Chapter Text
Over the roar of the wind, Kili still managed to hear when Gandalf called to him. “There ahead is Minas Tirith, the gleaming Citadel of Gondor!”
Or maybe it was because the city was impossible to miss.
If Erebor had been beautiful, the city tunneling into the mountain and showing depths and heights that no one had ever seen before, then Minas Tirith was its opposite and equal in every way. The city had been carved open from the mountain, and higher and higher it rose to a jagged peak that jutted out into the sky. It was stunning.
The city only loomed higher the closer they reached, until they were welcomed into the gates. Gandalf immediately turned and they began to ascend, higher and higher up the levels until Kili thought he’d be dizzy from all the turning. He gripped the horse’s mane tighter. Falling off now, after days of hard riding, wouldn’t be to his advantage.
Finally they reached the top, where gates separated them from the high rise Kili had seen from a distance. But when they made to enter, a guard stepped forward, hand held up to halt them. “I cannot allow you to enter,” the guard said. “By order of the Steward of Gondor, Ecthelion the Second.”
Gandalf blinked, clearly startled. “I am a friend,” he assured him. “I am Gandalf the Grey, and I have come to speak with him. I was once an advisor to him.”
The guard looked more hesitant, but still he shook his head. “I still cannot allow you to enter. None may pass.”
“It’s Gandalf,” Kili found himself saying. “You wouldn’t let the greatest wizard in all of Middle-Earth pass?”
“Kili,” Gandalf muttered under his breath, the warning clear. Still, it garnered a response.
“The Steward is very ill,” the guard said. “And will suffer no visitors. Does the explanation suffice, now?”
“I could, perhaps, help,” Gandalf said, but he made no move forward. “We will retire to the next level below: ask Ecthelion if we may enter and aid him.”
That caught the guard’s attention, or so Kili thought. Then, a very familiar voice spoke, and Kili whipped his head so quickly he felt it in his neck. “Gandalf is allowed entrance,” Denethor said, from above the gates. “Let him in.”
The guard nodded sharply, and the gates swung open. Gandalf urged his horse on and then they were in, entering the most beautiful courtyard of stone Kili had ever seen. White stone gleamed in the sunlight, and a murmuring fountain in the center tried to give water to the dead tree.
Flames licking up the tree, all the stone broken, screams in the air, you are MINE
Kili flinched and clutched at his head, but it had passed quickly. “Again?” Gandalf murmured. Kili nodded. “It is only a memory. It cannot hurt you now.”
If it had been anyone else, Kili wouldn’t have believed them, but Gandalf had saved him. Somehow, Gandalf’s hand had stretched through the nightmare and the fire and pulled him away from the Eye and back to his own unburned body. If Gandalf said it was a memory, then it was a memory.
He shook himself all the same and turned to where Denethor approached. “Denethor!” he called cheerfully. “You’re alive!”
“And you as well,” Denethor greeted. He moved slowly, as one severely injured, but he was moving. The young man’s smile fell. “I am sorry I could not keep them from taking you. I tried my best, Kili, please believe that.”
“You did more than that,” Kili assured him. “I thought you’d died saving us. I am glad to see you didn’t. Your fighting left Fili and I in a better shape to escape, which we did. We owe you everything.”
Denethor almost seemed to turn shy. “Well, I am glad you are alive,” he said at last, and Gandalf turned the conversation elsewhere.
“Your father is not well?”
Denethor’s face fell. “No. He has not been, for some time. But it is not a physical ailment of the body. It is in his mind. For a time, Saruman aided him with this sickness, but Saruman helps no longer, and now the orb whispers to him constantly.”
Kili froze. “The orb?” he whispered. Gandalf settled a hand on his shoulder, as if to ground him, but all Kili could feel were the flames licking at his feet.
“A black orb,” Denethor confirmed, and Kili’s heart sank. “It whispers to him…much as the Ring whispered to me.”
If Kili’s heart had stopped at the mention of the orb, his lungs refused to let him breathe now. “The Ring. You have seen the Ring? Where?” Gandalf said urgently. “How came you by it?”
“It is gone, now,” Denethor said, and he gave a small humorless laugh. “With Bilbo. May he destroy it.”
“You’ve seen Bilbo?” Kili whispered.
“A few days ago. He came into Minas Tirith, but when the Ring called to me, I made him depart. He is not to return until the Ring is gone.”
