Chapter Text
The river was wide and soothing, even as ships sailed in and out. Kili watched it for a little longer until he felt a tap on his back. When he turned, Gandalf was smiling. “The river is well fortified, now,” he said. “Any forces of Sauron’s will have been warned against.”
“Good,” Kili said. His gaze unconsciously drifted to the dark storm ahead of them. It was no storm, Gandalf had told him, but Mordor itself. There was lighting in the sky, and the wind that swept over the plains smelled cold and dead. He shuddered. “If they come, though, where will the people of Osgiliath go?”
“They’ll go to Minas Tirith,” Gandalf assured him. A soldier called his name, and Gandalf left him gazing at the horizon.
Somewhere out there, there was a hobbit and a guide, wandering into Mordor. “Be careful, Bilbo,” he murmured. “We’re waiting for you to come back.” Up until Denethor had led them to the city by the river, Mordor had been a fairy tale in his mind, a terrible name. It hadn’t been real. But there was no denying what was so close, close enough that Kili could make out features in the mountains.
When he was tapped again, he turned, but frowned when he didn’t see Gandalf. “Down,” a young voice said, and Kili immediately dropped his head.
She was young, much younger than he’d thought, only a child. But her eyes were deep and knowing, and when she smiled at him, he immediately smiled back. “Hello,” he said. “Are you lost?”
“You said Bilbo,” she said, and Kili froze. Mahal, him and his big mouth… “Do you know Mister Bilbo, too?”
He’d barely reprimanded himself for reprimanding himself, given that this was a child in front of him, and then her other words finally struck home. “You know a little hobbit?” Kili asked.
It was the right thing to say. Her face lit up. “Yes, I do!” she said. “He’s absolutely lovely. But he left without saying goodbye.” Her smile fell. “I’d wondered if…if you knew him. If he was still here.”
“He’s gone on,” Kili said regretfully. It was interesting that he had to look down, down enough that he finally crouched in front of her. He was actually tall enough to warrant crouching. That was a lovely surprise. “But he’ll be coming back. He’d better.”
“Are you one of his friends?” another girl said, this one – unfortunately for Kili – taller than the first. Her dark hair spun around her face in the wind, and she reached for the other girl, tucking her in against her. “He spoke of friends that were no longer traveling with him.”
“I am,” Kili said. “Kili, at your service.” He stood and gave a bow, much to their delight and laughter.
The first girl gave a quick curtsy. “Finduilas, at yours. This is my sister, Ivriniel,” she said, not even giving the girl a chance to speak. Ivriniel rolled her eyes but didn’t argue.
The hot pain of Fili tore through him, stuttering his breath. He missed his brother. “Well met, Finduilas and Ivriniel,” he said instead. “I’ve just been looking at the river.”
“We’re traveling on it today,” Finduilas said. “Back home, to the sea.”
“The sea?” Kili said, blinking. Of course everyone knew it was there, but he’d never thought it was so close. “This river leads to the sea?”
“It does,” Ivriniel said. “You should travel it, one day, you and Bilbo. You could come visit us in Dol Amroth.”
“That does sound like something fun,” Kili agreed. “I’ve only ever seen ponds and rivers and mountains and caves. I’d like to see the sea.” He grinned at his own words.
“Mountains?” Ivriniel said, her eyes widening. “And caves? Are you…are you a dwarf?”
“I am indeed.”
“But you’re so tall!”
Kili laughed. “A bit, more than most other dwarves. I got lucky, I suppose.” And had met an Ent, but that was neither here nor there.
“Wow,” Finduilas breathed in awe. Ivriniel looked just as awestruck. “A real dwarf. Just like we met a real hobbit.”
“Not many girls can say that,” Kili said, and they both giggled at his wink. He almost wished they weren’t going: they’d managed to brighten some of the dismay in his heart. Like Legolas did.
Well, so much for not feeling dismal anymore.
