Actions

Work Header

to rule the fate of many

Chapter 23: Revelations

Summary:

The end game of Caila is finally figured out. Broken relationships are finally mended. And hope may finally be restored.

Notes:

So I was wicked last chapter and gave y'all a cliffhanger. I am evil. How have you all not figured that out yet?

But. I have been very busy writing, and as you can see, there is now a final chapter count up top. Final. As in, I have a lot of chapters written and I'm nearly done writing them.

We're almost to the end. SO EXCITED.

Chapter Text

It was one of the few times in his many years of knowing them, Bilbo thought, that he had seen Fili and Kili so quiet. Not just quiet, however, but still.

Fili continued to stare at the ground from where he was seated on a bench. His eyes seemed to be fixed on nothing at all, and Bilbo could only imagine the horrors he was concocting in his head. To his left was Kili, always to remain by his brother’s side. Kili himself was blank-faced, but his one hand was wrapped tightly in his brother’s. His other hand continued to trace the arrowhead hanging from his neck. What was going on between the dwarf and his elf-husband, Bilbo still didn’t know, but though the tension had eased between them, something still remained broken. He could only hope whatever it was would be remedied in the time to come.

No one else was really much better. Éomund was off in the corner, shifting restlessly from one foot to another. He had a hair pin in his hands that he was moving back and forth between his fingers. Aragorn was pacing quietly in the back of the room, with his gaze moving to the door every other pass. Gandalf was leaning against the tree that Legolas had been against, and everyone else had found a bench.

When Thorin had gotten up to carefully pace as well, face dark and lost in thought, Bilbo hadn’t joined him. He’d stayed on the bench, half to spare his ankle, half to be anywhere except next to Thorin.

Erebor had been taken. How had it even happened? How?

Only when Legolas returned did everyone look up, waiting to breathe. “Bard will live,” he said softly, and a quiet sigh resounded around the room.

“Thank Mahal,” Thorin murmured. He seemed to have aged overnight, and the silver hair that had been steadily growing was even more present now than before. “And Tauriel?”

“Remaining here in Lorien, for the time.” Perhaps even longer than that and they all knew it, but no one had the heart to state the truth. Not when Legolas looked as grief-stricken as he did.

“Has Bard said anything?” Nori asked.

Legolas nodded. “He said they took Dale, then struck at Erebor. Though they injured a few, including Bard, their purpose was not to kill, but to capture, and he imagines it would be much the same in Erebor. He fled for help and was found by Haldir’s guard outside of Mirkwood.”

“A ransom?” Aragorn asked, perplexed. “Do they expect to ransom all of Erebor and its people?”

They had made no demands, and hadn’t seemed to have that plan, from what Bilbo had heard in Moria. “No, they don’t want a ransom,” Bilbo said. “But I don’t understand what else-“

“Slaves,” Dwalin said darkly, and Bilbo stared, stunned. “They’ll mine Erebor and use its people as slaves. She’ll take the kingdom for her own.”

“Moria is dangerous and empty,” Thorin said. He shut his eyes and shook his head. “Erebor is not.”

They’d stolen Erebor. They’d not wanted to steal its gold or its wealth, but to steal the mountain, the kingdom, itself. It hadn’t been about the rings, it had never been about the rings, Bilbo was certain of it, now more than ever. Especially after Galadriel’s soft spoken words of truth. No, they’d only been a smokescreen for her true purpose.

“But how could they overtake the entire kingdom?” Kili asked, incredulous. “We’ve got a capable Guard, our people are strong-“

“The Guard who is missing their Captain?” Aragorn said gently. “The kingdom that is missing their king and its heirs? It would have been a risky move, but it could have been done. Especially if there had been dwarves within willing to open the doors.”

Nori said something low and angry in Khuzdul, and even Bofur nodded grimly. “There weren’t that many dwarves there, though, in Moria,” Esmeralda said. “It was mostly men and orcs, in that army we saw. How could dwarves turn against your kingdom?”

“Not everyone approves of Thorin havin’ Erebor,” Bofur told her. “Even back in the days when the line of Durin held Erebor, there were warring factions of dwarves. They don’t always stand united.”

“I still don’t understand,” Kili said, shaking his head. “If that was what she really wanted, then why not just attack Erebor?”

