Actions

Work Header

Easier to Lie

Chapter 23: Remember

Summary:

bilbo says goodbye to his companions and returns to bag end in the shire.

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

The following days went by in a blur, for most everyone was operating as if in a haze.  The matter of the gold seemed to have fallen out of importance in the face of so much death and carnage.  And in times such as this one, such discussion would be indecent.  The company went into mourning, and the remaining forces from the Iron Hills joined them.  Of the original 13, only 10 had survived, and for some it was only just, pulled together with the work of Oin’s hands.

Thorin, Fíli and Kíli were laid to rest within the mountain halls, though Bilbo did not watch them be laid to rest.  Truth be told, he wouldn’t see Thorin after the king died before him, and he couldn’t bring himself to look at the two young princes’ lifeless forms.  Just the knowledge that they had fallen and breathed no more was painful enough for him.

Apart from the moment spent consoling each other, Bofur and Bilbo saw very little of each other in those passing days.  Bilbo kept to himself mostly, occasionally being sought by Balin from time to time as the dwarf found it necessary to check in on him to see that he was alright, and Gandalf, who though understanding the depth of suffering had a practical nature that made him seem at times unnecessarily callous.  Bilbo didn’t get comfort from either of them.  There were times when he wondered if perhaps he might have gained comfort from Bofur as he had the day he lost Thorin, but he recognized that the other was dealing with his own grief in his own way.  He did not seek him out, though there were several times he wanted to.

They met a few times in passing, and each time Bofur always gave him a smile that Bilbo remembered echoes of on their journey, though at the time he had not understood its import.  In his memory he always saw the dwarf as smiling, but now he realised just how deceptive something as simple as a smile could be, for though the dwarf was always smiling, it was clear that he was anything but happy.  A mask to hide the pain.

Bilbo wore his own mask.  He covered himself with closed doors and refused company when he could, and he wept quietly to himself often.  Upon arriving in Erebor, while Thorin still drew breath, Bilbo had been making up his mind to stay with the dwarves.  Now he wanted nothing more than return to his little hole in the ground in the Shire.  Perhaps subconsciously he thought “out of sight, out of mind” might work its magic on his aching heart, though an equally strong part of him knew such pains would never entirely be out of mind.

The hardest part, perhaps, was the realities of the might have beens.  There was no denying that he had loved the dwarf lord, and Thorin had loved him.  Things could have been so different.  Each day Bilbo’s mind invented a different scenario – in which he wasn’t knocked unconscious, in which he had been able to help his friends, in which none of his friends had died, and Thorin had taken up his role as king under the mountain.  He imagined their life together and the beauty of Erebor restored under Thorin’s rule.  He saw himself, a simple, silly hobbit as the king’s companion and consort, and after all, why not?

Because Thorin was dead, and the dead have no need of companionship.

How Bofur faired he wouldn’t know, and he daren’t ask.  Indeed, from Bofur’s own lips Bilbo would never hear tell of it.  The dwarf’s silence was a sign of his own grief, and Bilbo allowed him that.  But he wanted to leave, and after the pain became too much to bare, Bilbo made arrangements with Gandalf to return to the Shire.

His parting was one without much pomp, though he did not leave unburdered of treasure; as a result of his act of treachery, the Arkenstone was exchanged for a fourteenth of the share of the treasure – the Arkenstone itself was laid to rest with Thorin – and Bilbo himself received two small chests.  It seems unnecessary, and he would have refused had he the strength to put up much of a fight.  But the hobbit had grown tired of fighting.  It was not the time for fighting.  It was the time to acknowledge that which had not been lost.  Those who still lived.

The dwarves of the company who were able gave Bilbo a small send-off, though it was difficult for them to speak to him.  All knew of his affections for Thorin, and all recognized the depth of his suffering.  It was Balin who finally gathered enough courage to speak to the hobbit, but what he could offer was a feeble, “Goodbye, and good luck, laddie.  If ever y’ come back our way, when these halls have been restored, the feast will be grand indeed.”

All of course knew that Bilbo wouldn’t likely come back.

Bilbo’s response was equally ceremonial, though he meant it.  “And if you should pass my way, don’t wait to knock.  Any of you are welcome…at any time.”

Then Bilbo went to bid farewell to his companions who still suffered from their injuries.  Bombur and Ori hadn’t been able to leave the care of Oin and several others trained in the healing arts, though they fared much better than Bilbo might have originally thought.  Bombur’s appetite had improved tremendously, a sign that his healing was imminent, and Ori spent much of the spell of being bedridden writing or drawing.  Bilbo sat with Bombur first, and the dwarf expressed his sadness at the parting in as many words as the others, though the hobbit could tell it pained him as much as the rest.  Then Ori, who was able to form words much better, perhaps given the limited contact he’d had from others outside his own family while on the mend.  He was the only to enquire about Bilbo’s state upon Thorin’s passing, to which the hobbit could not respond for fear of releasing a torrent of emotion.

Standing up to leave, he was called back by the young scribe once more.  “Excuse me, before you leave,” the young dwarf spoke in his ever polite and gentle voice.  The hobbit hesitated and watched as Ori pulled out a large leatherbound book and flipped through the pages before he found a loose piece of parchment between two of the pages.  Removing it, he held it out to Bilbo.

It was a portrait.

For a moment the hobbit didn’t have words to respond.  The linework was exquisite; the mark of an unshaking hand and quill.  When he was finally able to speak, what he said was, “It’s…it’s lovely Ori, thank you.”

“It isn’t only mine; the ink work is my own,” Ori explained, a half-smile that betrayed both joy and sadness at the hobbit’s response and his swift parting.

“Who did the rest?” Bilbo inquired.

“Bofur,” the other answered simply, and he gestured to point out the thin pencil marks that were hiding under the layer of ink.  Then, settling himself back in his bed, he fought back the obvious discontent with the hobbit’s parting.  “Do come see us again.”

Bilbo agreed that he would.  Unfortunately, this day was the last time he would see many of his old companions alive.  He then attempted to dry his eyes that were threatening to leak again before he made his way to join Gandalf and Beorn, who had offered to see the hobbit safely home.  It was as he was leaving the makeshift infirmary that Bilbo ran into Bofur, who likely was coming to see to his brother.  They hesitated as they passed each other, and Bilbo saw that same sad smile on the other’s face.  Then Bofur went to pass Bilbo, though the hobbit gestured for him to speak with him, and when Bofur seemed uncertain, Bilbo finally forced his voice to speak for him.  “Can…can I talk to you?  Just for a moment.”

It was a simple request and Bofur didn’t refuse, allowing Bilbo to lead him to a small alcove; a recess in the stone wall of the great dwarf city.  A brief glance around to ensure privacy, he didn’t speak until he was satisfied they could not be overheard.  He did not want to pry, and certainly not within earshot of hungry ears.  “How are you?” he finally asked in a low voice.

He was surprised to find Bofur’s sad smile never faded, though his eyes flicked down to the ground, as if looking at Bilbo was too painful, and just seeing his eyes might betray him.  He didn’t answer the question, but instead changed direction entirely.  “Y’ sure y’ don’ want t’ stay here, with us?”

“I can’t,” Bilbo answered honestly, and there was that pang in his voice.  “I’m sorry.  I thought maybe…I thought if…if Thorin were here, I might stay to be with him.  But now…”  He stopped.  He wasn’t one of the types that would be found in a cemetery, paying respect to the dead.  In some ways Bilbo was still in denial in that respect.  He would not visit his fallen love, nor did he ever anticipate wanting to.  “I need to go home.”

Bofur nodded and gave Bilbo a gentle clap on the shoulder.  “I understan’.”

Then a thought occurred to the hobbit and he let it fall out his mouth before he even thought about what he was saying.  “You could come with me…if you like.  To the shire.”  It shocked him even as he was saying it, though the idea was appealing and he wished it had occurred to him sooner.

He was not surprised, however, when Bofur refused.  “My family is here,” is what he said, but they both knew what he really meant.  Kíli was there.  He didn’t want to leave his lover, even if the young dwarf lay in a cold hard tomb of stone.

So much had happened in such a short period of time, though it didn’t seem so short.  To Bilbo, the events shared with this ragtag bunch overshadowed the quiet, calm life he’d led before he met them.  They were like family to him now, in this time, and though his parting was imminent and necessary, he would miss them, and the need to return to the simplicity of Shire life did not outweigh his deep love for all of them.  If things had gone differently…and that was something else that Bilbo would wonder at.  Bofur had, after all, at one point expressed to others having feelings for Bilbo.  And there was a time, when Thorin’s wrath had been most vicious, that Bilbo had wondered just whether he might be able to share feelings for the other dwarf as well.  But now, thinking on it, he felt foolish.  Events had played out as they had, and pain or no pain, Bilbo would not have it any other way, despite the fact that the pair of them would bare the weight of loss of the rest of their lives.

Was it worth the pain?  There was no telling, but it was what it was, and life was to be lived, not to be spent counting up could have beens, even though they were hanging on the air between them.  Bilbo couldn’t know for sure, but he wondered if Bofur might have been thinking the same thing.  And something told him the dwarf wouldn’t have changed it either.  He’d only loved Kíli briefly, but he’d love him fiercely and it was more than enough.

As he had before, the dwarf surprised Bilbo once again with a sudden embrace, one in which it was as much for the hobbit’s comfort as for his own, and Bilbo received it willingly.  It was as if each was saying “I have seen your pain because I feel it.”  And though one can never know how another feels, both ventured they could sympathize.  “Y’ take care of y’rself now,” Bofur spoke when they finally drew back.

“And you.  And…look after the rest for me,” he added after a moment, and it was on these words that the pair parted.  It would not be the last they’d see each other, though it was the last time for many years.

Gandalf and Beorn escorted the hobbit as far as Rivendell, and it was the wizard who brought the hobbit the rest of the way to his old home.  It was strange for Bilbo to arrive in Bag End after having been gone for what felt like centuries, though was in point of fact only close to a year.  Yet the quietude was strangely unfamiliar to the hobbit.  It was as if the whole of the Shire had changed in his absence.

What Bilbo knew in the back of his mind but did not acknowledge, was that he was the one who had changed.

Notes:

this story is wrapping up. only a couple more chapters, if memory serves me. 1 chapter of real chapterness, and an epilogue.

thank you all for sticking with me through this journey. it has been wonderful. stick with it for the last few. i promise the epilogue will help ease the pain a little bit.

that conversation with bofur is one of the few things i've had planned for a long time. it was great to finally be able to write it, though as always now that it's written i can't look forward to it anymore. now its the epilogue that will keep me going.

<3