Actions

Work Header

Rating:
Archive Warnings:
Categories:
Fandoms:
Relationships:
Characters:
Additional Tags:
Language:
English
Collections:
Crown Jewels, Fics I have read 10+ times, LOTR fanfic time, Good Readings (ymmv), Creative Chaos Discord Recs, Too Legit to Quit (Reading), long fic to binge-read, AmazingLOTR, Bagginshield Classics, Def_Read_Again, Best Across Fandoms, Grade A Works, Masterpieces, sA's Tears Hall of Fame, International Fanworks Day 2022 - Classic Fic Recs, Dantalion's Library, Works So Good Id Physically Buy the Hard Cover Version in Stores, I Don'T KnoW WhaT a CollEctioN Is BuT I WanT To Keep ThiS StorY SomeWherE, This is a messy collection but I’m the mess the fics are great, They just have SO many words, Fics LunaK does not want to lose track of, Best Stories, quality writing just makes you cry sometimes yknow, Novel-Length Bagginshield Gems, My heart is full, What happens in (or out of) Arda..., I love you so, fics that completely altered the fabric of my reality, Favorites from Middle-Earth, B is for Brilliant, Aki's Enchanted forest
Stats:
Published:
2013-06-24
Completed:
2021-06-30
Words:
577,879
Chapters:
51/51
Kudos:
25,640
Hits:
0

Sansûkh

Chapter 33: Chapter Thirty-Three

Notes:

EVERYONE! I liiiiive! Thank you to every single one of you for your kudos and comments. Your support for this fic and for me is astounding and amazing, and so are you.

Art and artiness (remember to check the ever-expanding and awesome Mighty Sansukh Masterpost for everything! IT IS AWE-INSPIRING, just all that DEDICATION HARD WORK AND TALENT AAAHHH)

ART
Aviva0017: Frerin (and Frerin's death ouch)
Aviva0017: Alris daughter of Geris
Aviva0017: Orla
Taciturntentacles: But I made you a pen...
Taciturntentacles: Fris and Gimli
Taciturntentacles: Wee Thorin & Gimizh, Laerophen & Gimizh
scaggles: That one fanfic about your OTP (COMIC) bwaaahahahaha I am so mean
hhavenh: Loni and Frar, teasing

SONGS
notanightlight: Legolas' song to Arod (Chapter 32)

PLAYLISTS
cybermanolo: At the sign of the Prancing Pony

FICTION
Ladykes: An Even Greater Sunrise (Eowyn/Frerin)
Redring91: Onomatophobia
Oakwyrm: How to Thank Thorin Oakenshield
FoxDragon: Punctuality

Thank you all! You are incredimazing and make me flap my hands uselessly and make seal-noises galore. I love you and your work.

RIGHT. ONWARDS.

(See the end of the chapter for more notes.)

Chapter Text


Movie Poster, by evil-bones-mccoy

...

"This is no journey for you," said Théoden, kindly to be sure, but firmly. "You are of great heart, Master Merry, but small stature. We go to a hopeless battle, and seeing to your protection would turn my mind and sword from the business of bloodshed. No, you must stay and help my niece protect Edoras."

"Why?" Merry cried, and his jaw was outthrust pugnaciously. Ori had seen that look upon a Hobbit's face before, and he instinctively took a step backward. "Why did you accept my sword and my service if you had no intent to use them? And I would not have it said of me in song that I was always left behind!"

"I received you for your own safe-keeping, Master Holbytla," said the King, and he knelt before the irate Hobbit and let out a regretful sigh, before placing his hand upon Merry's shoulder and squeezing. "If the battle were before my gates, then perhaps your deeds would be yet sung by minstrels; but Gondor is too far for the legs of a pony, even one as sturdy as Stybba."

Merry glared, his eyes shiny and huge.

Ori gnawed on his scarf. "Hobbity big eyes," he mumbled.

"Shândabi," agreed Bifur, and he gently tugged the scarf from between Ori's teeth. "You'll unravel the wool that way."

Théoden bent his head. "I am sorry, my little friend."

Merry bowed stiffly. "My lord," he said, and his normally bright voice was tight. He then scurried out of sight so quickly that Ori and Bifur nearly lost sight of him altogether. Hobbits could move far faster and more quietly than any of these stomping, clattering Riders.

"He's not altogether wrong," Ori puffed, wrinkling his nose as they ducked and weaved through the striding Men and the long legs of horses. "Hobbits aren't exactly warriors…"

"Neither are we," Bifur reminded him.

"S'pose that's true. Ah, there he is!" Ori straightened, catching sight of Merry, and then pulled at his mittens as his shoulders immediately fell. "Oh, poor thing."

For Merry was watching the bustling flow of folk with unhappy eyes, staring at the gathering lines of horsemen and the folding tents as the Riders prepared for the departure. Misery was written into every line of his body. "All alone now," he mumbled, and then drew his little dagger-sword and peered up at the straight and shining edge. "Not any use except as baggage, I suppose."

"You should not draw your blade unless you propose to use it," said a quiet voice, and Merry yelped and whipped around, his sword held low as Boromir had so painstakingly taught him.

"Peace, little warrior!" laughed a quiet-voiced Rider; a tall figure swathed in leathers and a green cloak. "Put down your weapon: I mean no harm. You wish to follow the Lord of the Mark, do you not? I see it in your face."

Merry swallowed. "I just… I want to fight," he said simply. "Yes, I want to go, though I haven't any earthly idea what use I'll be."

"Where will wants not, a way opens, so we say," said the Rider. "I will carry you before me, and cover you in my cloak. Such good will should not be denied."

Merry's mouth dropped open. "Oh!" he said, and then checked his expression. "I thank you, sir! Though I do not know your name."

"Do you not?" said the Rider softly. "Then call me Dernhelm."

Merry clapped his horse-helm on his head and extended his arm to the Rider, who took it and swung the Hobbit up onto the saddle. "Then, Dernhelm, I am in your debt."

"For such bravery done for the love of Théoden-King, I hold any debt answered," said Dernhelm, and wheeled the great grey horse beneath them to join in the muster.

"Uh-oh," said Ori.

"Shândabi," said Bifur.

"You recognised her, then?" said Ori, craning back to look at Bifur.

"Sort of amazed that Merry didn't, to be frank," Bifur said.

"Oooooooh, Frerin isn't going to be happy about this," said Ori, and he buried his face in Bifur's shoulder. "Neither is Thorin. Neither is anybody. Hobbits don't exactly have the best luck on battlefields."

Bifur fiddled with a braid of Ori's hair as he thought, and then let out a groan of agreement. "Shândabi," he said, and winced in remembrance.

They watched Merry and Eowyn disappear into the sea of horses, and sagged in unison.

"Nobody knows they're tagging along, do they?" said Ori, though his voice didn't hold much hope for a positive answer. "Anybody at all?"

"Doubt it," Bifur said.

"Well, bugger," Ori said.

"Shândabi," said Bifur, with feeling.


The dread lay heavy in the air: thick and cloying like smoke. Thorin pushed through the darkness and drew his brother close. Fear rasped into his lungs along with his breath, and his feet staggered on the path as he followed after his star.

Endless whispers floated in the still, stifling darkness, the words unclear and just out of hearing. Thorin's ears pricked at each half-heard syllable and liquid hiss, even as his skin crawled. Frerin's hand clutched tightly to his, his hitching breath sounding loud in their ears. The blackness that enveloped them was even darker than that of Moria.

Thorin felt almost as though he were walking through the solid earth again.

Only the impact of heavy, unsure footfalls ahead reassured Thorin that Gimli indeed led the way, following in the steps of the Grey Company.

Abruptly there was the sputtering hiss of a torch, and Aragorn's face was cast into sharp and flickering relief as he bore aloft a thin brand. "Stay close," he said low. "We do not know what we shall find." He passed the torch to Elladan, and lit one for himself and raised it high.

They had arrived in a cavern of cold grey rock, and the walls had dropped away so that they appeared to float all unsupported beneath the earth.

"The stone feels sick," Frerin whispered. "And so do I."

"Aye," Thorin murmured in response. "The dead have dwelt here, unsleeping, for an Age. The stone itself must yearn for rest."

Something glittered in the gloom to the left, and Aragorn swapped the torch to his left hand and drew Andúril as he moved forward to see.

Gimli's mouth tightened as he swallowed, and his axe was ready in his hands. What could be seen of his face had been thrown into stark black shadow, and his pupils were nearly black with terror. "Does he feel no fear?" he said, his voice strangled and hoarse. "In any other cave Gimli Glóin's son would have been the first to run to the gleam of gold. But not here! Let it lie!"

