Chapter Text
Things were moving in slow motion as the pair rejoined the group. Perhaps not so much for Bilbo, for the hobbit had no idea what was going on inside his companion, but for Bofur’s own part he was as lost now as the hobbit had been when he dropped behind to talk to him. Only this time the shift went unnoticed. At least by most. Bilbo moved forward through the line until he was about halfway through their company, and Bofur tried to stay close enough to him as to keep an eye on him. However he didn’t seem quite ready to speak to the hobbit, as the confession had destabilized him.
How does one reset themself when someone else reaches inside and flips them about? That’s what it felt like was going on. Prior to Bilbo’s simple confession, it had seemed that the dwarf simply had a kind of caring affection for the hobbit. But now that he knew the hobbit might have feelings for their leader – for Thorin – it finally dawned on the miner that perhaps his affections were more than just friendly. And that realization troubled him the most.
Taking his hand and rummaging through his things until he found the flask that contained his portrait, he held it for a time in his hand, just secure in the knowledge that it existed, and perhaps more aware of its meaning. Had he known the moment he began the work what he knew now, he might not have finished it. Likely he wouldn’t have started it. Glancing up to the head of the company where Thorin charged on – proud, strong, majestic – Bofur couldn’t help but feel ridiculous about his own emotions. That he would discover all too late that he might have feelings for the hobbit, when the hobbit cared for Thorin, was enough to make anyone feel ridiculous.
A miner from the Blue Mountains was no comparison to the heir of Durin.
The higher they got, the more treacherous the road, and it wasn’t too long after they rejoined the others that it started to rain. The drops fell lightly at first, but hardly an hour had passed before the rain fell so heavily that it was difficult to see too far ahead, nor to hear one another over the deluge. Bofur stayed close to Bilbo, knowing full well that despite the fact that the hobbit seemed quite capable of caring for himself (and, for all intents and purposes, the rest of them) he would be unable to allow anything to happen to him. That one thing was very clear to him. Bilbo was too important to let anything happen to him. Too important to the company. Too important to the quest. Too important to him.
Once the hobbit proved him right by losing his balance and getting precariously close to the edge, but Bofur and several other nearby hands. He tried to speak words of encouragement, but they were lost in the roar of the wind and the crashing of the rocks. It was then that Balin’s voice was able to pull above the torrent - a thunder battle. Then they saw them, altogether for the first time.
“Giants! Stone Giants!”
It was difficult to see exactly what was happening over the swiftly falling rain, but the very ground beneath their feet seemed to move of its own accord, and before they realized what was happening, the company was split in two, each half clinging to the wall behind them as they watched the others pass them by. Without thinking, Bofur took hold of the hobbit’s hand, holding onto it tightly to keep him from harm. He wasn’t certain whether the hobbit knew; indeed, he hardly was aware himself, though when the stone giant on which they stood fell, and it looked as though they were all going to be smashed into the mountainside, impulse drove him to squeeze the hand he now held dearly, fearing it would be the last.
Fortunately the ledge above them protected them as it crashed into another ledge, the rock shattering above their heads as it spilled them onto the mountainside. Bofur’s ears were still ringing with the rain and wind when the rest of the company came upon them. He reached over to find Bilbo…only the hobbit wasn’t there.
Panic seized him.
Bilbo was hanging from the edge. He hadn’t landed on the ledge like the rest of them. He was holding on for dear life.
Leaning down and reaching for his hand, Bofur grasped for him in the desperate attempt to help him back up, but the hobbit only slipped further.
He would be lost.
It was at that time that Thorin took command and swung himself down the precipice; grabbing the hobbit and forcing him back up onto the ledge, risking life for the sake of the hobbit.
The moment it happened Bofur realised what he had lost. Or, rather, what he could have done. Still, he had pulled Bilbo back up to safety as Dwalin helped Thorin onto the ledge once more, and as Bilbo recovered his breath Bofur didn’t let go of his arm.
“For a moment there, I thought we had lost our hobbit,” Dwalin joked, his voice breaking through the deafening downfall. Bofur had thought so too, and it had been terrifying. But Thorin shattered the moment with his deprecation.
“He’s been lost ever since he stepped out his door. He’s thought nothing of his warm fire and his books since he left home.”
