Chapter Text
The night that came was cold. Bilbo was surrounded by elves and men, and Gandalf kept him company, but it brought him no real peace. His heart was inside Erebor with his friends and his love, but the distance between them was so great that nothing he could think of in the world of elves, men, dwarves, or hobbits could broach that terrible distance.
Inside the great dwarven city’s walls, the tension was equally palpable. Each dwarf knew that Thorin had no intention of giving a fourteenth share of the treasure in exchange for the Arkenstone, though he intended to get it back. There were some who did not blame him. It was, after all, the jewel of their people and the timeless sign of his rule. Many who had lived in Erebor before its fall agreed with Thorin, and supported his decision.
Others – among them the miners from the Blue Mountains, who did not hold the same esteem for the jewel as Thorin did – felt his behaviour reproachable at best, abhorrent at worst. Bofur for one was shamed by Thorin’s behaviour. He cared for the hobbit, perhaps not as he once had, but still deeply and counted him as a friend. And, for what it was worth, he felt he understood the depth of love between the two of them, and it was out of that depth of love that Thorin was reacting. He had been on the battlements the night before, when Bilbo and Thorin had shared their last tender embrace. He’d overheard some of the gentle, kindly, loving things that passed between them. He felt he understood because he knew what it felt like, to love deeply.
Kíli, on the other hand, was caught.
Fíli had wasted no time at all taking his uncle’s side, for good or ill, because that was expected of kin. When Thorin raged about his anger, his frustration, his betrayal by the traitorous little hobbit, Fíli listened and echoed his agreement. But Kíli struggled. He wanted to be with his uncle. Wanted to see the world, see the hobbit, see everything as Thorin saw it. Thorin was his uncle, after all. His kin. The closest thing he’d had to a father since he was a mere dwarfling. But on this thing Kíli felt he was wrong. And perhaps it was because he was too young to remember the jewel of their people. Perhaps it was because the treasure seemed to have lost some of its lustre since he’d discovered his own treasure. Perhaps it was because he too counted Bilbo among friends, though he had once counted him a rival. Bilbo was one of them. He might not have been a dwarf, but he had the heart of lion in his chest, and he had done so much for them having only known them such a short time.
Kíli watched his uncle battle with bitterness as greed poisoned his heart, and it frightened him. It was a side to Thorin that he hadn’t seen before, and he was uncertain that he wanted to see it.
That night he joined Bofur and his brother Bombur on the battlements, leaving his own brother Fíli to look after Thorin in his anger. They were waiting for Dain to arrive. That was the plan. Dain and the dwarves from the Iron Hills would overwhelm the elves and men with their sheer numbers, and the Arkenstone would again be theirs, without having to forsake any of the treasure.
Slipping into the space beside Bofur, Kíli let his hand lace with the others. “Well?” he asked tentatively. The night was cool and dark. The two were watching for any sign of Dain and his company. They were also looking for Bilbo.
When Bofur shook his head, Kíli understood and gave his hand a squeeze.
Morning broke with a blood-red sun, and the three on the battlements had gotten little sleep – worry for Bilbo, for their kin, and despite not wanting to admit such, for themselves. Open war was upon them. They could sense as much, and when the sun bled it’s crimson light on the sides of the kingdom, Oin startled everyone with a spoken prophecy.
“Th’ portents say when a blood-red sun spills on th’ mountainside, bloodshed will follow.”
All the dwarves felt the gravity of the words and readied themselves for a battle they felt unprepared for and reluctant to face.
With the morning came Dain’s forces, and for a moment only it seemed like perhaps battle would be thrust upon them, as Thorin was still determined to reclaim what was his without due payment to the forces amassed below. But that moment would never come.
A shadow grew on the horizon.
It was Gandalf who saw it first. His eyes were not sharp, but his senses were alight to what was gathering in the distance. Orc forces.
“Halt!” he called to the gathered armies of men, elves, and dwarves. “Gloom is upon us all! An orcish army rides from the North! Bolg and Azog – those foes who were expelled from Moria when the city was reclaimed ride to battle!”
The tables were turned, and for the first time since the love of gold had overtaken the hearts of the dwarves, it seemed common sense had wormed its way into their minds, who now saw the necessity of putting aside personal grievance in favour of alliance against this common enemy. The gates were soon opened so the three leaders – Dain (who had with his army marched through the night to reach his kin), Bard and Thranduil – might discuss their tactical response to the coming danger.
Within the dwarf city however, Thorin tarried. The company began to ready themselves for battle – taking up arms, armouring themselves, yet Thorin vanished for some time into the depths of the city. It was Fíli and Kíli who eventually found their uncle, deep within the treasure store, himself armed and dressed for battle, but his attention locked on what seemed to be an endless sea of gold before him.
