Chapter Text
The hobbit wasn’t sure how to take what he’d overheard in the cell. His ears were still ringing as he walked on silent footfalls between the cells, now the only sounds to enter his brain were the snores of his sleeping companions. Softly, he continued into the depths until he was at Thorin’s solitary cell. Sitting down outside the bars, he allowed himself a gentle sigh that was so quiet it couldn’t have been heard over the noises of the elven structure.
Okay, Bilbo, he thought to himself as he sat there, pulling his arms around his body. What are you going to do about this now? It was difficult to think his way through what he had just heard. After all, it was only a half conversation, really. His knowledge of Khuzdul was marginal at best (he could recognise it being spoken, but what the words meant he couldn’t even guess) and it seemed that what words he had understood were only half spoken, hiding previous conversations, or unspoken knowledges that were shared.
In the cell behind him he could hear Thorin’s gentle breathing. He wasn’t snoring like the others. Perhaps he was awake.
There was nothing that the hobbit might hear from him however, given that he was alone. And he rarely spoke aloud.
His mind returning to the conversation in the cell, the hobbit couldn’t shake the implication that those words held. The first being that Thorin might have affection for him and the second being that his affections were not the only ones to be had.
He’d paused in the hall when he heard the mention of his name, drawn by the familiar melody coming from the cell, but never had he expected that he – a strange, peculiar, not-even-a-proper-burglar like himself – could cause so much apparent heartache. And even in light of the honesty, he still had a hard time believing it.
Replaying the conversation in his mind again, one sentence stood out among the others. Jus’ because I migh’…have feelin’s for the hobbit, doesn’t mean I can’ let ‘im go.
Foolish dwarves, Bilbo thought to himself, tightening his arms around his body as he let the realization sink in. How long had this been going on? Since Mirkwood? Before that? Since the mountains? Since Rivendell?
Then he recalled the conversation between himself and Bofur on the mountainside. And he remembered the exchange in the cave, before they’d been captured by the goblins. Since then. At the very least, since then.
He sighed again, this time audibly, and covered his face with his hands.
It never occurred to him that the dwarf might have feelings for him. Indeed, he hardly thought it possible that any of them should have feelings for him, let alone that he might be a possible object of conflict. And he had spilled to Bofur his feelings for Thorin, and then treated him so unkindly in the cave.
That explained a lot. It explained more than he had even realised needed to be explained in that moment.
Looking over his shoulder into the cell behind him, he saw Thorin’s form though the dwarf barely moved. He hardly looked like he was breathing, though the soft exhalations made it clear that he was. Bilbo wondered how Thorin felt. Did Thorin have feelings for him too? Was that why Kíli had spoken to Bofur in the first place? Were they rivals? Or, supposed rivals. It seemed Bofur had already decided he was out of the race. He’d said as much.
Bilbo, you fool, he thought again, gritting his teeth in frustration. Of course he would give up. You told him you wanted to be more than a friend to Thorin.
And he felt the fool as he pondered it further. The way Thorin had been treating him until they’d been rescued by the eagles. The cruel and careless things he’d said to him. And yet he still had feelings for the dwarf. And yet Bofur, who had been nothing but kind to him – even kinder, he realized, knowing that the dwarf knew all along that he had not chance – since the beginning. Sharing with him, offering him a listening ear, holding his hand in the frightening Mirkwood nights.
In the cell behind him, he heard a rustling and glanced over his shoulder at Thorin. The heir of Durin had been awake, and for a moment Bilbo wondered if his mystery included an ability to hear the hobbit’s thoughts.
As if in answer to that, the deep baritone spoke once, softly, “I know you are there, Halfling.”
Bilbo didn’t say anything, and it was all for the better, because a few moments later one of the elven guard walked down the hall and peered into the cell before walking back to his post.
After the elf vanished, Thorin got up and walked to the bars until he was quite close to the hobbit, and he sat down again, reaching through the bars until he was able to find what he had been blindly searching for – the hobbit’s hand. It was, in effect, no different than the nights they’d spent in that inky blackness of Mirkwood forest. Blinded by darkness, or the invisibility that was afforded by the ring made no difference to Thorin. He was able to find the small hand and hold it in his own, like it fit.
And all Bilbo could sense, as he returned the gesture, was that his left hand was empty.
