Actions

Work Header

One of the Possible Questions

Chapter 3

Notes:

I'm adding tags as I go because I'm also discovering the story as I go. These dorks are so much fun. :)

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

Ori had been trying not to think about Fíli ever since the adrenaline of the Battle of Five Armies had worn off and he’d realized two things: One, he and Fíli were still alive. He’d been quite prepared for either or both of them to die, making the nature of their relationship moot. Two, Fíli was no longer merely an adventuring companion. He was the very real heir of a very real kingdom, with all the baggage that entailed.

Unfortunately, willing himself to lose interest in Fíli had not proved effective. Ori’s pulse continued to race every time he saw a flash of the prince’s yellow hair or heard his laugh, which happened unfairly often in the huge mountain.

Since the mere knowledge that it would be a bad idea to get involved with the royal family had been insufficient to erase his feelings, Ori had jumped at the opportunity to play pretend. A brief sham engagement, he thought, would convince him that he didn’t want the real thing.

But so far this plan wasn’t working, either.

Instead, Ori had been absurdly charmed by Fíli’s dogged determination to ask for Dori’s blessing. Fíli might make mistakes, he might lose ponies, he might be stupidly proud of himself for figuring out that a key presupposes the existence of a door, but he never gave up.

And Fíli was terribly cute when he was flustered. Ori couldn’t stop smiling as Fíli fumbled his way through an explanation of their sudden engagement to his family.

“I’m sorry, Mother, I really wanted you to know earlier, but I thought I should win over Dori and Nori first so we could tell you that we have their blessing, but then that was taking so long that we didn’t want to keep it from you any more, and, well, here we are.”

Dís’s thick eyebrows bunched together suspiciously. “Does that mean they still don’t approve?”

“Well, er, we’re working on it.” Fíli cleared his throat and glanced at Ori.

Ori had already assured him that Dori’s adamant refusal needn’t affect the plan. If their courtship were real, presumably they’d keep trying to change his mind. So he gave Fíli an encouraging nod, and told Dis, “They need a little time to get used to the idea, that’s all.”

“What better match could they possibly want?” asked Thorin impatiently. “Fíli’s an idiot sometimes, but he’s the crown prince.”

“And you’re the king, dear, but you’re also quite an idiot sometimes,” said Bilbo calmly. “It took me a while to accept that. I’m sure they’ll come around.”

Dís tapped her fingers on the table and sighed. “I’m sorry to bring this up, Fíli, but you do have to think about heirs. Obviously, there’s nothing wrong with marriages between men, but I thought you liked women.”

“I like both,” said Fíli, giving Ori an apologetic look.

Ori shrugged. Fíli didn’t have anything to apologize for. Preferences were preferences, and if Fili had bedded women before, so what? Ori had always preferred men, but Fíli was hardly the first to catch his eye. He could admit to being curious about Fíli’s history, but it didn’t have any relevance to their current relationship.

Which didn’t really exist. Right.

“Given that you have the option, though,” Thorin was saying to Fíli, “Why not choose a bride who can give you children?”

“Because I want Ori,” said Fíli firmly, and Ori’s heart gave such a loud thump he could barely hear the rest of Fíli’s words. “Anyway, Uncle, just like you I have a sibling who can produce heirs.”

“Um,” said Kíli, looking panicked. Clearly Fíli had not discussed this with him beforehand. “I don’t know if Tauriel wants to, um.”

Thorin folded his arms and fixed Fíli with a fiery stare. He did not shout, but his tone made iron seem soft. “You’d put a half-elf on the throne of Erebor?”

Meanwhile, Dís’s ire was focused on Kíli. “Well, it’s certainly something you should know! Do you two even talk?”

“I didn’t mean with Tauriel specifically,” Fíli tried to explain, only making things worse.

Kíli jumped up, eyes blazing. “You think I’d take a lover on the side?”

“No, of course not, but you’re not even married yet. It might not work out—”

“Oh, because things are working out so well for you!”

Ori should have kept his mouth shut. The issue of royal issue was none of his business. But the words I want Ori were still ringing like bells in his ears, and before he could think better of it, he said, “There are other ways to have children.”

The room fell silent. Dís frowned in confusion. “What do you mean?”

“Fíli and I could adopt a foundling.”

Thorin looked stunned. “You mean . . . a child with no kin at all?”

“That’s a human thing,” objected Kíli. “Dwarves don’t abandon babies. They’re taken in by family even if the parents are gone, right? I don’t know of any foundlings.”

“Yes, you do,” said Ori, the blood thundering in his ears. “Me.”

There was a longer silence.

Then Fíli said, “But Dori and Nori are your brothers.”

“Brothers by choice, not by blood.” Ori took a deep breath so he could get it all out at once. “Nori found a dwarf baby in a human caravan. They were going to sell it as a slave. So he took it back to Dori, and they raised it—raised me—as their brother.”

This silence was the longest of all. Ori could tell that everyone was staring at him, although his vision had gone blurry. When they found their voices, he knew what they would say: that a foundling on the throne was even more unthinkable than a half-elf who would at least be a descendant of Durin, and furthermore, that Fíli could never marry a fatherless, motherless dwarf with a blank page where his ancestry should be.

So Ori fled the room before they could start talking. He took turns at random, cursing the maze-like royal passages. He tried a door handle, found it unlocked, and stepped into an unoccupied room furnished with a daybed and a small carved table.

Grateful for the temporary escape, Ori sank onto the bed. He shouldn’t have told them, he shouldn’t have said anything, and yet—this was perfect, wasn’t it? Exactly what he’d wanted. Proof positive that anything between him and Fíli was doomed.

He was quite surprised when Fíli stepped into the room only a few seconds later. Although the prince had apparently tracked Ori’s haphazard footsteps with no trouble, the expression on his face looked lost.

“I didn’t know,” he said quietly.

Ori stared at him. Why would he have known? “I guess there’s a lot we don’t know about each other.”

“I guess there is.” Fíli scratched his beard. “Do you need to be anywhere else tonight?”

Ori told his mouth to say yes, but when it opened it said, “No.”

“Good. Wait here.” Fíli left.

Ori pulled the table over to the bed and traced its ornate patterns until Fíli returned, a small barrel under one arm and a huge golden goblet in his hand. It bore two hammered handles, and decorations of birds with jeweled eyes—

“Is that the cup of Thrór?” gasped Ori.

“Yeah, well, Great-Grandfather isn't using it anymore. We’re going to play a game.” Fíli set the cup on the table and filled it with wine from the barrel. “We take turns asking each other questions. If you don’t want to answer, you drink. And if you can’t think of a question, you drink.”

Ori looked at the goblet. A raven’s sapphire eye looked back at him. “There’s only one cup.”

Fíli grinned. “You kissed me in the library, and now you don’t want to share a cup?”

Face burning, Ori changed the subject. “What happens when it’s empty?”

“We refill it, obviously.” Fíli dropped onto the couch next to Ori. “You can go first, since I already learned something new about you.”

At Fili’s sudden warm proximity, all thoughts flew out of Ori’s head. He opened his mouth to see what would happen, and it asked, “Have you ever, you know, I mean, are you a virgin?”

Fíli gave an embarrassed laugh. “Yes. I guess. I fooled around with a couple of girls in the Blue Mountains, but only, uh, hands and stuff.” He rubbed the back of his neck and looked at the floor. “I’ve never been with a boy.”

Notes:

Ori's foundling origin is inspired by Chapter 25 of Dirty Deeds (Done Dirt Cheap) which absolutely captivated me. Probably everyone has already read this utterly brilliant work by greenkangaroo, but if not then I can't recommend it enough!