Actions

Work Header

to rule the fate of many

Chapter 25: The future questioned

Summary:

Bilbo shares the truth about fate with the others. Privately, he shares more truths with Thorin about their future and everything he would give for his husband.

Legolas and Kili have a brief respite to themselves.

Notes:

The fic's finished. One small section to write, but beyond it, it's all been written. I want to start posting on a more regular basis, but this weekend is insane. I'm going to try, though! So bear with me.

Y'all continue to be awesome. Thanks for hanging with me: I swear, my favorite part about posting is replying to comments and talking with you guys. :)

Chapter Text

Growing up, Aragorn had often thought himself a pawn on a board, being moved to and fro by the hand of fate and the winds of destiny. He had done everything he could to avoid what was laid out for him from the beginning. He had become a Ranger, had forsaken his name and cursed his bloodline. And yet, in the end, he had been given the throne of Gondor all the same, and he even now carried the blade once broken. Elrond had told him often enough that it was his destiny, his role to play, that he could never truly avoid it. He had a part to play, and it had to be done.

Apparently, he was not the only one whom fate moved about at its whim.

The leaves swayed above them in the breeze, the moving of the foliage and branches the only sound to be heard. Beneath their cover, hiding from the sunlight, stood the company, all in various degrees of shock. Dwalin had too far of a speculative look on his face, as if he knew more of the puzzle than the others, and Bilbo was doing his best to avoid looking at him, keeping his focus on his husband. Thorin appeared stunned, almost helpless, his eyes roaming between Bilbo and his sister-sons, both of whom were sitting together with Éomund and Legolas. Neither knew what to say, but Legolas’s grip in Kili’s tunic was all but leaving him white-knuckled.

They had nearly lost them in Moria, and could possibly lose them all again.

Finally Gandalf stepped forward, taking the pressure off of Bilbo. “That explains a great many things,” he said quietly. “For I knew that the journey to Erebor would result in the ruin of Sauron, yet would also leave much grief in the Lonely Mountain. And while I removed Sauron’s presence from Dol Guldur, I never found the grief that was supposed to reach Erebor. I had assumed, as time went on, that it had been Thorin and Bilbo’s pain over the Arkenstone, but it had never seemed right.”

“You knew?” Ori asked, astounded. “And you didn’t tell us?”

“It was not something I could tell,” Gandalf said, shaking his head. “It was nothing I could say. For to say it was to possibly condemn others to a worse fate. And I did not know for certain,” he hastened to add when Bilbo went pale and Thorin glared at the wizard for it. “When it is only a tendril of thought, more an idea and feeling than a clear image, one does more harm than good by speaking of it. That, I have learned through my many years.”

“Is that why you keep everything a secret?” Fili asked quietly. Aragorn paused at the thought, and a sudden understanding seemed to come to the company. Always did the wizard hold riddles and secrets from them, but they had merely attributed it to him being Gandalf. Yet if past pain and memory had left the wizard that way, it was another matter entirely, and left Aragorn’s heart aching for Gandalf.

“Partially,” Gandalf admitted, before he raised his eyebrows. “And partially to keep you from growing too big a head. Best to always keep you on your toes.”

Now that sounded much more like Gandalf. “You could’ve just said that you enjoy tormenting us and that would’ve been an acceptable answer, too,” Kili muttered. Legolas finally gave a quick grin and pressed a kiss to Kili’s forehead.

“What do we do?” Esmeralda said after a long moment. “What can we do next?”

It certainly changed everything about Erebor. If they attempted to retake the mountain, their lives were already in danger. But now, with fate pressing in against them, the lives of Thorin, Fili, and Kili were even more in peril. “We cannot let you out on the field,” Éomund said. “It can be that easy.”

“That’s if you believe this fate thing in the first place,” Nori said, crossing his arms. “And if they stay behind, what’s to say they won’t meet fate sometime else? Or wind up getting shoved into the battle anyway without meaning to and then wind up defenseless?”