Banished again. Kili was glad for Gandalf’s hand on his shoulder, or else he couldn’t have stood. Oh Bilbo.
“Where is he now?” Gandalf asked.
“On his way to Mordor. I sent with him a trusted friend, one who scouts for the Gondorian troops. He knows the paths well, and I would have no one else lead Bilbo safely from the Black Gate.”
Gandalf shuddered. “Yes, he moves away from the Gate,” he murmured, and when Kili glanced up, his eyes were distant. “You did well, Denethor, when other men would have faltered.”
Denethor shook off the praise. “Can you help my father? Can you save him?”
Gandalf pursed his lips. “I can try.”
It wasn’t the answer Denethor wanted, but he accepted it with a terse nod of his head. “Come; I will bring you to him.” He nodded to the man behind him, who held a crutch in one hand. The aide followed behind, clucking at Denethor when the man went faster than he probably should have. But Denethor was a man on a mission, and Kili remembered what it had felt like when the gold lust had fallen away, and he’d been left standing in Erebor, praying his uncle had been restored to sanity. If Thorin had still been under the thrall, he didn’t know how he would’ve felt, or what he could’ve done. Much like Denethor, he imagined.
The doors to the throne room opened, and Kili stared up in wonder at the tall ceilings. Light seemed to dash through the windows, turning the room a brilliant white. Down at the end was the tall seat of the King, and below it, on a small seat, sat a man.
The further they went down the room, however, the darker it grew. Even though the sun shone, everything seemed to be filled with gloom and vileness. A chill went down Kili’s back, and he shivered, despite the warmth of the sun. If he looked to the corners, he swore he saw a darkness waiting to devour him. He stepped closer to Gandalf and fixed his gaze on the man.
Denethor moved in front of him and gave a brief nod. “Father, they are here to see you,” he said. “Gandalf and a companion of my venture. Will you not receive them?” He walked closer when he heard no reply, and Kili was able to see the man Denethor called his kin. His skin was pale and wrinkled, and he looked to be a man of great age, despite having fathered Denethor. Spots danced across his leathered hands and face, and his eyes were pale and unseeing. In his dirty hands, nails so long that Kili winced uncomfortably, sat the orb.
Fire burning skin and memory and soul all for the GREAT EYE
Kili flinched again and looked anywhere except at the man.
Denethor’s voice now was a plea that would’ve sounded better on a fearful child wanting its mother. “Father? Will you not answer me?”
When Ecthelion spoke, it was not the voice Kili had been expecting. It was low and torn, as if he’d been screaming all night. Within it was a dark power Kili knew all too well. “Why would I answer a traitor?” Ecthelion said. His eyes never left the orb.
“Traitor?” Denethor gasped. “How have I betrayed you?”
“I ordered no funds to Adrahil, and yet you went behind my back and stole from me,” Ecthelion hissed. “You are a traitor indeed. Because you are my son, you are allowed to live.”
Denethor stumbled back, the pain on his face so wretched to look at that Kili reached to steady him. Denethor didn’t look at him, his eyes fixed on his father, but he clung to Kili’s arm. The hurt Kili saw wasn’t new, he realized, but resigned. This was not a new feeling. New words, perhaps, but Denethor had well expected the greeting he’d received. It only made Kili feel worse for him.
Already Gandalf was moving, his staff held high. “You will release him, Sauron,” he demanded. “Your darkness will not be allowed to linger!”
Ecthelion began to laugh, and it raised the hairs on Kili’s flesh. “The orb is mine,” he said. “If you think Sauron holds power here, you are wrong. This power is mine!”
“And with every day that passes, Sauron corrupts you, my old friend,” Gandalf said. He pushed his staff forward and Ecthelion fell back into his chair with a cry, the orb gripped tight in his hands. Denethor lunged forward, but Kili managed to hold him back.
“You seek someone…who wants a seat of power!” Ecthelion gasped. “You do not seek me! He is there, beside you! He tells lies to usurp me!” Ecthelion glared at Denethor, and Kili felt the urge to step in front of the young man in an attempt to defend him. “Do not believe him!”
“Silence!” Gandalf thundered, and the room turned darker still. Kili glanced around and found the guards held back by a mighty power. The mighty power of Gandalf. Even Denethor didn’t dare to move when Gandalf seemed to grow in scale right before them. A howling wind began to race around the room, pulling at them and whipping their clothes and hair about.
