Actions

Work Header

The Weight of the World and Its Heaven

Chapter 4: Sugar Loaf Key/Memphis

Chapter Text

Present day

Clarice's phone woke her in the darkness. She fumbled, sitting up. The fat bulldog named Marius lifted his head from her thigh with a whine.

"Starling."

"I need you back here," Crawford said. "Where are you?"

"About forty minutes drive from Key West. Um." She pulled the elastic band out of her ponytail and ran her fingers through her hair. "I'm not sure there's an address."

Jack paused, but his phone voice didn't give away much. "Is he coming with you?"

She'd passed out on Graham's couch in a pile of case file documents and dogs (six or seven of them, large and astoundingly ugly for the most part, with a litter resemblance). Now there was a blanket pulled over her legs, and the dogs had disappeared except for Marius. Graham was nowhere to be seen. "I think so. Yes."

"There'll be a chopper for you at Key West in an hour. Starling. Chilton brokered a separate deal between Lecter and Senator Martin. The Senator's offered a deal to transfer him into Tennessee, to an institution that meets with his conditions. They're getting ready to move him from the BSHCI. He says he'll only give her the information in person, once they've signed the papers. We'll have SWAT teams on the move as soon as we get the word."

Clarice thought hard, and quickly. Jack seemed to be saying her assignment was over. But he was sending a chopper. "What about the Marceau angle?"

"We'll talk about that. Key West Airport, sixty minutes. Make sure you bring Graham."

He hung up. At the same time the light in the little cabin came on. She looked up and saw Graham at the door. He'd put on real clothes and looked more sober than before, which was another qualified success.

"I dropped the dogs off with the neighbours," he said. "Was that Jack?"

"He's got a chopper waiting for us at Key West," said Clarice. "I'll tell you the rest on the way. What about this guy?"

"He's coming with me," said Graham. Marius nosed at his hand, and he caressed the dog's muzzle absently. "He has a tendency to run, otherwise."

Clarice drove her rental sedan. Marius sat in the back, where he promptly stuck his head out the window with his tongue lolling in the wind. Graham huddled tensely in the passenger seat. His overnighter bag had looked like it held maybe two changes of clothing, but he'd filled the trunk with a fortnight's worth of kibble.

Clarice explained Jack's message. Graham said nothing, only wound himself up tighter, like a clock spring.

"You don't like it," she said, when his distress was too evident not to acknowledge. Graham made a noise that resembled a laugh.

"You could say that," he said.

"Lecter'll have to hold up his end of the deal. If he doesn't he'll be back where he started."

"Will he?" said Graham. He ran a hand over his face. "It'll be, ah. A nice vacation for him. A break from the usual. Go down to Memphis, see the sights, talk to the locals. He's very interested in people. I imagine you've realized that."

"You're not pissed off at me," said Clarice. "I thought you were at first, but you're not. So I figure you're pissed off at Jack, I just happen to be in this car."

Graham looked out the window. "He shouldn't have sent you to Hannibal Lecter."

"I understand why Jack did it. And I had a choice. I took the assignment."

"Of course you did."

"Don't," said Clarice, "take that for granted."

There was a silence. The overseas highway unspooled before their high beams, a grey ribbon of tarmac bisecting an infinite blue-black expanse. Pinpricks of light on the horizon – houses, possibly, or fishing boats. Clarice stepped on the gas.

"Jack likes this deal as much as I do," said Graham, "that's why we're being pulled in. To work the fallback."

Clarice heard the we but didn't call it out. "We had someone on it before I came down," she said instead. "Most likely they've found her already."

"Finding's not the problem, time is. She's not an American citizen." Graham slumped lower in his seat. "What you have is a killer who may have found inspiration in the work of an international artist, for reasons of his own. He's obsessed with transformation. I couldn't implicate her then and there's barely a connection now. Miguel Diaz had a very specific victim profile, and it's not this."

"But she talked to you," Clarice said.

"Yeah. She was probably curious."

"Can I ask a question?"

Graham shrugged.

"Did Dr. Lecter tell you about her?"

Graham was silent for a moment. "No," he said, finally. "But I assume he wanted me to find out. Like everything else in that file, really."

"There's a pattern to the women in his file," said Clarice. "Young women. The sister--"

"Right," Graham said, "the sister. She would have been clever, wouldn't she? A really smart girl. Fearless, like him. Always up for an adventure, getting herself into the kind of trouble that big brother has to bail her out of. Maybe she should have stayed put in the basement, if she knew what was good for her."

"Christ, Will."

"What I'm trying to say is, you don't want Hannibal Lecter to think of you as family."

Something in his voice rang like grief. He'd been married, Clarice remembered. Step-child. That was evidently done with. No immediate relatives. Maybe no friends, if Price – whose social radar might charitably be described as rudimental – could be believed. Katz liked him, though, Price had said. Said he wasn't any more or less of a weirdo than the rest of us.