Despite appearing determined enough to box fate about the ears if given the chance, Bilbo still looked as if he wanted to be anywhere but where he was. His hands kept twitching, as if he wanted to cover his ears and not listen for a moment more. Aragorn quickly held his hands up to stop the noise that was beginning to rise. “If there is one thing I have learned through the years, it is that fate cannot be stopped,” he said when they’d gone quiet. “Fate will have its way. But. Fate can be diverted and set aside for a time.”

“So we can, what, die in a different battle?” Kili said incredulously.

“So you can pass to the halls of Mandos when you are old and the throne is in the hands of one who comes after your time,” Gandalf said, and Kili paused. “Fate is not fickle, but it can be dissuaded from its purpose, for a time. If its sole intent is for your lives to be ended, then all it must do is wait. Not even immortals are safe from the end of life, if that life is compromised or taken.”

No one needed to speak to know that they were all thinking of Tauriel in the healing rooms.

Dwalin continued to stand too stiffly, eyes boring into the side of Bilbo’s head, until at last the hobbit turned towards him. “Was Balin supposed to be taken?” he asked, lips tight. “Was Balin’s fate-“

“Please don’t ask me that,” Bilbo pleaded. “Dwalin, don’t.”

It was answer enough. Dwalin turned and left, with Ori hurrying after him. Bilbo pressed a fist to his mouth, face pained. It was clear that he had not been intending to let that information out, if just to spare Dwalin the pain of knowing. Balin’s life was always meant to be lost, then, and most likely lost in Moria.

It didn’t make the truth any less easy to deal with.

“So what do we do?” Bofur asked again, when no one else did. “What can we do?”

After a long moment, Fili stood. “I’m going to Erebor,” he said. Kili made a soft noise, and Fili shook his head. “No, I am, I’m going. If I don’t go, Dernwyn and the children…” He swallowed, but when he raised his head, his gaze was absolute. “I’m going,” he said again, and he looked like a warrior already on the battlefield. He looked like a king. “And if I need to, I’ll stand alone.”

“You won’t,” Thorin said. “I will go with you. Fate may do what it wants with me. But I will not leave my sister, or the children, or my wedded daughter alone. Nor my people.” He looked to Bilbo, and while there was an apology in his gaze, there was also a firm stance that held no wavering in it.

Bilbo finally nodded. “And I’m going with you. I made the difference before, between your living and dying, and I’ll do it again.” Thorin didn’t look particularly thrilled with that knowledge, but Bilbo’s gaze brokered no argument from him.

Slowly they all stood, one by one, until only Kili and Legolas remained. Legolas refused to move until Kili did, but by the way Kili kept moving his gaze from his brother to his uncles, it didn’t seem as if his choice would take long.

Within moments of the thought Kili was on his feet, carefully, with Legolas’s help. “If there’s any way that I can help, I will,” he said. “Galadriel said I’d healed enough to travel. If I can travel, I can do battle.”

“Kee-“

“There may be a way for you to aid without seeing the battlefield,” Aragorn said, cutting Fili’s protest off. “We need the mountain freed. Gandalf?”

“Your ‘dragon’ is coming along splendidly. It will prove a hearty distraction, that’s for certain. It will not last long, however.” The wizard stroked his beard, lost in thought. “You must get inside, and quickly. Someone has to get into the mountain to help free the dwarves within.”

“If we can free the mountain, we can catch Caila between our army and those in Erebor,” Thorin agreed. “She will have no place to go. It will not take a great deal of might to get inside of Erebor, but a great deal of cunning and hiding.” He looked to Bilbo again, and this time, Aragorn knew there would be no dissuading him. “A burglar might be of great use,” he continued.

Bilbo pursed his lips but nodded. “Fine. Kili can help me get into Erebor. Then I’m coming back out to join the battle. Kili can stay inside to help keep the mountain in the hands of the dwarves.”