"Steady," Frerin whispered, and his little hand clamped down upon Thorin's.

Thorin braced himself for the expected surge of guilt at the mere mention of gold, but his fear had frozen all guilt from him in this dreadful place. "As though I could summon my madness in this icy tomb," he muttered.

Strange disturbing shapes flickered in the light of Aragorn's torch, and they resolved as the Man drew closer. It was a skeleton, and it lay before a great closed door, the fingerbones still reaching towards it in twisted supplication, clawing at the cracks. Aragorn knelt down to peer at the golden sigils upon the dusty helm, and then he shook his head and stood. "Here is the door that he could not pass," he said, almost to himself, before raising his voice and calling to the cavern at large. "But we do not attempt it. Keep your secrets, and your hoard, hidden in the Accursed Years! Speed only we ask. Let us pass, and then come! Oathbreakers! I summon you to the Stone of Erech!"

There was no answer, and then a gust of wind eddied through the tunnels behind them to blast into the cavern and send the torches guttering. They sputtered, and then went out. The last thing Thorin saw was the whites around Legolas' eyes.

"They will not relight!" called Elladan.

"Get them lit!" Gimli cried urgently, and he was echoed by shouts from many of the Dúnedain. "Get those bedamned torches lit!"

"Here!" Aragorn shouted. "Here, my friends and kin! Come to my voice!"

"Look!" Frerin suddenly said, and his voice was only just shy of a scream. "The walls! The walls!"

For they had begun to glow with a sickly greenish light. It was not the odd luminescence of cave-algae, nor the dim twinkle of glow-worms. Both of these were as familiar to Dwarves as the sound of hammer on steel. This glow caused the freezing fear in Thorin's chest to stop his heart in its mad rhythm. For there were shapes in it: great pillared buildings and massive ornate facades, elegant colonnades and boulevards and a wide and graceful palace. All of them exuded a sense of unspeakable wrongness. All the while, the greenish glow pulsed and throbbed. Thorin tasted bile in the back of his throat. The flesh of his back pricked and crawled.

"I summon you!" Aragorn cried again, and he turned a circle with his unlit torch brandished high and Andúril shining before him. "I summon you to the Stone of Erech!"

The horses bucked and reared all at once and the Grey Company was forced to settle them. Halbarad had to hold his hand before the eyes of his steed and whisper in its ears, his stern mien softening slightly as he spoke soothingly in a flattened ear. The Half-Elven lords were smoothing down the faces and murmuring liquid Elvish words to their horses, and Elrohir had Brego's bridle wrapped around his wrist. Arod's withers were visibly trembling, but he remained behind Legolas though his eyes rolled and his nostrils were flared wide as he breathed hard.

"What's got into them?" Frerin wondered.

"Who enters my domain?"

Legolas had an arrow notched faster than the eye could follow, but there was nothing to be fired upon. The voice came from nowhere.

Gimli's hands were trembling upon his axe-handle. "Who in Mahal's blessed name is that," he breathed in horror.

"The dead," Legolas said softly. "They have come."

"One who will have your allegiance," Aragorn said proudly, and he lifted his chin. He still wore the tattered leathers of a ranger, and his hair was still stringy and his face unwashed and weathered, but something of the nobility of the Argonath had entered his expression and he wore it well.

And then an apparition appeared before them: a ghoul of decaying flesh and white-rotted eyes, bathed in that rank green light and wearing a crown of bones upon its head. "The dead do not suffer the living to pass," he said, and his skull could be seen shifting and sliding beneath the exposed muscle of his cheek.

"You will suffer me," said Aragorn. It was not a challenge. It was a simple statement of what the future held.

The King began to laugh, and it reverberated around the cavern until Thorin's whole body seemed to shake with it. Then he began to advance upon the small group of travellers in grey, and the dreadful corpse-light flickered around his sneer. "The way is shut. It was made by those who are dead. And the dead keep it!"

"Thorin!" Frerin shrieked, for all around them before the houses of the unnatural city had appeared an army of grotesque nightmares: of half-formed Men with their faces in various states of decomposition, their arms little more than bone and their rotting lips peeling away from their grinning teeth.

"Hold fast!" Thorin barked, and he pulled his brother as tightly to his side as he possibly could. "Hold strong, nadad!"

"The way is shut," said the King, and he grinned his skull-like grin. "Now you must die."

Legolas unloosed an arrow, and it flew straight through the ghoul without piercing him.

"No use," Gimli said. "These bastards willnae die when they're dead already!"

Aragorn stood fast as the dead poured towards him, breaking around him like a mouldering, rotting sea. Only the ripple of his jaw revealed his unease as the King of the Dead raised his ancient green-lit sword and brought it down towards him.

The shivery clang of blades meeting rang through the cavern.

Aragorn smiled grimly over the shining length of Andúril.

"The blade was broken!" the King hissed, and Aragorn reached for that stinking, ragged neck and gripped in it one fist.

"It has been remade," he grated, before throwing the ghoul back into the press of his undead fellows.

The restless sea of the Dead stilled, and the King straightened to stare at Aragorn with intent and eerie fascination. "Fight for us and regain your honour," said Aragorn, and he levelled Andúril at the horde before him. "What say you?"

"Ach! You waste your time Aragorn. They had no honour in life and they have none now in death," Gimli muttered.

Frerin frowned for a moment. "I wonder…"

Thorin spared him a second's glance, but his attention was far more firmly placed on the sight of Aragorn striding through the ranks of dead warriors clad in ancient armour. His long ranger's coat flapped at his sides, and his hair was drenched in fear-sweat. He looked nothing like a figure of legend, and yet everything like one.

"Only the King of Gondor may command me," sneered the Shadow-King.

"You look upon Aragorn, son of Arathorn," Aragorn said, and then he took a deep breath and set his shoulders squarely. "I am Elessar, Isildur's heir of Gondor. Fight for me and I will hold your oaths fulfilled."

"He's really doing it," Frerin whispered. "He's going to take his place and his name at last."

"You do your oath to Boromir proud," said Thorin, and something eased inside him. Though he had no wish to pick up these threads of destiny, Aragorn was honouring his commitment to his friend. Boromir's beloved city would have its King.

The King of the Dead stared at Aragorn with his milky eyes, and then the shadow-host began to fade. The strange glow throbbed and ebbed and the buildings sank back into the stone even as Gimli turned around to try to watch their disappearance. "Stand, you traitors!" he roared, but the ropy whiteness of his knuckles around his axe betrayed his terror.

"What say you?" Aragorn cried, leaping forward, but the King of the Dead and all his kind were gone, and only the echo answered him.

"Aragorn, they are gone," said Halbarad. Even his grim expression seemed a little shaken.

"They have been summoned," Aragorn answered, his face hard and unyielding. "To the Stone of Erech."

"Will they hold to that?" Gimli asked.

"We will see," said Legolas, and he laid a hand upon Arod's soft nose. The horse whinnied nervously and his skin was twitching as though a thousand flies were set upon his hide.

"A miracle none of those animals have stampeded or kicked yet." Thorin shook his head in disbelief, and Legolas frowned.

"Did you hear something?"

"The rock beneath us groans and cries for release," Gimli said, and he rubbed at his numbed mouth. "This place is sickened beyond anything I have ever felt. It is poisoned: rotted through! Not even the haunt of the Balrog felt so foul!"

The raspy slither of something nameless was carried to them over another sudden gust of wind, and Gimli cried out and dropped to one knee as his legs gave out.

"Gimli!" said Legolas, and pulled the Dwarf to his feet. "Stand fast!"

"Ach, girdîn, girdînel, gerdar! Must I weep and crawl to follow Aragorn?" Gimli muttered beneath his breath. "Now the road has darkened indeed: I would not prove faithless, I would stay my course. If only my feet could carry me!"

"Courage, meleth nin," Legolas said, and his neck bowed as though he wished to lay his cheek upon Gimli's madly snarled hair.

"Courage, my star," Thorin echoed.

"Aragorn! Whither now? We must get out," said Halbarad.

"There is a tunnel!" said Elladan, and Aragorn nodded, before gesturing to the Elf-lord to take the lead. The other twin, Elrohir, glanced back at Legolas and Gimli and a strange and faintly puzzled look crossed his face momentarily, though it did not seem disparaging.

"Aye, you heard something," Gimli said shortly as they fell in behind The Grey Company. Elladan and Aragorn had the lead, torches low and guttering, sending disturbing shadows dancing over the tunnel walls.

"Ah, they are here also?" Legolas murmured. "Surely this hillside is too crowded already for more of the dead to fit within."

