Chapter Text
In the beginning was a Song. Unfathomably fair, it lit the darkness of the primeval Nothing, bearing visions of a new world within its radiant harmonies. Though yet crude and imperfect, it veiled the Void in a mosaic of colored glass, aglow with the Secret Fire, kindled in its lifeless heart. Thus was Eä brought into being.
Bilbo Baggins, then still of unimpeached reputation as a respectable hobbit of a proper family, knew this tale quite well. His mother, Belladonna Baggins (maiden name, may Eru forbid he ever recall it, Took), would often recount to little Bilbo, along with other fabled stories, the saga of the world’s creation by Ilúvatar and the Ainur – the Valar – of the great music and the forms of Eä awakening therein, and of all that lives and moves, and all that does not. Such tales were rare among hobbits, and so all the more enchanting to Bilbo. At such times he would clamber into the rocking-chair by the hearth at the heart of the Smial, and to the soft crackle of logs and the soothing, melodious voice of his mother, he would journey, as if in waking dream, to the most marvelous and uncharted lands.
By the sixth decade of his years, the sedate master of Bag End had long since let such tales slip from mind. He had come to resemble old Bungo, his father, a hobbit so thoroughly rooted in propriety it seemed as though imagination had been banished from his very bones. All of Bilbo’s being was henceforth given to the proper concerns of a respectable Shire-dweller: neatness, the garden, good food, and fine tobacco; all manner of whimsy and oddity seemed foreign and unwelcome.
Yet, on the twenty-sixth day of April in the year 2941 of the Third Age,[1] in the fifty-first year of his rather uneventful life, the world of poor Baggins was destined to turn upside down, and never to go back.
☜ ☞
Disoriented, the hobbit found himself sitting on his own bed in his own house, yet somehow feeling entirely out of place. Not that he was unaccustomed to a lively gathering with ample cheer – such affairs were held in the Shire, and specifically at Bag End, with enviable frequency. No, for these he had always been ready, as a gracious host of a fine hobbit-hole with its well-stocked pantries ought to be. But never before had he encountered such boorishness and utter lack of tact from those with whom he shared a meal, and today’s company plunged him into a cultural shock most profound. Not to mention the shock he felt upon receiving their most generous offer.
The hobbit sighed heavily and rested his head against the wooden post of the bed. His new – unwelcome – acquaintances, in the form of an entire herd of dwarves (he could think of no other word for such a gathering), had fallen silent by the hearth in the sitting-room. At last. The clamor, the shouting, and the racket would suffice for the remainder of his days. Bilbo longed desperately to sink into the starched sheets, to wrap himself in his snug quilt, and to surrender to the sleep that promised oblivion from the dreadful memories of this day – but sleep would not come. And then he began to sing.
Thorin Oakenshield, leader of the entire company, so introduced by Gandalf (that thrice-cursed old codger, may his staff betray him), stood by the fireplace with his pipe, leaning slightly upon it. In his bottomless eyes, the color of strong Harad coffee[2] – which Bilbo so dearly loved – tiny sparks danced, yet his gaze was not upon the flames, but far, far away, beyond the borders of the Shire. His companions had settled nearby and, too, were lost in deep thought, each upon matters of their own.
Indeed, the minds of all the dwarves without exception now hovered over the heights of their abandoned home, their once-great kingdom, their Lonely Mountain. A sombre silence thickened. Words were needless, and the heavy grief pressing upon their hearts found its sole release – in song. And Thorin sang.
“Aifal ainad-Khishbanâd khel
Aitumundûm kagamilfêl…"[3]
In the spacious room, a velvet baritone spread itself like a warm wind. A song full of anxiety and hope, of homeland and exile, of hardships yet to come and of the long road ahead, swept away the gathered darkness and wrapped itself around the heart of every dwarf present. Soon, other voices joined the king-in-exile, firm and deep, lending their strength to the impromptu chorus.
Thorin Oakenshield’s commanding voice, standing out amid the ensemble, held a certain spell. Though individual words were harsh and blunt, the phrases they formed rang with a strange, haunting melody. Bilbo made no attempt to grasp the meaning of the song as it flowed in mighty, surging waves – he simply could not, for he did not know Khuzdul (or so he guessed it must be) – yet it carried him along, drawing him somewhere far beyond the room.
Bilbo was struck still. At first meeting, he had judged this so-called king (and the rest of his shambolic phalanx, for that matter) to be a pompous, unbearable peacock of a fellow – someone he would never willingly deal with. Yet in Oakenshield’s enveloping voice, the hobbit suddenly felt an almost desperate longing to sink and be carried away. The unexpected stirrings of his heart aroused a flicker of indignation, urging him to rise and retreat to the farthest corner of the house – but instead, almost without noticing, Bilbo moved to stand alongside Gandalf, who exhaled curling puffs of smoke and listened, enchanted, from the doorway between the bedroom and the sitting-room.
And then it happened for the first time. Bilbo’s mind drifted, untethered, upon the waves of the alluring melody, when, suddenly, it seemed as though he began to understand the words of the sorrowful dwarvish song.
“…we must away, ere break of day…”[4]
But worse still, in the dancing flames of the hearth, indistinct shapes began to take form. The hobbit stared, dumbfounded, into the fire. For a brief, fleeting moment, he thought he could make out the outlines… of himself. Himself, and dwarves suspiciously familiar, riding ponies along a winding path somewhere on the very edge of hobbit-land.
☜ ☞
Bilbo, still standing frozen in the doorway, let out a ragged breath. He recovered from the fiery haze as quickly and imperceptibly as he had fallen into it – or so it seemed. Apparently, it was only seeming: the keen eyes of the wizard, fixed upon him, suggested otherwise. By now the song had faded, the dwarves were beginning to wander about the hole in search of a rest, and Bilbo too had intended to slip away through the doorway, flouting all rules of courtesy and hospitality (he no longer cared where that wild, bearded chew-crew would drop their great hulking bodies). But his plans were halted by a firm hand resting upon his shoulder. Gandalf leaned down toward the hobbit’s face.
“Bilbo, are you all right?” he asked. “You look even more frightened and flustered than when you first heard of the dragon.”
The hobbit shivered under Gandalf’s piercing gaze and averted his eyes. He did not fully understand what had just occurred and was unwilling to admit that he might have imagined something – not to Gandalf, and certainly not even to himself. He was a Baggins, and Bagginses did not suffer such...
“I’m quite all right,” he said. “Aside from all the bad, unpleasant, and most vexing things I’ve had to endure today, thanks to you. Now, if you please, I’d like to go to bed and forget this evening as if it were some dreadful dream.”
Gandalf chuckled, a glint of mischief dancing in his eyes. He thought to himself that the hobbit might well outmatch any dwarf in grumpiness and obstinate stubbornness, so that it remained unclear which of them would prove the more disagreeable. Aloud, he said nothing, and, sighing heavily, withdrew his hand from Bilbo’s shoulder.
The wizard wiped thr pipe and slipped it into the deep pocket of his long grey cloak, all the while continuing to watch the hobbit from beneath his bushy brows.
“You seem to have changed greatly since our last meeting, Bilbo,” Gandalf said, sensing that the annoyed hobbit was about to protest. Hastily, he added, “But has your true nature changed? Before you sleep, I ask only that you give the offer one last, careful thought. We set out at first light, and it would please us greatly to have you among us.”
Bilbo said nothing, though his mind was already made up (and, of course, not in favor of some inept… hike), and trudged wearily back to his bedroom.
“Thank Eru, that mess is over” – the last coherent thought of Mr. Baggins, already drifting off, before the inevitable and irresistible
Took.
Notes:
[1]Here and further, I resort to the chronology of events taken from here (translator needed): http://www.kulichki.com/tolkien/arhiv/manuscr/elentirm.shtml[return to text]
[2]About hobbits, the state of Harad, and coffee in Middle-earth, you can read here (translator needed): https://coffeetea.ru/2017/08/15/25901/?ysclid=lcq6vtazs8770005946 [return to text]
[3]“Far over the misty mountains cold // To dungeons deep and caverns old…” (original text by J.R.R. Tolkien). This famous dwarven song – called “Far Over the Misty Mountains Cold” – is presented here both in English and in Khuzdul (translation by A. Bazarov). More about the translation of the song into the Dwarven language can be found here (for the file, a translator will also be needed, but there is a direct comparison of the texts in English and Khuzdul): https://drive.proton.me/urls/6AYEKSMW6M#y9VIN8iqk0qv [return to text]
[4]“Far Over the Misty Mountains Cold”. [return to text]
Chapter Text
The next morning Bilbo could not settle down. The emptied hobbit-hole suddenly felt uncomfortable and strange, and he paced anxiously back and forth across the hall. Something was gnawing at him, yet it stubbornly refused to take a clear shape. As he hurried past the small table in the entrance once again, the papers lying on it slid to the floor. Bilbo bent to pick them up and noticed the burglar’s contract, half unfolded. Frowning, he stared at his own name and the space left for a signature. Then he went to fetch a pen. To his surprise, the unease began to fade.
He never managed to explain to himself why he ran out of the Bag End with such a light heart, skipping along without even finishing his second breakfast, forgetting to take nearly everything that could possibly be forgotten, and hurrying to catch up with the company of dwarves who had set out on the road long before the hobbit had woken. Somehow, it simply felt right.
When he caught up with them, the dwarves accepted him into their ranks without much surprise, as if Bilbo’s belated appearance had been agreed upon from the very beginning. Gandalf, the grey-bearded Balin, and a few other members of the small company whose names Bilbo had not yet properly learned smiled at him kindly and with approval. The rest showed partial or complete indifference. Their haughty leader gave him the same brief but sharp, appraising look he had received upon their first meeting, sending an unpleasant chill down Baggins’s spine.
“Give our Mr. Burglar a pony,” Thorin said, waving to one of the dwarves who was leading a riderless pony by the reins. He turned away without another word, despite Bilbo’s indignant protest.
By the time the company reached the outskirts of the Shire, Bilbo – who had already grown slightly queasy in the saddle – was staring dully at a single point ahead of him, so as not to demonstrate just how substantial his first and unfinished second breakfasts had been. He decided to distract himself and look around.
The midday sun warmed the land with gentle springtime kindness, softly lighting the houses and clearings of the borderlands. Fourteen ponies and Gandalf’s horse plodded unhurriedly along the neatly paved road leading toward the boundary between the Shire and Bree. The hobbit caught faint scents drifting from the occasional roadside taverns: meat pies and apple tarts. His stomach lurched again.
“Who ever invented riding,” Bilbo muttered, as his pony trailed behind the Bofur’s (that was his name, he thought), “when one has perfectly good legs of one’s own?”
Yet aside from the nausea, another persistent thought would not leave him.
…thawân român udahanu…[5]
He glanced once more at the small company and the surrounding countryside, and suddenly it struck him: he knew what had driven him to join this journey. He did not want to admit it, but Bilbo had seen a similar sight before.
…The fire was red, it flaming spread…[6]
He had seen it in the flickering hearth fire.
☜ ☞
Bilbo strolled through the spacious halls with their high ceilings, adorned with intricate carved patterns. The castle of the Elven-lord Elrond in the hidden valley of Rivendell, where they had been warmly welcomed (not without Gandalf’s help), struck him with its splendour. Built on the edge of a gorge and surrounded by cliffs, valleys, and forest, it seemed to blend seamlessly with nature itself. Baggins stepped out onto a terrace roofed with graceful arches and paused by the railing. It was mid-June, and the air had grown warmer still. The scent of pine, beech, and oak drifting from the woods was lulling and sweet. Bilbo found himself admiring the stone bridges spanning swift streams and the curious fountains scattered here and there. With a contented sigh, he closed his eyes and basked in the rays of the setting sun. It was almost as pleasant here as it was at home – home, to which Bilbo longed to return.
Thoughts of the snug hobbit-hole he had left behind, and of how soon he would have to leave this blessed place as well, cast a shadow over his mood. Within the new company he felt out of place, despite having grown somewhat fond of the dwarves after getting to know them better and sharing their first hardships on the road. Balin’s tale of their battles, of forced wanderings and bitter losses, had touched Bilbo deeply. He still did not think of them as friends, but he had revised his initial, rather unflattering opinion of them.
He had begun to exchange a few words more often with certain members of the company: for instance, with the unbearable and endlessly curious brothers (and Thorin Oakenshield’s nephews) Fili and Kili, who could chatter the entire way, eagerly telling stories from their lives and questioning Bilbo about his own in the Shire. With wise and courteous Balin, who more than any other had supported and encouraged the hobbit from the very beginning. With good-natured and simple Bombur and Bofur, who were always ready to offer help of any kind – even if sometimes in a rather peculiar fashion (Bilbo would long remember his nervous twitch brought on by the sight of the scrap of cloak Bofur had tossed him as a substitute for a forgotten handkerchief). And also with Ori, reserved yet surprisingly perceptive and sensitive for a dwarf, with whom Bilbo had bonded over their shared love of books.
Even so, he continued to sense a certain distrust and chill from their side. Dwarves did not readily admit outsiders into their circle, and earning their favour was, it seemed, no easy task.
The pressure was felt most keenly from Thorin, who appeared to have formed a thoroughly unfavourable opinion of their so-called Burglar from the very start. Well, same here. Bilbo had more than once heard the blunt, rough-edged King under the Mountain mock him to his face and behind his back as being too soft and helpless. After the skirmish with the trolls, the dwarf seemed only to have grown more convinced of this view.
Bilbo let out a weary sigh and buried his face in his hands. He was torn by conflicting desires: on the one hand, he wanted to prove Thorin (and the others) wrong and earn at least a scrap of respect; on the other, an inner voice sneeringly echoed everything Oakenshield said – that a hobbit was unfit for such a quest and would be far better off returning home. What had he been thinking? What madness had possessed him to set out on this wretched journey? He had no need of dwarvish treasure, he was no true friend or companion of the dwarves to care so deeply for their cause, and there was not a single good reason for him to leave his warm, settled life behind. And yet – there he was, because he had taken some foolish sign from the fire.
Bilbo lifted his head and gave a hysterical little laugh. You’d be hard-pressed to find a greater fool than me. Gandalf certainly knew whom to approach. The unpleasant thoughts gave him a headache, and he decided to distract himself with a walk through the garden he had noticed earlier from the terrace.
As he rounded a hedge of fragrant trees, their branches heavy with long clusters of yellow blossoms, a tall fountain came into view in the distance. And in it – dwarves.
Bilbo managed to duck behind a tree before anyone noticed him, but curiosity got the better of him, and he peered out from behind the trunk. He immediately regretted it. Around the fountain, on the neatly trimmed lawn, lay the dwarves’ clothes in chaotic disarray. The dwarves themselves – not all of them, some were missing – stood utterly naked, ankle-deep in water on the lower tier, where they were engaged in playful fistfights. Stern dwarves were behaving like children: roaring with laughter, shouting at one another, shoving, slipping into the water and scrambling back up again, utterly oblivious to the shocked elves unlucky enough to pass by and witness this riot, their sensitive Elvish souls shaken to the core.
The whole scene was ridiculous and amusing, and despite his deep embarrassment, Bilbo smiled. He had never seen his dwarves like this and had not imagined that even these lumps of stone were capable of mischief. The smile faded when a sharp pang of loneliness pierced him. In the Shire, despite the lack of close friends, such feelings were drowned in routine, homely comfort, and frequent noisy dinners. There was simply no time to be idle long enough to sink into melancholy self-examination. Now, listening to the dwarves’ laughter, Bilbo found himself aching for the day when they might at least call out to him kindly, as a good companion. As a… friend?
“Is Mr. Burglar honing his thieving skills?”
Bilbo flinched instinctively at the sound of the insinuating whisper right by his ear. He turned his head and found himself face to face with the looming figure of Thorin, who was grinning maliciously and seemed to take a certain pleasure in tormenting poor Baggins. Sneaking up quietly was, after all, supposed to be the hobbit’s own prerogative – but Bilbo had been so lost in thought that he had heard nothing at all.