“Uncle Thorin?” It was Kíli who pressed his uncle tentatively as they approached. His own armour felt strange and heavy. He was quite unused to being so covered, having never been in open war himself, but it was a necessity, given the bloodshed outside. The others were already gathering near the gate, ready to charge and join forces with their kin and the loosely formed alliance.
“I do not believe I spoke to you of my grandfather’s sickness,” Thorin spoke softly in a voice that barely lifted above the sound of the crackling fire of their torches, or the din from outside the firm stone walls.
It was not something either of the brothers expected their uncle to say, especially at a time such as this.
“I watched him succumb to it, when I was still young.” He turned to glance over his shoulder at them and nodded once. “Like the pair of you.”
“Uncle Thorin, the others – ”
Thorin turned his back to them again, his eyes searching the wealth that lay before them. “I remember thinking to myself…how strange it was, to see him like that.” He sighed; a heavy sound in the great hall. “Shameful. Love of all else left his mind. And while there is beauty to be found in gold…and jewels…they offer little comfort. Their embrace is cold.”
Kíli reached out to place a hand on Thorin’s shoulder, and Fíli followed suit, placing his hand on the opposite shoulder.
“Many who knew him then believed it was my grandfather’s sickness that brought the dragon’s filth upon our kingdom.”
“Uncle Thorin…”
Thorin stopped and turned to look his nephews in the eye. He saw them clearly then, the both of them. They wore their armour proudly, though it weighed them down. It was clear that neither knew the reality of war. He did not want them to know it now.
But war was upon them. It was outside their door.
“I have brought shame upon you and the line of Durin,” he stated softly, and this time it was Fíli would reproached him, and his tone was firm and direct.
“Our friends…our kin…they’re dying uncle! An’ we can’ leave them t’ that!”
“No, you are right,” Thorin answered quickly, and he clapped both youths on the shoulders simultaneously before pulling them close. “I would have you stay within the city but I know you would fight me on it.”
“Wha’, an’ let our friends…our kin fall?!” It was Kíli this time, and there was a real fire in his gaze as he said it. No, there would be no holding the pair of them back. They would not be coddled when those who meant the most to them fell.
The three embraced then in the chill of the hall, then Thorin released his nephews and lead the way to the gate. When they joined the others, they were already loosely forming ranks, or as much of ranks as the thirteen of them could pull together. Dwalin raised the gate and it was Thorin who lead the charge; with him came the same tenacity, the same courage, the same dwarvish pride that had stood up against the pale orc when they reclaimed the dwarf city of Moria. His twelve companions bravely followed him. To victory. To defeat. To glory. To death. To whatever fate might meet them there, all love of gold now quite forgotten.
Many were already bloodied and fallen when they joined the fray, their presence quite forgotten by those outside. But when Thorin shouted with a mighty voice, he seemed to rouse them from their battle-wearied fatigue and they rallied together, the forces recharged by his presence. Bilbo, who had taken cover and the protection of the ring, felt a burning exhilaration in his heart upon seeing the dwarf lord finally emerge from his self-created prison.
Unlike the others, Bilbo never once forgot about the company within those stone walls. He would never forget them.
From the safety of where he crouched hidden, Bilbo was able to see them all, though they soon were separated in the fury of the battle. Thorin had led the charge right into the thick of the battle, heading straight for the pale orc who had a bounty on him, and he the vengeance of his blade upon it.
Fíli and Kíli were close behind their uncle, Kíli using the expertise of his bow to take down the foes that approached his uncle when Thorin’s attentions were directed elsewhere, and Fíli wielded his dual swords to slice down around the elder, to clear his path to the one he sought.
Dwalin was not so far from the Durins, battle axes taking off heads of every orc in his path. One was soon lodged in the neck of one of the hideous Gundabad wargs and he let lose such a battle cry that Bilbo felt in his heart such a swelling pride at having known such a courageous and dangerous dwarf.
Balin was separated fast from his brother and the Durin’s though he collided with Dain and the two faced down their foes back to back, protecting the other with swords held high and firm, unshaken by carnage and unimpeded by the gathering bloodshed.
Bilbo lost sight of Gloin quickly, as the dwarf was caught up amidst a swelling of human soldiers, though ever so often the hobbit would catch a flash of red – a bit of beard – or his axe and knew that he still drew breath, and blood.
Oin and Nori joined up when they were separated from their own brothers by the never-ending sea of bodies. An unlikely pair, and yet for one who was so quick to look over his shoulder, Nori was attentive to everything behind the older dwarf’s back, using his mace to crush anything that sought to injure his newfound companion.