That had been four whiskeys in. Clarice had learnt it took a minimum of three before either Beverley Katz or Will Graham was referenced in conversation. Lecter had killed Beverley Katz, too.

The Quantico rumours about Graham and Lecter were long-running and sensational. Clarice had had no truck with most of them: the verifiable facts were lurid enough. Now that she'd spoken to both, though, she understood viscerally that there had been something. Could see how it had come about, which worried her. Will Graham did not give off the same sense of monstrous self-sufficiency as Lecter did, but he was as cripplingly isolated. Precedent was unclear as to which one would crack first.

"Will," she said, "if it comes down to it, I'll talk to Dr. Lecter. He doesn't need to know you're involved. He finds me a little bit interesting, that's all there is to it. He can't do anything to me. You realize that, don't you?"

"A little bit interesting," Will echoed, after a moment. His intonation so suddenly resembled Lecter's that it prickled down Clarice's back. "Are you... trying to protect me, Clarice?"

He didn't sound like he liked the idea.

"I'm saying no one has to protect anyone," said Clarice. "You're doing us a favour; don't be a goddamned martyr to the cause. I'll do my job, Jack'll do his, and whether Lecter talks or not we'll catch the bastard."

It came out a lot more certain than she felt. For a long second she wasn't sure whether he would take the bait. Then Graham sighed, and she felt tension leech from him. Not completely, not by a long shot; but better than nothing.

"How long have you spent on this case?" he said. "Three weeks? Four? You're going to be held back a cycle, if this goes on."

Clarice had thought about it. Extensively. When she did the televised image of Catherine Martin came to her: playing with her family, carefree, on the riverbank. "I'll cross that bridge when I get to it."

"Don't be a martyr to the cause, huh?"

"Do as I say, not as I do," she said. Felt him smile, which hadn't happened yet.

 

* * *

 

They talked about the investigation, until the helicopter noise made it impossible. Graham had looked at the photos of the girls, back at the cabin; Clarice had stayed quiet, given him space, but there had been nothing to see. No psychic convulsions. Graham had looked tired and said: "This is a complex project. It's not his first, but it's special, life-changing – the best he's come up with in a long while. The women… the women aren't..."

He'd stood up, paced around in a tight circle.

"I'm no good at this," he'd said, abruptly. "Wrong mindset. I'm going for a walk."

That was when he'd disappeared, leaving the pack of dogs to keep her company. Clarice had been vaguely let down, which in turn had surprised and irritated her: on some well-squashed level, she had expected the magic dinner show of Quantico legend.

As if any part of this assignment would be that easy.

Graham pulled himself together, though, in the car: he articulated ideas in struggling bursts, but sensibly. The women weren't individuals, he said. Not people. Sometimes there was a sexual compulsion, even romantic, in a killer's actions, twisted as they might be; that was not Buffalo Bill's case. But paradoxically, ideally, he saw his victims as women. It was the messy stuff of their femininity itself that he was after – something more essential than raw flesh. Graham did not understand how, through the act of killing and skinning, Bill acquired what he needed to paint the abstraction. He was missing a step, he said, with a humourless laugh. But he did not offer to look at the pictures again.

They didn't discuss what would happen if Catherine were not found – whether, in the event they retrieved her body from the river, Graham would go down to the scene and look.

The détente lasted until they got off the helicopter at Quantico. Jack was on the tarmac to meet them, dark coat whipping in the wind from the rotary blades. Insofar as Clarice could see his expression under the floodlights' glare, he looked grim.

"Will," he said. "It's good to see you."

"Hello, Jack," Will said, evenly. He was holding Marius on a shortened leash. Jack glanced at the dog, and for some reason looked grimmer.

"Come down to the lab," he said. "Price wants to see you, and then we'll get you caught up. We found Marceau in L.A."

"I am caught up," Will said, "thanks to Special Agent Starling."

He wasn't looking at either of them as he said it. Jack stared at him for a moment, then turned and looked at Clarice. Clarice met his eyes and saw inscrutability descend over his face like a shutter.

"Good job, Starling," he said. "Go back to the dorm. Get some sleep while you can. Call my office in the morning."

 

* * *

 

"So he is an asshole," said Ardelia. "Prime grade. Triple A. All American."

"It's not even that," Clarice said. "Assholes are a cheap plentiful commodity. I'm just pissed I didn't see it coming." She thumbed at her phone – the photo of Jane Marceau's caged moth installation, back to Crawford's office contact, back—

"You think Graham outright doesn't want you on the case?"

"I think he's off giving Jack Crawford shit about Miriam Lass. And Beverley Katz, because we're interchangeable action girl figurines and history is bound to repeat itself. Christ, I thought Price was bad."

—To call history. There was an outbound that she had not made: Doctor Chilton's office line, at the Baltimore State Hospital for the Criminally Insane.

Clarice stared.

7:43PM to 8:01PM.

Jack's call was timestamped 8:45.

"Son of a bitch," she said aloud. Ardelia raised an eyebrow.

"Graham, Crawford, Lecter, or the dog? I assume that last one goes without saying."