Oakenshield was returning from Gandalf and Lord Elrond, with whom he had been arguing heatedly about the plan of the quest. Their raised voices had echoed through the entire castle. Apparently, he had left his dark blue cloak in one of the halls and now walked unencumbered, clad in a blue-black cotton tunic and black leather trousers, with the scabbard of Orcrist tied at his belt. The unexpected sight of a hobbit hiding behind a tree had eased the sour taste left by the discussion and even amused him. The dwarf straightened and stepped back slightly.
“My apologies, Mr. Oakenshield, I must be going,” Bilbo said stiffly and began to retreat. Thorin, watching him from beneath lowered brows, did not reply, only continued to bore into him with those impossibly compelling, cold eyes. No matter how hard the hobbit tried to decipher the thoughts hidden behind them, he could not. Wait – what did he just think?,Compelling? Bilbo grew utterly flustered, his face turning a sickly, earthy shade, and he fled in disgrace. He came to his senses only in one of the far halls of the Elven palace.
☜ ☞
Bilbo was feverish with restless energy. Rivendell had done him good, and when their company slipped away from the Last Homely House in secret, leaving Gandalf to answer for them all (serves him right), Bilbo promised himself not to brood any longer and to keep faith in better days. He began to look for joy in every small thing: Bombur’s hearty cooking, the dwarves’ amusing squabbles in their barking Khuzdul, resting by a warm fire, the gentle rustle of trees, and the pleasant summer weather. He did his best to buoy the spirits of the others and kept himself cheerful – right up until the crossing of the Misty Mountains, where all his bravado plunged into an abyss, one he himself would have fallen into, had Thorin not stopped him.
Oakenshield, standing at the edge of the precipice, then laid into the terrified hobbit more fiercely than the driving rain that had soaked them all to the bone.
“Mahal, akhjamu turmele! Nif!”[7] Thorin grew more and more heated, unable to stem the flow of curses. Bilbo might not have understood the words, but the tone left no room for doubt. A group of concerned dwarves gathered around them, trying to calm their leader.
“We nearly lost our hobbit,” said Bofur, one of the few who had grown genuinely attached to Bilbo – and whose company Baggins was glad of in return – smiling as he breathed a relieved sigh. Thorin shot him an angry glare, and another flare of temper followed at once.
“We should never have taken a halfling with us. He’s been lost ever since he left the bounds of the Shire!”
Bilbo had nothing to say in response. Only recently, similar thoughts had plagued him in the Elven lands. Still, his heart clenched painfully. He understood the reasons for Thorin’s fury: he was afraid of many things, he was nothing like the hardy dwarves, he could not wield weapons, and he truly missed his cozy home. Yet during the journey, a sincere wish had begun to kindle within him – to help them all in any way he could, even if that way was small.
Thorin had never been obliged to save him. Not from the trolls in Eriador, nor now from falling into the chasm between the stone giants. He had refused responsibility for the halfling’s life on the quest, saying so plainly to Gandalf back in Bag End – a remark Bilbo himself had half overheard. Yet the King of the Dwarves had broken his word twice already, and foolish Bilbo, deep down, had hoped in vain that it meant something. He had hoped – only to be mistaken.
The hobbit stared bleakly at the joyless, grim horizon. Just then Dwalin, a stocky dwarf with a noticeable bald patch, called out to the others and shouted something about a cave.
A procession of twelve exhausted, rain-soaked dwarves and one equally sodden and dispirited hobbit made its way in that direction.
Upon inspection, the cave seemed safe enough, and it was decided to make camp there. It was not very large, but it was dry and had several convenient corners. Óin and Glóin wished to light a fire and dry their clothes, and after a brief argument with Thorin, they were given leave to do so.
An hour later, the whole company had settled into places of their choosing. Bofur was left on watch, while the rest half-sat, half-lay on what dry garments they had, basking in the warmth of the newly lit fire. Bilbo took a spot near the entrance, deep in thought. He was drawn from his musings when Balin began to hum softly in his native tongue. The melody was simple but stirring; the grey-bearded dwarf had evidently decided to raise his friends’ spirits.
hâlun dalad-Bundûnu
hâl boru felkanul…[8]
Bilbo noticed the dwarves rouse themselves at once. Even Thorin, brooding in one of the corners of the cave, thawed a little and began to join the uneven chorus of muted voices. Catching the halfling’s attention, he turned toward him and continued to sing the familiar words, fixing him with the piercing gaze of his dark eyes.
…uzbad kibilbazânu
dunakh uzubdûn hûl…[9]
Time seemed to slow. Bilbo stood frozen, unable to break their prolonged eye contact. He thought he glimpsed a flicker of curiosity cross Thorin’s face, but the dwarf soon turned away. For no clear reason, panic began to rise inside Bilbo.
…the streams shall run in gladness,
The lakes shall shine and burn…[10]
Merciful Eru, the words… I understand the words again… Baggins struggled to his feet. He wanted to run. On stiff, unsteady legs, he began to turn toward the exit, and for a fraction of a second the blazing campfire fell into his line of sight. Bilbo stared at it in horror.
…and sorrow fail in sadness
At the Mountain-king‘s return![11]
He had never seen him before. But Balin’s tales and the recent clashes with Orcs were enough for Bilbo to recognize him without error: Azog the Defiler, the slayer of Thorin’s grandfather, King Thrór. A massive white Orc with a terrifying face stared with savage fury at the dwarf’s body lying nearby – a body Bilbo recognized as Thorin’s. A broad Orc-blade was pressed to the throat of the half-conscious king. The Orc holding it began to raise his arm, but before he could strike, Bilbo crashed into him at reckless speed, Sting in his hand.
Bilbo… had saved Thorin?
☜ ☞
Baggins slowly returned to reality. All this time he had been standing with his back to the cave entrance, staring unblinking at the campfire flames and screaming at the top of his lungs. Every single dwarf was gaping at him in stunned silence, not daring to move. Drawn by the shouting, Bofur – who had been keeping watch outside – came running in. He took in the scene at once and, without hesitation, hurried up to the screaming hobbit. The dwarf seized Bilbo by the shoulders and gave him a sharp shake. When Baggins suddenly began to sag, on the verge of fainting, Bifur rushed to help, answering Bofur’s brief “ai-oi!”[12] Together they gently dragged the hobbit closer to the fire and laid him down on one of the jackets.
“Mahal, what in–?” Thorin, who throughout the journey had confined himself to a narrow range of emotions between feigned indifference and stubborn anger, seemed for once to be genuinely – if briefly – astonished. He quickly pulled himself together, rose to his feet, and watched grimly as the other dwarves fussed around the completely unconscious hobbit.
“Bilbo, Bilbo, wake up! Mr. Baggins, what’s wrong with you?” The dwarves crowded around in confusion as the bewildered hobbit slowly began to come to consciousness. Bilbo’s head was splitting. He tried to recall his latest… vision? (or whatever it had been), and a violent shudder ran through his body.
“I don’t understand… I don’t understand anything, anything at all,” he whimpered in a quiet, trembling voice, his glassy eyes fixed somewhere deep within himself.
“Bilbo…” Bofur, sitting beside him, made another worried attempt to find out what had happened, but instead his gaze shifted to the sword hanging at Bilbo’s belt. Something was wrong with it. He patted Bilbo on the shoulder to get his attention, and when he succeeded, pointed at the scabbard. Bilbo peeled his stiff hand away from the jacket he was sitting on and slowly drew the short sword. It was giving off a faint, pale blue glow.
“Rakhâs…”[13] Balin, standing nearby, had just enough time to whisper it before the cave floor began to shake and give way beneath them. The last thing Bilbo remembered was the impact with something hard.
Then darkness came.
Notes:
[5]“…The winds were moaning in the night…” — song “Far Over the Misty Mountains Cold”, original. Khuzdul translation by A. Bazarov (https://drive.proton.me/urls/6AYEKSMW6M#y9VIN8iqk0qv)[return to text]
[6]“Far Over the Misty Mountains Cold”. [return to text]
[7]“Mahal, give me strength! Idiot!” If you’re interested in khuzdul, here’s a link to the Khuzdict [translated in English]: https://drive.proton.me/urls/H27YKECNC8#atLcLKe8ZwbK [return to text]
[8][8] “The King beneath the mountains, // The King of carven stone…” — song “The King Beneath the Mountains”, original. Khuzdul translation by A. Bazarov (http://khuzdul.su/blog/pesnja_korol_strany_podgornoj_na_kkhuzdule/2019-09-23-24) [return to text]
[9]“…The lord of silver fountains // Shall come into his own!…” — song “The King Beneath the Mountains”. Khuzdul translation by A. Bazarov (http://khuzdul.su/blog/pesnja_korol_strany_podgornoj_na_kkhuzdule/2019-09-23-24) [return to text]
[10]“The King Beneath the Mountains” [return to text]
[11]“The King Beneath the Mountains” [return to text]
[12]“Over here – quick!” [return to text]
[13]“Orcs…” [return to text]
Chapter 3: A Lull After the Storm. Part 1. A Foolish Heart
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
Merciful Eru, Bilbo Baggins was by no means like the heroes of old songs and lays, and he never thought of himself as one.
With a shudder, the hobbit watched the dreadful scene unfolding before him. A scene taken straight out of his vision. Unlike the first, this one stayed with Bilbo – alas, all too clearly. Thorin was drained of all strength and could neither rise nor reach Orcrist. A pale Orc sat astride a warg, baring his teeth in something like a smile. He was drawing out the Dwarf’s death, savouring the nearness of victory. At his command another Orc lifted his sword high over Thorin.
Bilbo was full of faults: a little vain and inclined to boast, suitably grumbly, selfish and timid, not given to desperate self-sacrifice – yet now and again prone to sudden, unconsidered acts.
For a few painfully long seconds he hesitated at a distance, nervously turning Sting in his hand. He was weak and worn to the bone; in such a state he could do very little. Baggins knew exactly what ought to be done, though that did not mean he could bring himself to do it. The choice lay with him, and he made it – without having truly thought it through at all.
He worried a great deal, wavered, and of course made foolish mistakes. Bilbo was an ordinary, somewhat plump hobbit of middle years, with an unremarkable kindly face, warm brown eyes, and coppery curls, deeply attached to his home and his own quiet corner of the world.
With a sudden rush he charged headlong, bowled the Orc clean over, and drove his small sword with all his strength into the creature’s chest. He might have noticed the flash of genuine horror that crossed Thorin’s eyes at that moment, had the hobbit’s attention not been fixed on the Orcs closing in around them both – and had Thorin not soon after lost consciousness altogether.
Bilbo did not think of himself as a hero or a warrior; yet he possessed a small measure of selflessness. He was kind, pure of heart, honest, and free from greed (and, now and then, inclined to a kind gesture). In truth, he did believe in Gandalf – believed in the whole mad business of the journey, felt a fondness for Thorin and the Dwarves, and was drawn to them. He simply did what he thought was right and needful.
And also what his foolish, tender heart urged him to do.
☜ ☞
Thorin’s eyes flew open, and he pushed himself up onto his elbows. His whole body ached with pain, and sleep would not come, weariness notwithstanding. He glanced about, searching for a way out of the house. The direct path was blocked by Fili, Kili, Óin, and Glóin, snoring with great enthusiasm and almost in unison as they lay sprawled on the warm oak floor, their cloaks spread beneath them.
Oakenshield rose to his feet with some effort and picked his way around the bodies scattered here and there. Twice he stumbled over someone and muttered a hearty curse. The wooden floorboards, too, betrayed him with their creaking beneath his weight; but the members of the company, at last enjoying a long-awaited rest, did not so much as stir at such trifles.
Thorin pushed open a large dark door and stepped out onto what was something like a veranda, overlooking a garden spread with a carpet of flowers. Limping slightly, he walked without haste to a wooden bench and sank heavily onto it.
It was the twenty-first of July. The weather had turned hot and almost windless, and the nights were warm and sultry. On the horizon dawn was slowly kindling, the milky light of the moon giving way to a widening band of orange. Only the chirring of crickets and the unrestrained snoring from the house disturbed the stillness.
Thorin drew a deep breath; his nose filled with a pleasant honey-sweet, floral scent. He surveyed the grounds carefully, and, seeing nothing amiss, leaned back against the rough bench and closed his eyes. That near-maniacal watchfulness had long since become habit. His mind filled with the events and images of recent days, blending into one another: stone-giants, trolls, goblins, orcs, eagles. One captivity after another, one escape after the next, clash following clash – each of them, as Thorin stubbornly believed, drawing them closer to their final goal, to their home, Erebor.
To the Arkenstone…
To think of home was a pleasure, for Thorin had spent his happy childhood there. He liked to lose himself again in those carefree days with his younger brother Frerin, in the nursery where the rudiments of many crafts were taught through play; or to wander once more, in memory, through the wide halls of the Mountain-kingdom, richly adorned with skilful carvings and reliefs in stone, their harmonious architecture giving voice to the very soul of rock. There were often held great, boisterous feasts, with music, dancing, and singing until dawn (and sometimes for days on end), in which he, despite his tender years, took part with keen delight – playing the harp and bellowing merry songs, often quite bawdy. If nothing else, Dwarves knew how to make merry.
The mighty kingdom flourished then. Folk of many peoples came to his grandfather, King Thrór, seeking aid, and Thrór gave it freely. Yet when he himself needed help most, none came to his side.
To return home in thought was sweet – and yet so painful. Beloved memories lay buried beneath the splintered shards of a grim past; to sink into them always cost Thorin a heart cut to ribbons. The piercing cries of his kin burning alive in the dragon’s fire. A wandering family, forced to beg, to endure disdainful looks, to take on the blackest labour merely to live. The Pyrrhic victory at the Battle of Azanulbizar, and the frozen mask of terror on his brother’s death-pale face. A new exile in the Ered Luin, and the disappearance of his father. Thorin came to be proudly named the King of Durin’s Folk – but within he was only an orphan, embittered against the whole world, bearing wounds of the spirit from which he had never recovered. Nor did he wish to. They reminded him of what he fought and avenged so fiercely, and of what he must live for. Upon Thorin lay the crushing burden of responsibility for an entire people, and for a family reduced to a sister and her sons. He had forgotten nothing – neither the good nor the ill.
All who met the King under the Mountain thought him overly stern and cruel, even merciless: a calculating, greedy Dwarf without a spark of compassion. They did not consider that the open, cheerful, and level-headed Thorin – who would not spare his last shirt, nor even his one life, for his people, his friends, his family – had never chosen to become otherwise. But now he chose to remain so.
From the mire into which his thoughts were dangerously sinking, Thorin was pulled by the creak of the door leading out onto the terrace. Bilbo’s head appeared in the doorway. He took a couple of careful, soundless steps across the wooden floor toward the bench he had taken a liking to earlier that day upon arriving at Beorn’s house, but froze halfway when he noticed Oakenshield already seated there. The Dwarf, who had tensed at the sound, turned toward it – and relaxed at once on seeing the hobbit, giving him a slight nod of invitation.
Bilbo sat down at the far end of the bench and, after a little fidgeting, settled into a comfortable position and fell silent. Thorin cast another brief glance at the unexpected visitor and turned away. Along the garden fence stood rows of beehives with flat straw-thatched roofs. As dawn took hold, the garden began to fill with the hum of great bees, still lazily drifting from flower to flower.
Bilbo, meanwhile, drew from his rather crumpled waistcoat a long, curved wooden pipe and lit it. Thorin caught the sweet scent of Old Toby.[14] He himself scarcely touched pipe-weed, yet now he breathed in the soothing aroma of the fragrant galenas with pleasure.
“There will be heavy rain,” the halfling said softly, releasing another puff of smoke.
Thorin looked up at the cloudless sky of early dawn and glanced at the hobbit inquiringly.
“If the bees are lively before the sun is fully up, there’ll be a strong rain by day. It’s a saying where I come from.”
