Actions

Work Header

Abigail Fell’s Master Plan That Most Definitely Will Get Her Dads Together and Won’t Cause Any Chaos at All

Chapter 3: Forced Proximity Can Induce Fits of Irrationality

Notes:

(See the end of the chapter for notes.)

Chapter Text

By the time about a week had passed, the Fell household was running as smoothly as ever. Will and Hannibal could be found making dinner, grading essays, or even cleaning up around the house without a lick of turmoil. Abigail could bring over friends without worry, and her fathers were perfect hosts. It seemed that her plan had worked perfectly, save for one not-so-small detail. 

Despite their cooperation and civility, Will and Hannibal still displayed a distinct lack of romantic overtures. Far too little, in Abigail’s opinion. Not that the platonic politeness was unappreciated, but it just wasn’t what Abigail was going for when she set up the whole blind-date-but-you-already-know-slash-hate-your-date-and-you’re-forced-to-communicate-like-adults situation. She also did not mean for it to be interrupted, nor for her to be discovered as the instigator and a spy. She had yet to address that situation, as it would prove far too embarrassing for her liking. But just because she wouldn’t admit it, didn’t mean she still wasn’t plotting ideas for how to at least encourage some sort of starry-eyed, soppy, romantic movie nonsense from the two men.

It took many hours of brainstorming and deliberation before she constructed her next attempt. The root of the last issues lay in the fact that they both took place in public. Other people caused pandemonium, and to avoid that, the next step would be private.

The last two were also purely lovey-dovey and romantic, and they obviously weren’t working. That meant only one thing… a venture into the physical.

Yes, as much as Abigail was very deeply disturbed by the mere thought of any sexual contact taking place in her home, it seemed to be the final frontier that could end this madness.

The most necessary next phase would have to include some kind of small space, far, far away from Abigail. A quick and easy solution that would leave the two very alone, and they couldn't even be mad at Abigail for spying, because she had no interest. Perfect.

It was that evening when she decided where her next scheme would take place. The whole family was working in the kitchen on some fancy steak dinner that Will and Abigail couldn’t pronounce. Abigail was tasked with mincing vegetables, on the other side of the kitchen from Will and Hannibal, who were standing next to each other at the range. When she had to step into the walk-in pantry to retrieve some kind of herb, she was struck with inspiration. The room was a decent size, large enough for two grown men, but with the spices and ingredients lining the walls, it could prove to be a tight fit. There was a small lock on the door, which confused Abigail, but she assumed it was some kind of rich person thing to keep the hired help away from the food. Just pretentious enough for Hannibal. Hopefully, he would enjoy it just as much when he was trapped inside.

Abigail had to lay in wait for an opportunity to strike. Will and Hannibal needed to both be in the pantry at the same time, which proved to be more difficult than expected. On multiple occasions, one could be found inside without the other, or they would just send Abigail in instead of them. 

After about a week and a half of trying, Abigail was losing hope and eventually decided that she would need to be a little sneaky to enact her plan. During breakfast, she was the first one served and asked Hannibal to fetch some syrup while he was up. Once he disappeared out of the dining room, Will walked in with perfect timing, still bleary-eyed and a little dazed from sleep to the point where he wasn’t too worried about things making sense.

Throwing on a charming smile and speaking in a conspiratorial whisper, she asked, “Will, can you do me a favor?”

Will only grunted and rubbed his eyes in response.

Abigail saw this as a perfect chance. “You can’t tell Hannibal about this, but I really want sprinkles on my waffle,”

Will was obviously confused. “I don’t see what that has to do with me?”

“I need you to get them from the pantry because if he sees me he’ll know, and he lets you do whatever you want.”

“First off, no he doesn’t, and second, I doubt he’d even be willing to live under the same roof as a box of sprinkles.”

“Please, Will? Just check. I haven’t had sprinkles since before I was living with Hannibal.”

A normal, coffee-fueled Will would have no problem deconstructing her argument, but this Will was not that. He sighed, long and tired, before slowly roaming away to the kitchen. Step one complete.

She stalked a few feet behind Will, always hiding behind a wall or cabinet, and keeping her sock-footed steps silent across the tile floor. Once he stepped inside the pantry, it was her time to shine. She heard a few mumbled words between the two before pouncing on the door and turning the lock. She couldn’t hear anything going on inside, which was probably for the best. She theatrically dusted her hands off and walked away with a smile on her face, content to finish her breakfast in peace and relaxation.

---

Meanwhile, Will was having a borderline shit-fit in the pantry.

“Again! Are you kidding me?” He was tugging at the door as if it would open only after it was pulled five hundred times.

Hannibal was level headed (as always), leaning against a wall of different jams, jellies, and pickled vegetables, all handpacked in small glass mason jars. “I assume what we accomplished on our date was not enough for Abigail.”

“ Date? We were not on a date. I didn’t even want to go. And anyway, what could she possibly want that we haven’t got now? We speak to each other, we act civil, God, we even send emails to your clueless students together!”

