Actions

Work Header

Easier to Lie

Chapter 21: White Blank Page

Summary:

i didn't want to go to the battle right away so instead i went to a slightly less painful but still painful episode of thorin and bilbo getting their hearts broken because of bilbo's choice.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

With as soundly as the archer and the toymaker slept that night, the hobbit struggled to get his eyes to close for even a second.  His heart pounded in his chest as he curled up on his bedroll near the rest of the others.  The gravity of what he had done still weighed on him and his heart.  He knew that Thorin would resent his actions.  Probably resent him, when he found out what had happened.  But what was there for it?  Bilbo had discovered something powerful, meaningful, and beautiful in his life through this adventure, and he didn’t want to risk losing it, even if it meant losing it in another way.  Any way to end the brewing conflict, so that life was spared.

And perhaps he was overreacting.  He told himself that the group of them had survived many trials together, relatively unscathed.  What was one more?

But this was different.  This was open war.  Or so it appeared to be.  Bilbo had never seen war before, and he prayed he would never have to.

Then there was Gandalf.  The wizard had been all but a memory to them for such a long time that Bilbo had quite forgotten him until he’d made his presence known to the hobbit in the encampment.  He thought Bilbo had made the right decision.

Bilbo himself was no so sure.

So, when dawn finally began to grace the face of the land with her presence, the rosey tinge of grey on the horizon, Bilbo felt his stomach drop out from within him, knowing that, for good or ill, what he’d done would be made known if not today, then soon.  Very soon indeed.

Trumpets sounded from the encampment outside.  Bilbo’s heart jumped into his throat.  He hadn’t seen Thorin since the night before, and as the king approached the gate, Bilbo felt ever more frightened of his response.  The dwarf lord turned to meet his gaze for a moment and there was a hint of what had chanced between them the night before in his eyes.

Oh, how Thorin would resent him.

The others were coming together to see what the news would be.  They knew why the armies stood by, and for the most part, they agreed with Thorin.  Bilbo wondered if this was in part what had earned dwarves their negative, somewhat greedy reputation.  It made him sad.  But nothing could top the worry in his heart at what was to come.

The last to join the group were Bofur and Kíli, who staggered in with the rest of them still heavy with sleep and affection, though the change in their prospects seemed to have affected them.  Everyone was curious to see what the nearby armies would say.

Would they all resent him?  These things all plagued the hobbit’s mind as he came to the wall and gazed down at the faces below.  The company gathered around him.  This was it.  This was the moment.

“Would the king listen to another embassy, as new tidings have changed the matters at hand?”

Thorin, ever strong, dignified, and power, gazed back down at the runner.  “I would,” he responded, before he turned and said quietly to Balin, who stood directly to his right, “That will be Dain.  The dwarves of the Iron Hills are with us.”

Bilbo stood some distance from them, but as they spoke he turned his eyes back to the ground below.  Bombur stood closest to him, then Bifur, and further along Bofur and Kíli, all staring down with rapt attention at the emissary.  It was a very real fear that they might all turn on him, if they knew.  Bilbo bit his lip.

A few moments and a small company appeared below them, among them the elven king Thranduil and Bard, the representative of the people of Laketown.  Bilbo already knew what they would say.

“Hail Thorin,” called Bard, carrying himself with much the same leaderly dignity that Thorin did, though of a softer vein.  “Are you of the same mind since last we met?”

Thorin scoffed at him in bemusement.  “I have seen no reason to alter my mind; if that is all you have come for, you are wasting your time.”

“Is there nothing for which you would yield any of your gold?”

“Nothing that you or your men might offer,” Thorin answered quickly.

“And what of the Arkenstone of Thrain?”  And just like that, Bard held the shimmering stone up so that the firstlight could catch it’s multifaceted surface.  The colours shown like stars.

In that moment, the silence was so dense that Bilbo was certain he could hear Thorin’s heartbeat.

When the dwarf lord finally spoke again, his voice was so low that it was a wonder any of the gathered party below was able to hear it.  “That stone belongs to my grandfather, and my father, and so is passed to me.  How came you by this?”

“We’re not thieves, if that is your mind,” Bard replied cleanly and clearly.  There was a hint of brazenness in his tone, and Bilbo felt himself shrinking further and further into the stonework of the wall.  He didn’t want to think of how this might end.  “But we will return to you your own if you give to us ours.”

The rage was building in Thorin.  The whole of the company could see it clearly, like an electrical current surging around his form.  And, for many of their own parts, the rage was collectively shared.  The beauty and honour of their people in the hands of those to whom it did not belong.

Many of them quivered.  Dwalin’s rage seemed to match Thorin’s; Gloin gripped his axe as if restraining the urge to cast it down at the gathered crowd.  Even Fíli was gripped with anger on his uncle’s behalf, and Bilbo thought perhaps the others might share it, though he refused to look at them.

“How came you by this?” Thorin asked again.