“Interesting,” Thorin murmured. He had little faith in omens – save, perhaps, those bound to the sacred Dwarvish number seven (he recalled how Dís had rejoiced at the sight of seven ravens together – good fortune), and the old superstition concerning their forefather Durin the Deathless.[15] Yet for some reason he found himself curious about other folk’s beliefs. All the more so because he had heard very little of the traditions, culture, and daily life of the halflings: a quiet, inconspicuous people, seldom seen beyond their own lands. He himself had visited them but once – and that briefly – when he sought out Baggins’ home.
“Thorin?” Bilbo called softly, drawing Oakenshield back to the present. He realised that he had been staring at the hobbit all this while. Watching the intricate column of smoke rising from the pipe-bowl, he recalled a question that had troubled him since before they had blundered into the trolls.
“Mr. Baggins,” he said, “tell me – what happened in that cave in the mountains? What frightened you so?”
Bilbo’s shoulders tightened visibly. He chewed nervously on the stem of his pipe and then took it from his mouth.
“I think I was a little… shocked,” he said at last, choosing each word with care, “by the fact that I very nearly fell off a stone-giant.” He turned the wooden bowl in his hands for a moment. “Yes. Quite so.” He bit down on the stem again and fell silent.
It seemed to Thorin that the hobbit was trying to convince himself of something more than stating it as certain; but he did not wish to press the matter. With only a slight nod in reply, Oakenshield returned to his contemplation of the garden.
A few minutes passed before the hobbit spoke again.
“Thorin, thank you – for saving me then… and before that as well.”
Bilbo looked a little embarrassed, yet his gaze met the King’s with steady, boundless gratitude. Thorin shook his head. It was not Baggins who ought now to be offering thanks, but Thorin himself.
“You have done far more for me, though you had little reason to do so. I am in your debt, Mr. Burglar.”
Seeing Bilbo falter slightly, Thorin wished to say more – but could not. He promised himself that he would prove his deep gratitude by deeds, since words had failed him.
When the sun had fully risen above the horizon, the rolling thunder of snores from the house gave way to the sounds of stirring and the voices of dwarves, soon joined by the Wizard’s. Thorin heard his own name mentioned more than once and rose reluctantly from his seat. Bilbo had long since finished his Toby and dozed off unnoticed. At the sight of the halfling’s comically nodding head, the corners of Thorin’s mouth twitched in the faintest hint of a smile. As quietly as he could (though that was properly their Burglar’s domain, not a dwarf’s), he made for the door and slipped inside, joining the general bustle.
Far away in the sky, lightning flashed, and thunder rolled.
Notes:
[14]For more on pipe-weed (often called “tobacco”) in Middle-earth, see: https://lotr.fandom.com/wiki/Pipe-weed [return to text]
[15]On the reincarnations of Durin the Deathless, see:https://lotr.fandom.com/wiki/Durin_I [return to text]
Chapter 4: A Lull After the Storm. Part II. A Night of Dancing
Notes:
(See the end of the chapter for notes.)
Chapter Text
They agreed to set out the next morning. Evening was already drawing in (and, Bilbo noted to himself with hope, so was supper), and the whole company was gathered around a massive oak table, listening to Beorn. In his booming voice, he was laying out his thoughts on their future route.
The torchlight picked out the dwarves’ grim, troubled faces as Beorn painted them a thoroughly cheerless picture: a journey through the lands of yet another Elven lord – and, as Bilbo gathered, one with whom Thorin and his companions had old scores to settle.
Baggins, unwilling to waste what little remained of his already frayed nerves, and pleasantly drowsy after the hearty meal their gigantic host had provided, listened with only half an ear. Most of the time he sat with his eyes blissfully closed, opening them now and then to reach for the drinking bowl set before him, filled with wonderful mead. After another sip, Bilbo drifted into a sweet doze.
Not for long.
Beorn’s voice fell silent, and at once chairs scraped and the company began noisily leaving their places.
The hobbit blinked and swept the hall with bleary eyes, noticing that someone was missing. The mystery was solved a moment later, when a clear voice rang out from the inner courtyard.
“The downpour’s stopped–”
“–which means we can light a fire!” Fili finished cheerfully for his brother.
Bilbo’s vision cleared faster than Fili could dash out into the garden. A fire meant supper. And if it was anything like lunch, the hobbit was ready to haul every last log outside himself – and in record time.
The door creaked and banged as, one by one, the dwarves shuffled out into the open air, which felt noticeably fresher after the rain. The clouds were slowly retreating, revealing a sky thick with stars. Beorn pointed out a clearing on the far side of the garden, well away from the beehives, and there they decided to build the fire. Beorn himself and Gandalf stayed inside, still deep in discussion.
Before long, a simple well-shaped stack of logs rose on the chosen spot, and above it they hung an entire boar. Where the dwarves had got it from, Bilbo had no idea – Beorn certainly could not have given it to them.
In eager anticipation, Bilbo spread his red velvet jacket near the growing fire, sat down on it, and waited. His stomach betrayed him with a loud growl, and Bofur, sitting beside him, heard it and burst out laughing. “Get a move on, Bombur! At this rate our dear Burglar will faint from hunger before you’re done!” he shouted to his brother, then shot a sly look at the hobbit, whose face twisted into an annoyed grimace at the dwarf’s ill-timed comment.
After what felt like an eternity, the dwarves scattered across the clearing – and the hobbit with them – finally heard the long-awaited “All ready!” from the pleased cook and perked up at once. Everyone received a generous portion on the wooden plates their host had provided and fell to with enthusiasm.
The last time they had eaten this well had been in Rivendell, so spirits were high, and no one begrudged the happy chain of events that had brought them to the giant’s doorstep – quietly ignoring, of course, that said chain involved a pack of orcs hot on their heels.
Bilbo might not have eaten his fill (after all, this was only his third meal of the day, which could hardly compare to his usual seven), but he was quite content. The others soon finished their portions as well and launched into animated conversation. Fili and Kili exchanged a conspiratorial nod – at which Bilbo’s eye always began to twitch, for the brothers could be plotting absolutely anything – and jumped to their feet.
“And now, a bit of music!”
Well, that’s not so bad, Baggins thought, though he had no idea where they meant to find instruments for such an undertaking. True, an inner voice promptly reminded him that there were orcs roaming somewhere nearby who might well decide to join their improvised celebration – but Bilbo quickly soothed himself with the thought that they were under the protection of a very large bear in human form.
When Dori and Ori produced flutes from the depths of their coats, Bilbo was mildly surprised. He was even more astonished when Bifur ran into the house and came back with a clarinet; but when Fili, Kili, and Bombur pulled two small fiddles, a little drum, and a tiny tambourine from their packs, his jaw simply dropped and his eyes nearly popped out of his head.[16]
The makeshift orchestra settled in a semicircle and, after a brief discussion of the repertoire, began to play. Bombur started first, setting the rhythm with energetic taps on the drum and tambourine. Nori and Bofur, who had no instruments, joined in by clapping their hands in time. Soon the firelit glade filled with the bright whistle of flutes, the mellow call of the clarinet, and the light, ringing tones of the fiddles.
Bilbo noted with some surprise how skilfully and tightly the dwarves played together. The lively, he enjoyed the driving tune so much that he began to sway and shuffle a little in place, without even standing up.[17]
He had barely recovered from one shock when he was struck by another: unable to sit still any longer, Nori and Bofur stopped clapping, jumped to their feet, and launched into a dance, dragging Óin, Glóin, and Balin along with them. And here Bilbo had thought that after the fountain incident nothing could possibly surprise him anymore.
The five dwarves danced with loud whistles and peals of laughter, with the same fierce enthusiasm they had once shown while multislicing their enemies. They formed a circle, moving first clock–, then counterclockwise, jumping and clapping as they changed direction. From time to time, two or three would break away, step briefly toward the fire, and then dart back into the ring.[18]
Meanwhile the music began to quicken. The dwarves with instruments had long since leapt to their feet and were dancing with gusto, never once missing a note. Only Dwalin and Thorin remained outside the whirl, nodding their heads in time while sipping from a flask, and Bilbo himself, who decided his participation would be ill-advised – if only because he had no idea what the steps were.
The tune ended as abruptly as it had begun, though it was clear that everyone was more than ready to continue.
When the flutes started up again, Dwalin – who had been tossing fresh logs onto the fire – gave up his show of restraint, spat to one side, and joined the spinning dance around the flames. Fili and Kili, no longer needed in the little orchestra, set their fiddles aside and hopped toward those still standing apart: Fili headed for Thorin, while Kili made straight for Bilbo.
The hobbit saw Fili, after some coaxing, finally crack the last bastion of dwarven composure – and shot a long-suffering look at the dark-haired dwarf now charging toward him.
“No, no, and absolutely not – I’m not doing this,” Bilbo protested, his voice treacherously edging toward hysteria. He had no desire to look foolish or spoil the dwarves’ fun with his awkward presence (though at any Shire festival Bilbo could never be kept from dancing – something he would not have admitted now even under torture).
“Miiister Burglaaaar! Biiilbo!” Kili, wearing a wild grin, had no intention of asking or persuading. He simply gave the entrenched halfling a powerful tug, nearly pitching Bilbo face-first into the grass.
Dragging Baggins by the hand, the dwarf hauled him back to the circle and effortlessly wedged them both into it. Thorin stood to Bilbo’s left, which made the hobbit dearly wish the ground would split open, as it had in the caves of the Misty Mountains, and swallow him whole. Since struggling was clearly pointless, he resolved to try to relax.
At first, this proved manageable enough: they circled the fire, whose flames seemed to dance along with them, clapped their hands, and changed direction just as they had during the first dance.[19] But then came variations for which Bilbo was rather less prepared.
After another round, the dwarves suddenly paired off and began spinning in place, arms linked at the elbow. For a fleeting second, Bilbo was relieved, assuming Kili would be his partner – but when he realized he was meant to turn left instead of right, he wished he could dance himself straight out of the glade.
Thorin caught his arm and swung him into a rapid spin. Reeling from the sheer speed of events, Bilbo thought he might faint from the strain. That would make the third time since falling in with dwarves, he reflected grimly. You don’t build up much health with this lot, he muttered under his breath.
They re-formed the circle, made another couple of turns around the fire – and then Bilbo was pushed back toward Thorin once more.
Oakenshield could not remember the last time he had been feeling so cheerful. He had nothing against spontaneous merrymaking; they had all endured a great deal and badly needed even a brief respite. Thorin glanced over his flushed, heated brothers, then let his gaze settle on the hobbit dancing beside him.
In the firelight, Bilbo’s coppery curls gleamed with gold. They reminded Thorin of the shine of Erebor’s treasure-hoard, and he found himself admiring them despite himself – feeilng an urge to reach out and touch them. Brushing the thought aside, he looked instead at Bilbo’s tense face and, in his genial mood, decided to lighten things.
“Mr. Baggins, do relax. It’s only a dance. I believe you’ve faced far worse things lately.”
Bilbo shot him a murderous glare from under his brows and made a peculiar snorting sound that reminded Thorin a little of an angry hedgehog. The comparison struck him as so funny that, for the first time in a very long while, he burst into loud, genuine laughter. Hearing this, the other dwarves began to smile as well.
Bilbo, however, seemed to take it all very much to heart and was mortally offended by the thought of being laughed at.
“I do have a name, Mr. Oakenshield – and you might stop mocking me already.”
This was not quite the reaction Thorin had expected. He had never meant to offend Bilbo, so he stopped laughing and looked at the scowling hobbit with as much attention as the whirling dance allowed. Just then the music ended, and Bilbo seized the moment to wrench his arm free and stride quickly back to his place.
Oakenshield watched him go, puzzled, but decided to leave the Burglar alone for now and sat down beside Dwalin.
After yet another dance – Bilbo had long since lost count – the dwarves finally called a halt and dropped to the ground one by one, thoroughly pleased with themselves. Baggins did not rejoin them; instead, he lay propped on his elbows, gazing thoughtfully up at the star-filled sky. Logs crackled as more were thrown onto the fire, and Bofur settled down beside him. Catching their breath, the dwarves began to murmur quietly among themselves.
From beneath half-lidded eyes, Bilbo noticed movement to his right: Bifur shifted restlessly, gripping his juniper-wood clarinet. After scratching his beard in thought, he nodded to himself, raised the instrument to his lips, and blew.
What, again… Bilbo groaned inwardly, having not the slightest desire to be dragged into more dancing – but his thoughts were cut short when Fili began to sing. Bilbo broke out in a sweat. Lately, fires and songs had become quite a combination for him.
The wind was on the withered heath,
but in the forest stirred no leaf:
there shadows lay by night and day,
and dark things silent crept beneath.[20]
Others joined in after Fili. Unlike before, the song was not in Khuzdul but in the Common Tongue. Bilbo chose not to tempt fate. He hastily gathered himself, rose to his feet, and walked briskly into the oak grove beyond the flower garden, away from the fire.
He did not go back into the house; he had no wish to meet Gandalf’s searching gaze again. The wizard would surely notice how on edge he was.
☜ ☞
Bilbo wandered aimlessly along the rain-softened path, skirting massive oak trees so huge they reminded him of Beorn himself. The moon washed their swaying crowns in silver light, and the twisted shadows of their branches lay strangely across the ground. Baggins shivered from the damp chill and the cool wind, regretting that in his haste he had left his jacket by the fire.
A clearing appeared not far ahead. Bilbo slipped between a pair of bushes and found himself on a small grassy glade, crossed by a narrow stream. The water murmured gently, and the sound soothed his taut nerves. He stepped closer and bent down to scoop up a diamond scatter of stars with his hand.
Behind him came the crunch of branches beneath heavy footsteps. Bilbo straightened at once and turned. Between the trees appeared the figure of Oakenshield.
Bilbo winced. He was still unsettled by his own sharp reaction to Thorin’s behaviour during the dance. The King under the Mountain had never shown him much respect before – something Bilbo had learned to tolerate. But not tonight. Not now.
“Did our amusements not please Mr. Baggins?” Thorin drew level with him and stopped, folding his arms.
Here we go, Bilbo thought.
The familiar form of address and the faint hint of a smirk on the dwarf’s face were enough to set him off at once.
“Mr. Baggins. Halfling. Burglar. This hobbit. A burden,” Bilbo rattled on. “What else would you like to call me? Don’t trouble yourself, Mr. Oakenshield – I’ll help you along. Perhaps the court jester of the King under the Mountain?”
Inside him, a righteous anger flared anew. Thorin frowned.
Bilbo knew he should shut up. He knew he would regret this again – but he simply couldn’t. For some unfathomable reason, Oakenshield managed to throw him off balance with effortless ease. Baggins shot Thorin an angry glance and turned back toward the stream.
There was a soft rustle behind him, and Bilbo felt a warm weight settle across his shoulders – a cloak trimmed with fur. Thorin’s cloak.
“Mr… hem… Bilbo…” Oakenshield hesitated, choosing his words.
Had Bilbo not been frozen to the spot, his jaw would certainly have dropped. Receiving no reaction, Thorin stepped around and faced him.
“I did not mean to hurt you.”
Bilbo finally managed to move and met his gaze. Thorin smiled and rested a hand on his shoulder.
“We set out early in the morning. We should head back, so we can get some rest.”
Baggins nodded slowly, caught in the dark pools of eyes now turned almost black in the night. He felt the hand slip from his shoulder as Oakenshield began to walk away. For some reasons, a small pang of regret struck Bilbo as he remembered the warmth and comfort of Thorin’s unexpected hug on the mountainside – where the Eagles had carried them. He quickly shook the thought away, wrapped the cloak more tightly around himself, and followed.
As they walked along the familiar path, something small and hard crunched beneath Bilbo’s foot. He paused and picked it up. It turned out to be nothing more than a cracked acorn. Smiling, and glancing around, the hobbit found another – whole and unblemished – and slipped it into his trouser pocket.
Before long they reached Beorn’s house and turned in for the night.