Kili didn’t look thrilled about it, but with Legolas and Fili both heartily nodding at the idea, there really wasn’t much he could do about it. “I might be able to fire some arrows from above, depending on where the battle is,” he offered, but was met with resounding silence and harsh glares. He let out a huff and leaned into Legolas, scowling at them all. Legolas gave him a consoling pat on the shoulder, and thankfully Kili missed his obvious relief.

“Honestly, Kee,” Fili said, giving his brother the most foul of looks. “You almost died. I’d rather you weren’t out there fighting for your life, thank you very much.”

“Right, because you fighting for yours is any better,” Kili snapped sharply.

“I’m not the one who got stabbed and is trying to get stabbed again!” Fili yelled.

“Enough,” Thorin bellowed, and they both fell silent. It was clear that fear was their motivating drive, and Thorin, too, seemed to sense it. He let out a sigh and hung his head. “Every battle has always held a potential for death. This is no different. There have been a dozen chances for fate to strike at us over the past ten years, and it has not done so. Face this as any other fight.”

“So, what, you’re saying that my dreams, fate, none of it’s real?” Bilbo asked angrily.

Thorin took his husband by the shoulder, his gaze dropping from fierce and kingly to soft and worried. “I’m saying that we cannot let ourselves think it is,” he said, and the fight went out of Bilbo in a single breath. “We will be ever mindful, but if it is our fate to go to our father’s halls, then-“

“Please, just, stop,” Bilbo said, his voice trembling. He took a breath, then another, then finally squared his shoulders. “We can believe that, all right. Just…don’t push what I’ve seen aside.”

“Believe me, none of us will,” Thorin assured him. “And I am glad you told us. I only wish you hadn’t had to suffer the nightmares for so long.”

“If they come true, does that make Bilbo prophetic? Can you tell me if I’ll ever get a beard?” Kili asked, and Fili finally turned and smacked him on the arm for it. Kili gave him a grin, and Fili seemed hard pressed to not return it. Gandalf rolled his eyes and huffed something about ‘dwarves’, but the tension amongst them was broken. Even Bilbo was giving Kili an exasperated look, his lips turning up against his will.

“We’ll be all right,” Thorin said. It was truly an empty promise, but Aragorn could see Bilbo clinging to it as the high hope that it was. “I swear to you, it will only have been a terrible dream.”

“And I’ll be right there beside you,” Bilbo told him. “I won’t leave.”

That, Aragorn knew he couldn’t promise either. For if fate could not have the one it wanted, it would just as easily take another life.

And if it could not take Thorin, what was to say that it would not take Bilbo?

His dark thoughts he kept to himself as he, Thorin, Bilbo, Fili, and Gandalf left to find Haldir and go over potential battle plans. Every move, now more than ever, could make the difference between life and death.

 

Lorien had left him feeling peaceful, ten years ago. Even as he’d worried about Bilbo and Uncle and the gold lust, Kili had felt a peace in the forest he’d never expected. It had been with elves, for crying out loud! But he’d still found it.

Then again, his greatest peace was with his husband, his elf. He shouldn’t have been surprised.

He was back in bed, not because he particularly thought he needed it, but because everyone had all but begged him to rest while he could. They were leaving in a few hours, and the ride would be hard on his tired body. Not that Kili particularly cared. No, all he could think about was Erebor and his mother, Dernwyn, and his little niece and nephew, all trapped inside under Caila’s hand. He wished he could’ve struck her when he’d had the chance.

He hadn’t exactly had a chance. He’d barely had enough time to get in front of Bilbo, a choice he would never regret. But if there was one thing he wished he could’ve done in Moria, it would’ve been to strike Caila down.

From behind him, Legolas pulled him closer, and Kili went with no fuss. After having had Legolas beside him but somehow still so far away, he felt greedy, desperate for more. He twined his hand with Legolas’s nearly over the wound. It didn’t hurt as much, now. Whatever the elves had done had left him able to breathe, to walk. He vaguely remembered Galadriel and Gandalf hovering above him, each as bright as the sun, and when he’d awakened, he’d felt more alive than ever before.