There was no answer.

“How came you by it?!”

“I gave it to them!” Bilbo shouted, though where Thorin’s voice rose in anger, Bilbo’s cracked in desperation.  In that self-same moment, all eyes turned to him and he could feel every emotion as it bored its way into his skin.  The anger, the resentment, the surprise.

But nothing matched the utter look of betrayal in Thorin’s eyes.  For that look, Bilbo felt like he might as well have ripped the dwarf’s heart out of his chest and stabbed it with his own sword.

“You?” was all he could say, and his tone had dropped.

The night before was flashing through both sets of minds in that moment.  The honesty of their words, their embrace, their confession.  In this very place, on these very walls.

For Bilbo, this was the truest expression of what he’d said.  But for Thorin, well, it was clear.

“You.  You…”  Thorin’s voice had shifted to a low growl as he breached the space between them in half a second.  “You said you were with me.”

There was a pain in Bilbo’s heart that was too much to take, seeing the betrayal in Thorin’s eyes.  If he could explain…

But no, that wouldn’t do it.  There weren’t words to explain what he’d done.  None that Thorin would hear.

“You!  You MISERABLE hobbit!” Thorin yelled, grabbing Bilbo by the shoulders and slamming him into the wall.  “You played your part well, burglar.”  The resentment coated his tone, and he shook Bilbo in his rage.  Like a doll.  Like a toy.  Several of the others tried to step in to stop him, among them Bombur and Balin, but Thorin would not release his painfully tight grip on the hobbit.  “Yes you played it well.  The burglar.  The expert.”  The words were well-chosen and terse.  Like he felt that all the things Bilbo had said, all the times they had struggled to be close, had been a lie.  A manipulation to get closer.  That Bilbo had taken advantage of him.  The smouldering hatred in those eyes was worse than being ignored.  Much worse.

Bilbo made to grab for the battlements as best he could for fear that Thorin might throw him from the wall to his death.  In his head he screamed a thousand apologies, but not a one could leave his lips.

“Curse Gandalf and his faith in you!  I wish I had him here, that I could tell him how his choice for you played out.”  And he lifted Bilbo by the front of his armour, pressing him ever closer to the dangerous fall from the wall.  By now, Balin, Bombur, and even several of the others were trying to pry the dwarf from the hobbit, though his fingers were tightly clenched, and Bilbo did little to fight it off.  “As for you, I would throw you to the rocks!”

Bilbo resigned himself to it when a sharp voice called up from the ground below.

“Enough!”

It was Gandalf.

“You wish to have me here, and your wish is granted!  Now release the hobbit and do not damage him!  Hear what it is he has to say.”

Thorin was less surprised by Gandalf’s presence than Bilbo had been that night, but the voice seemed to have a necessary power, for he did not so much as release Bilbo as he dropped him to the floor at his feet, taking a step back in anger, betrayal, hurt, and disgust.

“I care not what he has to say,” Thorin replied bitterly, and his piercing blue eyes gazed as if into Bilbo’s very soul.  “He has already said quite enough, but speak then.  Defend yourself, you descendant of rats.”

There was a moment where Bilbo thoughts perhaps their pain was equal, though Thorin did not see it.  For where Thorin only saw the hobbit’s betrayal, Bilbo’s heart ached at how cruelly Thorin was treating him now.  For in spite of everything, he still loved him.  He was doing this out of love.  All of it was for Thorin, even if the dwarf lord could not see it as such.  Tears glinted at the corners of the hobbit’s sad eyes, but they did not move Thorin’s heart, nor he ventured any others.  He could not look at them.  He only kept his gaze on Thorin, and the endless resentment in his gaze.

“You…you told me,” he began shakingly, biting back his emotions.  “That I was due one fourteenth of the share of the treasure.”  He paused and had to choke back his tears.  “Perhaps I took it too literally.  But, as…part of this company, I am…I am guaranteed my due.  What I do with it…is my choice.”

“Very well,” Thorin responded flippantly.  “Go then.  Join your friends.  I shall arrange to have a fourteenth of the treasure brought in exchange for the Arkenstone of my fathers.  But you…may you and I never meet again.”  His tone was cold as the icy gaze he cast on Bilbo.  It hurt to hear.  He ventured it hurt equally for the dwarf to say it.  “No friendship of mine goes with you.”  And with that, Thorin turned his back on Bilbo.  Likely forever.

As Bilbo was lowered down the wall towards the gathered ensemble, fresh tears streaked his cheeks.  Several of the dwarves – among them Bombur, Bofur, Ori and Balin – offered their sad farewells or sad, despondent glances.  Others – Dwalin, Gloin – were glaring into his skin their judgement.

Bilbo had done what had to be done to save that which had grown to mean so much to him, and lost it all in spite.

His feet touched the ground, but his heart was still on the battlements.

Notes:

i tried to keep as close to the book as possible, but added some of my own touches.

*weeps silently in the corner*