Finduilas looked up and frowned. “It’s not sunny anymore,” she said, and when Kili looked up, there were indeed dark clouds rolling in from the east. “I didn’t think it would storm today, it was so bright.”
“Neither did I,” Kili murmured. When he looked towards Mordor again, a tall ship moved to block his vision. He glared at it, annoyed, until it had passed. When it did, however, his eyes immediately locked onto several crafts coming across from the east bank. Crafts that were full of-
“Orcs!” Kili shouted. “Gandalf, orcs!”
That was all the orcs needed. Suddenly arrows whipped through the air, one of them striking Kili across his cheek. It stung, but not enough to halt him as he reached for the girls. Ivriniel screamed and clutched at Finduilas, and they needed to get out of there, now. “Come on!” Kili yelled, and he hauled them away.
Finduilas suddenly struggled against him, trying to get back to the docks. “Fin, no!” Ivriniel shouted.
“Papa!” Finduilas screamed, and Kili wanted to shut his eyes, wanted to not be here, listening to the fear in her voice. “Papa!”
But the orcs had nearly made the docks. There was no going back. People were running and screaming, racing in Minas Tirith’s direction, and that was exactly where Kili was taking them. His bow was back with Gandalf’s horse Shadowfax, and he couldn’t believe he’d left it there. All he had on him were his daggers and the small sword Fili had insisted he take before he’d left his brother in Rohan. Fili, Mahal, he couldn’t fight without his brother, he needed Fili-
There was a loud roar from behind them as the orcs made land. “Go!” Kili shouted, pushing at the girls. As fast as they were, Finduilas was still a child, and eventually Kili simply picked her up and carried her as best he could. She was small, but not that small, but they needed to run. He took Ivriniel’s hand in his and, keeping Finduilas on his hip, her arms wrapped tight around him, he made his way through the city.
All around him, people began to fall to the orcs. Soldiers appeared and began to fight, but the orcs had gained too much ground to be so easily beaten back. Kili thought of the other side of the city and wondered if they’d simply been silenced before a warning could be given.
“Gandalf, where is Gandalf?” Kili muttered. He didn’t remember the way out of the city, and there were so many passes, so many doorways and gates that he didn’t know how to get out. He just aimed in the direction the masses seemed to be going, and he urged the girls onward. “C’mon, we can make it,” he told them. “Just keep going, we’re almost there.”
He was almost out, the field to Minas Tirith in his sights, when something flew through the air. The chunk of rock that they’d catapulted hit hard, destroying stone and wood, and the arch began to collapse. Kili caught Ivriniel around the waist and pulled her in close, then threw himself into the arch, twisting to land on his back. He hit the ground hard and gasped as the air was forced from his lungs. The stones fell and he tried to curl around the girls as best he could. The arch was soon covered and crumbled, and the building next to it began to topple without the support.
Worse yet, there was enough room for things to get through. Things like orcs. “Go,” Kili managed to gasp, and the girls, who seemed unhurt, scrambled to their feet and raced out of the city. Kili pushed himself up slowly, painfully, and tried to reach for his sword. But he wasn’t breathing right, the air not back in his lungs yet, and two orcs were coming through. He stumbled and pulled the blade out, but it wasn’t in time. With a savage yell the orc’s blade tore through the air at his neck.
Then it froze, blade falling from its hand, and Kili could only stare at the arrow that was lodged deep in its skull. The other orc had suffered the same fate, and even as they fell, even before the sound of the approaching horse behind him registered, even before he turned around, he knew who it was.
“Legolas.”
The elf was already sliding off the horse by the time Kili had run out of the city. He threw himself at Legolas, and Legolas held on so tightly Kili thought he’d lose his breath again. “You’re here,” he mumbled. “What are you doing here? I don’t care, you’re here, and that’s all that matters, Legolas-“
“We have to go,” Legolas said, but he was reluctant to release Kili. “The orcs have taken Osgiliath.” He paused, eyes darkening in anger when he reached for Kili’s face. Kili frowned, confused, until Legolas’s fingers came away with blood. The arrow, the first arrow, before he’d grabbed-
“Finduilas! Ivriniel!” he shouted, wildly searching the fields. “Two girls, they came running out together, did you see them?”
