Actions

Work Header

Easier to Lie

Chapter 9: Kindly Unspoken

Summary:

lots of people thinking about stuff, both in barrels and on barrels.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

Something phenomenal happens when a group of people are left alone to their own thoughts. With enough time, it’s almost as though the boundary between one mind and another blurs, and thoughts slip in and out in a dance of sorts, shared and passed from one to other. And the permeable nature of these minds is unknown to others, though the same thought has travelled through them all. It started with the youngest, and nothing seemed to spark introspection quite like being alone in a barrel.

Well, at leas’ now I know.

It had been a battle to get Kíli into a different barrel from his brother, though arguably they might have been able to pull it off (after all, Bombur’s barrel was able to float, albeit a little lower than the others) but eventually the young dwarf had succumbed to being separated from him again, comforted only by the knowledge that they were, at the very least, no longer imprisoned, and that the second they were released from their current confines, nothing would be able to separate them.

And Kíli really needed to talk to his brother.

It had been a long time running, and though he’d often suspected and tried to drop subtle hints, he finally knew the truth. Bofur admitted his feelings for Bilbo. And more than that, he seemed content to continue loving him in spite of the fact that the hobbit showed no interest in him whatever.

And Bilbo was in love with his uncle. And his uncle seemed to have feelings for the hobbit, though he had a pretty horrible way of expressing them. The young archer added Thorin to his mental list of people he needed to talk to.

Then there was Kíli, the youngest, the end of the chain, the last little link. Where did he fit into all this mess? And what did he want? He wanted his uncle to be happy. He wanted Bofur to be happy too. But more than anything, he wished that Bofur might have been happy with him.

It was silly, in all actuality. Incredibly silly. So silly, in fact, that Kíli felt like a child whenever he tried to think about it. And compared to the rest of them, he was a child. Too young to go on the journey, if not for his uncle’s permission.

Too young to fully understand? He didn’t think so, but he didn’t know.

Stop tha’, Kí, he could almost hear his brother scolding him from inside his head. You don’ know for sure. You haven’ even ask’d ‘im yet.

I know enough, Fí, an’ get out o’ my head! he rebuffed with irritation, and he tried to steady himself as he shifted in the barrel. I’m jus’ Kíli.

I’m jus’ a silly dwarf.

Bofur patted the flask on his side several times as the barrel bobbed up and down, jostled by every small movement of his body and the water. At first the little leaks had discouraged him, but with as little of the water had made its way through his clothes, he was convinced that the portrait was still safe. The flask had kept it undamaged through the deluge on the mountainside – certainly it could keep the portrait safe from the little bits of water that sloshed in and dampened the bottom of the barrel.

It was strange to him, thinking back on their brief escape from the dungeons, the way Bilbo had lingered at the cell door. Relief had flooded the aging miner when he saw the hobbit there and alive, but there was something in Bilbo’s eyes that had struck him as he left him then. Something different. Like he’d aged more than the time they’d been down there. Bofur wondered what things he’d underwent in that place. What he’d seen. How he’d survived. How many times he’d attempted to free them, how many schemes had run through his little head before he’d settled on the success.

And a brilliant success it was, too. Right down to letting the elves themselves help the dwarves escape.

The hobbit often sold himself short.

The conversation in the cell was hardly fresh in his mind anymore, though the fuel behind it was always present. He wondered if Bilbo was with Thorin, or if perhaps the hobbit had found a way to bring himself closer to their leader. And the more he thought on that, the more he felt a dull ache that told him it was right. He just wished that Thorin might have been a bit more affectionate with him. If, as Kíli had implied, the feelings were there and Thorin had already laid claim to the Halfling, his abilities at winning the hobbit’s heart were lacking. Even in their escape initially, Thorin had been less than enthused about forcing himself into a barrel. There was no praise for the daring escape, no accolades for the brilliantly devised plan, only critique. Things were going back to the way they were at the beginning. Something was going on inside Thorin – that much was clear. The weight of the task, perhaps. And ever the optimist, Bofur had a difficult time holding that weight against Thorin, as his duty was far greater than the rest of theirs. But in spite of all that, he hated to see the hobbit suffer, for Bilbo did indeed suffer. Every time he was rebuffed by the dwarf lord, Bofur could watch the hobbit sink just a little bit more. Recognition was important to him, and more than anyone he deserved it.

