Chapter Text
The sunlight coming through the windows of their distant rooms felt wrong. It didn’t deserve to shine the way it did.
It had shone the day the dragon had come, too. It had shone the day Thorin had returned from Moria with news of Frerin’s death.
Dis glared at the door as subtly as possible. It was open, and had been, since they’d been kept captive in their main room. There was no point to closing it: there was no lock on it. There was a man guarding it outside the door, back to the wall, as casual looking as could be. She knew, however, that his ears were trained to catch anything from within the room and relay it back to the others. So far, Dis hadn’t given him the satisfaction, save for some random songs she sang to the children.
Dernwyn didn’t say anything either. Better to be safe than to be sorry.
She’d shared the story of what had happened, though, in halting terms. That the Shire had been saved, and Bilbo’s kin too, but that they had ventured into Moria and lost Balin. It had hurt, more than Dis had wanted to admit, and she’d forced her grief aside. She’d refused to show it in front of the thieves.
Then Dernwyn had told her of the army coming to Erebor, of the ragtag troops that this woman, Caila as the thief had added, had put together. Men and orcs, mostly, but a number of dwarves who’d happily stood against Erebor. They’d sneered at Dernwyn but hadn’t gone near the children, thank Mahal. One of the men had moved to push Holdred aside, but a dwarf had stopped him with brusque words. Even as vile as the children had obviously been to the dwarves, they were still children, and that was still respected. It had left Dis a little more comforted, though not by a lot. Especially not since a human had been placed in charge of watching them.
Not that a traitorous dwarf would’ve been any better.
For someone had let them into Erebor. Someone had opened the doors for them, and even as the Guard had rallied at the front gate to aid Dale, they’d slipped in the back and taken Dis hostage. Even King Aragorn’s men had stepped down and had let themselves be pushed away into the mines with the other dwarves. The women and children had been put in the kitchens and various halls. After that, it had been as easy as locking the doors and watching them.
She wished she knew what had become of Dril, of Dori, of Bombur and Bifur. But not a word had been given of their state. And frankly, Dis was suddenly very tired of not knowing. Mahal’s beard, she wasn’t some small, cowering thing, she was Dis, Princess of Erebor, and she would have answers.
Before she could so much as stand for the door, Dernwyn and the children immediately staring at her, the thief was met by a dwarf. “Relief,” the dwarf said, and the man nodded and headed down the hall. The dwarf took up his position, but there was something so familiar about him that Dis just couldn’t place. His face wasn’t familiar to her, but his voice and the way he held himself reminded her of someone.
She squared her shoulders and moved to the door before Dernwyn could hold up a hand to halt her. “I wish to make a request,” Dis said.
The dwarf side-eyed her but didn’t say a word. Pursing her lips, Dis continued. “There are kin within these walls, fast friends that I would know of. Dori the Guildmaster, for starters, and Bombur, Master Chef. Dril, second in command to the Captain of the Guard, and Bifur, in charge of the Armory. Where are they?”
The dwarf didn’t look at her, and Dis forced herself to remain calm. “What of those who were in Council when you swept into Erebor? Nadr, or his son Valdr? Where have they been placed?”
Again, she received no answer, merely the guard stretching his neck. Fury began to flood her veins, and she reminded herself of how many times she’d told her brother that anger was not a diplomatic solution. Now, however, she was beginning to think he had the right idea. Dernwyn’s words of her brother and how Thorin had been injured, of how Bilbo had faced Durin’s Bane and somehow lived to tell the tale, of Tauriel’s injury, of her youngest on the verge of death…
It was more than she could stand. “Even if you cannot bear the sight of me, or think the line of Durin traitors for whatever reason, give me this,” she said, voice low and full of righteous anger. “We are closer kin, you and I, than you and the rest of those thieves. I only ask for word on my kin, be they blood tied or honor bound.”
No doubt they were part of the dwarves who believed, as Dekir and Rutar did, of the sanctity of the bloodline. And Dis had never been happier than when Dernwyn had told her of their demises. She ruthlessly squashed down the thrill of victory at the memory.