“Kili!”
Then they were there, racing back to him, and he wrapped them tightly in his arms. “Can you bear us all?” Kili asked.
“For you, anything,” Legolas said. Kili felt warmth begin to blaze in his heart, sweeping through him even as the cold winds from Mordor continued to sweep around them. Legolas was here, with him, and while it didn’t ease the ache of missing Fili, there was still someone here with him.
They quickly put both girls on the horse, with Legolas in the back and Finduilas positioned in front of Kili. With the girls secure, they raced back to Minas Tirith, following the fleeing people of Osgiliath.
“Master Baggins,” Mablang said. “We must move on.”
Bilbo nodded absently, his eyes still gazing westward towards Gondor. The storm had begun to drift further beyond Mordor’s borders, and he could make out Osgiliath, clouded and smoking. His thoughts traveled back to just a few days ago, when they’d barely started climbing the mountain between them and Mordor. They’d hidden as orcs and more orcs had marched past them, all of them heading west. Bilbo had felt uneasy, praying that they’d go elsewhere, that they’d leave the innocents in Osgiliath alone.
But they were orcs, and orcs aimed at making the innocent suffer.
“Master Baggins?”
“It burns,” he said, his response nearly lost in the wind. They were nearing the top now, so close, and Bilbo had never been more grateful to be so high. Not that he was looking forward to going back down, but it had to be easier than climbing up unforgiving rock. He’d pulled cloth from his trousers to wrap around his hands when the sharp rocks had cut at him, and even Mablang’s gloves hadn’t lasted long against the stones they used to climb. They weren’t even going to discuss Bilbo’s feet, which were shredded and so painfully tender now that every step sent pain up his legs. He could feel every little pebble against his skin, and it made him want to hop to safety. And they weren’t going to speak of the ankle that throbbed with his pulse, pounding in pain with every waking moment. If he was able to walk at all after this, he’d be grateful. He didn’t even think he could handle walking on grass now.
Maybe cool stone. Cold stone passageways, perhaps, he could walk down those. Like the ones in Erebor that he’d walked along briefly before…
Mablang had come along beside him now, and was staring out at Osgiliath. For a moment, his eyes tightened in sadness, and then it was gone. “The orcs will have their way with the city,” he said at last. His voice was soft, as it had been since they’d begun their ascent. Speaking any louder seemed foreign and wrong, here in the mountains under the black clouds. “Osgiliath was never truly protected. But if it fell, then it served its purpose: Minas Tirith will be warned. It was meant to be a port and nothing more, but people began to flock there to live, especially those who work in trade.”
“Children?” Bilbo couldn’t help but ask. He hated himself for doing it, but the words left before he could halt them.
“Families, yes. That is something you should know by now, Master Baggins.” Something dark crossed past Mablang’s face, and when he turned to Bilbo, the hobbit barely managed to keep from shivering. “War does not ostracize the innocent from its path. If it breathes, then the orcs will cut it down. Even if it is another orc. They are nourished from the sight of spilled blood. You would do best to remember that. They turn upon each other just as easily as they would a brand new babe.”
Mablang turned back to their ‘path’, or what counted as one, and began to ascend. “Keep up, Halfling,” Mablang snapped, and after a long moment, Bilbo did so. There was something in Mablang’s past there, something dark and vile, something that had torn innocence from him. Something that had hardened him.
It still frightened him to walk beside Mablang, though. Bilbo had very carefully kept the Ring hidden and had kept his distance, so it didn’t whisper to the man. But he knew that the closer they came to Mordor, the louder it would get. And he didn’t know if it would be enough to save him, when the time came.
For now, he climbed. The cloth tied to his hands was beginning to unravel, and it wouldn’t last long. Please let us be near the top, he thought. Please. I’ll never make it through Mordor if I can’t climb the mountain.
