Chapter Text
Among the Khuzd there was a belief that, in one way or another, each of them had the One – but to meet someone meant for them was a rare stroke of fortune. Many never found a mate at all, not because they waited in blind faith for such a meeting, but simply because life unfolded that way. Those who did kindle their own hearth often shared it not with their One, but with someone who seemed the most worthy choice. No dwarf devoted their life to a futile search for a “true match” – the children of Mahal were practical, self-reliant folk who forged their own happiness instead of waiting for alms from a fickle fate.
Thorin had always believed the One to be a middling fairy tale for idle minds – those who could not find a real purpose or calling. Dís shared that view and bound herself in marriage to a skilled warrior and master smith of no great lineage, for whom she felt no passion, yet whom she respected without measure. There was great warmth between them, and in that hearth, for as long as Oakenshield could remember, trust and harmony had reigned. Choosing a partner by such measures was simpler and far more comprehensible than chasing a mythical, true love.
He was one hundred and ninety-five years old – a considerable age for a dwarf. All those decades he had lived unpaired, and only once, in early youth, had he wondered what that mythical One might be like, what he would wish that dwarf to be. He had never kept a mental list of “could I ever have imagined that…”, because he had always known, at least roughly, what he wanted and what to expect. But now, standing beside the bed and looking at Bilbo – his small body swathed in strips of linen – there was a first entry on that list:
“…that I would meet Him?”
And that he would understand it far too late.
Thorin never counted himself among the most perceptive of dwarves, especially where feelings were concerned – his own included, all the more so those he had only ever heard of from others. Still, he had not thought that such a realization would reach Balin, or Bofur, or any other of his brothers before it reached him. He was angry at himself for being so deaf and blind to the signs, and at the others for not seeing fit to spell them out for him. “We didn’t want to interfere, and then you were not yourself.” Balin had clearly misunderstood the duties of a king’s counselor.
When they finally sat down for a thorough conversation about everything that had happened during Azog’s attack and after, Bilbo inevitably came up. Thorin himself remembered little beyond the moment he lost consciousness, having failed to shove the Burglar off him before the orc’s mace met Bilbo’s back. The hobbit, in a desperate attempt to save the King under the Mountain, had shielded him with his own body, likely trusting in the protective virtues of mithril. But even mithril could not guarantee the absence of serious injury beneath the mail, and the blow that struck Baggins’s back was so fierce it left one massive, dark bruise from shoulder to hip. Worse still, no one could say for certain how deep the damage went or whether any organs had been affected – though Tharkûn assured Oakenshield that all would be well.
In Thranduil’s tented camp at Dale, the Wood-elves’ finest healers worked long and painstakingly over the hobbit. After several days, Thorin – who had been put back on his feet himself, though he was far from fully recovered – insisted on being allowed to move Bilbo into one of Erebor’s chambers. There Óin could watch over him, having helped care for both King and Burglar all this while. Gandalf, too, had promised to visit from time to time, to check on one reckless hobbit and lend whatever aid was needed.
Balin told Thorin of Bilbo’s vision, and of how the Battle of Erebor had ended in victory for the allied host of dwarves, elves, and men not least because of him.
The King stepped away from the head of the bed and sank heavily into a wooden chair. The movement sent a sharper throb through his right shoulder and left hip than usual – the battle refused to be forgotten.
“Mahal…” Oakenshield would not ask the Maker what he had done to deserve this; he could list a long chain of reasons himself, with his madness over the Arkenstone leading them all. The memory of his state during that final month in Erebor sent a flush of heat through him. He had forfeited the right to lead his people when greed and avarice outweighed his honor – and the lives of his brothers-in-arms, the lives of his own nephews. Dís would never forgive him for that. And there was no certainty she ever would, once she learned everything. He would not forgive himself – and had no intention of trying.
But what had Bilbo done to deserve this?
Twice he had saved Thorin’s life, and in return had nearly lost his own twice because of Thorin himself. An ugly, unjust balance. And there was nothing Thorin could do, yet the hobbit had mended an entire future for his sake. During their talk, Balin had held something back, but under the weight of Thorin’s gaze and a few pointed questions, he yielded and told him the rest: Bilbo’s vision had foretold three deaths – the one of Oakenshield, and those of his nephews. Thorin had been struck speechless, scant gift though his words already were.
They had agreed to carry that knowledge to the grave, yet Oakenshield could not stop thinking of it. Bilbo had run headlong through a blood-soaked chaos where he could have been killed outright, all for a single, slender chance to help save an ungrateful King under the Mountain. The only payment Thorin could offer the small hobbit was his own life, given wholly and without reserve. But what use would that be to Bilbo, after all Thorin had put him through? A paltry price for deeds beyond measure.
