Sorry, you need to have JavaScript enabled for this.

Actions

Work Header

Unsaid

Summary:

The mountain is reclaimed, the battle is won, and Thorin Oakenshield finds he has to live with his guilt and regret over how he treated his burglar. Years pass, Erebor flourishes and some important words still remain unsaid, waiting for a letter to find its way home.

Notes:

A companion piece to Unread, this is Thorin's POV but should work as a standalone as well. I tried to keep this one more like book-verse when it comes to timeline.

Some of the dialogue in the Mountain taken straight from The Hobbit.

And hot damn I left a lot of material on the cutting table!

Work Text:

It was not exactly clear to Thorin Oakenshield when he had begun to regard Mr. Baggins, his burglar, as more than a travelling companion, and expendable, at that. It had crept upon him slowly: first noticing the hobbit was not wholly useless; that he had curiosity, a bright mind, and a good heart. After Bilbo had saved the lives of Thorin and his companions while risking his own, Thorin could no longer deny his bravery (however foolhardy it seemed). Nothing bound the hobbit to the dwarves’ mission as it did the others, yet he showed loyalty time and again. It unsettled Thorin, though he could not have said why.

What was clear, though, was when it had dawned to him. In the Elvenking’s dungeon, Thorin’s fierce determination had curdled into frustration bordering on despair and fear that they would never reach the Mountain in time. Bilbo had watched his pacing, muttering, and sighing without getting a chance to speak until he could hold his tongue no longer and cut in.

“Oh dear now, wait a little… This is what we shall do. It’s what my mother used to do when my father was upset… Now stop and give me your hands, both of them. Breathe. Again. No, none of that, be quiet and listen to me. Are you listening? Good. So, there are a few things I’ve already noticed…”

Through the bars, Bilbo took his hands and whispered his observations, tidings from the other dwarves, his forming plan, its progress, and it was enough to anchor him again. Bilbo promised to return when he had news again and it would be safe. And he did, day after day, bringing news along with witty remarks and observations, while ensuring Thorin remained as well as one could be in such conditions.

The days blurred into one another. Isolation gnawed at him, unbearable for one sworn to lead and protect, yet now utterly helpless. But the hobbit’s company made it almost tolerable for a short while at a time, it meant hope. When his frustration became too much again, smaller hands closing over his own grounded him in something real. Thorin saw the dark circles deepen under Bilbo’s eyes, his clothes starting to sag, yet still he was unfalteringly brave. And Thorin could do nothing to keep him safe.

In the quiet darkness of that cell, it dawned upon him, slowly and unavoidably: it was not merely news or company he awaited, but Bilbo himself.

But a dungeon was no place for confessions. Thorin held his tongue and waited.

~~~~~~~~

Laketown tested his resolve. He almost let himself be swept away.

Bilbo had mostly recovered from his cold and was bored and restless, craving company. They walked to the balcony to enjoy what little daylight was left, gazing toward the Lonely Mountain in the distance. Bilbo had insisted on some fresh air, so they wrapped him in a pile of blankets. Wind from the lake tossed his hair across his face.

Thorin was perhaps overly sentimental when Bilbo, voice still rough from coughing, asked what he most looked forward to when he reclaimed Erebor. Not if, but when. A reassurance disguised as casual inquiry, and it worked. Thorin spoke of what he wished to restore and build anew, (although the extent of the damage made by the worm was unknown), and what he hoped to show Bilbo when they returned to his ancestral home. 

At last, almost naturally, he added, “I’d value your clever mind beside me when we make it real. You’ll have a place in my mountain.” He met Bilbo’s blue-grey eyes and tucked a flyaway strand of hair, golden in the light of the now setting sun, behind his ear. (Unfair, how sweet Bilbo looked just then). The hobbit’s eyes widened, lips slightly parted, and yes, perhaps Thorin was not alone in this after all.

Then Bilbo sneezed — loud, wet, barely turning away in time. They huffed awkward laughter, Bilbo blushing furiously at his toes, muttering apologies, Thorin staring at the balcony rail.

“Well, the sun’s almost down. Let’s get you inside, you could do with some tea.”

And so the moment was gone. It was for the best, Thorin reasoned. He was, after all, about to send Bilbo to likely death.

That thought sounded worse now than it had then.

~~~~~~~~

And that, in truth, was the full extent of what had occurred between them. It would have been wrong to rush; Thorin knew too well how looming death stirred rash passions and how campaign flings seldom lived in peacetime. If he and Bilbo survived, they would have clear judgment and time enough. Proper courtships took time, and Thorin had every intention of doing this honourably (provided there would be a courtship to begin with, but there had been time for him to think this through). He would not see Bilbo’s motives questioned. A non-dwarven spouse was rare; a non-dwarven consort was unheard of save perhaps one disputed case in the Second Age. He would do this right, for Bilbo, and for his people.