Clarice shook her head. Graham had known – no. Chilton hadn't told him about the deal. Chilton would have put the call through, probably recorded the entire conversation, confident that Lecter wouldn't give up his leverage now – not even to Will Graham. And if Graham had ferreted out anything about Buffalo Bill he wouldn't have kept it back. She could judge him well enough, she thought, to be sure of that.

Maybe it wasn't about Bill. What was it Graham had said? Lecter hadn't told him about Marceau. But I assume he wanted me to find out.

One last chance to ask.

Jesus, Graham, you hot mess.

One last chance—

"Back to the office?" Ardelia said.

"No." On her feet, shrugging into her jacket. "Memphis."

"Lecter?"

Intuition had outrun the chain of logic and arrived at conviction. "This whole setup stinks," said Clarice. "I don't know why. But if we don't get Lecter talking now that door is going to close."

Five minutes later she was in her car and flooring it back to Dulles.

 

* * *

 

Chilton got in Will's face as soon as he walked through the front door of the Shelby County Courthouse. He was white as a sheet, the scars standing out in red-livid blotches, and shaking: "What did you say to him? Graham! What the hell did you say!"

Jack looked at him sharply. Will brushed past Chilton and let him intercept Jack instead. Jack knew as well as Will did that Hannibal would have tried to escape the moment opportunity was afforded to him; Will's call could not conceivably have made a difference. It was why Starling's deal had been fake. Chilton had outsmarted himself, as always – invariably just intelligent enough to learn from the last mistake.

Chilton must have wanted it, Will thought. He didn't know it but on some level he must have. All the time Will had spent in a haze of whiskey, sun, and regret, Chilton and Lecter had been locked in the BSHCI, together. It must have worn both down. Years of that and even the deferred death sentence of Hannibal's freedom might have been preferable, so long as it ended with release.

Will himself was beyond fatigue, as bleached bones were beyond decay. And he was not sure what he wanted.

It was a shock to step again into a space Hannibal had made his own. Like being chilled and sinking into a bath just this side of too hot. Will had readied himself, clear-eyed, for the sensation to be pleasurable, but he was conscious of an unexpected melancholy. Something about the shape of the room – its two-storey height, the wood floor, the way the eye was drawn toward the cage at its centre, and what were surely Hannibal's chair and his little table – reminded him of the Baltimore office, a lifetime ago. But there were no books here, no framed prints and etchings, no carefully selected furniture. Hannibal had come down in the world, and he had had to make do.

There was the angel, strung up as Eliot Budish once had done: an ironic little quolibet of a prayer. There was the drying stain where he'd lain, disguised. The rest was theatre in the round, celebration, indulgence, the stands milling now with indifferent or horrified spectators like the Lyric Opera House's bar at intermission. Will bypassed them and approached the stage. The door swung open; he stepped over the threshold without hesitation.

The pendulum swung, gold in darkness.

"Thank you for calling ahead of your visit, Will," Hannibal said. He sat at the table with his back turned, drawing – Will could hear a soft marker tip move across paper – the way he used to in the firelight. "As I said, I appreciate the courtesy."

"I wasn't going to come," Will said.

"Liar," Hannibal said, simply. Will heard the smile in his voice, and closed his eyes.

"There was nothing I could have offered you," he said. "Not placed against this. You knew this would happen."

"I knew there would be opportunity, yes. Hence that it might be the last time you and I would speak. And Buffalo Bill, I think, is not for you. But as usual you underestimate yourself. We have passed through the natural end of the narrative: my infamy has grown beyond me, as your legacy is beyond you. Yet some fragment of our original selves remain."

"Barely alive," Will said. "Just the apparatus of flesh, hanging on out of inertia."

"I think there is more. It was posited to me, once, that we die before we cease to breathe; but that this was all the more reason to consider the thereafter. From here on all is uncertain, and uncertainty should be celebrated. Should you continue to evolve... I confess my devotion to the pleasure principle has only deepened with time. You have been one of the great pleasures of my life, Will Graham. I prefer to dwell on that over the pain."

"A token," Will said, "of your appreciation."

"If I have left one," Hannibal said, "it could only be here."

Reality reasserted itself. Will snapped on gloves and sorted rapidly through the artifacts on the table – tray and remnants of the meal, mp3 player, marker pens, drawings. There was a view of Florence, the Duomo clearly visible; and there, another, of a grand turreted house that seemed vaguely familiar. The trees surrounding it were dark, looming masses, blocking out the sky, but its windows blazed with light.

The third drawing was a half-length portrait of a young woman, facing the viewer, a lamb by her side; bearing in her hands a palm frond like a standard. Will recognized the iconography as that of Saint Agnes of Rome. He knew the face, too, and the direct clear gaze.

Saint Agnes, blessed martyr.

Buffalo Bill, I think, is not for you.

He whirled, paper in hand, and met Jack's eyes from across the room. His voice over-loud.

"Where's Clarice Starling? Where is she now!"