The realization hit Bilbo like a bag of bricks, and he buried his face in his hands. “The Shire,” he murmured.

They’d lured them out of Erebor with his kin, with the possible threat to the Shire. And of course Thorin had come with him, and the other dwarves as well. It would’ve been easy to cause an orc problem on the borders, removing more dwarves from the mountain. Then, with Dernwyn, Dis, and the children captured, the dwarves would’ve easily capitulated, moving where they’d needed to in order to keep Dernwyn and Dis safe. Doing whatever had been demanded of them in order to keep Holdred and Hildili alive.

Fili slowly shook his head. “I don’t…I don’t understand.”

Bilbo raised his head at last. He couldn’t even look at his husband, shame coursing through them. “Do you remember why we wondered where the great host of orcs was to march on the Shire? How we only found a few, much less than we’d expected? Because that’s all it was: a diversion. We flew from Erebor to race the orcs to the Shire, and they took over Erebor while we were gone. They wanted us out of the mountain, and they knew exactly how to do it. She wanted Erebor whole, which she wouldn’t have had if she’d attacked the mountain. So she had to get rid of us. And she did.”

He suddenly felt as he had ten years ago, after he’d been banished, pacing the room at the inn. He’d cursed out Thorin, and then, appropriately, cursed out himself. Damn me, damn me, damn me. He’d brought this down on Erebor, on all of them. If harm came to Dernwyn or Holdred or little Hildili, to Dis or Dori or any of the dwarves in the mountain, it would be completely and utterly on him. He dug his fingers tight into his curls.

“And Moria?” Bofur finally dared to say, when Bilbo had finished.

“They weren’t expectin’ us at Moria,” Dwalin said. “That much was obvious. No, they expected us to take forever gettin’ to the Shire, to deal with orcs, then make our way back. They were hopin’ to have us gone for months, not weeks. But Dernwyn got the ransom after we’d already left, so.”

It was little consolation. Beside him, Esmeralda said not a word. He could only imagine how much she had to hate herself, when she had done nothing wrong. It was Bilbo who’d done it, Bilbo who’d lost Erebor and its people. He’d never wished for the floor to give way and the ground to swallow him whole so fervently before. There was absolutely no way he could ever forgive himself for this or ever look his husband in the eye again.

He hadn’t even heard the soft tread of boots on the floor, so lost was he in his self-loathing. He definitely heard the voice right in front of him, however. “This was not your fault,” Thorin said.

“They knew,” Bilbo said miserably, still hunched over with his fingers pulling at his curls. “They knew that I’d leave the mountain for the Shire, for my cousins. I’m the reason we left Erebor. If it hadn’t been for me, you’d still be in Erebor, defending the mountain-“

Balin would be alive, Tauriel wouldn’t be on the brink of death, Dernwyn wouldn’t be a pawn, and the children wouldn’t be in danger. All of it his fault.

A fierce grip caught him and shoved him upright in his seat. Thorin’s eyes blazed at him in such a way that Bilbo hadn’t seen in years. “And if we hadn’t gone with you?” Thorin asked furiously. “What then? You and Esmeralda and a small group of soldiers would have gone back to the Shire anyway, and you would have been captured or killed. They would have brought me your body and I would never have forgiven myself.”

Bilbo shook his head but Thorin refused to let go, even tightening his hold, his one arm more than enough to pin Bilbo where he sat. “Do you understand me?” Thorin shouted, and his voice broke on the last word, his next words a mere whisper. “I never would have forgiven myself for your death. Not when I could have gone with you and saved you.”

“None of us would’ve,” Bofur said, as solemn as Bilbo had ever seen him before. From beside him, Nori gave a sharp nod, and Ori did the same. Fili and Kili looked as broken as their uncle, unwilling to take their eyes off of Bilbo for fear that he would be gone if they did. Bilbo forced himself to look at Dwalin, the only dwarf beside Thorin who deserved to hate him. His brother, lost, because of Bilbo’s kin.

But Dwalin only had a gruff smile for him. “Losin’ you would’ve been unforgivable,” he said. “Not an acceptable loss, lad.”

