Chapter Text
It was late when John came stumbling back to the safe house, miserable and tired. There was a gentle glow of light from the windows, which meant Sebastian had pulled back one of the curtains, to let John know he was still there.
He settled down on the stairs to the building instead. The cold had sunk into his bones, leaving him numb. He’d run and run until his cheeks had burned from the wind and the tears that had leaked from his eyes had long dried. He hadn’t stopped until he’d found himself on Baker Street. There’d been an official looking car in front of 221B – Lestrade’s, more than likely – and he’d stared at it for several long minutes before he’d slowly turned around to go back. Facing Lestrade and Mrs. Hudson was more than he could handle at the moment.
He was comfortably numb, even while his brain wouldn’t shut off. He’d ignored it for years, the events of Middle-Earth. He’d pushed them back while he’d helped Sherlock, saving lives like it made up for the horrors he’d inflicted on the men, elves, and dwarves of an age ago. On the hobbits, specifically four young hobbit lads who hadn’t deserved the atrocities they’d seen. He put a hand up to his face, covering his eyes.
Somewhere along their voyage to the last boats, Bilbo had found his book he’d given to Frodo. Old age had nearly robbed him of his sight, but not enough so that he couldn’t read what Frodo had added, of the ‘adventure’ his nephew had had. He’d let Frodo give the book to Sam, and the weariness on his nephew’s shoulders had suddenly meant so much more, knowing what Frodo had had to do because of Bilbo. Because of the ring Bilbo had so foolishly brought back with him from his doomed journey.
The destruction he’d caused. God, the cities that had burned, all because of him. Men and women and children, children, had perished because of his actions. That small, tiny ring that he’d selfishly used for so many years had claimed the lives of kings and noblemen. It had nearly claimed Frodo’s life. His bright-eyed nephew had come back haunted, desolate, never to truly smile again. He’d come back permanently injured, an ache in his shoulder and a finger forever gone. All because of Bilbo.
He hadn’t realized his eyes were burning until footsteps heralded someone approaching. He wiped his eyes with the back of his hand, looking up to try and see the figure in the dark. It could’ve been an assassin, for all he knew, a sharpshooter who had no inclination to spare his life the way Sebastian Moran had. He didn’t really care. Let him get shot: it was the least he owed the world. He’d failed Thorin, he’d failed Frodo, and now, he’d failed Sherlock. He didn’t move as the figure came into the light.
“Bilbo Baggins,” a throaty voice said, even as John felt his mouth fall open. “I had hoped to find you in better spirits.”
It was hard to breathe, but he managed to pull in a choked breath. “Gandalf,” he whispered, and the end of the wizard’s name came out half strangled.
Gandalf’s eyes crinkled in despair, but it was a familiar face, one he never thought he’d see again. “Oh Bilbo,” he said softly, and his gentleness was more than John could bear. He buried his face in his hands, shoulders shaking as he fought not to sob.
A hand rested on his shoulder, a silent support, and John reached blindly for his friend. His fingers found cloth, and the wizard tugged him forward until John’s face was buried in his knees, his hands clenched in the linens of his trousers. He began to weep, harsh sobs wrenched from his chest that cut off the ability to do anything except feel.
“My dear Bilbo,” Gandalf murmured, sounding sadder than he’d ever heard the wizard sound before. Gandalf rested his other hand on the back of John’s head, a presence of comfort against the heartsickness, fingers lightly brushing where ears had once been pointed. Once, long ago, Gandalf had comforted him much like this, in Bag End, when he’d told Bilbo about Thorin’s fate. And Bilbo had cried and wept and wished it could all be undone. No matter how much Gandalf had whispered words of comfort to him, he couldn’t be consoled.
Now, though. For some reason, Gandalf’s quiet presence was creeping into the depths of John’s very soul. It was pushing past the numbness that had pervaded his mind and heart and body, healing something he’d thought forever broken. Maybe it was because he’d finally been willing to accept the wizard’s comfort.
Or maybe it was because the door had opened behind them, and as John turned swollen eyes behind him, he saw Thorin standing there, framed in the light from inside. Except this wasn’t Thorin, King Under the Mountain. This wasn’t Thorin, lord of the dwarves.
This was Sebastian, with only a glimmer of Thorin in his gaze. This was a man who looked just as concerned as Gandalf did.
“Come, let’s go inside,” Gandalf said quietly, pulling John to his feet. John pushed back the last of his tears, even as his eyes burned with fresh pain.
“I’d always wondered how it was that you knew the events of the Fellowship.”
The kettle was nearly finished boiling. If there was anything they could use, it would be tea, though Sebastian knew well enough that Gandalf would’ve preferred some crazy coffee concoction. If there was one thing that Sebastian appreciated more now than in his previous lifetime, however, it was tea. Though he had to admit, he did have a flask of brandy tucked away in his jacket.
John didn’t even move under Gandalf’s soft gaze. The man looked drained, nowhere close to the crazed individual who’d stolen the air from Sebastian’s lungs earlier in the day. John kept staring at the floor, as if his head was too heavy to lift. A slight tremble had taken up residence in his small frame, and whether it was a chill or his tumultuous feelings, Sebastian didn’t know, but tea would help both. Tea was always a good answer.