And then he’d tried to sit up, and that had sort of ruined the glow. Still, he’d been able to get his feet beneath him, and that was all he cared about. That, and finding Legolas and Fili and Bilbo. That had probably mattered more than his own health. Seeing his uncle alive and whole, when all Kili could remember was pain and Bilbo’s too pale face above him, had been a balm on his soul. Fili breathing and Legolas standing beside him had helped, too.

Then the news about Tauriel and Bard, of Erebor, had dropped on him, outweighing the pure joy of finding them all alive and all right. And it had been so obvious that Legolas had wanted to go with Tauriel that Kili had had to ask.

“You still can,” he found himself saying. “Legolas, if you ever change your mind as I grow older-“

“I’ve made my choice,” Legolas said, his voice gentle but firm. “I will not leave. When you are gone, only then will I take my leave of Arda.” He sounded pained, but he pressed a kiss into Kili’s hair. “Dernwyn phrased it well, in Moria, when we had separated from you and Bilbo. She said that she would rather have one day with Fili, just one day more, than to be parted from him.”

Thinking of his sister hurt. The thought of her in Caila’s hands, much as Kili and Bilbo had been, left his stomach rolling. He knew what she was capable of. He knew how mad she was, what she would do. He could only hope that they would find Dernwyn, Dis, the children, and everyone else still whole.

Legolas pulled him back until he was flush against his husband, his back to Legolas’s chest. “I would rather one lifetime with you than be forced to face all the ages alone,” he whispered. Kili shut his eyes and tightened his grasp.

“That lifetime may be shorter than you think-“

“You will not fall in Erebor,” Legolas said. “I will not let you. You will be in Erebor, protected by a multitude of loyal dwarves, Bofur, Esmeralda, and Bilbo. And you will find Dis and Dernwyn to keep you safe as well. I will keep to Fili and Thorin on the field and watch over them. Fate could not take you ten years ago, it will not take you now.”

Kili took a deep breath in, feeling a slight dull throb from his wound before the pain faded. “Do you believe in fate?” he asked softly. “In what Bilbo said?”

Legolas was silent for some time, enough for Kili to shift so he could tilt his head up towards his husband. His elf didn’t seem puzzled or concerned, simply thoughtful, and Kili inadvertently relaxed. As much as he would’ve hated, loathed, watching Legolas disappear from his life, he would have let him go. Somehow, he’d found the strength to say the words he’d despised most, and had even found the strength to mean them.

Then Legolas had taken his hands and banished his fears, and his world had realigned itself.

Finally Legolas spoke, drawing him from his thoughts. “Fate, to me, means that the world must follow a certain course: birth and death are natural forces, as are good and evil. They are changed by choices, but whether those choices are of our own design or by the hand of fate, I do not know.” He paused before saying, “I believe that the world did change, when Bilbo made his small choice. And I believe that one day, everything is fated to fall away. It is partially what made Sauron an abomination: he did not follow fate’s rule, but rather imposed his over fate.”

“That doesn’t mean Bilbo is wrong, though,” Kili said, and Legolas swiftly shook his head.

“No. You heard what he said: the Ring was always meant to be destroyed, battles we fought were meant to happen, and lives were meant to be lost. Bilbo simply…rearranged the order. Suppressed some events to allow others to happen first. What he has changed, what lives were created, spared, or lost due to his twisting of fate, I do not think we will ever know, fully. But I think, so far, it has done a great amount of good, and left us all in a better place.”

Holdred and Hildili, Kili realized with a start, would never have existed if Bilbo hadn’t done what he did. Or would they have? What of Dernwyn? What of his mother, of Erebor, of Legolas? “My head hurts just thinking about it,” he whimpered, rubbing at his temples.