“How are the others?” Thorin whispered after a while, keeping his voice low so the elven guard wouldn’t become aware of Bilbo’s presence. As yet, they had no knowledge that he was there, and if they were to escape it was best that they remained ignorant.
Bilbo swallowed, though when he responded there was an odd hoarse character to his voice, like his throat housed something foul. “They’re all still there,” he answered as candidly as possible, but he couldn’t escape that conversation he’d overheard.
“All 12 of them?”
“Yes.”
Thorin’s tone was pleased, though still soft. “And they are alright?”
“Yes, I suppose,” Bilbo replied, this time having to choke back a cough as the dryness in his throat became more pronounced.
“You suppose?”
Bilbo didn’t know what to say and pulled his hand out of Thorin’s. He didn’t respond to that question, but instead offered, “I think I’ve come up with a way for us to escape.”
“When?”
“Soon. There’s a river that runs under the city, and I’m…well I’m quite certain if I can get the keys, I can get us all out by that way.”
“Good.” Thorin’s voice raised a bit, though the echo and the sound of distant footsteps alerted him to the fact that he was speaking too openly. “And what then?” He reached a second time for Bilbo’s hand, but the hobbit moved just a bit to the side such that he wouldn’t be able to find a trace of him through the bars.
“I’ll explain it all when we get there,” Bilbo replied. He was so confused that he wasn’t certain what more to say, or how to act, or even what to do. So it was best to think on the escape plan.
Thorin laughed a bit, though it was a low, deep sound in his chest, and had Bilbo not known the sound of his voice so well he might not have heard it at all. “Gandalf was right about you.” When Bilbo didn’t respond, he continued, doing his best to mimic the wizard’s intonation, “there is more to Mr. Baggins than any of you yet know,” and he concluded with a hint of endearment, “including himself.”
“Apparently,” Bilbo echoed in a voice that was hollow. Whatever it was that Thorin was thinking of him, his mind was in a different place entirely. Thorin might have thought the more to him was his ability to get them out of tight situations, but for Bilbo the more he discovered about himself was his own ability to sew threads between others hearts and his own. “You should get some sleep,” he whispered again, and without another word he got up and walked back down the hall to the others.
Bilbo didn’t return to Thorin directly again until their escape. He walked the halls and kept his eyes on the entire dwarven company, but he spent more time with the others than he yet had before. Yet, despite all his waiting and the sensitive ears, he never again heard Bofur or Kíli mention his name. Nothing at all. Had he not been in the hall in that moment, at that time, he might have heard nothing at all.
He couldn’t decide whether that would have been a good thing or not.
Chance shone upon them when the elves had a celebration with lavish wine. The elven guard were careless in their duties, and it was hardly a challenge for the hobbit to steal the keys and systematically release the dwarves. Starting on one end of the hall, he went cell by cell, whispering brief instructions to the dwarves before releasing them. The last cell he went to before Thorin’s was the one in which Dori, Ori, Bofur and Kíli were all held. He had hardly opened the latch when the youngest pressed past him and collided with his brother, who had remained with Bilbo when the others went in the direction of the underground river. For the first time since the journey had begun, the youth of the two dwarves was most obvious in that moment. No longer brazen and foolhearty, they cried and clung to each other. The innocence of their youth made emotions plain and straightforward – unashamed even, in spite of the many eyes that saw the tight, frightened reunion. Dori and Ori went in the direction of the others and Bofur went to follow them, wanting more than anything to find Bombur and ensure that his younger brother was doing well but Bilbo caught his shoulder as he moved past, exchanging a brief glance with the dwarf before he went off with the others. Bilbo wanted so much to talk to him, but in that moment there wasn’t time.
Making his way to the last cell, he released Thorin, and hardly had a chance to say anything to the kingly dwarf before Thorin had pushed past him, making his way for the others. No thanks, not even a simple recognition of the hobbit’s presence other than a nod of the head in passing.
The more things changed, the more they stayed the same, Bilbo pondered to himself as he ran after him down the hall. Only a few nights prior, he’d been sitting by the cell and Thorin had snaked his hand through the bars just to hold his own. And that same night, he’d learned something valuable too. The same thought that continued to haunt him as he helped each of the dwarves safely into the barrels through which they were going to escape, and on as the barrels were thrown into the river and he clung to the exterior of one and was nearly drowned in the icy cold water.
He, Bilbo Baggins, not-even-a-proper-burglar, was loved. And he had no idea what to do with that knowledge.
