. They would be discovered soon enough, however.

“Legolas!”

He had not realized the others were all across until Kili’s cry. Kili looked frantic, refusing to follow the others as they ran from the bridge, standing by the edge. Legolas crossed within moments, and yet Kili still looked anxious. “Kili-“

“I’m not leaving without you,” the dwarf said stubbornly, then caught Legolas’s hand. Together they ran along the dark pit to their left, the red stone wall to their right. The path went beneath archways and around curves, yet still Legolas strained to hear what he knew would soon come: the shouts of their attackers, the whistles of their arrows.

The path began to narrow until they were nearly all running in a single line. The ground beneath their feet sloped up, then turned, the rock wall disappearing beside them. Suddenly everyone stopped, and Legolas managed to pull Kili back in time to keep him from running into Ori. Only when he glanced beyond Gandalf did he realize why they had halted.

The path sloped down, down towards the darkness of the black abyss where even his eyes could not see. To their right was a small bridge, stretching over a vast emptiness, leading to a series of hallways. Without the wall, there was no defense from either side: they were standing in the open, in too vulnerable a place. “We must move,” he insisted.

Bilbo made up his mind first, having looked at both options and weighing them in moments. He crossed the narrow bridge without any trouble, one foot in front of the other. Thorin gave a brisk nod. “Everyone across, now,” he said.

Kili tugged Legolas’s hand forward. The sound of the approaching danger pulled him back. “Go,” Legolas encouraged, when Kili stilled. After a brief moment, Kili nodded and began to cross. Though not as small-footed as Bilbo, Kili seemed to have no difficulty crossing. Esmeralda stepped forward to go next.

The bridge gave. “Bilbo!” Thorin shouted, and Bilbo, having been warned, jumped at the last moment. Bofur frantically pulled Esmeralda away from the edge, and Legolas could only watch in horror as the pathway collapsed beneath Kili’s feet. Kili ran as far as he could, the stones disappearing beneath his boots, before he finally threw himself to safety. The path crumbled and fell away into inky blackness, and both Kili and Bilbo landed on solid ground on the other side. Only when they began to move, with Kili carefully helping Bilbo to his feet, did the realization of what had just happened dawn upon them.

Thorin frantically searched for another bridge, but even as Legolas glanced around, he knew there was no other. That was the only way across to the hallways. Even Gandalf gazed across the expanse, but his gaze held resignation. Aragorn held his sword forward, as if he could extend to the other side. Yet his face spoke of the truth that he knew.

Legolas took a step forward out of instinct to reach his husband’s side, but there was nowhere to go. He was trapped on the wrong side of the cavern, away from the one being he loved more than any other. Kili met his gaze, looking just as anxious as Legolas felt. It was as if someone had tightened metal bands around his chest, leaving him completely unable to breathe.

Thorin stared, helplessly, at the other side. Bilbo bit his lip, his gaze on no one but Thorin. The shouts were getting louder and Legolas knew they had to leave, knew they had to abandon Bilbo and Kili to whatever fate they would discover on the other side. He felt so sick he actually clutched at his stomach to steady himself.

“We have to go,” Tauriel said at last. Bilbo nodded jerkily but said nothing.

Thorin drew in a deep breath and stood at his tallest and most formidable. He looked regal and determined, his word his bond. “I will find you,” he swore. “I will.”

Bilbo slowly smiled. “You always do,” he called across the way. Kili seemed to speak, then did not, but his eyes stayed on Legolas. When the shouts came louder, it was Kili who moved first, tugging Bilbo away and down one of the hallways.

Legolas would have stared until they were gone, but their pursuers were nearly upon them, from the sound of it. “Swiftly we must move,” Gandalf said. “That is the only way we will find our loved ones once more.”

“And find ‘em we will,” Gimli said. “But we’ve to move now.”

Dwalin said not a word but took Thorin by the arm, pulling him down the sloping path. Tauriel was there not a moment later, urging Legolas forward, and then they were descending along a darker path. Somewhere above them, Kili and Bilbo were running for their lives.

And Legolas knew, without a shadow of a doubt, that were something to happen to Kili, he would not outlive him. He simply could not.



It was a long time before Bilbo called a halt, and he was half certain Kili was going to force him to if he didn't do so on his own. When his ankle couldn’t take any more, however, Bilbo finally stumbled against a column and took harsh gulps of air. “Uncle,” Kili began, but Bilbo waved him off.

