Actions

Work Header

Second Chances

Chapter 4

Notes:

I wish I could say that there wasn't going to be angst this chapter. But I'd be lying. If you like your angst sandwich extra angsty, well, then this is the chapter for you. Ta-da!

Continued thanks for the comments and the kudos. I'm starting to feel highly spoiled.

Chapter Text

Thorin looked completely at a loss, for once in his goddamn life.

Sebastian, Sebastian, Sebastian, John pounded through his head. He wasn’t Bilbo anymore, wasn’t that just what he’d told the man, what, an hour before? If that? That meant it wasn’t Thorin standing in front of him, and thank god for that, because Bilbo Baggins had more apologies owed to the dwarf king than anyone could ever owe anyone.

But just watching him pace with that look in his eyes, sideways glances being thrown John’s way when he thought he wasn’t being watched… it was Thorin, through and through, and it hurt. God it hurt. His Thorin-

John stopped himself. The man before him wasn’t ‘his’ Thorin. Not anymore. If he’d ever been. Maybe, before the accursed Arkenstone, before the world had gone to hell, before he’d left Thorin to die on the battlefield. Why was he the one who was always left behind while others died?

“That’s what people do, isn’t it? Leave a note?”

“Goodbye, John.”

He shuddered straight down to his toes. God. He saw Thorin, Sebastian, pause in his pacing to glance at him, but John only curled over in his chair more, and eventually the sharpshooter went back to walking a groove into the floor. John almost wanted to shout at him to do it elsewhere, but the sound provided background noise even while it grated slightly on his nerves. Besides, there wasn’t really much of anywhere he could go.

The house was small, lean and tall, cozy between two other buildings on the corner of some not very busy streets. The main floor was empty, save for some very Spartan furniture and what looked like a nice bed shoved into the back corner, surrounded by floor to ceiling curtains obviously meant for privacy. He hadn’t a clue what the other floors looked like. The front windows had thicker than usual curtains, perfect to curtail any sort of interest in the place. It looked like a normal, average building, and it was very obviously a safe house.

The pacing leaned towards too aggravating, and he thought about going up to the second floor, somewhere that Sebastian wasn’t. Anywhere else those deep blue eyes wouldn’t follow him or haunt him any further than they already did. Except now, now he had another pair of blue eyes to haunt his sleep, a tear-stained face and a bitter, broken voice that had led to one of the most brilliant minds John had ever met ending abruptly on the ground. It had been the end of Sherlock Holmes, consulting detective. The end of Sherlock, John’s best friend.

The sob burst out without his approval, and he slapped a hand over his mouth even as Sebastian stopped pacing. John squeezed his eyes shut and pulled his legs up further to him. Guess he was still small enough to curl up on a chair, legs, body, and all. Sherlock’s leather seat, he could curl up on that, too, or sit on the arm while listening to Sherlock explain in a dizzying fashion how the crime had been committed, and oh god, Sherlock, Sherlock, Sherlock.

He’d died for John. John knew it deep in his gut. Died for them all, left his ‘note’ and insisted John tell everyone that the papers were right, he was a fraud. Clearing John’s name, saving them from whatever Moriarty had planned. And all it had cost him was his life.

“John?”

The gentle, deep voice reminded him of a different age, where escaping large spiders and pale orcs had been all he’d needed to do. Where he’d had a company around him, laughing with him, accepting him, counting him among their own. Of a king who’d held him, had talked to him late at night with a soft smile and kind words until that goddamn treasure had lit his eyes with something Bilbo couldn’t pull him from. And he couldn’t talk about gold, because Bilbo had had his own gold sickness, tucked away in his pocket, and the damage he’d caused with it in the end, god, Frodo-

A hand, just as strong as he remembered, settled hesitantly on his shoulder, and he fought not to shudder again. “John,” he heard again, like it was an answer in and of itself. And suddenly, it was just too much. More than the sounds, this kindness was more than he could take.

Sebastian nearly stumbled back in surprise when John suddenly flung himself up and out of the chair. “John-“

“God, I almost liked it better when you called me Bilbo,” John said with a harsh laugh. “Not that the name really matters, does it? Both of us fuck-ups. Both of us failures.”