Mablang would be no help to him, and honestly, he wasn’t certain if he even wanted help from the man. He felt the Ring burn against his chest, and the pain was almost enough to distract him from his ripped hands and feet.
Almost.
“We’re nearing the top,” Mablang called quietly over his shoulder. “Then we’ll take the path higher into the mountains, to the stairs.”
“Stairs?” Bilbo asked. “You mean someone put stairs here?” Why hadn’t he been told this before?
“We could not reach them the other way. I would not take you to Minas Morgul, Master Baggins. It is the City of the Nazgûl. The black wraiths that you have seen flying around from time to time.”
The black riders that had attacked them and injured Holdwine. “But there are stairs,” Bilbo entreated. “A real path.”
“A real path.” Mablang huffed a laugh. “You could say that. I will take you to the stairs, but no further. You will find your way hence from there.”
Despite the fear that Mablang set in his heart, the fear of being alone was worse. “You won’t come with me?” Bilbo asked.
Mablang stopped his climbing and looked back at him, and from under the hood, his eyes glittered. “I would not cross the plains of Mordor for all the gold you could give me, Master Hobbit. Whatever deed you have to do, it is not so important that I would risk my life for it.”
Bilbo swallowed and fought the urge to reach for the Ring. He’d be on his own, then. Somehow, traveling across the plains of Mordor, filled with orcs and the black clouds and the fire he’d seen from a distance. And the Eye. The Eye that kept taunting him in what little sleep he could get. Honestly, he was surprised and grateful he hadn’t slid down the mountain yet, for all the sleep he’d been missing.
He began to climb again when Mablang did. His thoughts began to focus on the long walk from the borders of Mordor to Mount Doom. All on his own. He’d do this all on his own. There would be no one there with him. No Gandalf, no Aragorn, no Thorin-
He shut his eyes tight and allowed himself a moment to panic and fear and grieve. Then he shifted his shoulders to try and take some of the weight off of his back from his pack, refusing to think of the real weight that was pulling at his neck.
Stairs. He could climb stairs well enough on his own. One foot at a time, darling, his mother whispered in his ear. You can’t get anywhere faster by trying to walk with two feet at the same time.
His heart ached for her loss as if she’d passed on just yesterday, and he climbed.
“Where’s Papa?” the youngest girl whispered again, and once again Legolas felt his heart tear a little more at the seams for her. This child, human though she was, should never have had to face this deplorable day. She had possibly lost her father in Osgiliath forever. She was too young to have lost her dreams, her family.
“Fin, hush,” her older sister said, but it was clear she was just as panicked and fearful as her sibling.
Kili, who’d been having his face examined, broke free of the healer and went to them. The gash across his cheek looked uglier than it was, but it still made Legolas want to cut down every orc there was. The thought of Kili being hurt was just wrong, and it made his stomach twist. He wished he’d been quicker. He wished he’d been faster.
“It’ll be all right,” Kili was saying to them. The young dwarf had knelt in front of the girls and was now brushing their wind-blown locks from their faces, much as a parent would do for their child. “Lots of people were separated. I got separated from my friend, too.”
Gandalf. Legolas turned to scan the crowd, but there was no sight of the white wizard. He pursed his lips and turned back to the quiet scene before him. Kili continued to speak with them, and soon they were smiling, albeit with sadness in their eyes. They were old enough to know that clinging to hope would not do them well. But they were young enough to still believe in a happy ending.
Legolas envied them. The proof that a happy ending could be taken from you in a moment’s notice was evident on Kili’s cheek. An inch further to the right, and it would have pierced through Kili’s eye, and through his brain. He would have lost Kili forever. And all of it without truly telling the dwarf how much he mattered. Yes, they’d spoken briefly. Yes, they’d touched and kissed. But Kili had been under the spell of the Palantír, and Legolas had still not spoken with him the words that mattered.
He would. When he had a moment to himself, and he could draw Kili aside, he would speak them.