Gandalf pushed his staff forward, and Ecthelion cried out again. The orb began to burn in his hands, and Denethor finally made to move again. “No!” Kili shouted. “You can’t!”
“It’ll burn him!” Denethor yelled. “You don’t understand!”
“No, you don’t understand! I’ve been burned by that, by him!” Kili looked at it again and found himself caught by the Eye. That horrible, terrible Eye that had burned him away to nothing, until somehow, Gandalf had found him. “Gandalf saved me! He can save your father, too!”
Denethor looked torn, but when Kili pushed him back, he stayed, though his grasp on Kili’s arm tightened to the point of pain. It almost sounded like a storm now as Gandalf fought against the orb. “Release him!” Gandalf roared. “Release him!”
The orb flared so brightly that Kili thought he’d never see again. He shut his eyes tight and turned away to where Denethor was also cringing at its might.
Gandalf shouted again, somehow being heard over the tumult. “Release him!”
Ecthelion howled, a terrible sound that left Kili shuddering in fear, and then it all stopped. Something thudded against the ground, and when Kili finally dared to open his eyes, the orb was rolling towards his feet. He gave a frightened yell and shoved Denethor away from its path. It rolled to a stop in the middle of the room, a dark, silent orb once more.
Denethor recovered from his stupor and moved past Kili to the chair. Ecthelion was slumped over the side, eyes closed, cheeks sunken and still. He appeared dead. “Father!” Denethor cried, reaching for him.
Only the swiftness of Gandalf and his staff held him back. “Not yet,” Gandalf warned. “Let the power fade from him before you touch him, or you would be ensnared.”
Even as Kili watched, the pallor in Ecthelion's face began to warm to a rosier hue. His skin tightened, his hair was no longer wiry but full and long, and when his eyelids fluttered open, the eyes beneath were colorful and aware. He blinked a few times, though he did not move to rise. “Where…?”
“You are home, Ecthelion,” Gandalf said warmly. “Welcome back, my friend.” He removed his staff from Denethor’s path, and the young man raced to his father’s side. He clutched at his father’s hand, smiling brightly through the tears in his eyes.
“Father, you are well again. The curse is gone!”
Ecthelion nodded slowly, making it clear that while the orb no longer claimed his life, he was still weakened. Kili had only touched the orb but twice, and briefly: to be attached to it for so long, day after day… he forced himself not to quake in fear, but it was close. Mahal, he couldn’t even begin to imagine it.
The Steward’s eyes rose to Gandalf’s, and he smiled at last. “Gandalf, my old advisor,” he said. “Long have we awaited your return.”
“And it seems that I have come when I was needed most,” Gandalf said. “Would that you had not suffered at all.”
Ecthelion shook his head. “Such things are beyond us, my friend. But I am clear minded once more, and grateful to you for it. To you and your friend,” he said, turning to Kili. “Who has come with you?”
“He was one of the company with me,” Denethor said. “I saved his life, his life and his brother’s. That is how I fell.”
Ecthelion gave a short nod, but his eyes remained on Kili. Feeling awkward, Kili finally spoke. “I am Kili of the line of Durin, and I owe my life to your son, my lord. He indeed saved my life, and my kin’s, with his valiant efforts.” There, that hadn’t been too off, had it? He glanced at Gandalf for approval, and Gandalf merely smiled in clear amusement. Sure, let the wizard laugh and be of no help in times of political crisis.
“I am glad he was of use to you,” Ecthelion said. He rose at last, unsteadily, and when Denethor offered him an arm and a hand, Ecthelion very obviously ignored him. “Though I did not permit him to go.”
“You were ill,” Denethor murmured, but the resigned look on his face spoke of this conversation having been spoken before. “The Lady of the Woods has long been an ally, and never before has she called upon us for aid. I was glad to go.”
“Forgive me,” Ecthelion said, nodding to Gandalf and Kili with a smile. “I must retire. You have saved me: let me not damage the good work you have done by collapsing here.” Guards came forward then, along with several attendants, and as one they moved from the throne room.
Denethor looked as if his heart was broken. “Denethor,” Kili began, but Denethor shook his head.
“He must heal. How can he lead Gondor if he’s not well? I will not badger him with more questions.” He spun on his heel, heading for the door with bitterness in his brow.