Though he wasn’t certain the warm, calming beverage would help him at all. When he’d heard John sobbing on the steps, he’d all but raced to throw the door open. Seeing Gandalf had quelled some of his fears, but the look on John’s face of misery and heartache had nearly been more than he could’ve handled. Thankfully Gandalf had taken charge, though he’d subtly handed John over to Sebastian’s care as soon as they’d gotten inside. John had let Sebastian move him around and tug off his jacket, had even let him push the doctor into a chair. He hadn’t moved since.
John let out a long, deep sigh. “Frodo wrote of it, in the book I’d given him of my adventures. He added on to my writings. I picked it up by chance and got a firsthand look at the damage I’d truly wreaked, before he gave the book to Sam.”
Sebastian began to speak but Gandalf cut him off with a sharp wave of his hand. John didn’t notice, gaze still downcast. “What Frodo wrote would’ve been of his own adventure, Bilbo.” John made no move to correct the wizard, and Sebastian’s worry only furthered.
Gandalf gave him a look before he continued. “There were far too many details of Peregrin Took, of Gimli son of Gloin, and the adventures of countless others that Frodo would not have known about. How did you know about these to tell Tolkien?”
The kettle finally began whistling. Sebastian all but jumped up out of his seat, eager to have something else to do besides listen to the conversation. He didn’t feel like Thorin, dwarf lord and king. He didn’t even feel like Sebastian Moran, sharpshooter with nerves of steel. He felt like someone else, anxious and wanting Gandalf to leave John alone. He pulled the kettle off the small stove and began pouring tea. He was so engrossed in his work that he almost missed John’s response.
“I didn’t.”
Sebastian turned at the small voice, even as Gandalf sat up straighter. “You didn’t,” the wizard said, eyes widening.
“No, I didn’t.” John began fiddling with a stray thread on his pants, and it was like he was back in Middle-Earth, and Bilbo was right in front of him, nervous and lost amongst their company of dwarves. Uncertain as to whether he belonged, or if he was even wanted there. “Tolkien…Tolkien had heard the story from someone else. I don’t know whether it was Frodo or not. But he had heard it, all the same. The story of The Hobbit…that was mine. The Lord of the Rings, however, was not.” He began as if to speak again, then stopped, hunching over further in his chair.
Gandalf drew breath to speak again, and Sebastian quickly cut him off. “Earl Grey, Gandalf?” he asked. The look he got was almost a reprimand, but he didn’t give a shit. Leave him alone for half a goddamn second, you meddling wizard.
To his surprise, Gandalf didn’t push the issue. “Yes, thank you.” He was silent as Sebastian brought the tea over, only making a small sound of approval as he took his drink. Sebastian stood by John’s side, waiting for the man to even acknowledge his presence, but John kept staring at the floor. After a long moment, Sebastian finally caught the smaller man’s hand and brought it up to the handle of the cup. John blinked and raised his head, seeming startled at finding Sebastian there. It took another moment to focus on the cup of tea, but he did finally take it, bringing it down to rest in his lap.
Sebastian didn’t move away from John, opting to lean against the wall near the other man. He ignored Gandalf’s all too knowing gaze. Bilbo Baggins sat before him, falling apart, and John Watson had had his own tragedy to deal with today. No, Sebastian wasn’t going anywhere.
A tentative sip of tea seemed to bring John a little more back into the land of the living. “I’m not certain who did it, exactly. Who would’ve had the knowledge to do it. I never did find out. But Tolkien’s account matched up with Frodo’s story, so I assumed it was…an accurate portrayal.” His fingers tightened on the cup. “It was devastating, Gandalf, you don’t know…when I read that, read what that damned ring had done to more than just Frodo, I-“
“Bilbo Baggins, you will cease that nonsense talk right now,” Gandalf said sternly. “You had no idea about the ring.”
“But if I’d told you sooner,” John insisted. “If I’d just, just told you, said something, I could’ve saved so many lives. The Rohan, scorched, Gondor, decimated, the Shire nearly…” He swallowed hard and looked away.
“The Ring of Power was always going to spread darkness,” Gandalf said, a bit more calmly than before. “And in the end, Frodo used his Baggins strength to destroy it once and for all. I imagine he took much strength from you.”
John snorted loudly and put his cup aside. “If he got anything from me, it wasn’t ‘strength’. Maybe how to say the wrong bloody thing.”
He kept saying that. If I’d just said something different. “I’d have to disagree with you,” Sebastian said, inserting himself into the conversation at last.
“Good for you,” John snapped, and Gandalf rose to his full height.
“Bilbo Baggins-“
“It’s John Watson,” John shouted, but his eyes were pained, not angry. “I don’t want to be Bilbo Baggins anymore! He, he screwed it all up, can’t you see that? If I’d said something about the ring, maybe, maybe things could’ve been different.”
“Do you really think saying anything different in any situation, any, would’ve made a difference?” Sebastian asked incredulously. “When you spoke to me about the Arkenstone, I was so damned lost I wouldn’t have heard you if you’d shouted that my nephews were dead at my feet.”