“Kili!”
Legolas turned as Kili did, and there was Gandalf, striding through the commotion. “I am glad to see you,” Gandalf said with a relieved sigh. He didn’t even seem startled when he saw Legolas. “And I am glad you found your way safely to us, Legolas.”
It would not surprise him, if Gandalf had been waiting for him. “I went as swiftly as I could,” Legolas said. “I have matters to speak to you.”
“Then we will speak them together,” a voice from behind Gandalf said, and Legolas started at the sight of Denethor of Gondor, alive and well. He limped and clutched at his side, but it was much better than the death Legolas had feared he had suffered.
Denethor seemed to notice the surprise on his face, and he gave a short smile. “Well met again, Master Elf,” he said. He offered his hand, and Legolas took it, shaking it in the custom of men.
“I am glad to see you well.”
“The elves of Lothlorien are adept healers,” Denethor said. “Without them, I would have been lost.” His eyes cast around to the havoc about them, and his face tightened in sorrow. “I may still be lost, yet,” he murmured.
“Where is your father?” Legolas asked. Denethor’s face clouded, but it was Gandalf who spoke.
“Ecthelion is healing from the influence of a Palantír. It is Denethor whom we shall now speak to, in regards to Gondor’s future.”
Legolas nodded as Gandalf led them away, but Kili called them to a halt. “I won’t leave them,” he said, and when Gandalf frowned, the dwarf drew the girls before him. “They’re missing their father. I won’t abandon them here.”
Never before had Legolas felt so much pride in the one his heart called for. Kili truly was a light in the midst of the darkest times. His heart was so open and kind, and it was shown in the gentle ways he spoke to and handled the lost girls. He was much like Thorin was, Legolas presumed, when Kili and Fili had been raised. Thoughts of his own father came to mind, and Legolas pushed them away.
The youngest girl looked to Denethor, and there was recognition there. “Have you seen my father, m’lord?” she asked.
“I have not,” he said regretfully. To Gandalf he said: “Adrahil, Prince of Dol Amroth, is their father. Let me leave a message behind with the captains here, that if he comes forward, he will find his daughters with us.”
Gandalf nodded approvingly. “And a wise idea that is, Denethor. Kili, bring them.”
The girls stared up at Gandalf in awe, and Gandalf gave them a gentle smile. “Who have we here?” he asked, and Legolas knew of how Gandalf offered his fireworks and magic tricks to the youngest elves in the forest. Of one thing Legolas was certain of: Gandalf adored the children above everyone else. He delighted in their shrieks of laughter and their bright smiles. Innocence, joy. Hope. The wizard had spent time with the children in Rohan, performing trick after trick to bring them smiles.
It worked again now. “Ivriniel,” the oldest said, clasping her younger sister’s hand in hers. “This is Finduilas, my sister.”
“What beautiful names,” Gandalf complimented, and as one the girls smiled. “You have found princesses and ladies indeed, Kili. I would be glad of their company.”
“Come,” Denethor said, and they moved through the mass of survivors. Healers darted everywhere, but between the four of them, they managed to buffet the girls from the horrors and tragedy around them. Many were injured, and many more were dying, and Legolas fought not to reach for Kili. Kili was there, he was alive. That was what mattered.
Something brushed against his hand, and when he looked, Kili was there, his hand outstretched in an open invitation. Legolas smiled and took his hand. Finduilas, who was walking in front of them, happened to glance back at their joined hands. “Are you in love?” she asked Kili.
Kili swallowed hard, but he spoke out loud, despite his fear. “I am,” he said, and his voice was nearly steady.
In the midst of the chaos and destruction, in the midst of pain and fear, Legolas managed to find a way to smile so brightly that all hesitation fell from Kili’s face. Finduilas even smiled, adding a skip to her step.
All the way up the various levels, Kili’s hand was warm in his.