“Denethor,” Gandalf called, stopping the young man where he stood. The wizard looked pained but spoke and said, “Your father loves you.”
“He loves Gondor, as he should,” Denethor said, and there was the pain again, clear to all who would see it on his face. He gave a sad smile. “When a flower blooms, you do not need to tend to it as much as you would a seedling. It is self-sufficient. So it was with me: when I was full grown, I didn’t need the little things such as love or comfort.”
“But a flower will die if it can’t get what it needs,” Kili interjected. “And you’re not a flower, Denethor, you’re a person, you’re his son.”
Denethor’s pain disappeared beneath a mask of stone. “Then perhaps I should begin acting as a son of a Steward should.” He stormed off and out of the throne room, and Kili could’ve sworn he saw a young child in his shadow, lost and afraid. Then he was gone, and even the warmth of the sun that now brightened every corner of the room wasn’t enough to ease his heart.
It wasn’t as if Denethor was wrong, either. It was clear that Ecthelion felt no compassion or love for his son, and Kili felt his own heart twist at the thought of not being loved. How could you not be loved, especially by family? They were the only ones you were supposed to turn to, the ones you counted on. He’d had Mother and Uncle and Fili, and while it hadn’t been a lot, he’d still had something.
“This may not be something I can mend,” Gandalf said with a sigh. He wandered over to the orb, and Kili carefully looked away. When he looked back, the orb was wrapped in a cloth, and was being tenderly held by Gandalf. “I can push away the powers of darkness, and I can see distant events and people. But I cannot mend hearts or repair rifts long torn.”
“Everything can be healed,” Kili swore. “Two hearts pushed aside over some sense of betrayal can always be joined again. It might take work, but it can happen.”
Gandalf raised his eyebrows. “I think you’ve wandered away from Denethor and his father to two individuals no longer with us.”
Kili flushed and looked away. “What of it?” he mumbled.
“Kili, they may never reconcile,” Gandalf said gently. “What Thorin did to Bilbo was a grave injustice, worse still because he broke more than Bilbo’s heart, he broke part of Bilbo’s very spirit.”
“You didn’t see Bilbo,” Kili countered. “In Rohan. He misses Uncle. He still loves Uncle.”
“And yet, that may not be enough to repair their relationship,” Gandalf said. Kili stared at the white tile beneath him and found, to his humiliation, hot tears burning in his eyes. He felt all of twenty-five years old and crying over his favorite toy being lost. But he had never accounted for his uncle and Bilbo being unable to fix things between them. It had just been a matter of getting them together to actually talk, which Mahal knew his uncle was wretched at, and then things would’ve been better.
He’d never considered that they wouldn’t be together, in the end of it all.
“Perhaps they will,” Gandalf said. “But you must be prepared for it to not go according to your plans, Kili.” He walked towards the doors of the throne room.
“No.”
Gandalf stopped and turned back to him. “No,” Kili said again, raising his head and glaring at Gandalf. “I refuse. Because I’ve seen how much Bilbo loves Uncle, and I know how much Thorin loves Bilbo. I saw it on the journey, and I saw it in Bilbo in Rohan, in the letter he wrote to Uncle, and I saw it in Thorin in how he refuses to give up hope, how he’s desperate to find Bilbo. I will not give up, because they will make things better. Don’t give up on them now. If we can’t hope for happiness in their future, how are we supposed to hope for happiness amidst all this other darkness?”
It wasn’t often that Gandalf was struck silent, but Kili’s words seemed to have stopped him in his tracks. Kili tried to even his breathing, his fists unclenching.
Finally Gandalf cleared his throat. “I believe you’re right, Kili,” he said, and he smiled. “I’m proud of you, for you’ve seen the truth and the heart of it. We must hope, and we must hope for those we love. If they can achieve happiness, then joy and love will never be lost, not so long as we fight for it.”
Kili felt a real smile brighten on his face for the first time since they’d entered Minas Tirith. “And they’re fighting for it.”
“More than anyone else ever has,” Gandalf agreed. “Come. We have to find the Captain of the Guard and round up the Gondor troops. With Ecthelion ill, the power passes to Denethor. And Denethor would rather die than see the White City fall. I would also know more of Bilbo.”
Kili nodded and hurried after Gandalf, back into the real sunlight outside.
The days passed swiftly after that. Riders came and went, each bearing news of villages and whom they could spare. They were noble people, willing to lend aid to their king, but the numbers were too few and far to truly defend against the might of Mordor.