Bilbo, having entirely forgotten that the cloak he wore was not his own, fell asleep wrapped in it from head to toe. Thorin, well aware that the cloak Bilbo was wearing belonged to him, fell asleep with a faint smile on his lips.
Notes:
[16]In Tolkien’s book, more instruments are actually mentioned (including Thorin’s harp), but they were deliberately left out here for the sake of greater plausibility during the journey. More about dwarven instruments can be found here: https://tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Musical_instruments[return to text]
[17]This passage was inspired by stylised medieval music, which can be listened to here (the first track listed on the page): https://pinkamuz.pro/search/%D0%A1%D1%82%D0%B8%D0%BB%D0%B8%D0%B7%D0%B0%D1%86%D0%B8%D1%8F%20%D1%81%D1%80%D0%B5%D0%B4%D0%BD%D0%B5%D0%B2%D0%B5%D0%BA%D0%BE%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B3%D0%BE%20%D1%82%D0%B0%D0%BD%D1%86%D0%B0%20Maria%20Virgine[return to text]
[18]The description of the first dance was based on the medieval folk dance known as the Norwegian Circle Dance.[return to text]
[19]The description of the second dance was based on the medieval folk dance known as the Breton Circle Dance.[return to text]
[20]The dwarves’ song about their journey, “The Wind Was on the Withered Heath…”, original text.[return to text]
Chapter Text
Bilbo stood by the window, wrapped in a blue blanket, vainly trying to warm his hands with his breath. The woolen fingerless mittens that Bard’s younger daughter, Tilda, had kindly given him along with the blanket did little to keep out the biting cold – but it was better than nothing.
Through the windows he could see a palisade of weathered wooden houses. The piles they stood on were sunk deep into the bed of the lake. Esgaroth – once the wealthy and powerful Lake-town of Men on the western shore of the Long Lake – looked bleak and worn. Bilbo followed with a lingering gaze a flimsy little boat drifting along what passed for streets, its hull loaded with barrels. At the sight of them, he winced without meaning to; unpleasant memories of their forced “departure” from the Elvenking’s halls came unbidden to mind.
It was the seventh of October, which meant Durin’s Day was drawing near. And though Erebor lay only a short distance from the town, they still had to find the entrance – and that could take a very long time. Bilbo sighed, cast one last look at the dull gray veil that had stretched across the sky, and turned away. He noticed Óin, standing near Kíli, who was seated on a wooden bench by the large table, and beckoning Baggins over.
“Bilbo, help me here,” Óin said, passing him strips of clean cloth that Sigrid, Tilda’s elder sister, had brought, and settling him down beside Kili. Bilbo saw the young dwarf’s face twist with pain as the healer began to unwind the filthy bandages wrapped around his left thigh – the spot where Kili had been wounded by an orc during their escape from Mirkwood.
“How are you holding up?” Bilbo asked, hoping to distract the pale-faced dwarf from Óin’s unpleasant ministrations.
“Gamut ai-menu,[21] dear Mr. Baggins. For us, khazâd,[22] it’s barely… a scratch–ah–” Óin tore the last strip free from Kili’s leg, drawing a sharp groan from the suddenly emboldened dwarf. Bilbo handed Óin the first fresh bandage and looked at the wounds with concern.
“Really? You look worse than a ra… rakhâs,[23]” Bilbo didn’t recall the word at once, but Kili’s indignant expression was well worth it. Baggins gave a sly smile. He still hadn’t settled the score for that little stunt with the dance at Beorn’s.
“Rukhs,[24] Mr. Bilbo. Rakhâs means orcs,’” Óin corrected him, finishing his work on the bandage and giving it an appraising look.
Lately, the dwarves had taken to speaking their native Khuzdul more often in the hobbit’s presence, readily explaining the meanings of words he didn’t understand. Sometimes he managed to remember a few of them, but the language was so complex that he didn’t dare aim for more. Baggins had heard of the veil of secrecy surrounding the dwarves’ tongue, one they were reluctant to lift for outsiders, so the fact that they shared something so personal with him at all already felt like a privilege.
Óin moved off to the far corner of the room, where Thorin, Balin, and Dwalin were speaking in low voices. He exchanged a few words with them, after which all three glanced toward Kili and Bilbo – who suddenly found the rickety chandelier under the ceiling intensely fascinating. Thorin’s expression darkened, and he gave a reluctant nod.
The oppressive silence in the house was broken by Bombur, laden with assorted junk, who opened the front door without ceremony using his belly. Behind him, laughing loudly, the rest of the dwarves tumbled into the room, burdened with gear, weapons, and provisions.
“Greetings to you all from the Burgomaster, gentlemen!” Bifur announced, noisily dumping the goods onto the table. The others followed his example.
At the sight of food, Bilbo beamed like a well-polished copper pan. A proper meal – or any meal at all – had become a rare luxury, so one had to seize the moment. He wedged himself between Bifur and Bofur, who were rummaging through the meager haul, and gave the supplies – so “generously” provided for their journey by the Master of Lake-town – a critical inspection. They turned out to be rather scant indeed.
As Baggins busied himself counting loaves of bread, Bofur suddenly tugged him by the elbow, drawing him away from the noisy crowd around the table. Bilbo was just about to launch into a lecture on the subject of “why one should never come between a hobbit and his food,” but he didn’t get the chance. The dwarf flipped the trailing end of his knitted scarf over his shoulder and, after rummaging in his belt pouch for a moment, produced a small piece of cloth.
“Spotted it among the rest of the junk in that boar’s hoard. Saw it and thought of you – here,” Bofur said, handing Bilbo a silk handkerchief with a golden letter B embroidered in one corner. “So now it’s not the Burgomaster’s – it’s Bilbo’s.”
Bilbo turned the unexpected gift over in his hands and broke into a wide smile at the dwarf, who looked immensely pleased with himself.
“Thank you, Bofur. Let’s say I’ve forgotten about that little incident back in the Shire.”
Bofur winked cheerfully at Baggins and returned to the table. The hobbit folded the handkerchief with care and was about to get back to his counting when he nearly collided with Thorin, who seemed to have appeared out of nowhere beside him. And why did they even need a silent hobbit burglar, Baggins grumbled to himself, when Thorin himself could manage just fine?
He had noticed that Oakenshield had recently picked up the odd habit of keeping Bilbo within sight at all times. At first it made him uneasy – he half-feared Thorin would start escorting him even “into the bushes”. The unpleasant thought crept in that Thorin still didn’t trust him. But after the dwarf had backed his barrel scheme without hesitation, Bilbo put those worries aside. What the King under the Mountain had on his mind often remained a mystery to the hobbit, but the tension between them had eased, and he’d grown used to Thorin’s constant presence – and even to the fact that Thorin listened to him. One day, Bilbo realized with some surprise that Thorin’s company now made him feel calmer. He had neither the desire nor the strength to puzzle out why. Their goal was drawing inexorably closer, the road was growing more dangerous by the day, and Bilbo had far more pressing concerns.
From time to time, some members of the company cast strange, sidelong looks either at him or at the King under the Mountain – looks that seemed half knowing, half bewildered. Bilbo couldn’t quite tell. Perhaps they did understand something, but Baggins had no time for unraveling such riddles. He’d had more than enough of those in the goblin tunnels.
Bilbo realized he was still standing there, facing Oakenshield, who was staring intently at the little item in his hands. He murmured an apology and slipped past. Thorin exchanged a few rough, unfamiliar words in Khuzdul with Bofur, then returned to Balin and Dwalin. Bofur shot Baggins an embarrassed glance, but Bilbo was already back to his work and paid it no mind.
When Bard returned to the house, Thorin announced that they would set out for the Lonely Mountain in two days’ time. Everything they might need on the road to Erebor had already been packed into bags; all that remained was to discuss the route once more and secure a boat from the Master to cross the lake. Darkness was falling swiftly outside, and it was decided to put off the remaining business until morning. Tilda and Sigrid brought everyone bowls of hot fish broth and a slice of bread. After their modest supper, the dwarves and Bilbo spread out the blankets given to them on the floor and sank into an uneasy sleep.
Notes:
[21]“All is well.”[return to text]
[22]“Dwarves.”[return to text]
[23]“Or… Orcs.”[return to text]
[24]“An orc.”[return to text]
Chapter Text
“You have a sharp eye, Mr. Baggins!” Oakenshield exclaimed with feeling, giving Bilbo an approving clap on the shoulder. Bilbo could hardly disagree: he really was observant. But now that very observance frightened him more than a whole pack of orcs.
Thorin was not himself. And, it seemed, he had once again forgotten Bilbo’s name.
Back in Esgaroth, Bilbo had noticed the subtle changes that came over Oakenshield’s face as he stared long at the majestic slopes of Erebor. At times he would stand alone by a window, as if rooted to the spot, gazing at the Mountain when the mist cleared. Then, just as suddenly, he would shake off that stony mask and throw himself into everyday matters with renewed vigor.
At the time, Baggins had chalked up those small oddities in Thorin’s behavior to worry – for the fate of their group (Kili was growing worse by the day) and for the quest itself. But he had been wrong. And the closer and more tangible Erebor and its treasure hoard became, the more clearly he realized it.
Thorin was obsessed – and stubbornly refused to admit it. Bilbo tried to speak to the others in their small company, tried to tell them that something was wrong with Thorin, that he needed help. They refused to see the problem until the very end. All the while, it was rapidly getting worse. Their journey had lasted more than half a year, yet it had taken only a couple of weeks among the glittering trinkets of the kingdom for Oakenshield to go off the rails and become a shadow of himself. Bilbo could no longer tell what had been real: the Thorin he had known before, or that stone mask that had first shown itself back in Esgaroth, which Thorin had simply learned to hide so well.
“You were only ever a means to an end. That coward Oakenshield has weighed the value of your life and found it worth no-thing.” Smaug was dead, but his insinuating voice never left Bilbo’s head for even a moment. The hobbit fought it with the last of his strength. At the thought of the dragon, Baggins felt an unbearable itch in the left pocket of his jacket, where the Arkenstone lay wrapped in the first scrap of cloth he’d found.
Bilbo leaned against the cold wall beside the granite bench where he had sat down not long ago, seeking a moment of silence, and closed his eyes. He was dead tired – drawn and hollow-eyed, unable to sleep, with no appetite at all (something he would never have expected of himself). Baggins gave a bleak little smile. In a way, he and Thorin were alike: the cursed gem was driving them both mad. The difference was that the King under the Mountain wanted only the Arkenstone and nothing else, while Bilbo would have given up every diamond in the world just to have the old Thorin back.
The hobbit opened his eyes and looked at the acorn he held carefully in his hand, untouched by all the hardships of the journey. His nose prickled, and Bilbo dabbed at it with the handkerchief Bofur had given him. From his conversations with Balin, he had a general idea of what was happening to Oakenshield: the same madness that had overtaken Thorin’s grandfather Thrór was awakening in him – obsession taken to its extreme, boundless greed, the infamous Dragon-sickness.
Bilbo had grown attached to Thorin far more than he could have imagined – or cared to admit. He was perceptive in all matters except his own feelings, and he held long emotional soul-searching in quiet contempt. So the realization came late (and only thanks to the extreme circumstances they now found themselves in): the dwarf he had not known at all less than a year ago had become unimaginably dear to him.
Long ago he could have handed over the cursed stone, taken his share, and rushed back to the Shire at full speed, pockets jingling with the gold of Erebor’s hoards. He had helped the dwarves reclaim their home; he could have gone back to his own.
Bilbo bit his lip nervously. Nonsense. Perhaps he could – but warg take it, he didn’t want to. It hurt him physically to see Thorin in this state. And this wasn’t really Thorin anymore, but a greedy, ruthless King under the Mountain.
Bilbo truly was observant, and he had had time to study Oakenshield, who was by no means free of flaws: secretive, not particularly gentle with strangers, calculating, stubborn, and excessively proud. But he had been different, too.
Thorin knew how to listen – and how to hear. He was sensible and clever (for a dwarf; for at times Bilbo suspected that the only proper brain cell in the whole company – aside from his own – belonged to Balin, and that Thorin merely borrowed it now and then). He could look at you with such warmth that it felt as though he’d gladly give you his last crumb of food and was genuinely glad to see you of all people. He was caring, and he would fight to the death for those he loved and for what mattered to him. That was the Thorin Bilbo had seen, the Thorin he had come to know, the Thorin he had grown attached to – and the Thorin he was now losing at a frightening pace.
Baggins remembered the old dwarf-tales his mother had told him: according to legend, one of the Ainur (the Valar), the smith Aulë (or Mahal in Khuzdul), had carved the first dwarves from stone and made the fruits of their own craft the purpose of their lives. Poor dwarves – along with their skill, astonishing endurance, and strength – had been given an incredible greed, pride, and hard-headedness (both literal and figurative). Of course, they were not the only ones who could fall prey to the Sickness: men, elves – anyone could. But the flaws unintentionally woven into the dwarves, alongside their useful and admirable traits, made them the most vulnerable to it. And yet Bilbo still stubbornly refused to believe that Thorin was the same. It seemed the hobbit could give dwarves a run for their money when it came to obstinacy: once he made up his mind, it stayed made.
He didn’t know what to do. Balin had told him about the Arkenstone’s sacred and political importance to the dwarves of Middle-earth. This stone – stunning beyond measure, yet still only a stone – could, all by itself, unite scattered groups into a single mighty people. Bilbo could not – simply could not – decide its fate alone. But the price of that unity would be Thorin’s sanity, and a senseless war with the Wood-elves and the Men of Esgaroth, a war the King under the Mountain was ready to start just to protect his riches.
As if anyone were trying to take them from him.
Bilbo clenched and unclenched the hand holding the acorn. The weight beneath his eyes felt like lead, and he knew that a little more and he would simply lie down here from sheer exhaustion. For ever. In Erebor, there was no one he could turn to. He feared – with good reason – that the dwarves would not understand him (though even they had recently begun to worry about their king’s state of mind) if he told them that the Arkenstone could not remain in the kingdom. Bilbo was left alone with his torment – and the cursed gem.
“What is that you’re holding?”
Ah yes. And with a mad King under the Mountain.
☜ ☞
Thorin searched in vain. He prowled feverishly through the web of stairways and halls of Erebor, but the Burglar was nowhere to be found – not around any corner, not in any passage. Passing yet another empty corridor, the dwarf finally spotted a familiar silhouette in an archway: Baggins was sitting hunched on a bench, nervously turning something over in his hands.
He has found the Arkenstone. At that thought, the dull, painful itch that had been tormenting Thorin flared at once. He was swallowed by the sensation; it felt as though muscles and nerves, drawn tight as strings, were about to snap from the strain.
Oakenshield closed the distance between himself and the hobbit in a few long strides. The pounding roar in his head was deafening. He did not even hear his own question; all his attention narrowed to a single desire – to feel the weight of the diamond in his hands at once.
The Arkenstone. His Arkenstone. The greatest treasure of Erebor, whose beauty recalled the legendary Silmaril set in the Nauglamír.[25] A symbol of boundless power. It alone was worth any sacrifice, any blood spilled, any tears shed. Thorin had to claim it; he had endured too much not to. The gem was his by right.
Oakenshield stared without blinking at the hobbit’s hands, held behind his back. Impatience swelled, yet Thorin did not move. He savored the aching tension that wracked his body in anticipation. Any moment now, his face would be lit by that dazzling white glow, shimmering with every color of the rainbow.
Thorin was ready for this meeting. It seemed he had been yearning for it for a very long time indeed. But he was not ready for what he finally saw.
An acorn?
Thorin faltered. Why an acorn?
“…in Beorn’s garden.” The ringing in his ears gave way to a crushing silence. Thorin forgot what he had been thinking about before. Had he been thinking at all? He remembered wanting something fiercely. What was it he wanted? Despair welled up inside him. He shifted his gaze from the acorn to the speaker.
Bilbo.