Yet still, after all that he had seen and all that he had said, Bofur had given up this fight. Bilbo wanted Thorin, and Bofur wanted Bilbo to be happy. Even if it was with someone else. Patting the flask once more with a bittersweet smile crossing his face, he imagined the kind of friendship that could grow from being at the hobbit’s side; a companion, if that was all. Tha’ would be enough.

But is that really enough?

Clinging to the top of the barrel, Bilbo was having a hard time not losing the feeling in his limbs as the cold water bit into him, eating away at his nerves and slowly killing the sensation until he was nothing more than a chattering, shivering wet collection of parts. There was no telling which dwarf’s barrel he clung to now. He knew it wasn’t Bombur’s, for that one floated a deal lower than the others, but who might be inside he could only guess.

And at first he thought it might have been Thorin. And then he wondered if it might have been Bofur.

How does one respond to such news? It still struck Bilbo as odd; phenomenally odd. Who was he, really, in the grand scheme of things? Bilbo Baggins, not really very Tookish at the moment, nor indeed for most of the journey. He struggled to maintain a hold of the barrel and slipped into the water deeper than before, finally grasping at the top and pulling himself out again so that his lungs could fill with air.

He wanted so much to talk to Bofur about what he had overheard in the cell.

But what would he say to him? “Hello, I hear you’re in love with me.” No of course not. What then? What would he say? Would he explain to him that he didn’t know what he wanted? Or did he? Did he know? He wanted Thorin. He thought he wanted Thorin. Did he want Thorin?

Echoes of past insults, rebuffs and complications all came flooding back, the most recent of which being back in the elven dungeons. The odd juxtaposition of the hand holding one night, and the frustration another was too much for Bilbo to handle in that moment. Did Thorin want him? From what Kíli had started to say in the cell, he would have believed that Thorin did. But then why was he acting this way?

Thorin had a lot of things on his mind, or so Bofur had said to him that day on the mountainside. But was that true? Did Thorin have a lot on his mind? I suppose he does, thought Bilbo to himself, though it didn’t satisfy the thoughts that nagged at him. Alright, so Thorin had a lot on his mind. Then why bother with a silly little hobbit? Why even consider him an option? Why set a mark out against others?

Up and down, in and out, these thoughts wove their way from one mind to another long through the days and nights. The barrels were bound together by the men of Laketown and Bilbo was able to sneak off with the help of the ring into the city to dry himself and procure some food. It was the next day, when Bilbo set about to releasing the dwarves from their oaken-cask prisons, that Bilbo was finally able to have some resolution to his emotional problem.

The first barrel he opened was Thorin’s, and the dwarf emerged in a much fouler mood than he had gotten in. The wild look in his eyes said that the journey had been far from pleasant, and he blamed his current state of wet discomfort on the hobbit. But Bilbo had done plenty of thinking on his barrel ride, and hardly gave the dwarf a chance to further berate him and castigate him. “Halfling!”

“Oh what now?!” he scolded the not-yet king under the mountain, and the hurt that had been building up from the inability to know exactly how Thorin felt rushed to the surface. “Are you alive or are you dead? Are you in prison or aren’t you? This is your adventure, not mine! Now get up and help me open the rest of these!” And without giving Thorin any time to respond, he stalked away to open the nearest barrel.

Notes:

tried a different writing style this time around. not sure what i think of it. expect the next chapter to be more talking and stuff. i have a feeling i'm going to spend one installment, maybe two, in laketown establishing character dynamics, and then they'll go to the mountain. we'll see.

also a wild kili - bofur crush appears! as if this wasn't already complicated enough. but my internal kili tells me that he always had a crush on bofur, which is why he was checking out his art to begin with. *sighs* fucking dwarves.

i went book-verse in this one. i know they're doing something different in the movie by not having the barrels sealed (why?) and i didn't want that so i didn't. the end.