They were fine until the horses balked. Being nearly tall enough to ride horses instead of ponies, they’d been given swift horses to take them deep into the mountain. The pass through had been tough terrains at times. For the most part, it had been easy riding. The last stretch, however, had required leading the horses through as the passage became narrower and narrower.
The door they found had been dark and deep, and when the foul wind had blown from it, the horses had taken off. “No!” Thorin shouted, reaching for the bridle, but they were gone too quickly to catch. All of the horses ran back the way they’d come, leaving them abandoned in front of the door.
“What’s it say above the door?” Gimli asked, pointing to the ancient symbols that decorated the archway.
“Home of the Dead, wipe yer feet,” Dwalin muttered. His hands twisted the pole of his war hammer in his hands. It wasn’t his best hammer: that he’d left with Ori, back in Rohan. Something to defend the dwarf he loved, when he himself could not.
Thorin resolutely gazed into the darkness and didn’t think of the one his heart ached for.
A hissed voice called to them from the doorway, and the very hairs on Thorin’s neck rose at the sound. “Show yourself!” Aragorn yelled.
Nothing. Thorin pulled Orcrist from its sheath and held it forward in his hands. “Obey your king!” he bellowed. “Show yourselves!”
“There is no KING!”
The voice surged from behind them, and they all whipped around, weapons at the ready. No one stood there. There was nothing to see.
Gimli looked a lot less steady than he had only moments before. Thorin could admit to being unnerved, and even Dwalin looked hesitant. This was nothing they had ever dealt with, before. The dead remained dead. This was something they could not harm.
Aragorn looked uncertain as well, but then his gaze dropped to his sword. It was a beautifully crafted work, and Thorin could hear its ancient power as much as he could when he unsheathed Orcrist. There was a presence about the sword, and it carried itself.
Aragorn let his gaze rise to the door, and his eyes narrowed. “I do not fear the dead,” he said lowly, and before they could say anything he stepped inside. The darkness swallowed him immediately.
Thorin quickly moved forward, determined to follow the young man wherever he went. Dwalin was right behind him, and they stepped into the darkness. No light shone through, and Thorin began to make his way forward, following where Aragorn had gone.
A voice seemed to echo through the cavern from behind them. “A dwarf, afraid to go underground?” Gimli said, trying obviously to steady his voice. “If my father saw me now, he’d drop me in a barrel of ale and leave me to drown!”
Dwalin was rolling his eyes, Thorin knew it. “Get in here!” Dwalin snapped, and in a moment Gimli was with them.
Soon it began to lighten. Aragorn moved ahead through the mist that he could now see. The halls were made of stone, and there were skulls everywhere in the wall. Whole skeletons were laid out, and their empty eye sockets almost seemed to be peering through him. Thorin tightened his grip on Orcrist and refused to acknowledge the fear that was building at the base of his neck.
Something came up at him, and instinct made him swing at it, only to find the mist parting. But it had moved towards him…
“What is this?” Dwalin exclaimed, and when Thorin turned, the mist was coming up towards him. Fingers formed out of it, and Dwalin batted them away into nonexistence. Thorin turned to Aragorn, who looked just as bewildered as he was.
More hands began to reach for them, but they caused no harm. When his boot gave beneath him with a crack, Thorin looked down and through the mist at what was beneath his feet, and his chest tightened. He’d seen much death in his lifetime. But never before had he seen so many remains, nor had he walked on them or crushed the skulls of those passed beneath him.
There were so many of them, and he wondered at how many men had died here, in the mountain. Thousands of them, cursed, living their lives out in the mountain until they were left to rot here. When they had said it was the Paths of the Dead, he hadn’t thought it meant that the paths were made of the dead.
“Do not look down,” Aragorn warned, as more cracking noises came from the crushed skulls beneath them. Dwalin clenched his jaw and steadfastly kept his gaze up. Gimli winced with every step he took as more cracks echoed around them.