Gimli huffed a small laugh, and he looked up at Legolas and met his eyes. There was a wordless moment in the darkness as Dwarf and Elf simply looked at each other, and then Gimli said wryly, "that is not, actually, much of a comfort. But I thank you for the thought nevertheless."

"I cannot see nor sense the spirits of those faithless Men here," Thorin told Gimli. "They do not share our half-light, it seems. Theirs is a curse that has no surcease." Then he folded his arms. "Tell him, my star. Tell him you love him, and cease this maddening half-dance!"

"You are not helpful," Gimli grumbled. The bob of his throat betrayed his continued dread. "My king cannot see the cursed ones. It's as though they have melted back into this poisoned stone."

"That does not mean they are not following," Thorin said, scouring the darkness as though his glare could force it to give up its secrets. Then he fixed Gimli with another hard look. "Tell him!

"Ach!" said Gimli, and his body trembled like a leaf, shoulders bunching as though warding off unseen blows. "I will be undone by terror; I cannot go on. I will be crawling upon the ground like a beast before this is done." His voice quavered upon the last words. "My lord, I need you. I need your aid. Do not make this harder than it must be for me."

Frerin gave Thorin's arm a hard pinch. "Really, nadad," he muttered. "Your timing is still completely awful."

"I can hear the step of shadow-feet behind us," said Elrohir, and Gimli's eyes squeezed shut momentarily.

"Gimli, gerich 'ûn sui raw, estelion allen," said Legolas softly. "I am here, meleth nin."

"Why are you not afeared?" Gimli burst out, and he pried one hand from his axe-handle to roughly wipe at his clammy forehead. "There is a freezing sense of horror all around us. Death is everywhere here, can you not feel it?"

"What end may come will come," said Legolas. His voice was remote - even distant - but his hand drifted down to rest comfortingly upon Gimli's shoulder. "I will not fear it and I will not regret it."

"How can you say that?" Gimli demanded, and his thick fingers fumbled at his shoulder to grasp Legolas' hand and hold tightly. "You should live forever! Why resign yourself to such an end, one that was never meant for Elves?"

Legolas smiled into the darkness, though there was no joy in it. "Once, yes. Now? Now my end may come soon or late, but it will come nevertheless."

"We may yet live to see this war end," Gimli said pleadingly. "Legolas, you cannot hold your life so cheaply! Do not despair!"

The Elf blinked, and then he laughed under his breath. "Did it seem that I said so?"

Gimli only glared at him, his chest rising and falling quickly with his breaths.

"I am sorry, my friend," Legolas ducked his head. "That was not my meaning."

Thorin frowned. "Then what was his meaning?"

"But you, Gimli, do not let this fear master you!" Legolas was saying, and he gave Gimli's shoulder a gentle shake. "You have stood stalwart before impossible odds and laughed – you have faced death over and over, and never faltered. Why now do you shrink back?"

"I'm not afraid of death, daft Elf," Gimli muttered, and he rubbed at his sweaty brow once more. Behind him, Arod softly whickered. Hooves echoed through the tunnel. The soft clacking shuffle of bony feet could barely be heard, tantalisingly out of range. "My kinsman is proof that welcome waits for me. No - no, I'm afraid o' dying. There's a distinction, lad."

"Ohhhh," said Frerin, a dumbfounded look of realisation upon his face. Thorin narrowed his eyes at his brother.

"What does it mean?"

Frerin tugged at Thorin's sleeve. "I think I know," he whispered. "Thorin, remember what Aragorn said…"

Cold ice skittered down Thorin's spine. "No," he said blankly. "No."

Frerin leaned forward and began to speak very rapidly and very softly. "Remember, Aragorn said that Elves can die from a broken heart? Well, these two simpletons are afraid of the same thing! Legolas thinks he's going to die of unrequited longing – that whole 'lie-down-and-die' thing – and so he doesn't care what happens to him now because he thinks he's on borrowed time. But Gimli is afraid that when he dies, either in battle or of mortal age, that Legolas will also die of grief. Which is the whole reason he hasn't spoken, after all: he thinks that by never allowing Legolas to love him he can keep Legolas alive." Then he paused. "Which isn't working anyway, it seems, if Legolas thinks he's going to die of longing without even so much as having kissed…"

He trailed off in the face of Thorin's sudden and thunderous silence.

Thorin stared at his brother. Then he said, in a very flat and deliberate tone, "do you mean to tell me that this pair of fools are in fact causing the very thing they fear through this idiocy?"

Frerin gave him a worried little smile. "Um…"

"Lalâkh!" Thorin exploded. "Lalâkhel! Oh, a noble son of Durin's line you are, indeed – you monumental lackwit!"

"Well, you didn't even know yours when you saw him!" Gimli retorted immediately, his deep voice made hoarse and tight with fear. Thorin swelled with outrage and prepared to launch another blistering tirade at his foolish, self-sacrificing, thickheaded star, when –

"I heard that," said Legolas, eyes very wide.

"What?" said Gimli and Thorin and Frerin in unison.

"I heard a voice, a voice raised in anger, one I have not heard in eighty years," Legolas said. "He spoke in the secret Dwarvish tongue, and… and called you a lackwit?" His nose wrinkled.

Frerin groaned and put his head in his hands. "Oh, Thorin."

Legolas glanced sidelong at Gimli. "I am not wrong, am I?"

Gimli looked up at Legolas for a beat, his face parchment-rough and pale in the flickering dead glow of the torches. "No, you aren't wrong, laddie," he said. Then his breath snagged in his mouth audibly as a realisation struck him, and he began to plead, "my lord, my lord – no."

Thorin drew himself up tall, and faced Legolas directly. An old, feeble voice deep in the pit of his stomach began to rage, 'but he is an Elf! He is Thranduil's son! He took your weapon from your hand, aimed an arrow between your eyes, named your brave star orc-spawn, locked you in a cell!'

But an older, wiser and calmer voice now drowned out those old, pitiful hatreds, and Thorin could now see Legolas, the one who stepped between Gimli and Éomer; Legolas, the one who reached out to a grieving Dwarf in the glades of Lothlórien; Legolas, the one who had once, briefly, saved his life.

"Greetings to you, Legolas Thranduillion," he said, and inclined his head. Behind him, he heard Frerin's swift intake of breath. "You swore never to harm him by hand, word or deed, and you have proved true as steel. You have my gratitude."

Gimli made a soft noise of despair and turned away.

"Hail, Thorin son of Thráin," Legolas said, his voice faint, and he then suddenly stood straight and his bright elven eyes darted at the trudging Grey Company some distance ahead.

"They haven't noticed," said Frerin, frowning at them. "I don't think they can hear, that far away. Besides, the air is full of strange whispers."

"Get the others," Thorin muttered to him.

Frerin gave him a warning look, and pulled at one of his temple-braids. "Keep your temper."

Thorin waved him away irritably. "Yes, yes, I will hold it fast. Get them, and my sword too. Tell them to arm themselves. We may yet be facing this host in both life and death, and I would see us prepared." Frerin nodded and flashed away in a sudden halo of starlight.

"There, now my brother has left, and I may speak freely," Thorin said, and he fell in step between Elf and Dwarf as they walked through the claustrophobic tunnel.

"Please," Gimli said, low. "Please, my lord, do not – Melhekhel, ikhuzh!"

"Keep going," Thorin told them. "I will speak as we walk."

"I beg of you-"

"No, my star, calm yourself," Thorin said, as gently as he was able. "I will not speak of that which is yours to tell."

Gimli sagged. "Ah."

"I have something to say to this Elf, however."

Legolas appeared far, far more disturbed at hearing Thorin than he was at witnessing the dishonoured dead. He stiffened, wary. "To me?"

"Aye," said Thorin, and amusement and frustration warred within him. Was this how his Company had felt, witnessing him and Bilbo all those years ago? Fond, and yet also considering the best way to crack their skulls together?

Do not think of Bilbo, he told himself sternly. He grasped his fingers together behind his back and gazed ahead at the Company, some distance along the tunnel. Gimli's heavy, assertive footfalls had become plodding and fearful, and the Elf's light leather shoes were barely audible as they moved through the whispering, clinging blackness after the bobbing torches. "Will you hear me?"

"I am listening," said Legolas. His face was still and blank and proud, but Thorin now knew that it was no indication of unfeeling. "I will hear your words."

"I have learned much in eighty years, son of Thranduil," said Thorin after a beat. "I have learned that much I held true is false, and much that I held false is true. I will not be wroth with you if you should scorn it, but know that I am sorry."

Legolas blinked. "Why should you say such things to me? Son of Thranduil am I, but I am not my father."

