Actions

Work Header

One of the Possible Questions

Chapter 4

Notes:

get these boys drunk and it turns out they have a lot to talk about XD

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text

“You didn’t! The whole entire boar?”

“Every bristle,” confirmed Fíli. “It was a matter of honor!”

This sent Ori off into another paroxysm of laughter. Fíli watched him fall back on the daybed, wheezing and clutching his sides. They were both undoubtedly drunk, but the pleasant warmth washing over Fíli had little to do with alcohol. He loved making Ori laugh.

Ori’s messy red hair looked like a firework against the blue cushions. Fíli’s fingers itched to smooth it out of his face, tuck the loose ends behind his ears, fix the disheveled braids.

“You’re staring,” said Ori, with a smile in his eyes. “Can’t you think of a question?”

Fíli could think of exactly one question: Can I kiss you again? Or maybe, Can I kiss you for the first time? He couldn’t take any credit for the library kiss, which had surprised him so thoroughly he’d barely participated.

But Fíli hadn’t started the game to ask that kind of question. He’d been abashed to realize how little he really knew about Ori, who was first and foremost a friend. And, even more than he’d wanted to learn about Ori, he’d wanted to give Ori a chance to learn about him, to level the playing field after Ori had shared something so personal.

So Fíli grabbed the goblet, spilling a little wine on the table and lot more down his throat. He’d surely catch hell from Thorin for borrowing Thrór’s cup and making a mess with it, but that was well worth the sound of Ori’s laughter.

“Your turn,” said Fíli.

Ori’s smile faded into a thoughtful expression. “What happened to your father?”

Fíli sighed. It had been so long since he’d talked about it with anyone who didn’t already know. “A stupid accident. He didn’t get killed by a dragon or an orc. He was scouting a new mine with a few other dwarves, slipped on ice, and fell a hundred feet down the mountain.” Fíli had always been told that it was a quick end, with little suffering. “His friends climbed down to get his body and bring it home, and my mother yelled at them. She said it was too dangerous, he wouldn’t have wanted them to risk their lives. But she was grateful. I helped her clean and dress the body, and braid his hair for the funeral.”

Kíli had not wanted to help. He had been so angry. Angry at their father for dying, angry at their mother for not magically bringing him back to life, angry at Fíli for not being angry. He’d even been angry at Thorin for not being their father, and Fíli thought sometimes he still was.

“Oh, Fíli.”

Ori’s voice sounded very close. Fíli blinked, realizing that Ori was kneeling on the bed right next to him, stroking his wet cheek. “I’m so sorry. I’m sorry you lost him, I’m sorry I asked—”

“I’m glad you asked.” Fíli cleared his throat, took Ori’s hand in his, and laced their fingers together. “I wanted you to know.”

“Thank you for telling me.” Ori rubbed his thumb over Fíli’s knuckles. “I guess it’s your turn.”

Looking down at their hands, Fíli took a chance. “What did Nori mean when he said—”

“Oh, no. No. Absolutely not.” Ori was already reaching for the goblet with his free hand.

“You didn’t let me finish!”

“I am not explaining anything Nori said.” Ori took several swallows, then set the cup back on the table. “I can’t think of something to ask, so I’ll take a page from Bilbo’s book. What’s in your pockets?”

Fíli groaned. “Don’t ask me riddles, I can’t guess them even when I’m sober. I didn’t understand a single one of Bilbo’s or Gollum’s.”

“Well, I like riddles but I didn’t know most of those, either,” said Ori. “They were very unusual. I’d probably have been eaten by Gollum.”

“No, you’d have given him a taste of dwarvish iron right up his jacksy,” teased Fíli.

Ori covered his face with his hand. “Please let me forget I ever said that. I don’t know what I was thinking.”

“You were trying to impress me,” said Fíli, hoping it was true, because he’d done more than a few idiotic things during the quest in order to impress Ori.

“I was trying to impress everyone,” said Ori. “And you still haven’t answered my question. It wasn’t a riddle. I’m just curious what you keep in your pockets.”

“Oh. Knives.”

“How many?”