The dwarf said nothing for a long moment, and Dis refused to move from the doorway. Finally he glanced at her sideways and said quietly, “We share kin, aye. And good kin at that. My cousin speaks fondly of you.”
Dis blinked. From his sleeve he pulled forth a folded parchment. “That doesn’t mean I will honor you the same,” he said, but his tone was gentle and his eyes were warm, a complete opposite of his words. He handed it to her, and she quickly took it. A brief glance inside showed written words that looked very familiar. Almost like…
Her eyes snapped up to his. “I would know your name, if you will be our guard,” she said, keeping her voice even. “If there should be a need for aid.”
He gave her a short nod. “Hril, son of Idril, at your service. Your majesty.”
It was a term of honor given with utmost respect, one she had not received from any of the thieves thus far. Now that she knew the connection, she could see it in his tall figure, his broad shoulders, his bushy beard. Still, she had to ask. “Is your cousin well?”
“He is,” Hril said. He gave a quick nod to the letter, then turned away from her and spoke nothing more. But she’d found more than she’d expected here, in Erebor, when all else had been turned against her and those she loved.
She swept to the fireplace, Dernwyn right by her side. Carefully Dis unfolded the parchment and began to read silently.
My lady,
We have watched the dwarves of our towns go to Moria under Caila’s call. When we heard rumors of her gathering forces to decimate the line of Durin, we quickly gathered under her, not to join with her, but to be here for you. There are those here, amongst her ranks, which are loyal to King Thorin, his husband, the Great Bilbo Baggins, and to you, our Princess. We are here to see you and your heirs safely delivered.
My cousin Dril was right: you are as strong as you are kind. We serve, and with honor.
Wait for our signal.
Hril
Slowly Dis raised her eyes from the page. Hril stood, as silent and imposing as ever, as if he were an enemy. But the truth in the pages was unmistakable.
Dernwyn was all but trembling with anxiousness. “We need to make our own plans,” she said, no longer fearing what their guard would hear. Not know that they knew that Hril was on their side. Dis gave a short nod.
“And for the children.” For she would keep her grandchildren safe above all else. If she did not survive the battle she knew now was coming, she would at least ensure the future of Erebor and of those whom she loved.
“You know, my mother gave me a cloak, and the children might be cold later,” Dernwyn said, and her eyes were alight with fire once more. They’d gone dull and dark after the thieves had taken her sword, but they were burning now, and Dis was glad to see it.
Dis grinned and looked to the cloak which hung now by the fireplace. It was large enough to wrap around Holdred and Hildili both, and the mithril within would keep them safe. “Your mother was a wise woman,” she said, and Dernwyn rolled her eyes.
“Are we cold now?” Holdred asked, raising his eyebrow in such a way that made Dis ache for her own sons. From the doorway, Hril snorted.
Dernwyn grinned even wider. “Not yet,” she said. “Soon, though.”
“We’ll be ready,” Holdred promised. He wrapped his arm around Hildili, and Lili looked ready to go to war herself, her stuffed dragon held tight in one hand like a mace. Her brave and beautiful grandchildren.
Hope flourished in her breast, and coupled with her anger at their captivity, it was enough to make her dangerous. She was looking forward to when she could release it on the thieves. Hopefully Caila would be the first one she could break. At this point, anything looked like a viable weapon.
They thought they’d taken her axes and her blade. She was a Durin, and she would fight with the chairs and benches about her, if that was all that was left to her. They would rue the day they had entered Erebor.
“We’ll all be ready,” she said. Then she ushered Dernwyn and the children back to the corner where they’d been quietly drawing on the scrap parchment Ori had given them some time ago. It would give her time to think and to plan.
Caila wasn’t going to know what hit her, though Dis would make certain it was her face that the woman saw last before she went to whatever halls she was destined for.
“She’ll be all right.”
Fili looked up, the first time since he’d lifted his head in hours. It left him feeling dizzy. Éomund still stood there, however, and it didn’t look as if he minded waiting for Fili to get his bearings, a thought that Fili appreciated. Still, the young man’s words weren’t exactly welcome at the moment. “You don’t know that,” Fili said.