"And well do I know it – now," said Thorin, and he blew out a sigh from between his teeth. "I thought you all alike, in my rage and resentment. Honourless, disloyal, deceitful. I thought you unfeeling and cold-blooded; I thought the whole world would happily wade through Dwarven blood to grasp at our relics and our history and our treasures, quarrelling and bargaining even as we starved to death. I saw treachery everywhere I looked, and chiefly from those of elvenkind. I have hated you."

Legolas was silent.

"I have learned better, if too late."

"Nay, lord," Legolas shook his fair head. "Why should you have questioned what seemed to be truth? For I was there. Gimli may forgive as easily as he breathes, but I was there, and I know what was demanded and what was taken and what was given and what was stolen. I was there. I remember arguing with my dear friend that the troubles of Dwarves were nothing to us. I remember admiring a sword-hilt in my hand and taking it for my own, even as I accused you of being a thief and a liar. I remember that two whole armies were camped before the gates of a shattered Kingdom in order to coerce gold from thirteen Dwarves. I saw the gates shatter and the eagles scream, and a pale Orc stood upon the ice and my quiver ran dry of arrows. I was there."

"Aye, you were there," said Thorin and he let the frigid air fill his lungs until they ached. "And you remember what depths I sank to, in my madness. You remember my ears stoppered by the clink of gold, all my promises broken and all my resentment turned against the world. Despite it all, that sword you returned to me, and in the most timely manner possible. For my part, then, I am sorry."

Legolas bowed his head. "And I for mine."

"It has not been a painless process," Thorin continued and he kept his eyes looking ahead, feeling the swing of his legs in time with those of Gimli and the Elf. "It takes a long time to change the mind of a Dwarf, for we are slow to change, and even more time to change one of our line in particular. When you joined the Fellowship I thought you exactly like your father and railed against you. I held you responsible for his doings and failings. And later I thought your overtures of friendship a lie, and that you would in time prove false. My eyes could only see the one who took my blade, not the one who gave it back."

"Û, King Thorin," Legolas said, holding up a hand. "I need no explanations. If you have watched, then you have seen. I thought your people covetous, brutish, incapable of any true gentleness of spirit. I was an ignorant fool and I have also learned better. There is this, at least: I am grateful that I am able to say this to you, and not to your memory."

"My memory," Thorin snorted softly. "Tell it to the living and not the dead."

"I have," said Legolas, and his eyes darted down to Gimli who was listening with a faint crease upon his broad brow. "I do."

"You do not say enough," Thorin growled.

Legolas, so graceful and sure-footed, missed a step.

"Once, upon the battlements of Helms Deep, you pledged to me any service, any penance I might ask," Thorin said, and behind his back his hands tightened together, fingers squeezing. "For his safety, you begged me to find him and safeguard him. For the love we both bear him."

Gimli came to a dead stop, and his eyes were huge.

"Now I charge you, Legolas," Thorin said, and he turned to face Gimli in the darkness and smiled at his star's speechless, horrified face, "speak your heart."

Legolas could only gape, struck dumb. For such an ageless creature, ten times over Thorin's own age, suddenly his face looked quite young.

"Will you honour your word? I will not hold you to it," Thorin said. "But you may find your reception rather different than you had feared it to be."

Legolas' mouth closed shut with a loud snap!

"Stop," Gimli snarled. "Stop it, stop playing such games with us!"

"Then you know what you must do, Gimli," Thorin said calmly. "Tell him."

Gimli's mouth fell open around half-shaped words, and then he slumped.

"You have indeed learned and your acceptance is more than I could ever have guessed at, but you are not the one to whom I must speak my heart," Legolas said from between gritted teeth. "And I have not yet found the words that mortals use. In that, at least, I am still an Elf as you had imagined us to be."

"Lad," Gimli said, and he raised his hand with a tired expression. "Lad, hold it there, there's no need. I know."

"You know!?"

"Aye."

Legolas stared at Gimli, dumb once more. Utter hurt crossed his face, followed by flashes of pain and disbelief, before the blank mask came stealing back over his features to turn them back into waxy stone. "I see."

"No you don't, and don't think I'll forget this, Thorin Thráinul," Gimli spat.

"You are not afraid any longer," Thorin pointed out.

"Not of this foul freezing place, no. Now I have new and deeper fears!" Gimli began to stalk after the Grey Company once again, his face thunderous and his eyes ablaze. His boots hit the cold floor as though he were trying to smash it.

"What do you mean, you know?" Legolas said, hard and fast, and he sprang after the Dwarf. "Why did you not say?"

"Why did you not?" Gimli retorted.

"I did not know how," Legolas said. "Elves do not need these clumsy words, these awkward declarations so prone to misconstruction and rejection and other unpleasantries. We can feel these things in the rhythm between us, between our steps and our laughter and our breaths. We know why we seek each other out and why our songs sound sweeter when sung together. Why should I know the words Dwarves use for love?"

Gimli's breath punched out of him in a low 'ah!' at that word, and for a second he looked as though he had been struck. Then he shook his head. "We have found new words to span our different ways," he said. "Why – truly, why?"

Thorin stepped back and folded his arms in satisfaction, watching.

Someone appeared at his elbow, and glancing to his side Thorin saw Lóni staring at the half-seen shapes of the quarrelling Dwarf and Elf. "Oh no, what's happened now?" he groaned. "Has that fatheaded rogue stuck his overlarge foot in it again?"

Around him, the star-lined figures of Dwarves came fading into the gloom, and Frerin pushed through them to stand stock-still beside Thorin at the sight before them. "Thorin!" he said in dismay.

"I have kept my temper," Thorin told him, fighting the twitching of his lips.

"What have you done?"

"What should have been done in Edoras," Thorin said, and he threw a companionable arm around his little brother. "You know, these darksome unwholesome holes might actually become a favourite place of mine?"

"You are not funny," snapped Frerin.

"I am hilarious," said Thorin, perfectly straight-faced.

"Did my affection amuse you so?" Legolas was demanding in an icy tone. His resemblance to Thranduil had never been so pronounced. "Did it make you laugh, the Elf so foolish as to care for you? Did I prove a good diversion, my Lord Dwarf?"

"Stop that, stop it, stop it now!" Gimli hissed, and he glanced at the Grey Company ahead before he whirled and stuck a thick finger into Legolas' chest. "I held my tongue for your sake, you quarrelsome fluff-brained wood-headed Elf, so do not accuse me of such heartlessness! Do you think me so selfish as to watch my friends suffer for sport? Well, I thank you for your good opinion of me, O Prince Legolas!"

"My opinion!" Legolas cried. "Gimli, you know I love you! You know, and you said nothing!"

"Aye, and had my meddlesome kinsman never spoken, Mahal curse him, I would have kept silent to my grave." Gimli knuckled his eyes.

"Nay, I thank him," Legolas said, and his eyes shone with anger and pain even though his face remained impassive. "I thank him. You hear me, Thorin Oakenshield? I thank you for your service to me. For I did not know I was handing my heart to one who cared nothing for it. Nin gwerianneg, ai, meleth nin!"

Gimli began to stride along the tunnel once more, and his cheeks were beginning to mottle. "Pointed ears do not work, it seems! For I clearly remember saying that I did this for your sake, you foolish mad creature. For your sake, none other! Why else would I allow you to draw away from me, to avoid me, to punish us both? Why else, when I would have you by my side as ever?"

"This was no kindness, Gimli," said Legolas. There was a snap in his long stride that spoke eloquently of his fury. Yet he never outpaced the Dwarf, though with his long legs it would be easy. "We have bridged such vast oceans of mistrust and misconceptions, you and I, that this comes as a doubly-hard betrayal. I cannot see how your refusal is for my sake, not if…"

"I will not be responsible for your death!" Gimli finally bellowed, and he rounded upon Legolas again and stood with his fists balled tightly around his axe. "I cannot!"

The echoes rang through the tunnel, and Elrohir, Aragorn and several rangers all looked back and raised their torches to peer frowningly at the pair. "Gimli, Legolas?" Aragorn called. "Ci maer? Prestad?"

"Ú-iston," said Legolas to himself, and then he raised a hand and called back, "Gwaem, Aragorn."

Elrohir's forehead furrowed ever so slightly and his head tipped to one side as he studied the red-faced, furious Dwarf and the stony, wild-eyed Elf. "Do not fall too far behind," he eventually said.

Gimli clapped his helm onto his head, and began to trudge after the Grey Company in angry silence. Legolas breathed hard through his nose, still as a statue for a few heartbeats, before he shook himself, took Arod's halter in a death-grip, and stalked after him.

"What's all this about?" said Nori from behind Thorin.

"Our mighty leader here has thrown a mouse amongst spitting wildcats," sighed Lóni.

