Chapter Text
ELLEN MUIR: Tell me about The Weight of the World and its Heaven. How did you arrive at the concept for the piece?
ANDREI HAMADA: I watched a lot of coverage around the Catherine Martin kidnapping, before and after her rescue. 60 Minutes, tabloid blog BS, all those "inside the mind of a killer" special investigative segments – no offense. [laughs] I was pretty obsessed with it. It was really the story of these two girls, if you think about it: Catherine Martin and Clarice Starling. One of them kidnapped, stuck down a well, going through this insane ordeal, and the other one who's – not an FBI agent even—
ELLEN MUIR: A trainee. At the time.
ANDREI HAMADA: Yes. And she's the one who solves the case! With the help of Hannibal fucking Lecter! So the FBI says thank you love, the SWAT teams have got it from here, you go there and tie up some loose ends for the report, and she's the one to walk into Buffalo Bill's house and put four bullets in his chest. [gestures] Bam-bam-bam. Bam. Like she had God on her side. The Joan of Arc of behavioural profiling.
Anyway. Once they started documenting what was inside that house… that got to me. The thing that struck me was that Buffalo Bill – Jame Gumb – he thought he was an artist. That was the first thing.
ELLEN MUIR: He had all these moodboards.
ANDREI HAMADA: Exactly! It was like fashion school, what he was doing. It was a senior year thesis project. You had Ed Gein with his folksy shrunken heads—
EM: The classic naive outsider.
AH: Artists love transgression. We get off on the idea that we're supposed to play that social role. Get naked in the gallery, slice up a cow – Hirst released a statement during Hannibal Lecter's trial, after those details came out. At the end of the day, though: we, inclusive of me, want our work to be seen, and we don't want to get arrested. [laughs] And that's not hypocrisy, it's human beings drawing a line. Obviously I don't disagree with the line. The hypocrisy would be pretending it doesn't exist. But I was fascinated with the idea that these killers were taking a direct path to self-expression. Like why be Cindy Sherman and play around with fake props? Why be Serrano and wait for John Does to roll into the morgue? Make your own John Doe! Control the process!
EM: There's a quote I found recently, in Lawrence Durrell's Alexandria Quartet.
AH: Shoot.
EM: One of his characters says: "Bad art is what rapes the emotion of the audience without providing value." And the synonym he gives for this is "effectiveness." Bad art is highly effective.
AH: That's interesting. You know what he means.
EM: Would you say Jame Gumb was effective?
AH: He might be, in a movie.
EM: What about Hannibal Lecter?
AH: He was better than effective, sometimes. But what I liked were the dinner performances – the oral history of the performances. The more domestic the better. "Glossy stew," all that comedic unease. Over-the-top 16th-century Flemish nature mortes, like if Sam Taylor-Wood had served the hare with the pelt on: do I eat this? Do I watch it decompose? I didn't like his Ripper installations, those were self-aggrandizing bombastic bullshit. Though I should keep my mouth shut, since he's still out there and he reads his press. [laughs]
EM: Off the record, then. [laughs]
AM: But, you know, assume axiomatically that Durrell's right, and that there's no value to what Lecter or Gumb did to their victims, it's horrifying and purely detrimental. Why, then, do I feel Lecter's first-rate and Gumb second-rate? You get what I mean? That operation of taste?
EM: Hence—
AH: The piece. The Weight of the World and its Heaven. Which of course was immediately interpreted as a satire on the gallery system, on the art world. Late Capitalism dismembering its victims, ceci n'est pas un crime scene, et cetera. But the inspiration was naive. I was the critic. I was looking at these reconstructions from the media and asking myself: what are its formalist elements? Does it belong to a school of thought, a scene, a context? Is it critique? Is it self-expressive? What, in the artist's environment, is it responding to? And if that seems cold, the process wasn't. I had nightmares.
EM: Would you say you were profiling them?
AH: Not in the least. It was a completely fanciful paradigm. [laughs] I'm an artist, I make shit up. I don't instinctively think in terms of helping the police.
EM: So that was never the intent? You didn't actually think Jame Gumb situated himself in creative dialogue with, say, Cindy Sherman?
AH: Oh, no, I did. Factually, I think he did. He was delusional. And these guys exchanged ideas, for a given value of "exchange." Francis Dolarhyde, you know the Tooth Fairy, he was inspired by Lecter, who himself did that entire copycat series after Garrett Jacob Hobbs… Lecter was the figurehead. He pretty much exploded, or imploded, the year before he went on the run – actually he was a lot more interesting once he retired the Chesapeake Ripper persona. …Are we going to talk about Will Graham?
EM: Insofar as he became a central figure in your work, yes.