It was more than Bilbo could take. “But,” he choked out. “But Balin-“

“Lived a long life,” Dwalin said shortly. “And even if he’d been Fili or Kili’s age, we all knew what we were leavin’ for. We would’ve died to save you or your kin, and we still would.” He still looked pained at the mention of his brother, though, and Ori quietly took his hand in support. Saying the words was far less than accepting them, and the very fact that he’d said them at all, in order to help Bilbo, was more than the hobbit could almost bear.

Nods and rumbles of agreement echoed around the room, and Bilbo couldn’t look at any of them for a second longer. He buried his face in his hands, tears dripping through his fingers. Thorin murmured something before pulling him into a tight embrace. Even with one hand, he still managed to keep Bilbo feeling safe, keep him protected. It was more than he deserved, but Eru help him, he was going to take it.

“The only thing we have left to decide, then, is what we will do next,” Gandalf said. When Bilbo raised his eyes, dashing at them with the back of his hand, the wizard was staring straight at Thorin. “What we can possibly do against what is obviously a dangerous foe, I do not know. But if Caila takes Erebor, I fear for other races and kingdoms of Middle-Earth.”

“I have men within Erebor, who I know would defend your people as if they were our own,” Aragorn said. “If standing down would have spared lives, however, they would have done so.”

“So we have a force inside of Erebor. It’s not going to be enough for that army, though, unless we can get them out of the mountain.” Ori pursed his lips. “Did Bard say anything about his people?”

“Held within the city of Dale,” Legolas said. “Currently safe, to the best of his knowledge. After being struck, he remembers very little.”

The room fell silent. Outside, night was beginning to fall once more, the lamps on the paths glowing in the dimming light. Bilbo could faintly hear the murmurs of elves further off, leaving their company alone for the time. Galadriel had left with Haldir but had promised to return. She had looked to Bilbo for a long moment, staring deep inside him as if to see into his very soul, and he’d forced himself to not shudder under it. Never had she looked at him so oddly, so intently. He’d almost been…well, afraid of her. She had only ever looked on him with understanding and kindness.

He didn’t understand the difference. It hadn’t been the years, because he remembered waking up here in Lorien, tucked in her arms, feeling as if he were a child again in his mother’s embrace. She had smiled at him, assured him all would be well, and had brushed his hair from his face.

Had she known it was his fault? Had she known that Erebor had fallen, and that he was to blame? Did she hold him responsible, when the others wouldn’t?

He felt sick. Thorin’s arm tightened around him, as if sensing his thoughts, and he forced himself to settle.

“What will become of Tauriel?” Gimli asked quietly, the softest Bilbo had ever heard him. His heart ached for the dwarf who had become such a good friend to Tauriel.

Legolas couldn’t meet his eyes. “If she cannot heal, she will be sent to the Grey Havens, and there to sail to the Undying Lands. She would be with the rest of her kin and mine. It would be the only way to save her.”

Silence fell again. Gimli looked wretched but shrugged off Ori’s comforting hand. Ori bit his lip, and Dwalin gently tugged his husband away from the other distraught dwarf. It was clear that Gimli would accept no comfort, if not from knowing that Tauriel would be well.

“Will you go with her?”

The almost silent words still struck the rest of the company dumb. Legolas stared at his husband, eyes wide. “What?”

Kili watched Legolas with an unreadable gaze. “Will you go with her, to the Undying Lands?” he asked again. “It’s…I know you want to.”

Bilbo felt as if his eyes were going to fall out of his head. Where had that come from? “Kili,” Fili croaked, staring at his brother as if he’d never seen him before.

“I’m not a fool,” Kili continued, and there was a small smile on his face. It was filled with such resignation that it hurt to look at. “It took me awhile, but I figured it out. You only started being distant when I almost fell. You’ve got the same fear Uncle and Fee do. You can’t deal with mortality.”

“Everyone out,” Thorin said, and they all began to head for the door. Legolas and Kili deserved privacy, if nothing else.

“No, stay,” Kili said, and they all froze, Bilbo still having just risen from the bench. “You’re all going to know anyway, you might as well…” He cleared his throat and twisted the arrowhead hanging about his neck. “It’s all right,” Kili said, and his throat sounded tight. “I understand, I do. I couldn’t bear watching you die, either. I don’t blame you.” He huffed a watery laugh. “You deserve to be happy. I want you to be happy. And if you going over the sea to your kin, keeping me as a memory, is what will make you happiest, then…then I’ll let you go. If it would make you happy, I’d let you go.”