And yet he would try – try to use the chance he still had to show the hobbit just how much he meant to him. Dwarves were the smiths of their own fate; surrender was not in their blood. And Oakenshield, late though it was, would fight for Him to the very end.
His eyes burned with exhaustion. Thorin allowed himself to lean back against the high, carved chair and slipped into a restless doze.
☜ ☞
Bilbo was studying the tray with keen interest. It had been brought to him not long ago by Bombur, who had been beaming with joy. The choice fell on mushroom soup, and the hobbit carefully took the spoon in his left hand to taste it. Two weeks had passed since the battle ended, and a week since he had woken. His body ached all over, and every movement still came with effort – but for food… for food, he was willing to endure far worse.
He managed to scoop up a little broth and bring the first spoonful to his mouth.
Wonderful. Bombur truly knew his way around a kitchen.
The large chamber where he lay was unusually quiet. Unusual because from the very day he had regained consciousness until now, the dwarves had scarcely left him alone. There had always been one, two, or more visitors at a time, peppering the pale hobbit with questions and regaling him with stories of their own. Fili and Kili came especially often – restless as ever, and though the latter looked nearly as battered as Baggins himself, his energy was boundless. Bombur came bearing food, and Óin with bandages and medicines.
Bilbo finished the soup and glanced at the meat pies, but decided to pause: his back had begun to throb mercilessly. He slowly eased himself back against the pillow and closed his eyes with a small, contented sigh – the hot broth spread a pleasant warmth through him. His thoughts drifted lazily, tangled with memories of the past few days.
One of the last of the group to visit him was Balin, who had finally managed to break free from the staggering number of duties that had fallen on him after the battle. The road to restoring Erebor would be long and difficult, and part of that burden rested on his shoulders. He asked a few polite questions about Bilbo’s health and, nodding with satisfaction at the answers, took a seat beside the bed.
Bilbo felt a strong urge to ask about Thorin.
Oakenshield was the only one who had not come to see him even once since he woke, and the absence was beginning to weigh on him. Sensible explanations came to mind, along with far less pleasant ones. The King under the Mountain surely had far more on his plate than Balin – his absence could easily be put down to sheer busyness. But still…
“Balin,” Bilbo ventured, “have you had the Arkenstone returned?”
He would rather not have asked questions whose answers he dreaded, but the prickling curiosity got the better of him.
“Yes. Thorin paid the men the gold he promised, and Thranduil – after some hesitation on Thorin’s part, hehe – received his gems. So the bargain they proposed was honored.”
Balin noticed how Bilbo tensed, lips pressed thin. He understood perfectly why the hobbit was asking.
“Bilbo, Thorin has changed. I don’t think the Dragon-sickness will ever take hold of him again.”
Bilbo looked at him sadly and shook his head.
“You can’t know that. Last time, no one could have guessed what the treasure of Erebor – and that… stone – would do to him.”
Balin laid his hand over Bilbo’s.
“Last time, he was not so angry with himself. The Arkenstone consumed his thoughts and his heart – but believe me, now they are occupied with something else.”
There was something strange in Balin’s look and tone, as though he were hinting at more. He withdrew his hand and nodded toward the mail shirt neatly folded on the bedside table.
“Did you know mithril is an exceedingly valuable material? That coat is worth a kingdom.”
Bilbo eyed the armor doubtfully. He had assumed that anything from Erebor’s hoard was costly – but that costly? And Thorin had given it to him even while under the sway of the sickness?
“At the time Thorin gave it to you,” Balin added, “it was one of the most valuable thing he owned. The Arkenstone had not yet been found.”
Bilbo was beginning to sense where Balin was steering the conversation, but he could not bring himself to believe it.
“Balin… why did he give it to me? And why that?” He was not sure how best to phrase the question to test his suspicion, so he asked both at once.
“Oh, Bilbo,” Balin said, looking at him as of he were a child who simply could not grasp what was being explained, “you and Thorin are so blind it’s a wonder you noticed each other at all. Don’t interrupt, if you please.”
Bilbo had been about to protest the remark about blindness, but fell silent.
“Of course, you couldn’t have known what importance gifts hold among dwarves. Someone should have explained it to you–” (and it certainly ought to have been Thorin), “–for gift-giving is an entire rite, part of our ancient tradition…”
Balin tilted his head and hesitated. He was unsure whether he ought to say this himself, but there was no hope of Thorin doing so. The King could barely make sense of his own feelings to the very end, and explaining anything to Bilbo would never have occurred to him – even in ten years’ time.