“Three hundred men strong will come with Lord Wulf.”
Thengel nodded, and the Rider left. “Are there any others?” he asked.
The man at the door shook his head. “Not yet, my liege. But perhaps tomorrow; the sun has set for the evening.”
“Perhaps,” Thengel murmured. Aragorn could see the weariness beginning to set in his face, aging him quickly. “That will be all, Haleth. See to the Riders; you are now Captain.”
“It should be Holdwine, my liege,” Haleth said haltingly. “I cannot take the post.”
“Holdwine may not be fit for the post,” Thengel said. “And if he is, his recovery will still take time. Until such time, you are the Captain.”
Haleth gave a sharp nod and left. Only after the doors had shut did Thengel give a sigh and sink further into the throne. “Too few,” he murmured. “There are too few.”
“We must have hope,” Aragorn said. Thengel nodded and sat up straighter, but not by much.
“Is there no one else?” Thorin asked quietly. “No one else who would aid us?”
“Have you any kin left, Thorin?” Thengel asked, not unkindly. “For I have none that I have not sent Riders to. I called everyone whom I could for Isengard. I had not expected Sauron to mount another attack so quickly.”
The doors opened, cutting off Thorin’s response. Aragorn turned his attention to the two figures cloaked in black who approached. Something about them was…familiar. He leaned forward in his seat.
The figure on the left pulled back their hood. “Hail, King Thengel of Rohan,” said Lord Elrond, to the startled gasps of many. Thengel sat up straighter in surprise. “May your winds blow good fortunes to you.”
“Lord Elrond,” Aragorn whispered. It was all he could say, in his shock. What was Lord Elrond doing here, so far from Imladris?
“Well met, Lord of Rivendell,” Thengel greeted. “You are welcome in my halls. What brings you so far from your home?”
“I come to aid you,” Elrond said. “I have only a few warriors, but they, and I, shall stand with you against the abomination in the East. Long ago, I stood beside men to destroy the Ring, and I failed. I will not do so now. I would see this evilness destroyed.”
If someone had dropped a blade of grass, it would have made a sound, the halls were so silent. Growing hope was on every face, and Aragorn breathed in deeply. Hope indeed was welcome.
Then Elrond spoke again. “I confess that it is not the only reason I have come so far.” He looked hesitant, something Aragorn had not often seen. He stepped away, and the second cloaked figure approached, until only steps remained between them and Aragorn. Then the hood was pulled away.
Aragorn stared, stunned into silence. Lips turned up into a smile. “Is that a way to greet me?”
“Arwen,” he whispered, the name dragged almost painfully from his lips. She was there in front of him, beautiful and sweet, and with her came the fresh air of Rivendell. Somehow, she was here.
Murmurs from the dwarves behind him pulled him from his stupor, and he realized they were murmurs of admiration. They had seen the beauty of Lady Galadriel, but they had never seen Arwen. She was like the soft dew of the fresh morning, the gentle sunlight of the evening. She was bright, she was kind. She was his Evenstar, the only star he had ever turned to for guidance. And he had never dared to think that she could be his, for he was mortal, and she was not. She was his every desire that he could never have, his every hope for a happier life.
Yet she stood before him now, and she reached out to brush her fingers across his face. Aragorn closed his eyes and reveled in the sensation. “I am here for you,” she said. “I am here to give you what you need most. I am here to give you your hope back, Aragorn, son of Arathorn.” When he opened his eyes, her smile was subdued, but there was such warmth in her eyes he almost dared not look. “It is time.”
She pulled from beneath her cloak a long scabbard and blade and offered it to him. “Renewed shall be the blade that was broken,” Elrond said, and Aragorn let his trembling fingers wander over the sheathed blade. “And the crownless again shall be king.”
Narsil. The shards of Narsil were right before him, but no longer were they broken. “This is Andúril, the King’s Blade,” Elrond declared. He moved his gaze to Aragorn and seemingly pinned him there. “It is for one who would be King.”
Aragorn did not take the blade. He could not. “I am not King,” he whispered brokenly. “Arwen-“
“You are more than you have ever thought you were,” Arwen spoke to him. “You are the King. You always have been. You may one day be King of Gondor, but you have always been King of your own destiny.” She leaned forward, closer so only he could hear. “And you are King of my heart.”