Fili stood and walked away to one of the corners, and this time it was Ori who had to keep Dwalin from going over to him. No doubt Fili had thoughts of Dernwyn running through his head again.

Bilbo couldn’t stand to look at any of them. Not when all he could think of was the nightmare he’d had again, waking him from his healing sleep and urging him to seek out Thorin. The despair in Kili’s voice, the resignation but the determination to see it through, it made his own eyes burn. How anyone could have the strength to let their beloved go, he didn’t know. Apparently Kili had vaster depths of wisdom and strength that none of them had.

There were days when he wondered how his nephews could be thought of as smart, with all the rocks in their heads. And then there were days where they were so brilliant, even when they were heartbreaking, that Bilbo didn’t know how he could stand beside them as an equal.

Legolas’s soft voice broke the silence, his words damning. “I had considered it. After I had thought you fallen. The thought of you dead, silent forever, I could not…” There was a pause. “I would have done anything to spare myself the pain of losing you, no matter how selfish it made me.”

Bilbo forced himself to look up. Kili looked as if he were bracing himself for the blow where he sat upon the bench. No one else was moving, and beside Bilbo, Thorin was a tense as an iron bar.

Legolas slowly stepped forward until he was in front of Kili, never once breaking his gaze. “Then I nearly lost you, in Moria,” he said. “And I knew then that if I did lose you, I would fall with you. I did not want to live without you, but more than that, I could not. If you fall, I fall.”

Carefully he knelt in front of Kili, the dawning realization on Kili’s face almost more than Bilbo could stand to look at. “You are my hope, my light. There is nothing I would not do for you in order to remain by your side. I faltered, in my fear, but not anymore.” He smiled and took Kili’s hand in his. “I’m here. And I’m staying. I will never leave your side, no matter how dark or grim the days may be.”

Kili’s smile was as bright as the noonday sun, and he threw himself forward, wrapping himself around his husband and holding on tightly. Legolas cradled him gently, putting no further duress on his wound, but still clung as if he’d never let go.

Bilbo didn’t realize he was crying until Thorin brushed away tears from the edges of his smile. When he glanced at his husband, he found tears on Thorin’s face as well, sliding into the upturned corners of his lips. He took Thorin’s hand in his and held on tightly, feeling stronger and somehow lighter than before. Husband.

Thorin pressed a brief kiss to the top of his head. Beloved.

“You took long enough.”

Gimli let out a cry as they all turned. Pale and shaking, arm wrapped around her in much the same way as Thorin’s was, stood Tauriel. Before anyone could stop him Gimli was racing over to her and wrapping her in his embrace from the waist down. Aragorn and Dwalin managed to catch her and steady her, and Tauriel gave a warm smile at the dwarf holding to her tightly.

“You look terrible,” Dwalin told her. She swung her gaze over to him, even as Esmeralda scowled at the dwarf. “Well, you do.”

“I would like to see you injured and looking any fairer,” she retorted, though her voice was weak. Still very injured, then, a thought bolstered as soon as Haldir came behind her, glaring at her.

“You should be abed, Tauriel. You are not well enough-“

“Peace, I only came for a few moments,” she said. She turned to Legolas again. “Are you settled?” she asked him. “Are you staying?”

Legolas nodded, looking grieved. “I am. I’m sorry, Tauriel. I cannot accompany you.”

“You shouldn’t. Not since it will be me accompanying you.”

“You will not,” Haldir said firmly at the same time as Gimli. Both of them glanced at each other for a moment, then turned back to Tauriel. Tauriel merely raised an eyebrow at them both.

“A coin on Tauriel,” Nori murmured from beside Bilbo, and Thorin snorted. Bilbo knew little of the other elf, having only just met him here, but even as bold and talented as he appeared to be, Bilbo wouldn’t take Nori’s bet for all the world. Tauriel, even as weak as she was, was no one to meddle with.

Tauriel turned to Legolas. “Where you go, I go,” she said firmly. “I’m not ready to sail to Aman yet. I have made Arda my home.”