Bilbo looked embarrassed, yet he met Thorin’s eyes directly and openly – without a trace of fear or reproach, the kind that sometimes flickered in the looks of others. He smiled at Thorin warmly, and in his eyes burned… hope? The hobbit hesitated, then carefully slipped the acorn into his pocket. Like a treasure, a thought flashed through Oakenshield’s mind.
“…I’ll remember everything: the good, the…”
Another realization began to stir. Thorin forced the cogs of thought into motion; their grinding sent a sharp lance of pain through his temples. The haze before his eyes slowly thinned. Click. In his chest, a tightly wound spring snapped open with a powerful jolt. Mahal. That tiny fruit of an oak from the grove by the skin-changer’s garden – carried by Bilbo all the way through this journey like a priceless trophy – was his reminder of Thorin.
Heat washed over the dwarf. Warmth flooded his insides like molten gold and spilled outward in one of the brightest, most sincere smiles he had ever worn. Memories of Thorin were Bilbo’s treasure? Oakenshield recalled that he had not seen the hobbit among the others in Erebor’s gem-filled grotto. The immeasurable riches of the Lonely Mountain – and his rightful one fourteenth share of them – had not interested him?
Bilbo had long since finished speaking, but Thorin did not notice the silence hanging in the corridor. All that held him was a pair of amber eyes, glowing with a gentle light and looking at him with boundless devotion – and something more. He had seen that look before, in his nephews’ eyes, and in Dís’s.
Thorin held his breath. A sharp, nervous chill ran over his skin.
Oakenshield remembered how he had doubted Bilbo, how he had dismissed him. He had not intended to answer for the life of some clumsy, cowardly hobbit and could not understand why Thârkun[26] so stubbornly insisted on taking him along. “He will surprise you yet.” Thorin had not believed the wizard, but his persistence – and Thorin’s own curiosity – had prevailed. When the Burglar collapsed into yet another faint in the Misty Mountains, Thorin rolled his eyes and recalled Gandalf’s words. Well, no one said the surprise would be a pleasant one. When the hobbit, with a fervor not found in every dwarf, vowed to help them reclaim Erebor, Thorin found himself oddly unsettled. Could the wizard have been right after all? Was the hobbit not so simple as he appeared?
At his age, Oakenshield was rarely surprised, astonished even less so, and truly shaken only a handful of times in his life. But when the hobbit – who until then had cut little more than bread – stabbed an orc far stronger and taller than himself with fierce desperation, and did not leave Thorin’s side as (this time) he lay senseless (what an irony), even when they were surrounded, Oakenshield had been shaken to his core. From that moment on, he never doubted Bilbo again.
Thorin found it fascinating to watch their Burglar. In the grumbling, stubborn, and at times desperate hobbit, he sometimes glimpsed a reflection of himself. He did not know how to repay Baggins for all he had done for him and for their company. He had nothing to offer but a dubious, deadly quest. Even a share of the treasure he could not truly guarantee. And yet Bilbo – who had first heard of the King under the Mountain barely half a year ago – remained at his side, stubbornly believing in their mad undertaking, believing in Thorin. And the dwarf did not notice the moment when, in so short a time, the hobbit became an important, inseparable part of his life.
Oakenshield was a dwarf to the marrow: he was used to crafting treasures and possessing them. Yet it seemed that for the first time, he himself had become such a treasure – for someone outside his family.
He had always known what he wanted. But now he needed something more. Before that thought could fully take shape, the sound of footsteps tore Thorin from his reverie.
“Thorin, survivors are streaming into Dale,” Dwalin’s voice echoed down the corridor. Oakenshield’s gaze hardened instantly. Dwalin went on speaking, but the King under the Mountain no longer heard him.
The Arkenstone. He needed his Arkenstone.
Notes:
[25]For more on the Nauglamír, see: https://tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Nauglam%C3%ADr[return to text]
[26]“Staff-man” – one of Gandalf’s names among the Dwarves.[return to text]
Chapter Text
“By my mother’s beard, Thorin, I’ve got no idea what you mean.”
Dwarves were conservative folk and fiercely proud of their traditions and customs. From generation to generation they were carefully preserved within each clan. The clan of the Sigin-tarâg – the Longbeards, from which all of Thorin’s company hailed – once the most respected and numerous among the Dwarves of Middle-earth, was no exception. Tradition shaped every part of their lives, from the stages of an individual dwarf’s coming of age to the structure of their society as a whole. It governed marriage as well.[27]
That matter was approached rationally and pragmatically. A household was founded by dwarves who had completed their apprenticeship and come into maturity – between forty and fifty years of age – on a solid footing of craft mastery, steady means, and a warm, safe place to live. And it was taken very seriously. Dwarves were monogamous; divorce did not exist in their society, and even when separated by distance, the pairs remained tied by strong, unbreakable bonds.
Their people were not known for romance, yet almost every marriage was preceded by a long – sometimes years-long – period of courtship, with its own rules and customs, likewise grounded in practical, material concerns. “Tokens of regard” included displays of strength, skill at one’s craft, and prosperity. The latter found expression in gifts:[28] what mattered was their value, their uniqueness, and how personal they were. Most were made by the dwarf himself, though purchased items were not unheard of.
Thorin was unwed and had never initiated courtship. At the time of Smaug’s attack on Erebor he was only twenty-four, and his parents had not yet given thought to finding him a suitable match. In the years of wandering that followed, and during their brief stay in Dunland, such thoughts were pointless: all attention was bent toward survival and helping one’s kin. Soon came a fresh chain of tragedies – the murder of Thrór, the bloody war with the Orcs that cut down their already weakened clan even further, and another stretch of wandering, until at last they managed to settle in the mines of the Blue Mountains.
At first the workings brought little profit, having been nearly exhausted. This gnawed at Thorin’s father, Thráin: the hunger for gold gave him no peace, and he vanished without a trace after hastily setting out for Erebor in 2841. By then Thorin had only recently crossed into full maturity, and at ninety-five he inherited a heavy burden – the care of his younger sister and a whole blood-drained clan, meagre means, and an all-consuming thirst for vengeance. Hardly the foundation for a home of his own.
In time, matters improved. The clan prospered in its own way, and Dís founded a household of her own, where Thorin’s nephews, Fili and Kili, were soon born. The crushing weight borne by the King gradually lifted, and Thorin could finally have thought of his own future – but he… simply did not want to. He lacked neither attention nor interest from the few dwarf-women of the Blue Mountains, yet none stirred his heart. He did not think about heirs: first, without Erebor there was nothing to inherit, and talk of its return was not yet on the table; second, Fili and Kili were enough for him – he loved them as his own sons. If he were to die, there would be someone to take his place as King. Thorin withdrew into himself, and in that light, solitude felt fitting. He had found something to whichhe could devote his strength and his thoughts, and he had a small family nonetheless. He desired no more.
So it was that in Esgaroth, in Bard’s house, the point of their leader’s question did not dawn on Bofur at once. Thorin himself grasped the meaning of their exchange even later. At the time of the quest, only Glóin among the company had a household of his own – and children to boot. That was why Oakenshield grew wary when Bofur, for no apparent reason, presented Bilbo with a peculiar gift. He liked the hobbit’s reaction even less: it was plain the thing pleased him. Once Thorin learned that the kerchief was just a kerchief, with no hidden meaning or subtext, he relaxed. And then tensed again as another question crept in: why had it mattered to him at all? But pressing concerns soon claimed his full attention, and he pushed the thought aside.
Now the King under the Mountain was once more pacing slowly across the hills of jewels in Erebor’s treasury, taking fierce pleasure in the sight of every object there. He longed to gather it all into his arms, to become one with it, and never, ever let it go again. Of course, none of the hoard could compare to the Arkenstone, yet that did not make it any less precious or necessary to Thorin. Everything here was his – his by right, and his alone. And he would guard his treasures at any cost.
As he rounded one of the pillars, his eye caught a white gleam from within a chest. For a heartbeat he thought it might be the coveted gem, but drawing closer, Thorin saw it was no stone at all, but a coat of mail. He bent and lifted it. Mithril. True-silver. A metal of incredible beauty, rarity, and worth – light as a raven’s feather and strong as a dragon’s scale. Thorin stared absently at the armour set with white gems, whose value was second only to the priceless Arkenstone. Something troubled him. The mail was small, likely meant for someone young – or of slighter build.
Oakenshield studied the piece again, more closely now, more thoughtfully. To protect the treasure. That was the thought circling at the edge of his mind.
“Almost perfect…” Thorin folded the mail and slipped it beneath his cloak. He needed to find Bilbo.
☜ ☞
Baggins would never forget Smaug’s piercing eyes. Each of them alone had been larger than the hobbit himself – but that wasn’t even the worst of it (well, not only that). It was the way they looked. In the home library of Bag End, Bilbo had always loved illustrated books best. Not that he lacked imagination, but pictures set it alight all the more. The dragon’s burning amber eyes had reminded him of an illustration of waking volcanoes from one such book – their fiercely churning mouths both alluring and deadly. Paired with that cloying, sing-song, insinuating voice, the effect had been unforgettable and terrifying. That gaze you want to surrender – and to run as fast and as far away as you could.
Bilbo shivered and squirmed on the jacket spread beneath him on the cold stone floor. There came a soft chime of mithril rings. According to Thorin, the impossibly strong armour was almost weightless, yet to Baggins it felt as though he could not move at all. The mail bound him, pressed on him, nearly choked him.
He could feel a gaze fixed upon him. During their journey he had grown used to Thorin watching him constantly, and had stopped feeling awkward or trying to explain such excessive attention – but now that look spread a nasty, sticky fear through his insides. Bilbo was unhappy with the mail not only because it implied taking part in battle, but also because it had not been Thorin who gave it to him.
He had begun to regard Oakenshield with unease, though stubbornly refusing to avoid him, hoping to glimpse the old Thorin again and pull him back from the grip of madness. Baggins’s heart had skipped a beat when, to his amazement, he succeeded. Thorin remembered Beorn’s garden, remembered the oak grove. And then it dropped through the floor hours later, when Bilbo saw the King again. A dragon. Thorin looked and spoke like Smaug. (The dragon is dead – long live the dragon, indeed) That was when the hobbit grew truly uneasy.
The gaze was hard, commanding, greedy – frighteningly cold and empty. Bilbo did not need to turn his head to know that this was how Thorin was looking at him now. As Baggins tried on the mail under the “watchful” eye of the newly crowned Smaug, the other dwarves nearby in the armoury exchanged sly smiles and nodded approvingly. Then they visibly wilted and frowned when they caught their King’s eye. Oh – so it had reached them at last. Dwarf-level mpaths, may the Valar bless them.
Bilbo’s despair found a whole new low when that seemed impossible already. He was shaking with panic and anger – at himself, for being unable to decide anything; at the dwarves, who were no help at all; and at that stupid, useless bauble bearing the lofty name the Heart of the Mountain.
Lost in his turmoil, Baggins failed to notice the rest of the company drifting into the far hall of the armoury – where he sat with the ghost of Smaug, Glóin, Óin, and Balin – carrying plates of whatever they had managed to scrounge up for supper. The sight of the mushroom stew Bombur handed him made Bilbo feel sick. He had no appetite whatsoever.
He poked the food gloomily with his spoon but could not force himself to eat even a mouthful, staring dully instead at the fire burning in the hearth. Its light, along with that of the torches lining the walls, flickered over the faces of the dwarves as they ate. Bilbo chewed his lip, thinking feverishly. He had wasted a great deal of time on these thoughts and come no closer to an answer. Meanwhile, December had come outside Erebor – nearly a month had passed since they had settled within the Mountain. The patience of elves and men was wearing thin, and the cold breath of war felt ever closer.
The clatter of spoons faded, and the dwarves sank into contented warmth by the fire. In all the bustle, Bilbo forgot entirely about his strange visions. The last time he had seen anything of the sort had been in the Misty Mountains, and much water had flowed since then. He thought that at least on that front he could finally relax – and was sorely mistaken. He had no idea why such “grace” had descended upon him, but the dwarves, it seemed, were determined to help the hobbit stay on edge at all costs.
Bofur was no kin of Durin’s royal line – just a working dwarf, simple, open, not especially sharp, but kind and understanding. Bilbo liked him very much, but sometimes… Baggins’s head was slowly turning toward the dwarf who, settling comfortably on a makeshift pallet of jacket and cap, suddenly began to sing. Sometimes he wanted to throttle him – and the others along with him, too. The already impressive list in Bilbo’s head titled “Would I ever have thought, half a year ago, that…” had just gained a new entry: “…that I would so desperately want to kill someone?”
The thought had barely formed when others joined Bofur, and the song spilled through the hall, at the far end of which sat Thorin, “breathing fire”. I need to leave. Bilbo was exhausted, and thinking now came as hard to him as it did to his dwarf-friends, so he hesitated. And when the fire in the hearth slid into his line of sight – he realized it was far too late.
Daladbundûn dushkadahan
The King has come into his hall!
kuth agnân hûl
tragû ’ugrul
And ever so his foes shall fall.[29]
Was it just Bilbo – or had time stopped, the darkness around him turning almost solid?
The sword is sharp, the spear is long,
The arrow swift, the Gate is strong;
The heart is bold
that looks on gold;
The dwarves no more shall suffer wrong.
Was he imagining it, or had he stood up without noticing?
Now call we over mountains cold,
'Come hack unto the caverns old'!
Here at the Gates
the king awaits,
His hands are rich with gems and gold.
Right. The fire. It needs to be put out. With what – what do you put out a fire with?
The king is come unto his hall
Under the Mountain dark and tall.
The Worm of Dread
is slain and dead,
And ever so our foes shall fall!
“Bilbo!”
Notes:
[27]The depiction of Dwarven culture here was largely inspired by this source (translation needed): https://enir.in/viewtopic.php?id=7210&p=32 [return to text]
[28]For aspects of Dwarven courtship customs, the following post was particularly helpful: https://www.tumblr.com/luna-redamancy/182566737978/dwarves-are-private-very-secretive-but-caring[return to text]
[29]The lines in Khuzdul are taken from the quatrain “ Under the Mountain dark and tall <…> His foe is dead, the Worm of Dread,…” — from the song “Under the Mountain dark and tall.” The Khuzdul translation is by A. Bazarov and can be found here: http://khuzdul.su/blog/pesnja_korol_zakonnyj_zanjal_tron_under_the_mountain_dark_and_tall_na_kkhuzdule/2019-09-23-25 [return to text]
Chapter 8: The Battle. Part I. The Nature of Visions
Notes:
Buckle your seat belts and enjoy the experience of my 4-am-redbull-writing-extravaganza.
(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)
Chapter Text
Eru the One, Ilúvatar, allowed the offspring of his thought – the Ainur – to behold the Great Music they were making for him. From those visions the World was born: Eä, into which some of the Ainur entered of their own will and came to be known as the Valar. Yet the World that stood before them in the mind of the Creator was still an illusion – a future that had yet to be given Being.
Before the making of the World, there were not only the Valar. The people of the Valar, their helpers and servants – the Maiar – were less mighty than the Ainur who entered Eä, yet greater than all others. The wisest of the Maiar known to the peoples of Middle-earth was Olórin, who in visible form became a friend to all the Children of Ilúvatar and was known among them as Mithrandir, or Gandalf. From him sprang worthy impulses and fair visions, and by his words hearts were lifted from despair and sorrow.
When the shadow of Sauron’s return fell once more upon the world, the Istari – the Wizards – appeared in the west of Middle-earth, and among them was Gandalf the Grey. At the Great Council, convened to decide what should be done, Gandalf spoke words that would one day lead him to the Shire, to one remarkable hobbit. Bilbo.
“Many are the strange chances of the world,” Mithrandir said to his good friend Elrond, “and help oft shall come from the hands of the weak when the Wise falter.”[30]
Gandalf would at times foresee what was to come – whether through sudden insight or through his own keen foresight – and at times could even bend the course of events by his own efforts. Yet there were matters that even the Valar, who knew much, could not know; and if so, what could be said of him? The visions of the Great Music were not a precise prophecy. Ilúvatar revealed all his designs to none, and in every Age new and unforeseen things appeared. Hobbits, for instance.