Legolas chuckled and held him closer. “Then do not think about. Think ahead to a future, where you and I will stand alongside Fili and Thorin, Dernwyn and Bilbo, after we have reclaimed Erebor. You and I will go into Mirkwood and clear it once and for all, claim my father’s hall as our own, and return the Greenwood to its rightful status. We will teach Holdred and Hildili to climb trees as elves and dwarves, and listen to Tauriel tease Gimli when he cannot make it past the bottom branches…”

Kili closed his eyes and listened to the future he wanted, needed, letting himself drift off, safe in Legolas’s arms.

 

“You’re not angry with me, are you?”

For a long moment, Bilbo didn’t answer. The trees and leaves were green all around them, and it was better than looking at Thorin. It almost felt as if he was somewhere else, dealing with other things, rather than standing on the cusp of a war that was being led forward by fate. A war that could take his husband and his nephews in one fell swoop.

“Bilbo,” Thorin murmured, and two hands came up to run down his arms. He still wasn’t allowed to move the shoulder as much as he wanted to, but whatever the elves had used to help heal had done a wonderful job.

And there Bilbo was, trying to think of anything except for the question he didn’t want to answer, because it meant thinking about why the question had been posed. It meant he had to think of Thorin in battle. “I knew you were going to go,” Bilbo said quietly. “I knew that. Of course you were going to go to Erebor. I just…I had to tell you. You needed to know.” He almost regretted telling Kili and Fili, as frightened as they’d been about the idea, but they’d deserved to know. Galadriel had encouraged him to tell them, and so he had. He could only hope he hadn’t made the wrong decision.

Thorin planted a kiss to the top of his head. “If ever there was someone who could help me take back Erebor, it would be you. Knowing you’re inside, safe and away from battle, will let me focus, will keep me fighting.”

Bilbo closed his eyes and just let himself feel. The breeze, the sunlight through the trees, his husband behind him, Thorin’s hands running up and down his arms. It was all he wanted. And soon, they were going to leave it all behind to face Caila and Erebor.

There was so much he had left to say to Thorin, a lifetime of things, and he might not get to say them. He felt his next inhale shake, and he forced it out as steadily as he could. He could say some of them, at least. He could say the ones that mattered the most now, here, in this moment, before they left.

Bilbo turned until he was facing Thorin, still in his embrace. “You know,” he began, “you know, if I hadn’t known about the Ring being what it was, I still wouldn’t have left, after…the Arkenstone.” Thorin looked pained at its mention, causing Bilbo to rush on. “The orcs would have gone to Erebor, and I wouldn’t have left.”

He could see it now: him on the battleground, fighting through a thick swath of orcs, men, and elves, all to get to Thorin. Even before he’d seen it in the mirror, he still knew that was what he would’ve done. He still might have to, when they reached Erebor again. And he wouldn’t run.

“I would’ve stood between you and anyone else,” Bilbo said quietly. “I would’ve defended you with everything I had. I would’ve used my words and my riddles as best as I could to keep you safe, and when they failed me, I would’ve used Sting. And when my blade failed, well.” He met Thorin’s eyes surely, feeling nothing but calm truth in his very being as he spoke one more time. “I would’ve stood between you and any danger until I couldn’t stand anymore.”

“And you wonder why I refuse to let you onto the battlefield,” Thorin rasped, gaze haunted. “I will not see you lost for me.”

“I’m not leaving you,” Bilbo said, voice hushed but still firm. “I refuse. You’ll have to drag me away yourself, and in the end I’d still get what I wanted because then you were away from harm, too.”

Thorin looked as if Bilbo had gutted him. Bilbo caught Thorin’s hands, taking them and pressing them to his own chest. “If you’re not there,” he said softly, “then this won’t beat. You might as well let me stand beside you: the outcome’s just the same. I’ll get inside Erebor, but I’m coming right back out.”