He was certain the room was spinning. But when she offered him the blade again, he did not hesitate this time. He gripped the handle and pulled, and the long, gleaming blade shone in the light. It seemed made for his hand, and the balance was better than any other he’d ever had. It felt as if it belonged with him. It seemed to be an extension of his arm, and it felt right.
He finally looked back to her and her glowing face. He could take one of these offered gifts, but not the other. “I cannot be your King,” he murmured. “I would not see you parted from your people, from your life.”
A blade in one hand, the love he craved before him. He clenched his fists and wished he could cling to both with everything he could. Arwen merely smiled, her eyes bright.
“How many have you brought to aid us?” Thorin asked. His question was not growled but honestly asked, and it spoke volumes of how much Thorin respected the elf lord. Or perhaps, it spoke of one who was growing into his own crown, much as it seemed Aragorn was growing into his. He thought of the weight that the crown should feel like, of how it had felt before, but it only settled briefly onto his shoulders. When he looked to Arwen, it faded completely.
Perhaps…perhaps the weight was not so unkind, if there was someone there to aid you.
“Four hundred,” Elrond said, regret in his tone. “It was all I could spare. But there is another army. One whom you could call upon.”
All eyes rested on him. Elrond in turn looked to Aragorn. “There are those in the mountains,” he spoke slowly. “You could call them.”
Thengel reared back just as Aragorn did. “Traitors,” Aragorn hissed. “Murderers. All of them. These are who you would have us call?”
“Who are they?” Gimli asked, but it was Ori who answered.
“The Dead. You speak of the Dead.”
Elrond nodded, and Ori continued to explain. “Long ago, they swore an oath to the King of Gondor, but when he needed them, they turned and fled. He cursed them and swore they would never find release from this world until they had fulfilled their pledge to him.” His eyes widened when he realized what Elrond was suggesting. “You think Master Aragorn…?”
“I am no king,” Aragorn protested. “Elrond, I cannot command them.”
“You are the King,” Elrond persisted. He nodded to the blade in Aragorn’s right hand. “Put aside the Ranger. Become the King you were born to be. Summon them to your side, and you could release them and gain the aid you seek.”
The army of the Dead was rumored to be great indeed, and it was an army of soldiers who could never die. This was an army that could meet Sauron’s forces on the field and aid the beings of Middle-Earth for good. Mind made up, Aragorn turned to Thengel. “I would take leave of you, now that Lord Elrond is here. He can aid you, better than I could.”
“You underestimate yourself,” Thengel said, but he gave a sharp nod. “If you believe you can find us aid amongst the Dead Men, then I bid you good fortune. May it help us all.”
He had no idea if it was truly going to help, but he had to try. He gave a nod in return and, after taking the sheath from Arwen, he went for his things. There was no time to waste. If Elrond had foreseen that the Dead could aid them, he would not deviate from it. Perhaps he, too, could be the King that could make a difference.
Only when he had gathered everything to him did he realize there was a presence behind him. He turned and found Thorin at the door. “Walking the Paths of the Dead is dangerous, or so Ori so descriptively described after you left,” he said. “Don’t leave in the morning without us, we’ll be joining you shortly enough.”
Aragorn blinked. “We?”
From behind him, Gimli stepped out. “Aye, we. You didn’t think you’d be leavin’ without us, did you?”
“This is not your battle,” Aragorn said. “I would not see you come to harm.”
“And I would not leave you abandoned when I could aid,” Thorin replied. He gave a quick smile, the first that Aragorn had seen in days. “Haven’t you learned enough of the stubbornness of dwarves?”
“I may have heard such mention,” he said dryly, and Gimli chuckled.
“Best not argue with it then, laddie. We’re goin’ with you. Dwalin too, but he’s off tryin’ to leave Ori behind.”
“Ori, Bofur, and Fili will remain here to aid Thengel. We will go with you to help plead with the Dead.” Thorin’s smile fell to a dark frown. “They have no morals or honor, and they will not hesitate to cut us down. This, I do not need Ori to tell me. I studied their tale as a lad, much as Ori did. I will not leave you in that den alone.”
Despite the sorrow that seemed to have settled in the halls, of the despair that crept through the doorway with each Rider, Aragorn could not help but smile. This was the hope that they so needed. A guiding hand to show them the way, a light in the darkness that spoke of the only love Aragorn could ever want, and loyal friends to remain with him until the very end. “Thank you,” he managed. “Thank you.”