More passageways were filled with the misty arms of the dead, grasping at them for something. Echoes of voices long dead cried out in fear and pain, begging for relief. Thorin could feel their cold hands on him, chilling him to his core, and he wondered if this feeling of cold was what it felt like to be dead. When he passed on, would his spirit linger somewhere, perhaps in the halls of Erebor, cold and unable to feel, begging for life?
If he never made peace with Bilbo, if he could not find forgiveness and peace here, then he knew his spirit would be as damned as those here. He would be lost forever, and worse yet, he would have deserved it. He could not imagine entering the halls of his forefathers with what he had done. If forgiven, he could perhaps pass, and pass with honor. But not before then.
Then his traitorous mind left him thinking of Bilbo, dead and gone, his body cold and empty, and his spirit wandering lost across Middle-Earth. He shuddered so fiercely Dwalin caught his arm with concern. “All right?” Dwalin muttered.
Thorin gave a sharp nod. Dwalin didn’t look convinced, but he let Thorin go.
The passage began to open, and suddenly they were in a wide cavern, as tall and open as the Great Deep in Erebor. A steep cliff ended not far from them, and along the far wall were bodies tucked into crevices. But the greatest part of the cavern was there in front of them, reaching high to the top of the cavern.
The front of the building was massive, and the tops of the spires were lost in the cavern ceiling. This had not always been a cavern, then. Just hidden away, trapping it with the dead. It looked to be a royal hall, or had been, once upon a time, carved from the rock itself. It held an air of terrible awe, and Thorin could not help but admire it, even as it chilled his blood.
“Who dares enter my domain?”
The voice from the entrance to the Paths was there, angry and close, and before his very eyes. Even as he watched a figure, glowing the green hue of the rotten dead, appeared before him. It was a corpse with eyes long unseeing, but Thorin could feel when it stared straight at him. He could see beneath its tattered skin and its rotten hair. The only thing vibrant about the ghost before him was the crown atop his head. It had not saved even the king of the men here in the mountains. It was made of fine gold and jewels, but it glowed the same ghostly shade as the corpse, leaving it weathered and worth nothing.
In the end, the treasure you took with you into death meant nothing. You were still dead. Thorin thought of the cursed Arkenstone, of how Bilbo had seen the truth. It was a stone. It was not worth a life.
I will make it up to you, beloved. I swear it.
Aragorn stepped forward towards the being and cleared his throat. “I call upon you to fulfill your oath to Gondor,” he said. “I am Isildur’s heir, and I would have your allegiance.”
The ghost began to laugh, a horrible sound that made Thorin tighten his grip on Orcrist. Suddenly there were ghosts everywhere, pouring from the walls, their pale wisps surrounding them. Dwalin immediately set his back against Thorin’s, growling at them. One ghost came too close, and he swung his war hammer straight at it. It flew through it, as if it wasn’t there, but when the ghost reached out and touched Dwalin’s arm, the dwarf shuddered and stumbled back, his face pale. “Dwalin!” Thorin yelled as he hauled his friend back.
“M’all right,” Dwalin muttered. Color slowly began to return to his face. “The Dead aren’t friendly. And they’re not receptive to bein’ struck, either.”
“Find your feet,” Thorin urged. No other ghost made to come closer. “You wouldn’t have me return to Ori without you, would you?”
“Nah, I like you better than that,” Dwalin said, and Thorin couldn’t help chuckling.
“We answer to no man,” the king hissed. “No man but the King of Gondor.”
Aragorn moved forward, pulling forth his sword. The king faltered, his pale eyes wide. “You will answer to me,” Aragorn said, voice dangerously low. “I am Isildur’s heir. I can free you from your turmoil. You have only to follow me and aid me, and I will give you release.”
The king said nothing. Around them, the ghosts had gone silent. Thorin swung his gaze from them to the king, and for some reason, it felt just like it had the day Thranduil had said nothing. Though there had been screams of the innocents dying, of fleeing in terror, Thorin had heard nothing but the echo of his pained cry for help. And the silence of Thranduil’s answer as he’d turned and left.