Mithrandir knew that true insight, not founded on obvious causes or sober logic, could also descend upon the Children of Eru. Their own minds were shaped by lived experience and held no knowledge of the future in themselves, though they could at times make astonishingly accurate predictions, drawing on judgment, learning, and a keen sense of cause and effect. But such “prophecies” did not always come to pass, nor could they account for what could not be seen without knowledge of the Design.
Of the future, such a mind could learn only from another mind – one that beheld the Design of Eru. Such a guide might, in the end, be Ilúvatar himself, or the Valar, who saw a greater part of His purpose.
True insight took many forms: troubling dreams or waking visions, shapes of things to come upon the surface of water, a call of the heart, verses veiled in riddles, or clear and precise messages. They might be vague or exact; they might be unconditional – events that would come to pass exactly as foretold, regardless of any circumstance – or conditional, allowing for two or more outcomes, shaped by the choices and actions of particular individuals.
So when a shaken, breathless Bilbo appeared before Gandalf by night in the camp of the Elves and the Men of Lake-town, pitched beneath the walls of Erebor among the ruins of Dale, clutching the Arkenstone and stumbling through a tale of having seen something three times already in the fire, Gandalf was not surprised. Yet the more measured conversation that followed – after two mugs of tea and a bowl of fish stew had finally calmed the hobbit – stirred a genuine curiosity in the Wizard.
Bilbo’s first “vision” Olórin, not without some satisfaction, privately credited to his own efforts. He had sought to awaken the Took within Baggins, and by all appearances he had succeeded. Given Bilbo’s lively imagination – about which Belladonna Took-Baggins had once spoken to Gandalf – such fiery illusions were hardly unexpected. Mixed with the vivid impressions of his first meeting with the dwarves and Gandalf’s own gift of persuasion, Bilbo’s subconscious seemed simply to have conjured in the hearth an image he had already painted in his mind.
At first, the Istar could get no clear account from the exhausted Baggins of the other two visions and hastily dismissed them as well as products of an overexcited imagination, stirred by emotion. And while the second illusion could indeed be explained in much the same way, the most recent vision – seen in Erebor itself – caught his attention more than any other. It held details Bilbo could not possibly have known, nor heard, nor seen.
The inflamed mind of an impressionable Baggins – especially after all he had endured over the past month in Erebor – might well have foreseen Thorin Oakenshield’s death. Of all his kin, Thorin seemed to Gandalf the most sensible, yet he was a creature of extremes: great secrecy and suspicion, prudence and caution, standing side by side with reckless, “heroic” plunges taken without thought. Fili and Kili followed their uncle everywhere; fear for their deaths, too, was not unfounded. By the same token, drawing on grim experience and his own conclusions, Bilbo might have foreseen that Azog – or any other orc – could kill them all.
But he could not possibly have known where it would happen, nor that the orc host would be split in two. Gandalf had expected that Azog’s legion would soon march from Dol Guldur – the fortress in the southwest of Mirkwood – against Erebor, but he had not foreseen reinforcements from the northern stronghold of Gundabad, led by Bolg, spawn of the Defiler. From Bilbo’s account, Azog was to draw the forces of elves, men, and dwarves into battle until Bolg arrived from Ravenhill, where the orcs would slay Thorin and his nephews.
“Bilbo, true insight is rare,” Gandalf said gently. “Those it finds are not always ready for what it brings. To an unprepared mind it can cause great pain and confusion, especially when it foretells death. But I beg you – do not despair. Your vision is a gift. It gives us an advantage our enemies know nothing of.”
Gandalf smiled at Bilbo, lifted his hand from the hobbit’s shoulder, and leaned on Radagast’s staff. Despite the biting December wind and the snow on the ground, they had stepped out of Thranduil’s warm tent at Bilbo’s request; he wished to speak in private. The hobbit stood beside him, head bowed, clenching and unclenching his fists without thought. Gandalf knew what weighed on him, yet he could no more promise that all would be well than he could have at the journey’s beginning. He did not know whether Bilbo’s vision was conditional or not – but he knew that if they did nothing, there would be only one outcome, and it would be a bitter one.
“We will do all we can to save Thorin and his nephews. Of that you may be sure. Thanks to you, we may yet have a chance to shape what is to come.”
Baggins thawed a little and looked up at him with hope. Gandalf answered with an encouraging nod and glanced back toward the tent. There was still much to be settled: the matter of the Arkenstone, for one, and the far greater problem of uniting the scattered and embittered forces – dwarves on one side, elves and men on the other. The Istar sighed heavily. It would not be easy.
To his relief, matters went better than he had expected. Bilbo made a remarkable move, handing the gem over to Thranduil and Bard. The hobbit believed it might be used to pressure the King under the Mountain and avert open conflict, but Gandalf had known from the start that this plan would fail. The true value of showing the Arkenstone to Oakenshield lay elsewhere: it might yet draw him back from madness, restore his reason, and force him to see the situation clearly.
Olórin believed Thorin was capable of that. Dwarves were stubborn, but they were no cowards, and they did not shirk battle when the matter touched them directly. As it did now. If Thorin refused to come to their aid, he would lose Erebor once more – and his entire goup with it, for they could not withstand an orc assault alone if elves and men were defeated. The mad King under the Mountain had shut himself within his halls and would hear no one. All that remained was hope that Thorin would hear them.
Beyond the Arkenstone, Gandalf faced another problem: how to dissuade Thranduil and Bard from rash action after the King under the Mountain’s first response to their “generous bargain.” Once again, his dear hobbit came to his aid – more precisely, Bilbo’s vision. Bard had been inclined from the start to seek a peaceful settlement, especially with danger drawing near. The Lord of Mirkwood, however, flatly refused to heed Gandalf’s warnings about the orcs. Dwarves are stubborn by nature, elves by choice – and which is worse is hard to say, Mithrandir grumbled inwardly, nettled by Thranduil’s lofty manner.
The vision shook Thranduil’s distrust. The minds of the elves, unclouded by the influence of Melkor, were more open than those of others to the great minds beyond them, and among the peoples of Eä they possessed an unmatched capacity for true insight. They also knew its nature and its power well.
Thranduil listened closely as the hobbit recounted the heart of the prophecy, following Gandalf’s advice and omitting only the deaths of Thorin, Fili, and Kili. The Elvenking already suspected that the Wizard’s warnings were driven merely by his wish to save “his dear dwarves”; there was no need to press the point.
At last, after some thought, the King made his decision. He lifted his pale, unreadable eyes to Gandalf and gave a barely perceptible nod. Olórin let out a breath he had not realized he was holding and broke into a smile: they had just secured the support of Mirkwood’s army in the coming battle. Now it was time to shape a general plan. After exchanging a few words with Bard and Thranduil, Gandalf left them to work out their strategy and stepped out of the tent, taking Bilbo with him. Two important matters remained.
The Istar knew he would be placing the hobbit in grave danger if he asked him to return to Erebor and warn the dwarves of Oakenshield’s company, who had not yet lost the last shreds of their modest reason. Yet only Bilbo could slip in unseen – and persuade them to act. Over the course of the journey they had grown close, and they would not ignore the words of their dear Burglar.
“I’m not afraid of Thorin, Gandalf,” Bilbo said. “I wanted to go back anyway.”
Gandalf frowned. The hobbit’s resolve troubled him no less than the battle to come.
“You should be afraid. Never underestimate the power of gold. Dragon-sickness takes hold of the hearts of all who come too close to what the serpent once possessed. Almost all,” he added, seeing Bilbo’s stubborn determination and realizing his warning had not made the hobbit more cautious. “Do not let Thorin see you, Bilbo. He is not himself and capable of anything. You must keep your wits about you.”
There was no time for long farewells. Gandalf let Baggins go, hoping to see him again – safe and whole. He watched him for a long moment, thoughtful, and then turned back into the camp, where he had left his horse.
One last task remained. The strength of the elves and the men – exhausted by the sudden burdens of the past month – was clearly not enough to turn the tide of the coming battle. They needed help. And Gandalf knew where to seek it. No one hated orcs more than Beorn, whose family Azog had nearly wiped out, enslaving those who survived. All that remained was to get word to him in time.
Notes:
[30]In describing the nature of visions in this world, I partly relied on this source (translator required): https://dzen.ru/a/Y1VO650SBT_LNwQW[return to text]
Chapter 9: The Battle. Part II. Help Against All Odds
Chapter Text
Bilbo knew perfectly well that Thorin, in his current state, was a danger. Not only to Baggins himself, but to the other dwarves of their company as well – those whose loyalty he had begun to question, convinced that one of them had stolen his beloved Arkenstone (the sheer thought of it – he even suspected his own nephews). Bilbo did not know how far Oakenshield’s madness might carry him, but he feared that if nothing were done, Thorin would destroy both himself and those around him.
His heart hammered wildly in his chest. By the time Bilbo reached Erebor and climbed up the makeshift rope lowered from the wall of the Great Gate, dawn was already breaking. There was scarcely any time left to warn the dwarves of the danger closing in, and do it without running into the mad king himself. He slipped past the half-asleep Bombur on watch without difficulty and vanished into the Mountain. He meant to find Balin.
The hobbit hurried through the cunning tangle of stairways and, first of all, cautiously peered into the armoury. The last time he had seen the dwarves, they had been there, fast asleep, and Bilbo had seized the chance to steal quietly out of Erebor to do what he should have done long ago – to be rid of the cursed stone at last. Now the armoury stood empty.
What drove Baggins to this desperate step was the vision he had seen. In the camp, Gandalf had remarked in passing that Bilbo had been “fortunate” enough to receive true foresight. By Bilbo’s reckoning, the wizard had a rather odd idea of good fortune, for what he had seen filled him with sheer horror. Hordes of orcs. Mountains of corpses. Fili and Kili dead. Thorin mortally wounded. Whoever had sent this “gift” from on high had spared no effort this time, laying it on thick and forcing Bilbo to live through a waking nightmare. Dori and Nori had barely managed to drag him away from the fire when he tried to throw himself into it, hoping to smother the flames with his own body.
A masterstroke, really. Madness must be catching. Whoever had stirred up this whole business with visions must have nearly dropped dead when all his careful work almost went straight to the wargs. The thought made the hobbit give a hysterical little laugh. He had already searched a third familiar hall, but Balin was nowhere to be found. Bilbo began to shiver, panic rising in his gut. He stopped behind one of the pillars along the road leading to the Throne Room, trying to catch his breath and gather his thoughts. Balin could be anywhere – but so far, he was nowhere. As if the ground had swallowed him whole.
Bilbo was weighing his next move when the echo of heavy footsteps rang beneath the vaulted ceiling. He froze. The Throne Room was the king’s second favourite place after the treasure hoard, so there was a very good chance that whoever was coming out now was Thorin himself. For a moment Bilbo dearly wished he could simply melt into the pillar, but he forced himself to lean out from cover. In the torchlight, a bald head gleamed above a stocky frame.
Dwalin!
Not at all who he had been hoping to see – but beggars could not be choosers.
Balin’s younger brother was not known for his gentle nature even on his best days, and now he radiated such pure, undiluted fury that Bilbo regretted his decision to whisper his name a thousand times over. His relationship with Fundin’s son had never been especially warm, but after Bilbo had proved his loyalty to the dwarves’ cause, Dwalin had thawed and even begun to show him a fair measure of respect. Besides, Bilbo thought it highly unlikely that the Dragon-sickness had taken hold of him so deeply. He would never squander the wealth of his people – but if forced to choose between gold and the defence of his homeland and kin, he would choose the latter without hesitation.
At first, Dwalin could not tell where the mouse-like squeak was coming from. Then he spotted the hobbit, for some reason lurking behind a pillar and beckoning him closer.
“Bilbo, I don’t know what you’re up to, but you shouldn’t be here. Thorin has completely lost his mind.”
Oh, really? And here he was, completely unaware.
“Dwalin, we need to find the others – now. You have no idea what’s about to break loose outside the walls of Erebor.”
At Bilbo’s request, Dwalin led him first to what passed for the group’s brain trust – his elder brother. Baggins’s account of the vision was no simple thing, and its meaning needed to be explained to the sharpest mind among the dwarves who still had their senses about them. Besides, Balin was the one dwarf – though not without misgivings – to whom Bilbo would first entrust the crucial detail of where the Arkenstone was.
“I wish that stone had never been found.” Bilbo was not entirely in agreement with the grey-bearded dwarf’s words, spoken during one of their recent conversations. Without the Arkenstone, they had no chance of saving Thorin from himself. He had lived for so long with the dream of reclaiming Erebor and the throne of the King under the Mountain – whose symbol of power was that ill-fated gem – that it had consumed him utterly when he drew dangerously close to the object of his desire. Bilbo did not object to returning the diamond to Thorin; it was his by right, and no one – least of all some hobbit – had any standing to deny that. What he opposed was Thorin receiving it now, in the heat of the moment, when he could no longer clearly judge what he truly wanted: to be a king, or a pitiful shadow of one.
Balin, together with Ori, was found in the last place Bilbo would have thought to look – the library. He drew the bewildered dwarf aside and told him everything that had happened in the camp. Balin knit his brows and searched Bilbo’s face, as though seeking proof of his words.
“Balin, I know you can’t leave Erebor to fight and abandon Thorin in this state, and I’m not asking you to do that. Nor am I asking you to forgive me. I’m only asking you to remind Thorin who he is, and what he has been fighting for all this time. And to help save him.”
Balin shook his head heavily.
“Bilbo, there is nothing we can do right now. Neither I nor any of us doubt the truth of what you say, or… the goodness of your intentions. But tell me – why are you so sure Thorin can overcome the sickness?”
That was when Bilbo finally decided to tell the dwarf what he had left unsaid in the camp. One detail from the vision had little bearing on how the future might unfold, but that was not the only reason he had kept it from Gandalf.
“Because I know what he said to me before he died.”
But because remembering it hurt more than he could bear.
Balin and Bilbo agreed not to share the details of Thorin’s death – or Fili’s and Kili’s – with the entire company. Only the least impressionable dwarves and the most seasoned warriors were told, those who could keep an eye on the trio and prevent them from turning into a suicide squad. Everything else, including the matter of the Arkenstone (at Balin’s insistence), he volunteered to explain to the others himself. Signalling to Ori and Dwalin, they left the library together and made their way toward one of the chambers near the main entrance, where, according to Dwalin, the rest of the Company was gathered.
After everyone involved had been told the details of the vision, Bilbo wanted to remain with the dwarves in Erebor. Balin dissuaded him – though not without effort. He feared that if Thorin learned the hobbit had taken the Arkenstone, he might, in a fit of rage, try to kill him. Attempts on Bilbo’s life had somehow become far more frequent of late. He really ought to have taken Balin’s warning seriously, but Bilbo answered it with a mischievous chuckle. The dwarf’s words deserved belief; still, the adrenaline that had kept him going for months now had dulled his instinct for self-preservation to a dangerous degree.
Bifur was due to relieve Bombur shortly and offered to escort Bilbo to the Great Bastion. As they climbed over the stones with which the dwarves had barricaded the main gate, elven horns sounded from outside. Thranduil had arrived at Erebor with part of his host – and with Bard.
“So soon… They’ve come with the Arkenstone so soon…” Bilbo whispered.
He and Bifur exchanged a glance and broke into a run, but they were already too late to do anything. Bombur, unaware of the dwarves’ conversation with the hobbit, sounded his horn to summon his brothers to the wall. They answered the call.
And with them came the king.
☜ ☞
Paraphrasing a well-known saying in Middle-earth: love and hate are just one Arkenstone apart.