"Oh." Nori chewed on that for a moment, and then said, "so who'll lay a coin? Gimli on first blow, three to one, best I can do for you, special-like because we're all friends here, eh?"

"Not now, Nori," said Ori, and to Thorin's left Óin huffed in agreement.

"Pipe down, some of us are trying tae listen!"

"Oh, fished yourself out of your tankard, have you?" said Nori mockingly, and Óin growled low in his throat.

Thráin cleared his throat. "Out of academic interest, what odds would there be on Legolas to strike the first blow?"

"Four on the Elf!"

"On Gimli – to kiss him!"

Óin stamped a foot. "I said hush up! Mahal wept, y' make me wish I were still deaf!"

"Best be calm now, everyone, best not to argue," said Balin in his kind, gentle way.

"Looks as though they've been takin' care o' that without our help anyway," added Náli.

"All right, we're all here," said Frís, and by her side Haban raised her axes and gave them a virtuosic spin. Finally, Fíli stepped forward, bristling like an armoury, and handed Thorin his long, curved sword – made by his own hand in Orcrist's image and the only one that had escaped his wrath. Kíli stood beside him as always, and Frerin scuttled forward with his poniard held in his hands.

"Don't you dare send me away," he said warningly.

Thorin's hand landed in Frerin's hair, and he tapped their foreheads together. "No, not today," he agreed.

"You're rather pleased with yourself," Frís said, her eyebrows rising.

Thorin could feel the smile pulling at his lips and so he let it bloom. "They're talking at last."

"Let's hope you haven't done more harm than good," Thrór said, and Hrera pinched him.

"Have some hope if you can, you old grump," she commanded him sternly. "Goodness knows we need it, in this dank place! Thorin, darling, where in Telphor's name are we?"

"The Paths of the Dead," replied Thorin, buckling the sword to his side. He would have to think of a name. It was not as light nor sharp as Orcrist and it lacked the fine carvings and ornamentation. No curling Elvish words lay upon its sides and it certainly had no dragon's tooth embedded in its hilt, but the curve of the blade was exactly the same. "We have travelled beneath the cursed mountain and now we approach the vale before the mouths of Anduin that run towards the sea. And they can hear us."

"Hear us?" Lóni's eyebrows shot up, and he gripped Frár's hand more tightly. "What do you mean, hear us?"

"Actually…" Frerin scratched his head. "I think it's still just you."

"Nay, I hear many voices of Dwarves, though the King is the most easily heard," said Legolas suddenly, making half the assembled Dwarves jerk with surprise. "Such a crowd there is, and you grow clearer as we travel! But how can that be?"

"I don't know," said Ori when every eye turned to him for explanation. "Don't just assume I know!"

"Well, you do know an awful lot," pointed out Náli.

Bifur's chest puffed up proudly, and he slid his arm around Ori's waist and beamed at all and sundry.

"The Stone of Erech," said Thráin. "Is there something unnatural about it?"

"There is nothing natural about this place at all," said Gimli. "The very air stinks of death."

"What did you mean, my death?" said Legolas, more quietly. He would not look down at Gimli.

Gimli's lips tightened, and he would not speak.

"Oh, what a mess," sighed Frís. "Thorin, both your wildcats have climbed trees now, and will not come down."

Frerin prodded him. "What did I say? Timing, nadad!"

"My timing? It is past time, and past time again," Thorin said, and he let his hand slide up the hilt of his sword to the crossguard, where he gripped it securely. The weight of it at his hip was a comfort: he had almost forgotten how it made him feel, to bear it by his side. "There is never time. Or it is never the best time. Or time carries you away from the moment, and it is forever lost. I have learned – oh, how I have learned! - and the learning is hard cruel. There is never a right time. Either all times are right, or no time is. And then at the last and sooner than you can ever dream, there is no time at all. All chances are flown, and you are trapped beyond all hope of love as though behind transparent glass, watching life move on without you. I have told you before, Gimli, and I will say it as many times as I must: For you, it is not too late."

"Ach, you mine where there is no metal. I can endure no more: I will find an ending to this or run back and face the horrors behind!" Gimli grated. "Why, if you love me, would you force him to speak?"

"Because I will not see you tread my lonely path, whatever doom may come," Thorin said, and heard Legolas' slight gasp. "We are not wise in love, we of the Line of Durin. Your wilful stubbornness is neither strength nor wisdom, and no amount of noble intent can make it so. Aye, son of Glóin, ursuruh inùdoy kurdulu: I love you enough to stop you. I would die over again before I saw it done."

"Can you see anything?" said Elrohir, calling back.

"The light grows stronger!" said Halbarad, and he began to pick up the pace. "We near the end, surely!"

Suddenly there was a new sound in the tunnel, the faint plinking of water. The light grew and grew and Gimli's tread became firmer as the dread of that terrible place left him. The tunnel abruptly opened up into a broad and shallow vale, and Gimli blinked in amazement as the wind touched his face and tugged at his beard. Dusk was upon them, and the sky was swiftly turning from purple to deepest blue, the stars only just beginning to shine. "Air!" he said. "Never have I been so fearful below the earth. I will never pour scorn on those who live upon the surface ever again."

"Starlight!" Legolas breathed, and he tipped his head backwards and allowed it to bathe his face. His hair hung like a golden sheet behind him. "How can it only be hours since we entered by the black door? It seems years, decades – or I have grown older since."

"Nine million, perhaps," Gimli muttered, and then he finally looked up at the Elf. "We must speak."

Legolas did not move, gazing with unblinking eyes at the sky. "Yes, we must," he said, and Thorin shivered at the freezing anger in his voice.

"Where to, Aragorn?" Halbarad called, and he mounted his horse in one practised move and span her around. The mare's feet picked up high as she fairly pranced with suppressed nerves, her eyes rolling. Only the firm, gentle hand of the Dúnedain kept her in check.

"The Stone lies not three hours away, towards the river-fords," replied Aragorn, likewise mounting Brego. "We shall be there just before midnight."

"How very appropriate," said Ori, drily.

Legolas stroked a hand down Arod's nose, before he whispered a word in the horse's ear and swung onto his back. Then, perfectly blank-faced, he wheeled Arod to where Gimli stood and held out a hand.

"Will you ride?" he said, without tone or inflection to betray his thoughts.

Gimli hesitated, and then said, "if you do not wish to be burdened by me, then…"

"Will you ride?" Legolas repeated, his expression wooden, and his hand remained outstretched.

Gimli flushed with shame, before grasping Legolas' hand and allowing himself to be swung behind the saddle. Once seated in his customary spot, his huge hands hovered uncertainly for a moment over Legolas' waist, before settling upon his own thighs.

Aragorn took then the furled staff that Elrond had brought, carried by Elladan, and unrolled the standard upon it. If there was any device upon the flapping flag, Thorin could not see it: it appeared black against black in the darkness, a hole cut into the night sky. "Follow close," he said, and kneed Brego into a jangling trot.

"Can we keep pace?" said Frár, and Frerin muffled a snicker.

"I could, but I don't know about you," he said, a trifle smugly.

"More running," Óin sighed.

"Three hours ain't so bad," said Náli. "At least it ain't all day!"

"Well, we've surely done the scenic route around Rohan," commented Nori wryly. "Seen more of it than I ever wanted to. I could probably organise tours."

Brego let out a loud bray, and then the Grey Company was moving, moving through the night, and Thorin's company followed. "This must be the Vale of Morthond," Balin puffed as they ran after the horses. "Men live here, bound to Gondor's rule."

"Can you see that?" called Elladan abruptly, last of the Company, his keen eyes peering back at the Dwarves. Thorin came to a sudden stop, warily meeting the Half-elf's gaze.

"Do they see us?" whispered Haban incredulously.

"Nah, they can't!" whispered back Kíli, waving a hand in dismissal. "How could they?"

"What can you see?" said Aragorn. "Legolas, tell us, what do the eyes of the Elves show? Gimli, what do your night-eyes see?"

"It is dark, but I can make them out," Legolas said, turning Arod slightly and pausing upon a slight rise. At his back, Gimli squinted into the darkness – and met Thorin's eyes.

I see you, Lord, Gimli's hands said, moving in surreptitious Iglishmêk.

Follow, do not speak. Thorin signalled back.

"What?" said Halbarad, frowning and twisting back in his saddle to stare behind him.

"The Dead are following," said Legolas. "I see shapes of Men and of horses, and pale banners like shreds of cloud, and spears like winter-thickets on a misty night. The Dead are following."

'Yes, the Dead ride behind. They have been summoned,' said Elladan.