Dori kept close to Ori though they had hardly gotten into the thick of the battle before the young scribe was knocked unconscious from a blow to the head by one of the many rocks cascading down from the orc’s stationed above. Dori went down to protect his body from being trampled, and both were lost from Bilbo’s sight, but his heart ached for them, and for the uselessness of his own position. He lacked the courage they had. They were out spilling blood, shedding blood, and yet here he was, crouching and protected by the invisibility the ring provided.
Bifur, quite like Thorin, had charged into the fray without any apparent fear, and his cousins had been close behind him, following in his wake. The older dwarf used his boar spear to make quick work of anything that came close to him, and before his cousins were separated from him by a group of warg riders, they kept his back clear by wielding their mattock and cleaver. Once separated, Bilbo too lost sight of them, and his heart made another little leap. He couldn’t do this. He couldn’t watch this. He could not bear to watch his friends fall and vanish from sight, knowing naught if they were alive or dead. Pulling his small sword out of its sheath, he rose to his feet to join them. To do whatever little he could.
But he never got the chance. He was knocked unconscious.
Still, the battle raged on.
After being separated from his cousin and being unable to see where any of the others were, Bofur made his primary goal to keep his brother safe. Bombur did well to hold his own, but more than a few times he was approached from behind and Bofur would have to smash back the orc with his mattock. Each time it got worse. The fear of death was very real then; not his own death, but the death of his kin, the death of the others. No dwarf fears for his own death. They are a proud and mighty race.
But woe to the opponent who brings pain and ruin upon their loved ones.
It was when Bombur fell that things began to get real. The younger dwarf had all his energy occupied by a pair of warg riders, when the blow came from behind. He crumpled, and Bofur had not been fast enough to stop it. Crushing the offending orc’s skull with his mattock and smashing it into the ground, he was given the space of a few seconds to crouch down to see to his brother’s safety.
Bombur was unconscious.
The miner did not move from that stop again as he stood defensively over his brother’s fallen form, a renewed strength within him. He could not see the others. All he could see was the never-ending onslaught of orc scum. So he fought. With all his strength and everything he fought. Through fatigue and injury.
And some hundred yards away, his lover was doing exactly the same.
Fíli and Kíli had the strength and agility of youth on their side, and while many of the others were burdened with the pain of their years, this was not so for the two young Durins. Fíli held the orcs off so his brother could use his expert eye to take down as many of their foes as he could.
Until his arrows began to run low.
In hand to hand combat Kíli was no expert. He was hardly a failure, but his skill with the sword was not as strong as his skill with the bow. It took much of his concentration to keep the monsters at bay, and it seemed each time he took down an orc, three replaced it. It was a never ending battle to keep them at bay. He was losing strength. He was losing his certainty.
A sharp stab into the skull of a warg and he heard Fíli screaming their uncle’s name. Both brothers turned to watch as their uncle fell to his knees at the feet of Bolg.
For just a moment, the entire world seemed to stop around them. There was no battle. There was no sea of endless orcish filth to throw back. There was only Thorin. Their uncle. The closest thing they had to a father. Falling to his knees. Bleeding heavily from the side. Landing on his stomach. Eyes flickered and then closed.
No.
Fíli charged the orc first, both his swords flashing about him as he threw his weight into the great orc, his rage giving him flight while Kíli remained frozen, his eyes fixed on his uncle. There was no telling if Thorin lived, though he did not move. Then Fíli too took a blow to the side, though it did not keep him from swinging wildly at the gathering horde that surrounded him and their fallen uncle. It was then and only then that Kíli was finally able to will himself to move, and clenching his sword in both hands tightly, he charged the orc with a cry so feral that the orcs nearest him gave way to him in fear at the youthful fury. He too collided with Bolg’s massive form, though his sword did minimal damage. It was the force of his body weight that seemed to dislodge the orc, who fell before him as his brother still swung madly at any orc that drew near them, blood flowing freely from his side. Kíli followed his brother’s lead, swinging without as much direction as he’d had before, now so blinded by the fear and rage of watching his uncle fall. One by one they drove the orcs back, but it was not enough. Fíli was floundering. The loss of blood was beginning to affect his head and once he stumbled. Twice. Kíli came to his aid, now using what strength was in him to fight back the onslaught from his fallen uncle and falling brother. But he could not do it alone. There were too many of them.
There was a flash of light and searing pain when he took a blow to the back. An orcish blade ran him through. He saw the glint of metal tinged with the redness of his own blood as he crumpled onto the dirt beside his brother. Their blood mixed together, one great flow of red. Thorin was still unmoved. Fíli was barely moving.
Crawling to the space between them, Kíli did not release his blade and tried to fight them off until it was finally knocked from his shaking hands. Dark eyes searched. Neither moved. Fíli’s blood continued to flow from his wound. Kíli reached up to touch his own. It was hot.
In that moment he realized that they were dying, all of them. There was no glory and dignity to be found in the battle. Only pain and death.
Curling up between his uncle’s and brother’s bodies, his head grew light as he held them close. He could not see the others. He wondered if they would share the same fate.
He thought of Bofur in those moments, praying for his safety, or for a swift and painless death. And he was not afraid.
-----
When Bilbo finally came to, it was to a sharp pain in his head and a strange, unsettling quiet on the battlefield. Lifting his head, he was horrified to see the many bodies the covered everything he could see. His eyes flickered back to the ground beneath him. He couldn’t look. How long had he been out?
Slipping the ring off his finger, he tried to force himself to his feet. A man, a soldier from Laketown, saw him rustling and came to his aid. “Are you hurt?” the man asked, and Bilbo shrugged.
“I’m…no I’m alright. I got a nasty knock on the head though,” he offered, and the man did not hesitate to pick him up and carried him back to their makeshift camp. As he walked, Bilbo was overwhelmed by the sheer number of bodies that surrounded them. “What happened? While I was out?”
“We won,” the man answered softly, though there was a deep pain and regret in his voice. “But at what a cost.”
Bilbo could see as much, and he tried not to let his eyes wander too far through the sea of bodies to search out any that he might recognize. The carnage was clear enough to him; it would be a miracle if all his friends and companions still drew breath.
So this is the reality of war? Bilbo thought to himself. I see no glory in this. I only see death. Death and ruin. And blood. So much blood. So much waste.
When they arrived at the campsite, Gandalf was upon the hobbit so fast that he hardly had time to process that the wizard was there and pleased to see him. Gandalf embraced the hobbit, but his feeble return was emotionless and forced. “I feared your luck had finally run out,” the wizard spoke kindly as he released Bilbo, but the hobbit gave a weak shrug.
“Would that I had enough luck for…” and he gestured widely around him at the many fallen bodies.
Gandalf did not acknowledge the statement, but it touched him in his heart. “Come. There is someone you must see.”
The gravity of those words did not sit right with Bilbo, but he did as he was told and followed the wizard through what looked to be a makeshift triage. Oin was tending to the wounded. There was one, at least, that Bilbo knew had survived. Further off, there was a gathered collection of bodies that had been retrieved and identified, or so Bilbo thought, though he could not see them. They were covered with sheets of linen, a human custom of respect of the dead.
A few pairs of boots protruded from the sheets but Bilbo let his gaze flick away from them. He didn’t want to recognize any of them. Not yet.
Gandalf led him into a tent and stood aside, gesturing the hobbit inside but not daring to follow him. When Bilbo entered, he was both relieved and terrified to see Thorin lying within, bloodied and bruised, his eyes swollen and glazed. The second their gazed connected and Bilbo could see the pain in Thorin’s eyes, he rushed to his side and grasped his bloodied hand in his own, pressing it close to his chest. “Oh Thorin…”
The smallest of smiles pulled at Thorin’s mouth as he gave Bilbo’s hands as much of a squeeze as he could muster. “My thief,” he replied quietly. His voice was low; it pained him to speak, that much was clear, but Bilbo only heard his words. The ‘my’ was there again. Thorin had reclaimed him, for all that had changed between them leading up to the battle. It tugged at Bilbo’s heart and added to the pain he already felt at seeing his love so wounded. “I am glad you are here with me now.”
The hobbit had to bite back his tears as he knelt next to the dwarf king. He didn’t need to ask to know that Thorin meant now, at the end. Just a brief survey of his wounds said he would not last the night.
Bilbo wasn’t ready.
“I would take back my words at the gate,” Thorin continued softly, and with his free hand he reached up to tousle some of the hobbit’s golden curls. The touch was both welcome and horrifically painful for Bilbo to endure, but he would endure it, and as a few more tears threatened to overtake his face, Thorin let his thumb reach across to brush them away. “I cannot part from you without your love and friendship.”
“No,” Bilbo replied, shaking his head firmly. “They are all forgotten, Thorin.” He choked on his own words and had to take a moment to steady himself as he held tightly to Thorin’s hand. He wanted to caress him, but his body had lost its ability to move. And, even moreso, he feared that any touch might cause his love pain. He would sooner hurl himself into an abyss than bring any more pain to the one before him. “I…I am glad…that we are able…” He stopped again. Was he glad? No. He was not glad. He could not be glad at this parting. He could not be glad at losing the one whom he loved so deeply, who had changed his life so much in such a short space of time. Whom he had counted as his one, that he might spend the rest of his life with. He was willing to live out the rest of his years here in Erebor, with Thorin, simply to be with him. But it was not to be. The journey ended here. What he finally was able to force out was, “It was an honour…to be a part of your company, king under the mountain. It was…far more…far more than a hobbit such as me deserved.”
Thorin laughed lightly, though it was clear the action pained him from the way his eyes crinkled immediately following. “No. There is much good in you, my little burglar. More than you know. Courage and wisdom in great measure. If more in the world valued food, song and cheer over hoarded gold, it would be a better world.” The admission had a double edge to it, and Bilbo heard the dual meaning to the words as they were spoken. Thorin had been poisoned, albeit briefly, by the gold sickness, and it had consumed him. Now it seemed he held it as the reason for his ruin. Bilbo shook his head but Thorin reached out to cup his cheek once more, brushing a few more stray tears from the hobbit’s face.
Few words were spoken between them after that, but Bilbo lingered until darkness finally took Thorin from him, and he went to join his fathers in their heavenly halls. He watched as the eyes grew dark and dim. The light left them. And Bilbo felt his own heart fading along with it.
Outside his tent, Dwalin had returned from the field carrying more wounded. He’d found Bofur and Bombur in his search through the carnage, and wounded though he was, Bofur was able to help the other bear his brother back to the wounded, where Oin set to treating him. Bombur was alive, though his injuries were great and he would need attention. His body was laid out near Ori, who had yet to regain consciousness since his fall. Dori had been helping to tend to him, though had went back out into the battlefield to help search for survivors.
Bofur’s injuries were real but not as serious as the others, so he offered to help Dwalin in his search, but it was Balin who stopped him from going back. They exchanged a look that filled the dwarf’s heart with nervous dread, but it was the sight behind him that finally turned his attention.
For behind Balin were the many bodies, each covered with a sheet. He glanced over the many covered bodies. Each form had been identified, though many others were still missing and were being sought in the aftermath. But it was a pair of boots the protruded from one of the sheets that caught Bofur’s eyes and stopped his heart from beating. He knew them. And, he ventured, Balin had stopped him for just such a reason. Balin also knew them.
The pain did not outweigh his need as he pushed past the older dwarf to collapse on his knees beside the covered form and quickly pull away the covering.
But he hadn’t needed to see the face to know who lay beneath.
Kíli’s blood-stained face kick-started his heart again, and a great heaving gasp rocked through him.
In his life, Bofur had lost many who were dear to him. His parents. His cousin’s family. Friends. Some to orc raids. Others to cave ins in the mines. Some to war. And one thing had always stuck out to him when he was met with the face of a dead loved one.
There was something hideously unnatural about death. Oft he’d heard the dead described as ‘only sleeping,’ but there was nothing sleepful about a dead body. There was no way he ever felt he might confuse a fallen loved one for someone simply sleeping. There was always that strange, unnatural waxy lustre to the skin, the sallow fallen nature of the eyes, the way that spark – that breath of life – which normally illumined a living form was now lost and shaded, as if it had never been there to begin with.
The face was Kíli’s and yet it was not, for death does not look like life. That spark, that bit of Kíli that made him Kíli, was gone. Kíli was gone. His Kíli was dead.
Yet despite the fact that this empty, cold, waxy thing was not his love, he could not help himself as he pulled the youth’s body gently into his lap and pressed him to his chest. Tears slipped from his eyes onto the face that was and wasn’t Kíli’s, and he fought back the urge to sob openly as he did so. Never had he expected to be the one to live. If anyone had a right to live, it was the young one. His Kíli. His laddie-love.
He held him for a long time. Could have held him forever if the others had let him. But eventually Balin placed a coaxing hand on the miner’s shoulder, and he knew he had to let go of the body that wasn’t really Kíli anymore. Gently laying him back on the ground, he replaced the covering on his body, though not before he took a moment to press a gentle kiss into the forehead that was not Kíli’s anymore.
Finally forcing himself to his feet, he heard another choking back sobs. Turning tear-streaked eyes in the direction of the sound, he saw Bilbo, the hobbit, the burglar, the unsung, wiping his eyes desperately as sobs rocked through his small body.
Their pain was mutual, and before Bilbo was even aware of the other’s presence, he was enwrapped in a strong embrace as Bofur held him, the pair of them drawing comfort from their shared grief. Neither felt the need to be strong for the other, but just suffering together in that moment was enough.