“You could die,” Esmeralda blurted out, then clapped her hands over her mouth. Tauriel patted Gimli on the back, encouraging him to step aside so Esmeralda could stand beside her. Behind her, Haldir continued to watch carefully for any further faltering.

Esmeralda slowly placed a hand on Tauriel’s arm, as if afraid she would shatter. “You, you could go,” she said. “You could be safe.”

There wasn’t even a pause before Tauriel shook her head. “I would rather leave this world breathless, defending those whom I love, then sail away and breathe air that others cannot. I am staying with you, little sister.”

“You cannot come with us,” Thorin said. “You cannot aid us this way, Tauriel. I will not risk you.”

“And what exactly are we doing?” Nori asked.

“We’re taking back Erebor,” Fili said. He looked a wreck, but his eyes were like flames. “That’s what we’re doing.”

“We have no army,” Dwalin began, but Haldir shook his head.

“You had no army before. Now you do. I will lead the Lorien elves to aid you.”

That was an unexpected bit of luck. Thorin gave him a nod of gratitude, and Haldir offered a brief smile. “I had thought to aid you further, ten years ago,” the elf said. “But fell at Isengard instead. My call to arms now is long overdue.”

“Not overdue,” Aragorn said. He moved to clap the elf on the shoulder. “Just in time.”

Gandalf set his staff aside and clasped his hands behind his back, deep in thought. “The army that will be approaching Erebor from the north will be nothing short of massive. She has obviously been gaining deserters and supporters for some time. We will not number enough to withstand her might.”

“What if we freed the army in Dale?” Bofur asked. “What if we could get to them?”

“That would cut them off from coming from behind, too,” Kili said. “That would give us more troops and let us march on Erebor.”

Another day where Bilbo wasn’t certain he deserved to stand beside his nephew. “May he outshine us both, one day,” he murmured, and Thorin gave a nod of agreement.

“Queen Morwen is mustering the Rohirrim,” Éomund said, surprising them. “She spoke with…with Dernwyn. Before we left. She swore we would have aid in case of trouble.”

Bilbo was certain he’d never been more thankful for Morwen as a friend then now. “Would that suffice?” Legolas asked Gandalf, who still looked pensive. “Will that be enough to take Erebor back?”

“In numbers, yes. But I fear for the captives within. They could stall an entire army by threatening the life of just one being within the mountain.”

Bilbo’s eyes darted to Fili, but his nephew was staring out at nothing, his fists clenched beside him. It could be Dernwyn, it could be Hildili or Holdred or Dis. It could be a random dwarf they didn’t know by name, and it didn’t matter. They would stop any attack if it meant sparing a life.

“So we need them out of the mountain,” Nori said flatly. Gandalf looked just as pleased at the notion as he did. “Wonderful. How do you clear a mountain?”

“Well, a dragon worked well the last time,” Kili deadpanned. Thorin snorted and completely missed the look on Bilbo’s face. Bilbo slowly raised his head, the sudden, random, crazed thought so startling clear he couldn’t see anything else except the thought. His mind was whirling around and around, the idea building the more he spun it around.

“It could work this time,” he said cautiously, and everyone whipped their heads around to him. He could all but feel Thorin staring at him as if he’d lost his mind.

Kili stared at him. “A dragon,” he said. “Uncle, I know you say that we have rocks for brains, but…”

With every passing moment Bilbo became surer of himself. Slowly he pushed himself to his feet and stepped into the middle of the room, meeting Gandalf’s gaze. Gandalf raised an eyebrow at him. “You could do it,” Bilbo said. “If anyone could do it, it’d be you.”

“As much as I appreciate the faith you and young Kili seem to both have in me, regarding eleventh hour rescues, I’m still uncertain as to how I can aid beyond lending my own strength and power,” Gandalf said dryly. “I cannot summon a dragon. My power is not that great.”

It was so glorious an idea that Bilbo thought he’d about burst. “I’m not looking for great power or magic,” he said simply. “I’m looking for fireworks.”

Slowly Gandalf began to smile. Around the room, everyone seemed to stand straighter, as if hope had been inserted into their very being like steel rods up and down their spines. “Well?” Bilbo asked.

Gandalf took his staff from its resting place and leaned down to meet Bilbo’s gaze straight on. “That, my dear Bilbo,” he said, “can most certainly be arranged.”

And Bilbo smiled.