The words could easily have stabbed the hobbit in the heart, and just by glancing at his expression, it was clear they had. And, despite the fact that Bofur wanted the hobbit to himself, just that pained look on his face was enough to make the dwarf want to challenge their leader. How could Thorin hurt Bilbo so?
“Don’ mind him, lad,” he spoke consolingly to the hobbit, and he helped him to his feet. Yet once again Bilbo was all inside his head. He didn’t seem to feel Bofur’s hand on his shoulder, guiding him into the cave, and he hardly registered the discussions of the watch, or reconnecting with Gandalf. The hobbit simply made his way to the back of the cave and lay down, alone. Bofur had wanted to follow him, and had he not been assigned the first watch, he would have. However he did keep the corner of his eye fixed on Bilbo and Bilbo alone as he sat facing the entrance of the cave.
The hobbit hardly moved at all.
The night was cold. Even sheltered from the wind, the rain, and the battling giants, it still had a bitter chill that seemed to radiate from the very rocks of the walls. Bofur lit his pipe again and set about to smoking it as a way to ease his mind. There was too much to think about.
Finally turned his attention fully to the door, he fingered the flask once again. It was safe, for now. He opened it and delicately removed the parchment and unrolled it to look upon it in the dim light of the cave. It was still dry, completely unblemished. Perfect.
He rolled it back up and put it away in the flask.
The hours felt like no time at all as his thoughts ran away with him. He was still lost on the hobbit’s confession about Thorin. So Bilbo loved Thorin? Was that it? And Thorin did little else but insult him. Treat him as if he were a burden.
It was difficult in that moment to know exactly what he felt. There was a part of him that saw Thorin’s distress. How difficult it was for the dwarf lord to maintain himself and his quest, even his mind in light of all he had seen and been through. And there was a part of him that felt Thorin had no right to criticize the hobbit in such a way.
And deep inside, hidden away somewhere that even he wasn’t sure he could find it, was a part of him that wanted Thorin to do exactly what he was doing, because the hobbit deserved better.
It was not the kind of thought that the normally optimistic dwarf would have, especially about their king. But something different seemed to rule him, now that the hobbit was involved. Bilbo’s feelings meant more to him than his own, and to see the look on his youthful face each time Thorin criticized him and cut him down hurt the miner almost as much as it seemed to hurt the other. Bilbo might have been of a gentler spirit, but he was tough when he had to be, and he had proven himself to them. Shouldn’t that had been enough?
His thoughts had gotten so beyond him that he hadn’t heard the stirrings in the back of the cave. It was when the hobbit tried to slip past him that he realized what was happening. He started suddenly, though he kept it low so as not to disturb the others. “Where do you think you’re goin’?”
Bilbo’s eyes had that same sad, disheartened determination about them when he turned and met the miner’s gaze. “Back to Rivendell.” Just the look on his face told Bofur that he meant it.
A panic once again seated itself and he stood up to persuade him. “No, you can’t leave now. You’re par’ o’ the company!” And as much as he meant it, he already sensed what Bilbo would say.
“I’m not though, am I?” It was like everything Thorin had said to the hobbit hadn’t left his mind since that moment, and though Bofur couldn’t agree, he couldn’t begrudge the hobbit that either. “Thorin was right. I never should have stepped out my door.”
What could he say to convince the hobbit to stay? Tell him that they could hardly handle the journey without him? Tell him that he couldn’t handle the journey without him?
“You’re homesick,” was what he finally settled on. “I understan’.”
“No you don’t!” Bilbo bit back. “You’re dwarves! You’re used to this life! To living on the road, to never settling in one place, to not belonging anywhere!”
And in that moment, Bofur knew exactly how Bilbo had felt.
His expression must have fallen considerably because Bilbo’s did too. “I…I’m sorry,” he apologized, but it hardly meant anything.
Bofur turned his back on the hobbit and glanced among his sleeping companions. “No, you’re righ’,” he replied softly. “We don’ belong anywhere.”
Would it have been worth it to express why he wanted the hobbit to stay? Would it make any difference now?
He thought not.
Turning back to look at Bilbo, he forced the ever-present smile. “I wish you all the luck in the world.” And he clapped him on the shoulder. “I really do.”