“…of courtship,” the grey-bearded dwarf finished, lifting his brows and casting the hobbit a sly, mischievous glance.
“Uh… er–no, no, absolutely not,” Bilbo blurted.
While Balin struggled to keep his laughter buried in his beard, the hobbit went through every stage of accepting the information. He made incoherent sounds and flushed furiously, trying to form at least a single thought – with very little success. He drew his brows together so tightly that the muscles of his face began to ache.
At that moment, the door gave a plaintive thump as it opened – Óin had arrived for another check-up and a fresh dose of medicine. Balin hastily took his leave, leaving the healer puzzled by his muffled chuckling. Óin shrugged and went to Bilbo, but when he saw the hobbit’s crimson ears and cheeks, and the way he was gulping air, he broke into alarmed muttering.
“Mahal, Bilbo, are you unwell? What happened? Balin! Not a minute’s peace for our Burglar! I’ll lock him up until he’s fully recovered – orcs be cursed, I swear it!”
☜ ☞
Bilbo opened his eyes and felt well enough to turn his attention back to the tempting pies. While he had been lost in memories of a conversation that had taken place a couple of days ago, they had, to his regret, cooled a little. Balin had also mentioned then that it was Thorin who had insisted on moving the hobbit to Erebor – and into his former chambers at that – and that he had scarcely left Bilbo’s side right up until his awakening. To Bilbo’s very reasonable question, “Then why hasn’t he come to see me now, considering… er-everything you just said?” Balin had had no answer.
Bilbo hadn’t pressed him. Trying to make sense of what went on in Thorin’s head was a difficult business at the best of times. Often it was easier to feel the shifts in his mood than to guess the course of his thoughts. The hobbit was just reaching for his fourth pastry when the faint creak of the door reached his ears. Usually, any of the dwarves burst into the room with little ceremony, flinging the door wide open – sometimes with a foot, sometimes with a belly – so Bilbo tensed. Sneaking about was not their way.
Thorin appeared in the doorway.
Bilbo watched with undisguised interest as the dwarf, seemingly unaware of him, tried not to make a sound and closed the door almost as quietly as he had opened it. As far as Bilbo could recall, the King was the only one of their company – aside from their Burglar, of course – capable of moving nearly without a sound.
It seemed Oakenshield was quite certain he would not find Bilbo awake. When he turned toward the bed and met Baggins’s wide, intent stare, Thorin froze in a moment of uncharacteristic hesitation, then quickly pulled himself together.
“I see Bombur is taking excellent care of your meals, Mr. Baggins,” he stepped closer to the bed, but did not hurry to sit.
Great Eru, Bilbo thought, is my name some sort of insult to him?
“I understand that meals are of far greater importance to hobbits than to us. I won’t disturb you.”
Oh, look at him – so tactful. He might have remembered his manners when he tried to throw me off a battlement.
“And that is precisely why, Mr. Oakenshield, all of you managed to strip my pantries at Bag End bare in record time,” Bilbo replied, irritation creeping into his voice.
Thorin laughed outright; the “joke” clearly amused him, though Bilbo had meant every word.
“I’m glad to see you’re recovering.”
An awkward silence settled over the room. The King made no move to break it.
“Are you going to keep imitating an oak tree, Thorin?” Bilbo asked.
At the sound of his name, the veil of brooding slipped from Thorin’s face, and he finally took the chair beside the bed.
Bilbo felt a sudden surge of nerves and began to fidget with the edge of the blanket. Unhelpful fragments of his conversation with Balin came creeping back – particularly the part where courtship among dwarves had been mentioned so casually. Bilbo still could not believe such nonsense. Why would Thorin, with his rank and position, need a simple burglar? He had never given the slightest sign that he felt anything of the sort for Bilbo. And yet Balin had been so utterly convinced that Baggins, his head spinning with all this new information, had begun to doubt his own conclusions.
Which unsettled him more than he cared to admit – because the thought that he might mean that much to Thorin was… pleasant. Oakenshield mattered to him. But he did not want to comfort himself with illusions that the strange feeling was returned.
“Bilbo…”
He surfaced from his thoughts and looked up at the speaker. There was more silver in Thorin’s jet-black hair now, threaded through the intricate braids. He was looking at Bilbo as though preparing to leap headfirst into deep water. A chill ran down the hobbit’s spine. There was a flicker of something almost unhinged in those eyes – something Bilbo would have preferred not to notice.
Thorin cleared his throat.
“Bilbo… forgive me.”
Having said that, Oakenshield abruptly turned his head away and developed an intense interest in the carpet.
Is he… afraid? Of my reaction?
Bilbo continued to stare at the dwarf, drawn tight as a bowstring.