John gaped, trying to find an answer. “But I could’ve said something-“
“No, you couldn’t have,” Gandalf said. John turned to him, bewildered. “Things happened the way they did for a reason, Bilbo. If you hadn’t kept the ring for so long, Aragorn never would’ve ascended to the throne and brought about an age of peace to Middle-Earth. Sauron and his forces would never have been destroyed. The elves and dwarves would never have found a reconciling between them. That ring brought about good things, too. Things that had to come to pass. I am merely grateful that the ring didn’t affect you any more than it did, and not until many years later.
“And that, my dear hobbit, is entirely my fault. I suspected, very early on, that you had a ring with great power, yet never spoke to you of it. That was my wrongdoing. If anyone should have ‘said’ something differently, it should’ve been me.”
Sebastian didn’t realize he was walking to John until he was there, and it was easy then to rest a hand on the man’s shoulder. John turned his face up, moisture shimmering in his eyes. “I also should’ve said something different. What I said to you about the Arkenstone was more than wrong, it was unforgiveable. And I died regretting it.”
John looked stricken. “No, Thorin-“
“You did the right thing,” Sebastian said quietly. He offered a small smile when John still looked ill. “You didn’t make the mistake, Bilbo. I did. I threatened and cast out someone I…valued,” he finished. He didn’t dare look at Gandalf: one smug look from him was enough for a lifetime. And admitting to John – more importantly, to Bilbo – that he’d more than valued him, well, it wasn’t happening while the wizard was in the room.
Gandalf actually seemed to take a hint for once. He slowly stood, only catching John’s attention when he spoke. “It is late, and I should be on my way.”
“To where?” John asked. “Will you be back?”
Gandalf nodded. “Tomorrow, I will stop in. I have a few more things I should be doing right now, but you were my most pressing and, I will admit, my most indulgent meeting this night.” He smiled broadly at John, and Sebastian remembered that he’d been friends with Bilbo for a good many years. To know that an old friend wasn’t lost, well, Sebastian couldn’t deny him that. Especially when John returned his enthusiasm with a weary smile.
“It is good to see you at long last, Bilbo Baggins,” Gandalf said. He retrieved his cane from near the door and, pulling out a hat from seemingly nowhere, he was gone.
John was the first to speak. “Was he…wearing a fedora?”
“A brightly checkered fedora at that,” Sebastian agreed. How in the hell hadn’t he noticed that earlier? Now it was blazingly obvious. The wizard hat had suited him better. Though with his short haircut, perhaps the wizard hat didn’t work quite as well.
Something tensed beneath his fingertips, and he realized he was still holding on to John’s shoulder. Before he could pull his hand away, John turned to look at him, and fuck, that was the last thing he needed. John’s eyes were bright, but not nearly as empty as they’d been early. “You mean that,” he said. It wasn’t a question. Sebastian didn’t ask for clarification.
“Yeah,” Sebastian said. “I do. Meant it there on the battlefield, and I mean it now. You didn’t deserve what I said.”
“I took the Arkenstone,” John said softly. “More than that, I…I betrayed your trust. I never forgave myself for that. What-ifs plagued me every single day. If I’d just said this, if I hadn’t given it away, if I’d just done something, anything different.”
“If you hadn’t given the Arkenstone away, I imagine the casualties would’ve been more than they already were.” It was bad enough that he’d gotten his nephews slaughtered. Murdered. He swallowed against the knot in his throat. Their cheerful faces drenched with blood; it had been the last vision of them, and the one he’d keep forever.
He couldn’t undo everything, but he could undo how he’d left things with Bilbo. The last time he’d seen the hobbit, Bilbo had had tears in his eyes, voice getting smaller and smaller as he’d tried to reason against the gold sickness. He’d tried to save Thorin from himself, and had been cast out, cursed, raged at and loathed. There was nothing Sebastian could do, he thought, to make up for what his past self had done.
But John was right before him, still letting Sebastian hold him, and maybe…maybe he could try. “You don’t owe me an apology. You don’t owe Middle-Earth an apology.”
“The ring-“
“And if you hadn’t found it, taken it, used it? It would’ve stayed there in the mountains, maybe one day found by a goblin and wielded for evil. Your finding it was what led it to being destroyed.” The look in the other man’s eyes made him try again. “Don’t think about the lives lost. Think about how many of those lives were spared because of you. Don’t look at the casualties, Bilbo. Look at the ones who lived.”
John didn’t offer a rebuttal. Sebastian began to pull his hand away, only to stop when John inched his shoulder higher to keep the contact. He looked down at his hand, to John, then fought not to grip the other man’s shoulder. Where the hell was his Durin courage when he needed it? You were the leader of an army more than once, you battled Azog the Defiler and won, you slaughtered goblins and orcs, you can buck up and tell him-
“Sebastian?”
Sebastian pulled himself from his thoughts. John was frowning, a slight thing that marred his forehead. “Are you all right?” he asked.
Now or never. “I need to tell you something.”