“That’s two questions. But I’ll allow it.” Fíli reluctantly let go of Ori’s hand so he could get to his feet. Head swimming, he swayed to one side, then straightened up and began unpacking his knives onto the table. Boots, thighs, hips, back, ribs, forearms. “Two, four, six, uh . . . seven, eight, nine . . . eleven, twelve and thirteen.”

“Terribly unlucky,” observed Ori.

“Well, there’s a fourteenth between my legs, but I’m not drunk enough to show you that one.” The joke was out of Fíli’s mouth before he could think better of it.

“How could you ever get it out in a fight? And isn’t that a dangerous place for a blade—ohhh.” Ori’s cheeks turned redder than his hair. “You didn’t mean a real knife.”

Fíli shook his head and sat back down, blushing a little himself. “Sorry. Rude jokes are a habit.”

“Very princely of you,” snorted Ori. “It’s your turn to ask.”

With his attention refocused on the game, Fíli risked a question that he knew might be received even more poorly than his last. “Do you ever wonder about your birth parents?”

“Of course,” Ori answered readily. “When I was little, I dreamed up all kinds of absurd scenarios. I was the lost baby of a mighty smith, or my parents had been killed while defeating a dragon, or I was a king’s child from a distant land.”

“They’re not really absurd. Any of those could be true.”

“More likely I was a whore’s babe dropped by the side of the road, or sold to slavers for a handful of coins,” said Ori bitterly.

Fíli stared at him. That wasn’t something Ori would have come up with. And it wasn’t something either of his brothers would ever have said. “Who told you that?”

“That’s two questions,” said Ori. “It’s my turn.”

“I answered two of yours just now,” coaxed Fíli.

Ori reached for the wine. The stab of disappointment Fíli felt was so sharp he must have made a sound, because Ori glanced up at him with a wry smile. “I’ll answer it, I just want a drink first.”

He finished off the last wine in the goblet, wiped his mouth, and began. “Dori and Nori and I worked as traders for a while, with a regular route through the Blue Mountains and across the Lune. I was mostly in charge of packing and unpacking, fetching and carrying, but there was a smith in an eastern settlement who refused to bargain with Dori or Nori. He would only talk to me. He said I was the most beautiful dwarf he’d seen on either side of the mountains.”

Fíli had thought much the same when he’d first set eyes on Ori, and it made bile rise in his throat, for he knew this story would not end well.

“That was nonsense, of course, as I doubt he’d ever crossed a mountain in his life, but I was sixty-one and easily taken in by nonsense. His name was Galin. I bargained with him during the day, and snuck out to meet him at night. He said he wanted to marry me, and I told him about being a foundling, which I’d never told anyone before.

“When the time came for us to move on, I wanted to stay with Galin, but he said no, I was too young and my brothers would make a fuss. I’ll wait for you, he said, come back next year and we’ll be married. And we did come back the next year, and he was married. Already. To someone else.” Ori grimaced. “I was such a fool, I shouldn’t even have spoken to him, but I was so hurt and so proud. I faced him in front of his smithy and asked what all his promises meant, and he laughed and said that promises made to nobody mean nothing. That I was only—well, what I already told you.”

“That’s utter horse shit,” spat Fíli, hands in fists on his knees. “You know that, right? You’re not nobody. He was a liar and—”

“He was generally a bad dwarf, and I’m over him, Fíli,” said Ori. “But let’s be honest. He was probably right about my parentage.”

Fíli wanted to deny it. The words of denial were hot in his mouth, but he swallowed them down. “I don’t care,” he said instead. “It doesn’t matter who your parents were. And if anyone in my family thinks it does matter, I don’t care about that, either.”

A smile spread across Ori’s face, lighting up his eyes. He put his hands on top of Fíli’s fists and squeezed them. “Thank you.”

Fíli eased his fingers open so he could curl them around Ori’s. “I think it’s your turn.”

Ori looked down at their hands, then back up at Fíli’s face. He licked his lips. “You said you’d never been with a boy.”

“That’s not exactly a question,” said Fíli, with an embarrassed shrug. “But yes.”

“Want to change that?”

Notes:

a snippet of dialogue that didn’t make the final cut, but I still wanted to share:

“Did your brothers ever find out about Galin?”
“Oh, yes. I’m not allowed to talk about what Nori did to him.”
“What did Dori do?”
“Look the other way.”