Bilbo could tell himself a thousand times over that Thorin, even in his madness, would not truly do him harm, and beat his chest swearing he was not afraid of the king’s insanity. He could imagine Oakenshield hurling insults at him once he learned what had been done. He could picture him grabbing Bilbo by the front of his coat, shaking him hard like a kitchen towel, and hissing that he never wanted to see him again. He could even entertain the unlikeliest thought of all – that perhaps the sickness would lift at that very moment. Deep down, he had never fully believed either Gandalf or Balin, who spoke with one voice of Thorin’s deadly danger, and he thought himself ready for whatever might come.
But he was not.
He was not ready to see raw pain on Thorin’s face, shining through the haze. He had never once seen even the faintest hint of tears in Oakenshield’s eyes, believing that if Thorin had ever been capable of them, they had long since been spent on the suffering that had befallen his family and his people. All the more startling it was to glimpse their trace now. Why now, of all times?
For reasons Bilbo himself could not quite explain, he had remained the last of their group whom Thorin trusted almost blindly, even through the darkness of madness. Most likely because Thorin naively assumed that a hobbit would not steal his gold precisely because he was a hobbit – someone who cared nothing for the treasures of Erebor. Imagine that: he trusted a burglar, whom he himself had hired for that honourable post, more than his own kin and brothers-in-arms. Bilbo would have given anything not to lose the trust of a dwarf dear to him – but instead he betrayed him, and gave everything up in order to save him. And yet even betrayal should not have cut Oakenshield so deeply, not even in the grip of the sickness. After all, Bilbo was only a common burglar, hardly so vital a part of Thorin’s life. The whole thing made no sense. What kind of madness was this?
He was not ready, either, for the helpless anger that surged in him when he realised that the Thorin he had known had dissolved completely into greed and bitterness. Bilbo could not believe that the famed King under the Mountain was so weak that his own vows and principles meant nothing to him – no more than the loyalty of his brothers, which he had cast aside the moment they helped him reclaim Erebor. And that his own heart, which Bilbo had dared to place on Thorin’s scales against the “Heart of the Mountain,” proved lighter and less valuable than some stone.
And though Baggins had been warned that Oakenshield might well wish him dead, he still reeled when the king ordered him thrown from the battlement. No one was about to carry out the command, but Thorin was nothing if not decisive – and meant to finish it himself. He did not succeed. By some miracle, Gandalf arrived in time to stop him, and the dwarves helped Bilbo escape.
Events on the bastion unfolded so quickly that Bilbo scarcely had time to grasp what was happening. Only later, once he had put a safe distance between himself and Erebor, did he realise with surprise that the only things he had felt while Thorin dangled him halfway over the edge were a meagre flicker of fear and an overwhelming indifference. It did not hurt. He simply did not care. Toward the king who had tried to kill him, Bilbo felt nothing but pity and distaste; he did not know this Thorin, did not trust him, and so his actions could not truly wound him. Except by killing him, perhaps – but thankfully, it had not come to that.
All that remained was to hope that none of it had been in vain. And that they would yet manage to keep Thorin from dying – and from dragging Fili and Kili with him into the Halls of Mahal.
Chapter 10: The Battle. Part III. A Turn of Fate
Chapter Text
It was frightening. The vision had scared Bilbo half to death, and yet the worst was still ahead.
The army of elves and men was ready for battle only in theory. In truth, they were sorely outmatched, and everyone knew that without outside help they would not survive the ferocious, avalanche-like assault of the enemy’s legions. The first reinforcements came from an utterly unexpected quarter – from the dwarves. Not from Erebor, whose gates remained firmly blocked by the shattered remains of a massive stone statue, but from the Iron Hills. At Thorin’s secret request, a small yet fierce force had set out in great haste: five hundred dwarves under the command of Thorin Oakenshield’s cousin, Dáin Ironfoot.
At first, Dáin had actually intended to fight the elves – some of whom had taken up positions right at Erebor’s gates – having no inkling whatsoever of the vast orc host on the march. But the course was to change when the enemy came flooding into the valley. The orcs cared nothing for the petty quarrels of dwarves, elves, and men; they meant to crush them all alike. And so, though small in number and wholly unexpected, Dáin’s company arrived just in time. Even so, the chances of victory were still painfully slim.
Like a raging tide, the that vermin surged forward in wild disorder. Their assaults, led by Azog, were not as successful as he might have wished, but they struck home all the same. The elves and Dáin’s forces worked together with surprising precision to thin the ranks of orcs and wargs: while some attacked, others reloaded their weapons, ready to take their place in turn. For a moment, it seemed as though Azog’s onslaught was beginning to falter – but if only that had been the end of it.
Bilbo met the beginning of the battle in Dale. While part of the elven host and the dwarves held back the legions in the valley by the Mountain, and another part of Thranduil’s army lay in wait on Ravenhill for the second wave, the men of Esgaroth, together with Gandalf and Bilbo, were hard-pressed to defend the city.
Bilbo drew the attention of one orc while one of the men’s archers took aim at its head. The hobbit had been an “experienced” target since the very start of the journey, so he knew how to behave under fire. Somewhere nearby, Gandalf was struggling to make Radagast’s staff obey him, and Bilbo could hear him thumping it irritably with his palm, trying to coax at least some response out of it. Baggins had no idea what had become of Gandalf’s own staff, but the replacement was clearly a poor substitute.
The hobbit could not stop glancing back toward the gates of Erebor. From the vision he knew that Thorin would clear them one way or another and join the battle, but he had no idea when that would happen. One could only hope it would be before Bolg’s legions arrived from Gundabad. Bilbo was afraid of missing Oakenshield’s appearance – and of failing to help him, though he did not yet know how he might do so. He cast yet another look toward the Mountain when something heavy struck him on the head, and he blacked out at once.
He came to in the very place where he had fallen. Gandalf was leaning over him, his face etched with open concern, a thin line of blood running down from his temple. Bilbo jerked himself up onto his elbows and immediately regretted it – his head spun, splitting in two like a cracked nut.
“You took quite a knock. I’m glad you’re all right,” Gandalf said, nodding toward a large stone lying nearby – the very thing that had sent Bilbo into oblivion. An orc must have thrown it. The hobbit winced and touched the throbbing spot on his head. It really had been a solid hit. Baggins wiped his bloodied hand on his trousers with a grimace; this was no time for niceties. Of all things, no one had thought to put mithril on his head, and there was no helmet small enough to fit him in Dale. Squinting, Bilbo looked around, trying to take in what he had missed.
“Thorin?”
Bilbo and Gandalf were on the outskirts of the cit, from where there was a clear view of Erebor’s gates. When Baggins finally focused and saw a vast, gaping breach where they had been, his breath caught, and he could not bring himself to ask the next question. His gaze darted between Gandalf and the Mountain. The Wizard understood at once what the hobbit wanted to know.
“The horn sounded from Erebor, Bilbo,” Gandalf said quietly. “The King under the Mountain has made his choice.”
☜ ☞
The first real divergence from the vision came with Bolg’s attack. The orcs from the North were utterly convinced that they would meet no resistance on Ravenhill, but the moment they poured out of their caves, the Wood-elves drenched them in a deadly rain of arrows, and the enemy ranks thinned at once. Before long, however, it became clear that the stream was not running dry. The few elves holding the height were gradually forced back from their positions and driven down into the valley.
Bilbo knew that by then the course of the battle in the vision and the battle unfolding before his eyes had finally parted ways: by all rights, Thorin should already have been there with Fili and Kili, standing where the elves now fought. The future had grown murky, though a heavy foreboding would not leave Baggins – that the end would be all the same.
Pleased with his son’s progress, Azog turned his full attention to the valley. Seated astride a massive white warg, he scattered united forces with casual sweeps of his mace. Bilbo watched his jerky movements across the field in mounting despair, and when he traced their path, he realized with a jolt that the Defiler was hacking his way toward the right flank of the combined host, where the dwarves who had come out of Erebor were fighting just as desperately.
Toward Thorin. He was closing in on Thorin.
Bilbo looked at Gandalf in mute appeal, but the Wizard only shook his head. He knew that going after Thorin would be a suicidal folly, far beyond the hobbit’s strength. Gandalf could not abandon the men of Dale and go with him, and alone Bilbo would be torn to shreds by the first orcs he met. For the first time in his life, Baggins cursed the fact that he had been born an ordinary, weak hobbit, nothing at all like his forebear Bandobras Took, who had once lopped off goblin heads as if they were golf balls.
A thunderous roar rolled down from Ravenhill. Something new. Bilbo saw Gandalf break into a grin. What on earth was he so pleased about? Squinting toward the height, Bilbo saw orcs scattering in every direction from a gigantic bear that was crushing them like grapes beneath its paws.
Beorn. Beorn had come.
Baggins found himself grinning back at the Wizard. But the good mood vanished in an instant when Bilbo’s eyes returned to the slaughter in the valley. Oakenshield, Fili, Kili, and Dwalin were cut off from the rest of the dwarves, who had been pressed into a tight ring elsewhere. Balin, you had one job – may Smaug chew you up and spit you out. Rationally, Bilbo knew how hard the fighting was, and that it was not always possible for the dwarves to stay close to their king, but the sight was painfully familiar. Panic seized him: in his vision, this was how the end had begun. Only now Dwalin might fall as well. This was not at all how Baggins had planned to use his chance to change the future – but then, when had anyone ever cared about his plans?
Somewhere nearby, the bear roared again, deafeningly loud. The skin-changer was carving a steady path into the valley. Close behind him, Wood-elves followed over the mountains of corpses, swiftly finishing off any creature foolish enough to have survived an encounter with Beorn. Bilbo narrowed his eyes in thought – a sudden idea had taken shape. And the more he turned it over in his mind, the more tempting it became.
Gandalf eyed the suddenly quiet hobbit with suspicion; moments ago, Bilbo had been unable to keep still. The Wizard had barely time to call out before Baggins bolted headlong toward Ravenhill. Olórin let out a heavy breath, sank wearily onto a large boulder, and laid his staff across his knees. With a grim frown, he watched the once exemplary hobbit of the Baggins family charge, without a backward glance, small sword in hand, straight into the heart of the most brutal fighting.
“No… it seems my relief was premature.”
☜ ☞
Bilbo dimly remembered how, as a child, he had once or twice crashed headlong into enormous trees while charging through the woods in search of adventure. His mother had cleaned the wounds and soothed his badly shaken father, insisting that nothing terrible had happened. It seemed she had been mistaken. The consequences had simply lain dormant, biding their time. The meeting of his head with a stone in Dale proved fatal in that long chain of concussions.
The hobbit ran flat out away from the city, down a slope that ended in a sheer drop. Directly below lay the descent from Ravenhill, where battered orcs were fleeing at breakneck speed, driven by Beorn and harried by elves. Just in time – please, just in time. Really, he had no business worrying whether he might fail to carry out a plan that outdid even the wildest madness of Dragon-sickness. He tried very hard not to dwell on just how questionable an idea it was to leap off a cliff – and land squarely on the back of a gigantic, enraged bear. There simply wasn’t time for that.
Reaching his mark, Bilbo skidded to a halt and froze, waiting for the right moment. His heart felt ready to burst from his chest, but he forced himself to focus. Suppose he managed to grab hold of Beorn – there was still every chance the skin-changer would tear him apart on the spot without ever stopping to see who he was. Yet this was his only chance to reach Thorin and the other dwarves. And Bilbo had good reason to believe the bear was headed that way: Azog was pushing in the same direction. He remembered Beorn’s tale of his family, told during their first meeting, and knew that he would not shrink from settling accounts with the white orc for all the suffering the Defiler had brought upon him.
The first wave of wargs and orcs thundered down the slope. Bilbo steadied his breathing and took a few careful steps back. He slid Sting into its sheath, adjusted his mail, and ran.
The next moments were guided by instinct alone; any hesitation would have cost him his life. He slammed painfully into the back of the charging bear but managed to latch on before he could slip free. The skin-changer let out a furious roar, yet did not slow – and, mercifully, did not turn on Bilbo, who buried himself as deep into the thick fur as he could and did his utmost to appear lifeless (as far as that was possible), so as not to draw Beorn’s attention.
The bear tore across half the valley in a blur, trampling the enemies that dared to attack him. Bilbo could no longer feel his arms or legs, but he was not ready to let go, and clung on with a death grip. His reckoning proved correct – they were heading for the right flank. All that remained was to scrape together enough strength to finish what he had begun.
When Beorn smashed through the ring that separated the other dwarves from Thorin and slowed for a heartbeat upon spotting Azog, Bilbo wrenched open his petrified fingers with titanic effort and dropped like a sack of grain to the ground, landing right at Glóin’s feet. The dwarf raised his sword instinctively, then checked himself just in time, recognizing the limp bundle as their Burglar.
“Mahal, Bilbo – where in Eru’s name did you come from?” Glóin helped the disoriented hobbit to his feet. The first attempt failed, but with Bofur rushing in to help, they managed to get Bilbo upright, swaying on legs that would barely bend.
“Thorin… Kili…” Bilbo drew Sting with trembling hands and looked to the right, where he had last seen the King under the Mountain with his nephews and Dwalin.
Thorin lay on the ground, his armour pierced, straining to reach Orcrist. Blood poured from wounds in his leg and shoulder, streaking his face as well. Nearby, battered Fili and Dwalin were still fending off orcs with difficulty; before their very eyes, a huge orc struck Kili aside with a savage blow of its mace.
Bilbo’s reaction – still driven by the surge of adrenaline from his wild ride on Beorn – was instantaneous. “Déjà vu” was the only thought that flashed through his mind as he hurled himself toward the King, over whom some giant orc was already raising his weapon. Without a moment’s pause, he threw his whole body over Oakenshield, covering the gaps in his shattered armour.
The last thing he remembered was the eyes – filled with horror, yet clear at last, free of the shadow that had held them. Thorin’s eyes.
Chapter 11: The One
Chapter Text
Among the Khuzd there was a belief that, in one way or another, each of them had the One – but to meet someone meant for them was a rare stroke of fortune. Many never found a mate at all, not because they waited in blind faith for such a meeting, but simply because life unfolded that way. Those who did kindle their own hearth often shared it not with their One, but with someone who seemed the most worthy choice. No dwarf devoted their life to a futile search for a “true match” – the children of Mahal were practical, self-reliant folk who forged their own happiness instead of waiting for alms from a fickle fate.
Thorin had always believed the One to be a middling fairy tale for idle minds – those who could not find a real purpose or calling. Dís shared that view and bound herself in marriage to a skilled warrior and master smith of no great lineage, for whom she felt no passion, yet whom she respected without measure. There was great warmth between them, and in that hearth, for as long as Oakenshield could remember, trust and harmony had reigned. Choosing a partner by such measures was simpler and far more comprehensible than chasing a mythical, true love.
He was one hundred and ninety-five years old – a considerable age for a dwarf. All those decades he had lived unpaired, and only once, in early youth, had he wondered what that mythical One might be like, what he would wish that dwarf to be. He had never kept a mental list of “could I ever have imagined that…”, because he had always known, at least roughly, what he wanted and what to expect. But now, standing beside the bed and looking at Bilbo – his small body swathed in strips of linen – there was a first entry on that list:
“…that I would meet Him?”
And that he would understand it far too late.
Thorin never counted himself among the most perceptive of dwarves, especially where feelings were concerned – his own included, all the more so those he had only ever heard of from others. Still, he had not thought that such a realization would reach Balin, or Bofur, or any other of his brothers before it reached him. He was angry at himself for being so deaf and blind to the signs, and at the others for not seeing fit to spell them out for him. “We didn’t want to interfere, and then you were not yourself.” Balin had clearly misunderstood the duties of a king’s counselor.
When they finally sat down for a thorough conversation about everything that had happened during Azog’s attack and after, Bilbo inevitably came up. Thorin himself remembered little beyond the moment he lost consciousness, having failed to shove the Burglar off him before the orc’s mace met Bilbo’s back. The hobbit, in a desperate attempt to save the King under the Mountain, had shielded him with his own body, likely trusting in the protective virtues of mithril. But even mithril could not guarantee the absence of serious injury beneath the mail, and the blow that struck Baggins’s back was so fierce it left one massive, dark bruise from shoulder to hip. Worse still, no one could say for certain how deep the damage went or whether any organs had been affected – though Tharkûn assured Oakenshield that all would be well.