“I’m fine, truly.” No, he wasn’t, and Kili knew it, but if there was one way he could try and help his nephew, perhaps lying wasn’t the worst thing he could do. The last thing Kili needed right now was the truth: that he still felt weak and tired, that all of his energy seemed intently focused on his ankle, which was still throbbing incessantly and sending sharp pains up his leg with every step he took. It was all he could do to put it back down on the ground, knowing the pain that would immediately follow.

All he wanted was to be back in Thorin’s arms. And they were separated again and nothing was going to come of this.

Perhaps this time, it would be he who found Thorin, if just out of necessity. Because he wasn’t entirely certain he’d make it much further without his husband.

“Sit for a moment,” Kili urged. “We’ll be all right.”

“You don’t have the slightest idea if we’re all right,” Bilbo admonished, but he leaned more into the column and slid down to the ground, letting it take the weight off of his ankle. Oh sweet Eru it hurt, and he was faintly worried that something had snapped when the creature had grabbed him. All he’d known was one moment, he’d been reaching for Thorin, and the next, he’d been wrenched from his husband’s grasp, had felt the dirt giving way to wet pebbles, and a fire had begun burning from his ankle upward. Somehow, he’d wound up back in Thorin’s arms, and then Gandalf had been there, and it’d been everything he could do to not pass out.

He sighed and rested his head against the cool stone behind him. As much as he’d protested the idea of being carried, it hadn’t been long before he’d dozed off, desperate to escape the pain. He’d awoken to a shout from Dwalin in time to see Balin fall.

He shut his eyes. Balin. It had been a stroke of luck to see the door leading to the small side room. If only it’d been a stroke of luck to see the archer in time.

He opened his eyes and found Kili looking behind them, back down the hallway. Now that they were alone, Bilbo found himself asking the question he’d long wanted the answer to. “Kili, what’s going on with you and Legolas?”

“I don’t know,” Kili burst out, hands coming up to tangle in his hair. He was flustered and frustrated, but most of all, he looked afraid. “I don’t know what’s wrong, or what I’ve done. He’s not loved me any less, but he hasn’t truly been there, we haven’t really talked since Isengard. I just, I feel that there’s something going on or I’ve done something. And he won’t tell me.” He sighed and lowered his hands. “At least you and Uncle made up,” Kili said, as if trying to instill cheer.

Not entirely, to Bilbo’s satisfaction, or to Thorin’s. It’d been a quick, heartfelt moment, to be sure. Then the creature had come, and then there’d been pain, and then Balin and running and being separated again. He wanted to talk with Thorin. Still, they weren’t separated by vast miles again, only by walls and slopes. They were both in Moria. And as large as Moria was, they would find each other again.

“You and Legolas will have a chance to talk with one another,” Bilbo said softly. Kili nodded, but his eyes remained on the hallway they’d left behind. “But if we’re to have any chance of that, we need to keep going.”

Kili nodded again, then finally shook himself. “Right. So…which way?”

“I should be asking you that, but you’re a Durin: you’ve no sense of direction at all,” Bilbo teased. Kili very maturely stuck out his tongue, giving a little smile as he did so.

“Nah, that’s just Uncle. He’s a terrible sense of direction, always has. He seems to be able to find you well enough, though.”

Bilbo could only hope that luck would continue. “Well, you can help this uncle up. Then we’ll figure out which way is the best. Perhaps one smells better than the other.”

“Fresh air,” Kili said with a nod. “Sounds like a solid plan to me.” He carefully pulled Bilbo to standing, and though his ankle burned, it soon faded to a dull throb. He could walk on it. He’d be fine.

He turned and stilled, the sudden tip of the sword nearly piercing his nose. Kili’s hands on him tightened, but the dwarf didn’t move, given he had a sword of his own aimed at his throat. “Fresh air does sound good, don’t it?” one of the men before them said, earning nods from those around him. “Too bad for you both we’re goin’ down into the mines a bit more.” He gave a toothy grin, exposing black gums and missing pieces of teeth. Bilbo shuddered at the malice in the grin. “Way down. You’re both wanted guests, late for the feast.”

“Don’t,” Bilbo murmured when Kili tensed, ready to spring into action. “Just, don’t.” For a long moment, he was afraid Kili would ignore him and attack anyway, but finally he felt his nephew slump beside him.

He shut his eyes when the thieves reached for him. Thorin, find us, find me.