Seeing his burglar at work at Erebor’s doorstep delighted him; any earlier doubts of Tharkûn’s choice were long gone. “Full of courage and resource, far exceeding his size,” Thorin said as Bilbo prepared to enter the Mountain. And the hobbit had the audacity to scold the dwarves when they grumbled at the treasure he retrieved. Hands on hips, chin raised:

“Did you expect me to trot back with the whole hoard of Thrór on my back? If there's any grumbling to be done, I think I might have a say.”

They worked together almost seamlessly.

~~~~~~~~

And then, not long after, he brought it all to ruin.

In the madness of dragon-sickness, he offered the mithril shirt; a courting gift, a claim, whether Bilbo understood or not, but finding it had felt like Mahal’s blessing. “Cast off your old coat and put on this,” he had commanded. A promise of a life of splendour, but so rushed, utterly graceless. But the mail was perfect on him, and it kept him safe, and it marked him as the king’s own. Looking back, Thorin was grateful that in his obsession he had scarcely looked at his intended afterwards — and grateful that Bilbo had not understood the significance of his gesture. He felt shame at the deception, but also relief.

The madness came in waves, shifting between clarity, then darkness; trust, then paranoid fury. And in its depths Thorin turned on Bilbo, growling accusations of betrayal and theft; he laid hands on him, threatened to throw him from the wall. An act born of heartbreak, yet what justification was that? To assault one’s spouse would’ve been enough to annul a marriage under Erebor’s old laws. He spat, “May we never meet again.” And it nearly came true.

The battle followed, chaos and desperation. He did not see Bilbo on the battlefield. Three spears felled him: shoulder, thigh, side. His last sight was Fíli and Kíli stepping in front of him, Fíli taking a blow to the head.

They carried him to the infirmary. He woke briefly, all strength drained of him but mind clearer than it had been for days. He said his farewells to his companions. His burglar stood by his bed, pale, wide-eyed, trembling. There was a chance to tell him how he shouldn’t ever be scared or cold again in his life and how it was so right he had safety and comfort waiting for him. He dared not speak plainly, not even now, but hoped Bilbo understood how deeply grateful he was for him, even if it had been only for so short a time.

When he closed his eyes, he expected not to wake again in this world. Yet he was dragged back from the doorsteps of Mahal’s halls; cleansed, cauterized, stitched, bandaged, tended even by Thranduil’s healers, though he recalled nothing.

He slept for days. According to his company, Bilbo left the next day, once Thorin and his nephews seemed to be out of mortal danger (something one of the elves had said — if they make it through the night, they might have a chance). His farewells were brief. Thorin lay unconscious, Fíli drifted, disoriented; only Kíli was awake, though unable to rise from his cot. “What about Uncle?” Kíli asked. “He’ll be all right,” Bilbo answered, but his gaze didn’t meet Kíli’s.

Dwalin scarcely left Thorin’s bedside. When Thorin at last spoke, comforted by the news of his nephews alive, he managed an exhausted smile. And then he asked for Bilbo. During those first days and brief moments of being awake, in pain or drugged haze, it took repeated explanations for him to understand the hobbit was gone.

~~~~~~~~

Dáin ruled for the first month, while Thorin could not rise and Fíli suffered terrible headaches but fortunately didn’t seem to hold any memory of the battle. Kíli, inexperienced and wounded, was of little help but tried so hard. In the sickbed, there was a great deal of time to think, far more than Thorin would have preferred. Thorin loathed pain-dulling draughts; they dulled his mind. His rooms were better than the infirmary, but being confined, helpless, set his temper aflame. His stitches tugged, his shoulder was near-useless, and every movement was agony. He snapped, cursed and growled at healers.

He did not speak of Bilbo except to acknowledge his role in reclaiming Erebor, but never beyond that. A king had no right to public lament, and his guilt was his own. The first thing he signed was a decree: if ever dragon-madness returned, he would be dethroned.

His closest companions knew. They saw the signs; the crumpled letter drafts in the fireplace, the brief glance toward the empty consort’s seat, the quiet disappearances to the ramparts. When asked, he denied everything — stiffly, always.

“If you braid your own beard crooked,” his mother used to say when they were young, “do not cry to another about the knots.” There were councils, emissaries, guilds, trade, justice to mete. Erebor revived; trade routes were restored, mines were reopened, new homes built for those wishing to resettle the mountain. Justice dealt swiftly where trouble stirred. Thorin was proud, proudest of Fíli, who would soon outshine him.

But in darker hours, Thorin imagined giving it all up and travelling west to gentle, rolling hills, to a certain green door. But he had ruined any such hope with his own hands.

He trained three times a week with the guards. It had started out as a way to build back the strength he had lost while healing from his wounds, but it quickly became a way to empty his mind for a while (Dwalin mentioned how seeing Thorin push himself reminded him of how he was after Azanulbizar, and he didn't know if that was a good thing).