“Will you not answer?” Thorin shouted, fury coursing through his veins. He stepped forward beside Aragorn, glaring at the ghostly king. “Would you remain traitors, murderers, and locked here in this mountain of death? You abandoned the King when he needed you most, you left him in peril, and brought death and destruction to his people! All because you could not do the right thing!”
Nothing. Thorin could feel his chest heaving with his raging breaths, and he was suddenly so angry he could barely see anything but the red in his gaze. “Would you abandon him now, when he offers you a second chance? You could be free! You could do honorably by his people, by yours! You could live once more, and breathe the fresh air, then rest in peace!”
“I swear to you, if you aid me, I will set you free,” Aragorn said. “By my blood, I swear it!”
Slowly the king began to cackle. The ghosts began to vanish, one by one. “I give you my word!” Aragorn roared, and Thorin watched as none remained, not even the king. His laughter still echoed through the cavern.
Dwalin shook his head. “Honor. What would they know about honor? Dead or livin’, doesn’t matter: too few know what real honor is.”
Gimli looked as disheartened as Aragorn, but he moved over to the young man, resting a hand on his arm. “We’ll go with you,” he said. “We’ll not abandon ye now. Not when Gondor needs us.”
Aragorn gave a small smile at Gimli’s sincerity. “Thank you,” he said. He glanced up at Thorin, who merely nodded the same. “Thank you. We-“
The cavern began to shake. A whisper of sound began to grow louder and louder, like the falling of sand through fingertips or the clinking of gold on a pile. Suddenly the front of the royal hall burst open, and hundreds of skulls poured out. “Run!” Dwalin shouted.
It was too late to go back the way they’d come: Thorin could only pray there was an exit ahead of them. He dashed forward, making certain Gimli and Aragorn were ahead of him. More of the wall began to break, and thousands of skulls now began to flood the room. They pooled around him and pushed him towards the cliff, but Thorin’s feet were solid, and he made his arm a fierce wall. He was Thorin Oakenshield, as strong as a tree trunk with deep roots. He would aid his friend in saving Gondor, he would find his sister-sons again, and he would find Bilbo. He would make amends.
He pushed on.
A small crevice ahead was just big enough for them to fit through, and they hurried forward until they saw light. Fresh air called to them, a rare gift with the stench of decay thundering behind them. They quickly pushed onward and suddenly found themselves outside. Grass and sky and the breeze were there, all for the taking, and if Dwalin fell to his knees and pressed his hand to the grass, well, Thorin couldn’t blame him. He stood and tried to catch his breath.
“Thorin.”
At Gimli’s voice, he turned and saw a tall ship floating along the river not far from them. A village that ran along the river was smoking, and even from their distance, Thorin could hear the cries of fearful villagers, the death cries. The tall ship bore sharp spines that looked like bones, and Thorin felt his heart fall. Decimated, destroyed. Hopeless. All of Middle-Earth would look this way, if Gondor fell, and Sauron reigned supreme. Erebor would tumble, Legolas’s forests would fall to the darkness, and Bilbo’s beautiful Shire would be burned to the ground.
In front of him, Aragorn stumbled to sit on the ground, and he could see tears in the young man’s eyes as he stared at the village. Dwalin rested a hand on Aragorn’s shoulder, and Thorin watched as the young man began to silently weep. Gimli stared at the ground mutely.
They would not have enough to combat the forces Sauron would unleash on Gondor. They would fail Middle-Earth. They would fail Bilbo. Thorin swallowed back the sudden rush of tears.
A whisper stirred in the air behind them, and they all turned to suddenly see the ghost king emerge from the wall. Aragorn stood swiftly, hand still on his sword.
The ghost king looked down at the blade, then up at Aragorn. His wretched voice no longer echoed, almost silent in the sunlight, but it still creaked with his visible jaw bone, and it sounded like a horrible gasp for air. When he spoke, however, it was still the most joyous sound Thorin had ever heard.
“We fight.”