“I know her,” Éomund countered. “As do you. And you know Dernwyn is stubborn to a fault. There’s absolutely no way that she isn’t all right and raising a ruckus. If they’ve taken Erebor, I can guarantee you that she, along with your mother, will probably have it back by the time we get there.”
It was a consolation prize of words, but at that point, Fili was willing to take it. Kili was resting with Legolas, both of his uncles were healing, and Tauriel had finally been convinced into staying for a time. It’d been Gimli that had been more hard pressed to talk into leaving, as he’d been determined to remain with her. Fili still wasn’t sure the dwarf would be coming with them.
And none of it had to do with his mother, his Dernwyn, his children being in the hands of those thieves. It was more than Fili could bear, and if he didn’t want to bury his face in his hands and sob, he wanted to bury his hands in someone else’s face.
Éomund slowly sat beside him on the ground. “You trust her with your life, do you not?” he asked quietly.
Slowly Fili nodded. “Then trust her with hers and the little ones. She would hold no one in higher regard than them and your mother. They’ll be safe. You have to believe that, if just to focus. You can’t help her this way.”
“This is one of my worst nightmares,” Fili said, the words all but falling from his lips. “Her gone and I’m left with nothing. I can’t raise my children on my own, even if I still have them,” and the thought of Hildili and Holdred gone forever was enough to make him gasp for air.
A strong hand caught him on the back and helped him breathe. In, out. In, out. Éomund was right: he couldn’t help Dernwyn like this. He was falling apart, the images of what could be overwhelming his chance to do anything now. He could all but see the look on Dernwyn’s face if she’d found him like this. Gentle, kind, but with a crease of annoyance in her brow. What you’re sitting for, I don’t know. Up with you, and come help me.
Slowly his breathing evened out. “Better?” Éomund asked, and Fili nodded. Not great, but better.
The young man rose and offered his hand. “Good. I would hate to lose a brother when I’ve truly only just met him.” He gave a quick grin. “You married my sister, you know.”
“So I did,” Fili said, and his next breath was more even. “When are we leaving?”
“Tomorrow, from what I understand. Aragorn and Thorin both want to give Kili more time to rest. He seems to be healing well, though, even better now that he and Legolas are no longer broken.”
That, that had been hard to stomach. Fili had managed a small moment of peace in his heart when Legolas had pledged himself to Kili once more. That was how they were supposed to be. It was good to see them righted.
“I believe the elves have put together a meal for us,” and even as Fili looked up, Aragorn came around the corner. He looked to Éomund first, then to Fili, and he stood examining him for so long that Fili nearly fidgeted under the scrutiny, like a child. Then Aragorn smiled and continued, “It will be a small number of us, but I have hopes that Gimli will eat enough for those who will be partaking of a meal in their own quarters.”
“Hope?” Fili asked. “Mahal help you, you’ll never get a bite to eat if you hope for that.”
Aragorn grinned and extended his hand to offer them the doorway. Éomund moved through first, with Fili trailing behind. He forced himself to take another breath, then two.
He wouldn’t sit and mourn her when she wasn’t gone yet. And she couldn’t be gone. He would have felt it in his soul, he knew it. No, Dernwyn was still alive. And he would find her.
There was no helping the being who stood between him and her. They’d depart the earth so swiftly they wouldn’t even remember his rage.
In the twilight of the night, when all else were asleep, Bilbo found himself staring at the ceiling. Beside him, Thorin slept on, careful of his arm. Other rooms nearby housed the rest of their company, all of them having gone to bed long ago. But sleep continued to elude him.
It hadn’t exactly ‘eluded’ him so much as given him nightmares and nightmares only. Of Thorin and their nephews falling in Erebor’s shadow, of Bilbo’s hand on the blade in his husband’s gut. Of burying Thorin, Fili, and Kili beneath the mountain in stone tombs. After that, he was content to never sleep again.
He finally sat up and carefully removed himself from the bed. He couldn’t sit there any longer, he had to pace, he had to walk, he had to do something. Anything that wouldn’t make him think of what he’d dreamt of. The curtains billowed in the slight breeze, and Bilbo pushed them aside to feel the air for himself. Here in one of the ground rooms, the curtain was their only wall from the rest of Lorien, the trees behind them making up the back of the room. The glowing lights were still bright enough to see by, and Bilbo let himself look out into the woods and just breathe.