Thorin nodded. He paused, as if listening to something, then gave a smile. “You should say goodbye to your queen,” he said quietly. “Do not do as I have done, or you’ll regret it forever.”
“You may see him yet,” Aragorn said. Thorin just sighed.
“Even if I do, I will forever bear the regret in my heart. I should have told him when I had the chance. You have a chance: do not waste it.” He left then, tugging Gimli with him. Not a moment later, as if she had been waiting, Arwen appeared. Her cloak was gone, and her hair hung loosely around her shoulders and arms.
Aragorn did not hesitate to pull her close, and she brushed her nose against his. “Long have I waited to see you again,” Arwen said, the Elvish language flowing off her tongue. “And here you stand, on the cusp of a great battle that makes to swallow you whole.” Sadness crossed her face. “Will you make me a promise to return?”
“I cannot,” he murmured back in her language. “There is no promise that I can give of that. I can only try and do my best.”
She nodded and lowered her eyes. “If you do return…I would be yours.”
Aragorn stopped breathing. She could not mean-
“All the stars in the sky do not shine as brightly as your heart,” she whispered. “I have seen you, your valiant heart, your shimmering soul. I fell in love with you when first I saw you.” Her smile was warm, and her eyes spoke of the truth to her words. Gently she brushed a lock of hair from his face, and the longing in her eyes, the love that shone from them, nearly took his breath away.
“There will never be another for me. You are the one my heart desires. You are my everything. Long did I live, before you, but now I cannot imagine a lifetime without you.”
“I would take from you your very life,” he told her, and he wasn’t certain if he was begging her to stay or to go. “You would never be immortal with me.”
“I would rather spend one lifetime with you than live out the ages without you,” she told him. She looked down again, and when he felt her hand on his, he too let his gaze drift down.
In his hand was her necklace. The Evenstar itself. His eyes shot back up, his surprise making him drift into Westron. “I cannot take this-“
“It is a gift,” she said, and she wrapped his fingers around it. “And a promise. Your life and mine are entwined, now, like the roots and branches of a tree.” She leaned forward, and her breath was sweet on his face. His eyes drifted shut as he reached for her, his hand drifting up her shoulders. His Arwen, his beautiful Elven maiden.
She whispered, and the words sounded like a shout in his mind. “I choose a mortal life.”
He pulled her to him and brought his mouth down on hers. She wrapped her arms around him and brought herself closer still. Her lips were soft, so soft, and despite their gentleness, there was a determination behind each kiss, each pass of her lips against his, as if to tell him that she was his and would never leave. He clung to her, wishing it were true.
They stayed that way a long time, trading kisses, sharing breaths in their own intimate world. It was simply them for this short time, as short as they had. I will come back, he wanted to tell her.
She smiled at him, eyes shining. I know, she wanted to say.
They kissed again instead.
“Ori-“
Ori stiffly ignored him, shoving things into his pack. “You can’t,” Dwalin said softly again, and that was it.
He rounded on Dwalin, fury in his eyes. “You told me you hated the way Dori coddled me like a child. You said you hated when Nori would tease me like a babe. Yet here you are, ordering me around, doing the same thing!” He turned back to his pack, ignoring the shaking in his arms as he did so.
Dwalin didn’t. He put his hands on Ori’s shoulders, making him tense even more. When Dwalin said nothing, Ori began to speak, but then he felt a gentle nudge against the back of his head. “I said I didn’t want you to go,” Dwalin said. “I’m askin’ you to stay.”
“And you expect me to be all right with you, what, darting off into the Paths of the Dead?” Ori said before he snorted. “You’re going through the Dwimorberg, Dwalin. You’re going to walk amongst the Dead. No, I’m not all right with this!”
“Ori-“
Ori tensed up so hard he thought he’d shatter into a million pieces. Then he felt the fight leave him all at once, and Dwalin tightened his grasp to keep him upright. “I won’t leave you,” he mumbled. “I won’t.”
“Ori,” Dwalin murmured, and when Ori turned around, the gruff warrior looked heartbroken. “M’not leavin’ you. But I’ve gotta see Thorin through to safety. There’d be no one else to watch for you, like Bofur could.”