Thorin sent a quick look behind him, and then turned back as fast as possible. "Do not look behind us," he said low, and drew Frerin and Frís near. "Do not turn around."

"Do you see them also, Legolas?" Gimli murmured.

"Yes," Legolas said quietly. "A host of Dwarves, outlined in white fire, led by your kinsman."

"My uncle stands there to his left," said Gimli, and sorrow flashed across his face. "That must be my lord's brother, with the lucky hair. There is Balin, and Lóni – ah, my friend, my friend, you look so young! – clever Ori and old Náli, and there is Bifur without his great wound! Oh unkhash, Fíli, Kíli, my cousins...! Oh, that I should see you standing there as though you yet breathe, and was I ever so young as that? Were you truly thus when you went away and died and left me leaderless? Nekhushel! This is a knife to the very heart of me. This has been an evil day, and an evil night to follow!"

"Do the others not see them?" wondered Legolas. "They must be thirty or more."

"It seems not," Gimli said. "Perhaps we two see them because we were connected to them?"

"Perhaps," Legolas said, and his tone was distant and cool. He turned Arod with a clucking noise of his tongue, and pressed on after the Grey Company.

"Drat," sighed Hrera. "It seems Elves may be as stupidly intransigent as Longbeards."

"Save your breath and run," Thorin said, and picked up the pace.

"You'll command me no such thing, grandson of mine," she said acidly, and picked up her elaborate skirts and charged ahead, head high. "A 'please' here and there would not go astray."

Do not think of Bilbo!

"My apologies," Thorin managed, and put his head down. He could feel Fíli's eyes against his back, and ignored them as best he could.

There followed an uncomfortable few hours. The Grey Company followed Aragorn's dark banner through the night, and all the while a freezing unnatural chill followed them. Thorin resolutely did not look behind again, but he knew Frerin had when his brother yelped and slowed his swift pace to keep beside their father. The Dwarves all ran as steadily as they were able, trusting in their natural endurance, and Thorin silently thanked Aragorn and all the small mercies that the Grey Company never rose above a canter.

The Morthond Vale was indeed populated, but the terror of the dead caused every settlement to slam their doors and douse their lights as the Company passed. Bells rang before them, and people could be seen fleeing into the night. Whispers and half-choked screams followed them as the people huddled in their houses, and as they neared the Hill of Erech the small villages thinned until there were no signs of habitation. None lived in this place.

"Fewer folks than I expected, from the number of hamlets," said Balin, and in his hand he gripped a thick-bladed sword. "Many of these buildings lie empty."

"They will have fled this ghostly army," said Thrór. "Those who live near this cursed Mountain will no doubt know its legends well, and will have deserted their homesteads at the rumour of the Dead."

"Wisely, no doubt," Balin agreed, and he wiped at his forehead with his forearm. "And too, the war to the south will have taken many away."

Ahead, the Hill of Erech loomed and at its crest lay a truly remarkable sight.

"That must be it," said Ori, and indeed nobody could argue. "The Stone of Erech."

It was round as a great globe, the height of a man, though its half was buried in the ground. Unearthly it looked, as though it had fallen from the sky, as some believed; but those who remembered still the lore of Westernesse told that it had been brought out of the ruin of Númenor and there set by Isildur at his landing.

To that Stone the Company came and halted in the dead of night. Then Aragorn passed his standard back to Halbarad, who held it aloft. Elrohir gave to Aragorn a silver horn, and he blew upon it and it seemed to those that stood near that they heard a sound of answering horns, as if it was an echo in deep caves far away. No other sound they heard, and yet they were aware of a great host gathered all about the hill on which they stood; and an icy wind like the breath of ghosts came down from the mountains. But Aragorn dismounted, and standing by the Stone he cried in a great voice:

"Will you fight?"

The wind screamed as it surged again, gusting around the legs of the panting horses and sending Aragorn's hair twisting. Then the terrible chill that had followed the Dwarves all the way from the Dwimorberg seemed to coalesce and take shape once more, and the King of the Dead grinned his skull-like sneer as he stepped forward from thin air into the living world.

Aragorn lifted his sword. "Oathbreakers, why have ye come?"

The King said nothing, and his milky eyes bored into Aragorn. Around him the skeletal force of the cursed dead faded into view, gathering close around the great Stone like a moat around a castle.

"This is the hour," breathed Thorin. "This is the moment he steps from the shadows into his mantle and into history."

"Will you fight?" Aragorn demanded again.

The King breathed out, his breath misting green before him, and then he said, "We fight. We will fulfil our oath and have peace."

Then Aragorn's eyelids pressed closed, and his shoulders sagged slightly as though he bowed under the new weight he now bore. Then he straightened and levelled his grey stare at the ghoul and said: "The hour is come at last. Now I go to Pelargir upon Anduin, and you shall come after me. And when all this land is clean of the servants of Sauron, I will hold the oath fulfilled, and you shall have peace and depart for ever. This I swear as Elessar, Isildur's heir of Gondor."

The King of the Dead slowly bowed his head to Aragorn, the bones of his spine clacking together. "Where you lead, we shall follow."

Aragorn nodded gravely, and then he sheathed Anduril and turned to the Grey Company. "We camp here," he said, a sudden weariness in his face and stance. "We will ride on upon the morrow." He turned to the King and inclined his head, and the ghoul smiled his gruesome smile in response and faded from sight. Though the shadow-host melted from view, still the air seemed thick and cloying and the faint greenish tinge of the night sky was more than simple starlight.

Gimli slid down from Arod's back, his feet hitting the sod with a loud thud. Legolas did likewise, and wordlessly began to unbuckle Arod's saddle. Gimli seemed about to speak, but appeared to think better of it. Instead he unshouldered his roll and took off his helm once more. Sweat had plastered his hair to his forehead in meandering trails.

"Gimli," said Thorin.

"You are not in my greatest graces right at this moment, Thorin Oakenshield, if you don't mind," Gimli growled, and he began to pull his axes from his belt with sharp, jerky motions and throw them onto the worn wool.

"You have that right," Thorin said, and his heart sank slightly. "But have you no kind word for those with me?"

Finally Gimli looked up and his eyes met Thorin's once more. As before in Galadriel's mirror, to have his star see him, actually see him, was a staggering thing after so many years of being little more than a whisper in the wind. "Aye," Gimli said, hoarse, and then he cleared his throat. "And if it were not for your foolish games I would have kinder words for you also, my beloved Lord."

"What I did I have done for you, Gimli," said Thorin.

"That may be, but what I did I did for him," Gimli said, biting off the words in his anger. He turned away, glaring at his axes where they lay upon the bedroll. "Get you gone, Thorin Oakenshield. I will have no more of you this night."

"You'll keep a civil tongue in your head, nidoyel," said Óin crossly. "That's our King, that is. Don't be rude."

Gimli blinked, and then he began to blush like a sixty-year-old. "Sorry, uncle," he mumbled.

"You might have your father's temper, but try holdin' onto it now an' then for a bit o' variety, eh?" Óin smiled, and then beamed. "Ach, look at you. Look at you."

Gimli's head slowly rose, as though he were being dragged to look beyond his will. When he finally looked fully upon Óin, he let out a soft, "aaah!" and his eyes filled with sudden tears.

"You look young," he said. "Younger than I do."

"There's a mystery or two left for you to figure out," said Óin, gently. "I am proud o' you."

"Proud of you," echoed Balin. "Azaghâl belkul."

"Balin," Gimli breathed.

Thorin stepped back, and felt eyes upon the back of his head. Turning slightly he saw the Elf gazing between him and Gimli, a faint puzzled expression in those luminous eyes.

He inclined his head once more, before bowing slightly. Legolas bent his head, and then put his hand over his heart and held it forth in that elegant gesture of Elvenkind. They regarded each other silently for another moment, and then turned back to Gimli.

"….stop giving away so many bloody secrets," Óin was saying.

"You know better. I taught you better than that!" Balin said sternly, and Gimli waved a hand dismissively as he scoffed.

"Pah, what good do they do? They breed mistrust, is what they do. An' there's nothing shameful about 'em, so why not share 'em with those who care to hear?"

"Because there will be those who don't like the idea of us havin' them in the first place - those who see our secrets as just another shiny bauble they can take from us," growled Lóni, and Gimli shook his head.

"You are always so pessimistic."

"Well, one of us had to be."

"See, this is why you're de…" Gimli managed, and his voice broke off on the last word. He ducked his head and pressed his chin against his chest for a few rapid breaths, and then he looked up again into his best friend's face with a watery smile. "Hello, lad. You look well. That husband o' yours still doing right by you, then?"