When sleep fled him, the king walked the ramparts and relieved a watchman’s post. Dreams were treacherous; of failures, griefs, and once, a nightmare where madness drove him to push Bilbo from the wall. (“This is what happens to traitors”, he had roared to the crowd below). It had taken some time before he was quite sure he wasn’t going to throw up and he had to cancel the day's first meeting.

Another left him waking, heart aching and aroused, from a dream of waking beside his husband, whose sleep-warm skin carried the scent of summer-grass and morning sunlight. 

The Mountain noticed he sought neither queen nor consort. Even rumours of discreet companionship he shut down with a glare (although many beautiful dwarves and dams had high hopes concerning the unwed king). But none had the fierce loyalty paired with absolute lack of hesitation to call him out when he was out of line, the bravery and courage combined with unwavering kindness and clever, dry sense of humour. None of them were Bilbo. Let them believe he was craft-wed; questions faded.

~~~~~~~~

At last, others refused to tiptoe. Balin spoke first.

“Laddie, ye should.”

“Should what?”

“Write to him. I hate to see ye miserable. Ye try to pretend, but I’ve known ye all your life.”

“He left of his own will,” Thorin muttered.

“Aye — but ye did not see his face when he went. That was not a hobbit glad to leave.”

It made uncomfortable sense, as Balin’s advice always did. Thorin had never properly apologised. That failure stung. Maybe writing would give him some peace of mind, but at least it was the right thing to do. He drafted letters, burned the first three, and at last sealed the fourth. It eventually became a more forward and honest confession than he intended, though he still bit back his true feelings. He invited Bilbo to visit Erebor, to stay as long as he wanted, promising safe escort and even to fetch him personally if wished. He sealed the letter with green silk ribbon, the only colour that felt right.

He had a talk with the ravenmaster, so that he was absolutely certain she understood how important it was to choose a bird who was guaranteed to do the deed. She assured that the raven of her choosing had intelligence and endurance. 

The raven flew. Two months later it returned, empty-clawed. That was not yet cause for despair, not yet. His hopes went slightly up every time his personal secretary brought a new set of letters and messages to his desk. None of them ever were from the Shire.

Eventually, hope withered. He had wronged Bilbo; he could expect nothing. He had made an offer and Bilbo hadn't taken it up, as was his right. He had apologised, that must suffice. Life moved on, as it must. It didn't stop for a king, who was definitely not heartbroken.

~~~~~~~~

Erebor prospered. Some years went and Lady Dís returned; Fíli and Kíli were overjoyed and Dwalin flushed like a dwarfling beside her. Bofur married Marra, the future head of the miner’s guild; their wedding stretched three days, food was plenty and ale flowed freely. On the second night, Thorin accidentally stumbled upon Dís and Dwalin kissing like youths. Dís laughed, slightly flushed with ale, holding Dwalin’s hand. “Don't look at me like that, brother, I should’ve done this ninety years ago!” Dwalin’s soft smile agreed. Thorin raised his tankard. “About time, then.” He left the couple to their attempt to make up for the decades they had missed. 

Later he sat with Balin and Dori, the legendary observers and inquirers of the Mountain who seemed to know and notice everything. “So, your brother and my sister?” he teased. Balin all but giggled; “They didn’t!” exclaimed Dori, apparently only now hearing of the newest turn of events.

Life found its rhythm; never dull, never taken for granted. Erebor had been his duty since birth, it had been one even in exile. If he had forfeited his chance at love, so be it; duty came first. Besides, love was a weakness an enemy might seize.

Still, sometimes he wondered how Bilbo would cut down the pompous Orocarni ambassador with a single pointed remark, or what he would say of the newly restored moss-garden Thorin once described in Laketown. And Dís would have adored him, he was sure.

Years passed.

~~~~~~~~

Spring came. Sun warmed the stone of the mountainside, Dale roused from winter, traders crossed the Long Lake again.

Thorin’s day began, as always, with tasks and reports. Dale’s emissary would arrive by afternoon. Nori sought a private audience later. Patrols reported troubling orc movements; Thorin summoned his general. Lunch with Marra followed, reviewing rediscovered plans for old mine expansions Ori had found in the archives. “Some of these designs are from well before Thror’s time, can you imagine!”, Marra exclaimed as she spread the parchments eagerly, one hand on her great belly, determined to finish her work with the ancient plans before her second pebble arrived.

Returning, Thorin found new correspondence on his desk. Among them was a small letter, barely a note, wrinkled, rain-worn, smudged with mud, as though it had travelled long and rough.

He picked it up idly.

His breath caught at the signature:

Your burglar.

~~~~~~~~

Shortly after lunch, Balin pulled Fíli aside.

“Laddie, ye must cover the Dale emissary. Take the stonemasons’ guildmaster with ye. Your uncle needs a… moment.”

Fíli blinked, startled — then saw the fond smile.

“He received a letter from Mr. Baggins.”

 

 

Series this work belongs to: