Actions

Work Header

Easier to Lie

Chapter 3: Your Eyes Open

Summary:

the company ventures from imladris to the mountains, and bilbo and bofur fall behind for a little conversation

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

“C’mon now, we need t’ be going,” Bofur gave his brother a guiding tug, as the younger dwarf was still drowsily considering getting up. The rest of the company had been gathering in pairs, slipping off quietly without the elves totally being aware of what they were doing, with the express instructions to meet once outside the city and set off together. At this point however, Bofur was fairly certain that they were the last remaining dwarves. Giving his brother another tug, he peered out of the room to check for curious elven eyes before the pair of them made their way quietly through the city.

When they had slipped out of the city and rejoined their companions, they were only briefly chastised before the company made their way for the mountains, hardly turning to look back. That is, except for the hobbit. He seemed to have fallen for the beautiful elven city more than the dwarvish company, and from the wistful look in his eyes he would surely miss it.

As they made their way up the mountain road the hobbit trailed behind the rest, his gaze alternating from the ground beneath his feet to the splendour of Imladris that was fast disappearing behind them. The mountains loomed ahead of them, enormous and potentially threatening with the dark clouds that hung over their peaks, but for the most part everyone was quite cheerful.

Falling behind with Bilbo, Bofur was ever in good humour. “Wha’s on your mind, lad?”

The hobbit had hardly noticed him and was startled by his voice, but when he glanced up and saw the smile of the miner, he recovered.

“Hmm?” he answered, clearly so lost in whatever thought that he hadn’t even heard the words.

“Best keep your mind on th’ ground,” Bofur added, and he pulled the hobbit closer to the mountain wall beside them so he was not quite so close to the sheer drop.

“What? Oh…yes you’re probably right,” Bilbo replied and it seemed for the first time he noticed just how precarious of a drop it was, because he pulled even closer to the safety of the mountainside and had to stop for a moment to recover himself.

“Y’alright lad?”

“No no no I’m…I’m fine,” Bilbo answered quickly, and he was able to cast a glance at the dwarf with his best – though easily seen to be forced – smile. There was no mistaking the fact that he’d just given himself a minor heart attack with how close he’d been to danger.

“What were y’ thinkin’ about?”

The hobbit shook his head, his golden curls bouncing around his youthful face. Or at least it looked youthful, given his lack of facial hair. Sometimes when he talked however, he seemed as old as the best among them. “It’s nothing, really.”

Bofur slowed his pace so they were able to fall behind from the others some distance, and for the moment they remained unnoticed. “Oh c’mon, you can tell ol’ Bofur.” And he took a moment to remove his pipe from among his things, then produced some pipeweed, packing first his own pipe and then offering some to the hobbit, as he’d seen him smoking before.

Bilbo hesitated before accepting what was offered him, leaning against the mountainside so he could rummage through his things and pull out his own pipe. He packed the pipeweed in and then Bofur set about to lighting them both quickly. Once that task was done, they fell into step again, not wanting to fall too far behind the company, but still allowing ample space between themselves and anyone else who might overhear. The pipeweed seemed to settle the hobbit, though his eyes still had that glazed look of someone who was directed inwards, rather than outwards.

“So,” Bofur pressed after the silence had lingered for long enough by his measure. “Wha’s on your mind?”

Bilbo sighed, exhaling a thin cloud of smoke between his lips and gazed forward towards the mountains. Whatever was bothering him seemed to bear heavily on his mind, and his secrecy about it made the issue all the more of interest to the miner. Nothing should bother someone like Bilbo. His “gentle” demeanour should have earned him at least a little peace of mind.

When he finally seemed ready to speak, the hobbit’s voice dropped quite low as he leaned in to address his companion. “Well…I just…” He hesitated and took another deep lungfull of pipeweed, letting the smoke out with more control this time. A tiny circle of smoke drifted into the air and dissipated. To shift the focus from himself, he suddenly changed topics. “When do you suppose Gandalf will be back?”

“He’s Gandalf; he’ll be back,” Bofur replied with some authority to his voice, though he hadn’t missed the attempt at redirection. “Can’t go too far without him, can we?” he added with a hint of a joke in his tone. His eyes glanced ahead to the rest of the company. Their distance hadn’t been noticed by anyone save Balin, though the aged dwarf only gave them a quick backward glance before sharing a kindly smile and returning to his conversation with Fíli.

“No, I suppose we can’t,” the hobbit agreed, and he turned his attention back to his feet. The further they walked the more the mountain chill seemed to bite into them, but the hobbit was doing his best to appear as strong and hearty as the rest of them, never mind his garb was completely useless in heavy weather. The miner noticed but chose not to comment at the present.

“Was that wha’ was on you mind jus’ now?” he continued, knowing full well that it wasn’t, for Bilbo’s behaviour said whatever troubled him still controlled his mind.
Bilbo stopped in his tracks and sighed deeply, and for a moment Bofur wasn’t sure whether he was distressed or simply annoyed that he hadn’t forgotten about the troubling thought. It was always hard to tell with Bilbo – his distress often mascaraed as annoyance, which had been evident when they arrived at his home in the Shire. “You noticed?” he spoke finally, his free hand fisting at his side as he took in another lungfull of smoke. He let it out without any control, the smoke simply spreading from every orifice it could escape from, clouding him for a moment.

“One thing I’ve learned,” Bofur answered with his ever pleasant smile, “is no’ t’ keep too much inside.” He took the opportunity to tap the hobbit’s chest with his free hand once, to indicate his heart.

The action was not unwelcome, though it elicited a response in the hobbit that was difficult to read. Bofur had gotten rather good at reading others, but the expression on Bilbo’s face was as cryptic to him now as Kíli’s statement had been the night before.

But all the same, it seemed to do the trick because the hobbit smiled genuinely. “You’re probably right,” he admitted, then his smile faded into a layer of sadness – or perhaps it was disappointment? “I can’t win.”

“Wha’ d’y’mean?”

“I mean this,” Bilbo continued, gesturing ahead of him to the rest of the company, who as yet still had taken no notice of the pair of them. Not even Balin, who had noticed them previously, had cast them another wayward glance.

“The mountains?”

“No no no,” Bilbo sighed and took another inhale from the pipe, though he took it with a bit too much gusto and ended up coughing and sputtering. That did the trick and within moments the others had stopped to look back at the pair of them.

“Y’alright there, lad?” Bofur patted his companion’s back in the hopes to help him breathe, and though he was clearly alright, he continued to cough for a few more moments, each puff accompanied by another little burst of smoke.

Ahead of them, in his deep commanding voice, Thorin shouted, “Don’t fall so far behind. The mountains are treacherous, and it looks like we may be coming into a storm.” It was all he said to them, before directing the others to keep moving.

When Bilbo seemed able to breathe normally again, Bofur helped him to walk until he forced the dwarf to release him. Emptying the pipe with mild defiance and then storing it away in his things, he adjusted his jacket around himself and nodded his head once, with firm certitude. “That’s what I mean.”

“Y’ mean Thorin?”

“Well he isn’t too fond of me, now is he?” Bilbo expounded, though he kept his voice low as they drew closer to the company. “I can’t seem to do anything right.”

“Don’ let it bother you,” Bofur replied gently. “He’s got a lot on his mind righ’ now. He’ll come round.”

He felt like he’d had this conversation before.

“Yes well,” Bilbo continued, acknowledging the other’s words with a quick glance. “That’s not exactly what I meant.”

The statement left the dwarf dumbfounded. It was evident in his expression and Bilbo just waved it off absently.

“Never mind. I shouldn’t have said anything.”

Wha’ did you mean? “ Bofur pressed, but Bilbo simply shook his head again and walked off ahead of him.

“You wouldn’t understand.”

“You don’t know tha’,” Bofur responded without hesitation, and he quickened his pace to catch up with the hobbit so they were again walking side by side.

“Oh yes I do,” Bilbo confirmed, and that cynical side of him seemed to be slipping off.

“No, you don’.”

Bilbo stopped in his steps and gave Bofur a look that said he was reaching the end of his patience – or maybe he was just dealing with his own inner distress – but he seemed to be caving to the dwarf’s persistence. “It’s…complicated.”

“Alright.”

The hobbit hesitated again, dragging his feet as he glanced first at Bofur, then ahead to the company. When he seemed content that they were far enough to not overhear, he finally forced out, “I guess I’d just…I’d like for us to be friends.”

“Well…that’s no’ so bad, laddy,” Bofur responded with an encouraging smile, and he gave the hobbit’s shoulder a reassuring squeeze.

Bilbo flushed at the statement and looked down, not willing to meet the other’s eyes. “Maybe…more than friends.”

For the first time in a while Bofur had no idea what to say, but one thing was certain. That odd stirring sensation he’d felt while sketching by the fire flared up again, filling his chest and spreading to his stomach while licking his shoulders. It was not what he’d expected the other to say, nor was it the reaction he would have anticipated from himself.

His expression must have shifted noticeably because Bilbo paled. “You won’t mention anything to the others, will you?” he pleaded, suddenly the fear of being found out overwhelming him. It snapped Bofur out of the awareness of what was going on inside of him and he was able to pull a smile from somewhere inside him.

“Oh don’ worry about tha’. Your secret’s safe with me.”

Notes:

bofur feels, and bitchy thorin is bitchy.

i've gone with movieverse in this one, making gandalf stay behind, mostly because i don't want him creeping on bofur and bilbo's alone time (and you know, being a wizard, he totally would). as always, r&r appreciated.