“Please do not do this,” Thorin begged. “The thought of you in battle strikes terror into my heart that not even the Black Gates of Mordor could put there.” He began to speak again, then stopped, swallowing roughly. “You are my heart,” he said, his voice wrecked. “It is I who must stand between you and danger. Legolas is not the only one who will fall if his husband does.”

It seemed they would always come back to this thought, of protecting one another, but where it had once left him annoyed it now left him comforted and determined to stand by his husband. “I will do the same for you, every time,” Bilbo replied. He would do it now, too, could do it. Had done it, even, and even as his heart ached at the thought of having taken a life without pause, the thought of losing Thorin all but made his soul scream. Gandalf had once told him that true courage came not from taking a life, but knowing when to spare one.

He’d known not to spare Rutar. Not a second time, when his husband’s life had been on the line.

Thorin rested his forehead against Bilbo’s, the well-known gesture a comfort. “Know that I will stand between you and any danger,” Thorin swore. “You are my Bilbo, my beloved.”

His husband, his brave and powerful and adoring Thorin. Bilbo didn’t speak again to offer the same promise. It hung between them, unspoken but still there. He would follow Thorin into battle, and if it came down to it, he would stand between Thorin and any danger. He would’ve done it ten years ago, and he would do it now. Even if it cost him his own life.

Bilbo couldn’t think of a better way to finish his life. Sixty years was young, barely over half of his life lived, but he’d lived more than any other hobbit had already. He had a husband, nephews, a grand niece and nephew, a sister, and that was simply by his marriage. The dwarves he knew he counted as kin, now, as much as he did Legolas, Tauriel, and Dernwyn.

If it came to it, he would die for them. And he would die readily.

As if sensing his thoughts, Thorin pulled him in impossibly closer until their noses brushed. Bilbo let all his focus move to his distraught husband. There were no words of comfort he could give: they’d all be lies, and Bilbo wasn’t prone to lying to Thorin. He sat in silence, instead, holding on to his husband and sharing breaths with him.

That was how Dwalin found them, much later, still pressed nose to nose, clinging to one another. The dwarf cleared his throat, and as one they turned to him. “We’re ready,” Dwalin said, almost reluctantly.

It took Thorin a moment to find his voice. “Then we ride,” he said, his voice shredded as if he’d been weeping. Perhaps he had and Bilbo hadn’t noticed. He squeezed Thorin’s hand and felt a firm grasp in return.

“To Erebor,” Bilbo said, and Thorin gave a low nod.

“To Erebor.”

 

It was a large group that set forth from Lorien that day. Haldir led the elves on their horses, riding out into the plains. Horses went also to the company, who rode in a tight formation, fearing the future without those around them and not daring to voice such fears out loud. Éomund sent a raven flying east, in the hopes of sending word to the riding Rohirrim of what had transpired. Another raven was sent to Edoras, to tell the people of Rohan of potential danger at their borders. Who knew how the mind of a madwoman worked? For if she had taken Dale and Erebor, she could just as easily strike out again elsewhere.

From the forests of Lorien, Tauriel watched them go, solemn and still. Galadriel stood beside her, seeing so much more than the other elf ever could. Fate continued to weave a new fabric, strands pulling this way and that, all to tie into the lives of those who rode now for Erebor. Bilbo had torn it all asunder ten years ago, had demanded his own crafting, and fate had given in.

Now, however, fate might not be denied. For it had a purpose, a plan, a design, and even the strong will of Bilbo Baggins, Ringbearer, might not be enough to change it again.

“Can you see, what will happen?” Tauriel finally dared to ask. “When they pass beyond our vision?”

Galadriel kept her eyes on the travelers. “No,” she said at last. “I cannot. Fate can be set aside only so many times.” And she feared that there would be no holding back what fate would do this time.

Would that they remained safe, if just for the sake of her small, dear friend. For even if they fell and Bilbo did not, she feared it would be the end of the little hobbit, all the same.