AH: Oh, Christ. [laughs] A central figure… Well, I had this theory about Graham, at the time: Lecter thought he'd met either John Ruskin or Lizzie Siddal, he just didn't know which it was.
EM: Are you sure the framework isn't satirical?
AH: I didn't say it wasn't. Once shit hit the fan and the FBI showed up, I got very serious about the piece being non-serious.
EM: That's when you met with Agent Starling.
AH: Yes, I did. The ángel arcabucero herself. And that was interesting, because she understood. She understood immediately.
–Andrei Hamada, artist, video interview conducted and transcribed by Ellen Muir (unreleased notes)
* * *
Four years earlier
"Please," said the young girl's voice, "don't let the light in."
Will let go of the door, reflexively. It swung closed, and he paused, dizzied by the transition. Outside was bright, late morning. Inside—
Cartesian perspective returned slowly. The space, he knew, was a disused factory: cavernous and high-ceiling-ed, dilapidated brick walls left intentionally bare. On the far wall were the barely-visible outlines of tall windows, blacked out with paint. The floor... there did not seem to be a floor. Only the intimation of a surface, reflective and still like dark water, across which empty wooden shipping pallets were scattered like a makeshift bridge. Below that surface was black space, extending into infinity, and the glimmer of faraway stars.
(A trick of mirrors? Of screens? Light-emitting diodes?)
From the darkness of space vast white shapes emerged. Will counted twelve: they seemed humanoid, but somehow bloated, limbs too spindly or short. Some seemed to struggle on their bellies, or to rise to all fours. Others were tall and hunched, scapulars spreading into prototypical wings. Will blinked away the memory of other, more organic sculptures.
There was a flare of yellow light, like a lighter being struck.
"Over here," said the voice. Will followed it, stepping carefully from pallet to pallet, the way he would on floor protection plates at a crime scene. The light wavered and caught, became steady.
"The vernissage is this evening," Jane Marceau said. She wore an over-large painter's smock and stood on the top rung of a stepladder, next to the statue in the farthest right corner. "I have to test this first. Is that all right?"
Will made a vague gesture of assent. The light was emanating from the statue's head, as if it were a massive candle she had set alight. Perhaps it was. With the close illumination he could tell, now, that the wax was not homogeneous. Objects were caught in it, half-exposed, like fossils in sedimentary strata – a feather, a key. His perspective shifted, and for a moment the forms were weathered sea-boulders, worn smooth and strange by littoral action. Then he saw the thick ropes of red, running beneath the surface; branching like vessels that held blood.
Where the wax had been lit it was red. Was it the wick?
"You are Will Graham, aren't you?" she said. "Gabie said you wanted to see me. Is this about Miguel Diaz?"
As Will watched a crimson trickle began to run, from the top of the statue's head, dripping along its throat; then slowing and pooling, just above its heart.
"Miguel Diaz, yes," he said. "Among others."
Jane smiled. Leant forward and blew out the light.
* * *
They emerged from the exhibition space, blinking. A young man was waiting for them, hands shoved deep into his windbreaker's pockets. He was scowling.
"I told you to call first," he said to Will.
"It's all right, Gabie," Jane said. "We're just going to have a chat. Mr. Graham can drive me to the sanctuary." She turned to Will. "You don't mind, do you?"
"I'll take you," said Gabie.
"I need you to help me clear up here," said Jane. "And do the setup for the preview. I'll be fine."
"You'll tire yourself out, Jane. It's going to run late tonight."
"I'll be fine," she repeated, and smiled at him. In the sunlight her skin was nearly translucent, with the beginning of fine lines around the eyes. "It's a good day. Don't worry."
* * *
The migratory bird sanctuary was a T-shaped, wooded peninsula, extending into the middle of the Lachine Rapids, surrounded by whitewater and a scattering of smaller, marshy islands. It was maintained as a public park, with paved paths and foot bridges and picnic areas. Masses of black-eyed susans were still in late bloom. The roar of the river was muted, but omnipresent.
"I come here every other day," said Jane, "just to walk. I like to keep the birds company. There. Do you see?"
Will looked. He saw a great blue heron, coiled in the rushes and patiently observing the water. It was hunting. As he and Jane watched the long neck darted out, snake-like, and speared something silver-glinting that wiggled. A toss of the head, and the prey was gone. The bird folded, origami-like, back into its original stillness.
"I leave at the end of the month," said Jane, "and so will they. They come here to nest and bring up their children, but they're snowbirds: in autumn they go south. They overwinter in Florida, I'm told."
"In Key West," said Will. "There's another sanctuary. I've been there."
"I've never been. But I imagine it sometimes: white sand, and the herons, and the sea like a mirror held up to the sky." She smiled. "It must be unbearably bright. I don't… enjoy light, much."