In Thranduil’s tented camp at Dale, the Wood-elves’ finest healers worked long and painstakingly over the hobbit. After several days, Thorin – who had been put back on his feet himself, though he was far from fully recovered – insisted on being allowed to move Bilbo into one of Erebor’s chambers. There Óin could watch over him, having helped care for both King and Burglar all this while. Gandalf, too, had promised to visit from time to time, to check on one reckless hobbit and lend whatever aid was needed.
Balin told Thorin of Bilbo’s vision, and of how the Battle of Erebor had ended in victory for the allied host of dwarves, elves, and men not least because of him.
The King stepped away from the head of the bed and sank heavily into a wooden chair. The movement sent a sharper throb through his right shoulder and left hip than usual – the battle refused to be forgotten.
“Mahal…” Oakenshield would not ask the Maker what he had done to deserve this; he could list a long chain of reasons himself, with his madness over the Arkenstone leading them all. The memory of his state during that final month in Erebor sent a flush of heat through him. He had forfeited the right to lead his people when greed and avarice outweighed his honor – and the lives of his brothers-in-arms, the lives of his own nephews. Dís would never forgive him for that. And there was no certainty she ever would, once she learned everything. He would not forgive himself – and had no intention of trying.
But what had Bilbo done to deserve this?
Twice he had saved Thorin’s life, and in return had nearly lost his own twice because of Thorin himself. An ugly, unjust balance. And there was nothing Thorin could do, yet the hobbit had mended an entire future for his sake. During their talk, Balin had held something back, but under the weight of Thorin’s gaze and a few pointed questions, he yielded and told him the rest: Bilbo’s vision had foretold three deaths – the one of Oakenshield, and those of his nephews. Thorin had been struck speechless, scant gift though his words already were.
They had agreed to carry that knowledge to the grave, yet Oakenshield could not stop thinking of it. Bilbo had run headlong through a blood-soaked chaos where he could have been killed outright, all for a single, slender chance to help save an ungrateful King under the Mountain. The only payment Thorin could offer the small hobbit was his own life, given wholly and without reserve. But what use would that be to Bilbo, after all Thorin had put him through? A paltry price for deeds beyond measure.
And yet he would try – try to use the chance he still had to show the hobbit just how much he meant to him. Dwarves were the smiths of their own fate; surrender was not in their blood. And Oakenshield, late though it was, would fight for Him to the very end.
His eyes burned with exhaustion. Thorin allowed himself to lean back against the high, carved chair and slipped into a restless doze.
☜ ☞
Bilbo was studying the tray with keen interest. It had been brought to him not long ago by Bombur, who had been beaming with joy. The choice fell on mushroom soup, and the hobbit carefully took the spoon in his left hand to taste it. Two weeks had passed since the battle ended, and a week since he had woken. His body ached all over, and every movement still came with effort – but for food… for food, he was willing to endure far worse.
He managed to scoop up a little broth and bring the first spoonful to his mouth.
Wonderful. Bombur truly knew his way around a kitchen.
The large chamber where he lay was unusually quiet. Unusual because from the very day he had regained consciousness until now, the dwarves had scarcely left him alone. There had always been one, two, or more visitors at a time, peppering the pale hobbit with questions and regaling him with stories of their own. Fili and Kili came especially often – restless as ever, and though the latter looked nearly as battered as Baggins himself, his energy was boundless. Bombur came bearing food, and Óin with bandages and medicines.
Bilbo finished the soup and glanced at the meat pies, but decided to pause: his back had begun to throb mercilessly. He slowly eased himself back against the pillow and closed his eyes with a small, contented sigh – the hot broth spread a pleasant warmth through him. His thoughts drifted lazily, tangled with memories of the past few days.
One of the last of the group to visit him was Balin, who had finally managed to break free from the staggering number of duties that had fallen on him after the battle. The road to restoring Erebor would be long and difficult, and part of that burden rested on his shoulders. He asked a few polite questions about Bilbo’s health and, nodding with satisfaction at the answers, took a seat beside the bed.
Bilbo felt a strong urge to ask about Thorin.
Oakenshield was the only one who had not come to see him even once since he woke, and the absence was beginning to weigh on him. Sensible explanations came to mind, along with far less pleasant ones. The King under the Mountain surely had far more on his plate than Balin – his absence could easily be put down to sheer busyness. But still…
“Balin,” Bilbo ventured, “have you had the Arkenstone returned?”
He would rather not have asked questions whose answers he dreaded, but the prickling curiosity got the better of him.
“Yes. Thorin paid the men the gold he promised, and Thranduil – after some hesitation on Thorin’s part, hehe – received his gems. So the bargain they proposed was honored.”
Balin noticed how Bilbo tensed, lips pressed thin. He understood perfectly why the hobbit was asking.
“Bilbo, Thorin has changed. I don’t think the Dragon-sickness will ever take hold of him again.”
Bilbo looked at him sadly and shook his head.
“You can’t know that. Last time, no one could have guessed what the treasure of Erebor – and that… stone – would do to him.”
Balin laid his hand over Bilbo’s.
“Last time, he was not so angry with himself. The Arkenstone consumed his thoughts and his heart – but believe me, now they are occupied with something else.”
There was something strange in Balin’s look and tone, as though he were hinting at more. He withdrew his hand and nodded toward the mail shirt neatly folded on the bedside table.
“Did you know mithril is an exceedingly valuable material? That coat is worth a kingdom.”
Bilbo eyed the armor doubtfully. He had assumed that anything from Erebor’s hoard was costly – but that costly? And Thorin had given it to him even while under the sway of the sickness?
“At the time Thorin gave it to you,” Balin added, “it was one of the most valuable thing he owned. The Arkenstone had not yet been found.”
Bilbo was beginning to sense where Balin was steering the conversation, but he could not bring himself to believe it.
“Balin… why did he give it to me? And why that?” He was not sure how best to phrase the question to test his suspicion, so he asked both at once.
“Oh, Bilbo,” Balin said, looking at him as of he were a child who simply could not grasp what was being explained, “you and Thorin are so blind it’s a wonder you noticed each other at all. Don’t interrupt, if you please.”
Bilbo had been about to protest the remark about blindness, but fell silent.
“Of course, you couldn’t have known what importance gifts hold among dwarves. Someone should have explained it to you–” (and it certainly ought to have been Thorin), “–for gift-giving is an entire rite, part of our ancient tradition…”
Balin tilted his head and hesitated. He was unsure whether he ought to say this himself, but there was no hope of Thorin doing so. The King could barely make sense of his own feelings to the very end, and explaining anything to Bilbo would never have occurred to him – even in ten years’ time.
“…of courtship,” the grey-bearded dwarf finished, lifting his brows and casting the hobbit a sly, mischievous glance.
“Uh… er–no, no, absolutely not,” Bilbo blurted.
While Balin struggled to keep his laughter buried in his beard, the hobbit went through every stage of accepting the information. He made incoherent sounds and flushed furiously, trying to form at least a single thought – with very little success. He drew his brows together so tightly that the muscles of his face began to ache.
At that moment, the door gave a plaintive thump as it opened – Óin had arrived for another check-up and a fresh dose of medicine. Balin hastily took his leave, leaving the healer puzzled by his muffled chuckling. Óin shrugged and went to Bilbo, but when he saw the hobbit’s crimson ears and cheeks, and the way he was gulping air, he broke into alarmed muttering.
“Mahal, Bilbo, are you unwell? What happened? Balin! Not a minute’s peace for our Burglar! I’ll lock him up until he’s fully recovered – orcs be cursed, I swear it!”
☜ ☞
Bilbo opened his eyes and felt well enough to turn his attention back to the tempting pies. While he had been lost in memories of a conversation that had taken place a couple of days ago, they had, to his regret, cooled a little. Balin had also mentioned then that it was Thorin who had insisted on moving the hobbit to Erebor – and into his former chambers at that – and that he had scarcely left Bilbo’s side right up until his awakening. To Bilbo’s very reasonable question, “Then why hasn’t he come to see me now, considering… er-everything you just said?” Balin had had no answer.
Bilbo hadn’t pressed him. Trying to make sense of what went on in Thorin’s head was a difficult business at the best of times. Often it was easier to feel the shifts in his mood than to guess the course of his thoughts. The hobbit was just reaching for his fourth pastry when the faint creak of the door reached his ears. Usually, any of the dwarves burst into the room with little ceremony, flinging the door wide open – sometimes with a foot, sometimes with a belly – so Bilbo tensed. Sneaking about was not their way.
Thorin appeared in the doorway.
Bilbo watched with undisguised interest as the dwarf, seemingly unaware of him, tried not to make a sound and closed the door almost as quietly as he had opened it. As far as Bilbo could recall, the King was the only one of their company – aside from their Burglar, of course – capable of moving nearly without a sound.
It seemed Oakenshield was quite certain he would not find Bilbo awake. When he turned toward the bed and met Baggins’s wide, intent stare, Thorin froze in a moment of uncharacteristic hesitation, then quickly pulled himself together.
“I see Bombur is taking excellent care of your meals, Mr. Baggins,” he stepped closer to the bed, but did not hurry to sit.
Great Eru, Bilbo thought, is my name some sort of insult to him?
“I understand that meals are of far greater importance to hobbits than to us. I won’t disturb you.”
Oh, look at him – so tactful. He might have remembered his manners when he tried to throw me off a battlement.
“And that is precisely why, Mr. Oakenshield, all of you managed to strip my pantries at Bag End bare in record time,” Bilbo replied, irritation creeping into his voice.
Thorin laughed outright; the “joke” clearly amused him, though Bilbo had meant every word.
“I’m glad to see you’re recovering.”
An awkward silence settled over the room. The King made no move to break it.
“Are you going to keep imitating an oak tree, Thorin?” Bilbo asked.
At the sound of his name, the veil of brooding slipped from Thorin’s face, and he finally took the chair beside the bed.
Bilbo felt a sudden surge of nerves and began to fidget with the edge of the blanket. Unhelpful fragments of his conversation with Balin came creeping back – particularly the part where courtship among dwarves had been mentioned so casually. Bilbo still could not believe such nonsense. Why would Thorin, with his rank and position, need a simple burglar? He had never given the slightest sign that he felt anything of the sort for Bilbo. And yet Balin had been so utterly convinced that Baggins, his head spinning with all this new information, had begun to doubt his own conclusions.
Which unsettled him more than he cared to admit – because the thought that he might mean that much to Thorin was… pleasant. Oakenshield mattered to him. But he did not want to comfort himself with illusions that the strange feeling was returned.
“Bilbo…”
He surfaced from his thoughts and looked up at the speaker. There was more silver in Thorin’s jet-black hair now, threaded through the intricate braids. He was looking at Bilbo as though preparing to leap headfirst into deep water. A chill ran down the hobbit’s spine. There was a flicker of something almost unhinged in those eyes – something Bilbo would have preferred not to notice.
Thorin cleared his throat.
“Bilbo… forgive me.”
Having said that, Oakenshield abruptly turned his head away and developed an intense interest in the carpet.
Is he… afraid? Of my reaction?
Bilbo continued to stare at the dwarf, drawn tight as a bowstring.
“Thorin, I don’t hold it against you – though I probably should, considering you very nearly pitched me headfirst off a massive wall.”
Thorin winced. Good. He remembered. And regretted it.
“You weren’t yourself,” Bilbo went on. Seeing that his words had done little to ease the tension, he tried again. “I’m just glad it all ended the way it did. That you’re all alive. That you’re alive, Thorin.”
Oakenshield stopped studying the floor and slipped a hand into his pocket. Feeling for something, he carefully drew out some object and enclosed it in his palms. Bilbo didn’t catch what it was. Thorin looked at him again.
“I am deeply sorry, Bilbo. I was blinded, and I put all of you – put you – in danger time and again,” the effort it cost him was clear; every word was steeped in bitterness and regret,“Forgive me for what I did at the gate.”
By the end of the sentence, he looked darker than an autumn sky. It hurt Bilbo to see him like this, especially now, when – at least he wanted to believe – the worst lay behind them. But no words came. Thorin took the silence in his own way and pressed on, turning the knife on himself.
“I do not deserve the forgiveness I ask for. Nor can I ever truly repay you for all that you have done for me… for us. But I will do everything in my power so that, at the very least, we may part as… friends.”
Bilbo stared blankly at the faltering dwarf.
Friends? Balin, you old rascal, what on earth did you see here?
His gaze drifted, unbidden, to the gleam of the mithril coat in the firelight, and his heart sank. Thorin followed his look and stiffened.
“I never meant to offend you with that… gift,” he said, once again drawing his own conclusions.
Bilbo’s temper finally snapped. Why were dwarves so difficult? Why was Thorin so difficult? Everything was riddles and half-hints, as though the only thing they could do directly was cleave someone in two with an axe.
“And what exactly did you mean by that gift, Thorin?” Bilbo shot back. “Balin told me one could buy the entire Shire with it, if one wished. And I made it perfectly clear back then that I am not a warrior and have no need of armor. Were you trying to buy me? So I’d help you find out who stole your precious Arkenstone?”
He was ashamed of his outburst. He hadn’t wanted to lash out at Oakenshield – but all the evasions, the slippery hints, combined with his bone-deep exhaustion, had done their work. The thought had crossed his mind more than once that Thorin had simply been bribing him, and that there had been no talk of some “courtship” at all. Balin’s words, however, had been so convincing, so tempting, that Bilbo had allowed himself to believe them, just a little.
He shouldn’t have. Balin had clearly been mistaken.
Thorin looked stunned by the sudden shift in Bilbo’s mood. The hobbit muttered a brief, “Sorry,” and scraped his fingernail against the tray.
“What else did Balin tell you?”
Bilbo narrowed his eyes but chose not to answer. He had already said far too much.
“Bilbo, please look at me.”
Reluctantly, Baggins abandoned his fascinating task and raised his eyes. The anger drained away at once, leaving only regret and a heavy sadness.
“I was not trying to buy your friendship,” Thorin said quietly. “I wanted to protect you. And… I wanted to show how important you are to me.”
Bilbo’s heart began to pound, a tremor running through him. Thorin’s voice dropped to a near-whisper.
“You have every right to doubt my sincerity – for obvious reasons. But I would do the same again.”
Only then did Bilbo notice the dark circles beneath Thorin’s eyes; thr looked utterly exhausted. Oakenshield opened his hands and took hold of the ends of a simple bronze chain, from which hung a small pendant.
Bilbo’s mouth fell open.
He would not have been surprised even by the Arkenstone itself – but an acorn, a simple little wooden acorn capped with bronze on a chain, struck him straight to the heart. Something inside him gave way, and Bilbo began to cry, silently.
Thorin panicked and sprang to his feet, gently gripping Bilbo’s shoulders.
“Bilbo, what’s wrong? Are you unwell? Should I fetch Óin?”
A lump rose in Bilbo’s throat, stealing all words from him. Ignoring the ache in his back and arms, he pulled Thorin toward him and hugged him, burying his face in the dwarf’s chest. Oakenshield stiffened at first, then awkwardly sat down on the bed beside him and carefully wrapped his arms around the sobbing hobbit. He had expected many things – this was not one of them.
Bilbo shifted, and Thorin loosened his hold. Pulling back a little, the hobbit fished a handkerchief from beneath the pillow and wiped his face, though the tears still would not stop.
“Thorin, you are such an… Oakenshield.”
Thorin broke into a soft smile.
“You have no idea how much this means to me,” Bilbo said more quietly, looking at the pendant.
Thorin shook his head, smile never fading. He leaned in until their foreheads touched.
“Bilbo,” he murmured, “it is you who has no idea how much You mean to me.”