Off in the distance, the sudden sight of Galadriel made him pause. She gave him an unreadable gaze, then began to walk down the path she was on. In Bilbo’s head, her voice echoed.
Come with me, Bilbo. For I have things to show you.
He felt himself moving, as if in a dream, slowly and with the glow of the lights blurring everything save for the path beneath his feet. Every step seemed light and almost as if he were falling, and the next one only moved him upward. Yet he saw that he was still on the ground, moving after her in the quiet of the night.
He never heard her other words, directed to one whose blue eyed gaze watched him go. His heart is heavy. You know this. I seek to give him answers that may stop the faltering in his heart. Rest, Thorin. For I will keep watch and deliver him safely back to you.
He never saw his husband’s gaze slowly drift shut. When he did glance back, Thorin was right where he had been before, asleep in the bed, the curtains waving back and forth in the gentle breeze.
Down steps and along thick roots they wandered, until at last she began to descend down a curling stairway to a small grove, wrapped and hidden within large trees. Between the trees, amongst the mossy grass, stood a short column with a large bowl. Resting on the column was a large pitcher. There Galadriel stood, waiting for him, and her eyes remained on him.
Slowly Bilbo made his way down and soon found himself standing in front of her. She wasn’t silent long. “I spoke to you, ten years ago, of showing you my mirror, but you already knew then the dangers of that which you possessed, and that which you were walking toward.” She took the pitcher in her hand, carefully, both hands supporting its weight. “I would have you look into the mirror now, for I believe you have need of it.”
“What will I see?” he asked hesitantly. She was still staring at him with that same gaze, the gaze that he didn’t understand. As if he’d done something wrong. Well, he’d lost Erebor and possibly the children, Dis, Dernwyn-
She shook her head, hair falling about her. “Do not lay the trouble of Erebor at your feet,” she said. “It does not belong there. I seek to help you, Bilbo Baggins. You are a friend, and you deserve the truth.”
She began to pour water into the bowl, and it seemed to glisten like the crystals that Erebor mined. “The mirror can show you what has happened, what is here and now, and what may yet come. Nothing is set in stone. But fate can always change its mind.”
Then she said nothing else and set the pitcher aside. Bilbo took small steps towards the column and found he could rest his feet almost solidly on the ground and still peer over into the water. It was calm and still, his own reflection looking back at him and revealing his face for the first time in weeks. The scratch on his cheek from Dekir’s blade was there, bruised but healing. His hair looked a little shorter, thanks to the Balrog’s heat. Various other bruises and scratches were there, but otherwise, he looked like a hale and healthy hobbit. Save for the bruises beneath his eyes where he couldn’t sleep.
Then his own face was gone, and in its place was another. He blinked. “Mother?” he whispered.
Belladonna smiled at him, and he watched as she turned and began to play with his much younger self as a child. Then she was gone, and it was just him, a little older, sitting alone in Bag-End. Even through the years, Bilbo remembered the pain of loss, the silent years alone in the house by himself. He almost wished he could speak to that younger self, to tell him things would get better – and worse – by turn. That he would carry the earth’s worst burden, but meet the only one who called to his heart.
After that, it was a flurry of motion, in the mirror. The dwarves arrived, the journey to Erebor going by in quick glimpses and seconds. The dungeons, Esgaroth, the Arkenstone and the gold lust, Bilbo leaving the mountain. This, he knew. It didn’t hurt any less to look at, but ten years standing beside his husband quickly soothed the old hurt and put it away where it belonged: in his memories.
Then things got…odd.
One moment, he was standing and speaking to Bard, asking for the Arkenstone back, and then the next, he was in some sort of battle beside the man, racing amongst orcs and goblins. Bilbo stared, not understanding. That hadn’t happened.
The image shifted again. Wandering the Wold, alone and lost before the Rohirrim had found him. It shifted back to that unknown battle and the Eagles soaring high above, taking out orcs. In the distance, there was Erebor, and there was Thranduil, battling alongside Legolas.