Will was silent.
"You said you had questions about Miguel," Jane said. "But that's not what you want to ask me about, is it?" She tilted her head, considering him. "You may ask. It's not as hard as you think."
"How much," said Will, "do you remember of…"
"The Baby Doll Killer? The time I spent with him? Nothing." Still smiling. "I read the transcripts, after I turned eighteen, but I wouldn't be able to tell you the story now. There, you see? Easy answer."
"What's the hard answer?"
She reached out a hand to him, palm turned upward, and the long sleeve slipped a little over her wrist; he saw the silver patches of skin covering her arm. Burns so old they were hardly recognizable as scars.
"It's all still there. On me, in me – my bones are fragile. It's hard to walk. I get tired. Anyone can tell that from looking; though they don't usually pay attention. But you do, don't you? You see it clear as day."
"I see it," said Will. He looked at her, again to make sure, and a sense of desolation settled over him. "I saw it in your work."
"Yes."
"The world he made visible is the world you see."
"Yes. Don't apologize."
"I wasn't going to."
"Don't say I'm sorry because you feel bad for me, I mean." She looked away, over the water. "I'm not unhappy to be different. I make a lot of money, you know. And I do only what I want to do; only what comes naturally to me."
"Only the easy answers," Will said.
"Yes. But you don't trust easy answers, do you, Mr. Graham? Tell me what you know about Miguel."
"He was your assistant," Will said. "He helped you execute your installations, when the physical exertion involved was too demanding. He'd been with you for two years; he'd served briefly in the military, and at one time was a street artist in New York. Immediately before he met you, he'd voluntarily committed himself to a psychiatric facility, and was released eighteen months later. He had no immediate family.
"The two of you were in Paris, opening an exhibition, the week that he died. He was… cut open, put on display in a disused area of the Catacombs, and found three days later. Law enforcement now attributes the murder to Dr. Hannibal Lecter – the Chesapeake Ripper – whom the FBI and Interpol believe originally escaped to Paris from Baltimore. But no organs were taken from the body, and the mutilations were summary."
"Do you believe it was him?" The little-girl voice was low, dreamy.
"I do, yes. But not that the murder was planned. I believe Lecter was attacked."
"By Miguel?"
"A man named Paul Brody was murdered in his apartment, in Queens, in November 2012. His throat had been cut, and the body partially burned. A note was left suggesting gangland retribution. Hair and personal items of three missing girls were discovered among his belongings. Miguel Diaz was working with you in Brooklyn at the time, on a artistic residency.
"Geneva, June 2013: the body of one Lucian Junker was found after a house fire. His death was classified as a homicide, identical modus operandi. He'd been investigated in connection with the rape and murder of a vacationing hiker, but had been released for lack of evidence. You were in Switzerland, attending the Art Basel show. Stockholm, September…" Will paused. "Should I go on?"
"Baltimore," Jane said. "I had a piece in a travelling exhibition at the Walters, last winter. But you were getting to that."
"You were invited to a round table discussion," Will said, "at the museum member's preview. I can confirm that Doctor Lecter was in attendance."
"I suppose Miguel might have seen him there," said Jane. "But he couldn't have known. No one suspected at the time, did they?"
"No," said Will. "No one who knew him socially in Baltimore, at any rate. We're still interviewing in Europe – it's been years, but we might be able to jog someone's memory."
"I was immensely sad when Miguel died," Jane said. "We were very close – like brother and sister. He went through a lot at a very young age, just as I did. He told me I was the only one who was capable of understanding the world in the way that he saw it. And now you suggest to me that he killed two men – more – and that he attempted to kill Hannibal Lecter." She looked at Will. "Out of curiosity: do you see a difference between those killings, and the ones Doctor Lecter himself stands accused of? Or Paul Brody? Lucian Junker? ...Roland Piche?"
"In degree, perhaps," he said. "Not in kind. Not enough."
"Of course not," said Jane. "Never the easy answer, is it? Never what comes naturally to you."
Will forced himself to meet her gaze. There was no outrage in her eyes; no reproach or sharpness. Only a calm empathy.
"Doctor Lecter does stand accused of more than homicide," he said, "Or even cannibalism. He tortured his victims before death. He kept captives. He was known to abuse his patients and encourage their violent thinking, even to manipulate them into suicide or murder. I don't think Miguel Diaz was ever in that position."
"He wasn't," said Jane. "He never had authority over anyone. And now he's dead. What will you do?"
"Find Hannibal Lecter," said Will. "It's the one thing I can do."
"Then I wish you happy hunting," said Jane.
Behind her, the heron took to the air. The downward sweep of its wings set the rushes to swaying.