Sebastian’s eyes narrowed, and for a brief moment, it was like looking straight at Thorin. “Take care how you address John Watson and Bilbo Baggins, because the both of them are men I hold in high esteem,” he said, voice rough and low.

“Then you’re an idiot,” John snapped, turning away. He wrapped his arms around himself miserably, unconsciously beginning to pace in much the same way Sebastian had. The other man stayed silent, though John could almost hear the thoughts racing through Sebastian’s head.

John spun himself around and almost straight into Sebastian’s face. “Have you ever read anything that Tolkien wrote?” he asked, pointing a finger at the other man. “J.R.R. Tolkien. Have you?”

Sebastian paused. “I have,” he said at last, and any hope John had sank straight to the floor. Fuck. Fuck it all…

“I don’t understand what that has to do about anything. Unless you’re talking about The Hobbit.”

“No, the series in general,” John said, and he couldn’t believe he was saying anything about this at all. “I can’t…I’m not talking about the utter disaster that was the events of The Hobbit. I can barely talk about the Lord of the Rings and I was hardly in it!” No, but the lives he’d destroyed, the hopelessness he’d put upon his dearest nephew, and someone just needed to shoot him now.

If anything, Sebastian looked more baffled than before. “What are you talking about?” he asked. “John, I don’t-“

“The ring!” John shouted, and suddenly it burst out of him like a flood. “That…that goddamn ring! Sauron’s ring, the Ring of Power, the ring I brought back from Gollum’s cave! The perfect little burglar who…who all but damned Middle-Earth with it! You thought I’d only stolen the Arkenstone and hadn’t that been bad enough, but if you’d lived to see it, you would’ve seen the utter destruction my actions wreaked across the entire map!” He stopped when he couldn’t breathe any more, voice high and choked.

Sebastian could only stare at him. John felt a laugh burst out of him, and it was high-pitched and awful. “And I thought you had the gold sickness. God, I had the nerve to take what you held most precious and then I gave it to your enemies. No wonder you hate me.” Though that didn’t really explain why the hell Sebastian had been his almost friend, had saved his life again and again, the past few months. “Why?” he asked, just as Sebastian started to speak.

“Why what?” Sebastian answered, almost helplessly.

“Why the calls, the getting involved in the cases, the saving me, why? Why, Thorin? Why the fuck would you after…after all of it?”

Blue eyes showed obvious surprise, whether at his words or the slip of the dwarf name. “Why wouldn’t I?” he asked, completely bewildered.

What the hell was he getting at? “You’re not making a lick of sense,” John said.

“Neither are you!” Sebastian said, frustration finally bleeding through. “Why the fuck would I hate you?”

“I gave away the Arkenstone! I betrayed you!” I’m sorry, I was only trying to save you, I’m sorry.

Sebastian pursed his lips, nostrils flaring. “I told you, the Arkenstone doesn’t matter. Is that what this is about?”

“It doesn't...is that what… are you even listening to yourself?” John sputtered. His fingers flew to his scalp: better to wrench his hair than Sebastian’s neck. Since when had they discussed the Arkenstone, especially the Arkenstone not being important? Because that conversation, that Bilbo would've remembered. “That Arkenstone was your everything! And I just…” It hurt to say it, to admit it, but he wasn’t Bilbo, and the excuses of a lifetime ago weren’t going to cut it. “I just gave it away. I knew what it would do to you and I did it anyway, because I wanted you safe from whatever the hell the gold had done to you!” Oh, back to the excuses. So he wasn’t quite past that stage yet, apparently.

“It doesn’t mat-“

“You cast me out! You would’ve probably killed me if your nephews hadn’t held you back! I’m just surprised they didn’t want to help you cut me down where I stood!” And there was the tightening in his chest as he thought about Fili and Kili, remembered their laughter and their jokes. Remembered how Gandalf had told him they’d been laid to rest together after the battle, the fight maybe Bilbo could’ve saved them from if he’d just done something different, if he hadn’t taken the Arkenstone, if he’d just talked to Thorin or said something besides what he had, if he, if he…

It took a minute to realize that the only sound in the space was his heavy breathing. John looked up at Sebastian, confused at the way the other man had gone white as a ghost. Sebastian began to speak, then stopped, as if unable to pull in enough air. It took another try for him to actually get the words out. “Was my letter so ill received?” he managed. “Did it mean so little to you, that you would honestly believe that of me?”