Frár only raised an eyebrow, unimpressed. Lóni laughed. "Aye, he is, and you need to do likewise. Stop hovering over the gem and cut it already! We're all heartily tired of watching you nobly pining away, you great rascally idiot."

The Elf stepped nearer, and laid the saddle down upon the grass close to where Thorin stood. "Will you tell me who these Dwarves are, and who they are to Gimli?" he said quietly.

Thorin glanced at him, before nodding. "That is Gimli's closest friend, lost in Moria. His sky-name is Lóni, son of Láin, and there is his husband Frár. That is Ori, son of Zhori – lost in Moria also – and there his elder brother Nori. Both were of my company, you may recall them. No doubt you remember Balin and Óin, also. There is my mother, Frís, and Gimli's grandfather…"

Legolas watched, unblinking, as Dwarf after Dwarf greeted Gimli until he was weeping and smiling openly. Thorin quietly named them all, and watched Legolas' breath stop momentarily at Thrór's introduction, and then again at Haban's.

"Why did you charge me to speak?" Legolas finally asked.

Thorin mused for a beat or two, pondering how best to answer. Then he said, "Did you ever meet Bilbo Baggins?"

"Yes, in Imladris," said Legolas. "He kept much to himself after the Battle and I had not the chance then. Why?"

"I love him." Thorin let the words finally fly into the world, and revelled in their simplicity. It was easier than he had ever imagined. "I love him, and I cannot be with him."

When he turned back, Legolas was looking down at him with a new sympathy in his expression. It amazed him somewhat that he had learned to read Elven faces so well. They had seemed so immovable, before. "No, do not pity the dead," he said, and surprised himself with the gentleness of his own tone. "My life was spent well, in service of my kin. That is a better end and a higher honour than I had foreseen, once, when gold was the only thing that seemed of worth to me."

"Still, to love and lose is no small wound," said Legolas softly.

"No, that it is not," Thorin acknowledged. "I would not see others suffer needlessly in this way. Do you blame me, then, as Gimli does?"

"I do not know yet," said Legolas. "We may see."

"Hmm." That would have infuriated him, once: that strange Elven patience. Now Thorin leant his weight upon one leg and folded his arms, watching Gimli interact with his friends and family at last. "Do not let him push you away."

"Why does he do this?" Legolas said, and lifted his eyes again. "He confuses me so!"

"That is not for me to tell you," Thorin sighed. "I do not agree with him, and there lies our contention."

"Did you know also?" Legolas swallowed, though his expression was unchanged. "Did you know that Gimli was… aware of my… my regard?"

Thorin hesitated, and the silence stretched a little too long.

Legolas' eyes squeezed shut. "Ah."

"What a mess," Frerin whispered.

Finally Gimli's tears seemed to have run their course. Frerin pulled absently at one of his short cheek-braids, before peering up at the gloomy, whispering night sky. "Perhaps we should come back later?"

"I would have you stay," said Legolas. "If it is allowed."

Frerin goggled at the Elf.

"My brother, Frerin," Thorin said, and Legolas frowned.

"He is so y-"

"Handsome," snapped Frerin. "Yes, I am, and it's a terrible burden to me but somehow I bear it."

Thorin laid a comforting hand upon the back of Frerin's neck and squeezed reassuringly. "Nadad," he murmured. "He does not mean you any insult."

"I know, I know," Frerin sighed, and he darted a look up at Thorin.

"I cannae believe this," Gimli's hand half-rose as though to touch Fíli's shoulder, and then he appeared to check the motion. "I cannae believe I see you here. Do I dream?"

"No, little coz," said Fíli, smiling broadly. "And neither have you touched a drop, before you ask."

"Little!" Kíli snorted. "He's bigger than either of us now."

"I am always your little cousin," Gimli said, his heart in his voice.

"Those two I remember well," Legolas said, and Thorin felt his jaw clench.

"As you should," was his rather terse rejoinder.

The night was spent merrily for Gimli, at least: surrounded by friends and family, he sang quietly beneath his breath and spoke in a hushed voice of old times as he polished the nick from his axe-blade. Legolas remained near, but he did not interrupt. Many of the Grey Company wondered at this and sent confused looks at the Dwarf (who must have appeared somewhat unhinged by his trek through the Paths), but Legolas only shook his head to them and they moved on without asking. One by one, Thorin's people spoke to Gimli and then left to seek their own beds in the Halls.

Thorin stayed. Frís gave him a loaded look as she left, and he waved his hand in acknowledgment. "I will rest," he told her.

"You had better, my lad," she said, pulling upon his ear affectionately. She then collected Frerin (despite his complaints) and the starlight swallowed them both.

Finally, as dawn neared, Aragorn stepped forward and drew Legolas aside. "What troubles you?" he asked. "Ci vêr ? You have not seemed yourself ever since we took the Dark Door. That would unsettle the staunchest heart, but the Paths did not seem to haunt you as they did our Dwarf…"

Legolas stepped swiftly towards the ranger, his unmoving expression somewhat unnerving. "Why does Gimli believe he will be the instrument of my death?"

Aragorn frowned, and then his face paled. "What?"

Legolas did not repeat himself, but simply fixed Aragorn with that strange and piercing Elven stare.

"When do we leave, Aragorn?" called Elrohir. "The sun will rise in moments!"

"Ready the horses," Aragorn called back, and then he gripped Legolas' shoulder and said low and fervent, "I am the author of this, and I am sorry. I spoke of Arwen to him."

Legolas' brow creased the faintest amount. "Of the Evenstar? But I am no Peredhil."

The dawn's light spilled over the lip of the horizon, and Aragorn squinted into it, before patting Legolas' shoulder once. "This day will end in a red sunset," he muttered. "We ride to battle. Do not let my ill-timed words put you apart, not when peril faces us and bloodshed beckons. Make peace, and more than peace! Ai, I am weary of watching you circle endlessly!"

Legolas shook his head. "Aragorn, what…"

But the ranger was off, his long legs striding back to where Elrohir had Brego saddled and ready.

"Wake, my star," said Thorin and crouched down by Gimli's head. "The ride continues."

Gimli blinked, and then sat up in his blankets. "Ahh," he groaned and palmed his face. His beard was a shambles, and he scratched at his belly as he yawned. "That light is fierce! And did yesterday truly happen? I cannot fathom it – from such terror to such anger to such joy. I feel as though I have been pummelled relentlessly, and yet the true battle has not even begun."

"Do you forgive me yet, Gimli?"

Gimli peered at him from over his hands. "Not especially forgivin' first thing in the morning, if you'll pardon me, my Lord," he said dryly. "But I suppose I must. As my uncle pointed out, you are my King."

Thorin sat down at Gimli's side and leaned his forearms upon his knees. "I was not. Dáin is your King, and a fine one he makes."

Gimli laughed. "Haven't you heard? They change every so often. And Aragorn's my King too. I can have as many as I like. There's a surplus of them around here, after all. Why, wasn't that Thrór I saw last night standing beside my cousins?"

Thorin smiled. "Thank you, Gimli."

"Don't thank me yet. This will be an uncomfortable conversation, an' I'm not letting you slip away. Not after that stunt you pulled."

"Hah." Thorin's smile would not budge. Always there was this, Gimli's great gift to him: laughter and a lighter heart. "I am justly punished, then."

"Nnnngh." Gimli flopped back onto his bedroll and rubbed his eyes some more. "And the air still stinks of those unliving foul traitors. Well, I must drink the cup I have poured for myself, I suppose. I should not be wroth with you for stirring it."

"You should reach Anduin soon." Thorin said, and watched as Gimli stretched like a lazy lion. "And your hair is atrocious."

"I'm sure the Orcs and ghouls won't care," Gimli grumbled, but he did make an effort to tame the bright red frizz of his hair into a warrior's queue.

"You are making a mess of it," Thorin commented.

"Oh, hush yourself," Gimli muttered, and craned his neck to the other side to collect the lock that was coming astray. The wind blew it this way and that.

"Here," said a sudden light voice, and Legolas stepped forward and laid his hands over Gimli's. "May I?"

Gimli froze.

Thorin froze.

"Perhaps you should leave after all," Gimli said in an undertone.

"Not for all the gems in Erebor," Thorin said with no little satisfaction. "Not even for the Arkenstone itself."

Gimli's hands slowly descended, and Thorin could see their thick fingers trembling slightly. "Do as you will," Gimli eventually said to the Elf, and Legolas frowned.

"Do I overstep?"

"Yes, you do," Gimli said in a quiet voice. "But I would welcome it."

Legolas paused a moment, his hands still but lightly touching Gimli's vibrant, crinkled hair. Then he folded his legs beneath him, moving deliberately and calmly as though he were settling down upon an airy Elven talan and not the hard, cold ground, and began to separate the strands for the long, tight barrel-plait.