“Thorin, I don’t hold it against you – though I probably should, considering you very nearly pitched me headfirst off a massive wall.”
Thorin winced. Good. He remembered. And regretted it.
“You weren’t yourself,” Bilbo went on. Seeing that his words had done little to ease the tension, he tried again. “I’m just glad it all ended the way it did. That you’re all alive. That you’re alive, Thorin.”
Oakenshield stopped studying the floor and slipped a hand into his pocket. Feeling for something, he carefully drew out some object and enclosed it in his palms. Bilbo didn’t catch what it was. Thorin looked at him again.
“I am deeply sorry, Bilbo. I was blinded, and I put all of you – put you – in danger time and again,” the effort it cost him was clear; every word was steeped in bitterness and regret,“Forgive me for what I did at the gate.”
By the end of the sentence, he looked darker than an autumn sky. It hurt Bilbo to see him like this, especially now, when – at least he wanted to believe – the worst lay behind them. But no words came. Thorin took the silence in his own way and pressed on, turning the knife on himself.
“I do not deserve the forgiveness I ask for. Nor can I ever truly repay you for all that you have done for me… for us. But I will do everything in my power so that, at the very least, we may part as… friends.”
Bilbo stared blankly at the faltering dwarf.
Friends? Balin, you old rascal, what on earth did you see here?
His gaze drifted, unbidden, to the gleam of the mithril coat in the firelight, and his heart sank. Thorin followed his look and stiffened.
“I never meant to offend you with that… gift,” he said, once again drawing his own conclusions.
Bilbo’s temper finally snapped. Why were dwarves so difficult? Why was Thorin so difficult? Everything was riddles and half-hints, as though the only thing they could do directly was cleave someone in two with an axe.
“And what exactly did you mean by that gift, Thorin?” Bilbo shot back. “Balin told me one could buy the entire Shire with it, if one wished. And I made it perfectly clear back then that I am not a warrior and have no need of armor. Were you trying to buy me? So I’d help you find out who stole your precious Arkenstone?”
He was ashamed of his outburst. He hadn’t wanted to lash out at Oakenshield – but all the evasions, the slippery hints, combined with his bone-deep exhaustion, had done their work. The thought had crossed his mind more than once that Thorin had simply been bribing him, and that there had been no talk of some “courtship” at all. Balin’s words, however, had been so convincing, so tempting, that Bilbo had allowed himself to believe them, just a little.
He shouldn’t have. Balin had clearly been mistaken.
Thorin looked stunned by the sudden shift in Bilbo’s mood. The hobbit muttered a brief, “Sorry,” and scraped his fingernail against the tray.
“What else did Balin tell you?”
Bilbo narrowed his eyes but chose not to answer. He had already said far too much.
“Bilbo, please look at me.”
Reluctantly, Baggins abandoned his fascinating task and raised his eyes. The anger drained away at once, leaving only regret and a heavy sadness.
“I was not trying to buy your friendship,” Thorin said quietly. “I wanted to protect you. And… I wanted to show how important you are to me.”
Bilbo’s heart began to pound, a tremor running through him. Thorin’s voice dropped to a near-whisper.
“You have every right to doubt my sincerity – for obvious reasons. But I would do the same again.”
Only then did Bilbo notice the dark circles beneath Thorin’s eyes; thr looked utterly exhausted. Oakenshield opened his hands and took hold of the ends of a simple bronze chain, from which hung a small pendant.
Bilbo’s mouth fell open.
He would not have been surprised even by the Arkenstone itself – but an acorn, a simple little wooden acorn capped with bronze on a chain, struck him straight to the heart. Something inside him gave way, and Bilbo began to cry, silently.
Thorin panicked and sprang to his feet, gently gripping Bilbo’s shoulders.
“Bilbo, what’s wrong? Are you unwell? Should I fetch Óin?”
A lump rose in Bilbo’s throat, stealing all words from him. Ignoring the ache in his back and arms, he pulled Thorin toward him and hugged him, burying his face in the dwarf’s chest. Oakenshield stiffened at first, then awkwardly sat down on the bed beside him and carefully wrapped his arms around the sobbing hobbit. He had expected many things – this was not one of them.
Bilbo shifted, and Thorin loosened his hold. Pulling back a little, the hobbit fished a handkerchief from beneath the pillow and wiped his face, though the tears still would not stop.
“Thorin, you are such an… Oakenshield.”
Thorin broke into a soft smile.
“You have no idea how much this means to me,” Bilbo said more quietly, looking at the pendant.
Thorin shook his head, smile never fading. He leaned in until their foreheads touched.
“Bilbo,” he murmured, “it is you who has no idea how much You mean to me.”