John blinked. “Letter?” he asked. He frowned, hands falling to his side. “What…what letter?”

Sebastian took a step forward, and the name Sebastian was wrong here, now, because this was Thorin before him, in movement and words, though he’d never heard Thorin this desperate before. “The letter I dictated in my last moments. I…you must have received it.”

There’d been a letter? “No, I, no, I never got a letter.” He almost reached out to put a calming hand on Thorin’s shoulder, and almost had to physically wrench himself back. He wasn’t Bilbo, this wasn’t Thorin, they weren’t in Middle-Earth. But god if he didn’t feel like a hobbit before his dwarf lord again, wanting to offer solace to the king.

Because he had heard Thorin this desperate before: the night before Bilbo had wandered into the Lonely Mountain to face off against Smaug. Thorin had been more afraid for Bilbo than Bilbo had been, the king nearly lost in how frightened he’d been for the Halfling. “You sent a letter? To me?” John asked.

“I…I sent you everything I wanted to say in person.” The pain on Thorin’s face (Sebastian, Sebastian) was almost too much for him to bear. “How much I wanted to reconcile with you, the apologies I owed to you, the hurt and the wrongs I had done to you that I wanted forgiveness for. How that stone didn't matter, how it never should have. I thought…given how my death had been written in The Hobbit…”

How Bilbo had told the story. “No, I didn’t, I mean, I never received your letter.” He swallowed past the lump in his throat, and he was Bilbo again, small and hurt and wishing for something he knew he’d never get. For something he didn’t deserve, after he’d betrayed the person he’d held most dear. “I told Tolkien the story, your story. I was exact in everything-“ well, nearly everything, save for the quiet moments he’d held too close to let go, “-but…but I made it up. Your final farewell. The way I wished I could’ve said goodbye.” He bowed his head, wringing his hands. “I felt absolutely wretched telling Tolkien what I did, as if that was the way it had gone. Because I never would’ve dreamed that you, that you would’ve wanted…”

Thorin had died loathing him. It was a simple truth he’d had to live with for several lifetimes, now. If Bilbo had been there to say goodbye in the dwarf king’s final moments, he would’ve been pushed away with Thorin’s last strength. So he’d made up a bittersweet parting and hated himself for it, even while he’d secretly longed for it to be true.

But now, now to know that Thorin had wanted the same, that he’d spent his last moments dictating a letter to Bilbo to ask for reconciliation? It was almost more than Bilbo could stand.

“Bilbo.”

Two fingers gently caught under his chin and pulled his gaze up. Thorin no longer looked desperate but hopeful. His touch was tender, somehow forgiving which Bilbo couldn’t possibly imagine because after everything he’d done, it was the Arkenstone theft and the betraying of Thorin that had always sat the heaviest in his heart. But to see Thorin now, to feel his fingers brushing against Bilbo’s skin, to know that he wasn’t about to be cast out or cursed, it was more than he could’ve imagined in all his lifetimes. This was so much more than he deserved-

And just like that, he was John Watson again, no longer the hobbit who had failed everyone in every possible regard. He backed away, startling Thorin. “Bilbo-“

“I wish the letter had been delivered, for your sake and mine,” John said. “But that doesn’t change anything.” Liar, his heart screamed at him. The idea of the letter wrapped tightly around his mind, removing the sting of old memories, making them ache instead. “I still failed you. I failed Middle-Earth. I failed…”

Sherlock’s bright eyes suddenly came, unbidden, to the front of his thoughts, and suddenly he couldn’t be here. “I can’t,” he said, and it was Sebastian’s voice that called for him even while he raced for the door.

“John! Wait!”

He tore out of the safe house, not caring if there were fifty snipers ready to shoot the first thing that came out of the door. He couldn’t be there with Sebastian and Thorin and the ghosts of the past and his failures, his betrayals that were almost too much to speak of. He ran down the street, ignoring everything except the pounding of his feet on the pavement.

He never noticed the pained blue eyes that followed him.