Gimli's face was a study in itself. Thorin found he could not look at him long. His cheeks were flushed and his ears were a red nearly as bright as his hair, but his lips were drawn and thin.

"Why must I die to love you?" Legolas said, soft as the air that whispered through the Vale.

"Why must you be an Elf?" Gimli replied, just as soft.

"For the same reason you must be a Dwarf: that is who I am."

"It cannot be. Not for your life. Aragorn told me."

Legolas gently wound one of Gimli's clasps around the thick braid, and continued to work down the length of the hair. His long fingers flew, nimble and practised. They seemed oddly lingering as they slid through that coarse and bristly Dwarven mane. "I have spoken to Aragorn. He tells me this is his doing. Why then – what did he tell you?"

Gimli closed his eyes and sat silent for a moment, and then he said, "Elves may die of love."

Legolas continued working, and around them the Dúnedain packed away the camp as though they were moving upon a different world – as though they occupied the same shadow space as Thorin, watching forever removed from this oddly private, intimate moment. The anger lay banked, cooled for the moment but not put aside. This odd, dreamlike peace had replaced it: the hush before the thunderclap shatters the air.

"Aye," Legolas said after the moment had stretched until nigh breaking. "We may. It is rare, but we may."

Gimli said nothing.

"You would have removed my choice, then?" Legolas said, still soft, and he wound another clasp around the braid, nearer the midpoint of the length, cinching it in. "You would have me suffer and wane?"

"If you do not…" Gimli said, and stopped. He gnawed on his lip for a pause, and then said, "if you do not love me, then you do not die. I would not have you die, Legolas. You will not die. I could not bear it."

"You do not have the right to tell me so," Legolas murmured. "You cannot order my heart to do as you would have it do. Ah, a brave soul, unselfish but arrogant are you! If I die then so I die, and I do so with a song upon my lips. But you do not choose yea or nay. Only I may do so. And I have."

Gimli let out a sound as though he had been punched. "Oh, Legolas, sanmelekuh, âzyungeluh… birashagimi, birashagimi!"

"I would yearn, Gimli," said Legolas, and he pulled the great mass of fiery red together to form the last section of the braid. "I would lie my head down and weep for what has never been. I would long and long for you, and in the longing would be the bitter knowledge that you had foreseen this and done nothing."

"That is not so," Gimli managed, but Legolas tugged upon the braid once – a warning: be silent.

"Too, I would lie there and know that I died for a dream," Legolas said. "I would much prefer living it."

"But I am a Dwarf, Legolas! I am mortal!"

"Yes, you are." Legolas fastened the last clasp, and then smoothed his hand down the heavy, thick braid: dull without oil, and no doubt dry and strawlike from rough conditions. "You are very mortal, and you are every inch of you a Dwarf."

"And when I go?" Gimli said, and he took one deep gulping breath, then another. "What of you? What then?"

"Then we shall see," Legolas said serenely. "I do not know the future, Gimli – I am not Lord Elrond. These things are not certain, the risk is there, surely, but it is not inevitable. It is no more certain than survival in a battle, and we have now seen many and more to follow. I will say this, though: I would prefer to breathe my last knowing what it is to love, rather than die wishing for a never-was."

Gimli winced. "I… did not understand."

"You should have asked."

"You disappeared!"

"You should have found me, bothersome Dwarf," Legolas breathed, and he laid his face against the braid he had woven. "You should have found me."

Gimli's hand fumbled over his shoulder, and Legolas took it and held on. "And mortal grief? What of that? You feared it so, in the fields of Rohan. And now I will be its author. How do you expect me to bear this guilt?"

"If mortal grief should take me when the mortal gift takes you," said Legolas, and he squeezed Gimli's hand, "then that is the way of it. But I would have a light to hold against the darkness. I would have a memory of joy to carry with me against the tide of sorrow. Aragorn speaks with the tongue of his own guilt, but there is no need for it. Elves love where they will, and the gift is not one that is given lightly. Arwen has made her choice, and so will I."

"The Evenstar can live as a mortal, thanks to the choice of her half-elven blood," said Gimli. "Or so says Aragorn. She will not be forced to endure for long ages after he is gone to the stone!"

"Cold ages, lonely ages with no memory of fire or warmth." Legolas stood in one swift motion and moved to stand before Gimli, slim and fierce-eyed and proud. "Gimli, Glóin's son, do you love me?"

Gimli gazed up at Legolas, and Thorin had never seen him look so lost, or so utterly, profoundly adoring. "Must I say so?"

"Aye, you must," said Legolas. "In this, Gimli, you must learn to do as Elves do. This is the present, and time will run in its furrow no matter what we do. When all of Middle-Earth is poised upon the precipice and hope is held in the hands of Hobbits, what is the difference between Elf and Dwarf then? Neither of us may see the next sun rise."

"You would bind yourself to a doddering old Dwarf, wiping his chin and rubbing his aching feet?" Gimli shook his head. "No. No."

Legolas, amazingly, laughed. "The seasons will turn and you will age and I will not, and I will love you. The trees will turn red and gold and your hair will turn silver, and I will love you. Your eyes will dim and your legs ache, and your mighty strength will begin to wane and I will yet love you. Do you mean to frighten me away with the truth of aging? Gimli. I am not afraid, and I love you. Do you love me?"

Gimli hesitated, and then put his head in his hands. "Yes," he said, muffled, before taking a dragging, shuddering breath. "Yes. You are my Sanâzyung. I love you. I love you, Legolas of the Greenwood. With everything I am."

Smiling, Legolas knelt before him and took his great broad hands from his face and kissed the back of one, so slowly, so softly. "Good," he whispered. "Good."

Thorin let out an explosive breath. "Durin's beard and balls, finally!" he growled, and let the stars of Gimlîn-zâram bear him away.

(He didn't actually intend for the small jig to escape as he left, but some things cannot be helped.)



by FlukeofFate


by valveillen

TBC

Notes:

Sindarin
Gerich 'ûn sui raw, estelion allen – you have a heart like a lion, I trust in you
Nin gwerianneg – you betrayed me!
Ci vêr – are you well?
Prestad? – (is there) trouble?
Baw, avaro naeth – no, don't worry
Gwaem – let's go
Û - No
Peredhil - Half-elven
Ú-iston - I don't know

 
Khuzdul
girdîn, girdînel, gerdar! – Terror-place, the most terrible place, supreme terror!
Gimlîn-zâram – Star-pool
Inùdoy - son
Nidoyel – boy of all boys
Nadad – brother
Nadadel – Brother of all Brothers
Gimli – star
Birashagimi – I'm sorry (literally, "I regret")
Irrîn – Horror-place
Sanmelekuh – My Perfect (true/pure) half
Âzyungeluh – my love of loves
azaghâl belkul – mighty warrior
Melhekhel – King of all Kings
Ursuruh inùdoy kurdulu – my fiery son of the heart
Sanâzyung – Pure/perfect love
Ursuruh inùdoy kurdulu – my fiery son of the heart
Shândabi – agreed
'ikhuzh – stop
Nekhushel – sorrow of all sorrows
Unkhash – the greatest sorrow
Lalâkh - fools!
Lalâkhel! - Fools of all fools!

Some lines taken from the films and from the chapters 'The Passing of the Grey Company,' and 'The Muster of Rohan'.

The Half-Elven: Unlike other Elves, the Half-Elven were able to choose their fates. They could be counted amongst the Elven Firstborn (Elrond chose this path) or amongst the Secondborn, Men (his brother Elros chose this path, and became the first High King of Númenor). The children of Elrond are also granted this choice. Arwen has chosen a mortal life.

"Fading" vs "Dying of grief" - these describe the two different ways Tolkien's Elves may perish apart from grievous injury or harm. Elves do not fade when they are dying of grief or love. Instead they lie down and their soul departs their body, which remains young and unchanged. "Fading" refers to when an Elf becomes so old that they literally start to fade - they slowly grow transparent until they disappear entirely. This is, in my opinion, awesomely creepy. :)

The skeleton lying at the door upon the Paths of the Dead is that of the Prince of Rohan, Baldor, who in TA 2569 (nearly 450 years ago) vowed to walk the Paths. He never returned, and his father King Brego died a year later of grief.

Everybody has a lot of feelings, oh my god, this chapter has been brought to you by so MANY FEELINGS and Thorin Oakenshield as Captain of the good ship SS Gigolas ahahahah

 

AND NOW ANOTHER COMIC
By scaggles!

When that ONE fic about your OTP updated



Click here for the rest!