Will was still yanking the door handle as he said this, causing Hannibal to take a half-stride over to gently pull Will’s hand away. If Hannibal’s hand spent a little too long before dropping Will’s, or a deep red blush began to spread across Will’s face, no one mentioned it. 

Hannibal slid his hands into his pockets as he clarified, “I think that our current dynamic is simply a side effect and that there may have been a different goal in mind.”

Will did not want to hear it. “What is that even supposed to mean?” he fumed. “Actually, don’t answer that. Just stop talking.”

Hannibal didn’t push it but left Will to sit in his space on the floor as he perused his collection of exotic Himalayan salts. It didn’t take long for Will to break the tense silence.

“Do you have a watch?”

“Unfortunately not,”

Will groaned and dropped his head into his hands. This was going to be a long morning. As he continued to stare blankly at the door, he wondered how long it would be before Abigail would let them out. Could they yell loud enough to get her attention? She’d probably ignore them anyway. Hannibal didn’t have work that day, so there was no necessity for them to leave after breakfast, and since the pantry was filled with food, Will wasn’t sure they’d be let out anytime in the near future. 

Despite this, there was no better option than simply waiting it out, and Will began to count the number of pasta jars adorning the walls. He never looked to his side, but he could still see Hannibal in his peripheral vision, slowly lowering himself down next to him. He stared at the wall as if it were a painting in a gallery.

They sat there for an amount of time, although neither knew how long. After an internal debate with himself, he turned and spoke to the man at his side.

“When you were talking earlier, you said that Abigail wanted something other than friendship for us. I know I cut you off the first time, but what did you mean?”

An almost imperceptible smile spread across Hannibal’s face as he said, “I think Abigail may be trying to instigate a romantic relationship between us.”

This shocked Will more than anything. Of course, Hannibal was attractive, but Will had never imagined a romantic relationship with him. (or never allowed himself to) He thought back to their shared lunch, and the way he had focused on Hannibal’s lips. Even back during their therapy sessions in Baltimore, Hannibal’s voice was deep and smooth, and if Will wanted to hear it as he fell asleep, that was no one’s business. 

Of course, until now.

As Will took another glance at Hannibal, he was hit with a very jarring realization. He wanted that romantic relationship. It was unexpected and far beyond any sense of reason and rationality, but still, as he and Hannibal sat shoulder-to-shoulder in a cramped Italian pantry, it was the only thing that seemed to matter. He studied Hannibal’s side profile, bold and sharp, much like the man who wore it. Hannibal was everything Will wasn’t, put-together, charming, respected, but maybe that was what drew Will in. A messy, socially awkward, bundle of nerves falling for the elegant socialite. How cliche. But Will liked cliches, especially when they looked as good as Hannibal.

Instead of sharing this new development with Hannibal, Will let out a very dignified grunt of acknowledgment. 

It was many minutes before Hannibal spoke, just above a whisper. “You know Will, she may be right.”

“Right about what?” asked Will.

“Perhaps we could pursue a romantic relationship.”

“I- seriously?”

“Of course, if you are uncomfortable-”

Will shook his head, now face to face with Hannibal. “No, no, no, not that,”

Hannibal just kept looking at him, head tilting as if expecting an answer. Will wondered how Hannibal managed to stay so calm, especially considering the way Will was panicking internally.

“I-I just…” He wasn’t sure how to finish his sentence, so he didn’t. His heart was racing in his chest as he moved his hands to rest on Hannibal’s shoulders, making some very rare eye contact. With a deep breath, he closed his eyes and titled his head to the side. He slowly leaned in closer and closer, until….

“Hannibal!”

The door slammed open as Will pulled away from Hannibal at light speed, turning to look at the very angry Abigail standing in the doorway. She didn’t wait for Hannibal to respond, just continued to berate him. 

“What did you serve for dinner the other night? Or rather, who ?”

Hannibal chuckled, “Oh, well, Abigail-”

“No! Don’t pull that with me! Guess who was just at the door? La Polizia. Do you know what that means? You killed somebody and they’re on your trail.”

“I’m quite aware of my own murder record, Abigail.”

“Not the time for sarcasm.”

Will finally piped up when he asked, “Who did you even kill, and when? I thought you were too busy with teaching?”

“Now that you’re helping me with work, I had time to take care of a particularly discourteous janitor.”

“So, what does this mean, now that they’re onto us?” Abigail still looked to Hannibal for authority, despite her disappointment in him.

“I assume we’ll have to leave the country. Usually, I would stay longer, but I value your safety.”

Will spoke through a sardonic sigh as he said, “Better get packing,”

Notes:

Hey! Sorry if this chapter was a little short, I really wanted to get it out in a timely manner. It's currently about 1 am, and I wrote the majority of this chapter tonight, so ignore my many mistakes lol. As always, let me know if you liked it or have any criticism.