Anger began to swell again, and hurt, buried deep beneath where Ori didn’t want to look. “I don’t need watching over-“
“No, but I need to know you’re safe,” Dwalin said, and Ori paused. “This isn’t about you, it’s me that’s the problem. I can’t defend Thorin knowin’ you’re not safe. And I can’t keep you both safe at the same time.”
“You could,” Ori said defensively. “You could keep a hundred orcs at bay and still keep us both safe.”
Dwalin chuckled. “As much faith as you have in me, it doesn’t make it truth, much as I’d like it to.” He sighed and rested his forehead against Ori’s, and Ori closed his eyes. He knew what was going to happen. He knew what Dwalin was going to ask of him. And he knew what he was going to say.
“Please stay,” Dwalin said, and Ori’s eyes shot open at the word that never, ever passed his warrior’s lips. “Please. If I’ve got to get down on my knees to beg, I’ll do it.”
“Dwalin,” Ori breathed, but Dwalin wasn’t finished.
“I know about the Dead. And seein’ you there with ‘em, I couldn’t stand it. I didn’t swear to Dori or Nori to keep you safe, I swore to me, and I can’t…I can’t do that there. Even if you ride into battle with Rohan, you’ll have Bofur and Fili, Thengel and the elf lord. You wouldn’t be trapped with the Dead.”
“And you think I want you with them, either?”
“The Dead don’t scare me, Ori. I’ve seen enough dead in my lifetime. You amongst the Dead…aye. That’ll scare me more than anythin’ else in this world. I’d rather face Sauron with nothin’ more than a cheese knife than see you there.”
Ori bit his lip. “Please,” Dwalin entreated, and finally Ori nodded.
“I’ll stay. But you’ve got to come back.”
Dwalin smiled. “Give you my word as best I can. ‘Sides, I’ve got to make certain Thorin gets out alive. If he doesn’t, I’d have to answer to Bilbo, and a hobbit mad isn’t anythin’ I want to mess with.”
They both chuckled at the thought, though it quickly turned sad. Ori thought of his fellow book-lover, the friend who’d spoken with him when no one else would, the one who’d encouraged him to speak to Dwalin in the first place. He owed Bilbo so much.
It was important, now, that Dwalin know. “Bilbo told me to speak to you,” he said. “That night. When the others had all gone to sleep.”
“Did he?”
“He did. He saw how I watched you. Told me to at least speak to you and be friends.”
Dwalin chuckled, and his smile was bright and bold. “What?” Ori said, frowning.
“Nothin’. Only that he told me to talk to you that night. Said he was tired of my simperin’ around when you were right there for talkin’ to.”
Ori began to grin. Of course Bilbo had spoken to Dwalin. “I should’ve known: you spoke more openly that night than I’d ever heard you speak before.”
“Was his doing,” Dwalin admitted. “Wouldn’t have had the nerve otherwise. One of the bravest beings I’ll ever know.”
Ori thought of Bilbo, out there somewhere, all alone, and shut his eyes tight. He thought of Thorin, parted from him for so long, and wondered if he’d be the same. If he’d never see Dwalin again, and know that this was the last time he’d be able to speak to him.
“Dwalin-“
The warrior cut him off with a kiss, his tongue parting Ori’s lips easily. Ori moaned and tilted his head, his tongue brushing against Dwalin’s. He tasted of ale and something sweet, perhaps the berries from the table, and something distinctly Dwalin. It was everything Ori had ever wanted, and he clutched at Dwalin’s shirt, pulling him even closer.
It would be a while before they emerged, subdued but not sorrowful. They weren’t parting forever, and they were both certain of that. Just for a time. A short time, if Ori had anything to do about it. Dwalin was coming back.
And that, Ori was holding him to.
Inside the halls, a dwarf heir sat with his Shieldmaiden, sitting by the fire and thinking of those whom they loved no longer with them. Their hands were joined, and Dernwyn’s forehead pressed gently against Fili’s. He pulled her closer to him and shared breaths with her.
Outside the halls, a dwarf king gazed at the stars above, wondering if his beloved was watching the same stars as he was. Thorin closed his eyes and imagined that they were gazing at the same star in the sky, the bright one far out towards the south. He clenched his hands and wished they were holding Bilbo.
Far away, head tucked against a rock, Mablang sleeping beside him on the ground, a hobbit stared at the brightest star near him and thought of Thorin. Bilbo shivered from the cold winds sweeping over the mountain and clutched his hand over where a pin should’ve been.