Rohan, Edoras. Erebor, fallen men, elves, and dwarves everywhere. Racing away from the orcs near the White Mountain, then shifting back to him racing through the remnants of the battle and finding Thorin, fallen. Thorin speaking his apologies in Gondor, giving him his beloved pin. Thorin whispering apologies even as they carried his broken body away. Thorin and Bilbo, taking hands in the Shire.
Thorin taking Bilbo’s hand before breathing his last.
“No,” Bilbo murmured, unaware that he was shaking his head in a rapid manner. “No, this is my nightmare, this…no…”
They were in Erebor, but the image kept shifting, like some horrible distorted nightmare. They were laughing at Kili and Fili while Dernwyn scolded them, and then the image shifted again, and it was Bilbo standing amongst the company, watching as they laid the line of Durin to rest under the mountain. It shifted at a dizzying rate to Bilbo in their rooms, smiling, watching Thorin scour over various documents for the Council, and then it shifted to Bilbo sitting in Bag-End by the hearth, his face blank, the house empty.
This was wrong. This was…this was wrong. This wasn’t his future, it couldn’t be. Thorin, Fili, and Kili weren’t dead, that battle had never happened, there’d been no Eagles, and it was impossible because Thranduil was no longer there-
A fire suddenly rose up, taking the mountain, and then he could only stare helplessly as a ringwraith charged into the Shire, taking lives where it could. He shook his head and watched as Thorin slept on in the bed here in Lorien, just as he’d left him not so long ago, and then he was decaying, a corpse in a tomb of stone.
He hadn’t realized he was falling until he hit the ground hard. Above him, water trickled over the edges of the column, and his own clothes were damp, as if he’d been splashed. He tried to steady his breathing and looked to Galadriel. She looked pained, and Bilbo knew then that somehow, whatever had happened, she knew. “Tell me,” he said lowly. “Galadriel, please.”
She seemed to weigh the words before speaking them. “When you took your own gold to Bard, in exchange for the Arkenstone, you altered fate. The same events could not happen, not after your small token. Then you discovered the One Ring for what it was, and set into motion events which were meant to come to pass, but not for many a year. By doing this, you changed fate again, yet held true to it, all at the same time.”
Bilbo stared. “I changed fate?” he whispered. “But…what was supposed to happen?”
She only gazed at him, saying nothing, and his heart stopped in his chest. “The nightmares,” he breathed. “In the mirror, I saw it, things that couldn’t happen now-“
“They were meant to happen,” she said quietly. “Fate was meant to bring together five armies at the base of Erebor. The orcs and goblins were meant to be defeated, alliances were meant to be taken up.” She paused, as if unwilling to say the words, and Bilbo felt like begging her to say nothing, because he knew, he knew what she’d say next.
Yet he couldn’t even find the air to say them when she spoke. “And the line of Durin was meant to perish.”
Bilbo found himself clutching the moss beneath him in his fists, tearing it from the ground. “Fili and Kili were meant to die defending their uncle,” she said. “And Thorin was meant to be taken from the field, give his regrets and seek forgiveness from you, and then go to the halls of his ancestors. That is what fate intended for Thorin Oakenshield and his heirs.”
Distantly he remembered Dis telling Dernwyn something about having expected a letter stating her kin were all lost to her, and instead had received a letter of good tidings. She would’ve gotten that letter, of Fili and Kili dead and her brother too. Would Bilbo have even met her, if that had happened? Would he have known what it was like to have a sibling, a sister?
No. Because, from the looks of it, he would’ve gone back to the Shire and stayed in his empty house, alone, for the rest of his days. That was what fate had intended for Bilbo Baggins.
“Why am I having the dreams now?” he croaked. He felt as if there was a tight knot in his chest, and if he didn’t cry, he would scream, and he would shake until he cracked open. “It can’t, it can’t happen now.”
Galadriel was silent for a long time, leaving him all the sicker. “Galadriel, please,” he begged.
She came to him then and knelt beside him in the grass. “Fate is not so easily pushed aside,” she said softly. “In the end, fate will have its way. Lives that were meant to be lost will still one day succumb to fate’s will. Another’s life may take their place, but in the end, fate cannot be dissuaded. You cannot circumvent fate forever.”
“But I changed fate,” he insisted, tears in his eyes. “I did, I found the Ring, I took it to Mordor-“
“It was always destined that a hobbit bearing the name of Baggins would take the Ring to Mordor,” she said gently, breaking his heart and hope even more. “You simply spared those who will come after you.”
And now they were going back to Erebor to face an incredible army with elves and men beside them. Fate was lined up to play out the way it hadn’t been able to ten years ago. It would take Fili, and Kili, and it would take Thorin. It would take them all, and who knew what other lives it would take since it had been kept waiting all these years?
“Those who attempt to alter fate’s course often become the hand of fate itself,” she said, her eyes and tone a warning. “If you try to change what fate has destined for the line of Durin, you may very well help aid it in its goal.”
The knot in his chest was beginning to burn, a slow fire in his veins that was evening out into determination and fury. He met her gaze, her gaze full of sorrow for him, and said, “But nothing is set in stone. You told me that.”
Slowly her lips turned up. “I did. And it is true. Nothing is truly set into stone.”
It was all the hope she could give him, but it would have to be enough. It would be enough, because he wasn’t losing his family now. He wasn’t losing Thorin now. He’d changed fate once, he could do it again.
He paused, a thought coming to mind. “Was Balin meant to…?”
She gave a slow nod, and he swallowed hard. “Oh.” Just by entering Moria, they had tempted fate too much, and it had taken Balin’s life, much as it had apparently intended to.
“Balin son of Fundin was always meant to rest in the stone halls of Moria. As were two others of your company, one of whom was with you.” His head snapped up. “I can assure you that fate was altered enough that Dwalin was only dealt one loss, and not two,” she added, her eyes dark and knowing.
Ori. Ori had been meant to fall in Moria. It made Bilbo want to run and find the dwarf and embrace him, to hold on to him tightly, and to tell Dwalin how lucky he was to have his husband.
Could he even tell them, though? Would he leave them too nervous, too cautious, on the battlefield? Would the very telling of it leave them all hampered and that much more susceptible to falling?
His head ached now, more than ever, at the sheer weight that had been dropped on him. “All this time,” he murmured. “All this time and we never knew.” Everyone thought he was a great hero, set apart from others, for having had the courage and the gall to carry the One Ring to Mordor. Instead, he’d only been one chance among many. Fate had simply elected him when he’d thrown fate off of its course.
“You can never doubt your importance,” she said firmly, but when she brushed hair from his face, it was done tenderly, like a mother would to a child. No longer did she gaze at him with a solemn face, but with the same gentleness and kindness she had given him so long ago. “The Ring was fated to fall to your hands, but until you changed the course of the future, it was never meant to be you that bore it to Mordor. You did that, Bilbo. You did it when no one else could. And by doing so, you changed the fate and spared the lives of future generations.”
“And the line of Durin,” he said, and she nodded gravely.
“And those you love.”
After long moments of sitting and breathing, his mind running and spinning feverishly, he finally began to stand. She helped him to his feet, but did not let his hand go until he turned to face her. She bent low and placed a kiss to his forehead. “When they went to battle last, many things were different from how they are now. Thorin did not expect a loss that day. His gold lust was too strong to leave him anything except prideful and arrogant.”
It was her telling him to let them know, to share his fears and the truth with them. Not all of it: Dwalin didn’t need to know that Balin and Ori both had been slated for loss, and one other of their company beside, whomever that was. But he could tell them about his dreams, about the mirror, about what she had said.
“Go and rest,” she told him. “And know that tomorrow is always a different day. Every day, you change what will be.”
This was no different, that was all. And Bilbo was going to change it. He’d tell fate he was done with it, and it was going to listen to him. He’d changed the future once, he could do it again. She had left a fire burning in his veins, his fears fueling his desire to see fate hang. He could not fail. He couldn’t.
Still, even as he left, her ominous words rang through his head.
Those who attempt to alter fate’s course often become the hand of fate itself.
Somehow, he found his way back to Thorin’s side, and he spent the rest of his night clinging to his husband, sleep not even a thought in his mind.
